Here are some potential advantages and disadvantages to key stakeholders regarding victim compensation:
Victims/family:
- Advantage: Provides financial support for losses/injuries. Offers recognition of harm suffered.
- Disadvantage: Process can be lengthy/stressful. Compensation may not fully cover losses. Defendant may be unable to pay.
Defendant:
- Disadvantage: Required to pay compensation if found liable. May face financial hardship.
- Advantage: N/A
State:
- Advantage: Supports victims through compensation funds. Reduces burden on victims to pursue civil claims.
- Disadvantage: Requires public funds to operate compensation schemes.
Judge:
Here are some potential advantages and disadvantages to key stakeholders regarding victim compensation:
Victims/family:
- Advantage: Provides financial support for losses/injuries. Offers recognition of harm suffered.
- Disadvantage: Process can be lengthy/stressful. Compensation may not fully cover losses. Defendant may be unable to pay.
Defendant:
- Disadvantage: Required to pay compensation if found liable. May face financial hardship.
- Advantage: N/A
State:
- Advantage: Supports victims through compensation funds. Reduces burden on victims to pursue civil claims.
- Disadvantage: Requires public funds to operate compensation schemes.
Judge:
Here are some potential advantages and disadvantages to key stakeholders regarding victim compensation:
Victims/family:
- Advantage: Provides financial support for losses/injuries. Offers recognition of harm suffered.
- Disadvantage: Process can be lengthy/stressful. Compensation may not fully cover losses. Defendant may be unable to pay.
Defendant:
- Disadvantage: Required to pay compensation if found liable. May face financial hardship.
- Advantage: N/A
State:
- Advantage: Supports victims through compensation funds. Reduces burden on victims to pursue civil claims.
- Disadvantage: Requires public funds to operate compensation schemes.
Judge:
Here are some potential advantages and disadvantages to key stakeholders regarding victim compensation:
Victims/family:
- Advantage: Provides financial support for losses/injuries. Offers recognition of harm suffered.
- Disadvantage: Process can be lengthy/stressful. Compensation may not fully cover losses. Defendant may be unable to pay.
Defendant:
- Disadvantage: Required to pay compensation if found liable. May face financial hardship.
- Advantage: N/A
State:
- Advantage: Supports victims through compensation funds. Reduces burden on victims to pursue civil claims.
- Disadvantage: Requires public funds to operate compensation schemes.
Judge:
Download as PPT, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
Download as ppt, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 10
What is crime?
• Define crime in your own words before
you start the lesson Crime • A crime is what the legislature says is a crime. • An action or omission which constitutes an offence and is punishable by law. • It is conduct that attracts a penal sanction that is enforced by the state. • Reflects the attitudes and values of a society (jurisdiction). Again, define crime in your own words.
- Behaviour in one society may be unacceptable in another society
(for example different countries) - Consumption of alcohol, adultery (cheating), drug use and some forms of political opinion - Any visitor to those countries must observe those laws Proceedings • The prosecution has to establish the guilt of the accused person. • NOTE: there is a considerable difference between being innocent and being not guilty. • A ‘not guilty’ finding means that the prosecution has failed to establish the guilt beyond reasonable doubt. • Meaning the magistrate/jury must be satisfied that the accused is guilty without any other logical explanation. Offences Offences are classified into two different types •Indictable offence (serious matters) heard before a judge and/or jury •Simple offences (lesser charges) heard before a magistrate/justice of the peace without a jury.
•List three example offences for each.
Victims of crime • Civil law has always provided a remedy for persons who have suffered a loss or injury through the acts of others. • Although it is theoretically possible for a person who has suffered an injury or loss through the criminal conduct of another to seek a remedy in the civil courts, it is a difficult process. • Frequently even if the court action is successful, it may be an empty victory as the offender may be unable to pay any compensation (lack of money/ declare themselves bankrupt.) • Australian jurisdictions have introduced a statute based system of compensation for persons who suffered criminal injuries. Remedy for victim • Australian jurisdictions have introduced a statute based system of compensation for persons who suffered criminal injuries. • However there is a monetary limit on the amount that can be awarded although the state itself makes the payment (usually ex gratia)(sense of moral obligation not a legal requirement). • This does provide some compensation. • Criminal Offence Victims Act 1995 (Qld) and the Penalties and Sentencing Act 1992 (Qld) operate to provide redress and financial compensation for victims of crime. (max $75, 000) Student Task 1. Read the following information regarding victim compensation 2. Summarise into 66 words https://gouldson.com.au/compensation-claims-and-the-crim inal-offence-victims-act/
During the holiday season, criminal offences will rise in number.
Criminal offences not only leaving physical but mental injuries are more frequent. Depending on the damage to a person from a crime, the money you will get in return may vary. The more damage from a crime the more maximum compensation is $75,000 within the current legal system, this act is called the COVA Other Factors Other factors • Some states have mechanisms in place so the victims and others can be informed of the subsequent release of offenders from incarceration. • QLD= the Concerned Persons Register. • In 2008, the Corrective Services Act 2006 (Qld) was amended to enable persons who are seeking compensation against a prisoner to have another opportunity in a situation where a prisoner is awarded compensation for an injury suffered by the prisoner arising from their imprisonment or supervision. This money is paid to the Victim Trust Fund not the prisoner, where if compensation needs to be paid out to the victim, it will be. • Also the Australian and State governments can claim money from the victim trust fund to pay unpaid fines and child support of the prisoner. Identify the advantages and disadvantages to all stakeholders regarding victim compensation Stakeholders are anyone directly or indirectly affected by the situation
Stakeholders (direct Disadvantages Advantages
and indirect) Victims family Victim Defendant Judge state