LMM JJS PPT 3A Lean Production Principles
LMM JJS PPT 3A Lean Production Principles
LMM JJS PPT 3A Lean Production Principles
Production
Principles
J J SHRIKHANDE 1
This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA-NC
Five Lean Principles
Lean Enterprise
Raw Tier 2 Tier 1 General Customer
Materials Suppliers Suppliers Electric
LEAN OFFICE
LEAN ENTERPRISE
J J SHRIKHANDE 2
Five Lean Principles
Lean Thinking
The Fundamental Objective The Fundamental Insight
Provide perfect value to the customer Focus on each product and its value
through a perfect value creation stream rather than organizations,
process with zero waste in: assets, process technologies, and
career paths
Design (concept to customer)
Ask which activities are waste and
Build (order to delivery) which truly create value
Service (order to cash) Enhance value & eliminate waste
J J SHRIKHANDE 3
Five Lean Principles
Define value in from the 1 2 Map all of the steps…value
customers perspective and Specify Value Map the added & non-value added…
express value in terms of a Value Stream that bring a product of service
specific product to the customer
3
5 Establish Flow
Work to
Perfection
The complete elimination of The continuous movement of
waste so all activities create products, services and
value for the customer information from end to end
through the process
4
Implement
Pull
Nothing is done by the upstream process
until the downstream customer signals the
need
J J SHRIKHANDE 4
1. Specify Value Five Lean Principles
A capability provided to a customer at the right time at an appropriate
price, as defined in each case by the customer.
quality?
reliable delivery? Incidental
Work
Pure Waste
rapid response to changing needs?
fundamental definition of the product?
•Pure Waste
Value
This Photo by Unknown Typical Operation: 1-10% Activities are Value Adding
Author is licensed under
CC BY-SA
J J SHRIKHANDE 5
2. Map the Five Lean Principles
Value Stream “Whenever there is a product or service for a customer, there is a value
stream. The challenge lies in seeing it.”
(Womack, Learning To See)
J J SHRIKHANDE 6
Five Lean Principles
3. Establish Flow Line up all steps that truly create value in a rapid sequence
Continuous movement of products, Require that every step in the process be:
services and information through the
various transactions from end to end Capable – right every time (6 Sigma)
in the process
Available – always able to run (TPM)
Flow appears impractical and
illogical because we have been Adequate – with capacity to avoid bottlenecks and
trained to think in terms of: over capitalization (right-sized tools)
departments, silos
batches, queues
efficiencies and backlogs
Batch Processing – 1 minute per piece Continuous Flow – Make One Move One
A B C A B C
Cycle Time= 30++ Min (weeks) Cycle Time= 12 Min
J J SHRIKHANDE 7
Five Lean Principles
4. Implement Pull Nothing is done downstream until required upstream
One more
Okay
please!
supplier customer
J J SHRIKHANDE 8
5. Work to Perfection Five Lean Principles
A continual cycle of process improvements
Future State
Current State
Original State
J J SHRIKHANDE 9
Work Place Organization
J J SHRIKHANDE 10
To Be Ordered
Tool and WIP Board
Spec Card
In Process
Next Run
Maintenance Log
&
Maintenance
Request Forms
J J SHRIKHANDE 11
Organize & Demand the Maintenance of Tools
J J SHRIKHANDE 12
Everything has a Dedicated Home
Operating Room Orderliness
A place for everything and everything in
its place, clean and ready for use
J J SHRIKHANDE 14
Paper Kaizen
First analyze the Total Work Content, and design improvement on paper …
Current Improved
K
Paper Kaizen
240 Approach of immediately leaving
Total Work Content for one item
in the cell are activities A-K. out wasteful steps. You eliminate
some waste on paper before
210
implementation.
J
I K
180
H
Time
A A
J J SHRIKHANDE 15
Operator Balance Chart
… then connect to Takt TIme.
J J SHRIKHANDE 16
Is your System suitable for flow?
Should you have one integrated system, or different small systems connected by a simple workflow tool?
J J SHRIKHANDE 17
Is your item ideally designed for flow?
Are your items optimal designed for creating continuous flow?
J J SHRIKHANDE 18
Office Cell Layout
… or Digital
A cell can also be designed digital. Think of setting operators work
in a flow by aligning systems.
Workflow IT can help to let differ systems work together in a flow.
J J SHRIKHANDE 19
How to use your operators efficiently?
J J SHRIKHANDE 20
How will you distribute the work?
E E E 30
D H D D
B G B B 15
F
A A A 0
Incoming 1 2 1 2
Forms Out
J J SHRIKHANDE 21
Implementation Stages
Process associate
involvement
Paper Kaizen & Initial Mock-up Debugging Sustaining
Process Design
½-2 days 2-4 weeks
J J SHRIKHANDE 22
Basic Elements – Visual Management
Easy means can show us important information !
Traffic Light Systems Machine Conditions
J J SHRIKHANDE 28
Replacement Part
Kanban Maintenance
Addresses
01/10/2022 System Development and Monitoring
Establish Method of Ordering
and
Tracking Replacement Parts
Seeing is Believing
J J SHRIKHANDE 33
Andon Boards
Andon
• Andon approach is built with a view to alert the errors that are about to occur, and stop the
execution immediately.
• It focuses on developing processes, or services, or products that not just detect and alert, but
also stop the processes whenever any error is about to happen so that prompt action can be
taken either manually or automatically to prevent an error from proceeding further.
• The major challenge in this approach lies in anticipating error conditions, and errors accurately,
and implementing mechanisms that detect, alert, and stop whenever either the error conditions,
or the errors, or both are about to occur.
• Hence, this approach incorporates monitoring, alerting, and stopping actions into the process,
or service, or product design.
• An excellent example for the Andon approach would be any assembly line where the assembly
line is automatically stopped upon detection of an error or error condition.
J J SHRIKHANDE 34
Introduction to Single-Piece-Flow
(Continuous Flow)
J J SHRIKHANDE 35
Single-Piece-Flow in a Cell
Single-Piece-Flow A B C
Carrying out one-piece-at-a-time
processing in order to eliminate
stagnation of work (queue) in and
between processing steps. A B C
Digital Cell
J J SHRIKHANDE 36
Batch Vs Single Piece Flow
J J SHRIKHANDE 37
Why Use Single Piece Flow ?
J J SHRIKHANDE 38
Where to start?
Single
SingleFacility
Facility
(door-to-door)
(door-to-door)
Multiple
Multiple
Service
ServiceFacilities
Facilities
Across
B. An (potential) area for
AcrossCompanies
Companies
Cell
J J SHRIKHANDE 39
Which process area?
Supplier = Customer ?
Yes
A main characteristic for office processes is that the customer of the process is often the
supplier of the needed information for doing the whole value stream, as well. Therefore,
the customer often has to wait for the whole lead time of the process.
Start within the area with the
biggest potential of lead-time reduction.
No
Start with the pace-maker process.
That are the process steps in the value stream
that are closed to the customer.
J J SHRIKHANDE 40
Roadmap - Creating Continuous Flow
1. Cell Content
Start looking at what items you should have in the cell.
2. Actual Work
Then analyze actual work to be done in the cell.
3. System, Item, and Lay-out
Optimize System, Item, and Cell Lay-out for creating continuous flow.
4. Work Distribution Going to reduce waste out
Distribute the Work among the People of:
• Steps
5. Implement, Sustain, and Improve • People activities
Actual implementation of Continuous Flow in a Cell • System activities
• Item design
• Lay-out
J J SHRIKHANDE 41
Questions for Creating Continuous Flow
Key questions
Cell Content
• Do you have the right end items?
• What is the Takt Time?
Actual Work
• What are the work elements necessary to make one piece?
• What is the actual time required for each work element?
System, Item and Layout for Flow
• Is your System suitable for flow?
• Is your item design for optimal continuous flow?
• How can the process be laid out so one person can make one piece as efficiently
as possible?
Work Distribution
• How to use your people efficiently?
• How will you distribute the work among the people?
J J SHRIKHANDE 42
Do you have the right items?
1. Flexibility
Cell for multiple items
+ More flexible for
changing demand
+ Pushes you to create
short changeover time
Cells for one item (waste reduction) Cells for multiple items
A B A&B A&B
J J SHRIKHANDE 43
Identify Items for cell
Start with the product or service, that is the customer’s only interest in GE.
To simplify, identify the product/service families:
A group of products/service that go through the same or similar ‘downstream’ steps.
A X X X X X
B X X X X X
Item
J J SHRIKHANDE 44
Do you have the right items?
Time
Max. ~ 30%
Total Work Content (see also next section) of the
product going through the cell should not variance
more than 30%, otherwise take them apart.
A B
J J SHRIKHANDE 45
What are the Work Elements? (for making one piece)
Work element
‘smallest increment of work done by a person (not a system)
that could be moved to another person’
J J SHRIKHANDE 46
Process Study Form
me nts
e
o rk e l
s a sw
sw aste
i ou
ny obv
d ea
t in clu
Do no
J J SHRIKHANDE 48
What Is a Pull System ?
A system in which each process takes what it needs from the preceding
process when it needs it and in the exact amount needed.
• Employs a variety of visual signaling devices and uses the concept of
Kanban
• Just-in-time focused
• Controls production system and limits inventory
• Simplifies or eliminates documentation
J J SHRIKHANDE 49
What Is a Push System ?
J J SHRIKHANDE 50
Differences Between Push & Pull
• Planning
• Push: Work is completed based on a planning system
• Pull: Work is completed based on authorization from
downstream users
• Work Authorization
• Push: Work is immediately sent to downstream user upon
completion
• Pull: Work is not forwarded to next operation until requested
J J SHRIKHANDE 51
Why Use Pull ?
Schedule :
Customer need :
Inventory :
SHORTAGE SHORTAGE
J J SHRIKHANDE 52
Why Use Pull ?
Conventional ‘Push’ system : WIP = ?
Breakdown
Breakdown
J J SHRIKHANDE 53
Pull Characteristics
• Standardized application
• Visibility
• Simplicity
• Standard lot sizes
• Discipline
• Versatility/Flexibility
J J SHRIKHANDE 54
How does Pull work ?
Legend
Supermarket
END CUSTOMER
Material
Information
2
1
1 Sequence / Timing
9
2nd LEVEL
SUPPLIER
10
3 4 5 9
2nd LEVEL
SUPPLIER
8 7 6 10
J J SHRIKHANDE 55
How does Pull work ?
Max>
Pull
Pull Replenish
Pull
Min>
J J SHRIKHANDE 56
Heijunka
Heijunka is the foundation of the Toyota Production system, and is the process of
leveling and sequencing an operation.
There are three main elements of Heijunka…
Toyota
Customer Demand Leveling
Production System
Heijunka
Just-in-Time
Jidoka
Heijunka
J J SHRIKHANDE 57
Kanban
A Kanban is a signal used by a downstream operation
to request a material replenishment
Kanban
Supplying
Supplying Using
Using
Process
Process Process
Process
Required
Part/ material
Cards
Bins
Carts
Labels
Kanbans are used to signal the supplying process that more material is
needed
J J SHRIKHANDE 58
Cellular Manufacturing
One Piece Flow for Work teams
• When we observe the work in which operators handle machinery, then that work can be
classified into machine or human work.
• Understanding the separation of human and machine work is the basis for understanding the
interface between these two elements.
• If operators are merely observing the machine working then this is the waste of “Waiting” and
should be eliminated.
Human work
This refers to work that cannot be completed without human effort. For example,
• Picking up materials
This refers to work or incidental work that equipment, which has been started by
human hand, automatically performs operations.
• Milling
• Auto inspection
Standard Symbols
Manual
Automatic
Walking
Waiting
HOW TO DISPLAY WORK ON THE
STANDARDISED WORK COMBINATION TABLE
Manual Work
Takt
Walk Time
Automatic Cycle
Wait
HOW TO DISPLAY WORK ON THE
STANDARDISED WORK COMBINATION TABLE
Returning to
the same process.
TT
2,4
3,5
Issue date 30/09/99
Operator 129
TOTALS 95 125 34 Wait time 33
Phase 2: Converting to a Process-Based Layout
• Evaluate the Options: how to improve the four basic element of production:
• Methods
• Machines
• Materials
• People
• Plan Possible New Layouts
• Layout in the process steps is the basic principle
• Machines placed close together
• U or C shape
• Often Counterclockwise (R/H next to machine)
• Move the Machines
• Document the New Operating Procedures
• Test to Confirm Improvement
Phase 3: Continuously Improving the Process
• Rearranging the layout into a manufacturing cell is not really an end point - it is the beginning
of continuous improvement
1. Separate Internal and External Setup (can reduce setup time by 30-50 %)
• Internal setup refers to setup operations that can be done only with the equipment stopped
• External setup can be done while the machine is working
Cellular manufacturing is a type of layout where machines are grouped according to the process requirements for
a set of similar items (part families) that require similar processing. These groups are called cells. Therefore, a
cellular layout is an equipment layout configured to support cellular manufacturing. Processes are grouped into
cells using a technique known as group technology (GT). Group technology involves identifying parts with similar
design characteristics (size, shape, and function) and similar process characteristics type of processing required,
available machinery that performs this type of process, and processing sequence.
Workers in cellular layouts are cross-trained so that they can operate all the equipment within the cell and take
responsibility for its output. Sometimes the cells feed into an assembly line that produces the final product. In
some cases a cell is formed by dedicating certain equipment to the production of a family of parts without actually
moving the equipment into a physical cell these are called virtual or nominal cells. In this way, the firm avoids the
burden of rearranging its current layout. However, physical cells are more common.
Example : An automated version of cellular manufacturing is the flexible manufacturing system (FMS). With an
FMS, a computer controls the transfer of parts to the various processes, enabling manufacturers to achieve some
of the benefits of product layouts while maintaining the flexibility of small batch production.
J J SHRIKHANDE 78
CELLULAR LAYOUT ( Group Technology Layout )
The group of similar parts is known as part family and the group of machineries used to process an individual part
family is known as machine cell. It is not necessary for each part of a part family to be processed by every machine
of corresponding machine cell. This type of manufacturing in which a part family is produced by a machine cell is
known as cellular manufacturing. The manufacturing efficiencies are generally increased by employing GT because
the required operations may be confined to only a small cell and thus avoiding the need for transportation of in-
process parts.
Group technology is an approach in which similar parts are identified and grouped together in order to take
advantage of the similarities in design and production. Similarities among parts permit them to be classified into
part families.
J J SHRIKHANDE 79
J J SHRIKHANDE 80
J J SHRIKHANDE 81
Overview
• Working in Teams
• Standardizing Workplace Conditions through 5S
• Using Visual Management for Production Control and Safety
• Performing Autonomous Maintenance Activities
• Using Activity Boards and One-Point Lessons
• Summary
Working in Teams
• The 5S system is a set of five basic principles that have names beginning with S:
• Sort
• Set in Order
• Shine
• Standardize
• Sustain
Using Visual Management for Production
Control and Safety
• Visual management is an important support for cellular manufacturing
• Visual management techniques express information in a way that can be understood quickly by
everyone
• Sharing information through visual tools helps keep production running smoothly and safely
• Changes old view that operators just run machines and maintenance people just
fix them
• Operators learn how to clean the equipment daily and how to inspect it for
trouble signs as they clean
• A one-point lesson
• An easy to read poster to teach others about a particular problem
• An improvement example, or
• Basic knowledge that everyone should have
• Kept short and focused on one point
• Often illustrated with photos or drawings
Summary
• Working in Teams
• Standardizing Workplace Conditions through 5S
• Using Visual Management for Production Control and Safety
• Performing Autonomous Maintenance Activities
• Using Activity Boards and One-Point Lessons