Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Inexperienced knappers, but not wandering around

2023, EAA'23 Meetong / Belfast

Located near a permanent stream, at the base of a smooth slope, directly over Turonian deposits delivering excellent flint nodules, the Maîtreaux archaeological site (Indre-et-Loire, France) shows a series of exceptionally well preserved Solutrean occupation levels characterized by the abundance of lithic remains derived from systematic production of shouldered points, backed bladelet blanks and large bifacial laurel leaves, all to be exported from the site either as preforms or finished tool elements. The multidisciplinary study of the site produced an image of consecutive, seemly short, stays of relatively small groups, mostly composed of experienced knappers coming to the site to explore the local flint sources and produce reserves of specialized lithic tools. Nonetheless, a small portion of the refitted lithic operative chains undoubtfully testifies the presence of less competent knappers (moreover showing very diverse technicity levels, conceptual knowledge, experience, access to proper knapping tools, and specific patterns of intra-site spatial distribution), thus complicating the “experienced knappers party” picture. If any direct interpretation of technological evidence of insufficient knowledge or knapping experience as the “work” of children or juveniles should be ruled out as oversimplifying, at Les Maîtreaux, it is the combined analysis of technological, raw-material, and spatial data that can shed light on the on-site actions of these inexperienced knappers and help understand their role in the group and their presence at Maîtreaux.

Inexperienced knappers … BUT NOT WANDERING AROUND Miguel ALMEIDA (Dryas / Morph / Octopetala) [email protected] Thierry AUBRY (FCP – Fundação Côa Parque) [email protected] Bertrand WALTER (SERAP Vallée de la Claise) [email protected] Jean-Baptiste PEYROUSE (SERAP Vallée de la Claise) [email protected] SERAP Vallée de la Claise Société Études et Recherches sur le Paléolithique de la Vallée de la Claise why lillehammer? ■ “Meticulous Archaeology” “(…) the children and childhood perspective should form the regular part of an ever expanding meticulously archaeology of research practice on the macro/micro levels.” (Grete Lillehammer, 2018) S olutréen des Maîtreaux Le groupe solutréen Perspectives sur la technologie et répartition spatiale des vestiges lithiques et ses implications pour l’interprétation paléthnologique du registre archéologique Stage de technologie lithique – Étiolles 2005 Étiolles, 25-28 May 2005 location and context ■ Claise valley / Central France ■ Water, biotic and mineral resources ■ Regional Palaeolithic sequence e e us re C Clais Paléolithique supérieur Paléolithique moyen Paléolithique inférieure N 10 kms the upper turonian attraction ■ Direct location on the C3C flint source ■ Dimensions, morphology and aptitude ■ Complementary nearby flint sources ■ Systematic production goals ■ Laurel leaves ■ Shouldered points ■ Backed bladelets C3c small foliated points gîtes localisés ~ 60.000 coordinated objects Les Maîtreaux 50 cm 1 km 1 cm N shouldered points « Type J » laurel leaves backed bladelets Smith’s type J laurel leaves 10 cms geoarchaeological conditions ■ Almost pristine stratigraphic context ■ Consecutive occupations ■ Solutrean large-size laurel leaf models 1m S N long refitted laurel leaf shapping sequences diachronic spatial unities O N M SYSTEMATIC REFITTING 20 SPATIAL ANALYSYS 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 17 15 FIELD OBSERVATIONS STATISTICAL ANALYSIS MICROMORPHOLOGY 18 19 kind of a “workshop” ■ Preform and blank exportation ? PHASE : pressed to leave? ■ Time and logistics ■ … away from flint ■ Weight reduction INITIAL INTERMEDIATE ADVANCED FINAL PECH DE LA BOISSIÈRE SOLUTRÉ JEANBLANCS FOURNEAU DU DIABLE Solutrean data ▪ Preform morphology WIDTH / THICKNESS RATIO Flaking technique Raw material testing Volume configuration Preparation procedures Maîtreaux data ▪ Technology ▪ Spatial analysis Spatial distribution PHASING : 5,7 morphology Progressive attention PRESSURE ORGANIC percussion expedive Intensive importing raw and tested flint nodules PREFORME 5,2 thinning STONE percussion Préparation des éclats 4,8 Reasonned progression Maîtreaux Strategic intention 3,6 exporting advanced preforms THINNING SHAPING CONCLUSION ◼ blank supports deficit 10 Laurel leaves cms Backed bladelets Shouldered points production for deferred use Retouched blades Perforators Burins Endscrappers technical (and social) diversity ■ Abandoned used toolsRETOUCHED TOOLS ■ Ochre and pigments ■ Graphic manifestations ■ Absence of organic matter ▪ engraved ▪ endscrappers limestone used slabonsite 0 2 X USE-WEAR ANALYSIS by Hugues Plisson 1m ORGANIC HAMMER LIPS who’s here? ■ Technicity levels ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ Conceptual knowledge Strategic know-how Motor experience Raw-material selection Tool access tech level implications ■ ■ ■ Group structure and composition Territory and subsistence strategies Knowledge transfer procedures LOGISTIC SITES MAÎTREAUX ? allochthonous ▪ BLADE BLANKS ▪ RETOUCHED TOOLS ▪ FLINT NODULES LOCAL FLINT NEARBY SOURCES ▪ BLADE BLANKS ▪ SHOULDERED POINTS ▪ BACKED BLADELETS ▪ TESTED NODULES ▪ INITIAL PREFORMS ▪ PREFORMES COMPLEMENTARY SITES C3a ROCHES D’ABILLY MAÎTREAUX FRITSCH GUITIÈRE MONTHAUD TANNERIE PLACARD RAIL FOURNEAU DU DIABLE LAUGERIE-HAUTE CANTALOUETTE 2 PECH DE LA BOISSIÈRE JEANBLANCS VOLGU field method ■ Excavation specs ■ geoarchaeology, recovery, screening, and geolocation lab method ■ Multidisciplinary approach Bertrand WALTER Bruce BRADLEY Raw material identification Systematic refitting Experimental program Technological analysis Spatial analysis Functional analysis Palethological reconstituition Thierry AUBRY ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ Michel LENOIR Lab work Serge MAURY Jacques PELEGRIN ■ tech proficiency ■ DEFINING SKILL STRATEGIC INTENTIONAL OVERSHOOT FLAKING STRATEGY AND EFFICIENCY ■ Bruce’s expeditive early phase shaping… Fracture de fissuration ■ ■ Pigeot’86: “necessary and sufficient actions” x2 ■ … Solutreans solving geometry problems Workshop’05 ARCHAEOLOGICAL REFIT archaeological hard evidence of experience ■ CONFIRMED KNAPPERS ■ ■ ■ ■ Strategic competence Exhausted blade cores Successful preform exportation Complex recovery procedures 10 cms 10 cms Maîtreaux O18/0115 L14/0035 archaeological hard evidence of experience previous ■ CONFIRMED KNAPPERS ■ ■ ■ ■ shapping flakes Strategic competence Exhausted blade cores Successful preform exportation Complex recovery procedures 10 previous accident apical correction intentional overshot hinged mass cms cms 10 0 0 hard evidence of inexperience ■ NOVICE KNAPPERS (=CHILDREN?) ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ Conceptual knowledge Strategic planning Motoric experience Raw material availability Access to knapping tools MORPHOMETRIC EXHAUSTION ERRORS CAUSING IRRECOVERABLE LOSS OF CONFORMATION CRITERIA (REPURPOSED) CORES EXPLORED WITH HARD STONE HAMMER REVEALING VERY DIVERSE LEVELS OF TECHNICAL CONTROL EXPLORED STONE HAMMER hard evidence of inexperience ■ NOVICE KNAPPERS (=CHILDREN?) ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ Conceptual knowledge Strategic planning Motoric experience Raw material availability Access to knapping tools 10 cms Maîtreaux O13/0157 hard evidence of inexperience ■ NOVICE KNAPPERS (=CHILDREN?) ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ Conceptual knowledge Strategic planning Motoric experience Raw material availability Access to knapping tools 10 cms Maîtreaux N13/0061 2 x hard evidence of inexperience ■ NOVICE KNAPPERS (=CHILDREN?) ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ Conceptual knowledge Strategic planning Motoric experience Raw material availability Access to knapping tools 10 cms Maîtreaux O14/0150 hard evidence of inexperience ■ PROGRESSING KNAPPERS ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ Conceptual knowledge Strategic planning Motoric experience Raw material availability Access to knapping tools 10 cms hard evidence of inexperience ■ PROGRESSING KNAPPERS Conceptual knowledge Strategic planning Motoric experience Raw material availability Access to knapping tools 10 STRIKING PLATFORM MANAGEMENT DIFFICULTIES cms ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ 0 RECURRENT HINGED FRACTURES IMPROPER USE OF A HARD STONE HAMMER where were they (… playing)? ■ Spatial distribution of “level zero” blade cores cms 10 0 Concentration de débitages malhabiles more than just imitation ■ Evidence of ACTIVE TEACHING cms 10 0 ◼ Tentative shaping reduction sequence by an unexperienced knapper with intervention of a confirmed knapper more than just imitation ■ Indications of ACTIVE TEACHING SECONDARY HSH SEQUENCE 10 cms INITIAL HSH THINNING FIRST EXPERT INTERVENTION SECOND EXPERT INTERVENTION more than just imitation ■ Evidence of ACTIVE TEACHING 10 cms X2 x 2 more than just imitation ■ Evidence of ACTIVE TEACHING Imitation… and play(?) ■ Imitation of technical actions ■ Mimicking other grown-up activities? ■ A child’s play? SERAP Vallée de la Claise Société Études et Recherches sur le Paléolithique de la Vallée de la Claise