$ffiffiffiwffi:"wffiffi #D, Ffiffi, W.ffii1tr"fl: Macondo Technical Note
$ffiffiffiwffi:"wffiffi #D, Ffiffi, W.ffii1tr"fl: Macondo Technical Note
$ffiffiffiwffi:"wffiffi #D, Ffiffi, W.ffii1tr"fl: Macondo Technical Note
MacondoTechnicalNote
Tiile: Contributors: Shut-inPressures: Rangeand Likelihood MikeLevitan, Debbie Kercho, FarahSaidi, SimonBishop, Yun Wang, CharlesBondurant, AndrewSweeney, Galina DavidGrass,PierreAndreDepret, Tony Laio, Skripnikova, KellyMcAughan, ChrisCecil,Bob Merrill Bob Merrill M a y1 9 , 2 0 1 0 A - DRAFT
QuestionAddressedin this TechnicalNote: As Bl' is currentlyevaluating optionstbr the lrlacondo kill well, this technidl addresses ftrllowing{uestitns: the *il$
: $ffiffiffiwffi:"wffiffi #d,ffiffi,w.ffii1tr"
. IsflXlifipffigl-+{*4,"er$nffi ld rP*
expands uponearlier work documented a drafttechnical in notedatedl7-May. We arenot ableanswer third question this tinre;therewasinsuflicient the at time to obtainthe results from transient wellboresimulation. Key Conclusions l -8,100psiaand I 1,350 TheSIWHPis expected be betrveen psia.Thisrange to pressure zones, gas considers irnpact shallower the r.vhich foundat depths of high are bctwccn17,467 l7,806ftlvID-RKB. r . gas There\.vas consensus these zones that werelikely to be open.but the wasan areaof uncertainty. contribulion depletion these and of zones gas Theshallower zones l2,0ii0- 13.320 at ftN{D-RKB behind l35/sinch are the liner andarenot likelv to increase stated ranseof SIWHP. the
This
vszq
Page1 of6 Confidential
Exhibit No. Worldwide Court Inc.
CONFIDENTIAL
BP-HZN-21 79MDL0276694 1
BPD209-004851
the a 2. Theteamrvasrequested estimate likelihoodof SIWHPexceeding numberof to valucs. l'hc following figurc providcs that cstimatc. SIWHPis Exceeded Probabilitythat
r00
I
..-r..- ,-,.l.-
.- ''-
90
{, I R {, u
|lJ c
70 6t) 50 40 30
..**--.r*.--*x
o t u
s
I
m
t0 0
It is clearthat theteambelieves thatthereis a 20% probability that the SIWHP psia. The teamalsobelieves the SIWHPj will exceed10,000 that
probabrility Thetrendof GOR with time intluenced presented the cumulative chart.
Attachments l. Pressure Ranges Calculation and N{ethods probabilities 2. Ivlethod Establishing fbr i. Tablcof Formation Propcrtics 4. ThermalGradient
Page2 of 6
Confidential
CONFIDENTIAL
an(') rf) = UJ O
(o=
UO
l-- di ro
s8 -i odco
o E E' o g 5 o o o
o o
o
a
(l) o (D o o o o c o o o E -c c o c) -c o o o o o o c o o o o o o o o o o (9 o CI o o (, oo
t-
E E E E E E
6 6 G
E E E E E o o o (U -c 5 -c. o o o o ,g c) o o
(U
oo
(9
E o o o
o o
E o o o CI
o) t'-r e\t I N Ia
t!
= o > .-
tt ?
o o
t-
a c (, f,
U)
() lIJ IIJ UJ
o o o o
o tu
8 8T : o c (u
I
IU
UJ o
4
a
E
s s
iI
(J $ =
:E
o rF o L.
E 6 '6 o o F- o
I
E '6
tr iT iI
o
c.) 0) a o o I o
(L
Eo a o
tr
eI tT (L (L
(f)
E o o 6 E o E (l) o a o o () o o a o o o a a X x a o a a
ttr
L
t-
t-
IU UJ
eo o- it
E U'
t* CF N
E R '6
Q) 7( I g o Gg o- o- o- r
og -i
CJ
o o
s (o o. (o o,
3
o
r. r @ ro @ (t) r r @ @ cci @
E ffi
g F:
c{ co
N @
w w' r&
P
o o iI
E
c
lC
c)
a
$-
edffi ..w
rTjffi+
c o C)
a g 3
o
u, o
vt g
&.H
tr
!t
=
o o o
-g o o
=
tt
N N a (t (tr o (,
o o c r o o
o
o
$ @ f-
&
E
't-
+ + U' u, rc
c c (I'
U)
o
a o
5@=
oo6 ul
(0 (o rO lo
lJ-
o (o (o CI CO
ro lo rO
oo o o
J
e -o a (o o
c (I'
i o q o ct ro r(f
(o o
(f)
oo
o o) o$ J
uJ
tL
z o
z o
MethodUsedto DevelopCumulativeProbabilities
The petroleum probabilities The curnulative weredetermined through pollingprocess. a werepresented modelresults, modelling the assumptions, and engineers the andreservoir the otherconsiderations / constraints. wasasked consider range Eachengineer a ofvalues(8000,8500.9000.9500, 10000, to judgenrent probability the in 10500, I l-i50 psia)andestimate theirown best the that and range 8,100psia a of SIWHPwouldexceed that value. As the modelspredicted pressure psia. probability exceeding and the of 8,000psiawasalmost1007o thatof to 11,350 I exceeding l.:i50psiawas07o. wrote down their values,they were polled in a randomorder tbr their After eachengineer probability. These pernreability estimated werethenaveraged create cumulative to a pressure. curv'efor each This rvasthenfollowedby a discussion the technical reasons of behindthe estimatesAt groupconsensus to increase probabilities was the of the conclusion this discussion of the psiaby 5ozo. fbr cxccedancc 10.000 and 10,500
ili;:I'lk-"'Jil:J,,i:Tlff-ii,[]p[:'"'.'':::'% m,m o
liil ,iifl|tffry
Mear Mir Mar Probability tc Erceec Probabilih Probab{lih Pressure 95% 100o/o 8,00( 9901 86o/t 6001 100% 8.5001
9.00(
9.50( 10.00( 10.50( 11.35(
30o/o 504
10%
50h Oe/o
5SYo
0o/o
Page4 of 6
Confidential
CONFIDENTIAL
U'@
=|r)
(oI r- di ro
'-i o=co u o)
l'* r vo
A8
gi
f,*
z
N II
o -
c\ I
*I? :
ta
g,!
5 a l
i!
5;! I B I I
;; ; ; 8.8;8. ; ;I *.
834
i3: !:
33
il.
::
(t
#}b &#g
ffi ffi
iffi # :re-
c)
:iF%
l!l q, qt
*-=
we
.g o p c o C)
.&
?3
,:& :=E
O I fJ
,l;
G*=*aFi
(u
l-9
:E
i*g
te dI ilE 99 iI >g
"tu# '.wffi
@#
@ffi
E* .i
.ffi
u I !r t
E t f i={ $t H $ I 6=a? aa
sx :8
r
d?
ix
3iSs3::i3
i - : ET *
7t 6
; re 58{ z Et is tn TP aE t! E : i F; iE l; i- :;
6
{% ::
;i !i o
ReR3888l
: g !; g
; E
i
i 8.,
iilv E : a z
c I; se 3s^; 3 . ! E i . F
EE
l.i
E6 :
(o o tr) o o) o (L
J
uJ
LL
(J
a;
vo
ur@
98
r'- d| rcl
A8 '1 L
l'(t
C\l
|.1,
lr
z
N
il
+
(L E
a
l
(\
l')
@ c\
ij;;:, j -si-.-.-|-r . . , . iI : , - . , _ ;
g
O.,F ()tr
(o + x (\t o
o
F-
(\
(o c{
t':l -;.*a
ES
PP
(\
s +
X (o ol t* o o tl
o (r) c{
(t,I:
|"1
{f; =E
E_ ,q, o)
:;
!
&(L
0e
i ! r'.;
rf C\
.qg
-9 v(!
=.o
LL
vo o(Y) C'N
': '/:'i''
r 'lrrr:r
, ' i l i i l
l : :'-l: , r
tl
5!b . IEI V
F=
E bs =o
-F
.o
o oo cL (\ q o
(\,l
,,-,, "1.i, Ox =g
FF i ! . . 1I 1 : r - , - i r , - , , rj , r r , , ; o'_-
bF FO
E^
N q) E
36
I
It)
o c!
og >(L
..r
c o O
o c\l
r r'j-ri r ir,1 .i . "'-'i "'i
9 ga5>
ri
i:";.iilii-,t r: :: f:_i
:g(g)
otr CL ru EF
.q,
F =
I ,.-.-, .r. ,. I .; t.
Ifr_'1rr'_-1
; : ; - ; ' l ;, 1 :i
:= l : , ; t l i : , 1 (8 (g L L
o t\
llrlllrrll i i , : i: rr*'.!.-r i._ r+,i
',,,j'.,,1
tl
'""i"''l
|I,,iI,I
(o
!:i.1.1,,:..:..1.i.,
"..,'i,..,-',;iii,ji,j
lO
<)C.I(')tLr)(OF-6O)O rrrrrrrrrc\l
ssont qtdao
o (o o o)
N (L J
TL
z
\J