Ipm T14 Ha-Dinh S3 Q1

Download as xlsx, pdf, or txt
Download as xlsx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 10

Investment analysis

Assumptions
Cash flow

Year 0 1 2 3
Project 1 -350 50 100 140
Project 2 -250 125 100 75

NPV
Interest rate 9%
Discount rate 50 12%
Project 1 12.12%
Project 2 17.07%

Column1 0 1 2 3
12% Project 1 -350 45 80 99
Project 2 -250 107 73 44
Year Beginning Interest payment End Balance

1 50.00 4.50 54.50


2 54.50 4.91 59.41
3 59.41 5.35 64.75
4 64.75 5.83 70.58

Market interest rate development


Step 1%
T cash Profit
4 amount Margin
200 150 43%
50 100 40%

If do not take into account the time value of money, the better one is

4 Column2 Column3 IRR Project 2


127 0 0% 12.12%
27 0 0% 17.07% IRR
=> the discount rate that make project

Market interest rate development


Step 1%

r project 1 Project 2 Better Selection Refine decision


4% $85.95 $67.62 project 1 85.952873 project 1
5% $73.80 $61.35 project 1 73.799754 project 1
6% $62.13 $55.30 project 1 62.134888 project 1
7% $50.93 $49.45 project 1 50.93359 project 1
8% $40.17 $43.79 Project 2 43.794372 Project 2
9% $29.83 $38.32 Project 2 38.321003 Project 2
10% $19.89 $33.02 Project 2 33.023701 Project 2
11% $10.32 $27.89 Project 2 27.894801 Project 2
12% $1.12 $22.93 Project 2 22.927052 Project 2
13% ($7.75) $18.11 Project 2 18.113585 Project 2
14% ($16.28) $13.45 Project 2 13.447896 Project 2
15% ($24.50) $8.92 Project 2 8.9238175 Project 2
16% ($32.43) $4.54 Project 2 4.5355029 Project 2
17% ($40.07) $0.28 Project 2 0.2774033 Project 2
18% ($47.44) ($3.86) Project 2 -3.8557488 Reject both
19% ($54.55) ($7.87) Project 2 -7.8689567 Reject both
20% ($61.42) ($11.77) Project 2 -11.766975 Reject both
better one is Project 1

At what discount rate, the NPV of project=0


t rate that make project have no profit

Mannunaly Automated decision


1,2, but prefer 1 can take both but preferproject 1
1,2, but prefer 1 can take both but preferproject 1
1,2, but prefer 1 can take both but preferproject 1
1,2, but prefer 1 can take both but preferproject 1
1,2, but prefer 2 can take both but preferProject 2
1,2, but prefer 2 can take both but preferProject 2
1,2, but prefer 2 can take both but preferProject 2
1,2, but prefer 2 can take both but preferProject 2
1,2, but prefer 2 can take both but preferProject 2
Only 2 only takeProject 2
Only 2 only takeProject 2
Only 2 only takeProject 2
Only 2 only takeProject 2
Only 2 only takeProject 2
Neither one Reject both
Neither one Reject both
Neither one Reject both
3 4 Sum=NPVProfit Margin
140 200 27 8%
75 50 37 15%

You might also like