BLACK CARBON
BLACK CARBON
BLACK CARBON
Short Communication
Black carbon pollution in snow and its impact on albedo near the Chilean
stations on the Antarctic peninsula: First results
Francisco Cereceda-Balic a,b,⁎, Víctor Vidal a,b, María Florencia Ruggeri a, Humberto E. González c
a
Centre for Environmental Technologies, Universidad Técnica Federico Santa María, Valparaíso, Chile
b
Department of Chemistry, Universidad Técnica Federico Santa María, Valparaíso, Chile
c
Universidad Austral de Chile, Centro FONDAP-IDEAL, Valdivia, Punta Arenas, Chile
H I G H L I G H T S G R A P H I C A L A B S T R A C T
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: BC can be transported through the atmosphere from low and mid-latitudes to Antarctica, or it can be emitted in
Received 31 May 2020 the Antarctica in situ. To establish a possible relationship between BC and the human activities in Antarctica, shal-
Received in revised form 5 July 2020 low snow samples were taken in four sites from Antarctic peninsula during summer periods (2014–2019):
Accepted 5 July 2020
Chilean Base O'Higgins (BO), La Paloma Glacier (LP) (6 km away from BO); Chilean Base Yelcho (BY) and P4
Available online 7 July 2020
(5 km away from BY). BC concentration in snow samples was determined by using a novel methodology recently
Editor: Pavlos Kassomenos developed, published and patented by the authors. The methodology consisted in a filter-based optical transmis-
sion method at a wavelength of 880 nm. Results showed that snow from BO presented the highest BC concentra-
Keywords: tion (3395.7 μg kg−1), followed by BY (1309.2 μg kg−1), LP 2016 (745.9 μg kg−1), LP 2015 (233.6 μg kg−1) and
BC in snow finally P4 (179.4 μg kg−1). BC values observed in Antarctic snow were higher than others previously reported
Snow albedo in the literature and showed the influence of anthropic activities in the study area, considering that the two
Chilean Stations in Antarctica highest values of BC concentration in snow were found at sites near the bases. To evaluate the impact of the
BC concentrations found in the snow of the study area, snow albedo modeling was performed, using the on-
line version of the “Snow, Ice, and Aerosol Radiative” (SNICAR) Model. Modeling outputs exposed that the mea-
sured variations in BC content caused large differences in the modeled albedo in the visible range of the spectra,
which showed to be more sensitive at lower BC concentrations. These data could help to understand the role of
BC in the actual scenario of climate change, in which Antarctica is presented as a very fragile environment that
needs to be protected, starting with the management of the activities developed in-situ.
© 2020 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
⁎ Corresponding author at: Centre for Environmental Technologies, Universidad Técnica Federico Santa María, Valparaíso, Chile.
E-mail address: [email protected] (F. Cereceda-Balic).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.140801
0048-9697/© 2020 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
2 F. Cereceda-Balic et al. / Science of the Total Environment 743 (2020) 140801
Table 1
Sampling sites on the Antarctic Peninsula and the corresponding measured BC concentrations in snow, its contribution to the total material collected and the modeled broadband albedo.
Sampling site-Year Location Altitude (m.a.s.l) BC in snow Collected material in filter BC Other material than BC Modeled broadband
(μg kg−1) (mg L−1) (mg L−1/%) (mg L−1/%) albedo
Base O'Higgins (BO) -2014 63°19′15″S 0 3395.7 25.18 3.4/13.5 21.8/86.5 0.668
57°53′55″W
Base Yelcho (BY)-2019 64°52′33″S 0 1309.2 9.37 1.3/14.0 8.1/86.0 0.725
63°35′00″W
La Paloma (LP)-2016 63°21′20″S 409 745.9 0.89 0.75/84.1 0.14/15.9 0.748
La Paloma (LP)-2015 57°48′21″W 298 233.6 0.28 0.23/81.8 0.05/18.2 0.779
P4–2019 64°52′25″S 0 179.4 0.58 0.18/32.1 0.4/67.9 0.784
63°33′51″W
frozen (−20 °C), during transport and storage, until they could be proc- The BC mass concentration was calculated using a 5-points calibra-
essed. All sampling material were washed using acid to avoid contami- tion curve, previously prepared using real diesel BC soot as standard.
nation according to the procedure published by Cereceda-Balic et al. The reader is referred to the original publication (Cereceda-Balic et al.,
(2012). 2019) for more details about the methodology, its validation and quality
BC concentration in snow samples was determined by using a novel assurance/quality control assessment.
methodology recently developed and validated by Cereceda-Balic et al.
(2019) and included in the patent application registered in the US Patent 2.2. Albedo modeling
Office: US 16/690,013-Nov, 2019. Briefly, the methodology consisted in a
filter-based absorption method where snow samples were microwave- Spectral albedo was simulated by incorporating the measured BC
assisted melted, then filtered through a special designed filtration sys- concentrations in snow in the on-line version of the “Snow, Ice, and
tem able to generate a uniform BC spot on Nuclepore 47 mm polycar- Aerosol Radiative” (SNICAR) Model (http://snow.engin.umich.edu/)
bonate filters (Whatman, UK), weighted before and after filtration. BC (Flanner et al., 2007), widely used for snowpack simulations globally
deposited in filters was analyzed using a SootScan™, Model OT21 Opti- (He et al., 2018). SNICAR is based on the theory from Warren and
cal Transmissometer (Magee Scientific; Berkeley, CA, USA), where opti- Wiscombe (1980) and the multi-layer two-stream radiative transfer so-
cal transmission was compared between the sample collected in the lution from Toon et al. (1989). The input parameters were introduced in
filter and a reference blank filter at a wavelength of 880 nm. For clarifi- the SNICAR model using the default values proposed by the developers,
cation, it is known that there are other substances than BC that can ab- while the concentration of BC in snow used in each case was that mea-
sorb light and would be measured. Nevertheless, the term BC as an sured in this work. The input parameters include: Direct incident radia-
equivalent is used since in the optical method the absorption is con- tion, zenith angle of 48° (considered for Antarctic in January), clear sky
verted into mass by applying a BC mass-specific absorption coefficient surface spectral distribution, Snowpack thickness = 1 m, Snow den-
(Weller et al., 2013), considering that, at 880 nm, BC is by far the main sity = 400 kg m−2, albedo of underlying ground = 0.2 (visible range,
absorber of radiation, having the imaginary part of refractive index default value) and 0.4 (near infrared, default value), Snow grain effec-
N0.44; which is two orders of magnitude higher than that of organics tive radius = 100 μm (default value), BC coating = uncoated, BC con-
or dust (Chaubey et al., 2010). centration in snow = variable, according to measured data. As output,
Fig. 4. Simulated values of spectral surface albedo (0.3–1.5 μm) obtained with SNICAR
Fig. 2. BC concentration measured in snow samples from different sites of Antarctica. incorporating the measured values of BC in snow from studied sites in Antarctica.
F. Cereceda-Balic et al. / Science of the Total Environment 743 (2020) 140801 5
that passes through two points on the curve where its rate of change
is approximately constant. When observing the curve, two sections of
this nature can be differentiated, one before and the other after what
would be an inflection point for a value of BC = 1000 μg kg−1. Based
on this, two lines were drawn between known points on the curve,
and their slopes were calculated using Eq. (1) (Table 2).
These results indicate that in the first section of the curve (approxi-
mate derivative by line A, lower values of BC) the albedo decreases 6.3E-
05 units for each unit that increases the concentration of BC in snow. In
the second section, a “deceleration” is evident (approximate derivative
by line B, highest values of BC), where the albedo decreases 2.7E-
05 units for each unit that increases the concentration of BC in snow,
which means that from about 1000 μg kg−1, the effect of BC on albedo
Fig. 5. Simulated values of broadband surface albedo obtained with SNICAR incorporating
the measured values of BC in snow from studied sites in Antarctica.
is reduced by less than a half.
This analysis emphasizes the great impact that BC deposition could
have on those sites considered pristine, as Antarctic, where the BC
values found in the snow are generally low, so an apparently small in-
differ by up to a factor of 4 (He et al., 2014, 2018) depending on: crease in them can produce significant decreases in albedo and conse-
(1) snow grain shape and size, (2) particle size and composition that af- quently in the speed of melting snow and ice.
fects the assumed “mass absorption cross section” (MAC), (3) the
amount of dust, algae or colored organics that are also light absorbing, 4. Conclusions
(4) BC-snow mixing state, and (5) how impurities accumulate at the
surface and how radiative forcing progresses. In this sense, further ob- This study provides the first observational data set of BC concentra-
servational studies are needed to assess the additional contribution of tions in snow from Chilean Bases in Antarctica. Results showed a signif-
different absorbing impurities and snow features to albedo reductions icant and localized impact of human facilities in the surroundings
and snow and ice melt (Cereceda-Balic et al., 2018.). Nevertheless, and environments, considering the BC levels measured in the snow, the
despite all these uncertainties in the modeling, the obtained results amount of material collected in filters and the simulated albedo. These
herein yield information that furthers our knowledge, considering findings demonstrate that snow can be used as a suitable matrix to
that, actually data gaps are the main source of uncertainty. trace anthropogenic pollution in the Antarctica, where not only BC can
Fig. 6 presents the simulated broadband albedo values (Alb) vs BC be quantified but also other pollutants as metals or organics. Finally, it
concentrations in snow (BC), and it shows that the relation between is expected that this novel data could be used in the implementation
BC concentration in snow and albedo was not linear. The curve that rep- of models that could help to understand the role of BC in the actual sce-
resents this relationship (red) has a high rate of change (how much Alb nario of climate change, in which Antarctica is presented as a very fragile
changes for each unit that changes BC) at the beginning and later this environment that needs to be protected, starting with the management
rate becomes slower. Mathematically, that rate of change at each of the activities developed in-situ.
point on the curve is defined by the first derivative of the function
Alb = f(BC), that is, d(Alb)/d(BC), where Alb is the dependent variable CRediT authorship contribution statement
and BC the Independent one. Since in this case the mathematical ex-
pression of this function was unknown, its derivatives were calculated Francisco Cereceda-Balic: Conceptualization, Project administra-
by sections, using an approximation that considers the slope of a line tion, Funding acquisition, Supervision, Writing - original draft. Víctor
Vidal: Investigation, Resources, Writing - original draft. María Florencia
Ruggeri: Investigation, Software, Writing - original draft. Humberto E.
González: Investigation, Writing - review & editing.
Table 2
Calculation of rates of change of Albedo (Alb) with BC in snow (BC).