4500-F Fluoride : 1. Preliminary Treatment
4500-F Fluoride : 1. Preliminary Treatment
4500-F Fluoride : 1. Preliminary Treatment
4500-F⫺ A. Introduction
Fluoride may occur naturally in water or it may be added in TABLE 4500F⫺:I. CONCENTRATION OF SOME SUBSTANCES CAUSING
controlled amounts. Some fluorosis may occur when the flu- 0.1-MG/L ERROR AT 1.0 MG F⫺/L IN FLUORIDE METHODS
oride level exceeds the recommended limits. In rare instances, Method C Method D
the naturally occurring fluoride concentration may approach (Electrode) (SPADNS)
10 mg/L.
Accurate determination of fluoride has increased in impor- Conc Type of Conc Type of
Substance mg/L Error* mg/L Error*
tance with the growth of the practice of fluoridation of water
supplies as a public health measure. Maintenance of an optimal Alkalinity 7 000 ⫹ 5 000 ⫺
fluoride concentration is essential in maintaining effectiveness (CaCO3)
and safety of the fluoridation procedure. Aluminum (Al3⫹) 3.0 ⫺ 0.1† ⫺
Chloride (Cl⫺) 20 000 7 000 ⫹
1. Preliminary Treatment Chlorine 5 000 Remove
completely
with
Among the methods suggested for determining fluoride ion
arsenite
(F⫺) in water, the electrode and colorimetric methods are the Color & turbidity Remove or
most satisfactory. Because both methods are subject to errors due compensate
to interfering ions (Table 4500:F⫺:I), it may be necessary to for
distill the sample as directed in Section 4500-F⫺.B before mak- Iron 200 ⫺ 10 ⫺
ing the determination. When interfering ions are not present in Hexametaphosphate 50 000 1.0 ⫹
excess of the tolerance of the method, the fluoride determination ([NaPO3]6)
may be made directly without distillation. Phosphate 50 000 16 ⫹
(PO43⫺)
2. Selection of Method Sulfate 50 000 ⫺ 200 ⫺
(SO42⫺)
The electrode methods (C and G) are suitable for fluoride * ⫹ denotes positive error
concentrations from 0.1 to more than 10 mg/L. Adding the ⫺ denotes negative error
Blank denotes no measurable error.
prescribed buffer frees the electrode method from most interfer- † On immediate reading. Tolerance increases with time: after 2 h, 3.0; after 4 h,
ences that adversely affect the SPADNS colorimetric method 30.
and necessitate preliminary distillation. Some substances in in-
dustrial wastes, such as fluoborates, may be sufficiently concen-
trated to present problems in electrode measurements and will
not be measured without a preliminary distillation. Fluoride
measurements can be made with an ion-selective electrode and Ion chromatography (Section 4110) is an acceptable method if
either an expanded-scale pH meter or a specific ion meter, weaker eluents are used to separate fluoride from interfering
usually without distillation, in the time necessary for electrode peaks or fluoride can be determined by capillary ion electropho-
equilibration. resis (Section 4140).
The SPADNs method (D) has a linear analytical range of 0 to The flow injection method (G) is a convenient automated
1.40 mg F⫺/L. Use of a nonlinear calibration can extend the technique for analyzing large numbers of samples.
range to 3.5 mg F⫺/L. Color development is virtually instanta-
neous. Color determinations are made photometrically, using 3. Sampling and Storage
either a filter photometer or a spectrophotometer. A curve de-
veloped from standards is used for determining the fluoride Preferably use polyethylene bottles for collecting and storing
concentration of a sample. samples for fluoride analysis. Glass bottles are satisfactory if
Fluoride also may be determined by the automated complex- previously they have not contained high-fluoride solutions. Al-
one method, Method E. ways rinse bottle with a portion of sample.
For the SPADNs method, never use an excess of dechlorinat-
ing agent. Dechlorinate with sodium arsenite rather than sodium
* Approved by Standard Methods Committee, 1997. Editorial revisions, 2011.
Joint Task Group: 20th Edition (4500-F⫺.G)—Scott Stieg (chair), Bradford R. thiosulfate when using the SPADNS method because the latter
Fisher, Owen B. Mathre, Theresa M. Wright. may produce turbidity that causes erroneous readings.
1
FLUORIDE (4500-F⫺)/Preliminary Distillation Step
1. Discussion
2
FLUORIDE (4500-F⫺)/Ion-Selective Electrode Method
temperature reaches 180°C. To prevent sulfate carryover, turn distillation. After periods of inactivity, similarly flush still and
off heat before 178°C. Retain the distillate for analysis. discard distillate.
c. Add Ag2SO4 to the distilling flask at the rate of 5 mg/mg
Cl⫺ when the chloride concentration is high enough to interfere 5. Interpretation of Results
(see Table 4500-F⫺:I). The recovery of fluoride is quantitative within the accuracy of
d. Use H2SO4 solution in the flask repeatedly until contaminants the methods used for its measurement.
from samples accumulate to such an extent that recovery is affected
or interferences appear in the distillate. Check acid suitability peri- 6. Bibliography
odically by distilling standard fluoride samples and analyzing for
both fluoride and sulfate. After distilling samples containing more BELLACK, E. 1958. Simplified fluoride distillation method. J. Amer.
Water Works Assoc. 50:530.
than 3 mg F⫺/L, flush still by adding 300 mL distilled water, BELLACK, E. 1961. Automatic fluoride distillation. J. Amer. Water Works
redistill, and combine the two fluoride distillates. If necessary, Assoc. 53:98.
repeat flushing until the fluoride content of the last distillate is at a ZEHNPFENNIG, R.G. 1976. Letter to the editor. Environ. Sci. Technol.
minimum. Include additional fluoride recovered with that of the first 10:1049.
3
FLUORIDE (4500-F⫺)/SPADNS Method
water to the mark. This buffer, as well as a more concentrated cycle semilogarithmic graph paper. Plot milligrams F⫺ per liter
version, is available commercially. In using the concentrated on the logarithmic axis (ordinate), with the lowest concentration
buffer, follow the manufacturer’s directions. at the bottom of the graph. Plot millivolts on the abscissa. From
the potential measurement for each sample, read the correspond-
4. Procedure ing fluoride concentration from the standard curve.
The known-additions method may be substituted for the cal-
a. Instrument calibration: No major adjustment of any instru- ibration method described. Follow the directions of the instru-
ment normally is required to use electrodes in the range of 0.2 to ment manufacturer.
2.0 mg F⫺/L. For those instruments with zero at center scale, Selective-ion meters may necessitate using a slightly altered
adjust calibration control so the 1.0 mg F⫺/L standard reads at procedure, such as preparing 1.00 and 10.0 mg F⫺/L standards or
the center zero (100 mV) when the meter is in the expanded- some other concentration. Follow the manufacturer’s directions.
scale position. This cannot be done on some meters that do not Commercial standards, often already diluted with buffer, fre-
have a millivolt calibration control. To use a selective-ion meter, quently are supplied with the meter. Verify the stated fluoride
follow the manufacturer’s instructions. concentration of these standards by comparing them with stan-
b. Preparation of fluoride standards: Prepare a series of stan- dards prepared by the analyst.
dards by diluting with distilled water 5.0, 10.0, and 20.0 mL of
standard fluoride solution to 100 mL with distilled water. These 5. Calculation
standards are equivalent to 0.5, 1.0, and 2.0 mg F⫺/L. g F⫺
c. Treatment of standards and sample: In 100-mL beakers or mg F⫺/L ⫽
mL sample
other convenient containers, add by volumetric pipet from 10 to
25 mL standard or sample. Bring standards and sample to same 6. Precision and Bias
temperature, preferably room temperature. Add an equal volume
of buffer. The total volume should be sufficient to immerse the A synthetic sample containing 0.850 mg F⫺/L in distilled
electrodes and permit operation of the stirring bar. water was analyzed in 111 laboratories by the electrode method,
d. Measurement with electrode: Immerse electrodes in each of with a relative standard deviation of 3.6% and a relative error of
the fluoride standard solutions and measure developed potential 0.7%.
while stirring on a magnetic stirrer. Avoid stirring before im- A second synthetic sample containing 0.750 mg F⫺/L, 2.5 mg
mersing electrodes because entrapped air around the crystal can (NaPO3)6/L, and 300 mg alkalinity/L added as NaHCO3, was
produce erroneous readings or needle fluctuations. Let electrodes analyzed in 111 laboratories by the electrode method, with a
remain in the solution 3 min (or until reading is constant) before relative standard deviation of 4.8% and a relative error of 0.2%.
taking a final millivolt reading. A layer of insulating material A third synthetic sample containing 0.900 mg F⫺/L, 0.500 mg
between stirrer and beaker minimizes solution heating. With- Al/L, and 200 mg SO42⫺/L was analyzed in 13 laboratories by
draw electrodes, rinse with distilled water, and blot dry between the electrode method, with a relative standard deviation of 2.9%
readings. (CAUTION: Blotting may poison electrode if not done and a relative error of 4.9%.
gently.) Repeat measurements with samples.
When using an expanded-scale pH meter or selective-ion 7. Bibliography
meter, frequently recalibrate the electrode by checking potential FRANT, M.S. & J.W. ROSS, JR. 1968. Use of total ionic strength adjust-
reading of the 1.00-mg F⫺/L standard and adjusting the calibra- ment buffer for electrode determination of fluoride in water sup-
tion control, if necessary, until meter reads as before. plies. Anal. Chem. 40:1169.
If a direct-reading instrument is not used, plot potential mea- HARWOOD, J.E. 1969. The use of an ion-selective electrode for routine
surement of fluoride standards against concentration on two- analysis of water samples. Water Res. 3:273.
1. General Discussion made almost instantaneous. Under such conditions, however, the
effect of various ions differs from that in the conventional
a. Principle: The SPADNS colorimetric method is based on the alizarin methods. The selection of dye for this rapid fluoride
reaction between fluoride and a zirconium-dye lake. Fluoride reacts method is governed largely by the resulting tolerance to these
with the dye lake, dissociating a portion of it into a colorless ions.
complex anion (ZrF62⫺); and the dye. As the amount of fluoride b. Interference: Table 4500-F⫺:I lists common interferences.
increases, the color produced becomes progressively lighter. Because these are neither linear in effect nor algebraically addi-
The reaction rate between fluoride and zirconium ions is tive, mathematical compensation is impossible. Whenever any
influenced greatly by the acidity of the reaction mixture. If the one substance is present in sufficient quantity to produce an error
proportion of acid in the reagent is increased, the reaction can be of 0.1 mg/L or whenever the total interfering effect is in doubt,
4
FLUORIDE (4500-F⫺)/SPADNS Method
distill the sample. Also distill colored or turbid samples. In some reference, set photometer at some convenient point (0.300 or
instances, sample dilution or adding appropriate amounts of 0.500 absorbance) with the prepared 0 mg F⫺/L standard.
interfering substances to the standards may be used to compen- b. Sample pretreatment: If the sample contains residual chlo-
sate for the interference effect. If alkalinity is the only significant rine, remove it by adding 1 drop (0.05 mL) NaAsO2 solution/
interference, neutralize it with either hydrochloric or nitric acid. 0.1 mg residual chlorine and mix. (Sodium arsenite concentrations
Chlorine interferes and provision for its removal is made. of 1300 mg/L produce an error of 0.1 mg/L at 1.0 mg F⫺/L.)
Volumetric measurement of sample and reagent is extremely c. Color development: Use a 50.0-mL sample or a portion
important to analytical accuracy. Use samples and standards at diluted to 50 mL with distilled water. Adjust sample temperature
the same temperature or at least within 2°C. Maintain constant to that used for the standard curve. Add 5.00 mL each of
temperature throughout the color development period. Prepare SPADNS solution and zirconyl-acid reagent, or 10.00 mL acid-
different calibration curves for different temperature ranges. zirconyl-SPADNS reagent; mix well and read absorbance, first
c. Quality control (QC): The QC practices considered to be an setting the reference point of the photometer as above. If the
integral part of each method are summarized in Table 4020:I. absorbance falls beyond the range of the standard curve, repeat
using a diluted sample.
2. Apparatus
5. Calculation
Colorimetric equipment: One of the following is required:
a. Spectrophotometer, for use at 570 nm, providing a light path A B
of at least 1 cm. mg F⫺/L ⫽ ⫻
mL sample C
b. Filter photometer, providing a light path of at least 1 cm and
equipped with a greenish yellow filter having maximum trans- where:
mittance at 550 to 580 nm. A ⫽ g F⫺ determined from plotted curve,
B ⫽ final volume of diluted sample, mL, and
3. Reagents C ⫽ volume of diluted sample used for color development, mL.
a. Standard fluoride solution: Prepare as directed in the elec- When the prepared 0 mg F⫺/L standard is used to set the
trode method, 4500-F⫺.C.3b. photometer, alternatively calculate fluoride concentration as fol-
b. SPADNS solution: Dissolve 958 mg SPADNS, sodium lows:
2-(parasulfophenylazo)-1,8-dihydroxy-3,6-naphthalene disul-
fonate, also called 4,5-dihydroxy-3-(parasulfophenylazo)-2,7- A0 ⫺ Ax
naphthalenedisulfonic acid trisodium salt, in distilled water and mg F⫺/L ⫽
A0 ⫺ A1
dilute to 500 mL. This solution is stable for at least 1 year if
protected from direct sunlight. where:
c. Zirconyl-acid reagent: Dissolve 133 mg zirconyl chloride A0 ⫽ absorbance of the prepared 0 mg F⫺/L standard,
octahydrate, ZrOCl2 䡠 8H2O, in about 25 mL distilled water. A1 ⫽ absorbance of a prepared 1.0 mg F⫺/L standard, and
Add 350 mL conc HCl and dilute to 500 mL with distilled water. Ax ⫽ absorbance of the prepared sample.
d. Acid zirconyl-SPADNS reagent: Mix equal volumes of
SPADNS solution and zirconyl-acid reagent. The combined re-
6. Precision and Bias
agent is stable for at least 2 years.
e. Reference solution: Add 10 mL SPADNS solution to 100 mL A synthetic sample containing 0.830 mg F⫺/L and no interfer-
distilled water. Dilute 7 mL conc HCl to 10 mL and add to the ence in distilled water was analyzed in 53 laboratories by the
diluted SPADNS solution. The resulting solution, used for setting SPADNS method, with a relative standard deviation of 8.0% and a
the instrument reference point (zero), is stable for at least 1 year. relative error of 1.2%. After direct distillation of the sample, the
Alternatively, use a prepared standard of 0 mg F⫺/L as a reference. relative standard deviation was 11.0% and the relative error 2.4%.
f. Sodium arsenite solution: Dissolve 5.0 g NaAsO2 and dilute A synthetic sample containing 0.570 mg F⫺/L, 10 mg Al/L,
to 1 L with distilled water. (CAUTION: Toxic—avoid ingestion.) 200 mg SO42⫺/L, and 300 mg total alkalinity/L was analyzed in
53 laboratories by the SPADNS method without distillation, with
4. Procedure a relative standard deviation of 16.2% and a relative error of
7.0%. After direct distillation of the sample, the relative standard
a. Preparation of standard curve: Prepare fluoride standards deviation was 17.2% and the relative error 5.3%.
in the range of 0 to 1.40 mg F⫺/L by diluting appropriate A synthetic sample containing 0.680 mg F⫺/L, 2 mg Al/L,
quantities of standard fluoride solution to 50 mL with distilled 2.5 mg (NaPO3)6/L, 200 mg SO42⫺/L, and 300 mg total alka-
water. Pipet 5.00 mL each of SPADNS solution and zirconyl- linity/L was analyzed in 53 laboratories by direct distillation and
acid reagent, or 10.00 mL mixed acid-zirconyl-SPADNS re- SPADNS methods with a relative standard deviation of 2.8% and
agent, to each standard and mix well. Avoid contamination. Set a relative error of 5.9%.
photometer to zero absorbance with the reference solution and
obtain absorbance readings of standards. Plot a curve of the 7. Bibliography
milligrams fluoride-absorbance relationship. Prepare a new stan-
dard curve whenever a fresh reagent is made or a different BELLACK, E. & P.J. SCHOUBOE. 1968. Rapid photometric determination of
standard temperature is desired. As an alternative to using a fluoride with SPADNS-zirconium lake. Anal. Chem. 30:2032.
5
FLUORIDE (4500-F⫺)/Complexone Method
1. General Discussion
2. Apparatus
3. Reagents
6
FLUORIDE (4500-F⫺)/Ion-Selective Electrode FIA
4500-F⫺ F. (Reserved)
1. General Discussion
7
FLUORIDE (4500-F⫺)/Ion-Selective Electrode FIA
TABLE 4500-F⫺:II. RESULTS OF SINGLE-LABORATORY STUDIES WITH a. Recovery and relative standard deviation: The results of
SELECTED MATRICES single-laboratory studies with various matrices are given in
Relative Table 4500-F⫺:II.
Known Standard b. MDL: A 390-L sample loop was used in the method
Sample/Blank Addition Recovery Deviation described above. Ten replicates of a 1.0-mg F⫺/L standard were
Matrix Designation mg F⫺/L % % run to obtain an MDL of 0.02 mg F⫺/L.
Wastewater Reference — 101 — c. Precision: Ten replicate standards of 2.0 mg F⫺/L gave a
treatment sample* % RSD of 0.5%.
plant Blank† 1.0 91 —
influent 2.0 97 —
Site A‡ 0 — 4.8
1.0 93 —
2.0 82 —
Site B‡ 0 — 6.4
1.0 96 —
2.0 86 —
Site C‡§ 0 — 15
1.0 99 —
2.0 86 —
Wastewater Reference — 103 —
treatment sample*
plant Blank† 1.0 97 —
effluent 2.0 97 —
Site A‡ 0 — ND
1.0 ND —
2.0 ND —
Site B‡ 0 — ⬍0.1
1.0 80 —
2.0 78 —
Site C‡ 0 — ⬍0.1
1.0 93 —
2.0 91 —
Landfill Reference — 99 —
leachate㛳 sample*
Blank† 1.0 87 —
2.0 88 —
Site A‡ 0 — 13
1.0 74 —
2.0 68 —
Site B‡ 0 — 10
1.0 68 —
2.0 73 —
Site C‡ 0 — 32
1.0 66 —
2.0 79 —
ND ⫽ not detectable.
* U.S. EPA QC sample, 1.81 mg F⫺/L.
† Determined in duplicate.
‡ Samples without known additions determined four times; samples with known
additions determined in duplicate. Typical difference between duplicates for
influent 5%, for effluent 6%.
§ Mean concentration 0.18 mg F⫺/L.
㛳 All sites had mean concentration of ⬍0.2 mg F⫺/L.