Attorney General of Hawaii

The attorney general of Hawaii (Hawaiian: Loio Kuhina) is the chief legal officer and chief law enforcement officer of Hawaii. In present-day statehood within the United States, the attorney general is appointed by the elected governor with the approval of the state senate and is responsible for a state department charged with advising the various other departments and agencies of state government. The attorney general is responsible for the prosecution of offenses under state law. The attorney general can only be removed by an act of the state senate. In rare occasions, the attorney general serves as acting governor in the absence of both the governor and lieutenant governor from the state for an extended period of time.

Attorney General of Hawaii
Loio Kuhina
Incumbent
Anne E. Lopez
since December 5, 2022
Department of the Attorney General
TypeChief legal officer and chief law enforcement officer
AppointerGovernor of Hawaii
FormationFebruary 27, 1844
First holderJohn Ricord

The office has existed in several forms throughout the history of the Hawaiian Islands. It was created by Kamehameha III and was part of the administration of each successive monarch of the Kingdom of Hawaii. The office was kept in the provisional government, after Liliuokalani and the monarchy was overthrown, and became a part of the succeeding administration of the Republic of Hawaii. A regular part of the American model of the executive branch of government, the office of attorney general was part of the Territory of Hawaii under Section 80 of the Hawaiian Organic Act and made an appointed office after statehood was achieved in 1959.

Though a non-partisan office, in territorial days the office of attorney general was traditionally appointed from the political party of the sitting president of the United States who appointed the territorial governor. Similarly in statehood, the office of attorney general has traditionally been appointed from the incumbent governor's political party, thus far Republican or Democratic.

The current attorney general is Anne E. Lopez, who was appointed by Governor Josh Green. The Hawaii Senate confirmed Lopez's nomination on December 5, 2022.[1]

Agencies

edit

The attorney general leads a department of 180 attorneys and 500 professional and support personnel. The department oversees various public services. These include administering the Hawaii Criminal Justice Data Center, running the Missing Child Center, Child Support Enforcement Agency, Hawaii Internet Crimes Against Children Task Force, Hawaii Internet and Technology Crimes Unit, Office of Child Support Hearings, Tobacco Enforcement Unit, among others.[2] In accordance with Chapter 846E of the Hawaii Revised Statutes, the Criminal Justice Data Center maintains a registry of sex offenders in the state.[3] Likewise, the agency provides other criminal history information through the statewide criminal history record information system and Automated Fingerprint Identification System.[4]

History

edit

Origins

edit
 
Prussian-born Paul Neumann served as attorney general of Hawaii under Liliuokalani. In Washington, D.C., he argued against the overthrow of the monarchy. He later defended the deposed queen in trial for misprision of treason. She was convicted.
 
William Owen Smith (third from left) was attorney general of the provisional government and succeeding Republic of Hawaii. From left to right: Interior Minister James A. King, President Sanford B. Dole, Smith, Finance Minister Peter Cushman Jones.
 
Herbert Young Cho Choy served as a territorial attorney general. He was the first Korean American to be admitted to the bar and the first Asian American to serve as federal judge. During his tenure on the U.S. Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit, there were no other Asians sitting on any federal bench.

John Ricord served as the first attorney general of Hawaii. He arrived in the Kingdom on February 27, 1844, on the Columbia. He was the first Western-trained lawyer in the islands.[5][6] The previous year a land dispute by Richard Charlton led to a British occupation known as the Paulet Affair. A related case of Ladd & Co. required lengthy arbitration. These cases would consume his entire time on the islands.[7] Within a few weeks he swore allegiance to Kamehameha III and on March 9, 1844, was appointed first attorney general. In July 1845 he joined the Privy Council.[8] On October 29, 1845, the executive branch of the government was formally organized through legislation he proposed. On May 17, 1847, he resigned all his offices, and on June 12 was released from his oath of allegiance, so he could resume his citizenship of the United States.[8] He left August 19, 1847.[9] The office of attorney general was suspended until the 1860s.[10] His work on organizing the courts was taken over by the second trained attorney to arrive in the islands, William Little Lee.

Revival

edit

On August 26, 1862, Kamehameha IV revived the office and appointed Charles Coffin Harris as attorney general.[11] Having an attorney general proved useful on constitutional matters. Kamehameha V insisted on a new constitution that would restore some of the power to the monarchy that had been lost over time. Harris issued his legal opinion that the king had such a right and produced an early draft. A constitutional convention failed to reach agreement, so Harris got the cabinet to negotiate directly with Kamehameha V leading to the promulgation of the 1864 Constitution.[12]

Controversies

edit

A more modern controversy happened with the failed 1998 confirmation by the state senate of popular sitting attorney general Margery Bronster, as political payback for her actions to reform the corrupt Kamehameha Schools/Bishop Estate whose trustees were friends of various powerful legislators, many Hawaiʻi residents called for the right to elect the attorney general. Several attempts failed to create the constitutional amendment.

List of attorneys general

edit

The attorneys general with dates of service:[11]

Kingdom of Hawaii

edit
Name Portrait Term start Term end Monarch(s) served under
John Ricord
 
March 9, 1844 May 17, 1847 Kamehameha III
Charles Coffin Harris
 
August 26, 1862 December 21, 1865 Kamehameha IV
Charles Coffin Harris (Acting)
 
March 26, 1866 September 12, 1866 Kamehameha V
Stephen Henry Phillips
 
September 12, 1866 January 10, 1873 Kamehameha V
Albert Francis Judd
 
January 13, 1873 February 19, 1874 Lunalilo
Alfred S. Hartwell
 
February 18, 1874 May 28, 1874 Kalākaua
Richard H. Stanley May 28, 1874 November 5, 1875 Kalākaua
John Smith Walker (ad interim)
 
November 5, 1875 February 15, 1876 Kalākaua
William Richards Castle
 
February 15, 1876 December 5, 1876 Kalākaua
Alfred S. Hartwell
 
December 5, 1876 July 3, 1878 Kalākaua
Edward Preston
 
July 13, 1878 August 14, 1880 Kalākaua
W. Claude Jones
 
August 14, 1880 September 27, 1880 Kalākaua
John Smith Walker (ad interim)
 
September 27, 1880 November 29, 1880 Kalākaua
William Nevins Armstrong
 
November 29, 1880 January 17, 1881 Kalākaua
Henry A. P. Carter (Acting)
 
January 17, 1881 November 5, 1881 Kalākaua
William Nevins Armstrong
 
November 5, 1881 May 19, 1882 Kalākaua
Edward Preston
 
May 19, 1882 May 14, 1883 Kalākaua
Walter M. Gibson (Acting)
 
May 14, 1883 December 14, 1883 Kalākaua
Paul Neumann
 
December 14, 1883 June 30, 1886 Kalākaua
Walter M. Gibson (Acting)
 
September 18, 1884; August 3, 1885 September 18, 1884; August 3, 1885 Kalākaua
John T. Dare
 
July 1, 1886 October 13, 1886 Kalākaua
John Lot Kaulukou
 
October 13, 1886 October 23, 1886 Kalākaua
Luther Aholo (ad interim)[13]
 
October 23, 1886 November 14, 1886 Kalākaua
Antone Rosa
 
November 15, 1886 June 28, 1887 Kalākaua
Clarence W. Ashford
 
July 1, 1887 June 14, 1890 Kalākaua
Lorrin A. Thurston (Acting)
 
November 22, 1889 November 22, 1889 Kalākaua
Arthur P. Peterson
 
June 17, 1890 February 25, 1891 Kalākaua
William A. Whiting
 
February 25, 1891 July 27, 1892 Liliʻuokalani
Hermann A. Widemann (ad interim)[14]
 
July 27, 1892 August 29, 1892 Liliʻuokalani
Paul Neumann
 
August 29, 1892 August 30, 1892 Liliʻuokalani
September 12, 1892 October 17, 1892 Liliʻuokalani
Charles F. Creighton
 
November 1, 1892 November 8, 1892 Liliʻuokalani
Cecil Brown
 
November 8, 1892 January 12, 1893 Liliʻuokalani
Arthur P. Peterson
 
January 13, 1893 January 17, 1893 Liliʻuokalani

Republic of Hawaii

edit
Name Portrait Term start Term end
William Owen Smith
 
January 17, 1893 October 25, 1895
Francis March Hatch (ad interim)
 
October 25, 1895 November 6, 1895
Henry E. Cooper (ad interim)
 
November 6, 1895 December 13, 1895
William Owen Smith
 
December 13, 1895 February 10, 1897
Henry E. Cooper (ad interim)
 
February 10, 1897 April 16, 1897
William Owen Smith
 
April 16, 1897 March 20, 1899

Territory of Hawaii

edit
Name Portrait Term start Term end Territorial governor(s) served under
Henry Ernest Cooper
 
March 20, 1899 June 14, 1900 -
Edmund Pearson Dole
 
June 14, 1900 February 1, 1903 Sanford B. Dole
Lorrin Andrews
(grandson of missionary Lorrin Andrews)
 
February 1, 1903 November 21, 1905 George R. Carter
Emil C. Peters
 
November 21, 1905 August 15, 1907 George R. Carter
Charles R. Hemenway
 
August 15, 1907 January 30, 1910 Walter F. Frear
Alexander Lindsay Jr.
 
January 30, 1910 December 31, 1912 Walter F. Frear
Wade Warren Thayer
 
January 1, 1913 April 16, 1914 Walter F. Frear

Lucius E. Pinkham

Ingram M. Stainback
 
April 17, 1914 April 18, 1918 Lucius E. Pinkham
Arthur G. Smith
 
April 18, 1918 August 30, 1918 Lucius E. Pinkham

Charles J. McCarthy

Harry Irwin
 
August 30, 1918 August 31, 1922 Charles J. McCarthy

Wallace Rider Farrington

John A. Matthewman September 1, 1922 March 26, 1925 Wallace Rider Farrington
William B. Lymer
 
March 27, 1925 June 20, 1928 Wallace Rider Farrington
Harry P. Hewitt June 21, 1928 April 30, 1934 Wallace Rider Farrington

Lawrence M. Judd

William B. Pittman May 1, 1934 December 20, 1936 Lawrence M. Judd

Joseph Poindexter

Joseph V. Hodgson Acting February 15, 1935 February 15, 1935 Joseph Poindexter
S. B. Kemp January 2, 1937 June 30, 1938 Joseph Poindexter
Joseph V. Hodgson July 1, 1938 June 7, 1942 Joseph Poindexter
Ernest K. Kai June 8, 1942 October 4, 1942 Joseph Poindexter

Ingram Stainback

J. Garner Anthony October 4, 1942 December 31, 1943 Ingram Stainback
Cyrus Nils Tavares January 1, 1944 June 30, 1947 Ingram Stainback
Rhoda Valentine Lewis Acting July 1, 1947 October 13, 1947 Ingram Stainback
Walter D. Ackerman Jr. October 14, 1947 February 29, 1952 Ingram Stainback

Oren E. Long

Michiro Watanabe March 1, 1952 March 2, 1953 Oren E. Long

Samuel Wilder King

Edward N. Sylva March 3, 1953 November 14, 1956 Samuel Wilder King
Richard K. Sharpless November 15, 1956 May 7, 1957 Samuel Wilder King
Shiro Kashiwa May 8, 1957 June 8, 1957 Samuel Wilder King
Herbert Young Cho Choy
 
June 13, 1957 November 30, 1958 Samuel Wilder King

William F. Quinn

Jack H. Mizuha December 16, 1958 1959 William F. Quinn

State of Hawaii

edit
Attorneys general of the State of Hawaii
Attorney general Image Term of office State governor(s) served under
Jack H. Mizuha 1959 William F. Quinn
Shiro Kashiwa 1959–1960
Bert Kobayashi 1962–1969 John A. Burns
Bertram Kanbara 1969–1971
George T. H. Pai 1971
Ronald Amemiya 1974–1978[15] George Ariyoshi
Wayne Minami 1978–1981
Tany S. Hong 1981–1984
Michael A. Lilly 1984–1985
Corinne Watanabe 1985–1986
Warren Price, III 1986–1992 John D. Waiheʻe III
Robert A. Marks 1992–1994
1994–1995 Ben Cayetano
Margery Bronster 1995–1998
Earl I. Anzai 1999–2002
Mark J. Bennett   2003–2010 Linda Lingle
David M. Louie   2011–2014 Neil Abercrombie
Russell Suzuki (Acting) 2014–2015 David Ige
Doug Chin   2015–2018
Russell Suzuki 2018–2019
Clare E. Connors   2019–2021
Holly Shikada 2021–2022
Anne E. Lopez 2022–present Josh Green

See also

edit

References

edit
  1. ^ "New AG on the Block: Hawaii Attorney General Anne Lopez". Troutman Pepper. Retrieved February 19, 2023.
  2. ^ Attorney General's Office
  3. ^ Hawaii Criminal Justice Data Center Sex Offender Search
  4. ^ Hawaii Criminal Justice Data Center
  5. ^ Jon M. Van Dyke (2008). Who owns the Crown lands of Hawaii?. University of Hawaii Press. p. 34. ISBN 978-0-8248-3211-7.
  6. ^ Frear, Walter F. (1894). "Evolution of the Hawaiian Judiciary". Papers of the Hawaiian Historical Society (7). Honolulu: Hawaiian Historical Society. hdl:10524/966.
  7. ^ John Ricord; Stephen H. Williams; James F. B. Marshall (1846). Report of the proceedings and evidence in the arbitration between the King and Government of the Hawaiian Islands and Messrs. Ladd & Co., before Messrs. Stephen H. Williams & James F. B. Marshall, arbitrators under compact. C.E. Hitchcock, printer, Hawaiian Government press.
  8. ^ a b "Ricord, John office record". state archives digital collections. state of Hawaii. Archived from the original on 2012-03-06. Retrieved 2010-03-12.
  9. ^ "Passport records". state archives digital collections. state of Hawaii. Retrieved 2010-03-12.
  10. ^ "Attorney General's Department - Organization of" (PDF). state archives digital collections. state of Hawaii. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2010-05-27. Retrieved 2010-03-12.
  11. ^ a b "Attorney General, office record" (PDF). state archives digital collections. state of Hawaii. Archived from the original (PDF) on 30 July 2010. Retrieved August 13, 2010.
  12. ^ Phillip H. Harris (1993). "Charles Coffin Harris: An Uncommon Life in the Law". Hawaiian Journal of History. Hawaiian Historical Society. hdl:10524/224.
  13. ^ "Hawai`i Legal Research: Attorney General Opinions".
  14. ^ "Hawai`i Legal Research: Attorney General Opinions".
  15. ^ Dowson, Kapono (June 21, 2002). "Kimi Amemiya, 96, led family of achievers". Honolulu Advertiser. Retrieved November 28, 2020.
edit