ANNEX I

AGENDA (DRAFT)
MSD Session 1 (Day 1)
21st February 2024, 08:30–17:00 (Beijing, Manila, Manado Indonesia, GMT+8)

08:00 – 08:30 Registration of participants and connectivity test for online speakers
Welcome remarks
08:30 – 09:00 Welcome remarks by Representative of the New and Renewable Energy and Energy Conservation of ESDM
(30 min)
Steve Kepel, North Sulawesi Province Secretary
Steivan Defilla, APEC Sustainable Energy Centre
Craig Menzies, Global Factor. Overview of the MSD Session 1 objectives and programme

09:00 – 09:15 Group photo

09:15 – 10:30 Adoption of the MSD programme Agenda
(75 min.)
Introducing the MSD: Purpose, procedural approach, housekeeping rule and expected outcomes
Session moderated by Reza Dotolung (N. Sulawesi Province Gov), assisted by Global Factor
10:30 – 10:45
Coffee break
10:45 – 11:15 Summary of the outcomes of the Training of Trainer event (August 2023) & Presentation of the draft text of a
(30 min.) carbon neutrality vision for North Sulawesi Province
Session moderated by Craig James Menzies (Global Factor)
11:15 – 11:30 Initial feed-back by the North Sulawesi Province Government on the Draft text of the Vision
(15 min.)
11:30 – 12:15 Stakeholder Short Introductory Statements concerning the vision (3 minutes each)/MSD participants
(45 min.)
Session moderated by Reza Dotolung (N. Sulawesi Province Gov), assisted by Global Factor
12:15 – 13:30 Lunch break
13:30 – 15:30 Title of presentation Organization Speaker and time zone
(120 min.)
Climate Smart Philippines Environmental and Climate Change Glenn Banaguas (GMT+8)
Research Institute

Hong Kong, China 2050 vision and Government of Hong Kong Lee Ho Fung (GMT+7)
planning for low-carbon development

Solar energy planning and community Department of Energy, Environment Stan Krpan (GMT +10)
engagement in Victoria State, Australia and Climate Action, Government of
Victoria State (Australia)

Q&A and open discussion with participants. Moderated by Joseph Viandrito (Global Factor)
15:30 – 15:45
Coffee break
15:45 – 16:45 General comments by stakeholders on the draft text of the carbon neutrality vision
(60 min.)
Moderated by Joseph Viandrito, Global Factor
16:45 – 17:00 Closure of the MSD Session 1, Day 1 and Group photo
(15 min)
Group photo
End of Day 1

15
 MSD Session 1 (Day 2)
22st February 2024, 08:30–17:00 (Beijing, Manila, Manado Indonesia, GMT+8)

08:00 – 08:30 Registration of participants and connectivity test for online speakers
08:30 – 08:45 Welcome and introductory remarks from the moderator
(15 min.)
Overview of the objectives and agenda of day 2 of MSD session 1: Discussion of a comprehensive vision for a data
driven, carbon neutral and disaster resilient future
08:45 – 09:00 Group photo
09:00 – 10:30 Title of presentation Organization Speaker and time zone
(90 min). The Communal town plan 2020 – 2024 of Environment Department of Patricio Figueroa Espindola (GMT -4)
Temuco City, Chile Temuco City Municipal
Government, Chile

Practical approaches to the use of Multi- Carbon Neutral Cities Alliance Michael Shank (GMT -6)
Stakeholder Dialogue and ensuring
successful outcomes

Q&A and interactive and open discussion with participants

Moderated by Craig James Menzies, Global Factor
10:30 – 10:45 Coffee break
10:45 – 12:30 First detailed discussion on the first five points of the draft text on the carbon neutrality vision for North Sulawesi
(120 min.) Province / MSD participants
• The Province’s overarching purpose
• The Province’s 3 to 5 core values
• The Province’s 3 to 5 biggest current sustainability challenges
• The Province’s 3 to 5 most important measures addressing sustainability
• The Province’s 3 to 5 biggest current disaster threats
Chaired by Reza Dotolung, North Sulawesi Province Government, assisted by Global Factor
12:30 – 13:30 Lunch break
13:30 – 15:00 Title of presentation Organization Speaker and time zone
(90 min.) Long-term planning for energy sector National Planning and Dr. Nizhar Marizi (GMT +7) (tbc)
decarbonization in Indonesia Development Agency,
Government of Indonesia

Metro Manila Greenpoint 2030 Metropolitan Manila Ms Shiela Gail Satura (GMT +7)
Development Agency

The Role of Renewable Energy for Security, Republic of Indonesia Defense Dr. Ir. Agus Adriyanto (GMT +7) (tbc)
Energy Security and Disaster Resilience University (RIDU)
15:00 – 15:15
Coffee break
15:15 – 17:00 First detailed discussion of the second five points of the draft text on the carbon neutrality vision for North Sulawesi
(105 min.) Province / MSD participants
• The Province’s 3 to 5 most important measures improving disaster resilience
• The Strengths of Province to address Carbon Neutrality
• The Province’s weaknesses to address Carbon Neutrality
• The opportunities for the Province arising from Carbon Neutrality
• The challenges to the Province posed by Carbon Neutrality
Chaired by Reza Dotolung, North Sulawesi Province Government, assisted by Global Factor
Group photo
End of Day 2

16
 MSD Session 1 (Day 3)
23rd February 2024, 08:30–17:00 (Beijing, Manila, Manado Indonesia, GMT+8)

08:00 – 08:30 Registration of participants and connectivity test for online speakers
08:30 – 08:45 Introductory remarks from the moderator
(15 min.)
Overview of the objectives and agenda of Day 3 of MSD session 1: Discussion of a comprehensive vision for a
data driven, carbon neutral and disaster resilient future
08:45 – 09:00 Group photo
09:00 – 10:15 Second and final detailed discussion of the first five points of draft text of the carbon neutrality vision for North
(75 min) Sulawesi Province / MSD participants
• The Province’s overarching purpose
• The Province’s 3 to 5 core values
• The Province’s 3 to 5 biggest current sustainability challenges
• The Province’s 3 to 5 most important measures addressing sustainability
• The Province’s 3 to 5 biggest current disaster threats
Chaired by Reza Dotolung, North Sulawesi Province Government, assisted by Global Factor
10:15 – 10:30 Coffee break
10:30 – 11:30 Second and final detailed discussion of the second five points of the draft text of the carbon neutrality vision for
(60 min.) the North Sulawesi Province / MSD participants
• The Province’s 3 to 5 most important measures improving disaster resilience
• The Strengths of Province to address Carbon Neutrality
• The Province’s weaknesses to address Carbon Neutrality
• The opportunities for the Province arising from Carbon Neutrality
• The challenges to the Province posed by Carbon Neutrality
Chaired by Reza Dotolung, North Sulawesi Province Government, assisted by Global Factor
11:30 – 13:30 Prayer & Lunch
13:30 – 15:30 Adoption by the MSD of the text of a comprehensive vision for a data driven, carbon neutral and disaster
(120 min.) resilient future for the North Sulawesi Province
Stakeholder remarks
Chaired by Reza Dotolung, North Sulawesi Province Government, assisted by Global Factor
15:30 – 15:45
Coffee break
15:45 – 17:00 Additional time available for further discussion of the vision (if required).
(75 min.)
Closure of the MSD Session 1: Summary of sessions, outcomes and agreements. Overview of the MSD Session 2.
(Craig Menzies, Global Factor)
Group Photo
Group photo
End of Day 3

17
 MSD Session 2 (Day 1)
26th February 2024, 08:30–17:00 (Beijing, Manila, Manado Indonesia, GMT+8)

08:00 – 08:30 Registration of participants and connectivity test for online speakers
08:30 – 09:00 Opening address by Reza Dotolung, North Sulawesi Province Government
(30 min.)
Steivan Defilla, APEC Sustainable Energy Centre
Adoption of the MSD 2 Session Agenda & Overview of the MSD Session 2 objectives, programme and
housekeeping rules
(Craig James Menzies, Global Factor)
Group photo
09:00 – 11:00 Title of presentation Organization Speaker and time zone
(120 min.) Technological solutions for carbon neutral World Smart Cities Jaewon Peter Chun (GMT -6)
and climate resilient cities Foundation

Energy needs of decent living standards IIASA Dr. Jihoon Min (GMT-7)

Technological solutions and public planning Hong Kong University John Ure (GMT +7)
for sustainable transportation in Hong Kong

Q&A and interactive and open discussion with participants

Moderated by Joseph Viandrito, Global Factor
11:00 – 11:15
Coffee break
11:15 – 11:45 Title of presentation Organization Speaker and time zone
Two Alternative Global Scenarios APEC Sustainable Energy Steivan Defilla
Center
11:45 – 12:30 Stakeholder Short Introductory Statements on the proposed 2030 targets (3 minutes each)/MSD participants
Session moderated by Reza Dotolung (N. Sulawesi Province Gov), assisted by Global Factor
12:30 – 13:30
Lunch break
13:30 – 14:30 Expert speaker presentation: North Sulawesi, trends in the local population, GDP, energy, emissions, and
(60 min.) renewable energy
Summary presentation of the draft text on 2030 targets on energy intensity, GHG emissions intensity and
renewables share for the North Sulawesi Province
Dr Hizkia Tasik (Sam Ratulangi University)
14:30 – 14:45 Initial feed-back by the North Sulawesi Province Government on the draft text on 2030 targets on energy
(15 min.) intensity, GHG emissions and renewables share for the North Sulawesi Province
14:45 – 15:00 Coffee break
15:00 – 15:45 Just Energy Transition Partnership ICRES Paul Butarbutar
(45 min.) (JETP)

15:45 – 16:30 Energy needs of decent living Imperial College London Dr Jarmo Kikastra (GMT +0)
(45 min.) standards, from a climate planning
perspective
16:30 – 17:15 A positive approach to carbon IRENA Yong Chen, programme officer,
(45 min.) neutrality: Economic and employment IRENA (GMT+4) (tbc)
benefits of Net Zero
17:15 – 17:30 Closure of the MSD Session 2, Day 1
(15 min.) Group Photo
Group photo
End of Day 1

18
 MSD Session 2 (Day 2)
27th February 2024, 08:30–17:00 (Beijing, Manila, Manado Indonesia, GMT+8)

08:00 – 08:30 Registration of participants and connectivity test for online speakers
(30 min.)
08:30 – 09:00 Overview of the objectives and Agenda of Day 2 of MSD Session 2: Discussion of the text on 2030 targets on
(30 min.) energy intensity, GHG emissions intensity and renewables share for the North Sulawesi Province
Craig James Menzies, Global Factor
Group photo
Group photo
09:00 – 10:00 Detailed discussion of the proposed energy intensity target:
(60 min.)
Presentation of the proposed 2030 energy intensity target / Dr Hizkia Tasik (Sam Ratulangi University)
Detailed discussion of the proposed energy intensity target / MSD participants
Session moderated by Reza Dotolung (N. Sulawesi Province Gov), assisted by Global Factor
10:00 – 10:15
Coffee break
10:15 – 11:15 Detailed discussion of the proposed carbon intensity target:
(60 min.)
Presentation of the proposed 2030 carbon intensity target / Dr Hizkia Tasik (Sam Ratulangi University)
Detailed discussion of the proposed carbon intensity target / MSD participants
Session moderated by Reza Dotolung (N. Sulawesi Province Gov), assisted by Global Factor
11:15 – 12:00 Title of presentation Organization Speaker and time zone
Renewable energy potential of North Sulawesi Province Dr. Franciscus Maindoka (tbc)
North Sulawesi
12:00 – 13:00
Lunch break
13:00 – 15:15 Title of presentation Organization Speaker and time zone
(135 min.) Solar and wind energy in North Arik Setyo Nugroho, Head (tbc)
PT. Vena Energy di Likupang
Sulawesi
Geothermal energy in North PT.PGE Lahendong di Albertus Novi Purwono, General
Sulawesi Tomohon Manager (tbc)

Hydropower in North Sulawesi PT. PLN Nusantara Power Andreas Napitupulu, Manager (tbc)
UPDK Minahasa di Tondano
15:15 – 16:15 Detailed discussion of the proposed renewables share target:
(60 min.)
Presentation of the proposed 2030 renewables share target / Dr Hizkia Tasik (Sam Ratulangi University)
Detailed discussion of the proposed renewables share target / MSD participants
Session moderated by Reza Dotolung (N. Sulawesi Province Gov), assisted by Global Factor
16:15 – 16:30
Coffee break
16:30 – 17:00 Identification of problems and disagreement gaps for the three targets
(30 min.)
Chaired by Reza Dotolung, North Sulawesi Province Government, assisted by Global Factor

17:00 – 17:15 Wrap up of the progress achieved and progress gaps still to be bridged
(15 min.) Closure of the MSD Session 2, Day 2
Group Photo

Group photo
End of Day 2

19
 MSD Session 2 (Day 3)
28th February 2024, 08:30–17:00 (Beijing, Manila, Manado Indonesia, GMT+8)

08:00 – 08:30 Registration of participants and connectivity test for online speakers
(30 min.)
08:30 – 09:00 Overview of the objectives and Agenda of Day 3 of MSD Session 3: Discussion of the text on 2030 targets on
(30 min.) energy intensity, GHG emissions intensity and renewables share for the North Sulawesi Province
Craig James Menzies, Global Factor
Group photo

Group photo
09:00 – 09:30 Presentation of possible solutions to the outstanding problems and gaps
(30 min.)
Craig Menzies / Joseph Viandrito (Global Factor) / Dr Hizkia Tasik (Sam Ratulangi University)
09:30 – 10:30 Discussion of the proposed solutions to the outstanding problems
(60 min.)
Chaired by Reza Dotolung, North Sulawesi Province Government, assisted by Global Factor
10:30 – 10:45
Coffee break
10:45 – 12:00 Session available for further discussion on outstanding problems of the text on 2030 targets on energy intensity,
(75 min.) GHG emissions intensity and renewables share for the North Sulawesi Province, if required.
Adoption by the MSD of the text on 2030 targets on energy intensity, GHG emissions intensity and renewables
share for the North Sulawesi Province
Chaired by Reza Dotolung, North Sulawesi Province Government, assisted by Global Factor
12:00 – 13:15
Lunch break
13:15 – 14:15 Session available for further discussions on proposed targets, if required.
(60 min.)
Adoption by the MSD of the text on 2030 targets on energy intensity, GHG emissions intensity and renewables
share for the North Sulawesi Province
Information on the possible actions of the North Sulawesi Province Government in view of officializing the text of
the carbon neutrality vision and the text of the 2030 targets.
Chaired by Reza Dotolung, North Sulawesi Province Government, assisted by Global Factor
14:15 – 14:30
Coffee break
14:30 – 16:30 High-level policy consultations and discussion on the use of MSD as a permanent consultative forum for North
(120 min.) Sulawesi Province for managing the pathway towards carbon neutrality
Chaired by Reza Dotolung (North Sulawesi Province Government), assisted by Global Factor
16:30 – 17:00 Closure of the MSD Session (Moderated by Mr. Craig Menzies, Global Factor)
(30 min.)
Closing session address: Steivan Defilla (APEC Sustainable Energy Working Group)
Closing session address: Reza Dotolung (North Sulawesi Province Government)
Group photo
Group photo
End of MSD event
tbd Press release and media event

20