Conference Reports
45
45
Final Report of The IGCP - 499 – Devonian Land-Sea Interactions:
Evolution of Ecosystems and Climate (DEVEC)
Introduction
The Devonian period is one of the most
interesting systems in Earth history. It is
widely considered as a time of global
greenhouse climates, lacking any significant
ice shields, even when recently a discussion
on icehouse-related sea-level fluctuations –
not only near the Devonian/Carboniferous
boundary – has evolved (Elrick et al., 2009,
Joachimski et al., 2009). In any case it was
characterized by extensive shallow marine
and continental lowland areas yielding a wide
range of different habitats. Following the
work of numerous individuals and regional
groups which have been established within
IGCP 421, led by John Talent and Raimund
Feist, a group of scientists proposed a new
successor project (IGCP 499) in order to
develop a better understanding of marine and
terrestrial ecosystems, and the influence on
sedimentation in both the terrestrial and
marine realms. Within the marine realm this
included the neritic-pelagic correlation. An
important focus of the project concerned the
interrelated evolution of terrestrial and marine
palaeoecosystems with respect to biotic and
abiotic factors requiring high-resolution
stratigraphic control and detailed analysis of
different facies settings. The work on the rapid
evolution of early ecosystems on land and
their interaction with sedimentary processes,
climate, and palaeogeography, both on land
and in marine settings, was scheduled for the
duration of the project (2004 – 2009). For
that reason studies included individual
palaeoecosystems and their components as
well as their palaeo-biogeographic distribution which should provide a better understanding of the Devonian system with respect
to the evolution of palaeoecosystems and to
palaeogeographical and palaeoclimatical
changes. The project was developed in close
collaboration with the Sub-commission on
Devonian Stratigraphy (SDS) and many
workshops were organized worldwide
(Fig. 1), some of them as joint IGCP 499/
SDS meetings.
IGCP 499 meetings and
workshops
The inaugural meeting took place in
Rabat, Morocco, in conjunction with the
Subcommission on Devonian Stratigraphy
(SDS). The meeting was connected with a
field workshop in the Dra Valley of the Anti
Atlas Mountains. Both were perfectly
organized by Ahmed El Hassani, Rabat (El
Hassani, 2004). As a result of this meeting a
Special Volume was published on “Devonian
events and correlations” edited by Becker and
Kirchgasser (2007). In October 2004 the first
business meeting of the project was held at
the University of Göttingen, Germany, during
the annual meeting of the Paläontologische
Gesellschaft, and was attended by about 40
colleagues from 9 countries. Presentations
and discussions focused on the activities
during the initial phase of the project and how
forthcoming activities can be coordinated. In
order to channel the work within IGCP 499
which covered a wide range of scientific
disciplines, guidelines were established
providing different working groups/regional
coordinators which provided a better
coordination of forthcoming field meetings
and workshops. Furthermore, in the first year
we presented the new project in conjunction
with several conferences, such as the 11th
International Palynological Congress in
Granada, Spain; the 32 nd International
Geological Congress, Firenze, Italy; the
Geological Society of America in Denver,
Figure 1. IGCP 499 field meetings and workshops (2004 – 2009).
Episodes Vol. 33, no. 1
46
September, 26th - October, 03rd,
2005. The workshop was attended
by about 50 colleagues, mainly
from Turkey, but also from
Bulgaria, Germany, Lithuania,
Morocco, and the USA. There
have been about 20 oral
contributions and several posters
covering major aspects of the
subject with a special focus on the
Devonian of Turkey and adjacent
areas. The official part of the
workshop and field trip was
followed by an extended field
Figure 3. Field excursion in the northwestern Turkey
workshop (Fig. 3) in the
(Photograph courtesy of P. Königshof)
framework of a bilateral Turkishwith numerous new data and stimulating
German cooperation project (DEVEC-TR/
scientific ideas, e.g. on carbon isotope
2005 – 2008) coordinated by V. Wilde and
stratigraphy, climate fluctuations, sedimentoM.N. Yalçin. In the following years several
logy and microfacies, palaeoecology and mass
field campaigns and some workshops took
extinction events were presented. The
place in the course with this satellite project.
abstracts of the contributions to the T7
Some other meetings have been organized
session are published in the IPC abstract
in conjunction with International Congresses.
volume (Qun Yang et al., 2006). Other
The first North American meeting of the
workshop activities have been incorporated
project was integrated in a symposium entitled
in smaller congress events. Embedded in the
“Correlation of Devonian Marine and
meeting of the “Commission International de
Terrestrial Strata” chaired by D.J. Over in
Microflore du Paleozoique” (CIMP) that took
June 2005 at the North American Paleontoplace in Praha 2006, a symposium was held
logical Convention in Halifax, Nova Scotia.
on “Palaeozoic Palynology” (Bek et al., 2006)
The next meeting of IGCP 499 was included
as some of the palynological topics of the
in the 6th Baltic Stratigraphic Conference,
held in St Petersburg, Russia, that was
meeting appeared to be very important for
recognition of marine – non marine sequences
coordinated by Z. Zigaite in the framework
and for correlation between different shallow
of IGCP 491. It was focused on midwater areas.
Palaeozoic vertebrates (coordinated by M.
Zhu and G. Young). IGCP 499 was represenSeveral other field meetings and
workshops followed and in 2007 two
ted by J. Lazauskiene who organised a
meetings were organized. A workshop was
business meeting.
held from May 14th to 22 nd in San Juan,
In order to intensify cooperation between
Argentina. The Devonian of the San Juan and
China and Germany a session on “Devonian
Mendoza Precordillera and the San Rafeal
land-sea interaction: evolution of ecosystems
Block was also a focus of the project
and climate” (session T7) was held on June
regarding the palaeogeographic and
17, 2006 in conjunction with the 2 nd
International Palaeontological Congress
biostratigraphic importance in the Devonian
(IPC) in Beijing, China. The
Malvinokaffric realm, but also in terms of the
successful and enjoyable session (21
tectonic-sedimentary evolution of the
oral and poster presentations) took
Precordillera terrane. A two-day symposium
place in the Yingjie Conference
in San Juan was followed by excursions to
Centre. There was a large positive
Western Argentina covering stratigraphic
response to our call, and the
sequences from the Early to Middle
convenors of the session (Peter
Palaeozoic (Fig. 4). The workshop was
Königshof and Xueping Ma) could
organized by colleagues of the Facultad de
welcome more than 30 colleagues
Ciencias Exactas, Fisicas y Naturales,
from Australia, Canada, China,
Universitdad Nacional de San Juan, Instituto
European countries and the USA.
de Geologia “Dr. Emiliano Pedro Aparicio
Far more talks were offered than
(INGEO), Instituto Superior de Correlacion
could be accommodated in the
Geologia (INSUGEO) of the Facultad de
single-session
programme.
Finally,
Ciencias Naturales e I.M.L. Universidad
Figure 2. Field camp in Ust‘-Sema, Gorny Altai,
15
talks
on
a
wide
range
of
topics
National de Tucuman, Consejo Nacional de
Russia (Photograph courtesy of P. Königshof)
USA, and we organised a joint meeting with
IGCP 503 at the University of Erlangen in
Erlangen, Germany.
In the following years numerous
workshops and conferences took place in
different countries (Fig. 1). In the tradition
of successful joint meetings and field trips of
Devonian IGCP projects and the SDS a
meeting was held at the Institute of Petroleum
Geology, United Institute of Geology and
Minerology of the Russian Academy of
Sciences, Siberian Branch in Novosibirsk on
“Devonian terrestrial and marine environments: From continent to shelf”. The meeting
which included a splendid field trip to the
South of Siberia (July 26 – August 6, 2005)
and well-organised technical sessions (August
7 – 8, 2005) was organised by a great group
from Novosibirsk under the guidance of
E.A. Yolkin, A.V. Kanygin, N.K. Bakharev,
N.G. Izokh and O.T. Obut (Yolkin et al.,
2005a, b). The field trip led the participants
to various Devonian outcrops in the Salair,
Rudny Altai, and Gorny Altai regions yielding
a great variety of rocks in different facies
settings (from nearshore/terrestrial to open
marine conditions) and from the Lower to the
Upper Devonian (Fig. 2). About 75 scientists
presented 35 oral lectures and 4 posters during
the meeting. Results of the conference are
published in a Special Issue of the Bulletin
of Geosciences (Königshof et al., 2008). In
the same year a workshop was organized in
Istanbul (Yalçin et al., 2005). The Devonian
of Turkey was of special interest for the
project because it is comprising Laurasian and
Gondwanan components on different tectonic
blocks. Therefore, an active group of
Devonian researchers was assembled in
Turkey by co-leader M.N. Yalçin to work on
the goals of IGCP-499. This was the reason
to hold a workshop on “Depositional
Environments of the Gondwanan and
Laurasian Devonian” in Istanbul from
March 2010
47
perfectly arranged by J.R. Morrow
and the co-leaders C.A. Sandberg,
J.E. Warme, M.A. Murphy, and
D.J. Over. The meeting in Eureka
was attended by about 45
colleagues from 11 countries who
presented 40 oral and 12 poster
contributions which covered the
whole array of Devonian research
topics. Among those papers
dealing with sea-level changes
and/or cyclic sedimentation,
stratigraphy, regional geology,
palaeontology as well as land-sea
Figure 4. Carboniferous sequneces of the Rio Seco de
interactions were strongly
los Castanos Formation, San Rafael Block, Mendoza
represented. On September 17th
Province, Argentina (Photograph courtesy of P.
the annual SDS meeting was held,
Königshof)
followed by a business meeting of
Investigaciones Cientificas y Tecnicas
IGCP 499. The six days field trip (Morrow,
(CONICET). A 120-page abstract volume and
2007), representing an essential part of the
a field guide book was published, edited by
entire conference, started in Las Vegas on
G. Acenolaza et al. (2007). As a result of this
September 9th. Various Devonian successions
in different areas were demonstrated,
meeting, many papers from different
highlighting some of the classical as well as
palaeogeographic settings have been
published in a special volume of the
recently studied sections.
The field trip route within the Great Basin
Geological Society of London (Königshof,
region (Basin and Range province) covered
2009).
primarily carbonate shelf settings including
As in previous years, a joint meeting of
IGCP 499 and the Subcommission on
reefs, and slope to basinal deposits of different
areas such as the Confusion Range and
Devonian Stratigraphy (SDS) was held in
September 2007 in Nevada. Three days of
Burbank Hills in Utah, Lincoln County and
technical sessions took place in the historical
Antelope Range in Nevada (Fig. 5). Special
Opera House of Eureka, Nevada (Over and
attention was paid to the impact related Alamo
Morrow, 2007). A pre-conference field trip
Breccia and to several sections spanning the
led to sections spanning most of the Devonian
Frasnian/Famennian boundary (besides
in northeastern Nevada and western Utah. The
others the classical locality at Devil’s Gate
meeting in Eureka was well-organized by D.J.
near Eureka). Furthermore, Lower to Middle
Over, Dept. of Geological Sciences, SUNY
Devonian strata including the Silurian/
Geneseo, New York, and J. Morrow, Dept. of
Devonian boundary were demonstrated. It
Geological Sciences, San Diego State
was especially impressive for the participants
University, California. The field trip was
to visit sections which whee initially
Figure 5: Devonian sections , Central Great Basin, Nevada, USA
(Photograph courtesy of E. Schindler)
Episodes Vol. 33, no. 1
introduced by some of the pioneers of western
US Devonian research (e.g., C.A. Sandberg).
In addition to the field activities in
Turkey and the lab work in Turkey and
Germany, a joint fieldtrip led four Turkish
colleagues to the Devonian of the Rheinisches
Schiefergebirge and the tidal flats of the
German North Sea. These activities in
Germany gave important support for a better
understanding of the Turkish sections studied
within the frame of the DEVEC-TR Project.
In 2008 IGCP 499 went again to NorthAfrica. A meeting was organized in Libya
(April 23 rd - 30 th, 2008). The workshop
(Belgasem, 2008) and the field trip (Ben
Rahuma et al., 2008) were devoted to the
stratigraphic evolution of Devonian
sequences in the Awaynat Wanin area,
Southern Ghadamis Basin with a focus on
sequence stratigraphy, sedimentology and
facies, and palaeoecology (Fig. 6). The
Devonian of Libya was of special interest
due to the excellent sequences mainly
representing very shallow water environments, but also including fluvial sequences
(land-sea transitional settings). The workshop
was held at the Libyan Petroleum Institute
(LPI) in Tripoli with an opening ceremony,
which included the welcome adresses by the
General manager of LPI, B.A. Belgasem,
and the coordinator of the meeting, A.D. El
Mehdawi. A 43-page abstract volume and a
67-pages field guide book have been
published. Scientists from seven countries
attended the meeting.
Another joint SDS/IGCP 499 meeting
took place in Uzbekistan from August 24th
and September 03rd, 2008. The meeting was
entitled “Global alignments of Lower
Devonian carbonate and clastic sequences”
and colleagues from nine countries attended
Figure 6: Devonian siliciclastic rocks of the Southern Ghadamis
Basin, Libya (Photograph courtesy of P. Königshof)
48
the meeting. The main focus has been on the
the revision of the GSSP at the base of the
Emsian Stage and on stratigraphy, sedimentology and facies development in the classical
area of the Kitab State Geological Reserve.
Other subjects emphasized in the conference
and the field trip concerned cyclicity and
sedimentary markers for intra- and interbasinal correlations, neritic/pelagic associations and their interrelations as well as global
sedimentary and biotic events. The scientific
session included 30 oral presentations and 18
posters. A 97-pages field guidebook (Yolkin
et al., 2008) and a 122-pages abstract volume
(Kim et al., 2008) has been published.
Finally, a conference at the end of the
regular term of IGCP 499 and IGCP 497 (on
the Rheic Ocean) was held in Frankfurt,
Germany. As orogenic events involved in the
history of the Rheic Ocean range from the
Avalonian-Cadomian orogenies in the Latest
Neoproterozoic up to the formation of
Pangaea in the Devonian-Carboniferous time.
These incising events within the Devonian
played a major role for the evolution of life,
climate, palaeogeography, and environmental
conditions. This was the main reason to
combine the final meetings of IGCP 497 and
of IGCP 499 under the heading “From
Gondwana and Laurussia to Pangaea:
Dynamics of Oceans and Supercontinents”.
Scientific session were related to the
following topics:
Palaeogeography and Supercontinents
during Late Precambrian and Palaeozoic
times
Palaeobiodiversity and Palaeoecology
Past climate and sea-level changes
Neritic-pelagic correlation
Land-Sea interactions
Diversification of early terrestrial ecosystems
Palaeozoic orogenic processes at the
northern margin of Gondwana
Birth of the Rheic Ocean: AvalonianCadomian orogenic processess and Early
Palaeozoic rifting at the northern
Gondwanan margin
Closure of the Rheic Ocean: Palaeozoic
drift and the Alleghenian-Variscan
orogenic processess during the Pangea
configuration
Geochronology, Isotope Geology and
Provenance Analysis in Late Neoproterozoic and Palaeozoic times
The conference took place from
September 30th to October 04th, 2008 at the
Senckenberg Natural History Museum,
Frankfurt am Main, Germany, followed by a
6 day post-conference field trip (Fig.7)
displaying a cross section through the RhenoHercynian Zone (Rhenish Massif, Avalonia,
Laurussia), the Mid-German Crystalline Zone
(suture zone of the Rheic Ocean), the SaxoThuringian Zone (Bohemian Massif,
Cadomia, Gondwana). 130 participants from
26 countries attended the meeting. This
Figure 7. Members of the joint IGCP 497 / 499 field trip in 2008 (Photograph courtesy of
P. Königshof)
meeting was of international interest and we
are proud that the meeting was co-sponsored
by the German Science Foundation. A 241pages abstract volume and a 159-pages field
trip guidebook have been published
(Königshof and Linnemann, 2008a, b). A
special volume of “Gondwanan Research”
devoted to that meeting was published
recently, edited by Damian Nance (D. Nance,
2010).
In January 2009 the project received the
status on extended term (OET). Even if we
did not receive funding, the leaders and other
colleagues organized two meetings in this
year. The first one took place in Cincinnati,
Ohio, from June 21-26 in conjunction with
the 9 th North American Paleontological
Convention (NAPC 2009) where two special
sessions had been organized. One session
was entitled “Rapid evolution of terrestrial
ecosystems and their influence on marine
realms – land-sea interactions in the
Devonian” chaired by R. Brocke, P.
Königshof, and J.E.A. Marshall, the other one
had the focus on “Biological response to
Devonian sea-level and paleoclimate changes,
chaired by R.T. Becker, E. Schindler, and C.E.
Brett. A special volume on sea level and
climate, cyclicity and bioevents in Middle
Devonian marine and terrestrial environments
will be published in 2010 (edited by Brett et
al. in prep).
In September 2009 a joint meeting of
IGCP 497, 499 and 503 entitled “Paleozoic
Seas Symposium” was organized by Th.J.
Suttner, B. Hubmann, and W. Piller at Graz,
Austria from September 14 th –18 th. The
symposium was followed by a field trip to
the Devonian of the Graz Palaeozoic and to
Carboniferous localities of the Carnic Alps.
Additionally, there have been many
activities in the regional and local working
groups in different countries over the past
years.
All in all, even if there are many open
questions left which especially concern the
land-sea transitional settings or sequence
stratigraphy vs. global bioevents, it should be
stressed that this project has been a highly
successful IGCP. Relationships of
regional geological features and open
questions with respect to biostratigraphy,
facies interpretation and depositional
environment, especially land-sea transitional
settings generated vivid discussions in all of
these meetings and workshops mentioned
above and helped identify topics requiring
future research. They also acted as a catalyst
for future collaborative research between
March 2010
49
groups all over the world, as well as offering
a network for collaboration between
researchers involved in the IGCP 499 and
forthcomming activities.
Furthermore, the last six years have
shown that successful research is based on
multidisciplinary cooperation. On the other
hand, there are many open questions left and
there are some disciplines where we should
concentrate research in the Devonian. Based
on a profound knowledge of organisms
sequence stratigraphic correlations should be
brought into agreement with available
biostratigraphic data. Another focal point
could be a better correlation between
terrestrial events and the correlation with
marine realms, and in the neritic settings we
need a better biostratigraphic and sedimentary
record. Palynomorphs are a useful tool in this
context. Another interesting aspect could
be the evolution of the terrestrial vegetation
and the interaction with the arthropods as well
as the evolution of early terrestrial ecosystems. The meetings and workshops of
IGCP 499 clearly have shown that there is a
huge potential for special topics requiring
future research and perhaps successor
project of IGCP 499.
Outreach activities
Regarding outreach activities we have
improved our main websites (English and
German version) and we have also linked our
website with other “geo-sites”. Additionally,
P. Königshof and T. Agricola compiled a
touring exhibition (Fig. 8) on German IGCP
projects for the general public. In this context,
also geological excursions for the general
public took place. Several TV reports and
numerous reports in newsletters resulted from
this initiative. The touring exhibition was a
contribution to the International Year of Planet Earth
(IYPE). A short exhibition
guide as pdf-file is available.
Publications
Since 2004 more than
550 peer reviewed papers
(Fig. 9) have been published
representing the improved
knowledge on the following
topics:
Figure 9. In the framework of the IGCP 499 more than 550
climate change and events peer reviewed papers have been published.
during the Devonian
characterization of facies in marineFurthermore, we would like to express
terrestrial transitions and their correlaour thanks to the following companies and
tion
institutions for sponsoring: UNESCO/IUGS,
sea-level changes in the Devonian on
German Science Foundation (DFG), German
global and regional scale
Federal Foreign Office.
rapid evolution on early life on land and
its interaction with sedimentary processes
Peter Königshof, E. Schindler, E.
case studies of complex palaeoecosystems
and V. Wilde
in different palaeogeographic settings and
Forschungsinstitut und Naturmuseum
their correlation
Senckenberg,
biostratigraphic control in different facies
Senckenberganlage 25, 60325 Frankfurt
realms
Email:
[email protected]
Many more publications are expected
Email:
[email protected];
in the near future (e.g., edited volumes by
Email:
[email protected]
Brett et al., 2010). The references contain a
list of published conference volumes and
J. Lazauskiene
field trip guide books as well as Special
Geological Survey, Lithuania,
volumes.
Konaskio 35, Vilnius, LT-2009;
Email:
[email protected]
Acknowledgements
The leaders of the IGCP 499 would like
to express their thanks to the various
institutions and numerous colleagues who
helped to organize many meetings. For all
participants the workshops and accompanying field trips offered an unique opportunity
to get an insight into
complex Devonian
sequences at many
places around the
world. Cordial thanks
are expressed to the
local specialists for
the organization and
guidance of the field
trips. We are grateful
to these and many
other individuals who
helped to make the
workshops both,
successful and highly
Figure 8. Touring exhibition “Planet Earth” on IGCP projects with enjoyable. Thank you
German leaders or co-leaders (Photograph courtesy of P. Königshof). all again!
Episodes Vol. 33, no. 1
M. Namik Yalçin,
Istanbul University, Engeneering Faculty,
Department of Geological Engeneering,
TR 34850 Avcilar, Istanbul;
Email:
[email protected]
References
Acenolaza, G., del Milagro Vergel, M.,
Peralta, S. and Herbst, R, 2007, Devonian
land-sea interaction: evolution of ecosystems and climate – Field meeting,
Argentina, 2007, Abstract and Field trip
Guide Book, 1-119, University San Juan,
Argentina.
Becker, R.T. and Kirchgasser, W.T. [eds],
2007, Devonian Events and Correlations.
Geological Society of London, Special
Publication, 278, 1-280.
Bek, J., Brocke, R., Daskova, J. and Fatka,
O. [eds], 2006, Palaeozoic Palynology in
Space and Time, CIMP General Meeting,
2006, Spetember 02.-06., 2006 Prague,
abstract volume, 1-67, Praha, Czech
Republic.
50
Belgasem, B.A., 2008, Devonian land-sea
interaction: evolution of ecosystems and
climate (DEVEC). Libyan Petroleum
Institute (LPI), April, 23.-30, 2008,
Abstract volume, 1-43, Tripoli, Lybia.
Ben Rahuma, A.M., Proust, J.N. and Eschard,
R., 2008, Devonian land-sea interaction:
evolution of ecosystems and climate
(DEVEC). Libyan Petroleum Institute
(LPI), April, 23.-30, 2008, Field
Workshop The Stratigraphic evolution of
the Devonian sequences, Awaynat Wanin
area, Southern Gadamis Basin:a
Fieldguide Book, 1-67, Tripoli, Libya.
Brett, C., Schindler, E. and Königshof, P.
[eds], 2010, Sea level and climate
cyclicity and bioevents in Middle
Devonian marine and terrestrial
environments. Special volume of
Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology,
Palaeoecology (accepted, to be published
in 2010)
El Hassani, A. [ed.], 2004, Devonian neriticpelagic correlation and events in the Dra
Valleys (Western Anti Atlas, Morocco).
Documents de l‘Instiitut Scientifique,
19:1-100, Rabat, Morocco.
Kim, A.I., Salimova, F.A. and Meshchankina,
N.A., 2008, Global Alignments of Lower
Devonian Carbonate and Clastic
Sequences.August 25 – September 03,
2008, Kitab State Geological Reserve,
Abstracts volume. Novosibirsk SB RAS
Publishing House, 1-123, Tashkent,
Uzbekistan.
Königshof, P. [ed.], 2009, Devonian Change:
Case Studies in Palaeogeography and
Palaeoecology. The Geological Society,
London, Special Publications, 314, 1298.
Königshof, P. and Linnemann, U. [eds],
2008a, From Gondwana to Laurussia to
Pangaea: Dynamics of Oceans and
Supercontinents. 20 th International
Senckenberg-Conference and 2nd GeinitzConference. Final Meeting of IGCP 497
and 499. Abstracts and Programme, 1241, Frankfurt am Main, Dresden,
Germany.
Königshof, P. and Linnemann, U. [eds],
2008b, The Rheno-Hercynian, MidGerman Crystalline – and SaxoThuringian Zones (Central European
Variscides), Excursion Guide, 20 th
International Senckenberg-Conference
and 2 nd Geinitz-Conference: From
Gondwana to Laurussia to Pangaea:
Dynamics of Oceans and Supercontinents. Final Meeting of IGCP 497
and 499. Excursion Guide, 1-159,
Frankfurt am Main, Dresden, Germany.
Königshof, P., Obut, O. and Izokh, N. [eds],
2008, Devonian land-sea interaction
evolution of ecosystems and climate,
IGCP 499. Bulletin of Geosciences,
Special Volume 84 (4), 355-506.
Nance, D. ed., 2010, The Rheic Ocean:
Palaeozoic Evolution from Gondwana
and Laurussia to Pangaea. Gondwana
Research, v. 17, no 2-3, pp. 189-612.
Over, D.J. and Morrow, J.R. [eds], 2007,
Subcommission on Devonian Statigraphy
and IGCP 499 Devonian Land Sea
Interaction, Program and Abstracts, 1-93,
Eureka, Nevada.
Morrow, J.R. [ed], 2007, Devonian shelf-toslope facies and events, Central Great
Basin, Nevada and Utah, U.S.A.
Subcommission
on
Devonian
Stratigraphy, SDS 2007 field trip
guidebook: 1-93, Eureka, Nevada.
Suttner, T.J., Hubmann, B. and Piller, W.E.,
2009, Palaeozoic Seas Symposium.
Berichte des Institutes für Erdwissenschaften, Karl-Franzens-Universität,
Band 14, 1-94, Graz, Austria.
Yalçin, M.N., Nazik, A. and Wilde, V., 2005,
Depositional environments of the
Gondwanan and Laurusian Devonian.
Abstract and Field Trip Guide Book, 26
September – 03 October, 2005, Istanbul
University, Faculty of Engineering
Department of Geological Engineering.
1-77, Istanbul, Turkey.
Yang, Q., Wang, Y. and Weldon, E.A. [eds],
2006, Anchient life and modern
approaches – Abstracts of the Second
International Palaeontological Congress.
University of Science and Technology of
China Press, 1-553, Beijing, China.
Yolkin, E.A., Bakharev, N.K., Izokh, N.G.,
Gratsianova, R.T., Kipriyanova, T.P. and
Obut, O.T., 2005a, Devonian sequences
of Salair, Rudny & Gorny Altai, IGCP499
SDS joint meeting, Excursion guide.
Novosibirsk SB RAS Publishing House,
1-79, Novosibirsk, Russia.
Yolkin, E.A., Izokh, N.G., Obut, O.T. and
Kipriyanova, T.P., 2005b, Devonian
terrestrial and marine environments: from
continant to shelf. IGCP499 SDS joint
meeting, Abstracts volume. Novosibirsk
SB RAS Publishing House, 1-154,
Novosibirsk, Russia.
Yolkin, E.A., Kim, A.I. and Talent, J.A., 2008,
Devonian Sequences of the Kitab Reserve
Area., Field Excursion Guidebook,
August 25 – September 03, 2008, Kitab
State Geological Reserve, Uzbekistan;
Novosibirsk Publishing House of SB
RAS, 1-97, Novosibirsk, Russia.
March 2010
51
6th International Dyke Conference
4 to 7, February 2010, Varanasi, India
Introduction
The 6th International Dyke Conference
(IDC) was held on the banks of the Ganges
River, in the ancient town of Varanasi,
northern India. The sixth instalment, in a
highly successful series of conferences, a
gathering of close to 200 international and
Indian delegates and dyke swarm researchers
was hosted by Banaras Hindu University. An
able team of local conveners, led by Prof.
Rajesh K. Srivastava, put a superb program
together of 2½ days of talks and posters (http:/
/idc6.igpetbhu.com), further rounded out by
a number of well-attended cultural events and
a late afternoon trip to the “ghats” (stairs
leading down to the river) along the banks of
the Ganges, one of the most revered places
in Hindu religion.
A number of exciting new results were
unveiled, including many new precise U-Pb
baddeleyite ages for major dyke swarms from
several cratons. New paleomagnetic poles
from a number of these cratons (e.g., Slave,
Superior, Kaapvaal, etc.) and matching of
apparent polar wander (APW) path segments
is beginning to reveal, quantitatively, the
relative position of a number of cratons during
a key interval of the earliest Paleoproterozoic.
The meeting also highlighted new plans for a
Canadian led study (~2 M$) to “barcode”
(Bleeker and Ernst, 2006) all the major
cratons in the world: i.e. to establish precisely
dated magmatic event histories, with a focus
on short-lived mafic magmatism, for all the
major pieces of the continental terrane puzzle,
thus allowing identification of those pieces
that were formerly together. The vision and
ultimate goal of this major project is to
reconstruct past continental aggregations and
supercontinents back to 2.7 Ga (see:
www.supercontinent.org), and thus to fulfill
the ultimate promise of the plate tectonic
revolution.
In this context, the various cratons that
make up the Indian subcontinent, where they
originated, and when and how they came
together, are of special interest. The latest
chapter in India’s plate tectonic history—the
Figure 1. Field trip participants of the Dharwar pre-conference trip, in front of an ~1 m
wide, EW-trending, well exposed wall-like mafic dyke in a quarry near Madanpalli.
Participants are, from left to right, in the back: Wouter Bleeker, Ross Mitchell,
J. Mallikkharjuna Rao, M. Jayananda, Mike Hamilton, Mimmi Nilsson, Larry Heaman,
Shiva Kumar Patil, Henry Halls; foreground: Rais Latypov, Sofya Chistyakova, Taylor Kilian,
Jouni Vuollo, Satu Mertanen, Kumar Santosh and B.C. Prabhakar.
Episodes Vol. 33, no. 1
plume-assisted breakout of the Indian plate
out of the confines of supercontinent
Gondwanaland, starting at ca. 160 Ma (e.g.,
Storey, 1995) and culminating with the
ongoing collision and northward indentation
into Eurasia—is of course well understood.
But can we reconstruct the earlier cycles of
plate tectonics that formed India’s cratons and
brought them together into the collage that
now forms the Indian subcontinent?
It was of great interest to the participants
of the 6th IDC that a number of field trips
(Pre-conference field trip in the Dharwar
craton: 29 Jan. - 3 Feb. 2010) were organized
in conjunction with the conference. Pre- and
post-conference field trips covered: (1) the
dyke swarms of the Deccan Traps large
igneous province (LIP), (2) dyke swarms of
the Dharwar craton, (3) the ca. 1100 Ma
Wajrakarur kimberlite field of the easternmost
Dharwar craton, and (4) mafic magmatism in
a north Indian segment of the Himalayas. One
of these field trips to the Dharwar craton, is
discussed later in more detail. This trip
highlighted both latest Archean “synplutonic”
mafic dykes (Jayananda et al. 2009) of the
Dharwar craton as well as younger, mostly
Paleoproterozoic, dolerite (diabase) dyke
swarms that criss-cross this craton.
Mafic dyke swarms and synplutonic dykes
emplaced within the Dharwar craton
This 5-day field trip started out in
Bangalore (Bengaluru). First day explored
synplutonic dykes and Proterozoic dykes
southwest of Bangalore, and included a visit
to the famous quarry locality of Kabbaldurga
where late Archean flushing with CO2-rich
fluids, transforming upper amphibolite
gneisses into granulites, was first demonstrated (e.g., Pichamuthu, 1960). The day
concluded with a visit to one of the large,
approximately EW-trending dolerite dykes
that transect this part of the Dharwar craton
and are thought to be part of the “Bangalore”
dyke swarm. Two different dykes of this
swarm, one south of Bangalore and one well
to the north, have been precisely dated at 2367
Ma (French et al., 2004; Halls et al., 2007).
To date, this age of mafic magmatism
(“event”) is relatively unique in the global
LIP record although a possible age match
from a dyke in the North Atlantic craton was
mentioned at the conference (Nilsson et al.,
2010, 6th IDC abstract). Major dolerite dykes
from the middle of Geon 23 are also known
from the Karelian craton. As both North
Atlantic craton and Karelia share a major part
of their Paleoproterozoic barcode with the
52
Figure 2. One of the well-exposed EW-trending dykes cutting through late Archean granites
at Horsley Hill, eastern Dharwar craton. These sparsely plagioclase-porphyritic dykes form
a dense swarm in the area.
eastern Superior craton and are thus thought
to be fragments of late Archean supercraton
Superia (Bleeker, 2003), could it be that
Dharwar also originated from that ancestral
landmass? Further precise dating of
Dharwar’s dyke swarm inventory will test this
hypothesis in detail.
Following the first day, the field trip
proceeded to the northeast of Bangalore,
examining numerous dykes along a rough
transect from Bangalore to Anantapur. Field
trip participants (Fig.1) enjoyed two nights
at the hill top resort on Horsley Hill, one of
the typical inselbergs of more massive granite
sticking out several hundred meters above the
rolling terrain of the eastern Dharwar craton.
This granite hill and the surrounding area are
cut by numerous EW-trending dykes (Fig.2)
that appear to increase in number to the east.
If all these dykes are part of the 2367 Ma
Bangalore swarm, the distinctive pattern of a
few very large linear dykes (i.e. distal) west
of Bangalore, and more numerous and
variable width dykes (more proximal) further
east, strongly suggests a magmatic focus for
this swarm to the east of the Dhawar craton
(Bleeker, 2010, 6th IDC abstract), rather than
to the west of the craton (cf. Ernst and Shrivastava, 2008). In addition, a model in which
all approximately EW-trending dykes of the
Dharwar craton are considered part of only
one event (Bangalore swarm) may be too
simplistic, as there already is evidence for
more than one swarm with this general trend.
From Horsley Hill and the Madanapalli
area, the trip proceeded north to Anantapur.
Along the way, several major NW-trending
dykes were observed, some of which are
likely to belong to another major swarm
transecting much of the craton, the 2180 Ma
Mahbubnagar swarm (French et al., 2004).
However, as for the EW-trending dykes,
subtle dispersion in trends, minor differences
in petrographic characteristics and magnetic
susceptibilities (reflecting subtle differences
in and freshness of oxide mineralogy), and
the state of preservation of the chilled
margins, suggest that there is more than one
swarm, and thus different LIP events, among
the dykes with a general northwesterly trend.
To complicate matters, dykes of a single
swarm can also vary in trend, defining a
radiating swarm. Therefore, variations in dyke
orientations (trends), indeed a key tool in
distinguishing different dyke events at the
regional scale, may not always signify
different swarms at the scale of the craton.
Some of the larger NW-trending dykes
showed evidence for dynamic magma flow,
in the form of cm-scale layering defining
cross-bedding. Others were cut by late-stage
dykelets of feldspar porphyry formed by backinjection of melted country rocks (Fig.3).
On the final day of the field trip, major
dykes along the highway from Anantapur
back to Bangalore were examined. A final side
trip to major NNE-trending (~355º) dykes on
the west side of the ca. 2.52 Ga Closepet
Granite belt, some several hundred meters
wide (Fig. 4), rounded out the field trip. One
of the latter dykes has a preliminary U-Pb
baddeleyite age of ca. 2215 Ma (M. Hamilton,
pers. comm., 2010), identifying yet another
Figure 3. A complex dyke margin of a NW-trending dyke on the way to Anantapur. The
magmatic heat content of this large dyke was sufficient to melt the granitic country rocks,
leading to late-stage back-injection of felsic feldspar-porphyry dykes (at pen) into the almost
fully crystallized mafic dyke. A relatively low magnetic susceptibility (i.e. altered oxides)
and the presence of epidote-quartz veins suggest that this particular dyke is relatively old.
March 2010
53
in supercraton Superia. Following the “rule
of multiple barcode matches” (Bleeker, 2008),
this would place the ancestry of Dharwar
craton firmly within southeastern Superia,
in proximity to both Superior and Karelia
cratons.
In the late afternoon, and before the long
drive back to Bangalore and an early morning
flight to Varanasi, field trip participants were
treated to great Indian hospitality during a
quick visit to the family home of one of the
field trip leaders, enjoying refreshing “tender
coconut” followed by fried rice and sweet tea.
Towards a complete magmatic barcode
for the Dharwar craton
Figure 4. Major NNE-trending dykes forming major ridges on the western side of the Closepet
Granite belt. One of these dykes has a preliminary U-Pb baddeleyite age of 2215 Ma. Field
trip participants Mike Hamilton and Rais Latypov standing on tumbled boulders of dyke
in foreground. A major parallel dyke of this swarm, at least 200 m wide, is visible in the
distance. Low ground underlain by deeply weathered granitoid gneisses.
major barcode event for the Dharwar craton.
Could this be a match to the 2220-2210
Ungava LIP of the eastern Superior craton
(e.g., as exemplified by the Nipissing diabase
sills in the Huronian Supergroup overlying
the southern Superior craton)? If so, there are
now two preliminary barcode matches that
would link events in the Dharwar with those
1
10 km
2
Dyke orientations:
1
2
4
3
4
1
2
3
Figure 5. An example snapshot, from Google Earth, of a typical area of the Dharwar craton
west of Bangalore. This ~25x20 km image shows numerous mafic dykes exposed as dark
bouldery ridges. Even a cursory inspection of this image reveals four distinct trends of
dykes (swarms 1 to 4) and a number of interesting intersections (bold arrows) that may yield
relative timing relationships
Episodes Vol. 33, no. 1
The Dharwar craton represents a major
fragment of Paleo- to Neoarchean crust. It is
generally well exposed and readily accessible.
Numerous studies have detailed its Archean
history and there can be little doubt,
particularly after this field trip, that a detailed
analysis of its inventory of Proterozoic mafic
dyke swarms will be able to place this major
fragment of crust in the context of prePangaea supercontinents, all the way back to
the ancestral Archean landmass or
supercraton in which this piece of ancient
crust must have formed initially. This would
allow, for the first time, a full synthesis of
Dharwar craton geology with that of original
“nearest neighbour” cratons, thus allowing
deeper level questions to be asked.
In much of the Dharwar craton, mafic
dyke swarms are well exposed (Fig.4) and
readily visible on Google Earth images
(Fig.5). Such images, of generally good if not
excellent quality, cover the entire craton and
over the next few years will allow a complete
assessment of the dyke swarm inventory of
the craton. Plans are forged to precisely date
all major dyke swarms of this craton, in
conjunction with detailed paleomagnetic
investigations. Preliminary field observations,
during both the pre- and post-conference
field trips, suggest that there are at least
10-15 major Proterozoic dyke swarms
across the Dharwar, thus potentially
harbouring numerous constraints on ancient
reconstructions and breakup events. They
range from those barely younger than the final
tectonomagmatic events in the craton (i.e.,
LIP events with likely ages in the 2.5-2.4 Ga
range), to several major events that have
already been dated at 2367 Ma, 2215 Ma, and
2180 Ma, to yet much younger events, some
perhaps related to Rodinia breakup. This
preliminary tally of 10-15 swarms is similar
to the dyke swarm inventory of other well-
54
studied cratons. It is also clear from
preliminary field observations that there are
dykes with rather different characteristics
among those with superficially similar trends.
Hence, a careful analysis of dyke trends alone,
already indicating at least 5-10 swarms,
underestimates the total dyke swarm
inventory.
One challenge is that many of the dykes
are exposed as rubbly ridges (e.g., Fig. 4),
with stacks of rounded diabase boulders
outlining the trace of the dyke intrusion. Most
of these boulders have rotated somewhat or
tumbled down the slopes of the ridge.
Although this presents little limitation for
precise U-Pb dating of the dykes, it does
complicate detailed paleomagnetic
investigations. Rare in-situ outcrops along the
top of the ridge, if present at all, may have
suffered lightning strikes.
Conclusions
The 6th International Dyke Conference in
Varanasi, India, was a great success and
participants are already looking forward to
the next IDC, which is likely to be held in
Siberia. Field trips to the Dharwar craton
demonstrated the rich inventory of major
dyke swarms in this craton, with preliminary
observations suggesting at least 10-15 distinct
LIP events. Over the next few years, many of
these events will be dated precisely and
together with on-going paleomagnetic
investigations will constrain Dharwar’s
location in pre-Pangaean supercontinent or
supercratons, all the way back to the late
Archean ancestral supercraton of which this
craton is a fragment. Tentatively, several
precise U-Pb ages presented or discussed at
the meeting suggest a link with the Superia
clan of cratons.
Acknowledgements
The first author would like to express his
sincere thanks to conference and field trip
organizers for putting together an exciting
program and flawless organization. DST
(New Delhi) is thanked for funding support
for the field trip.
Both the content of the scientific program
and that of the cultural events will be hard to
surpass by future IDCs. Well done!
References
Bleeker, W., 2003. The late Archean record:
a puzzle in ca. 35 pieces. Lithos, v.71,
pp. 99-134.
Bleeker, W., 2008. The pulse of the Earth.
Abstract, 33rd International Geological
Congress Oslo 2008, August 6-14th
(www.33igc.org).
Bleeker, W., 2010. The anatomy of large dyke
swarms: Geometrical constraints on
ancient breakup events. In: Abstracts, 6th
International Dyke Conference, February
4-7, 2010, Banaras Hindu University,
Varanasi, India, p. 16.
Bleeker W., and Ernst R.E., 2006. Short-lived
mantle generated magmatic events and
their dyke swarms: The key unlocking
Earth’s paleogeographic record back to
2.6 Ga. In: Dyke Swarms—Time Markers
of Crustal Evolution; E. Hanski, S.
Mertanen, T. Rämö, and J. Vuollo
(editors); Taylor and Francis/Balkema,
London, p. 3-26.
Ernst, R.E., and Shrivastava, R.K., 2008.
India’s place in the Proterozoic world:
Constraints from the Large Igneous
Province (LIP) record. In: Indian Dykes:
Geochemistry, Geophysics and
Geochronology; R.K. Srivastava, C.
Sivaji, and N.V. Chalapathi Rao (editors);
Narosa Publishing House Pvt. Ltd., New
Delhi, p. 41-56.
Ernst, R.E., et al., 2010. Using the global
dolerite dyke swarm record to reconstruct
supercontinents back to 2.7 Ga. In:
Abstracts, 6 th International Dyke
Conference, February 4-7, 2010, Banaras
Hindu University, Varanasi, India, p. 41.
French. J.E., et al., 2004. Global mafic
magmatism and continental breakup at
2.2 Ga: Evidence from the Dharwar
craton, India. Geological Society of
America, Abstracts with Program, v. 36,
p. 340/
Halls, H.C., et al., 2007. Paleomagnetism and
U-Pb geochronology of eastern trending
dykes in the Dharwar craton, India:
Feldspar clouding, radiating dyke swarms
and position of India at 2.37 Ga.
Precambrian Research, v. 155, pp. 47-68
Jayananda, M., Miyazaki, T., Gireesh, R.V.,
Mahesha, N., and Kano, T. 2009,
Synplutonic Mafic Dykes from Late
Archaean Granitoids in the Eastern
Dharwar Craton, Southern India, Jour.
Geol. Soc. India, v. 73, pp. 117-130/
Nilsson. M., et al., 2010. Barcoding the North
Atlantic craton: U-Pb baddeleyite and
zircon dating of MesoarchaeanPaleoproterozoic mafic dykes and
intrusions in southern West Greenland.
In: Abstracts, 6 th International Dyke
Conference, February 4-7, 2010, Banaras
Hindu University, Varanasi, India, p. 101.
Pichamuthu, C.S., 1960. Charnockite in the
making. Nature, v. 188, pp. 135-136.
Storey, B.C., 1995. The role of mantle plumes
in continetal breakup: Case histories from
Gondwanaland. Nature, v. 377, pp. 301308.
Wouter Bleeker
Geological Survey of Canada,
601 Booth Street,
Ottawa, Ontario,
Canada, K1A 0E8
Email:
[email protected]
Jayananda Mudlappa
Department of Geology,
Delhi University,
Delhi 110 007, India
Email:
[email protected]
March 2010
55
Long-term Scientific and Technological Cooperation of Russia and
India: an Example of Collaboration
2006-2009, Apatity, Russia, and Delhi, India
A high level of scientific and
technological potential in Russia and India,
their progress in numerous fields of
fundamental and applied research together
with stable bilateral relations create
favourable prerequisites for development of
large-scale scientific and technological
cooperation (STC) on a long-term basis.
The treaty and legal basis for the RussianIndian cooperation in the scientific and
technological sphere is the intergovernmental
STC Agreement of 30 June, 1994. In
December 2002 the Joint Declaration on the
Strengthening and Extension of Economic,
Scientific and Technological Cooperation was
signed. It stated Russia and India’s resolve to
develop cooperation in the high-tech sphere.
The intergovernmental Protocol on Protection
and Use of the Intellectual Property Right
which is a legal basis for activation of the
commercialization process and high tech
transfer was also signed.
In November 2003 during the RussianIndian summit the Agreement on Scientific
Cooperation and Exchange of Scientists
between Russian Academy of Sciences (RAS)
and Indian National Academy of Sciences,
Memorandum of Mutual Understanding
between RAS and Department of Science and
Technology of the Indian Government on
Establishing Russian-Indian Gas-hydrate
and Earthquake Investigation Centres and
Protocol of Scientific Cooperation between
these organizations were signed.
In 2008, 94 applications were submitted
to the competition announced by the RFBR
and Department of Science and Technology
(DST) of the Indian Government. By results
of the examination conducted independently
by Russian and Indian experts, 39 projects
got financial support. The RFBR called for
applications for holding joint Russian-Indian
seminars.
The most important mechanism of STC
between the two countries is the Complex
Long-term Programme for Scientific and
Technological Cooperation (CLP STC). The
Agreement on its Prolongation to 2010 was
signed in October 2000. The main task of the
Programme is implementation of fundamental
and applied research with the object of
Episodes Vol. 33, no. 1
creating new technologies, equipment and
In 2006 in the context of CLP STC
materials on its basis. Currently, in the field
between Russia and India, the Geological
of medicine important results were obtained
Institute of the Kola Science Centre RAS and
for immunology, in particular, new generation
the University of Delhi signed the project
immuno-modulators were developed. A
“Geochemical, isotopic ànd geochronological
programme for poliomyelitis control deserves
characterization of granitoids from the
particular attention. Using the technology
Central Indian Tectonic Zone (CITZ) ànd
developed in Russia, the National Centre for
Central Indian Shear (CIS) Zones: constraints
Vaccine Production was established in
on Precambrian crustal evolution”. The aim
India. It fully meets the country’s needs for
of the project was reconstruction of the
vaccines. Specialists from P.N. Lebedev
Central Indian Tectonic Zones (CITZ) on the
Physical Institute of RAS together with
basis of geochemical and geochronological
Indian colleagues developed and handed over
studies, the main types of lithotectonic sublasers for tuberculosis treatment to India. On
divisions (mainly granites and gneisses)
the basis of Moscow Institute for Automated
comprising CITZ.
Design of RAS (IAD RAS) the joint Centre
The Central Indian Tectonic Zone is an
of Computer Investigations (CCI) was
ENE–WSW stretched polyfolded and polyestablished for modelling atmospheric
metamorphic belt (Fig.1). Generation of the
processes, investigations in microelectronics,
Central Indian Tectonic Zone is the key
medicine, seismology, ecology etc. The
moment of the Precambrian evolution of the
Department of the International Institute for
Central Indian Shield since it represents a
Information Technologies was established at
conjunction zone between the northern
the above Centre (Pune). Indian Centre of
protocontinent represented by the BundelAdvanced Computer Technologies and CCI
khand craton and southern protocontinent
jointly work on designing a supercomputer
represented by the Bastar-Singhbhum“Padma-Ru” is being done.
Dharwar craton. The proper understanding of
Leading research centres in both countries
the CITZ evolution is vital for constructing
(over 70 institutes in Russia and over 50
tectonic models.
institutes and laboratories in India) have been
To date there are two plate-tectonic
involved for the work on running the bilateral
models of CITZ generation (Yedekar et al.
projects. In the context of CLP more than 400
1990; Roy and Prasad, 2003) that differ in
projects in the field of
mathematics, mechanics,
chemistry, physics, material
science, laser and beam
technology, electronics,
oceanology, seismology etc.
At the present stage the
Programme covers a wide
spectrum of scientific
disciplines and involves
some 120 joint projects.
The way of their implementation and prospects were
discussed at the meetings of
the CLP STC Joint Council
meeting held in New Delhi
in October 2008). Co-chairmen of the Council were
Figure 1. Sketch map of the Central Indian Shield. Archaean
Academician V.G. Kadyshev
cratons: BKC – Bundelkhand, BC – Bastar, SC – Singhbhum,
DC – Dharwar (Roy and Prasad, 2003).
and Prof. S.N.R. Rao.
56
the direction (southern or northern) and time
(2.4 or 2.2 Ga) of subduction. According to
both models the subduction system culmination was a collision that occurred 1.5 Ga
ago and was marked by formation of the
Ramakona-Katangi collision belt which
marked a suture between Bundelkhand and
Bastar cratons. The final rock transformations
occurred about 1100 Ma ago which enables
one to compare the final processes that took
place in the CITZ with the Grenville orogeny
and to use them for Rodinia reconstruction.
India has got good petrological,
geological and geochemical data but it lacks
in geochronological data. This is related to
the scarcity of isotope-geochronological
laboratories in the country. Specialists from
the Laboratory of Geochronology and
Isotopic Geochemistry of the Geological
Institute KSC RAS and Geological
Department of Delhi University combined
their efforts for the purpose of a joint
geochemical study and dating Archaean
granitoids of the Central Indian craton,
establishing distinct age boundaries for the
crust evolution in the Precambrian in the
Central Indian Tectonic Zone and Central
Indian Shear Zone. This should be done for
better understanding of the suture structure
formation processes between the northern and
southern protocontinents represented by the
Bundelkhand and Bastar-SinghbhumDharwar cratons.
Field work was carried out in 2009 in the
areas of Nagpur and Betul (southern and
central CITZ) within the framework of the
project. In the region under study two big
gneiss complexes can be distinguished,
Amgon and Tirody, from which geochemical
and geochronological samples were taken.
Geochemically it can be compared with the
gneisses of the Bastar craton dated at 3.52.6 Ma. The field work resulted in selecting
representative samples for conducting
geochronological investi-gations with
simultaneous petrographical and geochemical
data.
Geochemical and geochronological
studies of granitoid samples (gneiss and
granite) from the southern Central Indian
Tectonic Zone were performed. The
granitoids were selected from different
complexes. They differ in the degree of
metamorphic changes and shearing.
Petrochemical investigations (an analysis of
the content and distribution of petrogenic,
trace elements and REE) show that gneisses
from the complexes studied belong to
granitoids of I type I. According to the
presence of the Eu positive or negative
anomaly or its absence, gneisses are divided
into three groups. The behaviour of
petrogenic elements also allows one to
distinguish these three groups with substantial
Ba, Nb, Sr, P, Eu and Ti anomalies.
Considerable positive anomalies are shown
by Th, U and Pb which are likely to imply
crustal nature.
Geochronological data indicates that the
Central Indian Tectonic Zone is mainly
composed of Proterozoic rocks that were
formed during two stages of granite
magmatism - 2.42-2.45 Ga and 2.29-2.31 Ga.
The Amgon gneiss complex is older than the
Tirody gneiss complex which granitoids
generated in the range of 1.5-1.1 Ga. Collision
processes related to the generation of the main
granulites occurred 1.56 Ga ago. The final
metamorphic transformations reflected by
Sm-Nd and Rb-Sr rock systems took place
1.37-1.1 Ga ago. This enables one to compare
the processes in the Central Indian Shear Zone
with the Grenville orogeny and use them for
reconstruction of Rodinia. The geochemical
and geochronological data obtained correlate
well with the subduction-collision formation
model of the Central Indian Tectonic Zone.
New geochronological data can essentially
supplement the regional scale of the
endogenic processes sequence and can be
used for compiling new geological maps of
the Central Indian Shield. Joint investigations
resulted in presenting 10 papers at
international, Indian and Russian conferences
and preparing 4 articles for the journals
“Gondwana Research”, “Chemical Geology”
and “Journal of the Geological Society of
India”.
In the framework of the project the
Geological Institute of the Kola Science
Centre, Russian Academy of Sciences, hosted
Prof. Talat Ahmad and Mukesh Kumar
Mishra, Ph.D scholar from the University of
Delhi to the Geological Institute KSC RAS
from June 25 to July 8. The visit aimed at
integrating results of geochemical and
geochronological analyses of the rocks
of the Central Indian Shield and discussing
the plan of writing joint articles on the project
results. Financial assistance for the visit was
provided by the Russian Academy of
Sciences.
The visit of the Indian colleagues
included their participation in two seminars
and one international workshop in the
Geological institute KSC RAS. On July 2
Prof. T. Ahmad took part in a weekly scientific
seminar in the Geological Institute KSC RAS
with a report on the U-Pb chronology of
basement gneissic complex, trace elements
and Sm-Nd characteristics of basement and
cover rocks in the Central Indian Shield. On
July 7, Mr. M.K. Mishra, Ph.D scholar,
reported on the geochemical characterization
of the Tirodi basement gneisses in the Central
Indian Shield. On July 5 the Geological
Institute KSC RAS hosted the Russian-Sino
Workshop “Deep Drilling and Metallogeny
of the Continental Crust”. Prof. T. Ahmad
presented his report on the geochemical
and isotopic characteristics of the Nidar
Ophiolitic Complex, eastern Ladakh, India.
During this visit Mr. M.K Mishra got
trained in geochronological methods at the
Institute and learnt the methods of chemical
and hydrothermal decomposition of rock and
mineral samples with Pb, U, Sm and Nd
isolation by ion-exchange chromatography.
He also became familiar with conducting
U-Pb and Sm-Nd analyses in the Finnigan
MAT-262 (RPQ) mass-spectrometer. Since
the geochronological laboratory at the
Geological Institute KSC RAS is one of the
best equipped in Russia, it serves as a training
centre for foreign students and postgraduates.
The Russian and Indian colleagues are
satisfied with the results of their scientific
collaboration. The parties plan to formulate
a new joint project in accordance with the
Memorandum of Understanding on scientific
and technical cooperation between the
Russian Foundation for Basic Research and
Department of Science and Technology
(DST) of the Indian Government started in
2009. The Russian Foundation for Basic
Research called for application for joint
Russian-Indian research projects in 7 fields
of knowledge. The University of Delhi and
Geological Institute KSC RAS shall continue
research works in the framework of the
section of the Earth sciences, considerably
extending the sphere of scientific interests.
Further studies will focus on the Baltic
and northern Indian Shields evolution in the
Archaean-Proterozoic. Apart from the
geochemical and geochronological investigations, the plan of work includes the
mineragenetic aspect, i.e. studying major
ore deposits. Possibly, the All-Russian
Geological Institute of the Russian Academy
of Sciences (VSEGEI) will join the partners.
The Indian colleagues established friendly
ties with VSEGEI during their visit to St.
Petersburg in June 2009, when they got
acquainted with the work of the Department
of geology of uranium deposits and Centre
March 2010
57
for isotopic investigations. This cooperation
will give way to including the Karelian region
in the area of study and using the technical
equipment of the Centre for isotopic
investigations in prospective research. Such
cooperation would correspond with the
current massive cooperation of Russian and
Indian scientific institutions. Thus, recently
in the framework of the CLP STC such a
promising form of cooperation was developed
as complex joint investigations on the basis
of the Russian-Indian research centres.
Seismology (New-Delhi), biotechnology
(Allahabad) powder metallurgy and
innovation (Hyderabad), polyvalent vaccine
production (Bulandshahr) and gas-hydrate
study (Chennai) centres operate. With the
assistance of Russian scientists from the
Siberian Department of RAS (Institute of
Nuclear Physics) a centre for production
of industrial electron accelerators was
established in Mumbai, a centre of radiationchemical investigations is being organized in
Indore.
implications in Rodinian crustal
assembly: Journal of Asian Earth
Sciences, no. 22, pp. 115–129.
References
Talat Ahmad
Professor, Department of Geology,
University of Delhi, Chatra Marg,
Delhi - 11 00 07, India
E-mail:
[email protected]
Yedekar, D.B., Jain, S.C., Nair, K.K.K., and
Dutta, K.K., 1990, The Central Indian
collision suture. Precambrian of Central
India: Geological Survey of India Special
Publication, 28, pp. 1–37.
Roy, Abhinaba, and Prasad, M. Hanuma,
2003, Tectonothermal events in Central
Indian Tectonic Zone (CITZ) and its
Yury L. Voytekhovsky
Professor, Director of Geological
Institute of Kola Science Centre,
Russian Academy of Sciences
14 Fersman Street, 184209
Apatity, Murmansk region, Russia
E-mail:
[email protected]
First YES Congress, Beijing 25-28 October, 2009
Probably, there is no bigger challenge to
mankind than understanding and exploring
the changing Earth. In 2008, the International
Union of Geological Sciences (IUGS) and the
United Nations Educational, Scientific, and
Cultural Organization (UNESCO) launched
the “International Year of Planet Earth”
(IYPE) in order to bring international focus
to the earth sciences. One of the legacies of
IYPE is the establishment of the Young Earth
Scientists (YES Network), an international
association of young and early-career
geoscientists who are primarily under the age
of 35 years (www.networkyes.org).
The event included poster and oral
presentations that focused on the ten major
themes of the IYPE (e.g. health, climate,
groundwater, ocean, soils, deep earth,
megacities, hazards, resources, and life) as
well as additional areas of regional interest
(e.g. Geoparks, Tibetan plateau changes, and
digital earth engineering), and roundtable
symposia that addressed scientific, academic,
and career challenges faced by young
geoscientists. The roundtable symposia
included sessions on climate change, natural
hazards, natural resources and energy
sustainability, issues facing global geoscience
Participants of 1st YES Congress, 2009
In 2009, in collaboration with the IYPE
and under the patronage of UNESCO, the
YES Network organized its first international
Congress at the China University of
Geosciences in Beijing, China from 25-28
October 2009 (www.yescongress2009.org).
The focus of the meeting was on present and
future scientific challenges facing society, as
well as academic and career challenges facing
young and early-career geoscientists.
Episodes Vol. 33, no. 1
education and research, industry-academic
linkages, international degree accreditation
and international licensure, and gender
parity in the geoscience workforce. The
YES Congress 2009 event concluded
with five field trips to various points of
interest including one field excursion to the
Gushankou recumbent fold region and Shifa
cave.
Over 300 young and early-career
geoscientists representing more than 35
countries attended the event. Additionally,
since the roundtable symposia were broadcast
over the web as ‘live’ webinars, there were
an additional 191 virtual registrants from 28
different countries for the roundtable
symposia. Of these registrants, 41
participated, representing 10 different
countries. Furthermore, because of the
virtualization of the roundtables, 16 speakers
from 5 different countries were able to
present their talks virtually and participate in
the panel discussions. The Indian national
IYPE committee and Geological Society of
India, Bangalore have
played an important
role to make maximum
participations through
partial financial support
of
Ministry
of
Earth Sciences, India,
LOC, China and
UNESCO.
The second international YES Congress
will be held as part of
the 34 th International
Geological Congress (IUGS) in Brisbane,
Australia in August 2012. For more
information, visit the YES Network website
at www.networkyes.org.
V. M. Tiwari
NGRI, Hyderabad, India
Leila M. Gonzales
AGI, Virginia, USA
58
Tectonic Evolution and Crustal Structure of the Tien Shan Belt and
Related Terrains in the Central Asian Orogenic Belt: Fourth and
Final Workshop of the IGCP-480 Project
The Central Asian Orogenic Belt
(CAOB), also known as Altaid Tectonic
Collage, is the largest accretionary orogen on
Earth stretching from the Uralides in the west
to the Pacific Ocean in the east, and is
squeezed between the Siberian craton in the
north and the North China craton in the south.
Considerable attention to its tectonic structure
and mode of evolution is given in numerous
papers published in international journals.
The amount of scientific works published in
Chinese, Kazakh, Russian, and other
languages is difficult to account for. These
studies often present different interpretations
of the tectonic evolution of the orogen as a
whole or its large regions. These differences
are rooted not in the scientific ambitions of
various authors but in the complexity of the
accretion-dominated tectonic processes,
which imposes constraints on traditional
methods of research (stratigraphy, petrology,
etc.). In addition there is a general lack of
modern data and insufficient level of bilateral
and international scientific cooperation. To
overcome the latter is one of the main aims
of the IGCP-480 Project “Structural and
Tectonic Correlation across the Central
Asia Orogenic Collage: Implications for
Continental Growth and Intracontinental
Deformation”.
Previous workshops and field excursions
of this project have been organized along a
transect starting at the boundary between the
Altaid/Baykalide structures with the Siberian
craton, passing through Central Mongolia and
ending within Paleozoic structures of Inner
Mongolia and their junction with the North
China craton. The workshop in Tien Shan
was organized pursuing a task to examine
structural styles and timing of events within
the Altaid orogenic collage located rather far
away from above mentioned transect.
Bishkek, the capital of Kyrgyzstan, as a
place of the workshop provided a good
opportunity from the logistic point of view
because Kyrgyzstan occupies a large territory
stretching from the Tarim northern margin in
the south to the Balkhash fold-belt in the north
(Fig. 1). Thus it covers all tectonic units
traditionally assigned to the Tien Shan
orogenic collage. The workshop has been
jointly organized by the Central Asian
Institute of Applied Geosciences (CAIAG) in
Bishkek, Kyrgyzstan, Institute of Geology of
National Academy of Sciences of Kyrgyz
Republic, ILP Projects Topo-Central Asia and
ERAS (Earth Accretionary Systems), in
cooperation with the IGCP-480 Project. 42
scientists representing Australia, China,
France, Germany, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan,
Russia, Turkey, and United Kingdom,
attended the workshop. Personal
responsibility for the organization of the
workshop was taken by a team led by Prof.
Helmut Peter Echtler from CAIAG. Dr. Farid
Apayarov, Prof. Apas Bakirov, Prof. Georgiy
Biske, Dr. Kadyrbek Sakiev, Dr. Vladimir
Kiselev, Dr. Andrew Korzhenkov, Dr. Rena
Maksumova, and Dr. Alexander Mikolaichuk
were guides during the 8 days field excursion
that predated the workshop.
Before the opening of the workshop,
CAIAG and the Institute of Geology of
National Academy of Sciences of Kyrgyz
Republic published an Abstract volume (66
pages, 34 abstracts, most of which are of
extended format with figures) and a Field
Excursion Guidebook (120 pages). The
abstracts and the guidebook are posted at the
IGCP-480 Project website: http://www.igcp.
itu.edu.tr/index.html.
Figure 1. Tectonic provinces of Tien Shan. Heavy lines indicate major faults some of which are interpreted as sutures. The Ili and Terskey
suture are of Middle Ordovician age, the Turkestan suture was formed in the late Carboniferous. Thin dash lines show state boundaries.
March 2010
59
Scientific program
The scientific sessions covered a variety
of topics on tectonics of Central Asia but
with the focus on the Tien Shan geology.
Bakirov gave an overview of the geologic
history and tectonic structure of the Tien Shan
fold-belt as it is known from its segments
exposed in Kyrgyzstan and Uzbekistan.
Traditionally this region is divided into
subunits, namely: Northern, Middle, and
South Tien-Shan (Fig. 1). He defined five
large mega-sequences (Archean, Mesoproterozoic, Neoproterozoic and Paleozoic,
and Mesozoic) thereby pointing out their
cyclic development. Charvet and his coauthors presented data on the Tien Shan
tectonic evolution based mainly on data
accumulated in the Chinese segment of the
Tien Shan belt. Their model interprets the
Southern Tien Shan belt (Fig.1) as the
succession of ensialic arcs accreted to the Yili
microcontinent first in the middle-late
Devonian and then in the late Devonian - early
Carboniferous. The later Carboniferous arc
developed on the Yili block was due to a
southward subduction located at the northern
margin of this microcontinent (Fig.1). The
most important aspect of this model is that
oceanic lithosphere in front of the arcs in the
Southern Tien Shan subducted to the south
as it was recorded from northern vergence of
ductile deformation relevant to subduction.
This model is at odds with other models
developed for the Chinese (Klemd and Gao)
and for the Kyrgyz/Uzbek segment of Tien
Shan belt (Biske and his co-authors, Bush and
his co-authors, Djenchraeva, Konopelko and
his co-authors) according to which the middle
to late Paleozoic tectonic history of Tien Shan
was governed by the northward subduction
beneath the Northern Tien Shan. The timing
of the latest oceanic closure was also the
matter of controversies. Charvet suggests the
earliest Carboniferous (Visean) closure in
Southern Tien Shan but scientists having
studied the western segment of the Tien Shan
belt insist for late Carboniferous age of this
event. More recently, a Permian-Triassic
collision of the Central Tianshan Terrane
(Southern Tien Shan arc) and the Tarim plate
was suggested by some Chinese geologists
on the basis of zircon rim ages from HP-UHP
eclogites of the Chinese Tien Shan. However,
in their contribution Klemd and Gao pointed
out that the age of these HP-UHP rocks and
the significance of intimately interlayered HPUHP rocks need further studies of structural
geology, petrology and geochronology.
Episodes Vol. 33, no. 1
The Kyrgyz Segment of Tien Shan
presents the unique opportunity for
deciphering the early Paleozoic history of the
Northern Tien Shan (Kazakhstan-Yili plate)
because in the Chinese segment these rocks
are poorly exposed or sealed by younger
successions. Masumova and her co-authors
and Mikolaichuk and Apayarov presented
stratigraphic and petrologic data on oceanic
and magmatic arc complexes occurring in
narrow zones with thrust contacts to
surrounding continental blocks of earlier
ages. They interpret these zones as relicts of
former oceans that were closed at
approximately the same time at the end of the
early Ordovician. Afterwards, the
amalgamated collage behaved as a magmatic
arc with southern polarity. This episode of
the evolution is poorly constrained in the
Chinese sector of the Kazakhstan-Yili block
to the internal part of which the early
Ordovician ophiolite may continue. Qian and
his co-authors reported Cambrian to
Ordovician ophiolites intruded by middle
Ordovician diorite and related island-arc
volcanic rocks exposed along the southern
boundary of the Yili block. The same timing
of events was reported from the Kyrgyz
segment. Thus the necessity of across border
tectonic correlation becomes obvious.
The Precambrian history of Tien Shan has
always been the subject of hot discussion.
Kiselev gave the overview of geochronologic
data and their geologic interpretation on the
Kyrgyz segment of the Tien Shan belt.
However, Kroener and his co-authors
cautioned the relevance of age data obtained
from multigrain samples. Their own age
determinations from earlier defined Archean
rocks reveal younger Neoproterozoic ages
including those around 1000 Ma which are
poorly detected in other structures of Central
Asia but well known from Tarim plate. Thus,
Kroener and his co-authors suggest a former
relationship of Tien Shan Precambrian blocks
and Tarim.
Bazhenov and his co-authors presented
recent paleomagnetic data on the Paleozoic
rocks of Tien Shan and Kazakhstan calling
for significant oroclinal bending of regional
structural trends. Natal’in emphasized the
importance of the late Permian – Triassic
transcontinental shearing in Northern Asia by
presenting new data on South Mongolia
where dextral shearing occurred as the
continuation of Permian dextral shearing
recorded in the Chinese Tien Shan.
The metallogeny of the Tien Shan has
been considered by Djenchuraeva and by
Konopelko and his co-authors. Concerning
the tectonic implication of their results the
late Paleozoic magmatism and ore deposits
do not record a collisional tectonic setting.
Subduction-related magmatism was
immediately followed by a post-collisional
one.
Geophysics of the Tien Shan was
characterized by Sidorova and by Rubin and
his co-authors. The first presentation
demonstrated the crustal level of the majority
of large faults in Uzbekistan and low
velocities in mantle beneath the famous
Muruntau gold mine. The second talk
presented the results of CMP seismic
profiling, receiver function and seismic
tomography analysis along a profile crossing
the Tien Shan range and the northern part of
the Tarim Basin. This profile demonstrates
underthrusting of the Tarim beneath the Tien
Shan.
Field excursions
Figure 2 shows the location of stops
made during the field excursion. The
participants examined both paleotectonic
and neotectonics structures, lithologies, and
relationships exposed in the Kyrgyz segment
of the Tien Shan orogen.
Stop 1, Neotectonic structures of the
Kyrgyz Range foothills. The panorama near
a dam shows the Quaternary terrace overlying
unconformably the tilted Neogene rocks that
are deformed due to the north directed
thrusting. In the Chu Basin, the top of the
Paleozoic reaches a depth of 4000 m,
implying an offset of 9000 m with the Kyrgyz
Range. The last important tectonic movement
occurred during late Pliocene-Pleistocene
time.
Stop 2, Basement of North Tien Shan,
Aktyuz area.
2-1: On the right side of the river KichiKemin, in front of Aktyuz village, outcrops
of gneiss and amphibolite with eclogite lenses
were considered as the possible old basement
of North Tien Shan. The ocean-derived HP
metamorphic rocks tectonically overlie an
ophiolitic complex metamorphosed under
greenschist-facies conditions. But the
relationship with the Devonian metasediments visible to the west of the gneiss
suggests that it is a Paleozoic mélange instead
of the basement; radiometric dating on zircons
gave a maximum age of about 800 Ma. The
most obvious lineation, trending N80, is
almost horizontal.
2-2: At the junction of Chu and KichiKemin rivers. Exposure of the upper part of
60
Figure 2. Location of stops made during the field excursion.
the gabbro of the lower ophiolitic unit; finegrained, with abundant plagioclase, it is crosscut by doleritic dykes and shows vertical
foliation trending around N-S.
Stop 3, Mid-Ordovician arc and its
unconformable contact with the older
granites, west slope of Kyok-Too Mountain.
The visited outcrop shows the stratigraphic
contact between a volcanic-sedimentary
sequence and the underlying granite. The
sedimentary sequence begins with a breccia
with granite pebbles, grading upwards into
sandstone and fossiliferous limestone dated
as Llanvirnian. The overlying volcanic rocks:
andesite, dacite, are more exposed on the
other side of the valley. The granite is
supposed to be Neoproterozoic.
Stop 3bis, additional stop: migmatitic
gneiss of the Proterozoic series. Dated at 1.1
Ga, banded gneiss, with few neosome veins;
sub-vertical foliation trending N120.
Stop 4, Cambrian-early Ordovician arc
volcanics of northern Tien Shan, Cholok
Complex. The volcanic and volcaniclastic
rocks, greenish in color, overlie with an
erosional unconformity Riphean porphyroids.
The basalts and andesites yield a sub-alkaline
affinity. They are intruded by a Permian
granite visible on the southern end of the
section, but the intrusive contact is here
hidden by Quaternary.
Stop 5, Metamorphic basement of the
Tien Shan, near the junction of Chu and
Kichi-Kemin rivers. Complex of gneiss,
migmatites, with relicts of ophiolitic material:
gabbro, serpentinite, and of carbonates. In the
landscape, the meta-ophiolites overlie the
gneiss unit. Another outcrop shows dark
migmatites, with a foliation trending N30,
dipping at 60° to the NW. Recent dating gives
an age of 830 Ma (Kröner et al., unpublished).
Stop 6, Boom canyon. Cretaceous-Paleogene basalts, covered by Neogene continental
deposits. The olivine basalts, dated at 61 Ma,
overlie the Paleozoic sequence showing a
beautiful Devonian polygenetic conglomerate. The Neogene is overthrust from the
north by a Lower Paleozoic unit made of
dark carbonaceous limestone.
Stop 7, Neotectonic structures, observation of the panorama on the Paleogene and
Neogene-Pleistocene sediments affected by
folds and faults. The Paleozoic (CambrianOrdovician) is overthrusting the Neogene
from the south, thus the Issyk Kul Lake is in
a ramp basin.
Stop 8, Akkulen, west of Lake Issyk-Kul.,
Permian syenite. Beautiful outcrop of an
alkaline syenite, with spectacular giant Kfeldpars. Zircons gave a U-Pb age of 292 Ma.
It is surrounded by other rocks of the Oktorkoi
complex such as quartz-syenite and granite.
Different interpretations, rifting due to
asthenospheric bulge or transtension, are
advocated for the tectonic setting.
Stop 9, Kochkor complex, Proterozoic
orthogneiss. The augen gneiss, which is
crosscut by late granitic dykes, shows a
foliation N100/60-70S. Some ultramylonitic
layers indicate a strain partitioning. The
stretching lineation, trending N60-80, has a
pitch of about 55-55° to the west; the
kinematic indicators (asymmetric pressure
shadows around feldspar porphyroblast)
show a top-to-N70 shearing (oblique thrust
with sinistral component).
Additional Stop 9bis, on the road
between Kochkor and Karakudzhur River.
Granite dated (SHRIMP) at 441 Ma (Kröner
et al., unpublished); porphyritic texture,
member of a suite of Late Ordovician-Early
Silurian age. Two interpretations are
proposed: for some authors, this suite was due
to a collisional magmatism; for others, it was
emplaced in an Andean active margin setting.
Stop 10, Karakudzhur River, SW-NE
cross-section of two Proterozoic thrust sheets.
The lower unit includes carbonaceous
(graphitic) shales, dolomites with rhyolites,
sandstones, and finally basalts. The volcanic
rocks reflect a Riphean rifting; rhyolites have
been dated at 1.08 Ga; detrital zircon grains
in sandstones at 1.2 Ga. The lower unit is
intruded by an Ordovician granite developing
a metamorphic aureole. The upper unit shows
calcareous siltites. The contact is underlined
by a 200 m thick mylonite at the top of basalts.
The foliation, N160/65W, bears a N280-300trending lineation. The apparent shearing is
towards the east. The contact is stitched
nearby by a 640 Ma old granite.
Stop 11, Tyulek, eastern end of Karakatty
Range, Lower Paleozoic ophiolitic mélange;
March 2010
61
blocks of gabbro, basalt, chert, in a
serpentinite matrix. TIMS zircon ages of
720 Ma for gabbro and 680 Ma for basalt
have been obtained. The cherts contain
Cambrian conodonts. Pillow-lavas overthrust
Riphean limestones. Along an east-west fault,
blocks of limestones yielded FamennianTournaisian foraminifera. Likely, the mélange
was reactivated during Late Paleozoic by a
strike-slip motion.
At the Tyulek depression border, pillowlavas overthrust the Neogene; the metapillows show a N40 trending vertical cleavage
and some evidence of northwest-directed
deformation.
Stop 12, Sarybulak massif, outcrop of
Devonian granite; the age is given by the
similarity with other granites (400-410 Ma).
Stop 13, Cambrian ophiolites, Sarybulak.
Section along the river of an ophiolitic
mélange: hyaloclastites, banded gabbro,
basalt, blocks of marble, foliated granite.
The matrix is supposed to be Arenigian
sandstone.
Stop 14, Dolon Pass area, several
outcrops. View on big blocks of limestone in
the olistostrome complex, dated as Cambrian
to Tremadocian. Outcrop of Cambrian-Lower
Ordovician turbidites, overlain with a
disconformity by a diamictite with huge
blocks of ophiolitic material, granite, and
sandstone. It is clear that an obduction
occurred before the deposition of the
overlying Arenigian sandstones.
After the saddle, outcrop of well bedded,
homogeneous sequence of sandstones and
shales, assigned to the Llandeilo; it shows an
incipient cleavage dipping northward and is
overturned to the south.
Another outcrop, along the road, shows
massive arkosic sandstones, dipping
southward, assigned to the Arenig. Devoid
of ophiolitic debris, they contain andesite
pebbles.
Stop 15, Nikolaev line. Actually several
outcrops were observed to the north and to
the south of the supposed main fault.
To the north (15a), an outcrop of Lower
Carboniferous continental red sandstones,
N75-80/65S, bear a vertical cleavage,
trending E-W, with a sub-horizontal lineation
(pitch of 10-30 ° E). This facies is presented
as typical of North Tien Shan.
To the south (15b), after crossing the
supposed main fault, we observed Visean
marine limy turbidites and limestones,
grading upward into a flysch, presented as
typical of Middle Tien Shan. Also, a supposed
tectonic contact was advocated, base of a
Episodes Vol. 33, no. 1
nappe of Carboniferous limestone thrust
northward upon Lower Paleozoic marbles.
For some participants (Charvet, Wilde),
although some northward deformation can be
seen within the sequence, this contact is
purely normal, stratigraphic, and there is no
nappe. This is also supported by the fact that,
on the geological map shown by the guide,
both red beds and Carboniferous turbidites
appear in the same unit, between two faults.
Outcrops of andesites and dacites were also
observed, assigned to Late Carboniferous or
Early Permian.
A sinistral motion of the Nikolaev Line
was advocated on the basis of a sinistral offset
of 60 km of a Permian granite. But this motion
is not constrained in age.
Additional stops (15 bis) on the way to
Naryn. We could see several outcrops of the
Middle Tien Shan Paleozoic sequence:
- Caradocian flysch-like succession of
sandstone and shale, N20/20SE, affected
by an incipient cleavage N40/60NW;
- Middle-Upper Devonian red sandstones
(N90/35S); the Silurian is lacking there;
- Uppermost Devonian (Famennian)
marine sedimentary sequence: limestone,
calcareous siltstone, typical for a
carbonate platform;
- Tournaisian dark reefal limestone, locally
dolomitic;
- Visean-Serpukhovian bluish limestone,
with a red alteration crust, showing overturned folds and brittle shear planes
indicating a southern vergence of
deformation.
Additional stop (15 ter) in Naryn city,
along the river: andesitic tuffs with andesite
pebbles, volcanic breccia assigned to Late
Carboniferous-Early Permian. Ar/Ar dating
gives an age of 290 Ma (Early Permian). They
are very weakly deformed and post-date likely
the main tectonic event.
In a recent paper, Alekseev and others
assigned this kind of volcanic material to a
northward subduction consuming the
Turkestan Ocean to the east of Talas-Fergana
Fault. However, the volcanics include
olivine basalts which suggest an intra-plate
rifting; the sequence, according to the authors,
is overlying with an unconformity the older
rocks. Therefore, it is likely the signal of the
post-tectonic latest Carboniferous-Early
Permian rifting or transtension, not the
record of a pre-collision subduction.
Stop 16, west of Naryn, active faults. Two
different stops which show the landscape of
recent faulting affecting the Neogene and the
Pleistocene. The Neogene Naryn basin is
overthrust on both sides by older rocks:
Paleogene to the north, Carboniferous
limestone to the south. The two faults merge
in the east and the Neogene deposits
disappear.
Stop 17, east of Naryn, Proterozoic rift
complex: porphyroids and tilloids. The oldest
part of Middle Tien Shan is exposed in the
core of an anticline.
A first outcrop shows black shales and
diamictites, assigned an age of about 600 Ma;
affected by a cleavage N95/35S which bears
a N160 lineation. Clear kinematic features
around the pebbles show a top-to-the-north
shearing.
A bit more to the east, near the river,
deformed red porphyroids show two
cleavages: S1 N120/35S and S2 N60:80N;
S1 bears a lineation trending N330. U-Pb ages
of zircon grains are about 764 Ma (Kröner et
al., unpublished).
After lunch, a small cross-section along
the Malyi Naryn River valley, more to the east,
allowed the participants to observe several
levels of the Cambrian sequence: black
bedded limestone, green calcareous slates and
cherts, affected by folds overturned to the
south and by brittle thrust planes with a topto-the-south shearing. Some north-directed
deformation can also be seen.
Stop 18, Tashrabat River, the Atbashi
suture zone. Several very interesting outcrops
of the metamorphic units underlining the
South Tien Shan suture could be observed
(from the north to the south).
18a: the Atbashi metamorphic complex;
assigned to Late Silurian (Bishke): HP
metamorphic rocks containing to the east,
along strike, lenses of eclogite; here they are
retrogressed under amphibolite- to greenschist-facies conditions. Blueish staurolitebearing schists are dipping to the south (S1
N80/50S in average); Microtectonic features
indicate a top-to-the-north sense of shear. A
radiometric age of 320 Ma was obtained,
detrital zircons give ages of 2.5 Ga to
400 Ma. A thermal event at 290 Ma can be
deciphered.
18b: marbles of the Chirmash unit,
assigned to Wenlock-Early Devonian; S1
N40-50/80N; some calcite sigmoids suggest
a top-to-the-north shearing.
18c: Tashrabat unit, green schists coming
from sedimentary and volcanic rocks, basalts
assigned to Early Devonian. Steep dip to the
north. The clearest lineation is sub-horizontal;
a less intense one can be anticipated downdip. Sigmoidal exsudation quartz suggest a
top-to-the-north shearing.
62
18d, Shiritiky unit, green schists and
slates, with two cleavages, S2 crenulation
cleavage marking the axial plane of kinks,
with a southern low angle dip.
18e, doleritic sills cross-cutting the
Shiritiky unit, near an old caravanserai.
According to Biske, the sequence reaches
the Lower Carboniferous. But the contact was
not observed, nor the Carboniferous rocks
which crop out at the Tashrabat pass.
The initial southward thrusting, generally
advocated, is questioned by the microtectonic
evidence, which strongly suggests a
northward early deformation. The southdirected deformation could be actually due
to a secondary phase.
The dextral or sinistral strike-slip
component of the Atbashi fault could not be
determined on the field during the short time
of observation.
Stop 19, Akbeit, ophiolitic mélange of the
Atbashi suture. Actually, this stop was
observed before the stop 18. Rather poor
outcrop in trenches, showing a serpentinite
mélange, overlain tectonically by a unit of
Silurian limestones, both units covered with
an angular unconformity by an Upper
Carboniferous conglomerate.
Additional stop (14 bis), Dolon Pass,
northern slope of Karadzhorgo Range, same
as stop 14. View on the Ordovician olistostrome, with giant Cambrian limestone
olistoliths.
Additional stop (8 bis), near Stop 8, close
to Issyk Kul Lake. Intraplate olivine basalt,
dated at 66 Ma, with xenoliths of lherzolite.
The host rocks are made of greenish
Carboniferous sandstone and tuff, trending
N-S and dipping westward at around 40°.
Stop 20 of the guide book was skipped.
Stop 21 (see Fig. 1), Ananevo rock slide.
Outcrop of fault scarp with fault gouge,
affecting the granite. This rock slide was a
consequence of the Kemin earthquake, in
1911, magnitude 8.2, along the Chon Aksu
fault.
The granite is a part of the huge magmatic
belt developed from Ordovician to Early
Silurian. The interpretation differs according
to authors: collisional or linked to Andeantype margin. Konopelko suggested a first
pulse around 470 Ma, linked to subduction,
and a second post-collisional one around
435 Ma.
Boris Natalin
Leader of IGCP-480
Istanbul Technical University,
Turkey
Jacques Charvet
Universite d’Orleans,
France
Reiner Klemd
Universitaet Erlangen-Nuernberg,
Germany
International Conference on Geoscience for Global Development
(GeoDev)
26-31, October 2009, Dhaka, Bangladesh
Modern urbanization and industrial
revolution, good and easy transportation and
communication systems, sophisticated
exploration and exploitation technology of
hidden mineral resources are the indicators
of development activities. It is now well
recognized worldwide that without
development activities upgrading of living
standard and sustainability of a society can
not be achieved. But reality is that, these
development activities are simultaneously
causing global warming, air, water and land
pollution and as a whole environmental
deterioration – a threat for living beings and
have direct or indirect adverse impacts on
global development whether it is developed
or developing world. But in the developing
world these impacts are much more acute and
it is due to lack of proper geoscience
knowledge. In spite of these adverse impacts,
we want development to raise our living
standards and at the same time we also want
to preserve the natural environment as we,
the human beings, have an unquenched liking
for the shape, beauty and charms of the nature.
In consideration of all these factors a 6-day
International Conference on Geoscience for
Global Development (GeoDev), which is
also the ‘Vision’ of the conference, was
successfully organized in Dhaka, Bangladesh
in October 26-31, 2009 jointly by the
Geological Survey of Bangladesh (GSB) and
Association of geoscientists for International
Development (AGID), Bangladesh
Geological Society (BGS), International
Geoscience Education Organization (IGEO)
and International Union of Geological
Sciences (IUGS). The conference had two
Inaugural Session. From right to left: Dr. Anthony J Reedman, General Secretary, AGID;
Mr. Mohammad Mohsin, Secretary, Energy and Mineral Resources Division, MPEMR;
Dr. Tawfiq-e-Elahi Chowdhury, BB, the Honorable Energy Advisor to the Prime Minister
of the Government of the Peoples’ Republic of Bangladesh; Brigadier General (Retd.)
Muhammad Enamul Huq, State Minister, MPEMR; Prof. Chris King, Founder Chairperson,
IGEO; Ms. Afia Akhtar, Convener, GeoDev & Director General, GSB and President AGID
& BGS; Mr. Sirajul Islam Khan, Member Secretary, GeoDev & Director GSB.
March 2010
63
fold programs – (a) the first 3-day program
in Dhaka for scientific paper presentations,
open discussions, theme-wise plenary
sessions and finally preparation of fruitful and
effective recommendations and (b) the last
3-day program in Greater Khulna for
geological field excursion in the Sundarbans
– the UNESCO declared world heritage
which is an ideal place for both geotourism
and ecotourism. The major objective of this
event was to address all the above mentioned
issues. For this purpose, research papers
were invited on the following themes and
sub-themes from geoscientists of different
corners of the world.
Theme A: Geoscience Education
A-1: Geoscience Education and Awareness for Mankind
A-2: Women in Geo-Education and GeoDevelopment
A-3: New Approaches in Geoscience
Education and Research
Theme B: Natural Resources
B-1: Exploration, Exploitation and
Management of Natural Resources
B-2: Combating Energy Crisis and
Researching Alternative Sources
B-3: Water Resources Development,
Management and quality Assurance
B-4: Role of NGO’s in National Resource
Management and Environmental
Protection
Theme C: Development Activities
C-1: Geoscience for Development
Activities: Development of Cities
and Industries and Construction of
Highways, Dams and Bridges
C-2: Impacts of Development Activities
on the Natural Environment
C-3: Natural Hazard Assesments and
Infrastructure Development
C-4: Climate Change, Ecology and
Biodiversity
The overall objectives of this event were
to gather innovative ideas and views, new
information and technology from international geoscientists who are directly or
indirectly involved with the conference
themes. It was hoped that open floor
discussion would bring local, regional and
global cooperation and coordination among
the geoscientists, planners, policy and
decision makers of different countries round
the world. Not only that, it was also hoped
that paper presentation, discussion,
recommendation and the end result - the
proceedings of the conference would
Episodes Vol. 33, no. 1
contribute towards achieving the sustainable
global development.
After circulation of the first and the final
announcement of the international GeoDev
conference, in addition to 300 geoscientists
of the host country, 149 foreign geoscientists
responded from 44 countries (Albania,
Algeria, Argentina, Australia, Brazil,
Cameroon, Canada, Check Republic, Cuba,
France, Finland, Germany, India, Indonesia,
Iran, Italy, Japan, Kenya, Lebanon, Malaysia,
Malawi, Mexico, Mongolia, Mozambique,
Nepal, Nigeria, Norway, Pakistan, Philippine,
Portugal, Russia, Saudi Arabia, Sierra Leone,
Singapore, Sri Lanka, South Africa, Sweden,
Taiwan, Tajikistan, Tanzania, Tunisia, Turkey,
UK, USA) covering all continents along with
abstracts of 145 scientific papers.
The Inaugural Session of the conference
was held on October 26 afternoon, 2009 at
the Osmani Memorial Auditorium near
about the Bangladesh Secretariat, the office
of the ministries and secretaries. More than
500 delegates including VIP guest and
Ambassadors of the participating countries,
high officials, geoscientists from 26 countries
attended this inaugural session. Dr. Tawfiqe-Elahi Chowdhury, BB, the Honorable
Energy Advisor to the Prime Minister of the
Government of the Peoples’ Republic of
Bangladesh was present as the Chief Guest.
Brigadier General (Retd.) Muhammad
Enamul Huq, the Honorable State Minister,
Ministry of Power, Energy and Mineral
Resources (MPEMR) and Mohammad
Mohsin, Secretary, Energy and Mineral
Resources Division (EMRD), MPEMR,
Government of the Peoples, Republic of
Bangladesh, were present as the Special Guest
and Guest of Honor respectively.
The welcome address was given by Ms.
Afia Akhtar, Convener, GeoDev, and Director
General of GSB and President of Bangladesh
Geological Society (BGS). On behalf of the
GeoDev Committee and the Geological
community of Bangladesh, she warmly
welcomed the delegates from home and
abroad to the inaugural session followed by
scientific sessions in Dhaka and geological
field excursion to the Sundarbans in Khulna,
SW part of the country. And then she
highlighted the background of this joint event
being held in Bangladesh and also the aims
and objectives of the conference. She
mentioned that geoscience or earth science
knowledge plays an unparallel role in
developing activities, mitigating geo-hazards
effect, maintaining healthy environmental
ecosystem and consequently in improving our
socio-economic infrastructure. She also spoke
that very unfortunately, in most of the
developing countries, this science is not
getting required importance due to
unawareness about application of it’s
knowledge for the betterment of a society. To
acquire a good concept about this science, it
is a must to give proper attention and
concentration to this science from the very
beginning of one’s life. Lastly she expressed
her sincere thanks to all delegates especially
to foreign delegates for their kind
participation at the conference from longdistance countries round the world.
Dr. Anthony J Reedman, Secretary
General of AGID and Prof. Chris King, Past
Chairperson of IGEO both from UK
welcomed the audience as representative of
their respective organizations. Dr. Reedman
highlighted the aims of AGID as to encourage
and facilitate greater communication among
geoscientists in the developing and developed
countries to transfer geoscience knowledge
and information relevant to sustainable
development to individual, agencies and
government, and to promote geo-scientific
activities within and appropriate to the needs
of developing countries. He mentioned that
during the succeeding 35 years, AGID has
co-organized and co-sponsored more than
200 projects in more than 40 countries. He
also expressed his opinion that Bangladesh
will face many challenges from climate
change and consequently effects on
geological processes and environment.
Geoscientists have a particular responsibility
to educate local people and provide
information to help them understand and
mitigate future risk, he added. Prof. King
stressed the importance of GeoDev’s
objectives, including developing understanding of industrialization, urbanization,
exploration and exploitation of mineral
resources and construction and their impact
on global warming, air and water pollution,
health hazards and degrading the natural
environments, necessary for the survival,
which should be addressed in classrooms
around the world. He also said that this
involves educating curriculum writers,
teachers and the general public in the vital
importance of geoscience to the education of
every child and promoting geoscience
understanding wherever possible. He pointed
out that earthquakes causes much more
damage and loss of life in the developing
countries than developed and it is because
many of the buildings in the developing world
are built to lower standards than elsewhere
64
and so collapse in earthquakes. He further
mentioned if the builders had understood the
importance of building properly, then this
might have been avoided and this is one of
the geoscience educational issues addressed
by the GeoDev and IGEO.
Unfortunately, the President and/or
Secretary of IUGS could not attend from
Argentina and Canada respectively to
represent their organization at the conference.
But the President Prof. Alberto C Riccardi
kindly sent a massage for the conference
where he expressed his thanks to the
Bangladesh government and the geological
community of Bangladesh, represented by
GSB and BGS and also to AGID and IGEO,
the two affiliated bodies of IUGS. He also
mentioned in his massage that the issues or
themes of the event are within the goal of
IUGS which must be considered in relation
to existing differences in social and economic
development as well as education and
capacity building throughout the world, and
need to emphasize actions adapted to these
diverse circumstances.
Mr. Mohammad Mohsin, Secretary,
Energy and Mineral Resources Division
(EMRD), MPEMR, addressed the audience
and mentioned that at the national level,
followed by the Rio Earth Summit, UNDP
assisted the government to identify and
prioritize environmental concerns, which
included management of natural resources,
and protection as well as the regeneration of
biodiversity unique to Bangladesh. He also
said that out of that exercise came the
comprehensive Sustainable Environment
Management Program (SEMP), which was
the first national attempt to target critical
environmental challenges through one
umbrella program, which works at the policy
as well as community level. He further
mentioned that at the global level, Bangladesh
is a strong supporter of international agreements aimed at environmental protection and
as a result the nation has already slashed the
production of the ozone depleting CFCs by
60 percent and is now on target to meet
commitments under the Montreal protocol.
Brigadier General (Retd.) Muhammad
Enamul Huq, the Honorable State Minister,
Ministry of Power, Energy and Mineral
Resources, Government of the Peoples,
Republic of Bangladesh, mentioned in his
address that the scope of the geological
sciences or earth sciences is much broader
than rocks, mountains and petroleum
exploration – it also includes climate change,
natural disasters, water, environment and
health as well as questions concerning any
other issues related to earth. The earth is a
highly complex system where many different
processes play together and affect each other
and consequently, the scientific work to
understand the earth and its processes is also
complex. He mentioned that the program of
the conference illustrates this complexity, as
it includes symposia in a wide range of
disciplines. He further mentioned that
Bangladesh as a developing country has big
challenges to fullfil the Millennium
Development Goals (MDGS) and to
overcome the challenges of the changing
climate. He expressed his hope that sharing
of expert knowledge and ideas gathered
during this conference would greatly
contribute towards sustainable development.
Dr. Tawfiq-e-Elahi Chowdhury, BB, the
Honorable Energy Advisor to the Prime
Minister of the Government of the Peoples’
Republic of Bangladesh said in his inaugural
address that geoscience knowledge is
essential for the sustainable development as
it deals with energy, mineral resources and
environment, and environmental degradation
and lack of access to clean affordable energy
Clockwise: Dr. Tawfiq-e-Elahi Chowdhury,
BB, the Honorable Energy Advisor to the
Prime Minister of Bangladesh facing the
reporters of TV Channels and printing
media after the inaugural session; Brigadier
General (Retd.) Muhammad Enamul Huq,
State Minister, MPEMR, Mr. Mohammad
Mohsin, Secretary, EMRD of MPEMR, and
Ms. Afia Akhtar, Convener, GeoDev.
services disproportionately affect the poor.
These issues cannot be addressed by
individual professional but geoscientists can
share their knowledge to other professional
for the optimum use of natural resources with
minimum environmental and social impact.
He mentioned that there are constant dangers
throughout the world in the form of geologic
hazards and geoscientists can help to
minimize our exposure to these hazards. He
further mentioned that climate change is
another important realm of study for
geoscientists. He also expressed concerns that
Bangladesh would experience some of the
most damaging effects of climate change in
the future, both related to rising sea levels
and to more extreme weather. Millions of
people live without access to clean water, and
groundwater sources become polluted as a
result of human activities and this adds to
other challenges now Bangladesh is facing.
He further added that more research is needed
and the earth sciences clearly have a central
role to play. He expressed his hope that this
conference would stimulate scientific debate
and increased the network among scientists.
An abstract volume of 145 pages and an
attractive colorful 96 pages souvenir album
were printed and distributed among the
participants during the conference. The
souvenir album contains messages from
Sheikh Hasina, the Honorable Prime
Minister, Government of the Peoples’
Republic of Bangladesh, the Honorable Chief
Guest, the special guest and guest of honor
of the conference and also massages from
representatives of IUGS, AGID, IGEO and
the convener of GeoDev as well as Director
General of GSB. As usual the souvenir
volume also contains overall programs of the
conference, list of delegates, advertisements
and brief description of organizing
organizations and the host country
Bangladesh.
The Honorable Prime Minister has
mentioned in her massage that the conference
is quite relevant to the present day concern
for prudent use of natural resources, facing
climate change, ensuring environmental
sustainability and global partnership for
development. She also expressed her hope
that deliberation, and mutual exchange of
knowledge and experiences among the
scientists from home and abroad will create
an opportunity for better understanding of our
nature and its resources and thereby help us
in maximum utilization of those resources.
Two-day scientific oral paper presentation
was held at 3 concurrent paralleled sessions
in 3 lecture rooms of the Bangladesh
Shilpakala Academy, Dhaka near about the
office of the Geological Survey of
Bangladesh. More than 100 papers including
poster were presented during the conference.
The scientific & industrial exhibition, poster
paper presentation as well as registration were
held at the National Art Gallery Open Plaza
of the Academy. Papers for oral presentation
were categorized into a) general papers, b)
keynote papers and c) special papers. Daily
presentation was divided into four time
March 2010
65
Scientific paper presentation at one of the three lecture
rooms at the Bangladesh Shilpakala Academy.
schedules: Morning Session, Pre-noon
Session, Post-noon Session and Evening
Session. Each morning session and post-noon
session in three parallel room started by a
keynote paper followed by a number of
general paper presentations. In theme A, two
keynote papers titled “Geoscience education
and training for all stakeholders for
sustainable development” and “Supporting
Global Education” were presented by
Australia and UK respectively. The keynote
papers “Energy security in Bangladesh: How
to ensure and sustain” and “Water Crisis, a
Threat to Peace” were presented by
Bangladesh and Italy respectively on theme
B. and in theme C, the paper titled
“Downstream impacts of development – A
geovisionary analysis of case studies” was
selected as keynote lecture from India but
unfortunately the author could not attend the
conference. After all scientific sessions three
special papers – “The Growth and Rise of
Tibet Plateau”,“Applying Geoscience to
Australia’s most important Challenges” and
“The Value of Geoscientific Information as a
Contributor to the National Econmies of lowincome countries” were presented to
the whole audience by Prof. Paul Tapponnier
of France, Dr. Paul Kay of Australia and
Dr.Anthony J Reedman of UK respectively
followed by plenary and discussion sessions.
A number of issues related to Geoscience
Education, Natural Resources and
Development Activities were presented and
discussed in the Scientific Sessions. The
recommendations mentioned in the box were
made unanimously in the conference. The
Conference Proceedings will be published
soon.
The recommendation was presented by
the Convener, Ms. Afia Akhtar, at the Closing
Session of the conference. Mr. Moshiur
Rahman, the Honorable Economic Advisor
to the Prime Minister of the Government of
the Peoples’ Republic of Bangladesh and the
Mr. Mohammad Mohsin, Secretary of
EMRD, MPEMR, were present as the Chief
Episodes Vol. 33, no. 1
Guest and Special
Guest respectively.
The closing session
was held on October
28 evening at the
National Theater Main
Hall of Bangladesh
Shilpakala Academy
followed by cultural
show representing the
culture of Bangladesh.
The Honorable Chief Guest spoke in his address that
industrial revolution that shaped today’s world was
largely driven by profound use of energy and mineral
resources and geologist had a key role in locating
and developing these resources. He also mentioned
that we have experienced some unprecedented natural
disasters in the last few years – the Indian Ocean
tsunami, cyclone in Bangladesh and USA, earthquake
in China, Pakistan and Indonesia, all remind us about
the great importance of geosciences in order to cope
with challenges. He further mentioned that today’s
A. Geoscience Education
1. Geoscience education must be delivered at a level appropriate to the audience: a. Primary
Schools. b. Secondary Schools. c. Tertiary educational Establishments. d. General public
2. More surveys amongst school children and the general public are needed to find out the
respondents awareness of the relevance of Geoscience to their daily lives. This information
should be used to focus local programmes of public education.
3. The participation of women in geoscience at both the professional and informal level should be
encouraged.
4. More collaboration between national geological societies, geological surveys and the private
sector in public geoscience education should be facilitated.
5. Studies of environmental pollution (e.g. at Land fill and waste disposal sites) should be holistic
and consider both the surface and sub-surface environment.
6. Studies in medical geology/mineralogy are to be welcomed and increased Educational Websites
such as the pioneering website www.earthlearningidea.com should be widely advertised amongst
teachers in every country.
B. Natural Resources
1. In respect of energy sector development, the conference is of the opinion that for attaining
energy security on a sustainable basis for socioeconomic development, the requirements are:
a. firm political commitment,
b. necessary acts, rules and regulations as well as comprehensive policies and an integrated
energy plan approved with national consensus,
c. institutional development to implement these policies and plans, and
d. greater focus on diversification and efficient utilization of energy sources.
2. Greater emphasis should be given to the exploration and development of all solid minerals
(heavy minerals, silica sand, peat, coal, limestone etc) as well as conducting necessary research
and development in collaboration with concerned countries.
3. Greater attention should be given for the development of water resources including research
and development for the solution of all water problems such as salinity and natural arsenic
contamination. Regional cooperation for assessing the development of water resources and
monitoring the impact of water development problems should be strengthened. Planning laws
should be put into place to control the siting of boreholes. Some of the aquifers that contain the
fresh water should be retained for drinking purposes only.
4. Necessary facilities for recording and forecasting all kind of environmental hazards including
the effects of climate change (flood, drought, cyclone), landslides, earthquakes and tsunamis
etc should be developed together with necessary facilities and capabilities for rescue, relief and
rehabilitation operations.
C. Development Activities
1. For spreading geosciences awareness among the mass population, awareness programs, specific
target groups and an implementation strategy should be planned for sustainable development.
2. Geological maps, mineral maps etc aimed at providing information on georesources for the
common people of society should be produced in such a way that the target audience understands
the importance of the information while exploiting these resources.
3. Water crisis has become a major threat and to combat the crisis, aquifer conditions should be
comprehensively evaluated and aquifers properly protected with the use of such geological
knowledge.
4. Community based development programs need to be promoted particularly in rural areas.
5. Exchange of views, knowledge and ideas among geologists, engineers, planners, stakeholders
and the general public should be encouraged.
66
One of the two cruise vessels: Delegates were waiting on speed boat to land at Hironpoint
climate change is a serious global challenge
– rising seal level threaten every coastline,
powerful storm and floods threaten every
continent and as Bangladesh has flat and wide
low lining coast, we must increase our efforts
in research to comprehend and cope with
climatic change and relative sea level rise in
Bangladesh. The Special Guest and
representatives of AGID and IGEO also
spoke at the closing session.
The second part of the conference
“Geological Field Excursion to the
Sundarbans” started on 28th October night
after cultural show and dinner. A part of
conference delegates more than 70 in numbers
both from home and abroad left Dhaka in
two big busses towards Mongla Port of
Khulna for boarding the two cruise vessels
of 46 and 48 bedded for three days to visit
the Sundarbans. Delegates visited Karamjol,
Herbaria, Hironpoint or Neelkamal, Kotka
and Kacikhali – different parts of Sundarbans
– the largest single halophytic mangrove
forest in the world. This forest is in the lower
catchment or confluence of three mighty
river system, the Ganges-Brahmaputra-
Meghna, which forms the largest sedimentary
basin – the fluvio-alluvial delta of the world.
The Sundarbans is a region of transition
between freshwater of mighty river system
and marine or saline water of the Bay of
Bengal, the most preferred condition of the
luxurious growth of mangrove forest. In terms
A part of excursion delegates looking for
tiger’s foot prints at Hironpoint of the
Sundarbans.
of fauna and flora, the Sundarbans has the
highest species diversity than that of any other
mangrove forest of the world. The delegates
enjoyed very much the artificial preservation
of wildlife at Karamjol, wide range of
biodiversity at Herbaria; and especially
they were very much excited to see the fresh
foot prints of the Royal Bengal Tigers at
Hironpoint and Kotka – the most attractive
places of the Sundarbans. As per UNDP
Report of 2006, there are 442 tigers but
according to the British Geological Society
and other sources, the number of tigers varies
from 250 to 350. As per Daily Star, a total
number of 275 species of birds, 55 species
of mammals, 83 species of reptile and amphibians, 150 species of fish, 50 species of
shrimp and other invertebrates exist in the
Sundarbans.
The conference was financially supported
by Petrobangla, Overseas Ltd., Euro Bengal,
AGID-UK and also by collection of quite a
good numbers of advertisements from various
organizations of the country. IGEO supported
the conference by sending large number of
IGEO Councilors from Argentina, Portugal,
South Africa and UK. GeoDev organizers
express their sincere thanks to all of them.
Organizers are also grateful to the Biman
Bangladesh Airlines for giving permission
to use their Airlines as the official Airlines of
the conference along with 25% discount on
airfare. The Convener, on behalf of all
organizing organizations, expresses her
sincere thanks to the Energy and Mineral
Resources Division, Ministry of Power,
Energy and Mineral Resources, Govt. of the
Peoples’ Republic of Bangladesh for giving
permission and cooperation to organize the
GeoDev Int. Conf. in Bangladesh
Afia Akhtar
Convener, GeoDev Int. Conference
President, AGID and
Bangladesh Geological Society (BGS)
March 2010
67
Annual General Meeting of the Geological Society of India
26th December 2009, Aizawl, India
The 50 th Annual General Meeting
(AGM) of the Geological Society of India
was held on 26th December 2009 at 3 pm in
the Department of Geology, Mizoram
University, Aizawl – 796 009, Mizoram. The
AGM was presided over by Harsh Gupta,
President, Geological Society of India.
R.H. Sawkar, Secretary, read the meeting
notice and presented the Annual Report and
audited statement of accounts for the year
2008-2009. The following awards of the
Society were presented: (1) Prof. L. Rama
Rao Birth Centenary Award to N.C. Mehrotra.
(2) Hari Narain Award to B.R. Arora.
(3) JGSI Radhakrishna Prize to K. Vijay
Kumar and C. Leelanandam. (4) H.S. Pareek
Award to D.C. Naskar, L.K. Das and A.K.
Lahiri.
A three-day (26 - 28 November, 2009)
National Seminar on "Geodynamics,
sedimentation and biotic response in the
context of India-Asia collision" was jointly
organized by the Department of Geology,
Mizoram University and the Geological
Society of India at Aizawl. It was inaugurated
by Vanhela Pachuau, Chief Secretary to the
Government of Mizoram on 26.11.2009 at
9.00 am in the Conference Hall, Beraw Tlang,
Aizawl, Mizoram. Harsh Gupta, President,
Geological Society of India was the Guest of
Honour, D.P. Singh, Joint Secretary, Ministry
of Earth Sciences (MoES), Goverment of
India and N.C. Mehrotra, Director, Birbal
Sahni Institute of Palaeobotany (BSIP) were
present as special invitees. The seminar was
attended by 125 eminent earth scientists from
46 organizations representing research
institutions, IITs and Universities spread
over 21 States of India.
R.P. Tiwari, Convener of the seminar, in
his opening remarks stated that the whole
issue of India-Asia collision should be
understood in its totality and the resulting
processes, particularly plate motion, crustal
shortening and seismicity need to be
monitored for improved understanding and
successful modeling. N.C. Mehrotra stressed
on the need for intensifying palaeontological
researches in the sedimentary succession of
northeastern region for solving several vexed
geological issues, and assured BSIP’s help
in this regard. Sri D.P. Singh was of the view
that geological inputs are of paramount
importance in all spheres of urban planning.
He further stated that crustal structure
studies, earthquake occurrence processes,
plate motion studies and structure safety and
public awareness are thrust areas in which
Ministry of Earth Sciences is encouraging
and funding research programs. Amar Nath
Rai, Vice-Chancellor of Mizoram University,
opined that such occasions provide a platform
for taking stock of the current status of
research and in drawing contours for future
course of research. He praised the organizers
for arranging a seminar of this magnitude.
Harsh Gupta, in his a keynote address
on “The successful medium term forecast of
an M~8 earthquake in Northeast India
Region: Revisit and Extension” called for
systematic study of earthquake swarms and
quiescence preceding major earthquakes in
the Himalayan region. He was hopeful in
identifying a few locales where precursory
swarm has already occurred and the region is
presently experiencing the quiescence phase.
This may lead to making
medium term forecasts.
A follow up effort should
be taken up with multiparametric precursor
studies to see whether
success can be achieved in
short-term forecasts also.
Vanhela Pachuau in his
inaugural speech stated
that the Himalayan
mountain range including
Indo-Burmese Range
(IMR) formed due to
India-Asia collision has
th
Annual General Meeting at Aizawl, 26 November 2009.
Episodes Vol. 33, no. 1
contributed significantly in shaping the
destiny of India as the fertile lands of IndoGangetic plains that ensures food security to
the vast population of the country, and mighty
rivers systems of the Indus, the Ganges and
the Brahmaputra ensuring perennial supply
of water owe their origin to the Himalayas.
The rock succession developed due to
collision has great economic potentials
particularly for coal, oil and natural gas. At
the same time this collision has rendered the
region highly seismic and highly susceptible
for land-slides as well. It is praiseworthy that
the organizers have selected the appropriate
theme to deliberate upon and address the
pertinent issues related to the India-Asia
collision. He appealed to the scientists to
disseminate knowledge to the grassroot level
for the benefit of the society.
Valedictory session was held at 5.30 pm
on 28th November 2009. R.P. Tiwari, while
welcoming the guests, expressed grateful
thanks to the Society for serving the earth
scientist community of the country
relentlessly and selflessly under the patronage
of B.P. Radhakrishna. Benjamina, IDAS,
Registrar of the Mizoram University, also
thanked the delegates. R.H. Sawkar, thanked
the Mizoram University for inviting the
Society and holding its Annual General
Meeting in Mizoram and made the case for
field workshop in the Northeastern region,
and also for enhanced activity of the Northeast
Chapter of the Society and assured full cooperation of the Society in these ventures.
V.K. Gaur was of the view that planet earth
is unique and stressed upon the need for
protecting it by all means. A meeting of the
Northeast Chapter of the Society was
also held and Harsh Gupta addressed the
young earth scientists.
A field visit along a well preserved section
of Upper Bhuban unit of Bhuban Formation,
Surma Group was organized on 29.11.2009
in which nearly 60 delegates participated.
Variable lithology, sedimentary structures
and biota of the Bhuban Formation were the
focus of attention during the field work.
R.H. Sawkar
Secretary
Geological Society of India
Bangalore 560 019
68
Geotrails in Greece
Explore the landscape, the rocks and the nature of six Greek
areas. Find out their geology, history and civilization
The series “Geotrails in Greece” is a pilot
publication of the Greek Institute of Geology
and Mineral Exploration (IGME),
Department of General Geology and
Geological Mapping, with funding by the 3rd
European Community Support Framework
for the project: “Designation of geositesgeoparks, contribution to sustainable
development” and the sub-project: “Creating
interpretative material for promotion,
designation and community awareness on
geosites-geoparks”. The trails were traced in
2008, within the scope of the sub-project
“Planning of walking and motoring geotrails
for potential geoparks”.
Planning of geotrails around the geosites,
in combination with other attractions of
biotic, archaeological and cultural interest, as
well as compilation of interpretative, awareness, printed material is one of the objectives
of the sub-project. Same material in DB and
GIS-aided digital form is used for appli-
cations, exploiting the potential of multimedia
and interactive technologies, to attract the
interest of the visitor on the geological history
and at the same time entertain him.
The aim of the project is the designation
and protection of the geological heritage in
the framework of nature conservation, and
also the establishment of new forms of
geotourism, a modern tourist trend contributing in the socio-economic development.
Designation of geosites will have a positive
impact as well on the awareness and
knowledge of geological history at all levels
of education, in the country and internationally.
The pilot series consists of 12x28cm²
geotrails waterproof bags with 12-15 cards
each, for six Greek areas scattered all over
Greece, such as: Maroneia area, Thassos
island, Vikos- Acheron river-Ziros Lake,
Lavreotiki area, Nisyros island , W. Crete and
Gavdos island. For two of these areas
Lavreotiki and Vikos,
candidature dossiers
have been deposited to
European and UNESCO
geoparks networks.
The trails described
in the cards (12 to 15 for
each area) have been
designed to unveil some
key points in the
geological history of the
area, all intimately
connected with its
cultural history. The
introductory cards focus
on how to use the cards,
give useful information
on the area, provide a
code of conduct and
warning
of
the
responsible hiker and
also briefly outline the
natural (biotic) and
geological (abiotic)
heritage of the area, as
well as its cultural
heritage, while the rest
of the cards describe the
respective trails.
Each geotrail is
traced in a different color and matches the
informative signs to be found on the spot.
Survey form of the publication and in spot
signs is to be found at http://www.igme.gr.
The opinion of those who have used the cards
will be very helpful for their improvement.
Credits of the series follow:
The following authors have contributed
to the book titled "Geotrails in Greece",
Edited by I. Theodosiou. Athanassouli, E.,
Pavlidou, S., Theodosiou, I., on Western Crete
and Gavdos island. Epitropou, N. on Thassos
island. Janikian, Z. on Lavrion and
surroundings. Kossiaris, G., and Michail, C.,
on Maroneia area. Paschos, P., Nikolaou, E.,
Papanikos, D. on Vikos-Aoos and surroundings. Vougioukalakis, G. on Nisyros island.
The book is published by Kaleidokopio.
ISBN 978-960-98903-3-5 in English and
978-960-87453-7-7 in Greek.
Maps on the cards compiled with
Geographic Information Systems, by
Kleisiouni, E.
During the planning of the series several
similar attempts were used as reference, such
as the series “Landscapes from stone”, a joint
publication by the Geological Survey of
Northern Ireland and the Geological Survey
of Ireland, ProGEO Croatia brochures for the
Island of Rab, the bilingual publication “The
geological heritage of Psiloritis”, “the guide
of Lesvos fossilized forest parks in Plaka and
Sigri”, and other relevant printed material.
For information, publications, studies and
maps on the Geology of Greece or of specific
Greek regions, contact Institute of Geology
and Mineral Exploration of Greece, Spyros
Louis 1, Olympic Village, Entrance C, 136
77 Acharnai, Attica, Tel.: +30 210 2413175;
Fax:+30 210 2413448; Email:
[email protected];
URL: www.igme.gr
Publication is dedicated to the year of
Planet Earth.
Eirini Theodosiou
D/ment of General Geology and
Geological Mapping
Institute of Geology and Mineral
Explorations (IGME)
[email protected]
March 2010