More new types for 1.0.x minor release #194
Conversation
Compiled from discussions on csl-evolution, zotero-bits, schema, and documentation. Also from the CSL-M spec. 1. `performance` is needed for live performances. Arts and musicology styles have distinct formatting rules for live performances versus conference-style presentations 2. `perdiodical` is for references to whole periodicals (e.g., a run of a journal, a special issue) 3. `collection` is for museum or archival collections. I believe that this would also cover citation of exhibitions/exhibit catalogues (@adam3smith?) 4. `hearing` and `regulation` are legal types with distinct citation needs that `bill` or `legislation` (e.g., 5. `classic` refers to ancient works with unique citation forms versus modern works Two CSL-M types I omitted: 1. `video`: - Defined as "The video type is appropriate for video works that are not disseminated through an access-restricted distribution channel. For example, content hosted on YouTube should be set to `video`, while a DVD release of “The Wizard of Oz” should be set to `motion_picture`." - I don't think this is a meaningful distinction, and I'm not sure that such a distinction is required by citation styles. 1. `gazette`: - A specific pubication format for some legal items - Appears to be superseded by a `gazette-flag` variable that might be assigned for types `legislation` or `regulation`.
|
I requested reviews from a few people. Hoping they can do this sometime during the coming week. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Question: do any of these close existing issues we control?
If yes, see this:
Also, I think the actual commit message can omit some of the details on the PR submission message.
You can amend the latest commit message like this:
git commit --amend
git push --force
|
Where do we stand on closing the zotero-bits issues that also entail Zotero changes? |
|
Obviously we wouldn't want to close them, but we could link from here.
We should also probably transfer those to Zotero?
|
We've had some discussion about this a couple of weeks ago, right? Perhaps we can just transfer the whole repo to Zotero once we've dealt with the CSL part... |
|
@bdarcus Could you give me editing rights To that repo so I can add a “zotero” tag to issues as we resolve them? |
|
I just gave you "triage" rights, which I think works for what you need. Let me know if not. |
|
Updated the commit comment to close issues. For zotero-bits issues, I added (By the way, for the extended commit comments, you can edit them directly on GitHub, rather than having to use git commands.) |
|
I don't see any changes ATM. Latest commit says yesterday. |
|
I just updated the commit comment, didn't make a new commit. The bottom of the commit comment now closes 2 issues. |
|
Ah, sorry. The vertical bars overlapped with my editor’s indentation guides and I didn’t notice. |
Dan Stillman actually asked for this here: zotero/zotero-bits#73 (comment) |
|
Yeah, so once we've finished tagging everything with |
|
OK, merged. Thanks. Note, I simplified the commit message, since that info is included here. |
Separate PRs coming for variables and terms.
Compiled from discussions on csl-evolution, zotero-bits, schema, and documentation. Also from the CSL-M spec.
performanceis needed for live performances. Arts and musicology styles have distinct formatting rules for live performances versus conference-style presentationsperiodicalis for references to whole periodicals (e.g., a run of a journal, a special issue)collectionis for museum or archival collections. I believe that this would also cover citation of exhibitions/exhibit catalogues (@adam3smith?)hearingandregulationare legal types with distinct citation needs thatbillorlegislation(e.g., Congressional hearings).classicrefers to ancient works with unique citation forms versus modern works (widely used in classical and biblical studies, for example).Two CSL-M types I omitted:
video:video, while a DVD release of “The Wizard of Oz” should be set tomotion_picture."gazette:gazette-flagvariable that might be assigned for typeslegislationorregulation.Closes citation-style-language/csl-evolution#22
Closes #22
Addresses #95
I've tagged zotero-bits issues with a
zoterotag to indicate that all that remains on them is Zotero implementation.