International Journal of Computer Applications (0975 – 8887)
Volume 114 – No. 13, March 2015
Review on Self Organization in Next Generation Mobile
Network
Swati Bairagi,
Saurav Verma,
Chaitanya Kaul
Assistant Professor, Department
of Electronics and
Telecommunication
SVKM‟s NMIMS MPSTME
Bhaktivedanta Swami Marg,
J.V.P.D. Vile Parle (W) Mumbai,
India
Assistant Professor, Department
of Information Technology
SVKM‟s NMIMS MPSTME
Bhaktivedanta Swami Marg,
J.V.P.D. Vile Parle (W) Mumbai,
India
Student,Department of Computer
Science
SVKM‟s NMIMS MPSTME
Bhaktivedanta Swami Marg,
J.V.P.D. Vile Parle (W) Mumbai,
India
ABSTRACT
This paper is the review of Self organization in future mobile
network. As for now self organization is being applied to
autonomic computer, or wireless network but presently self
organization in mobile network is the emerging field with lot of
research direction in various field related to mobile
communication. In this paper a brief introduction of the term self
organization and SON is presented. Also paper contains the
weakness of existing system with increasing complexity. Key
objectives for the deployment of self organization in system are
to ensure excellent coverage and capacity with reduced
interference. Deployment of SON also reduces capital operating
expenditure as it eliminates the need of skilled labour. SON is
mainly classified in three type’s viz. self configuration, self
optimization and self healing which covers almost all parameters
and function related to mobile communication. Lastly it
concludes with few research directions and the areas which
1.1 Reasons for developing Self organization
1.
In future cellular networks, number of nodes
too large to meet the requirement of all users
of capacity, quality of service (QoS) and
efficiency. Ultimately it is going to affect
configuration, operation and maintenance of
network by classic manual approach.
2.
The increased complexity of cellular network wills
prone to large number of errors if manual approach is
employed.
3.
There are always faults in network and it has to be
rectified soon. In manual approach, human error will
lead to long recovery and fault correction time
resulting in suboptimal service or no service at all.
4.
SO can also reduce the operating and maintenance
expenditure (OPEX) as it will reduce the need of
skilled labour required for configuration, maintenance
and recovery of system.
need more research work to be done.
Keywords
SON, eNB, OPEX, self configuration, self optimization, self
healing.
1. INTRODUCTION
In recent past years, mobile telecommunication industry has
experienced tremendous changes and it will continue to evolve
in coming generation. Cellular communication system has to
bear tremendous pressure owing to rapid growth in bandwidth
hungry application such as video, multimedia file sharing etc. in
coming future. Capacity of cellular network to support these
applications has to meet in a cost effective way as users may not
be comfortable in paying higher bills for better and improved
services. But there is a trade-off between providing improved
services and minimizing operating expenditure because in
cellular system major cost is associated with the operation and
maintenance of network.
Cellular network consist of large number of distributed
equipment and complicated system throughout the country.
Operation and maintenance of such a complicated cellular
system is difficult and require large no. of skilled labour in each
and every regional office around the clock.
The requirement to meet the needs of both users as well as
operators in cost effective way require to add some intelligence
named as self organization (SO) [1].
will be
in term
energy
regular
cellular
2. SON OVERVIEW
Self organization can be defined in various ways, it is an
intelligence that is capable of taking decision. SON can be
defined as the network that continuously monitor, and if it
encounters any change in the system it will make intelligent
moves to reduce those changes which are undesired.
Figure 2.1 illustrate Self Organizing system. Self organized
mobile network consists mainly of three phases viz.
1.
Planning:
Planning phase deals with the location and
interconnection of all base station, devices and
different network equipment, related parameters etc.
2.
Configuration:
This phase deal with the configuration of base station
during the development of network system. Or it may
be required whenever there is a need to extend or
upgrade the network. In SON, network is made such
that after equipment installation it provides means of
detecting equipment and downloading software as per
need and also testing various equipment.
29
International Journal of Computer Applications (0975 – 8887)
Volume 114 – No. 13, March 2015
capable of reconfiguring their radiation pattern. Provisions for
this are obtained by MIMO techniques. Azimuth and tilt angle of
antenna is most important parameter as it determines the
direction of propagation of signal and controls the interference
capacity of system. There may be electrical tilt or mechanical
tilt. Electrical tilting provide better performance compared to
mechanical tilting in terms of interference. While the
performance is comparable if noise parameter is considered [6].
Few research in self configuration can be obtained in papers [7],
[8], and [9].
Self configuration of future cellular system in this way would
require increased signaling with the centralized server and its
complexity would increase with the number of nodes making it
less scalable [1].
4. SELF OPTIMIZATION
Fig.1 Self Organizing Network
3.
Operation:
In these phase, network optimization, monitoring and
maintenance is done. In a view to have an efficient
system, there should be continuous monitoring of
system for any faults and optimize system parameters.
3. SELF CONFIGURATION
Configuration of base station and interconnection is required
after installation process. Configuration may also be required if
there is some fault in the system, or system need to be upgraded,
also when there is degrade in performance of the system. In
future cellular system there should be some intelligence which
perform all this task more efficiently compared to manual
configuration which require skilled labour in large number. F.
Parodi et Al. has presented self configuration of future LTE
system. In this paper problems associated with autonomous
setup of new node is projected. Node should self configure their
IP address, radio access parameter, neighbor cell list [3].
As the new node is deployed, it will scan its neighbour cell and
generates neighbour cell list. From this list it will select a
sponsor node. New node will make connection with the
configuration server using this sponsor node. Once a connection
is made new node will start downloading all software from
configuration server and IP addresses too [4]. The node will then
be in a full operation mode. Initial location dependent Radio
access parameters are obtained from the current setting of the
sponsor node [1].
Frequency allocation is one radio access parameter in self
configuration of future cellular network. For the deployment of
relays, pico cells determining the MAC layer (Media Access
Control) frequency channel that causes least interference to
existing nodes and which still provides enough bandwidth to
achieve the desired throughput is still an open research issue [1].
The decentralized medium access protocol proposed in [5]
shows that the proposed MAC protocol is capable of operating
in the worst case scenario of no frequency and eNB location
planning [1].
Propagation parameter configuration is another radio access
parameter. Network performance is highly affected by antenna
parameters, their gain and power. Although omnidirectional and
sectorised antenna are best suited in today’s cellular system
because of fixed radiation pattern yet there should be the
deployment of smart antenna in future cellular system which is
Every base station contains hundreds of configuration
parameters that control various aspects of the cell site. Each of
these can be altered to change network behavior, based on
observations of both the base station itself, and measurements at
the mobile station or handset. One of the first SON features
establishes neighbor relations automatically (ANR), while others
optimize random access parameters or mobility robustness in
terms of handover oscillations. A very illustrative use case is the
automatic switch-off of a percent of base stations during the
night hours. The neighboring base station would then reconfigure their parameters in order to keep the entire area
covered by signal. In case of a sudden growth in connectivity
demand for any reason, the "sleeping" base stations "wake up"
almost instantaneously. This mechanism leads to significant
energy savings for operators.
4.1 Reasons for self-optimizing networks
One of the major elements within SON optimization techniques
that can be used. As the environment for the base station, eNB
may change after installation and configuration, there is a need
to continue to optimize the operation on a regular basis.
Some of the reasons for a change in the environment may be:
1.
Change in propagation characteristics:
SON
optimization of the network can help take out the
effects of any changes to the propagation conditions.
These could arise from new buildings going up, or
coming down etc. Even changes resulting from leaves
falling in autumn can have a significant effect.
2.
Change in traffic patterns: As time progresses usage
patterns may change. This could result from increased
concentrations of users, from new housing, changes
resulting from more people being on holiday, schools
being on vacation, or any one of many hundreds of
reasons. These can result in further optimization being
required to re-asses the best operational characteristics
for the base station, eNB.
3.
Change in deployments: There could be many
reasons for the change in deployments in the area.
Other base stations, eNBs could have been optimized
and changed their characteristics, alternatively new
base stations may have been deployed and their
operation could affect that of others.
These reasons all mean that help for the maximum efficiency of
self optimizing.
30
International Journal of Computer Applications (0975 – 8887)
Volume 114 – No. 13, March 2015
4.2 Areas for cellular network optimization
There are many areas of cellular networks that can be optimized.
Some cellular network optimization schemes operate on
elements of the network. Other schemes may adopt to optimize
the cellular network as a whole. However for the sake of looking
at cellular network optimization there are two main areas that
can be considered:
1.
general self healing flow which is categorized in monitoring,
diagnosis, and compensation.
1.
Cell outage means dip in the performance operation of
system. In future, cellular system must employ
intelligent detection scheme so that outage can be
cleared remotely. This will reduce the manual effort as
well as time. Faults may be in the piece of equipment
or it can be interference or coverage problem etc.
When alarm is triggered, it should be correctly
diagnosed. In [10] Bayesian approach is used for
automated diagnosis of fault in UMTS networks.
Expert system built according to this Bayesian
approach have many advantages compared to other
techniques used in other application for diagnosis.
Bayesian network efficiently model the uncertainty
inherent to human reasoning [11].
Air interface Core network
These element of the network may be optimized
separately, or many newer networks are combining
these functions to enable a far greater level of
flexibility to be obtained in optimization and "healing"
when problems occur.
2.
Self Optimizing Networks
With network optimization now playing a major
element of many networks, a form of network
optimization known as Self-Optimizing Networks
(SON) is growing feature in network planning and
optimization.
Standards
bodies,
equipment
representatives and mobile operators are now working
to set the standards for self optimizing networks.
Self optimizing networks, SON are seen as a key feature of the
evolving cellular network architectures and as a result they are
seen as a key feature in the next generation networks.
4.3 Self-optimizing network functionality:
There are a number of areas where self-optimization of the
network is undertaken.
a) Mobility robustness optimization
b) Mobility load balancing and traffic steering
c) Energy saving
d) Coverage and capacity optimization
e) RACH optimization
5. SELF HEALING
Faults and failure are very often in Wireless cellular system.
The reason for this may be some natural disaster, improper
function of any component etc. And this failures are software or
hardware related and require personnel round the clock.
In present time, if there is fault in the system alarm will trigger
and this are mainly determined by centralized O and M software.
As the size and complexity of system is ever increasing, even
with reliable hardware and software there are certain faults that
are not cleared remotely and require personnel. To clear such
failures and faults engineers are mobilized to cell site for fault
compensation. This process could take days or weeks for
problem recovery. Even in some cases, there are faults which are
not even detected or determined by OnM until and unless a
customer lodged a complaint and will lead to end user
experience suboptimal service level or no service at all. If not
given proper service, users may switch to competing network
operator. Hence fault management also called as troubleshooting
(TS) is a key aspect of cellular system in a competitive
environment.
In future cellular system this process has to be improved by
incorporating self-healing process. In this process fault if
occurred in any node due to any natural calamity or any other
breakdown will be out of service using the flow given by Aliu et
al. fault is automatically detected and diagnosed and proper
compensation technique will be given. Aliu et al. has presented a
Self Detection
2.
Self Compensation
Self Compensation action to be taken is largely
dependent over the type of fault encountered in
system. Compensation action involve reconfiguration
or optimization that is by changing the antenna tilt or
increasing power level for proper coverage. To
achieve this there is need to continuously monitor the
system for any error or fault and as soon as the fault is
occurred alarm will be triggered. Depending over the
type of faults proper compensation action is taken. It is
desired to produce the simulation results to show that
the compensation action is halted when the fault is
being cleared.
6. FUTURE WORK
Self organization in future cellular network is very effective and
must be employed in cellular system so as to make system much
more reliable even if the network is complex. But still there is
lot to do to make cellular network with Self organization
intelligence realistic. As in self configuration, newly deployed
node generate cell list from neighbouring node and download all
software. While allocating frequency to newly deployed node it
should have enough bandwidth with least interference. Tilt angle
and power of node is also one of the challenging issue. In selfhealing whenever a fault occur alarm will trigger and fault
diagnosis is done by system itself. Here the main issue is there is
need to continuously monitoring the system even if there is no
fault. This will consume energy hence there should way in
which system is monitored after some interval which will save
energy. Again when the appropriate compensation technique is
generated and fault is recovered the process should be halted .
7. CONCLUSION
Self organization in future mobile network is powerful technique
which in future going to decrease operating capital and
personnel even with increased complexity. In this paper, we
presented the requirement and benefits of employing self
organization in future cellular network. Although there is large
number of paper on self organizing network yet there is areas in
which lot has to be done before deployment of SON in cellular
system. Also we have presented SO network in three different
categories viz. self organization, self optimization and selfhealing and related parameters with it. Lastly areas in which
more research need to be done is discussed.
31
International Journal of Computer Applications (0975 – 8887)
Volume 114 – No. 13, March 2015
8. REFERENCES
[1] Osianoh Aliu “A survey of Self Organisation in Future
Cellular
Network”,
IEEE
COMMUNICATIONS
SURVEYS & TUTORIALS, VOL. 15, NO. 1, FIRST
QUARTER 2013.
[11] R. M. Khanafer, B. Solana, J. Triola, R. Barco, L. Moltsen,
Z. Altman, and P. Lazaro, “Automated diagnosis for UMTS
networks using bayesian network approach,” IEEE Trans.
Veh. Technol., vol. 57, no. 4, pp. 2451–2461, 2008.
[2] M. B. Stefania Sesia, Issam Toufik, LTE - The UMTS
Long Term Evolution. From Theory to Practice. Wiley &
Sons Ltd., 2009.
[12] A. Eisenblatter, U. Turke, and C. Schmelz, “Selfconfiguration in lte radio networks: Automatic generation
of enodeb parameters,” in Proc.IEEE 73rd Vehicular
Technology Conf. (VTC Spring), 2011, pp. 1–3.
[3] F. Parodi, M. Kylvaja, G. Alford, J. Li, and J. Pradas, “An
automatic procedure for neighbor cell list definition in
cellular networks,” in Proc. IEEE Int. Symp. a World of
Wireless, Mobile and Multimedia Networks WoWMoM
2007, 2007, pp. 1–6.
[13] S. Das, H. Viswanathan, and G. Rittenhouse, “Dynamic
load balancing through coordinated scheduling in packet
data systems,” 22nd Annual Joint Conference of the IEEE
Computer and Communications. INFOCOM 2003., vol. 1,
pp. 786 – 796 vol.1, 2003.
[4] H. Hu, J. Zhang, X. Zheng, Y. Yang, and P. Wu, “Selfconfiguration and self-optimization for LTE networks,”
IEEE Commun. Mag., vol. 48, no. 2, pp. 94–100, 2010.
[14] C.-Y. Liao, F. Yu, V. Leung, and C.-J. Chang, “A novel
dynamic cell configuration scheme in next-generation
situation-aware CDMA networks,” Selected Areas in
Communications, IEEE Journal on,vol. 24, no. 1, pp. 16 –
25, 2006.
[5] P. Omiyi, H. Haas, and G. Auer, “Analysis of intercellular
timeslot allocation in self-organising wireless networks,” in
Personal, Indoor and Mobile Radio Communications, 2006
IEEE 17th International Symposium on, 11-14 2006, pp. 1
–5.
[6] O. Yilmaz, S. Hamalainen, and J. Hamalainen,
“Comparison of remote electrical and mechanical antenna
downtilt performance for 3GPP LTE,” in Proc. IEEE 70th
Vehicular Technology Conf. Fall (VTC 2009- Fall), 2009,
pp. 1–5.
[7] D. Kim, B. Shin, D. Hong, and J. Lim, “Self-configuration
of neighbor cell list utilizing E-UTRAN NodeB scanning in
LTE systems,” in Proc. 7th IEEE Consumer
Communications and Networking Conf. (CCNC), 2010, pp.
1–5.
[8] Temesvary, “Self-configuration of antenna tilt and power
for plug & play deployed cellular networks,” in Proc. IEEE
Wireless Communications and Networking Conf. WCNC
2009, 2009, pp. 1–6.
[9] C. Huan and X. Minghai, “Self-configuration model of
henb within lte,” in Proc. 12th IEEE Int Communication
Technology (ICCT) Conf, 2010, pp. 84–87.
[10] C. B. S. W. C. Mueller, M. Kaschub, “A cell outage
detection algorithm using neighbour cell list reports,”
International Workshop on Self- Organizing Systems, pp.
218 – 229, 2008.
IJCATM : www.ijcaonline.org
[15] A. Wang and V. Krishnamurthy, “Mobility enhanced smart
antenna adaptive sectoring for uplink capacity
maximization in CDMA cellular network,” IEE Trans.
Commun., vol. 56, no. 5, pp. 743 –753, May 2008.
[16] O. Tonguz and E. Yanmaz, “The mathematical theory of
dynamic load balancing in cellular networks,” IEEE Trans.
Mobile Computing, vol. 7,no. 12, pp. 1504 –1518, 2008.
[17] J. G. Andrews, “Interference cancellation for cellular
systems: a contemporary overview,” IEEE Wireless
Commun., vol. 12, no. 2, pp.19–29, 2005.
[18] T. Fujii and S. Nishioka, “Selective handover for traffic
balance in mobile radio communications,” IEEE
International Conference on Communications, pp. 1840 –
1846 vol.4, Jun. 1992.
[19] A. Imran, M. A. Imran, and R. Tafazolli, “A novel self
organizing framework for adaptive frequency reuse and
deployment in future cellular networks,” in Proc. IEEE 21st
Int Personal Indoor and Mobile Radio Communications
(PIMRC) Symp, 2010, pp. 2354–2359.
[20] S. Dixit and E. Yanmaz, “Self-organization of relaybased next generation radio access networks (RANs),” in
Personal Wireless Communications, 2005. ICPWC 2005.
2005 IEEE International Conference on, 23-25 2005, pp.
197 – 201.
32