Mauritius Position Paper MUN Helper
Mauritius Position Paper MUN Helper
Mauritius Position Paper MUN Helper
1.0 Question 1 & 2: Please provide examples of ways in which water pollution, water
scarcity and floods are having adverse impacts on human rights. Adversely
affected rights could include, among others, the right to life, health, water and
sanitation, food, culture, livelihoods, non-discrimination, a safe, clean, healthy and
sustainable environment, and indigenous peoples’ rights. How has climate change
exacerbated water-related problems?
Water Scarcity
1.3 Moreover, it is foreseen that water requirements in Mauritius will outpace the supply
by 2030 and that there would be a drastic drop in agricultural production by as much
as 20 – 30 % due to erratic rainfall pattern. The ecosystem and natural habitat of fish
and other marine species are being rapidly eroded, and beaches may slowly disappear
leading to the fall of the tourism industry which is one of the pillars of the economy.
Water Pollution
1.4 There have been several cases of environmental nuisances in Mauritius caused by
discharge and seepage of wastewater into the natural environment over the years. The
waste water originates from households, commercial buildings and industries, and
occur in both sewered and non-sewered regions.
1.5 Complaints are made to the Pollution Prevention Control Division of the Ministry of
Environment, Solid Waste Management and Climate Change or with the Police de
l’Environnement which are mandated to enforce environmental laws. The various
types of complaints pertain to:
Overflow of manholes;
Overflow of septic tanks and absorption pits;
Accumulations and stagnation of contaminated storm water in drains due to
improper drainage;
Leakage in WMA sewerage system; and
Illegal connection and discharge of wastewater/ effluents onto road, into drains
and canals or into waterbodies.
Filthy water coming from a premises flowing on the public road;
Filthy water coming from the yard of a person flowing into another person’s
yard;
Washing vehicles on the road; and
Allowing filthy water to flow onto land under cultivation.
Flooding
1.7 Additionally, for the past few years, Mauritius has been experiencing an increase in
the frequency of occurrence of high intensity rainfall events which resulted in flash
floods on several occasions. Flash floods that occurred on 26 March 2008, 30
March 2013 and 10 February 2016 affected different localities, including Port
Louis, Canal Dayot, Piton, Fond du Sac, Flacq, Curepipe, Quatre Bornes, St Aubin
and Mahebourg. The flash flood of 30 March 2013 in Port-Louis caused one of the
highest fatalities in recent times.
Impacts of water crisis on Human Rights
1.8 Water, being vital for our living, has serious implications on our basic human needs,
including health, safe and clean environment, adequate housing and access to food.
Consequently, flooding and factors inhibiting access to safe and clean water
adversely affect the rights of citizens of Mauritius in the following ways:
Flash floods as well as droughts cause crop losses which result in shortage of
fresh vegetables on the market leading to soaring of their prices.
Reduction in rainfall coupled with increasing water demand from different sectors
is a threat to our food security.
Floods cause serious impacts to the agricultural sector, leading to death of animals
and destructions of plantations.
Right to work
Water pollution leads to the degradation of the quality of the receiving waters due
to an excessive deposition of chemical nutrients and increase in biological oxygen
demand, which can also be toxic to animals.
Stagnant wastewater pollutes the soil and gives rise to foul odour.
Right to housing
Due to flooding, houses are destroyed and cause heavy damage to property and
loss of goods. For example, during torrential rain which hit the country on 09
and 10th April 2019, 54 houses in two northern villages (Fond du Sac and
Cottage) were flooded, prompting the evacuation of families.
2.0 Question 3: To protect a wide range of human rights, what are the specific obligations
of States and responsibilities of businesses in terms of addressing water pollution, water
scarcity and floods? Please provide specific examples of constitutional provisions,
legislation, institutions, regulations, standards, policies and programmes that apply a
rights-based approach to preventing, reducing, or eliminating water pollution, water
scarcity and floods. Please include, inter alia, any instruments that refer directly to the
right to a healthy environment and/or the rights to clean water and adequate sanitation.
2.1 Although the Constitution of Mauritius does not specifically provide for the right to clean
water and adequate sanitation, these rights are contained in various pieces of legislation,
namely:
2.2 Furthermore, the State of Mauritius has promulgated the Environment Protection Act (EPA)
in 2002. The EPA requires promoters for certain types of polluting undertakings, which may
cause harm to biodiversity and ecosystems, to submit an Environment Impact Assessment
(EIA). These include conversion of forest land to any other land use, lagoon dredging and
reprofiling of sea beds, land clearing and development in environmentally sensitive areas,
amongst others. The EIA process also allows for public consultations, where people
objecting to the development can submit their comments. People who feel their rights have
been violated can also have recourse to the Environment and Land Use Appeal Tribunal.
3.0 Question 4 & 5: If your state is one of the 156 United Nations Member States that
recognizes the right to a safe, clean, healthy and sustainable environment, has this
right contributed to preventing, reducing or eliminating water pollution, water scarcity
and floods? If so, how? If not, why not?
3.1 Recognising the right to a safe, clean, healthy and sustainable environment, the State of
Mauritius has embarked onto various initiatives with a view to preventing, reducing or
eliminating water pollution, water scarcity and floods. A few examples are as follows:
• Water distribution network is being enhanced with old pipes being replaced with
new ones.
Preventing Floods
massive investment in infrastructural projects especially drains, including the
implementation of projects at the level of local government and the construction
and rehabilitation of drains. Furthermore, the State of Mauritius has prepared a
Land Drainage Master Plan for topographical surveys and drain construction
which is currently being implemented.
Wastewater Management
investment of USD 54 Million for Pailles Guibies Sewerage Project Phase 2 for
the construction of approximately 4,050m of trunk sewer, construction of
approximately 43.9 km of sewer reticulation network, construction of 3,099 house
connections, replacement of 16.2 km of existing water pipes and road
reinstatement and other auxiliary works.
monitoring of the river water quality of twenty-seven rivers throughout the island
on a quarterly basis yearly in view to assessing the impacts of the National
Sewerage Programme on water sanitation in Mauritius by the National
Environmental Laboratory (NEL) of the Ministry of Environment, Solid Waste
Management and Climate Change.
provision of safe drinking water to all Mauritians. Water for irrigation purposes
is regulated by the Irrigation Authority and 99.4 percent of the population has
access to safe drinking water, with per capita consumption reaching up to 190
liters of water per day. The Ministry of Environment, Solid Waste Management
and Climate Change has promulgated standards on the quality of drinking water.
These standards have been developed based on WHO guidelines.
massive investment has been made to ensure water security through rain water
harvesting schemes to capture water at household level thereby reducing
dependence on water supplied by Authorities. Several sensitisation campaigns are
held at national level through the use of mass media to promote efficient use of
water. Public Sector irrigation has been upgraded to include water efficient systems
such as sprinkler, centre pivot and drip.
4.0 Question 6: Please identify specific challenges that your government, business, or
organization has faced in attempting to employ a rights-based approach to address
water pollution, water scarcity and floods and the impacts of these problems on
human rights.
4.1 There are periods of the year where shortage of water occurs, requiring concerted effort by
all stakeholders to ensure availability of water for priority sectors. During such times, the
agricultural sector, being given the lowest priority, suffers substantially such that the income
from production drops. Though rationing of water is done with an aim of providing support
to agriculture, this sector is the one which is mostly affected during times of drought.
Ultimately, the farmers are the ones who have to bear the burden associated with scarcity of
water during these dry periods.
4.2 In Mauritius, almost 99% of the population receives water in a decent quantity during
‘normal season’, that is, winter season. The challenge that the CWA faces in attempting to
employ a rights-based approach mostly arises during the summer season which we call ‘dry
season’ as there is a reduced number of hours of water supply to better manage water
available for distribution.
4.3 The water distribution network in Mauritius is relatively old with an estimated 39%, about
1600 km, requiring replacement. The Government has embarked on a massive pipe
replacement programme around the island to address this problem. Some 443.25 km pipes in
most entail regions have been replaced to date.
5.0 Question 7: Please specify ways in which additional protection is provided (or should
be provided) for populations who may be particularly vulnerable to water pollution,
water scarcity and floods (e.g. women, children, persons living in poverty, members
of Indigenous peoples and traditional communities, older persons, persons with
disabilities, ethnic, racial or other minorities and displaced persons). How can these
populations be empowered to protect and improve water quality and availability?
5.1 The small farmers’ community which is a vulnerable group to the effect of climate change
and water scarcity, benefits from irrigation service at subsidised rates within irrigation areas
operated by the Irrigation Authority (IA). Presently, seventeen irrigation schemes are
managed by the IA, which has technical expertise in the field of irrigation. Water efficient
systems such as drip, centre pivot and sprinklers, are constantly under operation to meet the
water demands of crops under these schemes.
5.2 In order to mitigate any adverse effect of water scarcity during dry season throughout
Mauritius, the following measures are undertaken by the CWA:
abstraction of water from irrigation pipeline networks and installation of
pressure filters for treating thereof;
abstraction of water from river sources;
commissioning of standby/additional boreholes;
mobilisation of all CWA water tankers and private water tankers to distribute
water to those affected by the limited hours of supply; and
decrease in water production and reduction in hours of water supply.
6.0 Question 8: How do you ensure that the rights of environmentalists working on water
issues (environmental human rights defenders) are protected? What efforts has your
Government or business made to create a safe and enabling environment for them to
freely exercise their rights without fear of violence, intimidation, or reprisal?
6.1 Mauritius is a democratic state and the rights of its citizens are guaranteed by the
Constitution (Section 3 to 16). Those provisions are safeguarded and applied to all
citizens including environmental human rights defenders. Moreover, Section 13 of the
Constitution guarantees the people’s right to peacefully assemble without fear of
harassment or intrusion.
6.2 The Constitution also makes provision under section 17 for redress to be afforded to any
individual whose rights under chapter II have been, are being or are likely to be
contravened. There is also the possibility of challenging acts of public bodies in Court by
way of applications for judicial review on grounds of illegality, "Wednesbury
unreasonableness", abuse of powers and procedural impropriety. Additionally, there is the
possibility of addressing minor petitions to the Attorney General.
6.3 A plethora of legal provisions is also available in the Criminal Code and specific laws
like Equal Opportunity Act, Workers Right Act, Labour Act that the rights of
environmental human rights defenders are not contravened. In addition, Section 78 of the
Criminal Code provides for the offence of torture by public official.
6.4 The Public Gathering Act provides the legislative framework for public gathering in
Mauritius. According to Section 2 of the Public Gathering Act 1991, a meeting means an
assembly of 12 or more persons, wherever convened or organized for any purpose.
6.5 Human rights defenders have the rights to hold peaceful demonstrations subject to
notification to the Commissioner of Police who depending on the level of threat/risk may
impose conditions for the smooth unfolding of such gatherings. For ensuring public order
and public security, necessary policing arrangements are made for protecting their rights
of expression.
6.6 Pertaining employment, the Employees Relations Act 2008 allows workers including
environmental human rights defenders to associate or join in trade unions via which they
can express their views and concern and collectively bargain over matters relating to their
work or conditions of work.
6.7 There are also a number of human rights institutions which an aggrieved individual can
resort to, notably the National Human Rights Commission, Ombudsperson for Children’s
Office, the Equal Opportunities Commission, the Independent Police Complaints
Commission and the Ombudsperson for Financial Services and the Office of the
Ombudsman.
6.9 Moreover, with respect to decision of the Minister of Environment Solid Waste
Management and Climate Change to issue an EIA licence, the EPA 2002 makes provision
that any person who is aggreived and is able to show that the decision is likely to cause
him undue prejudice may appeal against the decision to the Environment and Land Use
Appeal Tribunal.
7.0 Question 9: There is substantial evidence that the actions of high-income States (from
high levels of material consumption to high levels of greenhouse gas emissions) are
linked to adverse effects on water availability and water quality in low and middle-
income States. What are ways in which high-income States should assist low-income
States in responding to and preventing water pollution, water scarcity and floods?
7.1 High income States could provide facilities for capacity building and financial resources for
improving water quality, mitigating the impacts of water scarcity and preventing water
pollution and flooding.
7.2 The international community could also extend cooperation with Mauritius as a small island
developing state and provide further assistance through sponsorship programmes for studies
in water-related fields.
7.3 It is to be noted that Mauritius has developed comprehensive action plans to adapt to the
adverse effects of climate change. However, the costs of such adaptation measures are so
exorbitant that Mauritius can only achieve its targets if financial support in terms of grant and
technical support from partners is made available to enable it to implement the plans to
protect life and property.
7.4 Capacity building is another sphere of activity which is required on continuous basis to keep
abreast of innovative ideas which could enhance operational activities and empower
stakeholders with adequate knowledge to face scarcity of water.
8.0 Question 10:For businesses, what policies or practices are in place to ensure that
activities, products and services across the entire supply chain (extraction/sourcing,
manufacturing, distribution, sale, and end of life management) minimize water use and
water pollution and meet human rights standards, especially those articulated in the
Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights?
8.1 Although there is no specific legislation which explicitly regulates the business respect for
human rights, all laws are drafted in compliance with human rights norms. There are several
legal provisions pertaining to fundamental rights in the context in various pieces of
legislation, including the Workers’ Rights Act, Occupational Health and Safety Act and the
Environment Protection Act.
8.2 The Workers’ Rights Act sets out employees’ entitlements at work notably normal hours of
work, equal remuneration, sick leave, maternity leave and benefits or paternity leave.
8.3 The Employment Relations Act provides for the right of workers to inter alia freedom of
association, the protection of trade union of workers against acts of interference and the
protection against discrimination and victimisation.
8.4 The Occupational and Health Safety Act and the regulations made thereunder provide for a
number of safety and health norms notably for workers’ accommodation and provision of
protective equipment and clothing.
8.5 The Environment Protection Act provides for the submission of a preliminary
Environmental Report or an Environmental Impact Assessment Report before the
commencement of a number of undertakings.
8.6 The Business Mauritius has also been established to ensure that business interests are
represented thoroughly at all levels and to engage with government officials and local
authorities on a daily basis. It actively contributes to policy formulation in the interest of
Mauritian employers by way of various submissions to Government. Through its advocacy
role, it ensures that the position of employers on key economic, labour and social matters is
brought at the forefront and reflected in the formulation of policies.
8.7 The Business Mauritius will be made to undertake a more prominent role in the aspect of
business and human rights. They will be called upon to ensure that the Guiding Principles on
Business and Human Rights are fully considered in their policies and actions.
8.8 National Human Rights Institutions (NHRIs) such as the National Human Rights
Commission, Office of the Ombudsman, Equal Opportunities Commission, the
Ombudsperson for Children’s Office and Ombudsperson for Financial Services also provide
a platform for the protection and promotion of human rights at the national level.
8.9 One of the ways of reducing water in agriculture is through the use of efficient systems of
irrigation. There has been a shift from least efficient systems such as surface methods of
irrigation to more efficient ones such as drip, centre pivot and sprinkler. In addition, proper
irrigation scheduling is done to reap the benefits from rainfall that occur.
8.10 For the agricultural sector, the pricing of irrigation water is carried out so as to promote
efficiency in water use. The prices should, however, be within the farmers’capacity to pay.
For the industrial sector, water is priced at its economic value.
9.0 Conclusion
9.1 The world is currently facing an unprecedented pandemic, the Covid 19, which is far more
than a health emergency. It has turned to be an economic, social and human crisis. There is a
need to reflect on the way the obligations of the State are being altered with the Covid 19
and its possible impacts on the fundamental rights of people including the right to clean
water, right to a clean environment and the right to an adequate standard of living.
08/12/2020
Annex A
(A) The Central Water Authority Act provides for the establishment of a body corporate
responsible for the control, development and conservation of water resources. The Authority has,
amongst others, the duty to supervise the enforcement of any water legislation;
(B) The Public Health Act seeks to primarily ensure there is no threat to public health. The PHA is
a major piece of legislation in Mauritius which is focussed on the following issues, all of which
are of relevance to the present subject matter;
(v) Leprosy;
(vi) Protection of food;
(vii) Food and water supply;
(viii) Hospitals and dispensaries;
(ix) Cemeteries; and
(x) Cremation
Broadly, despite the fact that the Public Health Act does not provide for the right to water, it does
make it a punishable offence for:
(a) an owner/keeper of a common lodging house i to provide proper supply of water for the use of
lodgersii; and
(b) a person suffering from an infectious or communicable disease, knowing he is a patient, to
handle, convey, or otherwise come into contact with any aerated water intended for
consumption by maniii;
Also, the Public Health Act provides for the following water-related offences, which it treats as
‘nuisance’:
(a) a well, tank, pond, reservoir, canal or conduit –
(i) the water of which is so tainted with impurities;
(ii) which is otherwise so unwholesome as to be injurious or dangerous to the health of
persons living near or using that water; or
(iii) which is calculated to promote or aggravate epidemic diseases.
Although not a direct right to water, the provisions of the Waste Water Management
Authority Act are aimed towards providing a safe outlet for effluents in order to avoid
contamination of domestic water, which implies a right to access clean water.
(D) The Environment Protection Act (EPA) is a national legislative framework which provides for,
inter alia, the protection and management of environmental assets, including, but not limited to
water.
The EPA provides for the Minister of Environment, Solid Waste Management and Climate
Change to prescribe standards for water quality to protect the public health, welfare and the
environment, and to provide adequate safeguard for the quality of water iv. This provision ensures
that the quality of water is kept in check and the public has access to water which is fit for
consumption.
In order to prevent water pollution, the following are made punishable under the EPA:
In an attempt to protect the maritime water resources, the EPA also provides for emergency
powers towards conservation, protection and restoration of the maritime zone of Mauritius vi.
(E) The Ground Water Act aims to protect unlawful abstraction and pollution of ground watervii.
The Ground Water Act makes it an offence to:
(a) abstract, divert, obstruct, measure or use any ground water;
(b) construct or erect any works in or over any ground water, unless one has obtained a license
under this Act authorising him to do so; and
(c) alter the composition or quality of ground water by any physical, chemical or biological
means or process, that it is likely to cause injury to any person, animal or plant using such
water.
(F) The Rivers and Canals Act is a piece of legislation seeking to regulate the status and to protect
rivers, streams and canals in Mauritius.
In order to prevent the pollution of rivers, streams and canals, the Rivers and Canals Act
provides that:
(a) No dwelling house, kitchen, slaughter house, or camp of labourers, and no privy, urinal,
stable, cow house, cattle yard, pigsty, poultry house or poultry yard, and no distillery or sugar
or other manufactory, shall be erected within 100 feet of any river or stream, unless the
Permanent Secretary or the Sanitary Authority certifies in writing that the water of the river
or stream is not liable to be defiled by any matter or water issuing from such erection or
buildingviii;
(b) Where any quantity of sugar, cane trash, bagasse, syrup, molasses, wash, manure, dung, or
accumulation of matter of any kind, or any sewer, ditch, or drain, appears to the Supreme
Court (after a report on the matter by one or more persons of skill, and after the parties
interested have been duly called) to be so situated that any water or matter from there can
defile any river or stream, the occupier of the premises shall remove the water or matter or
make arrangements, to the satisfaction of the Permanent Secretary, or of some skilled person
appointed by the Supreme Court, for preventing the defilingix;
(c) Any person who –
(a) plants or causes to be planted on the bank or within 2 yards of any canal, any tree, shrub
or plant, capable of tainting the water in such canal;
(b) eases himself in a river, stream or canal or on the bank of a river, stream or canal;
(c) places or causes to be placed in a river, stream or canal or on the bank of a river, stream
or canal, any dead animal, or any dung, rubbish, manure, cane trash, bagasse or any filth,
or any poisonous narcotic or noxious substance or any other substance which tends to
pollute the water of the river, stream or canal;
(d) throws into or places in a canal, or on the bank of a canal any soap studs or dirty water;
(e) washes any part of his person or of any other individual or animal in a river, stream or
canal, where he or the individual or animal suffers from a cutaneous disease;
(f) washes any part of his person or of any other individual or animal in a canal;
(g) washes any article in a canal;
(h) places any linen, clothes, utensils, furniture, cart or implement in a canal;
(i) permits any impure water from a building or manufactory, or from an accumulation of
matter, to enter a canal, or to pollute or impair the quality of the water of a canal;
(j) places or causes or authorises the placing of any dead animal, dung, manure, cane trash,
or any filth or noxious substance in such a situation that water or matter issuing from it
can enter a canal, or does or causes to be done any other thing by which the water of a
canal may be polluted; or
(k) causes, or being in charge of any horse, mule, ass, cattle, sheep, goat or pig or other
domestic animal allows the animal to enter or drink out of a canal, shall commit an
offence and shall, on conviction, be liable to a fine not exceeding 1,000 rupees x.
(d) any person who throws, or causes to be thrown, or sends or allows to flow into a river or into
a canal, pipe or other conduit discharging into a river or canal, any scum, residue, refuse,
washing or other dirty waters or other liquid that may be tend to pollute the water of such
river or canal shall commit an offence and shall, on conviction, be liable to a fine not
exceeding 1,000 rupees.
(G) The Fisheries and Marine Resources Act is another legislative instrument aiming to consolidate
the law relating to the management, conservation, protection of fisheries and marine resources
and protection of the marine ecosystems.
In order to safeguard waterbodies, section 69 of the Fisheries and Marine Resources Act makes it
an offence to place, throw, discharge or cause to be placed, thrown or discharged into the
maritime zones or into a river, lake, pond, canal, stream, tributary or wetland any poisonous
substance.
In light of the above, it is submitted that, although there is no direct right to water, numerous laws
exist to prevent, reduce, or eliminate water pollution, water scarcity and floods.
i
“common lodging house” defined in the Public Health Act as: ‘includes all premises occupied by
more than 5 lodgers in return for payment’.
ii
Section 14 of the Public Health Act
iii
Section 49(e)(i) of the Public Health Act
iv
Section 38 of the Environment Protection Act
v
Ninth Schedule of the Environment Protection Act
vi
Part V of the Environment Protection Act
vii
Defined as: any water under the surface of the ground, and includes underground streams,
natural subsurface reservoirs and lakes and any water held underground in a zone of saturation,
but does not include water flowing in or contained in artificial pipes, conduits or reservoirs, nor
does it include surface water having as its immediate origin atmospheric precipitation or natural
springs issuing at the ground surface, and flowing over, or retained on, the surface