Leadership Traits Based On Ancient Indian Texts
Leadership Traits Based On Ancient Indian Texts
Leadership Traits Based On Ancient Indian Texts
Darmashakthini Arujunan
RESEARCH OUTPUT Rashtram School of Public Leadership, India
Abstract
Many leadership attributes and models are consistent with the Western paradigm, grounded in
Western thought processes. Current points of view show there is a need for other non-Western
centric leadership traits to be introduced for global growth and development. In particular,
leadership traits in ancient Indian texts provide the contextual background for the description
of these styles of leadership. The ancient models serve to address the gaps found in modern
leadership models and its corresponding criteria. Findings gleaned from the Bhagavad Gita,
Mahabharata, Ramayana, Tirukurral, the Sastras, ancient fables and notable scholars highlight
the Indic value system and its attributes relating to the three Gunas. These are Tamas, Rajas
and Sattva. These fluid attributes capture many styles of leadership displayed by characters and
expounded by ancient scholars. These findings reflect the importance of ethical boundaries and
higher ideals embedded in ancient leadership models. These traits would improve the education
curriculum designed to create future leaders and inculcate holistic participation among leaders
in high-level leadership positions.
Introduction
India’s ancient legacy rests in its intellectual property wealth, rooted in literature and its direct
effect influence on its leadership models. Primarily, this assumption was not common to the
western narrative and other communities dominated by the western worldview. S.S Ali (2006)
looks to Kautilya and his perception of good governance. Upon consideration of the World
Bank’s identification of good governance aspects, bureaucratic accountability, administrative
qualities and accompanying personal administration underlying leadership.
In comparison, Tisdell (2003) acknowledges the neglect of the western narrative with respect
to the Indian worldview pertaining to leadership traits. When comparing leadership with other
interlinking modes in governance models, he associates Kautilya’s contribution to the political
economy. These aspects were not limited to domestic duties but extended to international trade
and diplomacy. As Adam Smith’s Wealth of Nations advocated the liberal market-based
economy, fixed on the invisible hand and the impartial spectator, the East contributed in the
field of economic sciences, via leadership rooted in social security, consumer protection and
welfare.
The French sociologist, Emile Durkheim (1858-1917) observed social solidarity to mean
mechanical solidarity and organic solidarity. The former constituted a higher degree of likeness
whereas the latter constituted a complex society with specialists trained in different areas. In
contrast, Kautilya saw the republic, the Sangha to accommodate both types of solidarity.
Because ancient kingdoms were republics which then transformed into monarchies, the
leadership mantel was assigned to the King as the fountain of justice. His duties were
documented in many ancient Indian texts such as the Rajanitiprakasa, the Nitimayukha that
together formed the Rajaniti in words and scriptures,
If one was to observe the similarities of Hobbes and Locke to that of the ancient Indian context,
this meant giving up the laws of nature for laws prescribed by the government in charge. Here,
1
the transference of individual rights signaled the power of the state to enforce laws and
obligations manifested in the hands of secular thought and rationalism. In contrast, ancient
Indian governance was rooted in theology and sociology, but provided room for the King to
relinquish his power should he fail to live up to the prescribed standards. The ideal state was a
consensual, duty-based mechanism between King and subjects based on a Divine Code.
Punishment was observed as a last resort and the entire state mantel was held together as an
organic base (Alterkar, 1949).
The state model was held together by the aims and objectives of the state machinery. The king
upholds the divine law and order, premised on the dharma, artha and karma doctrines that
promoted virtue and public welfare. It encouraged trade and industry, and funded the
flourishing of the sciences and arts. In this social order of existence, leadership traits existed in
many folds of governance and administrative departments. This will be discussed according to
its contextual relevance.
Methodology
This paper employed qualitative methods, specifically, identifying ancient Indian texts that
described leadership traits ordained for the leader in its individual context. Adopting these
interpretations on a case-to-case basis, each angle of leadership is explored according to its
varied roles and functions. These include commentaries by Indian scholars, texts and
translations, puffin classics for children, and introductory approaches to Indian Knowledge
Systems. In an attempt to draw from varied sources, this paper transposes valid leadership traits
that are present in these reflections with an emphasis on creating greater awareness for the
search of the common thread that is present in ancient Indian texts. The methodology of
hermeneutics represents an interpretation that seeks to study leadership traits upon careful
analysis of pertinent literature. This qualitative method seeks to amalgamate relevant ancient
Indian texts embodying leadership aspects and document different perspectives found herein.
2
Seeking wise counsel from competent persons is another leadership trait that was present in the
Vedic period. The Mahabharata and the Arthasastra instill the importance of the presence of
intellectual input for a leader. In the Samhitas of the Yajurveda, the King’s Council were known
as Ratnins (jewels). The key members of this Council were the Queens, the Purohita (the Royal
Chaplain), the Senani (commander-in-chief), the Suta (commander of the royal army),
Gramani (headman), Samgrahita (treasurer) and Bhagadhuk (tax-collector). These members
also included the chamberlain and the guilds (Alterkar, 1949, p. 115).
The Dharmasastra and Nitisastra further provide evidence of mantrins, sachivas and amatyas
and the emergence of the Matri-parishad signified the prominence the Sungas gave to their
Council of ministers. This trait was developed by Vedic rulers to leverage on intellectual others
who could provide better insights. Their scope was similar to the role of the Privy Council and
its facilitation provided the members a higher status in the administrative set-up. The Royal
Chaplain’s role was to be the guru to the leader in areas such as political science, military art
and religious studies. His influence was key to the leader’s well-being and potential in the
dimensions of morality and virtue. This trait of keeping wise counsel rooted in good virtue
symbolized the ethical dimension for leadership to keep heading in the right direction. This
trait can be adopted by today’s leaders, found in the Sukraniti which elaborates this tradition
of staying true to virtues at the leadership level (Alterkar, 1949, p. 121).
The power sharing concept called Ubhayayatta is another trait that made the leader and the
administration interdependent of one another. This is partly due to the level of confidence the
administration projected as a collective, bound to the weaknesses and strengths of the leader.
The king-centred Rajayatta was a possibility whereas ministers would become team-players
when the King’s presence was weakened due to lack of intelligence. This power sharing
arrangement in normal situations was possible because the leader was open to influence from
the collective intelligence. This provided space for the welfare of ministerial responsibility as
a collective (Alterkar, 1949, p. 134).
In terms of delegation of authority, the Secretariat’s role in administration solidified the
machinery of the government. Members were expected to possess high qualifications,
experience, reliability, and were expert drafters (Alterkar, 1949, p. 139). It consisted of a small
but able group that was tasked to keep records at a Records Office, facilitate orders from the
King, supervise and control the local and district administration and conducting tours of
inspection. On top of that, leadership traits involved the King inspecting the situation to unearth
corrupt and/or oppressive practices. Other reasons include ascertaining the sentiments of the
commoners to serve their needs and collective voices. During the Chaulukya administration,
the Inspector-General of records was in charge of the Records Office and was responsible for
overseeing high-level supervision. The copper plates charters were documented to be under his
hand of composition.
In the judicial system, leadership was decentralized to keep away backlogs. First instance
complaints did not start in official courts. This was done so to provide autonomy to village and
town councils to decide local cases. Government courts were presided by dharmadhyakshas or
nyayakaranikas in the Gupta administration. This was common in big cities to facilitate most
of the big issues that came before them. The Chief Justice in the Royal Courts was grounded
in Smriti literature, making their presence crucial when handling large scale crimes. In the event
the King was not present to settle disputes and appeals, the Chief Justice was tasked to handle
3
them accordingly. Its socio-religious construct allowed others to participate in decision-making
at the judicial level. This hierarchy of courts allowed the facilitation from the easy to difficulty
ratio to be applied wisely (Alterkar, 1949, p. 152).
The diagram below explains the four elements that a leader should we well-versed with, and
becoming of an able leader. Anviksiki represents the dharmic philosophy entwined in the study
of the Vedas, political narratives, economics and the use of force. The Vedas represent content
collated in the Rigveda, Samaveda, and Yajurveda that lay down the roles and representative
capacity of a leader. This skill set encapsulates the dharmic vision for a just leader to adopt.
Varta looks at trade in the economic context, ranging from agriculture to imported goods
subjected to custom duties, and taxation principles. Dandaniti represents a legal framework
that upholds law and order with administrative functions bestowed upon officers in regulatory
capacities as well as the social dynamics to maintain control and respect by and on behalf of
the social collective (Mahadevan B. et al., 2022, p. 717).
b. The basis of taxation was fueled by the element of fairness that went both ways,
particularly in relation to the cost of labour and its returns;
4
c. Net profits were taxed with respect to trade and commerce;
e. Only a gradual increase in tax rates was allowed by the state; and
Tax exemption was imposed on military villages, students studying in Gurukulams, the poor,
those lacking capacity and women who owned negligible wealth. This was premised on
protecting the weak and on humanitarian grounds. Taxation was collected as in-kind payments
and 15% to 20% of the proceeds could be returned to the land-taxed local bodies from the
central government. The general rate was 16% and tax rates varied according to the produce
and goods traded.
Mainly because Brahmanas were living in poverty as a vow, they were expected to educate
others in Vedic and Sanskrit education without seeking monetary emoluments. To this extent,
they were only to pay quit rent when revenue was generated for the Brahmanas in such
circumstances by the Agraha villages. Therefore, as a general rule, Brahmanas were to pay
taxes if revenue was generated and in exceptional circumstances, the Brahmana poor and
lacking state patronage were exempted from taxation.
Unfortunately, not all Kings professed such equitable leadership traits when taxing their
subjects. Records show that Kings unaligned to the above principles abused their positions,
leaving the people in destitute circumstances. King Sankaravarman taxed the subjects so
heavily and left them only with air to breathe. Under Kulottunga III, the unjust tax rates resulted
in protests and imprisonment thereof. They were only released when payment due was settled.
It must also be mentioned that specific Assemblies in Karnatak and Tanjore allowed for
resolution of taxation issues among the members and even when to the extent of specifying
proportionate tax rates to be adopted (Alterkar, 1949, p. 209).
In responding to the above approach appearing in ancient Indian leadership models,
exploitation of resources was not seen as the economic norm to facilitate trade and investment
with regard to taxation. Transfer pricing was not practiced by the trading class to benefit from
other jurisdictions nor professing to weaker taxation laws designed to address transfer pricing.
This process respected taxation and its inherent purposes within the local villages and heads to
secure their lives and livelihoods.
Mainly due to the agricultural economy that thrived during the ancient Vedic period, the wealth
of the state was a reflection of sound financial planning to assist in building the Treasury and
the army. The King was assigned to safeguard these necessities for the benefit of the subjects.
As a leader, he was to exercise his role in order to maintain economic strength and prosperity
in good times and more so in the bad. Recruiting able officers to impart these duties was part
and parcel of this revenue-generating exercise. Penalties (Analtya) provided another means of
contribution towards a healthy economic balance. This framework ensured the leader was
tasked with employing sustainable economic and legal measures to enhance trade and
commerce for the collective well-being (Mahadevan B. et al., 2022).
5
The diagram below characterizes the importance of taxation and the role of the treasury in the
state apparatus. A well-stocked and managed treasury was crucial for the state to manage its
resources during bouts of scarcity. State income was classified according to city, country,
mines, irrigation, works, forests, cattle-herds and trade routes. State enterprises were subjected
to tax and import duties and indigenous produce attracted excise duty, usually collected at the
gates. Fines were imposed for selling produce at resource sites such as at mines, gardens, and
grain fields.
6
Therefore, the leader will be emboldened to serve the community because the religious premise
permits renunciation as a valid attempt to redistribute resources through the spiritual
manifestation of self-detachment.
Another central theme in the Gita dispels the notion of intrinsic selfishness. This is a response
to idealizing the Self as the eternal soul which resides in all as the Supreme. With this
worldview, Prabhupada (1986) opined that “concentrated selfishness” and “extended
selfishness” would be a thing of the past, mainly due to the effulgence of the Supreme
consciousness, a commitment to the welfare of others and the assimilation of servant leadership
principles. This implies a focus on others and not on oneself and personal ambitions. This
approach respects the collective as a just means to a political end.
The Gita advocates the control of one’s senses to refine the mind and its cognitive abilities.
This is done by practicing dhayana yoga, the union of self-regulation based on meditation
practices. This exercise of the mind cleanses the inner workings of the uncontrolled mind,
fueled by mental agitations and other constant flows of energy consumption negating
productive thoughts. Leaders can also benefit from the three Gunas analogy found in the Gita
that groups characteristics according to the inherent fluid tendencies.
Nayak (2018) narrates the three Gunas for the uninitiated. The Sattva Guna is the mode of
goodness and includes qualities such as knowledge, happiness, purity, and self-control. The
Rajas Guna personifies the mode of passion. These qualities are exhibited as restlessness,
intense emotion, false pride and easily affected by joy and sorrow. The Tamas Guna is the
mode of ignorance which accompanies indifference, confusion and procrastination. These
modes are in constant flux, depending on the conditions of the individual. As personal and
professional capacity dictates, controlling the senses incidentally relate to the flows of each
separate Guna and its corresponding influence on the individual. Presently, leaders that can
harness the continued exertion of these self-controlled Gunas can make progressive decisions
and limit disorderly conduct, unbefitting of their positions. This self-improvement tool enables
the process of transformational leadership to take place and find solace in Sattva qualities.
Time (Kala) is regarded as the agent of change and plays an active role in leading this change.
Therefore, leading by example involves utilizing time wisely and to accept change as it presents
itself to the leader. This is presupposed by the notion of performing one’s duty righteously,
pursuant to one’s dharma. The indifference towards success or failure connects the impartial
elements to one’s actions. This approach discards the drive attached to the results of actions,
and fends off the element of greed that consumes such desirous pathways.
The wisdom found in the Gita does not correspond directly to the western narrative. However,
when paired as transformative effects, this universal culture of imparting valuable knowledge
through teaching as an invocation exists. This approach is presented by Lord Krishna, the guru
and Arjuna, the disciple. The mentally agitated Arjuna received mentoring by his guru on
objectives and results arising from cause and effect. This transformative capacity can be
appreciated by all aspiring leaders capable of honing their skill sets and mental well-being.
These self-induced actions contain the innate ability to adopt western-centric values which take
into account the self-fulfillment of human potential in its highest grandeur.
Jeste and Vahia (2008) highlight the differences in the western and eastern outlooks. The west
invests in material pleasures and shies away from the spiritual God-based social judgment. The
7
Gita catapults duty and work-based presumptions in spiritual pursuits, whereas other post-
modern western schools represent secular beliefs that are modeled for personal success and
self-gratification of the senses. In essence, there is a cultural shift that can take place in this
civilizational kaleidoscope of spiritual cognizance. Finding merit in imparting the wisdom in
the Gita carries the groundwork most leadership schools can benefit from, precisely by
educating the Arjunas of their potential to deliver when duty calls to lead wisely.
8
parting with concentrated power is a monumental task. In other circumstances, micro-
managing personnel can come dangerously close to employees who have their assigned roles.
This cloistered ambiance suffocates growing talent who are honing their responsibilities in the
organizational hierarchy. Therefore, Rama teaches us to instill confidence in individuals who
are assigned their respective roles in the leadership framework. In this manner, the collective
functions and intended consequences, leading to victory in the Ramayana.
Vibhishana’s role in the Ramayana is testament to his individual ethics devoid of his familial
ties. Human rights education can be taught in the way Vibhishana displayed his inherent
peaceful tendencies. To the extent of Ravana’s aggressive exploits and the familial ties that
bound them, the younger brother of Ravana was bigger in heart and mind. Without fear or
favour, Vibhishana tried to talk his elder brother out of his monstrous ambitions. Power was
Ravana’s tool and enterprise-driven agenda. His motives mirrored his inward desires.
Fortunately, Vibhishana found strength in the power of peaceful motives, and drove his will
towards Rama and his collective. This personal attempt takes inner strength to uproot, away
from one’s familial convenience towards the guiding light of good conscience.
A true leader has the willingness to take the right side in these situations which have a powerful
resonance with futures and leadership potential. Having the ideals at heart, learning to make
powerful small steps in the right direction is Vibhishana’s model characteristic of a true leader.
Unlike Kumbhakarna who did not leave Ravana’s side, family bondage and privileges,
Vibhishana’s actions constitute an act of leadership by example, looking to peaceful means as
a source of power.
Finally, Hanuman is another example of a leader who can put his Ego aside for the greater
good. In his fight with the mother of serpents, Surasha, Hanuman retreated to the size of a
mosquito as Surasha multiplied her size to fit her Ego. Kumar D. et al., (2020) point to this
subtle male characteristic as opposed to the female characteristic in their keen scholarly sense
of male leadership criteria. This element falls squarely on men holding corporate positions,
outlining the soul of service and the need to leave the Ego at the lower stages in human
development. The duty of a leader can surpass the mundane needs of the Ego-ridden
manifestations. Hanuman did not match Surasha’s Ego-ridden motives. In contrast, Hanuman
surpassed that of Surasha’s mental strength and impressed her enough to let him pass. A leader
can look to Hanuman’s conduct as a sign of maturity in the face of adversity. Presenting this
front in leadership is not a sign of weakness, but rather a sign of inner strength one can revisit
via managerial roles facing internal conflicts.
9
provide context for the ancient text. However, the reader maybe surprised to note the
similarities in the following paragraphs.
Leadership traits can be observed at Kurral 382 which lays down courage, magnanimity,
intelligence and enthusiasm as the four qualities a leader should adopt (Chendroyaperumal and
Meena, 2007, p. 4). Ethical leadership is assumed at Kurral 384 and includes ethical behaviour
underlying the needs-based test for governance. Implicitly, governance devoid of ethics is
deemed incomplete governance. Therefore, behavioral traits are interwoven with ethics and
leadership qualities for an able and functioning government of the day. Intrinsically, social
cognitive resource theory embeds Kurral 390 in defining brilliant traits found in a leader,
namely, rewarding, awarding grants, good governance and paying attention to social welfare
of subjects. Therefore, responsible leadership appears to be a composite set of traits that can be
perfectly aligned to conventional theories. This analysis provides a glimpse of the similarities
and nuances that are present in the TiruKurral.
There are other notable traits that a leader can grasp from this text. In the translation by
Jayaprakasam (2019), remaining unbiased is specifically spelt out in Kurral 119. One who has
removed bias from his/her mind will always project a pronouncement that is independent. A
leader who is able to remain impartial when making decisions on behalf of the nation will
reflect the quality of decisions made. Apart from that, realizing the truth is another trait the
leader should embrace. Kurrals 354 and 355 highlights that intelligence goes in search of truth,
the innate propensity, and building the capacity for realizing the truth is fundamental in order
to attain the mastery of the five senses. In this context, the ideals truths hold and nurture are
seen as fundamental for the strengths to be imbibed in leadership. Unfortunately, in current
times, these ideals preserved in this text ring hollow due to many reasons. One being the need
to shield truths for material gains and individual prosperity. In this light, the Tirukurral reserves
its rights for the truth to be heard, through the able leader.
The element of refinement is seen as a boon for the leader. Kurral 1000 aptly states that a rich
person with unrefined senses is akin to pure milk becoming putrid due to a stain. Kurral 997
also looks at intelligence unrefined as a dummy block. For a more meaningful attempt at
finding the common good in all, Kurral 996 states that the world stays as it is because of the
refined person. Otherwise, the world would suffer destruction in the hands of the unrefined.
Therefore, the refinement of the senses is not only for the budding leader, but also for an entire
community to preserve their sanctity and creative abilities as human beings. As a member of
the ecosystem, Kurral 995 specifically states that refined persons would not stoop so low as to
deride others of their personality despite suffering from the enmity within themselves. These
are elements of higher-level consciousness that one needs to develop in order to be able to
handle these tense situations. Common parlance dictates that defamation actions are common
place when the unrefined demonstrate their abilities upon others. This is multiplied by the
emergence of lawyers who take this task on as a career to boost their futures. This under-
developed trait is then a tool for income generators that seek to exploit the unrefined person’s
senses to the detriment of his/her financial capacity.
Finally, the Thirukurral dedicates a chapter on governance and the sovereign. Kurral 388 deems
that meting out justice by the King in a wholesome manner is a precondition for protecting his
subjects. Other Kurrals in this specific chapter point to righteousness as a path of virtue (Kurral
384) portraying prestige by upholding it as a mark of valour. Becoming one with these virtues,
10
a leader has set high standards for his/her branch of leadership. Moreover, these embedded
qualities are seen as stepping stones that all can journey upon. For the leader, it becomes
imperative to adopt these traits because his/her leadership will set the markers for building
better futures in the land and for the inhabitants thereof.
In conclusion, these set of Kurrals offer valuable guidance to the lost and serve as constant
reminders to the alert. Being of value to the upcoming leader, spiritual growth is sorely
abandoned, as many go in search of material and financial pursuits to make leaders of
tomorrow. This ancient text ignites reasons as to why one has to look to high-level thoughts
and values in order to sustain success and treat others as one would want to be treated.
11
when the Vetal questioned the King as to whom he thinks has the penchant to perform evil
actions, the King’s answer places an emphasis on education and the need to discriminate
between good and evil. He thinks unlike males, women are prone to evil deeds, because they
are not conditioned to use this art of discrimination. Here, the reader should understand the
underlying note of female empowerment that requires attention. If women are educated and
given the platform to develop their mental abilities, they will not be prone to causing harm to
others. Therefore, the leader should enhance women empowerment and give space for women
participation.
Another noteworthy tale is that of the two magic balls. These magic balls were tactics deployed
by one Vamanaswami to deceive the King and planned to wed his daughter. He received this
advice from Muladeva but the trickster decided to turn his back on Vamanaswami and made
his partner, Sasi marry the King’s daughter in an open and transparent manner. Sasi married
the princess with the consent of the King and left Vamanaswami rudderless. From this tale, the
Vetal asked King Vikram who should be the rightful husband to the princess, to which the King
replied, Sasi. He was assured that Vamanaswami’s tactical misconduct, and seeking advice
from the trickster, Muladeva should not be rewarded. Instead, he welcomed transparency and
openness to seek the hand of the princess, conduct, worthy of appraisal. From this tale, one can
assume following procedural safeguards is tantamount to respecting law and order. If
Muladeva’s magic balls were used for discreet purposed resulting in unethical actions, King
Vikram would not condone these actions to be appropriate and/or intelligent to be subjected to
rewards of any kind.
The Panchatantra is a treatise, a collection of fables for children and adults alike. It comprises
of an open canon of five Tantras, each corresponding to distinct knowledge aspects. Taylor
(2020) loosely translated the five Tantras in chronological order. The first Tantra, “how to
break up a friendship”, the second Tantra, “how to win friends”, the third Tantra, “traditional
hostility, the fourth Tantra, “Loss of what is being gained”, and the fifth and only human
beings-based Tantra, “Rash deeds” reflecting his interpretation. These fables are similar to
Aesop Fables of the western canon and can be grouped together to demonstrate traits a leader
can pick up. Initially, the Panchatantra was believed to be written by Visnu Saman upon the
request of King Amarasakti who had three sons who showed no interest in study. To enhance
the spirit of learning, Visnu Saman was tasked to author the five Tantras to make the sons
develop their inclination to learn and absorb knowledge in the form of animal stories depicting
characters such as crocodiles, monkeys, owls and crows, and lion and bulls.
In Book Three, the owls become a victim of deception. The crows plot ways to bring down the
parliament of owls. The crow conference takes place with various strategies being discussed
and discounted. Unfortunately, the owls hold a double-agent crow captive and find themselves
in a losing position and ultimate downfall. Various debates and supportive arguments are
gleaned from other narratives and materials to hold these propositions as valid in the conference
and the parliament respectively. Here, the leader can learn to be wary of cunning strategies
designed to harm others, the enemy within the four walls of the state. Ultimately, the art of
deception can lead to untimely deaths and loss of amenities. In this book, hostility among
common enemies is picturesquely explained to impart realistic consequences a leader needs to
acknowledge. Therefore, the Panchatantra is suitable for adult professionals heading big
organisations, staying wary of their cunning competitors who may plot to harm reputations and
bring down legacies.
12
The Dharmic Duties in Leadership gleaned from Shanti Parva in the Mahabharata
The Shanti Parva describes the political ideology of Bhisma as he lays dying at the battlefield.
Amidst the men who come to seek counsel from this dying male presence, Bhisma relays his
pearls of wisdom which are attributes a leader can take up. His narrative has underlying tones
of disapproving of womanhood. However, this denotes the service that is expected of from men
and requires higher level responsibilities and duties that come attached for men to perform.
The Shanti Parva touches on various domains of leadership. These include but are not limited
to kinship, governance, diplomacy and ethical fundamentals for the prosperity of the internal
development of the leader and subjects (Garg, 2004). Of the many conversations Bhisma shares
in his dying days, his narrative gives the importance of upholding the dharma for the purposes
of sustaining righteousness on behalf of all living creatures that dwell among us. Therefore,
Rajadharma and Rajdharmanushasan are two aspects that clarify advice on royal duties and
responsibilities and the need for effective government to run the affairs on behalf of the masses.
The preservation of dharma implies the ideal workings of wealth accumulation (Artha) and
desires springing forth from within (Kama). Derived from the divine presence and the social
contract between the King and the subjects, this line of leadership advice also invokes law and
punishment (Danda) for the leader to supplant his/her duties.
In Canto 10 of the Rajadharmanusasana Parva, Part 1 of Shanti Parva, Bhisma outlines the
importance of meaningful actions to support an interconnected system consisting of the
existing social order and the natural tendencies for the purposes of execution. Here, being
passive and remaining inactive is highly disapproved of when active participation is expected.
Bhisma demarked the range of responsibilities that arise in the social order, making each
contribution a purposive account for respective stations in life. The dharmic consistency
maintains this equilibrium by monitoring performance in action of all workings of karmic
balance. This can arise in the conduct of the warrior class keeping up to their duties and/or the
leader’s role to take up Rajadharma responsibilities. This ensures the wheel of meaningful
actions continues to remain in motion (Menon, 2009).
In Canto 57, Bhisma observes the symbolism of a true leader, one who builds the confidence
of all his/her subjects. A leader who is able to speak truth to power and develop a sound
temperament is able to make decisions with a clear mind, free from insincere conduct and
emotional outbursts. Mainly due to the reliance on the sastras, judicious actions are ordained
by counsel who must be kept secret from others. In many circumstances, confidentiality is
paramount and keeping state secrets, a statutory obligation. In this manner, sound decisions
will not be affected by espionage and/or vices stemming from third parties. Peace-building
efforts become the catalyst for followers who are confident with the leader’s approach to
safeguarding their interests and bringing empowerment through the sphere of influence and
order. Securing peace and protection is the prime responsibility of a leader, as noted in Canto
58. This measure must be pursuant to righteous actions mandated by able counsel and to further
ascertain the nature of protection. In essence, a leader with crooked intentions will fail to
safeguard those counting on him/her for safe passage in life. Therefore, the force of strength in
a leader is an exertion of affirmative action that resonates with merit, enforced according to the
Rajadharma.
In areas that deal primarily with governance, policy matters and legislation, Bhishma’s counsel
professes that virtues must be open to objective scrutiny. Bhisma opined that legislators need
13
to stand up for the right side, which requires courage, truthfulness and sincerity. Counsels
learned in their respective fields will be a source of strength for the leader who will then require
adequate counsel in various legislative corners. Furthermore, solution-providers who observe
their commitments and stay true to their pledges will be around long enough to see sustainable
leadership. Walking away from problems and leaving the camp in the face of adversity amounts
to disorderly conduct unbefitting of their stations. The act of concealment is to keep their wise
counsels away from the limelight. This is partially rooted in the contribution of policy
developments without compromising on standards. Bhisma warns of the deceiving, envious
and vain. Finding able gurus and being educated in the “science of consultation” will ensure
balanced opinions and effective running of the government. In international relations, this is
linked to the collective strength of human capital, extensively discussed in Canto 83 (Menon,
2009).
Cantos 93 to 95 speaks of the public confidence a leader must instill in his/her followers.
Bhisma noted that leaders who do not meet these high standards will begin to lose their
influence among counsels and will slowly grow to undermine the state of governance and
eventually impact the subjects. When the presence of dharma starts losing its significance,
paying lip service to values become the norm, safeguarding self-interests and resorting to the
concentration of power will all form the dark ages. The analogy that is drawn out is that of a
large bag puffed up with wind as the dharmic elements begin to shed away, leaving with the
wind. As a direct result, the wind takes the adharmic persona away from its internal roots,
making him appear as “an earthen pot broken on a stony surface” deserving the consequences
that befall the leader. In this manner, the means to achieve the results must be built on dharmic
foundations seeking to embrace higher deals. Likewise, finding just means to create wealth and
harmony will depend substantially on leadership styles that do not seek to cut corners, nor
hopiing to get ahead of others in pursuit of personal fruits and currying favours.
Hence, the Shanti Parva is another valuable source of literature that seeks to implore future
leaders to develop their capabilities in securing a better future for others who do not have these
responsibilities accorded to them. Women were not painted in a meaningful light in these male-
dominated spheres. However, times have since changed and women can equally learn from
these bodies of literature to fulfill their dharma in various positions of leadership. This
approach can see equal participation of women and henceforth result in their empowerment as
they become exposed to various counselling sessions for the leader in waiting.
14
ignorance and transcend to the absolute Reality, the Brahman. Ethical goodness and ethical
evil are bound by certain characteristics that entertain such behaviour. These ethical
characteristics resonate with justice, the abolition of barriers in the social order, finding the
common in the universal existence, and living honestly. In contrast, selfish leanings contribute
to ethical evil, feeding the Ego. Bearing in mind that ethical conduct is a valid means to an end,
the trajectory of non-dualism brings together ethical conduct to concentrate upon direct
experiences that allows One to realise the Inner Reality found in all. This is the golden thread
that runs across space, time and causation, acting on its inter-dependent axis.
Shankara’s set of virtues bring forth this sense of connectedness among all and celebrates self-
control, mental poise, forbearance, tranquility and liberation. Therefore, as a seeker of
knowledge, the leader resorts to a guru who can illumine the path for ethical means to help
others. Liberation therefore are attempts to free oneself from selfish motives that bind the leader
towards personal gain and harmful self-interests. The English translation by Prabhavananda
and Isherwood (1971) gives prominence to the role of a teacher who is free from impurities
that haunt the untrained mind. The teacher’s abilities must be a call for a student who finds
devotion in his/her to service. In this context, human capacity is trained to build bridges and
hone talents to bring forth the light that shines as the illumed Atman. Therefore, education
tailored in this manner will train leaders to look beyond their personal interests clouding their
leadership capabilities designed to uplift the collective.
Furthermore, the concept of Rajas, Tamas and Sattva qualities are reproduced to bring clarity
to the uninitiated. In the tree of life, Tamas is the seed with potential to spring forth as creation.
The Rajasic desires envelope the leaves, the trunk and embody the sap. The vital forces and
sense-objects therein are the branches, twigs and flowers which ultimately bear fruit. In this
analogy, the individual is the bird that eats the fruit off the tree of life (Prabhavananda and
Isherwood, 1971, p. 66). In this sensual state, the leader needs to be taught how to discriminate
between the bondage of being caught up with oneself and the need to be armed with knowledge
of oneness to keep the mind pure, bound by Sattvic qualities. These skill sets empower the
leader to think of the collective as the interconnected Oneness.
Finally, the leader should be open to debates and advocacy that seek to bring progress to the
collective and appreciate the role of the scholarly community. This is aptly documented in the
debate between Adi Shankara and King Mandana Misra. The presiding judge was the Queen
consort and the debate lasted for many days. It concerned the philosophical premise of the
Brahman, the interpretation of Tat Tvam Asi, the doctrine of unity and its corresponding
contradictions, the purposive approach to Vedic authority and the persuasive authority of
supportive texts and materials. The winner of the debate would assume the responsibilities and
respective duties of the other’s vocation and stage in life; either the monk or the householder
respectively. During this discourse, the premise of the debate was strictly bound by their thesis
(pratijna), the means of knowledge (pramanas), and the binding conditions, with an
unequivocal agreement to respect the verdict (Tripathi, 2016).
The King lost the debate, and the verdict was handed down by the Queen consort, Bharati Misra
who was made the umpire (Sadasya). As a direct result, the King became one of Shankara’s
devoted disciples and committed himself to annotating Shankara’s Brahma sutras. This act of
leadership portrays the need for debates and the recognition of the younger generation in this
forum for talent development and intellectual progress. ‘Sureshvara Archarya’ therefore,
15
becomes the disciple-King of Adi Shankara. This change of heart by the King endorsed the
importance of debates and refined advocacy in the absence of adversarial means and the
assumption of tactical positions.
Adi Shankara was a learned individual and wise beyond his tender years. His capabilities as a
young scholar were celebrated and given prominence by the King in his Court. In the absence
of ugly tactics and a deep sense of mutual respect for the art of debate, the Shankara-dig-vijaya
documents these utterances in written form. In this regard, developing a keen sense of the art
of debate and equal participation allows the leader to observe this prestigious ancient art in
theory and practice.
16
Source: Sathish M. et. al., 2020
Therefore, the diagram above is constructed by Sathish M. et. al., (2020) to provide a thorough
fixation of the three Gunas and its corresponding leadership models. It provides an internal
perspective and its direct output is based on qualities hinged internally in one’s Self. For self-
reflection purposes, the leader is able to gage his/her qualities based on these fluid criteria and
change their respective styles. Further to this, other colleagues would be able to initiate
feedback to improve other structural flaws based on poor leadership styles. Pertaining to
leadership awareness for the finer values and ideals, potential leaders can look for guidance
herein and work towards enhancing their leadership capabilities.
The Indian Knowledge Systems (IKS) repository is an amalgamation of scholarly output that
is dated as ancient as 3000 BCE to 1800 CE. It covers a variety of knowledge systems with
references to spirituality, governance, statecraft and accompanying literature that has stood the
test of time. In preserving these written and oral traditions, many attempts have been made to
secure adequate recognition and preservation to bring forth its unique contribution in the sphere
of knowledge creation.
Drawing insights from the Indian epics (Itihasa) provide a basis to analyse leadership styles
portrayed by the characters pursuant to their distinct Gunas. Therefore, the Mishra model of
leadership is considered to be the morphed aspects which other prevalent models do not present
in their natural elements. For these reasons, the Daiva model of leadership carries with it, traits
that a leader can seek to study and adopt in naturally arising situations.
17
Leadership models analyzed in this section, can range from head prefects in school, CEOs’
running multinational corporations, to the Head of States taking up ministerial responsibilities.
Finding coherence in the international global architecture in sustainable leadership is critical at
this juncture. Currently, threats by climate change destruction, unfettered capitalism and
resource exploitation are harming the ecosystem. With these challenges in mind, leaders can
look to ancient models from a personal angle and reflect upon the impact and ways to meet
international challenges. Other leadership models do not look to the basis of the three Gunas
and its overall impact on the world at large.
Knowing one’s internal construct and finding the side-effects is a well-founded approach that
is designed to tap into the wealth of Indian Knowledge Systems offerings. This method seeks
to improve one’s state of being. Respecting these attributes and finding common ground
between different human setbacks constitute a universal approach designed to look past
national boundaries and differences in cultural perspectives.
The political situation in Myanmar and Russia are valid scenarios, aptly described, using the
diagram above, without the need to resort to regional alignments and communal setbacks.
Current leadership styles in two very different parts of the world are the source of constant
attempts at resolving state aggression. To counter these threats to harmony and collective
peace, spotting Ravana qualities and Rama attributes sheds light on behavioral rationale
employed by certain actors to exhaust their individual desires (Vasanas). Studying these minds
as they harness their unfettered power will enable significant others to find ways to gravitate
towards bolder versions of leadership that empower the average citizen, the aspiring student
activist or the diligent scholar.
Conclusion
In modern times, leadership schools are mushrooming in many parts of the world to tackle
leadership shortcomings. A valid example is the approach adopted by the British government
and the European Union as they proceeded with Brexit negotiations and breaches of the
Northern Ireland Protocol. The Belfast Agreement was forged to maintain international peace
between two countries that would become peaceful neighbours in the future. Due to leadership
constraints, the world witnessed the legal battles and unprofessional mannerism of the outgoing
state in the face of the Brexit departure.
In the same vein, the Russia-Ukraine aggression highlights another prominent example of
leadership pressed towards harming another’s sovereignty and breaking international law. As
a result, economic sanctions were imposed on Russia and an energy supply crisis is the direct
consequence for the European Union and its brand of open strategic autonomy. As Ukraine
raced towards the European Union for security and shelter, China filled the vacuum to
strengthen the international order and brought systemic cohesion to power relations in this
geopolitical collision between the Global North and the rest of the world. In this regard, public
opinion is divided as to which brand of leadership and its accompanying attributes are to be
held as the gold standard for other nations to adopt.
18
Closer to ASEAN shores, Myanmar experienced a power grab as the lady leader, Aung San
Suu Kyi was ousted by the military Junta. This country descended into chaos as civilians were
subjected to aggressive state control, costing civilian lives and livelihoods. Here too, other
developed nations heaped economic sanctions, further crippling the economy, resulting in
continued stagnation for progress. In this regard, Myanmar was pushed to a dark corner by
high-level players in international organizations and amongst the ASEAN community. This is
the state of leadership affairs for the selected few and the harmful effects are experienced by
significant millions.
In Sri Lanka, their leadership was ousted by the commoners, and was forced to seek shelter in
Singapore. There, Gotabaya Rajapaksa formally issued an email correspondence affirming his
resignation as the Head of State. Huge numbers started taking to the Sri Lankan streets and
caused unavoidable aggression on Sri Lankan soil. The economic meltdown saw prices sky-
rocketing to unimaginable levels. Students could not take exams because paper became scarce
and staple food for consumption became a luxury item. Naturally, China did not intervene to
safeguard its vested interests and strategic assets in Sri Lanka. As a free country with business
ties, it merely watched on as ugly scenes unfolded in Sri Lanka, expressing no intention of
making a foreign intervention in domestic political struggles. With other interests at stake,
Beijing walked into Afghanistan to strengthen economic ties with the Taliban, as the world
witnessed the United States walking away from its peacebuilding efforts. Therefore, failed
leadership attempts ring louder for all who live in peaceful environments and sustain privileged
livelihoods
In this plethora of disharmony, leadership traits lie aplenty in ancient Indian texts, documented
for future generations. Characters who appeared as Daiva and Asura in the Gita, Ramayana,
Mahabharata and ancient fables speak of these fluid traits.
Similarly, other renowned scholars such as Adi Shankara brought their brand of leadership to
the Indic spaghetti bowl. The electorate was keen to witness the scholar and the King debating
on matters of philosophy and reason. The Queen consort was made the umpire to adjudicate
the debate. Eventually, the King switched to disciple-hood, respecting the verdict and the
young scholar won the debate, teaching the leader to become a better version of himself.
Legal advisors and the King’s counsel were monumental figures for the leader to rely upon.
Texts such as the Arthasastra and the Nitisastra document essential needs that must occupy
the hearts and minds of the many and not the few. These were enumerated as leadership
pointers observed in taxation principles, legal standards, and the fundamentals of knowledge
preservation. The Sastras outlined an ethical code of conduct established in Rajadharma, the
leader’s duties and were subsequently tied to heavy responsibilities and the central protection
of the collective.
In this regard, divine power that rested in the King as the fountain of justice still carries
symbolism in today’s England and Wales. The Royal Courts of Justice and the Inns of Court
are a reflection of its Royal titles. The British academies and institutions of learning also carry
the “Royal” title to extrapolate this royal presence. In this manner, today’s Rajadharma duties
have assumed symbolic undertones on behalf of the Royal presence.
Finding ways to hone future leaders should not be limited to prestigious institutions that only
accept the elite and cater to their exploits. Leadership must be seen to embrace the three Gunas
19
to provide able leadership at all levels. Concentration of power and adharmic values which
sustain these efforts will see countries fall into disrepute, engage in chaos among its electorate
and produce refugees fleeing to other parts of the world in search of safety and better futures.
Presently, countries that are stuck in this irreparable condition face foreign interference in their
domestic sphere of influence, are forced to rely on foreign investments to save their domestic
economy, and harm their domestic capabilities and human capital.
With these constant threats and challenges, leadership must find its place and must deliver
when the occasions arise. To counter the adharmic forces that are present and all- pervading,
looking to dharmic traits in leadership formulas will bring together various characteristics. This
can be picked up by future leaders for their day-to-day responsibilities. These characteristics
are not meant to be exclusively for males-dominated roles. Following this gender-neutral
perspective, the ability of a person to refine his/her senses according to the Gunas will then
experience the development of the internal Self and its untapped potential.
Leadership figures such as Rama and Ravana further teach us the nature of the unfoldment of
the Self. One can learn the behavioral shortcomings from Ravana and follow one’s path
towards refining the senses. We can harness power in knowledge accumulation and seek to
embrace intellectual humility. We can aspire to embrace higher values and discard lower
tendencies. We can find guidance in Krishna’s empowering words and Bhisma’s responsible
mandates. Therefore, renunciation of the fruits of actions will lead one towards higher goals
and aspirations, without compromising on standards and principles. This pathway is
sustainable for all leaders who are free to choose their destiny.
20
References
Agarwal D. (2016). Listen, O’ King: Five-and-twenty tales of King Vikram and the Vetal. Puffin Classics,
Penguin Random House, India.
Alterkar A.S. (1949). State and Government in Ancient India, From Earliest Times to c. 1200 A.D. Motilal
Banarsidass, Banaras.
Bendale S. and Sharma P. (2017). A critical analysis of Valmiki’s Ramayana and its implications to
management & leadership qualities. International Journal of Academic Research and Development, 2(6),
1002-1005.
Burns, J.M. (1978). Leadership. New York, NY: Harper and Row.
Central Hindu College, (1904). Sanatana Dharma: An Advanced Textbook of Religion and Ethics. The Board of
Trustees, Central Hindu College, Benares.
Chendroyaperumal, Chendrayan and Meena, M. Archana, (2007). Indian Theory of Leadership from
Thirukkural. https://ssrn.com/abstract=1334703
Dilip V., Jeste, M.D. and Ipsit V. Vahia, M.D. (2008). Comparison of the Conceptualization of Wisdom in
Ancient Indian Literature with Modern Views: Focus on the Bhagavad Gita. NIH Public Access Psychiatry
71(3) 197–209.
Garg S. (2004). Political Ideas in Shanti Parva. The Indian Journal of Political Science, 65 (1), 77-86.
Jayaprakasam R. J.P. (2019). Thirukurral: Text in English and Tamil. Porselvi Pathippagam, Chennai.
Kumar D., Sinha A.K. and Singh D. (2020). Leadership Lessons for CEO’s from Hanuman. Center for
Spiritualism and Human Enrichment, Purusharta: Journal of Management, Ethics and Spirituality, 12(2),
82-94.
Mahadevan B., Bhat V.R., Nagendra Pavana R.N. (2022). Introduction to Indian Knowledge System Concepts
and Applications. PHI Private Limited, Delhi.
Menon R. (2009). The Complete Mahabharata, Adi Parva. Rupa Publications, New Delhi, India.
Muniapan, B. (2007). Transformational leadership style demonstrated by Sri Rama in Valmiki Ramayana.
International Journal Indian Culture and Business Management 1 (1/2), 104–115.
Nayak, A.K. (2018). Effective leadership traits from Bhagavad Gita. International Journal Indian Culture and
Business Management, 16(1), 1–18.
Prabhupada, A.C.B.S. (1986). Bhagavad Gita: As It Is. Bhakti Vedanta Book Trust, Mumbai.
Sathish M., Rajat Bhat V., Varma M S., Balasundarsun N.L. (2019). Leadership Lessons from Indian
Knowledge System. Purushartha, Journal of Management, Ethics and Spirituality 12(2).
S.S. Ali. (2006). Kautilya and the Concept of Good Governance. The Indian Journal of Political Science, 67(2),
375-380.
Strohmeier J. (2009). The Bhagavad Gita According to Gandhi, North Atlantic Books Berkeley, California.
Taylor M. (2019). A Companion to World Literature: The Panchatantra World Literature Before “World
Literature”. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, New York.
21
Tichy, N.M. and Devanna, M.A. (1990). The Transformational Leader. Wiley, New York.
Tisdell C. (2003). A Western Perspective on Kautilya’s ‘Arthasastra’: Does it Provide a Basis for Economic
Science. Working Paper (18) School of Economics, University of Queensland, Australia.
Tripathi R. (2016). Vada in Theory and Practice: Studies in Debates, Dialogues and Discussions in Indian
Intellectual Discourses. Indian Institute of Advanced Study
22