User:Beland/Civilization restart
Stability of democracy
edit- Graduated to Democracy#Disruption!
- Merge lists to Democratic backsliding by country; see also Democracy, Democratic backsliding
User:Freoh says: "there's a lot wrong with this map - political boundaries are historically wrong, and colonies like Alaska are not labelled as such"
VERY INCOMPLETE LIST, PROBABLY NOT SUITABLE TO USE
Autocracies that look like democracies are a threat across the globe
- March 1949 Syrian coup d'état
- 1973 Chilean coup d'état temporarily made Chile a military dictatorship. The Chilean transition to democracy ended when Patricio Aylwin became president in March 1990.
- Thailand#Contemporary history
Oldest:
- Athenian democracy - military coups, Roman conquest
Case studies of interest:
Whatever happened to
edit- Classical Athens - 508–322 BC - List of republics: Various Greek city-states under Classical Athenian influence; these loyalties and governments changed frequently (see synoecisms), and in some instances were even under the influence of Sparta without succumbing to oligarchy.
- Ancient Carthage - 480–146 BC - Fate: military defeat by Rome (another republic) in the Punic Wars ... List of republics: In 308 BC, an attempted coup to restore the monarch to full power failed, which led to Carthage retaining its republican government.[1]
- Republic of Sassari (1275-1323) - military surrender to Alfonso IV of Aragon, an absolute monarch
- Islamic Republic of Afghanistan (9 October 2004 – 15 August 2021) - military conquest - 2021 Taliban offensive
- Ecclesia (Sparta) - Sparta - absorbed into Roman Republic
- Licchavi Republic - conquered by Magadha in the Magadha-Vajji war
UNCLEAR SO FAR:
- Gotland (?-1285) - conquered, restored with Swedish democratization
- Novgorod Republic (1136–1478)[2] - Mixed government
- Bajjāna (886-922) - absorbed into Caliphate of Córdoba, unclear enfranchisement
YET TO RESEARCH:
- Republic#History and History of democracy explain a lot!
- Maritime republics - Venice, Genoa, Pisa, Amalfi, Ragusa (now Dubrovnik), Gaeta, Ancona, and the little Noli.
- Upstalsboom League (c. 12th century–15th century)
- Icelandic Commonwealth (930–1262)
- Couto Misto (c. 1000 – 1868)
- Taifa of Córdoba (1031–1070)
- Republic of Florence (1115–1537)
- Republic of Siena (1125–1557)
- Novgorod Republic (1136–1478)[3]
- Commune of Rome (1144–1193)
- Most Serene Republic of Lucca (1160–1805)
- Haudenosaunee (c. 13th century–1794)
- Old Swiss Confederacy (1291–1798)
- Republic of Poljica (1322–1806)
- Republic of Senarica (1343–1797)
- Pskov Republic (1348–1510)
- Confederacy of Tlaxcala (1348–1520)
- Dithmarschen (c. 1400 – 1559)
- Republic of Cospaia (1440–1826)
- Golden Ambrosian Republic (1447–1450)
- Most Serene Republic of Venice (697–1797)
- Republic of Gaeta (839–1140)
- Republic of Amalfi (839–1131)
- Republic of Ancona (c. 1000 – 1532)
- Republic of Pisa (c. 1000 – 1406, 1494–1509)
- Most Serene Republic of Genoa (c. 1100 – 1797)
- Republic of Noli (1192–1797)
- Republic of Ragusa (1358–1808) - aristocratic
- Free Imperial City of Ulm (de jure: 1290–1803; de facto: 1184–1803)
- Free Imperial City of Lübeck (1226–1811)
- Free Imperial City of Offenburg (c. 1240–1803)
- Free Imperial City of Regensburg (1245-1486; 1496–1803)
- Free Imperial City of Buchau (c. 1250–1803)
- Free Imperial City of Wimpfen (c. 1300–1803)
- Free Imperial City of Mühlhausen (1347–1798)
- Free Imperial City of Bremen (de jure: 1654–1811; de facto: 1366–1811)
- Republic of Gersau (1433–1798)
- Zaporizhian Sich (1552–1775)
- Polish–Lithuanian Commonwealth (1569–1795)
- Dutch Republic (1581–1795)
- Saint-Malo (1590–1594)
- Republic of Salé (1619–1668)
- Cossack Hetmanate (1649–1764)
- Commonwealth of England (1649–1660)
- Republic of Pirates (1706–1718)
- Corsican Republic (1755–1769)[4]
- Republic of Paulava (1769–1795)
- Lanfang Republic (1777–1884)
- Vermont Republic (1777–1791)[5]
- First French Republic (1792–1804)
- Republic of Graaff-Reinet (1795–1796)
- State of Muskogee (1799–1803)
- Republic of Liège (1789–1791)
- Rauracian Republic (1792–1793)
- Republic of Bouillon (1794–1795)
- Batavian Republic (1795–1806)
- Cispadane Republic (1796–1797)
- Transpadane Republic (1796–1797)
- Anconine Republic (1797–1798)
- Cisalpine Republic (1797–1802)
- Cisrhenian Republic (1797–1802)
- Ligurian Republic (1797–1805)
- Tiberina Republic (1798)
- Piedmontese Republic (1798–1799)
- Helvetic Republic (1798–1802)
- Roman Republic (1798–1799)
- Republic of Lucca (1799–1805)
- Subalpine Republic (1800–1802)
- Italian Republic (1802–1805)
- Rhodanic Republic (1802–1810)
- Swiss Confederation (1803–1815)
- Republic of Ragusa (1806–1808)
- Free City of Danzig (1807–1814)
- Republic of Maryland (1853–1857)
- Orange Free State (1854–1902)
- South African Republic (1856–1877; 1881–1902)
- First Republic of Haiti (1806–1811)
- State of Haiti (1810–1811)
- Federal Republic of Central America (1823–1841)
- Republic of Indian Stream (1832–1835)
- Republic of Texas (1836–1845)
- Republic of Canada (1837–1838)
- State of Los Altos (1838–1840; 1848–1849)
- Republic of Yucatán (1840–1843; 1846–1848)
- First Dominican Republic (1844–1861)
- California Republic (June–July 1846)
- State of Deseret (1849–1850)
- Republic of Sonora (15 October 1853 – 8 May 1854)
- Confederate States of America (1860–1865)
- Republic of Manitobah (1867–1869)
- United States of Central America (1896–1898)
- Republic of Entre Ríos (1820–1821)
- Peru–Bolivian Confederation (1836–1839)
- Riograndense Republic (1836–1845)
- United States of Venezuela (1864-1953)
- Republic of Independent Guiana (20 July 1886–1891)
- Republic of the United States of Brazil (1889-1930)
- Republic of Ezo (1868–1869)
- First Philippine Republic (1898–1901)
- Septinsular Republic (1800–1815)
- Republic of Genoa (1814–1815)
- United States of the Ionian Islands (1815–1864)
- Free City of Krakow (1815–1846)
- Free City of Bremen (1815–1871)
- Free City of Hamburg (1815–1871)
- Free City of Lübeck (1815–1871)
- Neutral Moresnet (1816–1920)
- First Hellenic Republic (1828–1832)
- Second French Republic (1848–1852)
- Free Cities of Menton and Roquebrune (1848–1861)
- Roman Republic (February–April 1849)
- Third French Republic (1871–1940)
- First Spanish Republic (1873–1874)
- Republic of Tamrash (1878–1886)
- Republic of Hawai'i (1894–1898)
- Tripolitanian Republic (16 November 1918–1922)
- Confederal Republic of the Tribes of the Rif (18 September 1921 – 27 May 1926)
- Republic of Tanganyika (9 December 1962 – 26 April 1964)
- People's Republic of Zanzibar and Pemba (12 January 1964 – 26 April 1964)
- Biafra (30 May 1967 – 15 January 1970)
- Rhodesia (2 March 1970 – 11 December 1979)
- Republic of Acre (1st: 15 July 1899 – 15 March 1900; 2nd: November 1900–24 December 1900 3rd: 27 January 1903 – 11 November 1903)
- First United States of Brazil (16 July 1934 – 29 October 1945)
- Second United States of Brazil (31 January 1946 – 31 March 1964)
- Republic of Venezuela (11 April 1953 – 15 December 1999)
- Republic of Anguilla (12 July 1967 – 19 March 1969)
- Urjanchai Republic (1 December 1911 – 17 April 1914)
- Transcaucasian Democratic Federative Republic (22 April 1918 – 28 May 1918)
- Democratic Republic of Armenia (28 May 1918 – 2 December 1920)
- Democratic Republic of Azerbaijan (28 May 1918 – 28 April 1920)
- Kars Republic (1 December 1918 – 19 April 1919)
- Republic of Aras (December 1918 – Mid-June 1919)
- Azerbaijan Soviet Socialist Republic (28 April 1920 – 12 March 1922)
- Armenian Soviet Socialist Republic (2 December 1920 – 12 March 1922)
- Republic of Mountainous Armenia (26 April 1921 – 13 July 1921)
- Tuvan People's Republic (14 August 1921 – 11 October 1944)
- Mongolian People's Republic (24 November 1924 – 13 February 1992)
- Commonwealth of the Philippines (15 November 1935 – 4 July 1946)
- Second Philippine Republic (14 November 1943 – 11 June 1945)
- Third Philippine Republic (4 July 1946 – 30 December 1965)
- Republic of South Maluku (15 April 1950 – 12 April 1963)
- Fourth Philippine Republic (30 December 1965–22/25 February 1986)
- Kruševo Republic (3 August 1903 – 13 August 1903)
- First Portuguese Republic (5 October 1910 – 26 May 1926)
- Independent Government of Western Thrace (31 August 1913 – 25 October 1913)
- Ukrainian People's Republic (25 January 1917 – 29 April 1918; 14 December 1918–18 March 1921)
- Mountainous Republic of the Northern Caucasus (11 May 1917–January 1921)
- Crimean People's Republic (13 December 1917–January 1918)
- Moldavian Democratic Republic (6 February 1918 – 10 December 1918)
- Kuban People's Republic (16 February 1918 – 17 March 1920)
- Belarusian People's Republic (9 March 1918–1919)
- Lithuania (16 February 1918 – 3 August 1940)
- Estonia (24 February 1918 – 6 August 1940)
- Don Republic (18 May 1918–1920)
- Democratic Republic of Georgia (26 May 1918 – 25 April 1921)
- Commonwealth of Zakopane (13 October 1918 – 16 November 1918)
- West Ukrainian People's Republic (18 October 1918 – 22 January 1919)
- Komancza Republic (4 November 1918 – 24 January 1919)
- Republic of Tarnobrzeg (6 November 1918–Spring 1919)
- People's State of Bavaria (8 November 1918 – 6 April 1919)
- Republic of German-Austria (12 November 1918 – 10 September 1919)
- Second Polish Republic (16 November 1918 – 6 October 1939)
- Latvia (18 November 1918 – 5 August 1940)
- First Czechoslovak Republic (28 October 1918 – 30 September 1938)
- Lemko-Rusyn People's Republic (5 December 1918–March 1920)
- First Austrian Republic (10 September 1919 – 1 May 1934)
- Free State of Fiume (12 November 1920 – 22 February 1924)
- Republic of Central Lithuania (12 October 1920 – 24 March 1922)
- Free City of Danzig (15 November 1920 – 2 September 1939)
- Georgian Soviet Socialist Republic (25 February 1921 – 12 March 1922)
- Second Hellenic Republic (1924–1935)
- Catalan Republic (14 April 1931 – 17 April 1931)
- Second Spanish Republic (de facto: 1931–1939; de jure: 1931–1975)
- Second Czechoslovak Republic (30 September 1938 – 15 March 1939)
- Carpatho-Ukraine (30 December 1938 – 18 March 1939)
- Slovak State (14 March 1939 – 4 April 1945)
- Republic of West Papua (1961–1963)
- Republic of Ancona (c. 1000 – 1532)
- Republic of Ragusa (1358–1808)
- Saint-Malo (1590–1594)
- Republic of Salé (1619–1668)
- Corsican Republic (1755–1769)[4]
- Vermont Republic (1777–1791)[5]
- Republic of Graaff-Reinet (1795–1796)
- Republic of Lucca (1799–1805)
- Republic of Ragusa (1806–1808)
- Republic of Spanish Haiti (1821-1822)
- First Mexican United States (1824-1835)
- Centralist Republic of Mexico (1835-1846)
- Free State of Costa Rica (1838-1847)
- Republic of Honduras (1838-1896)
- Republic of Nicaragua (1838-1896)
- Republic of El Salvador (1841-1896)
- Second Mexican United States (1846-1863)
- First Costa Rican Republic (1848-1948)
- Republic of Baja California (15 October 1853-January 1854)
- Confederate States of America (1860–1865)
- Second Dominican Republic (1865-1916)
- American Confederation of Venezuela (1811-1819)
- United Provinces of the Río de la Plata (1816-1831)
- Republic of Gran Colombia (1819-1831)
- Free Province of Guayaquil (1820-1829)
- Republic of Tucumán (1820-1821)
- Republic of Peru (1824-1836)
- Republic of Bolivia (1825-1836)
- State of Venezuela (1830-1864)
- Argentine Confederation (1831-1861)
- Republic of New Granada (1831-1858)
- Republic of North Peru (1836)
- Peru–Bolivian Confederation (1836–1839)
- Republic of Bolivia (1839-2009)
- State of Buenos Aires (1852-1861)
- Granadine Confederation (1858-1863)
- United States of Colombia (1863-1886)
- United States of Venezuela (1864-1953)
- Republic of Independent Guiana (20 July 1886–1891)
- Republic of the United States of Brazil (1889-1930)
- Republic of Biak-na-Bato (1897)
- Republic of Gersau (1814-1818)
- Swiss Confederation (1814-1848)
- Free City of Frankfurt (1816-1866)
- First Hellenic Republic (1828–1832)
- Free Cities of Menton and Roquebrune (1848–1861)
- Republic of San Marco (March 1848-August 1849)
- Cantons of Alcoy, Algeciras, Alicante, Almansa, Andújar, Bailén, Béjar, Cadiz, Camuñas, Castellón, Córdoba, Granada, Gualchos, Huelva, Jaén, Jumilla, Loja, Málaga, Motril, Murcia, Orihuela, Plasencia, Salamanca, San Fernando, Sevilla, Tarifa, Torrevieja, Valencia (1873) and Cartagena (1873-1874)
- People's Republic of Zanzibar and Pemba (12 January 1964 – 26 April 1964)
- Transkei (26 October 1976 - 27 April 1994)
- Bophuthatswana (6 December 1977 - 28 April 1994)
- Venda (13 September 1979 - 28 April 1994)
- Ciskei (4 December 1981 - 28 April 1994)
- Third Dominican Republic (1924-12 July 1965)
- Republic of Aras (December 1918 – Mid-June 1919)
- South Vietnam (26 October 1955 - 30 April 1975)
- Afghanistan (since 1973-1992)[6]
- Republic of German-Austria (12 November 1918 – 10 September 1919)
- Lemko-Rusyn People's Republic (5 December 1918–March 1920)
- Second Hellenic Republic (1924–1935)
- Carpatho-Ukraine (30 December 1938 – 18 March 1939)
- Slovak State (14 March 1939 – 4 April 1945)
Free imperial cities
editA free imperial city was a self-ruling city member of the Holy Roman Empire that was represented in the Imperial Diet.
German mediatisation - 1803 Dissolution of the Holy Roman Empire - 1806 - Napoleon
Some conquered earlier.
Oligarchic, maybe some semi-enfranchised.
- Free Imperial City of Worms (c. 11th century-1789)
- Free Imperial City of Goslar (1081-1802)
- Free Imperial City of Aachen (1166-1801)
- Free Imperial City of Besançon (1184-1654)
- Free Imperial City of Hamburg (1189-1806;)
- Free Imperial City of Konstanz (1192-1548)
- Free Imperial City of Wetzlar (c. 12th century-1803)
- Free Imperial City of Friedberg (1211-1806)
- Free Imperial City of Nördlingen (1215-1803)
- Free Imperial City of Nuremberg (1219-1806)
- Free Imperial City of Nordhausen (1220-1802)
- Free Imperial City of Pfullendorf (1220-1803)
- Free Imperial City of Rheinfelden (1225-1330)
- Free Imperial City of Colmar (1226-1679)
- Free Imperial City of Esslingen (1229-1802/3)
- Free Imperial City of Reutlingen (1240-1803)
- Free Imperial City of Bopfingen (1241-1802)
- Free Imperial City of Mainz (1241-1462)
- Free Imperial City of Regensburg (1245-1486; 1496–1803)
- Free Imperial City of Schweinfurt (1245-1803)
- Free Imperial City of Windsheim (1248-1802)
- Free Imperial City of Mühlhausen (1251-1803)
- Free Imperial City of Strasbourg (1262-1681)
- Free Imperial City of Memmigen (1268-1802)
- Free Imperial City of Rottweil (1268-1802)
- Free Imperial City of Überlingen (1268-1803)
- Free Imperial City of Gmünd (1268-1802)
- Free Imperial City of Rothenburg (1274-1803)
- Free Imperial City of Buchhorn (1275-1803)
- Free Imperial City of Lindau (1275-1802)
- Free Imperial City of Weil (1275-1803)
- Free Imperial City of Augsburg (1276-1803)
- Free Imperial City of Ravensburg (1276-1803)
- Free Imperial City of Hall (1280-1802)
- Free Imperial City of Biberach an der Riß (1281-1803)
- Free Imperial City of Kaufbeuren (1286-1803)
- Free Imperial City of Wangen (1286-1802)
- Free Imperial City of Cologne (1288-1801)
- Free Imperial City of Kempten (1289-1802/3)
- Free Imperial City of Dortmund (1293-1803)
- Free Imperial City of Leutkirch (1293-1803)
- Free Imperial City of Speyer (1294-1792)
- Free Imperial City of Weißenburg (1296-1802)
- Free Imperial City of Zell am Harmersbach (c. 14th century-1803)
- Free Imperial City of Donauwörth (1308-1607)
- Free Imperial City of Dinkelsbühl (1351-1802)
- Free Imperial City of Aalen (1360-1803)
- Free Imperial City of Gengenbach (1360-1803)
- Free Imperial City of Isny (1365-1803)
- Free Imperial City of Heilbronn (1371-1802)
- Free Imperial City of Frankfurt (1372-1806)
- Free Imperial City of Giengen (1391-1803)
- Free Imperial City of Diessenhofen (1415-1460)
- Free Imperial City of Soest (1449-1616)
- ^ Andrew Lintott, Violence, Civil Strife and Revolution in the Classical City: 750-330 BC, Routledge, 2014, p. 66.
- ^ "Brief history of Novgorod". waytorussia.net. Retrieved 26 December 2007.
- ^ "Brief history of Novgorod". waytorussia.net. Retrieved 26 December 2007.
- ^ a b Carrington, Dorothy, "The Corsican Constitution of Pasquale Paoli (1755–1769)," The English Historical Review, July 1973, pp 481–503
- ^ a b Van de Water, Frederic Franklyn (1974). The Reluctant Republic: Vermont 1724–1791. The Countryman Press. ISBN 0-914378-02-3.
- ^ Henry St. Amant Bradsher, Afghanistan and the Soviet Union, Duke University Press, 1983.
Formation
editMonarchies may form in a number of different ways, including:
- Conquest of neighboring lands by someone with wealth or military power
- Coup d'état or civil war overthrowing a government where multiple people shared power
Maintenance
editWhen a monarch dies, there are a few systems in current use to select the next one:
- Hereditary monarchy
- Elective monarchy
- Ex officio - by virtue of holding a different office
In constitutional monarchies, there may be an elected parliament with the power to determine the monarch or possibly to abolish the monarchy.
How currently active monarchies formed
editBy conquest
edit- Monarchy of the United Kingdom
- England - Unified under Alfred the Great of the House of Wessex. His distant relatives still rule, though the monarchy was interrupted by invasions by the House of Denmark, and the Interregnum (1649-1660). Which particular family members inherited the throne was influenced by wealthy nobiles, parliament, and military force (most notably the Norman conquest of England by William the Conqueror).
- Wales - somewhat united and sworn loyalty to England by Llywelyn the Great in 1216; Conquest of Wales by Edward I 1277-1283 results in Statute of Rhuddlan which annexes Wales to England; notional Principality of Wales absorbed into the Kingdom of England by Laws in Wales Acts 1535 and 1542 into the jurisdiction known as England and Wales
- Scotland - Unified under Kenneth MacAlpin, various dynasties, interruptions in monarchy (Guardians of Scotland); Union of the Crowns with England by personal union in 1603
- Northern Ireland - Partition of Ireland came after the Norman invasion of Ireland, Lordship of Ireland, and Kingdom of Ireland
- King of Bahrain
- Bani Utbah invasion of Bahrain under Ahmed ibn Muhammad ibn Khalifa, hereditary since then
Derived from the British monarchy
editThe United Kingdom colonized many territories around the world over its long history. Starting with the United States in 1776, some obtained independence and became republics without a monarch. 15 Commonwealth realms share the same person as monarch with the United Kingdom because their monarchies branched off from the British monarchy. The Statute of Westminster 1931 established that Dominions were legislatively independent and have independent monarchies, but also established the convention that any changes to the rules of inheritance must be agreed among all the dominions. These arrangements have been upheld in the formation and maintenance of the constitutions of the current realms, and in the Perth Agreement changes, which came into effect in all realms in 2015. Brunei, Eswatini, Lesotho, Malaysia, Tonga have chosen monarchs unrelated to the United Kingdom.
By invitation
edit- Monarchy of Belgium
- National Congress of Belgium after going through several candidates successfully invited a German prince to become Leopold I of Belgium; hereditary since then.
By election
edit- Monarchy of Cambodia
- As part of the settlement of the Cambodian Civil War, the Cambodia Constituent Assembly decided to create a ceremonial, elected monarchy. The political and religious leaders on the Royal Council of the Throne choose kings from the bloodlines which had held a hereditary monarchy until the Cambodian coup of 1970 declared a republic. The monarchy had originally been established through conquest.
- Holy See
- The Pope is both the leader of the Roman Catholic Church and the monarch of Vatican City, a theocracy created in 1929 by the Lateran Treaty. He is elected for life by the College of Cardinals, usually from their own group. The apostolic see of Rome, according to Catholic tradition, was founded by Christian apostles Paul and Peter. Papal primacy was not recognized by all Christians, and this issue resulted in schisms. Previously a private but influential property owner, the Pope gathered civic authority in the Duchy of Rome, which had been create by conquest of the Byzantine Empire. After the military defeat of the Byzantines, the Donation of Pepin created the much larger Papal States in 756, which expanded and contracted and were eventually lost by conquest of the Kingdom of Italy.
- O le Ao o le Malo
- It is unclear whether the head of state of Samoa is an elected monarch or the mostly ceremonial elected head of a republic. The office was established by the Westminster-style 1960 Constitution of Samoa which came into effect with its independence from New Zealand.
In exchange for land and military aid
editCo-Princes of Andorra reign in an unusual arrangement, sharing power between Bishop of Urgell and President of France, both of whom serve ex officio.
Tradition holds that Charlemagne created Andorra as a principality within the Frankish Carolingian Empire, in return for supplying troops to fight the Moors of the al-Andalus caliphate.[1] Andorra was in the Marca Hispanica, a border region between the two, and the Count of Urgell was designated overlord by Charles the Bald, Charlemagne's grandson. In 988, a descendant count, Borrell II, transferred Andorra to the Roman Catholic Diocese of Urgell (which includes Andorra and part of modern Spain) in exchange for church land in Cerdanya,[2] making the bishop the ex officio prince.
In 1095, the bishop requested military assistance (against the Count of Urgell) from the Lord of Caboet, in return signing a declaration of co-sovereignty.[3] The right of co-sovereignty passed through marriage and inheritance through the Count of Foix, the kings of Navarre, and then the King of France when King Henry III of Navarre became King Henry IV of France. The French head of state, including kings, emperors, and presidents, has held the position since, with a few interruptions.
The co-sovereignty arrangement was affirmed by Paréage of Andorra 1278, a 1607 edict from Henry IV, and the 1993 Constitution of Andorra approved by popular vote. It was interrupted several times:
- Brief annexations to the Crown of Aragon in 1396 and 1512.
- Renouncement of the French claim by the French First Republic in 1793 until restoration by Napoleon in 1806.
- Annexation with Catalonia to the First French Empire under Napoleon, reversed by the King Louis XVIII of France in 1814.
References
edit- ^ "El pas de Carlemany - Turisme Andorra la Vella". turisme.andorralavella.ad. Archived from the original on 3 August 2017. Retrieved 3 August 2017.
- ^ "La formació d'Andorra". Gran Enciclopèdia Catalana. Enciclopèdia Catalana. (in Catalan)
- ^ "Elements de la història del Principat d'Andorra" (in Catalan). Archived from the original on 9 February 2010.
Political correctness holding area
edit
Formerly in Category:Political correctness:
Political correctness Cisgender Code word (figure of speech) Collateral damage Color-blind casting Common Era Cosmic Trigger III: My Life After Death Counterstereotype Cultural appropriation Damning with faint praise Diversity (politics) Diversity training Euphemism Family values Freedom fries Freedom of thought Gender-blind Hate speech Hypatia transracialism controversy Ideological repression Inclusive language Kotobagari Language and thought Language ideology Language politics Linguistic prescription List of politically motivated renamings Lookism Loony left Microaggression Pavlovian session People-first language The Perils of "Privilege" Political insult Political socialization Post-racial America The Problem with a Poo Reappropriation Removal of Confederate monuments and memorials Reparations (website) Respect diversity Safe space Self-censorship Self-licensing Snowflake (slang) Social engineering (political science) Speech code Spinning into Butter (film) Suppressed research in the Soviet Union Thought-terminating cliché Thoughtcrime Xenocentrism
For reasons of inclusivity of specific racial or religious groups:
- Displays of the Confederate Flag
- Confederate monuments
- Native American mascots for predominantly European-American sports teams
- Blackface
- Mammy archetype
- Hollywood Indian
- Depictions of Muhammad
For political reasons:
- Glorification of violence or weapons, including toy weapons
- Depiction of tobacco smoking
- Depiction of drug use
Offensive to conservative viewpoints:
- Criticism of the character of military servicepersons[1]
Sometimes the use of particular language is politically controversial, such as a place name that favors one side or another in a territorial dispute. If there are egalitarian or human rights concerns associated with the controversy, liberal speakers can have a strong preferences for one term. For example, calling the country Burma instead of Myanmar might be a way of expressing solidarity with the Burmese people or opposition to the military government that ruled from 1962 to 2011 and which changed the name of the country. Referring to the city as Bombay rather than Mumbai might be considered to carry an air of colonialism, since "Bombay" is the Anglicised version used by English colonizers, whereas "Mumbai" is used in several indigenous languages. The use of the term "Native American" is popular because it emphasizes the status of being born in the Americas before Europeans, and because avoids the term "Indian" which was bestowed when Europeans who colonized and enslaved the indigenous people were confused as to whether or not they had arrived in Indies. (See Native American name controversy.)
Humor, especially insult humor and political humor, sometimes involves remarks that some people consider offensive. Depending on the context (for example, a comedy show vs. a workplace), the audience, the thoughtfulness of the comedy, and the specific implications or potential hurtfulness inflicted, such remarks may be received in good fun or may be seen as objectionable and "crossing the line".[2]
Social media have enabled people who want to criticize people who make "politically incorrect" remarks to do so immediately and directly.[2] One extreme example of online shaming of such comments is the Justine Sacco incident, in which a joke about AIDS in Africa posted before takeoff resulted in Justine Sacco losing her job by the time she landed.
Specific controversies related to political correctness include:
- Demands for use of inclusive language
- The Water buffalo incident and controversies about the word "niggardly", in which words which have no historical tie to racism and which are not used in a racist fashion are interpreted as racial slurs
- 2017 Berkeley protests
Any remarks seen as favoring a specific position on a controversial topic (such as abortion, gun rights, same-sex marriage, immigration) might be condemned by opponents of that position. For politicians, this can present worries about election or re-election if the constituency generally opposes the position or the votes of moderates are important. For businesses, this could result in a boycott. Such remarks might be termed "politically incorrect" in the sense that they are politically unacceptable to an important faction. Some of these positions or issues have been called the third rail of politics - anyone touching them is metaphorically electrocuted.
Dump from Category:Political correctness:
- Political correctness
- Cisgender
- Code word (figure of speech)
- Collateral damage
- Color-blind casting
- Common Era
- Cosmic Trigger III: My Life After Death
- Counterstereotype
- Cultural appropriation
- Damning with faint praise
- Deutsche Physik
- Diversity (politics)
- Diversity training
- Elephant in the room
- Euphemism
- Family values
- Freedom fries
- Freedom of thought
- Gender-blind
- Hate speech
- Hypatia transracialism controversy
- Ideological repression
- Inclusive language
- Kotobagari
- Language and thought
- Language ideology
- Language politics
- Linguistic prescription
- List of politically motivated renamings
- Lookism
- Loony left
- Microaggression
- Pavlovian session
- People-first language
- The Perils of "Privilege"
- Political insult
- Political socialization
- Post-racial America
- The Problem with a Poo
- Rakem Balogun
- Reappropriation
- Removal of Confederate monuments and memorials
- Reparations (website)
- Respect diversity
- Safe space
- Self-censorship
- Self-licensing
- Snowflake (slang)
- Social engineering (political science)
- Speech code
- Spinning into Butter (film)
- Suppressed research in the Soviet Union
- Thought-terminating cliché
- Thoughtcrime
- Xenocentrism
External articles:
References
edit- ^ See for example Politically Incorrect § Controversy and cancellation
- ^ a b The Limits Of Political Correctness (panel discussion)
Moved here
edit- Poverty, Extreme poverty, Poverty threshold, Talk:Poverty threshold -> archiving
- Technological revolution
- Knowledge economy
- Prosify government to better discuss civilian control of the military and other issues outside the form of government. Merge with political system?
- Automate updates to Wikipedia:WikiProject Countering systemic bias open tasks, using Template:CSBArticles?
- Wikipedia:WikiProject History of Science
- Article assessment, e.g.: http://toolserver.org/~enwp10/bin/table.fcgi?project=Bus_transport
- Keirsey Temperament Sorter may need merge from the four temperament articles?
- Private spaceflight
- Talk:Medication costs#Cleanup
- Homemaking and Housekeeping
- Magic (supernatural)
- Other (philosophy)
- Social Credit System
Photos
editMBTA Pictures
editHey i just read your profile and saw that you arw willing to take pictures arround boston. I am currently working on the List of MBTA subway stations, I'm trying to get it to featured list status, and have realized that most stations either do not have a picture or have a bad one. If you have time and find yourself walking past a T stop, could you snap a picture and add it to the stops page? That would help alot. Thanks in advance!--Found5dollar (talk) 15:35, 11 February 2009 (UTC)
Bot/analysis
editTo update
edit- Wikipedia:Neglected articles
- Wikipedia:WikiProject_Stub_sorting/Criteria/Current
- Wikipedia:Most wanted stubs help requested by Casliber, June 2013
- Wikipedia:Templates with red links, help requested by BD2412, June 2019
I am currently looking for help (a perl script) to parse and separate red and blue links for various lists at Missing encyclopedic articles. I have made a request at Wikipedia:Computer_help_desk#New_cases, but it has languished for over a week. There was a script that does some of what we need it to do developed by Avar, but it only works on a few of the many lists we are currently working on. Specifically I'm looking for something that would separate and sort a list like this:
- Link 1 External search for link 1 Comment about link 1 with link to another article]
- Nested comment about link
- Second nested comment
- Nested comment about link
- Wrongly nested comment
- Link2 Notice space has been removed
- Link3] Malformed links with [malformed link
into a list like this
Red links
- Link2 Notice space has been removed
- Link3] Malformed links with [malformed link
- Link4 Renumbering because of space
Blue links
- Link 1 External search for link 1 Comment about link 1 with link to another article]
- Nested comment about link
- Second nested comment
WronglyFixed nested comment
- Nested comment about link
- Link 5
- Link 6
This is a worst case example. The current script works well, but it evaluates link by link, not line by line and so [comments] about the link would be removed.
See separting reds and blues for more comments.
Your help would be greatly appreciated. --Reflex Reaction (talk)• 22:00, 17 January 2006 (UTC)
Yet another analysis project that screams "Beland!"
editHi - I've proposed a wikipedia wide project to find and eliminate instances within infobox-style templates of the anti-accessible technique of creating multiple visual rows withn a single row by embedding matching HTML breaks in two (or more) adjacent columns in a table, please see Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Usability#Infobox accessibility issue. So far, no one has signed up or in any way acknowledged that this is a problem worth pursuing (screw them blind folks - who needs em!). In any event, if you could whip up a little analysis program to find likely instances (difficult to be exact, but perhaps references to templates with multiple parameters whose values include an HTML break - being exact requires either looking at the rendered HTML or interpreting the template) it might help folks realize the magnitude of the problem. I'm pretty sure this is very widespread, and I've verified with a blind wikipedia user that it is a problem. If you could help, I'd appreciate it. -- Rick Block (talk) 04:13, 20 September 2006 (UTC)
- I've moved the description of the problem to Wikipedia:WikiProject Usability/Infobox accessibility and started a list of likely templates for manual checking (geographical infoboxes). -- Rick Block (talk) 03:13, 21 September 2006 (UTC)
Hello,
I'm currently renovating the old Wikipedia:Translation into English. I'm on the way of porting what I've done for fr:Projet:Traduction (it's not 100% translated yet, but don't worry)
I came accross Wikipedia:Community Portal/Opentask and noticed that it fit perfectly with what I intend to do. Could we add a new task for User:Pearle :
- Name : Translation Requests
- Content scan Category:Translation Request (or Category:Translation_sub-pages)
Send me an email if you need any information.
Jmfayard 11:21, 14 November 2006 (UTC)
New (hopefully simple request
editI've noticed lots of instances where people leave out spaces after links, parenthesis, and formatting syntax - e.g. they will write things like: It was a largecreature(possibly a dinosauror a giant wombat)which lived in the cavernof woe.
Can you pull together a page of all instances in article space of:
- A text character followed immediately by an open parens or bracket: x( or x[
- A close parens followed immediately by a text character: )x
- A text character followed immediately by italic or bolding syntax, which is in turn followed immediately by another text character: xx or x'x
Drop me a line and let me know.
Cheers! bd2412 T 23:06, 1 April 2007 (UTC)
Pearle action request
editHopefully I'm doing this right :) Can you use your Pearle bot to automatically put all of the articles in List of ADV releases into the category Category:ADV Films, and the ones in the list of licensed titles at Geneon#Anime licensed by Geneon USA into the category Category:Geneon? The Anime and manga project wants to get these lists into categories for better management, but not to many people are eager to manually tackle the categorizing. :P Collectonian (talk) 06:44, 5 February 2008 (UTC)
Status of Wikireason -- other projects
editHi Beland. Wikireason is "in hibernation" due to lack of participation. I've been offering advice to the admin of Chains of Reason, which seems to have similar goals to Wikireason and I think has a better chance of developing a sustainable community. If you are still interested, please check it out. You may also be interested in Debateopedia--which is more focused on documenting public debates, and less focused on developing logical arguments. AdamRetchless 02:16, 22 February 2007 (UTC)
From 2006
editActively monitoring
editShort-term
editQuite urgent now:
- Wikipedia talk:Community Portal - Spawning help and absorbing news - esp. Wikipedia:Help portal
- Wikipedia_talk:Bots#Chobot_exceeding_its_approved_behavior
- Proposed Iraqi constitution
- User talk:Beland requests!
- Wikipedia:WikiProject Usability/Main Page
- Wikipedia talk:Cleanup
Disputes:
- Talk:Offensive jihad
- Talk:Defensive jihad
- Talk:Rules of war in Islam
- Talk:Jihad, Jihad/draft
- List of terrorist organisations, Talk:List of terrorist organisations
Purge progress:
Image deletion:
- Wikipedia:Bot_requests#Pending_image_deletion_notifications
- Wikipedia_talk:Criteria_for_speedy_deletion#Warnings_requested_for_unidentified_images
- Wikipedia:Administrators'_noticeboard#image_deletion
- User_talk:Jimbo_Wales#image_deletion
- Wikipedia:Village_pump_(assistance)#.5B.5BUser_talk:Zscout370.23Photos.5D.5D
REPORTS:
- Wikipedia talk:Maintenance collaboration of the week
- Wikipedia:Bad links
- Wikipedia_talk:Cleanup#Sorted_cleanup.3F
- Wikipedia:Maintenance
- Template:Active Wiki Fixup Projects
- http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Toolserver#People
- Wikipedia_talk:Neglected_articles
Ongoing
editWatchlist checked through: end of 31 Jan 2005
- Wikipedia:Miscellany for deletion (underattended)
- Pearle
- User talk:Pearle
- Category:Articles to check for link ordering
- Category:Pearle edits needing manual cleanup
- m:Toolserver (stuff to be uploaded there)
- Wikipedia:LGBT notice board, Wikipedia:WikiProject Sexology and sexuality
- Wikipedia:Requests for comment/Religion and philosophy
- News: Wikipedia:Wikipedia_Signpost
- Wikipedia:Categories for deletion (for bot tasks)
- Wikipedia talk:Bots (for proposals)
- Wikipedia:Maintenance collaboration of the week
- Template_talk:Opentask (daily updates)
- Category:Wikipedia cleanup (talk) (regular refiling)
You can help improve the articles listed below! This list updates frequently, so check back here for more tasks to try. (See Wikipedia:Maintenance or the Task Center for further information.)
Help counter systemic bias by creating new articles on important women.
Help improve popular pages, especially those of low quality.
Censorship watch
edit- Wikipedia:Choosing appropriate illustrations
- Wikipedia:WikiProject Wikipedians against censorship
- Wikipedia:WikiProject Wikipedians for encyclopedic merit (formerly "Wikipedians for Decency")
- Wikipedia:WikiProject Wikipedians for encyclopedic merit/Working standard for encyclopedic merit of images
- Wikipedia:Toby
- Protected pages
- Wikipedia:Protected page
- Wikipedia:Requests for page protection
- Watch for comments on page protection/unprotection, unprotect any pages that no longer need to be protected
Meta cleanup
edit- Merge Wikipedia:Substub into Wikipedia:Stub.
- Category talk:Ireland
- Check up on Wikipedia:Boilerplate text
- Wikipedia:Links to disambiguating pages and Wikipedia:Multiple-place names must die!
- Wikipedia:Category schemes
Top priority cleanup
editMeta discussions:
- Wikipedia talk:Cleanup process
- Wikipedia_talk:Pages_needing_attention#Proposals_so_far
- User talk:Jekoko/Cleanup links
- Wikipedia:WikiProject Wikipedia Namespace
- Wikipedia talk:Categorization/Gender, race and sexuality
Meta cleanup:
- Wikipedia:Cleanup Taskforce/Members, then Wikipedia:Cleanup Taskforce
- Wikipedia:LGBT_notice_board/Archive_1#Mergers_and_renames
- Wikipedia:Votes_for_deletion/Homosexuality_and_morality
- Wikipedia_talk:Duplicate_articles#Depreciating_listings_on_this_page
- Wikipedia:Cleaning_department needs dusting off
- List of reports that might need updating (make table with last known update). (See Wikipedia:Maintenance.)
- Shouldn't Template:MainPageIntro use Template:Categorybrowsebar?
Content:
West Springfield/Pioneer Valley History
edit- Obtained source materials
- Extract and summarize
- Post full text of non-copyrighted content?
- Massachusetts
- Pioneer Valley
- West Springfield, Massachusetts
- Springfield, Massachusetts
Misc.
edit- Wikipedia_talk:WikiProject_Ethnic_groups#Pictures
- Talk:Court-packing Bill (Fix effects section)
- Separation of church and state (external links, Article Improvement Drive)
- Corporate farming (fix NPOV)
- Rural sociology, Demographic history of the United States (fix NPOV)
Journalism
edit- Talk:Infotainment (listed on WP:RFC)
- Journalistic ethics and standards, Category:Regional Wikipedian notice boards
- Objectivity (journalism) (needs help)
- Talk:Journalistic standards and ethics
Cities
edit- Wikipedia:WikiProject_Cities
- Need to start implementing proposal
- Need to check if recommended categorization scheme has been implemented.
- Intro texts do not conform to the recommendation. A bot should check all articles in a given category to see if the right phrase and/or links are present.
- Wisconsin towns (townships) are confusing (e.g. Springfield, Wisconsin).
- See Category_talk:Towns_in_Maryland?
- Intro texts do not conform to the recommendation. A bot should check all articles in a given category to see if the right phrase and/or links are present.
- Need to clean up talk page, esp "weird cases" or later
- Need to update status section on main page.
- Need to update status of mapping project
- Template:CDPpreface, Template:UnincorpNotCDP
- city-data.com
Sexuality
edit(See bookmarks, as well.)
- Homophobia cleanup
- Demographics of sexual orientation and Kinsey Reports cleanup and fact-check.
- Talk:History of human sexuality
- [1]
- Talk:Sex_in_advertising#Budweiser_ad
- Talk:Pederasty
To-do list for WikiProject Sexology and sexuality:
|
- http://en.wikinews.org/wiki/The_Swiss_vote_yes_to_same-sex_relationships_and_%22Schengen/Dublin%22
- Gender role needs POV check.
- History of sexuality and Demographics of sexual orientation need attention. May need to merge from Anthropological classification of homosexuality.
- Improve homosexuality, heterosexuality, bisexuality, Homosexuality and transgender and sexual orientation with regard to terminology and orientation/behavior/identity considerations.
- Improve Genetics and sexual orientation, esp. terminology in twin studies
- Refactor Causes_of_sexual_orientation in Sexual orientation w.r.t. genetic and environmental/choice subarticles. Talk:Causes_of_sexual_orientation suggests science/society not gene/environment split.
- Also sync homosexuality and morality
- Add something like the following to nature versus nurture debate and/or sexual orientation. Or maybe make a "multi-determined" article.
- Multi-determination: A car owner notices the check engine light on their dashboard is on, but continues driving for 3 days. On the highway, the engine suddenly fails. A second car that has been tailgating crashes into the first one. A nearby philosopher asks whether the cause of the accident was the way the car was built, or the way it was operated by the owner. In fact, if the car had been built differently, operated differently, or followed differently, the accident would not have happened. The accident is "multi-determined". Cite that STS book.
- Reconcile Wikipedia:WikiProject_Sexology_and_Sexuality/Terminology with Avoiding Heterosexual Bias in Language.
- Homosexuality, Heterosexuality, and Sexual_orientation, and Anthropological classification of homosexuality need to be re-synchronized.
- All sexology articles need their See Also sections cleaned, especially converion to categories where needed.
Meta
editUpdate once per DB dump
edit(It's been a long time - see Wikipedia talk:Database download)
- Category:Wikipedia categories in need of attention
- new-funny-categories.txt
- Category:Orphaned categories
- new-orphaned-categories.txt
- Wikipedia:Auto-categorization (USA state placenames)
- Add suppression feature before uploading next dump
First
edit- See Wikipedia talk:Browse (navigational templates)
- Wikipedia:WikiProject Countering systemic bias open tasks needs a refresh and overhaul
Mergers
edit- Wikipedia:Topical index needs to be converted into category listings, reconciled with templates on User:Beland and Wikipedia:Community portal.
- Wikipedia:Maintenance needs cleanup and updating. Is it in the most easily maintainable form? Is it redundant with Category:Wikipedia maintenance or any other pages? Templates? What maintenance pages should Wikipedia:Community Portal and Template:Opentask point to?
- Wikipedia_talk:Welcoming_committee - Some pages in Category:Wikipedia basic information could use merging.
- Category:Wikipedia needs cleaning again. Combine things about protected pages.
Avoidance mergers
edit- Upgrade Wikipedia:Be cautious with compliments and mass attribution and form consensus
- Wikipedia:Avoid weasel terms -> Wikipedia:Be cautious with compliments and mass attribution
- Wikipedia:Avoid peacock terms -> Wikipedia:Be cautious with compliments and mass attribution
- Wikipedia:Be cautious with compliments and mass attribution -> Wikipedia:Guide to writing better articles (or at least summarize it there)
- Update Wikipedia:Words to avoid
Talk mergers
edit- Wikipedia talk:Writers' rules of engagement -> Wikipedia:Wikiquette
- Wikipedia talk:Talk page guidelines -> Wikipedia:Wikiquette, Wikipedia:Talk page
Categorization
edit- Category:Wikipedia categories in need of attention
- Needs publicity or attention from Beland
- WP:CFD
- Periodic cleanup, especially requests for automated moves
- Wikipedia:Categories for deletion/likely is in cold storage.
- AMERICA
- Summarize decisions on Category talk:Ireland and see also Wikipedia:Irish wikipedian's notice board
- Clean up policy on WP:CFD and Wikipedia:Categories_for_deletion_phrases and their talk pages.
- Post gender-neutral nominations from Wikipedia talk:Categorization of people.
- Wikipedia:Auto-categorization/Wikipedia_namespace
- Needs publicity. Add to current categorization projects, maybe make an announcement. See what currently links to the parent page. Update. Re-add to Template:Active Wiki Fixup Projects.
- User:Sietse_Snel/Fix_common_mistakes
- Coordinate bugs on Wikipedia:Categorization with Wikipedia:Merge some redundant lists to categories.
- Clean Wikipedia:Category_schemes
- Clean Category:Wikipedia proposals
- Post to Wikipedia:WikiProject Categories
- Tidy Wikipedia talk:Categorization and Wikipedia:Categorization
More
edit- Wikipedia:Feature request needs to be converted into bugzilla requests
- Category:Cleanup by month needs June-September 2005 converted to tag-and-talk
- Wikipedia talk:Pages needing attention
- Wikipedia:Bot requests
- Wikipedia:WikiProject help desk is cute.
- Wikipedia:WikiProject U.S. special districts
- Wikipedia talk:Copyright problems#Implementing_the_Jimbo_declaration
- Editable version of Special:Ancientpages, including Wikipedia: space?
- Wikipedia:Protected page - Some things there could probably be unprotected.
Postmodernity
editSome of the antecedents of postmodernism are missing from modernism. The postmodern articles are too long and very hard to read.
Science
edit- Wikipedia talk:Naming conventions (chemistry)
- Category:Atmosphere, Category:Weather, Category:Meteorology, and Category:Climatology need sorting out
- Homeopathy
- SEPP
- History of science has growing pains [2] [3]
- Time could use a rewrite to make it flow better
- Timeline of scientific discoveries and Category:Science timelines
- Science_studies needs a lot of help. It may need a Wikibook project.
- Sociology of scientific knowledge
- Scientific enterprise
- Sociology_of_knowledge
- History_of_science_and_technology - may need inbound links fixed
- Peer-review Scientific_method and read Talk:Scientific_method. Possible merge with Scientific enterprise, Scientific hypothesis
- Scientific_skepticism: Categorize, check for accuracy, NPOV. Add to official list of Controversial topics?
- Wikipedia:WikiProject_Science#Project_Navigation
- Check Science
- History of parapsychology - needs NPOV, cleanup
- Talk:Obsolete_scientific_theory#Request_for_obsolete_theories_of_electricity
- Elminate "fluid" metaphor from Electromagnetic field
- E, B -> EMF -> EW -> QED -> Standard Model
- Electromagnetic field should say it's part of electroweak theory and is special relativity-compliant.
- Electric_field should say that it's part of EM/electroweak theory/standard
- See Talk:Photon
- Contact electrification - relationship to other articles?
- See Talk:Standard Model
- Electromagnetic field, Electroweak force, Fundamental interaction, SU(3)XSU(2)XU(1), Standard_Model
- E, B -> EMF -> EW -> QED -> Standard Model
- Global System for Mobile Communications, GSM core network, and related
- Three-phase electric power (hard to understand)
- Civilization
- Temperature (intro could be more public-friendly)
- Negative temperature - Ow.
- Decimal_time
- National_Oceanic_and_Atmospheric_Administration
- Gravitational_radiation
- Thermopower
- Peltier-Seebeck_effect
Religion
edit- Atheism needs rounding out after it is un-protected.
- Arguments_against_the_existence_of_God and Arguments for the existence of God might be fun to edit.
- Wikipedia:WikiProject_Bible
Politics
edit- Peer review UN Reform and later sections of United Nations, possibly organize its talk page
- Check up on Capitalism
- American imperialism
- Colossus: The Price of America's Empire by Niall Ferguson
- Empire: The Rise and Demise of the British World Order and the Lessons for Global Power by Niall Ferguson
- Note that many modern Americans reject the label "empire/imperialism".
- Abbreviations and Acronyms of the U.S. Government
- Address todo list on Progressivism
- Clinton v. City of New York
- Bill Clinton
- Civil_disobedience / Direct_action
Supreme Court History project
edit- Reading book on history of the Supreme Court
- May also need to check out the Supreme Court "encyclopedia" book
- Related articles to fix:
- Corporate personhood
- List_of_Justices_of_the_Supreme_Court_of_the_United_States
- Reconstruction
- Dred_Scott_v._Sandford
- List_of_United_States_Supreme_Court_cases
- Supreme_Court_of_the_United_States
- United States Constitution
- Dormant_Commerce_Clause
- Sixteenth_Amendment_to_the_United_States_Constitution, etc.
- See Lawrence_v._Texas
- Write an article on the Charles River Bridge case, find out more about the history of Charles River crossings.
- Nullum crimen, nulla poena sine praevia lege poenali