Strategic Financial Management Section 2
Strategic Financial Management Section 2
Strategic Financial Management Section 2
SECTION B
P a g e 1 | 18
R1910D9456174
1.0 Introduction:
Capital investment is a decision-making process for selecting, analysing, and evaluating long-
term investments. Organisations also make decisions concerning investments in the non-
current asset. The investment appraised usually requires a substantial initial investment, and it
is expected to produce returns to organisations for more than a year. Rutherford (2012) states
that “As major investments are risky and irreversible; capital budgeting is a crucial managerial
activity of firms.” Therefore, Organisations carry our series of steps at the appraisal level to
ascertain investment profitability.
Pontema Training (2018), identified the various steps in the investment decision process as
detailed in the figure 1.0 below.
This is the immediate cash outflows required by AYR Co. to start the nominated project.
P a g e 2 | 18
R1910D9456174
1.0.2.0 Annual Cash Flows:
Cash flows that occur throughout the useful life of the project. It evaluates and analyse cost
implications and benefits. For instance, decrease in maintenance cost in year 1-5 is a benefit for
AYR Company.
Cash flows that occurs only at the project’s termination. For instance, value of scraps if AYR Co.
decides to end the business and sell off the scraps.
The two techniques used by AYR Company are discounted cash flow, which means that future
cash flow will be discounted into present value. The examples are discounted payback period,
Net present value, and internal rate of return techniques. The concept uses the time value of
money. In contrast, the second technique is non-discounted cash flow, which includes the future
amount to occur regardless of timing and the interest effect. The examples are the payback
period and accounting rate of return techniques (Learn accounting, 2019). Fig 2.0.1 below
shows the link between these techniques.
Source: Learn accounting (2019) ‘Capital Investment Appraisal’ [Online] Available at:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hEkFq3y7Evk (Accessed August 2020).
Three main techniques that will only be discussed and analysed in this report for AYR Company
are the payback period, Net present value, and internal rate of return. pmtycoon (2015) agrees
that these techniques will help organisations make informed decisions when faced with
challenges concerning the financial viability and business justification of projects.
P a g e 3 | 18
R1910D9456174
2.1 Net Present Value (NPV):
It measures the present cash flow by a discounted sum of all cash flows received less with its
initial investment. To calculate AYR Co. NPV, we have to look at the relationship between future
value (FV) of money and present value (PV). FV=PV (1+K)n where FV=Future Value, PV=
Present Value, K=Discounted Rate, and n=Number of years. Therefore, Net present value=
Present value of cash inflow – Present value of cash outflows. (pmtycoon (2015). Negative NPV
will decrease the value of the firm. This suggests that the project is not financially viable.
However, if the NPV is positive, then it is accepted because it is financially profitable. Also, zero
results indicate that the firm’s value remains unchanged.
IRR is the interest rate at which the net present value of a project or investment is equal to zero.
IRR is a discount rate at which NPV becomes zero. Duncan (2017) states that “IRR is strictly
defined and used only to determine whether a plant or project will be profitable enough to a
company (the Enterprise) to build it.” If IRR is higher than opportunity cost, then the NPV will
always be positive, and vice versa. The higher the rate of return the better for the project when
comparing between the two projects.
Payback period measures the number of years AYR Co. anticipates to recover the initial
investment from the cash generated by the investment. It recognises that time is money. The
rule is; if the payback is less than the maximum time allowed, then invest in the project.
However, if it is higher than the maximum time allowed then, do not invest in the project
(Counttuts, 2019).
Aspire, and Wolf are the two projects that have the potential of increasing AYR Company’s
market share because the sum of $120,000 is already spent on market research to determine
market response to both projects. Therefore, Since AYR Co. can only fund one project at this
time, the company want to make an informed decision on which project to align with after the
report is submitted to the directors and decision taken. According to the available information,
the sum of $2,250,000 is the cost of plant and machinery for both projects, and it is payable
immediately the decision is taken. The period of project execution is also the same for both
projects.
P a g e 4 | 18
R1910D9456174
Part of the requirement of the Aspire Project is the consideration of selling off the machinery, at
scrap value of $375,000 at the end of five years. There is also $140,000 working capital to be
used immediately. This amount was released from the company’s retained profits with a
repayment plan to last to the end of the project. The cash inflow forecast in year one is
$650,000, with a 7.5% rate increase from subsequent years. Expected variable cost is $27,000
per annum and to rise at 6.75% per annum. The project has a capital allowance and will be
considered as cash inflows. However, capital allowances are deductions from taxable income,
according to Henry, (1985), who explained it as follows.
Capital allowances are given as a deduction from the taxable income in accordance with the
Capital Allowances Act, 1968. The allowances are given mainly to traders or self-employed
persons but can also be claimed by employees who are necessarily obliged to use capital
equipment during their employment. Normally, the allowances are given as deduction from
taxable income but in certain circumstances, they are given by means of tax repayment, for
example, on leased industrial buildings, leased plant, or agricultural buildings and patent rights.
The words plant and machinery are not statutorily defined and for this reason have been
defined by Case Law. Section 7 of the Capital Allowances Act, 1968, defines an industrial
building as a mill, factory, or warehouse attached to manufacture, buildings used for the trade of
catching fish, etc.
3.2 Project Wolf:
The expenditure of project wolf will not attract capital allowances. Nevertheless, it has a
constant annual cash flows of $955,000, which remains constant throughout the life of the
project. Cost of materials in year one will be $14,400 with annual inflation rise of 7.5% per
annum. Other expenses forecast is $18,000 in year one and will face depreciation of 7.5%
annually over the lifetime of the project.
AYR Corporation pays tax at the rate of 20%, and it is payable one year in arrears. In both
cases, the weighted average cost of capital is 10%, and unless otherwise stated, it is assumed
that cash flows occur at the end of the year to which they relate. Furthermore, a straight-line
method of depreciation at a rate of 20% is applied to all non-current assets. (USW-VLE, 2020).
P a g e 5 | 18
R1910D9456174
3.4 Interpretations:
Both projects have a useful net present value. However, Wolf project is more profitable than the
Aspire project. The weighted average cost of capital is 10% in both cases, and from our result,
Wolf has 18% Internal rate of return while that of Aspire is 16%. Furthermore, Wolf project has a
higher NPV of $475,111 as against Aspire with $409,559 NPV. Every investor seeks to invest in
a project with a faster return on investment (ROI). Wolf project, in this case, has a faster
turnaround time of 3.1 years than the Aspire project with a turnaround time of 3.6 years.
P a g e 6 | 18
R1910D9456174
environment, risk and uncertainty are very vital because all investments decisions have some
uncertainty. According to tutor2u, (2019) “Changes in the external environment can change
investment returns. Contingency planning and sensitivity analysis can help businesses address
the problems created by uncertainty”. Government policies that may have impact on the
business, business expansion, market penetration strategy and competitions are no exception.
issues, debt issues, and a combination of equity and debt issues.” Equity financing is not as
easy as debt financing, which is tax-deductible on interest paid. Reviewing the debt option is
instead an excellent decision to make than equity selection. Investors expect higher returns on
investment, and in situations where the firm could not meet up with such expectations,
shareholders lose money. It is, therefore, a significant risk by attempting to finance the project
solely on equity. The risk involved in financing the project with debt is low to AYR Co. because
the borrower takes the higher risk.
P a g e 8 | 18
R1910D9456174
6.0 Appendix:
Cash Inflow:
Year Calculations Result
Year 1 $650,000 and to increase by 7.5% $650,000
annually.
Year 2 $650,000 +7.5% $698,750
Year 3 $698,750 +7.5% $751,156
Year 4 $751,156+7.5% $807,493
Year 5 $807,493 + 7.5% $868,055
Variable Cost:
Year Calculations Result
Year 1 $27,000 and to increase by 6.75% $27,000
annually.
Year 2 $27,000+6.75% $28,830
Year 3 $28,830+6.75% $30,776
Year 4 $30,776+6.75% $32,853
Year 5 $32,853+ 6.75% $35,071
Capital Allowances:
Year Result as Provided
Year 1 $600,000
Year 2 $390,000
Year 3 $345,000
Year 4 $300,000
Year 5 $240,000
Future Value of Working Capital: Calculated using the formula as FV=PV (1+K)n
Year Calculations Result
Year 1 Fv= 140,000 x (1+ 0.1)1 $154,000
P a g e 9 | 18
R1910D9456174
Net Cash Flows: Calculated using the Cash inflow (CI) + scrap value (SV) – variable cost
(VC)– future value of working capital (FVWC)
Year Calculations Result
Year 1 $650,000-$27,000 $623,000
Year 2 $698,750-$28,830 $669,920
Year 3 $751,156-$30,776 $720,380
Year 4 $807,493-$32,853 $774,640
Year 5 $868,055 + $375,000 - $35,071 - $225,471 $982,513
Taxable Cash Flows: Calculated using the Net Cash flow (CI) – capital Allowance (CA).
Year Calculations Result
Year 1 $623,000 - 600,000 $23,000
Year 2 $669,920 – 390,000 $279,920
Year 3 $720,380 – 345,000 $375,380
Year 4 $774,640 – 300,000 $474,640
Year 5 $982,513 – 240,000 $742,513
Taxes at 20%: This is calculated using the Net Cash flow (CI) – capital Allowance (CA).
Year Calculations Result
Year 1 Payment will be done the following year
Year 2 $23,000 x 20% $4,000
Year 3 $279,920 x 20% $55,984
Year 4 $375,380 x 20% $75,076
Year 5 $474,640 x 20% $94,928
Year 6 $742,513 x 20% $148,503
Present Value: Calculated by multiplying net cash flows with discount factor.
Year Calculations Result
Year 1 $623,000 x 0.90909 $566,363
Year 2 $669,920 x 0.82645 $553,655
Year 3 $720,380 x 0.75131 $541,229
Year 4 $774,640 x 0.68193 $528,250
Year 5 $982,513 x 0.62092 $610,062
Net Present Value: This is calculated as, Net present value (NPV)= Sum of Present value of
cash inflow (SPVCI)– Sum of Present value of cash outflows (SPVCO).
Calculation was done using an excel package to arrive at the result shown in the table below.
P a g e 11 | 18
R1910D9456174
Year 0 $ -2,390,000.00
$ 2,390,258.75
Net Present Value $ 258.75
Internal Rate of Return 16%
Payback Period: The time taken to get the initial capital is referred to as payback period.
The inflows will be added up until we have the value of the initial capital of $2,390,000.00.
Year Cash flow Year 1 & 2 Year 1,2&3 Year 1,2,3&4 Result at
3.6years
1 $623,000.0
0
2 $669,920.0 $ 1,292,920 $ 2,013,300
0
3 $720,380.0 $ 2,733,680
0
4 $774,640.0 > Payback $ 64,553
0 Period
5 $982,513.0 Monthly $2,400,618
0 rate in year
four
It will take approximately 3years 6months less few days for payback according to the calculation
above.
P a g e 12 | 18
R1910D9456174
Material Cost:
Year Calculations Result
Year 1 $14,400 and to increase by 7.5% $14,400
annually.
Year 2 $14,400+7.5% $15,480
Year 3 $15,480 +7.5% $16,641
Year 4 $16,641+7.5% $17,889
Year 5 $17,889+7.5% $19,231
Year 6 $19,231+ 7.5% $20,673
Other Expenses:
Year Calculations Result
Year 1 $18,000 and to decrease by 7.5% $18,000
annually.
Year 2 $18,000 -7.5% $16,650
Year 3 $16,650-7.5% $15,401
Year 4 $15,401-7.5% $14,246
Year 5 $14,246- 7.5% $13,178
P a g e 13 | 18
R1910D9456174
Earnings before Interest and Taxes (EBIT): This is calculated by subtracting Cash inflows
from the additions of material cost, other expenses and rental forgone.
Year Calculations Result
Year 1 $955,000- $14,400 +$18,000+$75,000 $847,600
Year 2 $955,000- $15,480 +$16,650+$75,000 $847,870
Year 3 $955,000- $16,641 +$15,401+$75,000 $847,958
Year 4 $955,000- $17,889 +$14,246+$75,000 $847,865
Year 5 $955,000- $19,231 +$13,178+$75,000 $847,591
Net Cash Flows: Subtracting Cash inflows from the additions of material cost, other expenses
and rental forgone.
Year Calculations Result
Year 1 $955,000- $14,400 -$18,000-$75,000-0 $847,600
Year 2 $955,000- $15,480 -$16,650-$75,000-$169,520 $678,350
Year 3 $955,000- $16,641 -$15,401-$75,000-$169,574 $678,384
Year 4 $955,000- $17,889 -$14,246-$75,000-$169,592 $678,273
Year 5 $955,000- $19,231 -$13,178-$75,000-$169,573 $678,018
P a g e 14 | 18
R1910D9456174
$ 2,250,000
1 $ 847,600.00
2 $ 678,350.00
3 $ 678,384.00 $ 2,204,334.00
4 $ 678,273.00 $ 2,882,607.00 $ 56,523
5 $ 678,018.00 Monthly $2,260,857
rate in year
four
References:
Counttuts (2019) ‘Payback Period| Explained with Examples’ [Online] Available at:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lfyjasinZdY (Accessed 13th August 2020).
Donald Rutherford (2012) ‘Routledge Dictionary of Economics, p72’ [Online] Available at:
https://ebookcentral-proquest-com.ergo.southwales.ac.uk/lib/usw/reader.action?
docID=1244570&ppg=6# (Accessed 12th August 2020).
Duncan A.Mellichamp (2017) ‘Internal rate of return: Good and bad features, and a new way of
interpreting the historic measure’ Computers & Chemical Engineering Volume 106, Pages 396-
406 [Online] Available at:
https://www-sciencedirect-com.ergo.southwales.ac.uk/science/article/pii/S009813541730251X
(Accessed 14th August 2020).
Henry Toch BCom (2985) ‘7 - Capital Allowances’Income Tax Made Simple. 1985, Pages 89-
105 [Online] Available at: https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-434-98606-4.50012-0 (Accessed 13th
August 2020).
Investopedia, (2019) ‘The Impact of Financing’ CORPORATE FINANCE &
ACCOUNTING [Online] Available at: https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/051315/how-
does-equity-financing-affect-companys-financials-compared-effects-debt-financing.asp
(Accessed 15th August, 2020).
Learn accounting (2019) ‘Capital Investment Appraisal’ [Online] Available at:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hEkFq3y7Evk (Accessed 10th August 2020).
Pontema Training (2018) ‘Business Investment Appraisal Techniques’ [Online] Available at:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=57BY2dQfUVs (Accessed 12th August 2020).
Mario Fischer (2017) ‘The source of financing in mergers and acquisitions’ The Quarterly
Review of Economics and Finance Volume 65, Pages 227-239 [Online] Available at:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.qref.2017.01.003 (Accessed 12th August 2020).
Murray Z. Frank & Tao Shen, (2016) ‘Investment and the weighted average cost of capital’
Journal of Financial Economics Volume 119, Issue 2, Pages 300-315 [Online] Available at
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfineco.2015.09.001 (Accessed 13th August 2020).
pmtycoon (2015) ‘NPV - Net Present Value, IRR - Internal Rate of Return, Payback Period.’
P a g e 16 | 18
R1910D9456174
[Online] Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C5o6U7zOebM (Accessed 13th
August 2020).
SHOBHIT SETH (2019), ‘What is the Formula for Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC)?’
CORPORATE FINANCE & ACCOUNTING FINANCIAL RATIOS [Online] Available at
https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/063014/what-formula-calculating-weighted-average-
cost-capital-wacc.asp (Accessed 15th August, 2020)
tutor2u (2019), ‘Investment Appraisal: Factors Influencing Investment Decisions’ [Online]
Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tM5cDJOLqI0 (Accessed 12th August 2020).
University of South Wales ‘Summative Assessment 2 Brief and Marking Scheme V2’ [Online]
Available at: https://vle-usw.unicaf.org/mod/resource/view.php?id=181233 (Accessed 15th
August 2020).
Revision App - Student Blog, 2014 ‘Business Studies - Sources of Finance: Business Exam
Tips’ [Online] Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c8hIwQ5xFY8 (Accessed 14th
August 2020).
P a g e 17 | 18