Academia.eduAcademia.edu

The evolving ideology of the global jihad: a discursive approach

2009, Focus Paper - Royal Higher Institure for Defence

In this contribution, we will discuss developments in jihad ideology. First, we will take the reader on a journey back in time, to frame the origin of doctrines concerning jihad in classical Islam and the fundaments of Islamic law. Then, we will focus on the emergence of political Islam, its radicalisation and the new doctrines on jihad that it brought about. We will see how 'international jihad' emerged as a very special strain of radical political Islam, with al-Qaida and Osama bin Laden as its best known protagonists.

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