Thyristor Commutation Techniques: Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Thyristor Commutation Techniques: Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Thyristor Commutation Techniques: Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Techniques
• Forced Commutation
vs ~ R vo
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 4
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
S u p p ly v o lta g e v s S in u s o id a l
3 t
0 2
G a te P u ls e
t
L o a d v o lta g e v o
T u rn o ff
o c c u rs h e re
t
3 t
0 2
V o l ta g e a c r o s s S C R
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 5
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, t c E&E Dept., MSRIT
• Natural Commutation of Thyristors takes place
in
– AC voltage controllers.
– Phase controlled rectifiers.
– Cyclo converters.
• Inverters.
V
S
I S S
1
R SL
CS
CS V VC 0
C V VC 0
I S S
RCS S LC 1
2
2 R 1
LC S S
L LC
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 14
14
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
V VC 0
I S L
R 1
S S
2
L LC
V VC 0
I S L
2 2
R 1 R R
S S
2
L LC 2 L 2 L
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 15
15
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
V V 0
C
L A
I S
S
2 2
2 2 2
R 1 R
S
2 L LC 2 L
Where,
A
V VC 0 ,
R
,
1 R
2
L 2L LC 2L
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 16
16
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
is called the natural frequency
A
I S
S 2
2
V V 0 C
L
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 18
18
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Expression For Voltage Across
Capacitor At The Time Of Turn Off
T L V c(0 )
i R + -
Load C
vc t
V V 0
C R
2 sin t L cos t
t
V e
L
vc t V
V V 0
R
e
C
sin t t
cos t
2 L
SCR turns off when current goes to zero.
i.e., at t
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 22
22
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Therefore at turn off
vc t V
V VC 0 e
0 cos
vc t V V VC 0 e
R
vc t V V VC 0 e 2 L
t
0 /2
2V
C a p a c ito r v o lta g e
V
t
Conduction time of SCR
G a te p u ls e
t
t
V
V o l ta g e a c r o s s S C R
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 26
26
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Problem
• Calculate the conduction time of SCR and the
peak SCR current that flows in the circuit
employing series resonant commutation (self
commutation or class A commutation), if the
supply voltage is 300 V, C = 1F, L = 5 mH
and RL = 100 . Assume that the circuit is
initially relaxed.
100 5 m H 1 F
V =300V
V VC 0 SI O 1
I S 2 ; where
L S S
2 2 2
LC
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 35
35
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Taking inverse LT
C
i t V VC 0 sin t I O cos t
L
The capacitor voltage is given by
t
1
vc t i t dt VC 0
C0
1
t
C
vc t V VC 0 sin t I O cos t dt VC 0
C 0 L
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 36
36
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
1 V VC 0 C t IO t
vc t cos t sin t VC 0
C L o o
1 V VC 0 C IO
vc t 1 cos t sin t VC 0
C L
IO 1 C
vc t LC sin t V VC 0 LC 1 cos t VC 0
C C L
L
vc t I O sin t V V cos t VC 0 VC 0 cos t VC 0
C
L
vc t I O sin t V VC 0 cos t V
C
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 37
37
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
I0
i(t)
VC O V
t
/2
we get
v c( t)
i t I O cos t &
L
V
vc t I O sin t V
C
t
/2
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 38
38
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Turn off occurs at a time 'tO ' so that
tO
2
0.5
tO 0.5 LC
tO 0.5 10 10 50 10 6 6
tO 0.5 10 6
500 35.1 seconds
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 39
39
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
and the capacitor voltage at turn off is given by
L
vc tO I O sin tO V
C
6
10 10
vc tO 200 6
sin 90 100
0
50 10
vc tO 89.4 100 189.4 V
I0
i(t)
V C
L
L
IO
C and 1
where tan 1
V LC
C
The peak capacitor current is I V2
O
2
L
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 44
44
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Substituting the values, the peak capacitor current
6
50 10
3502 6002 6
1011.19 A
20 10
The expression for capacitor voltage is
L
vc t I O sin t V VC 0 cos t V
C
L
with VC 0 0, vc t I O sin t V cos t V
C
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 45
45
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
This can be rewritten as
C
V
2 L L
vc t V I O sin t V ; Where tan 1
2
C IO
L
The peak value of capacitor voltage is V I 2 2
OV
C
Substituting the values, the peak value of capacitor voltage
6
20 10
6002 3502 6
600 639.5 600 1239.5V
50 10
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 46
46
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
To calculate conduction time of T1
• The waveform
of capacitor
current is shown C a p a c ito r
in figure. c u rre n t
When the
capacitor
current becomes t
zero the SCR 0
turns off.
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 47
47
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
conduction time of SCR
L
IO
tan 1
C
V
1
LC
L
IO
Substituting the values tan 1 C
V
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 48
48
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
6
350 20 10
tan 1
600 50 106
20.25 i.e., 0.3534 radians
0
1 1
31622.8 rad/sec
LC 20 106 50 106
conduction time of SCR
0.3534
88.17 sec
31622.8
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 49
49
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Resonant Pulse Commutation
(Class B Commutation)
L
T
i
a
b C
IL
V
Load
FW D
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 50
50
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
• Series LC circuit connected across thyristor
‘T’.
• Initially ‘C’ is charged to ‘V’ volts with plate
‘a’ as positive.
• Current in LC oscillates when SCR is ON.
• ‘T’ turns off when capacitor discharges through
thyristor in a direction opposite to IL
tC
Ip i
t
IL
t
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 52
52
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
ISC R
T h y r isto r C u rre n t
V o lta g e a c r o s s
SC R
t
SL
L
T T 1
i
CS
+ +
C V C(0 )
=V V
- S
LC Circuit Transformed Circuit
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 56
56
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
VV
CS
s
I S S
2
1 S LC 1
SL
Cs
VC
V 1
I S
2 1 L 1
LC S S
2
LC LC
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 57
57
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
1
V LC 1
I S
L S2 1 1
LC LC
1
C LC
I S V
L S2 1
LC
C
Taking inverse LT i t V sin t
L
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 58
58
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
1
Where
LC
V
or i t sin t I p sin t
L
C
Ip V amps
L
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 59
59
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Expression For
Conduction Time Of SCR
Conduction time of SCR
t
1 I L
sin
I
p
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 60
60
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Alternate Circuit
For Resonant Pulse Commutation
T 1 iC ( t) IL
C L T
a b iC ( t) 2
+
V C(0 ) L
V T 3
O
A
FW D D
V
C a p a c it o r
v o lta g e v ab
t
t1
V 1
tC
V C(0 )
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 67
67
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Resonant Pulse Commutation
With Accelerating Diode
T 1
IL
C L iC ( t) T 2
- +
V C(0 )
L
T O
V 3
A
FW D D
0 t
V C
0 t
t1 t2
V 1
V C (O ) tC
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 71
71
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Problem
• The circuit in figure shows a resonant pulse
commutation circuit. The initial capacitor
voltage VC(O)=200V, C = 30F and L = 3H.
Determine the circuit turn off time tC, if the
load current IL is 200 A and 50 A.
+
V C(0 )
L
T O
V 3
A
FW D D
T 1
IL
C L iC ( t) T 2
- +
V C(0 )
L
T O
V 3
A
FW D D
6 6
1 200 3 10 6
t1 3 10 30 10 sin
200 30 106
t1 3.05 sec
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 79
79
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
1 1
6 6
LC 3 10 30 10
0.105 10 radians/sec
6
At t t1
VC t1 V1 VC O cos t1
VC t1 200 cos 0.105 10 3.05 10
6 6
VC t1 189.75V
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 80
80
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
iC t flows through diode D2 after T1 turns off.
iC t current falls back to I L at t2 .
t2 LC t1
t2 3 10 30 10 3.05 10
6 6 6
t2 26.75 sec
1 1
6 6
LC 3 10 30 10
0.105 106 rad/sec.
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 81
81
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
At t t2
VC t2 V2 200 cos 0.105 106 26.75 106
VC t2 V2 189.02 V
tC t2 t1 26.75 106 3.05 106
tC 23.7 secs
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 82
82
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Problem
• For the circuit shown in figure calculate the
value of L for proper commutation of SCR.
Also find the conduction time of SCR.
4 F
V
=30V L
R L i
30 IL
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 83
83
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
The load current
V 30
IL 1 Amp
RL 30
For proper SCR commutation I p ,
the peak value of resonant current i, should be
greater than I L
Let I p 2I L , I p 2 Amps
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 84
84
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
V V C
Also Ip V
L 1
L L
LC
6
4 10
2 30
L
L 0.9mH
1 1
16666 rad/sec
3 6
LC 0.9 10 4 10
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 85
85
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Conduction time of SCR
IL
sin 1 1 1
sin
Ip 2
16666 16666
0.523
radians 0.00022 seconds
16666
0.22 msec
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 86
86
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Problem
• For the circuit shown in figure given that the
load current to be commutated is 10 A, turn off
time required is 40sec and the supply voltage
is 100 V. Obtain the proper values of
commutating elements.
IL
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 88
88
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
C
I p peak value of i V & this should be greater than I L
L
Let I p 1.5 I L
C
1.5 10 100 ... a
L
Also, assuming that at the time of turn off the capacitor
voltage is approximately equal to V, and the load current
linearly charges the capacitor
CV
tc seconds
IL
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 89
89
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
& this tc is given to be 40sec.
100
6
40 10 C
10
C 4 F
Substituting this in equation (a)
4 106
1.5 10 100
L
6
10 4
4 10
1.52 102
L
L 1.777 104 H 0.177 mH
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 90
90
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Problem
• In a resonant commutation circuit supply
voltage is 200 V. Load current is 10 A and the
device turn off time is 20s. The ratio of peak
resonant current to load current is 1.5.
Determine the value of L and C of the
commutation circuit.
R 1 R 2
a b iC
V
C
T 1 T 2
C u rr e n t th ro u g h T 2V
1
R2
V
R 1
t
2V C u rr e n t th ro u g h T 2
R1
V
R2
t
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 97
97
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
C u rre n t
th r o u g h R 2
t
V
V o lta g e a c r o s s
c a p a c ito r v ab
t
- V
tC tC
V o lta g e a c r o s s T 1
tC
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 98
98
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Expression For
Circuit Turn Off Time tC
vc t V f Vi V f e t
Where V f is the final voltage, Vi is the initial
voltage and is the time constant.
At t tc , vc t 0, V f V , R1C, & Vi V
tc tc
0 V V V e R1C
V 2Ve R1C
V 2Ve R1C
; 0.5 e R1C
V
C
T 1 T 2
R 1 R L
iC
V
=100V C
A u x ilia r y M a in
SCR SCR
T 3 V C(O ) C
+
L
L T O
V 2
A
FW D D
V C
tC
V o lta g e a c r o s s T 1
t
-V C
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 110
110
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Expression For
Circuit Turn Off Time tC
tc depends on I L & is given by the expression
tc
1
VC I L dt
C0
(assuming the load current to be constant)
I L tc VC C
VC tc seconds
C IL
For proper commutation tc tq , turn off time of T1
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 111
111
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
T1 is turned off by applying a negative voltage across
its terminals. Hence this is voltage commutation.
tC depends on load current. For higher load currents tC
is small. This is a disadvantage of this circuit.
When T2 is fired, voltage across the load is V+VC;
hence the current through load shoots up and then
decays as the capacitor starts charging.
T 2
D
V
L
IL
R L
V C C a p a c ito r
v o l ta g e
- V
tC
T h is i s d u e to i
IT 1 IL
C u rre n t th ro u g h S C R V
R L
t
IL
L o a d c u rre n t
V V o lta g e a c r o s s T 1
t
tC
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 116
116
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Problem
• An impulse commutated thyristor circuit is
shown in figure. Determine the available turn
off time of the circuit if V = 100 V, R = 10
and C = 10 F. Voltage across capacitor
before T2 is fired is V volts with polarity as
shown.
-
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 118
118
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
When T2 is triggered
the circuit is as shown in figure
V C (O )
- i(t)
+ +
C
T 2
V R
-
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 119
119
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Writing the transform
circuit, we obtain
1 V C(0 )
Cs s
+ I(s)
+
V R
s
I S
V V 0
C
1
RS
RC
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 121
121
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Voltage across capacitor
1 VC 0
VC s I S
CS S
1 V VC 0 VC 0
VC s
RCS 1 S
S
RC
V VC 0 V VC 0 VC 0
VC S
S 1 S
S
RC
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 122
122
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
V V VC 0
VC S
S S 1 S
1
RC RC
t
RC
t
vc t V 1 e VC 0 e RC
In the given problem VC 0 V
t
vc t V 1 2e RC
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 123
123
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
The waveform of vC(t)
is shown in figure
V
v C (t)
t
V C(0 )
tC
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 124
124
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
At t tc , vc t 0
tc
0 V 1 2e RC
tc
1 2e RC
1 tc
e RC
2
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 125
125
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Taking natural logarithms
1 tc
log e
2 RC
tc RC ln 2
tc 10 10 10 ln 2 6
tc 69.3 sec
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 126
126
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Problem
• In the commutation circuit shown in figure
C = 20 F, the input voltage V varies between
180 and 220 V and the load current varies
between 50 and 200 A. Determine the minimum
and maximum values of available turn off time
tC.
C V C(0 )= V
+
V
T 2
I0
50
CVmin
And tc min
I O max
180
tc min 20 10 18 sec
6
200
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 130
130
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
External Pulse
Commutation (Class E Commutation)
T 1 T 2 L T 3
+
V S R 2V A U X C V A U X
L
+ IL
T +
3
_ C L
FW D O
V S A
L r D
T 2