GE B90 Presentation
GE B90 Presentation
GE B90 Presentation
Cost-efficient
Good performance
Modern communications capability
Member of the Universal Relay (UR) family
Easy integration with other URs
Common configuration tool for all B90 IEDs
Proven algorithms (B30) and hardware (UR)
Expandable
Two levels of scalability (modules and IEDs)
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
Busbar Protection Schemes
PVD
SPD
Any
BUS
B30
B90
Approach
GE offer
Industrial Systems
Why Digital Bus Relay?
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
Design Challenges for Digital Busbar Relays
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Reliability
Security:
Immunity to CT saturation
Immunity to wrong input information
Large number of inputs and outputs required:
AC inputs (tens or hundreds)
Trip rated output contacts (tens or hundreds)
Other output contacts (tens)
Digital Inputs (hundreds)
Large processing power required to handle al the data
Industrial Systems
Traditionally Two Distinctive Architectures are Offered
Distributed Bus Protection
52
52
DAU
52
DAU
52
52
52
DAU
CU
CU
co pp er
co pp er
fib e r
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
New Architecture Digital Phase-Segregated Busbar Scheme
iA, vA
Phase A
Protection
TRIPA
iB, vB
Phase B
Protection
TRIPB
iC, vC
Phase C
Protection
TRIPC
Foundation:
Single-phase IEDs for primary
differential protection
Separate IEDs for Breaker
Failure and extra I/Os
Inter-IED communications for
sharing digital states
Scalability and flexibility
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Breaker
Failure
Industrial Systems
B90 Capacity
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
B90 Applications
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Busbars:
Single
Breaker-and-a-half
Double
Triple
With and without transfer bus
Networks:
Solidly grounded
Lightly grounded (via resistor)
Ungrounded
Industrial Systems
B90 Architecture Overview
10
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
B90
COMMS
DSP
I/O
DSP
I/O
DSP
I/O
COMMS
Phase C Protection
DSP
I/O
DSP
I/O
DSP
I/O
UR #3
COMMS
DSP
I/O
DSP
I/O
DSP
I/O
CPU
Phase B Protection
UR #4
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
11
CPU
PS
UR #2
PS
I/O
I/O
I/O
I/O
I/O
I/O
CPU
Phase A Protection
CPU
PS
UR #1
PS
B90 Architecture
Industrial Systems
B90 Components: Protection IEDs
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
8 AC single-phase inputs
Comms
I/O
DSP 3
I/O
DSP 2
I/O
DSP 1
CPU
Power Supply
12
8 AC single-phase inputs
8 AC single-phase inputs
B90
B90is
isbuilt
builton
onUR
URhardware
hardware(4
(4years
yearsof
offield
fieldexperience)
experience)
Industrial Systems
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Comms
I/O
I/O
I/O
I/O
I/O
I/O
CPU
Power Supply
13
B90
B90is
isbuilt
builton
onUR
URhardware
hardware(4
(4years
yearsof
offield
fieldexperience)
experience)
Industrial Systems
B90 Scheme for Large Busbars
Dual (redundant) fiber with
3msec delivery time between
neighbouring IEDs. Up to 8
B90s/URs in the ring
Phase A AC signals and
trip contacts
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
Security of the B90 Communications
15
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
B90 Communications
16
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
Typical B90 Applications for Large Busbars
ZONE 1
7 to 24 feeders
23
24
ZONE 1
Basic: 87 & BF
for less than 16
feeders
23
17
24
21
22
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
ZONE 2
Industrial Systems
Typical B90 Applications for Large Busbars
ZONE 1
7 to 24 feeders
1
21
23
22
24
ZONE 2
18
23
11
ZONE 2
24
7 to 24 feeders
12
13
22
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
ZONE 1
Industrial Systems
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
8 phase-B currents
8 phase-C currents
Diff Zone 3
Spare
Diff Zone 1
One
OneB90
B90IED
IEDwith
with33zones
zones
could
protect
a
single
could protect a single
8-circuit
8-circuitbusbar!
busbar!
I/O
DSP 3
I/O
DSP 2
I/O
DSP 1
CPU
Power Supply
19
Diff Zone 2
8 phase-A currents
Two
Twolevels
levelsof
of scalability
scalabilityallow
allow flexible
flexibleapplications
applications
Industrial Systems
Spare
Spare
Spare
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
4 phase-C currents
8 phase-C currents
8 phase-B currents
Two
TwoB90
B90IEDs
IEDswith
with22zones
zones
could
protect
a
single
could protect a single
12-circuit
12-circuitbusbar!
busbar!
I/O
DSP 2
I/O
DSP 1
CPU
Power Supply
Spare
I/O
DSP 3
I/O
DSP 2
I/O
DSP 1
CPU
Power Supply
20
4 phase-A currents
4 phase-B currents
8 phase-A currents
Two
Twolevels
levelsof
of scalability
scalabilityallow
allow flexible
flexibleapplications
applications
Industrial Systems
8 phase-C currents
Spare
Spare
Spare
I/O
DSP 2
I/O
DSP 1
CPU
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
8 phase-C currents
8 phase-B currents
8 phase-A currents
8 phase-A currents
Three
ThreeB90
B90single-zone
single-zoneIEDs
IEDs
could
protect
a
single
could protect a single
16..24-circuit
16..24-circuitbusbar!
busbar!
Power Supply
Spare
Spare
Spare
I/O
DSP 2
I/O
DSP 1
CPU
Power Supply
Spare
Spare
Spare
I/O
DSP 2
I/O
DSP 1
CPU
Power Supply
21
8 phase-B currents
Two
Twolevels
levelsof
of scalability
scalabilityallow
allow flexible
flexibleapplications
applications
Industrial Systems
Applicability to Ungrounded and Lightly Grounded Systems
Phase A
IA
IB
Phase C
IC
3I0
Bl
n
ko
c
o
ex
l
au
lf
a
rn
te
ts
22
B90
B90can
canbe
beapplied
appliedto
tosolidly
solidlyand
andlightly
lightlygrounded
grounded
as
aswell
wellas
asungrounded
ungroundedsystems
systems
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Ground
Industrial Systems
B90 Configuration Program
23
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
B90 Algorithms
24
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
t0
t2
fault inception
fault conditions
d iffe r e n tia l
CT Saturation Problem
External
fault: ideal
CTs
t2
25
re s tr a in in g
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
t0
Industrial Systems
fault inception
fault conditions
t2
t0
26
External fault:
CT ratio
mismatch
re s tr a in in g
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
t0
t2
d iffe r e n tia l
CT Saturation Problem
Industrial Systems
t0
t1
t2
CT Saturation Problem
fault inception
CT saturation time
CT saturated
d iffe r e n tia l
t2
t1
27
re s tr a in in g
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
t0
External
fault: CT
saturation
Industrial Systems
Differential Protection
28
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
29
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
B90 Differential Function Theory of Operation
30
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
Various Definitions of the Restraining Signal
iR i1 i2 i3 ... in
sum of
1
iR i1 i2 i3 ... in
n
iR n i1 i2 i3 ... in
31
scaled sum of
geometrical average
maximum of
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
iR Max i1 , i2 , i3 ,..., in
Industrial Systems
Restraining Current
32
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
Sum of vs. Max of definitions of restraint
33
Sum of approach:
more restraint on external faults; less sensitivity on internal
faults
scaled sum of may take into account the actual number of
connected circuits increasing sensitivity
characteristic breakpoints difficult to set
Max of approach (B30, B90 and UR in general):
less restraint on external faults
more sensitivity on internal faults
breakpoints easier to set
better handles situations when one CT may saturate
completely (99% slope settings possible)
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
Differential Function Characteristic
d if fe re n tia l
|I D |
O PER A TE
HIG H
SLO PE
B LO CK
LO W
SLO PE
IR
re s tra in in g
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
H IG H B P N T
34
L O W BPN T
P IC K U P
Industrial Systems
Differential Function Adaptive Approach
d iff e re n tia l
R e g io n 2
(h ig h d iffe re n tia l
c u rre n ts )
R e g io n 1
( lo w d i f f e r e n t i a l
c u rr e n ts )
large currents
quick saturation possible due to
large magnitude
saturation easier to detect
security required only if saturation
detected
low currents
saturation possible due to dc offset
saturation very difficult to detect
more security required
35
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
re s tra in in g
Industrial Systems
Adaptive Logic
AND
DIF1
OR
OR
DIR
AND
SAT
TRIP
36
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
DIF2
Industrial Systems
d iff e re n tia l
Adaptive Approach
R e g io n 2
(h ig h d iffe re n tia l
c u rre n ts )
R e g io n 1
( lo w d i f f e r e n t i a l
c u rr e n ts )
Dynamic 2-out-of-2,
1-out-of-2 operating
mode
2-out-of-2
operating
mode
37
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
re s tra in in g
Industrial Systems
Directional Principle
AND
DIF1
OR
OR
DIR
AND
SAT
TRIP
38
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
DIF2
Industrial Systems
Directional Principle
External faults:
one current approximately out of phase
39
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Secondary current of
the faulted circuit
(deep CT saturation)
Industrial Systems
Directional Principle
40
Implementation:
step 1: select fault contributors
A contributoris a circuit carrying significant amount of current
A circuit is a contributor if its current is above higher break
point
A circuit is a contributor if its current is above a certain portion
of the restraining current
step 2: check angle between each contributor and the sum of all
the other currents
Sum of all the other currents is the inverted contributor if the
fault is external; on external faults one obtains an angle of 180
degrees
step 3: compare the maximum angle to the threshold
A threshold is a factory constant of 90 degrees
An angle shift of more than 90 degrees due to CT saturation is
physically impossible
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
External Fault
E x te r n a l F a u lt C o n d it io n s
imag
Ip
ID I p
OPER ATE
BLOC K
ID - Ip
Ip
real
Ip
ID I p
BLOC K
41
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
OPER ATE
Industrial Systems
Internal Fault
In te r n a l F a u lt C o n d itio n s
imag
B LOC K
Ip
ID I p
OPER ATE
ID - Ip
real
Ip
ID I p
Ip
B LOC K
42
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
OPER ATE
Industrial Systems
Saturation Detector
AND
DIF1
OR
OR
DIR
AND
SAT
TRIP
43
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
DIF2
Industrial Systems
t0
t1
t2
Saturation Detector
fault inception
CT starts to saturate
external fault under
heavy CT saturation
conditions
d iffe r e n tia l
t2
t1
44
re s tr a in in g
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
t0
Industrial Systems
Saturation Detector The State Machine
NORMAL
SAT := 0
saturation
condition
EXTERNAL
FAULT
SAT := 1
The differential
characteristic
entered
EXTERNAL
FAULT & CT
SATURATION
SAT := 1
45
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
The differential
current below the
first slope for
certain period of
time
Industrial Systems
Saturation Detector
46
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Operation:
The SAT flag WILL NOT be set during internal faults
whether or not any CTs saturate
The SAT flag WILL be SET during external faults
whether or not any CTs saturate
By design the SAT flag is NOT used to block the
relay but to switch to 2-out-of-2 operating principle
Industrial Systems
200
150
~1 ms
current, A
100
50
0
-50
-100
-150
-200
0.06
0.07
0.08
0.09
time, sec
0.1
0.11
0.12
The
directional flag
is not set
47
The element
does not
maloperate
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Despite heavy CT
saturation the
external fault current
is seen in the
opposite direction
Industrial Systems
Examples Internal Fault
The saturation
flag is not set - no
directional
decision required
The element
operates in
10ms
48
The
directional
flag is set
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
direction
Industrial Systems
User-Modified Tripping Logic
49
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
Dynamic Bus Replica
50
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
Dynamic Bus Replica - Isolators
51
Industrial Systems
Dynamic Bus Replica - Isolators
Isolator Open
Auxiliary
Contact
Isolator Closed
Auxiliary
Contact
Isolator
Position
Alarm
Block Switching
Off
On
CLOSED
No
No
Off
Off
LAST VALID
Until Isolator
Position is valid
On
On
CLOSED
On
Off
OPEN
No
No
ISOLATOR 1 OPEN
ISOLATOR 1 CLOSED
ISOLATOR 1 POSITION
alarm time
delay
alarm
acknowledged
ISOLATOR 1 ALARM
ISOLATOR 1 RESET
52
alarm acknowledging
signal
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
ISOLATOR 1 BLOCK
Industrial Systems
Dynamic Bus Replica Isolator Positions and Differential Protection
Iso
53
os
lat
o
rP
os
itio
osi
ti
on
Iso
or
t
a
l
itio
s
o
Up to 96 auxuliary switches
wired here; Isolator Monitoring
function configured here
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
rP
o
t
la
Iso
Iso
lato
rP
n
itio
Industrial Systems
Dynamic Bus Replica Tie-Breakers: Two-CT Configuration
Z1
TB
Z2
54
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
Dynamic Bus Replica Tie-Breakers Tie-Breakers: Single-CT Configuration
Z1
TB
Z2
55
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
Tie-Breakers: Single-CT Configuration
expand
56
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Sequence of events:
Z1 trips and the TB gets opened
After a time delay the current from the CT shall be
removed from Z2 calculations
As a result Z2 gets extended up to the opened TB
The Fault becomes internal for Z2
Z2 trips finally clearing the fault
Industrial Systems
Dynamic Bus Replica Breakers: Bus-side CTs
CT
57
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
CB
Industrial Systems
Dynamic Bus Replica Breakers: Line-side CTs
CB
CT
58
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
Dynamic Bus Replica Breakers: Line-side CTs
contract
CB
CT
59
but.
A blind spot created by contracting the bus differential zone
End Fault Protection required B90 provides one EFP element per
current input
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
End Fault Protection
SETTING
B90 FUNCTION:
Logic = 0
Protection = 1
SETTING
EFP 1 FUNCTION:
Enabled = 1
AND
Disabled = 0
SETTING
EFP 1 BLOCK:
SETTING
Off = 0
EFP 1 PICKUP:
SETTING
RUN
EFP 1 CT:
Current Magnitude, |I|
| I | > PICKUP
SETTING
SETTING
FLEXLOGIC OPERANDS
tPKP
EFP 1 OP
0
EFP 1 DPO
EFP PKP
tPKP
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
Breaker Failure Protection
61
BF Architecture:
Current supervision residing on protection IEDs
BFI signal can be generated internally (from protection IEDs)
or externally via communications or a digital input from any
IED
BF logic and timers residing on the logic IED
Trip contacts distributed freely between various IEDs
BF Performance:
Reset time of current sensors below 0.7 power system cycle
Communications delays around 0.2 power system cycle
between any two neighboring IEDs
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
Breaker Failure Protection Current Supervision
Cu
r
62
re
nt
S
tat
us
Cu
tatu
s
us
t
a
St
t
n
rre
Up to 24 BF elements
configured here
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
S
t
n
rre
Cu
Cu
rre
nt S
s
u
t
a
t
Industrial Systems
Breaker Failure Protection Initiate
BFI
BF
ate
Ini
tia
te
niti
BFI
BF
te
a
i
t
Ini
Up to 24 BF elements
configured here
63
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
BF
te
a
i
t
Ini
BF
I
Industrial Systems
Breaker Failure Protection Trip Action
Trip
Trip
Tri
pC
om
ma
Phase A AC signals wired
here, current status
monitored here
Tr
ip
Co
mm
an
d
64
nd
Trip
Trip
ip
Tr
nd
a
mm
o
C
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
p
Tri
nd
a
mm
o
C
Industrial Systems
Programmable Logic (FlexLogicTM)
65
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
Disturbance Recording
66
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
Sequence of Events Recording
67
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
Engineering the B90
SWITCHING ON Z1 & Z2, Z1 & Z3 OR Z2 & Z3 BUSBARS
LOGIC FOR COUPLER
CLOSING ORDER
0
100
ISO 2
ISO 3
ISO 8
ISO 9
TRIP
PERM
Z1/Z2
VO 63
ISO 4
ISO 6
ISO 6
ISO 9
ISO 7
ISO 9
ISO 2
ISO 5
ISO 7
ISO 8
ISO 8
F2-Z2-OUT
VO 54
ISO 2
ISO 3
68
F2-Z2-IN
VO 21
F3-Z2-IN
VO 22
F4-Z2-IN
VO 23
F2-Z3-IN
VO 37
ISO 1
F4-Z1-IN
VO 7
OPTION: ZONE 3 AS
TRANSFER BUS
ISO 1
B
ISO 1
ISO 2
A
F3-Z1-IN
VO 6
ISO 4
ISO 5
ISO 3
A
F2-Z1-IN
VO 5
ISO 3
ISO 5
ISO 6
F1-Z1-IN&
Z2-OUT
VO 4
F2-Z1-OUT
VO 53
ISO 4
F3-Z3-IN
VO 38
ISO 7
F4-Z3-IN
VO 39
Logic design
FlexLogicTM Implementation
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
52b
0
60
LATCH
Industrial Systems
B90 Summary
69
Cost-efficient
Good performance
Modern communications capability
Member of the Universal Relay (UR) family
Easy integration with other URs
Common configuration tool for all B90 IEDs
Proven algorithms (B30) and hardware (UR)
Expandable
Two levels of scalability (modules and IEDs)
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
Ordering the B90
**
**
B90
Base system
S
Single busbar
Double busbar
Special arrangement
C
Cabinet supply
Frame supply
A
125/250, AC/DC
70
Sequential number
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n
Industrial Systems
How to Order
71
International:
Europe:
Email:
Web:
In
Ve ter
rs na
io l
n