International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 2, Issue 8, August-2011
ISSN 2229-5518
1
Virtual Power Plants
Sherry Carr
Abstract— America is too dependent upon foreign energy sources, but it has the capabilities to free itself, while saving money
and preserving the environment. If the U.S. Government increased its R&D (Research & Development) spending on renewable
energy via Virtual Power Plants (VPP), America could be energy independent; coverting foreign energy dependency into
America’s renewable freedom. Sustaining and developing a cleaner, safer, more efficient world by implementing and developing
VPP’s.
Index Terms—America’s Energy Freedom, Combatting Global Warming, Cultivating Natural Resources, Gas and Oil
Dependency, Renewable Energy, Sustainable Energy, Virtual Power Plants
—————————— ——————————
1
INTRODUCTION
R
ENEWABLE energy can be found in many forms
- all of which can be harvested and used by
VPP’s to generate power for electricity, to create
heat, and to use as transportation fuels. Renewable
energies are in abundancy, America just has to
cultivate them. The more America relies on its own
vast variety of renewable energies, the less it will be
dependent upon foreign liquid gases and oils.
America is too dependent upon foreign energy
sources, but it has the capabilities to free itself, while
saving money and preserving the environment. This
paper questions the advantages of Virtual Power
Plants and the need for renewable energy sources.
Virtual Power Plants (VPP, hereinafter) are collective
generators of renewable energy sources that can store
and adjust energy output on demand and at will.
VPP’s can be employed to co-generate with current
grids or operate soley to produce reliable, efficient,
cost-effective energy while reducing costs and global
warming (Encorp, 2011). My hypothesis suggests that
VPP’s can create substantial and sustainable energy
from renewables,as it helps to reverse the destruction
of our planet and ourselves. We can create and
————————————————
Sherry Carr is currently pursuing bachelor’s degree program in
business economics at Ashford University, PH-1.866.711.1700.
E-mail:
[email protected]
sustaina cleaner, safer, more efficient world by
implementing and advancing VPP’s to meet and
possibly exceed our energy needs.
Renewable energy can be found in many forms: wind
power via wind turbines placed at on-shore and offshore farms; hydropower and hydroelectricity inclusive of kinetic energy, ocean energy, marine
current power, ocean thermal energy conversion,
tidal power, wave power, and dams; solar energy
produced by the sun’s radiation, which relies on
photovoltaics and heat engines; biomass from plant
residue created by the sun through the process of
photosynthesis; biofuels and biodiesels produced by
bioalcohols, which is produced by the fermention of
plant materials, bioethanolscreated via recycled
greases; and geothermal energy extracted from the
Earth’s core, drawn up by dry steam plants, flash
plants, and binary plants. All of these methods can be
employed, harvested, and used by VPP’s to generate
power for electricity, to create heat, and to use as
transportation fuels. This is not an exhaustive list as
renewable energies are in abundancy, America just
has to cultivate them. The more America relies on its
own vast variety of renewable energies, the less it will
be dependent upon foreign liquid gases and oils.
By increasing energy efficient technologies, VPP’s
could set the stage for the ―Missing Link‖ of the
energy crisis by providing energy storage (Bush &
Wolf, 2009). VPP’s have the capabilities to store
energy, with more R&D spending in this area, the
U.S. could greatly improve its production of
renewable energies more efficiently, more effectively,
and ultimately reducing its costs with less waste
(Alternative Energy Press, 2007).The whole country
would benefit in many ways: economically,
politically, environmentally, medically, and socially.
The benefits resulting from the implemention of equal
capture and distribution of all available natural
renewable resources would be reaped by all of
society, while conserving our planet. It’s a coalition of
the most available, least destructive, natural energy
resources coming together to maximize America’s
energy output and minimize environmental damage.
America would benefit from increasing its R&D
spending on VPP’s and the renewable energy
resources required to help sustain, maintain, and
IJSER © 2011
http://www.ijser.org
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 2, Issue 8, August-2011
ISSN 2229-5518
progress into the future. America would also benefit
from the implementation of other cost reducing,
energy efficient technologies that help to reduce
energy imports, phase-out nuclear power, and reduce
greenhouse gas emissions (Alternative Energy Press,
2007).Ultimately, by increasing R&D spending on
VPP’s for renewable energies, and employing cleanenergy efficient technologies, America would be
creating a substantial amount of sustainable energy
for generations to come (Alternative Energy Press,
2007), while simultaneously combatting global
warming in the United States (American Solar Energy
Society (ASES), 2007).
Renewed environmental awareness has led to new
methods of generating power (Newman & Mutale,
2009).VPP’s would be beneficial as they reduce
greenhouse gas emissions (Newman & Mutale, 2009),
which would help preserve our planet. America can
benefit in many ways from limiting its dependency
on foreign energies by increasing the production of
American energy renewables and creating efficient
technologies, as it also addresses the issues and
problems of global warming (American Solar Energy
Society (ASES), 2007).Implementing VPP’s greatly
increases the probabilities of self-efficiency;
promoting freedom, creating jobs, and reducing
costs.1If the U.S. Government increased its R&D
(Research & Development) spending on renewable
energy via VPP’s, America could be energy
independent; coverting foreign energy dependency
into America’s renewable freedom.
2 METHOD
By examining a variety of independent studies,
charts, and graphs - the validatity of the true value of
VPP’s and renewable energies will allow America to
be energy independent. Studies announce the benefits
and costs associated with VPP’s for renewable energy;
and acknowledge the benefits of clean, efficient
technologies that will promote sustainable energy for
all of America, as well as promoting energy freedom
and reducing global warming. It’s a winning solution
for all that cherish a world that is shared! The studies
used to constitute the writings of this paper show the
truth of the benefits and the costs; it also allows the
promotion of energy freedom, offers solutions to
global warming, and aides in the affordability of
energy sources for American citizens.
3 RESULTS
From the data collected, the results provide that in
2007 renewable energy only provided 7% of the
United States energy consumption and only 9.4% for
2
the total of parturitated electricity use (U.S.
Department of Energy, 2011), while nuclear energies
exceeded renewable energies by more than 25% for
R&D spending in that same year (Energy Information
Administration, 2007).The American Recovery and
Reinvestment Act of 2009 vowed $45.1 billion for the
production and development of renewable energy,
energy effiency, and other related energy programs
and incentives (Bullis, 2010), but yet, ―…of the $36.7
billion the U.S. Department of Energy has to spend, so
far it has distributed just $2.4 billion (although it's
announced awards totaling $25.4 billion)‖
(Bullis, 2010).Indicating that funds are available for
government investment of VPP’s, renewable energies,
and new advanced technologies – they just have to
take the inititives to move in that direction.
In 2010, the U.S. Department of Energy provided a
―Guide to Financing EnergySmart Schools‖ (U.S.
Department of Energy, 2010), which seems to indicate
that the U.S. Government is seeking new ways to
implement renewable energy plans. Even small,
conservative initiatives will provide great, extensive
benefits.The ―Guide‖ was issued to encourage the rise
of new schools to be built in exceedance of the current
code (ASHRAE 90.11999.2)by 50% or more, and
promotes improvements of existing schools by at least
30 percent (U.S. Department of Energy, 2010). Which
seems like a very good start to a hopeful future for
renewable energies. ―The program offers tools and
resources to assist school decision makers in planning
and financing energy efficient high performance
schools as well as education and training for building
industry professionals‖ (U.S. Department of Energy,
2010).
It’s the collaboration of team efforts that will educate,
change, and benefit communities, officials, and
families for the better as they seek improvements to
the physical world while protecting the environment
– all while saving everyone a lot of money (U.S.
Department of Energy, 2010), and that is very
beneficial!Investing in renewables today, could
promise a brighter, healthier, cleaner, more
affordable, less wasteful world tomorrow – creating
and transforming energy in ways that are innovative,
feasible, and practical.
It’s enlightening to know that companies like
ConocoPhillips
(http://www.conoco
phillips.com/EN/Pages/index.aspx)
are
also
dedicated to researching and developing renewable
energy, while improving performance, creating highefficiency technologies, and reducing negative
IJSER © 2011
http://www.ijser.org
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 2, Issue 8, August-2011
ISSN 2229-5518
environmental impacts. Research suggests that R&D
spending and certain forms of subsidies should not be
subsided for companies that are taking inititives to
improve, preserve, and sustain natural renewable
energy and efficient technology research and
development, as it is very much needed to maintain
our world as we know it, and to improve our planet’s
conditions for future generations.
Government subsidies ―aren’t a bad thing‖ (Kachan,
2007), without them many renewable energy sources
could not exist (Kachan, 2007). America’s biggest
problem is not that it offers subsidies that can help
with production and distribution of VPP’s and
renewable energies, but rather that it gives too much
money away (Kachan, 2007). Offering subsidies is
beneficial; but giving too much revenue away, or not
collecting enough revenue from taxes that are due is
what causes inflation, dead-weight loss, and increases
the national deficit – causing more harm than
good.Michael David (2008), said it best when he
published the following: ―Subsidies need to work for
the American tax payer and limited to qualified and
verifiable alternative energy research that yields
production by the end of a fixed period - else the
subsidy goes away.‖ This would create extended
benefits, increased productivities, and produce an
efficient environment for subsidies that will reduce
waste, fraud, and corruption, as well as promote the
most effective use of funds, and ensure the proper
distribution of revenues. Everyone can helpto reduce,
reuse, recycle, and repower America andits energy by
visiting http://www.repoweramerica.org/.
4 DISCUSSION
The U.S. Government appears to be on the right track
as they are implementing programs and using funds
to increase awareness and production of renewable
energy sources. Though they are progressing, it seems
as though the progression is very slow in times of dire
need. As non-renewable, non-sustainable energy
resources are consumed to depeletion on a global
scale, the need for new technologies and increased
renewable energy sources is significantly important to
sustain the world as we know it. Pfeiffer (2010)
acknowledges the global importance of an adequate
supply of climate friendly, environmently friendly,
and cost effective sources of energy.
With the evidence presented, it seems logical to
increase U.S. R&D spending on VPP’s to include a
wide variety of renewable energy resources, and to
invest in the production of energy efficient
technologies to increase America’s energy freedom
and eliminate American dependency on foreign
3
energy sources. Ex-President Bush is quoted as
saying, ―Today we make a major step toward
reducing our dependence on oil, confronting global
climate change, expanding the production of
renewable fuels and giving future generations a
nation that is stronger, cleaner and more secure‖
(Cannon, 2008, p.29),and that was on December 19,
2007 (Cannon, 2008, p.29).It’s in America’s best
interest to implement and use its own natural,
renewable energy resources to promote efficiency, to
increase production, and to allow for affordable
distribution of energy producing resources.
No one solution will eliminate America’s energy
dependency; it will take the collaboration of all
available renewable energy sources to free America.
Creating a sustainable development policy seems
feasible by reducing non-sustainable energies
(Schilling & Chiang, 2011). America needs to invest
less capital in non-sustainable energies and increase
its focus and investments in sustainable resources and
advanced technologies. It is undeniable in the facts
presented3, that it would be in America’s best interest
to seek sustainable, renewable energy sources and
technologies that can and will help develop the VPP’s
that are very much needed to rectify America’s
energy crisis, as it has the capacities and capabilities
of being successfulat its venture!
Freeing America from its energy dependency on
foreign sources will also increase American utilities as
it lowers the price of production, distribution, and
consumer pricing. The excessive amounts of revenue
lost caused by the current overlaxed subsidizing of
the oil industry (Kachan, 2007) could be used toward
the R&D and production of new technologies and
more efficient renewable energies.Ultimately, all
renewable energy resources have grown over the
years in production4, but there is still plenty of lead
way for improvements, growth, R&D, and production
of advanced technologies.
Global warming is a by-product of America’s energy
dependency; it is also a problem that is preventable simply by increasing America’s use of more efficient,
more sufficient, safer, cleaner, natural, renewable
energies and technologies. It’s the freedom of
winning solutions, and America has the power and
resources to do it. Natural gas and oil consumption as
not yet declined (U.S. Energy Information
dministration, 2010), nor is projected to do so anytime
soon, which only proves the need for America to
implement changesto a dire situation. Improving the
distribution of renewable energies today is important
IJSER © 2011
http://www.ijser.org
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 2, Issue 8, August-2011
ISSN 2229-5518
to sustain America, its environment, and ultimately,
the world - for generations to come!
VPP’s are ―truly an open-protocol end-to-end design‖
(Encorp), which has the ability to interact with other
automated energy management and energy grid
systems (Encorp). VPP’s are beneficial because they
allow utility companies and high-energy users to
control the amount and source of power drawn from
a network of power plants that distribute renewable
energy sources as needed (Encorp). Encorp is the
leader
in
Microgrid
System
Controller™
development, and has successfully implemented the
New Energy Economy5 by offering cogeneration, as
well as prime-generation of renewable energy sources
(Encorp). Today is all we have to protect our
4
tomorrow; additional research should be warranted
and conducted to address the specifics of the topics
mentioned herein. Addressing such issues could
provide clarity and understanding about VPP’s and
renewable energy, and how they offer solutions
and/or suggestions that we can all partake in and
learn from regarding sustainable energy, advanced
technologies, and American freedom. This paper is
limited by the constrains of time-frame given for this
assignment. This paper does not include in-depth
information of any given topic, but rather a general
perspective of the many issues surrounding VPP’s.
Further, in-depth research would provide greater
understanding, and perhaps speed things in the right
direction.
REFERENCES
[1]
Alternative Energy Press. (2007, September 13).21 Recent
Sustainable Energy Studies.Retrieved March 18, 2011, from
http://www.alternative-energy-news.info/press/21-recentsustainable-energy-studies/
[2] American Solar Energy Society (ASES). (2007, January, 31).
U.S. Energy ExpertsAnnounceWay toFreezeGlobal
Warming. Retrieved March 14, 2011, from
http://ases.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=arti
cle&id=139&Itemid=16
a.
(―Sustainable Energy Study #9‖ from 21 Recent
Sustainable Energy Studies).
[3] Bullis, K. (2010, February 20). The Stimulus Bill, One Year
Later. TechnologyReview. Retrieved March 19, 2011,
fromhttp://www.technologyreview.com/ energy/24633/
[4] Bush, R., & Wolf, G. (2009). Energy Storage Becomes A
Virtual Power Plant.Transmission & Distribution World, 811. Retrieved March 12, 2011, from EBSCOhost.
[5] Cannon, C.M. (2008, April). Outragous: Running on Empty.
Reader’s Digest, 29-31.
[6] ConocoPhillips. Alternative Energy Research and
Development. Retrieved March 12,2011,
fromhttp://www.conocophillips.com/EN/susdev/enviro
nment/ cleanenergy/alternativeenergy/Pages/index.aspx
[7] David, M. (2008, August 2). Removing Subsidies will not
raise gas prices. In OilIndustry Subsidies for Dummies
(Comments). Retrieved April 3, 2011, from
http://cleantech.com/news/554/oil-industry-subsidies-fordummies#comment-2876
[8] Encorp. Virtual Power Plant. Retrieved April 8, 2011, from
http://www.encorp.com/ content.asp56.htm
[9] Encorp Press Release. (2011, April 5). Encorp Launches
Microgrid System Controller.Retrieved April 8, 2011, from
http://www.encorp.com/
release_microgrid_system_controller.htm
[10] Energy Information Administration. Federal Financial
Interventions and Subsidies inEnergy Markets 2007.
Retrieved March 18, 2011, from http://www.eia.doe.gov/
oiaf/servicerpt/subsidy2/pdf/execsum.pdf
[11] Kachan, D. (2007, January 5). Oil Industry Subsidies for
Dummies. Retrieved April 4,2011, from
http://cleantech.com/news/node/554
[12] Newman G., & Mutale, J. (2009, October). International
Journal of ElectricalEngineering Education. 46 (4), 307-318.
IJSER © 2011
http://www.ijser.org
Abstract retrieved March 18, 2011, from ProQuest Direct
database.
[13] Pfeiffer, J. (2010, November 12). Germany’s Experience in
Upscaling RenewableEnergy: Pricing and Compensation
Issues. South Asian Survey. Abstract retrieved April2, 2011,
from SAGE Journals Online database.
[14] Schilling, M., Chiang, L. (2011, February). The Effects of
Natural Resources on aSustainable Development Policy: The
Approach of Non-Sustainable Externalities. Kidlington,
39(2), 990. Abstract retrieved April 6, 2011, from ProQuest
Direct database.
[15] U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Efficiency and
Renewable Energy. (1999). U.S.Department of Energy,
Building Energy Codes Program. Retrieved April 2, 2011,
from
http://www.docstoc.com/docs/17344954/ashrae_99_full
[16] U.S. Department of Energy. (2010). Guide to Financing
EnergySmart Schools. RetrievedApril 8, 2011, from ERIC
database.
[17] U.S. Department of Energy. (2011, February 9). Renewable
Energy Technologies.Retrieved March 15, 2011,
fromhttp://www.eere.energy.gov/
basics/renewable_energy/
[18] U.S. Energy Administration, Independent Statistics and
Analysis. (2010). International Energy Outlook 2010: Natural
Gas. Retrieved April 6, 2011, from
http://www.eia.doe.gov/oiaf/ieo/nat_gas.html
[19] Wikipedia. Renewable energy. Retrieved March 12, 2011,
from http://en.wikipedia.org /wiki/Renewable energy
[20] Wikipedia. Virtual Power Plant. Retrieved April 10, 2011,
fromhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtual_power_plant
[21] Zaffos, J. (2011, April 8). The New Energy Economy
[Electronic version]. Northern Colorado Business Report.
Retrieve April 10, 2011, from http://www.ncbr.com/
article.asp?id=57002