Life Cycle of A Trade: Training Academy
Life Cycle of A Trade: Training Academy
Life Cycle of A Trade: Training Academy
Training Academy
Introduction
Facilitator Self Course Outline Break Timings
Expectations
Page 2
Expectations
Static data How trade is booked Settlement and before settlement Trade booking and settlement Impact of incorrect settlement Pre-matching before a settlement Entire life of a trade
Page 4
Section One
The Market Participants
Clearing Banks
Regulators
Page 6
Page 7
The Marketplace
INVESTORS
ISSUERS
AGENTS
Securities
INVESTORS
AGENTS
Exchanges
AGENTS
Securities
INVESTORS
ISSUERS
Page 8
Other trades executed over the telephone are OTC (Over the Counter) or Non-Exchange Traded
Each securities market has an associated and recognisable place to effect settlement
Euroclear
Page 9
Stock Exchanges
Region Europe Country UK Financial Centre London Stock Exchange London Stock Exchange (LSE) London Metal Exchange London International Financial Futures & Options Exchange (LIFFE) Deutsche Bourse
Germany
Frankfurt
Spain
Asia Pacific China China
Madrid
Hong Kong Shenzhen Shanghai
Bolsa de Madrid
Stock Exchange of Hong Kong Hong Kong Futures Exchange Shenzhen Stock Exchange Shanghai Stock Exchange
Japan
Singapore Australia America USA
Tokyo
Singapore Sydney New York Chicago
Page 10
Page 11
Type of Issuer
Corporations Sovereign Entities Local Governments Government Agencies Supranational Organisations
Example
Vodafone (UK) Kingdom of Denmark City of London Federal National Mortgage Association International Bank for Reconstruction & Development (World Bank IBRD)
Page 12
Retail Bank
Page 13
So far Covered
I. Market Participants
Page 14
Section Two
Static Data
Page 17
Telekurs
Rolfe & Nolan SWIFT DTCC Alert Direct/OMGEO Standard and Poors Euroclear Wallstreet SIAC NSCC
Page 18
Type of Institution
Documentation signed Tax Status Registered Representative Confirmation Details
Page 19
Equity, Bond, Warrant, Derivative, Commodity Short Name, Long Name, Size, Denomination, Issuer Coupon Rate, Payment Characteristics - 30/360, A/360 etc ISIN, Common Code, RIC, Quick Code, Cusip etc
Issue
Coupon Dates
Alternative/External References,
Exchange Currency Maturity Date Factors
Page 20
Bad Static Data impacts operational risk and increases the cost per trade processed
Bad Static Data contributes to poor internal & external reporting impacting risk & reputation Static Data will continue to be an important dependency on the efficient processing of trades especially as the trade lifecycle window becomes smaller
STATIC DATA
Must be populated correctly within all of the relevant systems. Must be obtained from a credible source as timely as possible.
Page 22
So far Covered
I. II. Market Participants Static Data
Page 23
Section Three
Trade Execution & Trades Processing
Trade Validation
Position/Inventory management
Trade Enrichment
Trade Processing
Trade Confirmation/Affirmation/Matching
Trade Instruction
Instruction/Agent Matching
Trade Settlement
Page 25
Trade/Position Accounting
Corporate Actions
Reconciliations
Cash Funding
What is a Trade?
A legal contract between two counterparties. A seller and a buyer. The SELLER must deliver the commodity he has sold to the buyer. The BUYER must pay the agreed purchase price on the agreed value date.
Page 26
Page 27
Why Trade?
Speculate
Profit from price move or increase in value of the asset. Benefit from dividend on shares and interest on bonds.
Accumulate Hedging:
Page 28
Trade Execution
Trade execution tends to operate in one of three ways where sellers and buyers execute trades: Trading Floor
Computerised Exchanges
This term applied to the liberalization of the London Stock Exchange (LSE) when Trading was automated.
Telephone
Page 29
Trade Execution
Furthermore Trades can be: Quote Driven
Order Driven
Orders from sellers are matched with buyers orders electronically. Xetra (Germany) SETS (UK) SEATS (Australia) ECNs operate on an electronic basis only. Euro-MTS Brokertec Archipelago
Page 30
Trade Capture
Regardless of the trade execution/origin, all trades must be recorded formally by the market participant.
To allow trade detail to be sent through to the Back Office for trade processing and settlement
As part of Market & Regulatory Reporting requirements To facilitate risk management Traders use complex trading systems to facilitate trading & position management, trade processing is usually done via Back Office processing systems.
Page 31
Price
Counterparty
Page 32
Trade Validation
Trade validation occurs to check if the trade information received in the Back office systems corresponds with the Front Office record.
Is the security recognised on the system? Is the Counterparty account recognised? Is the Trader allowed to trade on the trading book? Is the trading book valid to trade security x? Is the value date a valid settlement date in the location of settlement? Are the securities restricted?
Page 33
Trade Enrichment
Trade enrichment exists to add specific trade data to the basic trade detail to allow downstream processing. This data is not usually held in Front Office Trading systems. This data can be added manually however in the STP environment the aim is to derive this automatically. Examples include:
Calculation of cash values. Regulatory Reporting required. Trade Confirmation requirements. Selection of custodian details. Selection of Settlement Instructions and communication method.
Page 34
So far Covered
I. II. Market Participants Static Data
Page 35
Section Four
Trade Confirmation
Trade Confirmation/Agreement
Trade Confirmation/Affirmation is an important process required to reduce the risk of the traders P&L. Until the counterparty acknowledges the trade detail the effect on the price or quantity of the trade is subject to change, impacting the traders book.
Sending trade confirmations to the counterparty. Receiving trade confirmations from the counterparty. Trade or Contract Matching. Trade Affirmation.
Page 37
Trade Matching
Trade Matching generally applies to mandatory electronic matching of trade details. Both parties are required to input details to a central matching facility. Matching results (i.e. matched, unmatched) are provided by the trade matching facility to both parties. Examples include:
Omgeo Central Trade Manager (CTM). TRAX (Internationally traded debt & securities). Depository Trust & Clearing Corporation (DTCC) National Securities Clearing Corporations Trade Matching Service.
(NSCC)
Page 38
Trade Affirmation
Trade Affirmation relates to the electronic matching of trade details typically between securities institutions and Institutional clients.
Trade details are input by the securities house and sent to a trade affirmation facility.
The Trade affirmation central hub sends on the message. The institutional client agrees (affirms) or disagrees and the response is sent back to the securities house. Both parties must subscribe to the service. Examples include:
Omgeos Oasys Global system. FIX (Global) Oasys Domestic - (US) DTC ID (Institutional Delivery) (US)
Page 39
Summary
Basic Principles The longer a trades detail remains unchecked after trade date, the greater the risk of price movement and P&L impact. Trade confirmation/matching messages should be issued as soon as possible after trade validation. Timely and accurate confirmation generation is a major client service consideration.
Page 40
So far Covered
I. II. Market Participants Static Data
Page 41
Section Five
Trade Instruction
Settlement Instructions
Settlement Instructions are used to communicate the movement of securities and cash to the custodian. Trade Agreement confirms the commercial details of the trade. Settlement Instructions indicate the commercial details of the trade AND the location and account details for the cash and security movements. (Settlement Details).
Page 43
Instruction Content
Settlement Instructions tell the custodian/Agent to carry out precise commands such as: The quantity of securities to be received or delivered. The net settlement value to be paid or received. From whom securities will be received. To whom payment must be made. From whom payment will be received. To whom securities must be delivered. On which date to carry out these instructions.
Page 44
Page 45
So far Covered
I. II. Market Participants Static Data
III. Trade Execution & Processing IV. Trade Confirmation V. Trade Instruction
Page 46
Section Six
Instruction/Agent Matching
Page 48
Instruction Matching
instruction.
Custodian attempt to match the instruction to the counterparty Attachment of the current status of the instruction.
(matched/unmatched/unknown).
Status Update
Page 49
1 2
Counterparty
Settlement Instruction
Counterparty
Status
1 2 3 4
Page 50
Instructions sent in by Securities House and Counterparty. Instruction matching occurs. Status is recorded. Instruction Status (Matched/Unmatched) is sent back to both parties.
So far Covered
I. II. Market Participants Static Data
III. Trade Execution & Processing IV. Trade Confirmation V. Trade Instruction VI. Instruction / Agent Matching
Page 51
Section Seven
Trade Settlement
Settlement Terminology
Trade settlement is the act of exchanging securities and cash between buyer and seller. Value Date / Contractual Settlement Date. Actual Settlement Value Date and Settlement Date will be the same in the majority of trade settlement cases. A percentage of trades fail to settle on value date and will settle on another date referred to as the actual settlement date.
Page 53
Settlement Considerations
How to ensure trade settlement Ensure the seller holds the required level of securities at the correct custodian.
Page 54
Types of Settlement
Full Settlement Partial Settlement Securities Only Cash Only Cross Currency Settlement Net Settlement
Page 55
Summary
Timely settlement of trades is an important part of the Trade Lifecycle with implications across the following areas: Inventory Management Cash Management
Settlement Risk
Cost Management Firm Reputation
Page 56
So far Covered
I. II. Market Participants Static Data
III. Trade Execution & Processing IV. Trade Confirmation V. Trade Instruction VI. Instruction / Agent Matching VII. Trade Settlement
Page 57
Section Eight
Position/Inventory Management
Inventory Management
Management of the stock holding is an integral part of trade settlement: Inventory Management ensures:
The correct amount of securities (nominal) are available At the correct location (depot). At the correct time (on value date).
Page 59
Borrow securities from another firm account same depot. Borrow securities from another firm account different depot. Borrow the securities from the market. Borrow the securities from the custodian/central depository.
Settle at Custodian
Securities
Cash
Choices
Choices
AutoBorrow
Lend
Do Nothing
Repo
Do Nothing
Borrow Unsecured
Page 61
Borrow required securities automatically. Borrow certain types of security automatically i.e. Spanish Bonds. Borrow upon request. Sometimes used as a last resort due to the cost. Lend all securities automatically. Lend certain types of security automatically. Lend upon request.
Lenders
Page 62
Manual Updates
Page 63
So far Covered
I. II. Market Participants Static Data
III. Trade Execution & Processing IV. Trade Confirmation V. Trade Instruction VI. Instruction / Agent Matching VII. Trade Settlement
Page 64
Section Nine
Fails & Fail Management
Unable to use the cash to fund other security purchases. Unable to lend on money markets and earn credit interest on cash. Unable to pay off existing overdraft/debt. Unable to use securities required for an onward delivery causing a
break in the chain. Risk impact due to movement in the market causing a change in the value of securities. (mark to market)
Page 66
Page 67
Fails make the reconciliation of corporate actions difficult which can lead to material losses
Regulatory Impact - In some markets fines are imposed for late trade settlement
Page 68
Interest Claims
An interest claim is compensation from the failing party to for the loss of cash interest or use of securities.
Failed trades are monitored to determine the reason for failure and
enable the interest claim to be executed against the counterparty. Some marketplaces (e.g. ISMA) have minimum claimable interest recommendations and deadlines by which claims must be issued. Back Office Settlements add immense value by actively monitoring instruction statuses and helping to accurately fund cash shortfalls or short positions. In some Securities Trading Houses, if the Firm Trader is at fault then the cost of the fail can be directly attributed to their book, impacting their P&L.
Page 69
So far Covered
I. II. Market Participants Static Data
III. Trade Execution & Processing IV. Trade Confirmation V. Trade Instruction VI. Instruction / Agent Matching VII. Trade Settlement
Section Ten
Reconciliations
Internally between systems and departments Externally where securities and cash are held.
A Reconciliation Break is a discrepancy between one record and another All breaks should be investigated, accounted for and corrected to ensure continued integrity Automation of reconciliation reporting facilitates timely investigation and resolution of breaks on a daily basis
Page 72
Types of Reconciliations
Position Reconciliations
Trade Reconciliations System Reconciliations
Page 73
So far Covered
I. II. Market Participants Static Data
III. Trade Execution & Processing IV. Trade Confirmation V. Trade Instruction VI. Instruction / Agent Matching VII. Trade Settlement VIII. Position / Inventory Management IX. Fails & Fail Management X.
Page 74
Reconciliations
Section Eleven
Clearing and Custody
Types of Custodian 1
Term
Custodian
Description
An organisation that holds securities and cash on its clients behalf and may effect trade settlement on its clients behalf. As per custodian, but has a network of local (or sub-custodians) that hold securities and cash and effect trade settlement on behalf of the global custodian. A custodian that operates within a specific financial centre. A custodian within a Global Custodians network of custodians.
Example
Deutsche Bank Domestic Custody Services State Street Citigroup
Global Custodian
BoNY
Paribas Credit Lyonnais Paris Banco Espirito Santo Lisboa Citibank Milan Citibank Madrid
Local Custodian
Sub-Custodian
Page 76
Types of Custodian 2
Term Central Securities Depository (CSD). National Central Securities Depository (NCSD) Description An organisation that hold securities, normally in book entry form; usually the place of settlement, effected through book transfer. A CSD that handles domestic securities of the country in which it is located. A CSD that handles domestic and international securities. Only two organisations are recognised as ICDSs. Examples DTC (USA) CREST (UK & Eire) JASDEC (JPY) CCASS (HK)
Settlement Agent
An organisation that effects the exchange of securities and cash on behalf of its clients; resultant securities and cash balances may or may not be held.
Citibank Milan
Citibank Madrid
Page 77
So far Covered
I. II. Market Participants Static Data
III.
IV. V. VI.
VII. Trade Settlement VIII. Position / Inventory Management IX. Fails & Fail Management
X.
XI.
Reconciliations
Clearing & Custody
Page 78
Coupon Payments Cash Dividends Stock Dividends Stock Split Bonus Shares
A notification that may or may not require a response from the securities owner
Page 79
Section Twelve
Trade & Position Accounting
Controlling
The accounting group within the bank is responsible for correctly recording and monitoring all of the financial transactions occurring within the Securities Trading House: Deutsche Bank Controllers include:
Page 81
Controlling Responsibilities
Monitor Stock/Security Positions Monitor Cash Balances Track Firm Books and Records Create Good Processes Create Controls Reconcile Trade Data Reconcile Cash Flow
Page 82
Page 83
So far Covered
I. II. III. IV. V. Market Participants Static Data Trade Execution & Processing Trade Confirmation Trade Instruction XI. Clearing & Custody XII. Trade & Position Accounting
VI.
VII. Trade Settlement VIII. Position / Inventory Management IX. X. Fails & Fail Management Reconciliations
Page 84
Section Thirteen
Regulatory & Compliance Responsibilities
Regulators
Regulatory authorities exist within the securities industry to ensure: All business undertaken within the marketplace is done in the proper manner To protect investors who are participants within the marketplace Guard the reputation and integrity of the marketplace Monitor activity which fails outside of normal business trading practice
Page 86
Regulator Responsibilities
Assessing suitability of securities trading houses to participate within the market place. Monitor the business undertaken by securities trading houses, investment advisors & fund managers. Enforcement of laws and possible prosecution of security law violators.
Page 87
Regulatory Authority
Australian Securities & Investments Commission Prudential Regulatory Authority Bahamas Central Bank Commission des Operations de Bourse Banque de France Securities & Futures Commission Monetary Authority Financial Supervisory Agency Financial Reconstruction Commission Monetary Authority of Singapore
UK
USA
Page 88
Reporting Methods
A number of methods exist dependent on how the local Regulator requires reporting to be effected Automatic forwarding of trade details by a computerised exchange requiring no additional reporting Automated message transmission by the member for confirmation/matching/instruction purposes part of which is used to satisfy transaction reporting requirements File feeds produced from Front Office/Back Office/Controlling systems and sent direct to Regulator
Page 89
Compliance
Compliance is the Banks internal regulator. Responsibilities include: Ensuring compliance to rules of appropriate financial regulatory body Handling confidential information
Ensure that personnel are adequately and properly licensed to operate in the marketplace
Managing anti-money laundering regulations
Page 90
So far Covered
I. II. III. IV. V. Market Participants Static Data Trade Execution & Processing Trade Confirmation Trade Instruction XI. Clearing & Custody XII. Trade & Position Accounting XIII. Regulatory & Compliance
VI.
VII. Trade Settlement VIII. Position / Inventory Management IX. X. Fails & Fail Management Reconciliations
Page 91
Section Fourteen
Conclusions
Conclusions
Reduce Settlement Cycles Increase Straight Through Processing for trades Increase use of central Counterparties Increase use of Golden Source static data Active management of collateral
Minimise Risk
Minimise Operational Cost Offer increased service to clients Manage increasing volumes Maximise internal efficiency
Page 93
Section Fifteen
References
Recommended Reading
Michael Simmons
Securities Operations A Guide to Trade & Position Management An Introduction to Western Financial Markets An Introduction to Equity Markets An Introduction to Repo Markets Treasury Management The Handbook of Equity Derivatives Dictionary of Finance & Banking
Stephen Valdez
David Dasey
Page 95
Industry Websites
http://www.crestco.co.uk/ http://www.dtcc.com/ http://www.euroclear.com/ http://www.isma.org/home.html http://www.fsa.gov.uk/ CREST Depository Trust & Clearing Corporation Euroclear International Securities Market Associations Bank of England Financial Services Authority
http://www.sec.gov/
http://www.nasdaq.com/ http://www.amex.com/
http://www.lchclearnet.com/
http://www.liffe.com/
Page 96
Industry Websites
http://www.iosco.org/iosco.html http://www.ipma.org.uk/ International Organ Securities Commission International Primary Market Association
http://www.isda.org/index.html
http://www.isla.co.uk/ http://www.isma.com/home.html http://www.liba.org.uk/ http://www.lsta.org/ http://www.sia.com/
http://www.securities-institute.org.uk Securities Institute http://dspace.dial.pipex.com/jhalsey/ Compliance Exchange http://www.world-exchanges.org/ http://www.trioptima.com/tri/ Federation of Exchanges OTC Derivatives termination service Financial Regulatory Authorities
Page 97
http://www.finanz-adressen.de/WE-fin-regulatory.html
Industry Websites
http://www.exchange-handbook.co.uk/Exchange Handbook http://www.investorwords.com/ Glossary
http://www.stpforum.com/
http://www.stpinfo.com/ http://www.afponline.org/
STP Forum
STP Info Association for Financial Professionals
http://www.calpers.ca.gov/index.jsp?bc=/investments/straightthrough.xml Virtual Matching Utilities (VMUs); http://www.omgeo.com/ http://www.sungard.com/ OMGEO Sungard Systems
Page 98