Angels of Aceh
This book is written to honour those who died in the
tsunami which hit on Boxing Day 2004; to salute those who
were injured and bore their suffering so bravely; and to
thank the CASTA team who went in the name of our
country Australia, to help in Banda Aceh, Indonesia.
For my boys, who will one day be men. And for their father,
who showed them what is possible.
‘Do what you can for others and not for yourself’
Liam Dunkin, January 2005
Angels of aceh
The compelling story of
Operation Tsunami Assist
Sophie York
First published in 2005
Copyright © Sophie York 2005
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted
in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including
photocopying, recording or by any information storage and retrieval
system, without prior permission in writing from the publisher.
The Australian Copyright Act 1968 (the Act) allows a maximum of
one chapter or ten per cent of this book, whichever is the greater, to be
photocopied by any educational institution for its educational purposes
provided that the educational institution (or body that administers it)
has given a remuneration notice to Copyright Agency Limited (CAL)
under the Act.
Allen & Unwin
83 Alexander Street
Crows Nest NSW 2065
Australia
Phone: (61 2) 8425 0100
Fax:
(61 2) 9906 2218
Email:
[email protected]
Web:
www.allenandunwin.com
National Library of Australia
Cataloguing-in-Publication entry:
York, Sophie.
Angels of Aceh: the compelling story of Operation Tsunami Assist.
ISBN 1 74114 746 8.
1. Indian Ocean Tsunami, 2004. 2. Natural disasters –
Social aspects – Indonesia – Aceh. 3. Disaster medicine –
Indonesia – Aceh. 4. Emergency medical personnel –
Indonesia – Aceh. 5. Aceh (Indonesia) – Social conditions.
I. Title.
362.18095981
Set in 12.5/14.5 Cochin by Midland Typesetters, Australia
Printed in Australia by McPherson’s Printing Group
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
All photos courtesy of the CASTA Team.
Contents
Map of tsunami-affected region
Map of Banda Aceh
viii
ix
1
The Call
1
2
Operation Tsunami Assist
16
3
The Gate Opens
28
4
The Real Work Begins
41
5
Keeping the Home Fires Burning
61
6
A New Year for All
67
7
On the Ground in Banda Aceh
84
8
Improvising
104
9
Building Bridges
116
10
The Bridge of Death: a Bridge of Hope
133
11
Support at Home
142
12
Reaching Out—Sigli
148
v
ANGELS OF ACEH
13
Helping and Coping
162
14
Kesdam
177
15
Australia Responds
196
16
Emergency Care
204
17
Last Days at Fakinah
212
18
Coming Home
229
Epilogue
246
Appendix 1:
Dramatis Personae
261
Appendix 2:
Governor Bashir’s speech
264
Appendix 3:
Acronyms, abbreviations and
explanations
267
Acknowledgments
270
vi
For whom the bell tolls
No man is an Iland,
intire of it selfe,
everyman is a peece of the Continent,
a part of the maine;
if a Clod bee washed away by the Sea,
Europe is the lesse,
as well as if a Promontorie were,
as well as if a Mannor of thy friends or of thine owne were;
any man’s death diminishes me,
because I am involved in Mankinde;
And therefore never send to
know for whom the bell tolls;
It tolls for thee.
John Donne (1572–1631)
vii
viii
ix
chapter one
The Call
The telephone rang at 10.20 p.m. It was either my family
or an emergency. My husband Paul answered it. ‘Let me
talk to the boss, I’ll call you back in ten minutes.’
Paul Dunkin hung up the telephone in his study alcove
and sat on the couch, facing me. We looked at each other.
He knew what I would say, but he had to hear it from
me. We knew each other well. Twenty-three years together
does that for you. You know exactly what the other is
thinking.
‘You have to go,’ I said finally. ‘They need your skills.
And even if you cannot do anaesthetics, just help in any
capacity you can. Set up systems, fix things. Repair stuff.’
We talked briefly and Paul called back David Scott,
anaesthetist in Lismore and consultant to the government
on anaesthetic matters.
‘Ask not for whom the bell tolls,’ I thought, as I listened
intently to the call.
We started packing. He had to be at RAAF Base
Richmond first thing in the morning.
1
ANGELS OF ACEH
It had been a lovely day at Stu Lloyd’s. It was Tuesday
28 December 2004. They had barbecued steaks and some
sausages for the kids while the chitchat meandered from
topic to topic. Stu poured some of his rich eggnog, to
curious sips and acclaim. It was a sunny day on Sydney’s
North Shore. Children jumped happily on the trampoline.
The dog played with the toddlers. Stu’s eclectic music taste
blared inside. Everyone was, as is typical in Sydney’s
clement summer weather, either on the front verandah or
out in the backyard.
The tsunami incident inevitably came up. I commented
on the newspaper headlines from Monday which had said
that as many as 5000 had been killed. ‘No, it is closer to
14 000, Soph,’ my husband gently updated me. People
sighed. ‘No, it is 24 000,’ said Roger, the host’s brother. I
gasped. It was too much for the brain. And nobody could
do anything. It was shaping up to be one of these overwhelmingly tragic events which you just absorb, feel gutted
by and ultimately cannot do anything about. It was bigger
than anything anyone had ever imagined or read about.
I hugged my baby, fifteen-week-old Pierce. I had seen a
televised story from Thailand where a baby had been
ripped from its parent’s arms. It was unthinkable to lose
a child.
I was not to know yet that my life, the life of my
husband and children, and some of the accepted dynamics
in the world, would be changed forever by this wave of
water called a tsunami. When enough droplets of water
join together, they can change everything in their path.
Paul Dunkin was 39. He was the type who looked the
same for the twenty years between 25 and 45. Rugged
2
The Call
and Australian, there was not a sniff of slightly feminine
Leonardo DiCaprio good looks about him.
His eyes were what grabbed your attention. Blue,
intense, and fringed by unfairly long dark lashes. And then
there was that roguish smile. He hadn’t been nicknamed
‘Maximus’ by nurses in the past for nothing. Think Russell
Crowe rather than Jude Law.
Paul was not sentimental, except perhaps about me and
our four sons. His style, which befitted an anaesthetist, was
no-nonsense, practical and dizzyingly time-efficient. He
was the president of a group of anaesthetists. He had started
the group a few months ago, three weeks before I had a new
baby, and while working on renovation plans to make room
for the new arrival. Setting up the anaesthetic practice had
meant meetings, telephone calls, solicitors, the drafting of
a raft of documents. He was working full-time in a number
of different hospitals, which included some weekends and
nights on call, and he was also studying a Post-Graduate
Diploma in Perioperative and Critical Care Echocardiography. He got through it all somehow, without drama. And
spent time with his children and wife, too.
Paul was a good anaesthetist. It was just one of those
things observed and remarked upon by his colleagues.
Real praise was always good to hear, everyone needs it
occasionally. It made you want to continue to live up to it
too. Over the years he had performed anaesthetics on a
host of people, for a host of conditions, from the doublelung transplant on a well-known Australian CEO and the
kidney-stone surgery for an Australian governor, to the
eye surgery on a comparative ‘nobody’. But to Paul, no
person was a nobody. People were people, to Paul. The
eye surgery would make that person see. The work was
intense, but it came with its own rewards.
3
ANGELS OF ACEH
Early the next morning, Wednesday, 29 December, Paul
re-packed his bags, throwing out half of my selections, and
loaded the luggage into the back of the car. As he drove
to RAAF Base Richmond, he rang everyone he could think
of to re-arrange his work so that the operation lists were
covered. Visiting Medical Officers (VMOs) like him often
work at a number of hospitals. He called his fellow anaesthetist and friend Nigel Symons to see if he could cover for
him. ‘Be careful Paul’, said Nigel. ‘Stay safe.’ He spoke to
Anne Pike at the Seventh Day Adventist Hospital, Greg
O’Sullivan at St Vincent’s. They immediately took care of
his lists. They each said warmly, ‘Good on you, Paul, for
going.’ It was gratifying to hear. He didn’t particularly feel
like a hero. The unknown was scary, but sometimes the
known can be worse. Some of the affected areas were
suffering severe aftershocks, some had disease outbreaks,
others were war zones. Piles of dead people. He didn’t
want to think about those things yet. Plenty of time to
meditate on the plane. Brace himself.
Reminding himself of the malaria risk, he looked for a
roadside pharmacy.
It was strange. Here he was, driving out to Richmond
with no idea of what his specific mission was or where on
the planet he was heading. He just knew he had to help and
that he had his wife’s full support. He did not want to
imagine how she was going to cope with four little boys on
her own while she was still breastfeeding Pierce, born
fifteen weeks earlier and still not sleeping through. Soph’s
going to be doing it tough, he thought. Twenty-two month
old Francis was fun, but a bit of a handful. He had begun
the terrible twos early. Darcy, four, was improving in his
behaviour as he began to articulate his requirements, but he
and Liam had their moments. Like young puppies, they
4
The Call
could all bounce off the walls sometimes. They were great
kids—really cheery, loving and capable. Thank heaven for
that at a time like this. But his family was healthy and alive.
They would be fine. He had to think positively.
Paul pulled up at a pharmacy, handed over his prescription and, while he waited for it to be filled, mentioned the
tsunami, its victims and his destination. The concerned and
generous proprietor loaded him up with travel items, gratis.
Paul was deeply touched and told me about it on the mobile.
I decided to compose a letter about this unexpected kindness
from a complete stranger, and emailed it to the Sydney
Morning Herald. It was printed the next day, Thursday,
30 January, amid a steadily growing host of Letters to the
Editor on the horror.
On Monday, 27 December, David Scott had emailed his
entire professional database at 3.25 p.m. He had been at
home in Lismore, New South Wales, and had watched
some early news reports. The tsunami story was unfolding
on radio and television by the hour and in the daily newspapers. David was a Wing Commander in the Air Force
Reserves and an anaesthetist at Lismore Hospital, and
he was also the chair of the Consultative Group to the
Australian Defence Force (ADF) on Anaesthetics. Issues
which came up were discussed by the group, usually by
email, and the feedback provided to the ADF. It could
relate to anything in anaesthesia, from the purchase of a
new monitoring machine, to the use of a particular drug or
technique. As chair of this group, David thought he should
get some anaesthetists on standby and that he was the best
person to put the word out, post-haste. This sounded like
something medical types should get involved in, and fast.
5
ANGELS OF ACEH
From the news reports, things were looking desperate and
they would not have time to lose if they were to do some
good. Critical injuries become fatal if left untreated.
Surgery, and therefore anaesthetics, would be needed.
He called Air Commodore Tony Austin, directorgeneral of the ADF Health Services to let him know what
he had in mind. Tony was the highest-ranking medical
officer in the permanent forces. Head Honcho. It was a triservice position—Army, Navy and Air Force all deferred
to him. David asked, ‘Do you need me to get a group on
standby, Tony?’ They knew each other well. ‘That would
be great, David. Thanks. I will be in touch.’ They spoke
briefly and quickly.
At this stage, too, the Commonwealth Department of
Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) was across the issue,
and was liaising with the prime minister’s office and the
Health Services Wing (HSW), the Air Force’s medical
department.
Health Services Wing called David at 10 a.m. on
28 December, wanting the names of two specialists for
an advance mission to the devastated areas. The two
chosen would be needed to do a reconnaissance, (a ‘recce’).
This was an advance mission to survey what the damage
was, what resources were available at a local level, and
what medical and other supplies and personnel were
needed to be sent in. These specialists would be responsible
for establishing Aero-Medical Evacuation services (AME)
in the region. Wing Commander Bill Griggs from Adelaide
and Squadron Leader Allan MacKillop from the Gold
Coast were chosen. They left immediately.
Griggs had sussed this kind of thing out before. He had
even assessed Christopher Skase for the government. But
the stakes here were altogether different.
6
The Call
Tony wanted a shortlist of anaesthetists. It had to be
top-heavy with specialists who had experience in particularly austere conditions, those who had shown in the past
they could hack it emotionally, professionally, and could
work very, very hard. The type who could face adverse
factors of every variety and not fall in a heap. Think
Rwanda, Somalia, Bougainville, East Timor. The fainthearted and prima donnas were not going to be needed on
this mission.
David Scott’s email to his professional database on the
Monday had been short and to the point; you were either
available or you weren’t. His initial contact asked recipients
for the number of days they could spare (at least seven
would be needed), contact details, and their nearest airport.
At this stage the mainstream news were reporting the big
picture details of the disaster but the real and technical
scope of the disaster was still undetermined. Communications (or comms in military speak) had been knocked out
in some places, and in others the survivors were still in
shock. The appropriate response Australia would make was
yet to be clarified. MacKillop and Griggs would gather
relevant information and report back from sites as fast as
they could. The challenge of this task, when many places
were in complete chaos, could not be underestimated.
The defence medical community is a close-knit one, and
the anaesthetists are even closer, but David wasn’t holding
out much hope. It had happened on Boxing Day; everyone
was on holidays with their families. The message was
hardly an attractive one in the scheme of things. David saw
that Paul Dunkin, a Lieutenant Commander in the Naval
Reserves, was on the list of recipients of his email. Paul
would be a non-starter this time, he thought to himself.
David recalled Paul telling him, ‘Won’t be able to play
7
ANGELS OF ACEH
soldiers for a while, mate, we have a new baby on the way.
Our fourth. Soph needs me.’
David and Paul’s paths had crossed a number of times
over the past years. David had been the Director of
Training at Lismore Hospital where Paul had undertaken
a stage of his anaesthetic training. They had been deployed
together to the Solomons on HMAS Manoora in 2003.
Australia had sent the Navy to support the 2000-strong
Australian Federal Police force there. Paul had been
involved in a dramatic episode involving a heavily
pregnant islander who had been convulsing with eclampsia, and seemed to be dying. The medical team had
choppered her to hospital from a field, from among a wideeyed village crowd. Paul had kept a cool head in a crisis
and both mother and baby survived. David smiled to
himself at the memory. She had given her baby a rather
unusual second name for an islander—Paul.
It would have been good to have had him along again.
Shame about the timing. So David was surprised when, at
6.36 p.m. that Monday, Paul responded and said he might
be available to go, if needed.
David was pleased at the overall response. His inbox
was filling, and the available list was growing. Thank
goodness for the internet—you could notify a stack of
people simultaneously. The only drawback was the reply
delay. Meanwhile, he gathered some of his things together,
handed over stuff to Rachel his wife and chatted to her
and his young son and daughter, James and Suzannah,
watched the news and waited for the next instructions
from headquarters.
He had fifteen people answer with a ‘yes’ by 6 p.m. on
the Monday. By 1.00 p.m. Tuesday, the next day, he had
30 volunteers. All who could respond had said yes. David
8
The Call
telephoned through the names to the director-general,
Tony Austin.
The answer came back. Four had been chosen: Paul
Dunkin, Paul Luckin, Brian Pezzutti and David Scott.
David hit the phone to confirm that these four could
definitely join the mission.
Paul arrived at RAAF Base Richmond at 9 a.m. on the
Wednesday, 29 December. When he arrived at the front
gate, he was told he needed to obtain a pass. But when he
went to the pass office, he was told that this requirement
had been waived for the mercy mission. So he went back to
the gate and was allowed through. Ahhh, military admin!
It was all coming back. He hadn’t been out of the permanent Navy—back in the civvie world and the Reserves
—long enough to forget.
He parked in the secure parking and strode purposefully over to the air movements building. He was the first
to arrive and stood in the warehouse watching the loading
of the aircraft. Air Force, CareFlight, New South Wales
Fire Brigade and Ambulance personnel had obviously
been working around the clock to load up the plane with
provisions. Pallet after pallet went in. Mike Flynn, former
commodore of the Royal Australian Navy and past work
colleague of Paul’s, walked up and shook his hand.
‘Glad to have you on board, Paul!’ he said. ‘I was very
happy when I saw your name on the list!’ Mike was to be
the team leader.
Paul smiled. Brothers in arms, now brothers in alms,
that’s how it was. There was a bond forged by the suffering you endured in the services. Well, not really, but you
shared camaraderie under training, you knew the pitfalls
9
ANGELS OF ACEH
of administration, the agony of dealing with large bureaucracies, the tedium involved in paperwork, the necessity
of working with hierarchies . . . and you also knew how
to get on with the job despite all these frustrations. The
armed forces gave you skills that you sometimes only
appreciated after you’d left. Not everyone could make
a proper speech, prepare a methodical lesson, organise a
function, drive a warship, fly a jet. It wasn’t only about
shiny shoes and parades. It was about being instantly able
to discern what was necessary, in any situation, and
quickly. It was about being adaptable. Managing change.
Improvising.
Mike Flynn was in his fifties. He was the New South
Wales State Health Services Functional Area Coordinator
for Disasters and was in the Navy Reserves. He had been
the Fleet Medical Officer in the permanent Navy. And a
pilot. He had been a classic good-looking fighter-jock in
his younger days. He had flown both fixed-wing and
choppers. CT4s, Maachis, and then Skyhawks. Wessex,
Iroquois and the UK Gazelles. He was close to six foot and
of normal solid build, clean-shaven with well-groomed
brown hair, cut short, back and sides. Mike had a reliable,
affable personality with a pleasantly relaxed manner. He
was savant, well-read and a deep thinker. A closet scientist
and philosopher. His life experiences had made him wise,
but not jaded at all. Married to Caroline, they had three
children—a daughter and two sons—who were all now
grown up and making their own marks.
Mike was vague on detail, preferring to leave that to
others, his concern was the big picture. His speaking style
was professorial. Why use two clipped words when ten
eloquent ones would sound so much better, that was Mike.
Although far from a military movie cliché, he was highly
10
The Call
competent and had a good handle on what was required and
how to achieve goals. His Navy background was going to be
a bonus here. His leadership skills would be crucial. You
cannot take 28 highly intelligent people out of their comfort
zones to where there will be numerous competing ideas on
how to do things and hope to dictate to them unless you can
command their respect. Expect mutiny otherwise.
Today his clothes were rumpled and his eyes red-rimmed.
His pen was behind his ear; his hands held paper. He had
obviously not slept, preparing for this mission.
Other members of the team began to arrive. Some
came from Perth. One was from Melbourne. A few from
Brisbane. They milled around for hours, as the planeloading went on. Watching the cricket on TV and twitchily
chatting. It was the Fourth Test. In Melbourne, against the
Pakis. There was a brew bay and bikkies. Bags to be
re-packed and fiddled with. Mobiles, texting. The time
dragged. Hurry up and wait.
The media were also there, wandering around. They
latched on to Paul and David, and a young blonde woman
TV reporter interviewed them briefly with a television
crew in attendance. Caught their smiles and reassurances
to their families and, before the cameras cut away, Paul’s
worried look.
Some of those waiting were given their immunisation
shots. Dr Jeremy McAnulty, the director of the Communicable Diseases Branch of New South Wales Public Health,
briefed everyone on health in a tsunami-affected zone,
‘Don’t eat anything you haven’t cooked or peeled yourself,’
he said. ‘Throw it away.’ They were to drink only bottled
water, take doxycycline daily for malaria, wash their hands
whenever possible, keep their fingers out of their mouths
and eyes; dress to cover their skin. Dr McAnulty outlined
11
ANGELS OF ACEH
the disease risks—the mosquito-borne ones: malaria;
dengue fever; Japanese encephalitis. Then there was cholera,
typhoid, hepatitis A, salmonella, dysentery, all contracted via
contaminated food and water. Hepatitis B, HIV—bloodborne diseases. The list seemed endless.
Paul was up to date with his shots, having been to the
Solomons. Going there in 2003 was one of the reasons he
probably made the short-list, he thought.
Finally, Mike called them all together. They knew why
they were there. There had been a major earthquake to the
south-west of Sumatra on Boxing Day, 26 December
2004. It was a 9.0 on the Richter scale, one of the largest in
forty years. The seismic movement had triggered tsunamis
in the Indian–South East Asian region, causing thousands
of fatalities and injuries. Eleven countries were affected:
Bangladesh, India, Indonesia, Kenya, Malaysia, Maldives,
Myanmar, Somalia, Sri Lanka, Thailand and Tanzania;
some more than others.
They were to learn more about tsunamis later. Right
now Mike was discussing Alpha and Bravo Team. Each
team comprised fourteen personnel. Paul Dunkin and Paul
Luckin were to be the anaesthetists on Bravo Team under
Dr Paul Shumack.
As the names of the two teams were read out (see
Appendix 1), everyone looked around at each other, sizing
up who was who, in which list. Nobody was in uniform.
Everyone looked tired, as though they had been packing
until all hours and sleeping restlessly. Funny that. One
name made heads swivel—René Zellweger. But it was not
the Hollywood actress, it was a male surgeon from Perth.
Mike continued with his briefing. Logistical support
was to be provided by the New South Wales Fire Brigade.
The medical team was to be totally self-sufficient for the
12
The Call
unspecified period of time, assessed at this stage to be
approximately a fortnight. Four teams—Alpha, Bravo,
Charlie and Delta—had been put together by the New
South Wales Health Department, acting in accordance with
the Commonwealth Government Overseas Disaster
Response Plan (AUSASSISTPLAN), in co-ordination with
the Commonwealth Department of Health and Ageing
(DoHA). Emergency Management Australia (EMA)
managed the plan for the Australian Agency for International Development (AusAID). EMA had been set up after
Cyclone Tracy.
A committee had been established in response to the
Bali bombing to ensure that health responses in an emergency were coordinated—the Australian Health Disaster
Management and Policy Committee (ADHMPC, the socalled ‘Alphabet Committee’ due to its letter-abundant
acronym). EMA played an active part in the AHDMPC.
Although it had not been determined yet, Charlie was to
end up in the Maldives, Delta in Sri Lanka.
Mike moved to the practical issues of medical supplies
and equipment. The Commonwealth did not keep disaster response stocks on hand, the states did. These were
medical supplies for treating victims of a disaster. The
event could be a bushfire, a train crash, an earthquake, or
perhaps a tsunami. Team coordination and supplies would
be provided by New South Wales. The obtaining of the
crucial items was a job in itself. The clinical pharmacist at
Westmead Hospital had stayed up all night on Tuesday,
filling a cache with drugs, while nursing staff had put
together the surgical supplies such as syringes, plasma-like
fluids, dressings and disposable scalpels. The list was
endless. Down at the fire station at Greenacre, firemen had
been feverishly packing tents, sleeping bags, mozzie-nets,
13
ANGELS OF ACEH
portable toilets and showers, torches, bottles of water and
ration packs of food.
New South Wales Health was requested to provide
teams that would give acute medical support for a fourteenday period. Dr David Cooper, director of New South
Wales Health and Ambulance Service Counter Disaster
Unit, and his deputy George Smith were busily matching
what was required with the people and the resources. The
names selected from David Scott’s replies had gone to
Canberra and, through the EMA network, were now part
of the response equation. The mission was to go in and set
up the support station and coordinate medical configurations for incoming longer-term support. It was called
‘Operation Tsunami Assist’.
They walked out to the waiting plane. Itching to go.
Hurry up and wait again. Paul could barely stand it. He
was on the hot tarmac, waiting to get to a disaster zone and
quick as a flash nothing was happening.
When he was a child, Paul’s mother was smart enough
to realise she had a clever, slightly hyperactive son who
was best-behaved when he had an engrossing project. She
gave him wood pieces and nails and he would happily bang
away with a hammer, constructing something, anything,
for hours.
Short of wood pieces and a hammer now, he started
writing on the lid of the RAAF in-flight ration box. This was
a small cardboard box containing a meal for the flight. They
each had one. He started a tote right there on the runway,
taking names and bets on the wheels-up time. His greatgrandmother had been an SP bookie. It was a great way to
get to know people’s names, too. Mike Flynn looked at Paul
14
The Call
smiling, ‘Are you going to be our light entertainment
for the trip, Paul?’ Someone had to have that vital role.
Mike then laughed, tossed Paul his own ration box and
disappeared off to the terminal with a ‘Put me down for
5 p.m.,’ over his shoulder.
Some of the team were optimistic, others not so. Ray
Southon bet it would be 4.27 p.m., Paul Shumack 4.38.
Mike got it on the nose, at 5 p.m. His prize was dinner,
with some still left in his own ration box, kindly left
uneaten by the others. Not a bad thing for Mike’s leadership, coming first at the outset.
15
chapter two
Operation Tsunami Assist
‘You’re welcome to come up the front and see the 1970s
workspace,’ said the young pilot. He had walked down
the plane, past the densely packed supplies, to talk to the
medical teams as they sat in their aircraft seats. He was
typically trim, athletic and baby-faced. Everything the Air
Force would dream of for its recruiting brochure. Not one
of those moustached silver-templed pilots from the
commercial airlines. Think Top Gun, not Flying High. They
were in a 707, a four-engined Boeing jet circa 1970. It was
state of the art back then when all the airlines flew them.
John Travolta now flies one, in a retro statement.
Paul had The Seekers playing in his head. Both pilots
were younger than the aircraft, which had daggy décor,
but was more comfortable than a Herc.
They had been warned not to take photographs at
RAAF Base Richmond, as it was a military base. It was
a legitimate request for security reasons, but Paul now
wondered light-heartedly whether it was to keep this
museum-piece under wraps.
16
Operation Tsunami Assist
Paul pulled the elastic seat pocket towards him and
pulled out of it a Qantas in-flight magazine, an early 2003
edition. An interesting find in an air force jet, probably a
kind donation from the commercial airline, he speculated,
flicking through it idly and catching a glimpse of the world
before the tsunami. There was something in it about the
Dixie Chicks. He remembered it had been a big year both
personally and professionally, he had qualified in cardiac
anaesthetics and his son Francis had been born.
Paul stretched out his legs. The late night and early start
were starting to catch up with him and the apprehension
he had first felt at Richmond hadn’t left him yet. The Air
Force ‘hosties’ walked past with garbage bags. ‘Pop your
stuff in here,’ they requested politely. There was to be no
clinking of drinks trolleys on this flight.
Their supplies filled the front two-thirds of the 707. The
team was jammed up the back in the last five rows, behind
a partition. They had no illusions about the mission now.
They had seen what was loaded onboard—bottles of water,
body bags.
The changeover to a different world was happening
incrementally. The plane, the old magazine, the food, the
lack of baggage-handlers, the absence of drinks trolleys.
The separation from their normal comfortable lives was
happening gradually. Despite this the destination was still
going to be a culture shock for some in the team.
People chatted and moved around, as much as the
remaining space allowed. Some slept. Others pondered life
and used the time to prepare themselves mentally. Some
tapped into themselves spiritually. For some, all of the
above. Bravo’s leader Paul Shumack, Alpha’s anaesthetist
Brian Pezzutti and the two firemen slept. Old hands at
this, they knew to grab the zeds while you could.
17
ANGELS OF ACEH
Ken Harrison sat and plotted a plan for the deployment.
How it was all going to work. They were going to be there
for about a fortnight. The logistics were his responsibility.
He was an anaesthetist by profession, but on this mission
he had the supplies and health of the team to take care of.
It was all so weird.
They were a motley crew, from Australia. Most did not
know each other. Most had never worked together. Now
these men and women were going to work, live, talk, eat
together. Sleep side-by-side. Share powerful emotions.
Nobody had full knowledge of what to expect. Each
wanted to contribute, and nobody wanted to be the
weakest link. Mike told them a Sydney Morning Herald
was circulating and that it contained useful information
about the tsunami. I had packed it into Paul’s bag as he
raced out the door that morning. It was looking pretty
tattered now. People talked about rumours they had heard,
that a whole island had been washed away, taking all of
its inhabitants. That 55 000 people had died, across all the
countries affected.
It had all been a bit strange at Richmond. They knew
only that they were headed to provide tsunami relief and
that they were stopping in Darwin. They had no clue
beyond that of their destination. They knew the aircraft
would have to top up its tanks in Darwin and take on
enough to do a return trip because there was no betting
on there being fuel in a tsunami-affected region.
Being the festive season, there was also the concern that
there might be nobody at Darwin to refuel the plane. The
silly season is when Australians chill out. Maybe nobody
would be around, apart from the odd person doing security
checks. The flight was not a normal or rostered one. It was
hardly ‘in the program’. So much was unknown. So many
18
Operation Tsunami Assist
decisions being made and updated. Everything changed,
sometimes by the time the speaker had finished his or her
sentence. Only the charter was the same. It was simple.
Get there, do your bit.
Mike Flynn was to say later, ‘You only get the call for
The Big One once in your lifetime.’ This was it.
They were told not to take uniforms or their military
identification cards. Some had turned up with their uniforms, unsure until that point whether the mission was
military or civilian. The reasons for making it civilian were
still not quite clear yet. They would be, eventually.
In Darwin, they learned of their next destination—
Jakarta. And by the time they landed at Jakarta military
airport it was night, 1 a.m. Sydney time, but who knew
what the local time was. All Paul knew was that it was late.
Paul got off the plane with his small blue daypack, and
milled around with the team nearby. The airport was a
military airfield. There was no terminal and it was quite
dark except for the occasional searing flood-light up high.
There were a few people around, but not many. It was
shadowy with not much happening except for every ten or
fifteen minutes when a plane would land near them, loudly,
and then there would be a burst of activity.
Paul realised he’d left his Navy issue bag, his ‘bluey’,
which held his undies and toilet bag on the plane. He
inwardly cursed himself. The plane looked like it was closed.
Nothing was being moved off it because the decision as to
what was the best craft to use to get to wherever they were
going had not been decided upon. It couldn’t be, at this
stage. Not until more was known about their destination.
The 707 needed heavylift machinery to unload. A Herc
didn’t. There were no guarantees that there would be
machinery available when they reached the disaster zone.
19
ANGELS OF ACEH
He stood on the tarmac looking out for the bus that
was going to take them into Jakarta, which eventually
appeared near the wing of the plane. At that moment, Mike
Flynn tapped Paul on the shoulder. ‘Isn’t your brother-inlaw in the military? Is that him over there?’
‘What? No, he wouldn’t be up here.’
Paul looked over, following Mike’s gaze and saw my
brother, Bernard York, standing on the tarmac. Bernard
was a lieutenant commander in the Royal Australian Navy.
Good-looking, olive-skinned with a big gummy smile,
doe-eyes, thick, shiny brown hair and short classic naval
haircut. Courteous, kind and always ready to listen; girls
wanted to mother him. Expressive hands and earnest
expressions as he spoke.
With wide grins and a bit of incredulity at how life
arranges things, Paul and Bernard exchanged news.
Bernard was the godfather to our eldest son Liam and
was very close to me. Sophie will worry twice as much,
knowing that Bernard is here, Paul thought to himself.
When news of the tsunami broke, Bernard had been
posted to Jakarta to augment the embassy staff. The staff
were busy. The Bali bombing had made everyone on edge
about travel to Indonesia and there had been recent
warnings, reminding them not to frequent places where
expats tended to gather, and not to stay in certain hotels.
The Australian embassy in Jakarta had been bombed
itself, not so long ago. It was hard not to take it personally.
None of this was on anyone’s mind right now. The
tsunami response had eclipsed everything else. People were
suffering. The irony of having your safety at risk, when you
had come to help, escaped them for now. They were too
tired to absorb it. Bernard was pre-occupied and couldn’t
talk for long. He was a supply officer and he was working
20
Operation Tsunami Assist
out the logistics. Essentially, he was traffic-copping
incoming aid provisions, supplies, non-government organisations (NGOs) and refugees, who were landing in from
all over the place. The Indonesians were wisely vetting
everyone, including aid workers who were arriving as a
pit-stop to elsewhere, in order to prevent the needy areas
becoming even more stressed by the arrival of wellmeaning but under-resourced groups.
Major Supri was a gracious officer from the Indonesian
military (the TNI) who was fluent in English, and helped
Bernard enormously, especially in the coordination of aid
from Indonesian warehouses into waiting RAAF aircraft
bound for the disaster zones. Over the next few days, an
AusAID representative and personnel from RNZAF and
the RAAF would take over the coordination of the aid
effort and aircraft tasking, which required liaison between
the TNI and the ADF Joint Task Force set up in Medan.
Paul joined the rest of the medical team, who were
boarding two hot, stinking, short-length buses. They
stopped at boom-gate after boom-gate to exit the airfield,
with endless discussions taking place between the bus
drivers and the uniformed figures manning each one. It
was dark and the traffic was thick on their way to the hotel.
Paul was feeling irritated and gritty. He looked forward to
relaxing after the long day.
The hotel was in a one-way street that was designed to
thwart terrorists. The guards swept mirrors under every
arriving vehicle, searching for explosives. There was no
friendly check-in process, it was more like going through
security at an airport. Bags through X-rays, hand-held
detectors sweeping over your body. Jeepers.
Sherryn Bates, the hotel’s marketing manager and
fellow Australian, met them in the foyer. She had stayed up
21
ANGELS OF ACEH
late to greet them and she warmly welcomed them all. She
was forty-ish, brunette, well-spoken and stylish. Nothing
was too much trouble for her. The embassy had organised
the medical teams’ stay. After writing down their names,
the teams went off to hit the hay.
Paul noticed that some kind team member had brought
along his bluey, he was relieved and thankful. His grimy
clothes could be changed after all. Everyone retired for the
night, believing they were exhausted. They were soon to
discover what true exhaustion was in the days to come.
Paul was disturbed at 4 a.m. by Dallas, a nurse at
the Sydney Adventist Hospital in Sydney. The TV in the
nurses’ tea-room was tuned to the Today show. Over her
Vegemite toast and before the morning shift started, she
had seen Paul interviewed at Richmond. She phoned
immediately, concerned but proud of him. She heard his
groggy voice. ‘Go you good thing!’ she said. Something
like that. Paul mumbled a response. He remembered the
call later that morning when he was woken by Bernard
knocking on the door.
Breakfast was croissants, perfect eggs, luscious fruit,
freshly squeezed orange juice and strong, fragrant coffee.
Sherryn had outdone herself. This was the last real meal
before ration packs. Beef bacon, of course, reminding the
team that they were in a Muslim country.
Paul breakfasted with Bill Griggs and Allan MacKillop.
Bill Griggs had been Paul’s instructor on Emergency
Medicine courses back in Paul’s Navy days. Big build, had
once had more hair, affable. He was known as Dr William
Griggs, AM, Director Trauma Services, Royal Adelaide
Hospital in his civilian life, and was a Wing Commander
in the RAAF Reserves. Whenever the country had a
problem, the government called on Bill Griggs to look into
22
Operation Tsunami Assist
it. He had been to countless disaster and war zones, and
numerous sensitive matters that he simply couldn’t talk
about.
MacKillop had also been an instructor on the courses,
but this was the first time Paul had met him personally.
Paul was surprised to see the men in uniform. The message
at Richmond had been that the initial Australian aid effort
was civilian. The two men in camouflage battle fatigues
looked incongruous in this five-star hotel. It was all part of
an unfolding story.
Griggs looked tired, but MacKillop looked dreadful as
he recounted some of what he had seen on their ‘recce’.
Paul was worried about him, as MacKillop was very
drawn and agitated. Slightly wild-eyed. The strange,
slightly apprehensive feeling Paul had felt at Richmond
came back. His stomach knotted a bit more. These guys
were old hands at disaster areas and were clearly carrying
some weighty psychological burden. It spooked the team.
Not that they needed a wake-up call. They already knew it
was not an adventure they were going on, it was something
else altogether.
There was nowhere to go, yet. Bernard, who was now at
the airfield, rang Mike Flynn: ‘There’s no point in coming
out here, Sir,’ he said. ‘You have no clearance to depart.
Banda Aceh is too congested with aid aircraft landing, for
the moment.’ Mike called the team together for a briefing
in the foyer of the hotel. ‘We’re going to Banda Aceh,’ he
said. Paul had never heard of the place. He had heard of a
war in Aceh from the news and from a visit to Jakarta in
1999, and thought it was probably a city or something.
Mike kept talking—important details, logistical matters,
mission update, expectations. Paul could barely hear him,
the distractingly jolly music in the foyer was drowning out
23
ANGELS OF ACEH
the key words. He asked the reception staff to turn it down
and they obliged immediately.
Mike brought them up to speed with their destination.
Banda Aceh was the capital of the province Aceh
(Nanggroe Aceh Darussalam), on the north-western tip of
the Indonesian island of Sumatra. Banda Aceh had had a
population of about 250 000 before the tsunami struck.
The population of Aceh province had been estimated at
just over four million in recent years. The population of
Indonesia was just under 240 million in 2004. Already they
knew that the western coastal areas of Aceh had been
levelled by the tsunami.
James Branley, an infectious disease physician on the
Bravo team, had earlier thought he had heard Mike Flynn
say ‘We are going to Madang’ and had dutifully filled
out his destination documents with Madang, Papua New
Guinea. It seemed smart, James had surmised, it was
probably a neutral place from where they would launch
operations. The others enjoyed James’ rationalisation
greatly, especially as they discussed landing arrangements
for Medan, Indonesia. The safety of landing at Banda
Aceh, Indonesia, at this stage was in question and so
Medan was being considered. They learned the airfield
could take the 707, but heavy-lifting equipment would be
needed, as there were 17 tonnes of densely-packed pallets
to be unloaded from the plane’s high doorways.
Mike Flynn then announced that the Australian medical
teams of Alpha and Bravo would combine to become the
Combined Australian Surgical Team (CASTA) Aceh. As
the CASTA members formally introduced themselves to
each other, Paul was characteristically upfront. ‘I have
never been into a disaster zone,’ he admitted to the others,
‘you’ll have to bear with me. If anyone is going to “lose it”
24
Operation Tsunami Assist
first, it might be the most inexperienced.’ René Zellweger,
a surgeon of considerable experience, looked at Paul
thoughtfully. Not many people hid their light under the
bushell like that. He heard Paul saying, ‘I will carry boxes,
fix things. I will do anything you find useful.’ This was a
highly trained medical specialist making this offer. René
knew then that the team would be good, with attitudes like
this. Others spoke up about where they had been—East
Timor, Bougainville, Somalia, Rwanda, Bali.
For Marjorie Raggett, Lisa Dillon and a few others this
was their first deployment. Marjorie and Lisa were emergency nurses from Westmead Hospital in Sydney. They
were equally as upfront as Paul. Now was not the time to
pretend to be a know-it-all. Being wet behind the ears
might be temporarily embarrassing, but the others on the
team needed to know, as it would mean the difference
between life or death in a critical situation. Experienced
people might have a better idea of what to do, to take over
a task or at least lead the way.
‘There is a phrase you’re going to hear more than any
other,’ said Paul Shumack, the leader of the Bravo team,
part of the newly combined CASTA, looking around at
their attentive faces. He cleared his throat, to speak a little
louder. Some had moved closer.
‘Shmackers’, as he was nicknamed from quite early on
in the operation, put them in the picture. He was scarecrowthin, medium height, with salt and pepper hair, moustache
and glasses. Very secure and laid-back, he didn’t take
himself too seriously, and had a ready humour. He worked
as a consultant physician in occupational medicine at
Amberley Airforce Base in Queensland. He was expert
at assessing and working towards preventing health
problems caused by hazards such as radiation, solvents,
25
ANGELS OF ACEH
fuels, and inhaled particles. He had been in the RAAF for
twenty years and the Specialist Reserve for another
sixteen. He was a Group Captain. Married to Christine
(‘Sam’), he had three adult children.
Shmackers was an extraordinary man. Apart from being
an accomplished physician and PhD, he had given much
of his private life in the last fifteen years to serving the cause
of Variety Club, Australia’s largest children’s charity. The
charity stages a state-wide old car bash each year to raise
money for disadvantaged and disabled children, and a
nation-wide bash through the Australian outback, every
four years. He now chaired the appeal in Queensland.
Shmackers was also an inveterate tinkerer. There was
nothing he couldn’t repair or build from scratch, a very
handy skill to have if you were going somewhere rendered
a backwater by war or disaster. As a veteran from war
zones, including East Timor and Iraq, he knew what was
required in demanding situations.
‘The phrase you’re going to hear most is “Get over it”.
Frustration is part and parcel of a disaster. Supplies are
always short. You’re going to have to get on and do your
job, in the most professional way, with half of what you’re
used to, and that’s if you’re lucky. You’ll probably find you
are getting by using your imagination and inventiveness
most of the time. You’ll find even washing your face, going
to the loo, becomes a challenge. Remain flexible, adaptable. Things can change at a moment’s notice, and there is
nothing you can do about it. Nothing.’ He stopped. Letting
the team absorb what he’d just said.
‘You’ll just have to get over it. You will wait, you will
hurry, then you will have to wait again. At some stage, each
and every one of you will have had a gutful. You will have
had it up to here.’ He placed the flattened back of his hand
26
Operation Tsunami Assist
vertically under his chin. ‘And do you know what? You
will just have to get over it. Good luck!’ He finished, with a
broad smile. ‘We are all in this together, don’t forget that.’
He was right. Shmackers was a plain-speaking man and he
knew what he was talking about. ‘Get over it’ was to
become their catch-cry.
27
chapter three
The Gate Opens
Bernard York was assisting Flight Sergeant Michelle
Maclachlan at Jakarta’s military airport, Halim
Perdanakusuma Air Base, with the embassy’s task of
being the intermediary between the Australian and
Indonesian governments. The Indonesians were being
very accommodating, showing their appreciation for the
assistance. However, nobody wanted to abuse this
latitude. If a soldier had forgotten his passport, you had
to find a way to smooth it. Promise to have it couriered
over as soon as possible. All rules of international transit
could not be completely cast to the wind, notwithstanding
an almighty disaster. It would be churlish to expect that,
simply because you had arrived to help.
Initially Bernard and Michelle simply had a small
exercise book where they made entries and did their
best to keep track of aircraft movements, cargo and
passenger details. Michelle’s mobile phone rang incessantly and Bernard’s first job on arrival had been to field
her myriad messages.
28
The Gate Opens
Bernard had been approached by a group of scientologists
who wanted to be flown to Banda Aceh. He was being told
by their liaison officer, ‘We know the Indonesian General
So-and-So.’ Bernard sighed inwardly. He, as politely and as
quickly as he could, indicated to the go-between that in a
disaster there are priorities. Medicine and water were
considered higher priorities than other things, even important ones such as general counselling services. Such
protocols are always hard to enforce. The flights were few.
They were also fully laden. Personnel being cleared for
departure in the early stages had to be fully self-sufficient so
as not to cause further liability to the suffering areas.
James Branley stepped in and convinced anyone still
in any doubt that they were not needed as critically as
the life-saving teams, who had their own supplies. James
wondered privately whether, given all the language barriers,
this group was being mistaken for ‘seismologists’.
The scientologists were briefed about the hostile natural
environment prevailing at Banda Aceh due to its having
borne the brunt of the tsunami, about the possibilities
of rampant disease and aftershocks, until they were eventually reconciled with the fact that their services were
better utilised where most of the refugees were being
taken, which was Medan. They thanked the team.
Bernard was no stranger to diplomatic relations. He had
been to sea numerous times on warships to different countries. There had been exciting moments, but the tsunami
response was something else again. He was helping a
nation recover from a terrible trauma. It was exhilarating,
and it was humbling.
The highlight of Bernard’s posting was to come later,
when refugees from the tsunami-affected areas arrived in
Jakarta. On touchdown they would shake his hand and
29
ANGELS OF ACEH
say thank you, thank you. They had escaped hell and they
thanked him with heartfelt voices for their rescue. He
would always remember them.
Knowledge of the rough conditions on the ground had
filtered through to the team. Having left their usual
military kits at home as instructed and realising that there
would be no issuing of gear, some of the team had needed
to buy supplies. Before heading out to Halim Air Base,
Paul had gone on a shopping expedition with the two
surgeons, René Zellweger and Peter Sharwood, and the
other anaesthetist Paul Luckin.
Paul Dunkin had met Luckin ten years before at a naval
medical symposium. Luckin was in the Navy Reserves. He
was a tall, slim, dark-haired anaesthetist with impressive
posture, and reminded Dunkin of the perennially wellgroomed Pierce Brosnan. Luckin had worked in South
Africa, medevac-ing people out of the snow in the Drakensberg. He had left before the system he worked within drove
him crazy. The night nursing staff used to turn off the
patients’ drips, go to sleep, and fill out the charts preemptively, as though the drips were on all night. Patients
missed out on medication, pain relief, antibiotics, saline
for tissue repair and care generally. If they survived until
morning, the drip went back on. Their recovery was slow
and painful under such a regimen, and no wonder.
Sometimes they died during the night and their charts,
which had been pre-filled in, showed them as having vital
signs for hours after they had died. Luckin had some
exposure to non-ideal medical scenarios, serious cultural
differences and urgent situations. There was no saying
what would prevail in Banda Aceh.
30
The Gate Opens
Paul Dunkin, Paul Luckin, René Zellweger and Peter
Sharwood had rushed back to the hotel from their supply
shopping, only to have to then wait out at Halim Air Base.
While they waited they loaded a heavy tow bar into the
plane, to assist in manoeuvring it out of the way once it had
landed at Banda Aceh airfield. Anything they could do to
facilitate their departure, they did—enthusiastically.
Waiting always seemed interminable, and never more so
than now. To while away the time, the team grabbed a stick
and a ball and started a game of backyard cricket with the
locals.
The pilot called Bernard from the cockpit.
‘Can you use your influence to get us a slot to land in
Banda Aceh?’
‘Leave it with me,’ said Bernard.
The air flight space around Banda Aceh was still too
congested and no landing slots were being given. The
impact of the heavy weight of the plane on the small
airfield’s runway was also being debated, as was its
manoeuvrability, which also didn’t help the cause for flying
in. A backdrop to these discussions was the fact that the
import of the immense tsunami tragedy—and the impact of
the international response—was still sinking in with the
Indonesian authorities. They had responded positively to
Australia’s offer of help, a response which had been the
trigger event at Australian government level for the formation of the team, but Banda Aceh was presently still in the
heart of a tightly controlled war zone. Permission to land
was not being given without vetting for good reason.
Finally, they took off after they had received approval
to land at the other end. Paul found himself sitting next to
James Branley. James was in his early forties, good-looking
and genial, with a well-developed sense of humour. He and
31
ANGELS OF ACEH
Paul had spotted each other at RAAF Base Richmond,
‘I know you,’ they had both said to each other. After the
twenty questions to work out how, it became clear. James
looked very similar to his brother, who was an eye surgeon
for whom Paul had done some anaesthetics. This did not
explain how James knew Paul, except that Paul had the kind
of face everyone thinks they know already. They chatted
very little about what they were in for. It was not what
anyone wanted to dwell on just yet. They were all keeping
their thoughts on that private—they just wanted to keep
their spirits buoyed, because there was a big task ahead.
At one stage, James commented to Paul about his
holiday plans for after Banda Aceh. ‘We will be going
north after this,’ he said. ‘My wife and I holiday at a beach
just near Forster.’
Paul replied conversationally, ‘So do we.’
Thinking this would trump him, James went on. ‘Yes,
and we’ll be taking our four boys.’
Paul answered, amazed. ‘So will we.’
It turned out they both holidayed on precisely the same
stretch of coast and their four boys were within the same age
range. They did not know it yet, but this little coincidence
would turn out to be quite providential.
They were also learning about others in the team.
Sudhakar Rao, a surgeon from Western Australia, had three
boys; Jeremy McAnulty, a New South Wales doctor who
had briefed them at Richmond, also had three. Between
these four doctors, they had fourteen young lads. It was too
good to be true—they were all going to have to get together
in the future.
As the plane approached Banda Aceh, they peered out
through the windows, some took photos. Voices were
hushed, aghast. They saw a beautiful sunset and a landscape
32
The Gate Opens
lit up with pink. Pink light reflected in water. Large
puddles of water, in places where there shouldn’t have
been puddles at all. There should have been houses and
signs of life. This was a city of over 200 000 people. There
should have been bright lights, colours, buildings, streets
with streetlamps, a patchwork quilt of properties. Instead,
there were only a few dim car headlights and a wasteland
which stretched for miles and miles along the coast. And a
couple of miles inland too.
This scarred landscape was Banda Aceh.
As the plane flew in to land at Sultan Iskandar Muda
Airport, Paul saw the lines of people along the road. There
were thousands of them. People had congregated around
the airfield, carrying plastic bags or suitcases tied with
string. Their remaining earthly possessions. Wide-eyed,
quiet, dazed. These were the uninjured, homeless locals. It
was a disturbing introduction for the team.
It was almost night-time and there was work to be done.
Boxes and boxes were being unloaded by a conga line
of enthusiastic people—doctors, nurses, firemen (fireys),
public health officers and aircrew. Paul went up to Scott
Bevan from Channel Nine and introduced himself. He told
Scott that his network had interviewed Paul’s family that
day. Bevan was busy trying to get Mike Flynn to do an
interview. But the Channel Nine television crew soon
worked it out—because there was a lot to be done here,
nobody could take time out to talk to them. In a short time,
the television crew were rolling their sleeves up and
unloading with the team.
It was hard work, but nobody shirked. Everyone
worked to his or her fullest extent. Paul kicked his knees
33
ANGELS OF ACEH
up and broke into a jog carrying some over-sized boxes.
He couldn’t help being a clown, he liked to keep the people
around him smiling. There was a lot to be sombre about, as
they had been given enough information and seen enough
to have heavy hearts already. Everyone would need to be
upbeat to last the distance.
The team stacked the boxes by the runway and covered
them to protect them from the weather, which was blowy
and unpredictable. Someone was put on watch, as they had
to keep an eye on their stuff—the food, drugs, surgical
supplies, camping equipment and personal gear. Some of the
local people wandered close to the boxes, curious. The team
did not know it then, but these people had not eaten in days.
Some of the Acehnese started boarding a heavylift plane
that would take them down to Jakarta, all sitting on the
floor like cargo. They were leaving their . . . what exactly?
These people had no homes anymore. Some had no
families either. They were leaving a nightmare.
Sudhakar Rao was asked to provide the flight safety
briefing. Sudhakar had been born in Malaysia, he had then
lived in India until he was two, before returning to
Malaysia and living there from age two to thirteen. He
could speak passable Bahasa, the official Indonesian
language, which was similar to Malay. Although the
Acehnese had their own language, most understood
Bahasa. Sudhakar felt his life had become slightly surreal
overnight. Here he was, the director of Trauma at Perth
Hospital, giving safety instructions to a planeload of wideeyed refugees, on a Boeing 707, in the middle of the night,
in a foreign language, in a disaster zone. Sudhakar was not
a novice to trauma—the Royal Perth was the largest
trauma hospital in Western Australia—but this was his
first deployment to a disaster zone. He had had theoretical
34
The Gate Opens
training in disaster management but had never been in the
military. When he got the call on the day after Boxing Day,
Sudhakar felt strongly that he had to go.
Sudhakar and his wife Narelle had three little boys,
Luke aged seven, James aged five and Andrew aged four.
Narelle was a physician whose parents had provided
assistance work for fifteen years in Papua New Guinea,
where she had grown up. She supported Sudhakar going
to Indonesia because the idea of going to another country
and helping out was not far-fetched to her, even though
news reports indicated that most of the areas were still
dangerous. On the afternoon when Sudhakar left Perth
young Luke said solemnly to his dad, ‘Don’t walk outside
when you get there, Dad. Don’t step on a landmine.’ Luke
had been watching the news, and the reports were of
disturbed landmines in Sri Lanka, one of the tsunamiaffected areas. At that stage, they had no idea where
Sudhakar would be sent. Narelle and Sudhakar prepared
their wills and photographed the boys with their dad. He
organised cover at work—not easy in the Christmas
holiday period—and packed. Narelle put in chocolates for
any children he might care for. He went into work to do a
last check on his patients and had a tetanus shot.
The family had their ‘last supper’ at the Mekong Restaurant in Mount Lawley, Perth, where they lived. His parents,
both in their eighties, insisted on coming to the airport. They
were proud of their son. And terrified for him. Narelle’s dad,
Barry, drove her and Sudhakar to the airport. Her mother
minded the boys. Andrew, the youngest, burst into tears.
There was so much that was unknown. This in itself can be
frightening. Even the adults felt the strain, as much as they
attempted not to show it. They tried to be reassuring, but
children somehow always know.
35
ANGELS OF ACEH
Darkness was falling rapidly, making tents and toilets a
priority.
Bruce Cameron, an officer in the New South Wales Fire
Brigade, had confidently told everyone their tents would be
ready soon. He and Greg ‘Watto’ Watson, another fireman,
fiddled in the dark with tens of thousands of dollars of new
kit, with which they were barely familiar, trying to put up
tents which had all these nifty little attributes, such as
windows, before the exhausted team arrived ready to hit
the hay. No pressure at all. The team would never know
that the kit was unfamiliar nor that it was tricky putting it
all together; the capable fireys had their pride.
Watto was a senior fireman with the New South Wales
Fire Brigade. Tall, slim, he was your quintessential Aussie
bloke. Laughter lines, a dry sense of humour and no
bullshit about him. He smeared his sunblock goodnaturedly all over his virtually hairless head, to the
amusement of the team. He was eager to help and good at
doing most practical things. He was married to Kerrieanne,
a father of three girls, two in their twenties and one in her
teens, and had a new grandchild, little Emily, and of course,
his dog, Annie. He would later tell the team, with a twinkle
in his eye, that being outnumbered by the girls in the house
meant he would continue to volunteer for deployments.
He worked in the rescue section. His deputy manager
had tipped him off about the tsunami and a likely
Australian response, then called him at home one night at
about 9 p.m. and told him to pack as he would be leaving
at 6 a.m. the next day. Watto never thought twice about it.
Major emergency response was the specialty of his
section. The section had been involved in fighting the
horrific Canberra fires of early 2003. There were countless
other disasters he’d participated in, including the Thredbo
36
The Gate Opens
landslide and the Glenbrook and Waterfall train crashes.
The job of a fireman is often portrayed in the movies as
simply spraying water on a fire but some of Watto’s
colleagues had been involved in rescue work at the Turkish
earthquake in 1999, when 17 000 died, and the one in
Taiwan, also in 1999. The firemen had brought with them
some tangible resources but, most importantly of all, Aussie
know-how. The specific skills they had to offer were the
ability to establish a water supply, to make a building safe
with support structures, to provide wiring for whatever
electrical supplies had been knocked out, and much more.
They were the ubiquitous Mr Fix-its.
The tsunami was different from others in one respect—
its immensity was unprecedented. Watto was no stranger
to sadness and death. He had learned that you deal with it
by being the most practical and the least needy. The needs
of those in trouble were what came first. And if you
couldn’t help those people directly, then you got in and
supported those who were helping in the heart of it and
needed backup. Yet, when he joined the Australian
medical team, Watto knew they were all initially wondering why on earth two firemen—Watto himself and
Bruce—were coming along to the aftermath of a giant
water wave. There was no fire, quite the opposite. He felt
that they were thinking, ‘Fireys on the medical team, what
the . . .?’, but were too polite to vocalise it. The medical
team would learn how useful fireys could be—their experience in the management of people and wreckage after a
crisis proved invaluable.
Now they were at the airfield in the dark, able to see
with torches the fireys had distributed—and the tents were
up. The East Timor veterans went and showered; they
knew the deal. You had to take any opportunity to clean
37
ANGELS OF ACEH
yourself, or eat, or rest, as you never knew if and when the
next opportunity would present itself.
Annette Holian, an orthopaedic surgeon from Melbourne,
felt sweaty and dirty after all the travel and unloading. She
heard there was a toilet and shower block across the airfield.
As she and a couple of anaesthetists made their way over
there, she ran into a few of the female nurses. They warned
her, ‘Don’t go in there!’ She went in anyway.
The toilets were three squats. The ‘shower’ was an
oblong area surrounded by a low corrugated-iron wall
with rocks underfoot. In the darkness she could make out
above the low wall the bare torsos of about a dozen men.
They were dipping water from a couple of 44-gallon
drums, which were lying on their sides, cut in half and full
of water, and tipping it over their tired bodies. Her male
colleagues picked up on her hesitation. ‘Come in, come in,’
they cried gallantly. ‘You can stand between us!’
She seemed to be the only woman and there were a
dozen foreign national men bathing in this one open area.
She thought she would wait for the numbers to dwindle,
but they didn’t. More and more men kept arriving as their
day’s work came to an end. Courage, Annette thought,
trying to bolster herself, it must be done. You are not
sleeping in a filthy state. Conditions may well be this way
for the entire duration of the mission. This might be as
good as it gets. Get over it. Get used to it early.
‘Tell me they have their undies on!’ she asked her
colleagues cautiously.
‘No. No undies in here!’ they laughed.
Right, she thought. I can wait no longer. I did not come
all this way to be a princess. It’s only the exposure of my
white flesh in the dark, with distant airport lighting, to a
dozen men I may never see again. She checked herself—in
38
The Gate Opens
an Islamic country, could a woman possibly be stoned for
this? Hygiene was important to good health. Health was a
priority for her assignment here. And Aussies loved showering—being fresh and clean. Get on with it, she thought.
She braced herself and stepped into the washing area.
Her colleagues were right. All the men were naked. She
resolved to keep her own underwear on and calmly hung up
her washbag and whipped off her T-shirt and trousers,
tossing them over the top of the surrounding wall to keep
them dryish. She waited her turn of the dipper. Dip and tip.
Ahh, bliss! Another dozen dipper loads to freshen the spirit.
She enjoyed the cooling effect on her skin, marvelling at
the fact that she was standing near-to-nude on an airfield
in a foreign country, in a cubicle with undressed men she
had never met. Some experiences you just couldn’t predict.
She soaped up and reached for the dipper again to wash
it off and rinse out her hair. The dipper was suddenly not
there. Annette stood, waiting, with soap running from her
stark white arms and belly. She felt naked and exposed,
despite her underwear. A man nearby kindly offered to
throw water over her hair rather than give up his dipper.
She accepted, leaning forward, to make the job easier for
him. He tipped the water over her head and she was again
refreshed by the combination of cool water and light
breeze. She waited for the dipper to rise again, and again.
Surreal. A delightful wash from an unknown man in
extraordinary surroundings.
She had to brave the toilet now. Three old blue doors,
side-by-side. Full length, she noted. Privacy! Really brave
and all-knowing now, she entered a just-vacated door.
With her torch on the ground to help locate the puddles
around the squat, she carefully took one shoe off, and
eased one of her legs out of her trousers, gripping the
39
ANGELS OF ACEH
gathered far end of the trouser leg firmly, making sure it
stayed well out of the puddles. She squatted confidently
and looked up. Straight into the eyes of a stranger, a man
standing to urinate in the next squat. The side walls of the
toilets were low, but she hadn’t noticed this until now. Once
upon a time she would have been mortified if this had
happened. Now it was almost normal. She still cringed with
embarrassment. Thank goodness it was dark, she thought.
Torch off. It was too late to reconsider, too late not to do the
business. There was some rough paper in a basket nearby
and a dipper to flush with before she gingerly returned her
leg to her trousers and her foot to her shoe.
Annette had survived the shower and the toilet. Smiling
to herself, in the darkness, she rejoined one of the anaesthetists outside and strolled back to the tent, as if she had
just had a warm private shower in a modern caravan park
shower block.
It’s amazing where life can take you, she thought. You
just need to accept the ride and keep going.
Paul had been trying to get through to me. The occasional
SMS message would get through, usually during Muslim
prayer time, when the congestion eased. He sent me a
message: ‘We R here safe! Things R worse than expected.
Luv U.’
When they landed, there had not been a drop of fresh
water to drink, nor a place to sleep. They had had to set it
all up themselves, and they had done so.
So ended their first day in Banda Aceh.
40
chapter four
The Real Work Begins
On 31 December 2004, Team CASTA all woke at 6 a.m.,
packed up their tents and ate their first ration-pack breakfast. Today was going to be a big one and they needed their
strength. One of the first things the fireys and paramedic
Jeff Gilchrist did was set up a latrine and familiarise the
team with its unique workings. While the men were happy
‘to take a leak’ anywhere, the women were not as keen—
there were men working in nearby rice paddies and the
toilets were squats and not the most private—especially in
daylight. Consequently the women were not tending to
drink the copious amounts of water the warm weather and
constant moving required.
Paul called me, getting through just as he reached the
head of the latrine queue. He couldn’t talk for long. He just
wanted to hear my voice, and hear that our boys were
okay. And let me know that he was not in any danger.
Wing Commander Greg Norman was the Officer-inCharge of the RAAF Hospital at Richmond and was
serving his final days in the Air Force when he was sent to
41
ANGELS OF ACEH
Indonesia. He had scouted Banda Aceh with Bill Griggs and
Allan MacKillop on their recce mission two days earlier,
with a couple of other service personnel. They had cursorily
inspected Banda Aceh’s main public hospital, Zainal Abidin,
and assessed it as unusable. It had borne the full brunt of the
tsunami and was full of mud and dead bodies. The clean-up
there was going to be a major project on its own.
As they drove around Banda Aceh, they saw bodies all
over the roads, which were being bulldozed into freshly
dug pits. On their way back to the airfield, the men had
seen that many of these piles had been lit so the bodies
could be cremated. The smell and the smoke filled the
air. The three of them chose not to dwell on these scenes
and impressions, but these were forever etched into their
memories. At one place they had seen a pile of little bodies,
with skinny arms and legs. Children.
Wing Commander Greg Norman was calling the team
together for a briefing. ‘Basically,’ he said to the gathered
team, ‘the first 2 kilometres of coastline have been picked
up and dumped on the next 2 kilometres.’ He went on to
describe a graphic scene of cats, dogs, human bodies and
rubble. He prepared the teams for what they might see,
telling them what he had seen on his earlier recce. ‘I saw a
mass grave and was told by the locals it contained some
8000 bodies,’ he said. ‘The locals have been bulldozing
bodies into a large hole in the ground. The risk of disease
is high, and the heat makes the decaying bodies perfect
incubators for bacteria.’ Identification of victims—
normally an intricate process involving dental records,
DNA sampling and analysis of personal effects—had
apparently been abandoned. The sheer numbers of dead
made it impossible. Bodies were simply being counted, for
the record.
42
The Real Work Begins
Greg then explained that there was a local private
hospital called Rumah Sakit Teungku Fakinah (Fakinah)
which had been secured by the Indonesian Police. It had
been closed since the tsunami. It was small—about 50
patient beds—but it would be suitable for the team to set
up in. There was also a large public hospital with 300 beds
called Rumah Sakit Kesdam (Kesdam), where Norman
and some Army medics were going to work, probably in
the Emergency Department.
While CASTA waited, an Australian surfer who was
married to a local Indonesian woman came and introduced
himself. Breathless, he described the tsunami approaching,
and how he put his wife and children into the car and
headed for the hills. When he and his family returned
from the high ground, the village was gone. He wanted
to help them and he had rounded up some local youths to
help with loading the trucks.
Meanwhile, Watto had had a slightly discomforting
introduction to Banda Aceh. He had been helping to finish
unloading the plane the night before with the precious lone
forklift—he was licensed in forklifts of course—and had
been noticed by the Indonesian military (TNI). The next
day a couple of soldiers approached him and asked him to
unload a generator for them off a truck. He was happy
to help, once everyone had broken through the language
barrier. Once he had unloaded it for them, the machinegun wielding soldiers indicated they wanted to have it
taken back to their camp. ‘No worries,’ he indicated, while
trying to look and sound as nonchalant as possible. ‘Where
would you like it to be taken?’ They set off for their camp
down the road from the airfield. One soldier sat next to
43
ANGELS OF ACEH
him, the other rode a motorbike in front, both still heavily
armed. They beeped their way through traffic, scattering
pedestrians (mostly dazed refugees) in all directions. As
they drove along in this interesting motorcade, an
Australian Army ute pulled up alongside them.
‘Worried I’d steal off with your forklift?’ Watto teased.
‘No, worried someone might be stealing you,’ the
Australian soldiers answered. They had observed an
unarmed Watto disappearing with the TNI strangers and
wanted to make sure it was on mutually agreeable terms.
One of the Aussie soldiers jumped onto the forklift with
Watto, while the ute accompanied them the rest of the way.
They drove to the TNI military camp, some 4 kilometres
from the airfield. Watto unpacked the generator, set it up
and also dropped off the TNI soldiers, who asked if he and
his Army colleagues would have their photograph taken
with about twenty of them—fully booted and spurred for
battle—out the front of their camp. They were all smiles
and very friendly, so the Australians happily did as asked,
and then went back to the airfield.
Mike Flynn, firey Bruce Cameron, Dr Ken Harrison,
paramedic Adrian Humphrey and Greg Norman went on
ahead to Fakinah to get it ready. They rode in a military
four-wheel-drive light truck (UNIMOG) which the
Australian Army had been using to tow the trailer carrying
their water purification plant. A Herc had arrived overnight bringing the Army’s water plant and the UNIMOG.
The vehicle was also loaded with grey space-cases.
Mike Flynn and the others clambered above all the
space-cases. The gear that they had brought from
Australia was mainly packed into these and this was the
first truckload of them. As the vehicle moved off, Greg
Norman shouted over the noise of the engine, telling the
44
The Real Work Begins
men to duck as there were many low branches and sagging
power lines draped between bent poles. The men flattened
their bodies as much as they could. Mike Flynn was
worried, but he kept it to himself. The team’s safety was his
concern, as he was their leader, but he knew there was no
other option other than for this small group to travel like
this, without seatbelts in a crowded vehicle. He had good
reason to worry. Suddenly Greg yelled out, as a large
branch snagged him, almost taking him straight off the top
of the UNIMOG. Greg’s head was bleeding where the
skin of his forehead had been split open by the branch.
On the way, Mike wordlessly gestured at something
down in the gutter. Bruce looked and saw a sight nobody
should ever see—a bloated, naked male corpse, with its
foot half ripped off, revealing exposed bones and tendons.
A mangy dog was feasting hungrily on the ankle, then it
began licking and salivating noisily through its teeth as
it turned its attention to one of the legs. Bruce was
completely shocked. It offended his sense of human dignity. This was someone’s father or brother. Where was his
family? Why was he there, abandoned in this disgusting
state? It was a brutal introduction to the horror of the
tsunami. The reality of it had not hit home yet. Bruce did
not know it, but by tomorrow all Bruce and the others had
thought was ‘normal’, would change.
The remainder of the CASTA team got moving out at
the airfield. Seventeen tonnes had to be manually loaded
onto trucks which had been arranged largely through the
diplomacy of René Zellweger. With Shmacker’s approval,
René had approached the driver of a nearby truck at the
airfield and a deal had been done. Yes, he could provide
transport but, in exchange, the medical team would have
to help at Kesdam Hospital also. The Australians did not
45
ANGELS OF ACEH
know the driver, but they needed the truck and he was
indicating their skills were needed at yet another hospital.
They were in no position to argue the toss, and they knew
that questions are not always answered in disaster situations. You have to roll with what is happening. They
agreed. They would work it out somehow. They were there
to build bridges, to get something established for later
teams and the arrangement merely added impetus to what
probably would have eventuated anyway. Greg Norman
and a handful of Army medics had already made a plan
to work at Kesdam. Some of the CASTA team could
undoubtedly be made useful there too.
They found an additional Indonesian truck, and the
Army UNIMOG was going to return for more loads.
Paul crawled over the top of the medical team’s supplies
into the front part of the tray of the second truck. Every
nook and cranny was occupied. The driver of the second
truck was reluctant to drive them initially but, after a
persuasive talk with paramedic Jeff Gilchrist, he finally
agreed. As the truck driver started the engine, Paul leaned
his hand out through a gap in the side of the truck and he
and Jeff high-fived each other. For Jeff, it was a turningpoint in his relationship with the team. He had felt, like
Watto, that there might have been a question mark over his
usefulness in this operation, as he was not a doctor or a
nurse. Again the team members were beginning to realise
how different roles were just as important and vital.
It was a scary truck ride, with the truck driver
constantly blowing his horn and scattering traffic. Paul
was not particularly fazed as he’d been to Indonesia
before, but some of the others were stunned. Near-misses,
swerving, close-call head-ons, drivers pulling out at the last
minute with no care for their safety—it was hair-raising.
46
The Real Work Begins
From time to time they passed what looked like the
odd dead body lying on the edge of the road. From their
earlier observation, efforts were being made to remove
them, restore normality to the streetscapes, but the sheer
numbers obviously outweighed the efforts.
Paul noticed piles of rubble along the route, and saw
several large burial sites being dug out by cranes. Mass
graves. In spite of the heat, he felt goosebumps. Mass graves
were on television, not by a roadside in your reality. There
was a strong smell of decay in the air.
They arrived at last at Fakinah hospital, which was a white
two-storey building in the shape of a square that enclosed
a large internal quadrangle. There were open balconies,
painted white with a brown wooden criss-cross pattern,
running all the way round the second storey. The front of
the hospital had a dark brown portico over a semi-circular
driveway and a decorative white fence across the front.
On the top floor, the team found a large lecture room
and decided to unload the boxes in there. It was incongruously adorned with pink streamers, making the team joke,
during their team-building unloading activity, about it
being a ‘safe-from-tsunami’ zone.
Bruce Cameron had checked out the Fakinah hospital
building earlier. It was dirty. He had found blood, faeces,
bits of human tissue. It appeared to have been used as a
temporary morgue. However, he was more interested in
the integrity of the building. His training in fire rescue
made this second nature; fires compromised the structural
integrity of buildings, so did earthquakes. When gas pipes
broke, explosions and fires followed. He knew what to
look for. As senior rescue instructor with the New South
47
ANGELS OF ACEH
Wales Fire Brigades Rescue Section, he not only operated
but often instructed in the art. Bruce’s specialty was Urban
Search and Rescue (USAR). USAR was an organisation
made up of the Fire Brigade, Police and Ambulance
Service. Their purpose was to recover as many people as
possible from such locations as the rubble of an earthquake, a bombing or a building site collapse. For urban
disaster, the equipment included drills which would go
through concrete, plus special thermal imaging cameras,
seismic listening devices, microphones and air fans—all on
long leads which could be fed through the hole which had
been drilled. They could then bring air to the trapped and
listen for sounds of life. September 11 would have attracted
a USAR response. The international body was INSARAG
(International Search and Rescue Advisory Group), under
the UN umbrella. It worked out international standards and
multi-nation cooperation and coordination, when the local
resources were overwhelmed or exhausted. It had been set
up after the 1988 Armenian earthquake. And in 2002, with
UN General Resolution 57/150, 58 nations got behind the
idea and agreed to strengthen it. New South Wales and
Queensland were registered with the UN for INSARAG
purposes.
However, the fireys had not come to Banda Aceh to sift
through rubble because even though there had been a
massive earthquake, very shortly afterwards the tsunami
would have drowned those surviving in the wreckage.
The tsunami had moved the disaster goalposts. Now the
fireys’ brief was to feed, water and shelter the doctors and
nurses, to ensure they could provide medical care. Bruce
had already met some of the Indonesian military. They had
worked out he was involved in rescue work by his uniform.
He was not armed, but they felt they could identify with
48
The Real Work Begins
him. ‘We do rescue too, and shoot terrorist,’ they told him
proudly, in halting English.
The medical team could not stay at Fakinah if the
building was in dangerous shape. Tents would be safer,
even if they were hotter and more awkward. Bruce looked
at the walls and corners of the building. He could see
cracks in the concrete which had come away in the corners
in some places, exposing the steel reinforcement bars.
There were a few broken windows, and the pipes leading
to the water well were broken. There were some piles of
rubble where presumably part of the building had been.
The hospital was obviously built more sturdily than other
buildings near it, as it was one of the few still standing.
Bruce found a spot on the balcony wall outside where
they planned to create the dormitory and measured the
width of the cracks with an engineer’s ruler, marking the
date next to them with a texta. The fissures were up to
3 millimetres across. This was to become his daily habit
over the deployment. It would become a journal which
would show what was happening with the building. If the
cracks became too large, the team would have to evacuate.
For now, it seemed safe enough. To make sure that the team
had an escape route in case of the building collapsing into a
stairwell, he threw a rope ladder over the balcony. As he did
so it occurred to him, rather ironically, how thrilled his son
Bradley would be if he were there. Bruce was a clean-cut,
fit and young-looking 42, married to Alison, with two
children—Bradley and Molly. Bradley loved to tie knots
and go camping. The idea of a handmade rope ladder to
climb down from a building was too exciting for words. The
danger would not be the main consideration.
Ken Harrison, the team’s medical logistics expert, had
already assessed with Bruce that the top storey would be
49
ANGELS OF ACEH
safer in the event of another earthquake, or aftershocks.
There would be less of the building to collapse on the team.
Bruce and Ken had the team stack the grey space-cases in
a simple block formation all the way up to the ceiling.
Normally a roof caves in as flat as a pancake but they
hoped that, with the stacking plan they had implemented,
any cave-in would create two tent-shaped spaces on either
side where the team members could lie. Basically, it would
create a void with the top of the cases acting as a ridgeline.
The team was extensively briefed on what to do if the
roof collapsed, and how to best prepare themselves. It all
seemed fairly theoretical at this stage. They were not to
know yet how important such safety measures would be.
It was another trying, physically demanding session of
hours and hours of unloading and carrying. The boxes had
to go up flights of stairs, which were narrow and slightly
slippery. You had to watch your step as you puffed up
them with the hard-edged weight of the boxes. The
CASTA team found that they had an ever-diminishing
band of helpers. There was no aircrew out here to help
with the unloading. Greg Norman and his band of medics
kindly pitched in. It was a huge job.
Jeff Gilchrist and Shmackers stayed at the airfield until the
last box was loaded, to guard the supplies. The trucks
returned from Fakinah and Jeff and Shmackers oversaw and
assisted with the loading of remaining supplies into them.
They also managed to find a much larger truck to take what
remained of the boxes. They didn’t leave the airfield until
about 4 p.m. It had been an incredibly long day, but neither
ever breathed a word of complaint about being left behind.
Jeff was in his fifties, moustached, and was very tall and
slim. He was not a normal ambulance officer, but a SCAT
paramedic. SCAT stands for Special Casualty Access Team.
50
The Real Work Begins
It had once been the case that rescue workers would work
valiantly to try to recover trapped and injured people, only
to have them die of their injuries and exposure during the
hours it took to free them. In 1984 a twelve-year-old girl
had fallen over a cliff at Bondi and died during the time
it took to bring her back up. Her death had prompted
changes in the approach to rescue work.
SCAT paramedics now crawled under trains to trapped
people, climbed down manholes, edged themselves into
collapsed buildings and down lift-wells, onto fire-ravaged
boats and down caved-in mines, and into swollen creeks.
They carried treatment packs on their backs. It was about
getting access and giving treatment, until rescue could be
carried out safely.
Jeff and a colleague had once stayed all night with a
patient who had fallen over the cliff at Dover Heights in
New South Wales. They abseiled down. Waves crashed
against them and took their gear—and almost their
patient—from their place on a high ledge. They hung in
there, in the dark and cold, maintaining the health and
spirits of the patient. Police rescue services hauled them up
when daylight came.
Jeff breathed life back into badly injured patients.
He re-established airways and gave oxygen, adrenalin,
morphine, fluids, you name it. He attached splints, neckbraces, bandages, compresses. He wrapped freezing
people who would otherwise die of hypothermia. Most
importantly, he encouraged them to hang in there. He had
helped rescue Stuart Diver, the sole survivor of those
trapped in the Thredbo landslide. SCAT paramedics never
knew what they would find. It was harrowing work.
Jeff trained with the Fire Brigade USAR unit. These
SCAT paramedics did not involve themselves in the rescue
51
ANGELS OF ACEH
or the police operations. They were there to perform
the medical side of it. They might accompany police to
siege situations, where there were gunmen and standoff
situations. If anyone was shot, Jeff could attend to them.
He had to be fit, courageous—and not become a liability
himself.
Jeff was a manager in the field of Counter Disaster
Planning and father of three girls, Danielle, Sarah and
Rebecca. His partner Fiona was the senior co-ordinator
for a call centre which took Emergency 000 calls. She fully
understood and supported his life. Her own was full-on, it
was all about life and death.
Jeff’s role in Banda Aceh was vital. He knew that he
had to look after the welfare of the team. His training had
taught him that if people’s mental states were good, then
they could function and do what they most needed to do.
If they faltered, you gave them a role. You might ask them
to look out for someone else. People would psychologically
gain confidence from that and approach their other tasks
positively, which they had previously found daunting.
Human psychology in stressful situations was complex.
You had to find a way to harness the very vestiges of their
spirit. As he had already shown in his dealings with the
truck driver, Jeff’s interpersonal skills would be crucial.
It was stinking hot out at Fakinah hospital, and the work
was getting harder to do. Paul’s T-shirt had a large wet
patch at the back. He wished he had a hairless body and
was skinny. And that a breeze might start up. Paul staggered up and down the stairs, with box after box, sweating
profusely. They all did. There was no point in slacking off
and nobody did. You knew you had to keep going until the
52
The Real Work Begins
job was done. Some people drank water constantly, they
were the smart ones. It was the only way to keep up your
endurance in the heat. Everyone was helping themselves to
the bottles of water that were sitting on the pallets. There
was no other water. The team were using bottled water for
drinking, washing their hands, shaving, and for cooking
instant noodles.
The team packed away lecture room chairs, swept
floors, moved things to make room for their supplies. The
boxes and grey space-cases were stacked up to the ceiling
at a point a third of the way along the empty lecture room
to demarcate the women’s sleeping quarters, and to hold
up and reinforce the ceiling, which appeared to have
been damaged in the earthquake which had triggered
the tsunami.
Paul finally took a break and went to set up his bed.
There were to be seventeen of the men in one area of
the lecture room. Four of the men—CareFlight doctors
Ken Harrison and Alan Garner, SCAT paramedic Adrian
Humphrey and firey Bruce Cameron—would have to pack
up their stretchers each day, as they were in a thoroughfare. The remaining space was for the seven women. Paul
was stringing up his mozzie net and chatting to Peter
Sharwood, one of the surgeons, who was setting up his
own stretcher. Suddenly, a spitting, snarling cat with no
tail fell through the roof, almost causing it to collapse. Paul
and Peter leapt up in fright as the cat loudly hissed and
spat at them, claws out, and then disappeared. They had
been jumpy to begin with, now they were completely
unnerved. The creepy tail-less cat remained unexplained,
its symbolic significance only being made clear to them
later. It was just another small segment in a series of
unusual things happening all around them.
53
ANGELS OF ACEH
The cat had caused part of the roof to cave in until the
electrical wiring stopped it, but broken pieces of ceiling
continued to fall on everybody. Watto and Bruce Cameron
were on the scene immediately to help repair the roof.
Sleep would be hard enough with the heat and mozzies
without roof fragments intermittently raining down on
them. Nails, which had previously been used to hold up
some pictures, were removed from the wall, and used as
stop-gap repairs. They felt bad not knowing anything
about the pictures they took down from the walls, which
had writing of some kind on them. Everyone in the
CASTA team was very conscious of being in someone
else’s hospital, someone else’s country.
Everyone learned very quickly not to touch your mouth,
your eyes, your nose. Diarrhoea, or even conjunctivitis,
was the last thing you wanted. Prevention was better than
cure. It was sometimes hard to remember this when you
had sweat trickling down your face, or insects sticking
to you, or a strand of hair becoming annoying. The antibacterial wipes I had stuffed into Paul’s bag were used
each time before eating. Paul remembered with gratitude
that his wife had put her foot down over a few items he had
thought would be unnecessary.
Liz Cloughessy, one of the nurses, set up a storeroom
downstairs for some of the supplies. She intuitively knew
that giving the Indonesian police ‘ownership’ of the
supplies was the best way to ensure nothing was stolen.
She was right. In return for this trust, they safeguarded
them with their lives. When she initially mentioned her
concerns to the police chief, he responded proudly, ‘Oh no,
if anyone tries to take anything, we will shoot them!’ Liz
54
The Real Work Begins
smiled weakly. Liz instituted a system of accounting for
the supplies with everything taken or used being written
down by them in a book. The police enjoyed reminding her
to use her system.
Liz was warm, sensible and very amenable to a hug.
She had reddish-brown short hair with striking blonde
patches in it, which made her extremely discernible from
a distance. She was the type to organise, fuss and be
consistently bright, warm and involved. A clinical nurse
consultant from Westmead, Sydney, she had originally
been designated as an emergency nurse in Alpha Team,
but CASTA’s Alpha and Bravo teams were now combined
into the one team (although occasionally they would still
refer to themselves as being from one or the other,
because it was easier) and the role Liz assumed in Banda
Aceh was not the one for which she had been originally
designated. She took on a broader one when she saw that
there was a need for someone to look after all the tasks
for which there had been no designation. She looked after
the team’s welfare, she liaised with the police and the
TNI, she looked out for the other nurses, she comforted
patients and she even washed clothes by hand for Mike
Flynn.
Liz had been a nurse for 30 years. She formed the
Emergency Nurses Association in 1982, which had become
the Australian College of Emergency Nursing, and she
lectured in EMST (Early Management of Severe Trauma).
She had been the nurse commander on the scene at reception when Australia took in the Kosovars; she had looked
after the displaced community when bushfires raged
through Sussex Inlet, she was on duty at the Waterfall
train derailment and the Rugby World Cup. Her children
Melee and Tharon were immensely proud of her.
55
ANGELS OF ACEH
She was the chief nurse for the Sydney Olympics and
the Paralympics. There had been huge responsibilities
inherent in her role with the hospital in the Olympic
Village, which provided 20 000 occasions of service, and
the Paralympic almost 10 000. Liz ended up sleeping there.
Her supportive husband Steve had seen the writing on the
wall with that one and brought in a fold-up bed for her,
from Clark Rubber.
With Liz around, Paul felt like his mum was there with
them. Liz bonded with the patients, making them feel that
they were real people who qualified for first-class medical
care (all being relative, of course), and showed them that
the Australians genuinely cared about them. She bossed the
fully armed police around, stopping them from smoking
near oxygen cylinders. They smiled and it broke down
barriers. They would laughingly ask permission whenever
they saw her: ‘Smoke? Yes? Okay?!’
Liz Cloughessy and Lisa Dillon, another nurse from
Westmead, together with Terry Jongen and Karyn
Boxshall, nurses from Western Australia, set up a ward.
They decided to ditch the hospital’s existing bed mattresses.
Although these were unaffected by tsunami water, these
were impregnated with blood and pus and various body
fluids, and they had also started to grow mould in the heat.
Exactly what you didn’t want people with open wounds
and in a weakened state to lie on.
The patients would have to lie on the metal bed bases and
where there were not enough of them, on the floor. The body
bags were going to come in handy as ‘white underlays’. These
bags were from Australia and were made of white PVC
plastic. They were preferable to the rank, blood-soaked
rags which accompanied some of the tsunami patients.
Fortunately, from a morale perspective, the patients did not
56
The Real Work Begins
realise that the underlays were body-bags—their own
country used black ones.
Meanwhile, Marj Raggett, Ray Southon, Rosie Clifton
and Rhonda Cowderoy, all theatre nurses (for this
deployment), were turning filth into a passable surgical
environment, with the help of the paramedics Adrian
Humphrey and Jeff Gilchrist. First they had to wash
down the theatres and all the equipment, from operating
tables to buckets, scrub trays and trolleys for instruments
and dressings. Some of these had stale blood and pus on
them, traces which were obviously months old. The theatre
staff asked everyone for any spare disposable polystyrene
plates from their evening meal kits, so they could be used
for laying theatre instruments out on. Ray cleaned the steriliser, refilled it with water and began the process of boiling
the precious few instruments.
The team continued to work. It had already been a long
day, but there was still a lot to do. Ken Harrison was
calling the shots. It was he who had decided that the
upstairs lecture room was relatively safe from cave-in in
the event of another significant earthquake. Carrying
boxes upstairs was back-breaking work. But because it
was in a dead-end—at the end of the balcony—it was also
fairly safe from theft. Harrison was being foreman to the
team, who were beginning to call themselves the ‘Storemen
and Doctors Union’. ‘Form a line, three feet apart,’ he
would call out. ‘We’re moving it all upstairs. Let’s move it!’
Slave driver, Rhonda thought. He’s certainly got the
whip out, thought Paul. The team hated what Ken was
doing, riding them so hard when it was intensely hot and
they were achingly tired. But the work had to be done and
57
ANGELS OF ACEH
he was being their coach. He did it well, and they loved
him for it.
Ken was the team doctor, as well as the logistician, and
he was going to be insisting on certain things to maintain
the team’s health in this foreign environment. Each member
would have to take doxycycline for malaria, and they would
all have to use mosquito nets while sleeping, and continually
use insect repellent sprays. They would have to wear long
sleeves and trousers from before dusk, despite the heat.
There were many risks for the team, and Ken was constantly
thinking of them all and how it was all going to be managed.
Diseases, earth tremors, dehydration, psychological impacts,
civil war hostilities—the list went on endlessly. One of
the first things he planned to do was arrange a medevac
arrangement with any incoming American ship for any
member of the team who became ill or injured and needed
more than what could be given onsite.
One of the fireys, Bruce Cameron, became ill from
working too hard in the heat and suffered dehydration. He
felt very unwell and had to lie down. It was a wake-up call
for Bruce. You had to look after yourself first, if you were
to help anyone else.
Fakinah Hospital had not been affected by the tsunami. You
could see the ‘shore-line’ or tide mark, a cricket ball’s throw
down the street. The wall of mud and debris had stopped
50 metres short of the hospital. Although not hit by the
water, it had ended up empty as a result of the tsunami. The
staff had left to attend to families, neighbours, friends or
relatives (or were possibly killed in the tsunami themselves).
A day after the tsunami had hit there had been rumours
that another wave was coming, which might reach the
58
The Real Work Begins
hospital this time. Terrified, any remaining staff had taken
fright and left. Since nobody was there to care for them,
the patients had then left. The procedures being undertaken before all this occurred were general low-grade
surgery, such as knee operations, urology, hernias. Paul
and Watto could see the type of work normally done at
Fakinah from looking at the surgical instruments, which
were locked in a glass cabinet. The owner subsequently
closed the hospital. He re-opened it in the days following
the tsunami, when Jakarta sent help for the injured who
were queuing. Indonesian doctors and nurses from the
capital arrived first, the day before the Australian team,
but they had not yet performed any operations. The first
operation they performed was on the night the Australians
moved into Fakinah. They allowed the new arrivals to
watch.
By about eight that night, the Australian medical team
were allowed to begin work. Brian Pezzutti anaesthetised
and Marj Raggett, theatre sister, assisted. Sudhakar Rao
operated on a groin wound in an elderly man who later
died of tetanus, and Annette Holian performed a debridement (the cutting away of rotten tissue, to prevent it
spreading into the rest of the layers of flesh and into the
bone). It was on a grossly infected wound on the top of a
man’s foot, where most of his skin was missing, and it
required urgent surgery. She had been told it was a break
in the tendon leading to the big toe, which was of a less
urgent surgical nature, but on examination it turned out
not to be. It wasn’t clear whether the diagnosis was wrong,
or whether the information related to a different patient.
This case flagged an early warning for the team that they
would need to be extremely careful, due to language
barriers, to accurately identify patient injuries.
59
ANGELS OF ACEH
Most of the newly arrived Australian team wandered
down at some stage over the next three hours to watch
both Indonesian and Australian teams at work. They
wanted to do something—anything—to make sure it all
got under way satisfactorily. The participants themselves
tried not to cause a scene when they observed the aseptic
techniques and the minimal sterilisation process in place. It
was an eye-opener. The correct equipment would have to
be found. Softly, softly, it was all going to happen properly.
‘Happy New Year, everyone!’ the onlookers joked to each
other as they drifted back to their makeshift dormitory,
shattered with fatigue.
Annette, Brian and Marj followed a while later, peeling
their gloves off and stretching their aching shoulders. The
theatre lights were switched off as they quietly slipped
upstairs to their waiting stretchers. They had been in
Banda Aceh for 30 hours.
60
chapter five
Keeping the Home
Fires Burning
It was New Year’s Eve and Linda and Jon, Paul’s sister
and her partner, had come over to keep me company. It
was going to be a quiet one, in contrast to the last few days,
which had passed in a whirlwind.
Two days earlier, I had gone shopping at Macquarie
Centre with toddler Francis, baby Pierce and four-yearold Darcy. We had met up with my brother Colin because
I had finally decided to buy a video camera, after years of
somehow thinking they were a luxury. I had changed my
mind because I didn’t want Paul to miss out on one minute
of little Pierce’s development. Paul had been away with the
Navy for all our children’s ‘rolling-over’ milestones, that
one before they start crawling. He was away for five
months when our eldest Liam was a baby, a few months for
Darcy, weeks for Francis and now, after we had congratulated ourselves that he would be around to witness young
Pierce, the call had come. Although this would be his
shortest deployment, the indicators suggested it would be
his most intense, and unique for its own reasons.
61
ANGELS OF ACEH
I was hot and the kids were yowling. The shops were
crowded and noisy, and I’d been lucky to get a park. The
post-Christmas shopping sales. I normally never went to
them, now I knew why. I struggled with the pram straps
of the double stroller—they were too tight because the
wrong-sized baby had been put in the wrong side of it last
time. You only worked that one out once you had plonked
the kid in it. Too hard to move them again, and too tired to
remember which side was whose. Sweat broke out on my
forehead, and my fringe started to stick to my face. When,
for the third time, a car driver asked, as I leaned over the
stroller, ‘Are you leaving?’, I ground my teeth. Broken
sleep takes away your light-heartedness.
Colin and I bought the camera, keeping to the bare
minimum that politeness allowed the explanation by the
shop assistant of how to work it and details of the fabulous
competition you could enter after buying it. Pierce whimpered, Francis grabbed things off the shelves. ‘Let me out of
here,’ I thought. Pierce had worked himself into a fullthroated roar, so I decided to breastfeed him in the back of
the Kombi before leaving the car park. It really was hot.
And cramped. The air was stifling. Darcy chatted endlessly,
Francis squawked, the two fought happily and fiddled with
the controls of the car. Colin discussed matters.
There were a dozen things I needed to do. First of all,
I had wanted to get out of this carpark because I had told
my sister Armelle I would visit. I then wanted to see Lisa
Hill, my close friend, drop off some things, and then get
back on the Pacific Highway before the peak-hour traffic
sludge engulfed us. I wanted to be home before the kids’
‘crisis hour’.
My mobile phone started going off, electronically
jangling out the tune of the opera Carmen. Colin handed it
62
Keeping the Home Fires Burning
to me amid the mayhem. Someone called Majella. She had
met Paul at RAAF Base Richmond—Could she interview
the family today.
‘Tomorrow?’ I pleaded. ‘Now is not a good time.’
No, they needed the interview then and there as it was
featuring first thing in the morning. Australians wanted to
see the families of people who went off to disasters. It was
all-important stuff. Did I mind? Paul had said I wouldn’t!
Reluctantly relenting I drove hurriedly to where I
agreed to meet the TV crew, at Bales Park, stopping only
briefly at my sister Armelle’s house nearby. Raced in,
grabbed a hairbrush and some makeup. The miracle of
makeup. Had to hide a thousand lost hours of rest. They
didn’t call it beauty sleep for nothing. Your face always
gave it away.
Majella and the Channel Nine crew turned up in
leisurely fashion, filmed the children, asked them what
daddy was doing. Ten-year-old Liam said that a tsunami
had attacked a city. Toddler Francis ran around. Baby
Pierce dribbled. Four-year-old Darcy said there was a
giant wave which swept it all away, and that his daddy was
a doctor who would ‘make it all better’. If only it were
so simple.
They asked me how I would cope while Paul was away.
Many of the interview’s initial questions were focussed on
this topic. I was staggered. How would I cope? At least
I was alive and well. The tsunami had destroyed people’s
lives, taking children, limbs, homes. Now was not the time
for navel-gazing about my own situation. Finally, Majella
asked whether it would be tough on Paul, looking after
children when he had kids of his own. I said it might, in
fact, make him even more caring, because he was already a
very good father and loved his children.
63
ANGELS OF ACEH
Watching the TV the next morning, we saw that the
program had ended with the piece about Paul caring for
others. Thankfully, the questions and answers about how
I would cope were not included. The thought of us portrayed
as a well-fed, nicely clothed, cheery family being ‘needy’
might have been construed as in shockingly poor taste when
set against the backdrop of the tsunami. Instead, you could
see how the children missed their dad and the commentary
accompanying the visuals of them playing in the park maintained that theme. But the sobering note, as Majella pointed
out in a compassionate voiceover, was that they had every
reason to hope and expect Paul would return safely, unlike
some of the children in the tsunami-affected areas.
The day the program was shown, Thursday, 30 December
I felt so frustrated by my inability to help that I decided to
write to the prime minister. I didn’t know if this was a
normal decision to make. What was normal?
I was one of twelve children. Six of each. My father had
often been away when I was very young. He had been
a marine engineer with the Royal Australian Navy. My
mother, multi-lingual, a teacher and an artist, had had an
insanely tough job raising twelve children. My father had
missed some of the births due to overseas deployments.
When he was ashore he always pitched in at home, especially once he had finished his sea-time for good. My father
worked hard, in the guts of the warships, wearing overalls
which were blackened by the soot from the oil-burning
engine-rooms of the vessels of those days. He sweated and
toiled around the boiler-room and the hot, cramped
machinery spaces.
Naval officers had not been paid particularly well, but my
mother whirred through the night on the sewing machine
and clicked away determinedly on knitting needles, to ensure
64
Keeping the Home Fires Burning
we always had a school uniform and a smart outfit to wear.
We moved house constantly. It had all been about boxes
and boxes. And new schools, new communities, new friends.
My mother had a backbone of steel. I realised that now
I had four of my own. I was not about to complain about
my lot to anyone in my family—four was considered more
than manageable. My parents were still in love after forty
plus years of marriage and the twelve siblings were all
important parts of each others’ lives and dreams.
I was now a mother of boys, a barrister and sometime
writer. And wife to a doctor who was in Banda Aceh, in the
wake of a tsunami. And I was contemplating writing to
the prime minister. There was nothing normal about any
of it. But it had to be done.
That evening, after I had put the children to bed, I
ignored the kitchen mess and started typing a letter to
Prime Minister John Howard asking him to take this
opportunity to re-build the tsunami-affected regions. I
reminded him that normally we might not be allowed such
latitude or interference, but these were extraordinary times.
It could be couched as an anti-terrorist measure if that was
considered necessary to make Australia’s involvement more
palatable. Poverty, neglect and extremism were probably
linked in any event. The reality was that it would be the
ultimate humanitarian act, no other reasons were needed.
I copied in Alexander Downer, the Minister of Foreign
Affairs. This letter could either put a cat amongst the
pigeons, or it could be ignored. I thought about how
Germany and Japan had been re-built by the allies after
World War II. This was slightly different but you made
friends when you helped out. When you showed you cared.
Nations might change governments, but the people would
surely remember.
65
ANGELS OF ACEH
Darwin had been flattened by Cyclone Tracy in 1975. It
had also been a Christmas-time disaster. It was re-built, in
what looks today like a snapshot of 1970s architecture.
What would be re-built in Indonesia after this obliteration?
It could be a snapshot of Australian generosity—homes
built safely for the areas, with plumbing, roads and all the
benefits of First World town-planning.
I ran the idea of the letter past a few friends. Too farfetched, would never work, nice idea but good luck. You
are writing to whom? Nobody writes to the PM. Nobody
normal. And he doesn’t get his ideas from real people
either. Haven’t you seen Yes, Minister?
I posted and faxed the letter anyway. You never knew.
But now it was New Year’s Eve. Linda was heavily
pregnant with her first child. By the time she and Jon
arrived, I had fed the children and parked them in front
of the television to watch the nine o’clock fireworks. It
seemed so incongruous, such elaborate celebrations in
Sydney when there had been such massive loss of life
in nearby countries.
Leo Schofield had appeared on camera during the week
saying the partying had been paid for already and would
go ahead. Mercifully, the fireworks were turned into a
fundraiser.
66
chapter six
A New Year for All
At about the end of the very first hour of the brand
new year, the medical team were jerked awake in their
stretchers. One or two of them dazedly fled half-asleep
out the door as an earth tremor shuddered and roared.
The walls heaved, the roof moved, building fragments fell
and the ground rumbled ominously. The mozzie nets
shook, and loose items jangled. Bags slid around the
room. Some of the team members lay there, frozen with
shock, unable to think, let alone move. Had they come
all this way simply to die, crushed in their beds? Paul
slept through the entire thing, lost in the dreamless sleep
of the exhausted.
The team whispered to each other, not wanting to wake
others, such as the loudly slumbering Paul. They discussed
the integrity of the building, the likelihood of another
quake, the possibility of being pulverised in the rubble.
They finally lapsed back into sleep, fitfully dreaming of
lonely faces at the airport, scarred landscapes, festering
wounds, bodies by the roadside.
67
ANGELS OF ACEH
Everyone woke again at about 6.30 a.m. and ate breakfast
on the narrow balcony—muesli from a ration pack, moistened with water or with anything liquid, like hot coffee
or fruit juice, rather than fresh milk (because there was
none). Paul and the team thought the urn was the most
important piece of kit they had brought. Hot coffee made
you feel human. A heart-starter. There was no microwave,
so the urn could heat meals too. The fireys had given
everyone a blue plastic plate, bowl and cup and a stainless
steel cutlery set, all in a calico drawstring bag.
The fireys had set up a small kitchenette arrangement,
called a brew bay, near the entrance of the women’s room. It
consisted of the urn, condensed milk, a plastic spoon pile,
and a roll of paper towel, hanging handily across a length of
niftily knotted string. There were also Kimberley Clark ISO
anti-bacterial wipes in a pull-out container and some detergent. You helped yourself to everything, and you washed up
your own bowl and spoon in a sink. There was no room
service and catering staff had been left off the team.
The first day of the new year was grey and overcast,
muggy, and a light rain was falling. Paul sent me an SMS:
‘We were in bed by 9 and not a drop to welcome in the
NY! The real stuff starts 2day. Thinking of u all the time.
PD.’ Later on he was able to get through to talk to me. It
was brief, but it was always good to hear his voice. I told
him how we were going. Paul needed to know that we
were all fine. And I duly told him that, every time.
My brother Ollie in Washington DC had emailed that
day. ‘Soph, I know you are busy, but promise you will keep
a diary (bullet form is fine) of what Paul tells you of what
he is doing, has seen, felt, etc, etc—this is history.’ Ollie’s
request reminded me of a passage from Lewis Carroll’s
Through the Looking Glass, ‘The horror of that moment,’ the
68
A New Year for All
King went on, ‘I shall never, never forget!’ ‘You will
though,’ the Queen said, ‘if you don’t make a memorandum
of it.’ I asked Paul if he could keep a diary at his end, while
I furiously scribbled, getting down everything he said,
even while we spoke. Paul sounded hesitant, even as he
promised. You had to face things if you wrote them down.
Explore feelings.
René Zellweger and Peter Sharwood and two of the anaesthetists, Paul Luckin and David Scott, jumped in the back of
a truck with some supplies and some of the original Bravo
Team, and headed for Kesdam, the TNI-controlled military
hospital. The tentative deal cut with the truck driver at the
airfield had been fortuitous. Mike Flynn had cased it out as
an appropriate place where the team could be used.
The Australian team remaining at Fakinah were all
called to a morning briefing with the top military personnel
and an Indonesian professor, Aryono Pusponegro, who
had spent some time at Liverpool Hospital in Australia. He
had come up from Jakarta and was put in charge of the
surgery coordination in Aceh province. Mike Flynn
gestured to the team at the start of the meeting that they
should stand for the professor. Mike opened the meeting
with a few words of Bahasa, thanking their hosts for the
welcome.
Lieutenant-Colonel Harianto was introduced and he
made it clear to Mike Flynn and the team that he was
in charge of Fakinah Hospital. This served as a sharp
reminder that, despite the fact that they were there to help,
at short notice and in what were trying conditions, they
were still visitors in another country. It was sobering, and
in some respects added another layer of stress. The medical
69
ANGELS OF ACEH
team was going to have to be very careful. There were
many sensitivities. The team was from a Christian country,
and Aceh province was predominantly fundamentalist
Muslim. The police were in charge of Fakinah Hospital,
the TNI in charge of Kesdam Hospital. Those who came
up from Jakarta were from the government. The Indonesian government was represented militarily by TNI,
who had been in conflict with the armed resistance group,
Gerakan Aceh Merdeka (GAM—Free Aceh Movement)
since 1976. There had been approximately 12 000 people
killed during the last three decades as a result of the clash
between the resistance and the military.
Aceh was where Arab traders first introduced Islam to
the Indonesian archipelago, around the eleventh century.
From here Islam subsequently spread to the rest of SouthEast Asia. That is why the province is sometimes known as
Serambi Mekah (the Window to Mecca or, as some call it,
the Verandah of Mecca). It was an independent Islamic
sultanate for over 300 years, up until 1873, when Aceh
vigorously resisted the Dutch who came and colonised
the East Indies. The Dutch declared war on Aceh and
eventually prevailed in 1904, after a long, drawn-out
struggle involving high casualties. Acehnese guerilla resistance fighting continued until 1942, when the Japanese
invaded the East Indies during World War II and
conquered the Dutch colonial forces. From 1945, when
Indonesia gained independence, Aceh fought to become
an independent Islamic state. In 1959, Indonesia granted
Aceh special territory status giving them cultural and religious autonomy, but the issues of foreign control and a
military presence remained unresolved.
As a result, GAM separatists had been active since
1976. Their emphasis was on freedom and independence,
70
A New Year for All
and they were very devout Muslims which was a key feature
of the Acehnese identity.
The Acehnese are determined people. Their history
shows that.
Their province had been under martial law since 2003.
Nobody was allowed in or out without permission from the
Indonesian government; it was all very tense. And here
were the Aussies, with little idea of the details of past
animosities, all stocked up and ready to swing into action.
Crikey, they were walking on eggshells.
The post-tsunami period might ultimately provide some
impetus for peace but right now both sides were in shock
and it was far too early for anyone to take up the political
opportunities the mass death and disaster afforded. The
Indonesians had sent help for their countrymen, despite
being at civil war with them days earlier.
It was a deadly serious business, from every perspective.
The team would have to liaise very diplomatically with
local authorities and all relevant entities to do what they
needed to do. Everything hinged on that.
Annette Holian, an orthopaedic surgeon from Melbourne,
had no problem with being taken seriously. She hadn’t
attained the still-rare achievement of being a woman
orthopaedic surgeon because she was a shrinking violet.
She knew she was in a Muslim country and the traditions in
relation to women professionals might well be different. She
also knew that some countries and faiths had different
ideas about standards of medical treatment. She listened
as Professor Pusponegro spoke to the group and contemplated the consequences of what he was saying.
Suddenly a rooster started crowing in the middle of the
meeting. Her mobile telephone was squawking loudly in
her bag. Everyone looked at her. Some grinned; it broke
71
ANGELS OF ACEH
the tension. Paul thought the timing was perfect. He
SMSed her: ‘You goose!’ She rummaged around and
quickly turned it off. The meeting resumed.
The team was informed that the TNI had lost about
1000 personnel in the tsunami. The police force, numbering about 3000, had been decimated. Of 300 Acehnese
health personnel, only about seventeen had survived. The
survivors were traumatised and incapacitated by grief;
many had lost family members, others their homes.
Paul was listening intently to the briefing when
suddenly he and the rest of the team were instinctively
scrambling for their lives out the door. He had no idea how
he got there, but he was out the door and into the middle of
the courtyard before he realised it. The whole building
shook violently. All the windows and walls were moving.
His mind was filled with sheer terror. Paul had never
experienced anything like it in his life. Awake, that is. In
the Navy, while you’re at sea you expect movement. You
develop sea-legs and it is not perplexing. When you are on
land, with four walls around you, twenty tonnes of rooftiles above you and solid concrete beneath you, and you
are sitting down for the first time in hours, fully engrossed
in a fascinating briefing, the last thing you are prepared for
is an earthquake.
It was to be one of the smallest quakes he would experience while he was in Aceh.
Everyone from the briefing stood in the courtyard,
away from the building, until they were sure the tremors
had stopped. Their fingers shaking, even some of the nonsmokers accepted a cigarette when the pack went around.
One of the Indonesian police fainted. He was terrified and
his blood drained into his feet. Nurses Liz Cloughessy
and Ray Southon rushed to help him. The assistance they
72
A New Year for All
provided caused a group of the police to insist on helping
with the stacking and sorting of supplies.
Of course, Paul’s mind adapted, which is what happens.
Your coping mechanism adjusts until even the strangest
occurrences seem normal. After experiencing a number of
these tremors, Paul acquired a highly attuned sensory alert
system, so that he eventually felt like Radar in MASH, and
was often the first to ask, ‘Did you feel that?’ to his
colleagues as a quake began. They had to evacuate each
time. If the roof or walls had collapsed, they would have
been crushed. Rhonda Cowderoy, one of the theatre
nurses, noticed that when the rumble first started, geckoes
would run down the walls frantically, cats would start
miaowing and dogs could be heard barking in the distance.
It was an eerie warning.
Technically, these were aftershocks. However, they
were quite significant quakes, and a couple were said to be
larger than the famed Newcastle quake in New South
Wales back in 1989. It came back to Paul now. He had
been lying on bitumen in Sydney, repairing a car from
underneath, when that one had happened—the car had
rocked on its jack, but fortunately stayed put.
After the briefing had concluded, the team was shown
over the hospital by their hosts. Even though it was the
middle of the day, the corridors were dark. The team was
then shown the Emergency Department (the ED) and
what work was being done there. There was a lot of
activity going on and cries from children in pain as they
were being examined and treated. Brian Pezzutti walked
over to see the array of surgical instruments being used,
with an eye to what might be borrowed at some later stage
for use in surgery. He found a tray of needles, syringes,
forceps and needle-holders and made a note of them for
73
ANGELS OF ACEH
later requests. As he returned to the group, he walked past a
black plastic garbage bag on the floor and suddenly he cried
out. He’d been stabbed by a hypodermic needle. He pulled
his trouser leg up and saw a nasty scratch low on his leg,
above ankle-height. The group stopped in its tracks. Everyone gathered round to see what had happened. The needle
was sticking out from the bag by about 5 centimetres—it
was thick, of the hollow type used for injections rather than
the fine type used for suturing. Being hollow made it potentially dangerous—there could be blood in it. They put the
bag safely into a bin, and Brian went off and had the wound
cleaned and swabbed with Betadine by Dr James Branley.
Brian was quite calm, partly due to his personality, and
partly due to the fact that he also mentally judged the risk of
infection from anything drastic as low—Aceh was a devout
Muslim province, so the possibility of HIV infection was
small. Brian’s military service had kept him up-to-date with
all his immunisations. Notwithstanding this reassurance, it
was a wake-up call for the Australian team. They were in a
different medical environment, with different protocols.
There was always a risk, even of straightforward infection,
from any wound by any cause; this was an environment
where many people had bacteria-laden wounds, were
coughing constantly, the cleaning regime was inadequate,
and the heat and damp helped germs proliferate.
To prevent any recurrence of this episode, Paul and
some of the others made makeshift sharps’ bins out of
plastic food containers, in which used syringes and needles
could be disposed of.
Channel Nine’s A Current Affair crew visited the hospital
in the middle of all this chaos. The crew were famished,
74
A New Year for All
so the medical team gave them some food, which they
appreciated. The TV people were aware of their multiple
responsibilities. They had an obligation to get news out,
because the world needed to know of the desperate plight
of these people, but they also knew that there were
medical-in-confidence issues, respect for the privacy of
patients, and cultural sensitivities to be considered. There
was also enough melodrama happening in real life to need
no embellishment by them. They could have filmed the
team in private moments when they shed tears or vented
frustrations, but they didn’t. Instead, they concentrated on
showing the patients arriving, being cared for, the level of
innovation and improvisation taking place and the ‘can-do’
attitude of the Australian team. The TV crew shared the
same attitude.
They assisted whenever and wherever they could. A
few days earlier they had helped unload the plane, now
they helped lift patients. They showed consideration for
the Indonesian people, the Acehnese patients, and, when
asked not to film, because it might be distracting or breach
medical ethics, they didn’t. When a power failure
occurred, they held torches aloft so the operation in
progress could continue.
Paul started seeing the media through different eyes.
They were telling the world about this place which was in
extreme need, and they were helping out in their own
ways, and in any way they could. He vowed to himself to
cooperate if they needed him. After all, they were all in this
together, they all had a job to do. Cut off from television,
radio, newspaper and the internet, Paul did not know at
the time what a powerful impact the press coverage was
having on Australians, and the world. It would trigger an
amazingly compassionate and generous response. The call
75
ANGELS OF ACEH
for him to help came later that day. A call on his mobile
came from Katie Jensen of the Today show in Sydney.
Could he be interviewed live on Monday morning at 4 a.m.
his time? No problem, he had answered as he resolutely
arched his creaking shoulders.
The work that day was still quite full on. There was
more stacking of stores and more cleaning to be done. The
combination of the smell and the heat was overpowering.
Like Bruce the day before, Paul began to feel unwell. He
felt woozy and thought he was experiencing earth tremors.
Luckily he had the sense to lie down before he fell down.
The team had been working in a very physically
demanding, team-building activity for two days without a
proper break. Now from time to time team members would
check on how their stricken colleague was faring, to the
point where Paul began feeling embarrassed. It was
comforting, of course, but Paul couldn’t wait to get up
again. After drinking lots of water mixed with a bit of salt
and sugar and some time spent horizontal, he began to feel
much improved.
Paul, Watto and Bruce went on a tour of inspection,
checking the effect of the aftershocks on the building. A
good idea of the lay of the land was important knowledge.
There were also many things they needed and finding
resources in the hospital was paramount. The integrity of
the building was a consideration. They saw cracks in walls,
and some doors did not close properly due to the ruined
alignment of the building. They had previously heard the
dubiously reassuring mantra, ‘It’s not the 9.0 earthquake
which gets you, it’s the 6.5 aftershock that follows which
brings the building down.’
76
A New Year for All
Watto described their scouting expedition to Paul as
‘security rounds’. ‘We’re just burglars in uniform, mate!’
he said with a grin. ‘Two weeks with us and you’ll learn
what it takes crims two years to learn in the “joint”!’ (a
slang reference to gaol). The reality was that they really
did have to check regularly on earthquake damage, and
also had to find much-needed surgical instruments,
medical supplies and anything else that would help, such
as anaesthetic equipment and electrical powerboards.
They still felt somewhat restrained by their desire to be
courteous and unintrusive, but the urge of necessity was
eroding this rapidly now.
There was a locked room just down the corridor from the
dormitory, which had high windows. Paul and Watto lifted
Bruce up towards the windows, passing him through an
open window so he could get inside and open the room’s
double doors. Once inside, they found a huge, clunky set of
jingly keys on a chair. It was too good to be true. They were
now able to gain access to the other rooms along the corridor.
One of these became a designated time-out room for the
team, another was later used for the loudest snorers to sleep
in. A third room, which appeared to have been the CEO’s
room, had an ablutions ensuite with the usual squat toilet and
dipper-in-water arrangement. No showers, but some of the
women would commandeer this room with delight.
The three men saw further signs of the quake damage in
the outside office. Achievement trophies lay on their sides,
some were smashed. Furniture was sitting at odd angles.
This area became the office area for the team. Ken
Harrison put the chargers for the radios in here and Paul
Van Buynder from public health made it his quiet place for
tapping out records of public health developments on his
laptop. Paul Dunkin found a stack of blank CDs for Ken to
77
ANGELS OF ACEH
download photographs and material on, some power cords
and other odds and ends.
The pièce de résistance of the tour was the discovery
of precious blood-pressure cuffs, in what appeared to be
a midwives’ training room—complete with silicon body
parts —for teaching birthing and breastfeeding techniques.
Taking blood pressure is a vital part of medicine and it is
a critical part of anaesthetics. This was an exhilarating find,
because checking blood pressure manually takes time and
interferes with the performance of other tasks because you
have to pump the cuff up by hand and use a stethoscope
to detect the pressure. Paul managed to rig these cuffs
up to a machine and take automatic recordings. It was
almost perfect!
Patients were suddenly turning up in droves, either
arriving on their own or with the help of friends and relatives. The word had got out that not only was a hospital
open, but it was free of charge, as the Indonesian government had agreed to provide free health care to those people
affected by the tsunami. The government also agreed to
indemnify the hospital owner against any damage done
by the Australians while they were present. This had a
powerful effect on the attitude of the owner, who became
more relaxed about the team staying and working there.
UNICEF representatives arrived at Fakinah and asked
the team for some supplies to distribute. Anything was
better than nothing—could they spare something? The
team had been given tarpaulins, empty water containers
(collapsible jerry cans) and water purifying tablets for
distribution where needed. They were not part of the
medical cache, but were a gift of aid from the Australian
78
A New Year for All
people. These were gratefully received. Public Health
doctor Jeremy McAnulty went out with the UNICEF reps
to the IDP (Indigenous Displaced Persons) camps, to help.
The tarpaulins made great shelters and, if you ran out of
body bags, you could use these for that purpose too. There
was no road down to Meuloboh, so Jeremy and the
UNICEF men drove to the villages they could get to. There
was often nothing left standing, but from the rubble you
could see there had been dwellings. People were digging
graves everywhere you looked. They had set up makeshift
living arrangements, gravitating together into camps. Kids
were cheerily playing, able to laugh despite being surrounded by surreality and horror. Oxfam were conducting
Wat/San (water and sanitation) and health assessments.
At Fakinah, Adrian Humphrey was working in the
wards and in Emergency. As a Sydney paramedic he was
used to certain standards, but here the medical equipment
fell drastically short of what he was used to. For starters,
there were hardly any oxygen bottles. Shmackers’ words
rang in his head. You couldn’t dwell on the shortages or
you would go crazy. You had to get over it. Improvise.
The Bravo part of the CASTA team came back that afternoon after having operated at Kesdam all day. They were
satisfied with how everything had gone as they had
actually been allowed to be useful. There had been some
settling-in matters naturally, but progress had been made.
That evening the two SCAT paramedics, Adrian
Humphrey and Jeff Gilchrist, together with Mike Flynn
and three of the doctors—James Branley, Jeremy
McAnulty and Paul Van Buynder—all attended a meeting
at 5 p.m. in a building across and down the road from
79
ANGELS OF ACEH
Fakinah Hospital. It was at the International Organization
for Migration (IOM) headquarters (the IOM was established in 1951 to resettle European displaced persons,
refugees and migrants after World War II). The IOM
premises were being used for the first few days by the
United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), the United Nations (UN) itself
and the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) until the latter two moved further down
the road. The meeting was chaired by OCHA. The
meeting was going to be a daily event. The building was
well guarded and people needed permission to enter.
Security was tight for various reasons, such as the safeguarding of aid supplies and the awareness of the conflict
between the TNI and GAM. The main reason, though,
was that there was a lot of important work to be done and
organised, and interruptions would only stall everyone’s
efforts.
All the top representatives of the various aid agencies
that had now arrived—about 23 already—turned up for
this meeting. Charlie Higgins, the Bangladeshi head of
OCHA—who reminded Jeremy of Sir Richard Branson
with his British accent, beard and hairstyle—was in
charge. Resources and supplies allocated to Aceh had to be
organised and divvied up, so Aceh province was dissected
into about six zones.
News that the military was accumulating thousands of
bodies each day, which would soon become a public health
hazard if they were not buried or burnt, was tabled. The
aid workers who had scouted the area returned with
reports of shortages of transport and difficulties in getting
through on some roads due to the damage caused by the
tsunami. All issues were pressing, all were urgent.
80
A New Year for All
The pivotal problem reported by everyone at the
meeting was the need to establish a reliable water supply.
The water pipes had been damaged, limiting the water
supply, and the water had also been contaminated. The
Australian Army had a water purification plant which
could supply 20 000 litres per hour. However, to purify
that amount, you had to have an equal inflow of water.
The piping was broken, and hard to locate and isolate,
making the whole process tricky.
The next biggest problem was that although there was
six months’ supply of food available in Indonesia from
Indonesian government and overseas aid sources, it had to
be distributed to the needier areas and quickly. The whys
and wherefores were all to be monitored by the various aid
agencies who were spread around Aceh province.
The USS Abraham Lincoln, an aircraft carrier which was
essentially a floating city of between 5000 to 6000 personnel was moored off the coast. It was commanded by Rear
Admiral Doug Crowder, hosted seven different aircraft and
had previously been sent to Somalia, the Gulf and Iraq. The
Lincoln had just been to Hong Kong and was scheduled
to head to Korea when it was diverted to Banda Aceh to
provide assistance. The carrier had a hospital on board and
the facilities to provide enough power to run the equivalent
of 100 000 homes. It could process 400 gallons of seawater
into fresh water each day. When Cyclone Tracy occurred,
Australia’s aircraft carrier at the time, HMAS Melbourne,
plugged into the main electricity grid and powered the
blacked-out city. These were the peacetime uses to which
such ships could be put. The Lincoln was not required for
electricity generation on this occasion, but it provided a
vital platform to the fleet of helicopters for medevacs and
for aid deliveries of food, fresh water and medical supplies.
81
ANGELS OF ACEH
Two thousand of its sailors volunteered to pack aid
supplies, all day, each day, in the sun.
The local roads were initially impassable and most boats
were too damaged to be used. It was rumoured that more
than 150 bridges had been destroyed and the rebuilding of
them would be a huge project. The American helicopters
tirelessly searched the coast for injured people and each
helicopter journey would return to Banda Aceh airfield
with patients to be transported to one of the two functioning
local hospitals.
By the following Monday, the Australian Navy would be
contributing three more choppers to the operation, but the
American contribution was incalculable. They had twenty
helicopters fully laden, doing constant food and water drops
along the kilometres of obliterated coastline. Had they not
conducted these aid deliveries to many otherwise unreachable
areas, thousands would have died of starvation.
With no warning the power went out. It was 7 p.m. and
Annette was operating. The patient was a young woman
who was very ill. Her wounds were extremely infected and
she needed to have them debrided. This involved cutting
away infected flesh and flushing away pus (the rationale
being to not only halve infection but also to help healthy
tissue grow again). Annette was operating with Sudhakar
Rao. Ray Southon and Marj Raggett were the theatre
nurses, Brian Pezzutti and Paul were anaesthetising. It
was early days and everyone was still getting accustomed
to all the shortcomings of the situation.
The instruments were not the right ones, there was a lack
of sterile supplies such as dressings, the anaesthetic equipment for administering gases and drugs was non-existent,
82
A New Year for All
and there were no monitoring machines—the beeps and
screens with wiggly lines were just not happening here in
Banda Aceh. The list went on. Everything was being done
manually, and it was laborious and slow. Now, a power
failure. This they did not need. They all laughed when the
lights went out. It was so beyond what was desirable, there
was no other way of dealing with it. Humour was a mature
coping mechanism; they had all learned that, in their
medical studies and their journey of life. Suddenly, headlamps and torches appeared from everywhere. Ken
Harrison turned up wearing a headband with a light in it.
He put one on Annette so she could see into the wound she
and Sudhakar were working on. The fireys, Watto and
Bruce, rigged up portable arc lights (Goliath lights) to
enable the operation to continue in safety. By 8 p.m. the
operation was completed and the lighting returned in the
next half-hour.
As was becoming customary, there was a briefing from
Mike Flynn that night in the dormitory. The members of
the medical team traded information and updated each
other. The team’s mission was to establish a working
surgical set-up which could be taken over by an incoming
team. So far they were doing well. Jeff Gilchrist briefed
them all on earthquake preparedness—they each had to
have a pair of running shoes close at hand, and a bumbag
or small backpack to grab in an emergency, containing
their passports, underpants and a bottle of water. They
were reminded that the fireys had hung a rope ladder over
the balcony, in case of roof collapse or stairway blockage.
There was no respite from being on the alert.
The team crawled onto their stretchers at about 11 p.m.,
still cheery, still running on adrenaline. It was the end of
their second day in Banda Aceh.
83
chapter seven
On the Ground in Banda Aceh
The team woke at 6.30 a.m., ate breakfast on the narrow
balcony, then Alpha and Bravo would go to their posts at
Fakinah and Kesdam hospitals respectively. Although the
teams had combined into one team (CASTA), covering
two hospitals had led to the original Alpha team working at
Fakinah and some of Bravo going to Kesdam.
The balcony outside the team’s dormitory sleeping area
was about 1.5 metres wide and 12 metres long. It had
become a thoroughfare, a cooking area, an eating area, a
community area, and was even the lavatory, because the zipup, plastic-walled tent toilet was down one end of it. It was
not always pleasant eating next to a little tent that barely
contained the noise and smell of human bodily functions,
but there was nowhere else to sit.
Fakinah (sometimes referred as the ‘police hospital’ to
distinguish it from Kesdam, the ‘military hospital’) had a
courtyard in the middle. The balcony and their dormitories
were on the top (second) floor along the whole rear length
of the hospital, facing the courtyard. The theatres were on
84
On the Ground in Banda Aceh
the ground floor and diagonally opposite, at the front of
the hospital, next to the Emergency Department.
At the beginning or end of the day or during meal
breaks, the team would return to the balcony and sit on
grey-ridged plastic boxes, which their bony bottoms
became accustomed to. Chairs felt so smooth in comparison. They brushed their teeth and spat onto the grass from
that balcony, where there were no basins or mirrors. When
someone needed to pass by, everyone had to draw their
legs up to make room. When Scott Bevan from Channel
Nine interviewed Annette on the balcony, there was literally no room anywhere for the poor bloke operating the
boom mike, so he sat on the toilet. All 28 members of the
team lived in this zoo for the deployment, and not a cross
word passed between them. If you can imagine all the
rooms of your house condensed into one smallish balcony,
with 28 people milling around on it, during certain hours of
the day—sometimes at the crack of dawn or last thing at
night, when they were preparing for bed—then you would
have imagined exactly what everyday life was like on that
congested open-air balcony of Fakinah Hospital.
The nights were hot and humid. The team all slept on
narrow Army stretchers with mozzie nets draped over them.
Paul ended up sleeping in his underwear, flat on his back,
trying to keep cool. With Dr Jeremy McAnulty, director of
Communicable Diseases New South Wales Health, on one
side and Dr David Scott, Lismore anaesthetist, on the other.
Some of the luckier ones scored a spot under the windows.
There was not a breath of moving air elsewhere.
Paul and the team who worked in Fakinah’s theatre—
Annette, Sudhakar, Ray and Marj, and some of the
others—would usually sneak in late at night so as not to
disturb the sleepers and climb into bed quietly in the dark.
85
ANGELS OF ACEH
They were quiet, but the room was not. It was like entering
a cave of grizzly bears. Ray was a snorer, as was Sharwood.
Paul contributed to the cacophony too, once he was
heavily asleep. Soon Ray was banished, like a Big Brother
eviction, to the small room Watto, Bruce and Paul had
discovered during their expeditions. The tremors were
frightening enough without nasal reverberations that
reminded them of earthquakes.
Everyone periodically rifled through their bags, during
breaks, looking for their stuff. There were no drawers or
cupboards, nor a lot of room to move around either.
Shmackers kept good-naturedly scratching his head and
complaining he couldn’t find his travel clock. He knew he
had packed it. Everyone had something they either
couldn’t find, or that they would have packed if they had
had a second chance.
The team were learning about each other. Picking up
pretty quickly on who was a morning person, who was a
night one. Larks and owls. Every morning at breakfast
David Scott (Scotty) would breezily greet everyone, ‘Good
morning!’ The less bright-and-bushy-tailed would grunt,
stare back fuzzily or ignore him until they had woken up
properly.
All were snaky about an alarm which went off every
night, at about 2.30 a.m., waking them all for a bleary
moment. It came from somewhere distant, muffled and not
discernible, so nobody could turn the darn thing off. It
sounded every night for the entire deployment, much to
their bemused annoyance.
Sometimes the hauntingly beautiful strains of the
Muslim call to prayer would filter through, between 4 and
5 a.m. Sudhakar would stir sleepily. He would be fully
awake soon. He worked long hours, in that driven way
86
On the Ground in Banda Aceh
some surgeons have. He was gratified to find that his
anaesthetist Paul Dunkin was always ready to start early
each morning, and understood without having to be asked
that they were going to be working late.
Sometimes Sudhakar would open one eye and see that
Mike Flynn’s nearby stretcher was already empty. Their
indefatigable leader was usually on the phone to the waking
east coast of Australia—Canberra or Sydney, four hours
ahead of Banda Aceh time—getting instructions or advice,
providing feedback, giving details of requirements for this
team or the incoming one. ‘Send a fax outlining your
requests,’ Mike would often be told. Although he found
this very amusing, he was too polite to laugh. Paper, fax
machines and a reliable power source were not part of the
team’s Banda Aceh experience.
The team ate all their meals on the balcony and they
were always ratpacks, the Army slang for ration packs.
A typical evening meal might be the snootily named
‘mushroom risotto’, which was really just a fancy name
for salty mushroom-flavoured rice. Chicken teriyaki was
another. You added hot water directly to the food, or you
could pop it on top of the urn to warm it up. Noodles
featured more than any other dish, for the entire duration
of the mission.
On about day three, some evening meals appeared with
both French and English writing on the boxes. They were
chicken and vegetables with ‘poulet’ on the label. They
were Canadian. Paul stuck with sausage and baked beans,
at least they were identifiable. The fireys had loaded these
meals before the team left Sydney, keeping them back until
now for a change of flavour. The Canadian batch had a
chemical heating mechanism whereby you put water into
a sachet, then placed it next to the meal and left it for a few
87
ANGELS OF ACEH
minutes to warm the food. The always inventive fireys had
made contact with some of the sailors from the Lincoln and
eventually the Australians were swapping meals with the
Americans. Their meals were amazing—their meal bag for
a single meal was the same size as the Australian allowance
for a whole day. It even had chewing gum in it. Paul tried
a New York Steak. It was manufactured meat, but was
carefully coloured to look char-grilled. Paul told me it
tasted heavenly and that it was great to finally chew on
something. All the other food was soft and mushy like
nursing home food.
They had a close call with the drinking water one day
when the wrong type was put in the communal urn but
nobody drank it, luckily, before they realised. The reliability of their help depended on them all remaining in good
health and in good spirits.
A truck would arrive each day to take the Bravo part of the
team to Kesdam, as per the deal struck at the airfield on
day one. Bravo were very conscious that they could not go
back and forth on a whim between the two hospitals as
Kesdam was 5 kilometres away through militarily sensitive
territory and there was no easy way for people to return, as
there was no freely available transport, no shuttle bus.
Resources such as fuel were precious. They needed local
cash to buy anything, and they needed lots of it. If they
forgot something, they had to make do, to their initial great
consternation and eventual resignation.
Mike Flynn had bought some benzene (petrol) via a
local called Marthoenis, a young nursing student helping
at Fakinah. The Australians needed this fuel for the electricity generators which supplied the hospital with power
88
On the Ground in Banda Aceh
and a couple of transportable backup generators the
Australians had brought with them. The normal city power
grid was out due to the earthquake and tsunami. The team
had not been able to transport petrol on the aircraft due to
its high flammability. Through Sudhakar Rao, who was
happy to play interpreter, Mike asked Marthoenis whether
he would accept a reward, over and above the cost of the
fuel. Marthoenis was adamant that he would not take one
cent for the labour involved, even though the Australians
would have become involved in a major rigmarole if they
had tried to obtain it themselves. ‘I work for charity, for
the Red Cross,’ he said proudly. He set off on his scooter
and returned with jerry cans of benzene. The Acehnese
were showing themselves to be very likeable people, in
myriad ways.
Mike was dealing with many issues. Everything from
coordinating with aid agencies on the ground to liaising
with Indonesian and Australian authorities there and elsewhere. The early meetings with UN representatives and aid
agencies had resulted in the relief effort being divided into
various categories. Health was one category, hospitals
another. Health included public health concerns—everything from digging sufficient latrines at a camp to
vaccinating against measles outbreaks. Hospitals was
dealing with surgical matters, where people needed operations for wounds or fractures, or with very ill people who
were suffering from inhaled saltwater pneumonia (aspiration pneumonitis), tetanus and other illnesses. The
Emergency Department at Fakinah was treating the
injured, some of whom were admitted if they needed longer
or a higher level of care than could be given in Outpatients.
Mike had been put in charge of the hospitals category
for the overall relief effort. There were field hospitals
89
ANGELS OF ACEH
arriving from everywhere—Lithuania, Jordan, Germany,
France, Norway, Qatar, to name just a few places. Most
were tents, but a couple were what James Branley called
‘blow-up hospitals’, because they were inflatable.
One thing Mike was not having to deal with overly were
personnel issues. Although the team comprised essentially
a bunch of strangers who had come together under
extraordinary circumstances and were having their professional and personal patience strained daily, they all got on
remarkably well. They were all leaders in their own areas
at home and, with such a bunch of mavericks, it could have
gone either way. There were always some issues—they
wouldn’t have been human otherwise—but these were
never major nor obstructive. There were some tense
moments as a result of the pressure everyone was under,
but they were always able to joke about them afterwards.
Paul was forever tinkering, trying to repair things.
When they had arrived, there were two anaesthetic
machines, neither of which functioned at all. He toyed with
one broken one and got it to work. Desperate for another,
so they would have a working machine in each of the two
theatres, he tried to fix the second one. On one occasion,
Brian Pezzutti and Paul were fiddling with the second
machine and were carefully listening for escaping air as
they tried to locate a leak in the oxygen tubing. Every time
they got close, someone would cough, talk, move or rattle a
door. Nurses and various team members kept walking in
and out of the theatre. With each rattle of the door Brian
was becoming more and more irate. He finally snapped at
the miscreants, ‘Either stay in or get out!’
Surgeon Annette and theatre nurse Ray Southon began
tiptoeing around the theatre. Brian explained, ‘It’s important, it wastes precious oxygen. We have so little to start
90
On the Ground in Banda Aceh
with and we don’t want to leave a leaking hose for the next
person and endanger a life!’ He and Paul began afresh to
listen for the leak when Ray’s plastic apron inexplicably
crackled. Brian exploded, ‘Get OUT!!!!!’
Ray and Brian laughed about it together later. That
bloody crackly apron!
Meanwhile at Kesdam, the surgeons René Zellweger and
Peter Sharwood did hospital rounds and identified
patients needing surgery. They were often accompanied by
Wing Commander Greg Norman, who was working in the
Emergency Department with about five hard-working
ADF nurses and medics. The Australians did the day shift
at Kesdam, the Indonesian medical teams did the evenings.
They would then head back to Fakinah and join the rest
of the team, who worked late into the night. The Bravo
Team were working on different cases over at Kesdam and
under slightly different conditions too. It was a much
larger hospital than Fakinah, and attracted more serious
cases. At Kesdam, they were operating on two tables in one
large theatre, prepared by the theatre sisters, Rosie Clifton
and Rhonda Cowderoy, together with the paramedic
Adrian Humphrey. The three of them were doing their
best, but it was hard to achieve sanitary, let alone sterile,
conditions. There were no shelves to put equipment on so
they all had to work out of boxes. Surfaces were not sterile
so things could not be put down. The hospital drapes were
rinsed and re-used, literally after each operation. It stuck
in your craw but there were no other options. There was
no working steriliser, so they were using copious amounts
of alcohol to sterilise the few surgical instruments that
were available.
91
ANGELS OF ACEH
There was also a critical shortage of nurses for a
300-bed hospital. Where family members had survived,
they looked after patients as best they could, cleaning
and feeding them, interpreting for them, keeping them
company and trying to make them comfortable. The team
were deeply touched by what they saw.
Paul Luckin and David Scott were the anaesthetists for
Kesdam. Shmackers was the only doctor available to do
pre- and post-operative care of the patients. It was a formidable job. Pre-operative ranged from ensuring the
patient was briefed, fasted and physically collected for
surgery, to assisting with putting up drips for fluid and
drugs. Post-operative responsibilities included ensuring
the patient woke from the anaesthetic, was not haemorrhaging, and had responses such as pulse and blood
pressure in the safe and healthy ranges. The patient would
also have the opportunity to discuss any problems and
future care requirements. Once the patient recovered,
there was the handover to ward staff, the few that there
were. Shmackers’ role was a challenge—he was largely
doing all the surgical patients pre- and post-op on his own,
and the differing culture and language created their
own hurdles. But Shmackers somehow managed. He was
tender and caring too. It wasn’t unusual for him to gently
hold the hand of a patient or mop a clammy forehead, even
in all the mayhem.
The team at Kesdam had a busy day on 2 January. Busy,
and quite typical. There were a number of operations
performed—at least four cases involved major wound
debridements and there were another two patients each
having a leg amputated. The leg amputations were the most
demanding types of surgery as they required all the
physical and mental resources which could be mustered,
92
On the Ground in Banda Aceh
on the parts of all involved. They used more supplies than
any other procedures done at Kesdam, and carried a high
risk of infection, haemorrhage and death.
Adrian was the scout at Kesdam. The ‘gopher’. The one
who runs around doing things. He would open the dressings, pass the instruments. He enabled the nurses to
remain as sterile as possible. As a SCAT paramedic, his
work in theatre was completely different to his normal
duties, but he rose to the occasion. Once he came back to
Fakinah from Kesdam each afternoon, he would slip into
theatre there to help out. Annette let him assist in wound
debridements, to his great satisfaction. He was learning a
lot and was gratified by her confidence in him.
Adrian had had much the same SCAT training as Jeff
Gilchrist, and both were doing things on this deployment
which were above and beyond their normal frame of reference. But they were used to rising to the occasion. Adrian
had worked in the first-aid post at Denpasar airport, after
the Bali bombings, treating anyone who was heading
home. People mostly had burns from the intense heat and
fractures from leaping out of windows and over fences to
escape the fire. As well as injured Australians, there were
Norwegians, Danish, English and other tourists.
He had also worked at the Thredbo disaster, which had
become a matter of body retrieval rather than assisting
survivors. Stuart Diver was the only one found alive of those
caught in the massive mudslide, which brought thousands of
tonnes of dirt and debris down a slope at around midnight
one night in July 1997, crushing and suffocating those in
its path. Eighteen people were killed. The large number of
rescuers had been moving about on an unstable cliff-face in
sub-zero wintry weather conditions, making the search a
hazardous activity in itself, requiring the SCAT backup.
93
ANGELS OF ACEH
Adrian had done USAR (Urban Search and Rescue)
training which was all about finding and caring for patients
in urban disasters such as building collapses, as opposed to
natural setting disasters such as bushfires. He knew some
of the members of the CASTA team from exercises in the
past. He had become a Queen’s Scout in his youth, and at
one stage had been in the merchant navy, training to be a
captain. Adrian wore a beard, was fit and trim in physique
and had a typically warm, friendly Aussie face, which went
with his good nature—he was very much a ‘people person’.
Adrian was married to Kay and had three grown-up
children, two sons and a daughter.
He was now here in case the team members themselves
needed medical help, and he also was determined to help in
any capacity possible. And he did—at both hospitals. He
also was keeping a detailed log of the days in the disaster
zone, so that lessons could be learned to improve future
services and training. The team had been involved in
moving heavy boxes, in heat they were unaccustomed to;
the tremors were always a threat to their bodily safety and
overall they were eating, working and sleeping in quite
physically demanding circumstances.
The tally so far was within expectations. Nobody had
pulled a muscle or popped a disc in the unloading process,
but one or two had chafed their hands on the handles of
the heavy tents and a couple of the men had keeled over
from over-exertion; there had been the needlestick injury;
one stye (infected eye); a few with swollen under-arm
nodes and one had a swollen knee. But so far the team’s
health had been good. Adrian was conscious that not only
was the work demanding for the members of the team,
they were all working under intense media scrutiny also.
One day as he was in the middle of something he looked
94
On the Ground in Banda Aceh
up—straight into an ABC television camera. (Then he
recognised his friend Gustav behind the lens, back from a
war zone, and he relaxed.) Despite the challenges, the
team’s psychological health had been good too. Morale
was high and people were functioning at par. He and Jeff
Gilchrist were onto them all about keeping up their doxycycline and water intake, and also—most importantly—
their mental wellbeing.
The fireys helped out here, opening their cache again on
about day two or three (not too early), and bringing out
coloured cordial and lollies of all descriptions. Spearmint
leaves, chikkoes, minties, mentos, jelly babies. It was great
timing. Such a contrast to what they were immersed in.
Everyone got into them like excited children—there is
nothing like deprivation to make you appreciate the small
things in life. Little things become wonderful, when life
isn’t ‘laid on’ to excess. The secret to happiness surely lies
in there somewhere.
The wounds of the tsunami victims were telling a similar
story at both Fakinah and Kesdam. Rapidly moving,
broken pieces of wood and sheets of raggedy-edged corrugated steel had gored and sliced people indiscriminately as
they scrambled for their lives out of the swirling water.
Now they had festering wounds, thick with hot pus and
oozing black fluid (a mix of the noxious water, blood
and denaturing pus). Pus is simply white blood cells and
platelets; when freshly formed, it is a light, creamy-coloured
fluid which rushes to the site of a wound. When it becomes
infected—which can be quite a quick development, in a
matter of hours—it begins to become offensive. Smelly,
thick, greenish-yellow. As it ages, it becomes darker and
95
ANGELS OF ACEH
even more offensive in odour, texture and colour. Its colour
can become black, the colour of rot.
Some patients had been like this for days now. They were
suffering greatly. A mere infected fingernail is distractingly
painful. These poor people had red, inflamed, pus-ridden
infections in many parts of their bodies. The Acehnese word
for pain was sakit (pronounced ‘suhkeet’). It was a word the
team heard more often than they had hoped.
The team begrudged every day that they had not been
there sooner. They did realise now how unstable conditions had been at Banda Aceh in the first days and how
pointless it would have been to send in an ill-prepared, illstocked team. You never want to send liabilities into a
disaster zone, or create more casualties. As it was, they had
the bare minimum in stores and the aftershocks were still
nerve-wrackingly sizeable and frequent. They couldn’t
have regrets; they just had to do whatever they could, with
whomever was left.
There were no X-rays, but there were broken bones
aplenty. The team were devising ways of detecting the
nature and extent of injuries without any of the devices
they relied upon back in Australia. Obvious breaks were
easy. Especially if the skin had been broken and you could
see a bit of snapped-off and bloody bone sticking out.
Closed fractures were more difficult to detect. Sometimes
the weird angle of a limb was a giveaway or bruising and
swelling was another. Extreme pain when pressing the
area or moving the limb signified something was not right.
The injuries were anywhere—on arms, legs, heads,
trunks. Punctures, penetrations, perforations. Body cavities,
such as stomachs and lungs, had been punctured; sharp
wood and steel bits had penetrated muscles; bowels had
been perforated. One little boy needed a colostomy bag.
96
On the Ground in Banda Aceh
One patient had her forehead and half her nose sliced off;
she would need plastic surgery to have her face restored
but, for now, radical measures were taken to prevent brain
damage or death from infection.
Amputation decisions were being made, but never, ever
lightly. The realisation that radical medicine was called for
had dawned on the team quickly, as the infections were
too deep in many cases. The victims from the tsunami had
effectively self-triaged, creating a natural hierarchy of
urgency. The worst cases had died already, and the very
ill needed drastic responses to save their lives. It was gutwrenching for the team as they knew that life without a
limb for these patients meant hardship for life. There were
no physiotherapists, no occupational therapists, no wheelchairs, no crutches. The team had no knowledge of what
welfare services would be available. They didn’t want to
speculate. But allowing the severely infected, ischaemically gangrenous (lacking adequate blood supply) and
sometimes pulverised limb to remain would kill the
patient.
Some patients did not want to be less than whole. That
made them imperfect and they were concerned this would
deprive them of the chance to go to heaven. Paul remembered how a cat with no tail had fallen on him through the
hospital roof. Since then, the team had seen many such cats
and had asked about this phenomenon. Cats had their tails
docked to keep heaven from being over-run. Some of the
patients made the horrendously difficult decision to die
staying intact, rather than have the life-saving amputation
of a poisonous limb.
The medical care was the best it could be in the circumstances. There were no medical records for the patients, no
referral letter giving a background, no GPs to call. There
97
ANGELS OF ACEH
were no pathology test results to shed light on conditions, no
X-rays to examine, no ECGs. Any notes made, when paper
was found, were useless to the Australians if written in a
different language, and useless to the non-English speaking,
if written in anything other than Acehnese or Bahasa.
Peter Sharwood and René Zellweger were operating at
Kesdam with the barest of essentials. They were having to
work with what was professionally unacceptable at home.
No steriliser, precious few instruments, no blood supplies.
They were flying blind, making educated guesses.
The fireys had given them protective goggles, because
the sawing of the limbs caused blood to spray. Peter and
René did not have a heavy-duty saw for amputating and so
the job was harder. The two were using disposable scalpels
for surgery and whatever else they could find. He and René
had two gigli saws for the amputations, but only one set of
handles. When both tables were doing amputations, they
had to improvise with artery forceps as handles. A gigli saw
is like a pipe-cleaner. It has a fine pebbly edge to it—it is
like cutting through bone with very fine and spiky barbed
wire. It became so hot from the sawing back and forth that
it began to smoke and burn the bone. One of the team
would dribble water onto the saw, to cool it. The surgeons
worked themselves into a lather. A couple of times Peter
had to ask for his mask to be cut off, as it had filled with
sweat, and he could no longer breathe through the soup.
Peter did rustle up a proper amputation saw eventually.
It looked like a carpenter’s tenon saw, with a weight on it,
so he didn’t have to lean into it as he sawed. Doing a
below-knee amputation was tricky as it involved cutting
through two bones. In their situation you didn’t want
to cut more skin or have more blood loss than you could
help. They were avoiding above-knee amputations because
98
On the Ground in Banda Aceh
even though cutting through just one bone was easier, it
was high-risk because of the blood loss when you cut
through the large thigh muscles, which are richly supplied
with arteries.
The team had no blood to give their patients and the
tourniquets were woeful, just a bit of sucker tubing held
tight with a clamp. In Australia, when a tourniquet was
needed you had a pneumatic one which was pumped up to
hold the limb tightly, cutting off the blood supply when
you needed it stopped. They had no diathermy to cauterise
the wounds. By burning the ends of cut tissue, it not only
stops the bleeding but reduces the chance of infection. The
surgeons had to make do with stitching up the stumps and
leaving a bit open to allow them to drain.
It was difficult to take down a patient’s history, yet it
was never more important, because the treatments were
extreme. Sometimes an Indonesian doctor who was bilingual was able to help. The patients, if they were in good
enough condition to talk, generally could not speak more
than a few words of English and the team could not speak
Acehnese. Back at Fakinah, Paul was using a Bahasa word
he had learned when he had travelled to Indonesia. Bagus,
meaning ‘good’, became a word of common understanding.
Communicating, even simply, was a way of connecting to
the patients. Reach them. Ease fears. Confirm progress.
The international media drifted around the medical team,
covering both hospitals, capturing the many challenges.
Relaying what was unfolding, to a waiting world. A world
in shock.
99
ANGELS OF ACEH
Out at the Sultan Iskandar Muda airfield at Banda Aceh,
Bill Griggs had set up an Aero-Medical Evacuation (AME)
system. Some USS Lincoln doctors had come ashore.
American helicopters were bringing in badly injured
survivors of the tsunami and they were being triaged by the
USS Lincoln doctors at the airfield. The IOM had a triage
tent set up which could treat some patients urgently if
needed, as well as monitoring inbound patients due for
Fakinah or Kesdam. This was also a holding place while the
airlifting process got underway for the outbound patients
coming from the two hospitals. The airfield was a hubbub
of comings and goings, activity and aircraft noise. Despite
the commotion, Bill had a system functioning.
Bill was well-placed to perform this pivotal AME role.
He not only had experience professionally, he knew the
various parties who were involved in making it work. He
had arrived in Banda Aceh before anyone else and he knew
what was where and who was who. He was liaising not
only with IOM, but with the Americans, the Spanish and
the ADF. He knew the members of the CASTA team who
were working at the two hospitals. His work in the Gulf
War, Bougainville, Bali, East Timor—and countless other
missions—was going to serve him well now. He knew how
to get people working and how to keep the goal uppermost
in everyone’s minds. Phone contact was very unreliable,
especially in the early days, which added an extra layer
of difficulty, and the tents had only torchlight after dusk.
Language barriers made communication tedious, even
when there was an interpreter available. Timing was everything with severely wounded people. The task needed a fast
and good decision-maker. It needed Bill Griggs.
He met with the key people, including Mike Flynn and
a doctor from the USS Lincoln, Lieutenant Lisa Peterson.
100
On the Ground in Banda Aceh
He needed their cooperation to coordinate the transfer
of arriving patients to Fakinah and Kesdam for treatment.
‘When we triage,’ explained Griggs, ‘we only do treatment we have to do. If the patients don’t need treatment
immediately now or if it’s not simple stuff that’s needed, we
will send them on straight away.’ He also negotiated via
Lisa Peterson the acceptance of ADF casualties onboard
the USS Lincoln, if it became necessary.
Some critically ill patients could not stay at Fakinah or
Kesdam and needed to be transferred to Medan where they
could be transfused with blood, X-rayed, tested, splinted,
ventilated and monitored more closely. Medan had not
been affected by the tsunami, as it was an inland city, and it
had a number of comprehensive and fully-staffed hospitals
complete with all necessary supplies and equipment.
Patients earmarked in the two Banda Aceh hospitals as
suitable for AME were sent to the airfield for airlifting to
Medan, where Bill’s friend and colleague Allan MacKillop
was at the receiving end of the AME, co-ordinating the
ambulances and hospitals to receive the patients.
Bill Griggs was everywhere. He stayed at Fakinah one
night, where the team swapped mobile batteries with him
and he re-charged his own battery by getting some food and
rest. Sleeping out at the airfield was an exercise in futility.
He went to Kesdam the next day, assisting anaesthetist Paul
Luckin in theatre with a major above-knee amputation. He
then stayed overnight on the USS Lincoln.
He had so much to do that eating and sleeping had
become a low priority. His colleagues could see it in his face.
Here was someone who needed a long rest. He was on the
go constantly. Organising transport and aircraft, and
ensuring patients are moved, fed and medically stable is
a big job on its own when conditions are good and every
101
ANGELS OF ACEH
service is orderly and reliable. In a disaster zone, it becomes
a mammoth task. He had patients on stretchers being blown
about by the strong, blustery updraft of dozens of helicopters,
landing and taking off continually. The chaotic cacophony
of rotors and engines of choppers, Hercs and assorted
international aircraft only increased as the airfield became
more and more congested by the hour.
In the middle of it all was this one tireless man, the
Australian doctor Bill Griggs. To his credit, he was keeping
it all together.
Back at Fakinah, the life-saving operations continued.
There were no patient records. And no paper. Paul tore off
box flaps and wrote down his patients’ details in the operating list on them. Sudhakar had a paper towel list of his
surgical patients on the wall.
The insect problem was constant. Paul found a bug
zapper which looked like a squash racket and zapped
flies and mosquitoes whenever he could. One night a
mass of mozzies invaded the operating theatre through
the air-conditioning vent. The room was thick with them.
It was quite unpleasant—and risky. There were daily
reminders about the dangers of vector-borne diseases.
Some fogging (fine-mist spraying with pesticide) had
taken place in the hospital grounds, in an attempt to get
the numbers down.
Because patients were on the floor and the floor was
putrid, the fireys gave the nurses kneepads, which were
thick black-ridged rubber with a velcro fastening at the
back. They also gave all of the medical team fluoro-plastic
trousers to protect them from the squirting and splashing
of blood from the debridements and amputations, and any
102
On the Ground in Banda Aceh
other bodily fluids that came their way. This was not about
neatness, but practicalities. They had few clothes, and a
mere handful of disposable hospital gowns, and no
washing machines available.
The weather was sticky and you could feel trussed up
like a chook, but the options otherwise were worse. Ken
had had smelly pus drip on him already and it occurred to
him that you did not even want a tiny scratch in your skin
where it could enter. His shoes were going to be left
behind, no matter what. He would travel in others; some
souvenirs you did not want—the dangerous kind.
The fireys also stuck down illuminated tape everywhere
to make hospital areas safer. The hospital was dark and the
tiled floor moist and slippery. Some of the access routes
had low ceilings, which Paul and the taller ones, like Paul
Luckin and Jeff Gilchrist, had already discovered with an
abrupt smack to the middle of the forehead.
The stench was horrific, even through hospital masks.
Death, decay, rot. Blood, sweat, pus. Ray and Marj put
Vicks VapoRub inside their masks to make breathing
bearable. They knew it was horrible for the patients to
have their surrounds and own bodies reeking in this way,
and the team’s hearts went out to them.
Somehow they were all coping. And still smiling.
103
chapter eight
Improvising
The medical supplies were critically short but there was
one thing the Australian team would not compromise
on—pain relief. Especially during surgery. How it would
be achieved in Banda Aceh was necessarily different to
how it was achieved in Australia. In Australia, under
normal hospital conditions, the way to have a person
remain still, calm, unaware of being cut, and not in pain, is
to give them something which will paralyse them and
then, simultaneously, something to mask their pain. Make
the brain unaware of the trauma of the incisions, the
sawing, the removal of flesh, the flushing into the wound,
the stitching.
If you don’t get the mix right, the patient might be
paralysed, feel everything yet be unable to scream. Or they
might feel nothing but, if their muscles are not relaxed
enough, they will move involuntarily, responding reflexively
to touch. You don’t want that either.
Ideally, patients metabolise the drugs during the appropriate period of time. You don’t want them unconscious for
104
Improvising
weeks, just long enough for the surgery and a bit of
recovery time. Then they can have post-op pain relief at a
lesser level than anaesthesia.
Because they are usually in a deep stupor, if the drug
dosage is sufficient, they need help to breathe. This is why
you stick a tube down their throats—it’s called intubating
and has to be done early on, in case they vomit and block
their own airway. Too early and the gag reflex and
coughing make it difficult.
There’s a lot that can go wrong, but trained people can
carry out extensive repair work on a patient and rarely
does anything go wrong. The drug to paralyse and the
drug to take away awareness are mixed together. If the
patients are elderly, or if they are very young, or if they
have certain medications in their systems already, you have
to work out how to get it all together in a safe and effective
way. It is no good having one drug interact badly with
another, or zonking someone out to the point where their
heart stops beating. In a normal setting, in an Australian
hospital, a range of anaesthetics can be used safely. There
is the backup of staff, drugs and machines. This was not
the case in the disaster zone of Banda Aceh. The anaesthetic best suited was Ketamine. This is a dissociative drug.
It works by allowing the patient to enter a euphoric dream
state. There were many pluses, including the fact that the
recovery period was safer than other anaesthetic drugs,
which required constant observation by recovery nursing
staff due to the dangers of vomiting or blocked airways.
Ketamine or ‘Special K’ as they were calling it, suited the
medical team’s limited facilities, as they did not have the
luxury of post-op staff and there was a shortage of oxygen.
Patients on ketamine could be left unattended in the wards
quite safely.
105
ANGELS OF ACEH
It was a different experience for the surgeons. In
Australia, their patients were paralysed and so didn’t
move. If they moved in Australia while you were cutting,
you would stop immediately and alert the anaesthetist. Not
so in Banda Aceh. Ketamine removed pain, but did not
paralyse. These patients smiled and reached out to catch
imaginary butterflies, sometimes they sang or prayed to
Allah. Gasped at beautiful colours, smells and lights.
Ketamine could produce a bad trip though, as it could
cause flashbacks and nightmares. It was in the same class
of drug as LSD. Pharmacologically, the brain was separated from the body, so during surgery the body might feel
pain but the brain wouldn’t register it.
The people in Banda Aceh had been through the worst
of all nightmares. Despite the possibility of side-effects
such as frightening hallucinations, ketamine couldn’t bring
the patients experiences any worse than those they had
already undergone. Most times it brought respite from a
cruel reality.
Paul worked mostly with Sudhakar and Marj in theatre,
although he sometimes worked with Ray, with Annette and
as a joint anaesthetist with Brian. They had no monitoring
equipment so they were each other’s eyes and ears. Under
normal circumstances in Australia, they would be able to
monitor with an ECG: pulse rate and rhythm and any irregular electrical activity such as arrhythmia or heart attack.
They would have machines to monitor blood pressure,
temperature, oxygen saturation of the blood (measured
normally by a pulse oxymeter), and any anaesthetic gases
being delivered.
None of these were present in Banda Aceh.
106
Improvising
Paul finally had the two broken anaesthetic machines
working satisfactorily, in his final days in Banda Aceh. He
scrounged bits and pieces, made them fit. Even got some
spare parts from a drawer full of scraps at Kesdam. An
anaesthetic machine is a gas delivery system, which mixes
and regulates the flow of volatile anaesthetic gases. It also
absorbs carbon dioxide, and has a ventilator as well as a
monitoring ability.
If anaesthetics could be compared to aeroplane flying,
there is the ‘take-off’ phase of the anaesthetic (the
knock-out), the ‘cruising’ phase (operating), and the ‘final
landing’ (recovery). There is an outdated gas called
halothane which, while not quite as ancient as chloroform
or ether, is not normally used nowadays in Australia—
although sometimes because of its sweet smell it is still
used with children in the knock-out phase. Halothane was
one of the few anaesthetic gases available in Banda Aceh
and it was in short supply, so they used it for the more
serious surgery cases. Ketamine was not the best anaesthetic for people with lung problems such as pneumonia, as
it depressed breathing, so for those patients the team used
halothane gas.
To understand what the medical team’s working day in
Banda Aceh was like, you must first understand what an
operating theatre is like in a First World country, and one
not in the throes of a catastrophic disaster. A typical
theatre in Australia is well-lit, it is clean—the floors, walls,
surfaces and machines are spotless. Everything—from the
tubes and syringes to the masks and hats—are ‘single-use’,
which means they are disposable. The people in theatre are
an anaesthetist, surgeon, scrub sister and a nurse called a
scout. They all wear a disposable or sterilised material
gown, their shoes are covered in sterile, disposable covers.
107
ANGELS OF ACEH
Hair is covered with a theatre hat, the face is covered with
a mask. Their hands and forearms are washed according to
a protocol—three times with an anti-bacterial, disinfectant
washing solution. Then gloves are put on. Germs are
banished, summarily.
Supplies of dressings, sponges, clamps are opened and
the sterile contents removed with sterile forceps and placed
onto a sterile tray. The packets are discarded, their nonsterile covers not permitted to touch anything. A finely
calibrated, computerised autoclave is used, which boils the
instruments within an inch of their lives, using extremely
high-pressured steam. For some instruments, powerful
chemicals are also used, in a high-tech machine which does
it all automatically.
A scrub sister guards against anyone going near the
demilitarised zone of sterile instruments and equipment. If
anyone even looks like sneezing in the vicinity, the sister is
likely to scoop up the first set and will demand another,
freshly sterilised set. If anyone moves his or her mask to be
heard more clearly, or to scratch an itch, the sister will
swoop like Cerberus, the mythical three-headed dog who
guarded hell and missed nothing, and have the offender
replace the mask. The usual background sound in theatre,
apart from the beeping of anaesthetic and monitoring
machines, is the shuffling of feet in covered shoes.
Before anything happens, the surgical site on the patient
is shaved of any hair and cleaned. The surgeon will take a
sterile sponge with a sterile pair of forceps, dip it into
betadine, a powerful antiseptic, and paint the site he or she
plans to cut. If this is done prior to going into theatre, it is
covered with a sterile dressing which will sit there for hours,
killing every microbe in its radius. The patient will be
brought in by a hospital porter and moved onto crisp white,
108
Improvising
sterile sheets. If even a postage stamp of skin has been
unpainted, the surgeon will not proceed with the operation.
The painting procedure would have to be re-done.
The skin is the body’s greatest protection; it is the
immune system’s strongest defence against outside
bacteria and infection. Before making an incision, which
could give germs a chance to invade, this invasion is
prevented through ‘triple-draping’, where the patient
is draped from head to toe. The first drape is plastic, the
second is green sterile fabric, and the third is a drape with
a window cut in it to expose the area, then a stretchplastic ‘skin’, impregnated with iodine, is stuck over the
whole area. The surgeon cuts into this with the scalpel,
and the remaining area stays completely sealed. Protected.
Germ-free.
The scrub sister counts out onto the patient five muslin
sponges. They are thrown out afterwards. In some countries they are re-used after being washed in steam. The
sponges contain a radio-opaque thread so that if a sponge
is ever left inside a patient, the thread will show up on an
X-ray. The surgeon is responsible for keeping count of
these, but the nurse will advise if the count is correct or
incorrect before he or she leaves the theatre and unscrubs.
If the operation is very long, they may do a count halfway through. Everything is kept and counted. Needles,
sutures, sponges. It is like the aircraft parts in a hangar, the
maintainers must count everything. One unaccounted-for
spanner clanking loosely around a flying aircraft engine
could cause a catastrophe. If a sponge is discovered
missing at the count, rather than immediately cutting open
the patient again, the theatre staff will look everywhere
in the theatre—on the floor, under the clothing layers of
the staff—then they will X-ray the patient.
109
ANGELS OF ACEH
This is the regime in Australia. Those who cannot
maintain this standard become identified as having poor
sterile technique and are hounded out of a career in theatre.
In Banda Aceh, the operating team washed their hands
in washing water then, if they were lucky, in drinking
water, before squirting an alcohol liquid or a betadine
concentrate on their hands. Marj or Ray might douse each
other’s hands, then they would put their own gloves on
while their hands were still wet. They couldn’t wipe them
as there was nothing sterile to wipe them on.
Glove packaging was used for drapes. The sterile inside
wrapping layers were used and even the packets themselves
came in handy, placed sterile-side down. There were no
surgical gowns, but they at least had some shoe covers and
some hats. Paul wore the same one for the entire time he
was there. He couldn’t throw it out as there wasn’t another
one available.
They had an old-fashioned, boiling water steam steriliser on the floor outside the door. It was the equivalent of
boiling water in a kettle. It got things clean, and the longer
you boiled them, the cleaner they got. Obviously if there is
a shortage of instruments you cannot let them boil forever,
otherwise no operations would get done. You also had to
leave some out for a while to cool, to prevent the surgeon’s
hand from being scalded.
There were not enough sponges to do the five-sponge
routine. There was no X-ray to check if anything was left in
a patient. The theatre was badly lit. There was a mat at the
door for people to wipe their shoes on. As it became sodden
and filthy, they abandoned using it—it dirtied their shoes.
As a scrub sister, Marj worked very hard in Banda Aceh.
The conditions were totally different to what she was used
to. She normally worked in the operating suite of Westmead
110
Improvising
Hospital in Sydney. This was her first deployment and she
had been asked to go by her Assistant Director of Nursing.
While she naturally had some trepidation about what she
faced, she thought she could help the local people of an
affected region, which was why she agreed to go.
Marj liked how the team all mucked in and did what
was necessary. There was no demarcation according to
rank, station in life, or job description. If the task needed
doing and you were the closest and available, you did it. A
surgeon might grab a mop to clean the floor after finishing
on one patient and before the next one arrived in theatre.
She felt privileged to be with such people. She noticed the
media moving noiselessly around, performing their work
of reporting, and thought how fortunate it was for the
viewers back home that it was television, and not smellavision. She sometimes had to breathe through her mouth,
the air was so foetid.
Paul offered to help her sometimes. At the end of a long
day the theatre had to be cleaned thoroughly, and then set
up for work the next day. He noticed how late it had
become and how tired she was. Marj thanked him, but her
look said it all—the sooner you leave, the sooner I can get
on with it. He left.
Although she never uttered a word, Paul knew that
Marj had her patience tested one morning when she came
in and found the theatre dirty and in disarray after she had
stayed on late the night before, as usual expending her last
vestiges of energy swabbing it down and arranging the
instrument and dressing set-up. The Indonesian doctors
occasionally used the theatres overnight and vacated them
before the Australian team came in. She rationalised that
they would have been strapped for time and would have
struggled to leave it in any better state.
111
ANGELS OF ACEH
There were simply no spare personnel for all the tasks at
hand. Clean-up and repeat preparation was hard work,
pretty thankless, and you had to be your own motivational
coach at times like that. What Marj liked most of all was
the appreciation of the Acehnese patients. They had lost
so much, yet always smiled and showed wholehearted
gratitude for their care. Marj found it warming—and quite
humbling.
Marj used to come back to the women’s dormitory
tired and drawn and flop gratefully into bed. She had
previously noticed Karyn always had her mozzie net very
neat and taut and had asked her for her secret. A limp net
would sometimes sag and cover your face, and you would
wake suddenly, startled and gasping for breath. After
following Karyn’s instructions, Marj’s bed and net looked
pretty good too. But one night, when they all leapt up
because of a large aftershock, Marj hurtled straight into
her tight mozzie net. It trampolined her straight back
into her stretcher, to everyone’s vast amusement. It was a
great way to break the tension created by the alarming
tremors. The tremors threatened to pull the rug out from
under the team, both literally and figuratively. Their
morale and determination to overcome hurdles were
repeatedly pitted against these seriously undermining,
unnerving and recurring forces of nature. They had seen
first-hand the harm that nature could cause. It was not
encouraging.
The particular one, experienced overnight on 2/3 January,
was the third aftershock they had experienced since the
dangerously large one on New Year’s Day, which had
registered 6.7 on the Richter scale. This had followed one
the previous night (New Year’s Eve) at 5.8, which had sent
them fleeing out of their dormitory.
112
Improvising
During their time in Banda Aceh there were approximately
25 earthquakes which registered over 5.0, over the course
of nine days.
The quakes would creep up on them. Paul and the
others would hear a rumble like a peal of thunder. It would
grow louder and louder until it was too loud for them to
talk normally—they could no longer hear each other. The
building would start shaking violently; sometimes they
would hear a snap as a building seam wrenched apart. In
theatre, the drips shook and things fell over. Their feet
would shift from under them and they would lurch and
grab frantically at whatever was near which seemed
sturdy. They gasped out whatever invocations came to
mind. It was horrible. Nobody enjoys being terrified.
Jeff Gilchrist had the most bizarre response to them.
He seemed to see things happen in slow motion when he
was in near-death situations. It had happened to him a few
times previously in his life. Once, he had been in his car
turning a corner when he realised he was heading into an
inevitable smash with another vehicle. Everything had
slowed down in his mind, enabling him to bolt out of his
car (a Mazda RX3), run a distance and stand and watch
it happen. He had even turned the ignition off and taken
the key out. Witnesses were incredulous afterwards—they
couldn’t comprehend how he had had time to react,
because to them the speedy approach and loud impact had
happened in a split second.
Now here he was in Banda Aceh, seeing these aftershocks
in slow motion. He lay resting in his stretcher one time and
saw the tiles on the floor compress and crack, as though a
film was being shown, frame-by-frame. Microscopic shards
of white glazed ceramic floated up in a cloud, the particles all
moving in slow motion. Jeff leapt up and dashed to the
113
ANGELS OF ACEH
nearest door-frame. He figured that, although the building
might come down, the door-frame could hold up. You had
to believe it. It was too frightening otherwise.
The tremors brought them out in a cold sweat. You were
helpless. You were not in control. For people who were
normally in control, this was disconcerting in a big way.
Although no one died or was injured by these aftershocks,
there was always the fear lurking that a really big one
would come along or that the cumulative effect of these
smaller tremors on already weakened structures might
have some unexpectedly fatal results.
They were surrounded by death. Everywhere they
looked were reminders of their own mortality. They had
known that coming here would be risky, but they still
expected to return home alive to their waiting families
and friends.
At Kesdam, Adrian Humphrey was finding that he could
not put anything down without someone moving it. He
could never discover who did this or how to get the stuff
back. Drip stands, instruments, even the rubbish bin to put
the amputated stumps in, would be moved. There were
many people at Kesdam in addition to the medical team—
patients, relatives and milling world media. With the
language barriers, it was not always easy to discern people’s
roles and responsibilities. Predictably, the only thing that
failed to move quickly was the rubbish from the operating
theatres, all the swabs, dressings, paper towels and cloth
rags. They were all put in a plastic bag, which would sit for
up to twelve hours outside the theatre. As there were no
cleaners—they were either dead or looking for missing relatives—the medical team did most of their own cleaning up.
114
Improvising
One afternoon Adrian stopped and stared blankly at the
thirty or so body bags lying at the rear of the Kesdam
Hospital building in the car park. They contained patients
who had died. It was a sight he had never seen before. It
was a shocking sight. But as others in the team were also
finding in response to appalling scenes and happenings,
his brain adjusted and eventually such things seemed
normal—even acceptable.
115
chapter nine
Building Bridges
There were some cultural differences which confronted
the team early. They had to resolve them; they had a job
to do.
Nobody wants to be awake when a knife goes into
your skin. You don’t want to feel the needle stitching you
back up, either. This is one of the biggest fears of people
about to have surgery. They put such trust in the anaesthetist—if you have to be awake, you don’t want to feel
a thing.
So when Sudhakar came into theatre one day in tears
saying, ‘You have to do something, Paul,’ Paul leapt into
action. Sudhakar had just seen a child aged about nine,
having a wound stitched up by the Indonesian doctors,
without anaesthetic. Something had splintered inside the
normally mild-mannered Sudhakar and he had roared at
the nearest person in authority to ‘Stop it!’ Then he
realised it was an Indonesian policeman wearing a sidearm. ‘Stop it, PLEASE.’ Hot with angry tears, he ran out
of Emergency to find Paul.
116
Building Bridges
Sudhakar had been burnt as a child. He knew what pain
was about. He was also, by nature, kind and empathetic.
Paul could hear the child screaming in agony as he
approached the Emergency Department. It was the little
boy, valiantly fighting off six people who were all trying
to restrain him. Paul quickly approached and said, ‘Whoa,
whoa, let’s just hold on a tick. Give me two minutes. Please
give me two minutes.’ He had to be polite, but he was
determined to sort this out. Doing a quick calculation in
his head, using his knowledge of drugs and dosages (and
making his assessment of the child’s weight by comparing
his body size to that of his own son, Liam’s), he injected
into the boy’s arm a syringe of what seemed to be the
appropriate amount of ketamine.
At Paul’s behest Sudhakar had gone to get the oxyviva
(a self-inflating bag that sucks in room air instead of
bottled gas, then the doctor deflates it by squeezing it to
aerate the patient’s lungs), and a mask from theatre, in case
the child stopped breathing. Paul had never before given
ketamine into the muscle, only into veins. It works more
slowly in the muscle, but you can jab it in quicker, and if
the patient is thrashing about you will never manage to get
a cannula (tube) into a vein.
Gradually, the child calmed right down and entered a
dreamy, relaxed state. His eyes began to wander until he
had a thousand-mile stare as he entered the ‘space travel’
that ketamine is renowned for. His parents, who were
present and worked up into a terrible state, visibly relaxed
and burst into tears with relief. The mother touched Paul’s
arm and looked at him, murmuring her thanks. He said to
her again and again, ‘It is okay, it is okay.’
The Indonesian doctors went back to their task. Paul
left soon after, privately horrified that they were sewing up
117
ANGELS OF ACEH
a wound which should have been irrigated, dressed and left
to dry out and heal. Sewing it up would potentially trap pus
and create a hotbed of bacteria, encouraging infection to
spread into the flesh and then into the bones; it was a recipe
for gangrene. He felt complicit in the exercise of bad
medicine, because the child’s quietened state meant the
doctors could now close the festering wound.
The incident with the little boy was not the first, nor the
only, occasion when the Australians would hear agonising
screams coming from the Emergency Department. These
Indonesian doctors acted in a way which initially led the
Australians to believe that they thought pain was not unbearable or life-threatening, and therefore should be borne.
There were many reasons for the Indonesians’ different
approach to emergency health care. It could not simply be
dismissed as cruelty. Not at all. One of the Indonesian
doctors at one stage took Paul aside and politely explained,
‘We are a lot stronger than you are. Indonesians are
strong.’ Paul knew the man was right to an extent. The
patients he was seeing were incredibly resilient. The antibiotics worked so well because most had rarely, if ever,
been exposed to them. Up until now the Acehnese immune
systems had fought every bug on their own.
Because it was still early in the developing relationships between the Australian and Indonesian doctors Paul,
despite strong mixed emotions, felt compelled to keep the
peace and the communications open. It was all very tricky.
Paul usually had a vibrant nature, but he kept a quieter,
more laid-back profile in Banda Aceh. There was a lot
going on, and he was happy to let others verbalise, to let
others say the words that needed to be said, make the
complaints that needed to be made, bond with the patients
who needed it, cry the tears that needed to be shed. He
118
Building Bridges
kept his mind on what he thought had to be done by him.
His mantra was to keep a cool head and work very hard.
There was tension everywhere. Everyone was working
in a war zone, they were outsiders and there was danger
from a number of quarters. The team was constantly in the
company of armed personnel. Some people were affected
by the death which surrounded them and reacted in sometimes strange ways. Paul had already been briefed that
there was a heavily armed colonel over at Kesdam who had
gone completely mad. Paul learned very early that you
couldn’t assume that people and situations would be
normal or that reactions would be as they were at home.
Paul sensed a lot of emotion around him. It was
enveloping, but he didn’t want to be engulfed by it. He
mostly closed his ears to the sounds which came from the
Emergency Department and tried not to think about it too
deeply. He didn’t want to be judgemental. Everyone in the
team adopted his or her own personal strategy for psychological survival. At the same time, everyone looked out for
each other. If you looked like the situation was getting to
you, there was always someone who noticed and shared
the load. The team was very strong on support, kindness
and loyalty.
Infection sometimes compromises the effectiveness of
local anaesthetics, and drugs were in short supply. The
Indonesian doctors were not trained anaesthetists. But the
Australian team included highly trained anaesthetists and
specialist emergency physicians. They had had years of
cutting-edge learning, with access to the latest knowledge,
from the world’s best in these disciplines. If you did not
have such specialist training and you administered anaesthetic drugs or certain kinds of pain relief, there were real
dangers to the patient. If the anaesthetic or heavy pain
119
ANGELS OF ACEH
relief compromised the patient’s breathing, then there was
a risk of death.
The Australians recognised that tempers could become
rather raw when fatigue set in. They had to be careful. Build
a bridge, they reminded themselves. They had always known
that they would have to get used to other methods and differing cultural approaches; likewise, the Indonesians knew they
had to work with the Australians. Both sides knew there was
work to be done and they had to work side-by-side because
they needed each other. They had been trained differently
and viewed suffering differently. One side believed it had to
be avoided at all cost; the other saw it as an inevitable part of
life in a developing country, where expectations could not be
elevated unrealistically. Neither perspective was completely
right, neither was completely wrong.
In one view, not using anaesthesia as you hacked into
a patient was barbaric; in the other view, a doctor with
incredibly limited time and resources was attempting to
save a life at a time when there had been massive loss of
life. Each life saved was investment in the future of this
community, which had been ravaged and would need years
to restore itself.
Mike Flynn knew what was going on. He had made a
leadership decision to let the team work it out for themselves. Micro-management was not his method, and
throwing his weight around had never been his way. It
could have poured petrol on a volatile situation in any
event. He reasoned that it was far better to have smart
people deal with it in their own ways. He saved his advice
for the regular evening briefings, which were being held at
about 10 p.m. each night in the dormitory.
Mike had worked in different cultural situations many
times. He had served on Australian naval ships that had
120
Building Bridges
gone to Indonesian ports and cities such as Surabaya and
Denpasar, and he’d gone to Sabah, Sarawak, Malaysia
and Borneo. He had spent time on Indonesian ships in the
1990s. He had served in East Timor with Interfet as a
Naval medical physician and public health consultant in
2000. He spoke pidgin from his time in Papua New
Guinea. He had a heightened awareness of the varying
mores and idiosyncrasies of societies. Every nation had
them, including Australia. He had been involved in the
Bali effort behind-the-scenes when New South Wales
doctors were sent at short notice after the bombing; and
he had also been involved in medical supplies going to
Baghdad. Mike was the man of the moment; it somehow
just worked out that way. That was why he had been
chosen to head up this team, which was working in the
epicentre of the tsunami devastation.
Mike had even been in China when the Tiananmen
Square massacre occurred in July 1989. He just happened
to be the Naval medical officer at the Australian embassy in
Beijing at the time, and ended up helping with the casualties. The sensitivities had been incredible. Thousands of
students demonstrating against the communist government
regime. Armed tanks were sent into the square, and many
students killed. The stakes had been high, but he felt he
understood why it had ended up so tragically—issues had
been forced and ‘face’ had become paramount, even at the
cost of death. It had been a complex and highly charged
event, which gave him a lot to think about later.
There were ways and there were ways. While Mike did
not advocate peace at any price, or capitulation, he didn’t
plan to sail with a fixed rudder at ramming speed over the
top of obstacles either. He steered things gently from the
stern, tacking and jibing as required.
121
ANGELS OF ACEH
Differences surfaced from time to time, causing
challenges for the team. They were very conscious of
being there with permission. It was a privately owned
hospital and it was not their country. They did not want to
overstep their welcome.
By 2 January, the team were a couple of days into operating,
and were bemoaning the lack of surgical instruments. It was
becoming very frustrating. Annette was using a gynaecological ring curette to scrape away rotting flesh from wounds.
‘If only the instrument cabinet wasn’t locked,’ said Marj. ‘If
only we could get into it.’ There was a glass cabinet between
the theatres, but it was locked. It had glass shelves and
instruments on display, taunting them.
Paul observed, ‘There was a key in it earlier.’
‘Really?’exclaimed Annette. ‘Let’s get what we need!’
A young Indonesian doctor was working with them at
the time, he said nothing.
The team trooped out to look at the cabinet.
‘The key is gone!’ said Paul, puzzled.
The young Indonesian doctor quickly disappeared and
was seen talking to his superior. He returned with a key.
Marj took out as many instruments as she could and put
them in the steriliser. Things were looking up.
What the Australians did not appreciate at the time
was that they had effectively confronted the Indonesian
doctor about the key, and the obvious lack of sharing of
vital instruments. It had become a matter of face. The
refreshingly direct and typically Australian approach had
somehow backfired here. They got the surgical instruments,
but it had built up tension. They were soon to discover by
how much.
122
Building Bridges
Shortly after the key discovery, Annette was virtually
thrown out of the operating theatre. A young Indonesian
surgeon called Dr Panini1 seemed to regard her as a foreign
woman who was insolently masquerading as a surgeon.
Naturally, Annette was distraught and incredulous. Furthermore, she was being prevented from doing indispensable
work for what seemed like an insulting and ludicrous reason.
There was a natural attractiveness to Annette. Womanly
rather than girly, she stopped short of being blokey. She
had a short boyish cut to her ash-blonde hair, pale skin and
pink cheeks; she was of medium build and average height.
Not elfin, but rather, someone substantial and to be
reckoned with. She had an openness, an inclusive manner
which was very appealing. Annette had been wearing a
pink fluffy stole at Richmond when Paul met up with her. It
was more a token of her confident freedom and sense of
humour than of any extreme femininity or tizziness. She
wore pearls in theatre in Banda Aceh.
Annette was the only orthopaedic surgeon the team
at Fakinah had; the other orthopaedic surgeon, Peter
Sharwood, was over at Kesdam. Orthopaedics was about
mending broken bones. The tsunami had broken many
bones in many Acehnese bodies and these stoic people,
broken in body but not in spirit, were waiting to be fixed.
The Indonesian surgeon would not accept a woman
working in the capacity of surgeon. Unless perhaps
enough deference towards the men was shown. Humility.
If she could be slightly apologetic, then she might be
allowed to help—a little bit, but there were no guarantees.
Annette had started this particular day (‘knife to skin’, as
it is called) at 8 a.m., as was her usual practice. The anaesthetist had met and prepared the patient earlier. This
1
Name has been changed.
123
ANGELS OF ACEH
patient, a man in his fifties, had a tibial fracture that needed
setting in plaster. The Indonesian surgeon appeared and
said to Annette in English, ‘I am in charge of theatres
and you should not be in here operating.’
Startled, she replied, ‘We agreed yesterday on the ward
round that I could operate on this patient.’ Annette then
quickly thought she should offer solutions. ‘Perhaps we
could use the other theatre?’ she said.
‘My friend is using the other theatre,’ the surgeon
replied stiffly.
‘Well, maybe after him?’ she suggested.
‘No,’ he answered firmly.
Annette, realising she was not making any headway and
beginning to feel hurt, said indignantly, ‘Well, I guess we
will pack up our stuff and leave, if that suits better.’
‘No, we need your supplies and your nurses,’ he said
very quickly.
Further discussion did not resolve the impasse. Annette was
by now shedding tears of frustration. She left, heading for the
women’s sleeping area upstairs at the back of the hospital. As
she walked off, she was stopped by the son of the patient.
‘Aren’t you going to operate on my father?’ he asked,
concerned.
‘It was going to be me,’ Annette answered flatly.
‘I would like it to be you.’ He went into theatre as
Annette continued on her way, hearing him berate those
inside. The son had seen another, less invalided woman
patient with a small foot wound walk unaided into theatre
and take precedence over his father in the surgery list.
As fate would have it, a new team of Indonesian doctors
and nurses had arrived that day and were overlapping
with the original team. The new team observed this
encounter and its aftermath, and went to great efforts to be
124
Building Bridges
conciliatory. The working relationship with this second
team would prove very successful.
Annette was unusual, and not only in Indonesian
society. When she graduated as an orthopaedic surgeon in
1989, she and Linda Ferris (in South Australia) were the
only women specialist surgeons graduating in this field in
Australia. Annette now worked as a specialist in trauma
surgery at the Major Trauma Centre of the Alfred Hospital
in Melbourne.
A mother of three children, Annette was quite a remarkable person. What she had achieved in life was no accident.
She was no shrinking violet, but a natural leader and a
high achiever. She didn’t know how to be retiring or obsequious; it wasn’t part of her psyche. She took charge and
made decisions. The team admired her style. In the situation of urgency that confronted them in Aceh, she did ward
rounds and worked in theatre making major decisions
swiftly and accurately. She was matter-of-fact and friendly.
Each procedure she undertook was life-saving—this was
not elective surgery, and it was far from cosmetic.
Annette also had something which made her immeasurably valuable to the team.
She had worked in a tidal wave disaster before. It was
in Vanimo, Papua New Guinea, after the Aitape tsunami
in July 1998 killed over 2000 people and destroyed the
homes of almost 10 000. She not only had specific posttsunami surgery experience, she had seen what happened
if you left wounds unattended—people died.
Annette sat upstairs with a cup of coffee, writing up her
notes and telling herself to get over it. But in the scheme of
all that had happened in the tsunami, it seemed nothing
short of an iniquity. It was a waste of a life-saving skill
for what seemed petty, antiquated and ultimately debasing
125
ANGELS OF ACEH
views about the status of women. If a woman had brains
and certain gifts, wasn’t it wrong not to use these gifts to
help others?
Peter Sharwood had warned them all to tread carefully.
In the aftermath of the Bali disaster, Australians had
scooped up burns victims and bundled them out of Indonesia, post-haste. Time was critical. In retrospect, they
might have tried to make those remaining feel less
deserted, been more sensitive. Everyone was learning, but
life was often about resolving differences and learning
how to treat each other with respect, which was a two-way
street. You would never get it if you never gave it.
The Australian team had a couple of male nurses (Terry
Jongen and Ray Southon) and a female orthopaedic
surgeon (Annette). In one view, these professionals were a
celebration of overcoming pre-conceptions about what is
normal. Right now, she could easily have been with her
family—enjoying her Christmas holidays, perhaps sipping
piña coladas beside the pool at Jupiter’s Casino. If she had
been the type to go there. But she had chosen instead to
do something that was meaningful, and now her gesture
appeared futile. And the many needy patients had not had
a say in it. She wondered how the admonishment by the
patient’s son had been received.
On a more personal level, Annette missed her children,
Lachlan, Caitlin and Alys, and her partner for life, Simon.
The SMS messages from her family made her eyes prickle
and her throat constrict. ‘We miss you Mum, we love
you.’ She had kept that one in the message inbox of her
mobile, and looked at it now as she slowly bit her lip.
Sudhakar and Brian Pezzutti hit upon a plan.
Brian was not just your average rural hospital anaesthetist. He was a brigadier in the Army Reserve and had
126
Building Bridges
been everywhere. He was in the surgical team that went
into East Timor to serve the 11 000 Interfet troops, where
he was photographed with a smiling patient who was none
other than José Ramos-Horta, the Nobel Peace prizewinning leader of the East Timorese Independence
movement. In fact, Brian had served in East Timor on six
separate occasions, in Bougainville twice and once in
Rwanda. For fifteen years Brian had also been a member
of the New South Wales Upper House. He had always
kept his professional qualifications and skills up to date so
politics would not be the be-all and end-all. This had kept
him grounded. He had grown up in Lismore, New South
Wales, studied medicine at Sydney University and was an
anaesthetic specialist in private practice by the time he had
turned 29. He was the father of four young adult children
and was married to a doctor, his supportive wife Chris.
Part of Brian’s role was about helping the team push into
new frontiers. In the matter of Annette’s difficult situation,
Sudhakar knew what would work culturally and Brian’s
political nous now came in handy.
A case came into theatre a little later that day. It was
complicated. An Acehnese patient in his mid-thirties had
a hand injury, which looked like it had been caused by a
deep rope burn, and he had broken some fingers and his
thumb. He stood to lose the use of his hand. Sudhakar
became concerned as he watched Dr Panini try to reattach the man’s hand. The case was difficult and it
required an advanced skill level. He and Brian said they
could offer the services of a hand surgeon—a professor in
the field, in fact.
Sudhakar rang Annette. He described the case and his
concerns. Could she help? ‘I have told the Indonesian
surgeon that you are a professor of hand surgery,’ he said.
127
ANGELS OF ACEH
Annette, shaking her head and smiling, assured Sudhakar
that she would come to help. It was well within her abilities.
She left immediately for the theatre, the heavy weight
across her chest lifting as she walked.
Unbeknown to Annette, Liz Cloughessy had headed to
theatre and put it as straight as she could in her best head
nurse style: ‘Annette is here to operate. No Professor
Annette, no nurses.’ The surgeon saw her point, and
indicated he would cooperate; nurses were in desperately
short supply.
Brian Pezzutti, Ray Southon and Marj Raggett were
there, working alongside the Indonesian surgeon when
Annette re-appeared. Paul and Sudhakar were also assisting. Watching. Helping. They were all being careful, not
wanting to ‘push in’. It was all being handled gently,
carefully.
Annette walked into theatre. Hesitant, but determined.
Brian addressed her as ‘Professor’. The others took his cue.
Annette watched carefully, courteously asking questions
as Dr Panini showed her the problem. His eyes were
downcast as he agreed to her scrubbing up. Eventually he
handed the case over to her. Assisted her.
Brian had given the patient a brachial plexus block, an
injection of local anaesthetic in the bunch of nerves which
go from the neck to the arm. The patient was conscious
and could speak some English. Brian said he could stay
quiet if he wanted, he didn’t have to make conversation. ‘I
must pray to Allah,’ he told Brian. And he prayed out loud
in Acehnese throughout the operation.
The rope had cut the skin and muscles. It was like a loop
had been cut into his hand, from the ring finger down and
around the thumb and back up to the ring finger. He’d
broken three metacarpals, the long bones in the hand that
128
Building Bridges
have the fingers attached to them. The most important is
the one that has the thumb attached to it.
Annette wanted to drill a hole in each end of the
broken metacarpals and suture the bone ends together to
oppose them and allow healing. If they met up, they
would knit neatly. She tried to make a hole in the wrist
side of the bone with a heavy needle, but the bone was too
hard. She needed a proper surgical drill. Unfortunately,
there was no drill. This was not the time to dither or
lament the inadequacies of supplies. They simply could
not send this poor man away. It was, once again, time to
improvise. Paul got on the radio: ‘We need a useful man
in blue down here.’
Jeff Gilchrist appeared moments later, in his paramedics’
uniform, handing Marj his stainless steel Leatherman
pocketknife. Marj opened it up and threw it in the steam
steriliser. Among the collection of gizmos and widgets in it,
there was one called an awl, which could be used to make
holes. Normally used for wood or leather, Jeff had yet to
try it on bone. Annette found it worked perfectly. Jeff
always carried his pocketknife. It was a very useful tool to
have with you. He had used the pliers in it to extract teeth,
when he had worked in a tribal village in Papua New
Guinea, some years ago. The team’s rich backgrounds,
skills and habits were proving useful.
While Jeff was in theatre he couldn’t help noticing how
Paul had adjusted his theatre hat so he was wearing it
French beret style, and had adopted some accompanying
jaunty mannerisms, making the others laugh. It broke the
tension. Even Dr Panini joined in.
Panini questioned Annette as they worked, asking about
when she had graduated, and when she had finished her
orthopaedic training. He appeared satisfied that she could
129
ANGELS OF ACEH
well have gone on to be a professor. He appeared contrite
and they were able to work together quite congenially
and productively. She also let him know that she worked
at a major trauma centre in Australia. It was a long-ish
operation. As they worked together, mutual respect grew.
Dr Panini was young and very junior in experience, but
he was having a go. Annette’s brain was ticking over,
considering the whole scenario, but she shelved it for
later. He had obviously had to put his own feelings aside
too.
It was gratifying for Annette in the days that followed
to have some of the Indonesian staff come and apologise
for the earlier upset. What she was able to deduce was
that it wasn’t her, and it also wasn’t necessarily an
Indonesian problem. It was the actions of an individual,
and you get them everywhere on the planet. Annette
figured this surgeon might become more secure as he
matured. He departed on the Monday, and the team
began working until late at night, tip-toeing softly
through darkened corridors and along verandahs, taking
patients to surgery. The second Indonesian team clicked
with them from the beginning, so there were no longer
any issues about usage of the theatres.
Annette was concerned that her own professor would
get wind of her spruiking that she was a professor. As soon
as she could, she sent word through Louise, the trauma
program manager at the Alfred Hospital in Melbourne, to
tell him about it before he heard it on the news. Louise
must have relayed the message well because the amused
response was along the lines of ‘whatever it takes’. The
goal of saving lives and limbs was paramount; delicacies
were not. Annette had called Louise before, when she was
banished from theatre. These mobile calls to the outside
130
Building Bridges
world and the SMS messages were invaluable for morale.
Louise supported her through that difficult patch, when
Annette thought all was lost and her going to Banda Aceh
was pointless. They chatted. Louise told her she had found
some new weighing scales, well priced in the Harris Scarfe
sale. Comfort talk. Hearing Louise talk about shopping in
Melbourne reminded Annette that what she was involved
in was temporary, and to keep it in perspective.
The patient was later reviewed by the surgeon Peter
Sharwood, who actually did have considerable experience
in hand surgery, and the results were judged promising at
that stage.
These issues of contrary medical practice and equality
of gender, which could have made things unworkable
in Banda Aceh, were coped with and worked through.
The team members knew they simply had to build a bridge
and get over it. The theatre incident and Annette’s impressively deft use of the pocketknife in surgery was the topic
of discussion that night. A good surgeon could operate
with a knife and fork, they jested.
What the team would also discern is that some things
are human nature and nothing to do with race or culture.
You might find an intolerant or rude person in the most
enlightened of environments. Conversely, presentation
was not the definitive gauge of a person’s character.
Polished charm was no guarantee of goodness. A brusque
exterior often hid a genuine heart. There were also good
people to be found everywhere across the globe.
Brian Pezzutti was coming into his own, and there were
going to be many occasions in this deployment where
his political skills would come in handy. He was bringing people together, helping break down barriers, and
taking the younger practitioners under his wing. He was
131
ANGELS OF ACEH
helping them acclimatise to work in a disaster zone, with
all its shortcomings and stresses.
‘Have you thought of this?’ he would ask. ‘This was
tried in East Timor and it seemed to work.’ Always ready
with a laugh, always willing to listen and offer an idea if
the moment seemed right. Sudhakar Rao and Paul Dunkin
found his approach invaluable. After surgery, needing to
wind down, the three would often talk about life—or
anything other than what they were immersed in—on the
balcony, in the dark of the Aceh night.
132
chapter ten
The Bridge of Death:
a Bridge of Hope
Paul Dunkin was told he would be visiting town on
3 January. Mike Flynn thought it was important that
they all take a break, to have a change of scene and also
get some understanding of what they were in the middle
of. It was easy to become cocooned in theatre. If you
didn’t have respite you might either get cabin fever and
go crazy or, worse, start to become over-reliant on the
safety of your little sheltered world and become underconfident about ever leaving it. It was healthy to get out
and about.
Mike also wanted members of the team to understand
the patients they were treating. You had to know where
they came from, what they were talking about, what they
had been exposed to. Patient histories and doctor recommendations were going to make more sense if you had a
realistic impression of their lives. Even telling them to get a
prescription filled, get bed rest, take medication an hour
before food, change sterile dressings daily, take vitamins
and see the physio—all of which might be perfectly normal
133
ANGELS OF ACEH
doctor advice in Australia—would be meaningless right
here, right now.
Paul started the day at 4 a.m. He stole quietly out of the
dark room full of sleeping bodies. Steve Liebman was on
the line. It was a live cross for the Channel Nine Today
show. Steve started asking questions. Paul was boneweary and felt drugged. He had just woken up and it was
the first time he had really thought about anything he
was doing in Banda Aceh. He explained to Steve you just
do it. He hoped nobody noticed the catch in his voice. He
just wanted to be strong and give a lot of detail for those at
home who wanted to know what was happening.
Later that day, Paul was driven into town with some
of the Fakinah theatre team by Jackie, an Indonesian
medical student who had tried to outrun the tsunami and
ended up climbing onto a roof to avoid its onslaught. Brian
Pezzutti, Sudhakar Rao, Marj Raggett, Annette Holian
and Ray Southon accompanied Paul and Jackie. The
Ward and Emergency Department groups had already
been out on an earlier day, and the fireys had gone even
earlier.
Firey Bruce Cameron had taken photographs of sights
which were very disturbing. The worst scenes in anyone’s
lifetime, and something he could never forget. It was not
normal. Not even for a disaster. A vast wetland filled
with thousands upon thousands of splayed olivey-purple
bodies, beaten to a pulp, bloated, their clothes shredded
from them. The others who went later were spared some
of this blatant horror. The bodies remaining were more
hidden, discolouration disguising them in the rubble. It
was confronting nonetheless. Up close, individual patients’
injuries were easier to deal with, at least you could help.
Mass death and destruction were another thing altogether.
134
The Bridge of Death: a Bridge of Hope
The sights shocked Paul, even though a lot had obviously
been done in the last seven days to clean things up. There
was ruination wherever you looked. On the coast, where the
water had entered the land beyond the normal tide mark,
the trees and buildings had been mown down. It was a plain
of acres and acres of nothingness. It looked as though
someone had taken a giant whipper-snipper and cleared the
land, leaving everything flattened. Now and again a lone
tree still stood, its branches shorn off for the first few metres
from the ground up. In an expanse of wasteland a solitary
small building was still standing—one home, the only perpendicular structure. It was as though the all-powerful wave
had decided to spare it, for some inexplicable reason.
The coastal area was particularly glary. The absence
of trees caused a lack of shade. There was none of the
variegated light you normally take for granted.
Paul wandered as near to the shoreline as he could
safely get. There was a road, but they did not drive closer
as there was a lot of mud and swampland; it was not a safe
area. He found a little brass bell on a piece of twine in the
churned-up earth. Someone had worn it and cherished it—
you could tell by the careful double knot in the yellow
cord. It was just long enough to be worn around the neck.
It seemed there had been a kindergarten here, judging
from some broken concrete playground equipment and
patches of what appeared to be painted children’s games in
hopscotch-style patterns. But it had vanished.
It was eerily quiet on the deserted coast. No birds. No
children playing. The sounds of life were gone.
Jackie drove the group into town, where, in loud
contrast, noisy bulldozers were moving wreckage. There
were no delicate rescue operations for trapped survivors,
as there were none. There were just decomposing bodies
135
ANGELS OF ACEH
and mounds of wet, rotting rubble needing to be moved.
The mounds were all becoming the same dull prison-like
shade of grey and brown. Now and then lakes of water
could be seen next to buildings and roads, strange sights in
the cityscape. Beside the roads were piles of spiky pieces
of wood and metal, smashed chunks of concrete, brokenoff wooden posts, fencing, roofing, walls. Bravo team had
been to see the devastation a day or two earlier. They
had been given a tour by the doctor who was the bizarre
army officer in charge of Kesdam Hospital. He had pointed
out the gaol where all the prisoners, locked in their cells,
had drowned. Paul thought about this chilling account
as he looked across the devastation. The wave had been
15 metres high in places and had swept through the land
for some 7 kilometres. Paul pondered on these facts, putting
them into a home perspective as it occurred to him that if a
comparable earthquake had taken place a similar distance
off the coast of any of Australia’s coastal cities, an equivalent wall of water with the same force would have
demolished those densely populated cities and their beach
suburbs. He shivered involuntarily.
They had now arrived at the Baiturrahman Grand
Mosque, a mosque in the centre of town, which appeared
mostly untouched. Its forecourt had been cleared, but there
were signs it had recently been full of flotsam. The mosque
was a huge, solid building, very beautiful, with impressive
pillars and domes. It stood reassuringly substantial and blindingly white in the sun, a tribute to the faith of its creators. It
seemed to be a symbol of strength in these troubled and tragic
times. Paul thought that, for the sake of the local community,
it was a divine mercy that it had been preserved. Faith was
so important in times when a two-dimensional perception of
life held no answers, and gave no fortitude.
136
The Bridge of Death: a Bridge of Hope
The sombre tour continued. Paul noticed a very large,
heavy book which was full of writing in a foreign language.
It looked as though it was some sort of sacred text. It
appeared to have been saturated, thrown about, and was
mulched in parts. It was now mouldy, greying and driedout. The pages were ruined.
Everywhere else was still wet and stinking. Humid
wafts of mould and decay enveloped the group as they
viewed the scene. To minimise the stench, they all breathed
through their mouths sporadically and Brian smoked.
They saw many upturned cars, partly or wholly crushed,
dinged and dented beyond repair. People had been gored
and ground down by the deadly swirling sludge of sharp
metal, glass and broken wood. The wave of water had
quickly become thick with refuse it had collected as it
mowed down everything in its path and moved it all along
with the inexorable force of a mighty ocean current. Now
some of the bodies were still trapped beneath the debris.
Property of every description had been smashed and
crushed against other bits and pieces; it looked like it had
all been picked up and mulched into a series of garbage
tips. A rubbish dump sat incongruously in front of the
graphic-designer-decorated ‘Perdana Tour’ shopfront. A
gaily patterned blue awning, now ripped and tattered,
hung limply out the front of the damaged building. One of
many such buildings. Too many. Two giant fishing boats
sat inappropriately in front of the Suzuki car dealership.
Huge, uprooted trees with full branches sat festively next
to them. It was a world gone mad.
Paul wanted to restore order, to put it all back where it
was supposed to be. His head had started throbbing early
in the tour. After working and concentrating for days in a
dark theatre, he was like some nocturnal animal blinking
137
ANGELS OF ACEH
against the bright sunlight and frowning with the effort of
deflecting any emotional feelings.
Paul and the group reached the bridge in the middle of
the city.
A river wends its way through the heart of Banda Aceh.
Spanning it is one of the city’s main bridges, made of
concrete, which had clearly provided a buttress against the
force of the tsunami. The river’s great cargo of moving
wreckage had smashed to a grinding halt at this point.
Large fishing boats were concertinaed against the bridge,
together with bodies, planks of wood, walls of homes,
pieces of glass, cars and refuse of every description.
The boats had had their main trusses and supports
ripped from their anchoring hull planks. But the hulls
now provided a dramatically vivid visual juxtaposition of
bright, primary colours against the otherwise drab and
sorrowful scene. Reds and blues were splashed about
randomly in a brownish-grey palette. Paul saw a dove
strutting about on the ground near the bridge, eerily
clean and white, in stark contrast to the dirty disarray
behind it.
Signs of the lives once lived there, but now gone, were
everywhere. Mattresses, clothing. All interspersed with
strips of bent metal, bits of roof, fence palings, boxes,
sprung bed bases. The heavy concrete pillars of the bridge
were cracked and the railings were broken.
Some people, obviously locals, wore face masks and
picked their way in the steaming heat through the dangerously unstable piles around the bridge and along the banks
of the canal. They appeared to be looking for something.
Maybe for a relative, a friend, a neighbour, a workmate, a
child. Perhaps hoping to find some precious belongings.
It seemed a mind-numbingly hopeless task. There were
138
The Bridge of Death: a Bridge of Hope
thousands upon thousands of bodies in these piles of
dredged-up refuse, and it was difficult to distinguish the
bodies. The heat had accelerated the decomposition, and
the bruising and wounds had made the skin of the dead
appear unnaturally dark.
Paul saw photographs sticky-taped to doors and street
poles and fences. Notes on them asked for any details of
missing loved ones. There were rumours that one in every
two people here had been killed, that half of Banda Aceh
had died.
Every now and then on this grisly tour, Paul spotted
something which his mind quickly catalogued as innocuous
before it could create psychological pain, before it made him
dissolve inside—a child’s tricycle, bent and rusting now, a
mangled toy, occasionally something intimately personal,
like a shirt or a family photo album.
A couple of trucks were being steadily uncovered in one
of the streets. One of the streams of rubbish had reached
the obstacle created by these trucks and had quickly
formed massive piles around it. It was now a deadly,
putrid, papier-mâché fortress. A few odd shoes sculled
around on top, signalling that life had once existed here,
where now there were only death mounds.
There were few animals around, apart from a few cats
with no tails, the occasional gecko and the odd cow
roaming through rubbish near the hospital. Paul noticed a
starving dog. Its owner gone, the dog was foraging for
itself. It joined a couple of other dogs feeding greedily on
something in the rubble. Paul knew what the dogs were
doing. They had found a corpse. This was too gruesome to
acknowledge, let alone watch.
Paul returned to the bridge, the scene of greatest
destruction in Banda Aceh. It was being called the Bridge
139
ANGELS OF ACEH
of Death. He noticed something nearby which made him
catch his breath. In a pile of heavy beams, branches, strips
of galvanised iron, his eye picked out a hand. It was
reaching out, its fingers ever so slightly upturned. He was
shocked. His brain knew instantly its owner was beyond
rescue. The hand was unmistakably decaying, it was
attached to an arm that was greyish-yellow and purple
with injury in places. He turned away, but changed his
mind, deciding to capture its image with his camera. When
the Emergency Department group had returned from their
earlier tour of Banda Aceh, James Branley had tried to
explain the inexplicable with the phrase ‘such a mass of
crushed humanity’, which had stuck in Paul’s memory. It
was what this disembodied hand now represented for him.
It seemed as though its supplicant gesture acknowledged
the help he had come all this way to give. To Paul, the hand
was a symbol of hope. He would not have been there to
photograph it if he and others had not come to Banda Aceh
to help. Australia and other countries, upon whom the
future of this place would rely for rebuilding, would never
know the extent of the damage and what was needed
unless images were captured and relayed to the outside
world.
He was here, as were the others, to help build a bridge.
After taking the photograph, Paul went back to Jackie,
their waiting driver. He and the others piled back into the
car. Paul asked Jackie to pull over so he could buy them all
some soft drinks at a roadside shop. Thin Indonesian cans
of Coke and Sprite, slightly warm but a welcome change
from urn coffee and bottled water. The sugar and caffeine
seemed to help cure his pounding headache.
They were all quiet as they returned to Fakinah
Hospital. Paul felt the weight of it too. Sadness.
140
The Bridge of Death: a Bridge of Hope
The scenes in theatre seemed so safe and familiar now,
even as dire and gory as they were. He was accustomed to
them. They were not as troubling as the scenes in Banda
Aceh.
141
chapter eleven
Support at Home
I put baby Pierce down, raced into the back room, took the
videotape out of the machine and pushed a blank one in.
Toddler Francis immediately started protesting, crying for
‘Doo doo’. He wanted Thomas the Tank Engine back on.
I SMSed this rather amusing fact (under the circumstances)
to Paul. I had warned young Francis that we needed to
tape Daddy on TV. It fell on deaf ears. Francis cried
throughout the broadcast. I kept turning up the volume
louder and louder so I could hear Paul. I hung on his every
word. I didn’t know what I would do if he didn’t make
it back. I stopped myself mid-thought; I could never let
myself think that far.
Paul was technically in a war zone and, although hostilities between the GAM and TNI had officially been halted,
a few gunshot deaths had been reported in Aceh province.
The medical team was very conscious of the dangers and
sensitivities. The police who ran Fakinah and milled around
the team as they worked were heavily armed. There were
earthquakes every day. Disease was now considered the
142
Support at Home
biggest threat to life. The team was too busy to focus on all
this, they were just getting on with the job.
The death toll across all the tsunami-affected countries
was now 130 000, with twelve Australians confirmed dead.
Many bodies had been washed out to sea and the final figures
would never be known. From what I could gather from news
reports and Paul’s phone calls, the team were surrounded by
more death than they would see in their whole lifetime, and a
succession of patients with the most hideous injuries they had
ever seen. There was sometimes pain which even their efforts
could not remove. Dead brothers and sisters, children,
mothers and fathers. The team was saturated in the sadness,
but they could not allow themselves to give in to it. I thought
Paul must be feeling pretty overwhelmed, deep down, and
I wished I could physically put my arms around him, to hold
him and comfort him.
Steve Liebman asked Paul whether anything could have
prepared him for this. The interview was a live voiceover,
but the footage shown was pre-recorded—people lying in
hospital corridors, children with amputated limbs, hungry
people reaching out their hands as they were thrown boxes
of food from American helicopters. A 360-degree view of
flattened homes. Rubble, body bags. Paul replied with an
almost imperceptible quaver in his voice, ‘Nothing could,
Steve . . . and nothing should. We just get in and do our
job. We’re taking each step as it comes, each new patient
who arrives. You can’t stop. You can’t think. When we get
home we’ll do that.’
I wondered whether any of the viewers would be able to
tell that his voice was thick with emotion. Maybe it was
just me because I knew him so well.
In this interview, Paul provided a great deal of information. He was asked about many things, including the children.
143
ANGELS OF ACEH
I knew from a conversation with him that many children
had not survived, that the elderly had fared badly too. The
children did not make up the biggest group of patients and
there was a reason for that. Most had died when the wave
swept through. The little ones had had no chance.
Those who had survived and were at the hospital were
asking: Why? They told Paul they had been in a war and now
this. Why? It was a good question. One to break your heart.
There had been just over twenty primary schools in
Banda Aceh prior to the tsunami. Paul later found out that
the surviving children only filled one school.
One of my brothers SMSed. He had seen the interview
and was very proud Paul was there. My brother had been
a fighter pilot and he had been on many deployments in his
own military service. He understood what separation from
family was like and the effect unfamiliar circumstances and
unusual threats could have on your emotional state—how
you had to hold it together, compartmentalise. My brother
was a brave man, and he knew how much the love and
support you had behind you mattered. It cheered me up
to have him make contact. My mobile beeped again. It
was my friend Julie and her son, Jai. Another SMS
message, and another, then the email inbox started to fill,
all day. Paul’s best man, Paul Ryan, emailed me from the
United Kingdom. ‘Pat and I are honoured to know him.
No doubt the events will have had some effect on him, but
he is made of pretty stern stuff. He is very lucky to be able
to come back to a stable and loving family. The boys will be
just the tonic he needs.’
My friend Lisa Hill also reassured me with: ‘Hope that
you are not too worried about Paul. As you know, he is
144
Support at Home
extremely capable and sensible. He is the perfect person for
the task at hand, if there can be such a person. Please let me
know if I can do anything for you.’ She then outlined plans
to take two of my sons, Liam and Darcy, to the zoo.
The phone began to ring. My friend Kate made contact
with me every day Paul was away. People came to help.
Within an hour of the interview being shown, my brotherin-law, Ross, was on the doorstep to take the two older
boys to play and have a sleep-over with their cousins.
Nanna collected Francis for the day. The Disaster Control
Centre rang. They would return Paul’s car for him from
Richmond and did I need anything?
I put together an electronic email address list and called
it my ‘Paul Update Group’, and began typing. I kept the
television in the lounge room on all day and all night,
muted, I did not want to miss one report. Anything that
looked like a tsunami report caused me to drop everything
and put a videotape in. I didn’t have time to watch—the
activities and needs of our four active little boys ruled that
out—but I hoped I might get a chance one day to watch
the tapes, perhaps after Paul returned home.
The children were no longer thrilled when Daddy was
on TV. The promotions for the news programs often
showed snippets of the Australian medical team at work
and Paul was shown many times. Francis didn’t seem to
make the connection and Darcy started kicking the wall.
Children, even if they can talk, cannot always verbalise
their concerns, so they manifest them in other ways. Liam
sometimes couldn’t sleep and would come and sit with me.
We would sip hot green tea together and chat as I cleaned
up or gave Pierce his night breastfeed.
Liam said to me one evening, ‘If my dad dies, he will
be a saint, as he will have given up his life for others.’
145
ANGELS OF ACEH
Dismayed, I realised Liam had been carrying a lot of worry
around with him and had been too thoughtful to dump it
on me. I hugged him and reassured him that his dad was
safe. I hoped he was, I couldn’t think otherwise. This
was my private prayer that played non-stop in my head.
Paul called home one time and Liam answered the
phone. After a while, Liam asked, ‘Did you get me a
souvenir, Dad?’ It was revealing that, even with the television footage of demolished Banda Aceh, he thought there
were souvenir shops still standing, doing a roaring trade.
Children are resilient, sometimes simply because they do
not grasp the depth of the horror.
The news that night reported that a charity cricket
match was being planned. Shane Warne was promoting it
in various ad breaks and Steve Waugh was being asked to
play. In his typically self-deprecating manner, the former
captain indicated to the media that he thought that nobody
wanted a ‘has been’ wheeled out. ‘Oh yes, they do,’ I
thought. Like many Australians, I am a bit of a longstanding Steve Waugh fan. There was talk of a rock concert to
raise money.
My friend Stu Lloyd emailed. He was involved with a
charity fundraising event at West Pymble Bowling Club,
planned for 16 January. The news was full of similar events
taking place all over Australia, in every club, in every
pub—picnics, dances, barbecues, door-knocks, raffles.
Every pharmacy, newsagent, bakery, general store and gift
shop had a tub on the counter with a little ‘For the Tsunami
Victims’ notice. Church plates were filling. Famous figures
were pledging sums. Australian entrepreneur Dick Smith
and his wife gave $1 million. World Champion Formula
One racing car driver Michael Shumacher reportedly gave
$US10 million. Someone else gave a small fortune too. And
146
Support at Home
people who did not have very much were giving what they
could. One story told was that one of the men’s prisons
passed a hat around.
The mind-numbingly huge extent of this tragedy was
triggering just as momentous compassionate action. It was a
wave of its own, and it was sweeping through everywhere.
147
chapter twelve
Reaching Out—Sigli
Sometimes, the moment you think you cannot do more
than you are doing, you are asked to do just that. The
medical team had become very close. Those who went to
Kesdam returned each day to Fakinah, where they
shared stories and dramas, ate and slept alongside each
other. They were like a tight-knit family. They cried
sometimes, when the death and the stench and the revolting injuries became too much. The stories of the patients
were affecting them. The team always hugged each other
and affirmed that each person was doing a good job. They
had to keep going.
A strange thing happens to time when you are working
in a disaster zone. It is compressed, at the same time as it is
elongated. A day becomes a lifetime. You experience a
range of emotions, and work at a rate that is far more
intense than at home. All your senses are heightened and
time seems like a hyper-reality. This physical response is
not sustainable in the long-term, of course, or you would
simply burn out. It is especially concentrated if you are
148
Reaching Out—Sigli
present in the more acute stages of the disaster. ‘Get in
early and get out early’ was the advice of those with
experience of working during times of intense crisis.
It was 4 January and the team felt as though they had
been in Banda Aceh for months and as though they knew
each other deeply. Even though they were doing a succession of patient cases back-to-back, they all felt that they
should be doing more—that what they were doing was
somehow not enough. It was strange, but their reactions
were perfectly normal. It is a phenomenon experienced by
many who have worked in mammoth tragedies. And this
tsunami was the most monstrous of them all.
Paul and the others were talking one day as they
worked about how they were hearing from home that
some people in Australia were even re-evaluating what
they did for a living since the tsunami. This was how
strongly they supported what was being done in Banda
Aceh and elsewhere. It made the team feel better, knowing
that what they were doing was considered so worthwhile
that people would question their own life occupations.
Sometimes the team thought what they were doing was a
drop in the ocean—there was just so much work to be
done, such a relentless stream of sick and injured people,
and there were always more. The flow never abated. What
they did not know was the impact the media images of
their work effort was having in Australia and in the rest
of the world. This by itself would prove vindication of their
presence there.
Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF) asked the team if
someone could be spared to go to Sigli General District
Hospital, as the surgical ward was overflowing with cases.
The local surgeons were missing, all believed to be with
their stricken families.
149
ANGELS OF ACEH
The team did not necessarily want anyone to go
anywhere. There were hundreds of needy people presenting at Fakinah and Kesdam every day, but Brian Pezzutti
thought the team members could extend themselves. The
head of MSF worldwide was a young Australian plastic
surgeon, Rowan Gillies, who had been a registrar at
Lismore Hospital where Brian was an anaesthetist. They
had worked together and, feeling that he didn’t want to
let anyone down, Brian spoke to Mike Flynn. Brian’s
attitude was, ‘No worries, can do. Let’s find a way.’ He was
always upbeat, positive and never shied away from the
next challenge.
MSF had been set up in 1971 by some French doctors
who had worked with famine victims. The doctors had
worked for the Red Cross during the Biafra war in Africa
and were frustrated by the bureaucracy they encountered,
and outraged by the degree of government interference in
the delivery of aid and relief services. They decided to form
a lean and independent group, which would be unhampered
by red tape and all the administration which sometimes
accompanied the bloated organisations. They often did not
accept funding from governments (depending upon the
crisis)—only private donors, to keep themselves free from
political influence. In 1999 they had received the Nobel
Peace Prize for their ability to work so effectively, and
without politics. They were now helping out in Banda Aceh
at the northern tip of Sumatra, at Sigli on the east coast, and
Lamno and Meulaboh on the west coast. MSF were waiting
on a surgical team to arrive from Belgium. Their nurses
were already helping out in the wards, but they needed a
fill-in surgeon and anaesthetist in the meantime.
Mike Flynn was conscious that the safety of the team
was in his hands. He couldn’t guarantee anyone’s safety
150
Reaching Out—Sigli
anywhere, and going to Sigli would put them at risk. It was
about 200 kilometres away from Banda Aceh. Some of the
roads had been opened along the coast but were still not in
the best condition and were putting pressure on the inland
roads. Many bridges had collapsed also. Adding to the
impact of the physical devastation was the ongoing
political turmoil. Aceh province had been in a state of
emergency since mid-1993, with nobody allowed in or out
without permission. There was presently an unofficial
ceasefire between the TNI and GAM but there were still
pockets of fighting, resulting in deaths since the tsunami.
Mike did not want any international issues or incidents, his
mission was to be a constructive one. Danger was to be
given a wide berth. There would be no avoidable deaths
in the team. Nobody would be shot at—he couldn’t live
with that.
Once again, the team was enriched by the resources
within its ranks. Paul Van Buynder had links to MSF,
partly because he had been born in Belgium and spoke
French, and partly because he had been dealing with them
already since arriving in Banda Aceh. He had been going
to the 5 p.m. meetings across the road from Fakinah at
the UN/USAID headquarters with a couple of the other
CASTA physicians—Jeremy McAnulty and James Branley.
These had quickly become regular meetings with nongovernment organisations (NGOs) in the area. There were
two dozen agencies represented in these early days but
there was little feuding about who was going to do what,
probably because there was so much work to be done. The
agencies included Oxfam, CARE, Red Cross and Red
Crescent, Médecins Sans Frontières, UNICEF, Save The
Children, the Jesuit Refugee Service, Caritas, Catholic
Relief Services and many, many more.
151
ANGELS OF ACEH
Paul Van Buynder used to talk to MSF about what
was happening at these gatherings because they were too
engaged to go themselves. OCHA needed to know what
MSF’s plans were for surveillance for disease outbreaks
and other activities which might have an impact on aid
work, or their plans for first-line malaria treatment and
Paul would feed MSF’s plans back to these meetings.
There were a few diseases around which needed to be
pounced on, before they became a major problem.
MSF wanted the option of using the Australian team as a
personnel safety net. If their staff became ill they wanted to
be able to ask the team to fill in for them. They thought
Fakinah Hospital could be a useful fall-back receiving
station for evacuations of patients they couldn’t deal with
‘out bush’. The CASTA team also had invaluable supplies,
which MSF could take out to their remote clinics in Aceh
province where there was no protection against certain
diseases. For example, the team had tetanus toxoid and
tetanus immunoglobulin for warding off tetanus.
Paul Van Buynder was the priceless intermediary
between CASTA and MSF. When Mike Flynn finally agreed
that three of the team could spend some time at Sigli, Paul
Van Buynder stepped into the breach and started working
in theatre at Fakinah. Paul was the principal medical consultant in the Office of Chief Medical Adviser, Western
Australia. He was the head of the emergency response
section of public health in that state. Despite his position, he
was very down to earth. With his sparkly eyes, cheeky moustache, reddish-tinged unruly short hair, he had a face you
instantly liked and felt comfortable with. A genuine Aussie
man—roguish, intelligent. Married to Jan. He was a fearless
Carlton supporter and, no matter where he lived, would fly
to Melbourne for key games. He was yet another Paul on
152
Reaching Out—Sigli
the team. (Out of 21 men, four were called Paul. Brian
Pezzutti said it was easy in the early days when the team
members were still getting to know each other—whenever
he was in doubt about a name, he just called the bloke
‘Paul’.) Paul Van Buynder was kind-hearted and mindful of
the team’s good health. He brought them eggs, bananas and
mandarins. Paul Dunkin put his hard-boiled egg in with his
noodles, making them taste like real food. Fantastic.
Paul Van Buynder’s years of research and experience
working with under-resourced Aboriginal communities in
the remote Australian outback were going to serve him well
in Banda Aceh. He had worked in clinics in outstations and
Aboriginal settlements in Western Australia, Northern
Territory and Queensland, including the Torres Straits. He
had given anaesthetics and done every type of operation—
from caesarean deliveries to vasectomies. You became an
expert in everything, by necessity, when you worked in
isolated communities. He was also an officer in the Army
Reserve. In his public health role he had reviewed issues
for the government such as the health response to the
World Trade Center bombing, and the anthrax release in
the USA. His varied background and wealth of experiences
equipped him with skills which were very helpful in the
Banda Aceh setting.
As he was fluent in French but normally spoke with a
broad Aussie accent, he entertained Sudhakar and the
surgical people in the team hugely with his French impersonations. ‘Pardon,’ he would say throatily, as he moved
elegantly past someone in theatre. He might have been
officially a public health doctor, but he really rose to the
occasion in theatre. Once again, the team members showed
that there was no demarcation—you did what you could,
you learned fast and got on with it.
153
ANGELS OF ACEH
Although one of the main public health officers of the
biggest state in Australia, who had been admonishing the
team about the risks of sunstrokes, malaria, drinking water
and so forth, Paul Van Buynder decided at one point that it
was a good idea to rescue a rabid cat out of a water well.
There were only two major health emergencies for the team
during the deployment. Brian’s needlestick injury was one
and the attack of a feral and possibly rabid cat was another.
Paul Van Buynder was woken one night—again—by
the mamp-mamp-mamp sound of a faint alarm clock.
Exhausted but unable to go back to sleep because of the
communal snoring, and aware that the nearby mosque’s
call-to-prayer would start in an hour or two, he fuzzily
contemplated the respective merits of finding the clock’s
owner and maiming him; or doing something constructive,
like writing up a public health report on Banda Aceh. He
chose the latter.
He left the dormitory. As he sat typing on his laptop in
the team’s office, he heard a strange noise nearby. He
investigated and saw a cat drowning in a water well.
These were the square-tiled tubs out of which the team
used to scoop water with a dipper to wash themselves. He
reached in and put his arm under the cat. The frightened
cat, clearly blaming Paul Van Buynder for its whole
predicament, scrambled to safety by ferociously scratching its way up the flesh of his arm, and promptly made
itself scarce.
Paul Van Buynder worked mostly with Jeremy
McAnulty and Mike Flynn. Jeremy didn’t know many
people in the team before going to Banda Aceh. He had
met James Branley when working on an outbreak of
parrot fever (psittacosis) in the Blue Mountains in 2002.
Jeremy was the director of the Communicable Diseases
154
Reaching Out—Sigli
Branch of New South Wales Public Health. Tall, dark and
handsome—think actor Tom Hanks, with a stronger jaw
line—Jeremy was in his early forties, quietly brilliant and
genteel almost to a fault. Married to Paula, he had three
boys, William (fifteen), Henry (twelve) and Alex (nine).
His work in public health had seen him involved in everything from cryptosporidium in the New South Wales water
supply to outbreaks of disease on pleasure cruise liners,
responses to bio-terrorism and respiratory outbreaks such
as SARS. Jeremy was finding that the Acehnese were very
sensible about disease control—they exercised proper
personal hygiene and knew the risks about food contamination. Unfortunately, however, the tsunami had fouled many
of the water wells in Aceh province, and homelessness and
camp living had led to bathing and washing taking place in
higher water reservoirs, which otherwise might have been
useful for drinking.
Jeremy had experienced his own sombre moments at
Banda Aceh. One day he was travelling to a camp with
Mike Flynn, and as they approached a river near Kesdam
Hospital they saw the local people slowly rowing out to
floating bodies, tying ropes around them and gently
hauling them, hand over hand, back to the riverbank. They
saw a pair of bodies which looked like a couple embracing—they appeared to have died clinging to each other.
It was too sad. All the team members had moments which
touched them, and would never leave them.
After some quick negotiations with MSF, Annette Holian,
Brian Pezzutti and Ray Southon set off for Sigli. They
sneaked out of their quarters at first light to join the
waiting MSF cattle truck—or what looked like a cattle
155
ANGELS OF ACEH
truck loaded with supplies—and a four-wheel-drive car.
There were three MSF people sitting in the car. ‘There
is no room for your bags!’ they called out in cheery French
accents. Annette and Ray pulled out all the boxes and bags
that were already in the car, re-packed the lot and discovered there was plenty of room for their bags after that.
They set off with Udi the driver, an MSF member
François, his wife Gabriele, Afe the translator, Eunice a
nurse, and the three Australians in the back. Annette asked
light-heartedly, ‘Where’s the champagne?!’ They were,
after all, French. ‘It is in the back, in the portable refrigerator,’ Gabriele assured her seriously, in her French accent.
Some things you did not compromise on.
The trip was uneventful. The roads were inland so had
not been directly affected by the tsunami, but it was
unclear how far the earthquake had been felt. At one stage
they passed what appeared to be yards and yards of
coloured cloth, being washed and dried in the sun. Life still
went on. Clothes still had to be made. Many fabrics and
furnishings had been ruined beyond salvage in places on
the coast, if not by the immediate wave and wreckage then
by the seeping rot and mould afterwards.
What struck Annette most as they travelled was that
they occasionally passed heavily secured TNI vehicles,
that looked like tanks on wheels. It was a two-and-a-half
hour drive to Sigli and they had originally planned to go by
twenty-minute helicopter ride, but MSF cancelled this
plan due to the risk of being shot at by those involved in
the fighting. MSF had also given them zip-up sleeveless
vests to wear, which identified them as medical personnel.
The city of Sigli was about 8 kilometres inland and had
not been directly affected by the tsunami. Thousands of
refugees were arriving daily because the fishing villages on
156
Reaching Out—Sigli
the coast had been ravaged. They drove in the driveway of
a hospital, which was not unlike Fakinah Hospital to look
at. A white single-storey building with verandahs and
grassy courtyards. When they arrived they were met by
the middle-aged director of the hospital, who was very
friendly and took their passports. Their arrival had to be
recorded with the police.
The director told them that 50 per cent of his staff was
missing from duty, either killed by the tsunami or with their
families, dealing with the trauma of losses and damage. He
knew a great deal about the new arrivals, clearly having
done his research. ‘The internet,’ he explained, smiling. He
even knew that Brian’s birthday was 6 January.
The hospital was desperate for an orthopaedic surgeon.
Hospital staff looked at the group and, after a quick query,
singled out Annette. ‘Come this way please,’ they said,
setting out on a ward round. The others followed.
They were taken to look at the theatres. One was bluetiled, dark and dingy. It looked very well-used. Down
the end of a corridor was another theatre, which was a
beautiful, white-tiled room with bright sunlight pouring in
through large glass windows. Natural light! Annette
thought. How different to Fakinah. She had assumed they
would be going downmarket when they left Fakinah,
expecting to rough it further and get even more out of their
comfort zones, professionally and personally. Sigli was a
complete surprise.
More was to be revealed. A veritable feast! Surgical
instruments. Suction units, anaesthetic machines, diathermy
machines. Annette wondered how she would operate with
all of this paraphernalia, as she had grown used to making
do without it. Brian was in his element. He was so thrilled
to find an anaesthetic machine that he could barely contain
157
ANGELS OF ACEH
himself. He was photographed as he examined it, beaming.
He couldn’t find an oxygen hose.
‘Where is it?’ he asked the staff.
‘We were given it as a gift,’ he was told, ‘it has never had
a hose.’
‘When were you given it?’ Brian persisted, searching in
cupboards. He hoped to find the hose stored nearby, or
something that would do the job.
‘Twelve months ago.’
Brian couldn’t use it. He was fuming inside—such a
disappointment. But then it was the usual matter of getting
over it. Again. He just laughed, which was always the
best response.
Ray had set up the theatre with instruments, dressings
and other supplies. Annette gave MSF a list of her surgical
requirements, and when they didn’t blink, she kept adding
to it. This was luxury. They had supplies such as surgical
drapes, gowns, instruments. She almost felt guilty about
her colleagues slumming it back at Fakinah.
They identified a number of patients needing immediate
surgery. Annette looked at one of them having his dressing
changed. He was biting down hard on a dirty, rolled-up
towel. He was in agony. Shocked, she looked around. There
were other patients doing the same thing, as their dressings
were being changed. The gauze dressings were stuck to
jagged-edged wounds, where the sharp debris in the
tsunami had sheared off skin and roughly cut away flesh as
it whipped past. She thought of how much a Band-aid could
hurt as it was ripped off. These were tearing and snagging at
the large, infected, deep gashes. She shuddered and her
eyes prickled in sympathy.
The differing pain philosophy was again evident. What
to do? Order immediate, appropriate pain cover for all the
158
Reaching Out—Sigli
patients? She knew from her work in other countries that
there was a fear that pain relief suppressed breathing. It
was all about adequacy of education, training. She couldn’t
change the world in one day. She knew there was no intention to be cruel. She would do what she had come to do.
You cannot take over and throw your weight around. You
do what you have come to do.
Annette, Brian and Ray commenced operating. The
power gave out almost straightaway. The theatre quickly
became like a greenhouse with steam rising from their hot
bodies and the sun streaming attractively but relentlessly
through the large windows. The three put on bandages as
makeshift sweatbands around their foreheads, laughing
at how with every challenge you had to dream up a way
of turning it into fun, otherwise it could all become too
annoying for words. Power was restored shortly and,
wonder of wonders, MSF was also able to put in running
water for them. Ray did not have to run the 20 metres up
the hall to the other theatre every time he needed to wash
something or scrub up. Brian was impressed with how Ray
managed to team-build with the local nurses. He was very
organised, smiled often and although he couldn’t speak
their language, managed to have a good working relationship with them as they helped each other.
They knew it was a day-to-day proposition whether they
were going to be able to return to Sigli but for now
the three would just do their best to alleviate some of the
patient workload.
Ray was very moved to be asked to go with them. He
was a nurse at Westmead Hospital in Sydney, working
in general surgery. He worked as a scrub nurse and
occasionally the scout (the former remains sterile, the latter
obtains what is needed for the surgery). The general
159
ANGELS OF ACEH
surgery he was involved in covered anything from varicose
vein removal and bowel repair to burns and fractures.
Ray’s background particularly suited him for this mercy
mission. He had been a minister of religion in the Seventh
Day Adventist Church for 28 years. Fifteen of those years
had been in a chaplain’s counselling role. He had been
exposed to many of the crises of life which people suffer
and had had to help people find a way out of their pain.
He had never been in the military but he had been
trained in outdoor activities such as abseiling and boy
scout-style camping.
Ray was married to Margaret, who was also a nurse
and was from a family of nurses. Together they were
the parents of two grown-up daughters and a son. His
vocation was nursing but, when his time was his own, Ray
made homes structurally safe and beautiful. He was the
ultimate handyman.
He had been on duty in the Royal Melbourne Hospital
the day the West Gate Bridge collapsed in 1970. He had
worked in East Melbourne and Adelaide on the community disaster response for the Ash Wednesday Bushfires of
February 1983. He was experienced in dire situations,
where injuries were horrific. He regarded the request for
him to help in Indonesia as an honour for his hospital, his
community and his country.
Annette, Brian and Ray found the Indonesian hospital
staff at Sigli very friendly and highly receptive to outside
assistance. So much so that the trio volunteered to stay on
the next day, and were rewarded with a magical meal that
night of ducks’ eggs and banana leaves.
That night the remainder of the CASTA team back at
Fakinah experienced the biggest earth tremor since their
arrival. It hit at 10.30 p.m. and registered 6.5 on the
160
Reaching Out—Sigli
Richter scale. It shook them to the core, but they all had
adopted a fatalistic approach—if they were meant to
survive they would, but if your number was up then it was
up. There was not much you could do about it.
161
chapter thirteen
Helping and Coping
The US Secretary of State, Colin Powell, and Florida’s
Governor, Jeb Bush, visited Banda Aceh on 5 January.
Both men had been sent by President Bush to assess the
situation and report back on what role the United States
could play in the recovery, and to raise the profile of the
area in need. The world press swarmed to capture this
amazing visit.
After they landed at Sultan Iskandar Muda airfield,
they boarded a Seahawk helicopter to get an aerial appreciation of how badly the region was affected.
Powell sounded staggered on his return. ‘I’ve been in
war and I’ve been through a number of hurricanes, tornadoes and other relief operations, but I’ve never seen
anything like this,’ he told reporters, in an aghast voice.
‘Flying over Banda Aceh and seeing how the wave came
ashore, pushing everything in its path. Cars, ships,
freighters overturned all the way up to the foothills. I
cannot begin to imagine the horror that went through the
families and all of the people who heard this wave coming
and had their lives snuffed out by this wave.’
162
Helping and Coping
Powell then visited the IOM tent in the middle of
the day.
Bill Griggs had a number of patients at the airfield. He
had had a tough couple of days trying desperately to airlift
patients to Medan. Earmarked for departure were a
number of cases from both Fakinah and Kesdam. He and
Sudhakar had done a ward round the previous day,
Tuesday, 4 January, and identified those patients who
needed to go to a fully equipped, fully staffed hospital for
treatment. These were mostly surgical patients that Paul
had anaesthetised and either Sudhakar or Annette had
operated on. These patients had to be stable enough to
travel but they required further and better hospital care
than could be provided locally. They were mainly patients
who required ongoing surgery and rehabilitation. There
was also a fifteen-year-old aspiration pneumonia patient
called Zahara who had been added to the list as a special
request from James Branley, on behalf of a local Indonesian doctor. These patients were moved onto the
verandah at Fakinah to make way for incoming admissions, while they waited for transport to the airfield. They
were unable to depart on the Tuesday, as a plane coming
in to land had hit a water buffalo on the runway, causing
chaos and shutting down the airfield. The incident was
relayed by Griggs to Fakinah by phone, to complete disbelief at the other end: ‘A plane hit a cow. A cow. Yes, a
cow.’ It was not the most comfortable of arrangements
for the patients as they waited, lying on body bags in
the outside humidity, and the plan was for it to be strictly
temporary. The patients were uncomplaining and cooperative at every step.
Another group of evacuees from Kesdam had been treated
and stabilised and were now waiting with their relatives
163
ANGELS OF ACEH
at the airfield. Griggs had rejected some prospective
patients as they were too ill to travel and unlikely to
survive, wherever they were. It was hot. The usual noise
and chaos of aircraft activity was not present. The prearranged flight was cancelled. All aircraft movements had
suddenly been halted due to Powell’s visit.
Griggs got on with his job and continued to do what he
could to keep his patients in a comfortable state until the
flight embargo was lifted. He had a tarpaulin placed over
the patients to shield them from the hot sun. No sooner had
he secured the shade for them than a Seahawk suddenly
flew over at low altitude, blowing the tarpaulin away, its
updraft pulling out drip-lines from the patients. It was
carrying Powell.
Hydrating and feeding the patients was difficult, let
alone keeping them cool, comfortable, toileted and medically stable. The security arrangements accompanying
Powell’s visit were such that if he had to leave at a moment’s
notice, then everything was on standby for this to happen.
Security on the airfield was tight as there was the potential
for a terrorist attack. The whole world was watching.
People were pre-occupied and vulnerable. With such considerations in mind, the security needs of this prominent
world figure were paramount.
Colin Powell found Griggs and spoke to him. ‘If there’s
anything I can do to help, anything at all?’ he offered.
Griggs responded politely, ‘My patients need to go to
Medan for hospital treatment, Sir.’
‘In that case, my leaving might help,’ said Powell.
‘Yes, Sir,’ replied Griggs. Powell understood immediately.
He had been in the military himself. He was not afraid
of straight talk. He had served his purpose by coming, in
drawing the world’s attention to Banda Aceh. The world
164
Helping and Coping
was already responding. Money needed to help these
desperate people was starting to pour in.
Powell left. But the impact of him being there was
enormous.
The team members’ backgrounds often gave clues to how
they had ended up in the disaster zone. Their particular
personalities were also a factor. These two aspects
combined seemed to be what helped them perform well
under pressure. Unless you were okay yourself, you
couldn’t help others. Expectations had to be realistic, and
endurance was crucial. Experience and character. You
needed both.
Paul had been unwittingly preparing for this important
role in Banda Aceh throughout his whole life. He had
watched the television program MASH as a fascinated
teenager, with family and friends telling him he reminded
them of Hawkeye. He spent years in Venturers, the teen
version of scouts, and he was also a Queen’s Scout. He had
gone camping, caving, abseiling, rock-climbing, canoeing—
combining loads of activity with the joys of improvising and
roughing it. Their food would usually be creations that
smelt great but looked awful, cooked on a campfire which
had been painstakingly made, sometimes with rain-soaked
wood in icy winds. There were many situations of danger,
when the tenacity of the team meant that the person
trapped in the too-narrow cave did not panic, and the
person dangling at the end of the abseiling rope was confident of being rescued. Rick, their calm and confident
leader, had let them make mistakes and learn. Paul had kept
the tin plates he had eaten off, as souvenirs of many happy
and character-building experiences.
165
ANGELS OF ACEH
Paul was an ordinary Australian boy who grew up in the
Sydney suburb of Ryde. His mother was a mathematician
who also taught English as a second language to migrant
adults, and his father was a professor of teacher education.
When Paul joined the Navy in the 1980s, he was required
to do survival at sea training. He went to sea on various
ships, where he lived in crowded messdecks and learned
to tolerate lack of basic creature comforts such as long
showers, comfortable beds and privacy, all of which are
sacrificed as part of shipboard life.
Paul completed flight-surgeon training in Pensacola,
Florida, in 1995. He and his group of 40 fellow doctors
were put out in the bush and left without food or water for
days. Four US Army Rangers had died of hypothermia in
survival training there, in an exercise a month prior to
his arrival.
It had been bitterly cold and his group had become
hungry. Paul caught a turtle, cooked it and ate its eggs,
even as his classmates watched and turned slightly bilious.
They couldn’t touch it, or anything else for that matter. He
felt he had to be able to stomach living off the wild—he
had to know what he was really made of. He ended up the
only one out of that class of 40 to successfully fly a military
jet solo. Mike Flynn had been another Australian who did
that course, back in the 70s.
Paul specialised in anaesthetics and transferred to the
Naval Reserve. He also became a cardiac anaesthetist, and
joined the heart–lung transplant team at St Vincent’s
Hospital. Cardiac anaesthetics was the most complex of
anaesthetics. The patients were the most sick, they were
usually on a cocktail of drugs which made interactions tricky
to calculate, and operations such as heart and lung transplants
were lengthy and high risk. But Paul thrived on challenges.
166
Helping and Coping
Paul always said it helped that he married someone who
understood him, was used to coping with separation
(because I came from a naval family), and who backed him
in his aspirations.
In his time at sea he had certainly had moments when
things were hairy. Boat transfers at 2 a.m. in pitch darkness across heaving seas to another vessel to treat a patient
(the much-loved son of a Thai admiral) were not for the
faint-hearted.
There were other dicey episodes from time to time. A
young pilot fell from a helicopter in a winching exercise on
the New South Wales South Coast and Paul had to reach
him using the same set of equipment which had just failed.
He would never know which felt worse—being unable to
save the young man’s life, because his body had been
completely broken on rocks—or returning to tell the bride
of a few months that she was a widow.
There was always the element of your own ‘human-ness’
which had an impact upon your ability to function and
achieve goals. Paul had packed for Banda Aceh on the
‘keep it simple’ philosophy. He was now regretting
ditching my packing choices. When he rang me one day,
and actually got through, he asked ‘Do you know the first
thing I had to borrow? Fungal powder!’ We laughed
heartily. It was hot and he was, manfully, not as hairless as
some. Constant sweat over your entire body meant rashes
and discomfort. The ‘shower-in-a-can’ as he called his
anti-perspirant, did not quite do the trick.
At 11 p.m. on the night before he left Sydney, he had
disdainfully thrown aside the vital provisions I had heaped
on the kitchen nook table, after a frenzied rummage
through cupboards. I had been mad about creating
survival kits as a child. I knew exactly what he needed:
167
ANGELS OF ACEH
candles, wind-up torch, fungal powder, waterproof matches,
sunblock, Rid insect repellant, Pine-O-Cleen antibacterial
wipes. He had taken only the Rid and the wipes from my
proffered pile. ‘They think I’m a legend because of the wipes,
Soph!’ he later teased. They did once end up operating by
torchlight, he also had to confess.
The food was something Paul had to ‘get over’. The
RAAF ration pack they had been given for the flight out of
Richmond Air Base had been pretty lame—a bit of devon
or something, a lonely piece of unbuttered bread, an Anzac
biscuit and a granny smith apple. These days Paul remembered it longingly. He hadn’t known it then, but it was to
be the best food he would have on the whole deployment.
It had had a fresh apple in it—and he didn’t even eat it! He
would have done anything to have it here. The ratpacks
they had now contained no fresh food.
Paul had heard about Al Stafford when he was learning
to fly in Pensacola. Al was an American who was shot
down in the Vietnam War. On his first day in captivity
he had been given a revolting fish-head soup, which he
couldn’t touch, let alone consume. Al later said he wished
he had known it would be the best meal he was offered for
the next six years. He’d been given it because some feast
day fell on the same day he was shot down. It was a gift
horse.
Paul thought about how he was starting to appreciate
the things he was now deprived of. Here in Banda Aceh,
you ate because you had to, to keep your strength up.
Although he had a strong stomach, some nights Paul felt he
couldn’t eat, even though he knew he had to. He would
sometimes just grab a cup of coffee and head back to
theatre to do more cases with Sudhakar and Marj, with
Adrian often helping. Sometimes the disgusting smell of
168
Helping and Coping
infected and sick bodies, which clung to every inch of you,
combined with the revolting sights of the day—rotting,
pus-encased open flesh—would saturate your senses. It
just overwhelmed you.
More and more, Paul would walk along the balcony to
get to theatre, rather than going through the ward. He
found that this routine—not seeing the people lying there
with wounds, not seeing the little babies or the children, not
breathing the pungent air—enabled him to come to theatre
emotionally strong and ready to perform professionally.
The nurses—Karyn Boxshall, Lisa Dillon and Liz
Cloughessy—and the physician James Branley were
working on the ward, and doing it very well. As an anaesthetist, Paul didn’t have to do this. He could just get on and
do his job and that suited him fine. Removing people’s pain
while they were being operated on was how Paul knew he
could best help them. During his working day at Fakinah
he saw case after case, until well after nightfall. It was
enough.
Paul did do ward rounds with the others on the team.
He remembers vividly an incident involving a man in his
late fifties, who had a severe head injury which had
become fly-blown—flies had laid eggs and maggots had
started living in the wound—and it needed to be debrided.
The maggots were not the problem. Maggots had been
used in World War I to clean wounds of rotten tissue and
deadly bacteria. It was a painful injury, but this patient was
a very stoic man. At one stage there was a drip-stand in the
theatre—one of those horrid, unsteady three-legged ones.
Suddenly there were earth tremors and people lurched
about, causing the stand to rock and fall, smashing the man
full in the face. The cracking sound of the impact on his
skull was horrific. Paul was beside himself when he saw it
169
ANGELS OF ACEH
happen, but the man just took Paul’s hand and squeezed it
reassuringly, saying brightly, despite all he had gone
through, ‘It is okay, it is okay!’
Increasingly, the team was getting an impression of the
Acehnese as strong and kind people, who saw the humour
in situations, no matter how dire.
Watto, Bruce and Ken Harrison spent most of their days
sorting out everything which would enable the hospital to
function. Repairs and supplies. One of the ongoing challenges was the water supply for the hospital. The tsunami
had put water, water everywhere, but not a drop to drink.
The team had bottled water and the hospital had a tank,
for all purposes including showering and the washing of
hospital cloths. Prior to the tsunami, the water from the
tank would be pumped electrically through the hospital
system. But the pipes leading from the town had been
broken in the massive earthquake which triggered the
tsunami.
The hospital water now had to be trucked in and the
tank had to be filled from the truck. Australian Army
personnel provided 20 000 litres of purified water from the
water purifying plant they had set up in the grounds of
the Catholic Church, close to the centre of Banda Aceh.
It was opposite the rubble of a huge shopping centre which
had collapsed in the initial quake. An Australian flag
fluttered over the plant, signalling the presence of the
service which steadily provided 480 000 litres of water,
every 24 hours, for the people of the city of Banda Aceh.
The 20 000 litres for Fakinah Hospital were meant to
last the whole of the hospital for a few days, but Watto and
the others were discovering that the tank would be drained
170
Helping and Coping
by morning. The first morning it happened, they thought
the tank or the pipes throughout the hospital might be
cracked and water possibly leaking out, so they decided to
isolate the pipes to the hospital. That evening, they shut off
the electric pump which sent the water into the pipes. In
the morning, the tank was drained dry. The tank must be
leaking, they thought. It cannot be the pipes after all. To
check there wasn’t another, less dramatic explanation—
such as extravagant water usage overnight for clothes
laundering or long showers—they cut the plug off the
power cord which ran the electric pump. Again, in the
morning, the tank was empty. It had been re-wired
overnight and plugged in again, with an Indonesian plug.
Watto asked the Army to refill the tank again, which caused
some concern about the rate at which the hospital
consumed the water. Clean water was gold. The Army
wanted to continue to be able to meet the demand. They
had their own pressures. The water purification relied upon
a steady flow of water in order to purify it, and the city’s
pipe maze had been damaged. There was also a time factor
involved in the purification process, and a queue of patient
but thirsty people. A queue which stretched forever.
Watto, aware that the supply was precious, cut the
power cord so short it could not reach the power socket.
He made himself a power cord which went from the cut
length to the socket and kept it hidden away.
If people wanted water overnight he reasoned, they
could fill a bottle and take it to their rooms. The Indonesian
police objected, saying that they did not carry water, it
was beneath their station. Watto and Bruce offered to
carry their water for them to their rooms. Shamed into
accepting that the tsunami had created different conditions
for everyone, the police capitulated. Although Watto and
171
ANGELS OF ACEH
Bruce never quite solved the mystery of the disappearing
water, from that moment on, the wastage stopped.
The police had a good relationship with Watto and
Bruce. One time they had locked themselves out of their
room and one of them called on the firemen for help. ‘You
are like thief!’ he said admiringly to the bemused fireys.
This particular policeman had watched as Watto and
Bruce deftly broke into rooms on security rounds. Bruce
had been keen to find some oxygen supplies, as they were
so desperately needed. The firey was overjoyed when he
shone his torch into the room on rounds one night and saw
a number of oxygen cylinders. They appeared to have
fallen this way and that during that first earthquake, firmly
blocking the door. Bruce had a little boy and his Indonesian family help by slipping the boy through a small gap in
a train-ticket-type window. The boy moved the cylinders
and Bruce was able to get the door open and distribute
the cylinders to the grateful doctors and nurses. Whilst
supplies of everything mattered, oxygen ranked as particularly important. Pain relief, given in the levels required
for serious discomfort, could cause depressed breathing.
Weakened patients, or patients labouring to breathe due to
pneumonitis, often would have plummeting oxygen levels.
Lack of oxygen could lead to brain damage, or even death.
Bruce’s find was a godsend. He gave the little boy a torch
for his help. He was thrilled.
Supplies were a constant challenge. Ken Harrison was
the team’s puppetmaster in that area. When it came to
logistics, nothing got past him. He was in his early forties
with a long dark ponytail and beard. Married to Jill and
father of pre-teens Luke and Rachel, he was running the
CareFlight Cache (supplies) at Westmead Hospital when
he heard about the tsunami. He promptly contacted David
172
Helping and Coping
Cooper, who headed up the disaster response section in
New South Wales Health. Ken was a qualified anaesthetist, but the role disaster response wanted him for was
to use his calculating logistical ability. He was a medical
equipment expert and was fast accumulating disaster
response expertise. He had assisted with the Sydney to
Hobart yacht race tragedy in 1998. He had helped at the
Waterfall train crash in January 2003, at bushfires too
numerous to mention, and, in contrast due to its nature, the
Olympics in Sydney in 2000. But he had never been to
anything on the scale of this tsunami. Nobody had.
As well as manning the supply situation, Ken also had
responsibility for team building, and he did it well. He got
the whip out in the early days to get the job done so the
work could start. He knew that morale would stay healthy
if the work could get started—there was nothing worse
than being somewhere, all revved up and then not being
able to do what you had travelled there for. The earthquakes were what unnerved Ken, he would never forget
them. The bad ones were those you could hear before you
actually felt them; you were in their power and there was
nowhere to run. They were not only disquieting, they
made you feel shivers of terror in your bones.
He had had experiences in Banda Aceh which would
probably never leave him. Battlefield protocol or disaster
triaging is so different to normal working procedures. You
saved those people who were most likely to survive, so that
they could rejoin the community and help their remaining
family members. A theatre could not be tied up all day by
one case—particularly if the patient would probably not
make it anyway—when ten people with better prospects
could have been treated in that time. The only option for
very ill patients was making them comfortable.
173
ANGELS OF ACEH
On one occasion Ken had had to let a young boy die.
The boy was about twelve, his own son’s age. It was a
tough call, one of the toughest of his life, and it seared him
to the core. The brutal reality was that the resources had to
be used elsewhere, as many more people would only be
able to live if the team conserved the medical supplies and
didn’t use them irresponsibly. There were only four
surgeons and the boxes of supplies were finite and dwindling fast. There were hundreds of people lining up at
Emergency, all needing help. Hundreds and hundreds per
day in fact.
Hard as it was to do, Ken did his job.
Sudhakar shed tears some days. It was completely understandable. Paul felt Sudhakar cried on his behalf, as Paul
had battened down his own hatches emotionally. He had
to, to make it through.
Sudhakar worked extremely hard. He drove himself.
He also knew the language, and therefore had no buffer
from what was being said around him. He was in a different position from the rest of the team in that respect.
Although it was an advantage, it brought with it a certain
rawness of experience.
There was a lovely little child to whom Sudhakar
became particularly attached. Zulfahmi was about nine
and could have been a playmate of Luke, the oldest of
Sudhakar’s three boys. He came to the hospital on 4 January. The Americans had picked him up in one of their
helicopter trips along the ravaged Aceh coastline, and he
had been triaged at Banda Aceh airfield. He was alone and
suspicious of all these strangers around him. He was
admitted to Fakinah Hospital because he needed surgery
174
Helping and Coping
on his festering arm and foot. Zulfahmi was an unusual
patient because so many children had died in the tsunami.
He was silent and looked warily at them through lowered
brows. His eyes were dark and dull, not how a young
child’s should be at all. Paul anaesthetised him and
Sudhakar operated on him.
As the ketamine coursed through the boy’s veins,
working its marvel and separating his mind from the pain,
a magical transformation occurred. Zulfahmi began to
smile, and make contact with them. They realised he had
some English and they started chatting to him. He began
counting animatedly and singing the Sesame Street version
of ‘ABC’. He called out spiritedly ‘1,2,3,4,5,6,7,9,10!’
Paul teased him. ‘What about eight? You left out eight!’
Zulfahmi laughed and concentrated harder: ‘Oh! Eight!
Eight! Okay! 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,9,10!’, leaving it out again. And
so it went on. Paul blew up a glove balloon for him. It was
so wonderful to see that little face uplifted. Paul playfully
called Sudhakar ‘doctorrr’, rolling his r’s. There was a
simple joy in hearing Zulfahmi chuckle merrily at his
pronunciation. Zulfahmi laughed with them and they
bantered happily as they helped fix him up. Now and then
he broke into a stream of Acehnese and would then burst
into tears. Sudhakar, listening, suddenly had tears streaming down his own face.
He interpreted for Marj and Paul that Zulfahmi had
just said, ‘I will never see my mother again! I will never see
my father again! Everyone in my family is dead!’ Marj
gasped and folded her arms around the little boy. Paul
stroked his hair. ‘Yes, you will. You will see them again,’ he
murmured, choking back his own tears. This child gutted
them all.
175
ANGELS OF ACEH
Sudhakar learned that Zulfahmi had been running out
of his home, away from the tsunami with his father,
mother, sister, brother and a young baby sibling when the
mother told them to go ahead as she could not keep up. She
had been through a hard pregnancy and had only recently
given birth.
Zulfahmi did not see any of his family again. He had
also become separated from his only surviving relative, his
grandmother, when the helicopter they were on became
too heavy to take off safely. Some of the passengers had
been obliged to alight, to alleviate the overloading
problem. His grandmother was one of them.
176
chapter fourteen
Kesdam
Kesdam Hospital was nothing special to look at. From the
front, this white, one-storey building was rather plain and
a bit grotty, but out the back it was quite lovely with grassy
courtyards and covered walkways.
Inside were rows of serious patients with hollow
expressions lying on beds. Dazed relatives milled around
them, doing what nursing staff normally would do—giving
them water and food, offering medicine, assisting with
toileting and liaising with the doctors on their behalves.
The Kesdam experience was different to Fakinah. The
Bravo team who went there worked in a cramped theatre
with two operating tables, with next to no suitable
instruments, no proper steriliser, and battled with the
overwhelming heat and flies. The hospital was large and
there was only a handful of medical staff, including some
who had come from Malaysia. Most amputations were
done at Kesdam rather than Fakinah, which was fortunately not as bad on the surgical trauma scale. But surgery
performed at both hospitals was what some surgeons
177
ANGELS OF ACEH
would call ‘Tiger country’. It was dangerous, frightening,
and challenging.
The officer in charge of Kesdam was Dr Arasanda, a
colonel in the TNI. He had been severely affected by the
tsunami and appeared to be suffering from some sort of
post-traumatic stress disorder. He had apparently lost
people close to him. He was armed and waved his weapon
around. Later on he invited Mike Flynn to enjoy some
Elvis Presley karaoke with him. The team was warned by
the Indonesians to be careful of him.
Paul Luckin had initially gone to Kesdam on 1 January
for an early ‘recce’ with Bruce Cameron, Adrian Humphrey,
Ken Harrison and Mike Flynn in Greg Norman’s Army
truck. They looked at the two theatres there and Luckin
met with a young Indonesian surgeon, Dr Panini, and an
Indonesian anaesthetist. Dr Panini was in his thirties and
was young and determined; it was he who clashed with
Annette Holian at Fakinah. He spoke English and said
pointedly to Luckin, ‘We do not need your assistance, we
do not need your help. We want your equipment.’ He was
almost aggressive in his demeanour.
Luckin was a gentleman—he had exquisite manners.
He was Bond, James Bond. Except he was here to do lifesaving anaesthetics, rather than car-chases, seductions or
elegant shoot-outs. ‘I will go to speak to our team leader,’
he said diplomatically, deliberately not taking offence.
‘Please do write down a list of your requirements. I would
be happy to meet with you again, say in one hour?’
‘We don’t need you,’ repeated the young surgeon.
People who go to other countries do not go as themselves
alone. They stand for the country who sent them. It is a
fact of life. And the reception you get from an individual
you feel is the reception that country gives you. Unless you
178
Kesdam
can limit it to the individual because you know what is
behind it. Luckin knew this. He had lived in a number of
different countries and he had served in many too. He had
been to Bougainville in 1998–99, East Timor in 2001, the
Solomons in 2003 and was in the military medical team
that went to Bali, arriving 30 hours after the bombing
which had taken place late at night on 12 October 2002.
There were any number of reasons for why this man
had such a suspicious attitude. It might have been something other than a simple personality problem or a personal
wariness of strangers, it may have been a culturally based
‘face’ issue. Some things cause loss of face. Some people do
not like to be at the receiving end of assistance. There were
also all the other sensitivities that had been outlined by
Mike Flynn—religion, history, the TNI/GAM relationship. Luckin suspected that the man’s attitude could be
related to past events where Indonesia and Australia had
medically interacted after a disaster.
Luckin had attended the last bi-annual ‘Controversies
in Civilian and Military Trauma Conference’ in Brisbane,
where a couple of senior Indonesian doctors had spoken
about how they felt after the Bali experience. The conference had been about improving approaches. Issues were
on the table for discussion, brainstorming, learning for the
future. The atmosphere was one of trust, where people
could open up and be frank.
When Luckin had arrived in Bali as part of the military
medical team to assist after the bombing in 2002, there
were dozens of patients waiting to be returned to
Australia. They were already at Denpasar airport when
he arrived. Pain relief was the most important thing as
all the survivors were burnt. Most had burns to 70 per
cent of their bodies. Their pain was indescribable. Many
179
ANGELS OF ACEH
had inhalational burns from the intense heat, flames and
dense smoke. Some people had ruptured ear drums, some
had blast-lung, where the explosion had caused tears in the
alveoli of the lung. For some the blast sent shockwaves
through the delicate tissues of the brain, liver, kidney and
spleen. Luckin had looked after these people the whole
way back to Australia.
The Indonesian doctor who spoke up at the Brisbane
conference was blunt. The Australians had rescued their
own during the aftermath of the Bali bombing and, in doing
so, had left the Indonesians without help. This had caused
unhappiness for his people. Understandably, Australia had
been caught up in its own national grief and shock. Yes,
time was critical with burn injuries. Sterile surrounds were
needed. Top-level medical care. Balinese facilities couldn’t
cope with the numbers. And yes, Australia had since
poured money into refurbishing the Intensive Care unit at
Kuta Hospital. All that aside, the Indonesians had needed
them at the same time. Bali had been host to Australian
holidaymakers for years. They were ‘family’.
Luckin knew all this. He and the Australian team were
here to make amends. If the Australian team could be
given the chance, they would do their utmost to help. That
was why they were here.
As brusque as this man was, Luckin was not going to take
offence at anything. Now was the time to start afresh. It had
to start somewhere, sometime. There was no point in harbouring grudges or labouring your own case. It was time to close
the chasm, to build a bridge. That initial meeting at Kesdam
had a satisfactory outcome. The Australians could help.
Paul Luckin had had a holiday booked to go to
Tasmania with his wife Geena and pre-teen daughter
Melissa when he received Peter Sharwood’s very early
180
Kesdam
morning phone call on Monday, 27 December. After telling
Peter dutifully that he could be counted on to go if needed,
he had rolled over in bed and groaned. It was the first time
in seven years he had had a break over the Christmas and
New Year holiday period. ‘It is not really convenient,’ he
thought aloud to his wife Geena, who stirred beside him.
‘It is rather more inconvenient for the people of Indonesia,’
she said quietly, snapping him into reality.
Now here he was in Banda Aceh. Not that you would
know it from looking at him. Luckin always looked like he
was at a country gymkhana, in the members’ tent. Pressed
shirt and trousers. Every day. Even in a disaster zone. He
never had a hair out of place and was always clean-shaven.
About six foot four, wide-shouldered and perfectly groomed.
Shaken not stirred, that was Luckin. Unflappable, he would
have ablutions anywhere, in the most disgusting of places,
but return as though he had been to a men’s salon. He sat
with a ram-rod back in theatre, and you fully expected to see
a Rolex peeping out of his theatre gown sleeve. When others
were stuffing dirty clothes in with clean into their backpacks,
blueys and duffel bags, he had two bags, one with clean, one
with dirty. He was organised. Scrupulous. He even had coathangers. But while clothes mightn’t make the man—manners
might, and he was always courteous.
Luckin lived his life to help people and he couldn’t stop
now. He had been born in Johannesburg, South Africa,
moved to Rhodesia at age five (now Zimbabwe) and
decided to do medicine at age eight after being a frequent
visitor himself to doctors, as a result of falling off bikes and
having scrapes, and generally having an adventurous spirit.
He moved to Tasmania at age nine, and grew up there.
His parents were teachers. By age eleven, he was an
ambulance cadet and by sixteen an ambulance volunteer
181
ANGELS OF ACEH
(with a motorbike licence); finally, as a young adult, he
worked his way up to being a paramedic. His introduction
to death and disaster was earlier than most. In his first year
of medicine, Luckin had studied in Papua New Guinea,
where his parents had moved some years earlier. He later
returned to South Africa to study the remainder of his
medical degree at the University of the Witwatersrand in
Johannesburg. His undergraduate training was at the
Barragwanath Hospital, Soweto (reputedly the largest
hospital in the world, with 2000 beds and 110 per cent
occupancy). Soweto was renowned for violence in the 70s
and 80s. Luckin became accustomed to seeing machete and
gunshot wounds. A common one was the classic stabbed
chest. One night he did his PB—30 chest drains in one
evening.
In Australia, handling a pneumothorax puncture would
be the work of a specialist emergency physician. In South
Africa, if you weren’t doing it confidently by your fourth
year of varsity (uni), there was something wrong. He qualified in anaesthetics in Durban at the King Edward VIII.
Here he dealt with something else in addition to the
gunshot or other wound—disembowelments by assegai, a
long Zulu blade. The action was in fact a traditional
courtesy to allow the dying spirit to escape.
He was becoming conscious of concepts which to
normal practitioners would be strange, unethical and
confronting. Pain relief, for example, was an essential in a
highly developed country, but it was considered a low
priority elsewhere. Luckin learned to work even where
you were constantly being reminded of a certain lack of
humanity towards one’s fellow man, although he never
quite got used to people sometimes walking straight past
an obviously stricken person on the footpath.
182
Kesdam
Fortunately, you could also find in any society good
people who cared. It kept your faith in human beings.
Luckin was clever. He had trained in cardiac anaesthetics,
as well as general.
His overseas experiences before Banda Aceh meant
that he knew that cultural sensitivities would always be
present, and that there was always more than one way to
do things. If you wanted something to happen, you had
to make it happen. You just had to work out a smart way of
achieving it.
On their first day at Kesdam, Bravo Team and the
Indonesian doctors did a ward round together to identify
patients who would need surgery. Luckin was tactful, and
sought the opinions of the Indonesian doctors, listening
carefully to what they had to say. The Indonesian surgeons
led the ward round. The anaesthetists, Luckin and Scott,
followed the entourage and noticed that occasionally they
skipped a patient, saying, ‘It is okay’, ‘No no, no need.’
Luckin was not sure why this happened but he hadn’t
come this far to overlook anybody who needed care. He
hung back and started to make his own observations.
He noticed one young lady who appeared to be very ill
indeed. We will call her Jamirah.1 She was burning with
fever and Luckin could tell she was dying, even without
examining her. When he was studying medicine in his
youth, he had scoffed at lecturers who said things like this,
but now he knew what they meant: he could see the pallor of
her skin, detect the laboured breathing, see the colour of her
lips, her fingernails; he noticed the pulse rate in her neck. He
was sure her lungs were full of phlegm and fouled seawater.
She clearly had pneumonitis. Luckin lifted up a dressing and
her injured leg literally burst open with offensive pus. If he
1
Name has been changed.
183
ANGELS OF ACEH
had been a weak-stomached type, he would have been
retching at that point but he simply said in his refined way to
his Indonesian colleagues, ‘She needs urgent surgery. Don’t
you agree?’ They demurred, but he insisted. With due savoir
faire. His years in the Soweto hospital as the young medical
student had made him no longer shy—it was sink or swim.
They took Jamirah to theatre. Peter Sharwood operated
on her, cutting away all the dead and rotting flesh in the leg
wound. If he could save her leg, he would. But saving her
life came first. None of the team held much hope for her but
all did their best.
The next day, when Luckin called into the ward, Jamirah
was in a much better condition. ‘Thank you,’ she said to him,
clutching his hand, and smiling up at him. He was touched,
even a little overwhelmed. He never expected that.
Before Luckin and the team departed from Banda Aceh,
Jamirah was discharged from the hospital. She left on her
own two legs, because nobody had had to cut either of
them off. She was so happy and relieved, she didn’t just
walk out of the hospital—she skipped!
Kesdam had shocked theatre nurse Rosie Clifton to the
core on day one. ‘Where are all the supplies we should
have had?’ she ranted angrily when they got back to
Fakinah that night for their regular briefing. ‘Do you
realise how busy we are, how desperate the situation is?
We are overloaded, it is dangerous, people will die because
of our understaffing! Where is the rest of our team? We
don’t even have half of Bravo out there with us!’ And so
she went on, not caring about etiquette. She had seen more
gore in that one day than most theatre nurses see in a
month, and was exhausted, and like the rest of the team,
184
Kesdam
she was being stretched professionally. She had worked
before in trying conditions, but these were the worst.
Liz Cloughessy took Rosie aside afterwards: ‘You need
to watch the way you speak,’ she admonished.
‘On the contrary,’ said Rosie. ‘It had to be said.’ Nurses
catch and kill their own. Rosie’s bravery paid off—Terry
Jongen and Adrian Humphrey were sent out to Kesdam
the next day to help, for the duration of the deployment.
They were hardly surplus at the understaffed Fakinah, but
it was a gesture of support. The team forgave her her outspokenness. They were family now, and the reality was that
they were all straining under similar pressure. Their experiences were bonding them, and airing your grievances was
not going to be held against you.
Rosie was an attractive brunette, whose age was never
discernible. She was petite, had her hair pulled back and
held her head high. Before becoming a theatre nurse, she
had been a ballerina and had danced all over Australia,
New Zealand, Europe and South America. She had had
four husbands. ‘I told them to shape up and if they didn’t,
I showed them the door,’ she explained to Paul cheerily.
Rosie’s figure never showed that she had had four children.
Her face didn’t give away that her eldest child was almost
30, either.
Rosie had done rigorous live-in training with the Red
Cross, where faux terrorists would burst in on the trainees,
without warning, during the course. She had done a
mission with MSF for three months in 2004 in the former
Soviet republics of Abkhazia and Georgia. Abkhazia had
been involved in sporadic fighting for independence for
some years. She had gone there principally to assess the
operating theatres, but she had also assisted in the surgery.
The operations included everything from the standard
185
ANGELS OF ACEH
appendectomies and hernias to amputations of limbs
shattered by landmine blasts.
Her philosophy was that, rather than throw a person a
fish and have them fed for a day, you taught them how to
fish and they fed themselves for a lifetime. To Rosie it was
galling that the team would be in Banda Aceh for such a
short time, offering medical services which might never be
able to be replicated after they left. That was life though,
and she got on with it. She was a professional. They rarely
stopped for lunch, and if they ever did, it was for a quick
bite from the ratpacks. They were swimming in blood and
pus from morning until night. They did about fifteen major
limb amputations in about five days, in amongst the wound
debridements and other procedures.
Rhonda Cowderoy, Rosie’s colleague for the deployment, had long given up on trying to keep the flies out of
her sterile field in theatre at Kesdam. The smell of the blood
on the floor and operating tables brought them in and they
crawled all over everything and everyone. They swarmed
on the pile of lopped-off limbs. She had also become accustomed to the ‘What does this woman want now?’ look
which the Indonesian medical staff humoured her with as
she asked for this and that, with gesticulations behind her
mask and without touching anything. Nurses are generally
considered ‘servants’ in the medical hierarchy in Indonesia
and it was up-ending the usual order to have her taking
charge. However, by the time she finished her deployment,
the Indonesians were in tune with her routine and happily
helping her, even anticipating what was needed.
Rhonda had short blonde hair, with fair skin and a radiant
face, and had been married to Bruce for 33 years. They had
had a son Rob and daughter Sarah. Rob had worked as an
electrician with a telecommunications company. Almost two
186
Kesdam
years ago, Rhonda was told Rob had been in ‘an accident’
and she rushed to the Royal Prince Alfred to be with him.
She never thought the worst—her husband was an electrical engineer, she was a nurse. Sadly, Rob had been
electrocuted at his worksite and died. Rob’s death had had
a huge impact on Rhonda and her family. Coming to
Banda Aceh had been a blessing in disguise. In this
disaster zone, she worked on people who were suffering
greatly, people who all had experienced loss. It changed
her outlook. For the first time, she was not thinking
constantly of what she had lost. It didn’t diminish her loss,
but it did make her look at life with new eyes. Although not
overtly religious, she believed in her Creator and had a
private spiritual dimension. When the violent aftershocks
in Banda Aceh threatened to bring the roof down one
night, she asked Rob, from her heart, to bring her home
safely to Bruce and Sarah.
Rhonda and Rosie worked solidly on case after case.
Their work was going to save someone’s life. There are
times when you do not need to be told to put your best
effort in.
Most afternoons the team at Kesdam finished by 3 or
4 p.m. and usually hitched a ride back to Fakinah. Sometimes Shmackers or René would stand by the roadside and
flag down a car or truck. Almost invariably someone
would stop and give them a lift, often for nothing in return.
The goodwill towards the Australians was overwhelming.
The idea of a stump where your leg should be sends a cold
shiver down most spines. The pain before, and afterwards.
Then the phantom pain, or the itch in the ankle you no
longer have. The changed life. The altered expectations.
187
ANGELS OF ACEH
Luckily, most people in modern times never have to
experience losing a limb. And when they do, they have
no say in it, it just happens, by terrible accident. Say in a
car accident.
At Kesdam Hospital, many of the patients were in
parlous states. Their conditions were serious and they
needed radical care. Amputations were taking place daily.
René Zellweger, the trauma surgeon on Bravo team,
performed amputations at Kesdam, alongside his colleague
Peter Sharwood, at the two operating tables. One surgeon
at each. The theatre soon became a disgusting mire of spattered blood and infected fluids. Despite his many years of
surgical work, René never quite got used to seeing human
limbs, with a large bone sticking out of the middle, being
dropped into the bin. It just wasn’t how it was meant to be.
Not in modern times. You rarely saw people with missing
limbs in Australia and you certainly didn’t saw off a
number of them, one after another, in any one day. It
would sicken you if you thought about it for too long, but
you had to remember that the limbs you had examined
were fast becoming fatally toxic to the rest of the body—
and there were no other remedies at this late stage.
René felt thwarted on one occasion. He had advised a
lady patient that her leg would have to be cut off and she
had said ‘No’. Surgeons like to solve things. She would
not be getting a second chance—if it didn’t come off, she
would be dead in days. Whatever had broken her leg bones
had left deep gashes, which had now become so infected that
her leg was dead. The sultry climate didn’t help: the heat had
made it fester worse than ever and suppurating wounds
become deadly. What an ironical situation—to survive the
tsunami and then to die because you refused medical treatment. He could understand it. You learned to understand all
188
Kesdam
manner of bizarre things. Life as a cripple could be cruel
if you had no support. No crutches, no prosthetic limbs, no
homecare, physio or occupational therapy. Who knew
what her personal circumstances were? You couldn’t judge
anyone, not after this event. René tried to persuade her,
firmly, gently. It was life or death, and there was no time
to waste. He had such feeling for her and her suffering.
She was being offered a below-knee amputation, but she
refused. A few days later she died.
René had seen extreme suffering before. He performed
trauma surgery at the Royal Perth Hospital in Western
Australia, and was also an Associate Professor in Traumatology at the University Hospital in Zurich.
René was fair, athletic and of slim build. He had David
Wenham-style looks and physique. René was at the peak
of his professional experience and had worked in other
disaster situations before, including war zones. In 1995, he
had been an emergency doctor at an earthquake in Kobe,
Japan, and in 2000, he was a surgeon for the International
Red Cross during a civil war in the Sudan.
A world-class surgeon, who could have been living the
high life with fast cars and mansions in the best parts of
exclusive suburbs, René wanted to make his life worth
living in a different way. A selfless, out-reaching way.
Without fanfare and aware that some might be cynical—or
think it unusual to the point of being eccentric—he did not
mention his life’s work to anyone, not even to those in the
team. His altruism was a joint effort—his wife Katrin, a
beautiful blonde physiotherapist, supported and fully
shared his idealism.
In 2002 and 2003, he had worked in South Africa, in
Cape Town and Johannesburg hospitals. He had operated
on injuries sent in by the truckload from the strife in the
189
ANGELS OF ACEH
townships. Ballistics, knife-wounds, axe and machete
slashings. He had repaired the injuries of war and lived
among human misery, coping with dramatically less than
ideal situations. These were desperate situations, in violent
times. The memories of those injuries would be with him
for life.
René enjoyed working with this highly motivated team
in Banda Aceh, where everybody pulled their weight. He
knew he would be sad to leave, partly because he wanted
to continue helping the tsunami victims and partly because
he knew that he would rarely see these team members
again, people that he had come to regard as friends. They
enriched each other’s lives with every passing moment and
he would always treasure that. Everybody helped each
other and nobody exploited any weaknesses they might
have noticed. Quite the opposite. They bolstered each
other, which was how they could continue to work under
such demanding circumstances.
If you live cheek-by-jowl with a small team, and share
harrowing experiences together over a relatively short
space of time, you either bond or you strain apart. René
had been in the military in Switzerland years ago in the
crack mountain forces, where one slip in the dark, in
the blizzards or on the ice, could mean death. His measure
of a person’s worth was whether he would have trusted
that person with his life in those conditions. He felt there
were people in the Australian team he would definitely
have chosen to have alongside him on the mountainside.
The poverty of the Acehnese and the hope in the eyes of
the patients also kept him going. These people had so much
to complain about, but they didn’t. They were goodnatured and thankful for every bit of help. Always. It
grabbed René’s heart.
190
Kesdam
He sensed that the Acehnese wanted to be treated by the
Australian medical staff in preference to any other. Although
this was affirming of the team’s skills and expertise, he
tried to ignore it as he was conscious of the feelings of the
Indonesian doctors, who were offering tremendous assistance and with whom he got on well. The Indonesians had
shown that they were willing to be taught and some of
them had discerned the limits of their own training.
He found their enthusiasm to learn very humbling and
wondered whether he and his colleagues would have had
the same humility were they in the same position.
On 3 January, René was interviewed by Daniela Lager
from SFDRS, the main Swiss television channel. It was
one in a series of interviews he gave to SFDRS.
René’s Swiss background gave him fluency in German.
He was able to talk about the destroyed infrastructure, the
high number of casualties, and the major surgery being
performed under the most extraordinary of circumstances.
These news reports about the tsunami relief work were
broadcast across Germany and Austria. René’s media
coverage, which highlighted the work being done by the
team, assisted in galvanising European generosity. He and
the team were written up by Jane Perlez, a reporter from
The New York Times and the story also appeared in the
European edition of the International Herald Tribune. The
activities of an Australian team in a remote Indonesian
‘village’ might not ordinarily have captured European
attention but the tsunami itself caught their initial interest,
and the medical work being done in its aftermath was
brought into their consciousness via René.
The German contribution to the relief effort was to be
among the world’s most generous—they donated over
$600 million.
191
ANGELS OF ACEH
The team members at Kesdam were always conscious of
the sensitive relations with their hosts. One day, midafternoon, Shmackers came into theatre white-faced and
tight-lipped. ‘Let’s go, pack up,’ he said. One look at him
and the team complied. He had been ordered to leave at
once by an unknown, high-ranking, armed Indonesian.
That was all Shmackers needed. There were no recriminations or arguments. The team returned the next day
apprehensively, but the man was gone and all seemed well.
No explanation was ever given and, in these unusual times,
none was really expected.
There were heavy times at Kesdam but there were
moments of levity as well. Shmackers one day turned a
corner and came face-to-face with a local who had been
given one of the Australian Army ratpacks. He had
anointed his many cuts and scratches on his arms and legs
with Vegemite out of the pack. ‘It is good! Very good!’ he
told Shmackers earnestly. Shmackers, his suppressed
desire to laugh almost causing him pain, acknowledged
him politely with a nod and smile and quickly moved on.
Terry Jongen, emergency nurse, spread himself around.
He had been hard-won for Kesdam by Rosie’s understandable ranting in a briefing in those early days and he wasn’t
going to lounge about. Some days he helped in theatre,
sometimes in the ward and often in the Emergency
Department, with Greg Norman and some army medics.
Terry was a clinical nurse specialist in charge of the
nurses in the Emergency Department at Royal Perth
Hospital. He was single, in his late thirties, dark-bearded
and into motorbike-racing. He had been at the receiving
end for the burn victims of the Bali bombing, when he had
had at his disposal the full resources of the Royal Perth.
But Banda Aceh was different.
192
Kesdam
One day he and Shmackers had a patient who had
severe and septic leg wounds. During the operation it
became apparent that her infection had spread further
than they had realised. The amputation was a difficult one,
and it became clear after the operation that she was dying.
She was tiny, in her forties, and was a very sweet and stoic
lady. Her family was around her, and her English-speaking
niece was the translator for the nurse and doctor. The
woman died soon after the operation and her family
wanted her body for a speedy burial for religious reasons.
Terry and Shmackers put the body into a body bag and
the niece hugged Terry. ‘Thank you,’ she said, trembling.
The family then asked if they could have the woman’s
severed leg as well. Terry thought it over. The leg had been
wrapped and discarded already. It was not going to be a
pleasant task. He decided he would go that extra mile for
this lovely family. Donning a pair of gloves, he rummaged
in the heat and thick swarms of flies through the putrid
rubbish in the back alley until he found the leg. He was
surprised at its heaviness. He carried it inside and placed it
carefully in the body bag under the family’s watchful and
appreciative gaze. They wanted her as intact as possible.
Shmackers found Terry after the family had left.
‘Thanks,’ he said. Nothing more was needed.
Peter Sharwood, the other surgeon at Kesdam, was a
complete saint. He didn’t wear a halo and he didn’t have
saintly charm. You just had to see how he spent his life.
He had obviously decided at some stage that he would
dedicate his life to serving others who were needy in the
worst kind of way. Being catastrophically injured in a
developing country might qualify for his help. And he
193
ANGELS OF ACEH
wasn’t afraid of being uncomfortable, in danger, or without
any of the items which could make his job easier. Although
a prestigious surgeon in his ‘normal’ life, he didn’t shirk
from any job. The higher your professional status, the more
you have to overcome to do what is demanding and sometimes lowly. Peter carried boxes with the best of them. He
would mop the floors when not operating. The operating
team had no suction machinery, so blood dripped and
occasionally flooded over the edges of the tables. It stank.
Sometimes it was a quarter-of-an-inch deep on the floor,
becoming dangerously slippery. Peter’s tradition of
swabbing the floors had started when he was in Rwanda.
The others wouldn’t let him help put equipment away, as he
put it in the wrong place. So while that went on, he mopped
the theatre. When the Bulletin magazine in Australia did a
write-up on him and some of the team at Kesdam, they
photographed him mopping the floors.
Peter had done 41 years in the Army Reserve by the
time he went to Banda Aceh, and was now a colonel. The
others in the team all talked about ‘When we’, as in ‘When
we were in Rwanda we did such and such’, and ‘When we
were in Somalia’ and traded stories about the disasters
they had been to and what they had dealt with. Peter had a
few stories. He was entitled to be a When we.
He had heard about the tsunami on the 5 a.m. news on
27 December and had immediately called in his contacts in
Queensland and Lismore. A surgical team was not being
put together yet, but he was told to stay packed and ready.
The next thing he knew he was farewelling Monica, his
wife, and his four daughters and was in the government jet,
the one Queensland Premier Peter Beattie used, flying to
Richmond with three anaesthetists and a physician—Brian
Pezzutti, David Scott, Paul Luckin and Paul Shumack.
194
Kesdam
The first day Peter had come to Kesdam, he had been
begged by an American doctor called Scott to stay and
help. The two Indonesians, Dr Arasanda and Dr Edison,
had talked in their own language in front of him about how
they didn’t need any outsiders to help. The American
understood what they were saying and chastised them
animatedly for being so unrealistic and ungrateful; Scott
was very helpful to the team that first day, but they never
saw him again. In that discussion Peter let Dr Arasanda
know that he was a senior officer in Australia’s military
reserve. Dr Arasanda visibly relaxed, sensing that Peter
was responsible and understood chains of command. He
allowed the team to stay.
Within one week, Sharwood and the others had turned
the initially resistant opinion around. When they were
leaving, Dr Arasanda gave the nurses double-cheek kisses,
calling them ‘his friends from Australia’ and videotaping
them. They were mutually sad to say goodbye to each
other by that stage.
David Scott was asked one day via an interpreter by
an Acehnese man, ‘Where are you from?’ David replied
‘Australia’.
The man was amazed and asked, ‘Why are you helping
us and asking for nothing in return?’ David replied simply,
‘Because you are our neighbours.’
Both teams were now winding down operations. They
had been briefed since 4 January that they were due to
return home the weekend coming up. They began the
gradual process of farewelling patients and mentally
preparing themselves for their eventual return home to
normal life, work, comforts, and loved ones.
195
chapter fifteen
Australia Responds
I woke bleary-eyed on Thursday, 6 January 2005, to
images of Prime Minister John Howard on morning
television and breaking news of some description. Too
tired to get myself back to bed, I had flopped during the
night onto the couch—the nearest horizontal surface—
after breastfeeding Pierce for the third time. There had
been no catch-up naps for days. I was half out of my mind
with fatigue.
The strip of information running across the bottom of
the screen began to sink in. The slight nausea I always felt
upon waking too early after one too many nights of broken
sleep, began to give way to excitement as I realised I was
not having a self-satisfied dream about the prime minister
doing my bidding in an important matter—this was real.
Howard was busy hugging someone in front of the
international media. Even then, in my under-the-weather
state, this struck me as not only quite moving, but a
spectacularly insightful thing to do. What nation’s leader
could resile from an agreement that had been sealed with a
196
Australia Responds
sincere embrace and beamed all around the world? John
Howard was hugging Indonesian President Susilo Bambang
Yudhoyono. They were hugging each other. You could never
have imagined it. Never. They were at some kind of regional
summit and the prime minister was being interviewed: ‘This
is a human tragedy on a scale that none of us in our lifetime
has seen and it does require a response above the ordinary,’
he intoned. ‘This is a terrible tragedy for mankind. On
humanitarian grounds alone, a lot of help is needed. But
what we are saying to the people in Indonesia in particular
is that we are here as your friends. There is an old saying
in the English language. “Charity begins at home.” Our
home is this region. And we are saying to the people of our
nearest neighbour that we are here to help you in your
hour of need.’
The Indonesian president was also filmed speaking at
the summit: ‘We are overwhelmed by the Australians’
generosity and we will never forget it,’ he said. ‘Your
presence here means so much to us in Indonesia. It means
that you care,’ he stopped, and then went on. ‘And you
care deeply.’
The toll from the tsunami was being reported as at least
145 000 people dead in eleven countries, with almost as
many missing. Eighteen Australians were believed to have
died. Faced with these appalling statistics, politicians had
found their hearts.
My phone began to ring. Funnily enough, none of the
callers knew about the letter I had sent to John Howard.
They just knew me well enough to know that I would be
thrilled by the latest outcome. They knew Paul was there
and that my level of involvement in the crisis was personal.
The first call was Jen Lloyd, Stu’s mother and a longstanding friend of my mother’s. Jen was enraptured by the
197
ANGELS OF ACEH
prime minister’s decision and slightly incredulous. We
chatted for a while about the tsunami, the horrific losses of
life, Paul being there, his television appearances and those
of the team, the appropriate responses of a nation to such
an event, and how Australia continued to amaze us both.
Then my brother-in-law Graham Swan, who was a
project manager for his own residential building company,
rang to say he was willing to throw his hat in the ring and
contribute his skills gratis. He was drafting a proposal as
he spoke. Paul’s groomsman Guy Sullivan rang. He was a
plumber. He’d seen Paul on the news on Channel Ten. The
two of us discussed the huge plumbing and re-building
issues thrown up by the devastated city of Banda Aceh.
Paul’s sister Linda rang in disbelief and excitement. Linda
had lived in Jakarta for a few years and knew of the
poverty in the kampongs.
When Paul and I had visited Linda while she lived in
Jakarta, we had been struck by the abject poverty juxtaposed with the incredible wealth. You could dine at the
opulent Dharmawangsa hotel having passed people who
had no running water in their homes on your way there.
You could not live in Indonesia, working and travelling
through it, without becoming uncomfortably aware of
the great divide between rich and poor, and the many
culturally and territorially sensitive issues, such as East
Timor and Aceh province.
The poverty seemed so depressing, because you felt that
you could never do anything to change these wretched
lives, and their government would not permit our own rich
nation to interfere in an effort to improve their lives. Our
motives would be judged, perhaps undeservedly, as
suspect. To change this perception, it needed something of
unprecedented magnitude. Such as a tsunami.
198
Australia Responds
Animated out of my round-the-clock lactation stupor,
I suddenly saw the prime minister transformed into
someone who could perform miracles. I emailed a summary of the Sydney Morning Herald’s lead news article to all
the people on my ‘Paul Update list’. Interestingly, the print
version of the Herald had the headline ‘Australia takes
charge in Indonesia’, while the online version proclaimed
‘Howard promises $1 billion in aid’, a far less inflammatory
and more diplomatically helpful headline. Nobody wants
to be bossed about, and that was never the intention.
I felt euphoric. An Alan Moir cartoon appeared in the
Sydney Morning Herald showing a staunch ALP voter
despondently admitting to flashes of admiration for
Howard. This particular decision was not going to be a
mistake. He was Australia’s Prime Minister, not simply the
leader of a political party, and today he had made a wise
decision, which he cannily guessed most Australians would
back to the hilt. He showed he was aware of how aghast
normal Australians felt about the tsunami and how keen
they were to help. He did not underestimate Australians’
generosity. This gift from the Australian people to the
people of Indonesia was going to be administered by
Australians, with the Indonesians assisting. Indonesian
President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono agreed wholeheartedly and it was sealed with a hug with our prime minister.
I picked up more details on the internet. The aid
package Howard had announced on behalf of Australia
included $500 million in direct aid and $500 million in
concessional loans. Indonesia would receive $1.8 billion
over the next five years, which included existing aid from
Australia. Kofi Annan had already made the point that the
disaster was of unprecedented proportions and would
require an unprecedented response.
199
ANGELS OF ACEH
Australia had first sent over doctors and nurses, plus
logistical support, but the next step was to send Australian
tradespeople and town planners. It was a golden opportunity
to help put proper sanitation, roads and safe infrastructure
into place in the rebuilding process. What would be recreated in these impoverished, desperate regions would
hopefully be a testament to both a regional neighbour’s
generosity and the wisdom of the Indonesian president—
help was being diplomatically given, and diplomatically
received. The gesture was generous and constructive, and
the effects would undoubtedly be long-lasting.
I was so excited that I couldn’t eat, couldn’t think.
Whenever I had travelled, especially in parts of Africa and
Asia, my heart had been weighed down by the intractable
poverty I witnessed. In the late nineties while visiting
Indonesia, I had dreamily looked out of an upper window
in Jakarta to suddenly observe a whole family below
washing with what appeared to be a soup ladle, scooping
water from a square tub. The heat, the smells, the ugly
dankness and the incongruity of my own comfortable
setting gave me a feeling of hopelessness and frustration
beyond description.
I had experienced this before, in Africa one winter when
I had seen families packed into small, smoke-filled and
smelly farm sheds. I gave some clothes and colourful little
books to the people I met, for their children. I will never
forget the looks of disbelief on their faces. It made me feel
sad and overall rather useless, in that it was a one-off gift
which would probably have very little impact upon their
lives in total.
I was also conscious that material things, of themselves,
are not the answer in any event. Feeling that you are
worthwhile is the key. Loved and respected. Although true
200
Australia Responds
self-worth can never be achieved through possessions—
because it is something deep within you—under these
extreme conditions, where the surroundings are not even
basic and are a constant reminder that you are low in the
human pecking order, how could you rise above this and
experience self-worth? My two sisters, Ingrid and Libby,
had done charity work in the Philippines. Despite the
grinding poverty they had witnessed, they had reported
that the people were very cheery and outreaching. It was
one of the ironies of life that those with no material
things, and no fretting about worldly advancement, were
carefree and happy. It seemed the clue was in the real
love they had for each other, because the greatest sadness
they experienced was when they lost the people they
loved. Life expectancies were often low in poor regions,
due to some of the negatives which came with crushing
poverty, such as disease, malnutrition, poor health services
and harsh living conditions. Sometimes these were compounded by conflict and extreme regimes. International
poverty is the true ongoing challenge for the nations of
the world.
These thoughts and feelings about the suffering of
people in the world had been gnawing at me for years. And
then the opportunity to do something tangible had come
up. Paul went to Banda Aceh, and I wrote a letter. Now
here was the Australian prime minister responding, it
seemed, almost in person! Who knows if he ever saw it?
There may have been 6000 similar letters faxed that same
day. It didn’t matter. My far-fetched wish had been
granted, before my dazed eyes. Nelson Mandela said, ‘It
sometimes falls upon a generation to be great.’ My nation
and generation were taking up the gauntlet.
I drafted a reply to the prime minister, thanking him.
201
ANGELS OF ACEH
In Jakarta, the Australian embassy staff broke into a
cheer. They had every television set on and had just heard
the good news. The prime minister of Australia had just
made his announcement. Brigadier Ken Brownrigg, one
of the top Australian Defence personnel seconded to the
embassy, slapped Bernard on the back: ‘I have never in my
life been as proud to be Australian as I am today, Bernard,’
he said.
Bernard grinned. He felt the same way.
The next day I checked my emails. There was a steady
flow coming in. There was one from my tutor back in my
early readership days at the Bar, Sandy Street SC. In his
usual upbeat and supportive way he had written, ‘Good on
the Saint! Happy New Year and keep up the sterling
effort!’ It was a longstanding joke between us. He used to
tease me that Paul should be canonised, for his father and
husband skills. Now Paul was in a disaster zone.
My sister Ingrid emailed from Frankfurt. Ingrid was an
in-house counsel for Deutschebank there. She had just
read in the European edition of the International Herald
Tribune an article about the Australian civilian volunteer
medical team in Banda Aceh operating at Kesdam on a
patient named Zaini, who had had half his leg amputated.
Dr Paul Luckin was quoted as saying sadly that the
chances of survival were still pretty grim. Ingrid went on
to say that she was picking up on the very positive press
that Australia was receiving. In all the mass of news in
Europe, a small Australian team in a remote corner of
Indonesia were getting detailed coverage in Europe.
Australia was being portrayed internationally as a highly
professional, humanitarian country. The prime minister’s
202
Australia Responds
donation of aid had been covered separately and had also
been very well-received. For days, CNN and the BBC ran
a league table of donor countries and Australia consistently
topped the list.
Germany was coming a close second on the donation
table, followed by Britain. Japan, the Netherlands, Canada
and Norway were close behind. Ingrid felt the Germans
really admired the generous move by Australia. A few
colleagues had asked Ingrid if it made her even more proud
to be Australian, as her countrymen were so generous. She
proudly mentioned that her brother and brother-in-law
were in the thick of it, and her colleagues marvelled that
someone they knew of was there. They were only six
degrees of separation away from the desperate tsunami
need, and the practical, real-life response.
People in the world felt the need and were responding
to the call in every way they could. In all the bombardment
of bad news, to hear of Australia’s generosity was very
welcome.
203
chapter sixteen
Emergency Care
If a few hundred car crash victims, some with pneumonia,
presented to an Australian Emergency Department in one
day, it would make headlines. If some had tetanus too,
a police cordon might be formed around the hospital. Yet
this, with a few exceptions, is what Norm Gray and Lisa
Dillon were effectively faced with every day in Banda Aceh.
In the Emergency Department at Fakinah Hospital,
patients were presenting at a rate of at least 300 per day.
Norm Gray was running the department in conjunction
with an Indonesian urologist. Nurses Karyn Boxshall and
Lisa Dillon and SCAT paramedic Jeff Gilchrist were
working between the Emergency Department and the
ward and there was a mere handful of Indonesian doctors
and nurses. It was ridiculously busy, but, as Mother Teresa
once said, ‘Never worry about numbers. Help one person
at a time, and always start with the person nearest you.’
Lisa was an emergency nurse from Westmead. She was
married to Chris, a fellow nurse. She was pretty, with
golden hair and a big smile. She was in her mid-thirties and
204
Emergency Care
always ready with a laugh and a quip. When she had been
telephoned by her Senior Nurse Manager late one night
and asked to go on a trip, she had initially thought it was an
invitation to go on a shopping jolly. This could not have
been further from reality but, once the request had been
clarified, she was more than happy to go. Lisa had undergone disaster training in the past and had also been to
Korea with the Australian paralympic team. Her sense of
humour was helping her in Banda Aceh, and it was a boon
for the suffering patients, and for her team-mates. She and
Norm bounced ideas off each other and kept morale high.
They shared the desire to keep patients pain-free and cared
for in a way which most resembled what they could offer
back at home.
Norm Gray and the urologist initially did not think
much of each other’s skills. Their techniques and
approaches to patient care were different. Everything—
how they diagnosed, triaged and treated—was different. It
was training, it was culture, and it was influenced by
resources and expectations. ‘Oh, no—this is bloody
hopeless,’ thought Norm on day one. His heart sank. He
had a huge job ahead of him but this doctor, in whom
he had no confidence as far as professional trust was
concerned and whose methods seemed so unorthodox,
was his stable-mate. In Australia, where two doctors are
working side by side, they share observations, advice, and
often assist each other. If there is time, they may quickly
run a treatment plan past the other to see if they agree, or
have a professional comment to make. They would make
sure that the patient was being assisted to the maximum
degree. In Fakinah, the other doctor was keeping information to himself, even though this might compromise the care
being provided. It was frantically busy, but the frost was
205
ANGELS OF ACEH
palpable. Any advice sought or offered by Norm was
rebuffed. No clinical opinion on a case was ever proffered.
But Norm persevered. Polite, inclusive, and clinically very
competent, he wore the other man down. After the first few
days, the urologist began to say good morning to Norm
when he arrived, and the forbidding scowl was eventually
replaced with a smile. The ice was beginning to melt.
Many of the cases they saw had multiple dirty wounds,
with infection creeping into the muscle layers, fat and tissue.
One day the urologist asked Norm to give some sedation to
a patient. The wound was so ingrained with dirt that
cleaning was not going to help. It would become a vat of
bubbling pus if they didn’t do something. Norm gave the
patient ketamine while the urologist scrubbed the wound
with a hard brush dipped in iodine. It was one of a myriad
similar cases, but now at least they were working together.
Norm adopted the technique of cutting away dead flesh
with a scalpel or a pair of scissors, whilst he had the patient
prone on a white plastic body bag, on a bench. Sometimes
there was an abscess which needed to be pierced and
drained. He would open it to let the brownish ‘sewer water’
out. Sometimes gas would escape and, more often than not,
greenish-brown pus. He always anaesthetised first.
One day he had watched speechlessly as an unknown
Asian doctor walked up to a sitting, fully conscious patient
and started cutting her mangled foot with a blade. She
shrieked, as one might expect. It was spine-tingling and it
made Norm ill. Reacting instinctively, from the core of
everything he stood for, he grasped the doctor by the front
of his shirt. ‘I’ll take it from here,’ he said firmly, while the
patient sobbed gratefully. The seeming savagery was what
shocked Norm. He was a tough Aussie bloke, renowned
for his calm, quiet nature, but he was knocked about by
206
Emergency Care
this seemingly primitive outlook towards a fellow human
being. He heard many screams from elsewhere in the
department, but he couldn’t be everywhere at once.
He was aware that the theatres were always in demand
and so, whatever procedures could be performed in the
Emergency Department, to quell the flow to theatre, were
being done. If the debridements were serious, or if amputation was required, he sent the patient to the ward for
inclusion in the surgery list. But you had to be careful that
the patient didn’t die of septic shock in the meantime.
Pustulent wounds and lung infections could be a fatal
combination.
Sometimes a patient presented with suspected tetanus.
This horrific disease causes paralysis as the muscles
throughout the entire body gradually stiffen. One young
man admitted to the ward became so stiff he could no
longer open his mouth to drink. They gave him fluids
(Hartmann’s fluid or saline) intravenously and pain relief.
Eventually, his chest wall hardened and breathing was no
longer possible. They put a tongue depressor in his mouth
to prevent him grinding and eventually crushing his own
teeth together. He foamed at the mouth and died with what
was known as a ‘devil’s grin’ or ‘sardonicus’, a contorted
grimace caused by the muscles of the face being pulled
back into an unnatural grin. It was the visible irony of the
disease that the patients grinned in this manner, while they
suffered greatly and died a ghastly and drawn-out death.
Tetanus usually took two to twelve days to manifest
itself, if the spores were in the body. These came from
the soil and manure in the community’s farms, which the
tsunami had washed everywhere. When patients presented
in the Emergency Department, Norm was usually told
by the accompanying family member that the person was
207
ANGELS OF ACEH
suspected of having tetanus. The team tried to make them
as comfortable as possible—hydrated and pain-free—but
they could not cure them as they simply did not have
the resources. Such patients eventually became hypersensitive, at the slightest sound or movement, even a hand
clap or when brushed by someone walking past.
Tetanus was almost never seen in Australia. There had
been one case reported in New South Wales in 2003, none
in 2002 and none in 2001. Most Australian cases tended to
be older women who were never immunised. They were too
old to have been given it as a regular childhood innoculation, and became exposed when tending their gardens in
their retirement. It was a cruel disease and it relied upon a
decent vaccination program to keep it at bay in a population
such as the one in Aceh province. It was not something you
might have looked for immediately, but Norm had seen
cases when he had worked in Rwanda and recognised it.
There was one thing which didn’t faze Norm at Banda
Aceh—earth tremors. Coming from New Zealand he was
used to them. Norm was a major in the Australian Army
Reserve. He had studied at Otago University in Dunedin
and ended up in Perth, where he was a specialist emergency
physician at Fremantle Hospital. He was now an Australian,
except for the All-Black barracking bit! Fortunately, citizenship didn’t depend on denouncing this. He had seen a bit in
life from his time serving in East Timor and Rwanda.
His dad had died when he was in Rwanda. That was
hard. Norm was a father himself with two boys, Connor
aged twelve and Rory aged nine. And unless his sons
happened to play one day for the Wallabies, he would keep
his secret rugby loyalty and never switch. The boys’
Scottish mother had left her husband, Norm, three years
ago. The boys loved their dad, but the Army was never
208
Emergency Care
going to be their choice of career, they assured him. Why
go out bush and get dirty and tired, when you could be
having fun on a ship or in a jet, they asked him. His boys
made him laugh.
By the end of his time at Banda Aceh, Norm and the
urologist had developed a genuine admiration for each
other. They had each learned a great deal from each other.
Norm found his colleague tireless—on duty from early
morning and there all day, never taking breaks and never
seeming to leave at night. The patients they were seeing
and the work they were dealing with was beyond what
normal doctors in everyday life ever have to deal with, yet
they were managing, they were developing a strong professional relationship and even eventually sharing the odd
macabre joke to alleviate the tension.
Karyn Boxshall divided her time between Norm’s Emergency
Department and the ward at Fakinah Hospital. An emergency nurse from the Royal Perth Hospital in Western
Australia, she had always wanted to work in a disaster
situation, where her emergency skills would be used to
their utmost. For her, Banda Aceh was the ultimate. It was
all she had ever trained for.
Every day they would do a ward round. Sometimes
they would be accompanied by some of the Indonesian
nurses and doctors. The strangest aspect for Karyn, in this
climate of very unusual happenings and experiences, was
the total absence of paperwork. Paper administration
dominated her practice in Australia. Here, radical lifesaving care was the paramount concern and the luxury of
documentation came second. Pens, paper and clipboards
were simply unavailable.
209
ANGELS OF ACEH
Each day, as they changed dressings on wounds, they
wrote on the dressing what date they changed it and when
it had to be next changed.
Initially rather sceptical about what type of people she
would be tending in Banda Aceh, Karyn soon realised that
the Acehnese were unusual people. Given their injuries and
personal tragedies, it would have been completely understandable if they had been irritable and incessantly
complained. Instead, each day the patients on the ward
greeted her with happy smiles and warm appreciation. Their
situation had not crushed their spirits at all. She couldn’t
quite believe it, but it was very rewarding for the nurses.
Karyn, Lisa and Adrian went through the ward,
inoculating dozens of patients against tetanus. The babies
cried but the team persisted—they would thank her one
day, she thought, if they could understand.
After days of no real showering, no shampooing, no
blow-drying, Karyn’s hair stank and was becoming slimy.
Normally her long blonde hair was glossy and swung
freely, shining as she walked. The sweat build-up, combined with insect repellant, sunblock and particles which
landed in the humidity on her blonde mane had made it
thick and dull. Her hair had become so rancid that she
wanted to retch one night when she rolled over on it and
breathed in the smell. She had one of the other nurses
braid it back away from her face. She had also developed
painful cysts under her arms from blocked sweat glands
from anti-perspirant build-up, and possibly from the doxycycline she was taking for malaria protection. There was
one small plastic, low-walled camp shower in the courtyard which the fireys had set up with a bag of water at the
top which sat warming in the sun. The bag hung low due to
the weight of the water, so you had to crouch to get under
210
Emergency Care
it. Smelly water trickled out of it and you ended up hot and
sweaty just trying to get washed.
On 6 January, the day before the team left, it rained
heavily. The monsoonal rains were starting, making life
even more difficult for the many homeless Acehnese. They
were sheltering under bridges and in damaged buildings,
attempting to cook food outdoors and stay in good health
in remote areas along the West Sumatran coast, far from
support. The last thing they needed were chest infections,
fungal problems and diseases, which thrived in moist,
muddy conditions where sewers over-ran and drinking
water became contaminated. Puddles were a perfect haven
for malaria-carrying mozzies to breed in.
For some the deluge was welcome for one reason—you
could have a long-awaited shower in it. Terry Jongen
offered Karyn his shampoo and conditioner, sweetsmelling liquid gold. Karyn was concerned about going in
the rain in her swimming costume, not wishing to offend
her devout Muslim patients. But James Branley (in his
best infectious diseases physician capacity) urged her, as
an important health measure, to take advantage of the
opportunity to have a thorough wash-down. Tentatively,
she walked out of the door of the hospital, self-conscious in
her swimming costume top and board shorts. The patients
all burst out laughing at seeing her becoming drenched.
But it was utter bliss.
211
chapter seventeen
Last Days at Fakinah
Dr James Branley was making headway on the ward
at Fakinah. One of the first patients he had seen after
arriving was Morita, a young woman of about 27 years of
age. She was septic with pneumonia, after inhaling
seawater in the maelstrom of the tsunami, and was near
death. Her lungs were heavily congested and she was
coughing up thick, brown ‘gutter water’, while gasping for
breath. The water had been contaminated with everything
imaginable—sewage, fuel, soil, bits of wood and metal. It
was salt water, so it burnt her lungs too. Then, as so often
happened, the fluid in her lungs became infected, killing
off some of the lung tissue, which is normally clear, pink,
vibrant and spongy. If you could have seen these lungs,
they would have looked brown, partly necrotised, slimy
and flaccid. Morita was very dehydrated and had not eaten
for days. Her husband, who had survived, encouraged her
to live.
James’ work overlapped with that of Norm Gray in the
Emergency Department, and with the surgeons, Sudhakar
212
Last Days at Fakinah
and Annette. He was also helped greatly by a doctor who
had come from Switzerland, Dr Rolf Streuli.
Some of the patients James cared for were medical,
meaning that they had illnesses caused by the tsunami.
Many had pneumonitis (inflammation of the lungs), or
aspiration pneumonia, infected eyes and eardrums. At one
stage he, Lisa and Karyn went through the ward with the
Indonesian staff and put drops in every patient’s eyes and
ears. The filthy tsunami water had seeped into these
sockets and pockets in their bodies.
Some of James’ patients had injuries which required an
operation, and were classified as surgical patients. The
truly unlucky had both illness and injury, which had a big
impact on how well and how quickly they would recover.
A lung disease, which makes you weak and struggle to
breathe, is hard enough to bear without having a painful,
infected leg wound as well.
Fitri was a young girl and a surgical patient in the care of
Sudhakar and Paul. She had bled so much that her haemoglobin level had dropped to 3.5 (normal is 13). There was
no blood to give her. She also appeared to have had some
sort of malnutrition prior to the tsunami and, by the time
the team saw her, she had not eaten for days. She had deep,
penetrating injuries from tsunami flotsam. Pockets of gas
had started to form in the poor girl’s legs, which were
becoming like popping bubble-wrap (this is called ‘crepitus’
and can be a sign of gangrene). She had to have her wounds
attended to surgically.
James would never forget Fitri because, as she
recovered, she would beam at James and the other team
members. Despite her suffering, she would always give
them her best smile. The TV journalists wanted to film her
as a poster-girl for the tsunami. James, always conscious
213
ANGELS OF ACEH
of people’s feelings, said to them, ‘Perhaps you should ask
her first?’ Startled, they did. She was still a patient with the
right of privacy. ‘No,’ she said. So they didn’t.
Meulwati was eighteen, but looked even younger. She
had pneumonia and had become hypoxic (her brain had
become oxygen-starved) in the water which had engulfed
her. She was constantly hallucinating, re-living the
tsunami, every day. James felt intense compassion for
her. He used the oxygen saturation meter on her, and
guarded it carefully—it was the only one, and it was vital
equipment.
James and Karyn would do ward rounds together,
where Karyn would note what happened and where
possible get it put into patient records by one of the
Indonesian staff. The charts were kept in the office, rather
than at the end of each bed—since the beds were stretchers on the floor, there was no place for normal hospital
apparatus.
Zahara was a twelve-year-old girl, in hospital because
she had aspiration pneumonia from inhaling tsunami
water. Her uncle was with her. He was the only surviving
adult in her life. James needed to get patients like Zahara
to move the dense build-up of fluid in their lungs.
Annette had given him a great idea she had seen used in
Vanimo, Papua New Guinea. James made a bubble
‘machine’ out of a bottle of water and a straw, with a tiny
dash of green (or sometimes red) cordial added to colour
the water. The patient would blow through the straw and
try to get bubbles happening. To do this they had to take
big deep breaths and blow hard, which in turn exercised
their lungs. It was a very simple, ingenious way of getting
sedentary patients to assist their own recovery. Some
of them were depressed, having lost their families, their
214
Last Days at Fakinah
homes and so when they finally got a hospital bed, they
often lay there stagnating, which was dangerous because
phlegm would settle in their lungs and fester.
This was another example of the team’s improvisation
skills. Their resourcefulness was evident everywhere. The
SCAT paramedics, Jeff Gilchrist and Adrian Humphrey,
had solved the problem of few drip-stands by stringing up
ropes like ceiling streamers, then successfully hanging the
patients’ drips from them. Terry Jongen had even managed
to create traction for a lady’s broken leg, using a weight
made from a bottle of water and some cord. The bones had
to be gently pulled apart to allow them to knit together
neatly and properly. His invention did the trick.
When Bill Griggs turned up at Fakinah on the morning
of 4 January to arrange the airlifting of some of the patients
to Medan for more comprehensive treatment, he told
James, ‘I can take about fifteen patients. They need to be
stabilised surgical patients, adults only and must not need a
relative to accompany them.’ He proceeded to go through
the ward with Sudhakar to identify suitable patients.
Zahara didn’t fit the bill. She was a high-maintenance
medical patient, but her chances for survival would
improve if she could get some decent, advanced-level
medical care. She was sweating profusely, breathing
hard, was quite delirious and needed constant monitoring
and complex medical attention. She also needed more
oxygen than they could spare, and generally more assistance from their minuscule number of staff than they
could give her.
James Branley talked to Bill. ‘Her chances will be best if
she gets out of Banda Aceh to a better-equipped and fully
staffed hospital,’ he said. After some persuasion, Zahara
was added to the magic list, much to the relief of her uncle.
215
ANGELS OF ACEH
To the world at that moment in time she might have been
just one person, but to her uncle she was the world. Her transfer boosted the morale of the team enormously. Her young
life now had a chance of being saved.
James had another patient, a policeman, with a degloving
injury to his foot—the skin and flesh had been peeled off.
He had his young daughter with him. ‘Here, sweetie,’ said
James, giving her a dinosaur. ‘This is for you!’ She smiled
and took it curiously. James had grabbed toys from his
own children’s toy chest as he had frantically packed for
the deployment. They were all boy-oriented, given he had
four sons, but this little girl didn’t seem to mind at all.
James also gave a small green car and a mouth organ to
the little boy on the ward who had stolen everybody’s
hearts—Zulfahmi. On the day before the team left, James
took Australian news reporter Jessica Adamson of
Channel Seven aside. She had asked if she could help.
‘You can help,’ he said, ‘you might be able to somehow find
this young boy’s grandmother. You are possibly the only
chance he has of finding her.’ He gave Jessica a mission—
to find Zulfahmi’s sole surviving relative.
James was keen to work well with the Indonesians and
to be able to relate to his patients. He hadn’t been schooled
by the Australian Jesuits for nothing. He had learned that
you reached out, to be truly kind. You put others and their
needs first. You made an effort. This underlying character
is what had brought him to Banda Aceh in the first place.
That and an understanding and supportive wife, Valeria,
who was a doctor herself—an obstetrician—and was also
raising their four boys, Hugo, Jack, Liam and Callum.
James had bought a book on Bahasa in Jakarta, studied
it on the plane, and he and Paul tested each other. When
James arrived at Fakinah, he wrote a list of commonly
216
Last Days at Fakinah
used Indonesian words on a cardboard box flap and put it
on the dormitory wall above the table where everyone
charged their mobile phones. Sudhakar added a few extra
words to it.
James worked out a way of doing what he needed
to do, without causing waves. He dressed down, in
Australian-style board shorts, and was always chuckling,
always being happy and light-hearted. James had been to
the Bali bombing and was uniformed there. Here, he felt
less threatening. The Acehnese patients had lived
through war, and they connected fear and suffering with
uniforms. He wasn’t about to compound their misery;
they had been through enough already. The reason for
the team attending as civilian rather than military made
sense now.
The fact that James was an infectious diseases physician and microbiologist, and the Head of the Department
of Microbiology for the Nepean and Blue Mountains
Pathology Service in New South Wales was something he
subordinated for the cause. He had no ego problem, and
he was determined to do what he had come here for.
On the ward rounds, he let the Indonesian doctors take
the lead. He would whisper in the ear of the resident
(junior) doctor what he thought should be done and let
the doctor say it aloud as though it were his own idea. He
had a close, cooperative relationship with this young
doctor and they both realised it was the way to achieve
their common goal.
The police ran Fakinah Hospital. James stood to
attention whenever they appeared. If he was using his
stethoscope, leaning over examining a patient, he would
stop, stand upright and snap to attention. He even saluted
them. They loved it.
217
ANGELS OF ACEH
One day, just when the place was starting to become
bearable so far as odour was concerned, about 30 TNI
personnel in full military uniform brought the horrifically
smelly, rotting corpse of the local police chief through the
ward, followed by a fascinated gaggle of press. It was one
of the many slightly surreal happenings James and those
on the ward would witness.
On the whole he was working well with the second
Indonesian medical team. They did not seem threatened
at all by the presence of the Australians and were happy
to trade professional ideas and treatment regimes. There
was Dr Andra, the orthopaedic surgeon, who had a heart of
gold according to Sudhakar; Dr Bambang the anaesthetist;
and Dr Billi the obstetrician, as well as a few general
practice doctors and a number of nurses. There was the
urologist in the Emergency Department—and Dr Luhut. It
had taken Sudhakar some adjustment to get used to the fact
that these last two were police doctors and wore side-arms
around the hospital. It was a tribute to the Indonesians who
had come from outside Aceh to help that they were there to
assist their compatriots, despite having been officially at
war with them days before the tsunami hit.
By about day four, James felt the Indonesians were
beginning to really relax as they started smiling at this
Australian clown of a doctor who wore brightly coloured
surf shorts and made the patients laugh. There was one
policeman with the job of overseeing the ward; he was so
busy he had become extremely frazzled. James spoke to
him, ‘Go to bed!’
‘I cannot! I cannot sleep!’ the man replied. He was dozy
with fatigue but wanted to keep going.
James prepared him a hot drink with four sachets
of coffee, four sugars and some condensed milk. The
218
Last Days at Fakinah
policeman drank it. It was like a tonic. He pepped up and
started buzzing happily around the hospital. Every day
after that, he asked James to make him a coffee.
At one particular clinical meeting James was incredulous
about certain priorities. The Indonesians were talking about
getting a nutritionist. He couldn’t quite believe his ears.
People talking about the quality of diet when there were
people dying of pneumonitis, tetanus, gross infections,
severe injuries? Was the nutritionist going to address these
people’s needs? Fortunately he kept his opinions to himself.
A few days into their deployment, the Australians had
finally cleaned the ward to the point where it no longer
carried the smell of death and decay. As James was walking
through the ward one day, he smelt the most appetising
aroma since arriving in the province. Ratpacks were
nothing on this, the smell was of freshly sautéed chicken
and fragrant steaming rice. Suddenly it became clear to him
what had been meant at the meeting—a cook was needed.
The patients were starving, some had not eaten for days.
Many of them were anaemic and suffering from malnutrition in addition to everything else they were enduring. Now
a couple of cooks from the Indonesian island of Kalimantan
had arrived. He, like them all, had been concerned with
helping the team set up for their own survival, and had
concentrated on giving urgent medical care. The patients
would eat at last. He offered to swap ratpacks with them;
there were plenty of smiles, but no takers.
Lisa and Karyn had made small nursing hats out of face
masks and drawn first-aid crosses on them. In the confusion of milling people—staff, media, patients, relatives,
friends, students, police and whoever else—there were
219
ANGELS OF ACEH
clearly identifiable nurses to approach with medical
problems. The patients were thrilled.
The crowds of people always hanging around the
hospital sometimes proved useful. If you needed to move a
patient, you only had to point. ‘You, you and you, we need
you over here.’ And suddenly you had ten volunteers
lifting the patient with you. There were no hospital porters
and no fancy adjustable pneumatic beds on castors. It was
all done by the good grace of anyone and everyone.
James noticed that the patients, relatives and visitors
did not use a normal greeting with each other. People had
all lost family in this tragedy. Instead of ‘How are you?’
they asked ‘How many?’
Taking a patient history was always a challenge because
of the language barrier and cultural differences. There were
many matters to discuss that would have an impact on their
care—the location and nature of their injuries, prospects for
recovery, how to take their medicine, any other medical
complaints. Prior to surgery, Paul and Annette would point
to the place where it looked bad and ask ‘Sakit?’ (pain) and
where it felt ‘Bagus?’ (good). Sudhakar was in a better
position as he could speak Bahasa and many Acehnese
could speak it also.
Joesra (Yusra) was an interpreter who helped the
team considerably. She was a volunteer and she was
always at the hospital. Her help and the help of those of
the Indonesian doctors who spoke some English was
invaluable and helped prevent misunderstandings and
misdiagnoses. The Indonesian medical student Marthoenis was also a great help. He could also speak English and
would interpret for them, as well as always being on hand
to help move a patient, clean something, or hold a piece
of dressing.
220
Last Days at Fakinah
Apart from injuries and normal non-tsunami-related
medical problems, there were many diseases which were
caused by the disruption of proper sanitation—from the
consumption of affected food, which couldn’t be stored
properly and festered in the heat, or was not cooked in a clean
environment; or from the contaminated water supplies, or
the mosquitoes breeding in the many puddles created by the
tsunami and the monsoonal rains. James was on the lookout
for everything from less commonly known diseases such
as shigellosis, meloidosis, amoebiasis and leptospirosis to
typhoid, cholera, tetanus, rabies, malaria and dengue fever.
He had made the laboratory at Fakinah useful, testing
patients’ bodily fluids to enable more targeted antibiotics to
be prescribed for various infections and lung conditions.
James would draw the drugs he needed from the
pharmacy. The Australians had brought these supplies
with them, but they diplomatically allowed the Indonesians to be in charge. The pharmacy, run by a Dr Rummer,
was on the ground floor, beneath where the team slept.
The Indonesian team was very hard-working. Apart
from the specialist doctors and a number of nurses, a band
of general helpers had arrived, wearing bright orangeyellow T-shirts. They tidied the hospital grounds, emptied
bins, and swept corridors. They used stiff brooms made of
twigs tied together. It worked a treat.
The hospital was looking colourful, almost festive, as it
was festooned with damp clothing which had been washed
and was hanging on lines strung up everywhere.
Relations were now good between the Australians and
the Indonesians. The second team which had arrived were
keen to work well with the Australians. CASTA, for their
part, no longer felt as though they were treading on
someone else’s turf.
221
ANGELS OF ACEH
James was usually the only Australian doctor on the ward
when the surgeons and anaesthetists were operating at
Fakinah and Norm was in the Emergency Department.
Alan Garner was the other designated emergency physician
in the original Bravo team.
Dr Alan Garner was the Medical Chairman for NRMA
CareFlight/New South Wales Medical Retrieval Service
and spent about a third of his time at Nepean Hospital as
an Emergency Medicine Specialist. He had completed a
Masters in Emergency Planning and Disaster Management
and had written on the topic. He had been in Brisbane in
late December when Dr David Cooper called him. He had
had to hastily organise colleagues to cover his work and
then he flew down to Sydney to get the CareFlight cache
ready and join the team. His wife Marie was very understanding, as were their children Lucy (six) and Daniel
(four). Alan had previously been summoned to the Bali
disaster and afterwards he and Marie had discussed the
issue of the ‘rushed departure’—it went with the territory.
CareFlight is a registered charity which runs an
emergency helicopter, road ambulance and fixed-wing
medical retrieval service in New South Wales, employing
doctors who specialise in anaesthetics, emergency
medicine and intensive care. CareFlight has also developed
its own disaster cache to support an Urban Search and
Rescue (USAR) response.
The cache for the USAR taskforce had been designed to
look after the medical team first, then ten critical patients,
fifteen moderate patients and 25 patients with minor
needs. The underlying principle was that the patients had
to be extricated from whatever disaster had befallen them
and then, after immediate stabilisation, be handed over for
care of a longer term nature.
222
Last Days at Fakinah
The CareFlight cache had been packed and ready to go by
the Tuesday evening, 28 December. It would not be sufficient
on its own, so Emergency Management Australia (EMA),
faxed through a 29-page list which would theoretically
provide medical care for 500 people for three days.
Alan Garner and Ken Harrison had gone to Westmead
Hospital, where the pharmacist and nurses bent over backwards to fulfil the list’s requirements. Drugs, bandages,
dressings, urinals, bedpans, syringes. The order was huge
and filling it took all that night. Supplies were also being
flown up pronto from the Commonwealth Serum Laboratory (CSL). Some of the much-needed diagnostic tools,
monitoring equipment, surgical equipment and anaesthetic
equipment were already in the CareFlight cache, but in the
meantime the equipment to outfit the team was being
hastily and methodically put together down at Greenacre
Fire Station. The fireys there were working solidly, assembling a cache of gear which included everything from tents,
sleeping bags, water, rationpacks and eating utensils, to
torches, protective clothing, shovels, brooms and electricity generators. Everything the team needed to enable them
to live in a ‘hostile’ environment.
Once they arrived in Aceh, Alan judged that his services
would be best utilised working initially with Ken, sorting
and managing the cache of equipment. In Bali, he had seen
what a shemozzle could result when stores were not
managed carefully. You ended up with a bunfight, with
people rummaging at random through boxes, and no
supplies that you could find.
He was impressed when he later saw how the Fire
Brigade managed their stocks. Every item had to be
requested and then it was handed over. Whatever came
back was cleaned, re-charged or whatever was needed, and
223
ANGELS OF ACEH
then it was returned to the store. He and Ken were not
going to let Banda Aceh become a stores debacle. You could
use things to their maximum benefit, even if you were
short on supplies, if you managed what you had with
extreme care. Alan stayed with Ken for the first few days
at Banda Aceh until the stores system was humming.
Then he could focus on patient care. One particular
patient affected him greatly. This patient was a 28-year-old
man, an engineer who spoke English quite well. He was
critically ill with aspiration pneumonia, and was becoming
more and more short of breath. He was in respiratory
distress, sweating profusely and his ability to take in air was
severely compromised. Despite his condition, he was determined to give an account of what had happened. His village
had less than 2000 people in it. The tsunami had washed
him out to sea, where he floated 2 kilometres off the coast,
hanging on to a piece of wood. He then managed to work
his way back to shore, a slow process which took him over
six hours. He found that there was not one building left
standing and not a single living person in his village. It was
deathly quiet. He walked north along the coast for two
days, until a fishing boat picked him up. He had then been
flown in from the west coast by the US Navy.
Alan gave him antibiotics and supplemental oxygen,
tried to make him as comfortable as possible, and help
him rest. This patient really needed around-the-clock
intensive care, with three nurses on successive shifts
devoted just to him and specialised medical equipment—
like ventilators and monitors—which they simply didn’t
have. He died during the night. This was a very sad
outcome for those on the ward. They had tried to save him,
and having heard that he had been the last known survivor
in his village and had gone through purgatory to reach
224
Last Days at Fakinah
them made it even harder to take. The media had swooped
on this man. A picture of him and Alan appeared in Who
magazine in Australia, as the story had epitomised the
spirit of the survivors of the tsunami.
Alan felt hollow after the man’s death. You could
rationalise it as an inevitable event all you liked, but you
still wanted to have saved that life. Afterwards, he stood in
the hallway at Fakinah, feeling the dull weight of the loss.
Running over everything he had done, thinking about the
hopelessness of unavoidable mortality. Wishing the man
could have survived. The man had the spirit and the will to
do it—why hadn’t he lived? He had made it thus far.
As Alan rested against the wall, James Branley went
busily past. James noticed his distressed team-mate—he
would never forget that look on his face. James stopped,
put his hand on Alan’s shoulder, and offered a few words of
comfort. They shared a quiet moment. They had all ‘been
there’. There was nothing you could do about it.
In the last few days in Banda Aceh, the team commandeered
the airconditioned offices upstairs at the back of Fakinah
Hospital. There was enough sleeping space for six people.
To decide who would get a spot, they all went into a ballot.
Ken Harrison told Paul that he had won a spot. Paul
asked, ‘Who put me into the ballot? I didn’t want to go
into the ballot!’ Ken had put all 28 names into the ballot.
It offered respite from sleeping in the crowded, stiflingly
warm dormitory, with its nightly nasal orchestra. Paul
felt that someone who worked in the heat all day should
have the benefit of it. After all, he was working in
Fakinah’s operating theatre, which was cooler than many
other places.
225
ANGELS OF ACEH
Rosie Clifton had also won a spot upstairs. These were
the best of nights for Rosie. She had worked extremely
hard and now she could actually sleep properly, out of the
oppressive heat.
It was the evening of 6 January and Mike Flynn was
pacing like a fractious lion. He had given the Sigli Three—
Annette Holian, Brian Pezzutti and Ray Southon—strict
instructions: leave at four, so you will be home before night
falls and the curfew comes into effect. Travel after dark
was forbidden in Aceh province and the UN had required
permits for their personnel to travel outside the metropolitan area. The province was controlled strictly; the ceasefire
between GAM and TNI was being managed tightly, to be
effective. Mike had also heard that there had been another
shooting incident out in Aceh province, and he was not
taking any chances.
But where were they? Frankly, all in the team were a bit
concerned, but couldn’t do anything. They knew this one
was pretty much completely on Mike’s shoulders. Some
tried to take his mind off it, discussing the team’s departure
from Banda Aceh, scheduled for the next day. There were
many aircraft movements, particularly as dignitaries and
world figures were beginning to arrive. The possibility that
the airfield would be closed and no departures permitted
when they were due to go was a reality they had to deal
with mentally. They wanted to get home to their families—
and get there safely. The earth tremors were still a constant
variable, which could change anything at a moment’s
notice. Nothing was guaranteed.
Mike knew the Sigli Three had to get back somehow,
they knew the whole CASTA team was about to pull out,
226
Last Days at Fakinah
and that they were all leaving together at first light. He
ran over some scenarios in his mind. If they had broken
down on some dodgy road in the dark in strange territory,
could he muster the resources at short notice to go and
find them, rescue them and return them in time for their
flight out? Would he be placing more people at risk? Oh,
for a portable NRMA road service! He began the sketch
of a backup plan in his mind. The possibility of them
being caught up in a hostile situation—a kidnapping or
worse—was not something he could seriously dwell on
right now.
Meanwhile the three had wrapped up surgery at Sigli
Hospital at around 4 p.m., as planned, but had been waylaid by the MSF and their hosts, who invited them to stay
for a celebratory champagne. It was Brian’s birthday and
it seemed boorish to decline. They were also rather wound
up after the whole deployment’s intensity. It was probably
not going to hurt to stay a little longer. There had been a lot
to be sad about, now was a chance to lift the spirits with
happy human contact and friendship. Ever-conscious of
their ambassadorial role, they decided to seize the brief
opportunity with both hands.
After an hour or so they set off. Night fell as they drove
the couple of hundred kilometres back to Banda Aceh. The
mobile phones were not working, but Annette managed to
send an SMS to Mike.
He received it anxiously. Let it be good news.
At first he was startled, but then he roared with
laughter. In the dark of the vehicle and unable to see the
mobile phone buttons, Annette had texted: ‘All Ok. Still
inbound. Annette, asian and ray.’ It broke the tension for
Mike. He realised she must have meant Brian, not ‘asian’.
They were safe. Hallelujah!
227
ANGELS OF ACEH
When their car finally pulled in, he barely waited for
them to alight before enveloping them all in an overjoyed
bear hug. They were surprised—Mike was generally not
the demonstrative type—but they were pleased. It was
heartening to be so cared about. Then they realised how
worried he must have been. They headed up to the dormitory to greet their relieved colleagues and to ensure they
themselves also had all their things ready for departure the
next day.
228
chapter eighteen
Coming Home
Paul climbed into the tip-truck. There were no supplies
this time, just the team and the team’s luggage. It was a
scary truck ride back to the airfield. He shouted to the
others to duck from time to time, as they swept under
branches. Everyone was excited to be going home, but at
the same time was sad to be leaving the Acehnese, who
needed them.
They had all risen at 5 a.m. on Friday, 7 January. The
early morning types—the larks—had woken all sprightly
as usual. Today Paul felt slightly nauseous. It was the
intense fatigue.
The incoming Team Echo had not arrived yet. They
were on a commercial aircraft somewhere, flying from
place to place. The CASTA team members had listened at
their various briefings to the updates on Echo’s movements
with heavy hearts, realising with each instalment of news
that the chances of a handover were becoming slimmer.
There were many theories flying about, not the least of
which was that the commercial aircraft was the same plane
229
ANGELS OF ACEH
type as the 737 aircraft which had hit the water buffalo and
crashed earlier in the week and was therefore considered
too much of a risk to land, necessitating their transfer to an
Air Force plane.
This morning the CASTA team members despite being
dog-tired were in fairly chirpy moods and when they were
advised that an Estonian medical team was due to arrive
any day at Fakinah, wrote a welcoming message on a
whiteboard, underneath a drawing of an Estonian flag.
They also messed with the minds of the incoming Echo
team, taping up a sign telling them to ‘Please keep BBQ
plate clean and put the empty beer bottles in the recycling’.
The CASTA team arrived at the airfield early in the
morning and found it congested. It had never been
designed for this amount of air traffic. Overnight it had
become an international airport. Australians were in the
tower, helping out with the traffic controls. It was hairraising work, and needed cool customers.
The airfield was teeming with forklifts and machinery
unloading and loading aircraft holds. The team looked on
longingly. If only they had had these when they first
arrived. The area surrounding the airfield was also
unrecognisable. One hundred and thirty aid agencies had
arrived, creating a busy tent city.
Kofi Annan, the UN Secretary-General, arrived at the
airfield just before 10 a.m. He was surrounded in the heat
and noise by a dense media scrum as he walked, looking
unusually uncomfortable and harried, to the terminal.
After about half an hour, he returned, still followed by the
same gaggle of press, to a helicopter waiting to fly over
Banda Aceh so he could see the effects of the tsunami.
The visit of the UN dignitary had the same effect that
Colin Powell’s visit had two days earlier. No aircraft
230
Coming Home
movement was permitted. The team had to wait at the
airfield for more than six hours. They would get to Jakarta
some twelve hours after leaving Fakinah hospital.
Having no overlap with the incoming Echo team was a
considerable downside to the departure of CASTA. A handover would have been preferable as nobody wanted to leave
the patients without cover. The team had cared for them in
their time of need and the Acehnese thought the care had
been very special; they had grown attached to each other.
The day before, one of Karyn Boxshall’s patients, a
young woman named Patria whose husband and child
were missing, had cried. She had heard the team was
leaving and she said to Karyn, ‘I don’t know what I will do
now. You are like my family. You have to go back to your
families, but you take a part of me with you.’ Karyn held
Patria’s hand and squeezed it. Swallowing hard.
Norm had been at a meeting the day before he left. It
was the usual morning clinical meeting. Or so he thought.
Then the urologist asked to say a few words. ‘Thank you
very much,’ he said in halting English. ‘We appreciated
your assistance. We could not have done without you. We
will miss you. Thank you for working with us. Thank you
for coming and helping us.’ He choked as he spoke, and
Norm felt his own heart lurch. He knew that their relationship had changed during their time together. He also
realised that he and the urologist had never learned each
other’s names. There had never been the need, and yet
they had formed a real bond, working together over long
hours tending to desperate patients. By the end, they had
shared patient care, swapped ideas, traded advice, helped
each other out—holding a scalpel here, lifting a limb there,
231
ANGELS OF ACEH
injecting sedation for each other’s patients. One day, after
he had returned home, he would learn the good doctor’s
name was Dr Lufti.
The clerical assistant who kept the records in the
Emergency Department spoke up too. ‘Thank you,’ he said.
‘We are sad that you have to go. What you did here was
very good.’ He paused, and his eyes filled with tears. ‘We
will not forget you.’ Norm almost couldn’t bear it, it gave
him a tight chest, but he thought it was a lovely farewell.
The time here had been fraught with emotion, and he
wanted to keep it all inside until he got home. Norm and
the urologist had graduated from mutual disdain and suspicion to total professional trust and admiration. It was a
lesson for life, for both of them.
Norm didn’t say goodbye to the patients, even though he
had admitted many of them to the ward and to surgery. It
was partly self-preservation, and partly a desire to remain
strong in their eyes. He felt that they were best supported
by him presenting a strong, professional persona. The
nurses were saying goodbye to the patients and seemed to
do so happily. Norm couldn’t risk showing how he felt, so it
was better to slip away. He hated the fact that he was
leaving—there was still so much to do.
Sudhakar had braced himself and left Fakinah without
looking back. He had his own reasons to feel heavyhearted. He didn’t know what would happen to Zulfahmi,
and there was nothing more he could do.
The team left everything—stretchers, bedding, supplies.
Paul tried to leave his bag of clothes, but some kind soul
packed it into the truck. Shmackers finally found his alarm
clock when he was assembling all his gear to leave. He
found it tucked in his shoe in one of his bags. Funnily
enough, the alarm was set. He realised with horror that it
232
Coming Home
was set for 6.30 a.m. east coast of Australia time, which
was about 2.30 a.m. Banda Aceh time. The mystery of the
annoying middle-of-the-night alarm was finally solved. He
would never be able to own up to that one.
One of the most comforting things about leaving was
knowing that they had done their best to set it up well for
Echo, the incoming team, who would have accommodation,
a pharmacy, a functioning operating theatre with anaesthetic machines which actually worked, a thriving ward
and Emergency Department, a kitchenette, a more reliably
working water supply, toilets and camping showers. It had
been a hard slog moving those 17 tonnes of supplies in disgustingly difficult conditions. Any thought that their set-up
and supplies might be in jeopardy was totally demoralising.
They left Yusra, their kind interpreter, in charge.
Sudhakar was at the airfield, still wondering about
Zulfahmi and what fate would befall him, when suddenly
he saw Paul Van Buynder walking beside the runway,
carrying Zulfahmi in his arms, followed by an entourage of
reporters. They had earlier sent an SMS to Sudhakar: ‘We
have Zulfahmi and Yusra with us. Will be at the airport
in 15 mins. Jessica, Ch 7’, but René had borrowed his
phone to call Switzerland so Sudhakar had never seen this
message. It all came as a delightful surprise. Sudhakar was
overjoyed to see Zulfahmi. The little boy felt the same
way—this kind doctor had made him better. Now they
could have a proper goodbye.
As Sudhakar and Zulfahmi were being interviewed,
concerned team members questioned Yusra. ‘Weren’t you
taking care of our stuff?’ they asked.
‘Yes!’ she replied. ‘But the police told me “Thanks very
much, we’ll take care of it from here”.’ Some of the team
members were very worried that the supplies might be
233
ANGELS OF ACEH
stolen, but Liz reassured them, reminding them of the
police chief who would shoot any would-be thieves. They
were later advised by the Echo team that everything was
present and accounted for on their arrival.
As Sudhakar hugged Zulfahmi, he saw Paul Dunkin
watching and called him over to join in. Paul was watching
this happy scene from afar, but he had to protect his own
heart here. He had his own life to live after this, and it
would have been just one wrench too many. He smiled and
waved goodbye from a distance. Sudhakar understood.
Zulfahmi smiled.
Sudhakar thought about Zulfahmi on the flight to Jakarta.
The last he had heard, Jessica was still trying to track
down the boy’s grandmother or any other distant, living
relatives. Sudhakar was fretful about him—he knew there
was a risk that he would never find any family again or that
he would be picked up by the Muhammadiyah group,
which was an Islamic group operating orphanages.
Sudhakar had approached the Americans at the airfield
the morning of the day CASTA was leaving. The Americans
were staging retrievals up and down the coast and were in
the best position to help. Perhaps one of their helicopters
could include this in a mission? He had urged US Lieutenant
Lisa Peterson, the US Navy doctor on board the USS
Lincoln, to: ‘Please help find a relative of this child.’ He
explained his concerns for the child, mentioning his darkest
fears—of child abuse, or that the child would be recruited
into a terrorist group. ‘I will talk to my superiors and get back
to you,’ Lisa had said. ‘I cannot promise anything.’ It was an
awkward situation. Nobody knew where the grandmother
had been left behind, and the language barrier meant that
234
Coming Home
it was hard to work it all out. There were hundreds of
people who had been collected, from many places along
the coast. There were thousands, in all sorts of different
accommodation. Their homes and streets were gone. How
were they going to find this child’s grandmother?
Sudhakar had taken photographs of Zulfahmi on his
digital camera and given his whole camera plus its memory
stick to the Americans, so they could show villagers the
child and find the one living relative. After farewelling
the team out at the airfield in the morning, Yusra went back
to Fakinah Hospital with the Americans and Zulfahmi.
There they discovered a patient who was a village elder from
Zulfahmi’s region. Together they pored over a map and
obtained detailed information about where best to search. It
was like looking for a needle in a haystack.
Some of the team slept on stretchers in a tent at the
airfield, waiting for the flight to leave. It was hot and
tedious but their weary bodies didn’t notice. They were
finally allowed to depart. They boarded the plane and
Sudhakar turned his phone off. There really was no point
in getting your hopes up. It was the end of the deployment
and, whilst it would have been very satisfying, it was
probably not meant to be. He would get on with life but
never forget the small, lonely boy who had embodied the
true sorrow of the tsunami. Zulfahmi had affected them all
deeply.
Sudhakar told himself that, in the scheme of things, it
was just another child’s welfare. He rationalised—many
had died, this one was lucky to be alive. Who knew where
he would end up? The community would surely look out
for him. But Sudhakar couldn’t help how he felt—he loved
his own sons very much and couldn’t help feeling anxious
for this child who would now have no love in his life, at a
235
ANGELS OF ACEH
time when he needed it most. Zulfahmi was recovering
from surgery on his injuries. Sudhakar felt strongly that no
child was ‘just another child’. Who knew what one particular life was destined for? It was such a shame that this
story couldn’t end more positively. He would just have to
get over it.
Leaving the airport in Jakarta that evening was a
shemozzle. Some of the team members left the plane,
followed by some Acehnese refugees, followed by more
team members. The Australians and Acehnese haphazardly
filled two buses. Luggage was intermingled even though
destinations were different. The two separate groups
should have been put on two separate buses, but it hadn’t
worked out that way.
The team had depleted its reservoir of cheerfulness. All
they wanted were showers and sleep. Now that they were
close to it, the delay and kerfuffle were torture. It was a
slow, irritating trip through many boom-gates. Each stop
to let people off meant discussions and raking through
bags searching for which belonged to whom. It was tough
on everyone. Nobody needed this; they had all been strung
out enough.
Sudhakar turned on his mobile when he boarded the
bus, on the way to the hotel in Jakarta. It beeped again and
again, interrupting his morose reverie. SMS messages
from Jessica. ‘Chopper due back in halfa. Has 5 evacuees
but not sure who. They’re going to try again first thing
tmrw if they don’t get her 2nite.’ The very next one read:
‘GOT HER! We r on our way to the hospital.’
Sudhakar leapt for joy and ran around the bus, showing
the message to members of the team. Everyone was thrilled.
Zulfahmi had somehow found his beloved grandmother,
with a bit of help from some Australians and Americans.
236
Coming Home
The team all knew that Sudhakar had grown close to this
child and that the rescue had been a long shot.
Marj and Paul chatted excitedly; everyone was beaming.
This was great news. This was unbelievable. They were
incredulous. Lisa Dillon was thrilled. Zulfahmi had been
Karyn’s and her patient on the ward, and she too had grown
very attached to the plucky little boy. In her eyes, this was
the best thing that had happened on the entire trip.
The next SMS beeped. ‘Of course . . . we went to 5
villages—she was in the last. Amazing pictures, very sad.
When Zulfahmi saw her, reality set in. He says he can now
sleep.’ Sudhakar punched the air with delight.
The Western Australian contingent did not get to stay
overnight in Jakarta despite being bone-weary. The delays
had gobbled up any time for relaxing. The next direct
flight to Perth took off in a few hours, but then there would
not be another until Sunday night, two days away. They
desperately wanted to get home and see their families. The
other option would have been to go via Sydney the next
day, which would add hours and hours of travelling time to
their trip. Terry didn’t mind leaving now, it would let him
attend a motorbike race. They rushed into the hotel, had a
shower, ate something and raced out to the airport for
a flight to Perth via Darwin.
The goodbyes were rushed. Inadequate. Nothing could
be said which really summed up anything. Nobody knew
when they would see each other again. They had formed
very close bonds and they had been in a surreal environment
together. They had laughed, teased, eaten many meals, slept,
worked, helped, cut into people, cried together. Now it was
over, and they hadn’t even thought about what ‘over’ meant.
237
ANGELS OF ACEH
Sudhakar looked out from the bus. The Western
Australian contingent had been forced to leave in the
middle of a wonderful dinner at the Jakarta Hotel, and
were now waiting on the bus, ready to move off. It was
dark, but one lone figure had left the sumptuous table to
see them off outside. The man stood at attention, and then
raised his hand in a farewell salute as the bus pulled away
from the kerb. It was their tireless leader, Mike Flynn.
It was a strange feeling going home for the Western
Australian seven—Sudhakar Rao and René Zellweger, Norm
Gray and Paul Van Buynder, Rosie Clifton, Terry Jongen
and Karyn Boxshall. They knew they would never be the
same again. They had a bond they would share forever.
Sudhakar’s wife, Narelle, bundled her three sleepy
young boys into her car. It was early morning and still dark
as they made their way to the airport. At arrivals, Paul Van
Buynder came out before Sudhakar. He walked into his
wife Jan’s arms and his protective resolve gave way. Goodhumoured throughout the whole deployment, the intensity
of what he had experienced—and undoubtedly overwhelming fatigue—had finally got to him. He had maintained his
cheerfulness the entire time, keeping buried in his heart all
that he had seen and been part of. Now that he was home,
amid love and safety, it surfaced.
Narelle Rao turned away as she saw Paul’s whole body
shudder, not wanting to intrude on such an intimate
moment. Privately she was concerned about whether
Sudhakar would be a complete basketcase. From what
she knew of Paul Van Buynder, he had never struck her as
a particularly demonstrative person. Sudhakar was more
emotional. She worried as she waited. You wanted to
support the effort but you didn’t want to lose your
husband’s psychological wellbeing by doing it.
238
Coming Home
A smiling Sudhakar walked out. He was very happy to
see her and his boys. He was fine. He was still Sudhakar,
but he carried many stories to share with his wife. One in
particular was rather special; it was about a brave little boy
called Zulfahmi.
Paul Dunkin, and a few of the others in the team who
were still awake following a lengthy after-dinner debrief,
remained talking until late in the bar at the hotel in
Jakarta. Sherryn Bates had outdone herself again. The
best champagne and beers on the house. A well-dressed
local Indonesian, sitting with friends, observed them for a
time and eventually came over and introduced himself to
Paul, as he stood ordering drinks at the bar. ‘Where have
you come from?’ he asked. ‘What have you been doing?’
The team looked fairly haggard.
Paul explained that they were Australians who had
come to help in Banda Aceh after the tsunami. How were
they doing up there, the man wanted to know. Paul said
they were doing it tough. They talked for a time about the
Australian relief effort and the Acehnese people, this man’s
fellow countrymen. After a while, the Indonesian’s friends
came over and each of them shook Paul’s hand. ‘Thank
you,’ they said. ‘Thank you.’
Nobody had said anything like this at this stage. It
didn’t compute that people would thank him. Paul hadn’t
even thought about what had been done as something
worthy of thanks. He wobbled inside now. This was very
special. These thanks were sincere and personal, and they
came from Indonesians.
239
ANGELS OF ACEH
Liz sat next to Paul on the Herc between Banda Aceh and
Jakarta. It was noisy, they couldn’t hear each other talk, so
they all passed around photos of their families instead.
Paul sat next to Alan Garner for the Jakarta to Sydney leg.
Qantas, of course.
Paul sat in the plane seat and tried to relax, but he was
in turmoil. Strangely disturbing thoughts were writhing
around his tired brain. Don’t go there, Paul told himself, but
the thoughts persisted. He had been inexplicably torn inside
when he had been told it was time to leave Banda Aceh. He
knew that getting a flight in or out of the place was horrendously difficult. The incoming team was going through a
tortuous time just getting there. When CASTA managed to
tee up the flight out, the team had to seize the opportunity—
the next chance might not have been for days. The chaos
and uncertainty which always accompanies disasters was
multiplied ten-fold for this one.
The fact that the medical team left without a handover
of patient care rankled within Paul. More than that, he was
consumed with guilt about leaving the patients at all. The
Acehnese, who had done nothing wrong and did not
deserve what had happened to them, were suffering
intensely. It was beyond human comprehension what had
happened to them, and here he was, running out on them. It
upset him deeply, but he couldn’t express it to anyone. He
did not even know where to start. These thoughts and
emotions, powerful and distressing as they were, tumbled
around in his head. Even as he adjusted his body in the
plane seat, feeling his weary muscles ache, he felt angry
at himself for having one thought about his own, pathetic,
bodily comfort.
His head was bursting with the stress of concealed
torment. He had no idea that these reactions were normal.
240
Coming Home
He wanted to crawl into the seat-pocket in front of him and
shed all the tears he had kept bottled up in Banda Aceh.
The pragmatic side of his brain tried to talk calmly over the
screaming emotional side. He tried to listen—he needed to
hear it. Needed to hear something now which would stop the
frenzied self-reproach that had hit him without warning.
The emotional side told him that bodies were still being
pulled from the rubble at a rate of a thousand per day
when the team left. The garbage mounds throughout
Banda Aceh were still there—although they were slowly
being moved, cubic metre by cubic metre. The precious
few children who survived were being rounded up and
questioned by aid agencies in order to establish their
identities and histories, with some hope of finding living
relatives. The bedrocks of the society—the children and
the elderly—had been mostly killed. What was going to
fix that? Priceless records and memories had been lost
forever. Countless livelihoods had been destroyed. All the
institutions which rely on an intact society to function—
government, justice, education, security, transport,
health—were effectively trashed. These people he was
deserting were so needy that it defied even broad description, let alone itemisation. In all the tens of thousands
of deaths, the team had saved only a relative handful of
lives. They had not been able to give the people they had
made amputees any paramedical aids such as walkingsticks, wheelchairs, crutches or prosthetic limbs. They
knew that the loss of a limb might consign some to a life
of poverty and physical incapacitation.
Then the pragmatic side of his mind kicked in. It had to.
Paul reminded himself that he and the team had been
gathered together in the Christmas holiday season, from all
across Australia, and at short notice. Nothing like this had
241
ANGELS OF ACEH
ever been done before. CASTA had been a civilian surgical
team, it was a major international disaster, they were the
first on the scene to help, and they were completely selfreliant. They had managed to spread their services across
three hospitals—Fakinah, Kesdam and Sigli. Mike Flynn
had lent himself to the task of coordinating field hospitals
arriving subsequently. The team had managed to do their
jobs well and stay in good health. Nobody had been injured
in the intensely physical, four-fold unloading activity of
17 tonnes of supplies, from plane, to airfield, to trucks, to
upstairs at Fakinah Hospital. It was nothing short of miraculous. Dysentery had been kept to a minimum, despite the
filthy surrounds and shortage of water for cleaning hands
and surfaces. Nobody had gone ‘troppo’.
From Paul’s own perspective, he had gone there to
anaesthetise patients for surgery and had found two dirty
operating theatres with two broken anaesthetic machines
and no monitoring equipment. Through steady scrounging
and tinkering—and the fellow scavenging and fix-it abilities of Watto and Bruce—the three had cobbled together
two working machines, and two monitors. He had been
able to contribute personally. They all had.
Paul knew that the presence of the team had boosted the
morale of the Acehnese. Every life the team had saved was
a bonus, when so many had died in that community. More
importantly, the team had captured the attention of the
world, with the help of the media. The Acehnese would
benefit for years from the donations this had triggered.
The team had left a legacy on many levels.
Apart from the surgical contribution, the team had been
part of a public health effort which had prevented the
possibility of yet another tragic consequence which could
have caused further widespread destruction—think cholera,
242
Coming Home
typhoid and other serious, contagious diseases. A measles
outbreak was detected and scotched.
They had parted on excellent terms with the Indonesians: with both those in charge and the medical staff.
Respect was the cornerstone of every successful relationship. They had managed to find common ground upon
which they could respect each other: they were both there
to help. They had worked hard and side-by-side. Even
with all the language barriers, cultural and religious differences—and the historical and territorial sensitivities—it
had somehow worked.
Yes, parting with the patients had been wrenching for
the team. The Acehnese were the most stoic and positive
people Paul had ever encountered. The memories of
their bright faces, their happy greetings each day and their
obvious gratitude, would stay with him—stay with them
all—forever. The deaths of those they tried so hard to
save would be stowed away deep inside, where only such
recollections can go.
The team members themselves had done the best that
they could. They had all wept at some point—when the
raw sadness occasionally engulfed them—but nobody
folded. Mike Flynn had briefed them that their aim was to
smooth the way for future teams’ arrivals and to alleviate
suffering, as much as they could. This had been their
mission, it had been achieved, and so the mission was then
complete. It was time to go. Time to let others take over.
It was time, as Paul told himself now, to build a bridge, and
get over it.
At Sydney airport, I waited with my sister Libby and
Liam, Darcy, Francis and baby Pierce. The young lads
243
ANGELS OF ACEH
tore around the private room, which had been thoughtfully
set aside for the arrivals from the disaster zone. It was away
from the public eye and allowed for distraught reunion
scenes to take place without embarrassment. There were
friendly personnel from New South Wales Health who
gave us a pamphlet about what to expect on Paul’s return.
Paul had also been given a similar one in Jakarta with a
cheery list of medical symptoms to be on the watch for, such
as indications of malaria, or something even more dire.
Common reactions described in the pamphlet included
feelings of great sadness and grief for what had been
witnessed, and for the overwhelming loss of human life
and devastation. The traumatic events for which the
person had been a participant, even in a saviour role, could
leave the person in a state of abnormal alertness, which
would prevent them from relaxing and feeling safe again.
They might find it difficult to return to normal pursuits and
everyday concerns, feeling that they were trivial in
comparison to what they had been doing, and because
there were people suffering in the disaster zone with
incomparably greater needs. It might be hard to understand your children squabbling over a toy, when you had
seen orphaned children, losing limbs, being strong.
I wondered to myself whether Paul would be okay
emotionally as well as physically. I hoped the mission had
not been at too high a price. We still had four little boys to
raise together. Paul came through the gate and his boys
rushed him. He was smiling widely and we all hugged in a
writhing family swirl of legs and arms and squeals of
delight. Things were looking good.
Paul brought home one souvenir, the little bell he had
found on the shore. It had tolled for him and he never
questioned it. No man is an island. We are all a part of the
244
Coming Home
human family, the world community. When one part hurts,
we all feel it and want to take the pain away. And in one
way or another, when this tragedy happened, we showed
we would. Quietly and quickly, we did what we could.
245
Epilogue
CASTA’s replacement, Team Echo, left Adelaide on
6 January flying with a commercial airline. Echo
expected to arrive in Medan, Sumatra, via Darwin,
later that day. They could not obtain air traffic control
clearance to land in Medan, so they flew to Batam (an
island south of Singapore), Indonesia and then Penang
via Kuala Lumpur the next day. Their aircraft was
unloaded and the cargo and team transported by truck
and bus to Butterworth, Malaysia. They grabbed a few
hours’ sleep before flying by Herc to Banda Aceh,
arriving at dawn on 8 January 2005.
The first operation they performed was emergency
surgery for a gunshot wound. They did their first full ward
round the following morning. Their role in their time there
was to perform reconstructive and restoration surgery—
grafts and skin flap operations.
One of the items they brought, in their ten tonnes of
supplies, were dog biscuits for the emaciated local dogs.
Echo was headed up by Dr Hugh Grantham.
246
Epilogue
Team Foxtrot from Queensland, Australia, arrived on the
morning of 19 January 2005 and Echo departed a few hours
after their arrival. Foxtrot had 25 personnel, with less
emphasis on surgical capability and more on public health.
Foxtrot was followed by Golf in early February, the last of
the acute disaster relief medical teams from Australia.
AusAID arrangements are now in place for long-term needs.
The night after Paul and the CASTA team returned home,
an international fund-raising cricket match was played at the
Melbourne Cricket Ground between teams representing
Asia (including Australia!) and the Rest of the World. It was
Monday, 10 January 2005. It drew a crowd of around
70 000; Paul watched it on television, as did people in 120
other countries. It raised over $14.5 million for the tsunami
relief effort. The CEO of World Vision, Tim Costello, said he
was ‘blown away’ by the level of generosity of contributors.
The Packer family gave $3 million. Others gave what they
could, and then gave some more, as did many corporations.
Tim Costello gave a run-down of how the money would
be spent: 30 per cent on emergency relief, 20 per cent on
economic recovery and community rehabilitation, and the
remaining half on infrastructure and redevelopment.
‘Australia needed to do this. Wanted to do this,’ he said,
after a charity telethon raised a further $20 million in one
night. Generous donations were made continuously over
the days and weeks following the tsunami. He reflected the
views of many as he went on: ‘This is a unity I have never
seen in my lifetime.’
A rock concert was held at the Sydney Cricket Ground
on Saturday, 29 January to raise money for the tsunami
victims. A crowd of 48 000 attended and, by all accounts,
it was a knockout success. The money raised, which was
estimated at almost $2 million, went to a group of charities
247
ANGELS OF ACEH
including the Australian Red Cross, Oxfam Community
Aid Abroad, Unicef and CARE Australia.
MSF was so inundated with donations that they had to
begin returning some of it.
Local communities staged their own fundraising
activities. Stu Lloyd was the MC at a social night at the
West Pymble Bowling Club and raised $46 000. There
were countless examples of such activities. One mother
started packing boxes in her garage to send overseas. All
in all, it has been estimated that over this period the
Australian public donated over $200 million to charity.
Caritas alone received $21 million.
Although it was never a contest, such generosity inspired
other nations and Australia led the field in the amount
donated by any government (a $1 billion Australian aid
and reconstruction package) until it was announced on
Wednesday, 9 February 2005 that the USA was almost
trebling its tsunami aid to $US950 million (A$1.2 billion).
Germany was incredibly generous, as were Britain, Japan,
the Netherlands, Canada and Norway, their donations—
both government and private—totalling hundreds of
millions of dollars. In addition to funds, many, many countries sent practical aid in the form of surgical teams,
NGOs and boxes of aid. Australians also helped in a
practical sense elsewhere than Indonesia. In response to
Australia’s offer of help, the government of the Maldives
requested primary care support (general practitioner-style
services), Sri Lanka—public health, and Thailand and
other places—disaster victim identification services (DVI).
Australian teams were sent accordingly.
The Americans’ immense practical contribution in
Banda Aceh did not go unacknowledged. At the end of
January 2005, the Indonesian Army Chief of Staff,
248
Epilogue
General Ryamizard, made time to visit the USS Abraham
Lincoln to say a personal thank you to the sailors onboard.
At the request of the Indonesian government, by the end
of January 2005, the International Organisation for Migration had agreed to build 11 000 pre-fabricated houses
for homeless Acehnese families. Each is to be 36 square
metres—not large, but they are only intended for use for up
to two years while permanent reconstruction plans are
being developed. They will then be able to be dismantled
and used elsewhere. Thousands of tents have already been
supplied to house some 400 000 families. IOM has a truck
fleet which brings in relief and reconstruction loads,
requested and co-ordinated with the relief agencies.
By the end of January, approximately 108 000 corpses
had been counted in Aceh and another 127 000 people
were still declared missing, with at least 400 000 Acehnese
refugees needing to be re-located. By April, the Indonesian
death toll was 126 915, and 37 063 people were still unaccounted for. The death toll for all eleven affected nations
was estimated to be as high as 200 000.
Father Chris Riley, Australian priest and Founder and
CEO of Youth Off The Streets, has, together with the
State Member for Bankstown, Tony Stewart, founded an
orphanage in Aceh. He is working in co-operation with the
Indonesian government and with Muhammadiyah, an organisation which represents 40 million Muslims in Indonesia and
acts as an aid distributor throughout Aceh Province. They
already operate hundreds of orphanages across Indonesia.
Sudhakar learned about the aims of this group after his return
home and became reassured about their purpose.
Australia sent the ADF (Australian Defence Force),
who set up a hospital in Zainal Abidin Hospital, the main
hospital of Banda Aceh, cleared out the mud-filled morgue
249
ANGELS OF ACEH
it had become, fixed up the equipment and stayed for ten
weeks until it was back on its feet again. HMAS Kanimbla
arrived on 13 January, fully stocked and full of medical
and other personnel.
Prime Minister John Howard visited Banda Aceh on
2 February, and Australia’s then Maritime Commander,
Rear-Admiral Rowan Moffitt RAN, followed up developments with a visit a month later.
In March 2005, it was announced that President Susilo
Bambang Yudhoyono would make an historic visit to
Australia. His mission would be an opportunity to thank
the Australian people in person for their support during
the tsunami crisis. He would attend a meeting of the
Australia–Indonesia Partnership for Reconstruction and
Development (AIPRD), a joint body formed to administer
the aid gift given to the Indonesian people by Australia.
President Yudhoyono’s trip, which was planned for
Wednesday, 30 March 2005, was postponed when an
earthquake measuring 8.7 on the Richter scale rocked
Nias, an island off the coast of Sumatra, south-east of
Banda Aceh, at 11.10 p.m. on Easter Monday, 28 March,
killing an estimated one thousand people and destroying
homes and public infrastructure. He visited Australia
shortly thereafter, on Sunday, 3 April 2005. In April he
signed legislation establishing the Rehabilitation and
Reconstruction Agency for Aceh and Nias (BRR). On
18 May, he lifted the state of emergency in Aceh, and
on 15 August a peace treaty was signed with GAM.
The New South Wales members of the CASTA team
received an award from then New South Wales Premier
Bob Carr and Governor Marie Bashir on Thursday,
17 February 2005. The plaque read: ‘For a job well and
bravely done in responding to the Boxing Day Tsunami,
250
Epilogue
2004’. The governor told the team that she had received
numerous letters and messages from diplomats and envoys of
tsunami-affected areas, and also from countries not affected,
expressing their gratitude and admiration. On 11 May, team
members from all over Australia were awarded recognition
certificates from the New South Wales government.
In September 2005, Australia’s treasurer Peter Costello,
accompanied by his brother Tim, made a goodwill visit
to Banda Aceh to witness first-hand how Australian aid
was being put to good use. The minister was mobbed by
grateful children at a school being re-built with the funds.
It was one of numerous such AusAID/AIPRD projects.
There is a gargantuan reconstruction project underway
in Aceh, with many contributors including Catholic Relief
Services, JRS, World Vision, ACTED, IRC CARDI and
many other agencies and governments. It encompasses
building thousands of new homes, repairing mosques and
setting up community programs for everything from sanitation to education and child protection, to farming and fishing
business recovery. UNICEF alone plans to build 230 new
schools.
Put simply, the world has rolled its sleeves up for the
immense job ahead.
Life has moved on for those who were involved at the
outset in this extraordinary humanitarian effort.
Bill Griggs came home and married his fiancée Maree on
4 February 2005. He recovered from a bout of pneumonia
which he developed at the end of his strenuous time in
Banda Aceh. He continues as the Director of Trauma
Services at Royal Adelaide Hospital.
251
ANGELS OF ACEH
Allan MacKillop was relieved of his Aeromedical Evacuation
Operations Officer role in Medan by Squadron Leader
Paul McCarthy (since deceased). Alan went back to life as
Medical Director of CareFlight Medical Services, on the
Gold Coast, where he lives with his wife and three grown
children. He remains in the RAAF Specialist Reserve.
Greg Norman left the RAAF on 17 January 2005 and
resumed civilian life in Queensland with his wife Sandra
and their three young sons. He still serves in the RAAF
Specialist Reserve.
Bernard York returned to Sydney from Jakarta on 19 January
2005 and repaired to Naval duties at HMAS Waterhen,
Waverton.
And as for the CASTA team . . .
Mike Flynn went back to his position as the New South
Wales Health Services Functional Area Coordinator for
Disasters and Medical Director of the Ambulance Service
of New South Wales. He gave a number of talks on the
Banda Aceh experience, as did many of the team members.
Paul Shumack went back to RAAF Base, Amberley, and
also to building his workshed. He successfully finished it
within a couple of months, complete with wiring. He
continues to work for the children’s charity, Variety Club.
Karyn Boxshall went back to life at the Royal Perth
Hospital and her partner Alan, with plans for possible
further studies.
252
Epilogue
James Branley returned to his work as Head of the
Department of Microbiology for Nepean and Blue Mountains
Pathology Services and gave talks from time to time on Banda
Aceh and the medical issues it raised. He and Valeria took
their boys north of Forster for some all-important time out.
Bruce Cameron stayed as the Senior Rescue Instructor with
the New South Wales Fire Brigades Rescue Section at
Greenacre Fire Station. The deployment had not only been
relentlessly hard work for the two fireys, it had been
unfathomably gruesome. However, along the lines of Paul
Hogan’s thinking, their view was ‘See a shrink? Don’t you
have any mates?’ He and Watto looked out for each other.
Bruce painted pictures of what he saw in Banda Aceh, and
spoke about some of his experiences at Warrimoo primary
school to an enthralled audience of school children.
Rosie Clifton went back to work in nursing and the
designing of a new home.
Liz Cloughessy resigned from her post as Clinical Nurse
Consultant at Westmead Hospital and began a new career
chapter in the New South Wales Health Counter Disaster
Unit. She kept in touch with Marthoenis, the young
student who had helped CASTA so selflessly at Fakinah.
Marthoenis stayed and assisted each Australian team that
followed. He was helpful clinically and also as an interpreter. Liz looked for sponsorship for his nursing studies
on her return to Australia. She arranged for books to be
sent over to him. He chose to write his final year thesis on
the psychological effects experienced by people who lost
their limbs in the tsunami. In September 2005, Marthoenis
graduated with a Bachelor of Nursing.
253
ANGELS OF ACEH
Rhonda Cowderoy went back to nursing on night shift and to
life with husband Bruce.
Lisa Dillon went back to being Nursing Unit Manager at
Westmead Hospital Emergency Department. She had
made many friends among the team and took time out to
catch up with many of them on her return. A highlight of
her deployment was being met by her husband at the
airport with fresh fruit and much-craved Diet Coke.
Paul Dunkin went back to his work as a cardiac and general
anaesthetist at various Sydney hospitals and his role as
president of Shore Anaesthetics. The day after he got
home, he took his wife and four sons up to a beachside
cottage near Forster, close to where James Branley and his
wife Valeria and their four boys were holidaying. After an
initially hesitant start, James and Paul ended up talking
for hours each night about their experience. Paul gave a
presentation at the Sydney Adventist Hospital about the
relief effort in Banda Aceh. In August he won the North
Shore Times Father of the Year.
Alan Garner appears on television from time to time, giving
the public information about various CareFlight activities.
He is endeavouring to gain government and corporate
support for a supply cache which would enable the State to
respond quickly and capably to a disaster.
Jeff Gilchrist remains a SCAT paramedic with the New
South Wales Ambulance Service.
Norm Gray went back to Fremantle Hospital to work and
took a month out to travel to New Zealand and then to
254
Epilogue
Hawaii for a conference. After the fatal SeaKing helicopter
crash in Nias, he was asked to replace the late Squadron
Leader Paul McCarthy who had been engaged to speak in
Fremantle, Western Australia, on the ADF contribution to
the tsunami. The talk topic was changed to the Australian
civilian contribution, and was made into a memorial
occasion to remember and honour Paul McCarthy. Paul
McCarthy had replaced Alan MacKillop as the AME
receiving officer in Medan in the final days of CASTA’s
time in Banda Aceh, and then had stayed to work with the
ADF in Banda Aceh, before he went to Nias. In August
2005 Norm joined a medical team working in Iraq.
Ken Harrison went back to his multiple roles, which are
too many to list, but which include being a consultant to
CareFlight and an anaesthetist. He put all the team photographs on CD and made up some T-shirts bearing the
logos of the various groups which had contributed people
to the effort, such as New South Wales and VicHealth,
CareFlight and the New South Wales Fire Brigade, plus
the slogan which had made their constant loading, unloading and stacking of boxes bearable —‘Storeman and
Doctors Union’.
Annette Holian ended up joining HMAS Kanimbla on
1 April 2005, bound for Nias, Indonesia, the island off the
coast of Banda Aceh which experienced the earthquake on
28 March. On 2 April, an Australian SeaKing helicopter
bringing a medical team from the ship to help in Nias
crashed in a field, killing nine service personnel. Annette
was on board Kanimbla when this happened and was
involved in operating on the two crash survivors and also
in identifying the deceased crash victims. The ADF Board
255
ANGELS OF ACEH
of Inquiry, before which she would appear, commenced on
6 September.
Adrian Humphrey, SCAT paramedic, on his return went
straight into his area office in Wahroonga, New South
Wales, where he is currently doing rosters and other bits
and pieces of administrative work behind a desk, which is
quite foreign to him. He volunteered to do a twelve-month
secondment in the office because he needed a shoulder and
knee operation this year to restore them after the toll
constant action and outdoor activities have taken, all part
of the normal hazards of life as a SCAT paramedic.
Terry Jongen went back to his motorcycle racing and to his
role as Clinical Nurse Specialist in the Emergency Department of the Royal Perth Hospital. He started his Masters
degree in Nurse Practitioner studies.
Paul Luckin went back to work as an anaesthetist in
Queensland. He gave many talks to trauma conferences,
St John Ambulance, and the local church.
Jeremy McAnulty went back to work as the Director of the
Communicable Diseases Branch, New South Wales
Public Health. He gave talks on Banda Aceh and sent out
a survey to the team to find out what impact the doxycycline had had, and to find out about any other health
issues they had experienced.
Brian Pezzutti stayed busy with speaking engagements,
emphasising his pride in being Australian. He continues to
work as an anaesthetist in Lismore and volunteered for
further service following the Nias earthquake, but was not
256
Epilogue
needed at that time. He continues to be very active in New
South Wales in improving mental health services. His
health test for the needle-stick injury gave him the 100 per
cent all-clear.
Marj Raggett returned to work as a nurse at Westmead and
travelled to Canada.
Sudhakar Rao went back to being Director of Trauma
Surgery at the Royal Perth Hospital, Western Australia,
and to life with Narelle and their three boys.
David Scott went back to life as an anaesthetist in Lismore
Hospital and his various other roles, including chair of
the Anaesthetists Consultative Group to the ADF. It felt
strange for him to walk the streets of Lismore and see
no piles of rubble, debris and bodies. His brain had
normalised the bizarre sights of Banda Aceh.
Peter Sharwood returned from Banda Aceh and started
packing almost immediately. He then set out to help in a
hospital in Iraq, where insurgents battled for power
against the newly elected democratic Iraqi government.
Ray Southon returned to theatre nursing and went to Fiji to
build a house for a relative.
Paul Van Buynder resumed his public health role, speaking at
various venues about the issues he had been involved in. He
spoke as far afield as Alice Springs in the Northern Territory.
Greg Watson (Watto) returned to Greenacre Fire Station
too and he and Bruce Cameron continue to work together.
257
ANGELS OF ACEH
Despite the success of the operation, they analysed it from
the perspective of lessons learned and implemented a few
changes. The power generators for future deployments
will run on diesel, a fuel which can be transported on the
aircraft, and collapsible trolleys will be included in the
cache. So will more lollies.
René Zellweger returned to his work as a trauma surgeon at
the Royal Perth Hospital. His work was greatly appreciated
by the team. One day after the team’s return, David Scott
was talking with Peter Sharwood about the merits of Peter’s
Swiss army knife. ‘We did better than that for Banda Aceh,’
David said. ‘We took a Swiss Army surgeon (René).’
Normally in a hospital in Australia you have a major,
distressing operation sporadically. In Banda Aceh, every
case was significant and every case was distressing.
The operations were back-to-back and there could be no
medical debrief about them—there was no time. While
working in the disaster zone, their minds had become so
numb that they never really talked about their circumstances. They did not begin to dwell on how it was affecting
them. Now, after they had arrived home, gradually, it all
came out. How they felt and what they thought of it all. It
was cleansing and healthful. And we learned more about
our spouses.
What they had witnessed and felt would be a part of
them now. Their lives were never going to be the same.
Experiences change you. You never view anything the
same way again. There was abundance everywhere you
looked—robust health, vitality, safe climate, peacetime,
sweet air. Comfortable homes, long hot showers, comfy
258
Epilogue
beds with fresh crisp linen, disposable everything, pain
relief on demand, bountiful food and, wonder of wonders,
fresh drinking water—out of the tap. But best of all was
that you had the loves of your life in your arms again.
Some of the Acehnese would never experience that joy
again. Their dear ones were gone. Paul just hoped that
knowing people cared about them had brought them some
comfort. You could bear anything in life if people cared for
you, loved you.
Something happened one night at home shortly after
Paul’s return which meant far more than any public
accolade could. Our ten-year-old son Liam asked me and
Paul to watch as he rehearsed his homework. The Year
Five boys had to give a short talk about what made a hero.
Character development was part of their school training;
‘People for Others’ was the school motto.
Liam held his notes and spoke clearly, earnestly. He was
not an ostentatious child. He described certain values and
why he thought they were heroic. Then he paused. He
obviously wanted to end his talk with conviction. ‘Dr Paul
Dunkin is an example,’ he said. We were speechless.
Paul Luckin perhaps best summed up how many of the
team felt on leaving Banda Aceh. He said the team would
never forget certain things about the time there: the
patients, the enormity of the disaster, the smell. The team
had witnessed a desperate need in the local people’s eyes
for someone to help them, to give them some moral and
emotional support and some physical assistance. There
was something else. A quiet acceptance. It was the same
quiet acceptance some in the team had seen before—after
horrific wars, disasters, accidents, terrorist bombings. In
Rwanda, Somalia, Bougainville, East Timor, Port Arthur,
Bali, Vanimo. After train crashes, police sieges, cave-ins,
259
ANGELS OF ACEH
bushfires, landslides, mountain and cliff rescues. It was
a deep sadness, but without despair. Something beyond
grief. As though feeling blessed to have survived. It was a
reverent, patient and quiet strength. A noble determination. It was the primordial core of all endurance—it was the
human spirit.
It was breathtaking to witness it. And humbling.
The human spirit is what inspired those who went to
help, and motivated those who gave support back home.
Not everyone could be on the ground in Banda Aceh in
those early desperate days, but people were still able to
help, in very real ways. As the needs continued and grew
more complex, Australians continued to help.
Cementing of relationships, building of bridges. A
tsunami of death brought an even bigger wave of hope.
Constant kindness can accomplish much. As the sun makes
ice melt, kindness causes misunderstanding, mistrust, and
hostility to evaporate.
Dr Albert Schweitzer (1875–1965),
1952 Nobel Peace Laureate.
Author’s note: On 1 October 2005, a second series of Bali
bombings took place. The references in this book refer to
the first Bali bombings, which took place on 12 October
2002.
260
Appendix 1
Dramatis Personae
Combined Australian Surgical Team, Aceh—‘CASTA’
Alpha
Team Leader: Dr Michael Flynn (NSW)
Orthopaedics: Dr Annette Holian (VIC)
Surgeon: Dr Sudhakar Rao (WA)
Anaesthetist: Dr Brian Pezzutti (NSW)
Anaesthetist: Dr David Scott (NSW)
Emergency Physician: Dr Alan Garner (Careflight NSW)
Public Health: Dr Jeremy McAnulty (NSW)
SCAT Paramedic: Jeff Gilchrist (NSW)
Emergency Nurse: Liz Cloughessy (NSW)
Emergency Nurse: Lisa Dillon (NSW)
Operating Room Nurse: Marjorie Raggett (NSW)
Operating Room Nurse: Raymond Southon (NSW)
Logistics (Medical): Dr Ken Harrison (NSW)
Logistics (General): Greg Watson (NSW Fire Brigade)
261
ANGELS OF ACEH
Bravo
Team Leader: Dr Paul Shumack (QLD)
Orthopaedics: Dr Peter Sharwood (QLD)
Surgeon: Dr René Zellweger (WA)
Anaesthetics: Dr Paul Luckin (QLD)
Anaesthetics: Dr Paul Dunkin (NSW)
Emergency Physician: Dr Norman Gray (WA)
Infectious Diseases: Dr James Branley (NSW)
Public Health: Dr Paul Van Buynder (WA)
SCAT Paramedic: Adrian Humphrey (NSW)
Emergency Nurse: Terry Jongen (WA)
Emergency Nurse: Karyn Boxshall (WA)
Operating Room Nurse: Rosemary Clifton (WA)
Operating Room Nurse: Rhonda Cowderoy (NSW)
Logistics and support: Bruce Cameron (NSW Fire Brigade)
Wing Commander Bill Griggs AM RAAF SR: Director
Trauma Services, Royal Adelaide Hospital. Recce team
member for Australian government. Head of AME at
Banda Aceh in the early days after the tsunami.
Wing Commander Allan MacKillop RAAF SR: Medical
Director of Careflight Services, Gold Coast. Recce team
member for Australian government. AME receiving
officer at Medan.
Wing Commander Greg Norman RAAF: (Then)
Commanding Officer Richmond Air Base Hospital. Recce
team member for Australian government. Worked at
Kesdam ED with Army medics in the early days after the
tsunami.
262
Appendix 1
Lieutenant Bernard York RAN: Officer-in-Charge, Fleet
Logistics Support Element, HMAS Waterhen Sydney.
Officer interface at Halim Perdanakusuma Air Base
Jakarta between NGOs and others and Indonesian government, assisting Australian embassy staff in the early days
after the tsunami.
263
Appendix 2
Speech At Reception With Premier
For Personnel Involved In The Tsunami Aid Effort
Government House
Thursday 17th February 2005
Her Excellency Professor Marie Bashir AC
Governor Of New South Wales
Premier, Minister Kelly, Minister Iemma, Distinguished
Guests And Friends
It is with the greatest pleasure that we welcome you all to
Government House today to honour and to express our
gratitude to you—unselfish and committed Australians—
you who responded so speedily and with great skill and
compassion to the victims of the Indian Ocean tsunami.
The United Nations has declared that this was the
greatest human catastrophe which it had faced. And
certainly across our own nation, Australians of all ages and
264
Appendix 2
background reacted with an immediate and extraordinary
empathy, an immediate responsiveness from yourselves
and other Australians like you, across all the professions
and trades, the services, national and international sport, and
countless volunteers.
You are the representatives of a good society, renowned
for its generosity of spirit and for its capacity to reach out
to one another, and to strangers in need.
But these qualities have never been more illuminated
than in the weeks following the tsunami, by yourselves and
your colleagues which have made your fellow Australians
so proud, and the whole world observe with admiration.
Watching the heartbreaking scenes of devastation on
the television, we had but a miniscule idea of what
awesome challenges confronted you. But I was also deeply
aware that your diligence in working together so cohesively, was miraculously able to prevent a second tragic
consequence of widespread destruction, that of typhoid,
cholera and other potentially lethal infectious diseases.
It is no exaggeration to say that because of your commitment, your skills—you have to a considerable extent
diminished the attitudes of suspicion and distance in which
Australia had erroneously been held for some years.
Indeed you have added valuable diplomatic strength
through your genuineness and humanitarian actions which
will never be forgotten.
I should tell you that I have received numerous letters
and messages from diplomats and envoys of tsunamiaffected areas, many also from countries not affected,
expressing their gratitude and admiration.
There is still much to do, working together to rebuild
shattered communities and lives, and being vigilant
scientifically to the possibility of another tsunami.
265
ANGELS OF ACEH
More than ever before, Australia stands in a strong
position to play an increasingly leadership role in the peace
and stability of the region.
Your contribution has been immense,—incalculable,—
and with the Premier, these sentiments—and our gratitude
— are expressed on behalf of all the people of New South
Wales.
Thank you all.
266
Appendix 3
Acronyms, abbreviations and explanations
ACTED
The Agency for Technical Cooperation and
Development
ADF
Australian Defence Force
AIPRD
Australia–Indonesia Partnership for
Reconstruction and Development
AHDMPC Australian Health Disasters Management
Policy Committee (known colloquially as
‘The Alphabet Committee’)
AusAID
Australian Agency for International
Development
AUSASSISTPLAN Australian Commonwealth
Government Overseas Response Plan
BRR
Baden Rehabilitasi dan Rekonstruksi
(Rehabilitation and Reconstruction Agency
for Aceh and Nias)
CASTA
Combined Australian Surgical Team, Aceh
CSL
Commonwealth Serum Laboratory
267
ANGELS OF ACEH
DG
DoHA
Director-General
Commonwealth Department of Health and
Ageing
ECG
Electro-cardiogram
EMA
Emergency Management Australia
(a Commonwealth body)
EMST
Early Management of Severe Trauma
ERC
Emergency Relief Co-ordinator
Fakinah
Rumah Sakit Teungku Fakinah Hospital,
a privately-owned hospital in Banda Aceh
secured by the police force after the tsunami
GAM
Free Aceh Movement (Gerakan Aceh
Merdeka)
HSW
Health Services Wing
HSFAC
Health Services Functional Area
Coordinator for disasters
Herc
RAAF C-130J Hercules, a cargo plane
flown by the Air Force
IDPs
Indigenous Displaced Persons
Interfet
International Force for East Timor
IOM
International Organisation for Migration
IRC CARDI International Rescue Committee
Consortium for Assistance to Refugees
and the Displaced in Indonesia
JRS
Jesuit Refugee Service
Kesdam
Rumah Sakit Kesdam Hospital formerly
military Hospital in Banda Aceh secured
by TNI after the tsunami
NUM
Nursing Unit Manager
OCHA
(United Nations’) Office for the
Co-Ordination of Human Affairs
PAR
Post-Activity Report
PKF
Peace Keeping Force
268
Appendix 3
RAAF
RAN
RNZAF
SARS
SCAT
paramedic
SIM
SMS
SNM
TNI
TVRI
complex
UN
UNIMOG
USAID
USAR
WHO
Royal Australian Airforce
Royal Australian Navy
Royal New Zealand Air Force
Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome
Special Casualty Access Team Paramedic
Sultan Iskandar Muda (Airfield at Banda
Aceh)
Short Message Service—text messages sent
via mobile telecommunications network
Senior Nurse Manager
Tentara Nasional Indonesia (Indonesian
Military)
The compound surrounding the TV station
in Banda Aceh which housed the largest of
the displaced persons camps
United Nations
A commonly used Military 4WD light truck
United States Agency for International
Development
Urban Search and Rescue
World Health Organization
269
Acknowledgments
Thank you to my sister Armelle who encouraged me all my
life to write and specifically suggested I write this book ‘in
my spare time’!
Thank you to my sister Libby who supported me along
the way and, best of all, found me my publisher Richard
Walsh.
Thank you, Richard, my wonderful publisher. Words
are somehow inadequate for what you did. You made the
recording of an extraordinary event in history, the tsunami
and the initial relief response, a reality. Thank you for your
kind and wise input. Thank you Annette Barlow, Karen
Gee, Jody Lee and the wonderful team at Allen & Unwin,
for bringing this story to the public.
My heartfelt thanks to the CASTA team: Michael Flynn,
Paul Shumack, Karyn Boxshall, James Branley, Bruce
Cameron, Rosemary Clifton, Liz Cloughessy, Rhonda
Cowderoy, Lisa Dillon, Alan Garner, Jeff Gilchrist,
Norman Gray, Ken Harrison, Annette Holian, Adrian
Humphrey, Terry Jongen, Paul Luckin, Jeremy McAnulty,
270
Acknowledgments
Brian Pezzutti, Marjorie Raggett, Sudhakar Rao, David
Scott, Peter Sharwood, Raymond Southon, Paul Van
Buynder, Greg Watson, and René Zellweger. Without
your contributions, loyalty and enthusiasm and generosity
of spirit which led you to go to the disaster zone, there
would be no story. Thanks for entrusting your tale to me.
Although reluctant to paint yourselves as heroes, and
busily back in your ‘normal’ demanding jobs, you made the
patient effort to meet me, answer my copious questions,
telephone calls, SMSs, emails and provide photographs. I
will never forget you. It was a complete delight meeting
every one of you, and an honour to record your story. I am
very proud to know you. Although I was not in Banda
Aceh, I hoped to capture some special memories of your
work and give a glimpse of what was happening back in
Australia. Any virtues to be found in the book are to your
credit, any mistakes are mine.
I thank all the team’s better-halves, families and
colleagues, too. Your support was evident, every member
of the team made mention of the fact that they could not do
what they did without strong backing from home, and the
cover given by their workmates.
Two of the spouses I must mention by name—Narelle,
Sudhakar Rao’s wife, for having a total stranger stay in her
home, waiting on me as I interviewed team members and
giving lots of encouragement; and Katrin Heusser, René
Zellweger’s wife, who sent me information a number of
times and gave me strong moral support from the day we
first met. Thank you to both of you!
Thank you to Bill Griggs, Alan MacKillop, Greg
Norman, Hugh Grantham, and my brother Bernard York
for your contributions to the book and for the work you
did in Indonesia.
271
ANGELS OF ACEH
Thank you to others such as Brigadier Ken Brownrigg
and Flight Sergeant Michelle Maclachlan, and the many,
many people involved in vital roles in the relief effort in
Indonesia from the ADF—from aircrew to loadmasters
and air-traffic controllers to medical personnel with the
ADF field hospital. Without the work of the former, the
CASTA team could never had done what they did, and
the work of the latter from all accounts helped put Banda
Aceh medically back on its feet.
Thank you to all the amazing people behind the scenes
who worked around the clock to enable the team to go to
Banda Aceh, properly equipped and with the right underlying plan, and supported their efforts while they were
over there.
To my late sister Noelle. Your love of literature, your
help with my essays over the years and your positive
comments about my letters to you helped me in so many
ways. Thanks Nellie.
Thank you to my sister Ingrid for your go-get-’em
words and timely copy of The Alchemist; Lisa Hill, for ideas,
advice, laughs and sharing of ideals and dreams—and
fascinating title suggestions; Julie Hatton, who has always
set the best example of perseverance and human spirit to
me; Pam Hatfield for setting me on the writing path years
ago, and Sandy Street for the positive energy and tips.
Thanks to Stu Lloyd for the invaluable eleventh hour
boost and advice. Thank you to Dr Nigel Symons and the
staff at the Sydney Adventist Hospital (‘the San’) who
treated me to an informative tour of a first-class Australian
hospital. Thank you Kylie Saul for helping me with my
children whenever you could, what would I do without you?
Thank you Dad, for offering to edit, and thanks Mum for
correcting my English in my childhood and convincing me
272
Acknowledgments
that I could do anything I set my mind to (because a young
French girl called Joan of Arc had led soldiers into battle).
My thanks to my wonderful extended family and
incredible friends for your ideas and friendship. The power
of an affirming word should never be underestimated.
Thank you to my beautiful boys: Liam, Darcy, Francis
and Pierce. This was definitely a whole-family effort.
Finally, thank you, Paul, for going to Banda Aceh in
the first place and for giving so selflessly throughout the
entire interviewing and writing process. I could not have
done this without your tireless support and love. You are
my rock and my inspiration. You have always encouraged
me in every endeavour of my life and I can never thank
you enough.
273