GST Tax 2
GST Tax 2
GST Tax 2
A
PROJECT
REPORT ON
A STUDY ON THE FINALCIAL MARKETS
SUBMITTED TO
ADMINISTRATION SUBMITTED BY
MBA, FINANCE
ACADMIC YEAR
2023-2025
1
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
DE
CLARATION
I, the undersigned, hereby declare that the Project Report entitled “A STUDY
ON THE FINANCIAL MARKET” written and submitted by me to the
Savitribai Phule Pune University Pune, in partial fulfillment of the
requirement for the award of the degree of Master of Business Administration
under the guidance of Prof. DRUGA BANSODE is my original work except for
the topics on organizational profile and the conclusion drawn therein are based
on the material collected by myself.
2
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
GUIDE CERTIFICATE
3
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
4
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
1 Introduction 8
2 Organizational Profile 13
Industry Profile 14 – 15
Vision, Mission
History
Product Profile
3 Research Methodology 16
Data Collection 17
4 Conceptual Background 18
Literature Review 19 – 36
7 Bibliography 52 – 53
8 Appendix/Annexure 54 – 57
5
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
This project aims to explore the key financial market. There are two types of financial
market are there 1. Capital market 2. Money market
The below diagram showing the more details about financial market
6
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
INTRODUCTION
7
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
2. Corporate Tax: Paid by companies on their net profit, this includes domestic
companies, foreign companies operating in India, and some special entities like
LLPs (Limited Liability Partnerships).
Types of GST:
1. CGST (Central GST): Collected by the central government on intra-state
transactions.
2. SGST (State GST): Collected by state governments on intra-state transactions.
8
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
9
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
Fiscal Policy: Exploration of the roles that Income Tax and GST play in shaping India’s
fiscal policy and influencing resource mobilization.
10
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
CHAPTER 2
ORGANISATIONAL PROFILE
11
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
INDUSTRY PROFILE
LOGO
VISION
“To be a leading provider of tax consulting and GST services,
empowering clients with comprehensive, innovative, and effective tax solutions while
ensuring compliance, fostering trust, and contributing to their financial growth and
success”
MISSION
“To deliver expert tax consultancy and GST services with integrity and
professionalism, ensuring our clients receive personalized solutions that enhance
their financial well-being, optimize tax liabilities, and navigate the complexities
of the tax landscape efficiently. We aim to build lasting relationships through
transparency, education, and proactive support, helping clients achieve their
business goals."
12
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
Over the years, the firm has expanded its services to include comprehensive tax
planning, compliance support, and advisory services tailored to the unique needs of
various industries. With a commitment to excellence and client satisfaction, Bhakti
Associates has built a reputation for delivering high-quality solutions and fostering long-
term relationships with its clients.
Today, Bhakti Associates continues to evolve, staying updated with the latest tax
regulations and leveraging technology to enhance service delivery, ensuring clients are
well-equipped to meet their tax obligations and maximize their financial potential.
OUR SERVICES
Tax Consultancy
Goods and Services Tax (GST) Services
Tax Planning and Optimization
Representation Before Tax Authorities
Corporate Tax Services
Bookkeeping and Accounting Services
Training and Workshops
Business Advisory Services
Financial Planning
Specialized Industry Services
13
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
CHAPTER 3
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
14
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
A Research design is a method and procedure for acquiring information
needed to solve the problem. A research design is the basic plan that helps in the data
collection or analysis. It specifies the type of information to be collected the sources
and data collection procedure. The present study is descriptive and it is a fact-finding
investigation with adequate interpretation. It is undertaken in many circumstances.
When the researcher is interested in knowing, the characteristics of certain groups such
as age, educational level, occupation or income, interested in knowing the proportion
of in a given population who have behaved in particular manner, making the
projections of certain things, or determining the relationships between two or more
variables, descriptive study may be necessary. Descriptive data are commonly used as
directed bases of marketing decisions; these studies are well structured.
DATA COLLECTION
In order to information from the respondent survey method has been
adopted. A neatly constructed questionnaire was prepared to collect information
from the respondents regarding information about the mutual fund. It contains both
open- ended and close-ended questionnaire.
PRIMARY DATA
Primary data is the first-hand data collected by the researcher directly it’s the
fresh data. Primary data was obtained through direct communication with respondents
SECONDARY DATA
Secondary data is the already available information collected someone
hence for their own study purpose and it is the published sources of information.
The secondary data sources for this study purpose are:
• Reference books
• Company broachers, documents & other related materials
• Websites
15
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
CHAPTER 4
CONCEPTUAL BACKGROUND
16
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
Literature Review
1. Introduction to Taxation
Taxation is essential for government revenue, categorized into direct (Income
Tax) and indirect (Goods and Services Tax - GST) taxes. Musgrave and Musgrave (1989)
highlight how these taxes impact economic behavior.
2. Income Tax
Income Tax is a direct tax on earnings, influencing financial decisions and public
goods financing. Auerbach (2002) notes its progressive nature, while Slemrod (2004)
emphasizes compliance challenges due to its complexity.
3. Goods and Services Tax (GST)
GST simplifies the indirect tax system, promoting efficiency and reducing the
cascading effect of taxes. According to the Economic Survey of India (2018), it enhances
business ease but presents compliance challenges, especially for SMEs (Bhatia & Singh,
2019).
17
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
DIFFERENCE -
Income tax and the Goods and Services Tax (GST) are two distinct tax regimes
with distinct goals. Aiming to streamline the tax system by replacing a number of other
indirect taxes, the Goods and Services Tax (GST) is an indirect tax on the supply of
goods and services based on consumption. On the other hand, income tax is a kind of
direct tax that is imposed on individuals and companies according to their profits. It is
enforced by the government to generate funds for public service and social welfare
initiatives. Compared to GST, which focuses on taxing consumption and focusses on the
earning potential of individuals and businesses, income tax is more personalised and
based on income levels. In this article, we will compare and differentiate these two tax
regimes In detail.
A Detailed Overview-
India's tax system was completely transformed by the Goods and Services Tax
(GST), which combined several indirect taxes into a single structure. It was put into
effect on July 1, 2017, and it ensures efficiency by streamlining taxes through staged
levies on products and services. This coordinated strategy promotes a smooth market and
gets rid of tax cascades. GST improves individual tax compliance and corporate
operations by displacing taxes such as VAT and Central Excise. Benefits include
consistent tax rates, streamlined administration, and service accessibility through the GST
site. In general, GST encourages economic growth by formalising firms, lowering tax
costs, and promoting transparency.
18
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
inbound supply from suppliers To claim the Input Tax Credit (ITC), use GSTR-1.
• GSTR-2B: Provides monthly ITC data and is static, akin to GSTR-2A. Every
month on the 12th, it is available.
• GSTR-4: An annual return for taxpayers with compositions that took the place of
GSTR-9A as of FY 2019–20. Deadline: April 30th of the upcoming year.
• GSTR-6: Input Service Distributors (ISD) monthly return that describes the input
tax credit that is received and disbursed.
• GSTR-8: A monthly return with details on suppliers and TCS collected that is
filed by e-commerce businesses that collect TCS.
• GSTR-9C: Taxpayers having a turnover over Rs. 5 crore are required to file
GSTR-9C, a reconciliation statement, by December 31 of the subsequent year.
19
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
• GSTR-11: A form that lists inbound supplies and claimed refunds that is filed by
people who have been given a Unique Identity Number (UIN) for refund reasons.
Depending on the kind of return and the taxpayer's annual revenue, there
are differences in the filing and due dates for other GST files. For example, GSTR-1 is
due on the eleventh day of the next month, and GSTR-3B is due on the twentieth day.
The following fiscal year's annual return, GSTR-9, is due on December 31. A taxpayer
may choose to submit GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B on a quarterly basis instead of monthly if
their revenue is up to Rs. 5 crores. In order to avoid late fines and interest, taxpayers must
adhere to the deadlines.
Penalties for inaccurate or incomplete filings, fines, interest, and even jail
time for tax evasion may be levied if the GST requirements are not fulfilled. With a
cap of 0.25% of the taxpayer's revenue, late fees for late GST returns are
assessed at a rate of Rs. 50 per day (or Rs. 20 for taxpayers who are not required to file).
An additional 18% yearly interest rate is applied to any underpaid or past-due taxes. To
cancel transferring their GST registration, compliant taxpayers must follow compliance
guidelines and file their returns on time.
20
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
200% of the avoided tax, interest on overdue taxes, and fines of up to Rs 10,000 for late
filing. There are situations where evading taxes or fabricating paperwork might land you
in jail. To avoid these fines, income tax returns must be accurately filed and submitted on
time.
Applicability:
GST applies to both goods and services, covering all transactions including sales,
transfers, barter, lease, or import of goods and services.
Different Rates:
GST has different rates depending on the category of goods or services. Essential
items, such as food grains, often attract a lower GST rate or are exempt, while luxury
items and certain services may attract higher rates. The standard GST rates in India are
5%, 12%, 18%, and 28%, which are applied based on the classification of the goods or
services involved.
21
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
Income Tax:
Income Tax is a direct tax levied on the total income of individuals, Hindu
Undivided Families (HUFs), companies, firms, and other entities. The tax is calculated
based on the income earned during a financial year, after considering various deductions
and exemptions allowed under the Income Tax Act.
Applicability:
Income Tax applies to the total income, including salary, business profits, capital
gains, rent, and other sources of income. It is mandatory for individuals and entities with
income above a certain threshold to file an income tax return and pay the applicable tax.
GST:
The calculation of GST is based on the value of goods or services supplied. The
tax is levied at multiple rates depending on the category of goods or services. For
example:
5% GST: Applicable to basic necessities and certain food items.
The tax rate applicable to a product or service determines the GST amount, which
is collected from the consumer and remitted to the government.
22
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
Income Tax:
Income Tax is calculated based on the taxable income of the individual or entity.
Taxable income is the gross income minus any deductions and exemptions allowed under
the law. The tax rate varies according to the income level and type of taxpayer:
Individuals:
Tax slabs for individuals are progressive, meaning higher income leads to higher
tax rates. For example, an individual with an annual income up to Rs. 2.5 lakh may not
pay any tax, while those earning more than Rs. 10 lakh could be taxed at 30%.
Companies:
Companies are taxed at a flat rate, which may vary depending on the type and size
of the company. For instance, domestic companies may be taxed at 25% or 30%, while
certain concessional rates are available for new manufacturing companies.
GST:
GST requires businesses to file periodic returns to report their sales, purchases, and
tax paid. The main returns include:
GSTR-1:
Monthly or quarterly return detailing all outward supplies (sales) made by the
business.
GSTR-3B:
A summary return filed monthly, showing the tax liability, ITC claimed, and net tax
payable.
GSTR-9:
An annual return summarizing all the monthly returns filed during the financial
year.
Income Tax:
Income Tax filing is an annual process, where individuals and businesses must
file their returns for the previous financial year using the appropriate ITR (Income Tax
23
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
Annual Filing:
All taxpayers must file their returns by the specified due date, typically by July
31st for individuals and September 30th for companies, unless extended by the
government.
Payment of Taxes:
Taxpayers may need to pay advance tax during the year if their tax liability
exceeds Rs. 10,000. Self-assessment tax and any balance tax liability must be paid before
filing the return.
GST:
Compliance under GST involves several key components:
Invoicing: Issuing GST-compliant invoices that include specific details such as
GSTIN, HSN/SAC codes, and GST rates applied.
Input Tax Credit (ITC): The ITC mechanism allows businesses to claim credit
for GST paid on inputs and adjust it against their output tax liability. Accurate
matching of invoices is necessary to claim ITC.
Income Tax:
24
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
income earned and tax deducted at source (TDS). Form 16A is provided for non-
salary income.
Tax Audit Requirements: Certain businesses must undergo a tax audit if their
turnover exceeds specified limits.
25
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
Advantages:
3. Boost to Economy:
o Encourages more formal economic transactions, increasing tax revenue for
the government.
6. Increased Transparency:
o Helps in reducing corruption and improving compliance through clearer
rules.
Disadvantages:
1. Complex Compliance:
o Initial challenges in understanding and complying with the GST
framework, especially for small businesses.
2. Technical Issues:
o Reliance on technology can lead to challenges, such as server downtimes
and filing errors.
26
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
Income Tax
Advantages:
3. Encouragement of Savings:
o Deductions and exemptions can incentivize individuals to save and invest.
4. Simplicity in Compliance:
o Generally, a more straightforward filing process for individuals compared
to business taxes.
Disadvantages:
1. Complexity in Filing:
o Deductions, exemptions, and varying rates can complicate the filing
process for individuals and businesses.
27
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
4. Inequality in Enforcement:
o Disparities in enforcement can lead to unequal tax burdens among
different income groups.
5. Administrative Costs:
o Significant costs involved in tax administration and enforcement can
reduce overall efficiency.
Types of GST
5. Composition Scheme:
o A simplified scheme for small taxpayers with a turnover below a specified
limit. It allows them to pay a fixed percentage of turnover as tax rather
than the regular GST rates.
1. Individual Taxation:
28
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
o Slab Rates: Income tax for individuals is based on different income slabs,
with progressive rates.
o New Regime: Introduced in FY 2020-21, this allows taxpayers to pay
lower rates but without most exemptions and deductions.
2. Corporate Taxation:
o Domestic Companies: Different tax rates apply depending on the
company's turnover and whether they opt for the old or new tax regime.
o Foreign Companies: Taxed at a different rate based on their income
earned in India.
6. Residential Status:
o Taxation also depends on the taxpayer's residential status (resident, non-
resident, or resident but not ordinarily resident), affecting the scope of
income subject to tax in India.
29
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
30
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
31
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
32
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
Rewards:
3. Increased Transparency:
o Digital tracking reduces corruption and tax evasion, leading to a fairer tax
environment.
4. Boost to Business:
o
P
romotes a unified market across states, encouraging trade and business expansion.
33
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
o Potential for increased revenue collection due to better compliance and reduced
evasion.
Risks:
1. Complex Compliance:
o Initial implementation can be challenging, especially for small businesses without
adequate resources.
2. Technical Challenges:
o Dependence on technology can lead to issues like server downtime or data
discrepancies.
34
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
Income Tax
Rewards:
1. Progressive Taxation:
o Higher income earners pay a larger percentage, promoting equity in the tax system.
Risks:
3. Economic Impact:
o High income tax rates can discourage investment and entrepreneurship, potentially
slowing economic growth.
4. Administrative Costs:
o Significant resources required for tax administration can reduce overall efficiency.
5. Inequality in Enforcement:
35
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
o Disparities in enforcement can lead to unequal tax burdens, causing frustration among
compliant taxpayers.
CASCANDING
The Goods and Services Tax (GST) plays a crucial role in reducing the cascading
effect of multiple taxes. The cascading effect, often called "tax on tax," occurs when a tax
is levied on a product at every stage of the production and distribution chain without
providing any credit for the tax paid at earlier stages. Here’s how GST addresses this
issue:
1. Unified Tax Structure:
GST is a comprehensive, destination-based tax levied on the supply of goods and
services. It has subsumed multiple indirect taxes like VAT, Central Excise, Service Tax,
etc., which used to be applied separately at different stages. Under GST, there is one
single tax from the manufacturer to the consumer, which reduces the layers of taxes.
2. Input Tax Credit (ITC):
GST allows businesses to claim input tax credit on taxes paid at previous stages of
production or services. For example, a manufacturer who purchases raw materials can
offset the GST paid on those materials against the GST to be paid when selling the
finished product. This mechanism ensures that tax is levied only on the value addition at
each stage, significantly reducing the tax burden on end consumers.
3. Elimination of Tax on Tax:
In the previous regime, taxes were levied on the total price, including taxes paid at
earlier stages, leading to a cascading effect. Under GST, tax is only charged on the value
added at each step. This has eliminated the compounding tax effects and reduced the
overall cost of goods and services.
4. Streamlined Compliance and Administration:
The simplification of tax rates and procedures under GST has led to easier
36
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
compliance for businesses. A more streamlined tax system, with fewer complexities,
helps reduce the chances of taxes being applied inefficiently, preventing double taxation
and cascading.
5. Reduction in Cost of Goods and Services:
By mitigating the cascading effect, GST has lowered the overall tax burden on
goods and services, which in turn helps reduce prices for consumers. This creates a more
efficient and competitive market.
CHAPTER 5
DATA ANALYSIS &
INTERPRETATION
37
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
Very High 20
High 30
Moderate 25
Low 15
None 10
Response Count
10%
20% Very High
High
15% Moderate
Low
None
30%
25%
DATA ANALYSIS
The data indicates that 50% of respondents have a strong understanding of Income Tax,
with 20% rating their knowledge as "Very High" and 30% as "High." However, 25% of
respondents reported a "Moderate" understanding, suggesting a need for improved
educational initiatives. Notably, 25% indicated a "Low" or "None" level of
understanding, highlighting a segment at risk of non-compliance.
38
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
respondent count
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
Very High High Moderate Low None
respondent count
DATA ANALYSIS
The data shows that 60% of respondents have a "High" or "Very High" understanding
of GST, indicating a strong general awareness. About 20% have a "Moderate"
understanding, while 15% report a "Low" level of knowledge. Only 5% of
respondents have no understanding of GST. Overall, the majority seem to be well-
informed, with relatively few lacking awareness.
39
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
Chart Title
100%
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Income Tax GST Both are equally significant Unsure
DATA ANALYSIS
The data shows that 40% of respondents believe GST is more significant for the
economy, while 30% think Income Tax is more important. Another 20% consider both
taxes equally significant, and 10% are unsure. This suggests that GST is viewed as
slightly more impactful, but a sizable portion also sees the importance of Income Tax or
both taxes combined.
40
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
4. Do you believe that Income Tax and GST serve different purposes?
Respondent
DATA ANALYSIS
The data shows that 70% of respondents believe Income Tax and GST serve different
purposes, while 20% think they do not. Only 10% are unsure. This suggests that most
people recognize the distinct roles these taxes play in the economy.
41
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
5. How familiar are you with the concept of direct and indirect
taxes?
Chart Title
45%
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
Very Familiar Familiar Somewhat Familiar Not Familiar
DATA ANALYSIS
The data shows that 70% of respondents are either "Familiar" or "Very Familiar" with
the concept of direct and indirect taxes, indicating widespread understanding. Around
20% are "Somewhat Familiar," while only 10% are not familiar, suggesting that the
majority have at least some knowledge of these tax types.
42
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
Respondent
DATA ANALYSIS
The data indicates that 45% of respondents believe Income Tax is more transparent,
likely due to the direct involvement in filing and payment. GST is seen as transparent by
30% of respondents, though it’s less visible since it's embedded in prices. Another 20%
find both taxes equally transparent, suggesting they perceive clarity in both systems,
while 5% remain unsure. Overall, Income Tax is viewed as more transparent in its
collection and usage.
43
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
Chart Title
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
Very Positively Series2
Positively
Negatively Respondent
Very Negatively
No Impact
Respondent Series2
DATA ANALYSIS
The survey data shows that 40% of respondents feel Income Tax negatively impacts
their financial planning, likely due to reduced disposable income or complexities in
managing taxes. 20% view it very negatively, citing a significant burden on earnings.
Meanwhile, 25% see a positive impact, perhaps from tax-saving opportunities, and 10%
find it very positive due to incentives for savings and investment. Only 5% believe it has
no impact, suggesting that tax planning or income levels may shield them from its effects.
Overall, Income Tax is seen more negatively in terms of financial planning.
44
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
Chart Title
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
Very Positively Positively Negatively Very Negatively
DATA ANALYSIS
The survey data shows that 35% of respondents feel GST negatively impacts small
businesses, likely due to the complexity of compliance and cash flow issues caused by
delayed input tax credits. 15% view the impact as very negative, citing increased
operational burdens. On the positive side, 30% believe GST benefits their business by
simplifying the tax structure and improving transparency, while 15% see a very positive
impact due to easier compliance. Only 5% feel GST has no impact, likely because they
fall below the threshold or have adapted well. Overall, opinions are mixed, but the
negative view dominates slightly.
45
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
Respondent
45%
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
x T s y lt re
e
ta GS ea cu
nsu
m lly iffi U
co ua l l yd
In eq ua
e eq
ar e
th ar
Bo th
Bo
Respondent
DATA ANALYSIS
The survey data reveals that 40% of respondents find Income Tax easier to comply with,
likely due to clearer guidelines and a more straightforward filing process. 25% feel that
GST is easier, appreciating its online filing systems. Additionally, 20% believe both
taxes are equally easy, indicating satisfaction with compliance for both. However, 10%
find both taxes equally difficult, suggesting challenges in navigating the complexities
involved. Only 5% are unsure, indicating a limited familiarity with the tax systems.
Overall, Income Tax is perceived as the easier option for compliance.
46
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
10. Do you feel that the tax system in your country is fair?
Respondent
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
Yes No Somewhat Unsure
Respondent
DATA ANALYSIS
The survey data shows that 40% of respondents believe the tax system in their country is
unfair, indicating significant dissatisfaction with aspects like high rates or perceived
inequities. 30% feel the system is fair, suggesting some appreciation for its benefits,
while 25% think it is somewhat fair, reflecting a mix of opinions on the system's
strengths and weaknesses. Only 5% are unsure about its fairness, pointing to a lack of
confidence or knowledge regarding tax policies. Overall, a majority perceive the tax
system as unfair, highlighting the need for reform or improvement.
47
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
CHAPTER 6
FINDINGS, SUGGESTIONS, MY
LEARNING,
CONTRIBUTION TO THE
ORGANIZATION
&
CONCLUSION
48
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
FINDINGS
Perception of Transparency:
Income Tax is perceived as more transparent in its collection and usage, with a
significant majority of respondents believing that taxpayers have a clearer understanding
of how much they owe compared to GST, which is often embedded in the prices of
goods and services.
Ease of Compliance:
A larger percentage of respondents find Income Tax easier to comply with
compared to GST, suggesting that the filing process for Income Tax is perceived as
clearer and more straightforward.
49
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
CONCLUSION
Perceived Complexity:
GST is often viewed as more complex than Income Tax, especially for small
businesses, leading to higher compliance costs and administrative burdens.
Equity in Taxation:
The perception of fairness leans towards Income Tax being more equitable for
individuals, while GST is seen as disproportionately affecting small businesses and
lower-income groups due to its nature as a consumption tax.
50
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
SUGGESTIONS
Feedback Mechanism:
Establishing a feedback mechanism for taxpayers to voice their concerns and
suggestions can lead to improvements in tax policies and compliance measures. This will
enhance taxpayer engagement and satisfaction.
51
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
CHAPTER-7
BIBLIOGRAPHY
52
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
BIBLIOGRAPHY
WEBSITES:
www.google.com
www.wikipedia.com
[email protected]
www.ascent-online.com
www.amfiindia.com
www.sebi.org.in
www.mutualfundsindia.com
www.investsmartindia.com
53
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
CHAPTER-8
ANNEXURE
54
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
ANNEXURE
Dear Sir/Madam,
I am Kunal Ramchandra Maradkar a student of “Sinhgad Institute of
Management and Computer Application” – MBA Program, final year MBA
(Finance) doing a project in Bhakti Associates Tax Consultant and GST
Practitioner, Pune. The topic of my project is “A STUDY ON DIFFERENCE
BETWEEN INCOME TAX AND GST” in India with reference to Bhakti
Associates Tax Consultant and GST Practitioner, Pune. I need some important
information from you for the completion of my project.
Would you please spare sometime to answer my queries? I assure you that
your answers will be kept confidential and will be used for the academic
purpose only.
AGE: 22
55
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
QUESTIONNAIRE
4. Do you believe that Income Tax and GST serve different purposes?
o Yes
o No
o Not Sure
Knowledge of Taxation
5. How familiar are you with the concept of direct and indirect taxes?
o Very Familiar
o Familiar
o Somewhat Familiar
o Not Familiar
6. Which type of tax do you think is more transparent in its collection and
usage?
o Income Tax
o GST
o Both
o Unsure
56
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
57
SINHGAD INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT AND COMPUTER APPLICATION, PUNE
10. Do you feel that the tax system in your country is fair?
o Yes
o No
o Somewhat
o Unsure
58