Thyristor Commutation Techniques: Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT

Download as ppt, pdf, or txt
Download as ppt, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 137

Thyristor Commutation

Techniques

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 1


Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Introduction
• Commutation
– Process of turning off a conducting thyristor.
• Current Commutation
• Voltage Commutation

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 2


Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Methods of Commutation
• Natural Commutation

• Forced Commutation

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 3


Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Natural Commutation
• Occurs in AC circuits
T
+

vs ~  R  vo


Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 4
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
S u p p ly v o lta g e v s S in u s o id a l

 3 t
0 2

G a te P u ls e

 t

L o a d v o lta g e v o
T u rn o ff
o c c u rs h e re
t
 

 3 t
0 2

V o l ta g e a c r o s s S C R
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 5
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, t c E&E Dept., MSRIT
• Natural Commutation of Thyristors takes place
in
– AC voltage controllers.
– Phase controlled rectifiers.
– Cyclo converters.

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 6


Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Forced Commutation
• Applied to dc circuits
• Commutation achieved by reverse biasing the
SCR or by reducing the SCR current below
holding current value.
• Commutating elements such as inductance and
capacitance are used for commutation purpose.

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 7


Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Methods of Forced
Commutation
• Self commutation.
• Resonant pulse commutation.
• Complementary commutation.
• Impulse commutation.
• External pulse commutation.
• Load Commutation.
• Line Commutation.
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 8
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Forced Commutation
is applied to
• Choppers.

• Inverters.

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 9


Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Self Commutation
Or
Load Commutation
Or
Class A Commutation
(Commutation By Resonating
The Load)
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 10
10
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
• Circuit is under damped by including suitable
values of L & C in series with load.
• Oscillating current flows.
• SCR is turned off when current is zero.

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 11


11
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
T L V c(0 )
i R + -
Load C

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 12


12
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Expression for Current V C(0 )
1
R I(S ) SL CS S
T + - + -
C

V
S

Fig. shows a transformed network


Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 13
13
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
V  VC  0 

I  S  S
1
R  SL 
CS
CS V  VC  0 
C V  VC  0 
I  S  S 
RCS  S LC  1
2
 2 R 1 
LC  S  S 
 L LC 
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 14
14
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
V  VC  0 
I  S  L
R 1
S S 
2

L LC
 V  VC  0  
I  S  L
2 2
R 1  R   R 
S S 
2
   
L LC  2 L   2 L 
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 15
15
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
 V  V  0 
C

L A
I  S  
 S  
2 2
 2 2   2
 R  1  R 
S      
 2 L   LC  2 L 
 
Where,

A
 V  VC  0   , 
R
, 
1  R 

2


L 2L LC  2L 
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 16
16
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
 is called the natural frequency
A 
I  S 
  S   2
2

Taking inverse Laplace transforms


A  t
i  t   e sin  t

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 17
17
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
 Expression for current
V  VC  0  2 RL t
i t  e sin  t
L
Peak value of current


 V  V  0 C

L
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 18
18
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Expression For Voltage Across
Capacitor At The Time Of Turn Off
T L V c(0 )
i R + -
Load C

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 19


19
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Applying KVL to figure
vc  t   V  vR  VL
di
vc  t   V  iR  L
dt
Substituting for i,
A  t d  A  t 
vc  t   V  R e sin t  L  e sin t 
 dt  
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 20
20
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
A  t A  t
vc  t   V  R e sin t  L  e  cos t  e  t sin t 
 
A  t
vc  t   V  e  R sin t  L cos t  L sin t 

A  t  R 
vc  t   V  e  R sin t  L cos t  L sin t 
  2L 
A  t  R 
vc  t   V  e  sin t  L cos t 
 2 
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 21
21
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Substituting for A,

vc  t 
 V  V  0  
C R 
 2 sin  t   L cos  t 
 t
V  e
L

vc  t  V 
 V  V  0  
R
e
C
sin  t   t
cos  t

  2 L 
SCR turns off when current goes to zero.
i.e., at  t  
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 22
22
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Therefore at turn off

vc  t   V 
 V  VC  0  e
 

 0  cos 

 
vc  t   V  V  VC  0  e 

 R
 vc  t   V  V  VC  0  e 2 L

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 23


23
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Note: For effective commutation
the circuit should be under damped.
2
 R  1
That is   
 2L  LC
With R = 0, and the capacitor initially uncharged
that is VC  0   0
V t
i t  sin
L LC
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 24
24
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
1
But  
LC
V t C t
i  t   LC sin V sin
L LC L LC
and capacitor voltage at turn off is equal to 2V
Fig. shows the waveforms for the above conditions.
Once the SCR turns off voltage across it is
negative voltage.
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 25
25
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
C u rren t i

t
0  /2 
2V
C a p a c ito r v o lta g e
V

t

Conduction time of SCR 
G a te p u ls e

t

t

V
V o l ta g e a c r o s s S C R
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 26
26
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Problem
• Calculate the conduction time of SCR and the
peak SCR current that flows in the circuit
employing series resonant commutation (self
commutation or class A commutation), if the
supply voltage is 300 V, C = 1F, L = 5 mH
and RL = 100 . Assume that the circuit is
initially relaxed.

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 27


27
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
T R L
L C

100  5 m H 1 F

V =300V

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 28


28
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
2
1  RL 
  
LC  2L 
2
1  100 
 3 6
 3 
5  10 1 10  2  5 10 
  10, 000 rad/sec
Since the circuit is initially relaxed, initial voltage
across capacitor is zero as also the initial current
through L and the expression for current i is
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 29
29
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
V  t R
i  t  e sin t , where  
L 2L
V
 peak value of current 
L
300
IP  3
 6A
10000  5  10
 
Conducting time of SCR =   0.314msec
 10000
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 30
30
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Problem
• Figure shows a self commutating circuit. The
inductance carries an initial current of 200 A
and the initial voltage across the capacitor is
V, the supply voltage. Determine the
conduction time of the SCR and the capacitor
voltage at turn off.

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 31


31
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
L T i(t)
 IO
10 H
C +
V 50 F  V C(0 )= V
=100V

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 32


32
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
The transformed circuit of the
previous figure is shown in figure below
SL IO L
+ -
I(S ) +
V C(0 )
+ - S
V
S - 1
CS

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 33


33
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
The governing equation is
V VC  0 1
 I  S  SL  I O L   I  S
S S CS
V VC  0
  IO L
 I  S  S S
1
SL 
CS
 V VC  0 
   CS
S S  I O LCS
I  S   2
S LC  1
2
S LC  1
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 34
34
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
V  VC  0  C I O LCS
I  S  
 2 1   2 1 
LC  S  LC S 
 LC   LC 
V  VC  0 SI O
I  S   2

L  S  
2 2
 S   2

V  VC  0  SI O 1
I  S   2 ; where  
 L  S   S 
2 2 2
LC
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 35
35
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Taking inverse LT
C
i  t   V  VC  0   sin  t  I O cos t
L
The capacitor voltage is given by
t
1
vc  t    i  t  dt  VC  0 
C0
1  
t
C
vc  t     V  VC  0   sin  t  I O cos  t  dt  VC  0 
C 0  L 
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 36
36
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
1   V  VC  0   C t IO t 
vc  t      cos  t    sin  t   VC  0  
C   L o  o 
1   V  VC  0   C IO 
vc  t     1  cos  t    sin  t   VC  0  
C   L  
IO 1 C
vc  t    LC sin  t   V  VC  0   LC  1  cos  t   VC  0 
C C L
L
vc  t   I O sin  t  V  V cos  t  VC  0   VC  0  cos  t  VC  0 
C
L
vc  t   I O sin  t   V  VC  0   cos  t  V
C
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 37
37
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
I0
i(t)

VC  O   V
t
/2
 we get
v c( t)
i  t   I O cos  t &
L
V
vc  t   I O sin  t  V
C
t
/2
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 38
38
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Turn off occurs at a time 'tO ' so that

 tO 
2
0.5
 tO   0.5 LC

tO  0.5   10 10  50 10 6 6

tO  0.5   10 6
500  35.1 seconds
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 39
39
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
and the capacitor voltage at turn off is given by
L
vc  tO   I O sin  tO  V
C
6
10 10
vc  tO   200 6
 sin 90  100
0

50 10
vc  tO   89.4  100  189.4 V

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 40


40
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Problem
• In the circuit shown in figure V = 600 volts,
initial capacitor voltage is zero, L = 20 H,
C=50F and the current through the
inductance at the time of SCR triggering is
IO = 350 A. Determine
– Peak values of capacitor voltage and current
– Conduction time of T1.

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 41


41
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
L T 1

 I0
i(t)
V C

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 42


42
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
The expression for i  t  is given by
C
i  t   V  VC  O   sin  t  I O cos  t
L
It is given that the initial voltage across
the capacitor VC  O  is zero.
C
 i t V sin  t  I O cos  t
L
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 43
43
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
i  t  can be written as
C
i  t   I V sin   t   
2
O
2

L
L
IO
C and   1
where   tan 1

V LC
C
The peak capacitor current is I V2
O
2

L
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 44
44
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Substituting the values, the peak capacitor current
6
50  10
 3502  6002  6
 1011.19 A
20 10
The expression for capacitor voltage is
L
vc  t   I O sin  t   V  VC  0   cos  t  V
C
L
with VC  0   0, vc  t   I O sin  t  V cos  t  V
C
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 45
45
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
This can be rewritten as
C
V
2 L L
vc  t   V  I O sin   t     V ; Where   tan 1
2

C IO
L
The peak value of capacitor voltage is  V  I 2 2
OV
C
Substituting the values, the peak value of capacitor voltage
6
20  10
 6002  3502  6
 600  639.5  600  1239.5V
50  10
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 46
46
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
To calculate conduction time of T1
• The waveform
of capacitor
current is shown C a p a c ito r
in figure. c u rre n t
When the
capacitor
current becomes t
zero the SCR  0
turns off.
   
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 47
47
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
 conduction time of SCR
 L 
 IO 
  tan 1
 C 
 V 
   
   
 1
LC
 L 
 IO 
Substituting the values   tan 1  C 
 V 
 
 
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 48
48
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
6
350 20 10
  tan 1

600 50 106
  20.25 i.e., 0.3534 radians
0

1 1
   31622.8 rad/sec
LC 20  106  50 106
 conduction time of SCR
  0.3534
  88.17  sec
31622.8
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 49
49
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Resonant Pulse Commutation
(Class B Commutation)
L
T
i
a
b C

IL
V
Load
FW D
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 50
50
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
• Series LC circuit connected across thyristor
‘T’.
• Initially ‘C’ is charged to ‘V’ volts with plate
‘a’ as positive.
• Current in LC oscillates when SCR is ON.
• ‘T’ turns off when capacitor discharges through
thyristor in a direction opposite to IL

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 51


51
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
G a te p u ls e
of SC R
t
t1 
V
C a p a c ito r v o lta g e
v ab
t

tC
Ip i

t

IL 
t
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 52
52
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
ISC R
T h y r isto r C u rre n t

V o lta g e a c r o s s
SC R
t

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 53


53
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Expression For tC ,
the Circuit Turn Off Time

Assume that at the time of turn off of the SCR


the capacitor voltage vab  V and a constant
load current I L flows.
tc is the time taken for the capacitor
voltage to reach 0 volts from  V volts and
it is derived as follows
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 54
54
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
tc
1 I L tc
V   I L dt 
C0 C
VC
tc  seconds
IL
For proper commutation tc should be greater than tq .
Magnitude of I p the peak value of i should be
greater than the load current I L .
Expression for i is derived as follows

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 55


55
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
The LC Circuit
During The Commutation Period
I(S )

SL
L

T T 1
i
CS
+ +
C V C(0 )
 =V V
- S
LC Circuit Transformed Circuit
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 56
56
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
VV 
  CS
s
I  S  S
 2
1 S LC  1
SL 
Cs

VC
V 1
I  S   
 2 1  L 1
LC  S   S 
2

 LC  LC
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 57
57
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
 1 
 
V  LC  1
I  S   
L S2  1  1 

LC  LC  

 1 
 
C  LC 
I  S  V 
L S2  1
LC
C
Taking inverse LT i  t  V sin t
L
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 58
58
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
1
Where  
LC
V
or i t  sin  t  I p sin  t
L
C
 Ip V amps
L
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 59
59
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Expression For
Conduction Time Of SCR
Conduction time of SCR

  t

 
1 I L
sin  
  I 
   p 

 
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 60
60
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Alternate Circuit
For Resonant Pulse Commutation
T 1 iC ( t) IL

C L T
a b iC ( t) 2

 +
V C(0 ) L
V T 3
O
A
FW D D

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 61


61
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
• Initially C charged with polarity as shown in
figure.
• T1 is conducting & IL is constant.
• To turn off T1, T2 is fired.
• iC(t) flows opposite to IL & T1 turns off at
iC(t) = IL

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 62


62
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
ic  t   I p sin  t
C
Where I p  VC  0  & and the capacitor voltage
L
1
vc  t    iC  t  .dt
C
1 C
vc  t    VC  0  sin  t.dt
C L
vc  t   VC  0  cos  t
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 63
63
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Instant at
which the thyristor turns off is at t1
t1
& I L  I p sin
LC
C
I p  VC  0 
L
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 64
64
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
 IL L 1

or t1  LC sin  
 VC  0  C 
& the corresponding capacitor voltage is

vc  t1   V1  VC  0  cos  t1


Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 65
65
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Expression For tC
Assuming a constant load
current I L which charges the capacitor
CV1
tc  seconds
IL
Normally V1  VC  0 
For reliable commutation tc  tq
tC depends on I L & becomes smaller for
higher values of I L
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 66
66
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
C u r r e n t iC ( t)

V
C a p a c it o r
v o lta g e v ab
t
t1

V 1

tC
V C(0 )
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 67
67
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Resonant Pulse Commutation
With Accelerating Diode

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 68


68
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
D 2
iC ( t)

T 1
IL
C L iC ( t) T 2

- +
V C(0 )
L
T O
V 3
A
FW D D

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 69


69
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
• Diode D2 connected as shown to accelerate
discharge.
• T2 turned on to turn off T1.
• Once T1 is off at t1. iC(t) flows through D2 until
current reduces to IL at time t2.
• From t = t2 , ‘C’ charges through load, T2 self
commutates.
• But thyristor recovery process low hence
longer reverse bias time.
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 70
70
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
iC
IL

0 t
V C

0 t
t1 t2
V 1
V C (O ) tC
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 71
71
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Problem
• The circuit in figure shows a resonant pulse
commutation circuit. The initial capacitor
voltage VC(O)=200V, C = 30F and L = 3H.
Determine the circuit turn off time tC, if the
load current IL is 200 A and 50 A.

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 72


72
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
T 1
IL
C L iC ( t) T 2

 +
V C(0 )
L
T O
V 3
A
FW D D

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 73


73
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
When I L  200 A; Let T2 be triggered at t  0
Capacitor current ic  t  reaches a value I L at t  t1
when T1 turns off
 IL 1 L 
t1  LC sin  
 VC  0  C 

1 200 3 10 6 
6 6
t1  3 10  30  10 sin    3.05 sec
 200 30 10  6
 
1 1
   0.105 106 rad / sec
LC 3  106  30 106
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 74
74
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
At t  t1 the magnitude of capacitor voltage is,
V1  VC  0  cos  t1
i.e., V1  200 cos 0.105 106  3.05 106
V1  200  0.9487
V1  189.75 Volts
CV1
& tc 
IL
6
30 10 189.75
tc   28.46  sec
200
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 75
75
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
When I L  50 A
 50 3  10 6 
t1  3  106  30  10 6 sin 1    0.749  sec
 200 30 10  6
 
V1  200 cos 0.105 106  0.749 10 6  200 1  200 Volts
CV1 30 106  200
tc    120  sec
IL 50
It is observed that as load increases the value of tc reduces.

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 76


76
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Problem

Repeat above problem


For I L  200 A if an antiparallel diode D2 is
connected across thyristor T1 as shown in figure

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 77


77
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
D 2
iC ( t)

T 1
IL
C L iC ( t) T 2

- +
V C(0 )
L
T O
V 3
A
FW D D

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 78


78
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
I L  200 A
Let T2 be triggered at t  0
Capacitor current iC  t  reaches the value I L at t  t1 ,
when T1 turns off
 IL 1 L
 t1  LC sin  
VC  O  C

6 6

1 200 3 10 6 
t1  3  10  30 10 sin  
 200 30 106 
 
t1  3.05 sec
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 79
79
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
1 1
 
6 6
LC 3 10  30 10
  0.105 10 radians/sec
6

At t  t1
VC  t1   V1  VC  O  cos  t1
VC  t1   200 cos  0.105 10  3.05 10
6 6

VC  t1   189.75V
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 80
80
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
iC  t  flows through diode D2 after T1 turns off.
iC  t  current falls back to I L at t2 .
t2   LC  t1
t2   3  10  30 10  3.05  10
6 6 6

t2  26.75 sec
1 1
 
6 6
LC 3  10  30 10
  0.105 106 rad/sec.
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 81
81
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
At t  t2
VC  t2   V2  200 cos 0.105 106  26.75 106
VC  t2   V2  189.02 V
 tC  t2  t1  26.75 106  3.05 106
tC  23.7  secs
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 82
82
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Problem
• For the circuit shown in figure calculate the
value of L for proper commutation of SCR.
Also find the conduction time of SCR.

4 F

V
=30V L
R L i

30  IL
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 83
83
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
The load current
V 30
IL    1 Amp
RL 30
For proper SCR commutation I p ,
the peak value of resonant current i, should be
greater than I L
Let I p  2I L ,  I p  2 Amps
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 84
84
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
V V C
Also Ip   V
L 1
L L
LC
6
4 10
 2  30 
L
L  0.9mH
1 1
   16666 rad/sec
3 6
LC 0.9 10  4  10
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 85
85
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Conduction time of SCR
 IL 
sin   1 1  1 
  sin  
  Ip    2
   
  16666 16666
  0.523
 radians  0.00022 seconds
16666
 0.22 msec
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 86
86
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Problem
• For the circuit shown in figure given that the
load current to be commutated is 10 A, turn off
time required is 40sec and the supply voltage
is 100 V. Obtain the proper values of
commutating elements.

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 87


87
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
C
V
=100V L IL
i

IL
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 88
88
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
C
I p peak value of i  V & this should be greater than I L
L
Let I p  1.5 I L
C
 1.5 10  100 ...  a 
L
Also, assuming that at the time of turn off the capacitor
voltage is approximately equal to V, and the load current
linearly charges the capacitor
CV
tc  seconds
IL
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 89
89
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
& this tc is given to be 40sec.
100
6
 40  10  C 
10
 C  4 F
Substituting this in equation (a)
4 106
1.5 10  100
L
6
10 4
 4  10
1.52 102 
L
 L  1.777  104 H  0.177 mH
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 90
90
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Problem
• In a resonant commutation circuit supply
voltage is 200 V. Load current is 10 A and the
device turn off time is 20s. The ratio of peak
resonant current to load current is 1.5.
Determine the value of L and C of the
commutation circuit.

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 91


91
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Ip
Given  1.5
IL
 I p  1.5I L  1.5 10  15 A
C
i.e., Ip V  15 A ...  a 
L
It is given that the device turn off time is 20 sec.
Therefore tc the circuit turn off time should be
greater than this,
CV
Let tc  30  sec & tc 
IL
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 92
92
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
200  C
6
 30  10 
10
 C  1.5 F
Substituting in (a)
1.5 106
15  200
L
6
1.5  10
152  2002 
L
 L  0.2666 mH
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 93
93
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Complementary Commutation
(Class C Commutation,
Parallel Capacitor Commutation)

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 94


94
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
IL

R 1 R 2

a b iC
V
C
T 1 T 2

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 95


95
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
• Two SCRs are used, turning ON one SCR turns
off the other.
• T1 is fired, IL flows through R1.
• At same time ‘C’ charges towards ‘V’ through
R2 with plate ‘b’ positive.
• To turn off T1, T2 is fired resulting in capacitor
voltage reverse biasing T1 and turning it off.
• When T2 is fired current through load shoots up
as voltage across load is V+VC
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 96
96
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
G a te p u ls e G a te p u ls e
of T1 of T2
t
 2V
V R1
IL
V
C u rr e n t th ro u g h R 1 R1
t

C u rr e n t th ro u g h T 2V
1
R2
V
R 1
t

2V C u rr e n t th ro u g h T 2
R1
V
R2
t
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 97
97
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
C u rre n t
th r o u g h R 2

t
V
V o lta g e a c r o s s
c a p a c ito r v ab
t

- V
tC tC

V o lta g e a c r o s s T 1

tC
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 98
98
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Expression For
Circuit Turn Off Time tC
vc  t   V f   Vi  V f  e  t 
Where V f is the final voltage, Vi is the initial
voltage and  is the time constant.
At t  tc , vc  t   0, V f  V ,   R1C, & Vi  V
 tc  tc

 0  V   V  V  e R1C
 V  2Ve R1C

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 99


99
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
 tc  tc

 V  2Ve R1C
; 0.5  e R1C

Taking natural logarithms on both sides


tc
ln 0.5 
R1C
tc  0.693R1C
This time should be greater than the turn off time tq of T1
Similarly when T2 is commutated tc  0.693 R2C
And this time should be greater than tq of T2
Usually R1  R2  R
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 100
100
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Problem
• In the circuit shown in figure, the load
resistances R1 = R2 = R = 5 & the
capacitance C = 7.5 F, V = 100 volts.
Determine the circuit turn off time tC

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 101


101
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
R 1 R 2

V
C
T 1 T 2

The circuit turn-off time


tc  0.693 RC seconds
6
tc  0.693  5  7.5 10
tc  26 sec
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 102
102
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Problem
• Calculate the values of RL and C to be used for
commutating the main SCR in the circuit
shown in figure. When it is conducting a full
load current of 25 A flows. The minimum time
for which the SCR has to be reverse biased for
proper commutation is 40sec. Also find R1,
given that the auxiliary SCR will undergo
natural commutation when its forward current
falls below the holding current value of 2 mA.
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 103
103
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
i1 IL

R 1 R L

iC
V
=100V C
A u x ilia r y M a in
SCR SCR

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 104


104
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
In this circuit only the main SCR carries the load and
the auxiliary SCR is used to turn off the main SCR.
Once the main SCR turns off the current through the
auxiliary SCR is the sum of the capacitor charging
current iC and the current i1 through R1, iC reduces to
zero after a time tC and hence the auxiliary SCR turns
off automatically after a time tC, i1 should be less than
the holding current.

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 105


105
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Given I L  25 A
V 100
i.e., 25 A  
RL RL
 RL  4
tc  40  sec  0.693RLC
6
i.e., 40 10  0.693  4  C
6
40  10
 C
4  0.693
C  14.43 F
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 106
106
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
V
i1  should be less
R1
than the holding current of auxiliary SCR
100
 should be  2mA
R1
100
 R1  3
2 10
i.e., R1  50 K 
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 107
107
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Impulse Commutation
(Class D Commutation)
T 1
IL


T 3 V C(O ) C
+
L
L T O
V 2
A
FW D D

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 108


108
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
• ‘C’ charged to a voltage VC(O) with polarity as
shown.
• T1 is conducting and carries load current IL.
• To turn off T1, T2 is fired.
• Capacitor voltage reverse biases T1 and turns it
off.
• ‘C’ Charges through load.
• T2 self commutates.
• To reverse capacitor voltage T3 is turned ON.
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 109
109
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
G a te p u ls e G a te p u ls e G a te p u ls e
of T2 of T3 of T1
t
V S
C a p a c ito r
v o lta g e
t

V C

tC

V o lta g e a c r o s s T 1
t

-V C
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 110
110
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Expression For
Circuit Turn Off Time tC
tc depends on I L & is given by the expression
tc
1
VC   I L dt
C0
(assuming the load current to be constant)
I L tc VC C
VC  tc  seconds
C IL
For proper commutation tc  tq , turn off time of T1
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 111
111
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
 T1 is turned off by applying a negative voltage across
its terminals. Hence this is voltage commutation.
 tC depends on load current. For higher load currents tC
is small. This is a disadvantage of this circuit.
 When T2 is fired, voltage across the load is V+VC;
hence the current through load shoots up and then
decays as the capacitor starts charging.

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 112


112
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
An Alternative Circuit
For Impulse Commutation
i
T 1 +
IT1 V C(O ) C
_

T 2
D

V
L

IL

R L

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 113


113
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
• Initially ‘C’ is charged to VC with top plate
positive.
• T1 is fired, load current IL flows.
• ‘C’ discharges at the same time & reverses its
polarity.
• ‘D’ ensures bottom plate remains positive.
• To turn off T1, T2 is fired.
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 114
114
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
G a te p u lse G a te p u lse
of T 1 of T 2
t

V C C a p a c ito r
v o l ta g e

- V
tC
T h is i s d u e to i
IT 1 IL
C u rre n t th ro u g h S C R V
R L
t

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 115


115
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
2V
R L

IL
L o a d c u rre n t

V V o lta g e a c r o s s T 1
t

tC
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 116
116
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Problem
• An impulse commutated thyristor circuit is
shown in figure. Determine the available turn
off time of the circuit if V = 100 V, R = 10 
and C = 10 F. Voltage across capacitor
before T2 is fired is V volts with polarity as
shown.

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 117


117
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
+
T 1
-
C V C(0 )
V +
T 2 R

-
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 118
118
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
When T2 is triggered
the circuit is as shown in figure
V C (O )
- i(t)
+ +
C
T 2
V R

-
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 119
119
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Writing the transform
circuit, we obtain
1 V C(0 )
Cs s
 + I(s)

+
V R
s 

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 120


120
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Expression for capacitor voltage
is obtained as follows,
1
 V  VC  0 
I  S  S
1
R
CS
C  V  VC  0 
I  S 
1  RCS

I  S 
 V  V  0 
C

 1 
RS  
 RC 
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 121
121
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Voltage across capacitor
1 VC  0
VC  s  I  S  
CS S
1 V  VC  0 VC  0
VC  s  
RCS  1  S
S  
 RC 
V  VC  0 V  VC  0 VC  0
VC  S    
S  1  S
S  
 RC 
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 122
122
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
V V VC  0
VC  S    
S S 1 S
1
RC RC
 t
RC 
t
vc  t   V 1  e   VC  0 e RC
 
In the given problem VC  0  V
 t 
 vc  t   V 1  2e RC

 
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 123
123
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
The waveform of vC(t)
is shown in figure
V

v C (t)
t

V C(0 )
tC
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 124
124
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
At t  tc , vc  t   0
  tc

 0  V  1  2e RC

 
 tc
1  2e RC

1  tc
 e RC
2
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 125
125
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Taking natural logarithms
 1  tc
log e   
 2  RC
tc  RC ln  2 
tc  10 10  10 ln  2  6

tc  69.3 sec
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 126
126
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Problem
• In the commutation circuit shown in figure
C = 20 F, the input voltage V varies between
180 and 220 V and the load current varies
between 50 and 200 A. Determine the minimum
and maximum values of available turn off time
tC.

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 127


127
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
T 1 I0


C V C(0 )= V
+
V

T 2
I0

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 128


128
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
It is given that V varies
between 180 and 220 V &
I O varies between 50 and 200 A
The expression for available
turn off time tc is given by
CV
tc 
IO
tc is max. when V is max. & I O is min.
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 129
129
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
CVmax
 tc max 
I O min
220
tc max  20  10   88 sec
6

50
CVmin
And tc min 
I O max
180
tc min  20 10   18 sec
6

200
Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 130
130
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
External Pulse
Commutation (Class E Commutation)

T 1 T 2 L T 3

+
V S R 2V A U X C V A U X
L

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 131


131
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
• T1 is conducting & RL is connected across supply.
• T3 is fired & ‘C’ is charged to 2VAUX with upper
plate positive.
• T3 is self commutated.
• To turn off T1, T2 is fired.
• T2 ON results in a reverse voltage VS – 2VAUX
appearing across T1.

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 132


132
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Load Side Commutation
• In load side commutation the discharging and
recharging of capacitor takes place through the
load. Hence to test the commutation circuit the
load has to be connected. Examples of load
side commutation are Resonant Pulse
Commutation and Impulse Commutation.

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 133


133
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
Line Side Commutation
• In this type of commutation the discharging
and recharging of capacitor takes place through
the supply.

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 134


134
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
L T 1

+ IL

T +
3
_ C L
FW D O
V S A
L r D
T 2

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 135


135
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
• Thyristor T2 is fired to charge the capacitor ‘C’.
When ‘C’ charges to a voltage of 2V, T2 is self
commutated. To reverse the voltage of capacitor
to -2V, thyristor T3 is fired and T3 commutates by
itself. Assuming that T1 is conducting and carries
a load current IL thyristor T2 is fired to turn off T1.

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 136


136
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT
• The turning ON of T2 will result in forward
biasing the diode (FWD) and applying a
reverse voltage of 2V acrossT1. This turns off
T1, thus the discharging and recharging of
capacitor is done through the supply and the
commutation circuit can be tested without load.

Power Electronics by Prof. M. Madhusudhan Rao 137


137
Prof. T.K. Anantha Kumar, E&E Dept., MSRIT

You might also like