The Babysitter Murders - Cast

Name	Known for
Caitlin Custer The Babysitter The Babysitter See fewer	The Mortuary Collection (2019)
Ben Hethcoat The Killer The Killer See fewer	Gary's Garden (2011)
Alison Gallaher Mrs. Debra Kubler Mrs. Debra Kubler See fewer	The Mortuary Collection (2019)
Mike C. Nelson Dr. Harold Kubler Dr. Harold Kubler See fewer	Shrinking (2023)
Bradley Bundlie Logan Kubler Logan Kubler See fewer	American Housewife (2016)
DeMorge Brown Don Weaver Don Weaver See fewer	The Dress Up Gang (2019)
Trian Long Smith Nora Waters Nora Waters See fewer	The Darkness (I) (2016)
Joe Hartzler Deputy Wilkes Deputy Wilkes See fewer	ThanksKilling 3 (2012)
Barak Hardley Deputy Barns Deputy Barns See fewer	Bounty Killer (2013)
Robert Craighead Detective Lou Mass Detective Lou Mass See fewer	Future Man (2017)
Sam Eidson The Slasher The Slasher See fewer	A Day Without Roses (2012)
Kayli Hernandez Sally Sally See fewer	The Mortuary Collection (2019)
Kirk C. Johnson Kirk Kirk See fewer	Beeps (2024)
Josephine McAdam Faye Faye See fewer	Tower (2016)
Katie Folger Kirk's Girlfriend (uncredited) Kirk's Girlfriend (uncredited) See fewer	Day 5 (2016)