UNIVERSITE DE DOUALA
UNIVERSITY OF DOUALA
*******************
ECOLE NORMALE SUPERIEURE D’ENSEIGNEMENT TECHNIQUE
HIGHER TEACHER’S TECHNICAL TRAINING COLLEGE
*******************
DIVISION DES TECHNIQUES INDUSTRIELLES
INDUSTRIAL TECHNICS DIVISION
*******************
DEPARTEMENT DE GENIE INFORMATIQUE
COMPUTER ENGINEERING AND INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY DEPARTMENT
=====================
Tel. : 699 753 095 /690 917 188 /696 937 955
Email :
[email protected]
ENSET
AUTOROUTE DE LA COMPETENCE TECHNOLOGIQUE ET DE L’INNOVATION
LE GENIE SANS FRONTIERE
DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION OF AN ULTRASONIC
SMART STICK WITH GPS TRACKING AND SMS
NOTIFICATION USING BLUETOOTH COMMUNICATION
FOR VISUALLY IMPAIRED PEOPLE IN CAMEROON
End of Year Memoir of the Master program presented for the purpose of awarding the Diplôme de
Professeur d’Enseignement Technique deuxième grade (DIPET II)
Redacted and presented by:
NKETCHOGUE MPATCHIE Henschel
Option: INDUSTR IAL COMPUTING (G2I)
Under the Supervisorship of
Under the Mentorship of
Prof. NNEME NNEME Léandre,
Mr. NDZANA Jean Calvin,
Lecturer at the Department of
Electrical Engineering of ENSET Douala
Associate Professor, HOD of Computer
Engineering and Information Technology,
and Director of ENSET Douala
Academic Year: 2019/2020
UNIVERSITE DE DOUALA
UNIVERSITY OF DOUALA
*******************
ECOLE NORMALE SUPERIEURE D’ENSEIGNEMENT TECHNIQUE
HIGHER TEACHER’S TECHNICAL TRAINING COLLEGE
*******************
DIVISION DES TECHNIQUES INDUSTRIELLES
INDUSTRIAL TECHNICS DIVISION
*******************
DEPARTEMENT DE GENIE INFORMATIQUE
COMPUTER ENGINEERING AND INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY DEPARTMENT
=====================
Tel. : 699 753 095 /690 917 188 /696 937 955
Email :
[email protected]
ENSET
AUTOROUTE DE LA COMPETENCE TECHNOLOGIQUE ET DE L’INNOVATION
LE GENIE SANS FRONTIERE
DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION OF AN ULTRASONIC
SMART STICK WITH GPS TRACKING AND SMS
NOTIFICATION USING BLUETOOTH COMMUNICATION
FOR VISUALLY IMPAIRED PEOPLE IN CAMEROON
End of Year Memoir of the Master program presented for the purpose of awarding the Diplôme de
Professeur d’Enseignement Technique deuxième grade (DIPET II)
Redacted and presented by:
NKETCHOGUE MPATCHIE Henschel
Option: INDUSTRIAL COMPUTING (G2I)
Members of the jury:
President: Dr. SOSSO MAYI Olivier Thiery
Rapporteur: Mr. NDZANA Jean Calvin
First Member: Mr. MBIHI DJOUMESSI Markov
Second Member: Mr. HYOUBISSIE SILEDJE Giresse
Academic Year: 2019/2020
DEDICATION
DEDICATION
TO MY FAMILY
i
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
At the time that this memoir was penned down, we acknowledge that many individuals
aided us, and we want to hereby express our deepest gratitude.
➢ To the President of the jury and its members who despite their busy schedule accepted
to preside our defence.
➢ To Prof. NNEME NNEME Léandre, Director of ENSET Douala, HOD of Computer
Engineering and Information Technology, and our Supervisor, for his pieces of advice and
his encouragement, during our entire training at his institution.
➢ To Mr. NDZANA Jean Calvin, our mentor, for his availability, critical analysis of our
idea, and correcting our report.
➢ To Mr. BETOLOUM Patrick, Technician in Automation and Industrial IT for assisting
us in the realisation of my project.
➢ To Dr. GAMOM NGOUNOU EWO Roland Christian, for admitting the pertinence of
this project and enlightening us on other aspects of this project.
➢ To my lovely sisters, Ms. NGUEYEP MPATCHIE Elsa and Ms. KEMAJOU
MPATCHIE Blessing, for proof-reading my work.
Last but not least, I would like to thank all those who both directly and indirectly helped my project
come to fruition.
ii
FOREWORD
FOREWORD
ENSET Douala is a higher teaching institution in the University of Douala created in
Cameroon by the ministerial degree No 260/CAB/PR of August 10, 1979. It has three key goals:
➢ To train teachers to teach in GTHS in Cameroon;
➢ To reuse teachers by perfecting their teaching personnel in the continuous training and;
➢ To encourage research skills in pedagogy.
ENSET Douala, as a technological institution, adopted the LMD system in 2007, which
focalises on knowledge, know-how, and expertise. Hence, it has placed a peculiar interest in the
professionalisation and the competence of its teachers in order to give an opportunity to teachers,
not only to be pedagogues, but also to be performant in the industrial sector.
At the end of their respective training, each student-teacher has to present a report (memoir)
according to the ministerial degree No 03/BU of November 26, 1985. ENSET Douala has three
cycles:
➢ First cycle (Level 100 to Level 300) sanctioned by a DIPET I;
➢ Second cycle (Level 400 and 500) sanctioned by a DIPET II and;
➢ Third cycle sanctioned by a Doctorate’s degree or PhD.
This memoir has to be compatible with the study course of the student-teacher. The
objective here is to ignite in the yet-to-be graduates, in addition to the skills of analysis, innovation,
conception, simulation and deduction, the skill of research. With this in mind, we chose the theme:
“Design and Implementation of an Ultrasonic Smart Stick with GPS Tracking and SMS
Notification using Bluetooth Communication for Visually Impaired People in Cameroon.”
The primary benefactors of this project are visually impaired Cameroonians in particular, and all
visually impaired people in the world in general; even academic and professional institutions can
benefit from this project.
iii
ABSTRACT
ABSTRACT
This end-of-year report discusses how this intelligent stick is built and how it will help
visually impaired people in their everyday lives, and has as objective to permit visually impaired
people in Cameroon to navigate freely using an Ultrasonic Smart Stick, to send SMS notifications
to family members, to permit family members to tract them, to find the cane in the case of loss. As
such we used the APTE (Application of Professional Method) based on the Value Analysis
(VA) methodology which permitted us to do: need analysis by using a Horned Beast diagram and
an Octopus diagram to define our needs and show the link between different elements of the project
respectively, to do functional analysis using Function Analysis System Technic (FAST)
diagrams to define our project’s functions and arrive at technological solutions, and to do
structured analysis using SADT (Structured Analysis Design Technic) to show a model of our
project. We used a breadboard to simulate our project and then we used a software ISIS in Proteus
to show the pinout of our system and ARES, still in Proteus, to draw our Printed Circuit Board
(PCB); also, we used Arduino IDE to program in C-language our two microcontroller boards
Arduino Nano, and MIT App Inventor to program and generate the Android installation package
(the apk file) of the Smart Stick Finder app, which will help the person with visual impairment to
both locate his cane and after finding his cane, to mute it by sending vocal commands to the
Arduino Nano through its Bluetooth device. After assembling our system, we did some tests and
noticed that: the ultrasonic sensor has an absolute error of 1cm in its readings, the higher the water
level the more sensitive the water sensor becomes in its readings, the motor and the buzzer vibrate
and beep respectively as expected, the accuracy of GPS readings depend on the last time that the
readings were taken, and the GSM module’s accuracy depends on the network. Our project
permitted us to solve the problem of visual impairment using a Smart Stick and we can rightfully
and joyously conclude that we had a 95% success.
Keywords: Smart stick, Visually impaired people, GPS, GSM, Bluetooth, Ultrasonic Sensor.
iv
RÉSUME
RÉSUMÉ
Ce mémoire discute la conception et la réalisation d’une cane intelligente pour les
malvoyants et a pour objectif d’aider le malvoyant à s’intégrer dans la communauté facilement en
lui permettant de se mouvoir aisément sans aucune assistance, d’envoyer des notifications à sa
famille en cas de danger, de localiser celui-ci, et de retrouver sa cane en cas de perte. Nous avons
utilisé la méthode APTE (Application des Techniques d’Entreprise) qui permet d’analyser les
besoins de notre système grâce au diagramme bête à corne, de voir la relation entre les différents
éléments du système grâce au diagramme pieuvre, de faire l’analyse fonctionnelle à travers les
diagrammes FAST (Analyse Fonctionnelle du System Technique) et de faire l’analyse structurelle
à travers les diagrammes SADT (Technique Structurée d’Analyse et de Modélisation). Ensuite
nous avons simulé notre système sur une plaque à essai et nous avons fait la programmation des
cartes Arduino Nano dans l’interface de développement intégré d’Arduino et la programmation
des applications Android sur MIT App Inventor. Après avoir vérifié qu’il fonctionne, nous avons
sorti le typon du système, l’imprimer sur papier glacé, puis l’avons transféré sur une plaque cuivrée
en utilisant un fer à repasser et de l’acide et l’eau oxygénée pour laisser les bonnes pistes. Le
soudage des composants sur la plaque et le montage de la maquette étaient les étapes suivantes.
Ensuite est venu le test qui a montré que les capteurs d’ultrason avaient une erreur absolue de 1cm,
le capteur d’eau était plus sensible lorsqu’il atteint des valeurs grandes et la géolocalisation est
plus fiable si le temps entre les lectures est moindre. Notre projet permet ainsi de résoudre la
problématique à savoir, d’aider les malvoyants à se mouvoir aisément, et par conséquent nous
pouvons dire, avec fierté et certitude, que nous avons obtenu une réussite de 95%.
Mots-clés: Cane intelligente, Malvoyant, GPS, GSM, Bluetooth, Capteur d’ultrason.
v
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
AVR…........ Alf and Vegard's RISC Processor
I2C/IIC…... Inter-Integrated Circuit
USART…... Universal Synchronous/Asynchronous Receiver/Transmitter
ENSET…...
Ecole Normale Supérieure d’Enseignement Technique
GPRS…....
General Packet Radio Service
GPS……....
Global Positioning System
GSM……...
Global System for Mobile communications
GTHS…....
Government Technical High School
IDE……....
Integrated Development Environment
LED………
Light Emitting Diode
LMD……... License/Bachelor’s degree—Masters—Doctorate
MP3………
Moving Pictures Experts Group Layer 3
AREF…….
Analogue REFerence
PIC……….
Programmable Interface Controller
RF……….
Radio Frequency
SMS………
Short Messaging System
WHO…….
World Health Organisation
Wi-Fi…….
Wireless Fidelity
FTDI…….
Future Technology Devices International
PCB………
Printed Circuit Board
SADT…….
Structured Analysis Design Technic
FAST…….
Function Analysis System Technic
SPI……….
Serial Peripheral Interface
APTE…….
Application of Professional Method
VA……......
Value Analysis
MOSI…….
Master Out Slave In
MISO…….
Master In Slave Out
MODEM…
MOdulation and DEModulation
vi
LIST OF TABLES
LIST OF TABLES
Table I.1 Comparative Analysis of Navigational Tools ........................................................... 12
Table II.1 Function Identification ............................................................................................. 17
Table II.2 Function Characterisation ....................................................................................... 19
Table II.3 Function Definition ................................................................................................... 21
Table III.1 Arduino Sensory Pin Configuration ...................................................................... 28
Table III.2 Arduino Tracking Pin Configuration .................................................................... 29
Table III.3 Ultrasonic Sensor Pin Specification ....................................................................... 32
Table III.4 Ultrasonic Pin Configuration ................................................................................. 32
Table III.5 Water Sensor Specifications ................................................................................... 33
Table III.6 Water Sensor Pin Configuration ............................................................................ 34
Table III.7 Buzzer Pin Definition .............................................................................................. 36
Table III.8 Buzzer Pin Configuration ....................................................................................... 36
Table III.9 Buzzer Pin Specifications ........................................................................................ 36
Table III.10 Motor Pin Configuration ...................................................................................... 38
Table III.11 Motor Specifications .............................................................................................. 38
Table III.12 HC06 Pin Configuration ....................................................................................... 49
Table III.13 HC06 Specifications............................................................................................... 49
Table III.14 Project Current Consumption.............................................................................. 54
Table III.15 Arduino Libraries .................................................................................................. 64
Table III.16 Arduino Functions ................................................................................................. 67
Table IV.1 Obstacle Detection Results (a) ................................................................................ 78
Table IV.2 Obstacle Detection Results (b) ................................................................................ 79
Table IV.3 Water Level Detection Results (a) .......................................................................... 80
Table IV.4 Water Level Detection Results (b).......................................................................... 81
Table IV.5 Sensory Module Detection Results ......................................................................... 81
Table IV.6 List and Prices of Smart Stick Components.......................................................... 86
Table IV.7 Classes of Software Projects ................................................................................... 88
Table IV.8 LOC Calculation ...................................................................................................... 88
Table IV.9 Cost of Software Development ............................................................................... 89
vii
LIST OF FIGURES
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure I.1 White Cane .................................................................................................................. 2
Figure II.1 Horned Beast Diagram............................................................................................ 15
Figure II.2 Octopus Diagram ..................................................................................................... 18
Figure II.3 Lost Cane FAST Diagram ...................................................................................... 22
Figure II.4 Tracking FAST Diagram ........................................................................................ 22
Figure II.5 Lost Cane FAST Diagram Sensory FAST Diagram ............................................ 23
Figure II.6 Sensory SADT Diagram .......................................................................................... 24
Figure II.7 Tracking SADT Diagram........................................................................................ 25
Figure III.1 Synoptic Diagram................................................................................................... 26
Figure III.2 Arduino Nano Board ............................................................................................. 27
Figure III.3 HCSR04 Ultrasonic Sensor ................................................................................... 30
Figure III.4 Obstacle Detection ................................................................................................. 31
Figure III.5 Water Sensor .......................................................................................................... 33
Figure III.6 Active (left) and Passive (right) Buzzers .............................................................. 35
Figure III.7 Mode of Operation of Buzzer................................................................................ 36
Figure III.8 DC Motor ................................................................................................................ 37
Figure III.9 Motor Construction ............................................................................................... 37
Figure III.10 Motor Pinout ........................................................................................................ 38
Figure III.11 SIM808 Front View.............................................................................................. 39
Figure III.12 SIM808 Rear View ............................................................................................... 39
Figure III.13 SIM808 Label ....................................................................................................... 40
Figure III.14 Mode of Operation of GPS .................................................................................. 41
Figure III.15 Segments of GPS .................................................................................................. 42
Figure III.16 GPS Satellite Relative Positioning Method........................................................ 43
Figure III.17 Time Division Multiple Access Technique ......................................................... 45
Figure III.18 HC06 Module ....................................................................................................... 48
Figure III.19 Circuit Diagram of Switches ............................................................................... 50
Figure III.20 Switch Configuration by Function ..................................................................... 51
Figure III.21 Push Button .......................................................................................................... 52
viii
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure III.22 Single Pole Single Throw Switch ........................................................................ 52
Figure III.23 Circuit Diagram of a Single Pole Single Throw Switch.................................... 53
Figure III.24 Power Bank........................................................................................................... 53
Figure III.25 ClickCharts Interface .......................................................................................... 55
Figure III.26 Sensory Module Flowchart ................................................................................. 56
Figure III.27 Tracking Module Flowchart ............................................................................... 57
Figure III.28 Proteus 8.8 Home Page for Windows ................................................................. 58
Figure III.29 Circuit Diagram ................................................................................................... 59
Figure III.30 3D View (Proteus) ................................................................................................ 59
Figure III.31 PCB (All Layers) .................................................................................................. 60
Figure III.32 PCB (Bottom Copper) ......................................................................................... 60
Figure III.33 Shining PCB ......................................................................................................... 61
Figure III.34 PCB Design ........................................................................................................... 61
Figure III.35 Bottom Copper PCB Layer ................................................................................. 62
Figure III.36 Top Copper PCB Layer....................................................................................... 62
Figure III.37 Smart Stick Control Centre ................................................................................ 63
Figure III.38 Arduino Desktop IDE .......................................................................................... 64
Figure III.39 Sensory Module Flowchart ................................................................................. 65
Figure III.40 Sensory Module Code (Extract) ......................................................................... 65
Figure III.41 Tracking Module Flowchart ............................................................................... 66
Figure III.42 Tracking Module Code (Extract) ....................................................................... 66
Figure III.43 Use Case Diagram ................................................................................................ 69
Figure III.44 Activity Diagram .................................................................................................. 69
Figure III.45 Sequence Diagram ............................................................................................... 70
Figure III.46 App Inventor Designer ........................................................................................ 72
Figure III.47 App Inventor Blocks Editor ................................................................................ 72
Figure III.48 Smart Stick Finder Flowchart ............................................................................ 73
Figure III.49 Launch On Boot App ........................................................................................... 74
Figure III.50 Launch On Boot Interface................................................................................... 74
Figure III.51 Smart Stick Finder Disconnected and Connected ............................................ 75
Figure IV.1 Water sensor expected readings ........................................................................... 77
ix
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure IV.2 Obstacle Detection Results .................................................................................... 79
Figure IV.3 Water Level Detection Results .............................................................................. 80
Figure IV.4 First Tracking Result ............................................................................................. 82
Figure IV.5 Second Tracking Result ......................................................................................... 83
Figure IV.6 Fourth Tracking Result ......................................................................................... 84
Figure IV.7 Android App Error Message................................................................................. 85
Figure IV.8 Android App Results from Serial Monitor .......................................................... 85
x
SUMMARY
SUMMARY
DEDICATION................................................................................................................................ i
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ............................................................................................................ ii
FOREWORD................................................................................................................................ iii
ABSTRACT .................................................................................................................................. iv
RÉSUMÉ ....................................................................................................................................... v
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ..................................................................................................... vi
LIST OF TABLES ...................................................................................................................... vii
LIST OF FIGURES ................................................................................................................... viii
SUMMARY .................................................................................................................................. xi
GENERAL INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................... 1
I LITERATURE REVIEW .......................................................................................................... 2
I.A LIMITATIONS OF EARLY NAVIGATIONAL TOOLS ............................................. 2
I.B HISTORICAL BACKGROUND OF INTELLIGENT BLIND STICKS IN THE
WORLD ..................................................................................................................................... 3
I.B.1 Ultrasonic Smart Stick for Visually Impaired People .............................................. 3
I.B.2 Ultrasonic Blind Walking Stick with Voice Playback ............................................... 4
I.B.3 Smart Blinding Stick with Holes, Obstacles and Ponds Detector Based on
Microcontroller ...................................................................................................................... 4
I.B.4 Ultrasonic Blind Walking Stick .................................................................................. 5
I.B.5 Ultrasonic and Voice Based Walking Stick for Blind People ................................... 7
I.B.6 Smart Walking Stick for Visually Impaired People Using Ultrasonic Sensors and
Arduino ................................................................................................................................... 7
I.B.7 Intelligent stick for blind friends ................................................................................ 8
I.B.8 Smart Electronic Walking Stick for Blind People ..................................................... 9
I.B.9 Ultrasonic Blind Stick with GPS Tracking System ................................................... 9
I.B.10 Ultrasonic Blind stick With GPS Tracking............................................................ 10
I.B.11 Electronic Stick for Visually Impaired People with buzzer alert ........................ 10
I.B.12 A Novel approach of bind stick based on Ultrasonic Sensors .............................. 11
I.C LIMITATIONS OF PRESENT NAVIGATIONAL TOOLS ....................................... 11
I.D COMPARISON OF PRESENT NAVIGATIONAL TOOLS ....................................... 12
II METHODOLOGY ................................................................................................................. 14
II.A WHAT IS APTE? ............................................................................................................ 14
II.B NEED ANALYSIS ........................................................................................................... 14
II.B.1 Need Identification .................................................................................................... 15
xi
SUMMARY
II.B.2 Need Validation ......................................................................................................... 15
II.C FUNCTIONAL NEED ANALYSIS............................................................................... 16
II.C.1 Definition ................................................................................................................... 16
II.C.2 Function Specifications ............................................................................................ 16
II.C.3 Function Identification ............................................................................................. 17
II.C.4 Octopus Diagram ...................................................................................................... 17
II.C.5 Function Characterisation ....................................................................................... 18
II.C.6 Results ........................................................................................................................ 19
II.D TECHNICAL-FUNCTIONAL ANALYSIS ................................................................. 19
II.D.1 Definition ................................................................................................................... 19
II.D.2 Components of a FAST Diagram ............................................................................ 20
II.D.3 Function Definition ................................................................................................... 21
II.D.4 FAST Diagrams ........................................................................................................ 21
II.E STRUCTURED ANALYSIS .......................................................................................... 23
II.E.1 Definition ................................................................................................................... 23
II.E.2 SADT Diagrams ........................................................................................................ 24
III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION................................................................................. 26
III.A DESIGN OF THE SMART STICK ............................................................................. 26
III.A.1 SYNOPTIC DIAGRAM ......................................................................................... 26
III.A.2 FONCTION OF EACH PART .............................................................................. 26
III.B IMPLEMENTATION ................................................................................................... 54
III.B.1 SMART STICK ....................................................................................................... 54
III.B.2 SMART STICK FINDER ....................................................................................... 68
IV TESTS, RESULTS AND COSTS ......................................................................................... 76
IV.A TESTS ............................................................................................................................. 76
IV.A.1 SENSORY MODULE ............................................................................................. 76
IV.A.2 TRACKING MODULE .......................................................................................... 77
IV.A.3 ANDROID APP ....................................................................................................... 77
IV.B RESULTS AND COMMENTS ..................................................................................... 78
IV.B.1 SENSORY RESULTS ............................................................................................. 78
IV.B.2 TRACKING RESULTS .......................................................................................... 82
IV.B.3 ANDROID APP RESULTS .................................................................................... 84
IV.C DIFFICULTIES ENCOUNTERED ............................................................................. 85
IV.D ESTIMATION OF THE COST OF OUR PROJECT ............................................... 86
IV.D.1 COST ESTIMATION OF THE SMART STICK ................................................ 86
IV.D.2 COST ESTIMATION OF SOFTWARE DEVELOPMENT .............................. 87
IV.D.3 TOTAL COST ESTIMATION .............................................................................. 89
IV.E FUTURE SCOPE ........................................................................................................... 90
xii
SUMMARY
GENERAL CONCLUSION....................................................................................................... 92
REFERENCES............................................................................................................................... I
TABLE OF CONTENTS ........................................................................................................... IV
LIST OF APPENDIXES ............................................................................................................ IX
Appendix 1: Arduino Nano Technical Specifications .......................................................... IX
Appendix 2: Arduino Nano Pinout ......................................................................................... X
Appendix 3: Arduino Nano Pin Layout ................................................................................ XI
Appendix 4: Arduino Nano Pin Configuration .................................................................. XII
xiii
GENERAL INTRODUCTION
GENERAL INTRODUCTION
Today’s world is moving very fast but there are some parts of the society which are lagging
behind because of some disabilities. The sense of sight is one of the best gift human beings have
received so far as 83% of human information from the environment is via sight. It is the basic
sense which provides independence in attaining our goals, fulfilling our dreams in life. But this
sense is unfortunately totally or partially absent in some people in our society referred in this
memoir as visually impaired people―including the blind. Nowadays through technology we can
develop equipments that can ease peoples’ lives. The use of technology in facilitating blind people
is one of the important research areas which need exploration. This is because it is unsafe for blind
people to walk freely outdoors or in areas to which they are not familiar.
The objective of this project is to provide an improved stick capable of solving most of, if
not all, the limitations of a traditional walking cane. To avoid uncomfortable walking experience
and for the visually impaired people to gain personal independence so that they can move from
one place to another easily and safely, we have designed an intelligent/smart electronic walking
stick for them. If there are any obstacles, it will alert the blind person to avoid that obstacle by
vibrating and beeping continuously until the obstacle is no more in his trajectory. The stick is
equipped with an SOS button which when pressed, sends the location of the visually impaired
person to his emergency contact list. In addition, family members can request the location of their
visually impaired relative by sending an SMS containing a code. Last but not least, the user can
find his lost cane by sending vocal commands in the Android app installed in his smartphone.
This end of year report is organized subdivided into four chapters. The first chapter covers
a literature review of smart stick projects. The second chapter presents the methodology used to
design our cane. The third chapter, demonstrates how we designed and assembled our cane. And
the last chapter shows the results of our tests, the cost of the cane and our project, the difficulties
we encountered, and our future works. So, let’s commence with examining a list of intelligent
canes developed around the world.
1
CHAPTER I LITERATURE REVIEW
I LITERATURE REVIEW
Visual impairment is a decreased ability to see to a degree that causes problems not
fixable by usual means, like eyeglasses. Some also include those who have a decreased ability to
see because they do not have access to glasses. The term blindness is used for complete or nearly
complete vision loss. Visual impairment may cause difficulties with normal daily activities such
as driving, reading, socializing, and walking.
Figure I.1 White Cane
In 2019, the WHO estimated that at least 2.2 billion people have a vision impairment or
blindness, of whom at least 1 billion have a vision impairment that could have been prevented or
has yet to be addressed [1]. That means that at least 28% of the world’s population are visually
impaired. Either no national survey of blindness has been undertaken in Cameroon yet, or we
simply couldn’t find one online. With a population of some 26.5 million peoples1, estimates from
the WHO suggest that approximately 1% of the population of Cameroon, and 9% of people having
an age of 50 years and above, are blind [2]. That information is of 2002 but we are almost two
decades later. Who knows, that figure has probably skyrocketed!
I.A LIMITATIONS OF EARLY NAVIGATIONAL TOOLS
In Cameroon, blind people still use traditional walking sticks to navigate around their
environment. Hence, they are exposed to some difficulties in their mobility, for example, to avoid
ponds and other obstacles.
1
Based on worldometer.info the current population of Cameroon is 26,495,721 as of Sunday, June 7, 2020.
2
CHAPTER I LITERATURE REVIEW
In developed countries and in some few developing countries, visually impaired people use
guide dogs. But it can be costly to take care of the needs of a guide dog. More to that, he needs to
be in a training phase to understand the visually impaired better. And last but not least, he can pass
away. These are just some serious limitations to having guide dogs.
What happens if they have lost their way? Is it possible to ask for help? Is it possible for
their family members to reach them? What happens if his cane is lost? Traditional canes answer
no to that.
I.B HISTORICAL BACKGROUND OF INTELLIGENT BLIND STICKS IN
THE WORLD
The first study on a smart stick was in 2011 by Shruti Dambhare and A. Sakhare. They
presented a theoretical model and a system concept to provide a smart electronic aid for blind
people. The system is intended to provide overall measures of artificial vision and object detection.
Other reports add some techniques to develop the work of this study and some of them were listed
below. Let’s present a number of intelligent blind sticks that some scientists have designed from
2015-2019.
I.B.1 ULTRASONIC SMART STICK FOR VISUALLY IMPAIRED PEOPLE
Shubham Adhe, Sachin Kunthewad, Preetam Shinde, and V. S. Kulkarni, from the E&TC
Department Rajarshi Shahu College of Engineering, in Pune, Maharashtra, India, developed an
“Ultrasonic Smart Stick for Visually Impaired People.” The blind stick is integrated with ultrasonic
sensor along with light and water sensing. Their proposed project first uses ultrasonic sensors to
detect obstacles ahead using ultrasonic waves. On sensing obstacles, the sensor passes this data to
the microcontroller. The microcontroller then processes this data and calculates if the obstacle is
close enough. If the obstacle is not that close the circuit does nothing. If the obstacle is close the
microcontroller sends a signal to sound a buzzer. It also detects and sounds a different buzzer if it
detects water and alerts the blind.
One more feature is that it allows the blind to detect if there is light or darkness in the room.
The system has one more advanced feature integrated to help the blind find their stick if they forget
3
CHAPTER I LITERATURE REVIEW
where they kept it. A wireless RF based remote is used for this purpose. Pressing the remote button
sounds a buzzer on the stick which helps the blind person to find their stick [3].
I.B.2 ULTRASONIC BLIND WALKING STICK WITH VOICE PLAYBACK
Vijayalakashmi Badre, Roma Chhabria, Tanmay Kadam, Kritika Karamchandani from the
Department of Electronics and Telecommunication, Thadomal Shahani Engineering College, in
Mumbai-50, designed an “Ultrasonic Blind Walking Stick with Voice Playback” which targets at
providing accurate detection of objects and guiding persons accordingly. They used a PIC
microcontroller to do calculations automatically at high speed with great accuracy. When they
combined the power of the latter with a pair of ultrasonic wave transmitter and receiver, they could
use PIC’s accurate time measurement feature to measure the time it takes for the sound waves to
reach an obstacle and bounce back to the receiver. By quick and fast calculations, they immediately
found the distance. And if the object is very close then the user can be alerted with a voice playback
and vibration on the stick. MP3 audio module is used for voice playback. Their project focuses on
obstacle detection, pit detection and finding location in order to reduce navigation difficulties for
visually impaired people [4].
I.B.3 SMART BLINDING STICK WITH HOLES, OBSTACLES AND
PONDS DETECTOR BASED ON MICROCONTROLLER
Mohammed Azher Therib, from the Al-Furat Al-Awsat Technical University/Engineering
Technical College of Al-Najaf, worked on the theme “Smart Blinding Stick with Holes, Obstacles
and Ponds Detector Based on Microcontroller.” The smart blind stick has three primary functions.
The first proposed is accomplished by putting the ultrasonic sensor in a measured angle of about
40o on a suitable blind stick to detect if there is a hole or stair in front of blind at about 48 cm
distance to prevent him from falling and as a result, may be causing many injuries.
The second one uses a moisture sensor which is used to measure the degree of the land/soil
moisture in front of the blind and alert him when that degree exceeds a predefined level that may
cause his feet to be wet. While the third one is made by using another ultrasonic sensor on the stick
to turn an alarm ON when there is an obstacle, person, or wall at a small distance about 50 cm near
him to prevent a collision accident. The stick is implemented practically using four leg blind cane,
4
CHAPTER I LITERATURE REVIEW
Arduino microcontroller and the three sensors. In addition to the three buzzers and one vibrator
motor, three LEDs on the stick will turn on when such problems occur [5].
I.B.4 ULTRASONIC BLIND WALKING STICK
Deepika S., Divya B. E., Harshitha K., Komala B. K., Shruthi P. C., from the Department
of Telecommunication, Dr. Ambedkar Institute of Technology, worked on a “Ultrasonic Blind
Walking Stick.” In this system the ultrasonic sensors are used to sense the obstacle (if there is any).
The sensors are set to a threshold limit; if any obstacle is found within that range, it gives beep
speech through speaker. Obstacles found in different directions are indicated with different pattern
beep and speech (Top, Middle, Pit and Water) to identify them easily. The ultrasonic sensors emit
soundscapes with frequency lying in ultrasonic spectrum (>20kHz), which is inaudible to human
ears. The sound waves hit the obstacle and bounces back to detectors. The ultrasonic sensor is used
for detecting objects/obstacles which are in front whereas two IR sensors are used to detect the
obstacles on the sides. After that, the distance of the obstacle is calculated. The signal is then sent
to the microcontroller which reads the distance of the obstacle using sensor and also commands
the buzzer. The buzzer beeps once for left side obstacle, twice for front obstacles and thrice for
right obstacles. The vibrator is also connected in parallel with the buzzer for vibration sensation.
The light sensor gives a feedback about the environment, that is it informs the user if it's
day or night or if a particular place is dark or bright. The moisture sensor is used to detect water
pits or any puddles if present. All these signals are then sent to the microcontroller which in turn
sends signal to the buzzer thereby alerting the user. The main component of this system is the RF
module which is used to find the stick if it is misplaced around. The transmitter keeps on sending
signals upon pressing a key. These signals are received by the receiver which then sends signals
to the microcontroller which in turn causes the beeping of the buzzer [6].
Abhishek Bhokare, Amruta Amberkar, Anvesh Gawde, Pratham Kale, and Abhijeet Pasi,
of the Department of Information Technology and the Shah & Anchor Kutchhi Polytechnic, spent
time on the same theme. They decided to modify and enhance the walking cane, since the blind
are only able to detect objects by touch or by cane. The user sweeps the cane back and forth in
front of them and when the cane hits an object or falls off of the edge of a stair, the user then
5
CHAPTER I LITERATURE REVIEW
becomes aware of the obstacle – sometimes too late. They added ultrasonic sensors at specific
positions to the cane that provided information about the environment to the user through audio
feedback. The main component of this system is the RF module which is used to find the stick if
it is misplaced around [7].
Other people like Yash Bais, Piyush Sharma, and S. V. Dhole, from the Electronics
Department, Bharati Vidyapeeth (Deemed to Be University) and College of Engineering Pune,
Maharashtra, India, worked on the same project. They proposed an advanced blind stick that allows
visually challenged people to navigate with ease using advanced technology. The blind stick is
integrated with three ultrasonic sensors for height, breadth and obstacle. Their proposed project
first uses ultrasonic sensors to detect obstacles ahead using ultrasonic waves. On sensing obstacles,
the sensor passes this data to the microcontroller. The microcontroller then processes this data and
calculates if the obstacle distance is close enough. If the obstacle is not that close the circuit does
nothing. If the obstacle is close, the microcontroller sends a signal through Bluetooth to the
application to sound a voice alert. One more feature is that it allows the blind to detect if there is
light or darkness in the room. The system has one more advanced feature integrated to help the
blind find their stick if they forget where they kept it. A wireless Bluetooth based remote is used
for this purpose. Thus, this system allows for obstacle detection as well as finding stick if
misplaced by disabled people [8].
Yet another group of people participated on the same project. They are Mrudula Oruganti,
Sai Charith Vadla, Vamshi Yellenki, Nikhil Shriyans, and Rushikesh. They have proposed an
innovative blind stick that allows visually challenged people to navigate with ease using advanced
technology. The blind stick is integrated with ultrasonic sensor along with light and water sensing.
Their project first uses ultrasonic sensors to detect obstacles ahead using ultrasonic waves. On
sensing obstacles, the sensor passes this data to the microcontroller. The microcontroller then
processes this data and calculates if the obstacle is close enough. If the obstacle is not that close
the circuit does nothing. If the obstacle is close, the microcontroller sends a signal to sound a
buzzer. It also detects and sounds a different buzzer if it detects water and alerts the blind. One
more feature is that it allows the blind to detect if there is light or darkness in the room. A GSM is
fixed in the stick which helps a phone to get connected via Bluetooth, which helps in receiving
6
CHAPTER I LITERATURE REVIEW
voice commands such as directions. Thus, this system allows for obstacle detection visually
disabled people [9].
I.B.5 ULTRASONIC AND VOICE BASED WALKING STICK FOR BLIND
PEOPLE
D. Sekar, S. Sivakumar, P. Thiyagarajan, R. Premkumar, M. Vivek Kumar, of the Sri
Eshwar College of Engineering, came up with an idea: “Ultrasonic and Voice Based Walking Stick
for Blind People.” This system presents a concept to provide a smart electronic aid for blind people.
The system is intended to provide overall measures artificial vision and object detection, real time
assistance via GPS. The aim of the overall system is to provide a low cost and efficient navigation
aid for blind people which gives a sense of artificial vision by providing information about the
environmental scenario of objects around them. In this system they are using the Ultrasonic sensor,
temperature sensor, humidity sensor, GPS receiver, Vibrator, Voice synthesizer, speaker or
headphone, microcontroller and battery [10].
I.B.6 SMART WALKING STICK FOR VISUALLY IMPAIRED PEOPLE
USING ULTRASONIC SENSORS AND ARDUINO
Dada Emmanuel Gbenga, Arhyel Ibrahim Shani, and Adebimpe Lateef Adekunle, from the
Department of Computer Engineering and Department of Computer Science of the University of
Maiduguri, Maiduguri, Borno State, Nigeria, and Emmanuel Alayande College of Education, Oyo,
Oyo State, Nigeria, designed a “Smart Walking Stick for Visually Impaired People Using
Ultrasonic Sensors and Arduino.” Their study proposes a new technique for designing a smart stick
to help visually impaired people that will provide them navigation. The conventional and archaic
navigation aids for persons with visual impairments are the walking cane (also called white cane
or stick) and guide dogs which are characterized by many imperfections. The most critical
shortcomings of these aids include: essential skills and training phase, range of motion, and very
insignificant information communicated. Their approach modified this cane with some electronics
components
and
sensors.
The
ultrasonic
sensors,
water
sensor,
buzzer,
and
RF
Transmitter/Receiver are used to record information about the presence of obstacles on the road.
Ultrasonic sensors have the capacity to detect any obstacle within the distance range of 2cm7
CHAPTER I LITERATURE REVIEW
450cm. Therefore, whenever there is an obstacle in this range it will alert the user. A water sensor
is used to detect if there is water in the user’s path. Most blind guidance systems use ultrasound
because of its immunity to the environmental noise. With the rapid advances of modern technology
both in hardware and software it has become easier to provide intelligent navigation system to the
visually impaired [11].
I.B.7 INTELLIGENT STICK FOR BLIND FRIENDS
Uruba Ali, Hoorain Javed, Rekham Khan, Fouzia Jabeen, Noreen Akbar, from the
Department of Computer Science, Shaheed Benazir Bhutto Women University, Pakistan, designed
an “Intelligent stick for blind friends.” They proposed a design of a blind stick which is based on
AI which can sense the obstacles in different directions. It helps the user to select the path free of
any obstacle. The directions about right path are given via audio voice. Blind sticks have been
designed earlier which can detect obstacles coming in front of blind people’s way, but they were
not designed to inform about the size of obstacles or the distance from obstacles. The direction of
their research effort is to keep the blind friend informed about the size and distance from obstacle,
i.e. is it near or far? Based on this information, recommendation about directions in a path to follow
are given.
Intelligent blind stick facilitates our blind friends’ lives and gives them protection. AI based
blind stick is an innovative stick designed for visually disabled people in order to provide them
improved navigation and helping them in making smart decisions about the selection of path that
has no obstacle till a certain distance. Our search space involves searching a best suited path for a
blind friend by using three ultrasonic sensors from front, left and right that will search the best
path which does not have an obstacle at a certain distance. These sensors sense the obstacles
through ultrasonic waves and direct the blind friend to the direction that is clear of any obstruction
to a certain distance. The knowledge is acquired through three sensors that senses the distance of
obstacle. This sensor feedback is compiled and through audio facility communicated to blind
person which is then used for decision making in selecting the path having no obstruction [12].
8
CHAPTER I LITERATURE REVIEW
I.B.8 SMART ELECTRONIC WALKING STICK FOR BLIND PEOPLE
G. J. Pauline Jothi Kiruba1, T. C. Mohan Kumar, S. Kavithrashree, G. Ajith Kumar, from
the Department of EEE, INFO Institute of Engineering, Tamilnadu, India, produced a “Smart
Electronic Walking Stick for Blind People.” Basically, the ultrasonic sensor is implemented in the
walking stick for detecting the obstacles in front of the blind/impaired persons. If there are any
obstacles, it will alert the blind person to avoid that obstacle and the alert the user in the form of a
buzz. In this technology driven world where people strive to live independently, their report
proposed a low-cost 3D ultrasonic stick for blind people to gain personal independence, so that
they can move from one place to another easily and safely. A portable stick is designed and
developed that detects the obstacles in the path of the blind using ultrasonic sensors. The buzzer
and vibration motor are activated when any obstacle is detected. In addition, the stick is equipped
with GPS and SMS message system. GPS system provide the information regarding the location
of the blind person using the stick to his family members. SMS system is used by the blind to send
SMS message to the saved numbers in the microcontroller in case of emergency. Computer
simulation is done to ameliorate the performance of the system using Proteus software [13].
I.B.9 ULTRASONIC BLIND STICK WITH GPS TRACKING SYSTEM
A. Tekade, M. Sonekar, M. Ninave, P. Dongre, from the Department of Electronics &
Telecommunication J.D. College of Engineering and Management, Nagpur, India, produced a
report on “Ultrasonic Blind Stick with GPS Tracking System.” Their objective was to provide the
visually impaired a better navigational tool. The ultrasonic blind walking stick is way more
advanced than the traditional walking stick as the use of sensors makes object detection easier.
GPS system provides the information regarding his current location. The system has one more
advanced feature integrated to help the blind find their stick if they forget where they kept it. A
wireless RF based remote is used for finding the lost stick by pressing the remote button and the
buzzer sounds on the stick. Thus, this system allows for obstacle detection as well as finding stick
if misplaced by visually disabled person. Another feature of this stick is to detect water on the
ground. This stick also indicates day or night vision for blind person. Their report discusses about
how this stick is built and how it will help blind people [14].
9
CHAPTER I LITERATURE REVIEW
I.B.10 ULTRASONIC BLIND STICK WITH GPS TRACKING
Vishnu Srinivasan B. S., Anup Murali M., Prakash. P., and N. Krishna Prasad, from the
Department of Electronics and Communication Engineering, Tamil Nadu, India, were interested
in an “Ultrasonic Blind stick With GPS Tracking.” The innovative Blind stick system is capable
of operating in user-friendly manner so that the blind person can walk independently without
getting help from others. This system assists the blind to navigate on their own. In case of
emergency situations such as high traffic density the location of the member is shared to the family
members. The prototype model consists of a stick and a hand cuff within built pulse detector. The
stick with sensors deployed can detect the obstacles in front with sensors and it will produce
various buzzer sounds depending upon the direction. The buzzer would alert the user. Furthermore,
the Sensors on the stick can detect water and fire on the ground and inform the person by buzzer.
The hand cuff is equipped with in-built GPS/GSM and pulse detector equipment, so that if the
member pulse falls below a threshold level then his location will be shared to his family. By a trial
and error method, the system can detect obstacles such as pedestrians, objects, water and heat with
greater accuracy [15].
I.B.11 ELECTRONIC STICK FOR VISUALLY IMPAIRED PEOPLE WITH
BUZZER ALERT
D. Siva Kumar, M. Prem Anand, K. Deepan Raj, P. Thalapathi Raj, R. Yashwanth, S.
Yogesh worked on an “Electronic Stick for Visually Impaired People with buzzer alert.” In their
work, we present and describe an electronic stick with buzzer alert to help visually impaired people
when they walk in uncomfortable environments. There are a greater number of people who have
difficulties and problems in their day-to-day life due to their visual problem. Walking with ease
and confidence is considered as one of their difficulties in unstructured environments. By
considering this issue, a new electronic stick with RF remote transmitter and receiver is developed
which uses Ultrasonic sensor and buzzer. Ultrasonic sensor is capable of detecting
obstacles/objects in front of the visually impaired person if there is any obstacle/object present in
their walking path. An Ultrasonic sensor calculates the distance between the visually impaired
person and an obstacle. If the calculated distance is in between the given range, there is an alert.
RF remote helps the visually impaired people to find the location of their electronic stick. Many
10
CHAPTER I LITERATURE REVIEW
experiments have been conducted in many places by a greater number of people to check and
ensure the correctness of an electronic stick and the outcomes are good enough [16].
I.B.12 A NOVEL APPROACH OF BIND STICK BASED ON ULTRASONIC
SENSORS
Kimmi Verma, Neelakshi Chawla, Riya Jain, from the Delhi Technical Campus, IP
University Greater Noida, India, inclined their research on “A Novel approach of bind stick based
on Ultrasonic Sensors.” Their work basically focuses on the theoretical concept to design an
intelligent blind stick to support visually challenged people by the use of technology. Their device
uses the combination of the two technologies of AVR microcontroller and ultrasonic sensor to help
those people to escape from hurdles. The circuit activates with the help of 6f22 9v general purpose
battery. The ultrasonic sensors consist of an emitter or transmitter, receiver along with the control
circuit. Wave of the known frequency is emitted by the emitter and after hitting the obstacle or
target it reflects back and is received by the receiver and forwards it to the microcontroller. The
AVR Microcontroller processes it and through the mathematical calculations (which is the part of
programming), time is calculated and then the distance. If the obstacle is within the range of 3m
the buzzer starts beeping and as the person goes nearer to the object, the buzzer will beep more
frequently. Stairs can also be detected with this stick. A button is glued underneath the stick. As
soon as the stick touches the ground, the working of the button is activated and ultrasonic sensor
calculate the hypotenuse and with the help of known perpendicular distance, base is calculated.
Again, with the help of buzzer but this time with different beep sound one can detect the stairs.
One RF remote with receiver is also provided along with this obstacle detecting stick. One can
find his/her misplaced stick with the help of this remote. The whole system is guided by the AVR
microcontroller [17].
I.C LIMITATIONS OF PRESENT NAVIGATIONAL TOOLS
If the blind person has a cane, he can use it to check for stairs already, isn't it? If he places
the cane in front of him, but there is no terrain, then it's a pit. If there is a lower terrain, it's stairs
down; if there is a higher terrain, it's stairs up; and otherwise it’s a wall. We don't see how adding
sensors for pit detection and hole detection is beneficial.
11
CHAPTER I LITERATURE REVIEW
Using obstacle and water sensors is very practical. And alerting the user using an alarm is
interesting but limited. What happens if he’s in a noisy environment? Also, we think that it is not
necessary to detect the luminosity of the room. We shouldn’t just add sensors because there are
available. Rather, we should add them to solve a given problem. People with visual impairment do
not need to know whether it’s light or day.
As you may have noticed, these projects have been rarely implemented in our country,
Cameroon. Also, none of the above canes is able to perform all the main functions of an intelligent
cane: obstacle avoidance, feedback, locate missing cane, track user, and notify family members.
A major limitation to these smart electronic canes is their cost. Let’s not focus on its price but on
the importation cost. It’s heavy, right? Let’s also talk about the maintenance of the cane after its
importation. Will you have to ship the cane so that a technical team can fix it or they’ll assist you
over the phone? It’s complicated and it’ll even cost you more to maintain the electronic cane. This
reminds us of a friend’s aunty who sent money to her relatives abroad to buy a laptop. Her idea
was to benefit from his visit in Cameroon. To her greatest surprise the computer got bad some few
weeks later. It means that she had to wait for her relative to leave the country with it. Little did she
know that her relative had to stay for months before traveling again. Even if her relative did go,
who will help to ship it back? So, importing canes is not an ideal solution to our problem and will
only increase the price of the smart cane, rendering it unaffordable for our dear disabled ones.
I.D COMPARISON OF PRESENT NAVIGATIONAL TOOLS
Below is a table showing a comparative analysis between present electronic sticks and our
smart stick.
Table I.1 Comparative Analysis of Navigational Tools
NAVIGATIONAL TOOLS
Ultrasonic Smart Stick for Visually
Impaired People
Ultrasonic Blind Walking Stick with
Voice Playback
COMPARISON CRITERIA
Find
Notify
Detect
Alert
GPS
Lost
Family
Obstacles User
Tracking
Cane
Members
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
No
12
CHAPTER I LITERATURE REVIEW
Smart Blinding Stick with Holes,
Obstacles and Ponds Detector Based on
Microcontroller
Ultrasonic Blind Walking Stick
Ultrasonic and Voice Based Walking
Stick for Blind People
Smart Walking Stick for Visually
Impaired People Using Ultrasonic
Sensors and Arduino
Intelligent stick for blind friends
Smart Electronic Walking Stick for
Blind People
Ultrasonic Blind Stick with GPS
Tracking System
Ultrasonic Blind stick With GPS
Tracking
Electronic Stick for Visually Impaired
People with buzzer alert
A Novel approach of bind stick based
on Ultrasonic Sensors
Ultrasonic Smart Stick with GPS
Tracking and SMS Notification using
Bluetooth Communication for Visually
Impaired People in Cameroon
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Our Smart Stick answers to all of the criteria above and it is ‘made in Cameroon.’
In this chapter, we have presented a historical background of most of the intelligent sticks
out there and presented their limitations and that of traditional canes. We also made a comparative
analysis of these smart blind walking sticks. Next, we are going to discuss about the methodology
used in our project. This will lead us to the specifications of our project. First of all, what needs
does our project solve? And how can these needs be used to design a solution to our problem? The
next chapter will shed more light on that.
13
CHAPTER II METHODOLOGY
II METHODOLOGY
“A problem well stated is a problem half solved.” These words were uttered by Charles F.
Kettering nearly 75 years ago. How true these words are today! Too many times, individuals and
teams jump into problem solving activities without fully or properly defining what is they really
need to solve, or what factors within the problem are likely or will create complications or prevent
the obvious or ready solutions from being effective, or are perhaps even detrimental [18]. We are
thus going to discuss about the APTE method which we used in the analysis of our project.
II.A WHAT IS APTE?
APTE stands for “APplication des Techniques d’Entreprise” or Application of
Professional Method. At the end of the 60’s Gilbert Barbey, French consultant for
KBWhite, created the APTE method based on the VA-VE (Value Analysis/Value Engineering)
as well as a synthesis of different think leads and scientific research. The APTE method proposes
a transversal approach to conduct a project [19]. The Functional approach concerns not only the
product and the services it provides to its user, but also the means used to achieve it. The ultimate
objective is competitiveness for which "increased quality" and "cost reduction" are compatible if
not inseparable.
Before performing any diagnoses or looking for any solution, it is necessary to define
precisely the purpose and objectives of the system. This must be done without any preconceived
solution, by questioning the existing solution in order to open all possible solutions. The studied
solution is replaced in its use environment (product, process, …) in order to express the functions
or services to be provided to the users. For each service to be provided, the APTE method
characterises the expected quality level (users satisfaction criteria). At the final stage of product
design, the solutions will reach the expected quality level at the lowest cost/resources.
II.B NEED ANALYSIS
The need analysis is the process of identifying and evaluating needs to create or to improve
a given system. It takes place in two steps: identification and validation of the need [20].
14
CHAPTER II METHODOLOGY
II.B.1 NEED IDENTIFICATION
Here, we need to define the objectives and limits of our system. In order words, we need
to define the need to which our system answers. To accomplish this, the APTE method proposes
a diagram called the Horned Beast Diagram. The Horned Beast Diagram permits us to ask three
fundamental questions about our system (0):
➢ To whom is the Smart Stick useful? (1)
➢ On who/what does the Smart Stick have an effect? (2)
➢ For what purpose is the Smart Stick prepared? (3)
Figure II.1 Horned Beast Diagram
II.B.2 NEED VALIDATION
After the Need Identification that the Smart Stick should answer to, it is necessary to
validate this need. Also known as Stability Study, the Need Validation is performed to identify
why does the need exist and what may alter or suppress the need. As such, the following three
questions are asked:
➢ Why does this need exist? Because blind people or visually impaired people are almost
always assisted.
15
CHAPTER II METHODOLOGY
➢ What could make it disappear? If blind people or visually impaired people were all
healed.
➢ Is there any risk the need will disappear? No.
II.C FUNCTIONAL NEED ANALYSIS
II.C.1 DEFINITION
The Functional Analysis is the fundamental step in the Smart Stick creation or
improvement. It consists in finding, characterizing, prioritizing the functions of the Smart Stick
expected by the visually impaired people to navigate freely. To define a function, we use the
French standard NFX 50-151 which stipulates that "function is an action of the product or of one
of its components expressed exclusively in terms of finality". The function can be formulated by
using a verb that describes the action and a noun to define the object of that action. This way to
express a function seems to be easy but actually searching for the most descriptive verb and noun
can be difficult and time consuming. For that reason, Functional Analysis is always undertaken by
a team and not by one person operating individually. The functional analysis is performed in
several steps [20].
II.C.2 FUNCTION SPECIFICATIONS
The designer to develop the most efficient product, must take into account the expectations
of the customer, usually expressed in terms of service functions in a document called Functional
Specifications (or CdCF: Cahier de Charge Fonctionnel). We have developed it in agreement
with the initiator of the project. It is presented below:
➢ Navigate freely;
➢ Track visually impaired;
➢ Notify family members in case of an emergency;
➢ Locate lost cane;
➢ Use cane for at least 8 hours non-stop;
➢ The cane should be compact.
16
CHAPTER II METHODOLOGY
II.C.3 FUNCTION IDENTIFICATION
In this stage, the functional analysis is aimed at the formulation of functions and its
description. In fact, the Smart Stick has to fulfil several functions in order to reach the goal and
satisfy the fundamental need of the visually impaired. There are several types of methods which
may be used to identify all functions such as the Intuitive method, RESAU2 method, etc. The
approach we used to enumerate with accuracy what the Smart Stick is to accomplish is based on
the "Octopus Diagram". This approach consists of listing the elements, which the Smart Stick
will have to coexist with, and identifying functions that it will have to accomplish. During this
step, we draw a diagram in which the Smart Stick is surrounded with its elements, functions being
represented like relations between these various elements. This diagram defines main and
constraint functions of the Smart Stick. We call "main functions" the interactions between the
Smart Stick and two elements and "constraint functions" connections between the Smart Stick and
one element of its environment.
Table II.1 Function Identification
Main Function
Constraint function
Name Description
Name Description
MF1
Avoid obstacles
CF3
MF2
Alert visually impaired CF4
CF5
Send SMS
CF6
Autonomy
Locate visually impaired
Find lost cane
II.C.4 OCTOPUS DIAGRAM
The following figure shows the Octopus diagram for our project.
“Recherche intuitive; Etude du cycle de vie et de l’environnement; l’analyse Séquentielle des fonctions; Examen des
efforts et des mouvements; Analyse d’un produit de référence; Utilisation des normes et des règlements.” It can be
translated respectively to: Intuitive Research, Environment and Life Cycle Study, Sequential analysis of functions,
Motions and efforts examination, Reference product analysis, Regulation and standards use.
2
17
CHAPTER II METHODOLOGY
Figure II.2 Octopus Diagram
II.C.5 FUNCTION CHARACTERISATION
Once the functions are identified, it is necessary to obtain more specific analysis in the next
step which consists of characterising the functions. For that, it is necessary to carry out:
➢ Appreciation Criterion: Each function should present one or more criteria associated to
the verb of the function. The criterion is a mean for measuring and verifying function
importance.
➢ Level: The level of a criterion is a means to provide details about the criterion.
➢ Flexibility: It consists in defining if the levels of criteria should be respected or may be
negotiated. The levels of flexibility can be classified as follows:
•
F=0: Imperative level (no flexibility);
•
F=1: slightly negotiable level;
•
F=2: Negotiable level;
•
F=3: Very negotiable level.
➢ Function Hierarchy: The standard AFNOR proposed classification the functions in order
of importance. To perform this, an importance scale coefficient was adopted as follows:
•
K=1: "useful";
18
CHAPTER II METHODOLOGY
•
K=2: "slightly important";
•
K=3: "important";
•
K=4: "very important";
•
K=5: "vital."
II.C.6 RESULTS
In a workgroup session of some experts, we identified, specified and summarized the
results in one table. The functions were adapted to the Smart Stick through three lifecycle phases:
planning, accessibility and use. The table obtained is called "Functional table."
Table II.2 Function Characterisation
Function
No.
Name
MF1 Avoid obstacles
Alert
visually
MF2
impaired
Locate visually
CF3
impaired
CF4 Send SMS
CF5 Find lost cane
CF6
Autonomy
Type
Service
Service
Classification method
Appreciation
Flexibility
Level
Criteria
(F)
Distance
30cm 1
- Vibration
2KHz 0
- Sound
Hierarchy
(K)
5
5
Constraint Duration
120s
3
4
Constraint Duration
Constraint Distance
Power
Constraint
discharge
30s
30m
3
1
4
4
8hrs
2
3
II.D TECHNICAL-FUNCTIONAL ANALYSIS
II.D.1 DEFINITION
This is also called Function Analysis System Technic (FAST). Its goal is to decompose
the main functions of a design problem into technical functions in order to end up with
technological solutions.
In developing a functional model, the team is forced to make a very clear definition of
the project by considering key questions such as:
➢ What are we trying to achieve?
19
CHAPTER II METHODOLOGY
➢ What must we get right if we are trying to achieve it?
➢ What considerations do we need to bear in mind while designing it?
➢ How do various design solutions contribute towards achieving the desired outcome?
II.D.2 COMPONENTS OF A FAST DIAGRAM
Three key questions are addressed in a FAST Diagram:
➢ How do you achieve this function? This question is answered by the function to the right.
The answer begins with “In.”
➢ Why do you do this function? This question concerns the function to the left. The answer
begins with “For.”
➢ When you do this function, what other functions must you do? This question applies to
one or more functions located at the same level. The answer starts with “Simultaneously.”
is not a time orientation, but indicates cause and effect.
A function should be identified as to what is to be accomplished by a solution and not how
it is to be accomplished. How the function is identified determines the scope, or range of solutions
that can be considered.
Scope lines represent the boundaries of the study i.e. that aspect of the problem with which
the study team is concerned, and are shown as two vertical lines on the FAST model. The left of
the scope line determines the basic function(s) of the study. The basic functions will always be the
first function(s) to the immediate right of the left scope line and identifies the beginning of the
study.
The objective or goal of the study is called the “Highest Order Function”, located to the
left of the basic function(s) and outside of the left scope line. The result of the study is called the
Technological Solutions which is outside the scope lines to the right. Those function(s) to the
immediate right of the left scope line represent the purpose or mission of the product or process
under study and are called Basic Function(s). Once determined, the basic function will not change.
If the basic function fails, the product or process will lose its market value. All functions to the
20
CHAPTER II METHODOLOGY
right of the basic function(s) portray the conceptual approach selected to satisfy the basic function
and are referred to as secondary functions.
II.D.3 FUNCTION DEFINITION
All of the different functions of our FAST Diagram are presented and defined in the table
below.
Table II.3 Function Definition
Type of
Function
TF1:
Navigate
freely
TF2:
Tract User
TF3:
Send SOS
TF4:
Find Cane
Highest Order
Function
Detect
obstacles,
Detect waterlevel
Verify SMS
Code
Press
Emergency
Button
Ring Cane,
Mute cane
Basic
Function
Secondary
Function
Technological
Solution
Compare distance
and water-level,
Calculate time
Alert User
Ultrasonic Sensors,
Water-level sensor,
Buzzer, Motor, Arduino
Get
Location
Send
Location
GSM, GPS, Button,
Arduino Nano
Get
Location
Send
Location
GSM, GPS, Button,
Arduino Nano
None
Alert User
Bluetooth, Buzzer,
Motor
II.D.4 FAST DIAGRAMS
The following diagrams show the function analysis of our project.
21
CHAPTER II METHODOLOGY
Figure II.3 Lost Cane FAST Diagram
Figure II.4 Tracking FAST Diagram
22
CHAPTER II METHODOLOGY
Figure II.5 Lost Cane FAST Diagram Sensory FAST Diagram
II.E STRUCTURED ANALYSIS
II.E.1 DEFINITION
Developed by Douglas T. Ross and SofTech, Inc., Structured Analysis Design Technic
(SADT) typically creates a hierarchy employing a single abstraction mechanism. The structured
analysis method employs IDEF03 based on IDEF4 which is process driven, and starts with a
purpose and a viewpoint. This method identifies the overall function and iteratively divides
functions into smaller functions, preserving inputs, outputs, controls, and mechanisms necessary
to optimize processes. Also known as a functional decomposition approach, it focuses on the
connection between functions leading to structured data.
3
IDEF0, used to produce a function model. A function model is a structured representation of the functions, activities
or processes within the modelled system or subject area.
4
It stands for “Icam DEFinition”, where ICAM is an acronym for “Integrated Computer Aided Manufacturing.”
23
CHAPTER II METHODOLOGY
The functional decomposition of the structured method describes the process without
delineating system behaviour and dictates system structure in the form of required functions. The
method identifies inputs and outputs as related to the activities.
II.E.2 SADT DIAGRAMS
The diagram below shows the SADT diagram of our project:
Figure II.6 Sensory SADT Diagram
24
CHAPTER II METHODOLOGY
Figure II.7 Tracking SADT Diagram
After stating or analysing our needs or problem using various tools like FAST and SADT,
we obtained primary and secondary functions that our cane should accomplish. We also arrived at
technological solutions, that the hardware that can be used to solve the problem. This brings us to
the next part of our report, that of discussing in details how these materials communicate between
them, what their specifications, pinouts and functions are.
25
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
In the preceding chapter, we presented the hardware that we are going to use to design and
implement our smart stick. In this chapter, we’ll present both the hardware and the softwares that
we used for our project. We’ll state the characteristics of each element, its pinout, how it is
connected to the microcontroller board, and why we are using it. This is the key chapter of our
memoir as it will show step-by-step how exactly our smart stick was designed.
III.A DESIGN OF THE SMART STICK
III.A.1 SYNOPTIC DIAGRAM
The visual aid below shows the synoptic diagram of our project.
Figure III.1 Synoptic Diagram
III.A.2 FONCTION OF EACH PART
III.A.2.1 ARDUINO NANO
The Arduino Nano is a small, complete, and breadboard-friendly board based on
the ATmega328P; offers the same connectivity and specs of the UNO board in a smaller form
factor. This microcontroller is also used in Arduino UNO. It is a small size board and also flexible
with a wide variety of applications. Other Arduino boards mainly include Arduino Mega, Arduino
Pro Mini, Arduino UNO, Arduino YUN, Arduino Lilypad, Arduino Leonardo, and Arduino Due.
26
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
And other development boards are AVR Development Board, PIC Development Board, Raspberry
Pi, Intel Edison, MSP430 Launchpad, and ESP32 board [21].
Figure III.2 Arduino Nano Board
This board has many functions and features like an Arduino Duemilanove board. However,
this Nano board is different in packaging. It doesn’t have any DC jack so that the power supply
can be connected straight to the pins VCC & GND using a small USB port. This board can be
supplied with 6 to 20 volts using a mini USB port on the board.
III.A.2.1.1 JUSTIFICATION OF COMPONENT
Maybe you are all wondering why we chose the Arduino Nano board in our Smart Stick.
This is so for at least three main reasons:
➢ First, it is one of the tiniest Arduino boards on the market with a dimension of 1.70 in x
0.73 in or 4.32 cm x 1.85 cm. This makes it almost perfect for our Smart Stick project
where portability is a vital element to consider.
➢ Second, it is one of the cheapest Arduino boards. And as you well know, price is another
vital element in the design of our cane.
➢ Last but not least, the total number of pins used for our project is less than the total pins
that the Nano boards has.
We chose to use two Arduino Nano boards. The reason is a technical one. It will be
explained in detail while we’ll be explaining the SIM808 module. But just to whet your appetite,
it’s because of the Smart Stick’s primary function, which was seen in the last chapter: to detect
obstacles. But during the tests, we notice that the GPS module’s time efficiency depends on the
27
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
last time it looked for the visually impaired person’s location. It’ll take more time to get his location
after two full days than after one full day; it’ll take more time to get his location after three full
days than after two full day; and so on and so forth… But once he has gotten his location, it’ll take
him lesser time to get his new location than the previous time he did so.
During the time the GPS module is getting/finding his location, an interruption is called
which blocks the execution of other functions of the cane, like to detect obstacles which is of
paramount importance in the design of our Smart Stick. That’s why we separated our project into
a sensory module and a tracking module.
➢ Sensory module: Here, the Arduino Nano is attached to sensors to gather input from the
environment and send to the Arduino Nano. With its comparator, it’ll send vibrational and
buzzing feedbacks to the visually impaired person. He in turn will interpret this and take a
decision.
➢ Tracking module: Here, the Arduino Nano is attached to the SIM808 module to track the
user (by his family members) and for him to notify his family members in case of any
emergencies.
III.A.2.1.2 ARDUINO PIN CONFIGURATION
The tables below show how the Arduino Nano pins were connected:
Table III.1 Arduino Sensory Pin Configuration
Pin No. Component Name Component Pin
A0
A1
A2
A3
A4
A5
A7
D5
Ultrasonic sensor 3
Ultrasonic sensor 2
Ultrasonic sensor 1
Water level sensor
28
Echo
Trigger
Echo
Trigger
Echo
Trigger
SIGNAL
VCC
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
D9
Buzzer 1
VCC
D10
Motor 1
VCC
D11
D12
RX
Bluetooth
TX
Table III.2 Arduino Tracking Pin Configuration
Pin No. Component Name Component Pin
A7
D2
D9 (PWRKEY)
SIM808
RX
D3
TX
D4
Motor 1
VCC
D5
Button 2
VCC
D6
Buzzer 1
VCC
III.A.2.1.3 COMMUNICATION
The communication of an Arduino Nano board can be done using different sources like
using an additional Arduino board, a computer, otherwise using microcontrollers. The
microcontroller using in Nano board (ATmega328) offers serial communication (UART TTL).
This can be accessible at digital pins like TX, and RX. The Arduino software comprises of a serial
monitor to allow easy textual information to transmit and receive from the board.
The TX & RX LEDs on the Nano board will blink whenever information is being sent out
through the FTDI & USB link in the direction of the computer. The library-like SoftwareSerial
allows serial communication on any of the digital pins on the board. The microcontroller also
supports SPI & I2C (TWI) communication. [18]
More than one component in our project needed to communicate with the main board
(“serially”). And they can’t all be connected to the Pin D0 (TX) and Pin D1 (RX). Hence, we use
an Arduino library called SoftwareSerial which permits us to use any pins for serial
communication.
29
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
III.A.2.2 ULTRASONIC SENSOR
The HC-SR04 is a type of ultrasonic sensor which uses sonar to find out the distance of
the object from the sensor. It provides an outstanding range of non-contact detection with high
accuracy and stable readings. It includes two modules like ultrasonic transmitter & receiver. This
sensor is used in a variety of applications like measurement of direction and speed, burglar alarms,
medical, sonar, humidifiers, wireless charging, non-destructive testing, and ultrasonography [22].
Figure III.3 HCSR04 Ultrasonic Sensor
III.A.2.2.1 PIN DEFINITION
This sensor includes four pins and the role of each pin is discussed below.
➢ Pin1 (Vcc): This pin provides a +5V power supply to the sensor;
➢ Pin2 (Trigger): This is an input pin, used to initialize measurement by transmitting
ultrasonic waves by keeping this pin high for 10us;
➢ Pin3 (Echo): This is an output pin, which goes high for a specific time period and it will
be equivalent to the duration of the time for the wave to return back to the sensor;
➢ Pin4 (Ground): This is a GND pin used to connect to the GND of the system.
III.A.2.2.2 MODE OF OPERATION
The HC-SR04 Ultrasonic sensor comes with four pins namely Vcc pin, Trigger pin, Echo
pin, and Ground pin. This sensor is used to measure the accurate distance between the target and
the sensor. This sensor mostly works on the sound waves.
30
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
When the power supply is given to this module, it generates the sound waves to travel
throughout the air to hit the necessary object. These waves strike and come back from the object,
then collects by the receiver module.
Figure III.4 Obstacle Detection
Here, both the distance as well as time has taken is directly proportional because the time
taken for more distance is high. If the trigger pin is kept high for 10 µs, then the ultrasonic waves
will be generated which will travel at the sound speed5. So, it creates eight cycles of sonic burst
that will be gathered within the Echo pin. The sensor uses the speed of sound in air and the time
taken by the sensor to transmit and receive the sound to calculate the distance. Thus, detects the
object and finds the location of the object. The actual distance can be calculated by dividing its
value by two as the time will be twice, that is to and from the sensor [22]. The following formula
is obtained: s = (V * t ) / 2 , where:
➢ ‘s’ is the required distance;
➢ ‘V’ is the speed of sound in air and;
➢ ‘t’ is the time taken for sound waves to return back after striking the object.
III.A.2.2.3 PIN SPECIFICATION
The table below shows the name and properties of each pin of an ultrasonic sensor.
5
The speed of sound is approximately 341 meters per second in air.
31
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
Table III.3 Ultrasonic Sensor Pin Specification
Properties
Values
Properties
Values
Voltage
5VDC
Accuracy
3mm
Current
15mA
Measuring Angle
15o
Frequency
40KHz
Trigger Input Signal
10µS TTL pulse
Range
2cm-4m
Dimension
45 x 20 x 15mm
III.A.2.2.4 PIN CONFIGURATION
Here, we are giving an example for the HC-SR04 ultrasonic sensor using the Arduino
board. This sensor is interfaced with an Arduino board. The required components of this project
mainly include the Arduino board, HC-SR04 ultrasonic sensor, breadboard, and jumper wires. The
connections of this project are very simple like the following:
Table III.4 Ultrasonic Pin Configuration
Ultrasonic Sensor Arduino Nano
VCC
5V
TRIG
A1, A3, A5
ECHO
A0, A2, A4
GND
GND
III.A.2.2.5 JUSTIFICATION OF COMPONENT
The following are a list of the advantages of using ultrasonic sensors:
➢ It provides precise and noncontact distance measurement within 2cm to 3m range.
➢ Ultrasonic measurement works in any lighting condition, hence a supplement for infrared
object detector.
➢ Three pins make it easy to connect to the development board directly or with an extension
cable without any soldering.
➢ Their high frequency, sensitivity, and penetrating power make it easy to detect all types of
materials.
➢ This sensor is not affected due to atmospheric dust, rain, snow, colour or transparency of
objects, etc.
32
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
➢ It has higher sensing distance (in centimetres and inches) compare to inductive/capacitive
proximity sensor types.
➢ It provides good readings in sensing large sized objects with hard surfaces.
➢ Our ultrasonic sensors are easy to use and not dangerous during operation to nearby objects,
people or equipment
III.A.2.3 WATER SENSOR
Water level sensor is used to measure the water level in a given environment. It is also used
in sensing rainfall, and even liquid leakage. Also, it can be used to detect the presence, the volume
and/or the absence of water.
Figure III.5 Water Sensor
III.A.2.3.1 MODE OF OPERATION
To use it as water level detector, the sensor must be positioned so that parallel lines are
perpendicular to the sensor water level. The signal pin S will give us a greater value as the sensor
is immersed.
III.A.2.3.2 SPECIFICATIONS
The table below shows the name and properties of each pin of a water sensor.
Table III.5 Water Sensor Specifications
Properties Operating Voltage Working current Sensor Type Detection area
Values
5VDC
<20mA
33
Analog
40mm x16mm
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
III.A.2.3.3 PIN CONFIGURATION
The table below shows the name and the pinout of an ultrasonic sensor.
Table III.6 Water Sensor Pin Configuration
Water level Sensor SIGNAL VCC GND
Arduino Nano
A7
D5
GND
III.A.2.4 BUZZER
Piezo buzzer is the handy sound generator used in electronic circuits to give an audio
indication. It is widely used as an alarm generator in electronic devices. It is available in various
types and sizes to suit the requirements. A Piezo buzzer has a Piezo disc and an oscillator inside.
When the buzzer is powered, the oscillator generates a frequency around 2-4 kHz and the Piezo
element vibrates accordingly to produce the sound. An ordinary Piezo buzzer works between 3 –
12 volts DC [25].
III.A.2.4.1 TYPES OF BUZZERS
There are several different kinds of buzzers. They are categorized by Type, Sound Level,
Frequency, Rated Voltage, Dimension, and Packaging Type. The most common types available
are Electro-acoustic, Electromagnetic, Electromechanics, Magnetic and Piezo-electric, among
others [26].
Buzzers are mainly divided into two types. The first one is active buzzers and the second
one is passive buzzers. In an active buzzer, additional circuitry is added to make the use it easier,
but it only produces a single type of sound or tone. It required a DC power source for generating
the sound or beep.
Similarly, passive buzzer can generate different sounds or beeps. It depends upon the
frequency which is provided to this passive buzzer. For generating any type of sound, the desired
frequency signal is provided to its oscillating circuit then it generates the desired frequency sound
or beep. It requires an AC power source for generating the sound or beep.
34
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
The simple way to distinguish between a passive buzzer and an active buzzer is:
➢ If you apply a DC voltage to them and it buzzes, it is an active buzzer.
➢ The height of the two is slightly different, the active buzzer has a height of 9mm, while the
passive has height of 8mm.
➢ On the pins side, you can see a green circuit board in passive buzzer. No circuit board and
closed with a black is an active buzzer.
➢ Using an ohmmeter, if you find the resistance between buzzer pins is about 16ohm (or
8ohm), the buzzer is passive.
➢ An active buzzer has a built-in oscillating source so it will oscillate at one specific
frequency. A passive buzzer on the other hand runs at a range of frequencies (2KHz-5KHz).
Figure III.6 Active (left) and Passive (right) Buzzers
III.A.2.4.2 MODE OF OPERATION
Piezo buzzers are simple devices that can generate basic beeps and tones. They work by
using a piezo crystal, a special material that changes shape when voltage is applied to it. If the
crystal pushes against a diaphragm, like a tiny speaker cone, it can generate a pressure wave which
the human ear picks up as sound6. When DC power input passes through an active buzzer, it will
make resonance device generate sound signal. We can see the schematic diagram below for the
working principle of active buzzer:
The oscillation in the Piezo buzzer is between 2 – 4 kHz. This sound is piercing because our hearing threshold is
maximum in this frequency.
6
35
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
Figure III.7 Mode of Operation of Buzzer
III.A.2.4.3 PIN DEFINITION
The table below shows the name and properties of each pin of an ultrasonic sensor.
Table III.7 Buzzer Pin Definition
Pin Number Pin Name Description
1
Positive
Identified by (+) symbol or longer terminal lead.
2
Negative
Identified by (-) symbol or short terminal lead.
III.A.2.4.4 PIN CONFIGURATION
The table below shows the name and the pinout of an ultrasonic sensor.
Table III.8 Buzzer Pin Configuration
Buzzer Arduino Nano
VCC
D6, D9
GND
GND
III.A.2.4.5 SPECIFICATIONS
The table below shows the name and properties of each pin of an ultrasonic sensor.
Table III.9 Buzzer Pin Specifications
Properties
Rated
Voltage
Operating
Voltage
Rated
current
Sound Type
Resonant
Frequency
Values
6V DC
4-8V DC
<30mA
Continuous
Beep
~2300 Hz
36
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
III.A.2.5 DC MOTOR
A motor converts electrical energy into mechanical energy. There are three different types
of motors: DC motor, Servo motor, and Stepper motor.
A DC motor (Direct Current motor) is the most common type of motor. A DC Motor uses
direct current―in other words, the direction of current flows in one direction.
Figure III.8 DC Motor
A DC Motor usually consists of: An armature core, an air gap, poles, and a yoke which
form the magnetic circuit; an armature winding, a field winding, brushes and a commutator which
form the electric circuit; and a frame, end bells, bearings, brush supports and a shaft which provide
the mechanical support. See the DC Motor cutaway near the bottom of this resource page. The
latter can be felt through vibrations. DC motors normally have just two leads, one positive and one
negative. If you connect these two leads directly to a battery, the motor will rotate. If you switch
the leads, the motor will rotate in the opposite direction.
Figure III.9 Motor Construction
37
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
We do not need to control the speed of the motor; we don’t need an L298N motor driver
or other components. All we need to do is to permit the user to feel vibrations through this motor.
This motor can be found anywhere even in toy cars.
III.A.2.5.1 PIN CONFIGURATION
The table below shows the name and pinout of each pin of a motor.
Table III.10 Motor Pin Configuration
Pin Name
Terminal 1 Terminal 2
Arduino Nano GND
D4, D10
Figure III.10 Motor Pinout
III.A.2.5.2 SPECIFICATIONS
The table below shows the name and properties of each pin of a motor.
Table III.11 Motor Specifications
Properties
Values
Operating Voltage
4.5V to 9V
Recommended/Rated Voltage 6V
Current at No load
<70mA
No-load Speed:
9000 rpm
Loaded current
~250mA
Motor Size
27.5mm x 20mm x 15mm
38
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
III.A.2.6 SIM808 MODULE
SIM808 module is a GSM and GPS two-in-one function module. It is based on the latest
GSM/GPS module SIM808 from SIMCOM, supports GSM/GPRS Quad-Band network and
combines GPS technology for satellite navigation. It features ultra-low power consumption in
sleep mode and integrated with charging circuit for Li-Ion batteries, that make it get a super long
standby time and convenient for projects that use rechargeable Li-Ion battery. It has high GPS
receive sensitivity with 22 tracking and 66 acquisition receiver channels. Besides, it also supports
A-GPS that available for indoor localization. The module is controlled by AT command7 via
UART and supports 3.3V and 5V logical level [23].
Figure III.11 SIM808 Front View
Figure III.12 SIM808 Rear View
7
The latest firmware support Bluetooth function. You can use all AT commands for BT functions right now.
39
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
Figure III.13 SIM808 Label
III.A.2.6.1 GENERAL FEATURES
Below are the global features of the SIM808 module:
➢ Quad-band: 850/900/1800/1900MHz
➢ GPRS multi-slot class 12/10
➢ GPRS mobile station: class B
➢ Compliant to GSM phase 2/2+
•
Class 4 (2 W @ 850/900MHz)
•
Class 1 (1 W @ 1800/1900MHz)
➢ Dimensions: 24*24*2.6mm
➢ Weight: 3.3g
➢ Control via AT commands
•
3GPP TS 27.007, 27.005
•
SIMCOM enhanced AT Commands)
➢ Supply voltage range: 3.4 ~ 4.4V
40
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
➢ Low power consumption
➢ Operation temperature: -40℃ ~ 85℃
III.A.2.6.2 GPS
Global Positioning System (GPS) is a network of orbiting satellites used to locate
positions anywhere in space back to earth. This kind of technology can be used in various areas
like commercial usage, military, and civil services all over the world. GPS can be used for these
purposes: perfect timing, trilateration, positioning of satellites and error connection. This system
can be used universally for 24 hours. Before discussing GPS based travel assistant for blind people
let us know about the concept of GPS technology [24].
Figure III.14 Mode of Operation of GPS
III.A.2.6.2.1 INTRODUCTION TO GPS
The global positioning system consists of three segments: space segment (SS), control
segment (CS) and a user segment (US). Control and space segments are developed, operated and
maintained by US air force; the user segment includes both civilian and military users and their
GPS equipment.
41
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
➢ Space Segment: This segment consists of 24 satellites from which 21 are navigational
space vehicles and 3 are active spares orbiting at an altitude of 11000 nautical miles. These
satellites are predictable and stable due to their high altitude. This system consists of six
orbital planes that are inclined at 55 degrees and equally placed at about 60 degrees on the
equatorial plane.
➢ Control Segment: It comprises a master control station, an alternate motor-control station,
six monitor stations, and four ground antennas. These monitor stations are positioned all
over the world, to measure the signal from space vehicles which are incorporated into an
orbital model of each satellite. Dedicated ground antennas are used for broadcasting signals
to satellites.
➢ User Segment: This system consists of receivers which can be handheld or installed on
aircraft, ship, submarines, cars, and trucks. GPS receivers can decode, detect and process
the signals to satellites. These signals can be changed into position, time and velocity. This
segment can be used in different applications such as satellite positioning, shipping,
military, surveying, and tracking.
Figure III.15 Segments of GPS
Global Positioning System (GPS) has been around since the 80's and is still one of the most
important features you can add to any electronic system. The idea of tracking something (or
someone) is cool enough but doing so without a telephone or an internet connection is much cooler.
42
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
III.A.2.6.2.2 HOW LOCATION IS TRACKED
The whole GPS system depends on 24 (minimum) satellites orbiting the earth. Each
satellite continually broadcast their current time and position. Generally, a GPS receiver requires
a connection to at least four of these satellites to acquire data to compute for position. The receiver
also computes for the clock difference between it and the satellite [25].
Figure III.16 GPS Satellite Relative Positioning Method
The standard horizontal accuracy of a GPS receiver is 15 meters. Augmentation schemes
like WAAS (Wide Area Augmentation System) and DGPS (Differential GPS) are implemented to
improve accuracy to within 2-3 meters. Assisted GPS (A-GPS) is another augmentation scheme
mostly utilized by mobile phones. In this scheme, the GPS receiver seeks "assistance" from mobile
networks to improve accuracy.
III.A.2.6.2.3 NMEA SENTENCES
The computed longitude, latitude and altitude can be read by devices using the NMEA 0183
protocol (National Marine Electronics Association). This protocol creates "sentences" in ASCII
format that contains those data plus additional information like bearing and speed. Each sentence
starts with a set of $GPXXX codes that describes what information is contained within the
sentence.
43
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
Out of all those codes, only 19 has been interpreted. Out of all those 19, only one code type
is generally used to read location: $GPRMC which is defined as "Recommended minimum
specific GPS/Transit data". An alternate to $GPRMC is $GPGGA which is defined as "Global
Positioning System Fix Data".
III.A.2.6.2.4 INTERFACING WITH GPS DEVICES
Because NMEA sentences are strings, we can simply extract the information we need
through various programming techniques. The NMEA sentences can be read from GPS devices
via serial communication, particularly RS-232. Therefore, any microcontroller with USART
features can read data from a GPS peripheral.
If you are inside a room, your GPS might not receive information from satellites. For best
results, see to it that the GPS antenna can "see" the sky.
It would be better for us to free up the hardware serial port for debugging and to connect
the GPS device to other pins. That is why we used the Software Serial library. We also used the
DFRobot library to easily interface with the GPS receiving.
III.A.2.6.2.5 AT COMMANDS
AT commands are commands which are used to control the modems, where AT stands for
Attention. These commands were derived from Hayes commands which were used by the Hayes
smart modems. Every wireless, as well as the dial up modems, require an AT command to interact
with a computer machine.
III.A.2.6.2.6 SPECIFICATIONS
The table below shows the properties of a SIM808 module.
➢ Receiver type
•
Tracking: 22
•
Acquisition channel: 66
•
GPS L1 C/A code
➢ Sensitivity
44
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
•
Tracking: -165 dBm
•
Cold starts: -148 dBm
➢ Time-To-First-Fix
•
Cold starts: 32s (typ.)
•
Hot starts: <1s
•
Warm starts: 3s
➢ Accuracy
•
Horizontal position: <2.5m CEP
III.A.2.6.3 GSM
GSM is a standard set developed by the European Telecommunications Standards Institute
(ETSI) to describe technologies for second-generation (2G) digital cellular networks. GSM is a
mobile communication modem; it is stands for Global System for Mobile Communication
(GSM). The idea of GSM was developed at Bell Laboratories in 1970. It is widely used mobile
communication system in the world. GSM is an open and digital cellular technology used for
transmitting mobile voice and data services operates at the 850MHz, 900MHz, 1800MHz and
1900MHz frequency bands [26].
GSM system was developed as a digital system using Time Division Multiple Access
(TDMA) technique for communication purpose. A GSM digitizes and reduces the data, then sends
it down through a channel with two different streams of client data, each in its own particular time
slot. The digital system has an ability to carry 64 kbps to 120 Mbps of data rates.
Figure III.17 Time Division Multiple Access Technique
45
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
TDMA technique relies on assigning different time slots to each user on the same
frequency. It can easily adapt to data transmission and voice communication and can carry 64kbps
to 120Mbps of data rate.
III.A.2.6.3.1 GSM ARCHITECTURE
A GSM network consists of the following components:
➢ A Mobile Station: It is the mobile phone which consists of the transceiver, the display
and the processor and is controlled by a SIM card operating over the network.
➢ Base Station Subsystem: It acts as an interface between the mobile station and the network
subsystem. It consists of the Base Transceiver Station which contains the radio transceivers
and handles the protocols for communication with mobiles. It also consists of the Base
Station Controller which controls the Base Transceiver station and acts as a interface
between the mobile station and mobile switching centre.
➢ Network Subsystem: It provides the basic network connection to the mobile stations. The
basic part of the Network Subsystem is the Mobile Service Switching Centre which
provides access to different networks like ISDN, PSTN etc. It also consists of the Home
Location Register and the Visitor Location Register which provides the call routing and
roaming capabilities of GSM. It also contains the Equipment Identity Register which
maintains an account of all the mobile equipments wherein each mobile is identified by its
own IMEI (International Mobile Equipment Identity) number.
The security strategies standardized for the GSM system make it the most secure
telecommunications standard currently accessible. Although the confidentiality of a call and
secrecy of the GSM subscriber is just ensured on the radio channel, this is a major step in achieving
end-to- end security.
III.A.2.6.3.2 GSM MODEM
A GSM modem is a device which can be either a mobile phone or a modem device which
can be used to make a computer or any other processor communicate over a network. A GSM
modem requires a SIM card to be operated and operates over a network range subscribed by the
network operator. It can be connected to a computer through serial, USB or Bluetooth connection.
46
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
It should also be noted that not all phones support this modem interface for sending and receiving
SMS messages, particularly most smartphones like the Blackberry, iPhone and Windows mobile
devices.
A GSM modem can also be a standard GSM mobile phone with the appropriate cable and
software driver to connect to a serial port or USB port on your computer. GSM modem is usually
preferable to a GSM mobile phone. The GSM modem has wide range of applications in transaction
terminals, supply chain management, security applications, weather stations and GPRS mode
remote data logging.
In these days, the GSM mobile terminal has become one of the items that are constantly
with us. Just like our wallet/purse, keys or watch, the GSM mobile terminal provides us a
communication channel that enables us to communicate with the world. The requirement for a
person to be reachable or to call anyone at any time is very appealing. In this project, as the name
implies, the project is based on GSM network technology for transmission of SMS from sender to
receiver. SMS sending and receiving is used for ubiquitous access of the Smart Stick. The system
proposes two sub-systems. Appliance control subsystem enables the user to control home
appliances remotely and the security alert subsystem gives the automatic security monitoring.
The Smart Stick allows family members to track the visually impaired person. The second
aspect is that the user is capable of sending his location through SMS in case of danger.
GSM will allow communication anywhere, anytime, and with anyone. The functional
architecture of GSM employing intelligent networking principles, and its ideology, which provides
the development of GSM is the first step towards a true personal communication system that
enough standardization to ensure compatibility.
III.A.2.6.3.3 SPECIFICATIONS
Below are the specifications for sending SMS via GSM or GPRS:
➢ Point to point MO and MT
➢ SMS cell broadcast
➢ Text and PDU mode
47
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
III.A.2.7 BLUETOOTH MODULE
The main function of the HC06 module is to communicate with the user’s smartphone
through Bluetooth. The user will send vocal commands to the Smart Stick Finder App on his app.
Then, his Bluetooth device will send info the HC06. The HC06 will then relay this information to
the Arduino Nano through serial communication.
Figure III.18 HC06 Module
III.A.2.7.1 MODE OF OPERATION
After connecting the module, you have to write the program in Arduino IDE to receive and
send data to the module. For successful wireless communication you need to remember a few
things [27]:
➢ In programming you need to set default baud rate of UART serial communication to 9600.
The value is default setting of module and can be change in program.
➢ The module is a slave and so you need a master to establish a successful wireless interface.
For that you need another [Arduino + module (with master feature)] setup or you can use
a smartphone as a master and search for HC-06 slave.
➢ The master searches for slave and connects to it after authenticated with password. The
HC-06 module has default password ‘1234’ which can be changed.
➢ In program you can receive data master sends (after authentication) and perform tasks
based on it.
48
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
➢ You can also type in AT command in serial terminal to communicate with the module.
III.A.2.7.2 PIN CONFIGURATION
The table below shows the connection between Arduino and the HC06 module.
Table III.12 HC06 Pin Configuration
Bluetooth Module VCC TX
Arduino Nano
5V
RX
GND
D12 D11 GND
III.A.2.7.3 SPECIFICATIONS
The table below shows the pins of the HC06 module and their properties.
Table III.13 HC06 Specifications
Properties Band
Values
2.40GHz
to
2.48GHz,
ISM
Operating
Safety feature voltage
range
Authentication
and encryption
+3.3V
to
+6V
Operating
temperature
range
Operating
Distance
Current
-20ºC
to
+55ºC
40mA
<100m
III.A.2.7.4 JUSTIFICATION OF COMPONENT
This module was chosen for the following reasons:
➢ It is the best option when short distance wireless communication is needed. The module is
used for wireless communications of less than 100 meters.
➢ The module is very easy to interface and to communicate.
➢ The module is one of the cheapest solutions for wireless communication of all types present
in the market.
➢ The module consumes very less power to function and can be used on battery operated
mobile systems.
➢ The module can be interfaced with almost all controllers or processors as it uses UART
interface.
49
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
We could have used a 433MHz Radio-Frequency (RF) module. The setback we had using
it was that it needed a separate microcontroller to work with. Its detection range is a few
centimetres and we would have bought an extra pair of antennae to extend its detection range.
III.A.2.8 BUTTON
It is also called a switch. It is a device which is designed to interrupt the current flow in a
circuit, in other words, it can make or break an electrical circuit. Every electrical and electronics
application uses at least one switch to perform ON and OFF operation of the device. A switch can
perform two functions, namely fully ON (by closing its contacts) or fully OFF (by opening its
contacts).
When the contacts of a switch are closed, the switch creates the closed path for current
flow and hence the load consumes the power from the source. When the contacts of a switch are
open, no power will be consumed by the load as shown in below figure [28].
Figure III.19 Circuit Diagram of Switches
Switches can be of mechanical or electronic type.
➢ Mechanical switches must be activated physically, by moving, pressing, releasing, or
touching its contacts. This what we are going to use in our project.
➢ Electronic switches do not require any physical contact in order to control a circuit.
These are activated by semiconductor action.
Mechanical switches can be classified into different types based on several factors such as
method of actuation (manual, limit and process switches), number of contacts (single contact and
50
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
multi contact switches), number of poles and throws (SPST, DPDT, SPDT, etc.), operation and
construction (push button, toggle, rotary, joystick, etc), based on state (momentary and locked
switches), etc. Based on the number of poles and throws, switches are classified into following
types:
➢ SPST (Single Pole Single Throw);
➢ SPDT (Single Pole Double Throw);
➢ DPST (Double Pole, Single Throw);
➢ DPDT (Double Pole Double Throw).
The pole represents the number of individual power circuits that can be switched. Most of
the switches are designed have one, two or three poles and are designated as single pole, double
pole and triple pole.
The number of throws represents the number of states to which current can pass through
the switch. Most of the switches are designed to have either one or two throws which are designated
as single throw and double throw switches.
For our project, we’ll need a Push Button Switch for emergency purposes and a Single Pole
Single Throw Switch (SPST) to power on/off our cane.
Figure III.20 Switch Configuration by Function
51
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
III.A.2.8.1 PUSH BUTTON SWITCH
It is a momentary contact switch that makes or breaks connection as long as pressure is
applied (or when the button is pushed). Generally, this pressure is supplied by a button pressed by
someone’s finger. This button returns its normal position, once the pressure is removed.
The internal spring mechanism operates these two states (pressed and released) of a push
button. It consists of stationary and movable contacts, of which stationary contacts are connected
in series with the circuit to be switched while movable contacts are attached with a push button.
Push buttons are majorly classified into normally open, normally closed and double acting push
buttons as shown in the figure below.
Figure III.21 Push Button
This push button is in this project called the SOS button. It permits the user to send his
location should any emergency arise.
III.A.2.8.2 SINGLE POLE SINGLE THROW SWITCH
This is the basic ON and OFF switch consisting of one input contact and one output contact.
It switches a single circuit and it can either make (ON) or break (OFF) the load. The contacts of
SPST can be either normally open or normally closed configurations.
Figure III.22 Single Pole Single Throw Switch
52
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
Figure III.23 Circuit Diagram of a Single Pole Single Throw Switch
This SPST switch is used in this project to power on or to power off the Smart Stick. When
powered off, it is used as a traditional cane. When powered on, its new technological features can
be explored.
III.A.2.9 POWER SUPPLY
Since our Smart Stick is a mobile and embedded system, it needs its own power supply.
Taking into consideration the power requirements of our different components, we chose to use a
Power bank with the following specifications:
➢ Charge: 20000mAh
➢ Input: 5VDC/2A
➢ Output 1: 5VDC/2A
➢ Output 2: 5VDC/2A
Figure III.24 Power Bank
53
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
We chose this power supply because the SIM808 demands a current of 2A and the overall
voltage used is 5V. Also, it has two outputs which is fairly suitable to power up our three main
components namely the two Arduino Nanos and the SIM808 module.
We want our Smart Stick to power on for at least 8 hours before being charged again.
Hence, the following calculations are deduced:
Table III.14 Project Current Consumption
Elements Arduino
Nano
Current 2*20mA
Draw
Elements Motor
Ultrasonic
Sensor
3*15mA
Water
Sensor
20mA
Buzzer
GSM
GPS
Total
Current
Draw
2*30mA
20mA
24mA
244mA
2*70mA
Level Bluetooth
Module
40mA
Total
145mA
Total Project Current Consumption 389mA
Battery Capacity in mAh = Project Current Consumption in mA * Run Time in Hours
Run Time (in Hours) = 8 h * 389 mA = 3112 mAh.
Hence, we need a power bank of at least 3500 mAh 5V 2A.
III.B IMPLEMENTATION
III.B.1 SMART STICK
III.B.1.1 CLICKCHARTS
This software permits one to quickly create visual representations of a process or
organization by making a diagram with ClickCharts. The most popular chart designs can be
crafted within the program, including Flowcharts, UML, ER diagrams, data flow diagrams, mind
map diagrams, and more. ClickCharts makes it easy to get started with chart templates and an
intuitive user interface. The program provides a variety of symbols, shapes, and colours to get the
most out of your diagrams. When finished, print your diagram or save to your computer with
commonly used formats like .pdf, .png, .jpg, and more. This app has the following features:
54
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
➢ Latest version: ClickCharts 5.25 for Windows
➢ Requirements: Windows 7 and above
➢ Languages: English, French, Polish, Chinese, Italian, Japanese, German, Spanish
➢ Author: NCH Software
➢ Size: <5MB
Figure III.25 ClickCharts Interface
III.B.1.2 FLOWCHARTS
The diagrams below explain the sensory and tracking modules.
55
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
Figure III.26 Sensory Module Flowchart
56
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
Figure III.27 Tracking Module Flowchart
57
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
III.B.1.3 PROTEUS
Proteus is a simulation and design software tool developed by Labcenter Electronics for
Electrical and Electronic circuit design. It also possesses 2D CAD drawing feature. It is a software
suite containing schematic, simulation as well as PCB designing.
➢ ISIS (Intelligent Schematic Input System) is the software used to draw schematics and
simulate the circuits in real time. The simulation allows human access during run time, thus
providing real time simulation.
➢ ARES (Advanced Routing and Editing Software) is used for PCB designing with
electronic routing, mounting, and processing functions. It has the feature of viewing output
in 3D view of the designed PCB along with components.
➢ The designer can also develop 2D drawings for the product.
Figure III.28 Proteus 8.8 Home Page for Windows
58
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
III.B.1.3.1 CIRCUIT DIAGRAM
This circuit diagram was drawn in ISIS and will permit us to automatically generate its
PCB using ARES.
Figure III.29 Circuit Diagram
III.B.1.3.2 3D VIEW
The 3D view of the circuit is automatically generated using the 3D Visualizer of Proteus.
Figure III.30 3D View (Proteus)
59
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
III.B.1.3.3 PRINTED CIRCUIT BOARD (PCB)
III.B.1.3.3.1 DRAWING THE PCB DESIGN
The PCB of our Smart Stick first had to be drawn of course in ARES. Using the Autoplacer feature will automatically place the different components on the PCB. But we don’t want
that. This is because we want the PCB to fit the dimensions of a traditional cane. And as such,
we’ve chosen the dimensions 154 mm x 40.5 mm.
Next, we have to use the Auto-router feature to automatically wire up the PCB with tracts,
linking the different connections in the bottom copper section. But we noticed that the distance
between the tracts are too close and can be problematic during the domestic fabrication of the PCB.
So, we have manually redrawn the PCB, distancing the tracts further. Here is a preview.
Figure III.31 PCB (All Layers)
Figure III.32 PCB (Bottom Copper)
60
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
III.B.1.3.3.2 DOMESTIC PCB MANUFACTURING
We printed our PCB at a cybercafé and manufactured it at home.
➢ Requirements
•
A glossy photo A4 paper;
•
A blanc single layer PCB;
•
An etching mixture of acid (ferric chloride) and oxygenated water;
•
A metallic sponge to clean the PCB.
➢ Procedure
•
Print the PCB design on a glossy A4 sheet of paper.
•
Cut the PCB according to the required dimension.
Figure III.33 Shining PCB
•
Clean the board using a metallic sponge, soap and water until it is shining.
•
Transfer the PCB design from the A4 paper to the board using a laundry iron. Iron the
paper until its completely white.
Figure III.34 PCB Design
61
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
•
Use a marker to reinforce and make more visible the PCB design. Put the board in a
plastic basin containing an etching solution to remove any unwanted copper layer. Wait
until it becomes yellow like the top layer. Don’t wait too long if not the acid will remove
the desired copper.
•
Use a sponge to watch off impurities from the board to obtain an exposed copper layer.
Rinse the board with water.
•
Drill holes on the board.
•
Place wires for the top copper layer, then place the components on the board through
the holes (from smaller to bigger ones). Solder them progressively onto the board.
Figure III.35 Bottom Copper PCB Layer
Figure III.36 Top Copper PCB Layer
III.B.1.3.3.3 ASSEMBLING COMPONENTS
The figure beneath shows the main part of our Smart Cane after being assembled.
62
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
Figure III.37 Smart Stick Control Centre
III.B.1.4 ARDUINO IDE
Arduino IDE is an open-source tool that makes it possible for users to write as well as
upload code to a work environment in real-time. The Arduino Software (IDE) allows you to write
programs and upload them to your board. The software can easily be deployed in any Linux, Mac,
or Windows operating systems. In the Arduino Software page, you will find two options:
➢ Arduino Web Editor: If you have a reliable Internet connection, you should use the online
IDE (Arduino Web Editor). It will allow you to save your sketches in the cloud, having
them available from any device and backed up. You will always have the most up-to-date
version of the IDE without the need to install updates or community generated libraries.
Tutorials are present for users who have little experience dealing with the tool’s
framework.
➢ Arduino Desktop IDE: If you would rather work offline, you should use the latest version
of the desktop IDE.
63
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
Figure III.38 Arduino Desktop IDE
III.B.1.4.1 LIBRARIES USED
To effectively use Arduino IDE, we needed to use libraries. Arduino libraries are
collections of code which make it possible for Arduino microcontroller boards like the Arduino
Nano to connect easily to sensors, displays etc… The following libraries were used in our project.
Table III.15 Arduino Libraries
Library Name
Library Definition
ProfileTimer
To show the duration of tasks
SoftwareSerial
To use any pins for serial communication
DFRobot_sim808 To use the SIM808 without AT commands
Ultrasonic
To use multiple ultrasonic sensors with little interference
III.B.1.4.2 PROGRAM CODE
III.B.1.4.3 SENSORY MODULE
Here, we’ll present, not the entire code, but an extract of our code and a flowchart listing
some of the functions used and how they interact with each other.
64
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
Figure III.39 Sensory Module Flowchart
Figure III.40 Sensory Module Code (Extract)
65
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
III.B.1.4.4 TRACKING MODULE
We’ll do the same procedure as in the previous heading.
Figure III.41 Tracking Module Flowchart
Figure III.42 Tracking Module Code (Extract)
66
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
III.B.1.4.5 FUNCTIONS USED
This is a list of all the functions used in our project, including their role.
Table III.16 Arduino Functions
Function Name
Function Definition
pinConfig()
To configure pins either as OUTPUT or as INPUT
allOutputHigh()
To set all output pins (buzzer and motor) HIGH
allOutputLow()
To set all output pins to LOW
setup()
To execute a set of commands once
detectObstacle()
To detect obstacles at the left, right and front
detectWaterLevel()
To send feedback once the predefined water level is attained
readWaterSensor()
To read the value of the water sensor
millis()
To set the timer (this is a non-blocking function)
ringCane()
To either ring the cane or mute it
simInit()
To verify the presence of a valid SIM card
detectButtonPressed()
To verify whether the SOS button is pressed
onButtonPressed()
To use getGPS() and sendGPS() once the SOS button is pressed
detectUnreadSMS()
To verify the presence of an unread SMS
onUnreadSMS()
To use getGPS() and sendGPS() once a valid code is present
sim808.readSMS()
To read any SMS
sim808.deleteSMS()
To delete an SMS on reception (after extracting its information) in
order not to exhaust the SIM’s memory.
validSMSCode()
To verify whether the message contains a valid code
sim808.isSMSunread()
Stores SMS information like phone number, date, time, message
getGPS()
To fetch the user’s location
sim808.attachGPS()
To turn on the GPS power
sim808.detachGPS()
To turn off the GPS power
sendGPS()
To send the user’s location through SMS
67
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
III.B.2 SMART STICK FINDER
This is the app that will help the user to locate his cane in case he lost it. This app is was
created to run on smartphones running the Android operating system. It is therefore important to
present to you a model of our app. We’ll use the Unified Modeling Language (UML).
III.B.2.1 UNIFIED MODELING LANGUAGE (UML)
UML is a standardized modeling language consisting of an integrated set of diagrams,
developed to help system and software developers for specifying, visualizing, constructing, and
documenting the artifacts of software systems, as well as for business modeling and other nonsoftware systems. The UML represents a collection of best engineering practices that have proven
successful in the modeling of large and complex systems. The UML is a very important part of
developing object-oriented software and the software development process. The UML uses mostly
graphical notations to express the design of software projects. Using the UML helps project teams
communicate, explore potential designs, and validate the architectural design of the software. In
this section, we will give you a description of each UML diagram we used [29].
There are 13 diagrams in the UML divided into two: structure diagrams and behaviour
diagrams. Structure diagrams show the static structure of the system and its parts on different
abstraction and implementation levels and how they are related to each other. Behaviour diagrams
show the dynamic behaviour of the objects in a system, which can be described as a series of
changes to the system over time. There are seven types of behaviour diagrams as follows, three of
which are vital to create our app: activity, use case and sequence diagrams.
III.B.2.1.1 USE CASE DIAGRAM
A use-case model describes a system's functional requirements in terms of use cases. It is
a model of the system's intended functionality (use cases) and its environment (actors). Use cases
enable you to relate what you need from a system to how the system delivers on those needs.
68
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
Figure III.43 Use Case Diagram
III.B.2.1.2 ACTIVITY DIAGRAM
Activity diagrams are graphical representations of workflows of stepwise activities and
actions with support for choice, iteration and concurrency. It describes the flow of control of the
target system.
Figure III.44 Activity Diagram
69
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
III.B.2.1.3 SEQUENCE DIAGRAM
The Sequence Diagram models the collaboration of objects based on a time sequence. It
shows how the objects interact with others in a particular scenario of a use case.
Figure III.45 Sequence Diagram
III.B.2.2 MIT APP INVENTOR
An easy and quick way to build an app is by using the website http://appinventor.mit.edu/.
MIT App Inventor is a web application integrated development environment originally provided
70
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
by Google, and now maintained by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). It allows
newcomers to computer programming to create application software (apps) for two operating
systems (OS): Android, and iOS, which, as of 8 July 2019, is in final beta testing. It is free and
open-source software [30].
It uses a graphical user interface (GUI) very similar to the programming languages Scratch
(programming language) and the StarLogo, which allows users to drag and drop visual objects to
create an application that can run on android devices. App-Inventor Companion is the program
that allows the app to run and debug on devices.
III.B.2.2.1 REQUIREMENTS
What are the software and hardware requirements for using App Inventor? The points
below answer that.
➢ Computer and the operating system
•
Macintosh (with Intel processor): Mac OS X 10.5 or higher
•
Windows: Windows XP, Windows Vista, Windows 7
•
GNU/Linux: Ubuntu 8 or higher, Debian 5 or higher
➢ Browser
•
Mozilla Firefox 3.6 or higher
•
Apple Safari 5.0 or higher
•
Google Chrome 4.0 or higher
•
Microsoft Internet Explorer is not supported
➢ Phone or Tablet (or use the on-screen emulator): Android Operating System 2.3
("Gingerbread") or higher
III.B.2.2.2 APP INVENTOR DESIGNER
App Inventor Designer permits us to design an app's user interface by arranging both on
and off-screen components.
71
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
Figure III.46 App Inventor Designer
III.B.2.2.3 APP INVENTOR BLOCKS EDITOR
App Inventor Blocks Editor enables us to program the app's behaviour by putting blocks
together.
Figure III.47 App Inventor Blocks Editor
72
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
III.B.2.2.4 FLOWCHART
The figure below shows in details how the Smart Stick Finder works.
Figure III.48 Smart Stick Finder Flowchart
III.B.2.2.5 AUTORUN SMART STICK FINDER
Remember that the visually impaired person should not start the app. The app should
autorun. But how can we accomplish. After some research, we found an app called Launch on
Boot. Follow the steps bellow to configure to autorun our app [31].
73
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
➢ Open the Launch On Boot app.
Figure III.49 Launch On Boot App
➢ Activate the Enabled and the Launch when device wakes up? buttons.
➢ Then, click on SELECT APP to select an app and choose Smart_Stick.
Figure III.50 Launch On Boot Interface
74
CHAPTER III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION
III.B.2.2.6 SMART STICK FINDER ANDROID APP
The following pictures show the Smart Stick Finder App’s window when the Bluetooth is
connected and when it is disconnected.
Figure III.51 Smart Stick Finder Disconnected and Connected
This chapter had as aim to present all the hardware and softwares used to design our cane.
We also showed the interaction between different elements of the cane using flowcharts. The next
phase is to do some tests and compare the results obtained with the expected results.
75
CHAPTER IV TESTS, RESULTS AND COSTS
IV TESTS, RESULTS AND COSTS
After dumping the desired code into the Nano using Arduino IDE the Smart Stick is ready
to be tested, the project is now ready to be tested. The testing will focus on analysing the distance
from the cane to the obstacles, the response of the cane in the presence of water, the response when
the SOS push button is pressed and the reply to any phone which asks for the location of the
visually impaired.
IV.A TESTS
IV.A.1 SENSORY MODULE
IV.A.1.1 OBSTACLE DETECTION AND FEEDBACK TESTS
Initially, we need to find the distance between the ultrasonic sensors and a given obstacle
using a ruler. Then, we find that same distance using the ultrasonic sensors. Next, we need to
compare both results using a table and find the error in the measurements. Then, the distance is
gradually varied for different objects of varying size. We expect to hear buzzing sounds and
vibrations from the cane when the distance between any given object is less than 30 cm.
IV.A.1.2 WATER LEVEL DETECTION AND FEEDBACK TESTS
To get accurate readings out of the water level sensor, it is recommended that we first
calibrate it for the particular type of water that you plan to monitor. As you know pure water is not
conductive. It’s actually the minerals and impurities in water that makes it conductive. So, a given
sensor may be more or less sensitive depending on the type of water you use.
Before we start storing data or triggering events, we should see what readings we are
actually getting from our sensor. Using the pinouts shown in the previous chapter, we noted what
values our sensor outputs when it was completely dry, when it was partially submerged in water
and finally when was completely submerged.
The following values are what we expect to see in the serial monitor: when the senor is dry
(0), when it is partially submerged in the water (~420) and when it is completely submerged
76
CHAPTER IV TESTS, RESULTS AND COSTS
(~520). Also, according to our program code we expect to hear buzzing sounds and vibrations
from the cane when the reading from the water level sensor is greater than 255.
Figure IV.1 Water sensor expected readings
IV.A.2 TRACKING MODULE
Testing the SIM808 module consists of answering the following questions:
➢ Does the cane respond when the SOS button is pressed? If yes, does the user receive
feedback and how long does it take to respond?
➢ How long does it take for the SIM808 to search for the location? Are the GPS coordinates
accurate?
➢ Does the SIM808 respond to any message or does it respond only to messages having the
code? If the latter is true, how long does it take for the sender to receive a notification?
IV.A.3 ANDROID APP
Testing the SIM808 module consists of answering the following questions:
➢ Does the Smart Stick Finder App automatically launch when the device is unlocked and
when it is started?
➢ Does the Android app automatically connect to the cane’s Bluetooth module?
➢ Does the proximity sensor work?
77
CHAPTER IV TESTS, RESULTS AND COSTS
➢ How accurate is the speech recognizer in recognising the user’s voice?
➢ How long does it take for the cane to be muted and to be ringing after receiving vocal
commands from the user?
IV.B RESULTS AND COMMENTS
IV.B.1 SENSORY RESULTS
IV.B.1.1 OBSTACLE DETECTION RESULTS
From these tests we can say that the Smart Stick is able to accurately calculate the distance
from obstacles. Some of the results of the test from the serial monitor of Arduino IDE are shown
below. All the results are in centimetres (cm). Also, ‘1’ means true (that the buzzer and motor were
turned on) and ‘0’ false.
Table IV.1 Obstacle Detection Results (a)
Expected Value Real Value Absolute Error Buzzer Motor Observation
(Ev)
(Rv)
= Ev – Rv
On
On
2
3
1
1
1
4
5
1
1
1
6
7
1
1
1
8
9
1
1
1
10
11
1
1
1
12
13
1
1
1
14
15
1
1
1
16
17
1
1
1
18
19
1
1
1
20
21
1
1
1
22
23
1
1
1
24
25
1
1
1
26
27
1
1
1
28
29
1
1
1
30
31
1
1
1
78
Error
CHAPTER IV TESTS, RESULTS AND COSTS
32
33
1
0
0
34
35
1
0
0
36
37
1
0
0
38
39
1
0
0
40
41
1
0
0
Figure IV.2 Obstacle Detection Results
Table IV.2 Obstacle Detection Results (b)
Number of Tests Number of Tests Succeed % Tests Succeeded
20
19
95%
These results show that this cane can accurately detect obstacles and ponds from the user. The user
was immediately alerted through buzzing sounds and vibrations.
79
CHAPTER IV TESTS, RESULTS AND COSTS
IV.B.1.2 WATER LEVEL DETECTION RESULTS
After a vessel containing water was placed on the table and the water level sensor was
immersed into it, continuous beep sounds were heard and the vibrations of the motor were felt.
The following visual aid depicts the results for water detection to prevent the user from entering
into stationary water in his environment. They were taken from Arduino IDE’s serial monitor.
Figure IV.3 Water Level Detection Results
Table IV.3 Water Level Detection Results (a)
Water Level Buzzer On Motor On
256
1
1
260
1
1
263
1
1
268
1
1
290
1
1
300
1
1
80
CHAPTER IV TESTS, RESULTS AND COSTS
301
1
1
303
1
1
304
1
1
305
1
1
307
1
1
308
1
1
309
1
1
313
1
1
315
1
1
Table IV.4 Water Level Detection Results (b)
Number of Tests Number of Succeed Tests % Succeeded Tests
15
15
100%
Table IV.5 Sensory Module Detection Results
Name of Sensors
Number of Tests Number of Tests Succeed % Tests Succeeded
Ultrasonic Sensor
20
19
95%
Water Sensor
15
15
100%
Average % Tests Succeeded
97.5%
Since the value is greater than 256, our default water level, we observed that the motor and
the buzzer were turned on. The higher the value of the water sensor, the more sensitive it becomes,
the reason why 520 is the level when fully immersed but 420 when the tank is half-full.
The water detector had to come in contact with water to activate an alarm. It had to be
touching the water before being able to detect water, which is why it was placed at the bottom of
the stick, not underneath.
81
CHAPTER IV TESTS, RESULTS AND COSTS
IV.B.2 TRACKING RESULTS
Consider the scenarios below and observe the results.
➢ A message “Hey!” was sent to the user’s telephone. No reply was observed from the cane.
(See Figure IV.4 First Tracking Result)
➢ Next, we sent another message “LOCATION”. Immediately after, we received his location.
Google Maps showed him at 450m from where he was expected to be found.
Figure IV.4 First Tracking Result
➢ We sent again another SMS with the wrong code: “Patrick”. No reply was observed. We
then pressed the SOS button 2 times and the location was sent. Google Maps showed him
at 400m from where he was supposed to be. (See Figure IV.5 Second Tracking Result)
➢ A third wrong code message was sent: “Visual impairment”. Once more, no reply was
observed.
82
CHAPTER IV TESTS, RESULTS AND COSTS
➢ Then, we sent the SMS with the right code: “location”. Instantly, we received his location.
Google Maps showed him at 30m from where he was supposed to be.
➢ Lastly, we sent two other wrong code messages: “Where are you”, “Hey” and “Heyh”. No
observations seen. (See Figure IV.6 Fourth Tracking Result)
➢ Even when we sent the right code messages: “location” and “LOCATION”, the can replied
with the location only after sending a wrong code. So, we pressed the SOS button and we
received our location. (See Figure IV.6 Fourth Tracking Result)
Figure IV.5 Second Tracking Result
83
CHAPTER IV TESTS, RESULTS AND COSTS
Figure IV.6 Fourth Tracking Result
The GSM module responded immediately. We can’t take credit for that as it is dependent
on the Service Provider. The GPS module gave us more accurate readings at the third trial. The
first reading had an absolute error of 450m. This is so because we stayed a long time without
getting our location. We can conclude for this particular test that the lesser the time between any
two readings, the more accurate the GPS readings. Of course, each time that th button was pressed
and the user’s location was sent, he was notified. We observed that the motor was vibrating and
the buzzer was beeping as expected.
IV.B.3 ANDROID APP RESULTS
We noticed that the speech recogniser had difficulties recognising our voice. This is
because it was not connected to the Google database (Google Assistant) through the internet. So,
we changed previous commands like “find my cane” and “stop ringing” to “find my stick” or
“help” and “stop” respectively. When the speech recogniser captures no voice, it sends an error
message like the one below. The user needs to tap the screen once to send vocal commands again.
84
CHAPTER IV TESTS, RESULTS AND COSTS
Figure IV.7 Android App Error Message
Figure IV.8 Android App Results from Serial Monitor
IV.C DIFFICULTIES ENCOUNTERED
After looking into the requirements and things the Smart Stick needs to do, we can conclude
that this project had several limitations that can’t be fixed or changed until there is enough budget
or new technology created.
85
CHAPTER IV TESTS, RESULTS AND COSTS
➢ First of all, the ability for the Smart Stick to work in rainy weather and low-power cellular
base-station signal like in basement and etc.
➢ Mobile credit data needs to be in sufficient balance in order to send the SMS notification
to the smartphone.
➢ Since the speech recogniser is not connected to internet, it sometimes has difficulties to
recognise the user’s voice.
➢ The stick is only able to detect obstacles the knee level.
➢ The cost price of some materials greatly increased because the COVID-19. For example,
the price of one litre of oxygenated water climbed from 2,500 XAF to 4,500 XAF because
some of its constituents are being used to produce hand sanitisers.
IV.D ESTIMATION OF THE COST OF OUR PROJECT
We are going to present to you an estimation of the total cost of this project. This includes
an estimation of the cost of the Smart Stick and an estimation of the cost of developing the Smart
Stick Finder App and in programming the Smart Stick.
IV.D.1 COST ESTIMATION OF THE SMART STICK
Here is a table presenting the complete list of the materials used in our smart cane and their
various prices.
Table IV.6 List and Prices of Smart Stick Components
Materials
Reference/Properties
Unit
Price
Quantity
Cost
Price
Arduino Nano + Cable
v3.0
3,500
2
7,000
GPS/GSM/GPRS
SIM808
15,000 1
15,000
Power Bank
5V 2A
3,000
1
3,000
Buzzer
Active/Passive
100
2
200
Motor
5VDC
500
2
1,000
86
CHAPTER IV TESTS, RESULTS AND COSTS
PCB
1,500
1
1,500
Oxygenated Water
4,500
1/4
1,125
Acid
2,500
1/4
625
1,500
3
4,500
2,000
1
2,000
Ultrasonic Sensor
10x10 cm2
HC-SR04
Water Sensor
Terminal Blocks
4 holes
350
4
1,400
Connectors
Male-Female 40 pins
350
2
700
Push Button
100
1
100
Mini On-Off Slide Switch
200
1
200
4,000
1
4,000
Bluetooth Module
HC06
Total (XAF) 42,350
Handwork (30%) 12,705
Cost Estimation 55,055
IV.D.2 COST ESTIMATION OF SOFTWARE DEVELOPMENT
IV.D.2.1 BASIC COCOMO OVERVIEW
The Basic Constructive Cost (COCOMO) Model computes software development effort
(and cost) as a function of program size. Program size is expressed in estimated thousands of
source lines of code (KLOC). COCOMO applies to three classes of software projects:
➢ Organic projects: "small" teams with "good" experience working with "less than rigid"
requirements;
➢ Semi-detached projects: "medium" teams with mixed experience working with a mix of
rigid and less than rigid requirements;
87
CHAPTER IV TESTS, RESULTS AND COSTS
➢ Embedded projects: developed within a set of "tight" constraints. It is also combination
of organic and semi-detached projects (hardware, software, operational, ...).
IV.D.2.2 EFFORT ESTIMATION
The basic COCOMO equations take the form:
➢ Effort Applied (E) = Ab * KLOC ˄ Bb [staff-months]
➢ Development Time (D) = Cb * E ˄ Db [months]
➢ People required (P) = E / D [staff]
where, KLOC is the estimated number of delivered lines (expressed in thousands) of code for
project. The coefficients Ab, Bb, Cb and Db are given in the following table (note: the values
listed below are from the original analysis, with a modern re-analysis producing different values):
Table IV.7 Classes of Software Projects
Software project Ab Bb
Cb Db
Organic
2.4 1.05 2.5 0.38
Semi-detached
3.0 1.12 2.5 0.35
Embedded
3.6 1.20 2.5 0.32
For our Smart Stick project, we choose the project as an Organic project, so the coefficients take
the values as Ab = 2.4, Bb = 1.05, Cb = 2.5 and Db = 0.38.
IV.D.2.3 NUMBER OF LINES OF CODE
The number of lines of code is simply the source lines of code (SLOC), that is the total
number the total number of lines of code excluding empty lines and comments. Since MIT App
Inventor does not contain lines of code but blocks of code, we calculated the total number of
blocks.
Table IV.8 LOC Calculation
Properties
LOC
No. of Spaces
No. of Comments
Net LOC
Sensory Module
170
18
15
137
88
CHAPTER IV TESTS, RESULTS AND COSTS
Tracking
Module
Android App
233
26
14
72
193
72
Total LOC
402
Here, we notice that we have 402 LOC or 0.402 KLOC.
IV.D.2.4 COST ESTIMATION
Finally, we apply the COCOMO equations using the coefficients and other calculated
parameters:
➢ Effort Applied (E) = 2.4 * (0.402^1.05) = 0.92 [staff-months]
➢ Development Time (D) = 2.5 * (0.92^0.38) = 2.42 [months]
➢ People required (P) = 5.54 / 4.79 = 0.38 [staff]
➢ Development Time expressed in hours gives 2.42 * 720 = 1745.17 hours.
➢ According to the SGR (Standish Group Report), 1 coding hour = 10 EUR and 1 EUR
= 655.957 XAF8. We obtained the following information below:
➢ D = 2.42 * 720 = 1745.17 [hours]
➢ 1 hour = 10 EUR
➢ 1 EUR = 655.957 XAF
Table IV.9 Cost of Software Development
Property
Development Time
Value
1745.17 hours
Cost of Development Cost of Software
per hour
Development
6559.57 XAF per hour 11,447,597.29 XAF
IV.D.3 TOTAL COST ESTIMATION
To get the total cost of our project, we need to add the cost of the Smart Stick to the cost
of software development. We obtain the results below:
8
This result is based on https://www.xe.com/currencyconverter/convert/?From=EUR&To=XAF.
89
CHAPTER IV TESTS, RESULTS AND COSTS
Our project is an Organic project and has an Effort of 0.92 staff-months, will need about 1
person to complete the Smart Stick in some 2 months. With the help of the COCOMO cost/effort
methodology, we can safely conclude that our project costs 11,502,650 XAF. Estimating software
development projects with a high level of accuracy is mostly desirable. Challenges can occur while
using COCOMO methods especially due to the issues of applying the generic software parameters
and other elements of this methodology. The Basic COCOMO is a good approach for quickly
estimating software costs. However, it does not account for differences in hardware constraints,
personnel quality and experience, use of modern tools and techniques, etc.
IV.E FUTURE SCOPE
The technologies behind blind sticks are upgrading day by day and our model ensures one
thing, that is making the task of moving of a blind person easy and comfortable. The stick is also
very light and handy to carry. And the components or parts that we used in the stick are also easily
available and less in cost. And besides all that the manufacturing cost is also quite low, that makes
the stick affordable for people of all class and age. In the future, if further improvement and
investment is carried out with the stick then it will be an even more effective device for the future
world. Some of the techniques in which this device can be modified are given below:
➢ Arduino Nano can be replaced by an upgraded microcontroller or chip.
➢ The application of the stick can also be replaced with wearables like waist belts, goggles,
boots, …. In all these cases the user does not have to hold anything; he or she can only
wear these things.
➢ Shape detection technique, for example using a camera, can also be used as it offers
accuracy.
➢ Increasing the number of sensors and actuators to implement some other applications like
on-coming vehicle detection, fire or smoke.
➢ A solar panel power bank can be used which permits the stick to automatically charge
itself.
➢ The stick can be further enhanced by using Very Large-Scale Integration (VLSI)
technology to design the PCB unit. This can make the system even more compact and thus
increase its portability and reduce its price.
90
CHAPTER IV TESTS, RESULTS AND COSTS
➢ A servo motor can be attached to the ultrasonic sensor to increase the detection range of
obstacles in front the user.
➢ The cane can integrate other GSM functions like to accept or reject a call, send a vocal
message, all these using an earphone connected to the user’s cane. Thus, the smart stick
becomes a smartphone.
➢ Vocal commands can be inserted directly into Google Assistant Server using IFTTT (If
This Then That) and MQTT (Message Queuing Telemetry Transport) protocol.
➢ Voice modules can be used which can permit the visually impaired person to hear the
observations from sensors like the distance from an obstacle, the shape of an obstacle, and
the water level when a cane is immersed in water.
➢ Building a water-resistant cane by using water-resistant materials and/or choosing waterresistant components.
➢ Use Wi-Fi to increase the range of distance from the cane while finding the lost cane.
In this chapter, we were to consider the different tests performed and their results. We also
commented on the results and say with confidence that the Smart Stick does what it’s expected to
do, that of detecting obstacles and ponds, alerting family members in case of emergencies, tracking
the user, and finding the lost cane.
91
GENERAL CONCLUSION
GENERAL CONCLUSION
This memoir shows that our Smart Stick is cheap, easily portable, and accurate in detecting
obstacles and tracking users. The main aim of this project was to detect objects in front of the
visually impaired person and enable them to walk with ease and more confidence in an unfamiliar
path and also ensure their safety. We therefore used a Horned Beast diagram, an Octopus diagram,
FAST diagrams, and SADT diagrams to model our system. After detailing all the hardware and
softwares needed for our cane to come to fruition, we did a simulation of our project on a
breadboard using Arduino IDE and MIT App Inventor for programming. Next, we used Proteus
to create our PCB design which we then fabricated and assembled with other components.
Of course, we faced some difficulties. Some were immediately addressed, others not. For
example, the cane cannot function under the rain, the Android app’s speech recogniser was
sometimes ineffective, the stick could only detect obstacles above the level of the knees, some
materials had their prices increased because of th current health crisis. Despite the above sticky
wicket, we learned how to pliant and not only improved our programming skills but also designed
a PCB at home!
This cane is far from perfect. What can make this walking stick even smarter is adding
vocal commands to Google Assistant servers, using water-resistant materials and increasing the
number of sensors. Nobody is perfect that’s why pencils have erasers. And as Anthony T. Hincks
once said: “When you write and draw in pencil, your eraser is your best friend.” We therefore
await your critics and remarks hoping that it’ll help to ‘sharpen’ us.
.
92
REFERENCES
REFERENCES
[1] WHO, "WHO," [Online]. Available: https://www.who.int/news-room/factsheets/detail/blindness-and-visual-impairment. [Accessed 1 February 2020].
[2] S. Resnikoff, D. Pascolini, D. Etya'ale, I. Kocur, R. Pararajasegaram, G. P. Pokharel and S.
P. Mariotti, "Global data on visual impairment in the year 2002," Bull World Health
Organ, vol. 82, pp. 844-851, 2014.
[3] S. Adhe, S. Kunthewad, P. Shinde and V. S. Kulkarni., "Ultrasonic Smart Stick for
Visually Impaired People," IOSR Journal of Electronics and Communication Engineering,
pp. 11-15, 2015.
[4] V. Badre, R. Chhabria, T. Kadam and K. Karamchandani, "Ultrasonic Blind Walking Stick
with Voice Playback," International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology,
vol. 3, pp. 1948-1951.
[5] M. A. Therib, "Smart Blinding Stick with Holes, Obstacles and Ponds Detector Based on
Microcontroller," Journal of Babylon University/Engineering Sciences, vol. 25, pp. 17591768, 2017.
[6] S. B. Deepika, E. Divya, K. Harshitha, K. B. Komala and P. C. Shruthi, "Ultrasonic Blind
Walking Stick," International Journal of Advance Electrical and Electronics Engineering,
vol. 5, pp. 20-22, 2016.
[7] A. Bhokare, A. Amberkar, A. Gawde, P. Kale and A. Pasi, "Ultrasonic Blind Walking
Stick," International Journal on Recent and Innovation Trends in Computing and
Communication, vol. 4, pp. 62-65, 2016.
[8] Y. Bais, P. Sharma and S. V. Dhole, "Ultrasonic Blind Walking Stick," International
Journal of Current Engineering and Scientific Research, vol. 5, pp. 110-113, 2018.
[9] M. Oruganti, S. C. Vadla, V. Yellenki, N. Shriyans and Rushikesh, IJARIIE, vol. 4, pp.
2188-2195, 2018.
[10] D. Sekar, S. Sivakumar, P. Thiyagarajan, R. Premkumar and M. V. Kumar, "Ultrasonic and
Voice Based Walking Stick for Blind People," International Journal of Innovative
Research in Electrical, Electronics, Instrumentation and Control Engineering, vol. 4, pp.
223-225, 2016.
[11] D. E. Gbenga, A. I. Shani and A. L. Adekunle, "Smart Walking Stick for Visually Impaired
People Using Ultrasonic Sensors and Arduino," International Journal of Engineering and
Technology, vol. 9, pp. 3435-3447, 2017.
I
REFERENCES
[12] U. Ali, H. Javed, R. Khan, F. Jabeen and N. Akbar, "Intelligent stick for blind friends.,"
International Robotics & Automation, vol. 4, pp. 68-70, 2018.
[13] K. G. J. P. Jothi, K. T. C. Mohan, S. Kavithrashree and K. G. Ajith, "Smart Electronic
Walking Stick for Blind People," International Journal of Advanced Research in
Electrical, Electronics and Instrumentation Engineering, vol. 7, pp. 1194-1200, 2018.
[14] A. Tekade, M. Sonekar, M. Ninave and P. Dongre, "Ultrasonic Blind Stick with GPS
Tracking System," International Journal of Engineering Science and Computing, vol. 8,
pp. 16248-16250, 2018.
[15] S. B. V. Srinivasan, M. A. Murali, P. Prakash and P. N. Krishna, "Ultrasonic Blind Stick
with GPS Tracking," International Journal of Pure and Applied Mathematics, vol. 119, pp.
761-768, 2018.
[16] D. S. Kumar, M. P. Anand, K. D. Raj, P. T. Raj, R. Yashwanth and S. Yogesh, "Electronic
Stick for Visually Impaired People With buzzer alert," International Journal of Recent
Technology and Engineering, vol. 7, pp. 918-922, 2019.
[17] K. Verma, N. Chawla and R. Jain, "A Novel approach of bind stick based on Ultrasonic
Sensors," International Journal of Applied Engineering Research, vol. 14, pp. 64-66, 2019.
[18] J. S. Borza, "FAST Diagrams: The Foundation for Creating Effective Function Models,"
2011. [Online].
[19] APTE, "The APTE method," [Online]. Available: http://methodeapte.com/methode_apte/tools/. [Accessed 1 June 2020].
[20] R. SOUSSI, "Functional analysis of industial zones in the Greater Tunis area,"
International Journal of Spaces and Urban Territory, pp. p-ISSN : 2534-8183 / e-ISSN:
2382-3011, 2016.
[21] T. Agarwal, "An Overview of Arduino Nano Board," June 2019. [Online]. Available:
https://www.elprocus.com/an-overview-of-arduino-nano-board/. [Accessed 15 June 2020].
[22] T. Agarwal, "What is HC-SR04 Ultrasonic Sensor: Working and Its Applications," January
2020. [Online]. Available: https://www.elprocus.com/hc-sr04-ultrasonic-sensor-workingand-its-applications/. [Accessed 15 June 2020].
[23] J. Miller, "Build a Car Tracking System with the SIM808 Module," August 2018. [Online].
Available: https://maker.pro/arduino/projects/build-a-car-tracking-system-with-thesim808-module. [Accessed 13 June 2020].
II
REFERENCES
[24] T. Agarwal, "GPS Based Voice Navigation System for Visually Impaired People," 2014.
[Online]. Available: https://www.elprocus.com/gps-based-voice-alert-system-for-blindpeople/. [Accessed 7 June 2020].
[25] R. Pelayo, "Arduino GPS Tutorial," [Online]. Available:
https://www.teachmemicro.com/arduino-gps-tutorial/. [Accessed 14 June 2020].
[26] T. Agarwal, "GSM – Architecture, Features & Working," 2013. [Online]. Available:
https://www.elprocus.com/gsm-architecture-features-working/. [Accessed 8 June 2020].
[27] Components101, "HC-06 Bluetooth Module," 3 November 2018. [Online]. Available:
https://components101.com/wireless/hc-06-bluetooth-module-pinout-datasheet. [Accessed
1 June 2020].
[28] E. HUB, "Types Of Switches," 26 September 2015. [Online]. Available:
https://www.electronicshub.org/switches/. [Accessed 2 June 2020].
[29] V. Paradigm, "What is Unified Modeling Language (UML)?," [Online]. Available:
https://www.visual-paradigm.com/guide/uml-unified-modeling-language/what-is-uml/.
[Accessed 6 June 2020].
[30] Wikipedia, "App Inventor for Android," 6 July 2020. [Online]. Available:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/App_Inventor_for_Android. [Accessed 15 June 2020].
[31] Phhsnews, "How to automatically start an app when you start or wake up Android TV,"
[Online]. Available: https://www.phhsnews.com/how-to-automatically-start-an-app-whenyou-boot-or-wake-android-tv4422. [Accessed 2 June 2020].
III
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TABLE OF CONTENTS
DEDICATION................................................................................................................................ i
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ............................................................................................................ ii
FOREWORD................................................................................................................................ iii
ABSTRACT .................................................................................................................................. iv
RÉSUMÉ ....................................................................................................................................... v
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ..................................................................................................... vi
LIST OF TABLES ...................................................................................................................... vii
LIST OF FIGURES ................................................................................................................... viii
SUMMARY .................................................................................................................................. xi
GENERAL INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................... 1
I LITERATURE REVIEW .......................................................................................................... 2
I.A LIMITATIONS OF EARLY NAVIGATIONAL TOOLS ............................................. 2
I.B HISTORICAL BACKGROUND OF INTELLIGENT BLIND STICKS IN THE
WORLD ..................................................................................................................................... 3
I.B.1 Ultrasonic Smart Stick for Visually Impaired People .............................................. 3
I.B.2 Ultrasonic Blind Walking Stick with Voice Playback ............................................... 4
I.B.3 Smart Blinding Stick with Holes, Obstacles and Ponds Detector Based on
Microcontroller ...................................................................................................................... 4
I.B.4 Ultrasonic Blind Walking Stick .................................................................................. 5
I.B.5 Ultrasonic and Voice Based Walking Stick for Blind People ................................... 7
I.B.6 Smart Walking Stick for Visually Impaired People Using Ultrasonic Sensors and
Arduino ................................................................................................................................... 7
I.B.7 Intelligent stick for blind friends ................................................................................ 8
I.B.8 Smart Electronic Walking Stick for Blind People ..................................................... 9
I.B.9 Ultrasonic Blind Stick with GPS Tracking System ................................................... 9
I.B.10 Ultrasonic Blind stick With GPS Tracking ............................................................ 10
I.B.11 Electronic Stick for Visually Impaired People with buzzer alert ........................ 10
I.B.12 A Novel approach of bind stick based on Ultrasonic Sensors .............................. 11
I.C LIMITATIONS OF PRESENT NAVIGATIONAL TOOLS ....................................... 11
I.D COMPARISON OF PRESENT NAVIGATIONAL TOOLS ....................................... 12
II METHODOLOGY ................................................................................................................. 14
II.A WHAT IS APTE? ............................................................................................................ 14
II.B NEED ANALYSIS ........................................................................................................... 14
II.B.1 Need Identification .................................................................................................... 15
IV
TABLE OF CONTENTS
II.B.2 Need Validation ......................................................................................................... 15
II.C FUNCTIONAL NEED ANALYSIS............................................................................... 16
II.C.1 Definition ................................................................................................................... 16
II.C.2 Function Specifications ............................................................................................ 16
II.C.3 Function Identification ............................................................................................. 17
II.C.4 Octopus Diagram ...................................................................................................... 17
II.C.5 Function Characterisation ....................................................................................... 18
II.C.6 Results ........................................................................................................................ 19
II.D TECHNICAL-FUNCTIONAL ANALYSIS ................................................................. 19
II.D.1 Definition ................................................................................................................... 19
II.D.2 Components of a FAST Diagram ............................................................................ 20
II.D.3 Function Definition ................................................................................................... 21
II.D.4 FAST Diagrams ........................................................................................................ 21
II.E STRUCTURED ANALYSIS .......................................................................................... 23
II.E.1 Definition ................................................................................................................... 23
II.E.2 SADT Diagrams ........................................................................................................ 24
III DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION................................................................................. 26
III.A DESIGN OF THE SMART STICK ............................................................................. 26
III.A.1 SYNOPTIC DIAGRAM ......................................................................................... 26
III.A.2 FONCTION OF EACH PART .............................................................................. 26
III.A.2.1 ARDUINO NANO ............................................................................................ 26
III.A.2.1.1 Justification of component ........................................................................... 27
III.A.2.1.2 Arduino Pin Configuration ........................................................................... 28
III.A.2.1.3 Communication ............................................................................................ 29
III.A.2.2 ULTRASONIC SENSOR ................................................................................ 30
III.A.2.2.1 Pin Definition ............................................................................................... 30
III.A.2.2.2 Mode of operation ........................................................................................ 30
III.A.2.2.3 Pin Specification........................................................................................... 31
III.A.2.2.4 Pin Configuration ......................................................................................... 32
III.A.2.2.5 Justification of component ........................................................................... 32
III.A.2.3 WATER SENSOR ............................................................................................ 33
III.A.2.3.1 Mode of operation ........................................................................................ 33
III.A.2.3.2 Specifications ............................................................................................... 33
III.A.2.3.3 Pin Configuration ......................................................................................... 34
III.A.2.4 BUZZER............................................................................................................ 34
III.A.2.4.1 Types of Buzzers .......................................................................................... 34
III.A.2.4.2 Mode of operation ........................................................................................ 35
III.A.2.4.3 Pin Definition ............................................................................................... 36
III.A.2.4.4 Pin Configuration ......................................................................................... 36
III.A.2.4.5 Specifications ............................................................................................... 36
III.A.2.5 DC MOTOR ...................................................................................................... 37
V
TABLE OF CONTENTS
III.A.2.5.1 Pin Configuration ......................................................................................... 38
III.A.2.5.2 Specifications ............................................................................................... 38
III.A.2.6 SIM808 MODULE ........................................................................................... 39
III.A.2.6.1 General Features ........................................................................................... 40
III.A.2.6.2 GPS ............................................................................................................... 41
III.A.2.6.2.1 Introduction to GPS ............................................................................... 41
III.A.2.6.2.2 How Location is Tracked....................................................................... 43
III.A.2.6.2.3 NMEA Sentences................................................................................... 43
III.A.2.6.2.4 Interfacing with GPS Devices ............................................................... 44
III.A.2.6.2.5 AT Commands ....................................................................................... 44
III.A.2.6.2.6 Specifications ......................................................................................... 44
III.A.2.6.3 GSM ............................................................................................................. 45
III.A.2.6.3.1 GSM Architecture .................................................................................. 46
III.A.2.6.3.2 GSM Modem ......................................................................................... 46
III.A.2.6.3.3 Specifications ......................................................................................... 47
III.A.2.7 BLUETOOTH MODULE ............................................................................... 48
III.A.2.7.1 Mode of operation ........................................................................................ 48
III.A.2.7.2 Pin Configuration ......................................................................................... 49
III.A.2.7.3 Specifications ............................................................................................... 49
III.A.2.7.4 Justification of component ........................................................................... 49
III.A.2.8 BUTTON ........................................................................................................... 50
III.A.2.8.1 Push Button Switch ...................................................................................... 52
III.A.2.8.2 Single Pole Single Throw Switch ................................................................. 52
III.A.2.9 POWER SUPPLY ............................................................................................ 53
III.B IMPLEMENTATION ................................................................................................... 54
III.B.1 SMART STICK ....................................................................................................... 54
III.B.1.1 ClickCharts ....................................................................................................... 54
III.B.1.2 Flowcharts ......................................................................................................... 55
III.B.1.3 Proteus ............................................................................................................... 58
III.B.1.3.1 Circuit Diagram ............................................................................................ 59
III.B.1.3.2 3D View ........................................................................................................ 59
III.B.1.3.3 Printed Circuit Board (PCB)......................................................................... 60
III.B.1.3.3.1 Drawing the PCB Design ....................................................................... 60
III.B.1.3.3.2 Domestic PCB Manufacturing ............................................................... 61
III.B.1.3.3.3 Assembling Components ....................................................................... 62
III.B.1.4 Arduino IDE...................................................................................................... 63
III.B.1.4.1 Libraries Used............................................................................................... 64
III.B.1.4.2 Program Code ............................................................................................... 64
III.B.1.4.3 Sensory Module ............................................................................................ 64
III.B.1.4.4 Tracking Module .......................................................................................... 66
III.B.1.4.5 Functions Used ............................................................................................. 67
III.B.2 SMART STICK FINDER....................................................................................... 68
III.B.2.1 Unified Modeling Language (UML) ............................................................... 68
VI
TABLE OF CONTENTS
III.B.2.1.1 Use Case Diagram ........................................................................................ 68
III.B.2.1.2 Activity Diagram .......................................................................................... 69
III.B.2.1.3 Sequence Diagram ........................................................................................ 70
III.B.2.2 MIT App Inventor ............................................................................................ 70
III.B.2.2.1 Requirements ................................................................................................ 71
III.B.2.2.2 App Inventor Designer ................................................................................. 71
III.B.2.2.3 App Inventor Blocks Editor.......................................................................... 72
III.B.2.2.4 Flowchart ...................................................................................................... 73
III.B.2.2.5 Autorun Smart Stick Finder .......................................................................... 73
III.B.2.2.6 Smart Stick Finder Android App .................................................................. 75
IV TESTS, RESULTS AND COSTS ......................................................................................... 76
IV.A TESTS ............................................................................................................................. 76
IV.A.1 SENSORY MODULE ............................................................................................. 76
IV.A.1.1 Obstacle Detection and Feedback Tests ......................................................... 76
IV.A.1.2 Water Level Detection and Feedback Tests ................................................... 76
IV.A.2 TRACKING MODULE .......................................................................................... 77
IV.A.3 ANDROID APP ....................................................................................................... 77
IV.B RESULTS AND COMMENTS ..................................................................................... 78
IV.B.1 SENSORY RESULTS ............................................................................................. 78
IV.B.1.1 Obstacle Detection Results ............................................................................... 78
IV.B.1.2 Water Level Detection Results......................................................................... 80
IV.B.2 TRACKING RESULTS .......................................................................................... 82
IV.B.3 ANDROID APP RESULTS .................................................................................... 84
IV.C DIFFICULTIES ENCOUNTERED ............................................................................. 85
IV.D ESTIMATION OF THE COST OF OUR PROJECT ............................................... 86
IV.D.1 COST ESTIMATION OF THE SMART STICK ................................................ 86
IV.D.2 COST ESTIMATION OF SOFTWARE DEVELOPMENT .............................. 87
IV.D.2.1 Basic COCOMO Overview .............................................................................. 87
IV.D.2.2 Effort Estimation .............................................................................................. 88
IV.D.2.3 Number of Lines of Code ................................................................................. 88
IV.D.2.4 Cost Estimation ................................................................................................. 89
IV.D.3 TOTAL COST ESTIMATION .............................................................................. 89
IV.E FUTURE SCOPE ........................................................................................................... 90
GENERAL CONCLUSION....................................................................................................... 92
REFERENCES............................................................................................................................... I
TABLE OF CONTENTS ........................................................................................................... IV
LIST OF APPENDIXES ............................................................................................................ IX
Appendix 1: Arduino Nano Technical Specifications .......................................................... IX
VII
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Appendix 2: Arduino Nano Pinout ......................................................................................... X
Appendix 3: Arduino Nano Pin Layout ................................................................................ XI
Appendix 4: Arduino Nano Pin Configuration .................................................................. XII
VIII
LIST OF APPENDIXES
LIST OF APPENDIXES
APPENDIX 1: ARDUINO NANO TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS
PROPERTIES
VALUES
Microcontroller
ATmega328P – 8-bit AVR family microcontroller
Operating Voltage
5V
Recommended Input Voltage for Vin pin 7-12V
Analog Input Pins
6 (A0 – A7)
Digital I/O Pins
14 (Out of which 6 provide PWM output)
DC Current on I/O Pins
40 mA
DC Current on 3.3V Pin
50 mA
Flash Memory
32 KB (2 KB is used for Bootloader)
SRAM
2 KB
EEPROM
1 KB
Frequency (Clock Speed)
16 MHz
Communication
IIC, SPI, USART
IX
LIST OF APPENDIXES
APPENDIX 2: ARDUINO NANO PINOUT
X
LIST OF APPENDIXES
APPENDIX 3: ARDUINO NANO PIN LAYOUT
Pin No.
Name
Type
Description
1-2, 5-16
D0-D13 I/O
Digital input/output port 0 to 13
3, 28
RESET
Input
Reset (active low)
4, 29
GND
PWR
Supply ground
17
3V3
Output
+3.3V output (from FTDI)
18
AREF
Input
ADC reference
19-26
A7-A0
Input
Analog input channel 0 to 7
27
+5V
Output or
+5V output (from on-board regulator) or +5V (input from
Input
external power supply)
30
Vin
PWR
Supply voltage
XI
LIST OF APPENDIXES
APPENDIX 4: ARDUINO NANO PIN CONFIGURATION
Pin Category
Pin Name
Vin
Power
3.3V
5V
Details
Input voltage to Arduino when using an external power
source (6-12V).
3.3V supply generated by on-board voltage regulator.
Maximum current draw is 50mA.
Regulated power supply used to power microcontroller
and other components on the board.
GND
Ground pin.
Reset
Reset
Resets the microcontroller.
Analog Pins
A0 – A7
Used to measure analogue voltage in the range of 0-5V
I/O Pins
D0 - D13
Serial
Rx, Tx
Used to receive and transmit TTL serial data.
2, 3
To trigger an interrupt.
3, 5, 6, 9, 11
Provides 8-bit PWM output.
External
Interrupts
PWM
Digital pins used as input or output. 0V for LOW and
5V for HIGH.
10 (SS), 11 (MOSI),
SPI
12 (MISO) and
Used for SPI communication.
13 (SCK)
Inbuilt LED
IIC
AREF
13
A4 (SDA),
A5 (SCA)
AREF
To turn on the inbuilt LED.
Used for TWI communication.
To provide reference voltage for input voltage.
XII