Executive Summary Jharkhand-English
Executive Summary Jharkhand-English
Executive Summary Jharkhand-English
Hkkjr ljdkj LokLF; ,oa ifjokj dY;k.k ea=ky; fuekZ.k Hkou] ubZ fnYyh & 110011
This executive summary presents, in brief, findings on the situation of youth in Jharkhand, part of a sub-national study undertaken by the International Institute for Population Sciences, Mumbai and the Population Council, New Delhi, as part of a project to collect information on key transitions experienced by youth in India, including those related to education, work force participation, sexual activity, marriage, health and civic participation; the magnitude and patterns of young peoples sexual and reproductive practices before, within and outside of marriage as well as related knowledge, decision-making and attitudes. The project was implemented in six states of India, namely, Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Jharkhand, Maharashtra, Rajasthan and Tamil Nadu.
For detailed reports please contact: International Institute for Population Sciences Govandi Station Road, Deonar Mumbai 400088 India Phone: 022-25563254-3256 email: [email protected] Website: http://www.iipsindia.org Population Council Zone 5-A, Ground Floor India Habitat Centre Lodi Road New Delhi 110003 Phone: 011-2464 2901/02 email: [email protected] Website: http://www.popcouncil.org/asia/india.html
The International Institute for Population Sciences (IIPS) is a deemed university under administrative control of Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India. The Institute engages in teaching and research in population sciences, and has been actively involved in building the capacity of Population Research Centres, and other state and central government offices that address population issues in the country and in the Asia-Pacific region. It has a proven record in conducting national- and sub-national-level studies in reproductive health, including the National Family Health Surveys and District Level Household and Facility Survey under the Reproductive and Child Health programme. The Population Council is an international, non-profit, non-governmental organisation that seeks to improve the well-being and reproductive health of current and future generations around the world and to help achieve a humane, equitable and sustainable balance between people and resources. The Council conducts biomedical, social science and public health research, and helps build research capacities in developing countries. Copyright 2009 International Institute for Population Sciences, Mumbai and Population Council, New Delhi Suggested citation: International Institute for Population Sciences (IIPS) and Population Council. 2009. Youth in India: Situation and Needs 2006-2007, Executive Summary, Jharkhand. Mumbai: IIPS.
he Youth in India: Situation and Needs study (referred to as the Youth Study), implemented by the International Institute for Population Sciences, Mumbai and the Population Council, New Delhi is the first-ever sub-nationally representative study conducted to identify key transitions experienced by married and unmarried youth in India. Young people (aged 1024) constituted almost 315 million and represented 31% of the Indian population in 2001. Not only does this cohort represent Indias future in the socio-economic and political realms, but its experiences will largely determine Indias achievement of its goal of population stabilisation and the extent to which the nation will be able to harness its demographic dividend. While todays youth are healthier, more urbanised and better educated than earlier generations, social and economic vulnerabilities persist. In the course of the transition to adulthood, moreover, young people face significant risks related to sexual and reproductive health, and many lack the knowledge and power to make informed sexual and reproductive choices. In recognition of the importance of investing in young people, several national policies and programmes formulated since 2000, including the National Population Policy 2000, the National Youth Policy 2003, the Tenth and Eleventh Five-Year Plans, the National Adolescent Reproductive and Sexual Health Strategy and the National Rural Health Mission, have underscored a commitment to addressing the multiple needs of this group in India. Effective implementation of both policies and programmes, however, has been handicapped by the lack of evidence on young peoples situation and needs. Currently available evidence is limited, at best, and comes largely from small-scale and unrepresentative studies. The Youth Study focused on married and unmarried young women and unmarried young men aged 1524 and, because of the paucity of married young men in the younger ages, married men aged 1529 in both rural and urban settings. The study collected information pertaining to key transitions experienced by youth, including those related to education, work participation, sexual activity, marriage, health and civic participation; the magnitude and patterns of young peoples sexual and reproductive practices within and outside of marriage as well as related knowledge, decision-making and attitudes. The Youth Study comprised three phases, and included both a survey and qualitative data gathering exercises prior to and after the survey. The study was conducted in a phased manner in six states of India: Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Jharkhand, Maharashtra, Rajasthan and Tamil Nadu. This report focuses on findings from the survey conducted in Jharkhand. The survey was undertaken between February and October 2006. During the survey, 10,708 young people were contacted, of which a total of 8,814 married and unmarried young women and men were successfully interviewed.
Situation of youth
As mentioned earlier, a total of 8,814 youth were interviewed. Age profiles suggest that a larger proportion of young men and women were concentrated in the 1519 year age group than in the 2024 year age group (5657% compared to 4344%). Moreover, the unmarried were younger than the married. Distributions by religion show that 7072% of youth were Hindu, 1314% were Muslim and 1113% belonged to the Sarna religion. Caste-wise distributions show that 1216%
of youth belonged to general castes, 14% to scheduled castes, 2425% to scheduled tribes and 4649% to other backward castes. About four in five youth reported that both parents were surviving. For those with just one parent surviving, this parent was more likely to be the mother (12%) than the father (46%). Finally, 23% reported that neither parent was alive.
Education
While youth were better educated than the general population in Jharkhand, schooling was far from universal among young people in the state. As many as one in seven young men and two in five young women had never attended school. Findings show, moreover, that young women in rural areas and married young women in general were particularly disadvantaged; about or more than half of rural young women and married young women had never been to school. Not only was school enrolment limited, but school completion rates were also low among young people, particularly young women. For example, among young women, of those who had completed Class 1, only 93% had completed Class 3, Cumulative percentage of youth who had completed each year and completion rates fell of education (Classes 1 to 17), Jharkhand (combined), 2006 below 90% in Class 4. Among young men, in contrast, 95% had completed Class 4, and completion rates fell below 90% in Class 6. Declines in school completion became progressively steeper as the level of schooling increased. There was a particularly steep decline between Classes 8 and 11, suggesting that MM=Married men; MW=Married women; UM=Unmarried men; UW=Unmarried women many youth discontinued their education at high Cumulative percentage of youth who had completed each year school level. Indeed, just of education (Classes 1 to 17), Jharkhand (urban), 2006 32% of young men and 16% of young women in the state had completed high school. What is notable is that, at the time of interview, almost half of all unmarried youth (and very few married) were still in school or college. Among the unmarried, moreover, an almost equal percentage of young men and women were MM=Married men; MW=Married women; UM=Unmarried men; UW=Unmarried women pursuing their education.
Leading reasons for never Cumulative percentage of youth who had completed each year attending school among of education (Classes 1 to 17), Jharkhand (rural), 2006 young men and women were economic (for example, the respondent was required for work on the family farm/business or for outside wage earning work, or the family could not afford school-related expenses) and attitude and perceptionrelated (for example, education was unnecessary or the respondent was not MM=Married men; MW=Married women; UM=Unmarried men; UW=Unmarried women interested in schooling). Housework-related factors (the respondent was required for care of siblings or housework) were additionally important reasons for young women never going to school. Percentage of youth who had discontinued schooling by class when discontinued and reasons for discontinuation, Jharkhand, 2006
Among those who had ever been to school, gender differences in reasons for school discontinuation became more apparent. Leading reasons for school discontinuation among young men and women, irrespective of the level at which schooling was discontinued, continued to be economic issues and attitude or perception-related factors. However, for young women, other factors were also important: school-related reasons (for example, academic failure, distance to school, poor school quality and infrastructure) and housework responsibilities were significant factors for discontinuation at all levels. Of note, particularly, is that over one in five married young women who discontinued their education before completing Class 7 and half or more of married young women who discontinued their education in Classes 79 and 1011, respectively, reported doing so in order to marry.
A gender divide was also observed in the type of educational facility that youth attended. While young men, typically attended co-educational facilities at all levels of education, young women were less likely to attend a co-educational facility at higher levels of schooling. Moreover, while fewer young women than men continued their education to high school and beyond, those who did so were more likely to attend private schools, particularly in rural areas. Differences were observed in the availability of amenities at educational facilities attended by youth who were still in school and those who had discontinued their education at various levels. For example, youth still studying were more likely, for the most part, to report the availability of water, toilets, playgrounds and libraries than were those who had discontinued their education. Schooling experiences also differed somewhat among those who had discontinued schooling and those who were studying at the time of interview. While differences in regular attendance and perceptions about academic load were less consistent, youth who were continuing their education were considerably more likely that those who had discontinued their education to report private tuition, and to have passed the last examination for which they had appeared.
Work
Work profiles suggest that two-thirds of young men and one-half of young women had at some time engaged in paid or unpaid work. Indeed, almost all married young men and three-fifths of unmarried young men had done so, compared with over half and two-fifths of married and unmarried young women, respectively. Likewise, larger proportions of youth in rural than urban areas had ever worked. While the majority of youth were engaged in paid work, considerable proportions of young men (27%) and women (33%) reported unpaid work on the family farm or business. Economic activity was often initiated at an early age: over one in four (29%) young men and one in three young women (35%) reported initiating work in childhood or in early adolescence (before age 15). Data on work participation in the 12 months prior to interview indicate that the majority of young men (57% of the unmarried and 96% of the married) and a substantial proportion of young women (42% and 47%, respectively) had engaged in paid or unpaid work at some point in the 12 months preceding the interview. The majority of young men (63%) who had worked in the year prior to interview had done so for the major part (at least six months) of the year. In contrast, among young women, Percentage of youth who engaged in just one-third had done so. paid or unpaid work in last 12 months, Jharkhand, 2006 Findings also show substantial levels of unemployment among young men (22%) and women (26%). Unemployment tended to be considerably higher among unmarried than married young men; among young women, a reverse pattern was evident. Findings also indicate that unemployment was particularly high among young women in urban areas, particularly the married. Unemployment was also exceptionally high among the educated and economically better off.
Percentage of youth who ever attended a vocational training programme and percentage who were interested in participating in such programmes, Jharkhand, 2006
M=Men; W=Women; MM=Married men; MW=Married women; UM=Unmarried men; UW=Unmarried women
Youth were clearly interested in acquiring skills that would enable employment generation; two in three young men and three in four young women reported interest in vocational skills training. However, far fewerjust 18% of young men and 14% of young womenhad attended at least one vocational training programme.
Media exposure
Large proportions of youth were exposed to the media, typically newspapers, magazines or books (88% of young men and 74% of young women with five or more years of education) and television (79% of all young men and 62% of all young women). Exposure to the internet was reported by many fewer (11% of young men and 6% of young women with five or more years of education). Findings also suggest that about one in three young men and 4% of young women watched pornographic films, and one in five young men and 5% of young women accessed pornographic books and magazines. Over half of those who had been exposed to pornographic materials reported that they accessed these materials sometimes or frequently. Finally, between twofifths and two-thirds of young men and women acknowledged the influence that media have on youth behaviours.
or male cousins. Likewise, while parents appeared to control both young mens and womens social interactions, particularly those involving members of the opposite sex, young women were more likely than young men to experience such restrictions. For example, 71% of young men and 8890% of young women reported expecting parental disapproval if they brought an opposite-sex friend to their home. Percentages of youth reporting gendered socialisation experiences relative to an opposite sex sibling/cousin, Jharkhand, 2006
M=Men; W=Women; MM=Married men; MW=Married women; UM=Unmarried men; UW=Unmarried women Note: For married respondents, questions referred to the period prior to marriage
Nonetheless, it is notable that large proportions of households did not discriminate between their sons and daughters in terms of expectations regarding housework. Just one-quarter of young men reported that they were expected to do less housework than their sisters or female cousins, and half of young women agreed that they were expected to do more housework than their brothers or male cousins. In addition, findings highlight that while young women were brought up with more restrictions, parents appeared to place considerable restrictions on young mens interactions as well, including with same-sex peers. Findings regarding communication with parents on issues relevant to youthsuch as school performance, friendships, being teased or bullied, physical maturation, romantic relationships and reproductive processesreiterate those from other studies, showing that such communication was far from universal. Moreover, sensitive topicssuch as romantic relationships, reproduction and contraception among all youth, and even adolescent body change issues among young menwere rarely discussed with either parent. That parent-child communication was restricted was also evident from responses to questions probing the most likely confidante on a range of topics from taking a job to boy-girl relationships. While parents were mentioned as leading confidantes on non-sensitive topics such as taking a job, they were rarely cited as leading confidantes on more sensitive matters. Moreover, while young women identified their mother as the most likely confidante on such matters as menstrual problems and experience of teasing, young men rarely identified a parent as a leading confidante
on matters relating to nocturnal emission or swapnadosh. Indeed, neither young men nor women identified a parent as a leading confidante on boy-girl matters. Young peoples family lives were marked by violence, both experienced and witnessed. About one in four youth had observed their father beating their mother. Many respondents reported experiencing a beating by a parent during adolescence; over two in five young men and one in seven young women reported such experiences.
were more likely to hold inegalitarian gender role attitudes. Also notable from the findings is the striking gender divide in all the dimensions of young peoples agency explored in the survey. Young women were far more disadvantaged than young men. For example, even the least educated young man was more likely than the most educated young woman to report independent decisionmaking on all three issues explored in the survey. Likewise, although young women were more likely than young men to have money saved (44% and 22%, respectively), they were no more likely than young men to own a bank or post office savings account (11% and 13%, respectively). Moreover, they were much less likely than their male counterparts to operate the account themselves (51% versus 87%, of those who had an account).
W=Women; MW=Married women; UW=Unmarried women; UM=Unmarried men; Note: Questions regarding freedom of movement were not asked of married men, as their mobility is generally unrestricted
Percentage of youth who reported having any savings, owing an account in a bank or post office and operating the account themselves, Jharkhand, 2006
M=Men; W=Women; MM=Married men; MW=Married women; UM=Unmarried men; UW=Unmarried women
While young men were not as disadvantaged as young women, findings indicate that many young men were also not able to exercise agency in their everyday lives. For example, only 59% of young men reported independent decision-making on all three issues explored in the survey. Similarly, young mens freedom to visit selected localities was far from universal; for example, just two in five unmarried young men were allowed to visit a place of entertainment or to attend a programme conducted outside their village or neighbourhood unescorted, and two in three were allowed to visit a health facility unescorted.
Percentage of youth who believed wife beating is justified in selected situations, Jharkhand, 2006
M=Men; W=Women; MM=Married men; MW=Married women; UM=Unmarried men; UW=Unmarried women
Although about half of both young men and women justified wife beating in at least one situation explored in the survey, relatively large proportions of youth espoused egalitarian gender role attitudes on other issues explored. Even so, it is notable that young men were consistently more likely than young women to report inegalitarian gender role attitudes on these issues.
M=Men; W=Women; MM=Married men; MW=Married women; UM=Unmarried men; UW=Unmarried women Note: *Other than HIV
10
in-depth awareness of condoms and oral contraceptives, the methods most familiar to youth, was reported by just 68% and 31% of young men and 30% and 41% of young women, respectively. Likewise, only 27% of young men and 17% of young women had comprehensive awareness of HIV. Findings suggest, moreover, that unmarried young women were the most poorly informed about sexual and reproductive matters among youth, implying that many young womenand fewer young menenter marriage uninformed. Leading sources of information on sexual matters were friends and the media for both young men and women. In contrast, few youth cited teachers and health care providers, respectively, as a source of information, and few young men and somewhat more young women cited a family member. Among the leading current sources of information on contraception among young people who were aware of at least one method were similarly, peers and the media. Again, teachers and health care providers were relatively infrequently reported as such. Indeed, health care providers were cited as an important source of information on contraception by only one-fifth of married young men; they were far less likely to have provided information to the unmarried and even to married young women. Teachers were cited by even fewer. However considerable proportions of young women (42%) but hardly any young men cited family members as a leading source of information about contraception. In short, health care providers, teachers and family membersoften assumed to be more Percentage of youth who received family reliable sources of information than peers or the life or sex education, Jharkhand, 2006 mediawere infrequently and inconsistently cited as sources of information on sensitive topics such as sexual matters and contraception by young people. Few youth had attended family life or sex education programmes either in or outside the school settingjust one in 10 young men and one in 20 young women. Despite this, youth were overwhelmingly in favour of the provision of family life or sex education to young people; typically, young people preferred to receive this education from a professional (health care provider, teacher and so on). Findings suggest, moreover, that youth who had undergone family life or sex education were indeed more knowledgeable about sexual and reproductive matters than those not exposed to this education.
11
Percentage of youth reporting knowledge of selected sexual and reproductive health matters according to whether they had or had not received family life or sex education, Jharkhand, 2006
disparities in expectations of a longer-term commitment emerged that show that young women were considerably more likely than young men to have expected a romantic relationship to lead to marriage. The experiences of the married suggest, moreover, a disconnect between intentions and reality: among those who reported the intention to marry their pre-marital partner, just three-quarters of young women and one-third of young men had done so. Percentage of youth who had made or received a proposal for romantic partnership formation and percentage who had an opposite-sex romantic partner, Jharkhand, 2006
M=Men; W=Women; MM=Married men; MW=Married women; UM=Unmarried men; UW=Unmarried women
There was a clear progression in reported physical intimacy and sexual experience with romantic partners: while over 90% of young men had held hands with a romantic partner, about twofifths had engaged in sexual relations with their partner; and among young women, while four in five had held hands with a romantic partner, two in five had engaged in sexual relations with their partner. It is notable that unlike many previous studies, gender differences in reports of pre-marital sex with a romantic partner were narrow. Partner communication and negotiation
12
regarding safe sex were rare, and the vast majority had engaged in unprotected sex. Almost one in five young women who had engaged in sexual relations with a romantic partner reported that their opposite-sex romantic partner had forced them to engage in sex the first time.
M=Men; W=Women
While sex with a romantic partner characterised pre-marital experiences for many of the sexually experienced, findings suggest that young men, but not young women, also engaged in sex in other contexts; other partners reported by young men included, mainly, sex workers, married women and casual partners. Many of the pre-marital sexual experiences reported by youth were risky, for example, one-quarter of young men and one-third of young women reporting pre-marital sex had engaged in sex with more than one partner. Moreover, consistent condom use was limitedonly 7% of young men and 2% of young women reported condom use in all pre-marital encounters. We acknowledge that youth, especially young women, may not report sexual experience in a survey situation. Hence, the Youth Study supplemented a series of direct questions with an opportunity to report sexual experience in an anonymous format. Surprisingly, findings suggest that a larger percentage of sexually active young men than women reported pre-marital sex only in the anonymous format. In total, direct questioning supplemented by self-reporting in an anonymous format provided considerably higher estimates of sexual experience among young men than did face-to-face questioning alone or anonymous third-party reporting of peer behaviours among young men. However among young women, differences between reporting only in face-to-face interviews, in face-to-face interviews supplemented by self-reporting in an anonymous format and anonymous third-party reporting provided largely similar estimates of pre-marital sex.
13
14
men reported forcing their wife to engage in sex. Recent sexual violence was experienced by one in five young women and perpetrated by almost one in 10 young men. Percentage of married young women reporting experience of physical and sexual violence perpetrated by their husband and percentage of married young men reporting perpetration of physical and sexual violence against their wife, Jharkhand, 2006
While the Youth Study did not explore extra-marital sexual experiences in detail, the available data indicate that 2% of young men reported an extra-marital sexual encounter. In contrast, hardly any young women reported an extra-marital sexual encounter.
15
Percentage of married youth reporting lifetime and current use of contraceptive methods within marriage, Jharkhand, 2006
Findings also show that although most youth wanted one child of each sex, son preference was evident. Over one-third of youth preferred to have more sons than daughters. In contrast, just 36% preferred to have more daughters than sons.
Substance use
Findings show that substantial proportions of young men reported the consumption of tobacco and alcohol; two-fifths of young men reported tobacco consumption and over onefifth reported alcohol consumption. Drug use was reported by less than 2% of young men. Few young women reported that they consumed any of these substances.
16
Finally, small minorities (12%) reported that they had undergone HIV testing. Youth were, however, overwhelmingly in favour of pre-marital HIV testing.
17
of educational opportunities. In contrast, the leading problem expressed by young women was lack of amenities and infrastructure, and to a lesser extent, poverty more generally, difficulties in finding employment, and lack of opportunities for education.
Strengthen efforts to achieve universal school enrolment and increase levels of school completion
Youth Study findings highlight that school enrolment was far from universal among young people in the state and that school completion rates were also relatively low, particularly among young women. The Jharkhand Youth Policy has articulated the need for universal school enrolment and the recently enacted Right to Education Bill has made education compulsory for all children. What is required now, particularly if the state is to achieve the Millennium Development Goal of ensuring universal primary school completion, are programme actions to implement these commitments. While the achievement of universal school enrolment and primary school completion are key goals, the importance of high school education in enabling youth to make a successful transition to adulthood underscores the need, at the same time, for efforts to overcome barriers to high school completion. The stark gender divide and rural-urban divide observed in school enrolment and completion call, moreover, for efforts that target female children and children in rural areas. Wide-ranging efforts are needed to address the barriers inhibiting school enrolment and completion in the state. Efforts must be made, for example, to address the economic pressures that dissuade parents from enrolling their children in school and from keeping them in school once enrolled. Conditional grants and targeted subsidies that encourage school enrolment and completion among disadvantaged groups need to be considered. At the same time, activities are needed that are directed at parents that promote positive attitudes towards education and school completion, raise parents aspirations for the education of their children and encourage greater parental involvement in their childrens education. School-related factors must also be addressed. Activities must address such barriers as distance to school, poor infrastructure and quality of education, and academic failure. The state government has launched various schemes to address these barriers (for example, the bicycle scheme for girls); however, it is important that the effectiveness of these schemes is evaluated and promising lessons are assimilated and scaled up. There is also a need to incorporate livelihoods skills building models within the school setting and provide opportunities for those in school to gain market-driven job skills that will raise young peoples aspirations regarding their education and career. Moreover, investments in improving the quality of the schooling experience are needed that focus on providing better training and
18
ensuring accountability for teachers. Given the large proportions of youth reporting that schooling had been interrupted because they were required for work on the family farm or business or for housework, efforts are needed to adjust school timings, or to establish evening schools, to enable children to accommodate their work commitments without sacrificing their education. Findings indicating that early marriage is an important reason for school discontinuation among adolescent girls emphasise the fact that programme commitments outside the education sector are also critical to the achievement of universal school enrolment and completion. Specifically required are programmes that seek to critically examine norms surrounding marriage and to eliminate the practice of early marriage. Explorations of subsidies and cash transfers that link school retention and delayed marriage among girls are needed. Moreover, findings suggest that married young women remain considerably disadvantaged in terms of school completion. Interventions are needed that give married young women a second chance to obtain a basic education.
19
Promote youth participation in civil society and political processes and reinforce secular attitudes
Findings reveal that for many youth in Jharkhand, opportunities to engage in civic and political processes were limited and secular attitudes were not uniformly observed. Programmes are neededat the school, college and community levels, through national service programmes, sports and other non-formal mechanismsthat encourage civic participation, incorporate value building components and reinforce secular attitudes and values that espouse responsible citizenship.
Provide family life or sex education for those in school and out-of-school
Youth Study findings on young peoples limited understanding of sexual and reproductive matters, their articulated demand for such information, and the fact that substantial minorities had engaged in sexual risk taking call for school-based family life or sex education for those in school and community-based expert-led education for those out-of-school. These programmes should provide information to youth on sexual and reproductive matters and rights, as well as enable young people to correctly understand and assess the sexual and reproductive risks they face and adopt protective actions. Attention must simultaneously be paid to the training of trainers. Finally, in view of the finding that the media are a major but not necessarily reliable source of information on sexual and reproductive matters for youth, efforts must be made to ensure that media content is accurate and comprehensive.
20
measures that go beyond information campaigns to address the underlying factorssocial norms and economic constraintsdriving early marriage. Strategies are needed that mobilise communities to help parents resist pressures that foster the practice of early marriage; that establish new norms and practices; as well as that initiate campaigns highlighting the adverse consequences of early marriage and how it is a violation of the rights of the child. Community mobilisation efforts must involve youth themselves, their families, as well as influential persons in the community, including religious and political leaders. Equally important is to ensure greater commitment on the part of law enforcement agencies to enforce existing laws on the minimum age at marriage and the registration of marriages, and to levy penalties on violators. Allowing anonymous reporting, making law enforcement agencies and others aware that the practice of early marriage is not a minor violation, and making the guidelines for penalties clear to enforcement agencies and the wider community are possible steps in this direction. Efforts to delay marriage also require providing girls with viable alternatives to marriage in the form of accessible and quality schooling and opportunities to build and use livelihood skills. Working with the education sector to make schooling for girls more accessible, and to make classrooms gender-sensitive and responsive to the needs of girls and the concerns of their parents is important. At the same time, it is necessary to provide livelihoods training within and outside the educational system. Parents must also be apprised of the need to involve children in marriage-related decisions and enable them to interact with their prospective spouse prior to the wedding day. Parents must also be made aware of the adverse physical and mental health consequences of early marriage and the adverse experiences of many young women (and some young men) who were married early or who were unprepared for marriage.
Enable married young women to exercise greater control over their lives
Findings on the multiple vulnerabilities faced by married young women underscore the need for programmes that support young women, especially the newly-wed, acknowledging that their situation and needs may differ from those of married adults. Married young women are notably isolated, have little decision-making authority and have few sources of support. They have little communication with their husband, and notable proportions have experienced physical and sexual violence perpetrated by their husband. Efforts are needed that address these vulnerabilities. Programmes need to break down the social isolation of married young women, encourage couple communication, build negotiation and conflict management skills early in marriage and enable married young women to have greater control over resources. Intervention models exist in India that have attempted to address these needs; these models should be reviewed and scaled up as appropriate.
Support newly-weds to postpone the first pregnancy and promote pregnancyrelated care among those who become pregnant
Many young women in Jharkhand experienced their first pregnancy soon after marriage. Programmes are needed that inform youth about their pregnancy postponement options and
21
enable them to access appropriate contraception. At the same time, providers must be trained and charged with the responsibility of reaching married young women and menincluding those who have not yet experienced pregnancywith information regarding contraception and other reproductive health matters as well as contraceptive supplies. The finding that the first and often the most risky delivery was only occasionally conducted by a skilled attendant underscores the need for programme attention on newly-married and first-time pregnant young women. Moreover, the finding that married young women lack the freedom of movement to seek health care underscores the need for health workers to reach these women in their homes.
Reorient service provision to address the unique needs of unmarried and married young women and men
Although the National Rural Health Missions Reproductive and Child Health Programme has advocated special services for youth, including the unmarried, these services had not reached many youth in our survey. Action is needed that sensitises health care providers about the special needs, heterogeneity and vulnerability of unmarried and married young women and men, and orients them to the need for developing appropriate strategies to reach these diverse groups, including young newly-weds. Programmes must be inclusive of unmarried young people and recognise their need and right to sexual and reproductive health and related information and services. Counselling and contraceptive services must be made available to unmarried young people in a non-threatening, non-judgmental and confidential environment. Indeed, these findings call for the implementation of strategies outlined under the Reproductive and Child Health Programme. The finding that few youth had sought care for health problems, and those who had sought care preferred to seek services from the private rather than the public sector, suggests the need to explore the feasibility of implementing various financing strategies, for example, health insurance, competitive voucher schemes and community financing schemes, which will allow youth to have a wider choice of providers and enhance the possibility of obtaining quality care. At the same time, efforts are needed to address the mental health needs of youth, for example, screening young people for mental health disorders when they avail of other primary health services, including sexual and reproductive health services, and to refer youth with such symptoms to appropriate health facilities and providers.
22
23
24
Key indicators
Number of respondents
Socio-demographic profile
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
Aware that a woman can get pregnant at first sexual intercourse (%)
16.
Aware of:
a. Condom (%)
c. IUD (%)
d. Withdrawal (%)
17.
a. Condom (%)
c. IUD (%)
d. Withdrawal (%)
Key indicators Combined 24.6 6.3 76.5 7.8 26.5 22.2 38.4 8.5 16.6 20.1 N.A. 11.5 8.9 0.4 36.1 17.9 17.3 5.8 70.4 10.9 2.4 0.0 3.8 4.2 20.4 2.8 47.7 61.7 16.8 11.5 N.A. 21.5 N.A. 8.1 7.7 0.4 31.6 18.4 37.6 5.6 66.9 4.0 6.7 9.5 5.7 4.7 53.2 34.4 14.3 24.7 14.9 41.3 1.9 2.4 N.A. 10.1 13.8 0.9 0.0 1.8 3.8 47.3 2.4 41.8 37.5 16.6 39.6 33.7 8.3 9.9 8.0 45.7 92.5 78.1 70.5 7.0 21.5 21.2 40.3 10.0 19.3 19.6 N.A. 12.7 9.3 0.4 37.7 17.7 9.6 5.9 71.7 13.5 5.6 5.8 6.5 6.5 22.0 27.4 18.8 23.2 Urban Rural 23.9 5.3 34.4 8.4 10.7 14.1 57.5 7.0 8.3 N.A. 12.0 17.8 2.9 0.0 4.5 4.4 11.1 2.9 49.7 69.7
Men (15-24)
Women (15-24)
Men (15-24)
Women (15-24)
Men (15-24)
Women (15-24)
18.
19.
20.
Heard about:
a. HIV/AIDS (%)
b. STI/RTI (%)
21.
22.
23.
First spent time alone with an opposite-sex romantic partner before age 15 (%)
24.
Ever had pre-marital sexual relations with an opposite-sex romantic partner (%)
25.
26.
27.
28.
Youth life-style
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
34.
35.
Marriage
36.
Note: 1Among all youth. 2Includes being aware that: (1) termination of pregnancy is legal for married women; (2) termination of pregnancy is legal for unmarried women; (3) aborting a foetus after 20 weeks of pregnancy is illegal, and (4) sex-selective abortion is illegal. 3Includes: (1) identification of two major ways of preventing HIV (using condoms and having a single sexual partner); (2) rejection of three common misconceptions about HIV transmission; and (3) awareness that one cannot tell by looking at a person whether he/she has HIV. 4Includes sex with opposite-sex romantic partner, same-sex partner, married woman (for young men not including wife), sex worker (for young men), casual partner, and forced and exchange sex relations, as well as responses in linked anonymous reporting (through sealed envelope). 5Includes genital ulcers, genital itching, swelling in the groin, discharge, burning during urination, etc. 6Among those aged 20 or above. N.A.: Not applicable.
25
26
MM (15-29) Combined 1,259 29.0 39.3 95.5 89.4 12.7 0.5 0.2 36.4 38.5 27.4 83.6 N.A. N.A. 58.5 46.2 82.5 69.8 30.7 7.9 71.8 40.4 18.1 6.7 32.8 6.6 63.3 10.3 20.0 22.4 31.6 35.5 10.7 12.2 12.7 54.4 38.9 47.1 20.0 23.9 30.6 5.6 68.0 29.8 11.3 4.4 23.4 6.6 80.2 7.4 29.6 21.2 36.8 19.5 32.5 10.3 1.5 10.8 5.5 57.3 5.2 21.6 16.3 52.5 58.6 76.9 36.6 29.3 85.9 66.2 28.2 6.9 54.6 70.3 31.2 2.7 41.0 32.9 28.6 47.2 98.5 91.4 50.3 13.8 88.8 53.8 30.5 11.7 43.8 7.6 91.3 11.2 34.5 26.4 28.8 45.0 65.2 61.8 68.4 66.2 41.0 83.6 93.6 64.3 40.1 58.8 67.4 36.1 35.0 32.5 6.9 65.6 12.4 28.8 16.9 45.5 9.3 62.6 11.4 N.A. 13.8 71.3 72.0 30.0 94.8 82.1 38.2 7.4 76.5 32.9 17.0 5.8 26.0 5.6 92.6 10.3 41.0 24.3 33.5 43.3 29.6 44.2 22.1 64.9 84.0 44.9 39.5 53.0 42.1 87.2 N.A. 59.4 40.9 50.9 28.6 73.6 88.2 61.7 53.0 62.8 13.9 79.1 24.0 77.7 89.3 44.9 2.8 28.3 45.1 14.9 1.6 10.2 6.2 85.1 5.5 36.5 13.8 38.5 24.7 82.9 N.A. N.A. 56.7 46.0 79.7 65.8 27.0 6.9 68.6 37.9 15.8 5.7 30.4 6.4 58.1 10.2 17.3 21.7 32.0 26.1 60.5 46.6 29.2 28.1 7.1 0.0 58.8 19.2 25.2 15.4 56.8 49.2 26.1 0.2 0.4 51.1 47.6 27.4 30.3 41.8 30.8 22.2 5.4 0.1 68.6 31.8 22.0 22.8 92.4 88.8 9.4 0.0 0.0 46.0 44.4 25.4 38.6 18.2 12.4 49.2 5.1 0.0 67.7 25.1 15.8 8.8 47.7 41.6 27.5 0.3 0.3 61.1 56.6 17.5 13.0 20.5 16.2 33.1 5.2 0.1 78.1 40.9 30.4 42.4 96.0 89.5 13.5 0.5 0.3 34.6 37.5 26.3 64.9 52.4 32.6 24.8 7.5 0.0 57.1 18.0 40.1 27.3 42.9 8.4 40.8 41.0 53.6 73.5 31.0 27.1 34.9 43.1 16.8 21.6 29.9 5.4 29.5 10.4 8.8 11.9 56.8 2,684 2,141 2,730 605 1,034 1,448 1,381 654 1,650 Urban Rural 693 29.5 18.4 60.9 52.6 25.4 0.2 0.4 46.6 43.6 19.2 61.1 82.1 58.6 62.1 34.2 81.9 59.1 23.7 6.6 64.1 28.4 8.6 3.8 22.1 7.0 74.7 6.2 24.6 19.8 38.6 1,349 32.6 39.5 53.1 38.5 17.7 5.5 0.1 63.5 26.9 36.1 32.3 47.8 10.2 52.5 31.0 42.4 60.2 23.9 2.7 14.8 25.8 7.9 1.5 11.4 5.1 42.6 5.1 13.8 17.6 58.2 MW (15-24) UM (15-24) UW (15-24) MM (15-29) MW (15-24) UM (15-24) UW (15-24) MM (15-29) MW (15-24) UM (15-24) UW (15-24)
Key indicators
Number of respondents Socio-demographic profile 1. Completed 7 years of schooling (%) 2. Not in school at age 12 (%) 3. Engaged in paid and/or unpaid work in last 12 months (%) 4. Engaged in paid work in last 12 months (%) 5. Unemployment rate (as % of labour force) 6. Mother discussed reproductive processes with respondent (%) 7. Father discussed reproductive processes with respondent (%) 8. Talked to mother about friends (%) 9. Talked to father about friends (%) Young peoples control over their own lives 10. Had a bank account (%) 11. Took independent decisions about buying clothes (%) 12. Allowed to visit friends within village/neighbourhood unescorted (%) 13. Allowed to visit health facility unescorted (%) Sexual and reproductive health knowledge 14. Correct knowledge of legal minimum age at marriage for females (%) Aware that a woman can get pregnant at first sexual 15. intercourse (%) 16. Aware of: a. Condom (%) b. Oral contraceptive pills (%) c. IUD (%) d. Withdrawal (%) 17. Correct specific knowledge1 of: a. Condom (%) b. Oral contraceptive pills (%) c. IUD (%) d. Withdrawal (%) 18. Reported that condoms do not reduce sexual pleasure (%) 19. Comprehensive knowledge of the conditions under which abortion is legal2 (%) 20. Heard about: a. HIV/AIDS (%) b. STI/RTI (%) 21. Comprehensive knowledge of HIV3 (%) Pre-marital romantic and sexual relationships 22. Ever had an opposite-sex romantic partner (%) 23. First spent time alone with an opposite-sex romantic partner before age 15 (%)
Key indicators Combined 11.8 25.7 9.6 N.A 13.9 23.0 0.8 64.9 15.8 9.4 5.6 83.6 MM (15-29) Combined 4.8 84.9 27.0 23.3 2.4 21.6 12.8 11.5 1.3 2.6 22.9 90.6 39.7 0.5 24.0 17.4 5.1 1.4 2.6 24.4 89.7 7.9 87.0 27.0 7.6 90.2 23.2 17.5 3.1 40.2 25.1 21.1 1.3 2.3 45.2 95.6 MW (15-24) MM (15-29) Urban 12.4 90.3 22.5 30.8 0.0 38.9 27.9 10.1 1.3 2.3 55.1 94.4 4.2 84.0 27.7 24.4 2.3 18.1 10.5 9.6 1.3 2.7 18.5 89.8 48.5 67.6 44.0 79.6 39.8 66.0 MW (15-24) 1.9 6.2 4.0 4.6 1.1 5.6 3.1 45.1 3.4 0.0 5.3 3.7 14.2 6.4 0.3 29.9 18.9 19.8 1.2 0.0 2.1 4.9 27.3 21.3 1.0 66.0 12.8 28.4 2.0 0.0 4.2 3.8 37.9 6.1 0.5 27.7 19.1 38.8 0.1 0.0 0.3 3.8 52.6 23.4 0.8 64.6 16.3 5.8 5.7 84.4 MM (15-29) Rural 7.0 86.4 27.9 41.5 0.6 21.0 15.3 4.1 1.4 2.7 18.5 88.9 12.1 20.3 N.A 11.3 10.7 12.4 N.A 6.6 10.6 18.6 N.A 8.2 9.7 11.2 N.A 15.2 N.A 22.9 N.A 9.1 N.A 22.9 N.A 9.7 N.A 12.4 20.7 3.6 0.0 5.5 3.6 9.4 2.0 50.6 6.5 12.4 7.2 15.3 3.5 8.2 1.7 27.7 7.1 14.3 22.9 N.A 12.6 6.5 0.3 30.9 18.8 11.3 6.5 68.5 MW (15-24) 5.8 6.1 5.8 8.7 3.1 4.1 1.4 12.4 6.4 7.0 Urban Rural
MM (15-29)
MW (15-24)
UM (15-24)
UW (15-24)
MM (15-29)
MW (15-24)
UM (15-24)
UW (15-24)
MM (15-29)
MW (15-24)
UM (15-24)
UW (15-24) 8.1 10.1 N.A 11.1 13.1 1.8 0.0 3.0 5.5 13.8 4.4 42.9
24.
Ever had pre-marital sexual relations with an opposite-sex romantic partner (%) 25. Ever had pre-marital sex4 (%) Self-reported health problems Anxiety about swapnadosh/nocturnal emission (men) in 26. last 12 months (%) 27. Menstrual problems (women) in last 3 months (%) 28. Symptoms of genital infection in last 3 months5 (%) Youth life-style 29. Consumed alcohol at least once in last month (%) 30. Consumed drugs at least once in last month (%) 31. Consumed tobacco products at least once in last month (%) 32. Involved in physical fights in last 12 months (%) 33. Watched television often (%) Programme participation and voting experience Participated in youth-related programmes implemented in the 34. community in last 3 years (%) 35. Voted in last election6 (%)
Married life
Reported a love marriage (%) Usually discussed money matters with spouse (%) Reported any physical violence perpetrated on wife by husband (%) Husband ever forced wife to have sex (%) Ever had extra-marital sex (%) Ever used contraception within marriage (%) Currently using contraception (%) Ever used a contraceptive method to delay first pregnancy (%) Children ever born (mean) Ideal number of children7 (mean) First delivery in health institution8 First birth attended by a health professional9 (%)
Note: MM: Married men, MW: Married women, UM: Unmarried men, UW: Unmarried women. 1Among all youth. 2Includes being aware that: (1) termination of pregnancy is legal for married women; (2) termination of pregnancy is legal for unmarried women; (3) aborting a foetus after 20 weeks of pregnancy is illegal, and (4) sex-selective abortion is illegal. 3Includes: (1) identification of two major ways of preventing HIV (using condoms and having a single sexual partner); (2) rejection of three common misconceptions about HIV transmission; and (3) awareness that one cannot tell by looking at a person whether he/she has HIV. 4Includes sex with opposite-sex romantic partner, same-sex partner, married woman (for young men not including wife), sex worker (for young men), casual partner, and forced and exchange sex relations, as well as responses in linked anonymous reporting (through sealed envelope). 5Includes genital ulcers, genital itching, swelling in the groin, discharge, burning during urination, etc. 6Among those aged 20 or above. 7Includes only numeric responses. 8Includes those whose first pregnancy outcome was a live or still birth. 9Includes institutional delivery or home delivery attended by a doctor/ANM/nurse/LHV, midwife (trained) or other health professional, among those whose first pregnancy outcome was a live or still birth. N.A.: Not applicable.
27
Notes
28
Supported by: