Simultaneous and Sequential Anticommons

Ben Depoorter

Simultaneous and Sequential Anticommons

Ben Depoorter

2004, European Journal of Law and …

visibility

…

description

22 pages

link

1 file

AI-generated Abstract

This paper examines the concepts of simultaneous and sequential anticommons in property law, proposing a model to analyze the effects of these two forms of ownership on resource allocation and economic behavior. Through rigorous analysis, the authors demonstrate that the presence of overlapping ownership rights can lead to significant challenges in resource utilization, highlighting the implications for both legal theory and practical governance.

Yale Law School Yale Law School Legal Scholarship Repository John M. Olin Center for Studies in Law, Economics, and Public Policy Working Papers Yale Law School Other Scholarship 3-20-2003 Simultaneous and Sequential Anticommons Francesco Parisi none Norbert Schulz none Ben Depoorter none Recommended Citation Parisi, Francesco; Schulz, Norbert; and Depoorter, Ben, "Simultaneous and Sequential Anticommons" (2003). John M. Olin Center for Studies in Law, Economics, and Public Policy Working Papers. Paper 279. http://digitalcommons.law.yale.edu/lepp_papers/279 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Yale Law School Other Scholarship at Yale Law School Legal Scholarship Repository. It has been accepted for inclusion in John M. Olin Center for Studies in Law, Economics, and Public Policy Working Papers by an authorized administrator of Yale Law School Legal Scholarship Repository. For more information, please contact [email protected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∂9 [ [ > ∂[ .? $ $ # ! $ # ! !(!)D!(!)8 ! # $ & !(!) ! & / (5) ∂9 ∂9 [ [ = [ [ = ∂[ ∂[ ! # # A # $ ! $ DD & ! $ &!Г! / & ∂9 ∂9 ∂9 ∂9 [ [ + [ [ = [ [ + [ [ = ∂[ ∂[ ∂[ ∂[ (>) A # ! $ !Г! # (>) ;! /DD F & # ! (5) (5)(>) # + (>) # 1# !()! # 1 #$ ( (1))! # (>) ## ! # ;! ! # (>) $# ()! (>) # 1 8 & # GH ! F $ $ & # $ ? ! ? ' ' B# ! $ ' # $ $! ? $ $ # !$ $ ' ' & /. $$ $ !DC $$ $ ! $ ? ' ' " # # # ( )$ ( ) $ # # $ $ # ! # ( ) & ( ) ' ! $ #$ # ( ) # ' # ( )! $ ! # ! ' '# ! ! ' ' #7$ 9 $ !!! !" # # . # # # ! $ .!(!) 8 ! ! (H) ∂9 S S < ∂S 8 ! $ 7 9 #@ & ! ! $ 7$ # 9 ! & ! @ # # $ =(5222) " ! ! $ ( @ @ ) =(5222) B $ # " # $ ! ! ( # ) ( @ )%! # @ @ # # ! ! # ! $ # (! $ ' ) # $ !$ ! # # 8 ! $ ! # ? # ! #$ !# #$ # $ ! ' '! ! #$ # # ' # ! + & # @ (!;!133H)B ( # )! 5 # %() 1 %( ) # # # # # 1!(! ) $ # # # ! # $ & : [ [ = 5 [ [ − & [ − & [ (4) 8 $ # #! # .(!) 1 5 @ ! @ # / (6) 9 [ [ = 5 [ [ − & [ − 8 [ [ 9 [ [ = 8 [ [ − & [ I @ ! # # # ;! # 5%#! # # 1 8 ! # # # # ! # # ! #8 ! # ! @ ! # # $ & # / (<) ∂9 ∂5 ∂& ∂8 [ [ − [ − [ [ = = ∂[ ∂[ ∂[ ∂[ (3) ∂9 ∂8 ∂& [ [ − [ = = ∂[ ∂[ ∂[ B # # ' / ∂& ∂& ∂5 ∂5 [ [ − [ = [ [ − [ = ∂[ ∂[ ∂[ ∂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Г L M % 4 & - && < % L M $ 0 - & 1 M $ * @ 8D 0 & & & 1 M % $ L " 6 % - K- &= 0 & K-+- =- L L N! Г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

Log In

Simultaneous and Sequential Anticommons

Related papers

Related topics