ISSN 0972-1045
Vol. 14, No. 2, July-December, 2012
Appl Hort
Journal of
THE SOCIETY FOR ADVANCEMENT OF HORTICULTURE
JOURNAL OF APPLIED HORTICULTURE
Vol. 14, No. 2, July-December, 2012
CONTENTS
Effect of root substrates and seed cover materials on the germination and growth of
organic tomato transplants
—Kurt O. Taylor, Muchha R. Reddy, Carl E. Niedziela Jr., Mary M. Peet and Godfrey Gayle (USA)
83
Ginger juice enhanced growth of aromatic chilli during in vitro culture and acclimatization
—K. Bodhipadma, S. Noichinda, P. Luangsriumporn, C. Meenapa, K. Nathalang, and D.W.M. Leung
(Thailand/New Zealand)
88
Water retention characteristics of soil bio-amendments used as growing media in pot culture
—S.S. Kukal, Debasish Saha, Arnab Bhowmik and R.K. Dubey (India)
92
Isolation of biomolecules of pharmacological importance from Garcinia indica fruit
and evaluation of total antioxidant activity
—P. Gayathri and P. Govindaraju (India)
98
Postharvest microbial diversity on major cultivars of Indian mangoes
—S.N. Jha, Pranita Jaiswal, K. Narsaiah, Rishi Bhardwaj, Poonam Preet Kaur,
Ashish Kumar Singh, Rajiv Sharma and R. Kumar (India)
102
Effect of dehydration on keeping quality of white button mushroom,
Agaricus bisporus Lange (Sing.)
—M.P. Singh, H.S. Sodhi, A. Singh and P.K. Khanna (India)
110
Relationship of nutritional status of field grown Thompson Seedless grapevines
with powdery mildew incidence
—Jagdev Sharma, A.K. Upadhyay, Indu S. Sawant and S.D. Sawant (India)
114
Effect of growing media on seed germination and seedling growth of
papaya (Carica papaya) cv. ‘Red lady’
—R.L. Bhardwaj (India)
118
Effect of plant bio-regulators on physico-chemical characteristics of three apple varieties
during ambient storage
—B.L. Attri, Hare Krishna, B. Das, N. Ahmed and Akhilesh Kumar (India)
124
Influence of biofertilizers on plant growth, fruit yield, nutrition and rhizosphere microbial
activity of pomegranate (Punica granatum L.) cv. Kandhari Kabuli
—Muzaffar Mir and Som Dev Sharma (India)
129
Resistance evaluation of the pistachio rootstocks to Meloidogyne species in Iran
—Mehrdad Madani, Ahmad Akhiani, Mahmoud Damadzadeh and Ahmad Kheiri (Iran)
134
Biology and seasonal activity of semilooper, Dichromia orosia (Cramer)
(Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) on anthmool, Tylophora asthmatica Wight and Arn.
—L. Saravanan and Vipin Chaudhary (India)
139
Occurrence of false smut on date palm (Phoenix dactylifera L.) in the
southern coastal plains of Yemen
—M.H. Abdul Sattar, A. Rashid Yassin Ibrahim and Watheq A. Aulaqi (Yemen)
144
Resource use efficiency of orange and kinnow cultivation in Jammu region of
J&K state
—Jyoti Kachroo, Anil Bhat and Dileep Kachroo (India)
146
Enhancing water relations and vase life of cut tulip (Tulipa gesneriana L.) using
floral preservatives
—R. Kumar, N. Ahmed, D.B. Singh and O.C. Sharma (India)
152
Forthcoming Papers
Growth control and flower promotion of salvia with benzyladenine foliar sprays
—Dennis J. Carey, Barbara A. Fair, Wayne Buhler, Ingram McCall, and Brian E. Whipker (USA)
Characterization and biostimulation of benzene biodegradation in the potting-mix of indoor plants
—Torpy, F.R., P.J. Irga, D. Moldovan, J. Tarran and M.D. Burchett (Australia)
Differential response of citrus rootstocks to copper concentration in sand culture
—Joseph P. Albano, Kim D. Bowman, P. Chris Wilson and Michael G. Bausher (USA)
Transformation of cabbage (Brassica oleracea var. capitata) expressing a synthetic cry1F gene
resistant to diamondback moth (Plutella xylostella) Lepidoptera: Yponomeutidae
—H.M. Mahadeva Swamy, S.N. Nagesha, Riaz Mahmood, T.K.S. Gowda and R. Asokan (India)
Molecular biology of tomato spotted wilt virus: an update
—Saurabh Kulshrestha, Anshul Sharma and Chandrika Attri Seth (India)
Improvement of somatic embryogenesis and plant regeneration of seven date palm (Phoenix
dactylifera L.) cultivars: Effect of cytokinins and activated charcoal
—Mona M. Hassan, Ibrahim A. Ibrahim, Mohsen K.H. Ebrahim, Ewald Komor (Egypt)
Growth and development response of Antirrhinum to plant growing media
—Farhat Naz, Jalal-Ud-Din Baloch, M. Munir and A.A. Khakwani(UK & Pakistan)
Grafting onto African eggplant enhances growth, yield and fruit quality of tomatoes in tropical forest
ecozones
—G.O. Nkansah, A.K. Ahwireng, C. Amoatey and A.W. Ayarna (Ghana)
Ecophysiological performances of eight Jatropha curcas L. provenances cultivated in Tunisia
—Z. Nasr, M.L. Khouja, R. Aini, A. Hammadi, H. Manai and B. Mimouni (Tunisia)
Performance of different potato genotypes under aeroponics system
—Margaret Chiipanthenga, Moses Maliro, Joyce Njoloma, Paul Demo and Navin Khumar (Malawi)
Effect of irrigation levels on fruit quality of the Picual olive (Olea europaea L.) cultivar
— M.M. Khattab, A.E. Shaban, I. Hussein and O.H. Elgamaal (Egypt)
Overcoming the seasonality of production by growing two types of indeterminate tomato (Solanum
lycopersicum) varieties under cooled plastic house conditions in Sudan
—Randa B.M. Ali and Saifeldin Mohamed El-Amin (Sudan)
Seasonal changes in endogenous hormone and sugar contents during bud dormancy in tree peony
—Philip M.P. Mornya and Fangyun Cheng (China)
Assessment of strength of self-incompatibility in the S-allele lines of cabbage (Brassica oleracea var.
capitata L.)
—Saurabh Singh and Vidyasagar (India)
The role of avocado in coffee based farming system of south western Ethiopia: The case of Jimma
Zone
—Berhnau Megerssa (Ethiopia)
Effect of different growth media on the growth and flowering of beef steak Begonia (Begonia
erythrophylla)
—Henry A. Akintoye, Olusola O. AdeOluwa, Olukemi Y. Akinkunmi (Nigeria)
Growth, yield and nutrient uptake responses of snake tomato (Trichosanthes cucumerina L.) to
organo-mineral fertilizer rates and leaf harvest methods
—O.O. Olubode, R.I. Adedeji, and O.O. Oyegbola (Nigeria)
QTL analysis associated with oleoresin content in intraspecific RIL population of chilli (Capsicum
annuum L.)
—Neeraj Dwivedi, Rajesh Kumar, Rakesh Kumar Singh and Major Singh (India)
Journal
Journal of Applied Horticulture, 14(2): 83-87, 2012
Appl
Effe c t of root subst rat e s a nd se e d c ove r m at e ria ls on t he
ge r m inat ion a nd grow t h of orga nic t om at o t ra nspla nt s
Kur t O. Ta ylor a , M uchha R. Re ddy a * , Ca rl E. N ie dzie la J r. b , M a r y M . Pe e t c a nd Godfre y
Ga yle a
a
Department of Natural Resources and Environmental Design, North Carolina Agricultural and Technical State University,
1601 East Market Street, Greensboro, NC 27411. bSchool of Natural Sciences and Mathematics, Ferrum College, PO Box
1000, Ferrum, VA 24088. cNational Institute of Food and Agriculture, USDA, 800 9th Street SW, Washington, DC 200242220. *E-mail:
[email protected]
Abstract
In two experiments, seeds of tomato (Solanum esculentum L.) cultivar ‘Celebrity’ were planted in four root substrates (Grower’s Mix
20, Fafard 4P, Johnny’s 512 Select and Sunshine Planter’s) in 72-cell plastic plugs trays using different cover materials. In physical
property evaluations, the four substrates had similar total porosity. However, Johnny’s 512 Select had the highest container capacity
and bulk density while Fafard 4P and Sunshine Planter’s had the largest air space. There was some seasonal variation between the
germination and growth results of the two studies. The use of root substrate, coir, or vermiculite resulted in better germination than
leaving the seeds uncovered, with the exception of the seeds germinated in Johnny’s 512 Select in Experiment 1. Also, in Experiment 1,
tomato seedlings were the tallest and heaviest when grown in Grower’s Mix 20. Using newspaper to cover seeds reduced germination
in Experiment 2. Tomato seedlings grown in Grower’s Mix 20 and Johnny’s 512 Select were equal or greater in shoot height or weight
as compared to those grown in the conventional substrate Fafard 4P.
Introduction
U.S. demand for organic foods and beverages has increased from
$1 billion in 1990 to $24.8 in 2009 (Organic Trade Association,
2010). Organic food and beverage sales in 2009 increased 5.1
percent above 2008 sales. The largest sales increase in 2009 was
in organic fruit and vegetable sales, which increased 11.4 percent
above 2008.
To be certified as organic, farms must use organically produced
seeds and transplants (National Organic Program, 2012).
However, these transplants are expensive and difficult to produce.
Cantliffe (1998) concluded that optimizing seed germination is a
critical step to ensure economic returns in a transplant operation,
but relatively little work has been performed on optimizing
germination in substrates approved for organic production.
Russo (2005) compared shoot height and dry weight of bell
pepper, onion, and watermelon transplants grown in approved
organic substrates to conventional substrates. Arancon et al. (2003
and 2004) and Atiyeh et al. (2000) conducted studies on the effect
of vermicompost as a rooting substrate component on emergence
and growth of a wide range of seedlings, including tomato. Larrea
(2006) suggested that covering the seed with vermiculite might
have increased germination in organic substrates containing
vermicompost; however, this hypothesis was not tested in a sideby-side comparison of germination rates.
Compost and other organic materials are commonly used on
organic and sustainable farms as a soil conditioner and source
of mineral nutrients. One barrier to large-scale use of compost
and similar soil amendments from waste materials is the need
for consistent and predictable quality (Baarth, 1999). Arancon
et al. (2004) stated that there are possible adverse environmental
and economic impacts of agrichemicals on ornamental plant
production and suggested a greater utilization of organic
amendments such as composts or vermicompost for greenhouse
production of bedding plants. With decreased use of synthetic
nutrient sources, which are typically applied in a more soluble
form than organic sources, the run-off of nitrogen (N), phosphorus
(P) and potassium (K) could potentially be reduced.
The use of a seed cover material provides the small-scale farmer
with a technique that may improve germination; however,
studies on the use of cover materials other than the substrate
itself to increase germination are limited. Materials with unique
properties, such as coconut coir and vermiculite, need to be
evaluated for cover materials in organic transplant production.
Coconut (Cocos nucifera L.) coir dust is an agricultural waste
product that is produced from the mesocarp or husk of the coconut
(Evans et al., 1998). There is limited research on the effectiveness
of coconut coir as a seed cover material. Vermiculite is frequently
used for this purpose.
This research was conducted to provide research-based results
on organic transplant production to meet the growing demand for
organically and sustainably-grown produce. The main objectives
of this study were: 1) to compare the effects of commercial
and custom organically blended substrates on tomato seed
germination and growth and 2) to evaluate coconut coir and
vermiculite as seed cover materials on tomato seed germination
in organic transplants production.
Complementary Copy
Key words: Solanum esculentum, vermicompost, feather meal, kelp meal, seedlings, root media.
Effect of root substrates and seed cover materials on the germination and growth of organic tomato
Materials and methods
Two experiments were conducted in the Reid Greenhouse at
North Carolina Agricultural and Technical State University in
Greensboro, NC, USA (36° N latitude). Temperatures were set
at day and night minimums of 25 and 21°C, respectively. Tomato
(Solanum esculentum ‘Celebrity’) seeds were germinated and
grown in 72-cell trays (Landmark Plastic Corp., Akron, OH) in
both experiments. Plants were watered as needed based on the
physical appearance of the substrate and seedlings.
Four substrates were selected for both experiments: a conventional,
commercial transplant substrate (Fafard 4P, Conrad Fafard, Inc.,
Agawam, MA), two commercial organic substrates (Sunshine
Planter’s, Sun Gro Horticulture, Bellevue, WA and Johnny’s
512 Select, Johnny’s Selected Seeds, Winslow, ME), and a
modified organic substrate mixed for this research (Grower’s Mix
20). Fafard 4P contained 45% Canadian sphagnum peat moss
combined with aged pine bark, vermiculite, Dolomitic limestone,
gypsum, wetting agent, starter nutrients, and slow release nitrogen
(Fafard Product Guide, 2011). Johnny’s 512 Select was a blend of
sphagnum and sedge peat mosses, compost, and perlite (Johnny’s
Selected Seeds, 2012). The Grower’s Mix 20 components and
mixing specifications were adopted from Larrea (2006). Grower’s
Mix 20 was a 4 peat: 1 perlite (v/v) amended with feather meal
(Boer Commodities.Inc., Fresno, CA) and kelp meal (Algit, P.B.
Ohrstrom & Sons Inc., Arlington Heights IL) at 19.53 and 8.40
L.m-3, respectively.
Tomato seeds were sown on 21 Aug. and 6 Dec. 2007 for
Experiments 1 and 2, respectively. In Experiment 1, each 72cell tray was covered with one of the four seed cover materials:
vermiculite (Peaceful Valley, Grass Valley, CA), coconut coir
(Down to Earth Distributors, Eugene, OR), the same substrate in
which the seed were planted, or left uncovered. In Experiment 2,
a single layer of wet newspaper was added as a fifth seed cover
material treatment over uncovered seeds. The wet newspaper
remained over the flat until ten days after cotyledons were visible
(20 Dec).
Sample and data collection: Samples of the soilless substrates
were collected for physical properties prior to planting.
Germination data were collected on 31 Aug. and 20 Dec. in
Experiments 1 and 2, respectively. Germination percentage was
calculated as the total number of seedlings that emerged divided by
the total number of seed sown multiplied by 100 (Bradford, 1986).
Height was measured on 20 randomly selected transplants from
each flat on 18 Sept 2007 (18 days after sowing) and 3 Jan 2008
(14 days after sowing) in Experiments 1 and 2, respectively.
Shoot tissue was sampled by cutting the stem at the base of 20
transplants using a hand pruner. Plant samples were collected 28 days
after sowing in Experiment 1 and 18, 32 and 39 days after sowing
in Experiment 2. The composited fresh weight of the 20 sample
transplants was recorded. Plant samples were rinsed in distilled water
for 30 s. The samples were then placed in brown paper bags and
dried at 70°C in a forced air oven until a constant weight was
attained (approximately 48 h). The dry weight of each sample
was then recorded. Dry plant samples were ground to pass a 1 mm
screen (20-mesh) using the Thomas-Wiley Laboratory Stainless
Steel Mill Model No. 4 (Thomas Scientific, Philadelphia).
Substrate and tissue analyses: All substrates were analyzed for
physical properties (total porosity, container capacity, air space
and bulk density) in the Horticultural Substrates Laboratory at
North Carolina State University using the procedures described
by Fonteno (1996).
Nitrogen was determined on 10 mg plant tissue samples with
a Perkin Elmer 2400 CHN elemental analyzer (Norwalk, CT).
Another 0.5 mg sample was placed in the Erlenmeyer flask for
dry ashing. The sample was then placed in the Muffle Furnace
for eight hours at 550 °C (Mills and Jones, 1996). Nitric acid
(2.5mL) was added to the ash. The Erlenmeyer flask was then
rinsed twice and filtered in a 50 mL volumetric flask. The
ash solution was diluted to 50 mL with deionized water. The
sample was then analyzed for potassium (K), phosphorous
(P), calcium (Ca) and magnesium (Mg), using an Inductively
Coupled Plasma Spectrometer (ICP-OES; Perkin-Elmer Optima
3300DV, Norwalk, CT). All tissue analyses were conducted at
the Analytical Services Laboratory, School of Agriculture and
Environmental Sciences, NC A&T State Univ.
Experimental design and statistical analysis: Experiment 1 was
a factorial design with four substrates and four cover materials
arranged in a randomized complete block with four replications
for a total of 64 experimental units (72-cell flats). Experiment 2
was a factorial design with four substrates and five cover materials
arranged in a randomized complete block with four replications
for a total of 80 experimental units (72-cell flats). Data were
subjected to analysis of variance using PROC ANOVA (SAS 9.3,
SAS Inst., Cary, NC). Means were separated using the Fisher’s
Protected LSD test at the 0.05 level of significance.
Results and discussion
Substrate physical properties: Total porosity was similar for the
four root substrates (Table 1). Container capacity was greatest in
Johnny’s 512 Select followed by Grower’s Mix 20 and least in
Fafard 4P and Sunshine Planter’s. Air space was greatest in Fafard
4P and Sunshine Planter’s, intermediate in Grower’s Mix 20, and
least in Johnny’s 512 Select. Bulk density varied from greatest to
least in the following order: Johnny’s 512 Select, Grower’s Mix
20, Fafard 4P, and Sunshine Planter’s.
Table 1. Total porosity, container capacity, air space and bulk density of
four root substrates used for growing ‘Celebrity’ tomato transplants
Substratez
Porosity
Container Air Space
Bulk
capacity
(% by
density
(% by
volume) (% by volume) volume) (g.cm-3)
Grower’s Mix 20
88.37
76.73
11.57
0.17
Fafard 4P
87.60
70.23
17.37
0.14
Sunshine Planter’s
87.37
70.40
16.97
0.09
Johnny’s 512 Select
86.93
80.53
2.16
6.43
2.14
0.26
0.03
LSD0.05
NS
z
Grower’s Mix 20, Sunshine Planter’s and Johnny’s 512 Select were
substrates formulated to meet the National Organic Standards for
transplant production. Fafard 4P was a substrate used commercially for
conventional transplant production.
Transplant production practices, such as frequency of irrigation,
must be adjusted based on a root substrate’s physical properties
and vice versa (Nelson, 2011). For example, root substrates
with a high container capacity and low percent air space, such
Complementary Copy
84
Effect of root substrates and seed cover materials on the germination and growth of organic tomato
85
as Johnny’s 512 Select, require less frequent watering during
plant production and retain more water during plant shipping and
marketing. However, greater care is required with these substrates
that plants are not over-watered during production. Well-drained
substrates such as Fafard 4P and Sunshine Planter’s, require more
frequent irrigations, which also affects the leaching of nutrients.
The greater bulk density of Johnny’s 512 Select may also increase
the shipping cost for the bulk substrate and finished transplants.
There was no root substrate x seed cover material interaction
or cover material effect on the shoot height. The tallest plants
were recorded in Grower’s Mix 20 followed by Fafard 4P and
Johnny’s 512 Select (Table 2). The shortest plants were produced
in Sunshine Planter’s.
There was a root substrate x seed cover material interaction effect
on shoot dry weight. With all four cover materials, shoots were
heaviest in Grower’s Mix 20 and lightest in Sunshine Planter’s
(Fig. 1B). Within plants grown in Fafard 4P and Sunshine
Planter’s, plants had similar dry weights regardless of seed cover
material. In Grower’s Mix 20, plants from seeds covered with
vermiculite were heavier than those covered with coir or left
uncovered. However, in Johnny’s 512 Select, plants from seeds
covered with vermiculite were lighter than those covered with
substrate or coir and those left uncovered weighed less than those
covered with substrate.
There was no root substrate x seed cover material interaction
or cover material effect on the shoot nutrient concentrations.
Nutrient concentration data is shown in Table 2. Shoot N
Table 2. Effect of root substrate on the shoot height and nutrient
concentrations of ‘Celebrity’ tomato transplants at 28 days after planting
in Experiment 1
Height
N
P
K
Ca
Mg
Substratez
(cm)
(%)
(%)
(%)
(%)
(%)
Grower’s Mix 20
31.9
3.50
0.97
3.17
1.78
0.55
Fafard 4P
19.4
2.05
0.50
2.94
1.15
0.68
Sunshine Planter’s
4.9
2.01
0.23
0.56
1.09
0.62
Johnny’s 512 Select 19.6
3.90
0.60
2.96
1.83
0.32
LSD0.05
1.3
1.01
0.08
0.39
0.24
0.08
z
Grower’s Mix 20, Sunshine Planter’s, and Johnny’s 512 Select were
substrates formulated to meet the National Organic Standards for
transplant production. Fafard 4P was a substrate used commercially for
conventional transplant production.
Fig. 1. Germination and shoot dry weight of ‘Celebrity’ tomato transplants
in four root substrates (Grower’s Mix 20, Fafard 4P, Sunshine Planter’s,
and Johnny’s 512 Select) in combination with four seed cover materials
in Experiment 1. Vertical bars indicate LSD0.05 for comparing root
substrate within each seed cover material or for comparing seed cover
materials within each root substrate.
concentration was higher in plants grown in Grower’s Mix 20 and
Johnny’s 512 Select than those grown in Fafard 4P and Sunshine
Planter’s. Shoot P concentration went from highest to lowest
in the following order: Grower’s Mix 20, Johnny’s 512 Select,
Fafard 4P, and Sunshine Planter’s. Shoot K was lower in plants
grown in Sunshine Planter’s than the other three root substrates.
Shoot Ca concentration was higher in plants grown in Grower’s
Mix 20 and Johnny’s 512 Select than those grown in Fafard 4P
and Sunshine Planter’s. Plants grown in Johnny’s 512 Select had
the lowest shoot Mg concentration and plants grown in Gower’s
Mix 20 had a lower shoot Mg concentration than those grown
in Fafard 4P.
Experiment 2: There was no root substrate x seed cover material
interaction effect on seed germination. However, seed germination
rate was greater in Sunshine Planter’s and Johnny’s 512 Select
than Grower’s Mix 20 (Table 3). Also, seed germination rate was
greater using the root substrate, coir or vermiculite than with
newspaper or uncovered seeds (Table 4).
There was no root substrate x seed cover material interaction
effect on shoot height. However, plants grown in Sunshine
Planter’s were shorter than those in the other three substrates
(Table 3). Also, plants were taller when seeds were covered
with vermiculite than when seed were not covered and plants
Complementary Copy
Experiment 1: There was a root substrate x seed cover material
interaction effect on seed germination. In Johnny’s 512 Select,
seed germination was similar for coir, vermiculite, and no cover
(Fig. 1A). However, using the Johnny’s 512 Select substrate as a
cover resulted in a lower germination rate than with vermiculite.
In Sunshine Planter’s, not covering seeds resulted in the lowest
germination rate. In Fafard 4P, the uncovered seeds germinated
at a similar rate to those covered with coir but a lower rate than
those covered with the substrate or vermiculite. In Grower’s Mix
20, seeds covered with vermiculite or uncovered germinated
at a lower rate than those covered with the substrate or coir.
These results indicate that the best choice of cover material for
germinating tomato seeds was dependent on the root substrate.
Johnny’s 512 Select was a heavier substrate with greater container
capacity and bulk density, the germinating seedlings benefited
from being covered by the lighter vermiculite or leaving the
seeds uncovered in Experiment 1. Whereas, the other substrates
were lighter and more prone to drying out so leaving the seeds
uncovered was detrimental.
86
Effect of root substrates and seed cover materials on the germination and growth of organic tomato
Table 3. Effect of root substrate on the germination rate, shoot height, and shoot nutrient concentrations of ‘Celebrity’ tomato transplants at 32 days
after planting in Experiment 2
Germination (%) Height (cm)
N (%)
P(%)
K(%)
Ca(%)
Mg(%)
Substratez
Grower’s Mix 20
84.4
14.6
5.36
0.15
1.61
0.39
0.15
Fafard 4P
88.2
13.9
3.68
0.08
0.96
0.17
0.15
Sunshine Planter’s
90.6
4.2
3.19
0.08
0.62
0.39
0.25
Johnny’s 512 Select
89.8
13.4
4.55
0.13
1.61
0.71
0.16
LSD0.05
4.3
1.4
1.96
0.06
0.63
0.21
0.05
z
Grower’s Mix 20, Sunshine Planter’s, and Johnny’s 512 Select were substrates formulated to meet the National Organic Standards for transplant
production. Fafard 4P was a substrate used commercially for conventional transplant production.
Table 4. Effect of seed cover material on the germination rate and shoot
height of ‘Celebrity’ tomato transplants at 32 days after planting in
Experiment 2
Cover
Substratez
Coir
Vermiculite
No cover
Newspaper
LSD0.05
Germination (%)
92.9
89.9
90.7
83.9
83.8
4.8
Height (cm)
12.0
12.3
12.6
10.9
9.8
1.5
z
The substrate used for the seed cover material was the same as the
respective root substrate material.
There was a root substrate x seed cover material interaction effect
on shoot dry weight (Fig. 2). Plants grown in Sunshine Planter’s
were lighter than those grown in the other three substrates
regardless of seed cover material. Plants grown in Grower’s Mix
20 and Sunshine Planter’s had similar dry weights regardless of
seed cover material. In Fafard and Johnny’s 512 Select, plants
grown from seed covered with coir or vermiculite were heavier
than those with other three cover materials.
There was no root substrate x seed cover material interaction
or cover material effect on the shoot nutrient concentrations
(Table 3). Shoot N concentration was higher in plants grown in
Grower’s Mix 20 than those grown in Sunshine Planter’s. Shoot
P concentration was higher in plants grown in Grower’s Mix 20
than those grown in Fafard 4P and Sunshine Planter’s. Shoot K
concentration was higher in plants grown in Grower’s Mix 20 and
Johnny’s 512 Select than those grown in Fafard 4P and Sunshine
Planter’s. Shoot Ca concentration was highest in plants grown in
Johnny’s 512 Select followed by Grower’s Mix 20 and Sunshine
Planter’s and lowest in those grown in Fafard 4P. Shoot Mg
concentration was higher in plants grown in Sunshine Planter’s
than the other three substrates.
Differences in the results between the two experiments can be
attributed to seasonal variation. Experiment 1 was begun in
August when daylengths were longer than 12 hours, light levels
were high, and greenhouse temperatures were hot. Experiment 2
was conducted in December and January when daylengths were
shortest, light levels were low, and greenhouse temperatures were
cooler. Thus, tomato seedlings were taller and weighed more in
Experiment 1 than Experiment 2.
Although total porosity was similar between the four root
substrates tested, container capacity and bulk density were
greatest in Johnny’s 512 Select and air space was greatest in
Fafard 4P and Sunshine Planter’s. The use of root substrate,
coir, or vermiculite resulted in better germination than leaving
the seeds uncovered, with the exception of the seeds germinated
in Johnny’s 512 Select in Experiment 1. Using newspaper to
cover seeds also reduced germination. Tomato seedlings grown
in Grower’s Mix 20 and Johnny’s 512 Select were equal or
greater in shoot height or weight as compared to those grown in
a conventional substrate (Fafard 4P).
Acknowledgements
This paper is a portion of a thesis submitted by K.O. Taylor. This
research was supported in part by the NCA&TSU Agricultural
Research Program (Evans-Allen Funds). The use of trade names
in this publication does not imply endorsement or criticism of the
products named, or criticism of similar ones not mentioned.
References
Fig. 2. Shoot dry weight of ‘Celebrity’ tomato transplants in four root
substrates (Grower’s Mix 20, Fafard 4P, Sunshine Planter’s, and Johnny’s
512 Select) in combination with five seed cover materials in Experiment
2. Vertical bars indicate LSD0.05 for comparing root substrate within
each seed cover material or for comparing seed cover materials within
each root substrate.
Arancon, N.Q., C.A. Edwards, P. Bierman, J.D. Metzger, S. Lee
and C. Welch, 2003. Effects of vermicomposts on growth and
marketable fruits of field-grown tomatoes, peppers and strawberries.
Pedobiologia, 47: 731-735.
Arancon, N.Q., C.A. Edwards, R. Atiyeh and J.D. Metzger, 2004. Effects
of vermicompost produced from food waste on the growth and
yields of greenhouse peppers. Bioresource. Technol., 93: 139-144.
Atiyeh, R.M., C.A. Edwards, S. Subler and J.D. Metzger, 2000.
Earthworm-processed organic wastes as components of horticultural
potting media for growing marigold and vegetables. Compost Sci.
Utilization, 8: 215-223.
Baarth, J. 1999. Compost quality, quality assurance and use: the basis
for sustainable organic waste management in Europe. Proceedings
of the International Composting Symposium. (P.R.Warman and B.R.
Taylor, ed.), 1: 14-31.
Complementary Copy
were taller when seeds were covered with root substrate, coir or
vermiculite than when covered with newspaper (Table 4).
Effect of root substrates and seed cover materials on the germination and growth of organic tomato
Larrea, E.S. 2006. Optimizing Substrates for Organic Tomato Transplant
Production. M.S. Thesis., North Carolina State University, 2006.
87 pp.
Mills, A.H. and J.B. Jones, 1996. Plant Analysis Handbook II: A
Practical Sampling, Preparation, Analysis, and Interpretation Guide.
MicroMacro Publishing, Inc, Athens, Georgia.
Nelson, P.V. 2011. Greenhouse Operation and Management. 7th Ed.
Prentice-Hall, Upper Saddle River, New Jersey.
Organic Trade Association, 2010. 2010 Organic Industry Survey. Organic
Trade Assn., Brattleboro, VT.
Russo, V.M. 2005. Organic vegetable transplant production. HortScience
40: 623-628.
Received: May, 2012; Revised: October, 2012; Accepted: October, 2012
Complementary Copy
Bradford, K.J. 1986. Manipulation of seed water relations via osmotic
priming to improve germination under stress conditions. HortScience
21: 1105-1112.
Cantliffe, D. J. 1998. Seed germination for transplants. HortTechnology,
8: 499-503.
Evans, M.R., J.N. Smith and R.A. Cloyd, 1998. Fungus gnat population
development in coconut coir and sphagnum peat based substrates.
HortTechnology, 8: 406-408.
Fonteno, W.C., 1996. Growing media: Types and physical/chemical
properties. In: A Grower’s Guide to Water, Media, and Nutrition for
Greenhouse Crops. Ed. D.W. Reed.: Ball Publishing, Batavia, IL.
Johnny’s Selected Seeds, 2012. <http://www.johnnyseeds.com/p-6693johnnys-512-mix-og-2-yard-bulk.aspx>
87
Journal
Journal of Applied Horticulture, 14(2): 88-91, 2012
Appl
Ginge r juic e e nha nc e d grow t h of a rom at ic chilli during in vit ro
c ult ure a nd a c clim at izat ion
K . Bodhipa dm a a , S. N oichinda a , P. Lua ngsrium por n a , C. M e e na pa a , K . N at ha la ng b
a nd D.W.M . Le ung c *
a
Department of Agro-Industrial Technology, Faculty of Applied Science, King Mongkut’s University of Technology North
Bangkok, Bangsue, Bangkok 10800 Thailand. bDepartment of Biology, Faculty of Science, Mahidol University, Rama VI
Rd., Rajathevi District, Bangkok 10400, Thailand. cSchool of Biological Sciences, University of Canterbury, Private Bag
4800, Christchurch 8140, New Zealand. *E-mail:
[email protected]
Abstract
Stem explants excised from seedlings of aromatic chilli (Capsicum frutescens L) grown under aseptic conditions were cultured on
basal medium alone (control), and basal medium supplemented with 5, 10 or 20 mL/L juice of ginger rhizome of 6 or 10 months old
(herein referred to as YGE and OGE, respectively). At the end of 6 weeks of culture, the average number of roots formed per stem
explant was higher when cultured on media supplemented with the three different levels of YGE or OGE (except 5 mL/L) compared
to the control. Roots, formed in stem explants cultured on media containing the different levels of YGE (except 20 mL/L) and OGE,
were longer than those cultured on basal medium. Particularly notable was that the average length of roots formed in stem explants
cultured on medium supplemented with 5 mL/L OGE was more than double that of the control. Prior culture on media containing
the different levels of YGE had no promotive effect on the number of leaves per exflasked plantlet compared to the control at the end
of three weeks of acclimatization but the plantlets cultured previously on 5 or 10 mL/L YGE were taller than the control. The best
performance of plantlets regarding leaf number and stem height after acclimatization was exhibited by those cultured previously on
medium containing 10 mL/L OGE as they had at least 20% more leaves and were taller than the control.
Introduction
substances that can be sourced locally such as ginger rhizomes
in Thailand for micropropagation of plants. Chemical analysis of
ginger juice has shown that it has antimicrobial potential and it is
a good source of antioxidants, carbohydrates and some minerals
(Shirin and Prakash, 2010). Here, we evaluated the hypothesis
that different concentrations of ginger juice had some beneficial
effect not only on in vitro culture but also on acclimatization of
exflasked aromatic chilli plantlets. In addition, the effect of juice
from ginger rhizome of two different ages was compared as it
might be possible that biological activity could vary with different
ages of ginger rhizomes.
Many complex food extracts have been added to plant tissue
culture medium for different purposes. For example, there
are reports showing use of banana and apple juice to promote
growth of cymbidium protocorms (Kusumoto and Furukawa,
1977), pineapple juice for plantlet development of several orchid
species (Kitsaki et al., 2004), coconut water and tomato juice
for shoot multiplication from encapsulated buds of Pogostemon
cablin (Swamy et al., 2009), banana extract for rapid plant
regeneration of Dendrobium lituiflorum (Vyas et al., 2009), yeast
extract, casein hydrolysate and potato extract for callus induction
of Stevia rebaudiana (Das and Mandal, 2010) and sugarcane
juice for shoot proliferation and growth of Pogostemon cablin
and bananas (Swamy et al., 2010; Buah et al., 2011). Rooting
of shoots derived from juvenile stem explants of avocado was
promoted in medium supplemented with peptone and an auxin
(NAA or 1-naphthlene acetic acid) but not with the auxin alone
(Nhut et al., 2008). There is no report on use of complex natural
substances to improve performance of exflasked plantlets during
acclimatization, particularly, if these substances are commonly
available at a relatively low cost. This is an important practical
objective of micropropagation of plants.
Materials and methods
In our preliminary work, a protocol was developed for
regenerating plantlets from stem explants of aromatic chilli, an
important ingredient in many Thai cusine. It is of interest to the
plant production industry to find low-cost natural organic complex
Preparation of ginger juice: Ginger rhizomes (Zingiber
officinale Rosc. Cv. Yai) of about 6- and 10-months old, herewith
referred to as young and old ginger rhizomes, respectively, were
purchased from a local market in the Nonthaburi province,
Plant materials and surface-sterilization: Seeds of aromatic
chilli (Capsicum frutescens L.) were purchased from Thai Seed
and Agriculture Co., Ltd., Bangkok, Thailand. The following
sequence of steps was carried out to surface-sterilize the seeds:
(1) soaking in distilled water overnight, (2) washing briefly with
tap water and liquid soap, (3) immersing in 15% (v/v) Clorox
(a commercial bleach solution containing 5.25% (w/w) sodium
hypochlorite as available chlorine) for 15 min, (4) 10% (v/v)
Clorox containing 3-4 drops of Tween-20 for 5 min, and (5)
rinsing 3 times (1 min each time) with sterile distilled water.
Complementary Copy
Key words: Acclimatization, aromatic chilli, ginger juice, root elongation, root induction
Ginger juice enhanced growth of aromatic chilli during in vitro culture and acclimatization
Germination of seeds, explant preparation and culture:
Surface-sterilized aromatic chilli seeds were placed onto basal
MS (Murashige and Skoog, 1962) medium gelled with 0.9% agar
(w/v) and kept under 16 h of illumination with white fluorescent
lamps (47.31 μmol/m2/s light intensity) and 8 h of darkness in a
growth room at 25±2 °C. After 3 weeks of culture, stem explants
(2 cm long comprising the shoot tip and 2-3 nodes) were excised
from aromatic chilli seedlings which were approximately 3 to 4
cm tall. These explants (one per culture jar and there were six
replications) were transferred to MS medium supplemented with
different concentrations (5, 10 and 20 mL/L ) of juice from young
and old ginger rhizomes. The pH of all the media was adjusted
to 5.6 before they were autoclaved. The cultures were kept for 6
weeks under the same conditions as already described for aseptic
germination of the surfaced-sterilized seeds.
Plantlet acclimatization: Plantlets were taken out of culture jars
and the agar adhered to the roots were removed by shaking gently
in running tap water for a couple of minutes before they were
placed in plastic pots (5.8 cm tall, 3.2x4 cm on top and 2x2.5 cm
at the base of a pot) containing a soil mixture (soil:sand:chopped
rice straw in 5:4:1 ratio). One plantlet was placed in each pot
(there were six replications) filled to the top with the soil mixture
which was kept watered to capacity throughout the experiment.
Each pot was covered loosely with a clear plastic bag and lifted
briefly daily throughout the experiment so that the leaves were
sprayed with water using a hand-held water spray bottle. At
the beginning of the second week of acclimatization, two holes
(1.5 cm diameter each) were made on the side of the bag and six
more holes of the same size were made at the beginning of the
third week. All the plantlets were grown in a plant nursery under
a plastic shade net with 12 hours of natural sunlight a day and
average day temperature around 30-32oC and night temperature
around 22-23oC. Number of leaves and stem height (measured
from top of a pot to the shoot apex) per plantlet were determined
after 4 weeks of acclimatization under ex vitro conditions.
Data analysis: Means of root number, root length, leaf number and
stem height ± SE per plantlet were analyzed. One-way ANOVA
(STATISTIX for Windows 2.0 analytical software) was first performed
at the significance level of 0.05. After this, when appropriate, Duncan
comparison of means was carried out at P<0.05.
endogenous auxin or hormonal balance within these explants was
sufficient for adventitious root organogenesis (Bodhhipadma et
al., 2010). However, compared to control more roots per explant
were induced when the explants were cultured on basal MS
medium supplemented with different concentrations of YGE or
OGE with the exception of 5 mL/L OGE (Fig. 1). Interestingly,
YGE or OGE at the concentrations used in this study had no effect
on root formation in stem explants of Kaffir lime (Citrus hystrix
DC.), another plant that rooted in medium without exogenous
plant growth regulators (data not shown).
With the exception of 20 mL/L of YGE, different concentrations
of YGE or OGE added to basal MS medium promoted root
elongation in aromatic chilli stem explants compared to control
(Fig. 2). The promotive effect of 5 mL/L of YGE on elongation
of roots formed in explants was more than that of the higher
concentrations of YGE (Fig. 2). This was also observed among
different concentrations of OGE. Overall, the most effective
treatment was 5 mL/L of OGE as root length was more than double
a
b
c
a
b
c
a
b
c
d
b
c
d
Fig. 1. Number of roots formed per stem explant (n=6) of aromatic chilli
cultured for 6 weeks on different media supplemented with different
concentrations of juice of young or old ginger rhizome (YGE or OGE
respectively). Values are mean number of roots±SE and those assigned
with different letters are significantly different (P<0.05). Different media:
1 = basal MS; 2= MS + 5 mL/L YGE; 3= MS + 10 mL/L YGE; 4= MS
+ 20 mL/L YGE; 5= MS + 5 mL/L OGE; 6= MS + 10 mL/L OGE; 7=
MS + 20 mL/L OGE.
a
b
c
d
e
b
c
d
e
c
d
Results and discussion
Root formation and growth in vitro: Adventitious root
formation is a crucial step in micropropagation from stem
explants. Many studies have been carried out to investigate the
factors influencing rooting in vitro. An auxin such as IAA, IBA,
NAA or 2,4-D is generally added to plant tissue culture media
for root initiation in vitro (Saxena et al., 2000; Ashrafuzzaman et
al., 2009). In the present study, root formation occurred in stem
explants of aromatic chilli cultured on basal MS medium without
any exogenous plant growth regulators (control), suggesting that
Fig. 2. Elongation of roots formed by stem explants (n=6) of aromatic
chilli cultured for 6 weeks on different media supplemented with different
concentrations of juice of young or old ginger rhizome (YGE or OGE
respectively). Values are mean root length±SE and those assigned with
different letters are significantly different (P<0.05). Different media: 1
= basal MS; 2= MS + 5 mL/L YGE; 3= MS + 10 mL/L YGE; 4= MS
+ 20 mL/L YGE; 5= MS + 5 mL/L OGE; 6= MS + 10 mL/L OGE; 7=
MS + 20 mL/L OGE
Complementary Copy
Thailand. Juice was extracted from 300 g of ginger rhizome (of
a particular age) which had been peeled and chopped into small
pieces using a juicer blender (Severin Entsafter Juicy 300 ES
3557). Young and old ginger rhizomes yielded 167 and 151 mL
of juice, respectively, which was added to plant tissue culture
medium as described below.
89
Ginger juice enhanced growth of aromatic chilli during in vitro culture and acclimatization
Table 1. Per cent survival (A), number of leaves (B) and stem height (C)
of aromatic chilli plantlets from different media at the time of exflasking
(day 0) and after acclimatization for 4 weeks
(A) Survival of ex flasked aromatic chilli plantlets (%)
MS medium
Basal
+5 mL/L YGE
+10 mL/L YGE
+20 mL/L YGE
+5 mL/L OGE
+10 mL/L OGE
+20 mL/L OGE
Day 0
100+0a
100+0a
100+0a
100+0a
100+0a
100+0a
100+0a
4 weeks
100+0a
100+0a
100+0a
100+0a
100+0a
100+0a
100+0a
(B) Number of leaves per exflasked aromatic chilli plantlet
MS medium
Day 0
4 weeks
Basal
18.5 ± 0.922a
24.66 ± 1.406c
+5 mL/L YGE
15.83 ± 0.543b
25.0 ± 1.693c
+10 mL/L YGE
15.83 ± 0.401b
25.0 ± 0.730c
+20 mL/L YGE
14.66 ± 0.494bc
25.16 ± 0.401c
+5 mL/L OGE
18.33 ± 0.882a
29.5 ± 1.258b
+10 mL/L OGE
19.16 ± 0.307a
31.5 ± 0.719ab
+20 mL/L OGE
20.0 ± 1.0a
33.5 ± 1.408a
(C) Stem height (mm) per exflasked aromatic chilli plantlet
MS medium
Day 0
4 weeks
Basal
40.0 ± 0.775c
50.0 ± 2.236cd
+5 mL/L YGE
41.16 ± 0.477b
65.0 ± 3.416a
+10 mL/L YGE
43.5 ± 1.204ab
60.0 ± 0ab
+20 mL/L YGE
41.0 ± 0.931b
52.5 ± 1.708cd
+5 mL/L OGE
45.16± 0.477a
63.33 ± 2.108a
+10 mL/L OGE
46.16 ± 1.014a
59.16 ± 0.833ab
+20 mL/L OGE
45.83 ±1.400a
55.0 ± 1.291bc
Values are means of 6 replications±SE and those sharing the same letter
are not significantly different. (YGE = young ginger juice, OGE = old
ginger juice)
that of control. Taken together, depending on concentrations and
age of ginger rhizome, juice of ginger rhizome added to basal MS
medium could generate more beneficial effects than basal MS
medium alone as far as formation and growth of roots in stem
explants of aromatic chilli was concerned.
Besides ginger juice, several complex natural substances have
also been shown to have beneficial effects on root formation and
elongation in vitro. It was hypothesized that extracellular extracts
of cyanbacterial culture might add some plant growth regulators
or other factors that act directly in promoting rooting response
(Manickavelu et al., 2006). Peptone together with NAA was found
better than NAA alone for root initiation and elongation in stem
explants of avocado (Nhut et al., 2008). It was thought that peptone
had an indirect rooting effect as it prevented deterioration of the
stem explants so that NAA could initiate root formation. In the
present study, ginger juice might have substances that augment the
action of endogenous auxin in the aromatic chilli stem explants.
Effect of culture treatments on ex vitro acclimatization:
There was virtually no significant difference in the survival
rates of all the exflasked plantlets of aromatic chilli under the ex
vitro acclimatization conditions in this study, regardless of the
previous in vitro culture treatments (Table 1A). This suggests
that the acclimatization conditions used in the present study were
adequate to ensure high survival rates of aromatic chilli plantlets
following exflasking.
Leaf production: At the time of exflasking, the aromatic
chilli plantlets developed on YGE-supplemented media had
fewer leaves per plantlet than control or those developed on
media supplemented with OGE (Table 1B). After 4 weeks of
acclimatization, exflasked plantlets previously cultured on media
supplemented with different concentrations of OGE formed 2030% more leaves per plantlet than control and those previously
cultured on media supplemented with YGE (Table 1B). Therefore,
it would seem more beneficial to add OGE rather than YGE to
MS basal medium as far as boosting leaf production in exflasked
plantlets during acclimatization was concerned.
Stem height: At the end of in vitro culture, the aromatic
chilli plantlets in control were shorter than those developed
on media supplemented with YGE or OGE (Table 1C). After
acclimatization, exflasked plantlets previously cultured on media
supplemented with 5 or 10 mL/L but not 20 mL/L YGE or OGE
were taller than control. Plantlets from the OGE treatments (5 or
10 mL/L) were about 15-30% taller than control. These results
were consistent with the notion that in vitro treatments could
have lasting or long-term effects on in vivo growth of exflasked
plants (Economou and Read, 1987; Nowak and Shulaev, 2003;
Iacona and Muleo, 2010).
In conclusion, this is the first report on utility of ginger juice
to influence growth and development of other plants. Aromatic
chilli plantlets exflasked from medium supplemented with OGE
(10 mL/L), generally grew better than those previously cultured
with YGE in terms of both increase in leaf number and stem
height during acclimatization. It would seem worthwhile in future
to identify the chemical basis of this effect of OGE. It has been
shown that ginger juice has antioxidants, carbohydrates and some
minerals (Shirin and Prakash, 2010). These are likely to vary with
different ages of the ginger rhizome from which the ginger juice
is extracted. It would be of interest to investigate more closely
if these substances present in ginger juice might promote root
initiation, root elongation and improved performance of exflasked
aromatic chilli plantlets after acclimatization. In addition, since it
is well-known that auxin and cytokinin are generally involved in
plant regeneration (Bodhipadma et al., 2011), it seems worthwhile
to investigate the occurrence and levels of these plant hormones
in ginger juice. Although it remains to be determined what factors
in ginger juice might be responsible for its effects on plant growth
and development, the practical benefit of ginger juice for improving
growth of exflasked aromatic chilli plantlets during acclimatization
has been clearly demonstrated which was the primary objective of
this study. It would be of further interest to determine if ginger
juice has any effect on other in vitro processes including callus
induction and growth, somatic embryogenesis etc.
References
Ashrafuzzaman, M., M.M. Hossain, M.R. Ismail, M.S. Haque and S.M.
Shahin-uz-zaman, 2009. Regeneration potential of seedling explants
of chilli (Capsicum annuum). Afr. J. Biotechnol., 8: 591-596.
Bodhipadma, K., S. Noichinda, I. Yadbuntung, W. Buaeiam and D.W.M.
Leung, 2010. Comparison of in vitro and in vivo inflorescence of
common cockscomb (Celosia argentea var. cristata). Science Asia,
36: 68-71.
Bodhipadma, K., S. Noichinda, W. Padyencheun, T. Khunthacharoen,
and U. Chikhunthod, 2011. Influence of preculture treatment and
types of explants on shoot growth and in vitro flowering of feathered
amaranth (Celosia argentea var. plumose). Plant Cell Tiss. Organ
Cult., 105: 465-469.
Complementary Copy
90
Ginger juice enhanced growth of aromatic chilli during in vitro culture and acclimatization
Nowak, J. and V. Shulaev, 2003. Priming for transplant stress resistance
in in vitro propagation. In vitro Cell Devel. Biol. Plant., 39: 107124.
Nhut, D.T., N.N. Thi, B.L.T. Khiet and V.Q. Luan, 2008. Peptone
stimulates in vitro shoot and root regeneration of avocado (Persea
americana Mill.). Sci. Hort., 115: 124-128.
Saxena, C., S. Samantaray , G.R. Rout and P. Das, 2000. Effect of auxins
on in vitro rooting of Plumbago Zeylanica: Peroxidase activity as a
marker for root induction. Biol. Plant., 43: 121-124.
Shirin, A.P.R. and J. Prakash, 2010. Chemical composition and
antioxidant properties of ginger root (Zingiber officinale). J. Med.
Plants, 4: 2674-2679.
Swamy, M.K., S. Balasubramanya and M. Anuradha, 2009. Germplasm
conservation of patchouli (Pogostemon cablin Benth.) by
encapsulation of in vitro derived nodal segments. Int. J. Biodiversity
Conservat., 1: 224-230.
Swamy, M.K., K.M. Sudipta, S. Balasubramanya and M. Anuradha,
2010. Effect of different carbon sources on in vitro morphogenetic
response of patchouli (Pogostemon cablin Benth.). J. Phytol., 2:
11-17.
Vyas, S., S. Guha, M. Bhattacharya and I.U. Rao, 2009. Rapid regeneration
of plants of Dendrobium lituiflorum Lindl. (Orchidaceae) by using
banana extract. Sci. Hort., 121: 32-37.
Received: March, 2012; Revised: July, 2012; Accepted: November, 2012
.
Complementary Copy
Buah, J.N., J.W. Tachie-Menson, G. Addae and P. Asare, 2011. Sugarcane
juice as an alternative carbon source for in vitro culture of plantains
and banans. Am. J. Food Technol., 6: 685-694.
Das, A. and N. Mandal, 2010. Enhanced development of embryogenic
callus in Stevia rebaudiana Bert. by additive and amino acids.
Biotechnol., 9: 368-372.
Economou, A.S. and P.E. Read, 1987. Light treatments to improve
efficiency of in vitro propagation systems. Hort. Sci., 22: 751-754.
Iacona, C. and R. Muleo, 2010. Light quality affects in vitro adventitious
rooting and ex vitro performance of cherry rootstock Colt. Sci.
Hort., 125: 630-636.
Kitsaki, C.K., D. Zygouraki, M. Ziobora and S. Kintzios, 2004. In
vitro germination, protocorm formation and plantlet development
of mature versus immature seeds from several Ophrys species
(Orchidaceae). Plant Cell Rep., 23: 284-290.
Kusumoto, M. and J. Furukawa, 1977. Effect of organic matter on the
growth of Cymbidium protocorms cultured in vitro. J. Japan Soc.
Hort. Sci., 45: 421-426.
Manickavelu, A., N. Nadarajan, S.K. Ganesh, R. Ramalingam, S.
Raguraman and R.P. Gnanamalar, 2006. Organogenesis induction in
rice callus by cyanobacterial extracellular product. Afr. J. Biotechnol.,
5: 437-439.
Murashige, T. and F. Skoog, 1962. A revised medium for rapid growth
and bioassays with tobacco tissue culture. Physiol. Plant., 15: 473497.
91
Journal
Journal of Applied Horticulture, 14(2): 92-97, 2012
Appl
Wat e r re t e nt ion cha ra c t e rist ic s of soil bio-a m e ndm e nt s
use d a s grow ing m e dia in pot c ult ure
S.S. Kuk a l 1 * , De ba sish Sa ha 1 , Ar na b Bhow m ik 1 a nd R.K . Dube y 2
Department of Soil Science, 2Department of Floriculture and Landscaping, Punjab Agricultural University, Ludhiana,
141004, India. *E-mail:
[email protected]
1
Abstract
Key words: Bio-amendments, growing media, bulk density, water retention, air filled porosity, easily available water, water buffering
capacity
Introduction
The commercial use of different organic growing media as bioamendments in soil used in nurseries and greenhouse crops is
very common due to their healthy effects on the soil physical
environment. The suitable use of growing media is of importance
for production of quality greenhouse crops. It directly influences
the growth, development, ramification and functioning of
rooting system (Argo, 1998; Richards and Beardsell, 1986). It is
important to maintain the optimum aeration and water status of
the media to avoid the drought or excess water stress due to the
shallow depth and limited volume of soil in the containers. The
ability of the growing media to make a healthy balance between
water content and gaseous exchange is critical for the keeping
quality of the ornamental plants (Dressboll, 2010). Thus, the
organic soil amendments are usually mixed with soil to provide
the optimal physical and chemical environment (Yangyuoru et
al., 2006) to the growing plants. This also buffers the temporary
water stress and plant failure during the establishment stage (De
Boodt, 1990; Johnson and Leah, 1990). Solely field soils are
generally not recommended for pot culture purpose as they do not
provide the required aeration, drainage and water holding capacity
which results in suppression of root growth and susceptibility
to soil borne diseases (Beattie and White, 1992). Thus, several
bio-amendments have recently been used in nurseries and
greenhouses. The coir, farmyard manure (FYM), sewage sludge,
vermicompost are the most commonly used growing media in the
greenhouses and pot culture. Recently the use of coir or coconut
mesocarp as a substitute of sphagnum peat has been well accepted
in horticultural nurseries (Yau and Murphy, 2000; Pickering,
1997) because of its better physical properties (Evans et al.,
1996; Prasad, 1997) and excellent ability to make a balanced air
and water supply to the roots. These non-soil materials can be
manipulated or processed in different ratios and combinations
to provide the superior physical and chemical environment for
optimum plant growth. Thus the success of plants grown in
pot culture can be summed up by the physical attributes of the
growing media that influences its ability to provide sufficient
water to the root systems without any oxygen shortage (Michel,
2010; Khayyat et al., 2007) which is the most determining factor
in containerised cultivation.
The good physical environment means the physical make up of
the growing media viz., maximum water holding capacity (WHC),
bulk density of the mixture, air-filled porosity (AFP), water
retention characteristics at a particular matric potential and the
mechanical support to the plant growth. The AFP is the volume
of air in a media mix after it has been watered heavily and then
allowed to drain. If the media mix is very dense and there is too
little air in the media mix (less than 10%) then the roots will not be
properly aerated and the plant will suffer, especially in a medium
like pot having limited drainage capacity. Although plants can
extract more than the available water, they will need to exert
extra energy to do so and this restricts their growth. The balance
between the available water and the air space depends on the size
and shape of the particles in the media or more precisely the pores
Complementary Copy
The efficacy of the natural bio-amendments in improving physical condition as well as water retention characteristics of the growing
media in pot culture was studied on ten different compositions of growing media. The treatments comprised of (i) soil as sole medium;
(ii) soil + sewage sludge (SS) in the ratio of 1:1; (iii) soil + SS + coir (CP) in the ratio of 1:1:1; (iv) soil + vermicompost (VC) in the
ratio of 1:1; (v) soil + VC + CP in the ratio of 1:1:1; (vi) soil + farmyard manure (FYM) in the ratio of 1:1; (vii) soil + FYM + CP in
the ratio of 1:1:1; (viii) soil + SS + VC in the ratio of 1:1:1; (ix) soil + SS + FYM in the ratio of 1:1:1 and (x) soil + FYM + VC in
the ratio of 1:1:1. The bulk density of media composition soil+SS+CP, soil+VC+CP and soil+FYM+CP was 24.2, 27.5 and 27.5%
lower than the media containing only soils (1.32 mg m-3), respectively. The water holding capacity (WHC) was lowest (45.4%) in sole
soil treatment and it was 6.3, 5.6 and 6.1 times higher in soil+SS+CP, soil+VC+CP and soil+FYM+CP, respectively. The volumetric
water retention at various suctions was significantly improved by addition of the organic amendments with soil. The magnitude of the
differences in water retention among the treatments became wider at the higher suctions. The combination of soil+VC+CP showed
the highest amount of water retention among all the treatments at all the suctions. The air filled porosity was highest (190.7%) in
soil+FYM+CP media and lowest (25.3%) in sole soil media. Significant increase in easily available water was observed with the
incorporation of coir with sewage sludge, vermicompost and FYM. The water buffering capacity was lowest in media with only soil
(7.56%) and the media containing soil+VC+CP recorded the highest (24.7%) water buffering capacity.
Water retention characteristics of soil bio-amendments used as growing media in pot culture
Materials and methods
The experiment was conducted at Punjab Agricultural University,
Ludhiana, India. Four different soil bio-amendments viz. FYM,
vermicompost, coir and sewage sludge were used for evaluating
their effect on soil water retaining characteristics on mixing with
soils at different proportion and combinations. The treatments
consisted of ten different combinations of soil and non-soil organic
amendments in equal proportion. The treatments comprised of (i)
soil as sole medium; (ii) soil + sewage sludge (SS) in the ratio
of 1:1; (iii) soil + SS + coir (CP) in the ratio of 1:1:1; (iv) soil +
vermicompost (VC) in the ratio of 1:1; (v) soil + VC + CP in the
ratio of 1:1:1; (vi) soil + farmyard manure (FYM) in the ratio of
1:1; (vii) soil + FYM + CP in the ratio of 1:1:1; (viii) soil + SS
+ VC in the ratio of 1:1:1; (ix) soil + SS + FYM in the ratio of
1:1:1 and (x) Soil + FYM + VC in the ratio of 1:1:1.
The organic amendments were dried under shade and then
different treatment combinations were prepared by mixing
them thoroughly by hand at equal proportions (w/w) to make it
homogeneous. In case of coir, the raw sample was used without
any grinding except removal of the knots.
Pot filling: The growing media was packed in the pots with a preselected compaction level. The soil mixed with bioamendments
in the desired proportions was filled in 30 cm high polyvinyl
chloride (PVC) pots having internal diameter of 20 cm. The
PVC pots had a hole of 1 cm diameter at the bottom end so as to
drain the excess water. The soil along with bioamendments were
filled in the pots in small lots with 30 strokes using a wooden rod
with cone-shaped pointed end. This was done to attain a uniform
packing of different mixtures of soil and bioamendments. The
pots were irrigated till near saturation and were then allowed to
attain the equilibrium for 2-3 days. The treatments of the mixtures
of growing medium were replicated thrice. In-situ sampling was
done for determination of different physical characteristics from
these pots.
Bulk density: The bulk density was measured by core method
(Blake and Hartge, 1986). A metallic core of 5 cm inner diameter
and 5 cm height was inserted in the packed pots to take out
undisturbed sample of the growing media mixture. The sample
was then dried in an oven at 105oC for 24 h or till the sample
weight became constant. The ratio of oven-dry weight of the
sample in the core and the internal volume of metallic core was
expressed as bulk density.
Water holding capacity: The water holding capacity (%) was
determined as per Richard (1954). It was computed as follows:
WHC (%) = 100 x
Wsw - Wsd - Wf
Wsd - Wk - Wg
Where, Wsw is the weight of watch glass + Keen’s box + filter
paper + saturated sample in g; Wsd is the weight of watch glass +
Keen’s box + filter paper + oven dry sample in g; Wk is the weight
of Keen’s box + filter paper in g; Wg is weight of watch glass in
g; and Wf is weight of water absorbed by filter paper.
Water retention characteristics: Water retention at various
soil matric suctions was determined with the help of Richard’s
pressure plate apparatus (Richard, 1949). For this purpose, the
cores sampled for bulk density measurement were sliced so as
to fit in retainer rubber rings on the porous, saturated ceramic
plate. These were then saturated overnight along with the
ceramic plates with an excess of water maintained in the tray.
The ceramic plate along with the saturated samples was placed
in the pressure plate chamber and connected to an outflow tube.
The required pressure equivalent to desired soil matric potential
was maintained by the air compressor fitted with suitable pressure
regulator so as to equilibrate the sample at required suction
levels. After the equilibrium was attained, the samples were
immediately transferred to the moisture box and the moisture
content at particular suction was determined gravimetrically by
drying the samples in an oven at a constant temperature of 1050C
for 24 hours. The relationships between volumetric water content
versus the soil matric suction were expressed in the form of soil
moisture characteristics curves. These water retention curves
were used to estimate the following parameters as suggested by
Michel (2010).
The air-filled porosity, defined as the volumetric proportion of
the water contained at saturation (water potential = 0 kPa) in the
coarsest pores and therefore, readily released and replaced by air
at water potentials between 0 and -1 kPa.
The easily available water, which is the volumetric proportion
of water retained in the growing medium by forces which are
compatible with root extraction capacity (defined for the range
of water potential from -1 kPa to -10 kPa).
The water buffering capacity, defined as the volumetric proportion
of water released by the growing medium between -5 and -10 kPa,
enabling physiological adaptation of the plant to the changing
water potential.
Statistical analysis: The data was analyzed using analysis of
variance (ANOVA) in a completely randomised design, so as to
estimate the critical difference among the treatments. Regression
analysis was carried to study the significance of relationship
between water holding capacity (WHC) and bulk density.
Least significant difference (LSD) at 95% probability level was
employed to compare the treatment means.
Results and discussion
Bulk density: Analysis of variance showed significant (P<0.05)
differences in bulk density among the growing media (Fig.1). The
influence of bio-amendments incorporation with soil on media
bulk density was more pronounced in case of coir treatments. The
bulk density of media containing soil+SS+CP, Soil+VC+CP and
soil+FYM+CP was significantly lower than the other treatments.
It was 24.2, 27.5 and 27.5% lower than the media with sole soil
(1.32 Mg m-3), respectively. Sudhagar and Sekar (2009) reported
the decrease in bulk density and particle density with increase of
coir could be due to light weight of coir and increased pore space
(Saravanan and Nambisan, 1995). On the contrary the application
Complementary Copy
between the solid particles. Therefore, the ideal mix should have a
balance between medium and coarse particles with a minimum of
fine particles. Thus, the present study was conducted to evaluate
the physical and water retention characteristics of different
combinations of soil and bio-amendments so as to identify the
best blend for easy availability of water and air to the plants.
93
Water retention characteristics of soil bio-amendments used as growing media in pot culture
Fig.1. Bulk density of soil as affected by different non-soil bioamendments. (Vertical columns are means and the bars on each column
are ± standard errors of mean; lower case letters indicate differences at
the 0.05 probability level in bulk density among the treatments)
of vermicompost and FYM slightly increased the media bulk
density as compared to control (only soil). The application of
sewage sludge (soil+SS) reduced the media bulk density by
6% than the control media. Subsequent addition of coir further
reduced the bulk density of media composition soil+SS+CP by
19.3%. On the contrary, the application of FYM increased the
bulk density by 23% in Soil+SS+FYM media combination than
the Soil+SS treatment. Differences in results obtained here are
most likely due to the variation in particle-size distribution of
the material (Richards and Beardsell, 1986). Being fibrous, the
coir fibers evenly spread in the soil and due to its lighter weight
it reduces the bulk density with concomitant increase in total
porosity (Awang et al., 2009). The lower bulk density with coir
media facilitates the mixing and incorporation of the media, easy
transportation and sufficient aeration to the plants.
Water holding capacity: The water holding capacity (WHC)
significantly differed among the different media combinations
(Fig. 2). With the application of organic amendments there was a
significant increase in WHC among the treatments as compared to
Fig. 2. Water holding capacity of soil as affected by different non-soil bioamendments. (Vertical columns are means and the bars on each column
are ± standard errors of mean; lower case letters indicate differences at
the 0.05 probability level in WHC among the treatments)
the control with no amendments. The prominent beneficial effect of
coir on soil physical make up is manifested by Fig. 2. The three coir
treatments, soil+SS+CP, soil+VC+CP and soil+FYM+CP exhibited
significantly higher WHC as compared to the other treatments. The
WHC was lowest (45.4%) in media with sole soil and 6.3, 5.6 and
6.1 times higher in soil+SS+CP (283%), soil+VC+CP (256%) and
soil+FYM+CP (276%), respectively. There was non-significant
difference in WHC with the application of sewage sludge, FYM
and vermicompost addition with the soil as in soil+SS, soil+VC
and soil+FYM treatments. The differences in the WHC among the
media could be due to the diversity in total porosity and pore-size
distribution. The light weight, fibrous coir adds higher porosity and
reduced bulk density that helps in holding higher amount of water.
The higher WHC of coir based media due to its higher total porosity
has also been reported by Evans et al. (1996) and Prasad (1997).
Several experiments have revealed that use of coir alone or as a
component of soil medium is suitable for various potted plants (De
Kreij and Leeuven, 2001; Treder, 2008) as well as vegetable crops.
There was a linear correlation (R2=0.75) (Fig. 3) between bulk
density and WHC of the growing media. With the increase in bulk
density there was a linear decrease in WHC. Thus the significantly
lower bulk density of the coir treatments renders the significantly
higher WHC as compared to other treatments.
Water retention characteristics and aeration: The water
retention characteristics are basically the capability of the media
to retain water at different moisture potentials. The water retention
curves of different media compositions have been presented in
Fig. 4. Significant differences were observed in water retention
among the treatments under different soil moisture suctions
except in Fig. 4d, where there was not much difference among
the treatments. The difference in water retention among the
treatments is narrow in the lower suction range and the magnitude
of difference increases with the increase in suction value. Awang
et al. (2009) reported that at the initial values of soil water suction,
the volume of water held by different media was more or less
similar. Among all the treatments the media with only soils as
growing media retained lowest amount of water at all the suctions.
The application of sewage sludge with soil (soil+SS) caused 2
times increase in water retention at 1bar of soil water suction
whereas, with the incorporation of coir with soil and sewage
Fig. 3. Relationship between bulk density and water holding capacity
of the growing media
Complementary Copy
94
Water retention characteristics of soil bio-amendments used as growing media in pot culture
a
b
d
Complementary Copy
c
95
Fig. 4. Water retention characteristics of different growing media as affected by different non-soil bio-amendments in different proportions
and combinations
sludge (soil+SS+CP) caused 4.3 times higher water retention at
the same soil water suction (Fig. 4a). With the increase in suction
the volume of water retained decreased in all the media but the
magnitude of differences among the treatments increased. This
indicated that the application of organic amendments improves
water retention even at higher suctions as compared to sole soils.
This is one of the important attributes of using bio-amendments
as growing media that could be exploited to avoid the drought
stress in the greenhouses. This is mainly due to the restricted
movement of water from subsurface to surface because of reduced
evaporation (Ouchi et al., 1990). The combination of soil+VC+CP
showed the highest amount of water retention among all the
treatments at all the suctions. The effect of coir was less prominent
when it is mixed with soil and FYM (soil+FM+CP) (Fig. 4c). The
remarkable increase in water retention of media with non-soil
organic amendments (especially coir) as compared to media with
sole soil is due to the predominant role of the organic amendments
on soil physical properties. The microbial decomposition of
the organic amendment compounds releases by-products like
polysaccharides and polyuronoides (Hillel, 1980) which helps
Water retention characteristics of soil bio-amendments used as growing media in pot culture
in stabilising aggregates by enmeshing the soil particles within
the aggregates. The water retention, air-filled porosity and gas
diffusion are mainly dependent on particle size of the growing
media and the pores between the particles (Caron and Nkongolo,
1999; Caron et al., 2005). The pore continuity is the most critical
physical factor influencing water dynamics and gas exchange
by roots (Gruda and Schnitzler, 2004). Evans et al. (1996) and
Verhagen (2004) have shown the increased water retention of peat
media with the addition of coco peat or coir dust. The positive
effect of coir on soil physical environment has also been reported
by Managecraft (2001).
The air filled porosity as calculated from the water retention
curve was significantly differed among the treatments (Table
1). It was highest (190.7%) in soil+FYM+CP combination and
lowest (25.3%) in sole soil treatment. The application of coir with
sewage sludge (soil+SS+CP) and vermicompost (soil+VC+CP)
caused 6.9 and 4 times increase in air filled porosity as compared
to media with only soil, respectively. Ensuring proper aeration
for proper root growth in pots in greenhouse and nurseries is
a real challenge for the growers because of impeded drainage
due to limited soil volume in the container. Aeration basically
depends on the media pore size. Watering in the pots causes
saturation of the total porosity. As the media dries up, water first
depletes from the larger pores. Application of coir improves the
macro porosity of the media and helps in draining excess water
and maintains the proper aeration status. Increased proportion
of larger pores enhances more aeration after drainage (Handreek
and Black, 2007). Khayyat et al. (2007) observed significant
differences on growth performances of Epipremnum aureum
Lindl. and Andre (‘Golden Pothos’) grown on coir based rooting
media. They explained the large differences on rooting quality
and shoot characteristics by the direct effect of growth substrate
on the basal portion of cutting rather than the indirect or earlier
physiological changes. Improved root formation and growth in
coir mixtures could be due to better aeration, drainage conditions
and water maintenance capability of the substrate (Eleni et al.,
Table 1. Air-filled porosity and water availability in different
compositions of bio-amendments in soil
Water
Water
Media composition
Air filled
buffering
availability
porosity
capacity (%)
(%)
(%)
Soil
25.3a
10.2a
7.36a
Soil+SS (1:1)
41.9b
13.3a
8.17a
Soil+SS+CP (1:1:1)
175.4c
30.3b
19.3b
Soil+VC (1:1)
66.0d
13.5a
10.0a
Soil+VC+CP (1:1:1)
101.3e
64.7c
24.7c
Soil+FYM (1:1)
53.21f
10.3a
6.90a
Soil+FYM+CP (1:1:1)
190.7g
25.4d
17.7b
Soil+SS+VC (1:1:1)
75.3d
20.0e
13.8a
Soil+SS+FYM (1:1:1)
65.5d
14.1a
10.8a
Soil+FYM+VC (1:1:1)
79.8h
19.6e
11.7a
The dissimilar lower case letters indicate significant differences among
the treatments at P<0.05
SS= sewage sludge; CP = cocopeat; VC = vermicompost;
FYM = farmyard manure
2001; Noguera et al., 2000) which are critical for the first phase of
the root initiation. The effect of sewage sludge, vermicompost and
FYM on increasing water availability only happened when they
were associated with coir (Table 1). Mere application of sewage
sludge, vermicompost and FYM did not significantly affect the
water availability in soil+SS, soil+VC and soil+FYM treatments
as compared to sole soils. Significant increase in water availability
was observed with the incorporation of coir with sewage sludge,
vermicompost and FYM. The effect of coir application on
water availability is very clear in soil+SS+CP, soil+VC+CP and
soil+FYM+CP treatment combinations where there were 2.9, 6.3
and 2.5 times higher water availability as compared to the control
treatment, respectively (Table 1). Similar trend was observed in
case of water buffering capacity of the media (Table 1). The media
with only soil had the lowest (7.36%) water buffering capacity
and the media containing vermicompost and coir associated with
soil recorded the highest (24.7%) water buffering capacity. The
higher water availability of the coir containing media indicates
more available water to the plants. At the same time high water
buffering capacity of the coir makes it more flexible in providing
irrigation and less restrictive in terms of water management
(Michel, 2010).
The study of organic amendments on water retention properties
showed that the non soil organic amendments have a positive
effect on physical environment of the media and hence improve
the water retention and aeration properties of the media. The
impact of coir, which is environmentally safe and cheap, was
much more pronounced among the organic amendments. The
application of coir in association with vermicompost, FYM or
sewage sludge rather than their individual use is found to be a
viable option for providing better aeration, water availability
to the plants as well as water buffering capacity of the media
which has long been a challenge for pot culture in greenhouses
and nurseries.
References
Argo, W.R. 1998. Root medium physical properties. Hort. Technol., 8:
481-485.
Awang, Y., A.S. Shaharom, R.B. Mohamad and A. Selamat, 2009.
Chemical and physical characteristics of cocopeat-based media
mixtures and their effects on the growth and development of Celosia
cristata. Am. J. Agric. Biol. Sci., 4: 63-71.
Beattie, D.J. and J.W. White, 1992. Lilium–hybrids and species. In: The
Physiology of Flower Bulbs. A. De Hertogh and M. Le Nard (eds.).
Elsevier, Amsterdam.
Blake, G.R. and K.H. Hartge, 1986. Bulk density. In: Methods of Soil
Analysis, Part I, A. Klute (ed). ASA Monograph No 9. Madison,
WI. p.363-376.
Caron, J., L.M. Riviere and G. Guillemain, 2005. Gas diffusion and airfilled porosity: effect of some oversize fragments in growing media.
Canadian J. Soil Sci., 85: 57-65.
Caron, J. and N.V. Nkongolo, 1999. Aeration in growing media: recent
developments. Acta Hort., 481: 545-551.
De Boodt, M. 1990. Application of polymeric substances as physical
soil conditioners. In: Soil Colloids and their Association in
Soil Aggregates. (M. De Boodt et al., ed.), Planum Publishing
Corporation, London, New York. p. 580-592.
De Kreij, C. and G.J.L. Leeuven, 2001. Growth of pot plants in treated
coir dust as compared to peat. Commun. Soil Sci. Plant Anal., 32:
2255-2265.
Complementary Copy
96
Water retention characteristics of soil bio-amendments used as growing media in pot culture
Ouchi, S., A. Nishikawa and E. Kameda, 1990. Soil-improving effect of
a super-water-absorbent polymer. II. Evaporation, leaching of salts
and growth of vegetables. Jap. J. Soil Sci. Pl. Nutr., 61: 606-613.
Pickering, J.S. 1997. An alternative to peat. The Garden, 122: 428429.
Prasad, M. 1997. Physical, chemical and biological properties of coir
dust. Acta Hort., 450: 21-29.
Richard, L.A. 1949. Pressure membrane apparatus construction and use.
Agri. Engg., 28: 451-454.
Richard, L.A. 1954. Diagnosis and Improvement of Saline and Alkali
Soils: Agriculture Handbook No. 60. USDA. New York.
Richards, D.M.L. and D.V. Beardsell, 1986. The influence of particlesize distribution in pinebark:sand:brown coal potting mixes on water
supply, aeration and plant growth. Scientia Hort., 29: 1-14.
Saravanan, A. and K.M.P. Nambisan, 1995. Utilization of coco peat as
pot culture medium for Begonia semperflorense. Madras Agric. J.,
82: 587-589.
Sudhagar, R. and K. Sekar, 2009. Effect of coco peat medium on growth
and quality of poinsettia (Euphorbia pulcherrima. Wild.). The Asian
J. Hort., 4: 52-56.
Treder, J. 2008. The effect of cocopeat and fertilization on the growth
and flowering of oriental Lily ‘Star Gazer’. J. Fruit Ornamental
Plant Res., 16: 361-370.
Verhagen, J.B.G.M. 2004. Effectiveness of clay in peat based growing
media. Acta Hort., 644: 115–122.
Yau, P.Y. and R.J. Murphy, 2000. Biodegraded cocopeat as a horticultural
substrate. Acta Hort., 517: 275-278.
Yangyuoru, M., E. Boateng, S.G.K. Adiku, D. Acquah, T.A. Adjadeh and
F. Mawunya, 2006. Effects of natural and synthetic soil conditioners
on soil moisture retention and maize yield. West Africa J. Applied
Ecol., 9: 1-8.
Received: February, 2012; Revised: October, 2012; Accepted: December, 2012
Complementary Copy
Dressboll, D.B. 2010. Effect of growing media composition, compaction
and periods of anoxia on the quality and keeping quality of potted
roses (Rosa sp.). Scientia Hort., 126: 56-63.
Eleni, M., K. Sabri and Z. Dimitra, 2001. Effect of growing media on
the production and quality of two rose varieties. Acta Hortic., 548:
79-83.
Evans, M.R., S. Konduru and R.H. Stamps, 1996. Source variation in
physical and chemical properties of coconut coir dust. Hort. Sci.,
31: 965-967.
Gruda, N. and W.H. Schnitzler, 2004. Suitability of wood fiber substrate
for production of vegetable transplants. I. Physical properties of wood
fiber substrates. Scientia Horti., 100: 309-322.
Handreck, K.A. and N.D. Black, 2007. Growing Media for
Ornamental Plants and Turf. 3rd Edn., UNSW Press, Sydney,
ISBN:13:9780868407968.
Hillel, D. 1980. Fundamentals of Soil Physics. Academic Press, New
York. p.113-117.
Johnson, M.S. and R.T. Leah, 1990. Effects of super absorbent
polyacrylamide on efficacy of water use by crop seedlings. J. Sci.
Fd Agric., 52: 431-434.
Khayyat, M., F. Nazari and H. Salehi, 2007. Effects of different pot
mixtures on pothos (Epipremnum aureum Lindl. and Andre ‘Golden
Pothos’) growth and development. American-Eurasian J. Agric.
Environ. Sci., 2: 341-348.
Managecraft, 2001. Results of Analysis of Coconut Husk Fibre or CocoPeat. Managecraft (GH) Ltd., Box 207. Takoradi, Ghana.
Michel, J. 2010. The physical properties of peat: a key factor for modern
growing media. Mires Peat., 6: 1-6.
Noguera, P., M. Abad, V. Noguera, R. Puchades and A. Maquieira, 2000.
Coconut coir waste, a new and viable ecologically friendly peat
substitute. Acta Hort., 517: 279-286.
97
Journal
Journal of Applied Horticulture, 14(2): 98-101, 2012
Appl
I solat ion of biom ole c ule s of pha r m a c ologic a l im por t a nc e
from Ga rc inia indic a fruit a nd eva luat ion of t ot a l a nt iox ida nt
a c t ivit y
P. Ga yat hri a nd P. Govinda ra ju*
Department of Biochemistry, Centre for Plant Molecular Biology & Biotechnology, Tamil Nadu Agricultural University,
Coimbatore – 641 003, Tamil Nadu, India. *E-mail:
[email protected]
Abstract
An investigation was undertaken to study the antioxidant activity of various solvent extracts of the fruit of Garcinia indica using FRAP
assay and to separate the compounds in the potential extract through TLC, HPLC and analyse using GC-MS. The study revealed that
methanol and ethyl acetate extracts showed a higher antioxidant value than the other extracts. The compounds present in the methanol
extracts were separated by TLC, HPLC and analysed using GC-MS. The results of TLC revealed the separation of two different spots
in case of phenols and a single spot in case of alkaloids. The eluted compounds, subjected to HPLC, separated into 8 peaks in case
of phenolics and 8 peaks in case of alkaloids with varying retention time. The HPLC fractions were subjected to GC-MS to identify
the compounds in comparison with the Wilcon-NIST library. The study is useful in identifying the bioactive compound for anticancer
activity using cell lines.
Introduction
Garcinia indica Linn belongs to family Clusiaceae commonly
called as ‘Kokum’ in Maharashtra and cultivated in Konkan,
Goa and the western region of India. Fruits of G. indica have
been suggested in the Indian system of medicine for a number of
diseases. These include its usefulness as an infusion, in skin rashes
caused by allergies, to relieve sunstroke, remedy for dysentery,
an appetizer, liver tonic, to allay thirst and as a cardiotonic
(Khare, 2007). The fruit rind contains polyisoprenylated
benzophenones, garcinol, its isomer isogarcinol, xanthochymol,
and isoxanthochymol (Kirtikar and Basu, 1991). Garcinol has
antioxidative, chelating, free radical scavenging, antiglycation,
anticancer, anti-inflammatory and antiulcer activities (Sheth et
al., 2006; Chattopadhyay et al., 2006). Kokum contains other
compounds with potential antioxidant properties which include
citric acid, malic acid, polyphenols, carbohydrates, anthocyanin
flavonoids and ascorbic acid (Ho et al., 2002; Yamaguchi et al.,
2000).
Free radicals include hydroxyl, superoxide, nitric oxide, nitrogen
dioxide, peroxyl, lipid peroxyl and hydrogen peroxide, which are
generated by products of normal cellular metabolism (Nordberg
and Arner, 2001). The mitochondrial leakage of these reactive
oxygen species leads to oxidative damage of cell components such
as proteins, lipids and nucleic acids (Block et al., 1992). Increased
oxidative stress has been proposed to be one of the major causes
of the pathogenesis of cancer, cardiovascular disease, diabetes
mellitus, neurodegenerative diseases (Alzheimer’s disease
and Parkinson’s disease), autoimmune disorders, rheumatoid
arthritis and ageing (Leifert and Abeywardena, 2008; Leja et
al., 2003; Li et al., 2007). Natural antioxidants such as vitamins
and polyphenols, in vegetables and fruits, are considered to be
responsible for health benefits (Li et al., 2008; Stangeland et al.,
2009). As an important category of phytochemicals, phenolic
compounds universally exist in plants, and have been considered
to have high antioxidant ability and free radical scavenging
capacity, with the mechanism of inhibiting the enzymes
responsible for ROS production and reducing highly oxidised
ROS. In recent years, considerable interest has been shown in
determining total phenolic contents and antioxidant activity of
vegetables, fruits, spices, medicinal plants and algae (Gan et al.,
2010; Ghasemzadeh et al., 2010; Cai et al., 2004; Devasagayam
et al., 2006; Rezaeizadeh et al., 2011).
The aim of this study was to evaluate the total antioxidant activity
of the various extracts of G. indica fruits and to separate the
components of the extract with high activity through TLC, HPLC
and analysed by GC-MS.
Materials and methods
Chemicals and reagents: 2,4,6-tripyridyl-S-triazine (TPTZ)
from M/s. Sigma-Aldrich Chemicals, Bangalore; HPLC grade
methanol, ascorbic acid, bismuth nitrate, sodium acetate, glacial
acetic acid, ferric chloride, potassium iodide, sodium carbonate,
folin ciocalteau reagent, hexane, chloroform, methanol and
ethyl acetate from M/s Merck, Mumbai were used in the study.
Deionized water was used for HPLC analysis. Ready made plates
coated with alumina from M/s Merck, Mumbai was used for the
separation of active components.
Plant material: G. indica fruits were collected from the local
market in Coimbatore.
Preparation of various solvent extracts of G. indica fruit:
Fruits were cut open and the pulp was separated from the rind.
The fruit rinds and pulp were allowed to dry in the shade. The
dried fruit (rind and pulp) was subjected to size reduction to a
Complementary Copy
Key words: Garcinia indica, methanol, ethylacetate, chloroform, hexane, FRAP, antioxidant
Isolation of biomolecules of pharmacological importance from Garcinia indica fruit
Total antioxidant activity: The total antioxidant activity of
the extract of G. indica was assayed by FRAP method (Ferric
Reduction Antioxidant Power) (Benzie and Strain, 1996). One
hundred microlitre of the diluted sample was added to 3 mL of the
FRAP reagent. The absorbance of the mixture was measured at
593 nm in 1cm light path at 37º C using ELICO SL159 UV–Vis
spectrophotometer after 4 min. Briefly, the FRAP reagent was
prepared from sodium acetate buffer (300 mM, pH 3.6), 10 mM
TPTZ solution (40 mM HCl as solvent) and 20 mM iron (III)
chloride solution in a volume ratio of 10:1:1, respectively. The
FRAP reagent was prepared fresh every time and warmed to 37° C
in a water bath before use. A standard solution of 1 mM ascorbic
acid was tested in parallel and the results were expressed as mg
ascorbic acid equivalents/g dry weight of fruit.
Thin layer chromatography: TLC of various extracts of
G. indica whole fruit was performed using readymade plates
coated with alumina. In brief, the plates were cut to the required
dimension (8 x 4 cm) and the extract was spotted using a
capillary tube leaving a distance of 1 cm from the bottom, for
10-15 times to get a concentrated spot. The spotted plates were
placed in a solvent system of Chloroform: acetic acid (9:1) in a
closed chamber and allowed for the run till the solvent mixture
reached three-fourth of the plate. The plate was air dried and
sprayed using the spray reagent Folin’s Ciocalteau (1:1 dilution)
reagent followed by 20% Sodium carbonate, air dried followed by
subsequent drying using drier to identify the presence of phenols.
The solvent system chloroform : methanol (9:1) was used for the
run and the Dragendorff’s reagent was used for spray to identify
the presence of alkaloids. Dragendorff’s reagent was prepared
as under (Sarkozi et al., 2006): Dragendorffs reagent: Solution
A - 1.7 g bismuth nitrate in 100 mL distilled water: acetic acid
(8:2); Solution B - 40 g KI in 100 mL distilled water; Solution
C- 20 mL glacial acetic acid + 70 mL distilled water; Solution D
- Mix 5 mL of solution A, 5 mL of olution B and 90 ml of solution
C just before use.
High performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) analysis
conditions: Methanolic G. indica extract fractions separated by
TLC were filtered using a 0.45 μm nylon filter. 15 μL of the extract
was separated on a Waters dual-pump high-performance liquid
chromatograph (HPLC) using a Waters C-18 Symmetry column
(Milford, MA) and Diode Array Detector. The method used HPLC
grade methanol (mobile phase A) and HPLC grade water (mobile
phase B) with the following linear gradient programme: 85% A,
0 min.; 75% A, 15 min.; 70% A, 20 min.; 45% A, 24 min.; 10%
A, 28 min.; 0% A, 30 min.; and 85% A, 35-40 min. Analytes
were detected at 280 nm and the mobile phase flow rate was 1
mL/min.
GC-MS conditions: The HPLC fractions of phenolics and
alkaloids of G. indica fruit extract were subjected to GC-MS on
a Perkin-Elmer Clarus 500 of mass range between 50-450 m/z
with a flow rate of 1 mL/min. The injection volume was 1 μL
and the Library used was Willey & NIST.
Results and discussion
The results of the total antioxidant activity determined by the
FRAP assay revealed that the methanol extracts of G. indica fruit
had the highest antioxidant activity in terms of mg ascorbic acid
equivalents compared to the other solvent extracts. This may
be due to the efficient extraction of various active components
of antioxidant property especially the phenolics in the methanol
extract.
Table 1. Total antioxidant activity of G. indica fruit
S.No Extract (1g dried sample)
Total antioxidant activity
1. Aqueous
1.32 ± 0.13
2. Chloroform
0.63 ± 0.08
3. Ethyl acetate
6.53 ± 0.62
4. Methanol
7.60 ± 0.51
5. Petroleum ether
0.79 ± 0.25
6. Hexane
2.87 ± 0.39
Values are mean ± SD of triplicates and expressed as equivalents of mg
ascorbic acid
Phenolic compounds have specific health effects even though
they are nonnutritive compounds. Antioxidant properties of
phenolic compounds play a vital role in the antioxidative defence
mechanisms of biological systems (Wright et al., 2001). The
antioxidative effect of phenolics is due to a direct free radical
scavenging activity (Halliwell et al., 2000; Halliwell, 1996),
reducing activity and an indirect effect arising from chelation
of prooxidant metal ions. The chelation of metal ions generally
requires ortho-dihydroxylation on the phenyl ring in phenolic
acids and flavonoids or the presence of a 3- or 5-hydroxyl group in
flavonoids (Shahidi, 2000; Shahidi, 2007). Natural antioxidants
can protect the human body against free radicals, and have also
been shown to retard the progress of a variety of chronic diseases
(cancer, heart disease, diabetes, etc.), as well as ameliorating or
retarding lipid rancidity in foods (Wettasinghe and Shahidi, 1999;
Kinsella et al., 1993).
Thin Layer Chromatography of methanol extract of G. indica whole
fruit was performed using various solvent systems to identify the
presence of secondary metabolites viz., phenols and alkaloids. The
results revealed the presence of phenolic compounds and alkaloids
which was confirmed by the blue and orange colour spots obtained
after spraying with the spray reagent.
HPLC analysis of TLC phenolics fraction of G. indica whole fruit
revealed the separation of the TLC phenol fraction into 4 major
peaks and 5 minor peaks (Fig. 1) with retention time as mentioned
in the Table 2. HPLC analysis of TLC alkaloid fraction of G.
indica revealed the separation of the TLC alkaloid fraction into
3 major peaks and 5 minor peaks (Fig. 2) with retention time as
mentioned in the Table 3.
The phenolic HPLC fraction of G. indica extract was subjected
to GC-MS and the compounds identified in the fraction upon
comparison with the library are shown in Table 4. The alkaloid
HPLC fraction of G. indica extract was subjected to GC-MS and
Complementary Copy
coarse powder. The coarsely powdered form of shade dried whole
fruit was extracted using various solvents viz., hexane, chloroform,
methanol, ethyl acetate using mechanical grinder. Then the
extracts were centrifuged and the supernatant was collected and
the solvent was evaporated at room temperature. The semisolid
extract obtained was stored in an airtight container in refrigerator
for further use. The solution of aqueous extract was prepared by
using normal saline as solvent for experiment. The suspension of
hexane, chloroform, methanol and ethyl acetate extract of G. indica
fruit was prepared in distilled water.
99
100
Isolation of biomolecules of pharmacological importance from Garcinia indica fruit
Table 2. HPLC peaks of TLC phenolics fraction with retention
time
Peak No
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Retention time
2.635
3.147
5.005
5.621
6.208
7.125
9.248
18.400
20.970
Table 3. HPLC peaks of TLC alkaloid fraction with retention
time
Fig. 1. HPLC of TLC phenolics fraction- G. indica
Peak No
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Retention time
3.135
4.133
5.312
6.144
9.621
18.325
20.853
34.630
Fig. 2. HPLC of TLC alkaloid fraction- G. indica
the compounds identified in the fraction upon comparison with
the library are shown in Table 5.
Compound
Trans, Trans-3,12-Dimethoxy-1,6,10dodecatriene
Tridecane,2,2,4,10,12,12-Hexamethyl7(3,5,5-trimethylhexyl
Tetradecanoic Acid, 10,13-Dimethyl,Methyl Ester
Octadecane
M.W Formula
224 C14H24O2
1,7-Dimethoxy-1,6-Heptadiene
394
C28H58
270
C17H34O2
254
C18H38
156
C9H16O2
Based on the study, it is concluded that G. indica fruit is a potent
source of antioxidants. The compounds identified through GCMS can be tested for antioxidant and anticancer activity using
different cell-lines. Further identification of active principles
present in the extract and structural elucidation can be done using
LC-MS and NMR.
Table 5. GC-MS of G. indica extract-Alkaloid-HPLC fraction
Compound
M.W Formula
6-Methyl-7-(Trimethylsilyl)-5-Hepten-1-ol
200 C11H24OSi
2R,3R,4R,5S,6R,8S,10S)-5-Acetoxy-10Benzyloxy-8-Benzyloxymethyl
498
C29H38O7
References
Tetradecanoic Acid, 10,13-Dimethyl, Methyl ester
270
C17H34O2
Benzie, I.F.F. and J.J. Strain, 1996. The ferric reducing ability of plasma
(FRAP) as a measure of “antioxidant power”: The FRAP assay.
Analytical Biochemistry, 239: 70–76.
Block, G., B. Patterson and A. Subar, 1992. Fruit, vegetables, and cancer
prevention: A review of the epidemiological evidence. Nutrition and
Cancer, 18: 1-29.
Cai, Y.Z., Q. Luo, M. Sun and H. Corke, 2004. Antioxidant activity and
phenolic compounds of 112 traditional Chinese medicinal plants
associated with anticancer. Life Science, 74: 2157-2184.
Chattopadhyay, S.K. and S. Kumar, 2006. Identification and quantification
of two biologically active polyisoprenylated benzophenones
xanthochymol and isoxanthochymol in Garcinia species using liquid
chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry. Biomed Chrom., 844
(1): 67-83.
Devasagayam, T.A., A. Mishra, M.A. Bapat and J.C. Tilak, 2006.
Antioxidant activity of Garcinia indica (kokam) and its syrup. Curr.
Sci., 91(1): 90-93.
Gan, R.Y., L. Kuang, X.R. Xu, Y. Zhang, E.Q. Xia and F.L. Song, 2010.
Screening of natural antioxidants from traditional Chinese medicinal
plants associated with treatment of rheumatic disease. Molecules,
15: 5988-5997.
1,2-Dihydro-1,4-Diphenylphthalazine
284
C20H16N2
Octadecane
254
C18H38
Ghasemzadeh, A., H.Z.E. Jaafar and A. Rahmat, 2010. Antioxidant
activities, total phenolics and flavonoids content in two varieties of
Malaysia young ginger (Zingiber officinale Roscoe). Molecules, 15:
4324-433.
Halliwell, B. 1996. Antioxidants in human health and disease. Annual
Review Nutrition, 16: 33-50.
Halliwell, B., M.V. Clement and L.H. Long, 2000. Hydrogen peroxide
in the human body. FEBS Letters, 486: 10-13.
Ho, C.T.S., C.H. Sang, M.H. Liao, Pan and R.T. Rosen, 2002; Chemical
studies on antioxidant mechanism of garcinol: analysis of radical
reaction products of garcinol with peroxyl radicals and their
antitumor activities. Tetrahed., 58: 10095-10102.
Khare, C.P. 2007. Indian Medicinal Plants. An Illustrated Dictionary.
Springer, p.279.
Kinsella, J.E., B. Frackel and J. Kanner, 1993. Possible mechanisms
for the protective role of antioxidants in wine and plant foods. Food
Technology, 47: 85-89.
Complementary Copy
Table 4. GC-MS of G. indica extract - Phenolics -HPLC
fraction
Isolation of biomolecules of pharmacological importance from Garcinia indica fruit
Sarkozi, A., G. Janicsak, L. Kursinszki and A. Kery, 2006.
Chromatographia Suppl., 63: S81.
Shahidi, F. 2000. Antioxidants in food and food antioxidants.
Nahrung., 44: 158-163.
Shahidi, F. 2007. Nutraceuticals and functional foods in health promotion
and disease risk reduction. IUFoST. Shanghai, China, 567-569.
Sheth, A.K., S.V. Joshi and K.D. Mitalia, 2006. The Herbs of Ayurveda,
1st ed., Vol 2, Bhavnagar. p.526.
Stangeland, T., S.F. Remberg and K.A. Lye, 2009. Total antioxidant
activity in 35 Ugandan fruits and vegetables. Food Chemistry, 113:
85-91.
Wettasinghe, M. and F. Shahidi, 1999. Antioxidant and free radical
scavenging properties of ethanolic extracts of defatted borage
(Borago borealis L.) seeds. Food Chemistry, 67: 399-414.
Wright, J.S., E.R. Johnson and G.A. DiLabio, 2001. Predicting the
activity of phenolic antioxidants: theoretical method, analysis of
substituent effects, and application to major families of antioxidants..
Journal of the American Chemical Society, 123: 1173-1183.
Yamaguchi, F., M. Saito, T. Ariga, Y. Yoshimura and H. Nakazawa, 2000.
Antioxidative and anti-glycation activity of garcinol from Garcinia
indica fruit rind. J. Agri. Food Chem., 48: 180-185.
Received: November, 2011; Revised: June, 2012; Accepted: July, 2012
Complementary Copy
Kirtikar, K.R. and B.D. Basu, 1991. Indian Medicinal Plants. Allahabad:
The Indian Press, 2nd ed., Vol. 1, p. 262.
Leifert, W.R. and M.Y. Abeywardena, 2008. Cardioprotective actions of
grape polyphenols. Nutrition Research, 28: 729-737.
Leja, M., A. Mareczek and J. Ben, 2003. Antioxidant properties of two
apple cultivars during long-term storage. Food Chemistry, 80:
303-307.
Li, H.B., K.W. Cheng, C.C. Wong, K.W. Fan, F. Chen and Y. Jiang,
2007. Evaluation of antioxidant capacity and total phenolic content
of different fractions of selected microalgae. Food Chemistry, 102:
771-776.
Li, H.B, C.C. Wong, K.W. Cheng and F. Chen, 2008. Antioxidant
properties in vitro and total phenolic contents in methanol extracts
from medicinal plants. LWT - Food Science and Technology, 41:
385-390.
Nordberg, J. and E.S.J. Arner, 2001. Reactive oxygen specie, antioxidants
and the mammalian thioredoxin system. Free Radical Biology and
Medicine, 31: 287-1312.
Rezaeizadeh, A., B.Z. Zuki, M. Abdollahi, Y.M. Goh, M.M. Noordin, M.
Hamid and T.I. Azmi, 2011. Determination of antioxidant activity
in methanolic and chloroformic extracts of Momordica charantia,
Afr. J. Biotechnol., 10 (24): 4932-4940.
101
Journal
Journal of Applied Horticulture, 14(2): 102-109, 2012
Appl
Post ha r ve st m ic robia l dive rsit y on m a jor c ult iva rs of I ndia n
m a ngoe s
S.N . J ha * , Pra nit a Ja isw a l, K . N a rsa ia h, Rishi Bha rdw a j, Poona m Pre e t K a ur, Ashish Kum a r
Singh, Ra jiv Sha r m a a nd R. Kum a r
Agricultural Structures and Environmental Control Division, Central Institute of Postharvest Engineering & Technology,
Ludhiana 141004, India. *E-mail:
[email protected]
Abstract
Microbial diversity on fruit surface of nine mango cultivars (Alphonso, Banganapalli, Chausa, Dashehri, Kesar, Langra, Mallika,
Maldah and Neelam) harvested from orchards of nine Indian states (Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Gujarat, Karnataka, Maharashtra, Orissa,
Punjab, Tamil Nadu and Uttar Pradesh) were studied using standard methods. A total of 47 fungal and 123 bacterial isolates were
purified from 761 mango samples, which included 63 Gram positive and 60 Gram negative bacterial isolates. The relative abundance
of Gram positive, Gram negative bacteria and different filamentous fungi varied among cultivars. Gram positive bacteria dominated on
Langra of Uttar Pradesh, while Dashehri from Punjab showed dominance of Gram negative bacteria. Among total fungal isolates, the
common genera were Aspergillus and Fusarium, while among bacterial isolates, the most common genera were Bacillus, Aeromonas,
Pseudomonas, Lactobacillus, Citrobacter, Mycobacterium and Serratia. Alphonso and Kesar variety from Maharashtra showed
maximum and minimum fungal diversity, respectively. Genera and species identified include members known for spoilage of fruits;
having all types of pectinase and cellulase activities and those used in biocontrol of plant pathogens.
Introduction
Mango (Mangifera indica) is an important tropical fruit and
India is the largest mango producer contributing 37% of 30.5
million tons of total global mango production. Annually, India
supplies 50,000 tons of mangoes to different parts of the world
including Japan, Middle East, Europe and United States and the
demand is increasing year by year (Pandit et al., 2009). However,
tropical and subtropical fruits such as mango present greater
problems in transportation and storage due to its perishable
nature and presence of numerous microflora on its surface (Mitra
and Baldwin, 1997) which may cause spoilage of fruits. The
postharvest loss of such perishable commodities is estimated to
be as high as 50% (Mitra and Baldwin, 1997). This can partly be
reduced by knowing the spectrum of microbial community and
devising the measures to reduce their effect.
Microorganisms associated with postharvest spoilage of fruits
have drawn attention of scientists for years (Verma et al., 1991;
Okigbo, 2001). Mango fruit is also susceptible to many postharvest
diseases such as anthracnose (Colletotrichum gloeosporoides) and
stem end rot (Lasiodiplodia theobromae) during storage under
ambient conditions or even at low temperature (Arauz, 2000).
Spoilage microbes are capable of colonizing and creating lesions
on healthy, undamaged plant tissue (Tournas, 2005). Many
spoilage microorganisms use their extra cellular lytic enzymes
to degrade plant polymers into simpler fractions which can be
used as nutrients for their growth. Fungi and many bacterial
strains produce an abundance of extracellular pectinases and
hemicellulases, which play a major role in spoilage (Miedes and
Lorences, 2004). Besides, many microbes isolated from the fruit
surface have been identified to be useful agents in postharvest
treatment (Wisniewski and Wilson, 1992; Wilson et al., 1993).
Extensive studies have been conducted on the diversity of
epiphytic microbes on annuals bearing deciduous leaves (De
Jager et al., 2001; Joshi, 2008). Recently microbial population
on long living leaves of evergreen trees like mangoes have also
been studied (Pruvost and Luisetti, 1991; De Jager et al., 2001;
Ngarmsak et al., 2006). Information on microbial diversity on
Indian varieties of mangoes is missing, thererefore the objective
of this investigation was to study the microbial diversity on
the surface of mango fruit for deciding strategies to reduce
postharvest spoilage of commercially important varieties.
Materials and methods
Sampling procedure: Major mango cultivars (Alphonso,
Banganapalli, Chausa, Dashehri, Kesar, Langra, Maldah, Mallika
and Neelam) were collected from orchards of nine Indian states
(Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Gujarat, Karnataka, Maharashtra,
Orissa, Punjab, Tamil Nadu and Uttar Pradesh) using complete
randomized block design (Jha et al., 2010). Fruits with 5-10 cm
stalk were manually plucked directly in pre-sterilized zip locked
plastic bags in the forenoon, from each side and also from centre
of tree canopy in random manner. Sampling schedule along
with abbreviations used for each cultivar is presented in Table
1. Zip locked plastic bags were transported to the laboratory
in the well ventilated corrugated fiber board boxes along with
partially refrigerated gel packs placed in between the two layers
of mangoes to minimize the quality loss (Jha et al., 2010).
Isolation and growth of bacterial and fungal isolates:
Microbial communities from the mango fruit were isolated by
washing and dilution plating method (Jha et al., 2010). In order
to isolate total microbial diversity from mango surface, three
Complementary Copy
Key words: Bacteria, biochemical, diversity, filamentous fungi, mango, relative abundance
Postharvest microbial diversity on major cultivars of Indian mangoes
mangoes from each cultivars were used in experimentation.
The mangoes were washed and suitable dilutions of wash water
were prepared. Inoculums from different dilutions containing
surface micro flora from mango were plated on Nutrient Agar
(NA) and Potatao Dextrose Agar (PDA, Himedia, India) plates
in triplicate (Atlas and Snyder, 2006). NA plates were incubated
at 37oC and PDA plates at 28oC. After incubation, the individual
colonies were picked up and purified with streak plate method.
The isolates were grown on their respective media in petriplates
or slants to study their morphological features. Bacterial isolates
were characterized based on shape, color, surface and edge of
the bacterial colonies while filamentous fungi were characterized
based on their hyphal and spore characteristics according to
Hawksworth et al. (1995). Identification of filamentous fungi was
further confirmed at NTCC (National Type Culture Collection
Center), Indian Agricultural Research Institute, New Delhi based
on morphological features.
Biochemical characteristics: Each bacterial isolate was
propagated in nutrient broth before use and an overnight culture
was employed in the tests. Standard staining procedures (such
as Gram’s staining, Negative staining, Acid fast staining,
Spore staining) and biochemical tests namely citrate, urease,
hydrogen sulfide production, carbohydrate utilization test,
lactose fermentation test, glucose oxidation and fermentation test,
indole production test, methyl red test, oxidase test, catalase test,
flouroscein production test, cellulose degradation test and pectin
hydrolysis test were used for characterization of microbial isolates
using commercially available media (Himedia, India). The
isolated organisms were purified and assayed as recommended
in Bergey’s manual (Holt et al., 1994).
Statistical analysis: Evenness/Relative abundance (RA):
Evenness is defined as a measure of the relative abundance of
different species which was calculated as below:
RA (%) = (N x 100) /T
Where, N = Total number of isolates belonging to one group
T = Total number of isolates belonging to all groups
Richness was calculated as number of species per sample.
Simpson’s Index (D) was calculated as below:
D = ∑ (n/N)2
Where, n = Total no. of organisms of a particular species
N = Total no. of organisms of all species
Simpson’s Index of Diversity
Simpson’s index of diversity = 1 – D
Where, D = Simpson’s index
Results and discussion
Bacterial diversity: Microbial diversity describes complexity
and variability at different levels in an ecosystem where, microbes
play a crucial role in biological organization. Special interest
in the fruit surface microorganisms exist in view of identifying
microbes responsible for spoilage of mango fruit and further
development of biosensor by generating antibodies against them
for quick identification. Further, microbes present on plant surface
have been reported to fix atmospheric nitrogen, compete with
plant parasites, produce plant growth regulator such as gibberellic
acid and produce lipases which degrade surface waxes (Chun
and Mc Donald, 1987). If such organism also resides on fruit,
they may predispose fruit to moisture loss and decay during long
term storage. In current scenario, the adverse effects of synthetic
chemical residues on human health and the environment have lead
scientists from all over the world to develop alternative control
strategies such as studies on natural microbial diversity on fruit
surface and their role in plant protection.
A total of 123 bacterial strains were isolated from the mango
fruit samples of nine major cultivars collected from nine Indian
states. All the isolates were characterized initially based on the
biochemical nature of cell wall using standard Gram staining
procedure. Results indicated that among total 123 isolates,
Gram positive and Gram negative bacterial isolates were found
to be 51.22 and 48.78%, respectively. The RA of Gram positive
bacteria varied from 11.11% in CU to 75.00 % in LU (Table 2),
while that of Gram negative bacteria varied from 25.00 % in
LU to a maximum of 100.00 % in DP. In variety BA and NT,
the RA of Gram positive and Gram negative was found to be
almost same. Results showed great variation in RA of Gram
positive and Gram negative bacteria among different mango
cultivars (except BA, MO and NT) which might be attributed
to variation in environmental condition (humidity) at the time
of sampling at different sampling site. Silva et al. (2000) also
reported that the percent composition of Gram positive and Gram
negative bacteria is mainly governed by moisture content of the
atmosphere, with Gram positive bacteria dominated in wet and
Gram negative bacteria in dry atmosphere. The percentage of
rods was found to be twice that of cocci in both Gram positive
and Gram negative bacteria in all the mango cultivars indicating
the dominance of spoilage causing microflora, as most of the
bacterial strains responsible for spoilage of fruits and vegetables
are reported to be Gram positive or Gram negative rods (Frazier
and Westhoff, 2008).
Among total bacterial isolates, the colonies of 55 isolates were
found to be pigmented (Table 3). Such chromogenic isolates
potentially have selective advantage over other inhabitants
because their pigmentation protects them from ultra violet
radiation and are frequently isolated and had been reported to
colonize plant surface in large numbers (Crosse, 1971; Hirano
and Upper, 1991; Mansvelt and Hattingh, 1987).
Biochemical characterization of all the 123 bacterial isolates
showed presence of 63 Gram positive and 60 Gram negative
isolates (Table 3). Among Gram positive isolates, 40 were found
to be rod shaped and the rest 23 were cocci form. Further, among
Complementary Copy
Table 1. Abbreviations used for mango cultivars harvested from different
locations
Name of cultivar
Place of procurement
Abbreviations used
Alphonso
Karnataka
AK
Alphonso
Maharashtra
AM
Banganapalli
Andhra Pradesh
BA
Banganapalli
Orissa
BO
Chausa
Punjab
CP
Chausa
Uttar Pradesh
CU
Dashehri
Punjab
DP
Dashehri
Uttar Pradesh
DU
Kesar
Gujarat
KG
Kesar
Maharashtra
KM
Langra
Uttar Pradesh
LU
Maldha
Bihar
MB
Mallika
Orissa
MO
Neelam
Tamil Nadu
NT
103
104
Postharvest microbial diversity on major cultivars of Indian mangoes
Table 2. Number and Relative abundance of Gram positive and Gram negative bacteria from different mango cultivars
AK
AM
BA
BO
CP
CU
DP
DU
KG
KM
LU
MB
MO
NT
Gram positive Gram positive Gram negative Gram negative Gram positive Gram positive Gram negative Gram negative
(number)
(RA)
(number)
(RA)
rods (RA)
cocci (RA)
rods (RA)
cocci (RA)
9
13
5
4
4
1
0
1
6
5
3
1
4
7
52.94
72.22
50.00
57.14
66.67
11.11
0.00
25.00
60.00
62.50
75.00
16.67
44.44
50.00
8
5
5
3
2
8
1
3
4
3
1
5
5
7
47.06
27.78
50.00
42.86
33.33
88.89
100.00
75.00
40.00
37.50
25.00
83.33
55.56
50.00
Gram positive rods, 14 isolates were found to form spores and
26 were non-spore formers. These spore forming strains were
purified under purely aerobic conditions, therefore, the isolates
identified belonged to genera Bacillus. Among the 26 non-spore
formers, 10 showed positive acid fast reaction, which may be from
genus Mycobacterium and remaining 16 showed the negative acid
fast reaction. Further, results of catalase test showed that all the
16 bacterial isolates with negative acid fast reaction belonged
to Lactobacillus genus, out of which 13 bacterial isolates
showed acid formation on glucose fermentation test, which gave
indication that these isolates may be L. casei or L. delbrueckii and
remaining 3 bacterial isolates gave no reaction, indicating that
they belong to other species of Lactobacillus genera.
Bacillus spp. as a group is one of the important components of
soil microbial community (Prescott et al., 2006). Many Bacillus
spp. had been reported to secrete wide range of degradative
enzymes such as cellulases, amylases, pectinases and proteases
(Silva et al., 2000). Both pectinase and pectate lyase had been
reported from Bacillus spp. (Soriano et al., 2000). In current
investigation many identified isolates as Bacillus (according to
Bergey’s manual) have shown presence of hydrolytic enzymes
cellulases and pectinases, which might endow them with the
advantage of colonizing the fruit surface. De Jager et al. (2001)
also reported the predominance of Bacillus pumilis on mango leaf
surface besides other bacterial genera (Cornyform, Pseudomonas,
Xanthomonas and Erwinia) found to be present on mango
phylloplane.
All 23 isolated Gram positive cocci showed negative catalase
activity indicating that they may either belong to Streptococcus or
Enterococcus genus (Table 3). Among 60 Gram negative bacterial
isolates, 37 were rod shape and rest were cocci. Among Gram
negative rods 26 isolates showed positive oxidase test, and other
11 showed negative oxidase test. The isolates showing negative
oxidase test belonged to family Enterobacteriaceae. Out of 26
isolates with positive oxidase test, 24 exhibited acid production
on glucose fermentation, further, they didn’t require presence of
sodium in the medium for growth. Therefore, isolates represent
characteristics of genus Aeromonas as given in Bergey’s manual
and rest of bacterial strains (2), although were able to ferment
glucose, didn’t produce acid in the medium. Thereby, indicating
that these isolates can belong to genus Pseudomonas. Among
the Gram negative bacterial isolates, Aeromonas was found to
35.29
38.89
40.00
42.86
50.00
0.00
0.00
25.00
30.00
62.50
50.00
0.00
11.11
35.71
17.65
33.33
10.00
14.29
16.67
11.11
0.00
0.00
30.00
0.00
25.00
16.67
33.33
14.29
29.41
22.22
30.00
28.57
16.67
44.44
100.00
50.00
20.00
37.50
25.00
50.00
33.33
28.57
17.65
5.56
20.00
14.29
16.67
44.44
0.00
25.00
20.00
0.00
0.00
33.33
22.22
21.43
be the most dominant genera as it has been isolated from 12
mango cultivars (AK10, AK11, AK17, AM04, AM06, AM07,
AM12, BA05, BA09, BA10, BO03, CP06, CU01, CU02, CU07,
DU03, KG09, KM03, KM08, MB02, MB06, LU03, NT07 and
NT10), while Pseudomonas was found on BO02, MO07 and
NT05 cultivars. Aeromonas is widely found in nature including
decomposing vegetable matter, while Pseudomonas is well known
for their ability to metabolize a variety of diverse nutrients (Frazier
and Westhoff, 2008). Many strains have been reported to play an
important role in environmental biotechnological applications
(Walsh et al., 2001; Mark et al., 2006; Ali Khan and Ahmad,
2006). However, on the contrary, many other have been reported
to be phytopathogen and are widely dispersed on plants mainly
on leaves and rhizosphere (Silva et al., 2000). Bacterial isolates
belonging to Enterobacteriaceae family were further sub grouped
based on the lactose fermentation test and results indicated that
7 (MB03, DU02, MO08, CU08, KG01, MO09 and NT01) were
able to ferment lactose (Table 3). Further MB03 showed indole
production by oxidizing an essential amino acid tryptophan,
which utilized citrate as sole carbon source and showed negative
VP test which is characteristic of genus Citrobacter. DU02 and
MO08 were able to ferment lactose, showed indole production
but did not show citrate reaction, which is characteristic of genus
Escherichia. CU08, KG01, MO09 and NT01 did not oxidize
tryptophan but KG01 showed positive reaction for both MRVP tests indicating that KG01 may be Enterobacter intermedius.
CU08 & MO09 showed positive test for methyl red only and NT01
showed positive VP test only indicating that CU08 and MO09 may
be Serratia fonticola / Klebsiella pneumoniae (subsp. Ozaenae)
/ Citrobacter freundii and NT01 may be Klebsiella pneumoniae
(subsp. pneumoniae)/ Enterobacter spp. / Erwinia caotovora /
Serratia rubidaea. The other four isolates of Enterobacteriaceae
family showing negative reaction for lactose fermentation were
able to oxidize tryptophan to indole and showed negative result for
hydrogen sulfide production test, may belong to genus Morgenella
/Providencia. Enterobacter is a common inhabitant of soil and
sewage. Erwinia spp. is another common Gram negative spoilage
microbe associated with fresh-cut vegetables. Erwinia, a genus
within the family Enterobacteriaceae are small rods and facultative
anaerobes. Erwinia is reported to cause rapid necrosis, progressive
tissue maceration called “soft-rot”, occlusion of vessel elements
called “vascular wilt,” and hypertrophy leading to gall or tumor
formation in plant tissues (Margaret et al., 2009). Brocklehurst et al.
(1987) and Manvell and Ackland (1986) identified E. carotovora as
Complementary Copy
Cultivar
Table 3. Morphological and biochemical characteristics of bacterial isolates from nine different mango cultivars
Morphological characteristic
Biochemical characteristics
Isolate
Group
G N
S
A
P
T
S
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9 10 11
AK1
A
+
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
AK2
A
+
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
AK3
A
+
R
+
+
+
+
+
AK4
A
+
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
AK5
A
+
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
AK6
B
+
C
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
AK7
B
+
C
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
AK8
B
+
C
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
AK9
A
+
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
AK10
C
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
AK11
C
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
AK12
C
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
AK13
D
C
+
+
+
+
+
+
AK14
D
C
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
AK15
D
C
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
AK16
C
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
AK17
C
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
AM1
B
+
C
+
+
+
+
+
+
AM2
A
+
R
+
+
+
+
+
AM3
B
+
C
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
AM4
C
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
AM5
B
+
C
+
+
+
+
+
+
AM6
C
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
AM7
C
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
AM8
B
+
C
+
+
+
+
+
+
AM9
A
+
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
AM10
A
+
R
+
+
+
+
AM11
A
+
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
AM12
C
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
AM13
A
+
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
AM14
A
+
C
+
+
+
+
+
+
AM15
A
+
C
+
+
+
+
+
AM16
D
C
+
+
+
+
+
+
AM17
A
+
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
AM18
A
+
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
BA1
A
+
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
BA2
B
+
C
+
+
+
+
+
+
BA3
D
C
+
+
+
+
+
+
BA4
A
+
R
+
+
+
+
+
BA5
C
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
BA6
D
C
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
BA7
A
+
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
BA8
A
+
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
BA9
C
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
BA10
C
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
BO1
D
C
+
+
+
+
+
+
BO2
C
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
BO3
D
C
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
BO4
A
+
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
BO5
B
+
C
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
BO6
A
+
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
BO7
A
+
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
CP1
B
+
C
+
+
+
+
+
+
CP2
A
+
R
+
+
+
+
+
CP3
A
+
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
CP4
D
C
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
CP5
A
+
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
CP6
C
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
CU1
C
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
CU2
C
R
+
+
+
+
+
+
CU3
D
C
+
+
+
+
+
CU4
B
+
C
+
+
+
+
+
-
105
12
-
13
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
14
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
-
15
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
-
16
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
-
17
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
-
Complementary Copy
Postharvest microbial diversity on major cultivars of Indian mangoes
CU5
CU6
CU7
CU8
CU9
DP1
DU1
DU2
DU3
DU4
KG1
KG2
KG3
KG4
KG5
KG6
KG7
KG8
KG9
KG10
KM1
KM2
KM3
KM4
KM5
KM6
KM7
KM8
MB1
MB2
MB3
MB4
MB5
MB6
LU1
LU2
LU3
LU4
MO1
MO2
MO3
MO4
MO5
MO6
MO7
MO8
MO9
NT1
NT2
NT3
NT4
NT5
NT6
NT7
NT8
NT9
NT10
NT11
NT12
NT13
NT14
Postharvest microbial diversity on major cultivars of Indian mangoes
D
D
C
C
D
C
D
C
C
A
C
B
D
A
D
B
A
B
C
A
A
A
C
A
C
A
A
C
B
C
C
D
D
C
A
A
C
B
B
A
D
B
D
B
C
C
C
C
A
D
D
C
A
C
A
A
C
A
B
D
B
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
C
C
R
R
C
R
C
R
R
R
R
C
C
R
C
C
R
C
R
R
R
R
R
R
R
R
R
R
C
R
R
C
C
R
R
R
R
C
C
R
C
C
C
C
R
R
R
R
R
C
C
R
R
R
R
R
R
R
C
C
C
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
-
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
-
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
-
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
-
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
-
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
-
+
-
-
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
-
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
-
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
-
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
-
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
-
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
-
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
-
G=Gram reaction, N=Negative staining, S=Spore staining, A=Acid fast staining, P=Pigmented colony, T=Transparent colony, S=Smooth edge on colony.
Biochemical characteristics: 1=Lactose fermentation 2=Casein Hydrolysis 3=Starch hydrolysis 4=Flouroscein production 5=Peroxidase reaction
6=Gelatin hydrolyis 7=Methyl red test 8=Voges-Proseuker test 9=Urease test 10= Indole production test 11=Citrate utilization test 12= Hydrogen
sulphide production test 13=Glucose fermentation test 14= Oxidase test 15 = Cellulose degradation test 16=Pectate lyase production test 17= Pectinase
production test
Complementary Copy
106
Postharvest microbial diversity on major cultivars of Indian mangoes
107
Mango cultivar
Alphonso,
Maharashtra
Isolate
AM01
AM02, 07, 10
AM08
AM03, 04, 06
AM05, 13
AM09
Alphonso,
AK02,0 4
Karnataka
AK03
Baganpalli,
BA02
Andhra Pradesh
BA08
Baganpalli, Orissa BO03
Chausa, Punjab
CP01, 03
CP02
Chausa,
CU01
Uttar Pradesh
CU04
CU03
CU06
Dashehri, Punjab DP01
DP02
DP03
DP04
Kesar, Gujarat
KG01
KG02
KG03
Kesar, Maharashtra KM01, 02
Langra,
LU01
Uttar Pradesh
LU02
LU03
Maldah, Bihar
MB01
MB03
Mallika, Orissa
MO05
MO01
MO06
MO02
MO03
Neelam,
NT01
Tamil Nadu
NT02
NT03, 4
Fungus
Evenness / Relative
Abundance, RA (%)
Species
9.09
A. fumigatus
27.27
A. flavus
9.09
A. niger
27.27
Fusarium
F. solani
18.18
Alternaria
A. alternata
9.09
Cladosporium
C .cladosporioides
66.66
Aspergillus
A. niger
33.33
A. flavus
50
Aspergillus
A.terreus
50
Pencillium
P. citrinum
100
Aspergillus
A. niger
66.67
Aspergillus
A. fumigatus
33.33
Pencillium
P. chrysogenum
25
Fusarium
F. moniliforme
25
F. oxysporum
25
Aspergillus
A. flavus
25
A. fumigatus
25
Fusarium
F. pallidoroseum
25
Aspergillus
A. niger
25
A. nidulans
25
A. fumigatus
33.33
Fusarium
F. moniliforme
Aspergillus
A. fumigatus
33.33
33.33
A. flavus
100
Aspergillus
A. niger
33.33
Alternaria
A. alternata
33.33
Aspergillus
A. niger
33.33
Heminthosporium H. spiciferum
50
Aspergillus
A. fumigatus
50
Trichoderma
T. longibrachiatum
20
Fusarium
F. pallidoroseum
20
Pencillium
P. chrysogenum
20
P. oxalicum
20
Aspergillus
A. terreus
20
A. niger
25
Aspergillus
A. flavus
25
A. terreus
50
A. niger
Genera
Aspergillus
a principal spoilage microbe of both fresh-cut and fresh vegetables.
Buick and Damoglou (1987) found that E. carotovora was the
dominant spoilage microorganism on sliced carrots packed in air,
consisting of more than 80% of total detectable microflora. Robbs
et al. (1996) identified Erwinia in 5 of 16 soft-rot samples of
fresh-cut celery. Erwinia had been reported to produce pectinolytic
enzymes, which cause degradation of cell wall leading to soft rot
disease (Lund, 1983).
All the bacterial isolates were tested for presence of hydrolytic
enzymes. Out of 123 isolates, 50 showed cellulase activity and 32
showed pectin hydrolysis out of which 17 showed production of
pectatae lyase and 15 showed production of polygalacturonase.
Such microbes having capability of producing hydrolytic
enzymes may use it to overcome plant defence mechanisms and
gain access to plant nutrients. The pectolytic enzymes, including
pectin methyl esterase (PME), polygalacturonase (PG), pectin
lyase (PNL), and pectate lyase (PL), can degrade pectins in the
middle lamella of the cell, thereby resulting in liquefaction of the
plant tissue leading to conditions such as soft rot.
Besides, many strains of Bacillus and Erwinia had been reported
to show antagonistic effect against pathogens causing black spot
Species
Richness
Simpson’s
index (D)
Simpson’s index of
Diversity (1-D)
6
0.17
0.83
2
0.56
0.44
2
0.50
0.50
1
1.00
0.00
2
0.56
0.44
4
0.25
0.75
4
0.25
0.75
3
0.33
0.66
1
1.00
0.00
3
0.33
0.66
2
0.50
0.50
5
0.20
0.80
3
0.37
0.63
of mango (Pruvost and Luisetti, 1991). Okigbo and Osuinde
(2003) reported bio-control of fungal leaf spot disease of mango
with Bacillus subtilis. In South Africa, concerted efforts had been
made to develop biocontrol agent against anthracnose disease
of mango (Burger and Korsten, 1988). Korsten et al. (1991)
reported effective reduction in the incidence of the disease when
Bacillus licheniformis was used as either pre or postharvest
application. They further reported that the efficacy of the biocontrol agent could be further improved when it was applied with
recommended fungicide used at lower concentration (Korsten et
al., 1992, Silimela and Korsten, 2001). Bacillus licheniformis is
now available in commercial formulation (Mango green), and is
reported to effectively reduce the fungal population from mango
surface (Govender et al., 2005).
Fungal diversity: Altogether 47 filamentous fungal isolates were
purified from mango fruit surface of nine mango cultivars and
among them the most abundant genera was Aspergillus followed
by Fusarium and Pencillium with a relative abundance (RA) of
60.00, 17.00 and 8.00 %, respectively. Other fungi identified
in minority belonged to genus Alternaria, Cladosporium,
Helminthosporium and Trichoderma.
Complementary Copy
Table 4. Mold diversity on different mango cultivars from different parts of India
Postharvest microbial diversity on major cultivars of Indian mangoes
Among the genus Aspergillus, the dominant species were A.niger,
A. flavus and A. fumigates., while the genus Fusarium was
dominated by F. monoliforme. Aspergillus species are highly
aerobic and widespread in nature, being found on fruits, vegetables
and other substrates which may provide nutriment, where they
commonly grow as molds on the surface of a substrate, as a
result of the high oxygen tension. Some species of this genus are
involved in food spoilage (Pelczar et al., 2008).
Acknowledgement
Aspergillus niger and Aspergillus flavus were found to be most
common on mango cultivars representing 23.00 and 15.00 % of
the total fungal isolates, respectively. Aspergillus niger is reported
to cause black mould disease on certain fruits and vegetables such
as grapes, onions and peanuts and is a common contaminant of
food. It is ubiquitous in soil and is commonly reported from indoor
environments (Frazier and Westhoff, 2008). Fungal composition
did not vary much among the cultivars however, maximum
species richness was found on AM followed by MO, CU and DP
while lowest on BO and KM. Alphonso mango harvested from
Maharastra (AM) showed presence of 11 fungi belonging to genus
Aspergillus, Fusarium, Alternaria and Cladosporium with RA
45.45, 27.23, 18.18 and 9.09 %, respectively, thereby exhibiting
highest Simpson’s index of diversity (measure of the probability
that two individuals randomly selected from a sample will belong
to the same species.) amongst various mango cultivars under
study (Table 4). While cv. BO and KM showed the presence of
Aspergillus niger only and hence, depicting lowest species richness
and Simpson’s diversity index (Table 4). Tournas and Katsoudas
(2005) also reported the dominance of Alternaria, Cladosporium,
Penicilium, Fusarium, Trichoderma, Geotrichum, Rhizopus and
A. niger in their study with citrus fruits.
Ali Khan, M.W. and M. Ahmad, 2006. Detoxification and bioremediation
potential of a Pseudomonas fluorescens isolate against the major
Indian water pollutants. J. Environ. Sci. Health Part A Toxic/
Hazardous Subsances Environ. Eng., 41(4): 659-674.
Atlas, R.M. and J.W. Snyder, 2006. Handbook of Media for Clinical
microbiology. CRC Press, London.
Arauz, L.F. 2000. Mango anthracnose: economic impact and current
options for exported mango. Plant Disease, 84: 600-611.
Barnby, F.M., F.F. Morpeth and D.L. Pyle, 1990. Endopolygalacturonase
production from Kluyveromyces marxianus. I. Resolution,
purification and partial characterization of the enzyme. Enzym.
Microb. Tech., 12: 891-897.
Brocklehurst, T.F., C.M. Zaman-Wong and B.M. Lund, 1987. A note
on the microbiology of retail packs of prepared salad vegetables. J.
Appl. Bact., 63: 409-415.
Buick, R.K. and P.A. Damoglou, 1987. The effect of vacuum-packaging
on the microbial spoilage and shelf-life of “ready-to-use” sliced
carrots. J. Sci. Food Agr., 38: 167-175.
Burger, R. and L. Korsten, 1988. Isolation of antagonistic bacteria against
Xanthomonas campestris pv. Mangiferaeindicae. South African
Mango Growers Association Yearbook, 8: 9-10.
Chun, D. and R.E. Mcdonald, 1987. Seasonal trends in the population
dynamics of fungi, yeasts and bacteria on fruit surface of grape fruit
in Florida. Proc. Florida State Hort. Soc., 100: 23-25.
Crosse, J.E. 1971. Interactions between saprophytic and pathogenic
bacteria in plant disease. In: Ecology of Leaf Surface Microorganisms,
Preece, T.F., C.H. Dickinson, (eds.). Academic Press, London. p.
283-90.
De Jager, E.S., F.C. Wehner and L. Korsten, 2001. Microbial ecology on
the mango phylloplane. Microbial Ecol., 42: 201-207.
Frazier, C.W. and C.D. Westhoff, 2008. Food Microbiology. Fourth
Edition. McGraw Hill, New Delhi.
Govender, V., L. Korsten and D. Sivakumar, 2005. Semi-commercial
evaluation of Bacillus licheniformis to control mango postharvest
disease in South Africa. Postharvest Biol. Technol., 38: 57-65.
Hawksworth, D.L., P.M. Kirk, B.C. Sutton and D.N. Pegler, 1995.
Ainsworth and Bisby’s Dictionary of the Fungi. CAB International,
Wallinford, UK.
Hirano, S.S. and C.D. Upper, 1991. Bacterial community dynamics.
In: Microbiol. Ecology of leaves. J.H. Andrew and S.S. Hirano
(eds.).Springer-Verlag, New York. p. 271-294.
Holt, J.G., N.R. Krieg, P.H.A. Sneath, J.T. Stanley and S.T. Williams,
1994. In: Bergey’s Manual of Determinative Bacteriology. M.D.
Baltimore, (eds.). Ninth edition. Williams & Wilkins. p. 787.
Hoondal, G.S, R.P. Tiwari, R. Tewari, N. Dahiya and G.K. Beg, 2002.
Microbial alkaline pectinases and their industrial applications - A
review. Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol., 59: 409-418.
Jha, S.N., P. Jaiswal, K. Narsaiah, R. Bhardwaj, R. Sharma, R. Kumar
and A. Basedia, 2010. Postharvest micro-flora on major cultivars of
Indian mangoes. Scientia Hort., 125(4): 617-621.
Joshi, S.R. 2008. Influence of roadside pollution on the phylloplane
microbial community of Alnus nepalensis (Betulaceae). Rev. de boil.
Trop., 56(3): 1521-1529.
Korsten, L., J.H. Lonsdale, E. De Villiers and E.S.De Jager, 1992.
Preharvest Biological Control of Mango Diseases. South African
Mango Growers Association Yearbook, 12: 72-74.
The fungal isolates were tested for presence of hydrolytic
enzymes (cellulases and pectinases) and results indicated that
6 out of 47 isolates showed presence of one or more hydrolytic
enzymes (data not shown). Majority of these isolates belonged
to genus Aspergillus except one, which belonged to genus
Alternaria. Aspergillus is well known fungus for its hydrolytic
activity. Almost all the commercial preparartions of pectinases
are produced from fungal sources (Singh et al., 1999). Aspergillus
niger is the most commonly used fungal species for industrial
production of pectinolytic enzymes (Kotzekidov, 1991; Barnby
et al., 1990; Naidu and Panda, 1998).
Current study showed that mango surface harbored a huge
microbial diversity, which comprised varietal as well as regional
variation. In general, Gram positive rods showed predominance
in bacterial community and Aspergillus spp. in fungal community.
The highest fungal diversity was observed in variety AM, followed
by MO, CU, DP, KG, LU, NT, BA, MB, AK, CP, BO, KM. This
study is an important step in identification of spectrum of microbial
community on mango surface which will be helpful in devising
measures to reduce the effect of spoilage and pathogenic microbes.
Further, the available bio-resources on mango surface can be used
to screen the potential micro-flora with a role in biocontrol of plant
diseases, for production of metabolite/enzyme of commercial
importance or for the development of instrumental methods such
as biosensors, spectroscopic instruments, etc. for rapid detection
of microbial as well as physico-chemical characteristics.
This research was supported by the National Agricultural Innovation
Project (NAIP), Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR)
through its subproject entitled “Development of non-destructive
systems for evaluation of microbial and physico-chemical quality
parameters of mango” Code number “C1030”.
References
Complementary Copy
108
Korsten, L., M.W.S. Van harmelen, A. Heitmann, E. DeVilliers and E.S. De
Jager, 1991. Biological Control of Postharvest Mango Fruit Diseases.
South African Mango Growers Association Yearbook, 11: 65-67.
Kotzekidov, P. 1991. Production of polygalacturonases by Byssachlamys
fulva. J. Ind. Microbiol., 7: 53-56.
Lichtenberg, E. and D. Zilberman, 1987. Regulating environmental and
human health risk from agricultural residuals. Appl. Agr. Res., 2:
56-64.
Lund, B.M. 1983. Bacterial spoilage. In: Postharvest Pathology of
Fruits and Vegetables. Dennis, C. (ed.). Academic Press, London.
p. 218-257.
Mansvelt, E.L. and M.J. Hattingh, 1987. Scanning electron microscopy of
colonization of pear leaves by Pseudomonas syringae pv. Syringae.
Canad. J. Bot., 65: 2517-2522.
Manvell, P.M. and M.R. Ackland, 1986. Rapid detection of microbial
growth in vegetable salads at chill and abuse temperatures. Food
Microbiol., 3: 59-65.
Margaret, B., R.H. Thomas, Z. Hong and B. Frederick, 2009.
Microbiological Spoilage of Fruits and Vegetables. In: Compendium
of the Microbiological Spoilage of Foods and Beverages. Food
Microbiology and Food Safety, Sperber, W.H. and M.P. Doyle, (eds.).
doi, 10.1007/978-1-4419-0826-1_6, ©Springer Science+Business
Media, LLC, 2009.
Mark, G., J.P. Morrissey, P. Higgins and F. O’gara, 2006. Molecularbased strategies to exploit Pseudomonas biocontrol strains for
environmental biotechnology applications. FEMS Microbiol. Ecol.,
56(2): 167-177.
Miedes, E. and E.P. Lorences, 2004. Apples (Malus domenstica)
and tomato (Lycopersicum) fruits cell-wall hemicelluloses and
xyloglucan degradation during pencillium expansum infection. J.
Agr. Food Chem., 52: 7957-7963.
Mitra, S.K. and E.Z. Baldwin,1997. Mango. In: Postharvest Physiology
and Storage of Tropical and Subtropical Fruits, CAB International,
West Bengal, India. p. 85-122.
Naidu, G.S.N. and T. Panda, 1998. Production of pectolytic enzymes-A
review. Bioproc. Eng., 19: 355-361.
Ngarmsak, M., P. Delaquis, P. Toivonen, T. Ngarmsak, B. Ooraikul
and G. Mazza, 2006. Microbiology of fresh-cut mangoes prepared
from fruit sanitised in hot chlorinated water. Food Sci. Tech. Inter.,
12: 95-103.
Okigbo, R.N. 2001. Occurrence, pathogenicity and survival of
Macrophoma mangiferae in leaves, branches and stems of mango
(Mangifera indica L.). Plant Prot. Sci., 37: 138-144.
Okigbo, R.N. and M.I. Osuinde, 2003. Fungal leaf spot diseases of mango
(Mangifera indica) in South Eastern Nigeria and biological control
with Bacillus subtilis. Plant Prot. Sci., 39(2): 70-77.
Pandit, S.S., H.G. Chidley, R.S. Kulkarni, K.H. Pujari, A.P. Giri and V.S.
Gupta, 2009. Cultivar relationships in mango based on fruit volatile
profiles. Food Chem., 114: 363-372.
Patil, S.R. and A. Dayanand, 2006. Exploration of regional agrowastes
for the production of pectinase by Aspergillus niger. Food Technol.
Biotechnol., 44(2): 289-292.
109
Pelczar, M.J., E.C.S. Chan and N.R. Krieg, 2008. Microbilogy. 5th ed.
McGraw Hill, New Delhi, India.
Prescott, M.L., P.J. Harley and A.D. Klein, 2006. Microbilogy. 6th ed.
McGraw Hill, Singapore.
Pruvost, O. and J. Luisetti, 1991. Effect of time of inoculation with
Xanthomonas campestris pv. mangiferaeindicae on mango fruits
susceptibility. Epiphytic survival of X. c. pv. mangiferaeindicae on
mango fruits in relation to disease development. J. Phytopathol.,
133(2): 139-151.
Robbs, P.G., J.A. Bartz, G. McFie and N.C. Hodge, 1996. Causes of
decay of fresh-cut celery. J. Food Sci., 61: 444-448.
Silimela, M. and L. Korsten, 2001. Alternative methods for preventing
Pre and Post harvest diseases and sunburn on mango fruits. South
African Mango Growers Association Yearbook, 21: 39-43.
Silva, C.F., R.F. Schwan, E.S. Dias and A.E. Wheals, 2000. Microbial
diversity during maturation and natural processing of coffee cherries
of Coffea arabica in Brazil. Int. J. Food Microbiol., 60: 251-260.
Singh, S.A., M. Ramakrishna and A.G.A. Rao, 1999. Optimization of
down-stream processing parameters for the recovery of pectinase
from the fermented broth of Aspergillus carbonarious. Proc.
Biochem., 35: 411-417.
Snedecor, G.W. and W.G. Cochran, 1967. Statistical Methods. Oxford
and IBH Publishing Co. Pvt.Ltd.
Soriano, M., A. Blanco, P. Diaz, F. Jawier and I. Pastor, 2000. An unusual
pectate lyase from a bacillus species with high activity on pectin:
cloning and characterization. Microbiology (UK), 146: 89-95.
Tournas, V.H. 2005. Spoilage of vegetable crops by bacteria and fungi
and related health hazards. Crit. Rev. Microbiol., 31: 33-44.
Tournas, V.H. and E. Katsoudas, 2005. Mould and Yeast flora in fresh
berries, grapes and citrus fruits. Int. J. Food Microbiol., 105: 11-17.
Ubalua, A.O. 2007. Cassava waste: treatment options and value addition
alternatives. African J. Biotechnol., 6(18): 2065-2073.
Verma, K.S., S.S. Cheema, M.S. Kang and A.K. Sharma, 1991. Hitherto
unrecorded disease problems of mango from Punjab. Plant Dis.
Res., 6: 141-142.
Walsh, U.F., J. P. Morrissey and F.O’Gara, 2001. Pseudomonas for
biocontrol of phytopathogens: from functional genomics to commercial
exploitation. Current Opinion in Biotechnol., 12(3): 289-295.
Wilson, C.L., M.E. Wisniewski, S. Droby and E. Chalutz, 1993. A
selection strategy for microbial antagonists to control post-harvest
diseases of fruits and vegetables. Scientia Hort., 53: 183-189.
Wisniewski, M.E. and C.L. Wilson, 1992. Biological control of postharvest diseases of fruits and vegetables. Scientia Hort., 27: 9498.
Weaver, J.E., H.W. Hogmire, J.L. Brooks and J.C. Sencindiver, 1990.
Assesment of pesticide residues in surface and soil water from a
commercial apple orchard. Appl. Agr. Res., 5: 37-43.
Received: February, 2012; Revised: July, 2012; Accepted: October, 2012
Complementary Copy
Postharvest microbial diversity on major cultivars of Indian mangoes
Journal
Journal of Applied Horticulture, 14(2): 110-113, 2012
Appl
Effe c t of de hydrat ion on ke e ping qua lit y of w hit e but t on
m ushroom , Aga ric us bisporus La nge (Sing.)
M .P. Singh, H .S. Sodhi, A. Singh* a nd P.K . K ha nna
Department of Microbiology, Punjab Agricultural University, Ludhiana, *Department of Processing and Food Engineering,
Punjab Agricultural University, Ludhiana-141004, India. E-mail:
[email protected],
[email protected]
Abstract
Key words: Agaricus bisporus, cabinet drying, microwave-oven drying, color index, texture index, carbohydrates, proteins, lipids
Introduction
drying had been combined with conventional hot air drying to
reduce the drying time, optimize energy efficiency and improve
product quality (Zhang et al., 2006). Pretreatments of mushrooms
before drying by, washing in water, KMS, sugar, salt either
alone or in combination help in checking enzymatic browning,
stabilizing color, enhancing flavor retention and maintaining
textural properties (Singh et al., 2001). The optimum conditions
of drying were established by Kar et al. (2004) on the basis of
rehydration ratio and sensory evaluation. Drying at microwave
intensity of 400 W with pretreatment of blanching in boiling
water for 3 min., followed by steeping in solution of 0.1% KMS
+ 0.2% CA + 6% sugar + 3% NaCl at room temperature for 15
min. yielded an acceptable dehydrated product in about 45 min.
The rehydration ability of the dried product is a critical parameter
indicating the degree of damage caused by physiochemical
treatments (Krokida and Marinos, 2003). Present investigation
was undertaken to study the effect of drying by different methods
on color, texture, biochemical and microbiological quality
parameters of the dehydrated white button mushrooms.
White button mushroom (Agaricus bisporus) is devoured by
mankind for its characteristic aroma, texture and nutritional
value (Arumuganathan et al., 2003). Dehydration appears to be
a promising and cost effective method of mushroom preservation
for the Indian conditions as it is easy to transport the dried product
compared to canned, pickled and frozen products. The dehydrated
products, apart from the increased shelf life, offer an advantage of
decreased weight and volume with a potential for saving the cost
of packaging, handling, storage and transport (Amuthan et al.,
1999). Dried mushrooms, packed in airtight containers can have
a shelf life of above one year (Bano et al., 1992). Mushrooms
could be dried to a moisture level down below 10% at drying
temperature of 55˚C to give the end product with the desired
qualities of texture, color and rehydration. At a drying temperature
of 55-60˚C, the insects and microbes on the mushrooms would
be killed in a few hours, which give the dehydrated final product
of lower moisture content with longer shelf life. A cabinet drier
with proper air circulation has been reported to be superior by
Mudahar and Bains (1982).
Materials and methods
Microwave oven drying is an alternative way which generates
very rapid heat and mass transfer resulting in quick drying of
mushrooms. It offers the product with good organoleptic and
nutritional values (Sahni et al., 1997). Heating of foods by
microwave energy sources are instantaneous. Microwave-vacuum
Two strains S11 and U3 of A. bisporus, were harvested from the
Mushroom Research Farm, PAU, Ludhiana. Half the sample of
mushrooms (500g) from each strain was treated with 1% KMS
for 10 minutes in order to inactivate the enzymes and improve
its color characteristics while other half was left untreated as
Complementary Copy
White button mushrooms, Agaricus bisporus (strains U3 and S11) were dried in cabinet at two temperatures (45 and 55°C) and
microwave oven at 380W for 30 minutes. Dried mushrooms were subjected to physical (color, texture, rehydration ratio, dehydration
ratio), biochemical (carbohydrates, proteins and lipids) and microbiological (total bacterial count) parameters after three months of
storage period. In strain U3, carbohydrate content was highest in 0.1% KMS treated mushrooms dried at 45˚C, protein ranged between
3.43 to 3.89 g/100 g of fresh mushrooms, lipid content ranged between 0.06 to 0.30 g/100 g of mushrooms and the total bacterial count
ranged between 1.48 to 2.07 log cfu/g which was within the permissible limits of dried fruit products while in microwave oven dried
mushrooms there was no significant difference in two strains in terms of carbohydrate, protein and lipid contents. Bacterial count
was found to be within the permissible limit of dried fruit products (1.85-2.17 log cfu/g). The weight of dried mushrooms remained
almost constant throughout the storage period of 3 months. However, cabinet drying was preferred for most of the color and texture
index parameters. Springiness was maximum for microwave oven dried mushrooms of S11 strain treated with 0.1% KMS, followed
by the unwashed mushrooms. Resilience ranged between 0.23 to 0.33 in all the treatments. Cohesiveness was maximum in unwashed
mushrooms of U3 dried at 55˚C, followed by cabinet dried mushrooms of S11 strain (55˚C) both unwashed and 0.1% KMS treated.
Chewiness and gumminess were also maximum for cabinet dried unwashed mushrooms of U3, followed by microwave oven dried
0.1% KMS treated mushrooms. A. bisporus was most acceptable in cabinet drying for 0.1% KMS treated U3 strain at both 45˚C and
55˚C while in case of microwave oven drying, total color difference (2.88 for U3 and 2.58 in S11) was minimum and rehydration ratio
(1.91 to 3.06) was found to be maximum for U3 strain.
Effect of dehydration on keeping quality of white button mushrooms
Cabinet drying: Mushrooms were dried in cabinet tray drier
(Kilbron Oven, Macneil and Magor Ltd.) where mushrooms were
kept in series of trays and warm air temperature of 45oC and 55oC
was passed with air velocity of approximately 1m / sec. Weight
of tray was noted regularly. Readings were taken at an interval
of 2 hours till 7-8% constant moisture was achieved.
Microwave drying: Mushrooms were dried in microwave
[Electrolux (250-700)] at 380W for 30 minutes. The dried
mushrooms were packed in airtight polyethylene bags of 150
gauze. The observations were made on wt. loss (%), appearance,
color, optical density, dehydration ratio, rehydration ratio,
biochemical and microbiological properties in comparison to
the unwashed mushrooms as control. Rehydration was done by
dipping weighed sample (5g) of dried mushroom in distilled
water. Dehydration and rehydration ratio was calculated using
the formula of Ranganna (1986).
Color and texture analysis: The color of freshly harvested and
stored samples was measured by using Miniscan XE plus Hunter
Lab Colorimeter (Burton et al., 1987; Gormley, 1974). L, a, b
values for samples were obtained in triplicate. From these values
of ‘L’, ‘a’ and ‘b’ total color difference was obtained using the
formula:
ΔE =√ΔL2 + Δa2 +Δb2
Where, ΔL, Δa and Δb are deviations from L, a and b values of the
fresh sample.
ΔL = L sample - L standard; + ΔL means sample was lighter than
standard, -ΔL means sample was darker than standard.
Δa = a sample - a standard; +Δ a means sample was redder than standard,
-Δa means sample was greener than standard.
Δb = b sample - b standard, + Δb means sample was yellower than
standard, -Δb means sample was bluer than standard.
The hue (H), chroma (C) and browning index (BI), which represented
the purity of brown color (Polou et al., 1999), were also calculated
according to the given equation:
Hue= tan-1 (b/a), Chroma = (a2 + b2)1/2
BI= 100(x - 0.31) /0.172,
Where, x= (a + 1.75L) / (5.645 + a-3.012b)
The textural behavior of the whole mushroom was estimated in
terms of the texture profile analysis (TPA) curve. The parameters
of brittleness, hardness, cohesiveness, adhesiveness, chewiness,
springiness and gumminess were calculated from the plot of
two cyclic compression text performed on mushroom sample
of about 5 mm thickness using an aluminium cylinder known as
P/75 cylindrical probe having 75 mm diameter. The conditions
set for TPA were: Load cell: 50 kg, Test mode: measure force
in compression, Pretest speed: 10 mm/s, Test speed: 5 mm/s,
Post test speed: 10 mm/s, Time lag between 2 compressions: 2s,
Test strain: 75% of sample height, Trigger force: 0.05 N, Data
acquisition rate: 200 pps, Probe: SMS P/75 cylindrical probe,
75 mm diameter.
Total bacterial count: Total bacterial count (cfu/ g fresh
mushrooms) was determined by standard method of serial dilution
and plating.
Biochemical analysis: Estimation of total sugars was done by
Dubois et al. (1956) method. Extraction was done by taking
carbohydrates from dried samples of A. bisporus. Estimation of
proteins was done by method given by Lowry et al. (1951) and
extraction and estimation of total lipids was done by Folsch et
al. (1957) method.
Results and discussion
Biochemical and microbiological analysis: Fruit bodies of A.
bisporus strains S11 and U3 were subjected to cabinet drying
(45˚C and 55˚C) and microwave oven drying (380W, 30 minutes)
followed by their biochemical and microbiological analysis. In
strain U3, carbohydrate content was highest in 0.1% KMS washed
and mushrooms dried at 45˚C followed by mushrooms received
same pretreatment and dried at 55˚C. The protein content ranged
between 3.43 to 3.89 g/100 g of fresh mushrooms whereas lipid
content was 0.06 to 0.30 g/100 g of mushrooms (Table 1). The
total bacterial count ranged between 1.48 to 2.07 log cfu/g which
was within the permissible limits of dried fruit products (less
than 2.7 log cfu/g, non pathogenic). In microwave oven dried
mushrooms, there was no significant difference in two strains in
terms of carbohydrates, proteins and lipids contents and bacterial
count was found to be within the permissible limits of dried fruit
products (1.85-2.17 log cfu/g) (Table 1). The weight of dried
mushrooms remained almost constant throughout the storage
period of 3 months. Dehydration ratio for all the treatments
ranged between 9.25 to 13.78 with lowest for 0.1% KMS
treated mushrooms (S11 and U3) dried in microwave oven. The
rehydration ratio for all the treatments ranged between 1.91 to
3.06 with highest in 0.1% KMS treated U3 mushrooms dried in
microwave oven (Table 1).
Color index: The mushrooms from two different strains received
different pretreatments and dried by two different methods along
with control were compared for color index for L, a, b, ΔE, hue,
chroma, browning index. In each treatment, L value for 0.1%
KMS treated mushrooms was better with highest value of 41.45
L for U3 strain. There were no significant differences in a value
for different treatments. ΔE value was lowest for microwave oven
dried mushrooms in comparison to cabinet dried mushrooms. The
hue index showed increased value from 0.1% KMS pretreated to
unwashed mushrooms of S11 strain in cabinet drying whereas
contrast was true for mushrooms of U3 in cabinet drying and both
S11 and U3 for microwave oven dried mushrooms. The browning
index for cabinet dried unwashed mushrooms of S11 was higher
whereas it was low for unwashed U3 mushrooms. However, there
was no significant difference in browning index in microwave
oven dried mushrooms (Table 2).
Texture profile: The texture profile of dried mushrooms indicated
adhesiveness ranging from -1.57 to -6.98 for all treatments. In
cabinet dried mushrooms, maximum hardness (texture) was in
0.1% KMS treated mushrooms from U3 strain. In microwave
oven dried mushrooms, maximum hardness for both 0.1%KMS
treated and unwashed mushrooms was in U3 strain. Springiness
was maximum for microwave oven dried mushrooms of S11 strain
treated with 0.1% KMS, followed by the unwashed mushrooms.
Complementary Copy
control. The mushrooms were then cut longitudinally into pieces,
blanched and dried in cabinet drier and in microwave. Five
replicates for each set of experiment were observed and analyzed
statistically for ANOVA at P= 0.05.
111
112
Effect of dehydration on keeping quality of white button mushrooms
Table 1. Physico-chemical and microbiological properties of dried A. bisporus using different techniques
Drying
Strain Treatment Temperature Carbohydrate Proteins
Lipids
Bacterial
Change in Dehydration Rehydration
type
(g/100g of
(g/100g of
(g/100g of
count
ratio (x)
ratio (x)
wt. during
mushrooms) mushrooms) mushrooms) (log cfu/g) storage (%)
Cabinet
S11 0.1%KMS
45˚C
2.04
3.79
0.06
1.70
7.24
13.47
2.39
Unwashed
2.89
3.58
0.12
2.07
6.66
9.93
2.22
drying
0.1%KMS
55˚C
2.47
3.61
0.21
1.61
15.75
13.78
2.76
Unwashed
2.50
3.52
0.30
2.0
5.5
12.63
2.56
U3 0.1%KMS
Unwashed
0.1%KMS
Unwashed
45˚C
55˚C
CD (P=0.05)
Microwave S11 Unwashed 380W(30min)
oven drying
0.1%KMS
U3 Unwashed 380W(30min)
0.1%KMS
CD (P=0.05)
4.39
2.17
3.02
2.01
0.73
2.48
3.64
3.89
3.43
3.77
NS
3.80
0.06
0.09
0.08
0.07
0.35
0.10
1.48
2.07
1.31
2.0
0.17
2.17
4.32
6.20
4.51
12.61
0.34
-13.0
11.32
11.42
11.80
12.13
0.34
10.22
2.48
3.03
2.25
1.91
0.35
2.41
2.50
2.13
2.14
NS
3.63
3.50
3.43
0.38
0.13
0.10
0.08
NS
1.91
2.07
1.85
0.12
-.0015
12.01
-28.70
1.63
9.25
11.12
9.25
0.37
2.61
2.70
3.06
0.18
NS= Non Significant in all the three table
Resilience ranged between 0.23 to 0.33 in all the treatments.
Cohesiveness was maximum in unwashed mushrooms of U3 dried
at 55˚C, followed by cabinet dried mushrooms of S11 strain (55˚C)
both unwashed and 0.1% KMS treated. Chewiness was also
maximum for cabinet dried unwashed mushrooms of U3, followed
by microwave oven dried 0.1% KMS treated mushrooms. This
lot also indicated maximum gumminess (Table 3).
Singh et al. (2007) also showed that button mushroom samples
dehydrated at 50˚C gave better quality. They reported diffusivity
of 1.05x10-08 to 7.48x10-09 m2/s and it increased with drying air
temperature. Drying using microwave oven has been reported as
non satisfactory mainly because of lack of temperature control
and high time of exposure resulting in charring of mushrooms
particularly at the edges (Walde et al., 1997). However, the time
taken for drying from 7.5% (db) moisture to 2% (db) has been
reported more for cabinet than for microwave oven drying (Walde
et al., 2006). A comparative new technique ‘Microwave-vacuum
drying’ had resulted in 70-90% reduction in the drying time with
better rehydration characteristics as compared to convective air
drying (Giri and Prasad, 2007).
Observations after three months of storage indicated that
cabinet drying at temperatures of 45 and 55˚C gave best results
particularly in 0.1% KMS treated mushrooms of U3 strain. The
drying temperature of 55˚C in the plenum chamber gave the end
product with the desired qualities of texture, color and rehydration
(NRCM, 2008). Pre-drying treatments had a significant effect
on whiteness and color change of the dried mushroom slices.
Whiteness is reported to be high in blanched mushrooms
compared to other treatments but it gave very low rehydration
ratio (Nour et al., 2011). In present study, cabinet drying gave
superior results with respect to color and texture index, while
microwave drying required lesser time for drying to achieve same
Table 2. Color index of dried A. bisporus using different techniques
Drying type
Strain Treatment Temperature
L
Cabinet drying S11 0.1%KMS
45˚C
Unwashed
0.1%KMS
Unwashed
U3 0.1%KMS
Unwashed
0.1%KMS
Unwashed
C.D (P=0.05)
Microwave
oven drying
55˚C
45˚C
55˚C
S11 Unwashed 380W (30 min)
0.1%KMS
U3 Unwashed 380W (30 min)
0.1%KMS
CD (P=0.05)
Use of cabinet and microwave-oven drying for the dehydration
of A.bisporus (strains U3 and S11) suggested that, in cabinet
drying, out of two strains, 0.1% KMS treated mushrooms of U3
strain gave good results for most of the parameters at both drying
temperature of 45˚C and 55˚C while in case of microwave oven
Color index
ΔE
a
b
28.66±0.83
5.27±0.22
-1.10±0.96
22.04±0.68
4.27±0.16
6.18±0.64
34.99±0.61
6.41±0.13
5.20±0.25
30.02±0.62
39.47±0.47
32.02±0.15
41.45±1.16
34.46±0.39
5.41±0.12
7.27±0.18
5.81±0.07
8.00±0.34
6.59±0.01
6.20±0.21
8.42±1.06
2.51±0.16
6.39±0.59
3.49±0.21
3.13
28.80±1.67
30.49±1.67
NS
6.5±0.12
8.18±0.14
0.94
4.53±0.15
3.53±0.15
2.58
2.88
9.890
5.16
9.62
7.69
HUE
CHROMA
BI
-11.79
5.38
8.91
55.35
7.51
46.05
39.09
8.25
28.64
48.89
49.19
23.37
38.62
27.91
8.22
11.12
6.33
10.24
7.46
35.45
36.58
20.64
29.99
23.81
0.47
34.87
23.34
0.57
7.92
8.91
0.19
32.60
30.64
30.15±0.04
6.7±0.02
5.68±0.09
40.28
8.78
36.12
32.15±0.02
8.53±0.05
4.68±0.09
28.75
9.73
33.90
NS
NS
NS
0.20
NS
0.77
Complementary Copy
level of moisture content in the end product (Table 2 & 3).
Effect of dehydration on keeping quality of white button mushrooms
Cabinet drying
S11 0.1%KMS
U3
C.D (P=0.05)
Microwave
oven drying
Unwashed
0.1%KMS
Unwashed
0.1%KMS
Unwashed
0.1%KMS
Unwashed
45˚C
55˚C
45˚C
55˚C
S11 Unwashed 380W (30
min)
0.1%KMS
U3 Unwashed 380W (30
min)
0.1%KMS
CD (P=0.05)
Springiness
(mm)
Resilience Cohesiveness Chewiness Gumminess
(g x mm)
(g)
-3.89
10562
0.68
0.27
0.03
281
411
-5.00
-5.33
-5.30
-6.98
-2.08
-6.79
-3.42
0.36
-1.57
-1.99
-4.93
-4.02
0.19
12274
14487
14400
197140
35485
170870
88010
628626.0
44550
44965
109876
103921
47.64
0.78
0.94
0.90
0.42
0.61
0.001
0.40
0.16
1.00
1.10
0.14
0.15
0.22
0.29
0.31
0.25
0.33
0.24
0.32
0.28
0.37
0.23
0.24
0.29
0.30
NS
0.02
1.96
1.80
0.07
0.75
0.80
2.18
0.17
0.57
0.75
0.07
0.09
0.19
195
26851
23509
6044
16450
226
77033
13.84
25616
37657
1239
1573
0.60
250
28396
25920
14391
26862
137550
191863
3531.0
25393
34039
8438
9997
0.60
drying, L Value and rehydration ratio were highest for mushrooms
of U3 strain (0.1% KMS treated and untreated) as compared to
S11 (0.1% KMS treated and untreated). Among the two drying
methods, cabinet drying should be preferred for texture and
whiteness index (L value) while to save time, microwave drying
should be preferred for lower ΔE value and better rehydration
ratio of the product.
References
Amuthan, G., R. Visvanathan, R. Kailappan and V.V. Sreenarayanan,
1999. Studies on osmo-air drying of milky mushroom, Calocybe
indica. Mush. Res., 8: 49-52.
Arumuganathan, T., R.D. Rai, C. Induranic and A.K. Hemkar, 2003.
Rehydration characteristics of the button mushroom (Agaricus bisporus)
dried by different drying methods. Mush. Res., 12: 121-23.
Bano, Z., S. Rajarathnam, Shashi and M.N. Rekha, 1992. Mushroom
as the unconventional single cell protein for a conventional
consumption. Indian Fd. Packer, 46: 20-31.
Burton, K.S., C.E. Frost, P.T. Atkey, 1987. Effect of vacuum cooling on
mushrooms browning. Intl. J. Fd. Sci. Technol., 22: 599-606.
Dubois, M., K.A. Gill, J.K. Hamilton, P.A. Roberts and F. Smith,
1956. Colorimetric method for determination of sugars and related
substances. Anal. Chem., 28: 350-356.
Folsch, J., M. Less and G.H. Stanley, 1957. A simple method for isolation
and purification of total lipids from animal tissues. J. Biol. Chem.,
226: 497-509.
Giri, S.K. and S.K. Prasad, 2007. Drying kinetics and rehydration
characteristics of microwave-vacuum and convective hot air dried
mushroom. J. Fd. Eng., 78: 512-521.
Gormley, R. 1974. Chill storage of mushrooms. J. Sci. Fd. Agr., 26:
401-411.
Kar, A., P. Chandra, R. Prasad and S.K. Dash, 2004. Microwave drying
characteristics of a button mushroom (Agaricus bisporus). J. Fd. Sci.
Technol., 41: 636-641.
Krokida, M.K. and K.D. Marinos, 2003. Rehydration kinetics of
dehydrated products. J. Fd. Eng., 57: 1-7.
Lowry, O.H., N.J. Rosenbrough, A.L. Farr and R.J. Randall, 1951.
Protein measurement with folin phenol reagent. J. Biol. Chem.,
193: 265-275.
Mudahar, G.S. and G.S. Bains, 1982. Pre-treatment effect on quality
of dehydrated Agaricus bisporus mushrooms. Indian Fd. Packer,
28: 19-27.
Nour V., I. Trandafir and M.E., Ionica, 2011. Effects of pretreatments
and drying temperatures on the quality of dried button mushrooms.
South-West. J. Hortic. Biol. Environ., 2(1): 15-24.
NRCM, 2008. Annual Report of All India Coordinated Mushroom
Research Project. Solan, p. 16-19.
Palou, E., M.A. Lopez, C.G.V. Barbosa, C.J. Welti and G.B. Swanson,
1999. Polyphenoloxidase activity and colour of blanched and high
hydrostatic pressure treated banana puree. J. Fd. Sci., 64: 42-45.
Ranganna, S. 1986. Handbook of Analysis and Quality Control for
Fruits and Vegetable Products. Tata McGraw Hill publishing Co.
Ltd., New Delhi.
Sahni, C.K., D.S. Khwidiya, M.A. Dalal and S.B. Maini, 1997.
Microwave processing of foods-potentialities and prospects. Indian
Fd. Packer, 51: 32-42.
Singh, S.K., M. Narain and B.K. Kumbhar, 2001. Effect of drying air
temperatures and standard pretreatments on the quality of fluidized
bed dried button mushroom (Agaricus bisporus). Indian Fd. Packer,
55: 82-86.
Singh, U., S.K. Jain, R.C. Verma, A. Doshi and M.K. Jaipal, 2007.
Dehydration characteristics and quality analysis of button mushroom
slices (Agaricus bisporus). Agr. Eng. Today, 31: 43-46.
Walde, S.G., K. Balaswamy, R. Shivaswamy, A. Chakkaravarthi and
D.G. Rao, 1997. Microwave drying and grinding characteristics of
gum karaya (Sterculia urens). J. Fd. Eng., 31: 305-13.
Walde, S.G., V. Velu, T. Jyothirmayi and R.G. Math, 2006. Effect of
pretreatment and drying methods on dehydration of mushroom. J.
Fd. Eng., 74: 108-115.
Zhang, M., J. Tang, A.S. Mujamdar and S. Wang, 2006. Trends in
microwave related drying of fruits and vegetables. Trends Fd. Sci
Technol., 17: 524-534.
Received: April, 2012; Revised: October, 2012; Accepted: October, 2012
Complementary Copy
Table 3. Texture profile of dried A. bisporus by different techniques
Drying type
Strain Treatment Temperature Adhesiveness Hardness
(g x mm)
(g)
113
Journal
Journal of Applied Horticulture, 14(2):114-117, 2012
Appl
Re lat ionship of nut rit iona l st at us of fi e ld grow n T hom pson
Se e dle ss gra pevine s w it h pow de r y m ilde w inc ide nc e
Ja gdev Sha r m a * , A.K . U pa dhya y, I ndu S. Sa w a nt a nd S.D. Sa w a nt
National Research Centre for Grapes, Pune (MS)-412307, India. *E- mail:
[email protected]
Abstract
Relationship between nutritional status of open field grown Thompson Seedless grapevines and powdery mildew incidence was
studied for two years at two growth stages. Amongst different nutrients, potassium showed highest degree of significant and negative
correlation with the powdery mildew disease rating (r= -0.817 and -0.875) at two growth stages. Regression analysis also revealed
the importance of potassium nutrition in powdery mildew incidence. During the first year of the study, N, P, K, Ca, Mg and Na when
regressed together accounted for 82.7 % (R2 = 0.826) variation in disease incidence and potassium alone accounted for 66.8 % variation
in disease incidence (R2 = 0.667). During the second year N, P, K, Ca, Mg and Na when regressed together accounted for 85.7 % (R2
= 0.857) variation in disease incidence and potassium alone accounted for 76.6 % variation in disease incidence (R2 = 0.765).
Introduction
Materials and methods
Powdery mildew is one of the major diseases of grapevines in
India. The disease is mainly managed by fungicide application.
However, fungicidal efficacy varies from vineyard to vineyard.
It is known that the nutritional status of plants has a substantial
impact on their predisposition to pests and diseases. All essential
mineral elements are reported to influence disease incidence or
severity (Huber, 1978 and 1980; Graham and Webb, 1989) and
potassium is of particular importance. Perrenoud (1990) reviewed
almost 2450 literature references on this subject and concluded
that the use of potassium (K) decreased the incidence of fungal
diseases in 70% of the cases. Potassium alters the compatibility
relationship of the host-parasite environment within the plant
(Marschner, 1995). Sweeny et al. (2000) have found reduced
incidence of diseases as a result of K fertilization in different
crops. Increased incidence of powdery mildew in vines exhibiting
inward leaf curling (symptoms of potassium deficiency) has
been observed (Sharma et al., 2009). Leaf curling interferes in
fungicide coverage thereby promoting the disease development.
Crop loss in field grown vines due to downy mildew was also
higher in potassium deficient grapevines (Sawant et al., 2010).
Petiole samples exhibiting varying degree of inward leaf curling
(potassium deficiency symptom) and powdery mildew incidence
were sampled on 45th and 90th day after foundation pruning
during 2009 and 2010, respectively from field grown vines in
experimental plots of NRC for Grapes, Pune. In order to get
wide range of nutrient contents, vines grown on different stock
scion combinations were sampled and rated for disease severity.
Nutrient composition of petioles was studied as per standard
methods of analysis. All the vines were grown under uniform
package of practices, including the fungicides applied for the
control of powdery mildew. The 5th leaf position was selected
for nutrient analysis on 45th day after pruning. Each sample was
collected from a set of three vines. Severe powdery mildew
incidence was observed on the basal leaves at 90th day after
pruning. The leaves at 3rd to 7th nodes (middle representative)
were selected for analysis from vines having severe disease
incidence as well as those having fewer incidences. The basal 10
leaves on each shoot were rated for disease incidence (visually
active fungal growth) on a scale of 0-4 (Fig.1). The data were
analyzed by correlation and stepwise regression using SAS
software. Data on micronutrients is not presented as they were
not related to the disease incidence and the vines were sprayed
with micronutrients.
The effect of mineral nutrition on diseases has been determined
either through observing the effects of fertilization on disease
severity, comparing the mineral concentration in resistant and
susceptible cultivars or correlating conditions influencing mineral
availability with disease incidence or severity or combination
of these factors. Since very little information is available on the
relation of the nutritional status of the grapevines with powdery
mildew incidence, relationship between nutritional status of the
open field grown Thompson Seedless vines raised in different
stock scion combinations and powdery mildew incidence at two
different growth stages of grapevines was worked out.
Results and discussion
The data on nutrient contents and powdery mildew ratings are
presented in Table 1 and 2 and correlation coefficients in Table
3. The nutrient contents particularly that of N, P and K varied
greatly in different stock scion combinations. Nitrogen has been
implicated in many studies to increase the disease incidence.
Nitrogen exhibited positive but non-significant correlation with
disease rating (r=0.3536) and (r=0.3056). Although there was
strong and positive correlation between N:K ratio and disease
rating during both the years, nitrogen content might not have
played a direct role in increasing the disease rating in the present
Complementary Copy
Key words: Powdery mildew, nutritional status, grapevines, potassium, disease incidence
Relationship of nutritional status of field grown Thompson Seedless grapevines with powdery mildew incidence
Table 2. Nutrient status of vines and disease incidence 90th day after
foundation pruning during 2010
Plot
number
N
(%)
P
(%)
K
(%)
Ca
(%)
Mg
(%)
Na
(%)
1.
1.06
0.52
2.04
2.04
0.96
0.44
Cl Powdery
(%) mildew
rating
0.35
1.5
2.
1.13
0.33
2.55
2.17
0.86
0.73
0.35
1.2
3.
1.21
0.3
1.85
2.05
0.83
0.63
0.42
1.3
4.
0.85
0.48
2.35
2.15
0.92
1.15
0.7
1.3
5.
1.13
0.45
1.78
2.21
1.12
0.5
0.4
1.5
6.
0.96
0.35
2.65
2.13
0.95
0.8
0.35
1.3
7.
1.1
0.28
1.8
1.85
0.84
0.55
0.35
1.2
8.
1.03
0.52
2.16
2.06
1.02
1.03
0.42
1.2
9.
1.24
0.5
1.85
2.29
0.93
0.46
0.46
1.3
10.
1.13
0.3
1.95
1.95
0.91
0.72
0.32
1.2
Table 1. Nutrient content of vines and powdery mildew ratings on 45th
day after foundation pruning during 2009
Plot
N
number (%)
P
(%)
K
(%)
Ca
(%)
Mg
(%)
Na
(%)
1.
0.78
0.27
0.71
0.63
0.97
0.18
Cl Powdery
(%) mildew
rating
0.11
1.5
2.
0.76
0.22
1.02
0.71
0.75
0.23
0.18
1.2
3.
0.63
0.25
0.73
0.77
0.88
0.23
0.25
1.5
4.
0.62
0.26
1.00
0.69
0.77
0.28
0.21
1.2
5.
0.90
0.26
0.66
0.65
1.00
0.18
0.11
3.0
6.
0.99
0.25
0.66
0.61
1.00
0.15
0.18
7.
0.89
0.25
0.64
0.68
0.96
0.23
8.
0.95
0.35
1.65
0.52
0.91
9.
0.78
0.33
1.53
0.56
0.83
10.
0.50
0.42
1.85
0.57
11.
0.62
0.40
1.63
12.
0.76
0.32
13.
0.74
14.
11.
1.15
0.35
1.69
1.89
0.95
0.56
0.4
1.2
12.
0.95
0.56
2.4
2.32
1.18
1.09
0.75
1.5
13.
1.18
0.23
1.28
1.85
0.80
0.65
0.4
3.2
14.
1.12
0.48
1.06
2.14
0.86
0.42
0.35
3.8
15.
1.12
0.2
1.17
2.05
0.63
0.75
0.35
3.6
16.
1.17
0.6
1.33
2.06
0.92
0.37
0.42
3.2
17.
1.21
0.28
1.02
1.85
1.02
0.65
0.46
3.2
18.
1.03
0.52
1.15
2.21
1.12
0.39
0.32
3.7
19.
1.13
0.22
1.1
2.15
1.13
0.7
0.42
3.2
20.
1.16
0.32
1.02
2.16
0.73
0.68
0.46
3.3
21.
1.24
0.26
1.16
2.06
0.94
0.68
0.32
3.2
Table 3. Correlation coefficient (r) between powdery mildew rating and
petiole nutrient content
Nutrient (%)
45th days after pruning
90th day after pruning
N
0.3536
0.3056
P
-0.4631*
-0.1909
3.0
K
-0.8170*
-0.8750*
0.11
3.2
Ca
0.4125*
-0.03878
0.33
0.50
1.0
Mg
0.4902*
-0.1678
0.33
0.46
1.1
Na
-0.5999*
-0.3390
0.96
0.38
0.64
1.0
0.65
0.85
0.35
0.64
1.1
Cl
-0.5837*
-0.2211
0.78
0.64
1.17
0.16
0.18
2.1
0.30
0.57
0.70
0.95
0.19
0.21
2.1
0.62
0.32
0.60
0.72
0.89
0.20
0.21
2.0
15.
0.62
0.29
0.53
0.67
1.15
0.15
0.14
2.4
16.
0.74
0.34
0.75
0.68
0.95
0.19
0.11
2.3
17.
0.71
0.40
1.55
0.53
0.83
0.24
0.21
1.0
18.
0.66
0.40
1.52
0.55
0.85
0.25
0.21
1.0
19.
0.75
0.32
1.30
0.56
0.90
0.25
0.25
1.2
20.
0.72
0.35
1.60
0.53
0.78
0.20
0.21
1.0
21.
0.66
0.32
0.80
0.64
1.10
0.19
0.21
2.0
22.
0.71
0.34
0.75
0.64
0.96
0.24
0.14
2.2
23.
0.64
0.36
0.62
0.56
1.20
0.18
0.21
2.4
24.
0.64
0.32
0.58
0.62
1.02
0.21
0.18
2.3
25.
0.64
0.31
0.68
0.66
1.09
0.15
0.18
2.1
* Significant at P<0.05
vigorously growing vines in a vineyard and more vigorous shoots
in a vine vineyards where the K applications are either inadequate
or not made (Sharma et al., 2009a). Further leaves of vines
having severe powdery mildew incidence also exhibited ‘shiny
spots’ on leaves associated with potassium deficiency (Sharma
et al., 2009b). Leaf curling interferes in fungicide coverage
thereby promoting the disease development. Further shaded
conditions are always favourable for spore germination and
mycelial growth than sunny conditions (Willocquet et al., 1996).
Increased sensitivity to powdery mildew incidence exhibiting
leaf curling (potassium deficiency symptoms) has also been
reported by Mundankar et al. (2008) and Sharma et al. (2009a).
Nutrition alters the compatibility relationship of the host-parasite
environment within the plant. However, K is especially critical
in the production and transport of fungus inhibiting phenolic and
Complementary Copy
situation since its content was not high at 45th day (Table 1) as
per the petiole nutrient standards (Sharma and Shikhamany,
2008). Further, at 90th day during 2010, nitrogen content in
some of the healthy vines was higher than that in affected
vines. Amongst different nutrients, potassium showed highest
degree of significant and negative correlation with the disease
rating (r=-0.8170*) followed by P (r=-0.4631*) at 45th day after
pruning. At 90th day K again exhibited significant and negative
correlation (r=-0.8750*) with disease rating (Table 3). Other
nutrients did not exhibit significant correlation. Since more
than one nutrient exhibited significant correlation at 45th day of
sampling with disease rating stepwise regression analysis was
carried out. Regression analysis also revealed the importance
of potassium nutrition in powdery mildew incidence. N, P, K,
Ca, Mg and Na when regressed together accounted for 82.7 %
variation in disease incidence. Potassium alone accounted for
66.8 % variation in disease incidence (R2 = 0.6678) on 45th day
of sampling. During the second year, N, P, K, Ca, Mg and Na
when regressed together accounted for 85.7 % (R2 = 0.8573)
variation in disease incidence. Potassium alone accounted for
76.6 % variation in disease incidence on 45th day of sampling.
Potassium is one of the essential and major nutrients in viticulture
involved in a variety of functions in grapevines. Its deficiency in
grapes causes inward leaf curling. Inward leaf curling symptoms
are commonly observed during the vegetative growth period in
115
116
Relationship of nutritional status of field grown Thompson Seedless grapevines with powdery mildew incidence
Fig. 2. Severe leaf curling and higher powdery mildew incidence in unfertilized vines (RHS) compared to vines fertilized with potassium (LHS).
flavonoid compounds and a shortage of K reduces the amount of
the plants’ natural antifungal compounds at the site of infection
(Marschner, 1995). Bowen et al. (1992) found no difference in
Uncinula necator infection in water sprayed and K2HPO4 sprayed
leaves of potted grapevines. However, their studies did not
mention K and P content of the leaves. In their studies, the amount
of K2HPO4 used in the spray was not enough to change the P and
K content of the vines. However, in studies carried out by Saleh
et al. (2007), vines fertilized with low NPK concentration were
more susceptible to disease than those fertilized with high levels.
Reuveni et al. (1993) observed that number of grape clusters
infected by U. necator and the severity of infection were greater
on vines fertilized with a low level of NPK (50% infection) than
in plants fertilized with a high level (9.5% infection). During
2010, one set of Thompson Seedless vines (20 vines) was
fertilized with recommended doses of K and also sprayed with
K at fortnightly interval (Fig. 2) during the foundation pruning
and the other set of vines was neither fertilized nor sprayed
with potassium. Disease incidence was recorded on 90th day
when the environmental conditions for powdery mildew were
highly favourable. Unfertilized vines exhibited severe inward
leaf curling symptoms and more incidence of powdery mildew
as compared to fertilized vines (Fig. 2). The average petiole
K content in vines having more disease incidence was lower
(1.21%) than those having less incidence (1.95%).
These results suggest that powdery mildew incidence is related
to nutritional status of the vines. Amongst different nutrients,
potassium was the most important nutrient whose deficiency
increased the sensitivity of grapevines to powdery mildew
disease. Thus maintaining the optimum level of potassium in
grapevines should become a part of the integrated disease
management strategy for Indian vineyards.
References
Bowen, P., J. Menzies, D. Ehret, L. Samuels and A.D.M. Glass, 1992.
Soluble silicon sprays inhibit powdery mildew development on grape
leaves. J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci., 117(6): 906-912.
Graham, R.D. and M.J. Webb, 1991. Micronutrienis and disease
resistance and tolerance in plants. In: Micronutrienis in Agriculture.
R.M. Welch (ed). 2nd Edition. Soil Sci. Soc. America, Madison,
WI. pp 329-370.
Huber, D.M. 1978. Disturbed mineral nutrition. In: Plant pathology – An
Advanced Treatise, Vol. 3: Academic Press, NY. p.163-181.
Huber, D.M. 1980. The role of mineral nutrition in defence. In: Plant
Pathology – An advanced Treatise, Vol. 5: Academic Press, NY. p.
381-406.
Huber, D.M. and D.C. Arny, 1985. Interactions of potassium with plant
disease. In: Potassium in Agriculture, R.D. Munson (ed). American
Soc. Agronomy, Madison, WI. pp 467-488.
Mundankar, K.Y., S.D. Sawant, Indu S. Sawant and J. Sharma, 2008.
An expert system for the management of powdery mildew disease
of grapes in India. Acta Hort., 785: 297-300.
Marschner, H. 1995. Mineral Nutrition of Higher Plants. 2nd edition.
Academic Press.
Complementary Copy
Fig. 1. Disease rating 1/4 (LHS), disease rating 2/4 (middle) and 4/4 (RHS) on 90th day
Relationship of nutritional status of field grown Thompson Seedless grapevines with powdery mildew incidence
Sharma, J., A.K. Upadhyay, S.D. Sawant and Indu S. Sawant, 2009b.
Studies on shiny spot symptom development on leaves and its effect
on fruitfulness, disease incidence and vine yield. Indian J. Hort.,
66: 48-52
Sharma, J. and S.D. Shikhamany, 2008. Petiole nutrient standards for
Thompson Seedless vines on Dog Ridge rootstock. Acta Hort.,785:
379-382.
Sweeney, D.W., G.V. Granade, M.G. Eversmeyer and D.A. Whitney,
2000. Phosphorus, potassium, chloride, and fungicide effects on
wheat yield and leaf rust severity. J. Plant Nutr., 23(9): 12671281.
Willocquet, L., D. Colombet, M. Rougier, J. Fargues and M. Clerjeau,
1996. Effects of radiation, especially ultraviolet B, on conidial
germination and mycelial growth of grape powdery mildew.
European J. Plant Pathol., 102(5): 441-449.
Received: February, 2012; Revised: July, 2012; Accepted: November, 2012
Complementary Copy
Perrenoud, S. 1990. Potassium and plant health. In: IPI Research Topics
No. 3, 2nd revised edition. Basel/Switzerland.
Reuveni, M., A. Naor, R. Reuveni, M. Shimoni and B. Bravdo, 1993.
The Influence of NPK fertilization rates on susceptibility to powdery
mildew of field-grown winegrapes. Journal of Small Fruit and
Viticulture, 2(1): 31-41.
Saleh, M.M.S., N.E. Ashour, M.H. El-Sheikh and M.A.A. El- Nagaar,
2007. Foliar sprays of potassium dihydrogen phosphate and their
impact on yield, quality and controlling powdery mildew disease
of Thompson Seedless Grapevines. American Eurasian J. Agric.
Environ. Sci., 2(2): 133-140.
Sawant, Indu S., S.D. Sawant, Anuradha Upadhyay, J. Sharma, A.K.
Upadhyay, D. Shetty and R. Bhirangi, 2010. Crop loss in grapes due
to downy mildew infection on clusters at pre- and post-bloom stages
under non-epiphytotic conditions. Indian J. Hort., 67(4): 425-432.
Sharma, J., A.K. Upadhyay, Indu S. Sawant and S.D. Sawant, 2009a.
Association of mineral nutrients with vein reddening and necrosis
in Thompson Seedless grape. Indian J. Hort., 66: 154-162.
117
Journal
Journal of Applied Horticulture, 14(2): 118-123, 2012
Appl
Effe c t of grow ing m e dia on se e d ge r m inat ion a nd se e dling
grow t h of pa pa ya (Ca ric a pa pa ya ) c v. ‘Re d La dy’
R.L. Bha rdw a j
Krishi Vigyan Kendra-Sirohi (Rajasthan ), India. 307001. E-mail:
[email protected],
Abstract
The effect of three types of media and three levels of cocopeat were studied under agronet house conditions on germination and
development of papaya seedling in a Complete Randomized Design with nine treatment combinations. The results showed that the
medium of vermicompost + sand + pond soil (1 : 1 :1) with 2 cm cocopeat on the top (T9) gave maximum speed of emergence (277.6
and 709.09), highest germination per cent (95.27 and 90.15), highest seed vigour (91.97 and 86.69), maximum germination index (7.15
and 7.22), germination value (17.33 and 33.83) and least time required for imbibtion (9.45 and 9.30 days) with minimum germination
period (3.70 and 2.75 days), respectively in both years of experimentation. This medium was also found to be the best medium for the
growth of papaya seedlings as it gave the highest parameters in terms of seedling height (23.43 cm and 22.67 cm), leaf area (349.33
cm2 and 329.20 cm2), number of leaves (10.02 and 9.67), stem girth (3.16 mm and 3.48 mm), number of roots (17.20 and 16.17), root
length (10.20 cm and 9.67 cm), production of total biomass (5.02 g/plant and 4.77 g/plant) and least root/shoot ratio (0.22 and 0.20).
This treatment also significantly reduced the seedling mortality and produced maximum healthy seedlings (92.23 % and 93.15%) in
minimum days (35.33 and 35.15) with highest net profit (Rs. 3493.30/1000 seedling and Rs. 3448.00/ 1000 seedling) and B:C ratio
(1.85 and 1.84) of seedlings, in both years (2008-09 and 2009-10), respectively.
Introduction
Use of suitable growing media or substrates is essential for
production of quality horticultural crops. It directly affects the
development and later maintenance of the extensive functional
rooting system. A good growing medium would provide sufficient
anchorage or support to the plant, serve as reservoir for nutrients
and water, allow oxygen diffusion to the roots and permit gaseous
exchange between the roots and atmosphere outside the root
substrate (Abad et al., 2002; Argo, 1998a; Argo, 1998b; Bunt,
1988; Richards and Beardsell, 1986). Nursery potting media
influence quality of seedlings produced (Agbo and Omaliko,
2006; Baiyeri, 2005; Sahin et al., 2005). The quality of seedling
obtained from a nursery influences re-establishment in the field
(Baiyeri, 2006) and the eventual productivity of an orchard
(Baiyeri and Ndubizu, 1994). Papaya is an important fruit crop
which is propagated by seeds only. Seed germination is affected by
many factors, which include type of substrate used, environmental
factors such as oxygen, water, temperature and for some plant
species, light (Hartmann et al., 2001). The germination of seed
of papaya (C. papaya) is frequently reported to be slow, erratic
and incomplete (Chacko and Singh, 1966). Freshly harvested seed
gave only 6 per cent germination (Koyamu, 1951). Red Lady is
choicest variety of papaya grown due to hermaphrodite nature
and prolonged shelf life of fruits but the seed cost of this variety
is very high (Rs. 2.0 lakh/kg). The germination of papaya (C.
papaya) cv. Red Lady seeds faces certain problems in germination
and has high seedling mortality due to damping off disease in
nursery stage. Initial mortality and incomplete germination is
also one of the causes of reduced survival per cent of papaya
plants. In heavy soil, without enough drainage, the development
of root system is suppressed and plants are more susceptible to
soil borne diseases (Beattie and White, 1992). The papaya seed
is enclosed within a gelatinous sarcotesta (aril or outer seed coat
which is formed from the outer integument). While this sarcotesta
can prevent germination, dormancy is also observed in seeds from
which the sarcotesta has been removed (Lange, 1961; Yahira,
1979). Growing media plays important role for seed germination.
It not only acts as a growing place but also as a source of nutrient
for plant growth. Media composition influences the quality of
seedling (Wilson et al., 2001). Generally, media for fruit crop
seedling are composed of soil, organic matter, pond soil and
sand. The pond soil is usually used as a basic medium because
it is cheapest and easy to procure. Supplementing the sand is
aimed to make media more porous while the organic matter (FYM
and vermicompost) is added so as to enrich adequate nutrients
for the seedling. There is better rooting in manuare rather than
conventional soil mix and less susceptibility of the seedling to
soil borne pests and diseases (Akanbi et al., 2002).
Cocopeat is an agricultural by-product obtained after the
extraction of fiber from the coconut husk. It is considered as a
good growing media component with acceptable pH, electrical
conductivity and other chemical attributes (Abad et al., 2002).
Cocopeat has good physical properties, high total pore space,
high water content, low shrinkage, low bulk density and slow
biodegradation (Evans et al., 1996; Prasad, 1997). Due to
usually high initial level of potassium and sodium in cocopeat,
the fertilization program should be adjusted carefully to plant
requirements.
Keeping in view the influence of media on germination and
seedling growth of papaya, the present investigation was carried
out to study the effect of different media viz., sand, pond soil,
FYM, vermicompost and cocopeat on seed germination, seedling
growth and vigour of papaya seedlings.
Complementary Copy
Key word: B: C ratio, cocopeat, plant growth, pond soil, seedling, vermicompost
Effect of growing media on seed germination and seedling growth of papaya
Seed material and treatment: Seed germination and seedling
growth experiments of papaya were carried out at NHM
Model nursery (average temperature, 32 + 10 0C and RH,
60-80%) of Krishi Vigyan Kendra-Sirohi (Rajasthan), India
during two successive season from July to August 2009 and
2010. Experimental treatments comprised of nine treatment
combinations consisting of different combination of growth
media and cocopeat filling at the top of seedling polybags (10
x 12 cm) namely, T1 – sand + pond soil (1:1) without cocopeat,
T2- sand + pond soil (1:1) with 1 cm cocopeat, T3- sand + pond
soil (1:1) with 2 cm cocopeat, T4- FYM + sand + pond soil (1:1:1)
without cocopeat, T5- FYM + sand + pond soil (1:1:1) with 1 cm
cocopeat, T6- FYM + sand + pond soil (1:1:1) with 2 cm cocopeat,
T7- vermicompost + sand + pond soil (1:1:1) without cocopeat,
T8- vermicompost + sand + pond soil (1:1:1) with 1 cm cocopeat,
T9- vermicompost + sand + pond soil (1:1:1) with 2 cm cocopeat.
The seed sowing was done in month of July about 1 cm deep in
different media as per treatments. The polybags were irrigated
immediately after seed sowing and repeated every day till the
final emergence. After the completion of germination the bags
were irrigated once in 2 days.
Experimental design and measured parameters: Experiment
was conducted in Complete Randomized Design with three
replications. Each treatment was composed of 100 polybags.
All the observation on germination parameters were recorded
at the time of germination and growth parameter at the time of
transplanting (45 days after seed sowing) from 100 seeds for
germination parameter and randomly selected 10 seedling for
growth parameters. Data on germination was recorded from
the first germination until no further germination at two days
interval. The imbibtion period, number of days from sowing
to commencement of germination, was recorded for all studied
treatments. The speed of emergence (SE) was calculated according
to Islam et al. (2009) using the following formula:
Speed of emergence =
No. of seedlings emerged 5 days
after sowing
x 100
No. of seedlings emerged 15 days
after sowing
The germination percentage was calculated as the percent of
germinating seeds starting from the first germination to no
further germination. Germination percentage was calculated
by number of germinated seeds divided by the total number of
seeds sown in polybags and multiplied by 100. The germination
period was calculated as the difference between initial and final
emergence (number of days) recorded. Seed vigour was calculated
by total number of healthy seedling divided by the number of
total seedlings and multiplied by 100. The germination index
was calculated as described in the Association of Official Seed
Analysis (1983) by the following formula:
Germination index= Σ (GT/Tt) or
Germination index =
No. of
germinating seeds
Days of first count
+ . . . .+
No. of germinating
seeds
Days of final or last
count
The germination value (GV) was calculated according to Hossain
et al. (2005) by the following formula:
Germination value = (Σ DGs/N) X GP/10.
Where, GP is the germination percentage at the end of experiment,
DG is the daily germination speed obtained by dividing the
cumulative germination percentage by the number of days since
sowing, (Σ DGs) is the total germination obtained by adding
every DGs value obtained from the daily counts, (N) is the total
number of daily counts starting from the first germination and
(10) is constant.
Counting of number of leaves was done at the end of experiment
when the true leaves have emerged. Stem girth was measured 1
cm from the base of the stem using vernier calipers. Plant height
was measured from polybag top soil surface upto the highest
leaf tip by straightening all leaves. Leaf area was calculated by
the leaves traced on a graph paper. Number of roots, root length
was measured by destructive method of uprooting the plants and
taking measurement by standard method. Stem and root were
weighed to record stem, root fresh weight, root/shoot ratio, and
total weight per plant (g) was recorded at time of transplanting.
Survival per cent (after transplanting in main field) was recorded
by following formula:
Survival percent =
Total survival transplanted plants
Total transplanted plants
x 100
The net return was calculated by subtracting cost of each treatment
from the gross return and benefit: cost ratio = Gross income/Cost
of seedling production. All data was subjected to analysis of
variance (ANOVA) to determine significant differences followed
by Tukey’s test for the comparison of means at significant level
of 5 per cent.
Result and discussion
The results showed that growing media and cocopeat had
beneficial effect on seed germination and growth of papaya
seedling.
Seed germination parameters: Seed germination parameters of
papaya (Carrica papaya) as affected by growing media and use
of cocopeat are presented in Table 1. The treatment T9 was found
to be best followed by T8 with regard to germination behaviour
as these media have suitable physical properties and good water
holding capacity that supports the germination of papaya seeds
(Table 1 and Fig. 1). Coir dust when mixed with organic manure
acts as the best media because coir dust has good physical
characteristics (Garcia and Daverede, 1994) and also successfully
tested as a growing medium in ornamentals (Van Holm, 1993).
Germination started at the 9.45 days and 9.30 days after sowing
in vermicompost medium with 2 cm cocopeat (T9) for both year
of experimentation, respectively. Germination continued until
the 25.72 days and 22.03 days from sowing thereafter further
germination was not noticed in both year of experimentation,
respectively. For both years of experimentation, the maximum
speed of emergence (277.6 and 709.0), highest germination per
cent (95.27 and 90.15), highest seed vigour (91.97 and 86.69),
maximum germination index (7.15 and 7.22), germination value
(17.33 and 33.83) and least time required for imbibtion (9.45 and
9.30 days) with minimum germination period (3.70 and 2.75
days) were obtained in vermicompost + sand + pond soil (1:1:1)
with 2 cm filling with cocopeat of seedling polybags (T9) in both
year of experimentation, respectively. The sand + pond soil (1:1)
Complementary Copy
Materials and methods
119
Effect of growing media on seed germination and seedling growth of papaya
without cocopeat showed the poor results in most cases. The
vermicompost medium with 2 cm cocopeat allowed increased
values of germination parameters from the beginning to the end
of experiment compared to other media combination in both years
of experimentation. The reason for the best performance of pond
soil and vermicompost was high organic matter content which
increased the water and nutrient holding capacity of the medium,
which improved the water utilization capacity of plant. Joiner
and Nell (1982) found similar results in peat + perlite mixture
for Aglaonema and Dieffenbachia. Vermicompost is reported to
have bioactive principles which are considered to be beneficial
for root growth and this has been hypothesized to result in greater
root initiation, higher germination, increased biomass, enhanced
growth and development (Bachman and Metzger, 2008) and
also balanced composition of nutrients (Zaller, 2007). The well
decomposed organic matter (vermicompost) may preserve soil
humidity, increase nutrient content and improve soil structure
which increase water absorption and maintains the cell turgidity,
cell elongation and increase respiration at optimum level, leading
to conditions favourable for seed sprouting. Vermicompost
mixed with pond soil affects properties of soil, since organic
matter acts as glue for soil aggregate and source of soil nutrient
(Soepardi,1983). Vermicompost may improve soil aggregation
leading to improved permeability and airflow in the polybags.
Vermicompost and pond soil (due to high organic matter) may
decrease fluctuation of soil temperature. Further, seed germination
and root growth becomes easier to the particular depth so that
plant grows well and may absorb more water and nutrient (Jo,
1990). Organic matter may also improve nutrient availability and
improve phosphorus absorption (Karama and Manwan, 1990). All
these factors were favourable for seed germination and ultimately
increased seed germination per cent, speed of emergence, seed
vigour, germination index, germination value and reduce imbibtion
period. Combined application of vermicompost and cocopeat in
the treatment T9 showed significant effect on germination, seedling
growth and plant biomass probably due to the synergistic effect of
both the factors in improving physical condition of the media and
nutritional factors (Sahni et al., 2008).
Seedling growth and development parameters: Data presented
in Table (2 and 3) and Fig. 1 show that growth and development
of papaya seedling was significantly affected by growing media
and cocopeat. Significant differences were observed among the
different treatments with regard to seedling growth characters
and maximum number of leaves was observed in T9 treatment
(10.02 and 9.67) which was at par with T6 treatment (9.20 and
9.00) respectively, in both years (Table 2). Maximum seedling
girth (3.16 and 3.48 mm), highest seedling height (23.43 and
22.67 cm), largest leaf area (349.33 and 329.20 cm2), longest root
length (10.20 and 9.67 cm) and highest fresh weight of plants
(5.02 and 4.77 g) were recorded in T9 treatment in both years of
experimentation, respectively. Similarly maximum number of
roots per plant was also higher in T9 treatment (17.20 and 16.17)
which was at par with T8 treatment (16.83 and 15.20). Highest
fresh weight of shoot (4.12 and 3.98 g), fresh weight of roots (0.89
and 0.78 g) and least root/shoot ratio (0.22 and 0.20) was also
reported in T9 treatment in both years of experimentation (200809 and 2009-10), respectively. Manure (vermicompost) provides
adequate nutrients and enhances both the physical properties and
the water holding capacity (Soegiman, 1982). The similar result
was also reported by Supriyanto et al. (1990) working on orange
seedling that media containing manure produced the growth
Table 1. Effect of seedling growing media and cocopeat on the germination parameters of papaya
Treatments
T1
T2
T3
T4
T5
T6
T7
T8
T9
SEm+
CD at 5%
Imbition
period
2008-09 2009-10
16.67
14.67
14.60
12.60
12.35
11.75
16.45
14.25
13.55
13.62
11.75
11.42
14.30
13.38
11.13
12.12
9.45
9.30
0.377
0.618
1.117
1.829
Speed of
Germination
Germination
Seed
Germination
Germination
emergence
(%)
period
vigour
index
value
2008-09 2009-10 2008-09 2009-10 2008-09 2009-10 2008-09 2009-10 2008-09 2009-10 2008-09 2009-10
129.51 125.22 61.70
57.67
9.05
7.35
52.80
57.67
2.00
2.73
1.66
2.21
133.12 205.99 69.14
66.50
7.35
6.60
62.72
65.60
2.81
3.46
3.20
3.79
166.74 285.68 79.36
81.30
6.50
5.25
73.78
77.69
3.70
4.97
5.64
8.02
152.02 156.21 69.45
72.13
7.90
6.65
62.08
67.30
2.94
3.53
2.53
4.20
188.06 366.19 79.70
83.40
5.65
4.10
73.18
80.33
4.23
4.78
5.59
9.84
206.08 445.04 84.65
86.65
4.72
3.17
80.22
85.39
5.30
5.60
9.01
15.92
231.47 273.54 80.33
74.90
6.95
5.35
73.92
73.60
3.86
3.51
4.44
5.59
257.91 603.16 90.13
85.00
4.55
3.60
84.90
81.62
5.69
6.29
10.35
18.64
277.65 709.09 95.27
90.15
3.70
2.75
91.97
86.69
7.15
7.22
17.33
33.83
5.874 12.833 1.830
2.173
0.264
0.265
1.804
1.853
0.224
0.136
0.278
0.278
17.385 37.979 5.416
6.432
0.783
0.786
5.338
5.484
0.665
0.404
0.822
0.834
Table 2. Effect of seedling growing media and cocopeat on the growth parameters of papaya
Treatments
Number of
Stem girth
Seedling height
leaves
(mm)
(cm)
2008-09 2009-10 2008-09 2009-10 2008-09 2009-10
T1
4.00
3.07
0.96
1.28
7.20
9.33
T2
6.05
5.13
1.28
1.60
8.45
10.33
T3
7.11
8.25
1.92
2.24
10.45
12.33
T4
7.23
6.00
1.28
1.80
9.05
9.17
T5
8.25
8.15
2.24
2.44
12.20
12.17
T6
9.20
9.00
2.87
2.76
17.45
17.17
T7
8.13
6.63
1.89
2.21
16.43
11.67
T8
9.02
7.60
2.53
2.84
20.18
19.67
T9
10.02
9.67
3.16
3.48
23.43
22.67
SEm+
0.318
0.386
0.083
0.119
0.422
0.448
CD at 5% 0.941
1.142
0.245
0.353
1.251
1.326
Leaf area
Number of
Root length
Fresh weight of
(cm2)
roots
(cm)
plants (g)
2008-09 2009-10 2008-09 2009-10 2008-09 2009-10 2008-09 2009-10
18.30
15.14
5.00
6.60
3.01
3.90
0.60
0.63
33.35
30.30
9.45
10.35
3.55
4.21
0.80
0.79
51.23
50.37
12.03
12.30
6.02
5.45
1.00
1.02
41.25
59.45
7.10
7.83
5.25
4.90
0.72
0.65
84.31
99.00
11.13
9.69
7.37
6.47
1.20
0.80
134.00 134.30 12.17
12.35
7.60
6.94
1.65
1.23
126.17 149.12 13.80
12.00
8.15
7.19
2.67
2.17
216.25 249.25 16.83
15.20
9.45
8.58
3.82
3.30
349.17 329.20 17.20
16.17
10.20
9.67
5.02
4.77
3.457
3.457
0.581
0.536
0.218
0.196
0.046
0.051
10.232 10.232 1.721
1.587
0.647
0.580
0.137
0.152
Complementary Copy
120
Table 3. Effect of seedling growing media and cocopeat on the growth parameters,
Treatments
Fresh weight
Fresh weight of
Survival
Root /Shoot
of shoot
root
per cent
ratio
(g)
(g)
2008-09 2009-10 2008-09 2009-10 2008-09 2009-10 2008-09 2009-10
0.39
0.39
0.21
0.23
77.30
78.12
0.55
0.59
T1
T2
0.53
0.51
0.27
0.27
80.37
82.14
0.50
0.54
T3
0.69
0.68
0.31
0.34
84.35
86.00
0.45
0.50
T4
0.54
0.47
0.18
0.18
81.80
82.60
0.33
0.37
T5
0.95
0.61
0.27
0.19
84.88
86.65
0.28
0.31
T6
1.27
0.96
0.35
0.27
86.86
90.61
0.27
0.28
T7
2.12
1.74
0.50
0.43
87.20
84.30
0.24
0.25
T8
3.11
2.77
0.71
0.60
90.25
89.35
0.23
0.22
T9
4.12
3.98
0.89
0.78
92.23
93.15
0.22
0.20
SEm+
0.057
0.057
0.016
0.016
1.633
1.570
0.009
0.009
CD at 5%
0.170
1.170
0.048
0.048
4.835
4.649
0.029
0.028
and roots better than those containing sawdust and rice hulls.
Purbiati et al. (1994) proved that soil + manure (1:1) was the best
medium for the growth components of salacca cv. Pondoh and
Bali. Erwin (1998) also reported that in case of L. longiflorum
forcing media such as cocopeat and rice hulls have produced
equal or superior crops compared to many existing commercial
media. Combined application of vermicompost and cocopeat in
the treatment T9 showed significant effect on seedling growth
parameters and plant biomass probably due to the synergistic
effect of both the factors in improving the physical conditions
of the media and nutritional factors (Sahni et al., 2008). Thus
based on the results of this study, it can be concluded that the
treatment T9 (Vermicompost: pond soil: Sand 1:1:1 with 2 cm
cocopeat) showed better water holding capacity, favourable pH,
increased accumulation of nutrients which helped in better nutrient
availability to the growing plants and hence supporting enhanced
seed germination and seedling growth compared to the other
treatments. This result is akin to the findings of Campos Mota et
al. (2009) and Abirami et al. (2010) who suggested that since coir
dust is low in nutrients when mixed with vermicompost provides
a better growth medium for plant establishment. Air filled porosity
(AFP), easily available water (EAW) and aeration of vermicompost
and FYM were not at the recommended level which in turn limit
the root growth and lowered the water holding capacity. Therefore,
the medium with vermicompost and cocopeat is more suitable than
vermicompost alone because of the better physical properties and
enhanced nutrient level.
Treatment,T9 was also helpful in reducing damping off disease in
seedling due to proper aeration in root zone of the seedling and
produced highest survival per cent of seedling (92.23 and 93.15
%, respectively) which was at par with T8 treatment (90.25 and
93.15 %, respectively). Because of the better physical properties
and enhanced nutrient level in T9 treatment growth of seedling
was rapid and minimum days required for gaining transplanting
size (35.33 and 35.15 days) were at par with T6 (37.62 days) in
second year (2009-10) of experimentation (Table 3 and Fig. 1).
Vermicompost with cocopeat may improve soil porosity, water
content, drainage pores, soil permeability and water availability,
whereas weight of soil may decrease. This may develop soil
aggregation, and improves permeability and air flow in the soil.
This type of condition sharply reduced damping off disease in
nursery stage and provided support to fast growth of the seedling
due to availability of better nutrition with water and air in root
zone of the seedling. Ultimately the seedling gained transplanting
survival per cent,
Days required for
transplanting size
of seedling
2008-09 2009-10
47.35
45.30
45.30
42.35
42.50
41.20
43.60
40.60
40.50
39.50
38.58
37.62
40.25
40.30
38.30
38.35
35.33
35.15
1.006
1.006
2.979
2.979
net return and B:
Net return
(Rs./1000
seedlings)
2008-09 2009-10
805.00 755.0
1005.0 955.0
1905.0 1855.0
1093.0 1043.0
1893.0 1843.0
2393.0 2343.0
2193.3 2148.0
2993.3 2948.0
3493.3 3448.0
60.324 45.057
178.53 133.34
121
C ratio of papaya
B:C
ratio
2008-09 2009-10
1.17
1.15
1.19
1.18
1.35
1.34
1.20
1.19
1.34
1.33
1.41
1.40
1.65
1.64
1.78
1.77
1.85
1.84
0.066
0.066
0.198
0.198
size very soon in this treatment combination then other treatments.
It seems that good physical and biological conditions in cocopeat
and vermicompost had positive effect on root development,
which is helpful in increased survival per cent of seedling in
main field after transplanting. Beneficial effects of cocopeat on
root system was observed on nutmeg seedling (Abirami et al.,
2010), Osteospermum cuttings (Nowak, 2004), salvia, viola
(Pickering, 1997) and Impatiens (Smith, 1995). Application of
vermicompost: pond soil: sand (1:1:1) with 2 cm cocopeat media
(T9) for preparation of papaya seedling proved profitable and
showed maximum net return (Rs. 3493.30/1000 seedlings and Rs.
3448.00/1000 seedlings) and benefit: cost ratio (1.85 and 1.84)
for the first and second year of experimentation, respectively
due to higher germination percent and survival percent obtained
(Table 1 and 3). This treatment was significantly superior to rest
of the treatments during both year but benefit: cost ratio was at
par with T8 treatment.
At the end, it can be concluded that vermicompost and cocopeat
could be used successfully in production of papaya seedlings
due to suitable physical, chemical and biological properties.
Vermicompost+ pond soil+ sand (1:1:1) with 2 cm cocopeat was
considered the best media as the germination, seedling growth
and development parameters were higher as compared to other
media. Therefore, it can be suggested that vermicompost, pond
soil and sand with cocopeat should be used as growing media for
higher germination per cent, quick seedling growth of papaya and
more profit by sale of seedlings.
References
Abad, M., P. Noguera, R. Puchades, A. Maquieira and V. Noguera, 2002.
Physico-chemical and chemical properties of some coconut dusts
for use as a peat substitute for containerized ornamental plants.
Bioresearch Technology, 82: 241-245.
Abirami, K., J. Rema, P.A. Mathew, V. Srinivasan, and S. Hamza, 2010.
Effect of different propagation media on seed germination, seedling
growth and vigour of nutmeg (Myristica fragrans Houtt.). Journal
of Medicinal Plants Research, 4: 2054-2058.
Agbo, C.U. and C.M. Omaliko, 2006. Initiation and growth of shoots of
Gongronema latifolia Benth stem cuttings in different rooting media.
African Journal of Biotechnology, 5: 425-428.
Akanbi, B.W., A.O. Togun, and R.A. Baiyewn, 2002. Suitability of plant
residue compost as nursery medium for some tropical fruit tree
seedlings. Moor Journal of Agriculture Research, 3: 24-29.
A.O.S.A. 1983. Seed vigour testing handbook. Contribution No. 32 to
handbook on seed testing. Association of Official Seed Analysis.
Complementary Copy
Effect of growing media on seed germination and seedling growth of papaya
Effect of growing media on seed germination and seedling growth of papaya
Complementary Copy
122
Fig. 1. Effect of growing media and cocopeat on germination (1a), survival (1b), plant height (1c), root growth & leaf area (1d) of papaya.
In Fig. 1a, 1b, 1c results only under T3, T6, T9 are depicted.
Argo, W.R. 1998a. Root medium physical properties. HortTechnology,
8: 481-485.
Argo, W.R. 1998b. Root medium chemical properties. HortTechnology
8: 846-894.
Bachman, G.R. and J.D. Metzger, 2008. Growth of bedding plants
in commercial potting substrate amended with vermicompost.
Bioresour Technology, 99: 3155-3161.
Baiyeri, K.P. 2005. Response of Musa Species to Macro-PropagationII: The effects of genotype, initiation and weaning media on sucker
growth and quality in the nursery. African Journal of Biotechnology,
4: 229-234.
Baiyeri, K.P. 2006. Seedling emergence and growth of pawpaw (Carica
papaya) grown under different coloured shade polyethylene.
International Agrophysics, 20: 113-117.
Baiyeri, K.P. and T.O.C. Ndubizu, 1994. Variability in growth and field
establishment of Falsehorn plantain suckers raised by six cultural
methods. Mus. Africa, 4: 1-3.
Beattie, D.J. and J.W. White, 1992. Lilium –hybrids and species. In:
The Physiology of Flower Bulbs. De Hertogh A.A. and Le Nard M.
(eds.), Elsevier, Amsterdam.
Bunt, A.C. 1988. Media and Mixes for Container- Grown Plants. 1st
Edn., Springer, London, ISBN:10: 0046350160.
Campos Mota, L., U. Van Meeteren and C. Blok, 2009. Comparison of
physical properties of vermicompost from paper mill sludge and
green compost as substitutes for peat based potting media. Acta
Horticulture, 819: 227-234.
Chako, E.K. and R.N. Singh, 1966. Studies on the longevity of Papaya,
Phalsa, Guava and Mango seeds. Pro. International Seed Testing
Association, 36: 147-158.
Erwin, J.E. 1998. Easter lily production. Minn. Commune Flower Grower
Bulletin, 47: 1-10.
Evans, M.R., S. Konduru and R.H. Stamps, 1996. Source variation in
physical and chemical properties of coconut coir dust. HortiSciences,
31: 965-967.
Garcia, M. and C. Daverede, 1994. Dust from coir fibres: New substrate
for soilless culture. PHM Revue Horticole, 348: 7-12.
Hartmann, H.T., D.E. Kester, F.T. Davies and R.L.
Geneve, 2001. Plant
th
Propagation; Principles and Practices. 7 Edition, Prentice Hall
Publishers, New Jersey.
Hossain, M.A., M.K. Arefin, B.M. Khan and M.A. Rahman, 2005. Effect
of seed treatments on germination and seedling growth attributes of
horitaki (Terminalia chebula Retz.) in the nursery. Research Journal
of Agriculture and Biological Sciences, 1: 135-141.
Islam, A.K., M.A. Anuar and M. Yaakob, 2009. Effect of genotypes and
pre-sowing treatment on seed germination behavior of Jatropha.
Asian Journal of Plant Science, 8: 433-439.
Jo, I.S. 1990. Effect of organic fertilizer on soil physical properties and
plant growth. Paper presented at seminar on “The use of organic
fertilizers in crop production”, at Suwon, South Korea, 18-24 June
1990. p. 25.
Joiner, J.N. and T.A. Nell, 1982. Fired montmalillonite clay as a
propagation and hydroponic growing medium. Proceedings of the
Florida State Horticulture Society, 93: 214-215.
Karama, A.S. and I. Manwan, 1990. Penggunaan pupuk organic pada
tanaman pangan. Makalah pada Lokakarya Nasional Efisiensi
Penggunaan Pupuk. Cisarua Bogor, 12-13 November 1990, p. 44.
Koyamu, K. 1951. A preliminary note on the germination of Papaya
seed. Madras Agriculture Journal, 38: 348-349.
Lange, A.H. 1961. Effect of Sarcotesta on the germination of Papaya
(C. papaya). Bot. Gazette, 122: 305-311.
Nowak, J. 2004. The effect of rooting media and CO2 enrichment, P
– nutrition and micorrhizal inoculation on rooting and growth of
Osteospermum. Acta Horticulture, 644: 589-593.
Pickering, J.S. 1997. An alternative to peat. The Garden, 122: 428429.
Prasad, M. 1997. Physical, chemical and biological properties of coir
dust. Acta Horticulture, 450: 21-29.
123
Purbiati, T., Q.D. Ernawanto and S.R. Soemarsono, 1994. Pengaruh
Komposisi Media Tumbuh and Ukuran Pot terhadap Keberhasilan
and Pertumbuhan Tunas Anakan Salak yang Diperbanyak secara
Vegetatif Penel. Horticulture, 6: 1-12.
Richards, D.M.L. and D.V. Beardsell, 1986. The influence of particlesize distribution in pinebark: sand: Brown coal potting mixes on
water supply, aeration and plant growth. Sciences of Horticulture,
29: 1-14.
Sahin, U., S. Ors, S. Ercisli, O. Anapali and A. Esitken, 2005. Effect of
pumice amendment on physical soil properties and strawberry plant
growth. Journal of Central European Agriculture, 6: 361-366.
Sahni, S., B.K. Sarma, D.P. Singh, H.B. Singh and K.P. Singh, 2008.
Vermicompost enhances performance of plant growth promoting
rhizobacteria in Cicer arietinum rhizosphere against Sclerotium
rolfsii. Crop Protection, 27: 369-376.
Smith, C. 1995. Coir: a viable alternative to peat for potting.
Horticulturist, 4: 25-28.
Soegiman, M. 1982. Ilmu tanah. Terjemahan dari. The Nature and
Properties of Soils. Buckman and Brady. Bhatara Karya Aksara.
Jakarta. 788 hal.
Soepardi, G. 1983. Sifat dan cirri tanah. Department Ilmu-ilmu Tanah,
IPB. Bogor.
Supriyanto, A., Q.D. Ernawanto and L. Setiono, 1990. Media Tumbuh
Pembibitan Jeruk. Penelitian Hortikultura, 5: 1-8.
Van Holm, L. 1993. Coir as a growing medium. 7th floricultural
symposium, Oct. 11, Institute of fundamental studies: Hantana,
Kandy, Srilanka, p. 1-23.
Wilson, S.B., P.J. Stoffella and D.A. Graetz, 2001. Use of compost as a
media amendment for containerized production of two subtropical
perennials. Journal of Environment and Horticulture, 19: 37-42.
Yahira, M. 1979. Effects of seed pretreatments on the promotion of
germination in Papaya (C. Papaya L.). Memoirs of the Faculty of
Agriculture, Kago Shima University, 15: 49-54.
Zaller, J.G. 2007. Vermicompost as a substitute for peat in potting media:
Effects on germination, Biomass allocation, Yields and fruit quality
of three tomato varieties. Scientia Hort., 112: 191-199.
Received: November, 2011; Revised: March, 2012; Accepted: July, 2012
Complementary Copy
Effect of growing media on seed germination and seedling growth of papaya
Journal
Appl
Journal of Applied Horticulture, 14(2): 124-128, 2012
Effe c t of pla nt bio-re gulat ors on physic o-che m ic a l
cha ra c t e rist ic s of t hre e a pple va rie t ie s during a m bie nt st ora ge
B.L. At t ri* , H a re K rishna , B. Da s, N . Ahm e d a nd Ak hile sh Kum a r
Central Institute of Temperate Horticulture, Regional Station, Mukteshwar – 263 138, Uttarakhand, India.
*E-mail:
[email protected]
Abstract
For extending the shelf life, a study was carried out on the effect of bio-regulators viz., salicylic acid and Ca-EDTA on three apple
varieties viz., Fanny, Golden Delicious and Vance Delicious. The selected fruits were dipped for 30 minutes in aqueous solution of
salicylic acid @ 200 ppm, Ca-EDTA @ 0.4% ppm and control (distilled water dip). The treated fruits were stored in CFB boxes at
ambient temperature (18-20oC) for 60 days. During storage, the effect of bio-regulators on various physico-chemical characteristics
such as TSS, acidity, ascorbic acid, sugars and antioxidants of apple fruits were studied at 10 days interval. The results revealed that the
fruits treated with bio-regulators had significantly better retention of firmness and low PLW (12.10, 12.80 and 13.69%) as compared
to control (20.26, 18.75 and 19.35%) during storage for 60 days. The TSS, acidity, ascorbic acid, sugars and antioxidant contents in
the treated fruits were stable, whereas in untreated ones the conversion rate was faster. During storage, salicylic acid and Ca-EDTA
slowed down respiration rate resulting better shelf life of apple. The treated fruits of Golden Delicious had a shelf life of 60 days as
compared to 40 days in control. The study revealed that the shelf life of the apple fruits could be increased with better physico-chemical
characteristics using bio-regulators like salicylic acid and Ca-EDTA.
Introduction
In India, the North-West Himalayan Region (NWHR) comprising
Jammu & Kashmir, Himachal Pradesh and Uttarakhand, have
mountainous, low and mid hills with valleys, which are suitable
for a number of temperate fruit crops. Uttarakhand is very rich in
the plant diversity because of its congenial climatic and geographic
conditions suitable for cultivating a number of temperate fruits
like apple, pear, peach, plum, apricot, walnut etc. Apple (Malus
domestica Bork.) is the largest cultivated fruit in the region covering
an area of 32,050 ha with a production of 1.30 lakh tonnes (Anon.,
2009). Besides local consumption, the apples are also preferred
in the distant markets of the country due to the crisp texture and
pleasant flavour. However, due to poor postharvest facilities
available in the hilly regions and lack of proper transport, the fruit
do not reach distant market in good condition, thus resulting in
high postharvest losses (Sharma and Singh, 2010).
The costly and improved techniques such as cold storage,
controlled atmospheric storage and modified atmospheric
packaging are used in developed countries to check these losses.
Under Indian conditions, simple and inexpensive techniques
such as postharvest chemical treatments offer better prospects for
reducing the post harvest losses of fruits (Randhawa et al., 1980).
In Uttarakhand, a number of apple varieties including Delicious
group as well as spur types are being grown. However, only a
few of them had a better shelf life because of hard fruit skin
whereas others lack in postharvest shelf life restricting their entry
to distant markets and ensuring availability for a longer duration.
Further, harvesting of fruits in a limited period create a glut in
the market because of which the growers don’t get remunerative
returns for their produce. The apple in Uttarakhand matures early
as compared to Himachal Pradesh and Jammu & Kashmir, when
both temperature and humidity in the air are quite high. The
onset of monsoon and poor roads in the state also restrict the fast
transport of the harvested fruits to the distant markets thereby
causing losses to the growers.
Bio-regulators like salicylic acid and calcium play a significant
role in enhancing the postharvest shelf life of a number of fruits
(Issar et al., 2011). Salicylic acid (C6H4 (OH) COOH), which
is also known as 2-hydroxybenzenecarboxcylic acid, is an
organic acid and functions as plant hormone. Several studies
show that it has beneficial effects on the shelf and storage life
of several temperate fruits. Calcium is thought to be the most
important mineral element determining the fruit quality. It helps
in maintaining fruit firmness and decreases the incidence of
physiological disorders (Conway et al., 1998). Although, it is one
of the most significant fruit tree nutrients but it is very difficult
to accumulate in enough concentrations in the fruit because of
its less mobility in the plant. Its accumulation is more during the
fruit development but tends to decrease in the latter phase (Cline
and Hanson, 1991). In several studies, it has been demonstrated
that Ca improves fruit quality and shelf life of apples. Hence,
the present investigations were carried out to study the effect of
salicylic acid and Ca-EDTA on the physico-chemical characters
of three apple cultivars during storage at ambient conditions.
Materials and methods
The present investigation was undertaken during 2009 at
Central Institute of Temperate Horticulture, Regional Station,
Mukteshwar, situated at 2,200 m above mean sea level in Nainital
district of Uttarakhand, India.
Complementary Copy
Key words: Apple varieties, salicylic acid, Ca-EDTA, physico-chemical characters, ambient storage, anti-oxidants
Plant bio-regulators and physico-chemical characteristics of apple varieties
Treatments: The total treatments were 9 as T1= Fanny 200 ppm
Salicylic acid, T2= Fanny 0.4% Ca-EDTA, T3= Fanny control, T4=
Golden Delicious 200 ppm Salicylic acid, T5=Golden Delicious
0.4% Ca-EDTA, T 6= Golden Delicious control, T7= Vance
Delicious 200 ppm Salicylic acid, T8= Vance Delicious 0.4%
Ca-EDTA, T9= Vance Delicious control. The concentration of the
bio-regulators was selected on the basis of earlier work carried out
in other temperate fruits. 30 fruits of each variety were dipped for
30 minutes in aqueous solutions of bio-regulators. The dipping
duration was based on the earlier work. The treated fruits were
subjected to air drying in shade at room temperature followed
by storage in the corrugated fibre board boxes (CFB) at ambient
temperature (18-20oC) having relative humidity of 85-90%. The
storage study was conducted for 60 days.
Physico-chemical characters: The physiological loss in weight
(%PLW) of the marked 5 fruits in each treatment was recorded at
regular interval (10 days) on initial weight basis. The firmness of
the fruits was observed with fruit pressure tester model FT 327
and the results were expressed as lb/in2. The fruits as well as
extracted juice was subjected to physical characters analysis viz.,
weight (g), length (mm), breadth (mm), juice (%), and pomace
(%) by following standard methods (Ranganna, 1997). Similarly,
the total soluble solids (TSS oBrix) of the juice were recorded with
hand refractometer (Erma, Japan) corrected at 20oC, acidity (%)
by titrating a known volume of aliquot against N/10 NaOH using
phenolphthalein as indicator as described by Ranganna (1997).
The reducing and total sugars (%) of the juice were estimated as
per the methods of AOAC (1990). The ascorbic acid contents
(mg/100g) were recorded by titrating a known volume of juice
with metaphosphoric acid against 2,6 dicholophenol indophenol
dye (Ranganna, 1997) and were expressed as mg/100g juice.
Antioxidant activity: Antioxidant activity was measured by
following the method of Apak et al. (2004), which measures
the copper (II) or cupric ion reducing ability at 450 nm after
30 min. of sample reagent mixing. To a test tube were added 1
mL each of copper (II) chloride solution (10-2M, 1.705g in 1
L distilled water), Neocuproine solution of 7.5 x 10-3M (1.562
g in 1 L ethanol), and ammonium acetate buffer, pH 7 (19.27
g in 250mL distilled water) solutions. Antioxidant sample (or
standard) solution (x mL) and H2O (1.1- x mL) were added to
the initial mixture so as to make the final volume 4.1 mL. The
tubes were stoppered and after one hour, the absorbance at 450
nm was recorded against a reagent blank. The antioxidant activity
was expressed as m mol Trolox® per litre, or mM TE.
Statistical analysis: The experiment was undertaken in
completely randomized design, replicated four times. The data
on physico-chemical characteristics of different varieties of apple
recorded during storage at ambient temperature were analysed as
per method described by Panse and Sukhatme (2000).
Results and discussion
All the physico-chemical characteristics of the three varieties of
apple varied significantly (Table 1). Fruit firmness was maximum
(15.0 lb/in2) in Golden Delicious followed by Vance Delicious.
Fruit weight was highest in Vance Delicious (177.76 g) and lowest
in Fanny (78.00g). The recovery of extracted juice was maximum
(62.82%) in Fanny followed by Vance Delicious (55.64%). The
highest TSS of the juice (15.0oB) was observed in Fanny and
lowest (13.0oB) in Golden Delicious. The ascorbic acid content in
the juice was maximum (13.6 mg/100g) in Fanny and minimum
(5.0 mg/100g) in Vance Delicious. The total antioxidants in the
extracted juice of different varieties were recorded and found
highest in Fanny (10.51 mMTE/L) and lowest in Vance Delicious
(6.89 mMTE/L). The variation in the physico-chemical characters
in different varieties of apple may be attributed to their genetic
characterstics (Farooqui et al., 2004).
Table 1. Physico-chemical characters of different apple varieties
(mean±S.E.)
Characters
Pressure (lb/in2)
Weight (g)
Length (mm)
Breadth (mm)
Juice (%)
Pomace (%)
TSS (oB)
Acidity (%)
Ascorbic acid (mg/100g)
Reducing sugars (%)
Total sugars (%)
Total antioxidants
mMTE/L
TSS acid ratio
Fanny
9.20±0.057
78.00±1.154
47.60±0.346
57.67±0.387
62.82±0.242
37.18±0.242
15.0±0.115
0.67±0.0057
13.6±0.196
6.25±0.057
7.69±0.103
10.510.008
Golden
Delicious
15.00±0.115
125.00±2.886
58.50±0.288
65.56±0.323
54.59±0.225
45.41±0.225
13.0±0.057
0.50±0.0011
7.0±0.016
5.88±0.046
7.14±0.034
8.61±0.008
Vance
Delicious
12.60±0.230
177.76±1.154
66.45±0.144
76.25±0.144
55.64±0.138
44.36±0.138
14.0±0.230
0.40±0.0011
5.0±0.057
7.14±0.023
8.00±0.057
6.89±0.008
22.38±0.375 25.89±0.178 34.82±0.386
The physiological loss in weight (% PLW) of different varieties
of apple was recorded at different intervals and a significant
difference was found among different treatments (Table 2).
Irrespective of the variety, the lowest PLW (%) was recorded in
the fruits treated with Ca-EDTA (Ca) followed by salicylic acid
(SA) and control. Among the varieties, the maximum PLW was
recorded in Fanny (13.69,15.46 and 20.26%) and minimum in
Golden Delicious (12.10, 13.32 and 18.75%) in the fruits treated
with Ca, SA and control, respectively after storage for 60 days at
ambient conditions. The minimum PLW in the fruits treated with
Ca and SA may be attributed to the restrictions in the respiration
process thereby decreasing the loss in weight during storage.
Han et al. (2003) had reported similar findings in peaches after
exogenous application of salicylic acid. Similarly, Kumar et al.
(2005) reported significant effect of Ca(NO3)2 in maintaining the
physico-chemical characters of aonla during storage.
The firmness value of the fruits, irrespective of the variety and
treatments declined significantly during storage period of 60 days.
The maximum loss in firmness was recorded in the fruits under
control in each variety whereas minimum in the fruits treated
with Ca (Table 3). Among the varieties, the highest firmness
loss was recorded in Golden Delicious (43.83%) and lowest in
Fanny (37.50%) after 60 days of storage (Fig. 1). The maximum
retention of the firmness in the fruits treated with Ca may be
due to creating a barrier for the loss of water and checking the
breakdown of insoluble protopectin thereby maintaining the
firmness better as compared to other treatments. The exogenous
application of salicylic acid inhibited the respiration rate and
delayed the ethylene production peak of ripening peaches at
Complementary Copy
Raw material: The matured and uniform fruits of Fanny, Golden
Delicious and Vance Delicious varieties were procured from the
orchard of the Regional Station. After sorting out, the uniform
matured fruits were selected on the basis of water dip method.
125
Plant bio-regulators and physico-chemical characteristics of apple varieties
Table 2. Physiological loss in weight (%PLW) of different varieties of
apple during storage
Treatments
Storage period (Days)
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
T1
0.0
1.92
5.35
8.74 11.10 13.79 15.46
T2
0.0
1.27
4.74
7.19
9.10 11.78 13.69
T3
0.0
3.84
7.47 11.30 14.66 17.51 20.26
T4
0.0
1.45
4.70
7.87 10.35 11.85 13.32
T5
0.0
1.02
3.92
6.40
8.30 10.58 12.10
T6
0.0
2.75
6.72
9.65 12.68 15.67 18.75
T7
0.0
1.56
5.10
8.26 10.86 12.46 14.38
T8
0.0
1.15
4.24
6.90
8.90 11.10 12.80
T9
0.0
3.08
7.18 10.95 13.20 16.75 19.35
CD 0.05
0.03
0.03
0.06
0.05
0.04
0.05
Table 3. Effect of salicylic acid and calcium on firmness (lb/in2) of
different varieties of apple during storage
Treatments
T1
T2
T3
T4
T5
T6
T7
T8
T9
CD 0.05
0
9.20
9.40
9.60
14.80
15.00
14.60
12.40
12.60
12.80
0.10
10
9.00
9.20
9.00
14.20
14.60
13.40
12.00
12.20
12.00
0.09
Storage period (Days)
20
30
40
8.80
8.20
7.80
9.00
8.40
8.00
8.70
7.80
7.00
13.60 12.80 12.00
14.00 13.40 12.60
12.00 11.00 10.20
11.40 10.80 10.00
11.80 11.20 10.60
11.20 10.00
9.40
0.16
0.17
0.14
50
7.20
7.40
6.60
11.20
12.00
9.40
9.40
10.00
8.80
0.16
60
6.80
7.00
6.00
10.40
11.20
8.20
8.60
8.20
7.90
0.19
ambient storage conditions (Han et al., 2003). The plum fruits
treated with Ca(NO3)2 (0.5, 1.0 and 2.0%) and stored at low
temperature revealed that the fruits treated with 2% Ca(NO3)2
recorded the highest firmness throughout the storage as compared
to control signifying the utility of calcium nitrate during transit
and marketing (Mahajan et al., 2008). Similarly, the PLW (%)
was also less in fruits treated with calcium nitrate revealing
that calcium is helpful in maintaining fruit firmness and tissue
rigidity thereby checking the moisture loss from the fruit surface.
The retention of higher firmness with postharvest application of
calcium nitrate may probably be due to the role of calcium in
maintaining the cellular organization and regulating the enzyme
activities (Jones and Lent, 1967).
A significant increase in the total soluble solids of the fruits in
different treatments of apple was recorded upto 30 days followed
by decrease during storage. The highest increase followed by
decrease was found in the fruits under control and lowest in Ca
(Table 4). The minimum increase in the TSS in the fruits treated
with Ca may be due to the restriction in the physiological process
and respiration during storage thereby maintaining the total
soluble solids better as compared to the fruits under control. The
results are in conformity with those reported by Mahajan et al.
(2004) in Asian pear.
During storage, the acidity (%) of the fruits in different treatments
of apple was found to reduce significantly. It was observed that
the acidity reduced faster in the control as compared to SA and
Table 4. Effect of salicylic acid and calcium on total soluble solids (TSS
o
B) of different varieties of apple during storage
Treatments
T1
T2
T3
T4
T5
T6
T7
T8
T9
CD 0.05
0
15.0
15.2
15.0
13.0
13.2
13.0
14.0
14.0
14.2
0.1
10
15.2
15.2
15.4
13.2
13.4
13.4
14.2
14.2
14.4
0.1
Storage period (Days)
20
30
40
15.4
15.8
15.2
15.6
16.0
15.6
15.8
16.2
15.0
13.4
13.8
13.4
13.6
14.0
13.8
13.8
14.4
13.0
14.4
14.8
14.2
14.6
15.0
14.6
15.0
15.4
13.8
0.2
0.2
0.2
50
14.6
14.8
14.0
13.0
13.4
12.6
13.6
14.0
13.0
0.2
60
14.0
14.2
13.2
12.6
13.0
12.0
13.2
13.6
11.8
0.2
Table 5. Effect of bio-regulators on acidity (%) of different varieties of
apple during storage
Treatments
T1
T2
T3
T4
T5
T6
T7
T8
T9
CD 0.05
0
0.67
0.67
0.67
0.50
0.50
0.50
0.40
0.40
0.40
0.01
10
0.60
0.59
0.57
0.48
0.47
0.44
0.37
0.34
0.32
0.01
Storage period (Days)
20
30
40
0.59
0.54
0.44
0.57
0.50
0.40
0.54
0.44
0.37
0.47
0.40
0.37
0.44
0.37
0.34
0.40
0.34
0.32
0.34
0.32
0.30
0.32
0.30
0.28
0.30
0.28
0.23
0.01
0.01
0.01
50
0.37
0.34
0.27
0.35
0.32
0.28
0.28
0.27
0.22
0.01
60
0.34
0.27
0.24
0.34
0.30
0.27
0.27
0.23
0.20
0.01
Table 6. Ascorbic acid (mg/100g) of different varieties of apple as
affected by salicylic acid and calcium during storage
Treatments
Fig.1. Per cent loss in firmness of apple in different treatments during
storage
T1
T2
T3
T4
T5
T6
T7
T8
T9
CD 0.05
0
13.6
13.6
13.7
7.0
7.0
7.0
5.0
5.0
5.0
0.1
10
12.5
12.0
11.5
6.5
6.3
6.0
4.8
4.6
4.4
0.1
Storage period (Days)
20
30
40
12.0
11.4
11.0
11.5
11.1
10.5
11.0
10.7
10.0
6.3
6.1
6.0
6.1
6.0
5.8
5.8
5.4
5.2
4.7
4.4
4.2
4.5
4.2
4.1
4.2
4.1
4.0
0.1
0.1
0.1
50
10.6
10.1
9.5
5.7
5.1
5.1
4.1
4.0
3.9
0.1
60
10.0
9.6
9.0
5.2
5.0
4.9
4.1
4.0
3.8
0.1
Complementary Copy
126
Plant bio-regulators and physico-chemical characteristics of apple varieties
The ascorbic acid content of the different varieties of apple treated
with SA and Ca was recorded during storage and it was found
that the fruits treated with the bio-regulators retained significantly
higher ascorbic acid content than fruits dipped in water (control),
irrespective of the variety (Table 6). As SA and Ca had restricted
the process of ripening the retention of the ascorbic acid was
attributed due to slow rate of ripening and oxidation. The postharvest dip in calcium chloride, calcium lactate and calcium
propionate helped to increase significantly the shelf life with
reduced ethylene production in peach stored in cold storage for
4 weeks (Manganarisa et al., 2007). Ascorbic acid breakdown is
accelerated by amino acids and in the presence of amine as it is
oxidized to dehydroascorbic acid that is the reactive intermediate
in the pathway to furfural and brown pigment production (Sharma
et al., 2006).
The reducing and total sugars (%) in the fruits of different
treatments of apple under study showed significantly increasing
trend irrespective of the variety upto 30 days followed by
reduction. The increase was recorded faster in the fruits of control
as compared to SA and Ca (Table 7 & 8). The increase in the
reducing and total sugars was probably due to the hydrolysis of
starch as well as other complex carbohydrates to simpler sugars.
Further, the reduction in the sugars during storage may be due to
the utilization of the same in the respiration process. The results
are in conformity with those reported by Knee and Smith (1989)
in apple fruits. On complete hydrolysis of starch, no further
Table 7. Effect of salicylic acid and calcium on reducing sugars (%) of
different varieties of apple during storage
Treatments
Storage period (Days)
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
T1
6.25
6.32
6.36
6.49
6.28
6.17
6.02
T2
6.25
6.36
6.41
6.57
6.25
6.09
5.88
T3
6.25
6.41
6.57
6.84
6.17
6.02
5.74
T4
5.88
5.95
6.09
6.25
6.25
5.95
5.74
T5
5.88
6.09
6.25
6.41
6.17
5.88
5.61
T6
5.88
6.25
6.57
6.84
6.09
5.74
5.49
T7
7.14
7.24
7.40
7.57
7.29
7.19
6.94
T8
7.14
7.35
7.51
7.69
7.24
7.14
6.84
T9
7.14
7.46
7.69
7.93
7.19
7.04
5.37
CD 0.05
0.04
0.05
0.03
0.08
0.05
0.04
0.03
Table 8. Effect of bio-regulators on total sugars (%) of different varieties
of apple during storage
Treatments
Storage period (Days)
T1
T2
T3
T4
T5
T6
T7
T8
T9
CD 0.05
0
7.69
7.70
7.68
7.14
7.15
7.14
8.00
8.05
8.00
0.04
10
7.78
7.84
8.00
7.24
7.29
7.40
8.06
8.13
8.26
0.05
20
8.00
8.16
8.34
7.35
7.40
7.54
8.19
8.34
8.47
0.05
30
8.26
8.51
8.69
7.54
7.69
8.00
8.34
8.51
8.69
0.04
40
8.13
8.00
7.90
7.40
7.35
7.24
8.16
8.09
8.00
0.05
50
8.00
7.93
7.78
7.29
7.24
7.19
8.00
7.90
7.78
0.06
60
7.90
7.78
7.63
7.19
7.14
7.09
7.93
7.84
7.69
0.04
Table 9. Total antioxidants (mMTE/L) of different varieties of apple
affected by salicylic acid and calcium during storage
Treatments
T1
T2
T3
T4
T5
T6
T7
T8
T9
CD 0.05
0
10.52
10.52
10.52
8.61
8.62
8.61
6.89
6.89
6.90
0.01
10
10.49
10.45
10.39
8.59
8.54
8.49
6.85
6.81
6.72
0.01
Storage period (Days)
20
30
40
10.37 10.22 10.01
10.31 10.15
9.94
10.27 10.11
9.82
8.47
8.34
8.16
8.40
8.27
8.07
8.38
8.22
7.97
6.71
6.56
6.38
6.66
6.50
6.32
6.60
6.45
6.26
0.01
0.01
0.01
50
9.79
9.69
9.56
7.93
7.85
7.79
6.19
6.07
5.95
0.01
60
9.51
9.39
9.26
7.73
7.61
7.49
6.01
5.89
5.77
0.01
increase in TSS and sugars occurs and consequently a decline in
these parameters is predictable as they are the primary substrates
in respiration (Wills et al., 1980).
The total antioxidants in fruits of all the varieties of apple under
the study exhibited a significant decrease during storage. The
reduction was found highest in control in each variety and lowest
in fruits treated with SA. Among the varieties, the maximum
(9.51, 9.39 and 9.26 mMTE/L) antioxidants were recorded in
Fanny whereas minimum (6.01, 5.89 and 5.77 mMTE/L) in Vance
Delicious after storage for 60 days (Table 9). The reduction in the
antioxidant contents may be attributed to the over ripening of the
fruit thereby breakdown of these contents as well as oxidation
during respiration. The shelf life of different cultivars of peach
was found to increase significantly by post-harvest application of
SA and Ca as compared to control (Attri et al., 2010).
From the present study, it can be concluded that the apple varieties
like Fanny, Golden Delicious and Vance Delicious can be stored
for more than 60 days at ambient temperature after treating with
either salicylic acid or Ca. There was minimum loss in physicochemical parameters and PLW with better firmness in Golden
Delicious as compared to other two varieties.
References
Anonymous, 2009. Statistical Database (2008-09) on area and production
of fruits and vegetables. Directorate of Horticulture and Food
Processing, Chaubattia, Ranikhet (Uttarakhand).
A.O.A.C. 1990. Official Methods of Analysis. Association of Official
Analytical Chemists. 13th Edn, Washington, DC.
Apak, R., K. Guclu, M. Ozyurek and S.E. Karademir, 2004. Novel total
antioxidant capacity index for dietary polyphenols and vitamin
C and E, using their cupric ion reducing capability in presence
of neocuproine: CUPRAC method. J. Agr. Fd. Chem., 52: 79707981.
Attri, B.L., H. Krishna, B. Das, J.K. Ranjan, Pragya and N. Ahmed,
2010. Effect of bio-regulators on the shelf life of different cultivars
of peach (Prunus persica L. Batsch.). Natl. Symp. on Conservation
Hort. (21-23 March, 2010, Dehradun, India), Book of Abstracts,
pp. 262.
Banik, D., R.S. Dutta, S.K. Ghosh and S.K. Sen, 1988. Studies on
extension of storage life of sapota (Achras sapota L.). Indian J.
Hort., 45: 241-48.
Cline, J.A. and E.J. Hanson, 1991. Calcium accumulation in Delicious
apple fruit. J. Plant Nutr., 14(11): 1213-1222.
Conway, W.S., C.E. Sams and K.D. Hickey, 1998. Pre and post harvest
calcium treatment on apple fruit and its effect on quality. J. Agr. Fd.
Chem., 46(7): 2452-2457.
Complementary Copy
Ca treated fruits (Table 5). As the respiration was checked due to
exogenous application of bio-regulators the acidity was found to
remain under control. The results are in line with those reported
by Banik et al. (1988) where it has been mentioned that retention
of high acidity means slow ripening. Further, the decline in
acidity during storage might account for use of organic acids in
respiration (Ulrich, 1974).
127
Plant bio-regulators and physico-chemical characteristics of apple varieties
Farooqui, K.D., K.M. Bhat and A. Mehmood, 2004. Effect of different
levels of fertilization on quality and production of apple cultivars.
Progressive Hort., 36(2): 216-220.
Han, T., W.L. Li and X. Ge, 2003. Effect of exogenous salicylic acid on
post harvest physiology of peaches. Acta Hort., 628: 583-589.
Issar, K., M.C. Nautiyal, S.K. Sharma and T.S. Bisht, 2011. Effect of
chemicals, GA treatment and packaging on shelf life and quality of
apple. J. Hill Agr., 2(1): 63-73.
Jones, R.C.W. and O.R .Lent, 1967. The role of calcium in plants. Botl.
Rev., 33: 407-26.
Knee, M. and S.M. Smith, 1989. Variation in quality of apple fruits stored
after harvest on different dates. J. Hort. Sci., 64: 413-419.
Kumar, S., A. Kumar, M.J. Baig and B.K. Chaubey, 2005. Effect of
calcium on physico-chemical changes in aonla (Emblica officinalis
Gaertn), Indian J. Hort., 62(4): 324-326.
Mahajan, B.V.C., A.S. Dhatt and W.S. Dhillon, 2004. Effect of prestorage treatments on the quality and storage of Asian pear. Indian
J. Hort., 61(3): 342-344.
Mahajan, B.V.C., J.S. Randhawa, H. Kaur and A.S. Dhatt, 2008. Effect
of post harvest application of calcium nitrate and gibberellic acid on
the storage of plum. Indian J. Hort., 65(1): 94-96.
Manganarisa, G.A., M.Vasilakakisa, G. Diamantidisa and I. Mignani,
2007. The effect of post harvest calcium application on tissue calcium
concentration, quality attributes, incidence of flesh browning and
cell wall physicochemical aspects of peach fruits. Fd. Chem., 100
(4): 1385-1392.
Panse,V.G. and P.V. Sukhatme, 2000. Statistical Methods for Agricultural
Workers. ICAR Pub., New Delhi.
Randhawa, J.S., B.S. Dhillon, S.S. Sandhu and J.S. Bhullar, 1980. Effect
of post harvest application of GA3, cycocel and CaCl2 on storage
behaviour of Le Conte pear. J. Res. Punjab Agr. Uni., 17: 363-365.
Ranganna, S. 1997. Handbook of Analysis and Quality Control for Fruit
and vegetable Products. 2nd Edn. Tata McGraw Hill Pub. Co. Ltd.,
New Delhi.
Sharma, S.K., B.B.L. Kaushal and P.C. Sharma, 2006. Reduction of
non-enzymatic browning of lemon juice concentrates by removal
of reaction substrates. J. Fd. Sci. Technol., 43(1): 83-88.
Sharma, R.R. and D. Singh, 2010. Effect of different packaging materials
on shelf-life and quality of apple during storage. Indian J. Hort.,
67(1): 94-101.
Ulrich, R. 1974. Organic acids. In: Biochemistry of Fruits and Their
Products. A.C. Hulme (ed.). Academic Press, New York, pp. 89118.
Wills, R.B.H., P.A. Cambridge and K.J. Scott, 1980. Use of flesh firmness
and other objective tests to determine consumer acceptability of
delicious apples. Austral. J. Exp. Agri. Ani. Husb., 20: 252-56.
Received: November, 2011; Revised: March, 2012; Accepted: July, 2012
Complementary Copy
128
Journal
Journal of Applied Horticulture, 14(2): 129-133, 2012
Appl
I nfl ue nc e of biofe r t ilize rs on pla nt grow t h, fruit yie ld, nut rit ion
a nd rhizosphe re m ic robia l a c t ivit y of pom e gra nat e (Punic a
gra na t um L.) c v. K a ndha ri K a buli
M uza ffa r M ir* a nd Som Dev Sha r m a
Dr. Y.S. Parmar University of Horticulture and Forestry, Nauni, Solan (H.P), India-173230.
*E-mail:
[email protected]
Abstract
The present study represents the positive response of biofertilizers in pomegranate cuttings followed by their transplantation in
field conditions. Nursery and field experiments were carried out to assess the effectiveness of selected N2-fixing bacteria, phosphate
solubilizing bacteria and AM fungi alone or in combination, on the growth and biomass production of Punica granatum. In both
experiments, the combined treatment of Azotobacter chroococcum + Glomus mosseae was found to be the most effective. Besides
enhancing the rhizosphere microbial activity and concentration of various metabolites and nutrients, these bioinoculants helped in
better establishment of pomegranate plants under field conditions. A significant improvement in the plant height, plant canopy, pruned
material and fruit yield was evident in 6-year-old pomegranate plants in field conditions. In view of the above results, use of biofertilizer
technology may be adopted for the establishment and development of other horticultural plant species in rainfed agroecosystem.
Introduction
Pomegranate (Punica granatum L.) is an economically important
commercial fruit plant species belonging to family Punicaceae.
The plant is drought tolerant, winter hardy and can thrive well
under rainfed conditions. Pomegranate is a good source of
protein, carbohydrate, minerals, antioxidants, vitamins A, B and
C, also useful in controlling diarrhea, hyperacidity, tuberculosis,
leprosy, abdominal pain and fever. Pomegranate juice contains
antioxidants such as soluble polyphenols, tannins, anthocyanins
and antiatherosclerotic properties (Michel et al., 2005), and can
be used in the treatment of cancer and chronic inflammation
(Ephraim and Robert, 2007). Commercial pomegranate orchards
are found in Indian rainfed areas, which is characterized by
nutrient-deficient soils, low organic matter, irregular distribution
of rainfall and generally experience water deficit during plant
growth period (Panwar and Tarafdar, 2006). Vegetation of rainfed
areas is often hindered by the lack of resident microflora, which
acts as both source and sinks for essential plant nutrients and is
fundamental to the transformation of various nutrients. Production
of horticultural crops has undergone significant changes in recent
years due to development of innovative technologies including
integrated nutrient management practices involving biofertilizers,
which include phosphate-solubilizing bacteria (PSBs), symbiotic
and non-symbiotic N2-fixing bacteria and arbuscular mycorrhizal
(AM) fungi. The use of biofertilizers in enhancing plant growth
and yield has gained momentum in recent years because of higher
cost and hazardous effect of chemical fertilizers. Nitrogen-fixing
bacteria and arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi were found to enhance
the growth and production of various fruit plants significantly
(Khanezadeh et al., 1995), besides improving the microbiological
activity in the rhizosphere (Kohler et al., 2007). Though there are
many reports on the effect of different biofertilizers on various
fruit plants, no information is available on usefulness of these
biofertilizers with respect to pomegranate. Hence, an attempt
has been made to examine the effect of biofertilizers namely
Azotobacter chroococcum (AC), phosphate-solubilizing bacteria
(PSB), Glomus fasciculatum (GF), and Glomus mosseae (GM)
on growth and nutrient uptake as well as rhizosphere microbial
activity of pomegranate under field conditions.
Materials and methods
The field experiment was conducted on pomegranate cv.
‘Kandhari Kabuli’ during 2008-11. The experimental farm is
located at 30° 50’ 45” latitude and 77° 88’ 33” longitude at an
elevation of 1320 m above mean sea level, representing mid hill
zone of state. The climate of the area is typically sub-temperate.
The annual rainfall ranges between 800-1300 mm. The orchard
soil was sandy in texture with pH 6.55, 0.59 dS/m electrical
conductivity and 0.61 % organic carbon content. Water holding
capacity, bulk density and porosity of surface soil at 15 cm depth
were 31.65 %, 1.30 % and 48.50 %, respectively. The initial
available N, P and K contents of the soil were 309.85, 11.75 and
342.82 kg/ha, respectively. DTPA extractable micro-nutrients viz.,
zinc (Zn), manganese (Mn), iron (Fe), copper (Cu) and boron
(B) were 1.97, 45.72, 57.24, 2.47 and 0.70 ppm, respectively.
Strains of Azotobacter (a free living non-symbiotic N2-fixing
bacterium) were isolated using N-free semisolid malate medium
(Day and Dobereiner, 1976) and Jensen’s N-free agar medium
(Jensen, 1954), respectively, from the roots and rhizosphere soil
of field-grown pomegranate. The identification of strains was
carried out by Indian Agriculture Research Institute (IARI), New
Delhi (India) as PSB and A. chroococcum. The pure cultures
of these strains were maintained in Microbiology Department,
University of Horticulture and Forestry, Solan, (H.P.), using
above-mentioned media. After 3 days of growth, the cells were
Complementary Copy
Key words: Pomegranate (Punica granatum L.), azotobacter, mycorrhizal fungi, PSB, soil enzymes.
Influence of biofertilizers on growth, yield, nutrition and rhizosphere microbial activity of pomegranate
centrifuged, washed twice in sterile distilled water and suspended
in 0.15 M phosphate buffer at pH 7.0. Ten milliliters of cell
suspension having 108 cell mL-1 was used as inoculums for both
bacterial types at the time of planting pomegranate cuttings.
Spores of AM fungi were extracted from the rhizosphere soils
of field grown pomegranate plants by wet sieving and decanting
technique (Gerdeman and Nicolson, 1964). Total number of
spores was estimated by the method of Gaur and Adholeya (1994)
and spore densities were expressed as the number of spores per
50 g of soil. Taxonomic identification of AM spores up to species
level was based on spore size, spore colour, wall layers and
hyphal attachment and was made using the identification manual
of Schenck and Perez (1990) and the description provided by the
International Collection of Vesicular and Arbuscular Mycorrhizal
Fungi (http://invam.wvu.edu). The AM fungi were identified as
G. fasciculatum, G. margarita and G. mosseae. The pure cultures
were maintained on pearl millet/wheat plant roots under sterile
condition. Ten grams of soil including root bits containing about
10-12 viable AM fungal propagules per gram soil were used as
inoculum and spread as a thin layer 2 cm below soil surface in
polythene bag (30 × 10 cm) containing 900 g substrate (soil:farm
yard manure:pond silt, in the proportion of 3:1:1 by volume).
In case of control treatment, similar amount of inoculum was
sterilized in autoclave and added to polythene bag in same
manner. Semi-hard wood cuttings of pomegranate (5-month-old
cuttings) were kept in 250 ppm indole butyric acid solution for
12 h and then planted in polybags one each. The experiment was
laid out in a complete randomized design consisting of eight
treatments with 20 replications during the years 2008-2011. Dual
inoculation of A. chroococcum + G. mosseae, A. chroococcum
+ G. fasciculatum and A. chroococcum + PSB, were selected
based on the data obtained on various combinations of AM fungi,
nitrogen-fixing bacteria and phosphate solubilizing bacteria under
sterile condition during our preliminary study. The plants were
watered on alternate days to field capacity.
After sampling rhizosphere soil along with root fragments of
3-month-old seedlings grown in polythene bags, 10 plants from
each treatment were harvested and leaf area (leaf area meter, C203, USA) and total chlorophyll (Arnon, 1949) were measured.
Total phenols, reducing sugars and amino nitrogen in the leaves
were analyzed from the alcohol extracts (Mahadevan et al., 1965).
Shoot along with leaves were dried at 65 °C till constant weight
and dry weight were recorded.
The percent root colonization was determined by root slide
technique (Read et al., 1976) after clearing 1 cm root segment
with KOH and staining with trypan blue. Dehydrogenase
activity, a measure of microbial activity, was assayed by the
method of Tabatabi (1982). The soil samples were incubated
with 2,3,5-triphenyl tetrazolium chloride, and production of
triphenyl formazone was determined spectrophotomitrically.
Hydrolysis of fluorescein diacetate (FDA) was determined by
the standard procedure of Schnurer and Rosswell (1982) and the
fluorescein released was quantified spectrophotomitrically. For
this, soil sample (0.1 g) was placed in plastic tubes and 10 mL
sterile potassium buffer (pH 7.6, 60 mM) was added to it. The
reaction started after adding fluorescein diacetate (1 mg mL-1 in
acetone). Tubes were sealed and kept in an incubator at 37 °C
four 4 h. After incubation, 10 mL acetone was added to stop the
reaction and after centrifugation (3200 rpm), supernatant’s optical
density was determined at 490 nm. Total nitrogen-fixing potential
(nitrogenase activity) of the soil was determined by incubating
50 mg of soil in 7 mL test tube containing 3 mL nitrogen-free
semisolid malate medium for 48 h at 30 °C. The cotton plugs
were replaced with suba seals and 10% of air was replaced
with C2H2 and later ethylene (C2H4) produced was estimated
by an AIMIL-Nucon Gas chromatograph fitted with Porapak-N
column (2 × 0.003 m) using N2 as carrier gas at a flow rate of
25 mL min-1. Nitrogenase (N2-ase) activity was expressed as n
mol C2H4 produced per hour (Rao and Venkateswarlu, 1982).
For activity of alkaline phosphatase in the rhizosphere soil, the
p-nitrophenyl phosphate was used as a substrate in a borex-NaOH
(pH 9.4) buffer (Tabatabi and Bremner, 1969). Dry powder of
shoot was used for analyzing total nitrogen (by microkjeldhal
method), phosphorus (by vanado-molybdo phosphoric yellow
colour method), potassium (by flame photometer), calcium and
magnesium (by titrimetry employing disodium salt of EDTA)
after di/tri acid digestion (Jakson, 1967). Estimates of copper,
zinc, manganese and iron were made by using atomic absorption
spectrophotometer (AAS 4141).
Out of the remaining seedlings, 30 healthy plants of each treatment
were transplanted at research field of Department of Fruit Science,
UHF, Solan during January 2009 in rows with 6.0 m inter and
intra row spacing. For this purpose, pits with depth and diameter
of 0.6 m were dug and filled with 30 kg of the same soil mixture
used for the plantlets production added with 100 g endosulfan dust
(4%). The plants were irrigated at fortnightly intervals. Immature
fruits along with few leaves and young branches were removed
during the first season (November-February, 2009). After every
winter season pruning was done for which weak and dead limbs
and basal suckers were removed to give proper shape to plants.
Pruning is encouraged for the growth of new spurs in each season
and it helps the plant to sustain more fruit weight (Panwar et al.,
1994). Pruned material (weak and dead shoot portion along with
leaves) weights were recorded after drying in a hot-air oven to
a constant weight and ground to a fine powder. Plant canopy
was calculated using the formula πr2 in which radius mean was
measured from all the directions of crown. Plant height, canopy,
pruned material and fruit yield were recorded yearly for next 3
years (2009, 20010 and 2011).
Results
Sprouting of pomegranate occurred in 6-9 days in the biofertilizers
inoculated cuttings while it took 8-10 days longer (data not
given) in non-inoculated controls, resulting in a higher number
of branches (Table 1). However, significant differences were not
observed in number of branches between various biofertilizers
used. A significant enhancement (27.4-57.6%) was observed in
leaf area. The increase was maximum in dual inoculated seedlings
with A. chroococcum + G. mosseae followed by A. chroococcum
+ G. fasciculatum. Biofertilizer inoculation enhanced shoot
dry weight by 16-36%. The inoculation effect varied among
treatments with the maximum in dual inoculation treatment and
minimum with control. Inoculation resulted in a significantly
higher total chlorophyll content as well as accumulation of
reducing sugars, total phenols and amino nitrogen in 4 months
old inoculated plants (Table 2). Total chlorophyll was observed
Complementary Copy
130
Influence of biofertilizers on growth, yield, nutrition and rhizosphere microbial activity of pomegranate
AC
Branches
(number plant-1)
4 ± 0.54
Leaf area
(cm2 plant-1)
289.9 ± 0.57
Shoot dry wt.
(g plant-1)
1.63 ± 0.012
GF
9 ± 0.36
241.2 ± 0.67
1.60 ± 0.022
GM
9 ± 0.56
264.4 ± 0.43
1.61 ± 0.097
PSB
9 ± 0.57
261.8 ± 0.22
1.52 ± 0.023
AC+GF
12 ± 0.43
291.3 ± 0.57
1.90 ± 0.066
AC+GM
12 ± 0.58
293.7 ± 0.57
1.92 ± 0.076
AC+PSB
12 ± 0.21
290.1 ± 0.57
1.72 ± 0.034
Control
4 ± 0.34
180.4 ± 0.44
1.39 ± 0.006
Treatments
Table 2. Effect on inoculation with different biofertilizers on chlorophyll
content and various metabolites (mg g-1 fresh weight) in pomegranate
after 4 months
Treatments
AC
Total
Total
Amino
Reducing
chlorophyll
phenols
nitrogen
sugars
5.60 ± 0.017 1.95 ± 0.009 3.06 ± 0.029 3.19 ± 0.45
GF
5.12 ± 0.007 1.90 ± 0.076 3.02 ± 0.045 3.15 ± 0.78
GM
5.45 ± 0.023 1.91 ± 0.064 3.05 ± 0.027 3.17 ± 0.35
PSB
5.10 ± 0.058 1.89 ± 0.029 3.00 ± 0.023 3.14 ± 0.93
AC+GF
6.12 ± 0.078 2.11 ± 0.073 3.54 ± 0.08 3.74 ± 0.018
AC+GM
6.25 ± 0.099 2.14 ± 0.059 3.57 ± 0.45 3.75 ± 0.065
AC+PSB
6.0 ± 0.008 2.08 ± 0.065 3.51 ± 0.78 3.71 ± 0.010
Control
5.05 ± 0.016 1.78 ± 0.064 2.68 ± 0.085 2.85 ± 0.019
AC=A. chroococcum, GF=G. fasciculatum, GM=G. mosseae, PSB=
Phosphate solubilizing bacteria. ± represents standard error of means.
highest in dual inoculated seedlings with A. chroococcum + G.
mosseae followed by A. chroococcum + G. fasciculatum. A
similar trend was found in total phenols, amino nitrogen and
reducing sugars contents.
Four months after inoculation, AM fungi spore population
and percent root colonization by AM fungi was enhanced by
103.57-183.92% and 267.77-444.45%, respectively over the
control (Table 3). Uninoculated control also showed infection by
mycorrhiza which could be attributed to the presence of native
AM fungi in the soil. Dual inoculation resulted in maximum
mycorrhizal root infection. Soil inoculation with biofertilizers
significantly enhanced the activities of dehydrogenase, alkaline
phosphatase and nitrogenase (N2-ase) and hydrolysis of fluorescein
diacetate in rhizosphere soils of pomegranate compared to that of
uninoculated plants (Table 3).
Uptake of various nutrients was significantly higher in plants
upon inoculation with various beneficial microorganisms (Table
4). In general, dual inoculation led to maximum uptake of N, P, K
and micronutrients in pomegranate seedlings. In case of N, dual
inoculation with A. chroococcum + G. mosseae followed by A.
chroococcum + G. fasciculatum treatment and in case of P, dual
inoculation with A. chroococcum + PSB treatments, respectively
recorded higher uptake of nutrients.
K, Cu, Zn, Mn and Fe were found in significantly higher
concentration in dual inoculation treatment with A.
chroococcum + G. mosseae followed by A. chroococcum +
PSB treatments, however, significant variations were noticed
in efficiency of different biofertilizers. Among nitrogen fixers
and AM fungi, A. chroococcum and G. mosseae, respectively,
Table 3. Effect of inoculation with biofertilizers on AM fungal spore density, percent mycorrhizal root colonization, rhizosphere enzyme activity and
hydrolysis of FDA
Percentage root
Dehydrogenase
Nitrogenase (n
Alkaline phosphatase FDA-hydrolysis
Treatments
AM spores
colonization (%)
(p kat g-1 soil)
mol C2H4 h-1)
(n kat100 g-1 soil)
(p kat g-1 soil)
(50 g-1 soil)
AC
236 ± 2.72
72 ± 1.59
8.26 ± 0.023
392 ± 1.19
13.2 ± 0.86
2231 ± 3.18
GF
232 ± 2.57
70 ± 1.35
8.06 ± 0.053
389 ± 1.23
13.6 ± 0.26
2223 ± 3.14
GM
233 ± 2.52
71± 1.29
8.21 ± 0.022
390 ± 1.13
13.5 ± 0.29
2291 ± 3.19
PSB
228 ± 2.72
68 ± 1.45
8.01 ± 0.065
387 ± 1.16
14.9 ± 0.98
2211 ± 3.18
AC+GF
315 ± 6.64
96 ± 2.55
9.15 ± 0.021
410.5 ± 2.37
16.9 ± 0.147
2710 ± 2.39
AC+GM
318 ± 6.56
98 ± 2.79
9.68 ± 0.086
412.5 ± 2.49
16.5 ± 0.145
2772 ± 2.53
AC+PSB
313± 6.69
96 ± 2.32
9.25 ± 0.028
411.5 ± 2.35
16.8 ± 0.167
2715 ± 2.53
Control
112 ± 1.63
18 ± 0.49
6.25 ± 0.078
217 ± 1.78
9.6 ± 0.132
1695 ± 2.68
± represents standard error of means
Table 4. Nutrient uptake (mg plant-1) by pomegranate plants as influenced by inoculation with various biofertilizers after 4 months
Treatments
AC
N
(%)
23.7 ± 0.12(1.39)
P
(%)
3.4 ± 0.12(0.21)
K
Cu
Zn
Mn
(%)
(ppm)
(ppm)
(ppm)
18.1 ± 0.06(1.10) 0.026 ± 0.001(16.5) 0.15 ± 0.02(91.1) 0.26 ± 0.01(157)
Fe
(ppm)
0.22 ± 0.01(135)
GF
22.0 ± 0.06(1.37) 4.83 ± 0.09(0.30) 18.6 ± 0.09(1.16) 0.030 ± 0.001(19.1) 0.14 ± 0.02(91.3) 0.25 ± 0.01(158.4) 0.24 ± 0.01(150)
GM
22.5 ± 0.11(1.38) 5.57 ± 0.12(0.34) 20.3 ± 0.09(1.24) 0.027 ± 0.001(17.4) 0.15 ± 0.02(95.1) 0.26 ± 0.01(160.6) 0.26 ± 0.01(157)
PSB
22.8 ± 0.13(1.38) 3.07 ± 0.12(0.20) 18.6 ± 0.09(1.16) 0.026 ± 0.001(16.5) 0.14 ± 0.02(91.3) 0.26 ± 0.01(157)
0.23 ± 0.01(139)
AC+GF
26.5 ± 0.29(1.42)
6.1 ± 0.19(0.32)
22.4 ± 0.02(1.20) 0.036 ± 0.001(18.6) 0.16 ± 0.01(89.2) 0.28 ± 0.04(156.4) 0.29 ± 0.02(160)
AC+GM
27.0 ± 0.29(1.43)
6.4 ± 0.15(0.34)
22.8 ± 0.06(1.21) 0.037 ± 0.001(19.6) 0.17 ± 0.01(90.3) 0.29 ± 0.02(158.6) 0.30 ± 0.02(161)
AC+PSB
26.5 ± 0.29(1.42)
7.4 ± 0.15(0.36)
22.6± 0.54(1.21) 0.036 ± 0.001(18.6) 0.16 ± 0.01(89.2) 0.29 ± 0.02(156.2) 0.31 ± 0.01(164)
Control
18.9 ± 0.23(1.36)
2.5 ± 0.09(0.18)
13.2 ± 0.18(0.95) 0.022 ± 0.001(16.3) 0.12 ± 0.01(86.9) 0.21 ± 0.02(152.4) 0.15 ± 0.02(106)
± represents standard error of means.
Complementary Copy
Table 1. Effect of inoculation with different biofertilizers on growth of
pomegranate after 4 months
131
Influence of biofertilizers on growth, yield, nutrition and rhizosphere microbial activity of pomegranate
were found to enhance maximum uptake of aforesaid nutrients
as compared to control.
The results of field study revealed that inoculated plants resulted
in a significant enhancement in plant height and fruit yield
(Fig. 1) with a maximum increase in dual inoculation with A.
chroococcum + G. mosseae treatment. Enhanced plant height,
canopy, pruned plant material and fruit yield were recorded in
first year (2008-2009) and almost similar trend was observed
afterwards (2009-2011). Further appraisal of field study data
indicates that A. chroococcum + G. mosseae enhanced all field
study parameters among N2-fixing bacteria and AM fungi,
respectively.
Plant height
Fruit yield
Fig.1. Effect of inoculation with various biofertilizers on plant height
and fruit yield of pomegranate grown in field conditions. AC=A.
chroococcum, GF=G. fasciculatum, GM=G. mosseae, PSB= Phosphate
solubilizing bacteria, Cont=Control
Discussion
During the present study, sprouting of pomegranate occurred in
7-10 days in the biofertilizers inoculated cuttings while it took
8-10 days longer (data not given) in non-inoculated controls. It
may be due to the action of plant growth regulators mainly indole
butyric acid secreted by both nitrogen fixers and AM fungi (Luis
et al., 2003). Occurrence of maximum branching and enhanced
rooting in 2-year-old trifoliate orange (Poncirus trifoliate L.)
cutting with AM fungi inoculation (Yao et al., 2009) has also
been reported. Increased leaf area and shoot dry weight upon
inoculation were observed in this study. Similar observations
of enhanced leaf area and shoot dry weight have been made in
different fruit plants upon inoculation with AM fungi (Khanezadeh
et al., 1995), PSB (Karlidag et al., 2007) and Azotobacter + G.
fasciculatum (Sharma et al., 2008). During the present study it
was observed that dual inoculation with A. chroococcum + G.
mosseae had resulted in a higher biomass production compared
to that of uninoculated or single inoculation treatment. Sharma et
al. (2009) reported that root inoculation of citrus seedlings with
AM fungi and A. chroococcum could produce large and better
plants. The higher vegetative growth (seedling’s height, diameter
and leaf area) of AMF treated plants might be due to the growth
promoting effect of fungus and Azotobacter that improved P
and N availability and thereby causing higher protein synthesis
resulting in improved morphological growth. A significantly
higher total chlorophyll content as well as higher accumulation
of various metabolites (reducing sugar, total phenol and amino
nitrogen) might have resulted from enhanced plant growth and
biomass production (Kohler et al., 2007). These observations are
in conformity with those from Aseri et al. (2008) who reported
higher chlorophyll content and photosynthesis in pomegranate
upon inoculation with N2-fixing bacteria. Mathur and Vyas (2000)
reported enhanced synthesis of reducing sugars, free amino acids,
soluble protein and chlorophyll in Ziziphus mauritiana seedlings
upon inoculation with AM fungi.
The increase observed in dehydrogenase, alkaline phosphatase,
nitrogenase and hydrolysis of fluorescein diacetate may be
mainly due to increase in the rhizosphere microbial population
as a consequence of the inoculation treatments (Skujins, 1973)
and (Aseri et al., 2008]). The enhanced phosphatase activity
may help the plant to mobilize P and thereby increase the
biomass production (Tarafdar and Gharu, 2006). A significant
enhancement in total nitrogen-fixing potential as reflected by
increased nitrogenase activity in rhizosphere soils was observed.
The measurement of these enzymatic activities can provide an
early indication of changes in soil fertility, since they are related
to mineralization of important nutrient elements as N, P and C
(Ceccanti et al., 1994).
The degree of root colonization and sporulation in rhizosphere
soils varied significantly among different treatments. The degree
of mycorrhizal colonization and sporulation was higher in dual
inoculation with A. chroococcum + G. mosseae as compared
to single inoculation treatment. This suggests that plant growth
promoting rhizobacteria act as a helping tool for AM fungi
for better establishment and functioning of symbiosis (Kohler
et al., 2007). Inoculation of soil with Azotobacter increased
microflora population whereas; addition of AM fungi inoculum
had synergistic effect on Azotobacter. The synergistic host
response could mainly be due to the production of phytohormones
or growth regulators produced by these microbes. It has been
reported that spores of AM fungi seems to give Azotobacter an
operational base in the vicinity of roots and supply of carbon
that increases the efficiency of both AM fungi and Azotobacter
(Saxena and Tilak, 1994). There was a good agreement between
AM fungal spore density and percent root colonization.
Higher uptake of nutrients was due to the synergistic effect
of improved biomass and higher nutrient concentration in the
inoculated plants (Table 4). Maximum N and P uptake was
observed in dual inoculation treatment which may be due to
the improved symbiotic N2 fixation as well as due to improved
phosphatase activity and thereby P mobilization and subsequent P
uptake by mycorrhizal hyphae. These results confirmed the earlier
findings of Singh and Sharma (1993) who reported enhanced
N and P concentration in sweet orange when inoculated with
biofertilizers.
Inoculated seedlings were found to contain significantly higher
amount of other nutrients viz., K, Ca, Mg, Cu, Fe, Zn and Mn
mainly in dual inoculation treatment. This could be attributed
to the N-fixation ability of Azotobacter, better P mobilization
and enhanced uptake of micro-nutrients due to AM fungi
application.
Because of enhanced accumulation of various metabolites,
increased rhizosphere activity and higher nutrient uptake,
transplanted pomegranate grew significantly better in field
conditions and growth trend were almost the same between all the
Complementary Copy
132
treatments as found during nursery period. Similar observations of
increased plant growth and fruit production under field conditions
were made in banana and tomato by Jeeva et al. (1988) and Kohler
et al. (2007), respectively.
The present study represents the positive response of biofertilizers
in nursery seedlings followed by their transplanting in rainfed
conditions. In conclusion our results showed that biofertilizers
technology play a vital role in helping pomegranate to establish
rainfed soils. The pre-inoculation of nursery seedlings with
selected N2-fixing bacteria, phosphate solubilizing bacteria or
AM fungi or combination of synergistically interacting species
may be helpful in producing vigorous plants to survive and thrive
under rainfed conditions.
References
Arnon, D.I. 1949. Copper enzymes in isolated chloroplast: polyphenol
oxidase in Beta vulgaris. Plant Physiol., 24: 1-15.
Aseri, G.K., Neelam Jain, Jitendra Panwar, A.V. Rao and P.R.
Meghwal, 2008. Biofertilizers improve plant growth, fruit yield,
nutrition, metabolism and rhizosphere enzyme activities of
pomegranate (Punica granatum L.) in Indian Thar Desert. Scientia
Horticulturae,117: 130-135.
Ceccanti, B., B. Pezzarossa, F.J. Gallardo-Lancho and G. Masciandaro,
1994. Bio-tests as markers of soil utilization and fertility,
Geomicrobiol. J., 11: 309-316.
Day, J.M. and J. Dobereiner, 1976. Physiological aspects of N2-fixation
by a Spirillum from Digitaria roots. Soil Biol. Biochem., 8: 45-50.
Ephraim, P.L. and A.N. Robert, 2007. Punica granatum (Pomegranate)
and its potential for prevention and treatment of inflammation and
cancer. J. Ethanopharm., 109: 177-206.
Gaur, A. and A. Adholeya, 1994. Estimation of VAMF spores in soil: a
modified method. Mycorrhiza News, 6: 10-11.
Gerdemann, J.W. and T.H. Nicolson, 1963. Spores of mycorrhizal
Endogone species extracted from soil by wet sieving and decanting.
Trans. Br. Mycol. Soc., 46: 235-244.
Jakson, M.L. 1967. Soil Chemical Analysis. Prentice-Hall of India Private
Limited, New Delhi.
Jeeva, S., M., Kulasekaran, K.G. Shanmugavelu and G. Oblisami, 1988.
Effect of Azospirillum on growth and development of banana cv.
poovan (AAB). South Indian Hort., 36: 1-4.
Jensen, H.L. 1954. The Azotobacteriace. Bact. Rev., 18: 195-214.
Karlidaga, H., Ahmet Esitkenb, Metin Turanc and Fikrettin Sahind, 2007.
Effects of root inoculation of plant growth promoting rhizobacteria
(PGPR) on yield, growth and nutrient element contents of leaves of
apple. Scientia Horticulturae, 114(1): 16-20.
Khanizadeh, S., C. Hamel, H. Kianmehr, D. Buszard and D.L. Smith,
1995. Effect of three arbuscular mycorrhizal fungus species and
phosphorus on productivity and vegetative growth of three strawberry
cultivars. J. Plant Nutr., 18: 1073-1079.
Kohler, J., F. Caravaca, L. Carrasco and A. Rolden, 2007. Interactions
between a plant growth-promoting rhizobacterium, an AM fungus
and phosphate-solublizing fungus in the rhizosphere of Lactuca
sativa. Appl. Soil Ecol., 35: 480-487.
Luis, J., M. Martinez, S.U. Lucia, E.B. Beatriz, A. Jose and A. Sanchez,
2003. Indole 3-butyric acid (IBA) production in culture medium by
wild strain Azospirillum brasilense, FEMS Microbiol. Lett., 228:
167-173.
Mahadeven, A., J. Kui and E. George, 1965. Biochemistry of resistance
in cucumber against Cladosporium cucumerinum in presence of
pectinase inhibitor in white clover. Plant Soil, 136: 49-57.
133
Mathur, N. and A. Vyas, 2000. Influence of arbuscular mycorrhizae on
biomass production, nutrient uptake and physiological changes in
Ziziphus mauritiana Lam. under water stress. J. Arid Environ., 45:
191-195.
Michel, D.S., E.R.N. Melanie, W. Gerdi, J.D. Jennifer, H.C. Mailine, M.
Ruth, J. Caren, R.N. Raisin and O. Dean, 2005. Effect of pomegranate
juice consumption on mycocardial perfusion in patient with coronary
heart disease. Am. J. Cardiol., 96: 810-814.
Panwar, J. and J.C. Tarafdar, 2006. Distribution of three endangered
medicinal plant species and their colonization with arbuscular
mycorrhizal fungi. J. Arid Environ., 65, 337-350.
Panwar, S.K., U.T. Desai and S.N. Choudhary, 1994. Effect of pruning
and thinning on growth, yield and quality of pomegranate. Ann.
Arid Zone., 33: 45-47.
Rao, A.V. and B. Venkateswarlu, 1982. Nitrogen fixation by Azospirillum
isolated from tropical grasses native to Indian Desert. Indian J. Exp.
Biol., 20: 316-318.
Read, D.J., N.K. Kouckeki and J. Hodgson, 1976. Vesicular arbuscular
mycorrhizae in natural vegetative system. The occurrence of
infection. New Phytol., 77: 641-653.
Saxena, A.K. and K.V.B.R. Tilak, 1994. Interaction among beneficial soil
microorganisms. Indian Journal of Microbiology, 34(2): 91-103.
Schenck, N.C. and Y. Perez, 1990. Manual for the Identification of VA
Mycorrhizal Fungi. 3rd ed., Synergistic Publications, Gainesville,
Florida, USA.
Schnurer, J. and T. Rosswall, 1982. Fluorescein di-acetate hydrolysis as
a measure of total microbial activity in soil and litter. Appl. Environ.
Microbiol., 43: 1256-1261.
Sharma, S.D., P. Kumar, S.K. Singh and V.B. Patel, 2009. Indigenous
AM fungi and Azotobacter, and their screening from citrus seedlings
at different levels of of inorganic fertilizers application. Indian
Journal of Horticulture, 66(2): 183-89.
Sharma, S.D., N. Sharma, C.L. Sharma, R. Sood and R.P. Singh, 2008.
Studies on correlation between endomycorrhizal and Azotobacter
population with growth, yield and soil nutrient status of apple (Malus
domestica Borkh) orchards in Himachal Pradesh. Acta Horticulturae,
696: 283-87.
Singh, C. and B.B. Sharma, 1993. Leaf nutrient composition of sweet
orange as affected by combined use of bio and chemical fertilizers.
South Indian Hort., 41: 131-134.
Skujins, J. 1973. Dehydrogenase: an indicator of biological activities
in arid soils. Bull. Ecol. Res. Commun., 17: 235-241.
Tabatabai, M.A. and J.M. Bremner, 1969. Use of P-nitrophenyl phosphate
for assay of soil phosphatase activity. Soil Biol. Biochem., 1: 301307.
Tabatabai, M.A. 1982. Soil enzymes. In: Methods of Soil Analysis. Part
2. Chemical and Microbiological Properties. Page, A.L., Miller,
R.H., Keeney, D.R. (Eds.), Amer. Soc. Agron., 903-947.
Tarafdar, J.C. and A. Gharu, 2006. Mobilization of organic and poorly
soluble phosphates by Chaetomium globosum. Appl. Soil Ecol., 32:
273-283.
Tiwary, D.K., M.A. Hasan and P.K. Chattopadhyay, 1999. Leaf nutrient
and chlorophyll content in banana (Musa AAA) under the influence
of Azotobacter and Azospirillum inoculation. Environ. Ecol., 17:
346-350.
Yao, Q., L.R. Wang., H.H. Zhu and J.Z. Chen, 2009. Effect of arbuscular
mycorrhizal fungi infection on root system architecture of trifoliate
orange (Poncirus trifoliate L. Raf.) seedlings. Scientia Horticulturae,
121: 458-61.
Received: February, 2012; Revised: July, 2012; Accepted: October, 2012
Complementary Copy
Influence of biofertilizers on growth, yield, nutrition and rhizosphere microbial activity of pomegranate
Journal
Journal of Applied Horticulture, 14(2): 134-138, 2012
Appl
Re sist a nc e eva luat ion of t he pist a chio root st ock s t o
M e loidogyne spe c ie s in I ra n
M e hrda d M a da ni 1 * , Ahm a d Ak hia ni 2 , M a hm oud Da m a dza de h 2 a nd Ahm a d K he iri 3
1
University of Tarbiat Modares, College of Agriculture, Plant Pathology Department, Tehran, Iran. Present address: University of Manitoba, Soil Science Department, Winnipeg, MB, Canada. 2Plant Pest and Disease Research Institute. Ministry
of Agriculture and Jahad, Esfahan, Iran, 3University of Tehran, College of Agriculture, Plant pathology department, Karaj,
Iran. *E-mail:
[email protected].
Abstract
Pistachio (Pistacia vera) is a edible nut native to Iran, the country that ranks first in worldwide pistachio production. Root-knot
nematodes (RKN), Meloidogyne species, are among the most important pathogens that restrict the cultivation of pistachio in Iran. The
objective of this study was to evaluate resistance of native pistachio rootstocks for resistance to isolates of M. incognita. Greenhouse
experiment was conducted to determine the reaction of eleven cultivars of P. vera and six accessions of wild pistachio viz P. mutica,
P. khinjuk, P. terebintus, P. atlantica, P. atlantica sub sp mutica and P. atlantica sub sp cabilica, against five selected populations of
RKN. Meloidogyne incognita and M. javanica were identified based on the morphological characters, and esterase isozyme phenotype.
Resistance was characterized based on root gall and egg mass indices and nematode reproduction. Resistance to M. incognita was
detected among the cultivars and wild accessions of pistachio. There was a significant interaction among nematode populations and
host genotypes, suggesting the presence of virulent pathotypes among the M. incognita isolates. These data suggest that it will be
possible to development cultivars with resistance as a means of suppressing damage to pistachio that is caused by RKN.
Introduction
Pistachio originated from central part of the Middle East located
in North Eastern part of the Iran. The pistachio tree (Pistacia vera
L.) is heterozygous, deciduous, dioucious with separate male
and female plants and is cross-pollinated. Iran is the leading
producer of pistachio nuts with more than 252,790 hectares under
cultivation with an annual production of 190,000 metric tons. The
main areas of pistachio cultivation are located in central Iran in
the provinces of Kerman and Esfahan; however, the provinces
of Yazd, Semnan and Ghazvin also produce pistachio. The wild
species P. khinjuk and P. mutica are found in mountainous regions
of the country especially in the west and south.
Root-knot nematodes (RKN) Meloidogyne (Nematoda:
Heteroderidae), including M. incognita and M. javanica are the
most destructive plant-parasitic nematodes found throughout subtropical, tropical and temperate regions of the world. Pistachio
vera is the principal rootstock used and is susceptible to both of
these species. Estimated production losses in pistachio worldwide
caused by Meloidogyne species is US $118 million (Koenning
et al., 1994). In Iran, M. incognita and M. javanicva has been
reported attacking pistachio roots (Abivardi et al., 1979; Akhiani
et al., 1986; Banihashemi and Kheiri, 1995; Kargar, 1989,
Mojtahedi and Barooti, 1976; Madani et al., 1988). These species
were also reported from pistachio roots in California (McKenry
and Kretsch, 1984).
Although several reports indicate wide presence of RKN in
pistachio orchards in Iran and the occurrence of M. incognita
and M. javanica, there is no systematic study on damage caused
by RKN and/or resistance/susceptibility of pistachio cultivars
and species in Iran. Therefore, the objective of this study was to
screen diffierent pistachio cultivars including P. vera and wild
relative accessions against Meloidogyne spp.
Materials and methods
The experiments were carried out at the Plant Pest and Disease
Institute of Ministry of Agriculture, Esfahan, Iran. Test for
identification of nematodes were performed at the Plant Research
International, Wageningen, The Netherlands. A survey was
conducted in the main cultivation areas of pistachio in Iran to
collect pistachio seeds and nematode isolates. Infested trees were
easily identified based on stunted growth habit with moderate to
severely necrotic and chlorotic leaves. Thirteen seed samples from
different cultivars of P. vera and 16 samples of wild species were
collected from trees or provided by local growers. Additionally,
three samples of wild pistachio seeds previously identified as
P. atlantica, P. terebintus and P. sp. were received from Dr.
Sh. Dehghani, University of Adelaide, Australia). A sample of
wild species collected from Hormozgan province were kindly
provided by Dr. Z. Banihashemi, Shiraz University, Shiraz, Iran.
Sampling location and information on host plants are presented
in Table 1. Collected seeds were kept in paper bags, placed in a
cool dry container and transferred to the laboratory where they
were maintained at 4°C until use. Nematode isolates were isolated
from 30 soil and root samples collected from naturally infested
pistachio orchards from different locations in Iran (Table 2). Two
or three sub-samples were collected from different parts of each
orchard, and mixed together to make a composite sample of about
1 kg containing feeder roots with rhizosphere and bulk soil from a
depth of 50-70 cm. One composite sample was taken from each
Complementary Copy
Key words: Pistachio vera, root knot nematodes, gall index, eggmass index, cultivar
Resistance evaluation of the Pistachio rootstocks to Meloidogyne species in Iran
No. Code
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
Pv-Mes
Pv-Jan
Pv-Fa-Kh
Pv-Bo1
Pv-Bo2
Pv-Bad-Ra
Pv-Fa-Ra
Pv-Kh-Ra
Pv-Sar
Pv-Ard
Pv-DM
Pv-Kh-Dam
Pv-Gh
Pw-Kh-sem
Pw-Mu-sem
Pw-Kh-Bam
Pw-Mu-Bam
Pw-Kh-Jir
Pw-At-Jir
Seed source
(Province- location)
Esfahan-Mesr
Esfahan-Jandagh
Esfahan-Khor Va Biabanak
Esfahan-Borkhar
Esfahan-Borkhar
Kerman-Rafsanjan
Kerman-Rafsanjan
Kerman-Rafsanjan
Khorasan-Sarakhs
Yazd-Ardekan
Semnan-Damghan
Semnan-Damghan
Ghazvin
Esfahan-Semirom
Esfahan-Semirom
Kerman-Bam
Kerman-Bam
Kerman-Jiroft
Kerman-Jiroft
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Pw-Kh-Sar
Pw-Mu-Sar
Pw-Mu-Mar
Pw-Mu-Mok
Pw-Mu-Ghir
Pw-Mu-Siv
Pw-Mu-Khan
Pw-Mu-Koh
Pw-At-Cab
Khorasan-Sarakhs
Khorasan-Sarakhs
Fars-Marvdasht
Fars-Mok va kavar
Fars-Ghir
Fars-Sivand
Fars-Khanemein
Fars-Kohanjan
Hormozgan-Geno
29
30
31
32
33
Pw-Mu-Ker
Pw-Mu-Koh
Pw-Ter-Aus2
Pw-At-Aus3
Pw-sp
Kermanshah
Kohkiloieh
Australia
Australia
Australia
Species / cultivar
P. vera-Mesri
P. vera-Jandaghi
P. vera-Fandoghi-Khor
P. vera-Borkhar
P. vera-Borkhar
P. vera-Badami
P. vera-Fandoghi
P. vera-Khanjari
P. vera-Sarakhs
P. vera-Ardekani
P. vera-Mamoli
P. vera-Khanjari
P. vera-Ghazvini
P. khinjuk
P. mutica
P. khinjuk
P. mutica
P. khinjuk
P. atlantica sub sp
mutica
P. khinjuk
P. mutica
P. mutica
P. mutica
P. mutica
P. mutica
P. mutica
P. mutica
P. atlantica sub sp
cabulica
P. mutica
P. mutica
P. terebinhtus
P. atlantica
Pistachio sp
orchard and placed in a plastic bag and transported to laboratory
in cooler box at 7-12°C. For locations where no distinct gall
symptoms were observed on pistachio roots, an extra soil samples
were collected from weeds infected with RKN close to trees. No
soil sample was collected from wild Pistachio spp.
Collected seeds were surface sterilized with 1% NaOCl solution
for 5 minutes followed by soaking overnight in sterilized
water. Seeds of P. vera cultivars were then placed between two
layers of wet cotton tissue in a plastic tray and kept at 23-28°C
until germination. To prevent contamination with common
saprophytic fungi, seeds were sprayed with solution of 0.002%
pentachloronitrobenzene (PCNB) fungicide every two days
during the incubation period. After one week, germinated seeds
were transferred to plastic containers (20×25×10 cm), filled with
a sterilized mixture of sand, Perlite and peat moss (50:25:50
v/v) and then covered with 1 cm layer of sand. Containers were
then kept in a greenhouse at 25-27°C until seedlings emerged.
Seedlings with two leaves were then transplanted to a steam
pasteurized clay pot (15×25 cm) containing approximately 500
cm 3 of sterilized river sand, vermiculate and peat moss (50:25:25
v/v). Pots were kept in a greenhouse with temperature ranging
from 22 to 28 °C and 65-85% relative humidity, for a week, and
then inoculated with nematodes.
Seeds of wild species were dormant, therefore, they were soaked
overnight in water and green coat was removed. Seeds were
then transferred to plastic container filled with sterile river sand,
wrapped container with aluminum sheets and maintained at 4°C
for 30 to 40 days until germination. Each germinated seed with
two leaves were then transplanted to a clay pots and kept at
greenhouse under conditions described above. As an alternative,
a method based on H2SO4 treatment was also tested to overcome
the seed dormancy. For this, seeds were subjected to a solution of
1% acid for 1-2 minutes, rinsed with water and then planted.
To obtain pure populations of nematodes, a single egg mass from
each sample was collected and used to inoculate a susceptible
tomato (Lycopersicum esculantum Mill. cv. Rutgers) seedling.
Several egg masses from pistachio roots were used separately for
inoculation of tomato seedlings at 2-4 leaf stage. For pistachio
root samples, where it was difficult to find an egg mass, tomato
seedlings were planted in collected soil and/or an egg mass
was picked from the roots of weeds. Inoculated tomatoes were
maintained in a greenhouse, separated from each other by plastic
sheets to prevent any cross contamination of the nematode
species. After 55 days tomato plants were harvested, soil washed
from the roots and several egg masses and female nematodes were
collected for species identification.
Perineal pattern from at least 20 mature females were prepared
using lactic acid, mounted in glycerin (Brito et al., 2004) and
examined for identification of species of each RKN isolate. Based
on preliminary species identification, four isolates identified as
M. incognita from the main geographical region of pistachio
production including (Kerman, Davaran (RD), Esfahan, Khor Va
Biabanak (KH) and Kashan, (K and P) and one M. javanica isolate
(MJ) from the province of the Yazd (Ardekan). Only M. incognita
isolates were selected for subsequent experiments. Further
confirmation of species was performed on these isolates using
esterase and malate dehydrogenase protein isoelectrophoresis
(IEF) of white female (Karssen et al., 1995), electron microscopy
examination of perineal pattern and J2 morphology and
morphometric characters (Courtney et al., 1995).
Populations of the selected isolates of M. incognita population
collected from Kashan, race 2, (Mi-K), Kashan race 4 (Mi-P),
Khor Va Biabanak, Esfahan, (Mi-KH), and Rafsanja, Davaran
(Mi-RD) and M. pistachio from Ardekan, Yazd (MJ) were raised
from single egg masses and propagated on tomato seedlings for
two generations. Inocula were prepared by macerating infected
roots using a blender. Eggs and J2 were collected on a 25-μm pore
sieve and gently rinsed with sterilized water into a 250-mL glass
beaker. Three 1-mL samples were taken with a pipette to estimate
numbers of eggs and J2 under a stereomicroscope.
Eleven cultivars of P. vera and six accessions of wild Pistachio
spp. were selected for evaluation of resistance to these isolates.
Seedling pots were arranged in a randomized complete block
design with four replications of each plant genotype and nematode
isolate combination. P. vera seedlings were at the 4-6 leaf stage
of development and wild accessions were 3-month-old seedlings
when inoculation was done. Each seedling was inoculated with
1x104 eggs and J2 of nematode isolate. Control plants were
inoculated with water and maintained in a greenhouse. Pots
were watered every three days and fertilized weekly with a 0.5%
Hoagland solution for 135 days.
Complementary Copy
Table 1. Origin, species and location of pistachio seeds used
135
136
Resistance evaluation of the Pistachio rootstocks to Meloidogyne species in Iran
population, soil from each pot was
transferred onto a tray, mixed and
Species
Species identification
a sub sample of 250 cm3 taken for
Perineqal pattern, J2
M. incognita
nematodes extraction by elutriation and
Peineal pattern, J2
M. incognita
centrifuge (Lo´pez-Pe´rez et al., 2005).
M. incognita
Peineal pattern, J2-IEF* The host reaction was determined as
resistant (GI ≤ 2, RF <1), tolerant (GI
Peineal pattern, J2
M. incognita
≤ 2, RF >1), hyper-susceptible (GI ≥
M. sp (un identified) Peineal pattern, J2
2, RF <1), and susceptible (GI > 2, RF
Peineal pattern, J2
M. incognita
>1) (Canto-Saenz, 1987). Rootstock
reaction was interpreted either based
Peineal pattern, J2
M. incognita
on GI and EI (Taylor and Sasser, 1978),
Peineal pattern, J2
M. incognita
or using index of R (Trudgill, 1991).
Table 2. Nematode sampling location, host and test applied to identify Meloidogyne population used
Host
1
Esfahan-Ardestan
P. vera
2
Esfahan-Natanz
P. vera
3
Esfahan-Khor va Biabanak
P. vera
4
Esfahan-Khoram dasht-1
P. vera
5
Esfahan- Khoram dasht-2
P. vera
6
Esfahan-Chopanan
P. vera
7
Esfahan-Mazrae Nemoneh
P. vera
8
Esfahan-Alah Abad
P. vera
9
Esfahan-Amir Abad
P. vera
M. incognita
Peineal pattern, J2
10
Esfahan-Mesr
P. vera, Cabbage M. incognita
Peineal pattern, J2
11
Esfahan-Frah zad
P. vera, Cabbage M. incognita
Peineal pattern, J2
12
Esfahan-Jandagh
P. vera, weeds
M. incognita
Peineal pattern, J2
13
Esfahan-Arosan
P. vera
M. incognita
Peineal pattern, J2
14
Esfahan-Golestan
P. vera
M. incognita
Peineal pattern, J2
15
Esfahan-Neishabor
P. vera
M. incognita
Peineal pattern, J2
16
Esfahan-Kashan-Sabahi
P. vera
M. incognita
Peineal pattern, J2-IEF
17
Esfahan-Kashan-Kaghazi
P. vera
M. incognita
Peineal pattern, J2-IEF
18
Esfahan-Kashan-Ghale gosheh P. vera
M. incognita
Peineal pattern, J2
19
Yazd-Ardekan
P. vera
M. javanica
Peineal pattern, J2-IEF
Peineal pattern, J2
20
Kerman-Zarand
P. vera
M. incognita
21
Kerman-Zarand
P. vera
M. sp (un identified) Peineal pattern, J2
22
Kerman-Anar
P. vera
M. incognita
Data analysis: Data on gall and egg
mass numbers (GN and EN) per root
system were subjected to analysis of
variance using SAS, version 7.1. Mean
comparison of data were performed
and significance differences in
means of nematode reproduction
were separated using Duncan’s test
with significant differences at 5%
probability and differences among
treatments were determined for each
nematode population by cultivar.
Results
A total of 36 indigenous P. vera and
16 wild accessions were collected
during the survey, from which 11
Peineal pattern, J2
P. vera
M. incognita
23 Kerman-Rafsanjan
cultivars and six wild accessions were
Peineal pattern, J2
P. vera
M. incognita
24 Kerman-Heidar abad
selected for resistance assessment
Peineal pattern, J2
P. vera
M. incognita
25 Kerman-Heidar abad
(Table 1). Preliminary identification
of RKN from soil samples revealed
P. vera
M. incognita
Peineal pattern-IEF
26 Kerman-Davaran
the presence of two species, M.
Peineal pattern, J2
P. vera
M. javanica
27 Kerman-Davaran
incognita and M. pistachio in 27
Peineal pattern, J2
P. vera
Meloidogyne (un
28 Kerman-Davaran
of sampling locations (Table 2).
Peineal pattern, J2 , J2
P. vera
M. incognita
29 Kerman-Naserieh
Meloidogyne incognita was identified
in 25 sampling areas from either
Kerman-Naserieh
Peineal
pattern,
J2
P.
vera
M.
incognita
30
pistachio roots or weeds, whereas
Species in bold were used for the final experiment on resistance test. *IEF: Isoelctrofocusing
M. javanica was identified from the
pistachio roots in two locations from Yazd province (Ardekan)
After harvest, the roots were gently washed with tap water, and
and Kerman province (Davaran). Three populations collected
placed in beakers containing approximately 400 mL of 0.05 %
from pistachio roots, one from province of Esfahan (Khoramdasht
Phloxin B solution for 10 to 15 min to stain the egg masses a
2), and two from province of Kerman (Zarand and Davaran),
bright red color. Each root system was scored for nematode galls
could not be identified to species level due their unusual perineal
(gall index=GI) based on 0 to 5 scale where 0= no gall, 1=1 to
pattern
morphology. Esterase and malate dehydrogenase IEF
2, 2=3 to 10, 3=11 to 30, 4=31 to 100 and 5= >100 galls (Safdar
protein profile, electron microscopy of perineal pattern, J2
and McKenry, 2007). The length and weight of each root and
morphology and morphometric obtained for the selected isolates
stem were measured.
of M. incognita (Mi-K, Mi-P, Mi-KH, Mi-RD) and M. javanica
The reproduction factor (RF) was quantified based on R=Pf/Pi,
(MJ), were in agreement with published data (Karssen et al.,
where Pf and Pi were final and initial population densities,
1995) and confirmed the identity of these isolates.
respectively (Zhou and Starr, 2003). For calculation of Pf, the
In the greenhouse screening test, egg mass number per seedling
J2 per root system was estimated by macerating the roots using
ranged from 1 to 167 for P. vera cultivars inoculated with M.
a blender with 1% NaOCl solution. Because eggs viability was
incognita (Table 3). The mean number of eggs masses across
not a concern the higher concentration of 1% NaOCl was used to
increase the extraction efficiency (Zhou et al., 2000). Released
all pistachio cultivars for the four isolates of M. incognita ranged
eggs and J2 were collected on a 25-μm pore sieve and then
from 41.4 to 61.4, whereas the means across all four nematode
counted under a stereomicroscope. To quantify the soil nematode
isolates for the cultivars ranged from 11 to 114.7. For the egg
Peineal pattern, J2
Complementary Copy
No. Province-Location
Resistance evaluation of the Pistachio rootstocks to Meloidogyne species in Iran
Mi-Kh
Mi-RD
Mi-K
Mi-P
Table 4. Root gall production by four isolates of M. incognita on eleven
cultivars of pistachio in a greenhouse test. Abbreviation for pistachio
cultivar are given in table 1. Cultivars with the same letter not differ
significantly (P <0.05)
Mean
Mi - Kh
Mi-RD
Mi-K
Mi-P
Mean
Kh-Ra
28.0
4.0
1.0
3.3
11a
Kh-Ra
147.5
30.8
39.0
21.3
59.7c
Bad-Ra
139.7
65.5
24.3
12.5
60.5d
Bad-Ra
281.5
170.7
69.0
22.8
136.0ab
Ard
29.3
18.5
37.7
21.3
26.7b
Ard
51.7
67.5
75.7
48.7
60.9c
Gh
7.3
7.0
4.0
52.5
17.7a
Gh
15.8
29.5
10.0
58.3
28.4d
Bo1
54.0
57.7
21.7
25.0
39.6bc
Bo1
82.6
89.8
72.7
56.5
75.4bc
Dam-Mam
15.3
16.7
15.0
72.0
29.8b
Dam-Mam
47.0
47.0
21.0
93.5
52.1c
Fa-Ra
10.5
68.5
73.5
20.7
43.3c
Fa-Ra
190.0
147.3
88.0
55.0
120.1b
Bo2
30.3
50.5
72.3
28.0
45.3c
Bo2
71.7
143.0
85.5
58.0
89.6c
Sar
28.5
9.5
15.3
39.3
23.2b
Sar
69.3
34.7
18.5
42.5
41.3d
Fa-Kh
54.0
58.7
68.0
33.8
53.6c
Fa-Kh
130.0
98.5
167.0
63.3
114.7e
61.4a
42.3c
Kh-Dam
Mean
47.9a
41.4a
45.4a
mass production in P. vera cultivars, there was no significant
differences among isolates across the cultivars; however, a
significant difference in mean value of egg mass number was
observed by cultivar among the four nematode isolates (Table
3). Two-way analysis of variance for the gall number also
revealed significant differences in gall production among cultivars
across all nematode isolates. Differences were observed in gall
production among nematode. Nematodes isolate of Mi-K and
Mi-P both collected from Kashan province were significantly
different in gall production and separated from the rest of
populations (Table 4).
Analysis of data from the wild accessions showed there were
no significant differences among nematodes isolates across
the accessions for either gall and egg mass production (Table
5). Mean value of gall number in Pw-Te-Aus3 and Pw-AtCab accessions showed significant differences with the rest of
accession. Mean value of egg mass number in Pw-At-Mu and
Pw-At-Aus2 accession showed significant difference compared
to other accessions for production of egg mass.
Discussion
The main aim of the present study was to identifying possible
source of resistance through screening of cultivated pistachio root
stocks and wild accession. During the survey and based on our
observation and results of the experiments, RKNs obviously are
among the most important pistachio root disease in Iran which
51.5
113.7
80.0
117.0
Kh-Dam
187.5
148.7
237.5
89.3
Mean
108.7a
93.0b
72.4abc
60.3c
90.6bc
165.8a
83.6ab
can restrict planting of pistachio, especially in loamy sandy soil.
Although sites with potential infestation of RKN were targeted
in this study, wide distribution of RKN in pistachio orchards,
especially in nurseries, were observed causing damage and
reduction of yield in pistachio trees. M. incognita was identified
in most of the sampling areas and detected in more than 80% of
soil samples. This species was the most prevalent RKNs found
in pistachio orchards. Although M. javanica was identified only
in two locations, it appears to be the second important member
of RKNs in terms of spreading and causing damage in pistachio
orchards. Possible presence of other Meloidogyne species on
pistachio is likely, where an unusual perineal patterns morphology
in three populations collected from pistachio roots in Esfahan
province (Khoramdasht 2), and Kerman province (Zarand and
Davaran) was observed. More study needed to confirm the
identity of these populations.
Usefulness of wild germplasm as source of resistance to plant
parasitic nematodes has been emphasized by other researches
(Yaghoobi, et al., 1995). From this preliminary study it appears
that a wide range of reaction from resistance to highly susceptible
is present in pistachio root stocks against M. incognita. In addition,
identifying the pistachio cultivar used as rootstocks is crucial in
resistance experiments, especially when study of different flora from
Iran and neighbor countries showed the differences in nomenclature
or speciation of pistachio cultivars. In resistance experiments, study
of cultivars and nematodes originated from the same geographic
Table 5. Mean comparison of egg mass (EN) and gall numbers (GN), of six accessions of wild Pistachio species against Meloidogyne incognita in
green house experiment. Data are from four replicates. Abbreviation for pistachio cultivar are given in Table 1. Cultivars with the same letter not
differ significantly (P <0.05)
Cultivar/code
Pw-At-Aus2
Pw-Te-Aus3
Pw-At-Mu
Pw-At-Cab
Pw-Kh1
Pw-Kh2
Mean
Mi-Kh
GN
22.3
7
6.5
7.5
8.3
9.3
10.2a
EN
30.3
1.5
22
2.3
29.8
31.8
19.6a
Mi-RD
GN
EN
27
23.5
7
1.8
5.8
6.3
5.5
8
9.3
28.5
7.3
30.5
10.3a
16.4a
Mi-K
GN
23.5
6.3
6.3
4.5
9
9.8
9.9a
Mi-P
EN
20
1.3
1.5
0.5
45.3
46.5
19.2a
GN
26.8
3
36
7.5
9
9.5
15.3a
Mean
EN
27
3.5
24.5
12
28.5
17.8
20.6a
GN
25.2c
2.0a
13.6b
5.7a
33.0c
34.2c
EN
24.9c
5.8a
13.7b
6.3a
8.9a
9.00a
Complementary Copy
Table 3. Egg mass production by four isolates of M. incognita on eleven
cultivars of pistachio in a greenhouse test. Abbreviation for pistachio
cultivar are given in table 1. Cultivars with the same letter not differ
significantly (P <0.05)
137
Resistance evaluation of the Pistachio rootstocks to Meloidogyne species in Iran
0region is more validated due to co-evolution of the two organisms.
In this study pistachio seeds and nematode samples were collected
from the same location. It is assumed that the root galling is not
more accurate indicator for the stability of RKN resistance (Safdar
and McKenry, 2007; Zhou et al., 2000), therefore, in this study the
virtual number of egg mass were also used for analysis of root stocks
reaction. Nematode population from soil and roots were extracted
and used for study of virulence and pathogenicity of the different
population (data not shown). This provide valuable data for further
study on resistance of pistachio root stocks against RKNs.
In some sampling area severe disease symptoms were observed
on above ground parts of pistachio trees while infestation of RKN
was low and in some areas trees showing mild symptoms had
severely infested roots to nematodes. This was in accordance with
greenhouse experiments where the same phenomenon was observed
in some of the cultivar nematode interaction. This indicates the
presence of varying level of resistance/susceptibility among cultivars
and existence of variation in nematode population in terms of
pathogenicity and virulence. Range of variation was more limited in
wild accession compare to the domestic pistachio cultivars.
For most of the nematode cultivar interaction there was a positive
correlation between gall and eggmass numbers, however it was
observed that some cultivar with high number of galls did not
support nematode reproduction. In addition, less variability
in mean value of eggmass production was observed between
nematode isolates than between cultivars. This shows that
cultivars represent more variability in terms of supporting
nematode reproduction. The same was observed for wild
accession with nematodes isolates. Almost all of the nematode
isolates caused galling and high rate of reproduction on pistachio
cultivars. This is the first report on evaluation of pistachio
cultivars used as root stocks in Iran. This provides preliminary
information on identifying source of resistance. More studies are
needed to understand the host pathogen interaction in orchard and
trial plot. Study of differential interaction of nematode population
will reveal more details on this phenomenon.
Acknowledgements
Authors are thankful to James, L. Starr and C. Abivardi for
reviewing this paper carefully, Z. Banihashemi and Sh. Dehghani
for providing some of the pistachio seeds. This work is dedicated
to Ahmad Akhiani for his major participation in this work, who
passed away while this research was being conducted.
References
Abivardi, C., M. Shahcheraghi and M. Sharafeh, 1979. Recent studies
on distribution and control of the root-knot nematodes Meloidogyne
spp in southern Iran. Proceedings of the 2nd research planning
conference on root-knot nematodes, Meloidogyne spp., Region VII,
Athens, Greece, (International Meloidogyne Project, Contract No.
AID/ta-c-1234)
Akhiani, A., H. Mojtahedi and A. Naderi, 1986. Hosts of the root knot
nematode in Iran. Proc. Plant Pathol., p.134 .
Banihashemi, Z. and A. Kheiri, 1995. The occurrence of root knot
nematode (Meloidogyne javanica) on Pistachio in Damghan. Iranian
J. Plant Pathol., 31: 37-38.
Brito, J., T.O. Powers, P.G. Mullin, R.N. Inserra and D.W. Dickson,
2004. Morphological and molecular characterization of Meloidogyne
mayaguensis isolates from Florida. J. Nematol., 36: 232-240.
Canto-Saenz, M. and B. Brodie, 1987. Comparison of compatible
and incompatible response of potato to Meloidogyne incognita. J.
Nematol., 19: 218-221.
Courtney, W.D., D. Polley and V.L. Miller, 1995. TAF, an improved fixative
in nematode technique. Plant Disease Reporter, 39: 570-571.
Hirchmann, H. 1985. The genus Meloidogyne and morphological
characters differentiating its species. In: An Advanced Treatise on
Meloidogyne, vol. 1. Biology and Control. J.N. Sasser and C.C. Carter
(eds.). Raleigh: North Carolina State University. p. 79-93.
Karssen, G., T. Vanhoenselaar, B. Verkerk-Bakker and R. Janssen,
1995. Species identification of cyst and root-knot nematodes from
potato by electrophoresis of individual females. Electrophoresis,
16: 105-109.
Kargar, A. 1989. Study on nematode fauna in pomegranate, pistachio and
almond orchards in Yazd province. M.Sc. Thesis. Tarbiat Modaress
University. 240 pp.
Koenning, S.R., C.O. Verstreet, J.W. Noling, P.A. Donald, J.O. Becker
and B.A. Fortnum, 1994. Survey of crop losses in response to
phytoparasitic nematodes in the United States for 1999. J. Nematol.,
31: 587-618.
Lo´pez-Pe´rez, J.A., M.L. Strangeb, I. Kaloshian and A.T. Ploeg, 2005.
Differential response of Mi gene-resistant tomato rootstocks to
root-knot nematodes (Meloidogyne incognita). Crop Protection,
25: 382-388
Madani, M., A. Kheiri and A. Akhiani, 1988. Races and species of the
Meloidogyne in Pistachio orchards in Iran. Proc.Plant Protection,
1989, Tehran, Iran, p. 87.
McKenry, M.V. and J.O. Kretsch, 1984. Nematodes in pistachio orchards.
California Agriculture, 38: 21.
Mojtahedi, H. and S. Barooto, 1976. The chemical control of root-knot
nematode in Esfahan. Iranian J. Plant Pathol., 12: 45-46.
Safdar, A.A. and M.V. McKenry, 2007. Variability in reproduction of
four population of Meloidogyne incognita on six cultivars of cotton,
J. Nematol., 39(2): 105-110.
Taylor, A.L. and J.N. Sasser, 1978. Biology, identification and control of
root-knot nematodes (Meloidogyne spp.). Coop. Publ. Department
of plant pathology, Library of Congress catalog card No. 77-94505,
North Carolina State University, Raleigh, N.C.
Trudgill, D.L. 1991. Resistance to and tolerance of plant parasitic
nematodes in plants. Ann. Rev. Phytopatho., 29: 167-192.
Yaghoobi, J., I. Kaloshian., Y. Wen and V.M. Williamson, 1995. Mapping
a new nematode resistance locus in Lycopersicon peruvianum.
Theorotical Applied Genetics, 91: 457-464.
Zhou, E. and J.L. Starr, 2003. A comparison of the damage functions,
root galling, and reproduction of Meloidogyne incognita on resistance
and susceptible cotton cultivars. J. Cotton Sci., 7: 224-230.
Zhou, T., A. Wheeler and J.L. Starr, 2000. Root galling and reproduction
on Meloidogyne incognita isolates from Texas on resistance cotton
genotypes. J. Nematol., 32: 513-518.
Received: March, 2012; Revised: July, 2012; Accepted: October, 2012
Complementary Copy
138
Journal
Appl
Journal of Applied Horticulture, 14(2):139-143, 2012
Biology a nd se a sona l a c t ivit y of se m iloope r, Dic hrom ia orosia
(Cra m e r) (Le pidopt e ra : N oc t uida e ) on a nt hm ool, Tylophora
a st hm a t ic a Wight a nd Ar n.
L. Sa rava na n 1 * a nd V ipin Cha udha r y 2
Directorate of Oil Palm Research, Pedavegi-534 450, Andhra Pradesh, India. 2Directorate of Medicinal and Aromatic
Plants Research, Boriavi-387 310, Gujarat, India. *E-mail:
[email protected]
1
Abstract
Dichromia orosia (Cramer), a near monophagus pest was observed to cause severe defoliation to its host plant, anthmool (Tylophora
asthmatica Wight and Arn.), an important medicinal plant used in Ayurvedic formulations to treat asthma world over. Biology and
seasonal activity of the pest was studied during 2009-10 at Anand, Gujarat. Though incidence was observed throughout the year,
however, the pest activity was more during July, August, December, January and February months. The pest completed its life cycle in
24.53±0.40 days (Eggs 3-4, larvae 10-14 and pupae 6-7 days). The longevity of the male and female was 15.70±0.68 and 19.70±0.42
days, respectively. Each female laid an average of 178.5±17.66 eggs, mostly on the under surface of the leaves in 12.20±0.49 days
of oviposition period. The larvae developed through five instars in 12.9±0.35 days and pupal period lasted for about 6.8±0.11 days.
Correlation of peak pest population periods with corresponding and previous Standard Meteorological Weeks (SMW) revealed that
prevalence of maximum temperature (27.5-30.20C) mean temperature 29.31 0C, high RH and low rainfall recorded in increase of
larval population.
Introduction
Material and methods
Tylophora asthmatica Wight and Arn. (Synonym T. indica
(Burm. f) Merr.) (Asclepiadaceae) is a climbing perennial plant
indigenous to India. It grows wild in the southern and eastern
regions and has a long-standing reputation as a remedy for
asthma. Its leaves and roots are used as laxative, expectorant,
diaphoretic, and purgative. The plant is also used for the treatment
of bronchitis, colds, diarroahea, dysentery and joint pain (Prajapati
et al., 2003). Over exploitation and lack of organized cultivation
led to a rapid decline in the wild population of this species.
Besides, the plants were reported to be severely defoliated by
a semi looper, Dichromia orosia (Cramer) (=Hypena sagitta
(Fabricus)) (Devaiah et al., 1983). The pest was observed to cause
severe defoliation in the host plant throughout the year in the
Herbal gardens of Directorate of Medicinal and Aromatic Plants
Research, Anand, Gujarat, India. Since there was no previous
report of this pest from Western India, its identity was confirmed
by the Insect Identification Service, Indian Agricultural Research
Institute, New Delhi (Registered under RRS No.67-69/10) as
Dichromia orosia (Carmer).
Studies on biology: The larvae of D. orosia (Noctuidae:
Lepidoptera) were collected from field and reared on the host
plant in laboratory in 20x15 cm plastic jars covered with
muslin cloth. The food to larvae was replenished every day till
the pupation. The pupae were collected from the jars and kept
separately in a jar for adult emergence. The freshly emerged adults
were sexed based on abdomen size and black markings at the tip
of the abdomen of male insects. Ten pairs of male and female
adults were kept in mating jars (15 x10 cm) provided with pieces
of cotton soaked in 50 per cent honey fortified with few drops
of multivitamin syrup and 2 to 3 twigs of T. athmatica dipped in
water filled vials for egg laying. The twigs were carefully replaced
with fresh twigs daily. The observations on fecundity, duration
of oviposition and longevity of adults were recorded daily until
the death of both the adults.
Except for preliminary information on biology, feeding preference
and predation of larvae by a pentatomid bug (Canthecona parva)
(Sridhar and Jhansi Rani, 2003 and 2010), no other information is
available. In view of this, systematic investigation on life traits,
nature of damage, and seasonal abundance in relation to climatic
factors was carried out. The present investigation certainly
contributes to plan the strategy for effective management of the
pest on T. asthmatica.
The fresh batches of eggs were monitored regularly to find
out incubation period. The neonate larvae (15 nos.) were
carefully picked up with the help of a fine brush and transferred
individually on the excised fresh leaves of T. asthmatica kept
in 90 mm transparent plastic Petri dishes lined with moistened
blotting paper to prevent the desiccation of leaves. Fresh leaves
were replenished daily until the larvae reached pupal stage. The
larvae were monitored regularly and moulting was confirmed
by the presence of exuviae and head capsules. The duration and
number of larval instars were determined. The newly formed
pupae were moved to 200 mL plastic jar covered with muslin
cloth and checked daily to record the adult emergence. The
diameter of eggs, body length and width of I and II instar larvae
and head capsule width of all the instars were determined with
Complementary Copy
Key words: Dichromia orosia, Tylophora asthmatica, biology, seasonal activity, longevity
Biology and seasonal activity of semilooper, Dichromia orosia (Cramer) on anthmool, Tylophora asthmatica
the help of ocular micrometer (calibrated with stage micrometer)
fitted to a microscope. The body length and width of 3rd, 4th and
5th instar larvae, pre pupa, pupa and adults stage were measured
using standard measuring scale. The width was taken from the
thickest part of the body which coincided at the central part of
it. The experiment was conducted in BOD incubator at 30±1 oC
and 70±5 % RH.
Studies on seasonal activity: The observation on the seasonal
abundance of D. orosia was carried out on T. asthmatica
plants grown in herbal garden of Directorate of Medicinal and
Aromatic Plants Research, Anand, Gujarat during 2009-10. The
experimental plot area was kept free from any plant protection
measures throughout the study period to encourage natural insect
incidence. The plot was divided into 6 quadrats (1m2 each) and
total number of larvae feeding in each quadrat (includes larva
present on plant as well as on the ground) was counted at weekly
interval. The observation was taken at early hours of the day as
the larvae tend to move to the soil surface and hide under plant
debris, soil clods and crevices during the later part of the day.
The relation between the weekly distribution of immature stages
and prevailing weather parameters viz., rainfall, maximum and
minimum temperature and relative humidity was assessed by
simple correlation analysis using MS excel.
Results and discussion
Studies on biology
Adult stage: Both male and female adults were nearly identical
except in size, where males (32±0.17 mm at wing expanse) were
slightly bigger than female (30±0.23 mm at wing expanse). The
thorax was with grayish scales and abdomen was yellow coloured.
Fore wings were grey with a large sub-triangular black patch with
pale edges occupying the medial area, but not reaching the inner
margin. Hind wings were yellow in colour with apical area dark
brown. The female moths lived longer (19.70±0.42 days) than
male moths (15.70±0.68 days) and the sex ratio was in favour of
females (1: 1.1) (Table 1 and 2). Sridhar and Jhansi Rani (2010)
reported adult longevity of 21.5±1.69 days.
Eggs stage: Gravid female laid eggs mostly in groups and some time
singly on the under surface of the leaves (often at the point where
the leaf blade joins the petiole or either along side a major vein) and
tender twigs. On an average, each female laid 178.5±17.66 eggs
during the oviposition period of 12.20±0.49 days. The eggs were
pale yellowish in colour, spherical and sculptured with a diameter of
0.75±0.01mm. The eggs hatched in 3-4 days. Soon after hatching the
neonate larvae fed on epidermal tissue of leaves. Sridhar and Jhansi
Rani (2010) reported duration of egg stage as 4-5 (av. 4.4±0.49) days
and fecundity per female was 172.4 eggs.
Larval stage: The Ist instar lasted for 2-3 (av. 2.3±0.13) days.
Larvae grown to a length of 2.48±0.23 mm and width of 0.34±0.01
mm before moult. Its colour was pale yellow with pale black
tubercles all over the body. Head was very minute with a head
capsule width of about 0.34±0.01 mm. Instar II also lasted for
2-3 (av. 2.5±0.13) days and attained a length of 4.6±0.71 mm and
width of 1.18 ± 0.22 mm. The head capsule width was 0.53±0.07
mm. The IIIrd instar was yellow in colour with prominent black
coloured warts, this instar lasted for an average of 2.2±0.17 days.
The length and width of the body was 11.8±0.87 and 1.7±0.49
Table 1. Duration of different life stages and reproductive phases of D.
orosia on anthmool at 30±10C and RH 75±5%
Stages
Egg period (days)
Larval period (days)
1st Instar
2nd Instar
3rd Instar
4th Instar
5th Instar
Total larval period (days)
Pre-pupal period (days)
Pupal period (days)
Total life cycle (days)
Longevity of Adults
a. Male
b. Female
Pre- oviposition period (days)
Oviposition period (days)
Post oviposition period (days)
Fecundity (Nos.)
Range (days)
3-4
Mean ± SE
3.4±0.13
2-3
2-3
1-3
1-3
2-4
10-14
1-2
6-7
21-26
2.3±0.13
2.5±0.13
2.2±0.17
2.2±0.14
3.6±0.16
12.9±0.35
1.4±0.13
6.8±0.11
24.53±0.40
12-18
18-22
4-6
10-15
2-5
88-292
15.70±0.68
19.70±0.42
4.6±0.22
12.20±0.49
2.9±0.0.28
178.5±17.66
Table 2. Morphometrics of different stages of D. orosia on anthmool
(Mean ± SE)
Stage
Width of
Length
head capsule of body
(mm)
(mm)
Width of
body
(mm)
Wing
expanse
(mm)
Diameter
(mm)
Egg
0.75±0.01
Larva
1st Instar 0.34±0.01 2.48±0.23 0.34±0.01
2nd Instar 0.53±0.07 4.6±0.71 1.18±0.22
3rd Instar 1.0±0.13 11.8±0.87 1.7±0.49
4th Instar 1.5±0.11 16.5±1.0 2.5±0.34
5th Instar
1.8±0.22 21.7±1.73 3.7±0.32
Pre-pupa
18.0±1.87 4.1±0.22
Pupa
12.2±0.65 3.9±0.2
Adult
a.Male
32±0.17
b.Female
30±0.23
mm, respectively and the width of the head capsule was about
1.0±0.13 mm. The IVth instar lasted for 1-3 (av. 2.2±0.14) days,
its length and width were 16.5±1.0 and 2.5±0.34 mm, respectively
and the head capsule width measured about 1.5±0.11 mm. The
Vth instar lasted for 2-4 (av. 3.6±0.16) days, grown to a length
of 21.7±1.73 mm and a width of 3.7±0.32 mm. The colour of
the larvae were dark yellow having dark black warts all over
body with setae. The head was now quite distinct and measured
about 1.8±0.22 mm (Table 1 and 2). The larvae is a semilooper
having three pairs of true jointed legs just behind the head and
four additional pairs of fleshy legs called ‘prolegs’, three pairs on
the abdominal segments 4th,5th and 6th and fourth pair on the final
abdominal segment. They move with a characteristic “looping”
motion. Larvae were pale to dark yellow. The head and somites
were having series of small black tubercles from where spines
arisen. The larvae passed through five instars in 12.9±0.35 days
and reached pupal stage. Sridhar and Jhansi Rani (2010) reported
a total larval period of 25.5±0.65 days. The different instars lasted
as, Instar-I, 3-4 days; Instar-II, 4-5 days; Instar-III, 4-6 days;
Instar-IV, 5-7 days and Instar-V, 6-9 days.
Nature of damage: All the instars inflicted severe damage to the
host plants. On hatching, the neonate larvae immediately moved
Complementary Copy
140
Biology and seasonal activity of semilooper, Dichromia orosia (Cramer) on anthmool, Tylophora asthmatica
to the under surface of leaf and started feeding on tender leaves.
The larvae of Ist to IIIrd instars scrapped the under surface of the
leaves leaving the upper epidermal layer intact. It was observed
that 5 to 6 early instar larvae were feeding on a single leaf. These
larvae fed mainly on the chlorophyll content of the leaves from
under surface of the leaves and leaving the upper epidermis intact.
In a badly infested situation, the climbers presented a look, as if the
plant had been scorched. Such leaves quickly dried up and fallen
to the ground, resulting in complete denudation of the climber.
The late instar larvae (IVth and Vth instars) fed voraciously on the
141
entire leaf tissues leaving major leaf veins. When the population
of late instar larvae were high, the climber defoliated completely
and giving the appearance as it was grazed by the cattle.
Pupal stage: During the pre-pupal period of 1-2 days the full
grown larvae stopped feeding. The body contracted and larvae
settled in a place and spun cocoon with the help of silken threads,
plant/leaf debris and excreta. The pre-pupae measured 18.0±1.87
mm in length and 4.1±0.22 mm in width. It transformed into
pupae within 1-2 days. The pupae were brown in color and pupal
Complementary Copy
A
B
Fig.1. A. Average weekly incidence of Dichromia orosia on Tylophora asthamatica B. Environmental variables during the
pest incidence period.
Biology and seasonal activity of semilooper, Dichromia orosia (Cramer) on anthmool, Tylophora asthmatica
Table 3. Correlation between mean weekly larval population (19-52nd &
1-18th SMW) and corresponding weekly weather parameters
Weather
Maximum Minimum
Mean
Relative Rain fall
Parameters TemperatureTemperatureTemperature humidity
Correlation
-0.238
-0.210
-0.247
+0.016
-0.080
coefficient
Table 4. Correlation between peak pest population periods (1st- 7th SMW)
with corresponding week (1st- 7th SMW) weather parameters
Weather
Maximum Minimum
Mean
Relative Rain fall
Parameters TemperatureTemperatureTemperature humidity
Correlation
+0.644**
+0.933**
+0.887**
+0.057 0.0000
coefficient
Table 5. Correlation between peak larval population and previous week
weather parameters (46-52nd SMW)
Maximum Minimum
Mean
Relative Rain fall
Weather
Parameters TemperatureTemperatureTemperature humidity
Correlation
-0.048
+0.348*
+0.281*
+0.469** -0.26
coefficient
stage lasted for about 6-7 (av. 6.8±0.11) days (Table 1 and 2). It
measured 12.2±0.65 mm in length and 3.9±0.2 mm in width at
the broadest end. Sridhar and Jhansi Rani (2010) reported pupal
period of 7-9 days (av. 7.7±0.64 days).
The characters of full grown larvae observed in the present study
are in conformity with those observed by Sridhar and Jhansi Rani
(2010). The total development period from egg to adult emergence
was determined as 24.53±0.40 days at about 30oC, thus permitting
a maximum of 8 to 9 overlapping broods per year. This behavior is
in line with the expectation of tropical butterflies to have a short life
cycle, and multiple broods over the year. The developmental period
of some stages determined in present study are not in conformity
with the study made by Sridhar and Jhansi Rani (2010) on similar
species under Bangalore, India conditions. Since climatic factors
influence the instar duration and the overall development time
(Mathavan and Pandian, 1975; Palanichamy et al., 1982; Pathak and
Pizvi, 2003; Braby, 2003), the present findings may vary in other
parts, depending upon prevailing climatic conditions. However,
the development period of 24.53±0.40 is in good agreement with
development period of related species H. laceratalis on lantana
(Visalakshy and Jayanth, 1990).
Seasonal activity: The mean incidence of D. orosia on anthmool
is presented in Fig.1. The infestation of semilooper was first
observed in 20th standard meteorological week (SMW), when
the larval population was 1.6 larvae/m2. The maximum and
minimum temperature during the week were 38.6 and 27.3oC,
respectively and relative humidity (RH) was 63.0 per cent. The
population increased slightly in 21st SMW to 3.2 larvae/m2 and
reached to 22.67 larvae/m2 in 27th SMW, during this period slight
rainfall (1.4 mm) in 24th SMW reduced the summer temperature
to some extent and increased the RH from 51.6 to 69.3 per cent.
Prevailing weather condition along with availability of foliage
favoured the build up of larval population. This increased density
of larval population at this particular point of time, resulted in
complete defoliation of the climbers. Non availability of food
and shelter coupled with monsoon rains (233.7 mm total rainfall
during 27, 28, 29 and 30th SMW) resulted in mortality and forced
pupation of larvae and hence nil population was observed from
28th to 32nd SMW. However, rainfall during these weeks increased
the humidity up to 83.7 per cent (30th SMW), which resulted in
rejuvenation of fresh flush of leaves. The congenial condition,
like high RH (av. 74.80 per cent), nil rainfall and presence of
fresh foliage triggered the emergence of adult from hibernating
pupae, which resulted into increased egg laying, as egg mass
and early instar larvae were abundant during 33th SMW (30.7
larvae/m2). In the subsequent 34th SMW population of late instar
larvae was maximum (36.5 larvae/m2). Abundance of larvae per
unit leaf area, left no space for adult moth to lay eggs. In general,
some lepidopterans especially discriminate the egg load, larval
competition on their host plants or relative abundance of host
plants (Charnov, 1982; Wellings, 1991; Mugrabi and Moreira,
1996) either directly by vision (Wiklund and Ahrberg, 1978;
Shapiro, 1981) or chemically through the presence of deterrent
pheromones (Schoonhovan et al., 1990; Theiry et al., 1992). It
was found that due to the scarcity of leaf tissues, the late instar
larvae forcibly entered into pupal stage, as large number of pupae
were observed among the dried leaves and on the soil surface
during the period (35th SMW). Moreover, heavy down pour (131
mm) during the end of 35th SMW caused mortality in remaining
larvae. The rain has been shown to cause the death of wide variety
of insects in the pre imaginal as well as adult stages (Sappington
and Showers, 1983). Owing to severe defoliation and denudation,
the climbers did not recoup until 44th SMW. During 46th SMW
few early instar larvae were seen (1.5 larvae/ 1m2quadrat) on the
newly emerged flushes, the maximum and minimum temperature
during the week were 28.5 and 18.9 oC, respectively and relative
humidity was 73.4 per cent. The precipitation (4.8 mm) received
during the later part of the 46th week resulted in mortality of those
early stage larvae. Thereafter, the pest did not appear until 50th
SMW. The intermittent precipitation and absence of pest activity
for about 14 weeks favoured the climbers to recoup fully, which
resulted in abundance of fresh foliage. The pest again appeared
in 51st SMW, initially with the population of 8.2 larvae/m2,
which increased steadily and a maximum of 163.2 larvae/m2
was observed during 6th SMW. At the end of that week the pest
population was mixture of early (1-3rd instars) and late instars (4th5th instars). During the week maximum and minimum temperature
were 31.0 and 16.2 0C, respectively and RH was 58.8 per cent.
The abundance of pest completely defoliated or denuded the
climbers and in the want of food and shelter the larval population
declined to 16.7 larvae/m2 in 7th SMW due to mortality and
forced pupation. As a result, during the period (7th SMW) large
number of pupae was observed on the soil surface and among
the dried leaves. Due to lack of green tissue, no pest population
was observed upto 12th SMW. The moderate activity of pest was
again observed from 13th SMW (1.33 larvae/m2), when fresh flush
of leaves again rejuvenated and it remained continued upto 18th
SMW. The temperature and humidity during the period ranged
between 29.0 to 33.2 0C and 39.9 to 51.9 per cent, respectively.
The correlation analysis between pest population and maximum,
minimum and mean temperature (r= -0.24, -0.21 and -0.25,
respectively) showed negative correlation. Relative humidity
showed non-significant positive correlation (r=0.0164) (Table 3).
Though rainfall could influence the insect population negatively
(r= -0.081), but the correlation was not significant. Correlation
of peak pest population periods with corresponding and previous
SMW, revealed that out of 5 weather parameters tested 3 parameters
viz. maximum temperature, RH and rain fall during 46-52nd and
1st -7th SMW were found to be effective in determining the level
of infestation. The analysis inferred that prevalence of maximum
temperature (27.5-30.20C), mean temperature 29.31 0C, high RH
Complementary Copy
142
and low rainfall recorded in maximum increase of number of larval
population (Table 4 and 5).
The year round presence of immature stages on the host plant,
T. asthmatica, showed that D. orosia breeds continuously.
Weather conditions, especially RH and temperature though
favoured the population build up of pest, yet their impact was
non-significant, which contradicts the finding of several authors
(Kaul and Kesar, 2003; Atluri et al., 2004 and 2010; Selvaraj et
al., 2010), who found a significant effect of RH and temperature
on population buildup of different lepidopteran pests. However,
host abundance (particularly new flushes) and host quality
favoured the population buildup of pest, as new flush facilitate the
performance of larvae due to the likely higher levels of nitrogen
and water content (Slansky and Feeny, 1977; Scriber, 1977;
Mattson, 1980; Price, 2000; Awmack, 2002). Correlation of peak
pest population periods with corresponding and previous SMW,
revealed that prevalence of maximum temperature (27.5-30.20C),
mean temperature 29.31oC, high RH and low rainfall recorded
in maximum increase of number of larval population. However,
the overall effect of weather on population trends is complex and
difficult to predict, as also expressed by Pollard (1988).
The semilooper, D. orosia has emerged as serious pest of
anthmool, T.asthmatica and active almost round the year. The
pest could generate another generation in 21-27 days. The weather
parameters did not have significant effect on the built up of the
pest. However, presence of new flushes favoured population built
up. This knowledge on the pest will be helpful in formulating
effective pest management strategies.
Acknowledgements
The authors are thankful to Director, Directorate of Medicinal and
Aromatic Plants Research, Boriavi, Anand (Gujarat), India for
providing facilities for the study and also to Dr. V.V. Ramamurthy,
Division of Entomology, I.A.R.I., New Delhi for identifying this
insect.
References
Atluri, J.B., B. Samantha, B.R. Matala, S.D. Devara and S.R. Chilakala,
2010. Ecobiology of the common castor butterfly Ariadne merione
merione (Cramer) (Lepidoptera: Rhopalocera: Nymphalidae). J.
Res. Lepidop., 42: 13-20.
Atluri, J.B., S.P. Venkata Ramana and S.R. Chilakala, 2004. Ecobiology
of Catopsilia pyranthe, a tropical pierid butterfly. Curr. Sci., 86(3):
457-461.
Awmack, S.C. and S.R. Leather, 2002. Host plant quality and fecundity
in herbivorous insects. Ann. Rev. Entomol., 47: 817-844.
Braby, M.F. 2003. Larval and adult food plants for some tropical satyrine
butterflies in northern Queensland. Austral. Entomol., 22(1): 5-13.
Charnov, E.L. 1982. The Theory of Sex Allocation. Princeton University
Press, Princeton. 355 pp.
Devaiah, M.C., R.R. Gouda, Y.K. Kotikal and Y.S. Yelshett, 1983.
A noctuid defoliator pest, Dichromia orosia Cramer (Noctuidae:
Lepidoptera) of antamul, a medicinal plant. J. Bombay Natural
History Soc., 80(3): 659.
Kaul, V. and Y. Kesar, 2003. Incidence and management of lepidopteran
fruit borers of Guava (Psidium Guajava L.) in Jammu, India. J.
Asia-Pacific Entomol., 6(2): 201-205.
Mathavan, S. and T.J. Pandian, 1975. Effect of temperature on food
utilization in the monarch butterfly Danaus chrysippus. Oikos, 26:
60-64.
143
Mattson, W.J. 1980. Herbivory in relation to plant nitrogen content. Ann.
Rev. Ecol. Systema., 11: 119-161.
Mugrabi, O.E. and R.P. Moreira, 1996. Conspecific mimics and low
host plant availability reduce egg laying by Heliconius eratophllis
(Fab.) (Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae). Revista Brasialia Zool., 13(4):
929-937.
Palanichamy, S., R. Ponnuchamy and T. Thangaraj, 1982. Effect of
temperature on food intake, growth and conversion efficiency of
Eupterote mollifera (Insect: Lepidoptera). Proceedings of Indian
Academy of Sciences (Animal Sciences), 91: 417-422.
Pathak, M. and P.Q. Pizvi, 2003. Age specific survival and fertility table
of Papilio demoleus at different set of temperatures and host plants.
Indian J. Entomol., 65(1): 123-126.
Pollard, E. 1988. Temperature, rainfall and butterfly numbers. J. Appl.
Ecol., 25: 819-828.
Prajapati, N.D., S.S. Purohit, A.K. Sharma and T. Kumar, 2003. A
Handbook of Medicnal Plants’ A Complete Source Book. First
Edition. Agrobios (India).
Price, W.P. 2000. Host plant resource quality, insect herbivores and
biocontrol. In: Proceedings of the 10th International symposium on
Biological control of weeds (Neal. R. Spencer ed.), Montana State
University, Montana, USA, 1999, p.583-590.
Sappington, T.W. and W.B. Showers, 1983. Effects of precipitation and
wind on population of adult European corn borer, Ostrinia nublinalis
(Lepidoptera: Pyralidae). Environ. Entomol., 12: 1193-1196.
Schoonhoven, L.M., E.A.M. Beerling, J.W. Klijnstra and Y. Van Vuggt,
1990. Two related butterfly species avoid oviposition near eather’s
eggs. Experimentia, 46: 526-528.
Scriber, J.M. 1977. Limiting effects of low leaf water content on nitrogen
utilization, energy budget, and larval growth of Hylaphora cecropia
(Lepidoptera: Saturniidae). Oecologia, 28: 269-287.
Selvaraj, S., D. Adiruobane, V. Ramesh and A.L. Narayanan, 2010.
Impact of ecological factors on incidence and development of
tobacco cut worm, Spodoptera litura Fabricus on cotton. J. Biopesti.,
3: 043-046.
Shapiro, A.M. 1981. Egg mimics of Streptanthus (Cruciferae) deter
oviposition by Pieris sisyonbrii (Lepidoptera : Pieridae). Oecologia,
48: 142-143.
Slansky, F. and P. Feeny, 1977. Stabilization of the rate of nitrogen
accumulation by larvae of the cabbage butterfly on wild and
cultivated food plants. Ecolol. Monographs, 47: 209-228.
Sridhar, V. and B. Jhansi Rani, 2003. New record of Canthecona parva
(Distant) (Heteroptera: Pentatomidae) as a predator of Hypena
quadralis (Walker) a pest of Tylophora indica (Burm.f) Merr. J.
Biol. Contr., 17(2): 179-180.
Sridhar, V. and B. Jhansi Rani. 2010. Occurrence and biology of
semilooper, Hypena sagitta (Fabricus)(=Dichromia orosia Cramer)
(Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) on Indian Ipecae, Tylophora indica (Burm.
F.) Merr. Pest. Mgt. Horti. Ecosys., 16(1): 78-79.
Thiery, D., D. Gagel, P. Farkas and V. Pronier, 1992, Identification of
an oviposition regulating pheromone in the European grapevine
moth, Lobesia botrana (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae). Experimentia,
48: 697-699.
Visalakshy, P.N.G. and K.P. Jayanth, 1990. Studies on biology and
seasonal abundance of Hypena laceratalis Walker (Lepidoptera:
Noctuidae) on Lantana camara L. in India. Entomon, 15 (3-4):
231-234.
Wellings, P.W. 1991. Host location and oviposition on animals. In:
Reproductive Behaviour of Insects: Individuals And Population, W.J.
Bailey and J. Ridsdill- Smith (eds.). Chapman and Hall. p. 75-107.
Wiklund, C. and C. Ahrberg, 1978. Host plants, nectar source plants and
habitat selection of males and females of Anthocharis cardamines
(Lepidoptera). Oikos, 31: 169-183.
Received: June, 2012; Revised: October, 2012; Accepted: November, 2012
Complementary Copy
Biology and seasonal activity of semilooper, Dichromia orosia (Cramer) on anthmool, Tylophora asthmatica
Journal
Journal of Applied Horticulture, 14(2): 144-145, 2012
Appl
Oc c urre nc e of fa lse sm ut on dat e pa lm (Phoe nix da c t ylife ra L.)
in t he sout he r n c oa st a l pla ins of Ye m e n
M .H . Abdul Sat t a r 1 , A. Ra shid Ya ssin I bra him 2 a nd Wat he q A Aula qi 2
Plant Protection Section, 2Horticulture and Food Technology Section, El Kod Agricultural Research Station(AREA),
Abyan Governorate, Republic of Yemen. E-mail:
[email protected]
1
Abstract
Twelve date palm cultivars were evaluated for field resistance to Graphiola leaf spot caused by Graphiola phaenicis (Moug) Poit. The
disease incidence and number of sori were compared on both surface of leaf, pinnae position on leaves and plant age. Cultivars, Gizaz,
Tha’al and Khodari showed negligable infection and fewer number of sori on the leaf surface and rachis. Symptom of disease was absent
on leaves and rachis in cultivar Sagaee. These cultivars differed significantly from susceptible cultivars viz., Shahree, Soqotree and
Khalas (P= 0.01). Abundant distribution of sori caused a drastic reduction of the leaf area covered by the fungus. Adaxial leaf surface
trapped more number of sporidia and significant differences were detected among test cultivars (P=0.05). The temperature ranging
between 32-38◦ C in summer and humidity accompanied by heavy dew in the night and early morning favored the development of
infection. Correlation of age of cultivar “Shahree” and disease incidence revealed that older trees are more susceptible to disease.
Key words: Date palm, Graphiola phaenicis, Southern coastal plain, Yemen.
Graphiola phaenicis (Moug) Poit. causing leaf spot, infects older
leaflets and rachis of the date palm (Phoenix dactylifera) and
causes serious loss in yield (Guar, 2000). G. phaenicis has been
extensively studied and reported from United States (Simone,
2004), Qatar (Abbas et al., 2004), Libya (Edongali, 1996),
Canary Island (Cabrera et al., 1990) and India (Guar, 2000).
Attempts have been made to control false smut by application of
fungicides (Mehta et al., 1989) which is not desirable due to its
negative impact on public health and environment. Cultivation
of resistant and high yielding cultivars is the safe alternative
to minimize pesticide use and consequently reduce the cost of
production. Several reports indicated that date palm cultivars
differ in their susceptibility to false smut disease (Mehta et al.,
1989; Lodha, 2003).
This study aimed on susceptibility of existing date palm cultivars
in southern coastal plains to false smut disease in relation to age
of tree and disease incidence.
Materials and methods
Present study involved several visits to date palm orchards in
Lahej and Abyan Governorates which constitute the southern
coastal plain of the Republic of Yemen. The date palm cultivars
in each orchard were identified. Eight trees for each cultivar were
randomly selected (Table 1). Leaflets from the apical, middle and
base of the rachis were examined for infection by G. phaenicis.
The number of sori were counted and recorded. Parts of these
samples were transported to the laboratory, El Kod Agricultural
Research Station for microscopic examination of basidiocarp
and sporidia. Readings for incidence of disease for each cultivar
were also taken by counting the number of infected trees for
a given cultivar divided by total number of trees of a given
cultivar in the orchard and expressed as percentage. A total of 360
samples representing the leaves and rachis were collected from
three positions of pinnae and examined. The effect of age on the
susceptibility of cultivars to false smut was studied utilizing the
cultivar “Shahree” which is highly susceptible and widely grown
in these areas. Trees 2, 12, 20 and 70 years old were selected for
this study.
Statistical analysis: Data were analyzed following standard
procedures for analysis of variance and differences between
means were compared for significance at P= 0.05 and P= 0.01.
Correlation and regression analysis were conducted following
standard procedures (Steel and Torrie, 1980). In all cases, the
data were analyzed utilizing Genstat program (Genestat 5, No
3.1, 1996).
Results and discussion
Variation in the incidence of Graphiola leaf spot was apparent
in 12 cultivars. Pathogen and symptom development appeared
to be affected by the cultivar, age and position of leaf. Cultivars
Gizaz, Tha’al and Khodari showed negligable infection and
consequently less number of sori on the leaf surface (Table 1).
Symptoms of the disease were almost absent on leaves and rachis
in cultivar Sagaee, despite the presence of source of inoculum in
the proximity of the cultivar. Although no significant difference
(P= 0.05) was detected among these highly resistant cultivars,
they differed significantly with the susceptible cultivars (P=
0.01). The symptoms (sori) exhibited a drastic reduction of the
leaf area due to fungus covering. Singh et al. (1970) reported
reduction in leaf area and decline in chlorophyll level in the leaves
due to infection by G. phaenicis. Comparison of leaf surface
revealed that the adaxial leaf surface trapped more number of
sporidia than the abaxial surface (Table 1). Number of sori was
higher and showed significant variation among test cultivars
(P= 0.05). The distribution of sori in terms of leaf position was
random (Table 2) and contradicts the trend reported by Lodha
Complementary Copy
Introduction
Occurrence of false smut on date palm (Phoenix dactylifera L.) in the southern coastal plains of Yemen
145
Table 1. Disease incidence and number of sori at both surface of date palm
leaves
Table 4. Relationship between plant age and disease parameters on
date palm cv. “Shahree”
Cultivar
Average number Average number
Age of
plant
of sori on lower of sori on upper
(years)
leaf surface
leaf surface
70
85.4
75.8
20
22.1
18.3
12
44.1
31.1
2
7.8
4.5
CV
16.596
28.120
20.669
17.172
LSD (P=0.05)
30.072
24.983
LSD (P= 0.01)
Disease
incidence
(%)
Shahree
95.0
Medini
9.0
Soqotree
65.0
Barhee
6.0
Gizaz
1.0
Zabidi
10.7
Mashtaf
4.0
Tha’al
2.0
Khodari
1.7
Ghahree
16.7
Khalas
40.0
Sagaee
0.0
12.3
LSD (P= 0.05)
16.6
LSD (P=0.01)
CV
25.4
Number of sori on
leaves
Abaxial Adaxial
75.8
83.7
19.5
39.1
24.9
30.4
5.8
12.9
1.2
1.9
4.3
7.1
7.8
12.3
5.4
8.9
4.0
6.2
7.7
11.8
32.0
44.3
0.0
0.0
10.7
20.4
14.5
27.7
19.9
25.6
Disease reaction to
false smut
Highly susceptible
Resistant
Highly susceptible
Resistant
Highly resistant
Resistant
Resistant
Highly resistant
Highly resistant
Resistant
Highly susceptible
Highly resistant
Disease
incidence
(%)
95.0
30.0
30.0
3.0
17.5
14.2
20.73
(Table 3), where the disease incidence was highest in 70 years
old trees (Table 4). Although the coefficient of determination
are high and the slopes of the regressions are quite similar,
the regressions differ principally in intercept values. This
explains that older trees are more susceptible to Graphiola
leaf spot than younger trees.
Table 2. Position of leaves on the pinnae and number of sori on the leaves of
date palm
Cultivar
Abaxial (number of sori)
Adaxial (number of sori)
Apical
Mid
Base
Apical
Mid
Base
Shahree
75.0
108.1
44.3
84.4
119.6
52.1
Medini
15.1
19.7
23.6
16.5
20.8
29.5
Soqotree
18.3
31.0
25.4
19.8
36.7
34.4
Barhee
4.8
5.7
7.0
12.3
13.7
12.7
Gizaz
0.9
1.4
1.2
2.0
1.9
1.7
Zabidi
4.0
3.9
5.0
6.7
7.0
7.5
Mashtaf
3.9
8.2
11.2
7.2
11.6
18.2
Tha’al
3.7
4.8
7.7
6.3
8.2
12.3
Khodari
5.9
3.1
3.1
8.2
5.2
5.0
Ghahree
5.5
8.9
8.8
8.7
15.8
10.8
Khalas
23.1
54.7
18.3
29.2
77.1
26.8
Sagaee
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
12.2
24.2
18.2
11.1
32.1
23.8
LSD (P=0.05)
16.5
32.8
24.7
15.1
43.6
32.3
LSD (P=0.01)
CV
23.0
27.8
32.6
21.5
28.7
34.8
Table 3. Relationship between different variables (X) and age of date palm
trees cultivar “ Shahree” (Y)
Ŷ= a + b (x)
Ŷ= 6.26+1.2784 x
Ŷ= 7.00+0.978 x
Ŷ = 13.09+1.028 x
Ŷ = 11.12+0.939 x
Ŷ = - 0.40+1.510 x
Ŷ = 10.41+0.483 x
Ŷ= 16.36+0.999 x
Ŷ= 6.8+1.574 x
Ŷ= 16.09+0.510 x
F(prob)
< 0.001
< 0.001
< 0.001
< 0.001
< 0.001
0.038
< 0.001
< 0.001
0.083
R2
94.0
83.6
74.9
69.9
80.6
30.1
65.8
69.7
19.8
Variables
Disease incidence (%)
No of sori on upper surface of leaf
No of sori on lower surface of leaf
No of sori on apical upper surface of leaf
No of sori on mid-upper surface of leaf
No of sori on basal upper surface of leaf
No of sori on apical lower surface of leaf
No of sori on mid-lower surface of leaf
No of sori on basal lower surface of leaf
Abbas, E.H. and A.S. Abdulla, 2004. First report of false smut
disease caused by Graphiola phaenicis on date palm trees in
Qatar. Plant Pathology, 53(6): 815.
Cabrera, R., F. Hodgson, M.De. Armas, C.T. Santiago, C.D. Lorenzo,
C. Prendes and P. Plata, 1990. A fungus disease of canary palm
(Phaenix canariensis chab.) produced by Graphiola phaenicis
(Mong) Poit. Fisher in the Canary Islands. Phytoma Espana,
18: 21-25.
Edongali, E.A. 1996. Disease of date palms (Phaenix dactilifera L.)
of Libya. Arab Journal of Plant Protection, 14: 41-43.
Elliot, Monica L. 2006. Graphiola leaf spot (False smut of palm).
Florida Cooperative Extension Service. http: // edis.ifas.ufl.
edu.
Guar, V.K. 2000. Studies on Graphiola leaf spot disease of date palm.
In: Proceedings of International Conference on “ Integrated
Plant Disease Management for Sustainable Agriculture”, Vol
I, New Delhi, India, 471-472. pp.
Lodha, S. 2003. Influence of pinnae position, leaf age and some
fungicides on the development of graphiola leaf spot on date
palm. Arab Journal of Plant Protection, 21: 162-165.
Mehta. N., P.C. Gupta, R.K. Tharija and J.K. Dang, 1989. Varietal
behavior and efficacy of different fungicides for the control of
date palm leaf spot caused by Graphiola phaenicis. Tropical
Pest management, 35: 117-119.
Simone, G.W. 2004. Graphiola leaf spot (false smut). In:
Compendium of Ornamental Palm Diseases and Disorders.
M.L. Elliot, T.K Broschat, J.Y. Uchida and G. W. Simone eds.
American Phytopathological Society. St. Paul. MN. p. 26-27
Singh, M.K., R. Singh and R. Jeyarjan, 1970. Graphiola leaf spot on
date palm (Phaenix dactilifera) , susceptibility of date varieties
and effect on chlorophyll control. Plant Disease Reporter, 54:
617-619.
Steel, R.G.D. and J.H. Torrie, 1980. Principles and Procedures of
Statistics. A Biometrical Approach . 2nd Edition. Mc. Graw Hill
Book Company. 633 pp.
Received: December, 2011; Revised: June, 2012; Accepted: July, 2012
Complementary Copy
Reference
(2003) who stated higher number of sori at the base on both the abaxial
and adaxial surface of leaflets. Temperature ranging from 32-38° C
in summer and 18-27° C in winter accompanied by heavy dew in the
night and early morning hours regardless of duration are favorable
for subsequent development of infection. No false smut is reported in
Seiyun, Hadhramout governorate, which constitute the eastern plateau
and is a major date palm cultivation area in Yemen is characterized
by dry climate with low humidity (Personal communication, Ashoor
AlZubeiri, 2009). This observation is in confirmity with findings of
Elliot (2006). Regression of age of tree “Shahree” on disease incidence
and the number of sori gave the highest coefficient of determination (r2)
Journal
Journal of Applied Horticulture, 14(2): 146-151, 2012
Appl
Re sourc e use e ffi c ie ncy of ora nge a nd k innow c ult ivat ion in
Ja m m u re gion of J & K st at e
Jyot i K a chroo* , Anil Bhat a nd Dile e p K a chroo
Sher-e-Kashmir University of Agricultural Sciences and Technology – Jammu, Chatha – 180009, Jammu and Kashmir,
India. *E-mail:
[email protected]
Orange and kinnow occupy an important place in the horticultural industry of the country as well as in J&K state. In the present
study, resource use efficiency of orange and kinnow was analysed. The regression coefficient values of selected inputs under orange
orchards, mainly human labour, manures + fertilizers, irrigation, plant protection and training/ pruning varied significantly at the five
age groups of five years from 5th to 28th years, corresponded to overall values as 0.955, 0.012, -0.012, 0.013 and -0.050, respectively.
Out of which human labour, manures + fertilizers and plant protection with positive sign indicated that with one per cent increase in
the use of these inputs, the output could be increased by 0.96 per cent in case of human labour and 0.01 per cent each in other two
inputs. The regression coefficient of training/ pruning was statistically significant but negative indicating that one per cent increase
in expenditures on training/ pruning could decrease the output to the extent of 0.05 per cent. The marginal value productivities of
human labour, manures + fertilizers and plant protection were positive with their values at 0.185, 110.452, 0.076, respectively, whereas
that of training/ pruning (-0.638) and irrigation (-0.054) were negative thereby indicated that there still existed scope of investing on
human labour, manures + fertilizers and plant protection. The overall regression coefficient values obtained from kinnow cultivation
were 0.029, -0.024, 0.016, 0.015 and 0.138 for human labour, manures + fertilizers, irrigation, plant protection and training/ pruning,
respectively, out of which human labour and training/ pruning were statistically significant, indicating that one per cent increase in
expenditures on these two inputs could increase the output to the extent of 0.03 per cent and 0.14 per cent, respectively. The regression
coefficients of irrigation, plant protection and manures + fertilizers were non significant. The marginal value productivities of human
labour, irrigation, plant protection and training/ pruning were positive with their values at 0.031, 0.025, 0.014 and 0.175, respectively,
whereas that of manures + fertilizers (-0.027) was negative thereby indicating that there still existed scope in the investment on human
labour, irrigation, plant protection and training/ pruning.
Key words: Orange, kinnow, resource use efficiency, regression coefficient
Introduction
In a predominantly agricultural economy, the rate of growth
in agriculture depends on the way farmers react to various
programmes (Prasher et al., 2006). Diversification to horticultural
crops has been found to be best option as they make more profit,
generate additional employment for rural masses and conserve
natural resources. Under present agricultural scenario, fruits in
the food consumption play the key role in enhancing trade and
business worldwide. The country’s population has almost tripled
in the last five decades and its food grain production has more
than quadrupled, significantly enhancing the per capita food
grain availability. On the other hand, the share of agriculture in
GDP has declined substantially from 55 per cent in early 1950s
to about 42 per cent in the 1980s and further to 15.7 per cent in
2008-09 (Economic Survey, 2009-10). However, there is only
a marginal decline in the number of resident in rural area. So,
the government has identified horticultural crops as a means of
diversification which are more profitable on the basis of efficient
land use, optimum utilization of natural resources and creating
employment opportunities for rural masses especially for women
folk.
India is the world’s second largest producer of fruits (57.73
million tonnes in 2008) which may increase to 98 million tonnes
by the year 2020-2021 (Banerjee, 2009) and contributes 10.0
per cent in the world fruit production (Economic Survey, 200809). Productivity of horticultural crops has increased from 1.2
tonnes per hectare in 1953-54 to around 4.95 tonnes per hectare
in 2007-08. Out of total production of fruits and vegetables about
65-70 per cent has been consumed domestically, two per cent for
processing, and only one per cent exported while post harvest
losses accounted to 20-30 per cent of the stored fruits (Wani,
2008). India’s export of fresh fruits and vegetables has increased
from US$ 383.43 million in 2005-06 to US$ 605.33 million in
2007-08 i.e., an increase of 57.87 per cent (APEDA, 2008).
Among the fruit crops, citrus is one of the major commercial
fruit crop widely consumed both as fresh fruit and juice. Its
global demand is attributed to its high vitamin C content and its
antioxidant potential (Gorinstein et al., 2001). It is rich in folic
acid, a good source of fiber, fat free, sodium free and cholesterol
free with additional quality of containing potassium, calcium,
folate, thiamin, niacin, vitamin B6, phosphorus, magnesium and
copper. It may also help in reducing the risk of heart diseases
and some types of cancer and has been found helpful in reducing
the risk of pregnant women to have children with birth diseases
(Economos and Clay, 1999). Essential and volatile oils are
obtained from the citrus fruits’ peel sacks. So much so, it is used
by the food industry to give flavor to drinks, foods and also acts as
Complementary Copy
Abstract
Resource use efficiency of orange and kinnow cultivation in Jammu region of J&K state
The state of Jammu and Kashmir, with its favourable climatic
conditions for horticultural crops, is suitable for growing many
fruits of commercial importance. The fruit industry is the second
most important industry after tourism in Jammu and Kashmir state
with 41.82 per cent area under horticultural crops out of the total
net sown area of 7.34 lakh hectares and an income of Rs 2000.00
crore has been generated from fruits production during 2008-09
(Economic Survey, 2008-09).
Yt = β0
ut
(i = 1,2,3, …., n)
Where, Y and Xi (i =1,2,3, …., n) are the output and levels of
inputs. The constant β0 and βi’s (i = 1,2,3, ...., n) represent the
efficiency parameters and the production elasticities of the
respective input variables for the given population of fruit at a
particular period, t.
The fitted Cobb-Douglas production in present case with five
input variables was written as:
Y = a0 x1b1 x2b2 x3b3 x4b4 x5b5
Among the various fruit crops, growing of citrus has vast potential
in Jammu region of Jammu and Kashmir state as it comprises
highest area under its cultivation (11762 hectares) which is
99.62 per cent of total area under citrus in J&K, whereas its
production has been realized to (19202 metric tonnes) which is
99.96 per cent of the total citrus production of J&K (Economic
Survey, 2008-09). In Jammu region, the districts mainly Rajouri,
Kathua, Jammu, Udhampur, Samba and Reasi are the prominent
areas where it is grown. Keeping in view the importance of the
orange and kinnow for our orchards and the facts described
above, a study was undertaken with the following objectives: to
estimate resource use efficiency of orange and kinnow in respect
of important factor inputs.
On log transformation, the above function then was transformed
to a linear form as:
Materials and methods
x5 = Expenditure on training and pruning (Rs/acre)
A multi stage sampling was adopted for the selection of samples,
with districts, blocks, villages and orchardists as the first, second,
third and fourth stage sampling units, respectively for orange
and kinnow. Rajouri, Kathua, Jammu and Samba districts were
selected because these four districts covered the maximum area
under citrus cultivation (Rajouri covered 22.93 per cent, Kathua
20.56 per cent, Jammu 16.37 per cent and Samba 12.67 per cent of
the total area under all citrus fruits cultivation in Jammu region).
Three blocks from each district were selected except in case of
Kathua where only two blocks were selected on the basis of area
under orange and kinnow cultivation and from each block two
villages were selected. The ultimate units, that is, orchardists were
selected randomly from each village so as to constitute a total
sample of 176 orchardists for the present study.
a0 = Constant
The primary data from growers of citrus was collected by survey
method, using well-designed schedule. Collection of data was
done by the personal interview method. The schedule was pretested before using for actual data collection. The reference period
for this study was the year 2009.
Production function analysis: In order to study the relationship
between output and various inputs used, Cobb- Douglas
production function was used. Here, gross product had been taken
as dependent variable with manures + fertilizers, irrigation, plant
protection, training/ pruning and human labour as the independent
variables. The age of the orchards (orange and kinnow) were
grouped into six groups viz. 5th to 9th year, 10th to 14th year, 15th to
19th year, 20th to 24th year, 25th to 28th year and overall group which
included the whole age of the orchard. First four years were not
taken in to account as these were the non fruit bearing years. The
functional form applied is given as under:
Log y = log a0 + b1 log x1 + b2 log x2 + b3 log x3 + b4 log x4 + b5
log x5
Or log y = log a0 + bi
Where,
Y
i
= Output (quintals/ acre)
x1 = Human labour (man days per acre)
x2 = Manure + fertilizers (kg/acre)
x3 = Expenditure on plant protection (Rs/acre)
x4 = Expenditure on irrigation (Rs/acre)
b’s = Elasticities of production of respective resource
categories
To examine the productivity of different inputs used in production
of studied fruits, marginal value productivities of inputs were
estimated at geometric mean levels of inputs. To calculate
Marginal Value Productivity (MVP) of resource xi, the following
formula was used.
× Py
MVP =
Where,
MVP (xi)= marginal value productivity of ith resource
= regression coefficient (estimated)
GM (Y) = geometric mean of output
GM (xi) = geometric mean of inputs
Py
= price of output
Various combinations of variables were tried and the choice of
the best equation was made on the basis of R2 explained and the
relevance of the expected sign of coefficient. Some variables like
irrigation and plant protection (in some age groups) were omitted
during the analysis as the sample orchardists had not used these
resources in those age groups. The marginal value productivity
(MVP) of these resources used was worked out with the help of
regression coefficients obtained. MVP of a particular resource
represents the expected addition to the gross return caused by the
additional one unit of the resource input while the other inputs were
held constant.
Complementary Copy
a component for the pharmaceutical industry for the preparation
of medicines, soaps, perfumes and other cosmetics, as well as for
home cleaning products (Braddock, 1999).
147
Resource use efficiency of orange and kinnow cultivation in Jammu region of J&K state
Results and discussion
Table 1. Estimated regression coefficients of various factors, standard errors
and MVP of orange and kinnow production (5th -9th year)
Resource use efficiency of orange and kinnow: The results
of regression function and marginal value productivity of
orange and kinnow from 5th-9th year are depicted in Table 1. The
table indicated that the output of orange orchards was regressed
against human labour, manures + fertilizers, irrigation, plant
protection and training/ pruning. For this group, production
function was statistically significant having R2 value (0.622)
meaning that 62.2 per cent of the total variations in the
production of orange were explained by the explanatory
variables under consideration. The regression coefficients of
orange for human labour (0.771) and manures + fertilizers
(0.010) with positive sign indicated that with one per cent
increase in the use of these two inputs keeping all the other
inputs constant, could increase the output by 0.77 per cent
and 0.01 per cent, respectively. The contribution of irrigation
(-0.014) and plant protection (-0.010) were found negative
and non-significant. The regression coefficient of training/
pruning (-0.017) was also found negative and significant.
All the regression coefficients were observed less than unity
thereby indicating diminishing returns. It could be seen from
the Table 1 that marginal value productivity of human labour
(0.153) and manures + fertilizers (0.034) were noted positive
while that of irrigation (-603.966), plant protection (-0.223)
and training/ pruning (-260.371) were noted negative hence
indicating their excess use and should be avoided to check
the fall of returns. These results are in close conformity with
Chinappa and Ramanna (1997).
Variables
The Table also depicted that the crop production function
used from 5th-9th year of establishment was found statistically
significant having R2 value (0.787) meaning that 78.7 per
cent of the total variations in the production function for
kinnow was explained by the explanatory variables under
consideration. The table further revealed that the regression
coefficients for human labour (0.316) and manures +
fertilizers (0.320) with positively significant coefficient
indicated that with one per cent increase in the use of these
two inputs keeping all the other inputs constant, could
increase the output by 0.32 per cent in both cases and at
same time, both these inputs had significant contribution in
the kinnow production. The regression coefficient of plant
protection (-0.006) was however found negative and non
significant. It could also be seen from the table that marginal
value productivity of human labour (0.097), manures +
fertilizers (0.469), irrigation (2.047) and training/ pruning
(0.064) were positive and showed that additional one rupee
spent on these inputs, could add to gross returns by Rs 0.10,
0.47, 2.05 and 0.06, respectively and hence there still existed
a scope to invest more on these inputs. Similar findings were
also reported by Iqbal (2009).
The Table 2 in the age group of 10-14 years depicted that
the R2 (0.884) value was statistically significant meaning that
88.4 per cent of the variation in the production of orange
was due to the above mentioned explanatory variables. The
regression coefficients of orange for human labour (0.867),
plant protection (0.045) and training/ pruning (0.022) with
positive sign indicated that with one per cent increase in
Orange
Kinnow
Reg.
Stand MVP
Reg.
Std. MVP
Coeff. error
Coeff. error
Constant
-0.057
0.254
0.796* 0.262
Manures + Fertilizers 0.010
0.013
0.034 0.320* 0.073 0.469
Irrigation
-0.014
0.007 -603.966 0.004
0.024 2.047
Plant Protection
-0.010
0.010 -0.223 -0.006
0.038 -0.104
Training/ Pruning
-0.017** 0.008 -260.371 0.030
0.030 0.064
Human Labour
0.771* 0.080
0.153 0.316* 0.094 0.097
F Value
20.75
19.37
R2
0.622*
0.787*
* and ** Significant at P=0.01 and P=0.05, respectively
Table 2. Estimated regression coefficients of various factors, standard errors
and MVP of orange and kinnow production (10th -14th year)
Variables
Orange
Kinnow
Reg.
Stand MVP
Reg.
Std. MVP
Coeff. error
Coeff. error
Constant
-0.358** 0.145
0.884*
0.382
Manures + Fertilizers -0.056* 0.014 -1.845 0.573*
0.065 0.996
Irrigation
0.045** 0.018 1.354
-0.005
0.063 -0.0002
Training/ Pruning
0.022
0.013 512.188 0.124** 0.059 0.009
Human Labour
0.867* 0.040 0.085
0.245*
0.062 0.003
F Value
122.51
81.33
R2
0.884**
0.760*
* and ** Significant at P=0.01 and P=0.05, respectively
Table 3. Estimated regression coefficients of various factors, standard errors
and MVP of orange and kinnow production (15th - 19th year)
Variables
Orange
Kinnow
Reg.
Stand MVP
Reg.
Std.
Coeff. error
Coeff. error
Constant
-0.532* 0.158
1.837* 0.288
Manures + Fertilizers 0.001 0.014
0.040 0.263** 0.108
Plant Protection
-0.002 0.012
-0.995 0.137** 0.064
Training/ Pruning
-0.015 0.013 -622.236 0.026
0.069
Human Labour
0.874* 0.040
0.106 0.226** 0.097
F Value
129.03
24.65
R2
0.890*
0.889**
* and ** Significant at P=0.01 and P=0.05, respectively
MVP
9.071
0.021
0.007
0.012
the use of these inputs, keeping all the other inputs constant, could
increase the output of the crop by 0.87 per cent in case of human
labour, 0.05 per cent in case of plant protection and 0.02 per cent in
case of training/ pruning. The contribution of manures + fertilizers was
however found negative but significant (-0.056) thereby indicating that
one per cent increase of this input, keeping all other inputs constant,
could decrease the output by 0.06 per cent. It could be seen from the
Table 2 that marginal value productivity of plant protection (1.354),
training/ pruning (512.188) and human labour (0.085) were positive
thereby indicated that these inputs were utilized sub-optimally hence
additional use of these inputs could increase the output while that of
manures + fertilizers was negative (-1.845) hence indicating its excess
use and should be avoided to check the decrease in returns. These
results are supported by the findings of Ahmad and Mustafa (2006).
In case of kinnow in the age group of 10-14 years the R2 value worked
out to be 0.760, thereby indicated that 76.0 per cent of the total variation
in the production of kinnow, explained by the explanatory variables
under consideration. The regression coefficients for human labour
(0.245), manures + fertilizers (0.573) and training/ pruning (0.124)
with significantly positive sign indicated that with one per cent increase
in the use of these inputs, keeping all the other inputs constant, could
Complementary Copy
148
Resource use efficiency of orange and kinnow cultivation in Jammu region of J&K state
The result of regression function and marginal value
productivity of orange and kinnow falling in the category
of 15th-19th years have been given in Table 3. For this group,
production function was statistically significant having R2
value of 0.890 meaning that 89.0 per cent of the total variations
in the production of orange were explained by the explanatory
variables under consideration. The regression coefficients of
orange for human labour (0,874) and manures + fertilizers
(0.001) respectively with positive sign indicated that with
one per cent increase in the use of these two inputs, keeping
all the other inputs constant, could increase the output of the
orange crop to 0.87 and 0.01 per cent, respectively, though
non significant coefficients for manures + fertilizers revealed
that this input had negligible role in the production of orange
during this period. These results have been found supported
by the findings of Utomakili and Molua (1998) in banana.
The contribution of plant protection (0.002) and training/
pruning (-0.015) were negative and non-significant. These
findings have been in close conformity with Koujalagi et al.
(1999). All the regression coefficients taken together were
less than unity, thereby indicating operation of diminishing
returns. It could be seen from the Table 3 that marginal
value productivity of human labour (0.106) and manures +
fertilizers (0.040) were positive while that of plant protection
(-0.995) and training/ pruning (-622.236) were negative
hence indicating their excess use should be avoided to have
a check on fall of returns.
The regression coefficients of kinnow (Table 3) for human
labour (0.226), manures + fertilizers (0.263) and plant
protection (0.137) with positive sign indicated their under
utilization and with one per cent increase in the use of these
inputs keeping all the other inputs constant, could increase
the output of the kinnow crop to 0.23, 0.26 and 0.14 per cent,
respectively. The production function used was statistically
significant having R2 value as 0.889. The contribution of
training/ pruning (0.026) was however positive but nonsignificant. All the regression coefficients were less than
unity thereby indicating operation of diminishing returns.
Here, the marginal value productivity of all the explanatory
variables were positive with their value at Rs 0.01, 9.07,
0.02 and 0.07 in case of human labour, manures + fertilizers,
plant protection and training/ pruning, respectively which
meant that there is still a scope in investing in these inputs.
These finding are in close conformity with the results of
Iqbal (2009).
The estimates of regression function and marginal value
productivity of orange and kinnow falling in the category of
20th -24th year are presented in Table 4. The crop production
Table 4. Estimated regression coefficients of various factors, standard errors
and MVP of Orange and Kinnow production (20th-24th year)
Variables
Orange
Kinnow
Reg.
Stand MVP
Reg.
Stand MVP
Coeff. error
Coeff. error
Constant
-1.178** 0.567
1.619** 0.643
Manures + Fertilizers 0.054
0.057 59.545 0.710* 0.105 0.004
Plant Protection
-0.052
0.103 -0.003 0.156
0.135 0.006
Training/ Pruning
0.889* 0.074
0.098 0.005
0.090 0.020
Human Labour
43.86
46.29
F Value
0.733*
0.872*
R2
0.890*
0.889**
* and ** Significant at P=0.01 and P=0.05, respectively
Table 5. Estimated regression coefficients of various factors, standard errors
and MVP of Orange and Kinnow production (25th -28th year)
Variables
Orange
Kinnow
Reg.
Stand MVP
Reg.
Stand MVP
Coeff. error
Coeff. error
Constant
-0.582 0.635
-0.575
0.785
Manures + Fertilizers 0.173* 0.064 203.462 0.025
0.084 0.042
Plant Protection
-0.158 0.115
-0.010 -0.143
0.162 -1.079
Human Labour
0.723* 0.064
0.365 0.751* 0.086 0.498
F Value
33.76
58.35
R2
0.678*
0.727*
* and ** Significant at P=0.01 and P=0.05, respectively
Table 6. Estimated regression coefficients of various factors, standard errors
and MVP of Orange and Kinnow production (overall)
Variables
Orange
Kinnow
Reg.
Stand MVP
Reg.
Stand MVP
Coeff. error
Coeff. error
Constant
-0.399
0.387
2.991* 0.084
Manures + Fertilizers 0.012
0.013 110.452 -0.024
0.021 -0.027
Irrigation
- 0.012
0.009 -0.054 0.016
0.011 0.025
Plant Protection
0.013
0.011 0.076 0.015
0.019 0.014
Training/ Pruning
-0.050* -0.017 -0.638 0.138* 0.011 0.175
Human Labour
0.955* 0.094 0.185 0.029** 0.014 0.031
F Value
27.61
35.61
R2
0.687*
0.736*
* and ** Significant at P=0.01 and P=0.05, respectively
function used was found statistically significant having R2 value as
0.733 which means that 73.3 per cent of the total variation in the
production of orange was explained by the explanatory variables
under consideration. The results further showed that the regression
coefficients of human labour and manures + fertilizers with positive
sign were 0.889 and 0.054, respectively which indicate that with one
per cent increase in the use of these two inputs, the output could be
increased by their respective coefficients. The regression coefficient
of plant protection (-0.052) was negative and non significant indicated
its negligible role in production and over utilization. The marginal
value productivity of manures + fertilizers (59.545) and human labour
(0.098) indicated that an additional one rupee spent on them could
increase the gross return by Rs 59.54 per acre and Rs 0.01 per acre,
respectively. Hence, there was scope of investing more on manures +
fertilizers and human labour.
Results of regression coefficients of kinnow in the age group of 2024 years (Table 4) showed that the production function used was
statistically significant having R2 value as 0.872 meaning that 87.2 per
cent of the total variation in the production for kinnow was explained
by the explanatory variables under consideration. The table further
revealed that the regression coefficients of human labour (0.005),
manures + fertilizers (0.710) and plant protection (0.156) with positive
sign indicated that with one per cent increase in the use of these inputs,
Complementary Copy
increase the output of the crop by 0.25, 0.57 and 0.12 per
cent, respectively. The contribution of plant protection
(-0.005) was negative and non significant. Similar findings
were reported by Koujalagi et al. (1999). It could be further
seen from the Table 2 that marginal value productivity of
human labour (0.003), manures + fertilizers (0.996), and
training/ pruning (0.009) with positive sign revealed that one
rupee spent on these inputs could increase the returns by Rs
0.003, 0.99 and 0.01, respectively while as plant protection
(-0.0002) with negative sign indicated its excess use.
149
Resource use efficiency of orange and kinnow cultivation in Jammu region of J&K state
the output could be increased by 0.01 per cent, 0.71 per cent and
0.16 per cent, respectively. The marginal value productivity of all
the explanatory variables was observed positive. This showed that
additional one rupee spent on these inputs would add to the gross
returns by Rs 0.004, 0.01 and 0.02 in case of manures + fertilizers,
plant protection and human labour, respectively. Ahmad and
Mustafa (2006) also recorded the similar observations.
The calculated values of regression analysis of orange falling in
the age group of 25-28 years (Table 5) showed that the production
function used was statistically significant having R2 value 0.678.
It means that 67.8 per cent of the total variation in the production
of orange was explained by the explanatory variables under
consideration. The estimates further revealed that regression
coefficients of human labour (0.723) and manures + fertilizers
(0.173) with positive significant sign indicated that with one per
cent increase in the use of these two inputs, could have increased
output by 0.72 per cent and 0.17 per cent, respectively. The
regression coefficient of plant protection (-0.158) was negative
and non significant. It could be observed that MVP of manures
+ fertilizers (203.46) and human labour (0.365) indicated that
an additional one rupee spent on manures + fertilizers could add
to the gross return by Rs 203.46, while that of human labour
indicated that an additional one rupee spent on human labour
could increase the returns by Rs 0.37 per acre and hence there
was scope of investing more on manures + fertilizers as well as
on human labour.
Regression coefficients of kinnow in the age group of 25-28 years
depicted in Table 5 showed that the production function used was
statistically significant having R2 value (0.727) meaning that 72.7
per cent of the total variations in the production for kinnow was
explained by the explanatory variables under consideration. The
regression coefficients of human labour (0.751) and manures
+ fertilizers (0.025) with positive sign indicated that with one
per cent increase in the use of these two inputs, the return of
output could be increased by 0.75 per cent and 0.03 per cent,
respectively. The human labour contribution was significant in
the kinnow production where as manures + fertilizers contribution
was not significant in its production. The regression coefficient of
plant protection (-0.143) was negative and non significant. The
MVP of human labour (0.50) and manures + fertilizers (0.04)
indicated that an additional one rupee spent on human labour
could add to the gross return by Rs 0.50, while that of manures
+ fertilizers indicated that an additional one rupee spent on it
could increase the returns by Rs 0.04 per acre and hence there was
scope of investing more on human labour as well as on manures
+ fertilizers, but spending on plant protection could decrease the
returns by Rs 1.08 per acre.
The coefficients of regression analysis and MVP for overall
groups of orange and kinnow are furnished in Table 6. It showed
that the production function used was statistically significant
having R2 value (0.687), indicating that 68.7 per cent of the total
variations in the production function for orange was explained
by the above mentioned explanatory variables. The regression
coefficients for human labour, manures + fertilizers and plant
protection with positive sign were 0.955, 0.012 and 0.013,
respectively. It indicates that with one per cent increase in the use
of these inputs, the output could be increased by 0.96 per cent in
case of human labour and 0.01 per cent each in other two inputs.
The regression coefficient of training/ pruning (-0.050) were
found negative but significant. It indicates that this input was
significant in the production of orange but it was used at more
than optimum level, whereas that of irrigation (-0.012) was
negative and non significant. The MVP as shown in Table 6
indicated that an additional one rupee spent on manures +
fertilizers, human labour and plant protection could add to
gross returns by Rs 110.45, 0.19 and 0.08, respectively, hence
there was scope of investing more on these inputs. The MVP
of irrigation (-0.054) and training/ pruning (-0.638) indicated
that with an additional one rupee invested on these inputs
would reduce the gross returns and hence should be checked.
These findings are in close conformity with Chinappa and
Ramanna (1997).
The results of regression coefficients of overall group of kinnow
depicted in Table 6 indicated that the production function used
was statistically significant having R2 value as 0.736 meaning that
73.6 per cent of the total variations in the production function
for kinnow was explained by the explanatory variables under
consideration. Regression coefficients of human labour (0.029),
irrigation (0.016), plant protection (0.015) and training/ pruning
(0.138) with positive sign indicated that with one per cent
increase in the use of these inputs, the output could be increased
by 0.03 per cent, 0.02 per cent, 0.02 per cent and 0.14 per cent,
respectively though only human labour and training/ pruning
contributed significantly in kinnow production for the whole life
of this orchard. The manures + fertilizers (-0.024) with negative
and non significant regression coefficient implied its negligible
contribution in the production of kinnow. These findings are in
close conformity with Koujalagi et al. (1999). The MVP as shown
in Table 6 indicated that an additional one rupee spent on human
labour, plant protection, training/ pruning and irrigation may add
Rs 0.03, Rs 0.01, Rs 0.18 and Rs 0.03 per acre, respectively, to
gross returns, hence there was scope of investing more on these
inputs.
Conclusion and policy implications: The present study estimated
the importance of various inputs in orange and kinnow production
in Jammu region of J&K state. Estimates of Cobb-Douglas
production function indicated that human labour was significant
and underutilized in orange and kinnow in all age groups except
in the age group of 20th to 24th of kinnow where human labour
was found to be non significant and in the age group of 25th -28th,
manures and fertilizers were found to be non significant.
The farm resources such as human labour and manures + fertilizers
were underutilized in case of orange whereas as in case of kinnow
human labour, plant protection and irrigation were underutilized.
There was overutilization of other farm resources also, so rational
allocation of these resources is necessary. Also, growers must be
convinced about the need and utility of application of manures +
fertilizers in order to have more gains. The substitutability among
different input factors has to be seen in depth and technologists
should give enough thought in devising such strategies.
References
Ahmad, B. and K. Mustafa, 2006. Forecasting kinnow production in
Pakistan: An econometric analysis. Intl. J. Agr. Biol., 8(4): 455458.
APEDA, 2008. State-wise area, production and productivity of fruits.
APEDA. www.apeda.com.
Complementary Copy
150
Resource use efficiency of orange and kinnow cultivation in Jammu region of J&K state
Iqbal, Mudasir, 2009. Investment Appraisal Of Mango And Ber Fruit
Production in Jammu District of J&K state. M.Sc. Thesis. Shere-Kashmir University of Agricultural Sciences and Technology of
Jammu, Jammu, India, 2009. 125pp.
Koujalgi, C.B., R.S. Poddar and V.R. Kiresur, 1999. Profitability of
production of marketing of pomegranate orchards in Bijapur district,
Karnataka. Indian J. Agril. Economics, 58(4): 811.
Prasher, R.S., M. Thomas and Y.S. Negi, 2006. Estimation of supply
functions for Himachal apples. Indian J. Economics, pp. 433-451.
Utomakili, J.B. and E. Molua, 1998. Analysis of resource use efficiency in
banana Musa Sp. (AAA group) production in the south-east province
of Cameroon: A case study. Intl. J. Trop. Agr., 16(1-4): 113-118.
Wani, G.M. 2008. Past, Present and Future of Horticultural Development
in J&K, India. www.buzzle.com.
Received: October, 2011; Revised: June, 2012; Accepted: July, 2012
Complementary Copy
Economic Survey, 2009. Directorate of Economics and Statistics,
Ministry of Agriculture, Govt. of India.
Economic Survey, 2010. Directorate of Economics and Statistics,
Ministry of Agriculture, Govt. of India.
Banerjee, G.D. 2009. Poised for a golden revolution. Times Agr. J.,
20-21.
Braddock, R.J. 1999. Handbook. of Citrus By-products and Processing
Technology. John Wiley & Sons, Inc. p.247.
Chinnapa, B. and R. Rammana, 1997. An economic analysis of guava
production. Agril. Banker, 21(3): 29-33.
Choubey, Manish and B.R. Atteri, 2000. Economic evaluation of litchi
production in Bihar. The Bihar J. Agril. Mrktg., 8(2): 123-131.
Economos, C. and W.D. Clay, 1999. Nutritional and health benefits of
citrus fruits. FAO, Food, Nutrition Agr., 24: 11-16.
Gorinstein, S., O. Martin-Belloso, Y. Park, R. Haruenkit, A. Lojek, I.
Milan, A. Caspi, I. Libman and S. Trakhtenberg, 2001. Comparison
of some biochemical characteristics of different citrus fruits. Food
Chemistry, 74(3): 309-315.
151
Journal
Journal of Applied Horticulture, 14(2): 152-156, 2012
Appl
Enha nc ing w at e r re lat ions a nd va se life of c ut t ulip (Tulipa
ge sne ria na L.) using fl ora l pre se r vat ive s
R. Kum a r* , N . Ahm e d, D.B. Singh a nd O.C. Sha r m a
Laboratory of Post Harvest Technology, Central Institute of Temperate Horticulture, Srinagar-190 007,
Jammu and Kashmir, India. *E-mail:
[email protected]
Abstract
The influence of different floral preservatives were assessed to determine their effect on the water relations and vase life of cut tulip cv.
Yellow Purissima. Uniform size scapes of tulip at bud colour break stage were kept in ten different treatments of floral preservatives
comprised of sucrose-(2, 4 and 6%), aluminium sulphate (100, 200 and 300 ppm) and 8-HQS (100, 200 and 300 ppm) along with control
(distilled water). All the preservatives improved water relations and vase life of cut tulip significantly in comparison to control. The
greatest cumulative water balance and maximum vase life were recorded in 8-HQS 300 ppm (10.5 g/scape and 10.1 days) followed by
aluminium sulphate 300 ppm (9.67 g/scape and 8.9 days) over control (2.53 g/scape and 5.4 days), respectively. Maximum fresh weight
change (10th day) was recorded in 8-HQS 300 ppm (105.13%) followed by aluminium sulphate 300 ppm (103.75%) in comparison to
control (89.91%). The floral preservatives delayed the senescence of cut tulip by improving water uptake and post harvest physiology,
thereby maintained better water balance leading to improved fresh weight and vase life.
Introduction
Tulip (Tulipa gesneriana L.) is an important bulbous flowering
crop owing to its wide range of cultivars having attractive colours
and exquisite shapes. It occupies 4th position among the top ten
cut flowers in global floriculture trade (Jhon and Neelofar, 2006).
In India, tulips are grown successfully in temperate regions of
Jammu and Kashmir, Himachal Pradesh and Uttrakhand. Like
other spring flowering bulbs, tulips are characterized by a short
vase life by tepal senescence i.e. change in colour followed by
dehydraton and tepal abscission (Iwaya-Inoue and Tikata, 2001).
The vase life and post harvest quality of cut tulip is an important
phenomenon of physiological process which depends upon
water uptake, transpirational loss of water and water balance.
Unlike fruits and vegetables, cut flowers are comprised of many
morphological units like- sepal, petal, androcium, gynocium, stem
and often leaves. The relationship among these parts determines
the water balance and ultimately quality of cut flowers (Khan et
al., 2007).
The floral preservatives are mainly composed of sugars, biocides
and acidifiers. Usually loss of turgor due to depletion of water
results in deterioration of quality and vase life of cut flowers.
Floral preservatives have been reported to maintain turgor,
water balance and thus prolong the cut flower life. These floral
preservatives reduce microbial growth, prevent vascular blockage
and improve water balance to keep the flower fresh for longer
duration (Patil, 2009). When cut flower is detached from the
plant, the continuity of water to flower is disrupted. Hence, water
relations play an important role in postharvest physiology of cut
flowers (Bhaskar et al., 1999). Exogenous supply of sucrose
balanced the depletion of carbohydrate and improved the vase
life and quality of many cut flowers (Van Doorn, 2004). Chua
(1971) suggested that 8-hydroxy quinoline sulphate (8-HQS) has
cytokinin like activity in retarding senescence in cut flowers. HQS
has also been reported to inhibit ethylene production (Wilkins,
1973). Aluminium sulphate overcome the water stress through
its effect as germicides (Mukhophadhyay, 1982) and thereby
encouraging continuous water transport through the cut stem.
Hence, the present attempt was made to study the role of sucrose,
aluminimum sulphate and 8-HQS in maintaining water relations
for improving the keeping quality of cut tulips.
Materials and methods
Tulip cv. Yellow Purissima was grown during 2009-2011 in
the experimental farm of CITH, Srinagar using recommended
growing practices. Tulip scapes were harvested at bud colour
break stage in the morning during third week of March. The
flowers were precooled at 5°C for about one hour to remove field
heat. Then scapes were sorted to uniform length of 25 cm and
lower leaves removed to prevent them touching the preservative
solution. After recording initial weight, scapes were placed in
conical flask (250 mL) containing vase solution of different floral
preservatives. Ten different treatments of floral preservatives were
as follows: T1 (sucrose 2 %), T2 (sucrose 4 %), T3 (sucrose 6 %),
T4 (aluminium sulphate 100 ppm), T5 (aluminium sulphate 200
ppm), T6 (aluminium sulphate 300 ppm), T7 (8-HQS 100 ppm),
T8 (8-HQS 200 ppm), T9 (8-HQS 300 ppm) and T0 control
(distilled water).
The experiment was laid out in Completely Randomized Design
(CRD) with three replications and five scapes constituted one
sample unit. The flask were plugged with cotton and covered
with aluminium foil to prevent loss of water due to evaporation.
The experiment was conducted in the laboratory of Postharvest
Technology, CITH, Srinagar at temperature 16 ± 2° with relative
humidity 70 ± 5 under natural light. The weight of each container
Complementary Copy
Key words: Floral preservatives, sucrose, aluminium sulphate, 8-HQS, Tulipa gesneriana, water relations, vase life
Enhancing water relations and vase life of cut tulip
The difference between the initial and consecutive volume of
solution in the flask was recorded as water uptake expressed
as g/scape and the difference between consecutive weights of
flask with solution plus flower scape recorded as transpirational
loss of water (g/scape). The water balance in the flower scape
was computed by subtracting the transpirational loss of water
from water uptake. The fresh weight change, measured by the
difference between initial and the consecutive fresh weight
of scape, was expressed as per cent of fresh weight of scape
taking original as 100 per cent. The termination of vase life was
considered when tepals started wilting, falling and discolouration
etc. Data obtained were analyzed statistically by the methods
suggested by Gomez and Gomez (1984).
Results and discussion
Water uptake: Analysis of data revealed that different floral
preservatives had significant influence on water relations and
vase life of cut tulips. The water uptake by tulip scapes was
significantly affected by different preservatives and the increasing
concentration of preservatives improved water uptake. On the
first day, the water uptake was recorded maximum (Table 1).
Among all the treatments, the maximum uptake was found in 8HQS 300 ppm (7.20 g/scape) followed by 8-HQS 200 ppm (6.72
g/scape) and was at par with control. There was no significant
difference in the water uptake between 8-HQS 200 ppm and
8-HQS 300 ppm and similar trend was also observed among
different concentration of aluminium sulphate. Minimum water
uptake was recorded with sucrose 2 % (5.15 g/scape) followed by
sucrose 4 % (5.20 g/scape). On the whole, all treatments showed
a decreasing trend of water uptake up to 5th day and thereafter a
slight increase on 6th day was observed with all the treatments.
On day 8th, water uptake increased with different concentrations
of aluminium sulphate and 8-HQS. While decreased water
uptake was recorded with different concentrations of sucrose and
control on 8th day. On day 7th, 9th and 10th, all treatments recorded
decreased water uptake.
The highest cumulative water uptake was found in 8-HQS 300
ppm (48.61 g/scape) followed by 8-HQS 200 ppm (43.37 g/scape)
and minimum in sucrose 2% (28.37 g/scape) (Fig.1). This may
be attributed to the fact that 8-HQS and aluminium sulphate
acidifies the holding solution and act as biocides and keep it free
from micro-organism and thus helps in preventing the plugging
of conducting tissues (Bhaskar et al., 1999). Increased water
uptake was reported with application of 8-HQS (0.4 %) in daisy
by Patil (2009) and 8-HQS (200 ppm) application in gerbera
cut flowers by Prasanth et al. (2009). Increased water uptake
maintains turgidity, freshness of flowers and thus enhances vase
life of cut tulips owing to improved water balance and postharvest
physiology.
Transpirational loss of water (TLW): The tulip scapes held in
different preservatives treatments differed significantly on TLW
(Table 2). On each day, among different preservatives, maximum
TLW was recorded with 8-HQS followed by aluminium sulphate
and sucrose. On first day maximum TLW was recorded with
8-HQS 300 ppm (4.68 g/scape) followed by 8-HQS 200 ppm
(4.37 g/scape), which were at par with control and minimum
TLW was recorded with sucrose 2% (3.05 g/scape). There were
no significant differences among different concentrations of
8-HQS and similar tendency was also reported with different
concentration of aluminium sulphate and sucrose. On 2nd day,
again maximum TLW was recorded with 8-HQS 300 ppm (4.45
g/scape) followed by 8-HQS 200 ppm (4.26 g/scape) but were
differed significantly over control (2.80 g/scape). On 3rd day,
maximum TLW was recorded with 8-HQS 300 ppm (4.29 g/
scape) and minimum with control (2.19 g/scape). On 4th and 5th
day, maximum TLW was recorded with 8-HQS 300 ppm (3.56
and 3.48 g/scape) and minimum with sucrose 4 % (1.73 and 1.78
g/scape), respectively. On 6th day, maximum TLW was noticed
with 8-HQS 300 ppm (4.95 g/scape) followed by 8-HQS 200 ppm
Table 1. Effect of floral preservatives on water uptake of tulip cut flower (g/scape)
Treatment
Days after keeping scape in preservative solution
T0-Control
1
6.83
2
4.80
3
3.60
4
3.46
5
2.81
6
3.20
7
1.60
8
1.50
9
1.10
10
0.80
T1-2 % Sucrose
5.15
4.90
4.30
3.20
2.92
3.10
1.70
1.10
1.30
0.70
T2-4 % Sucrose
5.20
4.98
4.40
3.25
3.00
3.32
1.60
1.20
1.40
0.90
T3-6 % Sucrose
5.80
5.30
4.70
3.65
3.31
3.47
1.75
1.31
1.20
0.95
T4-Alumunium sulphate 100 ppm
6.16
5.80
5.55
4.30
3.77
4.00
2.70
3.70
2.28
2.00
T5-Alumunium sulphate 200 ppm
6.20
5.91
5.68
4.34
3.82
4.03
3.15
3.60
2.40
1.80
T6-Alumunium sulphate 300 ppm
6.25
6.05
5.75
4.40
3.95
4.22
2.81
3.42
2.27
1.90
T7-8-HQS 100 ppm
6.50
6.10
5.92
4.63
4.12
4.52
3.00
3.63
2.10
1.80
T8-8-HQS 200 ppm
6.72
6.32
6.10
4.87
4.31
4.81
2.80
3.50
2.22
1.72
T9-8-HQS 300 ppm
7.20
6.80
6.42
5.40
4.80
5.22
3.32
4.25
2.80
2.40
LSD (P=0.05)
0.62
0.20
0.15
0.62
0.15
0.16
0.10
0.08
0.07
0.11
Complementary Copy
with and without flower scape were recorded daily up to 10th
day, when more than 90% scapes lost their keeping quality as
indicated by tepal fall, discolouration, wilting and scruffy form.
Keeping quality of flowers was determined by flower size, shape,
condition, longevity, colour, texture, appearance, water balance,
fresh weight and wilting.
153
154
Enhancing water relations and vase life of cut tulip
Table 2. Effect of floral preservatives on transpirational water loss of tulip cut flower (g/scape)
Days after keeping scape in preservative solution
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
T0-Control
4.76
2.80
2.19
3.04
2.91
3.42
1.98
2.80
1.62
1.63
T1-2 % Sucrose
3.05
3.10
2.76
2.00
2.12
2.99
1.78
1.25
1.60
1.11
T2-4 % Sucrose
3.06
2.98
2.78
1.73
1.78
3.11
1.72
1.41
1.72
1.48
T3-6 % Sucrose
3.62
3.26
2.93
1.98
2.01
3.13
1.93
1.55
1.72
1.75
T4-Alumunium sulphate 100 ppm
3.91
3.88
3.85
2.58
2.91
3.90
2.52
3.74
2.38
2.17
T5-Alumunium sulphate 200 ppm
3.89
3.78
3.92
2.46
2.62
3.88
2.89
3.66
2.55
2.01
T6-Alumunium sulphate 300 ppm
3.78
3.80
3.81
2.67
2.68
3.99
2.44
3.51
2.47
2.22
T7-8-HQS 100 ppm
4.20
4.13
4.22
2.88
3.32
4.33
2.77
3.71
2.26
1.99
T8-8-HQS 200 ppm
4.37
4.26
4.27
2.93
3.19
4.53
2.55
3.44
2.34
1.88
T9-8-HQS 300 ppm
4.68
4.45
4.29
3.56
3.48
4.95
2.93
4.12
2.99
2.66
LSD (P=0.05)
0.59
0.15
0.15
0.18
0.09
0.12
0.12
0.11
0.10
0.13
(4.53 g/scape) and minimum with sucrose 2% (2.99 g/scape). On
8th, 9th and 10th day, maximum TLW was recorded with 8-HQS
300 ppm (4.12, 2.99 and 2.66 g/scape) and minimum with sucrose
2% (1.25, 1.60 and 1.11 g/scape), respectively.
The highest cumulative TLW found in 8-HQS 300 ppm (38.11
g/scape) followed by 8-HQS 100 ppm (33.81 g/scape) and
minimum in sucrose 2% (21.76 g/scape) (Fig.1). Patil (2009)
and Prasanth et al. (2009) also obtained increased water loss by
8-HQS (0.4 % and 200 ppm) application in daisy and gerbera cut
flowers, respectively. It is apparent from the study that besides
increased water uptake, reduction in TLW helps in improving
water balance and is essential for extending the vase life of
cut flowers. However, water uptake and TLW both were high
in 8-HQS but the improved water balance in 8-HQS helped in
improving the turgidity and freshness, and ultimately enhanced
vase life of cut tulip.
Water balance: Among all the treatments, 8-HQS (200 and 300
ppm) maintained positive water balance up to 8th day; aluminium
sulphate and 8-HQS (100 ppm) maintained positive water balance
up to 7th day, whereas sucrose maintained positive water balance
up to 6th day. In control positive water balance was maintained up
to 4th day only (Table 3). On first day, maximum water balance
was recorded with 8-HQS 300 ppm (2.52 g/scape) followed by
alumunium sulphate 300 ppm (2.47 g/scape) and minimum with
control (2.06 g/scape). There were no significant differences
among the concentrations of each one preservative. On 2nd and
3rd day, maximum water balance was recorded with 8-HQS 300
ppm (2.35 and 2.13 g/scape) followed by alumunium sulphate
300 ppm (2.25 and 1.93 g/scape), respectively. On 4th day, water
balance was recorded maximum with 8-HQS 200 ppm (1.94 g/
scape) followed by alumunium sulphate 200 ppm (1.88 g/scape)
and minimum with control (0.42 g/scape). All preservatives
improved water balance over control but there were no significant
differences among different preservative treatments except 8HQS 200 ppm which was statistically superior from sucrose 2 %.
On 5th day, maximum water balance was recorded with 8-HQS
300 ppm (1.32 g/scape) followed by alumunium sulphate 300
ppm (1.27 g/scape) and minimum with control (-0.10 g/scape).
On 6th day, maximum water balance was recorded with sucrose
6 % (0.34 g/scape) followed by 8-HQS 200 ppm (0.28 g/scape)
and minimum with control (-0.22 g/scape). On 7th and 8th day
maximum water balance was recorded with 8-HQS 300 ppm
(0.39 and 0.13 g/scape) and minimum with control (-0.38 and
-1.30 g/scape), respectively. On 9th and 10th day, all the treatments
maintained negative water balance.
Table 3. Effect of floral preservatives on water balance of tulip cut flower (g/scape)
Treatment
Days after keeping scape in preservative solution
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
T0-Control
2.06
2.00
1.40
0.42
-0.10
-0.22
-0.38
-1.30
-0.52
-0.83
T1-2 % Sucrose
2.10
1.80
1.53
1.20
0.80
0.11
-0.08
-0.15
-0.24
-0.41
T2-4 % Sucrose
2.14
2.00
1.61
1.52
1.22
0.21
-0.12
-0.21
-0.28
-0.58
T3-6 % Sucrose
2.18
2.04
1.76
1.67
1.30
0.34
-0.18
-0.24
-0.45
-0.80
T4-Alumunium sulphate 100 ppm
2.25
1.92
1.69
1.72
0.86
0.10
0.18
-0.04
-0.07
-0.17
T5-Alumunium sulphate 200 ppm
2.31
2.13
1.75
1.88
1.20
0.15
0.26
-0.06
-0.13
-0.21
T6-Alumunium sulphate 300 ppm
2.47
2.25
1.93
1.73
1.27
0.23
0.37
-0.09
-0.17
-0.32
T7-8-HQS 100 ppm
2.30
1.97
1.70
1.75
0.80
0.19
0.23
-0.08
-0.16
-0.19
T8-8-HQS 200 ppm
2.35
2.06
1.83
1.94
1.12
0.28
0.25
0.06
-0.12
-0.16
T9-8-HQS 300 ppm
2.52
2.35
2.13
1.84
1.32
0.27
0.39
0.13
-0.19
-0.26
LSD (P=0.05)
0.25
0.28
0.21
0.70
0.16
0.17
0.13
0.15
0.17
0.18
Complementary Copy
Treatment
Enhancing water relations and vase life of cut tulip
155
The cumulative water balance was recorded highest with 8-HQS
300 ppm (10.50 g/scape) followed by alumunium sulphate 300
ppm (9.67 g/scape) and minimum with control (2.53 g/scape)
(Fig. 1). The variation in water balance might be on account of
different water uptake and water loss behaviour under treatments.
Active role of sugar in improving the water uptake and restricting
the stomatal closure might have resulted in improved water
balance. Antimicrobial agent (8-HQS and aluminium sulphate)
improved water balance by inhibiting vescular blockage (Wani
et al., 2010). Aluminium sulphate reduces transpiration and
improves water balance due to stomatal closure, thus keep flowers
afresh for a longer duration (Patil, 2009).
Fresh weight change: Change in fresh weight differed
significantly among the different treatments (Table 4). Increase in
fresh weight change was found up to 6th day and then decreased
sharply during 7th to 10th day in different treatments. On the whole,
tulip scapes kept in solution of 8-HQS and aluminium sulphate
maintained increased fresh weight over initial up to 9th day, while
sucrose maintained increased fresh weight over initial up to 7th day
as compared to control (up to 6th day). On 6th day, fresh weight
change was found maximum with 8-HQS 300 ppm (129.28
%) followed by aluminium sulphate 300 ppm (126.29 %) and
minimum with control (108.97 %). Treatments 8-HQS (200 and
300 ppm) and aluminium sulphate (200 and 300 ppm) maintained
increased fresh weight over initial on 10th day also, while other
treatments showed decreased fresh weight over initial on 10th
day. On tenth day, maximum fresh weight change was recorded
in 8-HQS 300 ppm (105.13%) followed by aluminium sulphate
300 ppm (103.75%) in comparison to control (89.91%). Stimart
(1983) reported that there was initial increase in fresh weight
changes followed by decline and increase being larger in flower
kept in preservatives than those kept in de ionised water. Decline
in fresh weight of scapes may be attributed to poorer water relation
parameters. 8-HQS might have reduced the physiological stem
plugging, whereas aluminium sulphate acted as antimicrobial
agent (Mukhopadhyay, 1982) and improved water uptake and
thereby maintained the improved fresh weight of scapes over
control. Decrease in pool of dry matter and respiratory substrate
especially in tepal might be considered as other important factors
responsible for decline in fresh weight of cut tulip.
A significant improvement in vase life of cut tulip was observed
due to various preservative treatments (Fig. 2). Floral preservative
showed their superiority in enhancing vase life and maximum
vase life was recorded in 8-HQS 300 ppm (10.1 days) followed
by aluminium sulphate 300 ppm (8.9 days), 8-HQS 200 ppm (8.8
days), aluminium sulphate 200 ppm (8.6 days) as compared to
control (5.4 days).
Table 4. Effect of floral preservative on fresh weight change (%) of tulip cut flower
Treatment
T0-Control
1
110.55
2
111.66
Days after keeping scape in preservative solution
3
4
5
6
7
8
113.03
116.13
119.64
108.97
97.20
95.02
9
93.59
10
89.91
T1-2 % Sucrose
109.66
112.12
113.25
116.46
120.16
122.67
114.36
99.64
97.73
96.43
T2-4 % Sucrose
109.83
112.50
113.42
116.62
120.74
123.81
115.00
104.97
99.55
97.73
T3-6 % Sucrose
110.02
113.10
113.86
117.45
121.98
124.75
114.97
108.06
99.44
99.83
T4-Alumunium sulphate 100 ppm
110.35
113.29
114.69
118.37
121.60
124.58
111.62
107.90
103.5
97.73
T5-Alumunium sulphate 200 ppm
110.63
113.57
116.18
119.11
122.04
125.49
115.24
111.35
106.00
102.37
T6-Alumunium sulphate 300 ppm
111.35
114.74
116.35
119.55
123.53
126.29
115.55
110.77
106.13
103.75
T7-8-HQS 100 ppm
114.30
116.28
116.90
120.33
122.65
125.30
117.15
109.88
104.47
99.66
T8-8-HQS 200 ppm
114.97
116.41
117.45
120.80
123.09
126.04
119.47
111.38
109.11
103.45
T9-8-HQS 300 ppm
115.19
116.40
117.48
123.81
124.91
129.28
119.66
114.36
106.35
105.13
4.25
2.71
0.32
0.45
0.52
0.41
0.38
1.37
0.48
0.41
LSD (P=0.05)
Complementary Copy
Fig. 1. Effect of floral preservatives on water uptake, TLW and water balance of cut tulip
156
Enhancing water relations and vase life of cut tulip
Fig. 2. Effect of floral preservatives on vase life of cut tulip
Depletion in sugar pool, plugging of vascular tissue by micro organism and
damage by ethylene have been identified as the major cause of poor keeping
quality of many cut flowers (Qadri et al., 2001 and Khan et al., 2007).
Applied sugar might have countered the depleted sugar and improved
vase life over control. While aluminium sulphate and 8-HQS improved
the water balance and protected the flower from microbial vascular
blockage and thus improved vase life of cut tulips. The fact of 8-HQS in
the improving the vase life of cut flowers may be attributed to its nature as
broad specturum bactericide and fungicide that reduce physiological stem
blockage by chelating metal ions of enzymes active in creating the stem
blockage (Marousky, 1972).
It is, therefore, concluded that improved water relations due to low
microbial activity in tulip scapes held in 8-HQS and aluminium sulphate
solutions lead to higher water potential in comparison to control. The floral
preservatives delayed the senescence of cut tulip by maintaining turgidity
and improving postharvest physiology of cut tulips. The preservatives
improved water uptake and thereby maintained better water balance
leading to improved fresh weight and vase life of cut tulips. Among all the
treatments, the greatest cumulative water balance and maximum vase life
were recorded in 8-HQS 300 ppm (10.5 g/scape and 10.1 days) followed by
aluminium sulphate 300 ppm (9.67 g/scape and 8.9 days) over control (2.53
g/scape and 5.4 days), respectively. Hence, enhanced water relations and
vase life of tulip can be achieved through the use of 300 ppm aluminium
sulphate and 8-HQS.
Bhaskar, V.V., P.V. Rao and Y.N. Reddy, 1999. Effect of minerals
on post harvest vase life of cut tuberose (Polianthes tuberosa
L.) cv. Double. Indian J. Horti., 56 (4): 368-374.
Chua, S.E. 1971. Cytokinin like activity of 8-hydroxy Quinoline
Sulphate. Nature, 225: 101.
Gomez, K.A. and A.A. Gomez, 1984. Statistical Procedures
for Agricultural Research. Second edition. John Wiley and
Sons. Inc., New York, USA.
Iwaya-inoue, M. and M. Tikata, 2001. Trehalose and
chloremphenicol prolong the vase life of tulip flowers.
HortScience, 36: 946-950.
Jhon, A.Q. and Neelofar, 2006. Tulip. In: Advances in
Ornamental Horticulture, Vol. 3: Bulbous Ornamental
and Aquatic Plants, S.K. Bhattacharjee (eds). Pointers
Publishers, Jaipur-302 003 (Raj.), India. p.1-72.
Khan, F.U., F.A. Khan, N. Hayat and S.A. Bhat, 2007.
Influence of certain chemicals on vase life of cut tulip.
Indian J. Plant Physiol., 12(2): 127-132.
Marousky, F.J. 1972. Water relations, effect of floral preservative
on bud opening and keeping quality of cut flowers.
HortScience, 7: 114-116.
Mukhopadhyay, T.P. 1982. Effect of chemicals on flower
development and vase life of tuberose (Polyanthus tuberosa
L.) var. Single. South Indian Horticulture.30: 281-284.
Patil, V.S. 2009. Effect of chemical preservatives on vase life
of daisy (Aster amellus L.) flowers. Journal Ornamental
Horticulture, 12(1): 54-58.
Prasanth, P., R. Chandrasekhar and K.C.S. Reddy, 2009. Effect
of postharvest application of biocides on water relations and
vase life of cut gerbera (Gerbera jamesonii Bolus ex Hook.).
Journal Research, SKUAST-J, 8(1): 40-49.
Qadri, Z.A., A.Q. John and Z.A. Rather, 2001. Effect of
chemicals on longevity of cut Dutch iris. Journal
Ornamental Horticulture, 4(1): 40-43.
Stimart, P. 1983. Effect of physiological factors on flower zinnia.
Journal Horticultural Sciences, 14: 62-73.
Van Doorn, W.G. 2004. Is petal senescence due to sugar
starvation? Plant Physiol., 134: 35-42.
Wani, S.A., M.A.A. Siddique, F.U. Khan, Z.A. Qadri, F.A.
Khan, Q.A.H. Dar and S. Ali, 2010. Effect of various floral
preservatives on post harvest quality of Asiatic lilium cv.
Novecento. Journal Ornamental Horticulture, 13(1): 55-58.
Wilkins, H.F. 1973. Proceedings of workshop on postharvest
physiology of floral crops. HortScience, 8: 189-205.
Received: March, 2012; Revised: October, 2012;
Accepted: November, 2012
Complementary Copy
References