002 Article A005 en
002 Article A005 en
002 Article A005 en
Policymakers, investors, and firms in Singapore have started to act on climate change risks, including
the mainstreaming of green financial solutions. There are increasing efforts by both regulators and
market participants to integrate climate considerations in risk assessments, financing decisions and
disclosure practices. While the green finance market is still modest in absolute value, it is growing fast
with Singapore accounting for about half of cumulative ASEAN green debt issuances.
Sources: Network for Greening the Financial System, IMF Global Financial Stability Report October 2019.
2. The financial system plays a fundamental role in mobilizing the resources needed for
investments in climate mitigation and adaptation. While policymakers implement policies to
1
Prepared by Jochen Markus Schmittmann (APD), Han Teng Chua, and Natalia Novikova (Singapore Resident
Representative Office).
2 See the October 2019 Global Financial Stability Report for an overview of sustainable finance globally.
price in externalities, for example through carbon taxes, and provide incentives for the transition to a
low-carbon economy, the financial system can also help achieve these goals. Investors can play a
crucial role by allocating capital toward lower carbon activities, engaging with company
management, advocating for low-carbon strategies as investor activists, and lending to firms that
are committed towards sustainability.
3. Sustainable investing and green debt issuances have grown rapidly over the past few
years. The Global Sustainable Investment Alliance (GSIA) estimates that at least US$30.7 trillion of
funds were held in sustainable or green investments in early 2018, up by 34 percent from 2016 in
the five largest markets.3 As of 2019, ESG assets under management in Singapore grew to about
US$700 billion (about 28 percent of total) (Figure 2). Global green debt issuances meanwhile grew
cumulatively to US$2.2 trillion in 2020, compared with around US$31 billion in 2012. Over the same
period, green debt issued in Asia Pacific (APAC) and ASEAN increased to around US$433 billion and
US$56 billion, respectively, from US$6 billion and US$1 billion. Singapore accounted for 55 percent
of ASEAN issuances, and its share relative to global green debt issuances stood at around 1.4
percent in 2020 (Figure 3).
Figure 2. Assets of ESG AUM in Singapore Figure 3. APAC Sustainable Debt Total Issuances
(Billions of US dollars) (Billions of US dollars)
800
700
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
2017 2018 2019
Sources: MAS Asset Management Survey 2019, IMF staff calculation
3
In the absence of a uniform global definition, in its biannual reports the GSIA uses an inclusive definition of
sustainable investing, without drawing distinctions between this and related terms such as responsible investing and
socially responsible investing. The assessment covers the US, Europe, Japan, Australia and New Zealand.
6. In addition, MAS has started to attune the industry towards stress tests for climate
change-related risks. In 2018, MAS subjected insurers to a scenario featuring extreme flooding,
with insurers having to consider the impact of higher claims on their balance sheets arising from
damage to insured properties. By end-2022, MAS will incorporate a broader range of climate risks in
stress tests for the financial industry. This will help MAS and the industry to enhance awareness of
the economic and financial implications of such risks and encourage the collaborative development
of relevant capabilities.
7. To encourage green debt issuance, MAS has introduced grant schemes to help defray
associated costs. In 2017, MAS launched the Sustainable Bond Grant, which subsidizes the cost of
external reviews for green, social and sustainability bonds. By end 2020, about S$11 billion in green,
social and sustainability bonds had been issued in Singapore. The scope of the grant was expanded
in 2020 to include sustainability-linked bonds. In 2018, MAS introduced a grant scheme to subsidize
the issuance of insurance-linked securities, which could be catered towards all forms of risks
including natural catastrophes. In 2020, MAS launched a grant scheme for green and sustainability-
linked loans. This scheme aims to support corporates of all sizes and sectors to access green finance,
by defraying the expenses of engaging independent service providers to validate the green and
sustainability credentials of the loan.
4
The guidelines recognize that FI’s board and senior management play a critical role in incorporating environmental
considerations into risk appetite, strategies and business plans, and set the expectation that they should oversee and
steer the organization’s response to international agreements (e.g. the Paris Agreement) and other national policies.
transition to a low-carbon economy. In addition, to grow green funds, MAS has announced a US$2
billion Green Investments Program (GIP). The GIP places investments with asset managers who have
a good track record of sustainability investing and stewardship and are committed to deepening
green finance capabilities in Singapore.
10. The government has identified green infrastructure projects worth S$19 billion (US$14
billion) for which it plans to raise funds through green bonds. The issuance will be spread over
several years and will serve as a reference for Singapore’s green finance market and support market
liquidity.
11. MAS actively participates in several international fora, cooperating with other global
regulators on green finance. MAS is a founding member of the Network for Greening the Financial
System (NGFS).5 At the NGFS, MAS is leading a workstream on micro-prudential practices, which
provides guidance on incorporating climate and environmental risks into prudential supervision. It is
also a member of the Sustainable Insurance Forum (SIF), which closely partners with the United
Nations and International Association of Insurance Supervisors. MAS is also an active member of the
International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO) Sustainable Finance Taskforce (STF),
which has established a Task Force on Sustainable Finance with an aim of addressing issues
concerning sustainability-related disclosures and investor protection. Singapore joined the
International Platform on Sustainable Finance (IPSF) in June 2020, which comprises government
ministries and central banks from countries across regions, and seeks to enhance international
coordination on environmental taxonomies, disclosures and green standards and labels, to mobilize
private capital towards environmentally sustainable investments.
12. Private sector initiatives focus on standards and guidelines. The Association of Banks in
Singapore (ABS) has published guidelines to support more transparent ESG disclosures and define
minimum standards on responsible financing practices to be integrated into the business models of
member banks and FIs. The Singapore Exchange (SGX) introduced mandatory sustainability
reporting requirements for its listed entities for financial years ending on or after 31 Dec 2017, with
5
NGFS aims to enhance the role of the financial system to manage risks, and to mobilize capital for green and low-
carbon investments in the broader context of environmentally sustainable development.
guidelines to aid listed entities in their sustainability reporting on 5 primary components6, including
material ESG factors. In early 2021, the GFIT launched a public consultation of Singapore-based
financial institutions on a taxonomy to identify activities that can be considered green or
transitioning towards green. In May 2021, Singapore announced a carbon exchange to trade carbon
offsets, Climate Impact X (CIX).7
6
The five primary components are: (i) material ESG factors, (ii) policies, practices, and performance, (iii) targets, (iv)
sustainability reporting framework, and (v) board statement. SGX-listed issuers must report on these 5 primary
components on a comply or explain basis.
7
CIX is a voluntary carbon market backed by DBS, Temasek Holdings Pte Ltd., Singapore Exchange Ltd. and Standard
Chartered Plc.
15. Sustainability became an integral part of investment strategies for many Singapore
asset managers, including sovereign wealth funds. 11 The number of Singaporean asset manager
8
DBS have been reporting under TCFD since 2018. DBS’ analysis of transition risks includes a combination of: (i)
bottom-up assessment assuming a carbon price increase for a sample of listed companies in carbon-intensive
sectors (about 9.6 percent of the Institutional Banking Group’s total exposure, covering 60 percent of companies in
five sectors); (ii) a top-down, portfolio level approach for the rest of the entire corporate lending portfolio. Under the
first approach, DBS found that credit ratings of 40 out of over 400 customers would be reduced by at least one
notch.
9
Based on a sample of large corporates and SMEs covering about 5 percent of total non-bank loans, UOB found that
under a high carbon price scenario credit rating of companies included in the sample would deteriorate by two
notches. Most carbon-intensive sectors like building materials would be hit the most. A similar assessment for the
real estate portfolio (about 6 percent of non-bank loans) suggested negligible deterioration of credit ratings. Overall,
while acknowledging the limitations of the methodology and data availability, UOB concluded that the resulting
credit risk for the bank would be immaterial.
10
The Equator Principles is a risk management framework adopted by FIs for determining, assessing and managing
environmental and social risks in large-scale development projects.
11
Temasek Holdings aimed at closing 2020 with carbon neutrality and committed to halve the net greenhouse gas
emissions of its portfolio by 2030. GIC is taking a long-term and holistic approach towards sustainability. It is
incorporating climate change into its portfolio by evaluating the way long-term capital market assumptions are
affected by climate change drivers and under different scenarios.
signatories to the United Nations Principles for Responsible Investment (UN PRI) has risen quickly
(Figure 6). Total assets of ESG-listed funds available in Singapore stood at around US$120 billion as
at end-2020, with equity funds accounting for more than 80 percent of total assets (Figure 7). ESG
fixed income funds in Singapore are small at around 10 percent but are benefitting from an
increased recognition of the relevance of ESG in fixed income.
Figure 4. Singapore Local Banks: Emphasis on Figure 5. Green and Sustainability-Linked Loans
Sustainability Total Issuances
(Number of times ‘climate change’ and ‘ESG’ were mentioned (US$ billion)
in the annual and sustainability reports)
Figure 6. Singapore Asset Manager Signatories to Figure 7. ESG-Listed Funds Available in Singapore
United Nations Principles for Responsible Asset Class Breakdown
Investment (Percent of Total Assets)
(Cumulative Number; 2009-2020)
17. Singapore’s green bond issuance and trading has further room for growth. Green
bonds listed and traded on the SGX are expanding rapidly but are lagging behind European peers.
The cumulative number of green bond listings on the SGX grew to 103 valued at US$44 billion in
2020 from just one listing valued at US$500 million in 2013. The number and value of green bond
listings are however small in comparison to those on the Frankfurt and Luxembourg stock
exchanges (Figure 10). Green bonds listed on the SGX were largely denominated in US dollars and
issued by foreign entities mainly from Asia, but also from other regions. The average issuance size
was about US$200-800 million (Figure 11).
12
The score measures the extent of a company’s environmental disclosures. Firms that disclose every data point
collected by Bloomberg have a score of 100. A score of 0 indicates no disclosure.
Figure 8. Environmental Disclosure by Companies listed Figure 9. Environmental Disclosure by Companies listed on
on SGX SGX and Peers
(Bloomberg Environmental Disclosure Score, Out of 100) (Median Bloomberg Environmental Disclosure Score, Out of 100)
60
Max Median Min
50
40
30
20
10
0
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Sources: Bloomberg, IMF staff calculations
Note: (1) Environment disclosure score measures the extent of a company's
environmental disclosure. Firms that disclose every data point collected by
Bloomberg will have a score of 100.
(2) Calculations are based on companies trading on the Straits Times Index
Figure 10. Cumulative Amount of Green Bonds Figure 11. Green Bonds Listed on SGX Breakdown by
Listed at Exchanges Economy of Domicile, 2012-2020
(Billions of US dollars; 2012-2020) (Percent)
400
300
200
100
0
New York
Shanghai
Frankfurt
Singapore
Luxembourg
London
Zurich
18. The sectoral coverage expanded overtime in all segments of green and sustainable
finance. While financial institutions tend to rely more on securities funding, real estate projects are
present in all types of funding.
19. Singapore is also promoting innovative disaster risk insurance products to strengthen
climate risk resilience in Asia. There have been 14 insurance-linked securities launched in
Singapore. The first catastrophe bond (cat bonds) in Singapore was issued in February 2019 by
Insurance Australia Group. Subsequently, two World Bank Philippines cat bonds were listed on the
SGX (the first ever on SGX and on an Asian exchange) on November 2019. The World Bank bonds
finance up to US$225 million of protection against earthquakes and cyclones in the Philippines over
the next three years.
Figure 12. Singapore Sustainable Debt Issuance Figure 13. Singapore Green Loans Issuance Industry
Industry Breakdown Breakdown
(Percent of Total Issuances, 2017 to 2020) (Percent of Total Issuances)
Consumer Discretionary Renewable energy
Consumer Discretionary Renewable energy
Real estate Health Care
Real estate Health Care
Financials Industrials
Financials Industrials
Utilities Consumer Staples 100
100
80 80
60
60
40
40
20
0 20
Green Loan Green Bond, Social Sustainability-linked
Bond, Sustainability Loan & Bond 0
Bond 2018 2019 2020
Sources: BloombergNEF, IMF staff calculation Sources: BloombergNEF, IMF staff calculation
Figure 14. Singapore Green, Social, and Figure 15. Singapore Sustainability-Linked Loans and
Sustainability Bond Issuance Industry Breakdown Bond Issuance Industry Breakdown
(Percent of Total Issuances) (Percent of Total Issuances)
Consumer Discretionary Renewable energy Consumer Discretionary Consumer Staples
Real estate Financials Real estate Financials
Utilities Utilities
100 100
80 80
60 60
40 40
20 20
0 0
2018 2019 2020 2018 2019 2020
Sources: BloombergNEF, IMF staff calculation Sources: BloombergNEF, IMF staff calculation
E. Conclusion
20. The growing green finance market provides an opportunity for Singapore to support
climate-friendly capital allocation. As a well-developed financial hub, Singapore is already
attracting a good proportion of green finance related flows in Asia. The MAS can facilitate these
trends by enforcing prudent climate risk management and disclosure, while supporting the
development of green and sustainable finance solutions. The private sector has a key role to play in
shifting investment priorities, which require incorporating climate and sustainability considerations
in its strategies.
References
Association of Banks in Singapore 2018. “Guidelines on Responsible Financing”. Available at
https://abs.org.sg/docs/library/abs-guidelines-responsible-financing.pdf.
Grippa, P., J. Schmittmann, F. Suntheim. 2019. “Climate Change and Financial Risk.” Finance &
Development (December 2019). Washington, DC
Heng, S.K. 2019. “Keynote Speech.” OMFIF Global Public Investor Launch, Singapore (June 12).
Available at https://www.mas.gov.sg/news/speeches/2019/keynote-speech-by-mr-heng-
swee-keat-at-the-omfif-global-public-investor-launch
IMF 2019a. “Global Financial Stability Report – October 2019.” Chapter 6: Sustainable Finance:
Looking Farther. Washington, DC
Menon, R. 2021. “The Future of Capital is Green.” Speech, Singapore (October 13). Available at
https://www.mas.gov.sg/news/speeches/2021/the-future-of-capital-is-green
Menon, R. 2020. “Harnessing the Power of Finance for a Sustainable Future.” Speech, Singapore
(October 13). Available at https://www.mas.gov.sg/news/speeches/2020/harnessing-the-
power-of-finance-for-a-sustainable-future
Monetary Authority of Singapore. 2020a. Guidelines on Environmental Risk Management for Banks,
Insurers, Asset Managers. Available at
https://www.mas.gov.sg/regulation/guidelines/guidelines-on-environmental-risk-
management
Monetary Authority of Singapore. 2020b. Sustainable Finance:
https://www.mas.gov.sg/development/sustainable-finance
Monetary Authority of Singapore. 2021. Sustainability Report. Available at
https://www.mas.gov.sg/publications/sustainability-report/2021/sustainability-report
OCBC. “Responsible Financing”. Available at www.ocbc.com/group/sustainability/sustainability-
framework/environmentally-and-socially-responsible.page
Ong,Y.K. 2019. ”Green Finance for a Sustainable World.” Speech, Singapore (November 11). Available
at https://www.mas.gov.sg/news/speeches/2019/green-finance-for-a-sustainable-world
Singapore Exchange. 2021. “Sustainability Reporting – Progress and Challenges”. Available at
https://api2.sgx.com/sites/default/files/2021-
05/Sustainability%20Reporting%20Review%202021_p.pdf
Singapore Exchange. 2019. “Sustainability Reporting – Progress and Challenges”. Available at
https://bschool.nus.edu.sg/cgio/wp-content/uploads/sites/7/2019/12/SGX-CGIO-
Sustainability-Reporting-Progress-and-Challenges-Report-2019.pdf