Complet Project Report Group No (109) ..
Complet Project Report Group No (109) ..
Complet Project Report Group No (109) ..
C E R T I F I C A T E
This is to certify that Mr. Dongare Aniket Sundarrao, has successfully completed
the Project Stage – I entitled “LPG Cooling System.” under my supervision, in the
partial fulfillment of Bachelor of Engineering - Mechanical Engineering of University
of Pune.
Date:
Place:Pune
Prof.T.S.Sargar Prof.A.V.Deshpande
Head of the Department Principal
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
It’s my great pleasure to present project report entitled “LPG Cooling System”
This project is an outcome of various efforts by us in collating and identifying the
sources of information and knowledge. I use this occasion to thank my guide with
whose guidance this effort would not have borne fruits. I find no words to express
my gratitude to Prof. S.M Jadhav Sir who not only advised and guided me
during the report writing but also answered all my queries concerning collection
of data, proper structuring of the report, and its improvement. I would also
thankful of my friends which gave me a proper guide line about my subject. I am
virtually indebted to the Head of the Department Prof. T.S.Sargar Sir from
Shrimati Kashibai Navale College of Engineering who have bestowed all their
blessings in the form of guidance which was the leading light to complete this
seminar report. I would also like to thank our principal, Prof. A.V. Deshpande
Sir who provided me valuable support in completion of seminar by providing me
different facilities in college and by giving permissionfor working out of college.
CONTENT
1. Introduction
2. Literature Review
3. Problem Definition
4. Objectives
5. Design Methodology
6. Design and Development
7. Actual Model
8. Testing and Result
9. Conclusion
10. Future scope
Reference
List of Figures
Refrigeration has made the milestone in human life . Since from very long time the human
being has developed so many ways of refrigeration for preserving food, cooling water, etc. but yet
the techniques are developing. The science of refrigeration has developed so many ways to improve
our lifestyle.
Our project considers law of conservation of energy maximum utilization of the fossil fuel
and saving energy. This project has done LPG as refrigerant, instead of using closed cycle as it is
used in normal practice (VCR),the open cycle has been used. Before burning the LPG in burner, it is
passed through the expansion device and evaporator and produce the refrigeration effect without
using electric energy.
LPG is cheap and posses environmental friendly nature with no ozone depletion potential.
The energy crisis persists all across the globe. We think of recovering the energy
which is already spent but not being utilized further, to overcome this crisis with no
huge investment. The climatic change and global warming demand accessible and
affordable cooling systems in the form of refrigerators and air conditioners. Annually
billions of dollars are spent in serving this purpose. Hence forth, we suggest NO COST
Cooling Systems.
Petroleum gas is stored in liquefied state before its utilization as fuel. The energy spent
for pressurizing and liquefying is not recovered afterwards. If it is expanded in an
evaporator, it will get vaporized and absorb heat to produce cooling. This property has
been used for refrigeration and air conditioning. So that the liquefied form of LPG can
be used for cooling and the expanded gas (LPG) can be further used for combustion as
a fuel.
The ozone depletion potentials (ODPs) of HFC-134a relative to CFC-11 are very low
(<5 · 10_4), the global warming potentials (GWPs) are extremely high (GWP¼1300)
For this reason, the production and use of HFC-134a will be terminated in the near
future.
The applications of new refrigerant mixtures to replace conventional refrigerants in
domestic refrigerators have been studied by a number of researchers. Jung and
Radermacher, performed a computer simulation of single evaporator domestic
refrigerators charged with many pure and mixed refrigerants. The study attempted to
find the best potential replacement for CFC- 12. James and Missenden studied the use
of propane in domestic refrigerators. Energy consumption, compressor lubrication,
costs, availability, environmental factors and safety were the criteria for investigation.
The results revealed that propane showed as an attractive alternative to CFC-12.
Richardson and Butterworth determined the performance of a vapor compression
refrigeration system working with propane and a mixture of propane and isobutene.
The obtained performance was higher than that obtained from CFC-12 under the
similar experimental conditions. Alsaad and Hammad, investigated experimentally the
refrigeration capacity, compressor power and coefficient of performance (COP) to
1
determine the performance of a medium size CFC- 12 domestic refrigerator working
with a propane/butane mixture. The results indicated the successful application of the
mixture of propane and butane for the replacement of CFC-12 in domestic refrigerators.
Jung et al., examined the performance of a mixture of propane and isobutene used in
refrigerators. A thermodynamic analysis showed that the coefficient of performance of
the system was increased up to 2.3% as compared to
CFC-12 when the test was run at a mass fraction of propane ranging between 0.2 and
0.6.
2
2. LITERATURE SURVEY
COOLING METHODS-
From the ancient age man always prefers to have cold water for drinking purpose. Also
in India, our country the weather is too hot. Particularly in summer season, the normal
water temperature in open space is 35 to380 C. The water is not suitable for drinking
purpose. The required temperature is at the most 250 C. Hence lowering down of the
temperature is an essential task.
In old age there was ample space available to keep the earthen container
also the houses were sheltered by the trees and bushes which were enough to lower
down the water container temperature. Because in most of the situations the
temperature was depending on the temperature of the flowing air.
3
cooling is above 350 c & another requirement is a relatively low. Wet bulb temperature.
The cooling effect given by the evaporative cooling always depends upon the outdoor
temperature although the evaporative cooling does not perform all the function of true
water-conditioning but it provides coolness by filtering heat & circulating the cooled
air.
Its capacity is limited by WBT of the ambient air. Maximum cooling achieved is
the wet bulb temperature. It is not useful for high D.B.T. & high summer weather
conditions. However, even with all this limitations, there are many regions in India as
the part of Rajasthan; part of Bihar Vidharbha in Maharashtra & some hot spot in
North where evaporative cooling will produce a condition well within the summer
comfort zone. There is increasing demand of evaporative earthen pot coolers in these
regions, as they are quite inexpensive compared with refrigerated water-cooling system.
Hence quick operating and reliable Vapour compression system, which is having the
massive capacity of cooling, is used.
Generally refrigeration is defined as any process of heat removal. More
specially, refrigeration is defined as the branch of science that deals with process
of reducing and maintaining the temperature of a space or material bellow the
temperature of the surroundings. Since ancient times, human being searched for
warmth in cold weather and cooling in hot weather. The ordinary people used lakes
and rivers to get relief from hot weather. Others brought the lake water to houses and
circulated it inside the house in the form of channels or fountains. But in modern time
this search led to refrigeration systems. The system maintained at the lower
temperature than surrounding atmosphere temperature is known as refrigeration system
while the equipment used to maintain this lower temperature is known as refrigerating
machines.
4
Fundamentals of refrigeration-
The refrigeration may be defined as the process of removing heat from
substance under controlled conditions. It also includes the process of reducing &
maintaining of temperature of body below the general temperature of its surrounding
in other words, the refrigeration means continue extraction of heat from a body whose
temperature is already below the temperature of surrounding.
5
Cold storage –
In country like India the problem of storage of vegetables, fruits, and fishes
is accomplished by the use of cold storage. It is the best known method of
perseveration of food & other things. From very longer time the method of cold
storage is known to human beings.
The temperature designed for the storage is approximately -20±2ºc for most of
the foods. Essential requirement of cold storage is to design a refrigerating system that
would be energy efficient, less costly, and flexible with high reliability & ease of
maintenance. There are various methods of cold storage but as far as medium
temperature is taken while designing a cold storage system 0ºc to 8ºc temperature
range is taken. In case4 of frozen food storage the temperature rang is -18ºc to -22ºc is
taken.
The following table gives different values for different products-
PRODUCT STORAGE PRODUCT LIFE STORAGE
TEMP.(ºC) (WEEKS) SEASON
6
LIQUID VAPOUR
CONDENSER
HIGH PRESSURE
VALVE COMPRESSOR
LOW PRESSURE
EVAPORATOR
Win
COP = R.E/Win
Where,
R.E = Refrigerating Effect
Win= Work Input
The above diagram shows the simple vapour compression system. It includes
following components,
7
1. Evaporators –
It is an important device used in low pressure side of refrigerating system. The
liquid refrigerant from the expansion valve enters in to the evaporator where it is boils
& changes in to vapour. The function of evaporator is to absorb heat from surrounding
location or medium. Evaporator becomes cold & remains cold due to following two
reasons –
1. Temperature of evaporator coil is low due to the low temperature of the refrigerant
inside the coil.
2. The low temperature of the refrigerant remains unchanged because any heat absorbs
is converted to latent heat as boiling proceeds.
Compressor-
Compressors are the heart of vapour compression system. It performs two
functions; one is to draw vapour from evaporator & lowers the pressure of refrigerant
in evaporator to desired level. And other is it rises pressure of refrigerating vapour in
condenser enough so that saturation temperature is higher than the temperature of
cooling medium.
In order to secure satisfactory performance, long life, and to protect the
compressor against overload, certain design criteria should be observed. Compressor
application notes and data should always be consulted when designing a system.
Ensure compressors are clearly labelled to indicate that refrigerants are being used in
the system. The use of crankcase heaters should be considered to avoid excessive oil
solubility.
8
Condenser-
This is another important part of refrigeration system, which needs more
considerations its selection. The condenser removes the heat from refrigerant carried
from evaporator & added by compressor & convert the vapour refrigerant into liquid
refrigerant.
It is heat exchanger in which heat transfer takes place from high temperature
vapour to low temperature air or water, which is used as cooling medium.The types of
cooling media available air water. Both can be used separately combines as per the
availability and requirement. The condensers are classified according to cooling
medium used.
Expansion valve-
It is an important device used in refrigeration. It performs two functions, one
is it reduces high pressure liquid refrigerant to low pressure liquid refrigerant before
being fed to evaporator. And second it maintains desired pressure difference between
high & low pressure side & it also controls the flow of refrigerant.
Design and selection criteria are the same as those for conventional
fluorinated refrigerants. Capillary tube length is specific to each refrigerant. Computer
programmers and tables are available for determining capillary tube size and length,
although trial and error is generally the preferred route. Thermostatic Expansion
Valves (TEVs) for hydrocarbons are available. Alternatively TEVs for other
refrigerants that operate with similar pressure-temperature relationships can be used.
Electronic Expansion Valves (EEV) may also be used. EEV’s used in hydrocarbon
systems must conform to the requirements of electrical components.
9
Refrigerants-
Definition-
Any substance capable of absorbing heat from another required substance can be used as
refrigerant.
Desirable properties of refrigerants-
It should be nonpoisonous.
It should be non explosive
It should be non corrosive
It must be nonflammable
Leaks should be easy to detect.
Leaks should be easy to locate.
It should operate under low pressure.
Part moving in the fluid should be easy to lubricate.
It should be nontoxic (not harmful if inhaled or if spilled on skin).
It should be a stable gas.
10
Classification of refrigerants-
1. R11(C��� F) -
Synthetic, non flammable, non toxic, low pressure refrigerant
0.2 bar at -15ºc
1.2606 bar at 30ºc
B.P=23.77ºc at atm. Temp.
Used in centrifugal compressor system of 200 TR,
Leak detected by soap solution halide torch,
Cylinder colour code is orange
R12 (C��� �� ) -
Popular, colourless, almost odourless, non toxic, non corrosive, non flammable
B.P= -29ºc at atm. Pressure
Low latent heat value,
Require less sensitive & more positive,
Low but positive head & good volumetric efficiency.
Refrigerator, freezer, water coolers, room & window Arcs , etc.
0.82 bar at -15 ºc & 6.4 bar at 30ºc
Latent heat of 159KJ/Kg at -15ºc
Leak can be detected by soap solution, halide torch & electronic detector
11
R22 (CHCl�� )-
Man made, to maintain temp. of -29ºc to-40ºc
A/C units & household refrigerators
Reciprocating ¢rifugal compressors
B.P= -41ºc at atm. Pressure
Latent heat is 216.5KJ/Kg at -15ºc
Non toxic, non corrosive, no irritating, non flammable
Water mixes well with R22 than R12 by ratio as 3:1 hence drier has to be used
Colour code is green
Azeotrope refrigerants –
R500 -
Non flammable, non corrosive, less toxic
Reciprocating compressor
20% greater refrigerating capacity than R12
Condensing pressure 7.78 bar at -30ºc & evaporating pressure 1.37 bar at -15ºc
Latent heat 198KJ/Kg at -15ºc
Highly soluble in oil
Cylinder colour code is yellow
12
Inorganic refrigerants –
R717 ( N�� ) -
Oldest, used in large & commercial plants, where toxicity is secondary
Absorption system
Under normal condition it is colourless gas
B.P= -33.33ºc at atm. Pressure
M.P= -78ºc from solid
Latent heat of vaporisation is 1315KJ/Kg at -15ºc
Large refrigerating effects with small sized machinery
Condensers pressure at 30ºc is 10.78 bar & water cooled type
Poisonous & toxic, irritating to eyes, nose & throat
Flammable, with 16% to 25% air by volume
Lighter than oil hence oil can be easily separated
Large reciprocating compressors
Ice manufacturing; bear mfg. Food freezing, cold storage, etc.
13
Hydrocarbons-
commercial
propane
commercial
butane
values vary
mixtures of the
above
14
COMPARISON OF REFRIGERANT PRRFORMANCE -
15
Table compares refrigerant properties (Gallagher et al. 1993) and parameters
Affecting COP for domestic refrigerators. Saturated vapour at -15°C is assumed to
Enter an ideal compressor and saturated liquid at 30°C to enter the expansion valve
Except for calculating COP with 20 K suction superheat. ASHRAE (1993), Table 7
On page 16.7 also uses these assumptions. Table 5 includes the three refrigerants
Currently in mass-produced domestic refrigerators and RC270 which was not in
ASHRAE (1993)'s
Table shows R600a has one irrelevant disadvantage and many significant
Advantages for domestic refrigerators discussed in the following:.
1. When R12 was introduced, open-drive compressors were common and R600a's
Below atmospheric evaporator would cause ingress of air through the shaft Seals
reducing reliability. Domestic refrigerators no longer use open-drive Compressors.
3. The COP calculated for a simple reversed Rankine cycle (Figure 1) with zero
sub cooling of liquid and superheat of suction vapour and ideal heat transfer and
compression is 1% higher for R600a than R134a. All the refrigerants are close to the
reversible COP of 5.74 which is the maximum thermodynamically possible.
16
4. Domestic refrigerators use a capillary tube in close thermal contact with the
compressor suction line instead of an expansion valve. The liquid-suction heat
exchange increases COP for some refrigerants and reduces it for others. With 20 K
superheat R600a has an idealized COP only 2% higher than R134a. The measured
difference of 10% to 20% must contain other effects.
5. The low compressor discharge temperature for R600a allows a cheaper and
more efficient design of electric motor.
17
9. For hermetic compressors diffusion through the ceiling compounds is a major
source of refrigerant loss. Liquid molar volume is related to the size of the molecule. A
large molecule means a lower loss rate and a longer period of operation with high COP.
In the absence of measurements, R600a's larger molecule suggests it will have lower
diffusion loss.
10. Significant refrigerant leaks occur typically by laminar isothermal flow through
pinholes or cracks. The leakage speed is approximately inversely proportional to the
time a complete charge of a given refrigerant takes to leak out. R600a systems with
large leaks will function with high COP much longer. These advantages make R600a
desirable in other applications where equipment mass and leakage is important and
evaporator or condenser temperatures are high e.g., transport air conditioning and
domestic water heat pumps. RC270 is a better replacement for R12 and R134a but if
the equipment must be redesigned to minimize GWP; R600a will give a better result.
Ammonia R717 has higher heat transfer than all these but its vapour pressure,
corrosion and toxicity are higher. The toxicity is especially a disadvantage in domestic
applications. LPG refrigerants are completely soluble in and compatible with
hydrocarbon lubricants. LPG liquid absorbs only trace amounts of water, like R12, so
LPG refrigerants are completely compatible with R12 driers. LPG refrigerants with
appropriate vapour pressures are `drop-in' replacements for CFCs on equipment using
thermostatic expansion valves. Other expansion devices may require adjustment or
replacement.
18
LPG as a refrigerant-
19
Composition of LPG-
LPG is mixture of C3 & C4 type of hydrocarbons. The chief constituents of LPG are
propane (C3H8) & butane (C4H10). Owing to the demand for industry LPG sold as
fuel mode largely as propane.
20
Properties of LPG-
Density of LPG = 496.47Kg/m3
Boiling range at 1 atm.= -42ºc to 0ºc
Gross calorific value of LPG =11400Kcal/Kg
Limit of flammability (lower)=1.8%(gas in air /gas mixture ),upper=9%
Flash point = -37.73ºc
Auto ignition temp.=493.33ºc to 548.89ºc
Considering the above data it is clear that liquid LPG can be certainly used as
refrigerant, but some precautions are to be taken due to the following properties of
LPG:
21
Hazards and precautions for refrigerants:
The principal hazards are:
Explosion in space -
Any refrigerant with vapour pressure above ambient can _ash
to a larger volume. The potential increase in volume is greater if combustion
of lubricant or refrigerant occurs. Explosion venting may be necessary to
limit pressure rise to what the space can safely withstand. 2 kPa can blow
window glass off a building.
Fire -
Combustible lubricant and refrigerant must be discharged safely outside
a building when a _re occurs especially if the heat of combustion exceeds
200 MJ.
Asphyxiation or poisoning -
All refrigerants except air and oxygen are asphyxiants.
Ventilation must prevent serious injury or death on a sudden total
release of refrigerant. The quantity of ventilation necessary varies greatly
between refrigerants.
Flying metal-
System must comply with piping and pressure vessel codes.
22
Chemical or cold burns-
Accidental contact between skin and cold metal must be
prevented by insulation. Accidental releases of liquid refrigerant must drain
safely.
23
THEORY OF DESIGN
Considering LPG as refrigerant, the system for cooling water is as designed below .
In this section the layout & various components like cylinder , regulating valve, pipe ,
heat exchanger ,etc used in the system are explained. Also considering various
properties of material properties ,standard specimens, & various theories of design
&heat transfer the system is designed.
(A) Layout-
The main principle behind this project is of making use of liquid LPG as coolant for
this latent heat required for phase transformation of liquid LPG in to gaseous state is
taken from water which is to cooled thus the layout of system is as shown in following
fig.
24
Block Diagram &Technical Specification
14ºc
Gas stove
Cooling tank
LPG
cylinder
The layout consist of cylinder ,regulator , suraksha pipes, heat exchanger, burner ,etc.
cylinder is as shown in inverted form & regulating valve connected to it so as to get
liquid LPG at the outlet of the valve . the heat exchanger is placed in between burner &
cylinder with the help of pipe (wire reinforced ). The length of pipe between cylinder
& heat exchanger is less as compare with length between het exchanger & burner . so
as to allow liquid LPG to enter in heat exchanger & pipe connected between heat
exchanger is long enough so as to convert remaining liquid LPG into gaseous state.
25
(B) System components-
1. Cylinder-
26
2. Regulating valve-
27
3. Pipes-
4. Clamping clips-
28
5. Heat exchanger:
5. Coil.
29
6. Burner:
30
7. Insulation-
Energy conservation has gained great importance in the recent years,
due to rapidly escalating cost of fuel .Energy conservation calls for better thermal
insulating .insulting materials have extremely low thermal conductivity. Properly
applied insulation helps in economic running of refrigerating plants. The selection of
proper insulating material for a particular purpose depends upon desired properties of
insulating material , economics & structural conditions.
31
Types of insulating material-
1. Flake insulation - it composed of small particles that finely divide the air space
E.g-expanded mica
2. Fibrous insulation – It is composed of small diameter fibers that finely devide
the air space e.g- inorganic fibers of rock wool ,glass wool
3. Granular insulation-It is composed of small nodules containing voids e.g-
magnesia cork , calcium silicate
4. cellular insulation-it is composed of small individuals cells that finely divide
the air space e.g –glass, rubber, or plastic.
32
MATERIAL SELECTION
RAW MATERIAL & STANDARD MATERIAL
4 REGULATOR STD 1
5 PIPE CLIP MS 4
6 TANK STEEL 1
33
CALCULATIONS-
Evaporator design-
Q = UA(T2-T1) W or J/S
34
Refrigeration effect is given by ,
RE = mCp∆T
m=
V=
1
U= 1 1 �� 1
+ ��( )+
ℎ� �� � �� ℎ� ��
Q = UA(T2-T1)
A=
2�L =
For L =
Q=
35
TESTING OF SYSTEM
Working-
The working of LPG cooling prototype may be described as follows-
Before starting the experiment some arrangements are necessary which
may have given high priority. Firstly LPG cylinder is placed in inverted position on
stand properly. Then proper connections are made to evaporator & expansion device.
After this regulator is operated & equipment is checked for leakage keeping the
regulator in open position. If any leakage is found, it is rectified.
For safety, the everything is kept away from burner. The first step is
lightening the burner. The flow of LPG is controlled by regulator fitted on cylinder.
Thus the controlled flow is maintained to avoid the frosting & liquid accumulation at
the burner inlet. After performing many trials we got proper position of valve, at which
burner works properly. In our refrigeration there is no need of compressor & condenser,
because in LPG cylinder it is stored under high pressure & very low temperature. So
the compression process is adopted directly by LPG cylinder.
In case of condensation process high pressure vapour is converted into
liquid form. The LPG heavier than air. It is stored in liquid form in cylinder. By
keeping cylinder vertically downward position, we get high pressure liquid LPG. The
liquid form LPG coming out from cylinder is passed through expansion device. Where
they converted in low pressure & low temperature & then passed through evaporator.
The vapour state LPG coming out from evaporator chamber is then passed through gas
chamber to gas burner. Where it burns & gives energy for cooking purpose. The liquid
coming out from cylinder takes heat from surrounding to change the phase from liquid
to gaseous. For that purpose the length of rubber pipe have kept longer, so it will give
enough time for change in phase.
The digital thermocouple is used to measure the temperature readings in
the experiment. The readings are taken out for varying temperature & time. Thus from
that readings we will come to know the change in temperature for specific time.
36
Actual construction of project-
37
Demo test in college campus-
38
OBSERVATION & RESULTS-
DEMO TEST NO -1 (with domestic regulator)
Demo test readings -Duration of test is 3 4 hour.
39
Diagram - Time –temperature graph
The above graph shows the readings taken during first demo test. The test readings
taken may show very minor temperature change . The test readings shows the
temperature difference of approximately 2.8ºc .Thus in refrigeration this temperature
difference is very low as compare to other refrigerating techniques. There is loss of
energy which causes decrease in efficiency of refrigerating effect.
40
OBSERVATION & RESULTS-
DEMO TEST NO -2 (with industrial regulator)
Demo test readings - Duration of test is ½ hour.
41
previous test. It shows approximately 16.2ºc decrease in the initial temperature within
½ hour.
TIME-TEMPERATURE GRAPH
Diagram - Time–Temperature
The above diagram shows the readings taken during demo test with
industrial regulator. The time temperature diagram shows the change in temperature &
time. As in first case flow rate is less due to domestic regulator but in this case the
industrial regulator is used which increases flow of liquid LPG through regulator . This
causes the increase in efficiency of refrigeration . The temperature difference given is
approximately 16.2ºc for 30 min. But as time increases the refrigerating effect also
increases.
42
CONCLUSION
Studying all aspects of LPG it can be stated that, LPG is versatile fluid can be utilized
as better cooking gas . A better fuel for IC engine as well as better & eco friendly
refrigerant .The zero phenomenon of system is most existing one of this project, which
the potential of LPG is directly harnessed from commercial LPG cylinders.
Actually the system employed is designed for chilling effect equal to 5ºc
& practically the result obtained are in the range of 6ºc to 6.6ºc indicating the efficacy
& accuracy of the system. Hence it can be concluded that , whatever the consumption
of commercial LPG is considerably high , the system will definitely work positively.
This system in beginning fruitful in case of restaurant ,hotels, where
consumption of LPG is high enough. The only limitation of the system can be
inflammable property of LPG . But the proper arrangement & operation an easily
evade this limitations , as the construction & operation made during the process are
very handy.
43
SCOPE OF IMPROVEMENT
LPG refrigerant system is sufficient only for hotels & restaurant the many of this
system having scope of improvement.
By proper maintaining pressure we can re-circulate when burning is not
required.
It can be converted into close type system.
LPG refrigerants can be used for air-conditioning , ice-plant purpose.
It can be used in household refrigerator.
In areas with electricity problems or rural or remote areas LPG can be used for
cooling purposes.
44
REFERENCE
1. FROM BOOKS
2. FROM PAPERS
1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shell_and_tube_heat_exchanger
2. Heat Exchangers: Selection, Rating and Thermal Design (2nd Edition ed.)
http://www.southwestthermal.com/shell-tube-exchanger.html. Retrieved
2009-05-08.Sadik Kakaç and Hongtan Liu (2002).
45
46