Peter Schiff - Gold Scams Report
Peter Schiff - Gold Scams Report
Peter Schiff - Gold Scams Report
1.800.GOLD.160
Euro Pacific Precious Metals was founded with a purpose: to make gold- and silver-buying as simple and transparent as possible. With so many new buyers coming into the marketplace, there is ample opportunity for dishonest firms with big advertising budgets to lure and take advantage of investors who are making an otherwise smart decision to invest a portion of their assets in physical precious metals. With a strict policy against selling complex products like numismatics, we hope that gold and silver buyers like you come to see us as a trustworthy ally in your pursuit of the best return on your investment. Our CEO, Peter Schiff, has spent a quarter-century on Wall Street striving to deliver the best value to his clients. He has long recommended investors keep 5-10% of their portfolios in physical precious metals, but also heard horror stories of buyers falling in with the wrong crowd of bullion dealers. So, partnering
with industry-veteran Michael Freedman, he decided to open his own precious metals firm with his name on the door. Peter jealously defends his record of accurate economic analysis and fair-dealing, so its no surprise that Euro Pacific Precious Metals has quickly gained a reputation for competitive prices and ethical business practices. And, in doing so, has become a major player in the bullion industry. In keeping with our tradition of education and service to the everyday investor, Euro Pacific Precious Metals has issued this Special Report detailing all the tricks, traps, and scams that can befall gold and silver buyers. Our hope is that this report saves you a lot of costly trial-and-error, and proves why no asset class in history has ever out-classes plain old gold and silver bullion. Good luck, and good gold!
As a matter of business policy, Euro Pacific Precious Metals does not offer numismatics, collectibles, or gimmicks. We offer only well-known, extremely liquid pure bullion gold and silver coins and bars at competitive prices.
For more information about our prices and products, Call 1-800-GOLD-160 or CLICK HERE to request a callback.
If youre buying a numismatic coin, you will not be paying a fair price for the bullion contained in the coin. Dealers sell numismatics at mark-ups of 20-40% or more over the spot price of the metal, and a large chunk of that will simply go into the dealers pocket. A serious collector might buy a truly rare coin for double, triple, or even many multiples of the value of the metal it contains because he values its rarity and/or 1.800.GOLD.160
4
beauty. But, for the average investor, numismatic coins clarity, color, etc., are not money. Numismatic coins, which vary in rarity, condition, date of issue, etc., are are on par with stamps or baseball cards. also not money. Sure, the coins metal content will provide a floor to Bullion gold coins will always have value to your their value that stamps and baseball cards dont have, fellow Americans, while paper dollars have less but the gold value is typically only a fraction of the and less. As the dollar declines, the price of gold retail price of a numismatic coin. If you pay twice the and silver will continue to rise, reflecting the stable bullion value to buy a rare coin, bullion could double purchasing power of the precious metals. Whats in value and you still might not be able to sell your more, in a volatile environment, bullion will carry coin for a profit. If you buy a regular bullion coin, the a premium for being reliable and widely accepted gold price only has to rise a few points above spot money just as the US dollar does now. before you profit. In short, if you are buying numismatic coins, chances are youre making a fast-talking salesman very rich at your expense.
2: THEYRE HARD TO LIQUIDATE
Even if your rare coin does appreciate, good luck trying to sell it. While bullion coins are accepted at near spot-price around the world, there is no ready market for numismatics. You could try selling the coins back to your dealer, but chances are hell offer much less than what you paid. eBay doesnt work because the buyer cant verify that the coin is actually rare. And its nearly impossible to sell them to the general public, as you probably dont have the persuasive power of the fast-talking broker who sold the coins to you. Experienced collectors do their trading at coin shows, but a novice investor is sure to get a bad deal there. A few off-hand questions and the coin trader will know that youre in over your head. Meanwhile, bullion coins are easy to sell. But even better, you can barter them locally for the stuff you need food, clothes, a roof over your head even if the other guy isnt a coin enthusiast. In other words, bullion is money. One of the characteristics that makes gold and silver money are their uniformity meaning each coin is the same as every other coin of the same weight. Diamonds, which are not uniform because they vary in
numismatic coins during the past year or two, you will probably receive less than you paid but you still deserve a fair price from a dealer you can trust. If you experience problems liquidating your holdings, Euro Pacific Precious Metals may be able to help you sell your coins. Even though we do not offer numismatic coins, we have access to major wholesale dealers who are marketmakers in the more popular coins. If your coin is graded by a major coin grading lab, and is not a little known, esoteric coin, we will try to sell it for you. Call one of our Precious Metals Specialists to get more information at 1-800-GOLD-160.
1.800.GOLD.160
5
3: THE CHARTS ARE COOKED
Numismatics salesmen might show you a chart showing the performance of rare/numismatic coins against regular/bullion coins. Of course, the chart shows the numismatics performing much better. But these graphs almost always track particular rare coins which are cherry-picked with the benefit of hindsight. For every one rare coin that outperforms, there could be ten that severely underperform. Only afterwards would you know which coin you should have bought. Comparing the wide index of rare coins issued by the Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) against the spot price of gold bullion shows that numismatics have in fact missed most of the gains of the last decade: And this comparison omits the most numismatic
PCGS 3000 Index (10 years)
74000 72000 70000 68000 66000 64000 62000 60000 58000 56000 54000 52000
confiscation. This is based on a little piece of history taken way out of context. In 1933, President Roosevelt issued Executive Order 6102, prohibiting the private holding of gold and requiring US citizens to turn over their gold bullion or face a $10,000 fine ($167,700 in todays dollars) or 10-years imprisonment. For private citizens, the order listed the following exemption: Gold coin and gold certificates in an amount not exceeding in the aggregate $100 [about 5 troy ounces at that time] belonging to any one person; and gold coins having a recognized special value to collectors of rare and unusual coins. Seizing on this rare and unusual language, many coin dealers try to convince unsuspecting customers that regular bullion coins are not safe, but that their rare coins would be exempt from a Roosevelt-style confiscation. The reality is that almost all coins sold as numismatic by these dealers are really quite ordinary coins sold at high mark-ups to make them extra profits. If we were in 1933, the vast majority of these coins would absolutely not fall under the definition of rare and unusual. As mentioned above, true numismatics are extremely rare or one-of-a-kind coins that collectors purchase for their historical and aesthetic qualities. These coins might retail for $25,000 or more, while only containing $1,400 worth of gold. Just like all art isnt museum art, all old coins are not numismatic. But even if you were buying a genuine rare coin to avoid confiscation, you would be wasting your money because there isnt likely to be another confiscation. In 1933, when Roosevelt issued his infamous order, the United States was still on a gold standard, meaning every 20.67 paper dollars could have been redeemed 1.800.GOLD.160
dealers high mark-ups which could more than wipe out the meager gains for retail investors.
4: CONFISCATION IS A CON
Some unscrupulous dealers wont even pretend that numismatics are a better investment (helps avoid lawsuits for fraud), but instead tell customers that only rare coins will be exempt from a coming gold
6
by the bearer on demand for a troy ounce of gold. Since Roosevelt had many public works projects to finance and wanted to lower real wages to drive employment, he confiscated gold and then devalued the exchange rate to $35/oz. Thus, Americans instantly saw a 40% drop in value for the dollars they held. Its important to note that confiscation was necessary to Roosevelts plan because we were under a gold standard. Gold at that time was widely held throughout the population. If Roosevelt had devalued the dollar without confiscation, then whatever savings Americans held in gold would have been immune from this hidden tax. Furthermore, many Americans likely would have redeemed whatever paper dollars they held in fear of another devaluation. This could have wrecked the dollars viability as a currency. These rationales no longer apply. In the aftermath of Roosevelts and Nixons dismantling of the gold
PCGS 3000 Index (10 years)
74000 72000 70000 68000 66000 64000 62000 60000 58000 56000 54000 52000
1.800.GOLD.160
HISTORICAL NOTE
Even in the heat of Roosevelts confiscation scheme, government troops did not break into peoples homes. The singular prosecution under the order took place when a New York lawyer tried to withdraw 5,000 troy ounces from Chase Bank, and he wasnt even convicted! Ironically, all the gold actually collected by the Treasury was willfully surrendered in a wave of misguided patriotism, while many law-breakers simply kept their gold. Gold has been prized throughout history for its high value-to-weight, making it easy to conceal and trade under tough political conditions. Consider: you could store enough gold to care for a small family for six months (approx. 9 ounces) on the inside of a belt buckle.
standard, gold is no longer currency (though it is still money). Most Americans hold their savings in dollars and it is the only legal tender, meaning it must be accepted in payment of all debts. Thus, President Obama and his buddy Bernanke dont need to confiscate gold to devalue the dollar and finance excessive spending. In fact, the Fed has more than doubled the monetary base since the financial crisis started! The bottom line is that unscrupulous dealers use the threat of confiscation as a scare tactic to get you to buy gold coins at mark-ups well above the spot value of the metal they contain.
5: NUMISMATICS ARE NOT CRASH-PROOF
FPO
PCCS 3000 Index (10 years) Six Month Moving Average
Many people assume that the crash our firms founder Peter Schiff wrote about in his original book, Crash Proof, was the credit crunch of October 08. They are mistaken. Though he did accurately forecast the economic events of 2008, his ultimate prediction was that these events would set into motion a larger crash
As a matter of business policy, Euro Pacific Precious Metals does not offer numismatics, collectibles, or gimmicks. We offer only well-known, extremely liquid pure bullion gold and silver coins and bars at competitive prices.
For more information about our prices and products, Call 1-800-GOLD-160 or CLICK HERE to request a callback.
7
to follow. That crash, the one he has been warning about for a decade, is a collapse of the international US dollar standard. This is the crisis for which the smart money is preparing. The Peoples Bank of China, Reserve Bank of India, Goldman Sachs, Barclays Capital, John Paulson, Jim Rogers, and countless other big names are all protecting themselves from a global monetary breakdown by buying gold. But are they doing it with numismatics? Among the big players, the answer is universally no. If we enter into depression conditions, numismatics may actually drop in value while the gold price rises. As mentioned above, numismatic coins depend on the demand of collectors. Collectors are folks with plenty
THERES A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN OLD AND RARE
Even if the economy recovered and reached new highs, most numismatic investors face another insurmountable hurdle: the coins they purchased are not actually rare. The firms pushing these coins tend to stock old coins like turn-of-thecentury French Roosters, Swiss Helvetias, and British Sovereigns. But just because a coin is old doesnt mean its rare. While these coins may be beautiful, they are about as common as a can of Coke. Some firms have even coined a new names for these coins semi-numismatics. Issued during their respective countries heydays, they were produced by the bucket load and shipped around the world and a number of them are still produced today. In other words, there is no reason you should be paying any more for them than the value of their weight in metal. Actually, the mark-up should be less because these coins are less well-recognized, and therefore less tradable, than the more popular American Gold Eagle, South African Krugerrand, and Canadian Maple Leaf. Many of these old coins were produced in irregular weights or purities. The standard today is a coin containing one troy ounce of gold and a purity above 90%. The popular coins mentioned above all meet this criterion; many old coins dont.
of discretionary income. When inflation is eating away savings and the economy is contracting, who are these mystery millionaires that are going to buy your stash of St. Gaudens Double Eagles? Chances are many collectors will also be liquidating their collections as they lose their jobs and their investments go south. So, even if the stars align and numismatics manage to outperform bullion, you may find that you dont own any truly numismatic coins only a bunch of bullion coins sold to you at rare-coin mark-ups.
1.800.GOLD.160
8
commodity to own when the worlds paper money system is in upheaval. The only people who should be buying numismatics are serious and knowledgeable collectors. those who appreciate the coins for their aesthetic value and take pleasure in owning them, and and hope they may eventually see a financial reward. Casual investors, hoping to protect their wealth against recession, inflation and sovereign default, should avoid buying numismatic coins.
1.800.GOLD.160
As a matter of business policy, Euro Pacific Precious Metals does not offer numismatics, collectibles, or gimmicks. We offer only well-known, extremely liquid pure bullion gold and silver coins and bars at competitive prices.
For more information about our prices and products, Call 1-800-GOLD-160 or CLICK HERE to request a callback.
9
commemoratives are marketed as gold or silver coins at a fraction of the cost of a bullion coin. How do they manage to sell a gold coin for $19.99, plus shipping and handling? Because it is only clad in gold most of the coin is a base metal. While these companies are legally obligated to mention that the coins are clad, they will do whatever they can to distract you from that fact. The most common and successful way to do this is to try to give the coin great sentimental value. Thus, we see commemoratives made from gold or silver recovered from the vaults beneath the Twin Towers after 9/11. They might bear the image of the towers or the USS New York, the warship built from Ground Zero steel. This is all part of a strategy to distract you from the fact that the coins are essentially worthless. In fact, one such company recently lost a court case brought by New York State for $2 million in damages for fraud and false advertising.
Commemorative Coin Sample Ad:
While a few customers may simply wish to commemorate a historic event with a pretty trinket, these companies are betting that you will be suckered into thinking that these coins have the same value as their surface metal. After all, a zinc coin doesnt look that much different than a silver one. Why bother cladding it at all if not to associate the coin with the real value of precious metals? Official mints seldom issue commemorative coins made of pure gold or silver. When they do, the coins carry large mark-ups that make them risky investments. And you will never see them advertised. Actual commemorative coin collectors (there are very few) know when the United States Mint is releasing a coin and what its worth; they dont jump for the shiny coin on TV even if it shows the bombing of Pearl Harbor or the first man on the Moon. Those moments will still be significant even if you dont waste your money commemorating them with high-priced paperweights posing as precious metal coins.
FPO
The advertising for this 9/11 commemorative coin talks about it being made from silver recovered from the vaults underneath Ground Zero but the coins are only clad or covered in gold and silver. The inside is a base metal like steel or tungsten. Also, the ads claim the coins are legal tender dollars, but fail to mention that the dollar in question is the currency of the small African state of Liberia, not the currency of the United States.
1.800.GOLD.160
1.800.GOLD.160
11
1.800.GOLD.160
As a matter of business policy, Euro Pacific Precious Metals does not offer numismatics, collectibles, or gimmicks. We offer only well-known, extremely liquid pure bullion gold and silver coins and bars at competitive prices.
For more information about our prices and products, Call 1-800-GOLD-160 or CLICK HERE to request a callback.
12
to borrow another $20,000. The total value of the gold you control now equals $25,000. The gold price drops by 15%. Your gold portfolio is now worth $21,250. The gold company will probably require you to send in another $2,000 , since their $20,000 loan is in some jeopardy. If you cant come up with the money, they will sell out your gold, take back their loan, and send you the balance of $1,250. So, instead of taking a paper loss of $750 on your original $5,000 investment, you have taken a real loss of $3,750. Heres an easy example of the risks of leverage: You have $5,000 to invest, but the company convinces you to borrow another $20,000. The total value of the gold you control now equals $25,000. The gold price drops by 15%. Your gold portfolio is now worth $21,250. The gold company will probably require you to send in another $2,000 , since their $20,000 loan is in some jeopardy. If you cant come up with the money, they will sell out your gold, take back their loan, and send you the balance of $1,250. So, instead of taking a paper loss of $750 on your original $5,000 investment, you have taken a real loss of $3,750. entire value of the purchase. If you have to pay 3% commission on the whole $25K, thats actually 15% of the $5K you invested, or $750. Then, there is interest on the $20K loan, which may run you 8% per year, adding an additional $1,600 in the first year of holding. With the commissions, this amounts to a staggering 47% of your original $5K investment! Tack on leasing fees, transaction fees, administration fees, storage fees, delivery fees... with many of these accounts, it is nearly impossible to come out ahead.
1.800.GOLD.160
13
1.800.GOLD.160
BUT THESE COMPANIES ADVERTISE EVERYWHERE AND ARE ENDORSED BY MAJOR CELEBRITIES!
The real tragedy of the physical precious metals industry right now is that the less scrupulous a dealer is, the more likely you are to do business with them. Thats because these firms are raking in record profits at the expense of you, their customers, and using them to fund sweeping TV, radio and print advertising campaigns and to pay well-respected radio and television hosts to endorse their products. That way, you become familiar with their brand name, and then someone who shares your political or cultural viewpoint tells you the company is trustworthy. Well, its time for a reality check.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
For many celebrity hosts, accepting advertising dollars from these questionable gold dealers presents a real conflict of interest. If these dishonest companies werent raking in big profits on unsuspecting customers, then they wouldnt have enough money to bankroll the radio and TV shows. If you were in that position, could you imagine the pressure to look the other way when you realize customers are being grossly overcharged?
A SILENT EPIDEMIC
We think there is little outrage because precious metals are in a bull market. Customers are buying, then watching the gold price go up, and assuming theyre making a profit. Yet, widely sold products like numismatic coins do not directly follow the gold price, often carry huge mark-ups, and they have much poorer liquidity. So, these customers may be in for a rude awakening when they actually try to sell. This is especially the case if the gold market turns south and many people are trying to sell at once. Do you remember any exposs on the housing market when it was going up? Media outlets werent warning people that cheaply built subdivisions in the Nevada desert might be worth nothing in a couple of years. In the hysteria, they assumed all housing was a good investment. The same holds true for gold. Bullion is equivalent to a one-bedroom apartment in a doorman building in Manhattan and numismatics are like those Sunbelt ranch houses that sold for almost the same price. One kept its value, the other never had the value to justify the price.
As a matter of business policy, Euro Pacific Precious Metals does not offer numismatics, collectibles, or gimmicks. We offer only well-known, extremely liquid pure bullion gold and silver coins and bars at competitive prices.
For more information about our prices and products, Call 1-800-GOLD-160 or CLICK HERE to request a callback.
1.800.GOLD.160
unknown private mint) or less liquid products (1/10 troy oz coin vs. the typical 1 troy oz coin).
A TYPICAL TRANSACTION
The two keys facets of a gold or silver transaction are the spot price, the premium and the mark-up. The spot price is what major institutional buyers and bullion banks are paying at commodities exchanges in places like New York, London, and Hong Kong. These trades are mostly futures contracts, where the buyer doesnt take physical delivery. Next in line are the huge, multibillion-dollar physical bullion dealers who can buy directly from the various national mints worldwide at prices a little above spot. There are only a handful of these dealers in the US, and none of them sell to individual investors. These dealers add on a small profit and overhead margin, which is called the premium, and sell to large gold retailers, such as Euro Pacific Precious Metals. Premiums vary according to market conditions, supply and demand, product type, and the outlook for gold. Once purchased, gold retailers sell the coins to gold investors at a mark-up, which covers their overhead and profit. If the dealer pays a premium of 3.5% above spot for a gold coin and sells for 5.5% above spot, the mark-up is 2%. In current market conditions, buyers should pay less than 6% above spot for gold bullion coins. Expect to pay more for well-known coin types (American Gold Eagle vs. a gold coin struck by an
Its important, before any purchase, to take some time to familiarize yourself with the most common gold and silver coins. This list isnt long: American Eagles, Canadian Maple Leafs, South African Krugerrands, Austrian Philharmonics, Australian Kangaroos, and a few others. These are widely produced, 1-ounce gold coins that are not rare, numismatic, collectible, commemorative, or special in any way. Theyre just a standard unit of the metal you want to buy. If the guy on the phone is leading you to a product youve never heard of, or claims that his coin is somehow better than the usual suspects, hang up and look elsewhere.
2) Do you understand the price offered and all associated fees?
Before you make a purchase, any reputable dealer will be able to tell you the current price above spot and any associated fees or taxes. They should be able to give you a total dollar amount for your order before the order is processed. The point is to deal with a firm with a good reputation that is honest, reliable, and doesnt pressure you. As with any business transaction, you should only deal with a firm you trust. If you cant get a straight answer on the price of the product you want, hang up and look elsewhere.
As a matter of business policy, Euro Pacific Precious Metals does not offer numismatics, collectibles, or gimmicks. We offer only well-known, extremely liquid pure bullion gold and silver coins and bars at competitive prices.
For more information about our prices and products, Call 1-800-GOLD-160 or CLICK HERE to request a callback.
15
3) Is the dealer willing to buy back what theyre trying to sell you, and at what price?
1.800.GOLD.160
if they wont buy back at all hang up and look elsewhere. A final test is more common sense than anything else. When you call a dealer, the person who answers the phone should be a precious metals specialist who is there to answer your questions and guide you through the ordering process. You wouldnt walk in a hardware store looking for a wrench and let the shopkeeper talk you into buying a 3-foot tall flowerpot, would you? The same goes for buying precious metals. If youre talking to someone who is pushing you to buy anything you didnt call up to order, do yourself a favor hang up and look elsewhere!
This is a really key test of a scammer versus a legitimate dealer. Scammers sell products that either have no value or have a value much lower than what theyre asking. This means that they will either not want to buy the product back at all or theyll only buy it back for substantially less than the sale price. A reputable dealer makes a few percentage points on a transaction, and will happily buy any coins back from you just below his cost, meaning the amount he pays for the same coin from wholesalers. If you buy a coin and want to sell it back the next day, you should only take a loss of only a few percentage points. If the spread, or difference between what the dealer sells for and what they buy for, seems large or especially
As a matter of business policy, Euro Pacific Precious Metals does not offer numismatics, collectibles, or gimmicks. We offer only well-known, extremely liquid pure bullion gold and silver coins and bars at competitive prices.
For more information about our prices and products, Call 1-800-GOLD-160 or CLICK HERE to request a callback.