Microwave High Power Amplifiers (Hpas) For Satellite Communication (Satcom) Applications
Microwave High Power Amplifiers (Hpas) For Satellite Communication (Satcom) Applications
Microwave High Power Amplifiers (Hpas) For Satellite Communication (Satcom) Applications
By
Raghuvir Tomar
The LNM Institute of Information Technology
Jaipur, India
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 1
Microwave High Power
Amplifiers (HPAs) for
Satellite Communication
(SATCOM) Applications
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 2
Mobile Earth Station
(MES) versus Fixed Earth
Station (MES)
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 3
AGENDA
Typical SATCOM Topology
Typical SATCOM Transceiver
Architecture
HPA Architecture
Understanding HPA specifications
Design Example 1 (250mW Driver)
Design Example 2 (12W HPA )
Design Example 3 (60W HPA )
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 4
A Typical SATCOM System
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 5
A Typical SATCOM Transceiver
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 6
SATCOM HPA Design Challenges
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 7
Typical HPA Lineup
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 8
Understanding HPA
Specifications
Bandwidth vs. power are the two main conflicting
requirements. Good impedance matching
techniques are needed.
Power rating is usually expressed in continuous
wave (CW) mode.
Tolerance limit on gain and/or output power needs
to be specified to capture HPA performance
changes with frequency, temperature, input power
level, aging, etc.
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 9
Understanding HPA
Specifications Contd...
Conservative power
and bandwidth
ratings imply
availability of extra
headroom, and
indicate a good
design!
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 10
Understanding HPA
Specifications Contd...
Specifying minimum power (over frequency,
temperature, and other electrical and
environmental parameters) is the most desirable
approach since enough power headroom will be
available to users.
Nominal power is also usually specified since it
gives users a more realistic view of the HPA
capabilities.
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 11
Understanding HPA
Specifications Contd...
HPA bandwidth is the frequency range outside
which the output power falls below the minimum
power specification, or below the range of flatness
specification.
Beware of 3-dB definition of bandwidth in this
context!
Oscillation-free operation under high VSWR
loading is a must.
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 12
Understanding HPA
Specifications Contd...
Pout
Pin
Pout
PAE
Pin PinRF
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 13
Linearity
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 14
1-dB Gain Compression Point
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 15
Multi-Carrier Operation
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 16
Third-Order Intercept
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 17
HPA Linearization
Linearizer is a device for reducing
distortion.
Feedback linearization is relatively
narrow-band and also displays
stability problems.
Feed-forward linearization is
complex to implement but wide-
band operation is possible.
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 18
HPA Linearization
continued
Pre-distortion is a very favored
linearization technique.
Pre-distortion is based on
generating a transfer characteristic
(both magnitude and phase) that is
opposite of the saturation
characteristic of the HPA.
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 19
Pre-distortion example
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 20
Pre-distortion example
continued
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 21
HPA Pre-Driver Stage
Pre-driver usually handles low signal levels (<0 dBm).
Standard 50-ohm input/output operation of pre-driver
achievable thru commercially available devices ,without
major re-design effort for SATCOM bands.
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 22
HPA Driver Stage
Driver typically has to handle medium power (up to
500mW, or even 1W in some cases).
Driver linearity plays an important role in the overall
linearity budget.
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 23
HPA Final Stage
Most critical stage in the HPA lineup.
Linearity specifications can be very demanding and may
not even be met, without the aid of an external
linearizer.
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 24
HPA Linearizer
Spectrally efficient modulation schemes are here to stay
(more and more traffic packed in a limited bandwidth!).
Digital modulation generates time-varying waveform
envelopes which pass through a non-linear HPA and
generate inter-modulation distortion which leads to
interfering signals in adjacent channels.
Linearizer brings inter-modulation signals to acceptable
levels.
Two commonly used methods of HPA linearization are
feed-forward and pre-distortion. Pre-distortion can be
either at base-band or at RF.
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 25
Design Example 1 (Driver Amplifier) :
Design Goals
Frequency = 1626.5MHz-1660.5MHz
Nominal RF gain = or >18dB
Gain flatness (over frequency) = +/-0.3dB
Max. RF input power = 0dBm
1-dB compression point P1dB >24dBm
Third-order intercept IP3>34dBm
Input/output return loss < –9.5dB
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 26
Design Example 1
(D.C./Environmental/Mechanical
Requirements)
D.C. voltage +12V nominal
D.C. current 300mA maximum
Thermal dissipation <3.5W
Operating temperature -400C to +850C
Storage temperature -550C to +1250C
Size 3.75” by 0.75” by 0.5” maximum
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 27
Design Example 1 : Device Line-up
(Devices are from WJ Communications,
which is now owned by Triquint
Semiconductors)
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 28
Design Example 1 : AM1 Data Sheet
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 29
Design Example 1 : AH102 Data
Sheet
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 30
Design Example 1 : AH102 Data
Sheet Continued...
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 31
Design Example 1 : Key Performance
Parameters of Selected Devices
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 32
Design Example 1 : Design
Challenges
Large-power scattering parameters (S-parameters) for
AM1 and AH102 need to be measured for 1626.5MHz-
1660.5MHz frequency band.
Vendor-recommended impedance-matching circuitry
needs to be re-assessed and optimized for 1626.5MHz-
1660.5MHz
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 33
Design Example 1 : Circuit Schematic
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 34
Design Example 1 : PCB Layout
Bottom Layer
Top Layer
Two 14 Thou GETEK substrates sandwiched to create a 3-layer PCB
(Middle GND, Bottom DC Generating Circuitry, Top RF,J2 Input)
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 35
Design Example 1 : Measured Gain
(1000MHz-2000MHz)
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 36
Design Example 1 : Measured Gain
(1626.5MHz-1660.5MHz)
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 37
Design Example 1 : Measured P1dB
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 38
Design Example 1 : Measured Output
Return Loss
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 39
Design Example 1 : Measured Input
Return Loss
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 40
Design Example 1 : Compliance
Matrix
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 41
Design Example 1 : Conclusion
All specifications met or exceeded.
The only exception is the input return loss for which a
1.5dB shortfall in meeting -9.5dB specification was seen
(not an issue for practical purposes, since RF pads will
be used at the RF input to adjust gain to 18dB
requirement, thereby improving the overall input return
loss).
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 42
Design Example 2 (12W HPA) : Key
Design Parameters
Frequency 1626.5MHz-1660.5MHz
P1dB=12W or higher
Gain=40dB nominal
Gain Flatness=+/-0.3dB
Input/Output Return Loss<-9.5dB
Unconditional Stability over DC-18GHz
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 43
Design Example 2 : Design
Challenges
Poor yield (due to device-to-device variations) is a big
challenge if narrow-band (34MHz) impedance matching
networks are used.
A practical solution is to redesign impedance-matching
circuitry for relatively broader bandwidth (~100MHz)
so that the design can absorb the effects of device-to-
device variations.
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 44
Design Example 2 : Device Selection
Q1 : MRFIC1818 (GaAs MMIC,Motorola, now
available as MRFIC1819)
Q2 : PTF10053 (Laterally Diffused MOS,Ericsson)
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 45
Design Example 2 : Impedance-
Matching using Conventional Method
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 46
Design Example 2 : Impedance-
Matching using New Method
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 47
Design Example 2 :Design Schematic
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 48
Design Example 2 : Inter-stage
Matching Network
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 49
Design Example 2 : Output Matching
Network
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 52
Design Example 2 : Measured P1dB
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 53
Design Example 2 : Measured Input
Return Loss
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 54
Design Example 2 : Conclusion
Conclusion
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 55
Design Example 3 (60W HPA)
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 56
Design Example 3 : Highlights
General-purpose WJ Communications devices in pre-
driver stage.
Fujitsu bipolar transistors in driver stage.
Four 30W Ultra-RF LDMOS devices in parallel in the
output stage.
No linearizer necessary since P1dB~80W in open-loop.
Many power splitters and power combiners needed.
Isolator at the output (guarantees unconditionally stable
operation with variations in output load).
Temperature-compensation circuitry included in driver
(to meet +/-1dB gain flatness over temperature).
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 57
Design Example 3
Contd..
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 58
What This Means
Designing highly-linear HPAs for SATCOM bands is a
research area of wide interest, especially because
vendors produce and characterize devices mostly for
terrestrial bands.
SATCOM-specific designs for other RF components
(LNAs,diplexers,filters,power combiners,isolators,etc.)
are rare too.
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 59
KEY POINTS TO REMEMBER
SATCOM HPAs are required to be highly linear.
Linear HPA design without linearizer pleases
management (cost savings!). This is a worthy goal and
achievable too (example 3 of this presentation).
Be prepared to do device characterization & matching
network design in-house, for your frequency band of
interest, since most vendors are not of much help (not
much interested either).
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 60
Next Steps
Research latest SATCOM product specifications
for HPAs and other RF components like LNAs,
diplexers, power combiners, etc.
Research latest SATCOM vendors.
Identify need for original experimental design
work.
Research RF test methodologies unique to
SATCOM specifications.
5/30/2019 Dr. Raghuvir Tomar, LNM Institute of Information Technology, Jaipur, India 61