This is a bit perplexing to me.
When I do a NSLOOKUP on 10.0.0.17 it comes back as "ProductionServer01.domain.com" which is a decommissioned server. 10.0.0.17 is actually ProductionServer02.domain.com, and when I NSLOOKUP that hostname, the correct IP comes back.
I logged into MainDC04 and checked the DNS records for ProductionServer02, and it is listed as 10.0.0.17, and ProductionServer01 is listed as 10.0.0.85. This is the correct addressing for these machines.
I did flush my DNS records, and test from a different machines (MainDC04 and another laptop I had lying around).
Is this even something I should be concerned about, or can it be ignored? Any thoughts on the cause of this issue would be appreciated.
TL:DR; ProductionServer01: 10.0.0.85 ProductionServer02: 10.0.0.17
DNS lookups put ProductionServer01 as 10.0.0.17 and 10.0.0.85
Our Main Domain Controller is a Windows Server 2012 machine, and we have 2 older DCs running 2k3.