Welcome to Wikimedia Commons, Ismael zniber!

Moving of Category:Salé to Category:Salé (Morocco)

edit

Hi, I saw you are moving a rather large category for disambiguation - what are the options for the disambiguation? I am asking because Category:Salé (Morocco) still includes the city and the prefecture. Would you not be better off calling it "Category:Salé (city)? -- Deadstar (msg) 12:18, 23 October 2024 (UTC)Reply

Salé is salt in french :) and the results are sometimes misleading when you search Salé on commons. You can try. My best. Ismael Ismael zniber (talk) 12:21, 23 October 2024 (UTC)Reply
Ah - I see. It is also similar to the English for "sale", but in a search, these things are easy to filter out. Do you want to add a "move" template and open a discussion? -- Deadstar (msg) 12:26, 23 October 2024 (UTC)Reply
Edit to add that there is no need to move categories such as Category:Mohammed VI Tower to have a location added unless there are more buildings called "Mohammed VI Tower". From my limited search, the one in Salé is the only one. -- Please read Commons:Categories before continuing. Deadstar (msg) 12:30, 23 October 2024 (UTC)Reply
that's because it is often wrongly attributed and associated with Rabat Ismael zniber (talk) 12:34, 23 October 2024 (UTC)Reply
As you want. I will probably not have enough time to engage a discussion here, I apologize, but "Category:Salé (city)" fits too. Thank you Ismael zniber (talk) 12:32, 23 October 2024 (UTC)Reply
No problem. I think we are both trying to do what's best. I have reverted your move of Category:Salé for now. In other questions: is a "Riad" the same as a "House"? as Category:Buildings_in_Salé has more or less the same subcategories as Category:Riads in Salé - should they be merged/should one be redirected to the other? Thanks for your help -- Deadstar (msg) 08:13, 24 October 2024 (UTC)Reply

Moving of Category:Bouregreg Marina to Category:Bouregreg Marina (Salé) not required

edit

Hi, me again. Please don't move categories unless there is a clear need. Please read Commons:Rename_a_category before doing any more, and perhaps tag them with a {{move}} template to discuss your reasons. From our previous conversation, I understand that you want to move the marina category because people are mistaken and think it is in Rabat. This is not an issue for Commons to sort out. The category Bouregreg Marina is categorised under "Transport in Salé", clearly linking it to Salé in the Commons tree.

Google translated: Bonjour. Merci de ne pas déplacer de catégories à moins que cela ne soit nécessaire. Veuillez lire Commons:Rename_a_category/fr avant de faire quoi que ce soit d'autre, et peut-être les étiqueter avec un modèle {{move}} pour discuter de vos raisons. D'après notre conversation précédente, je comprends que vous souhaitez déplacer la catégorie marina parce que les gens se trompent et pensent qu'elle se trouve à Rabat. Ce n'est pas un problème que Commons doit régler. La catégorie Bouregreg Marina est catégorisée sous « Transport à Salé », la reliant clairement à Salé dans Commons. -- Deadstar (msg) 14:42, 24 October 2024 (UTC)Reply