Our Secret Moments - Janisha Boswell
Our Secret Moments - Janisha Boswell
Our Secret Moments - Janisha Boswell
DRAYTON HILLS
BOOK 1
JANISHA BOSWELL
OCEANOFPDF.COM
Copyright © 2024 by Janisha Boswell.
All rights reserved.
No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any electronic or mechanical means,
including information storage and retrieval systems, without written permission from the author,
except for the use of brief quotations in a book review.
Cover design by Layla Brown.
OceanofPDF.com
For those who always have something to say.
And for those who listen.
OceanofPDF.com
The art of conversation lies in listening.
MICHAEL FORBES
OceanofPDF.com
CONTENTS
Content Warnings
Playlist
Dicktionary
1. Cat
2. Connor
3. Cat
4. Connor
5. Cat
6. Connor
7. Cat
8. Cat/Connor
9. Connor
10. Cat
11. Cat/Connor
12. Cat/Connor
13. Connor/Cat
14. Connor
15. Connor/Cat
16. Connor
17. Cat
18. Connor
19. Cat
20. Connor
21. Connor/Cat
22. Cat/Connor
23. Connor
24. Cat
25. Connor
26. Cat
27. Connor
28. Cat
29. Cat
30. Connor/Cat
31. Cat
32. Cat
33. Cat
34. Cat
35. Cat/Connor
36. Connor/Cat
37. Connor
38. Cat
39. Connor/Cat
40. Cat/Connor
41. Cat/Connor
42. Cat
43. Connor/Cat
Epilogue
Acknowledgments
About the Author
OceanofPDF.com
CONTENT WARNINGS
This book contains explicit content. It also deals with grief and the loss of a
parent as well as anxious thoughts and situations described on page. If these
are sensitive to you in any way, this book might not be the best for you to
read.
If you ever feel alone, talk to someone. Anyone. Talk to me. I’m always
here to listen and so are friends and/or a professional.
OceanofPDF.com
PLAYLIST
OceanofPDF.com
DICKTIONARY
For those that want to skip the particularly spicy scenes, or those that want
to skip straight to them. Whatever your preference. It’s a judge free zone
over here…
OceanofPDF.com
ONE
CAT
THE MANIFESTATION CHAMBER
OceanofPDF.com
TWO
CONNOR
FOOTBALL BUTT
OceanofPDF.com
THREE
CAT
“THESE ARE TEARS OF RELIEF! I PROMISE.”
I blink at the paper in front of me again. I can’t tell how long it’s been.
Maybe five minutes? Or maybe even an hour. All I know is that my face is
covered in tears as I reread the comments and feedback in front of me.
This is surreal.
I’m not living real life right now.
I passed. I didn’t get the best mark in the class like I had hoped, but I
got something even better.
Professor Rotford never leaves kind comments on reports. Ever. She’s
prone to constructive criticism only. She even told us on our first day of
classes that we should not expect a pat on the back for writing a sub-par
essay and that tears are not allowed in her classroom. I was tough enough to
take her criticism and I’ve been using it to improve my writing and it has
finally paid off.
This is a lot better than your last, but not
as good as one of your firsts. Your voice is
coming along very well, Catherine. You should be
grateful.
– A. Rotford.
I mean, she could have said ‘proud’ instead of ‘grateful,’ but a win is a
win, right? I wipe my face with the sleeve of my sweater, knowing my
makeup and my face in general is ruined. George elbows me, snickering a
little as the rest of the class talk amongst themselves about their reports. I
know he’s telling me to stop crying, but I can’t help it.
“Catherine.” Professor Rotford’s voice booms across the classroom. I
snap my head up, my glassy eyes meeting her steel blue ones. “Do you need
a second?”
“Oh, these are tears of relief! I promise,” I say through a sniffle, my
voice betraying my words.
She sighs, looking back down at her desk as she murmurs, “The door is
open.”
OceanofPDF.com
FOUR
CONNOR
“IS SHE FUCKING CRYING?”
When Nora and I moved out for college, we made an agreement with our
parents that we’d come home at least once every two weeks to visit them.
We’ve always had a strong relationship seeing as we’re the only children
and we don’t have much extended family.
They were only eighteen when they had Nora and I and it always felt
like they’re the ‘cool’ aunt and uncle all my friends talk about having. It's
always been us in this small little bubble in a huge house in Fort Collins.
High school me would definitely deny it, but I’m one hundred percent
sure that I’m a mama's boy. I’ve gotten used to it now, knowing that I’m
always going to need my mom in my corner, but as a kid I would do
anything to deny it.
I’ve always loved my dad and I always will. He’s the one I have to
thank for getting me into football, but there is nothing that will compare to
the kind of bond my mom and I have.
My mom was the one who dropped me off at my first day of middle
school and the same person who picked me up earlier after I freaked out
during the icebreakers.
My mom was the one who took me out for ice cream after winning my
first football game even when my dad tried to keep me on a diet.
My mom was the one who let me and Nora into her bed after she
miscarried and made my dad sleep on the floor of the bedroom. Even
though we fully didn’t understand the significance of what happened, she
let us be there for her and joked around with my dad when he made
breakfast for us the morning after.
Our family has never been perfect and it never will be. But that’s what I
like about coming home. I like coming home to the faint smell of pumpkin
and spices no matter what time of year it is. I like coming home to the
maroon comforter that lays on the back of the couch that never seems to
move. I like coming home into my parents arms as they run down the
driveway as Nora and I jump out of my truck.
My dad gets to Nora first, trapping her in a hug as if they haven’t seen
each other for years. It’s been two weeks, but still. My mom almost trips
over the overgrown grass as she runs towards me, her white summer dress
and red apron flowing in the wind as she reaches me.
I used to think mom was a princess because of the movies we used to
watch. “I’m not a princess, sweetie. I’m just your mom,” she told me once
after I went through a phase of calling her Princess Emma for a week
straight. “You’re the best mom-princess ever,” I told her.
“Oh, honey,” she says, pulling out of the hug she immediately trapped
me in. I smile up at her, her bright green eyes squinting at me in the sun. I
reach into the car quickly, returning with the cookies I made. “And a
Connor Bailey special? How did I get so lucky?”
“You’ll be lucky if you don’t die,” Nora shouts back, walking up the
path back into the house, chasing after my dad and probably pestering him
with questions about New York. Dad goes there a lot for business and it’s
her dream to go one day. My dad has been planning a big trip for her
twenty-first birthday, but she doesn’t know it yet. I do not want to be in the
same room as her when she finds out.
My mom wraps her arm around my shoulder, her blonde hair tickling
me. “How are you, my sunshine?”
“I’m good. Just a little tired,” I say, swaying with her as we walk into
the house. When she shuts the door, she studies me curiously, her arms now
pinned across her chest. “What?”
“You went out last night, didn’t you?”
“Yes…?”
“But you didn’t drink?” she asks, continuing her walk into the kitchen. I
follow behind her, not sure what she’s getting at exactly. I don’t say
anything and she takes my silence for an answer. “Connor.”
“Mom, you know I don’t drink during the season,” I say with a sigh,
taking a seat at the island.
“I know, I know. I just feel like you need to loosen up a little, you
know?”
“I can have fun without drinking.”
She sighs wistfully, looking out the window into the bright backyard
and then back to me. “I just don’t want you to miss out on things, that’s all.
You know I just want you to have fun. And part of that is because your dad
and I had to grow up pretty quickly. I just don’t want you to feel like you
need to be one-hundred percent responsible all the time, Connie.”
I’m not an uptight person. It’s never really been my style. Or, well, I
thought it wasn’t. That was until I started college, realised parties and
fraternities weren’t just for movies and they were actually very real.
Moving out and into a space where everybody wants to be out all the
time and drinking was the main priority, was daunting. So I stayed away
from it. I know people on my team can manage football and a social life
easily, but for me, eliminating the social aspect that leads to drama and
things that I can’t risk being apart of, has improved my performance
immensely. I want it to stay that way.
“I’m fine, mom. You don’t have to worry about me. Trust me, I’m
getting the full college experience,” I say as convincingly as I can. She
nibbles on her bottom lip before her shoulders sag, signifying defeat. She
presses a kiss to my forehead before walking past me and out of the
kitchen.
I don’t get another second to breathe before Nora walks in, her hair
somehow a mess from the car to the house as she inspects the box of
cookies on the counter. Mom took a bite of one already and seemed to enjoy
them. Well, she didn’t spit them out, but she also didn’t compliment them
either.
“What are these supposed to be?” Nora asks, shaking the box of steel
cookies.
“Cookies, obviously. Do you want one?”
Her face scrunches up. “Your baking looks like death inside a
Tupperware container.”
One thing about Nora? She knows exactly where your weak spots are
and how to poke them. “Mom ate one,” I say, desperately trying to justify
the fact that they look inedible.
Nora laughs. “That’s because she doesn’t want to hurt your feelings,”
she says sweetly, giving me that older sister – by eleven minutes – glare.
“Watch,” she says, moving towards the white kitchen wall that connects
with the living room. “Dad, do you want a cookie?”
“Ooh, yes,” my dad replies, his voice clear with excitement. I give Nora
a sarcastic smile. She’s such a know-it-all sometimes and it pisses me off.
“Connor made them,” she shouts back, a smug smile on her face.
“You know what? On second thought, I’m good,” my dad replies and
my heart sinks. Am I really that bad at baking? “I don’t want to fill up too
much before dinner.”
My sister holds her chin high, doing her famous exit which she’s
practised over a million times growing up.
I look back down at my apparently undesirable cookies and shove one
into my mouth. They can’t be that bad.
They somehow taste even worse than they did this morning. Still, I
force myself to eat it because nobody else will.
I love coming home to my perfectly imperfect family.
OceanofPDF.com
FIVE
CAT
FREE-FALLING AND FOOTBALLERS
If you have ever wondered how many times a person could fall asleep in
Annie Rotford’s class without her knowing, the answer is zero. Yet, George
manages to get a few seconds in before she slams a book closed and pushes
something over on purpose. She’s never openly discussed the common
pattern of people falling asleep in her class, but it’s obvious that her voice
puts people to sleep.
“George,” I whisper, nudging him with my shoulder. His head lolls
forward before his eyes shoot open, his blonde hair falling in his face. “You
need to stay awake. What the hell have you been doing?”
It’s not unusual for him to fall asleep in class. Holding his head up has
become my part-time job and I don’t mind it, but he’s been extra tired
today. He wipes the drool from the corner of his mouth. I would find it
gross if he didn’t have the looks and the attitude of a golden retriever.
“Jacks was watching some videos the other day,” he mumbles out of the
side of his mouth, pretending to take notes even though I know what he’s
writing doesn’t make any sense. “And he wanted to try something new. So,
he bought this toy from–”
I hold up my hand. “Forget I asked,” I say, shivering. “You and Jacks
are cute, but you’re also a little sickening. It should be illegal for two
people to love each other that much.”
His cheeks flush. “I know, sometimes I think–”
“Are you and your friend finished talking, Catherine, or am I boring
you?” Rotford’s voice brings us both back to the conversation as the rest of
class snickers. Not everyone in our class is as nice as George, which is why
I’m grateful to have him as my one friend in this class rather than have
twenty bad ones. We both nod in unison. “Good. I think this would interest
the both of you.”
I straighten my posture, instantly intrigued. When Rotford starts a rant
like that, you know it’s bound to be good. Everyone in the class quietens as
she switches the powerpoint on the main board, the title changing from our
last assignment feedback to a picture of… A football field?
What the hell?
“As you know, Drayton runs a series of campus-wide magazines to keep
with tradition and keep students engaged in what is going on in and outside
of the state. We try to keep up with every aspect of the curriculum, every
course and even every fraternity and sorority, as ridiculous as it sounds,”
she begins.
She changes the slide to a picture of an old newspaper from Drayton.
It’s black and white so it must be old. “After a staff briefing with the head
of the sports department, it has come to my attention that the Titans Daily,
the newspaper designated for the football team, has been abandoned for five
years. Nobody has picked it up again and nobody has even purchased any
of the old copies. Now, I know that running the school newspapers is not a
part of your course or what you signed up for when applying for this at
Drayton, but it does give many opportunities in the outside world if you are
able to start somewhere small. As a favour to Coach Mackenzie, I offered to
ask you all if anyone would be up for taking over the newspaper. We’re
looking for someone who will give it a modern spin, reintroduce the players
and what Coach Mackenzie says, ‘Make football great again.’”
Everyone in the class bursts out into laughter at Mrs Rotford using such
casual language.
After the laughter dies down, the whole room goes quiet. Nobody raises
their hands, nobody suggests taking it over and nobody even dares to look
at her. Most of us don’t even like sports, so it’s understandable. I can
tolerate a good game when I’m in the mood for it, but writing about it and
the players is a whole other thing. I’ve never really considered sports
journalism and the module we had on it had been quick enough to forget
about.
Rotford sighs. “I thought this would be the case,” she mutters. She looks
up, her piercing blue eyes scanning the room before her eyes land on me. I
feel the sweat pick up on my neck. It feels like she’s looking straight
through into my soul. “That’s why I chose someone in advance anyway.”
No.
No.
No.
She couldn’t possibly be talking about me. I know I’ve started to up my
game this year, but this is where I draw the line. I want her approval more
than anything. I want to succeed in this class above all, but this?
This would be absolute torture.
“Catherine Fables,” she announces and my blood runs cold. Everyone’s
head turns to me and I swallow the lump in my throat. George elbows me in
the rib as I blink at her. “Congratulations. The assistant coach will take you
down to meet Mackenzie now. This will be a great learning experience for
you. Enjoy.”
My mouth practically hangs open.
I stay put in my seat, trying to wrap my head around it as George packs
away my stuff for me since I’m apparently incapable. I’m shoved out of the
door before I can even process what’s happening.
A young blonde woman with green eyes greets me at the door, a
clipboard in hand as she rests her hand on my shoulder. “I’m guessing it
wasn’t voluntary, huh?” I shake my head. “You’ll be fine. I looked through
some of the things you’ve written. Rotford gave them to me over the
weekend. You’re really good. I’m sure you’ll fit right in.”
“Thanks,” I mumble, somehow telling my feet to continue walking.
“I’m Olivia, by the way,” she says, smiling up at me. I’m thinking about
introducing myself, but she already knows who I am. I want to ask how
long she’s been working at Drayton given how young she is, but I think
better of myself and try to mentally prepare myself on the walk over to the
other side of campus.
Football is not my thing. At all. I watched a few of Connor and Wes’s
games growing up by default, but I’ve never been completely interested. It
seems fun and a little violent. Nothing that necessarily checks my boxes for
entertainment. So, I try to shake off all the nerves and paint on my best I’m
totally fine and normal face as Olivia pushes open the door to the Coach’s
office.
Coach Mackenzie looks exactly as he did as the first time I met him
when Wes, Nora, Elle, Connor, and I had a playdate. He’s freakishly tall, a
dirty brunette, an unkept beard, and a beer belly. His blue eyes light up
when he sees me.
It’s been years since I’ve seen him.
After my dad became mayor, he started to distance himself from the
people that made him who he is and the friends that picked us both back up
after my mom died. It was too awkward to visit him on my own, but I still
make sure to send him a Christmas card every year when my dad forgets.
“Catherine!” He beams, leaning back in his chair. I smile back at him.
“I’m so glad you’re willing to take this opportunity. No one has run Titans
Daily in over five years. I've seen your work in the school paper, your dad
must be very proud of you. I’m proud of you.”
The feeling in my chest warms at his words. No matter how much
distance my dad seemed to put between us, he’s acting as if it didn’t exist.
“Thank you and he is.”
He nods happily. “So, if you’re on the team does that mean you’ll be
attending games?”
I shrug. “Some of them, I’m assuming, but not all. I've still got a ton of
school work to do and I’m not sure exactly what it is that I’m doing here.”
“Well. If you do, I'd love for you to bring your dad too. It’s been a while
since we've had a celebrity on campus,” he says, shaking his head at the
thought. I don’t know why he places so much trust in my dad after the way
he treated him.
“I’m not sure being mayor grants him celebrity status, but I’ll ask,” I
say.
“It seems like you're more interested in her dad than you are in her,
Coach,” Olivia says, leaning against the doorframe. I smile at her, grateful
she can redirect the conversation. I’m still a little starstruck about my new
role, but a little excited to get started. I’m going to need all the help I can
get.
He laughs. “Sorry. Anyway, the boys have just finished practice and
they’re having a mothers meeting in the locker room. I’ll introduce you to
them now. They’re going to be a bit hyper. They’re all like little puppies.”
I have no idea what I’ve gotten myself into.
OceanofPDF.com
SIX
CONNOR
HE KNELT TO THE GROUND AND PULLED OUT A
RING AND SAID
OceanofPDF.com
SEVEN
CAT
STICH AND BITCH
IT’S BEEN four days since my mind will never be the same again.
It’s been four days since I walked into the football locker room where
almost fifty twenty-something year old men were sweaty and shirtless,
singing and dancing to one of my favourite Taylor Swift songs.
It was as ridiculous as it was adorable.
I see those trends online all the time, but seeing it in person is another
thing. When they all broke apart, realising that we’d been standing there,
they all looked so vulnerable, as if they’ve had this mask on pretending
they’re big and strong when really they’re just little boys.
I’ve known what the team is like. I knew that the second I walked in
they’d use any chance to try to give me the ‘fuck me’ eyes and I ignored
them. I stared straight ahead, trying not to make eye contact with anyone
who was trying way too hard for my attention.
But when I looked down and saw Connor, my chest felt like it was on
fire. He wasn’t doing what anyone else was doing. He wasn’t immediately
in flexing mode. He just looked comfortable. Like that was his safe space
with his friends. Insanely hot, but comfortable.
That was four days ago and I’m still getting flustered just thinking about
it, despite being in the cold produce aisle in the supermarket.
Every Sunday, the girls and I do a weekly grocery shop as well as a
walk. We get all the essentials we need and extra picnic snacks, bring them
back to our dorm, pack our picnic and we go out again. Each week, when
we can remember, we think of a new activity to do. This week we’re going
to bring our favourite books as well as practising our crochet. It’s our little
Sunday ritual and I love it.
Nora’s mom says it makes us look like little old people, but I couldn’t
be happier in the middle of a supermarket while Elle and Nora check and
then check the list again before picking up the right fruits.
“What are you looking for, Elle-Belle?” I ask as she stares at the
refrigerated fruits, frowning with her arms crossed, basket in hand.
“You know those strawberries that my mom brings over sometimes?” I
nod, knowing she is referring to Annie, one of her moms. She has a knack
for picking up the best snacks. “I can’t find them anywhere.”
“Maybe it’s because you left your glasses at home, babe,” I say, tapping
between her eyes and she laughs before sighing heavily. “It’s just
strawberries. We can get some different ones.”
She sighs again. “I know. I just really wanted those ones, but I’m just a
mess right now.” Nora appears by our side, eating some of the grapes we’re
going to buy. We both give Elle a look, our eyes softening. We don’t have to
say anything else before the words start to pour out of her. “I haven’t been
home in a few weeks because I’ve got a recital coming up, but I don’t want
my moms to come. I don’t think I’m ready for them to see me dance again.”
Even as one of the strongest and bravest people I know, Elle has a lot of
difficulty with her confidence. No matter how many times Nora and I try to
drill it into her that she’s amazing at everything she does — especially
dancing — she’s finding it hard to believe she is as good as she was before
the accident.
“You don’t have to tell them if you don’t want to,” Nora says around a
mouthful. She swallows. “If I don’t think my show is going to be good, I
tell my parents not to come. They end up showing up anyway, but that’s not
the point. You don’t owe it to them, or anyone to be at your best all the time
and if you don’t want them to see you at what you think is your lowest, then
you don’t have to.”
Elle nods, chewing on her bottom lip. “Yeah,” she says quietly before
gaining more strength in her voice. “Yeah, you’re right. I’m going to see
how rehearsals are this week and make a decision.”
“That’s our girl,” I say, nudging her with my shoulder. “Now, let’s get
all this back so we can go to the park for sunset.”
We somehow end up coming back to campus with four different grocery
bags and one of them filled with books we got at the Little Free Library
around the corner from the supermarket. We exchanged some of our books
for some of theirs and now we’ve got a whole new set of books to talk
about.
Walking through Estes Park in late September as the sun starts to set has
to be one of my all time favourite feelings. We’ve each got a bag in hand,
the sun casting a gentle glow on our faces as the purple-pink of the sky
starts to set near the mountains.
It’s usually quiet around this time of year, so we don’t feel bad about
taking a spot in a public park where the odd dog walker walks past as we
set out our picnic blanket and food.
As soon as I’m about to take a picture of our spread — cheeses, grapes,
mini subs, crackers and more cheese – my phone screen is engulfed with a
picture of my dad.
My heartbeat immediately picks up, knowing that if he’s calling I have
to answer immediately. I hate that our relationship has gotten to this – that I
have to feel anxious every time he calls.
I excuse myself, walking further away until I get to a bench as I hear
Elle and Nora bickering about moving spots so the lighting is better. I
answer the phone and as always, I have to make the first move.
“Hi, dad. I’m glad you called,” I say into the phone, resting it against
my ear as I look out to the frosted mountains where I spent most of my
summers and winters as a kid. I wonder if my dad remembers the time he,
mom, and I went for a hike and were fully convinced we saw James
Marsden trekking down.
“Are you?” He just loves to make things difficult.
“Yeah…?” I say, my voice heavy with concern and uncertainty. “What’s
up?”
My dad never calls unless there’s been a problem or he suddenly
remembers he has a daughter who only lives an hour away from him.
Mostly, I don’t mind. But seeing the relationship my friends have with their
parents, I’m a little envious that my dad doesn’t call just because. He
doesn’t call because he’s randomly thinking about me, or if he’s stumbled
across one of my baby pictures.
“Checking how the semester is going,” he says simply. I hear him
typing in the background. Of course he can’t take a few minutes out of his
day to call his daughter with no distractions. Work always comes first.
It’s also coming towards the end of September, so I’ve been in school
for over a month now, but he doesn’t know that apparently.
“It’s going okay. My grades are good and I'm alive, so I guess
everything is great. How are—”
“Great,” he says, cutting me off. I take a deep breath, trying my best not
to get upset or angry. “Well, I wanted to ask who is the person who is
emailing me about attending a football game? You know I don't do that.”
“Oh, it’s just Coach Mackenzie. You remember him, don’t you? He was
asking me about it when—”
“Why were you talking to him? You're not on the football team.”
Deep breaths are doing nothing for me right now.
“Well, if you could let me finish my sentence, maybe you’d
understand,” I bite out. There is nothing but silence on the other end. It’s
rare that I ever snap at my dad like that. “I’m writing the newspaper and
blog for Titans Daily. The opportunity came up in class and no one wanted
to go for it. I thought it would look good on my CV.”
I’m bending the truth a little, trying to make it seem like this is a choice.
This is supposed to be a power move of some sorts. A new era. A new
challenge.
“Well, there's a reason no one wants to do it. Nobody cares about
college football, Catherine.”
“That's the thing. I’m going to change it up a little," I say, waiting for a
snarky response, but I don’t get one. this is my chance. “I’ve planned out a
few things and—”
”I’m sorry, Indira is calling me into a meeting. We'll talk another time,
darling. Love you.”
“I love—” The cell ends and the ache in my chest deepens. “I love you
too,” I say to nobody.
I walk back over to the girls, painting on my best face as they lay down
on the blanket staring up at the sky. When they see me, Nora leans up on
her elbow, frowning at me.
“Why the long face?” She asks. I lift up my phone as an answer. “Papa
Fables giving you a hard time?” I nod. “Jeez, what is it with parents today?”
I shrug, taking a seat next to them, pulling my crochet needles and wool
from my bag, resting them in my lap. Elle sits up too, crossing her legs.
“He’s just busy,” I say, shrugging again and looking out onto the sunset
as if it’s not a big deal. I don’t know why I’m still making excuses for him.
“It’s a Sunday afternoon. What could he possibly be busy with?” Nora
asks, sounding more upset than I am. Sometimes I think she feels
everybody else's pain more than her own and she takes on that extra load.
Maybe it’s an acting thing. I don’t know.
“Pilates?” Elle suggests and the tension in my body immediately starts
to smooth out as I laugh at the idea of my dad doing any kind of yoga.
When Nora’s initial anger simmers down and she joins in on the laugh, I
try to push all the negative feelings aside and just enjoy my time with the
girls. As much as my dad can get under my skin, I’d be damned if I let him
enjoy the things I love the most — my best friends, sunset, crocheting and
books.
Sometimes, I feel like I need nothing more.
OceanofPDF.com
EIGHT
CAT/CONNOR
“IT’S CALLED EDGING.”
CAT
I WISHED someone could give me more of a helping hand with this new
project. I wish Coach Mackenzie had not just left the room, saying nothing
but ‘good luck’ and gave me a double thumbs up. I wish Rotford had given
me some sort of direction to where to take this instead of leaving me in the
dark.
This is supposed to be a good thing. It’s supposed to show me how my
writing could work in the real world and how I would conduct interviews
with real celebrities or even with local people. But trying to organise a room
full of football players is like trying to teach a puppy to potty train.
Coach managed to line them up in the sports classroom, but it feels
fucking tiny with me at a desk, papers and my laptop in front of me and
men who are way too tall to be considered students towering over me,
pestering me with questions I don’t have the answers to. It’s only half of the
team, but it feels like there’s at least fifty of us in here.
I’ve never been in a space with this many men and it’s starting to freak
me out. They all talk too much and too loud. They also smell disgusting and
they keep giving me the heebie jeebies for looking at me for too long.
Worst of all? Connor fucking Bailey won’t keep his eyes off me. Since
the party, I’ve felt him everywhere and in every fibre of my body. It’s like
he’s attached himself to my mind and my body without meaning to. And I
hate that it feels like I have no control. But I’m supposed to. I’m supposed
to have the upper hand.
I take a deep breath, ready to calm them down and get my first person
up. I stand, hoping to make myself visible to anybody who will listen.
“Can everybody calm down, please?” I ask as loud as I can without
sounding insane. Nobody moves. “Hey!” I try again and nothing.
I’m about to give up and try again in a few minutes before Connor’s
eyes lock with mine as Wes and another guy talk at both sides of him
animatedly. I don’t know what’s going on in his brain, but he looks at me
like he knows what I was trying to do and he nudges Wes and the other
dude and they stop talking.
“Can everyone shut the fuck up so we can get on with this and you can
all leave and get about your day?” he booms.
The deepness and roughness in his voice causes me to stumble a little
and I catch myself on the table as everyone goes hauntingly silent. He is the
captain of the team after all, and the bossy side of him is weirdly attractive.
He keeps his eyes on me and half of me is grateful that he has my back
like that, but the other half of me is annoyed that they don’t listen to me. If
I’m going to do this, it needs to be on my terms and under my leadership
and control. I won’t be able to survive in the real world if I can’t get a
bunch of twenty-year-old boys to listen to me.
“Thank you,” I mouth to him, and he nods, his cheeks turning the tiniest
shade of pink before he continues talking to Wes at a manageable volume.
The classroom is big enough so the boys should be able to take a seat at
the tables that are scattered around like a detention room, but most of them
settle for sitting on top of the tables. There’s something so fascinating about
boys and their inability to sit on furniture the right way.
I double check the list that Coach made for me. He suggested I get
through as many as I could until I couldn’t take it anymore, which seems
doable.
I call out the first name. “Michael Redford?”
The boys whoop and cheer as the unlucky guy walks forwards. Unlucky
because he’s the same guy who suggested keeping his shirt off when I first
went into the locker room and also because he’s ginger with the unlucky
last name ‘Redford’ and everybody calls him ‘Red.’
He walks towards me, his cheeks – you guessed it – red. His legs are so
long that they go way past my chair underneath the table. I scoot back a
little, trying to put some distance between us.
As much as it’s easy to get information about the players from Coach’s
files, I’ve learned that the best way to learn things about someone you
already know is by asking them basic questions and seeing how they
present the answers to you.
Which is why I shouldn’t be surprised by the number of stupid answers
that I get when I asked three boys in a row what their height was, and they
replied with some variation of “Do you want to know my shoe size too?
You know what they say. Big feet means big dick.”
When I’ve gone through four boys, each of them having similar
descriptions and hobbies, I’m already falling asleep. It’s not that they aren’t
interesting. Some of them say the most outrageous things that confuse me
so much that I need to take a step back. Some of the boys are quiet, a little
shy and nervous that they’re being questioned like this on a random day.
But when Wes’s name is called, I can’t help but smile up at him. It feels
like we’ve not spoken properly in years, but he’s always fun to be around.
He’s usually attached to one of the Bailey twins’s hips and often has
something inappropriate to say. It’s best when all of us are together and I
can watch the way he feeds off everyone's energy and becomes one huge
ball of light.
Connor doesn’t think I notice the way his face scrunches up and he rolls
his head back when Wes walks up to me. I’ve purposefully skipped his
name off the list, moving to all the people around him instead of him.
I also don’t think he’s noticed that I’ve picked up on him trying to skip
the queue – if you can even call it that – by attempting to bribe others to
make up an excuse and leave early so he can get to me quicker. He’s getting
antsy and I’m having way too much fun watching him squirm.
“Cathy!” Wes calls, pulling out the chair and immediately man-
spreading as he sits. Like his dad, he has dirty blonde hair that is a messy
heap on his head and he’s one of the lucky people whose eyes change
colour depending on the lighting. Now, they look sort of grey. It’s
fascinating.
“Don’t call me that. You make me sound like an old woman,” I say,
laughing as I pull up a clean page on the document I’ve been working on.
He sulks, crossing his arms against his chest. “But you’re my old lady,”
he says.
The laughter rushes out of my chest. He’s been calling me that for as
long as I can remember. I think it has something to do with the fact that I’d
always get chosen to be the grandma when we’d play house as kids. Wes
was always the pet on a leash and he always belonged to Nora.
“Keep doing that,” he whispers, turning back to the group of boys as
most of the room has cleared now. I end up gasping, trying to catch my
breath and process his words at the same time.
“What?”
“When you have the next person come up to you, laugh and smile at
them like they’re the funniest person you’ve ever met,” he says quietly,
leaning into me. I smile, shaking my head slowly at his mischievousness.
“It will drive Connor up the wall. He’s already being pushed back and he
clearly wants to talk to you.”
“What’s his problem? He seems nervous,” I say to Wes.
He shrugs. “Talking to people isn’t his thing, apparently.” I nod, feeling
a strange pang in my chest for drawing out this process for him when he
probably would have benefitted from going first and getting this over with.
Wes takes my silence as dismissal. “Just do it, Cat. Please. I’m begging
you.”
I sigh, catching Connor’s eye as he fiddles with the hem of his shirt.
“Okay,” I say quietly. Wes’s eyes light up at the challenge. “Okay, fine.”
He whispers a silent ‘yes’ to himself before using every given moment
to try to make me laugh as I ask him the basic questions like his age
(nineteen), birthday (June 14th), star sign (Gemini), height (six-one, but he
looks five-eleven) and hobbies which ranged from kayaking to chess. He
answers them all lazily and I keep my face painted in a smile the entire time
until he winks at me and moves on.
When Sam Cho takes a seat at the table I smile so hard that my cheeks
hurt. It helps that he’s an attractive guy – smooth face, adorable dimples and
a smile to match. He’s also one of the boys who gave me the eyes in the
locker room the other day.
“Hi, Sam. It’s nice to meet you,” I say when he crosses his arms against
his chest.
“You too,” he says. I laugh as if he said something funny, tucking my
curls behind my ear. His eyebrows crunch as he looks left and right for the
joke he must have missed and when I train my gaze over his head where
Connor’s eyes are burning holes through the back of Sam’s head. “Ooh,
Connor? Tell you what would make him mad?”
“I’m open to suggestions,” I say, shrugging. Connor has no right to be
this upset over not getting a chance to talk to me and I’m having the time of
my life seeing how far he’ll go before he has a tantrum.
Sam’s smile creeps up on his face as he leans into me and I lean
forward. I have no idea what I’m doing, or what he’s going to do, but my
heart is pounding with anticipation. The desk isn’t that big so he reaches
over easily, tucking another strand of hair behind my ear. His face is so
close to mine now I can feel his steady breathing against my neck, the
sensation so weirdly foreign to me that my eyes flutter closed for a second.
“I’m not going to do anything, but from his angle it probably looks like
I’m saying something filthy,” he murmurs softly. “I’m giving him three
seconds before he comes over.”
CONNOR
OceanofPDF.com
NINE
CONNOR
“I DON’T GET IT. WHY IS HE JEALOUS?”
“WHAT ARE you doing for your birthday, Connie boy?” Wes asks.
I glare at him across the gym. He’s lunging from one end of the room to
the other with weights in each hand, effortlessly trying to have a
conversation with me even though he knows I prefer to work out in silence.
I’ve tried to put on my noise cancelling headphones more than once and he
still makes sure I can hear him. I can’t tell if I just have an old shitty pair of
headphones, or if he’s really just that loud.
“It’s in three weeks,” I say, sucking in a breath as I continue my
crunches. He walks past me, shaking his head as if this is the worst news
he’s heard in his life. “Plus, Nora is probably going to want to plan it. I
really don’t care.”
He starts to lunge back in my direction, not breaking a sweat. “You’re
turning twenty on the second greatest night of the year and you’re letting
your little sister pick what to do?” He sounds so angry and serious, it’s
ridiculous.
I groan, throwing my head back and stopping my reps because now I’ve
lost count. “Second greatest night of the year?” I repeat, looking at him
curiously as he finally collapses on a bench in front of me.
“After my birthday, obviously,” he says easily.
“Right, obviously. And Nora is technically older than me by eleven
minutes, so I really don’t mind if she picks a theme. I don’t care about my
birthday, you know that,” I say with a huff.
As for my birthday being on the greatest night of the year as Wes says,
he means that it’s on October 31st, Halloween, and in three weeks from
now. It’s a lucky birthday for someone who enjoys partying.
Every year we always spend spooky season watching old horror films
and Halloween episodes of our favourite sit-coms and then we end the
month off with a birthday party and Halloween party in one. Growing up, it
was the lead up to my birthday that was the most exciting part of the year.
As for parties, I don’t care much for them. I never have and I probably
never will. Even though I’m dragged to one nearly every weekend and I
have a good-ish time. I stick to playing games that are apparently more fun
when you’re drunk, or I spend most of the time talking Wes out of doing
something stupid. Or, he does that stupid thing and I have to bring him
home. Coach puts enough trust in me to keep the team in line on and off the
pitch, so I’m one of the only people who takes things seriously.
If I’m going to play in the NFL, I have to show good leadership skills
and be a good example by taking my health seriously. I know a lot of my
teammates can handle both, but I’d rather not take the risk, especially after
hearing about the countless injuries that can happen while intoxicated.
Once, I spent the whole night riddled with anxiety, searching for the
worst injuries you could get as a football player and how easily they could
happen if you’re not careful with your body and how easily accidents can
happen when you’re not fully sober. It scared me so much that I swore off
drinking and making sure that me and everyone else around me is safe.
As for my birthday… I’ve hated it for as long as I can remember. Not
because I’m a twin, — I always knew that would be hard — but because of
who I am and who Nora is. As proud as I am of my sister for being so
fucking talented at everything she touches, I also envy her ability to be able
to answer and ask so many questions that often fills the silence of any room
we’re in.
She never has to worry about running out of things to say and she can
come up with anything on the spot. She always has something to talk about,
something to show and something for people to be interested in. I, however,
am only good at one thing.
Everybody plays football. It’s the most popular sport in the US, so it’s
not extraordinary that I am the QB for my college. I’m a conversation filler,
a quick two-minute question and answer. Nobody asks how much time I
spend training, or how I got to the level I’m at today. Nobody cares to ask
for routines or rituals that I do with the boys. So, it’s hard to feel different
and appreciated when you shared a womb with somebody so extraordinary.
Nora knows how to work a room that nobody notices I’m in.
So, yeah, it sucks to share a birthday with somebody who manages to
make everything about her on the one day that is supposed to celebrate both
of us. I can’t blame her though. It’s what she’s good at and it’s just not one
of my strengths. I’m trying to get better at talking to people, but this whole
thing with Cat and the newspaper is making me extra fucking nervous.
There’s no way I’d be able to make it to the NFL without a few interviews
here and there. I need to suck it up and do better.
“Fine,” Wes grumbles. “If you want to be a grump about it, I’ll drop it.
But just so you know, when you get married, I’m throwing you the best
bachelor party ever.”
“I’m literally shaking with anticipation,” I reply, bored.
“Alright, Connie boy,” he says, rolling his eyes as he gets to his feet.
“Last rep before we hit the showers, or we’re going to be late.”
One thing I love about having a campus college is that everything is close
together. After hitting the gym this morning with Wes, we made it back to
our dorm, showered and were out of the door in less than an hour and we
made it to class on time.
Unlike most of the team who chose the easy way out to minor in some
sort of sports science, Wes and I decided to minor in Literature. I’ve always
liked studying books in high school and my parents have always been huge
readers. I guess having teachers as parents really rubs off on you. Most guys
in my classes growing up hated it, but I loved it.
I loved the feeling of feeling so incredibly immersed into a book that
you forget that you’re reading. When reality seems like the worst possible
place to be, there’s always some kind of universe to lose yourself in.
Studying them now at a degree level is a lot harder than I thought it would
be, but that doesn’t mean I like it any less. I enjoy the challenge, the way it
makes my brain work twice as hard.
Wes, on the other hand, has been staring at the extract from
Shakespeare’s Othello for the last twenty minutes, asking me more and
more ridiculous questions. We’ve been studying this text for months, going
over the same key scenes and picking out the authorial methods and the
psychological context behind the antagonist’s intentions.
“I don’t get it. Why is he jealous?” Wes asks, pushing the sheet away
from him as he crosses his arms against his chest, his face painted in serious
concern. “Like, I get some of his motives, but did he really have to do all
that just to stay silent in the end?”
“That’s the whole point. He’s a sadist, or a ‘motiveless malignity,’” I
say, flicking through the text. Wes’s face crumbles in confusion. “He
doesn’t need a reason to do what he does. It’s something deeper, more
psychological. He’s just manipulative and he gets drunk on power.”
“The more you speak, the less I understand,” he mumbles, picking up a
pen to write what I just quoted from one of the critics of the text. I shake
my head at him with a laugh, about to do the same before I look out of the
window.
All classrooms on the ground floor in the humanities building form a
square around a courtyard that holds a flower bed and a statue of the first
headmaster of Drayton. It’s a beautiful and distracting sight during the
summer as the sun shines directly onto the grey stone and it reflects through
the large windows of the classroom.
It’s especially distracting now as I watch Catherine walk from one side
of the building and across the window. It’s like she’s walking in slow
motion. Since the day at the party — l’ll be honest, it was way before that,
but still — I can’t help but notice her everywhere I go.
She is a picture of academic perfection. Her hair is tied back into a bun,
wild curls falling loose in her face as she clutches her binder to her chest.
She has a backpack instead of a tote as she doesn’t even look in my
direction, only seeing her destination.
She’s always had this unwavering sense of confidence even when we
were kids, and she would boss us around. She looks so sure of herself until
she’s caught off guard and her stance slightly falters.
Recently, it’s been me who has been making more and more of a fool of
myself while she gets to say things like ‘It’s called edging’ while I try and
find the right words. For once, I want to regain that control that I had in the
closet, or at least some of it.
There's only so much that I can get out of Nora about what Cat thinks of
me without arousing suspicion. We’ve all had our little friend group from
when we were kids, but everything feels different now that we’re at college.
If Cat actually took one look at me without dying to take a jab at me, she
would see that I’ve been at her feet for years waiting for the day she’ll give
some of herself to me.
“Whatever,” I say to Wes, remembering that we were just having a
conversation. I don’t know how long I was staring at her for, but the quirk
in his eyebrow makes me believe that it was longer than need be. “I’m
going to fill my water at the fountain. Talking some sense into you is
making my mouth dry.”
“Right. It isn’t because you just saw Cat walk into the building, is it?”
he asks.
“It just so happens that she is also going to class in the same building as
us,” I say calmly. He doesn’t give up the strange look he’s giving me, so I
add, “Don’t read into it.”
He finally drops his gaze from mine, giving me the second to breathe as
he continues writing while he murmurs, “Oh, I’m not the one reading into
it, Connie.”
OceanofPDF.com
TEN
CAT
IT SMELLS LIKE OLD PEOPLE
OceanofPDF.com
ELEVEN
CAT/CONNOR
ROMANCE IS NOT DEAD
CAT
YOU KNOW that feeling when you first bring a puppy home and they’ve
overcome that awkward stage where they’re adjusting to the new
environment. It’s usually only a few days in where they start to become
their hyperactive self, jumping off furniture, biting holes into socks and
slippers, practically bouncing off the wall.
That’s a pretty accurate description as to how Connor has been acting
since he told me he needed my help.
Don’t get me wrong, I want to help him. All I’ve done today is plan
ideas and questions to ease him into the interviewing process. But every
time I write a new question down, alternating between picking up my phone
or getting a snack, I get a new text from him. I’m toying with him, using the
day to recoup on ideas before reaching out to him. Still, he’s as eager as
ever as he continuously texts me as I lounge on the couch in the empty
dorm, watching my favourite TV show.
CONNIE
I’m busy.
CONNIE
Monday?
I’m busy.
CONNIE
Tuesday?
CONNOR
OceanofPDF.com
TWELVE
CAT/CONNOR
KILL ME AND MY UTERUS NOW.
CAT
If I had one wish in life, it would be a picture of the exact moment I told
Elle and Nora to come with me to paint pottery with the football team and
have it framed and sent to my house with a bright red bow.
I wasn’t surprised that they said yes. Elle minors in photography and is
always taking pictures on her phone and her digital camera whenever she
has the chance. She’s also a budding influencer, but she is yet to go
completely viral. Nora is here for the vibes and the vibes only.
After rushing around to make our way to the store, we’re huddled
together outside the door, ready to walk in when Archer Elliot, Wes and
Connor’s roommate, exits the store. If I thought Connor was tall, Archer is
something else. He’s like a Greek god – scarily tall, sharp cheekbones, hair
so dark-brown that it’s almost black, a compression shirt that just shows
he’s built on pure muscle and a tiny gift bag in his huge hands.
“Oh, hi,” Elle says. Out of all of us, she sees him the most. The dance
teacher she’s had pretty much since she was born also happens to be
Archer’s mom. You wouldn’t believe the amount of awkward run-ins
they’ve had. One of those being a time where she bumped into him, and she
told him thank you.
“Eleanor,” he greets gruffly. I look between them as Archer’s grey eyes
zone in on Elle, she drops her gaze as her cheeks flush pink. Nora saves the
day as always.
“Archer Elliot, I never thought I’d see you out in broad daylight,” Nora
quips. She’s always going to try her best to ease awkward tension wherever
she goes while the rest of us stand and watch painfully.
“Nora Bailey, I never thought I’d see you without that hideous green
stuff on your face, but here we are,” he replies, giving her a sarcastic smile.
She jabs a finger in his face. I don’t think he even notices because he’s
that fucking tall. “It was a face mask, and you know it was.”
“Are you joining the painting session?” Elle asks quietly. He clears his
throat when she looks up at him, averting his eyes to a spot behind us where
the main street bustles.
“No. I’m just picking up something,” he responds coolly.
Nora and I shimmy our shoulders at the same time. “For a girlfriend?” I
tease. His face remains serious. Jesus. This guy needs to lighten up.
“No,” he says simply, “Goodbye.”
And then he’s just… gone.
“Goodbye?” Nora repeats angrily, pushing open the door. “Who the hell
says goodbye? He’s a twenty-year-old man not a viscount from the
nineteenth century. He might as well have said good morrow.”
“I think he’s cute,” Elle whispers, looking back as Archer’s huge body
walks away from us. We all step into the warmth of the shop, the tiny
doorway barely fitting all three of us in there.
“You think that six foot something giant man person is cute? Elle,
respectfully, that man could easily break every bone in your body,” Nora
retorts, shrugging off her coat.
The loud roars coming from the team messes up my senses and all I can
hear for a second is the loud obnoxious chatter coming from the boys. I
swear I hear Elle mumble ‘I think I’d let him,’ but it’s too loud to tell.
We walk into the small shop where eight of the team members sit on a
low table in the middle of the room. Around the room holds smaller stations
with two seats where other team members sit quietly. All the noise is
coming from the table of eight as paintbrushes fly around, the pink aprons
they’re supposed to be wearing in every place but the correct one – Wes is
wearing his on his head like a chef hat and Connor has his on backward.
Not only are they arguing with each other, but there’s a small red-
headed girl – probably Michael’s sister – who is bossing them around like
it’s her job. Her little apron is covered in paint splatters, her hair an unruly
mess as she stands between Wes and Sam, peering down at what they’re
drawing.
When Connor’s eyes land on mine, I swear the whole world stops.
Suddenly it doesn’t feel like the room is loud and chaotic, it feels like it’s
just us.
After seeing a more vulnerable and caring side to him the other day,
looking at him now feels different. He brings this weird and overwhelming
sense of peace over me. He might look ridiculous and huge at that table
with his apron on backwards, but the shy smile he has on his lips when he
sees me makes fireworks explode in my chest. Not the loud kind that you
hear up-close, but the ones far in the distance that you only see and hardly
hear.
I don’t get a second to over analyse it before Wes sees me. “Cathy, Elle,
Nor-Nor! Take a seat. We don’t bite,” he says, winking at us.
“I’m just going to stay near the window. I’ll get better lighting that
way,” Eleanor says, taking her camera out of its case as she squeezes past
me to the window area where two boys paint quietly.
“You two better take a seat before Eve here drags you by your ear,”
Connor grumbles. Eve shoots him a look, but when he sticks his tongue out
at her, she bursts into giggles. There is something so undeniably hot seeing
a man interact with a child.
It’s truly sick and twisted.
Kill me and my uterus now.
We do as we’re told and I take the empty seat next to Connor while
Nora takes the seat next to me that is next to Wes and Sam. Elle gets
comfortable across the room, lifting her camera and trying different lenses
before she starts to walk around the room, looking for a good place to start
taking pictures.
Once Nora and I settle on painting a heart shaped jewellery box, all I
can focus on is Connor’s leg against mine. We’ve been close before. That
closet was certainly something. But this?
I don’t know what it is, but the light brush of his leg against my tights is
driving me crazy and it really shouldn’t. Especially not here.
He’s been so careful and practiced with his painting. I still can’t tell
what it is. All I know is he selected a plain square and is not revealing what
he’s painting to anybody. But I’m curious as hell. He might be an awful
painter, but he’s doing something.
I nudge my leg into his. I might as well try, right? “Can you tell me
what you’re painting?”
“Nope,” he says quietly, focusing on what he’s doing.
“Why not?”
“Because it’s a secret,” he whispers.
“But you can tell me,” I say back. I rub my thigh against his on purpose,
trying to get a reaction out of him. I know what I’m doing, and I know how
stupid it is because I’m selfishly doing it for myself too. He hisses,
readjusting his paintbrush in his hand.
I don’t have any logical reason for why I’m doing this other than it feels
good, and I haven’t felt good in a while. That’s why I slip my hand under
the table, gently resting it on his knee in the most subtle way I can. My
hand and body instantly flare up at his proximity.
“Catherine,” he bites out.
“Connor,” I say back. I turn to look at him, but he’s refusing to catch my
eye. I bump my shoulder into his. “Just tell me what you’re painting.”
“It’s for–”
“You’re doing really well, Connor,” Eve says, appearing out of thin air.
She looks down at Connor’s something, smiling at it. As much as the girl is
adorable, she kind of ruined our moment. Was it even a moment, or did I
make that up myself?
“Thank you, Eve,” he replies, smiling at her. From this position with us
way down on the floor, they’re almost face to face but she just about towers
over him. “I’m not as good as you though,” he says sweetly. This man
really knows how to charm people because he’s even got this little girl
almost as red as her hair. Connor’s shoulder bumps into mine. “You know
the ones in the window? Eve painted those ones.”
“They’re not my best work,” she sighs wistfully like she’s a million
years old. Small humans are strange. Funny, but strange.
“They’re still great. I think you’re my favourite artist, Eve,” Connor
coos and she tries to hide her giddy smile before she walks away.
“You’re good with kids, Connie,” I say, pulling my hand away from his
knee and back to my piece. He shrugs as if it’s not a big deal. It shouldn’t
be a big deal, but I know if I write anything about this in my report, the girls
at Drayton will go absolutely feral. And honestly, me too.
It’s not long before the boys are restless again and Wes at some point
tackled Nora to the floor. They’re both covered in paint, somehow getting
the acrylics from a drawer Mrs Redford and Eve told us not to go into.
Nora’s face is almost completely yellow with purple streaks running down
across her face while Wes’s face pretty much looks like a rainbow.
While they play-fight like kindergarteners, Elle uses the opportunity to
take photos getting every possible angle she can of those two idiots.
“Can you paint inside the lines?” Eve asks, stepping behind Sam and
looking at the turtle he’s painting. Connor and I snicker, knowing we
haven’t got told off in a while.
“Yes, inside the lines, you idiot,” Oliver says from the other side of the
table. He’s one to talk. He’s got told off twice by Eve in the last ten minutes
and he’s had to restart his butterfly three times.
“That’s a bad word,” Eve points out, whispering.
“Boys say bad words all the time,” I say to her. Connor bumps his knee
into mine, coughing into his hand as he says ‘liar’ and Eve giggles, sitting
down in the seat Wes abandoned.
“I heard that girl over there say a bad word,” Eve whispers to us as she
points down at the floor where Nora is very aggressively playing with Wes
as he pins his knees on either side of her, not letting her get her paintbrush
in his face. “She called the boy she’s fighting with a mother–”
“Fucker!” Wes shouts. Oh my god. We’re going to get kicked out of
here even though they booked out the store. “You got paint in my ear,” he
groans, sitting back on his heels as Nora tries to scoot out from underneath
him but he keeps one hand on her stomach, the other in his ear. “How the
hell did you get paint in my ear?”
“I look like a Minion, you imbecile,” Nora retorts, pushing his hand off
her. I hear the click of Elle’s camera as she giggles from behind us. “How
do you think I feel?”
“You look like a cute minion, though. Like the tiny one who doesn’t say
anything, but has those cute little eyes,” Wes coos, adding a dot of black
paint on her nose. She snatches the paint brush out of his hand, turning him
around so she’s straddling him.
“I’m going to kill you,” she threatens.
These two, I swear.
Connor shakes his head at them like a disappointed dad as Eve turns
back to us. “Mikey says that boys are only mean to girls that they really
really like. Does that mean they’re going to get married?”
I look down at them who are still rolling around on the ground. “Nora
and Wes?” I laugh.
Connor scoffs. “There’s a better chance of flying cars than that fu–”
Eve’s innocent green eyes widen before Connor stops himself. “Fudging
silly boy marrying my sister,” he says smoothly.
The second the words leave his mouth, everyone is looking down at
them again. Wes has somehow managed to get on top of her again as he
pins his knees on either side of her, holding her hands above her head as she
writhes beneath him.
“Can’t paint me now, can you, Nor?” he asks playfully.
“You’re so annoying,” she says, laughing. If she wasn’t covered in
paint, she would definitely be blushing right now. She can act tough all she
wants, but I know that sometimes with the things Wes says or does, she
clearly gets flustered over it. He’s the world’s biggest flirt, and she’s taken,
but sometimes that line is on the brink of breaking.
“I’m annoying, huh?” he teases, and she nods, unable to stop laughing.
He rubs his painted cheek against hers, causing the colours on their faces to
merge together into a deep, dirty, green-purple colour. “Is this annoying? Is
this annoying? Is this annoying?”
She’s still giggling as she says, “Yes. Oh my god, Wes. Stop!”
“That’s not usually what women say to me when they’re in this
position,” Wes says.
Connor sighs beside me loudly. “Get off her, you animal,” he says to
Wes and eventually he does. Not before covering her face with another blob
of paint.
Yep.
Damn puppies.
All of them.
CONNOR
Maybe painting in silence while the rest of the team runs wild is my calling.
I’m not exactly great at it, but every month, I try something new in hopes of
getting better. I guess the trying part is what counts.
I’ve spent most of the day trying to pretend that Catherine’s proximity
doesn’t make me want to curl up in her lap and let her hold me. Is that
weird? Probably. Whatever. I just don’t understand how she can come in
here, in that black skirt and tights and not expect me to lose my fucking
mind.
Once Nora and Wes have cleaned up from their fight and we’re all back
around the small table again, I watch as Cat watches everybody else. I don’t
know if this is part of her process for getting to know us as a team, but she
seems to be so lost in whatever bullshit Sam is feeding her. The team is a
mess on and off the pitch which is understandable. But there are moments
like these where we feel like a team in nearly every aspect of life.
“I bet this isn’t what you thought you’d be getting into when you got
told about this, huh?” Sam asks, not taking his eyes off his turtle. Cat
shakes her head, laughing a little.
“No, but it’s fun, though. It’s better than being in that tiny classroom
with you guys,” she says before adding quietly, “You’re like a little family.”
I shrug. “Yeah, you could say that.”
“Oh, that reminds me,” she says, wiping her hands with a wet wipe
before pulling up her phone. “That’s a good question, actually. Who would
you say are the parents of the group? People do that all the time for
celebrity friendship groups. It could be a good segment for a poll of some
sorts.”
Wes and Sam exchange a mischievous look. “Well, we all know who
the mom is,” Wes says, doing a very bad job at trying to discreetly point his
head in my direction.
That fucker.
“Oh, one hundred percent,” Oliver chimes in. He turns to Catherine,
pulling all of her attention on him. “You should have seen the day you came
into the locker room. He was telling us all that we couldn’t go anywhere
near–”
“Okay,” I say, cutting him off as Cat leans further into my side, only to
get closer to him to listen to his story. Her scent throws me off a little and
the memory of her hand on my knee. She does not need to know that I told
them to stay away from her just because I secretly want her to myself. It’s
true, though. Catherine has always been my little secret. She had been my
first crush and has been the only reason I ever looked forward to my
English class at the thought of bumping into her. She’d always been my
Catherine before she ever knew it. “So, if I’m the mom then who is the
dad?”
Cat studies me for a second, silently judging me as if she knows Oliver
was about to say something stupid.
“Me, obviously,” Sam says proudly.
“Just because you have a kink for people calling you ‘daddy’ does not
make you the dad of the group,” Wes says, pinning his arms across his
chest, pouting.
“So, you can see who is so obviously the moody child,” Nora says,
ruffling Wes’s hair like he’s a puppy. The satisfied grin on his face shows
that he loves every single second of attention my sister gives him.
“Yeah,” I say quietly, laughing at the two of them. I look over at Cat,
but she’s already looking at me. “I guess you could call us a family.”
Once everyone has finally settled down and ready to clean up, I offer to
help clean the pallets and paint pots because I know Catherine is there. She
was the first one up when Mrs Redford asked people to help her with the
washing up.
When we’re alone again, I don’t know what to say so I stick to drying
whilst she washes. She keeps glancing over at me, smirking a little before
shaking her head as if she’s about to say something before thinking better of
it. I’m doing the same thing – stupidly opening my mouth just to close it
again when the words don’t come.
“You can relax, you know? I’m not going to ask you any questions,” she
says quietly. She passes me the last pot and I dry it off.
“I know,” I reply, drying off my hands and leaning back against the
counter as she drains the water from the sink. Once she’s done, she dries off
her hands too, studying me, those dark brown eyes figuring me out like a
puzzle.
“Then why do you look so tense?” she asks, moving to stand in front of
me. My heartbeat instantly picks up and I have no idea why. She looks so
much shorter like this even though I’m leaning back on my hands.
“I’m not,” I breathe out, but it sounds and feels like a lie. I’m always a
little tense, always wound a little too tight, but that’s just the way I am. I’m
only extra anxious now because she’s in front of me, looking up at me like
she…
I shake my head at the thought, dropping my gaze to the floor.
“Connor,” she presses, her voice sounding slightly desperate. She reaches
out, latching her small hand over mine as she steps closer to me. I turn my
hand around on the counter, my palm up, knowing it’ll calm me. I don’t
even have to say anything before she starts to massage my palm. Her touch
is so soft and gentle. So her. “Not tense, huh?” she asks, moving her
thumbs around my palm. I shrug. “Be real with me.”
I sigh, knowing I won’t be able to cower and back away from this like I
could try. “I’m just worried I won’t be any good at the whole social media
thing like you mentioned earlier. I like seeing other people do it and Wes
and Sam are great at it, but I don’t know… Maybe I’m not as good at it as
them. It doesn’t feel like me.”
She nods but she doesn’t stop working her fingers over my palm. “I saw
that TikTok that was posted – the Love Story one. You were really good,
Connie.” My chest pinches at the compliment. “I said I’m going to help
you, so I will. Your birthday is next weekend, just relax until then, okay?
We’ll figure it out.”
My mouth tugs at the idea.
We.
“Are you suggesting that we’re a team, Catherine?” I tease, catching her
hand in mine so I can lock my fingers with hers.
“Something like that,” she whispers.
It feels like time stops when she says that, when she looks up at me and
for the first time in a while, I see a sense of wonder in her eyes. A sense of
what-if. A slight sense of hope. Maybe it’s nothing and it’s my overly
optimistic brain when it comes to her, but I swear I feel the energy between
us crackling. And for one of the first times, it doesn’t feel like it’s just me
that feels it.
She keeps her eyes locked with mine as I drop our interlocked hands to
the side, using my other hand to slip around her waist, pulling her into me.
She gasps, her mouth parting desperately. The feel of her beneath my hand
is maddening. It’s wholly distracting, and I just want more of it.
“Connor,” she murmurs, a half-plea. The sound goes straight to my
dick, my hand flexing in her hip that the only sound that comes out of me is
a low hum of approval. “What are we–”
The door swings open as Mrs Redford comes rushing in. Catherine
leaps apart from me as if I have the fucking plague. Her eyes fall to the
floor as Mrs R walks over to us, her face lit up in child-like happiness as
she looks around at the clean back-room.
“You two are lifesavers,” she exclaims. “You really make a good team.”
OceanofPDF.com
THIRTEEN
CONNOR/CAT
HAPPY FUCKING BIRTHDAY
CONNOR
CALL IT TWIN TELEPATHY, but I knew the second I let Nora choose
the theme for our party, it was about to be something stupid.
Nora usually gets the last say in anything that we do together. Most of
the time, I don’t give a shit, but this right here, in my parents’ house with
two of my friends as we set up for the party is where I draw the line.
Wes is smiling like a loon, pleasantly happy with his costume choice.
“You’ve got to lighten up man,” he says to me, walking back into the
kitchen after he opened the French doors to the backyard. He fiddles with
his tail, sighing as he pushes it behind him. “It’s a party, not a funeral.”
“It might as well be,” I grumble, pulling the packs of beers from the
fridge and on to the kitchen island.
Archer turns then. He looks the most ridiculous out of all of us. It’s been
an hour since we all changed into our costumes, but Wes and I’s laughter
streams out of us as Archer scratches his nose behind the carrot nose he has
attached to his face.
“I still don’t know how you talked me into doing this,” he groans.
“Well, the movie wouldn’t be as good without trusty Olaf,” Wes says,
patting him on the back as he drifts past him.
Of course, this year’s theme is Disney movies. We had to set up a list so
no outfits would be repeated, and Wes begged Archer and I to go as the
main characters from Frozen.
I don’t just mean he asked us nicely with his puppy dog eyes, but I
mean this man got on his hands and knees for us to do a group costume in
exchange for him doing anything we asked for a week.
For me, that means uninterrupted training sessions, and I don’t have to
listen to him yap on. For Archer, it means he can also tell Wes to fuck off
when he’s in the dorm also pestering him for something stupid.
So Archer is dressed in an Olaf costume, looking as stupid as ever while
I get to look somewhat normal dressed as Kristoff. I just hope to God that
the rewards of this costume pay off in the end.
Archer takes a seat at the table, picking up one of the beers I just set out
for us. “So, Connor,” he says, twisting open the can. “What did you get for
your birthday?”
“Are you actually going to have a conversation with me, or are you just
going to make fun of me?” I ask, curiously. I’m surprised more than anyone
that Archer agreed to come to the party. He very rarely comes to the parties
we go to, but after I told him who Nora and I invited, he agreed. It’s strange
from him, but not as strange as the mysterious way he exits Fired Arts every
month when we go in for our monthly painting sessions. He thinks I don’t
notice, but I do.
“Just trying to make conversation,” he answers dryly. I raise my
eyebrow, but he just rolls his eyes, taking a sip of the beer.
“Got the usual stuff from my parents – money, socks, underwear, you
know, the boring stuff. Nora got me a photo album filled with pictures of us
when we used to match every day right up until high school,” I say, smiling
a little at the gift. I got her a similar present, except it was just a box filled
with the things we used to like growing up and pictures of the shows she
would drag us to see at the local theatre.
As much as I hated it then, I secretly loved seeing that part of my
sister’s life – the flair in her eyes when she saw the lights go down on stage
– it was truly insane watching her fall in love with something like that. I
always wondered if she saw the same change in me.
“That’s not the only thing he got,” Wes chimes in. That asshole. Archer
quirks his head curiously and before I can tell Wes to shut his huge mouth,
he continues. “You should have seen what Cat got him. It was a little apron
that said Connie on it with tiny little hearts and matching oven gloves,” he
coos, his voice extra sweet.
“You’re an ass, you know that?” I mumble.
“Whatever,” he retorts, turning back to Archer with the biggest smile on
his face. “He was looking at it with fucking tears in his eyes.”
“No, I wasn’t,” I bite out.
Okay, maybe I was a tiny bit emotional over a stupid gift with a stupid
card and stupid oven mitts from the girl I can’t stop thinking about. It’s
natural. I know that she was only doing it because she feels bad, and she
gets me a gift every year.
“Dude, it’s okay,” Wes says quietly. “With a gift like that, she’s
definitely into you.”
“Do you really think so?” I ask, trying to keep my voice as chilled as
possible.
“Oh, definitely,” he says, nodding. “Girls only do cute shit like that
when they’re thinking about you constantly.”
My chest expands at the sentiment. “You think she thinks about me?”
He shakes his head. “You didn’t hear me,” he replies. “I said
constantly.”
CAT
If there’s one day of the year I love most of all, it’s Nora and Connor’s
birthday.
I love a good party like the next person. I love the loud music, the
people, the vibes. It never gets too out of control here at Drayton, which is
what makes it more fun. There’s never any crazy drugs, or any spikings.
There’s never any violence or bad energy between people, it just feels safe
and comfortable. Especially at the Bailey’s estate.
They lucked out with a luxury lake house only a twenty-minute drive
away from campus, a few houses down from my dad’s house. We used to
spend every one of their birthdays here. We’d get sick on candy and the joy
of being in each other’s presence. But now, coming here as adults, our lives
and our bond has changed tremendously.
What hasn’t changed is the fact that each year the twins have to have a
theme for their birthday and this year it’s very on-brand for Nora.
The only logical answer for my character would be Tiana from Princess
and the Frog which just so happens to be my favourite Disney movie. Elle
is dressed as Moana, her tanned skin and curly hair making it a perfect
match as Nora is matching with her boyfriend as Rapunzel and Flynn from
Tangled. I haven’t seen them together yet as Ryan is late as always, but Wes
and Connor are making up for his tardiness.
“He’ll show,” Connor says quietly just to her as he pulls her into his
side. Nora shrugs him off, painting on her best I’m fine face as she smiles.
“I know,” she replies immediately. Wes rolls his eyes at the side of us,
not making it discreet as he sips his beer from a red cup.
The party is in full swing now and despite the twins being the birthday
people, they’re stuck in a little huddle with us in the backyard next to the
raging fire as we try to keep warm. Even as the loud music blares out from
the kitchen speakers and people pass by to wish them a happy birthday,
both Nora and Connor seem to be more comfortable with our little circle
more than the groups of people that came here just for them.
“How’s your birthday so far, Nor?” Wes asks, throwing away his cup
into a bin bag. Her face lights up at the question.
In the kindest way possible, Nora loves to talk about herself. I’ve never
seen it as a bad thing. I think it’s downright adorable. Her whole face
transforms as she talks about the things and people she loves. But as their
conversation continues, my gaze snags on Connor as his eyes drop to the
ground and then he swiftly turns away, excusing himself.
Weird.
“Your outfit looks really good,” Wes says, and my attention is drawn
back to the two of them. Nora holds eye contact with him as Elle bumps her
shoulder into mine as if to say are you seeing this. And the fuck I am. Wes
flirts with everyone, but this… This feels different. He seems nervous,
which is unusual. “You look, uh, pretty, I meant.”
“Thank you,” Nora replies after what feels like an eternity of them just
looking at each other.
“Give us a spin,” I say, nodding to her. She really does pull off the
brunette version of Rapunzel with her dark brown curls and bright green
contacts. She turns, but as she stumbles a little, Wes’s arm catches onto
hers.
“What are you doing later?” he blurts out. She looks taken aback as she
turns around and gestures at the party. “Do you wanna come over?”
“To your dorm?” Nora asks, her tone bored and slightly confused. He
nods, blushing. “To do what?”
“I dunno,” he answers, shrugging. “I could eat you out. Wait. No- Not
eat you out. I mean, I would take you to eat. With me. Together. Me and
you… Eating… Food…”
Oh my god what is happening?
Nora laughs, throwing her head back. Wes shoots me and Elle a look to
help him, but I have no clue what’s going on. He’s clearly had too much to
drink, and I highly doubt Nora will remember this in the morning.
“I’ll come over,” she says.
“You will?” Wes asks, his eyes hopeful.
“As long as I get to pick the activities,” Nora warns, pointing an
accusing finger in his face. He takes her outstretched finger as a sign of a
promise and weirdly interlocks his index finger with hers. “And I get to
decide what we eat.”
Those two are the weirdest people I’ve ever met.
After tiring myself out dancing with Nora and Elle to Taylor Swift songs in
a crowd full of sweaty twenty-somethings, I finally make my way back into
the house. Somehow, it’s cooler here than it is outside. Nora and Connor
always underestimate the amount of people that turn up to their parties and
it ends up getting overwhelming sometimes.
As much as I love partying and dancing and doing stupid shit with my
friends, it’s also exhausting. I always get this heavy feeling in my chest no
matter how many times I go out where I have a sudden realisation that these
kinds of moments won’t last forever. It’s pathetic and self-sabotaging but
it’s also a very real possibility. If I ever lost the bond I have with these girls
or our little family, I don’t think I could function as a real human ever
again. That sounds dramatic, but it’s true. They are my lifeline.
That moment in the night comes a lot earlier than expected tonight. I try
my best to ignore it. I’ve had a few too many drinks and I just need some
water, that’s all.
I make my way into the kitchen, my head pounding from the music and
the drinks when I spot Connor’s unforgettable silhouette by the sink. He’s
ditched the thick sweater thing that Kristoff wears and is instead only
wearing the pants and a thinner brown long sleeved top as he… washes the
pots at his own party.
“What are you doing?” I ask, coming up behind him.
“What does it look like?” he retorts, looking back at me with a lazy
smile before washing off a plate.
“It’s your birthday, Connor. You don’t need to worry about cleaning up.
Especially not in the middle of your party,” I say, looking at the neat pile of
plates he’s already staked up. He takes in a deep breath before shrugging.
“Is the party that bad?”
He shrugs again. “Not as fun as I thought it would be.”
“That’s because you’re in here and everyone is out there,” I say,
laughing a little. He finally switches off the tap, drying his hands before he
turns to me. Instantly, I grip onto the counter, needing to steady myself as
his dark eyes bore into mine.
“What I want isn’t out there,” he says, his tone laced with an emotion I
can’t place. The cold pizza I had earlier churns in my stomach as my eyes
gloss over at his proximity. He steps in closer to me.
My voice sounds scratchy and breathy when I finally compose myself
enough to speak. “And what is it that you want?”
He takes a very purposeful perusal of my outfit, stepping even closer to
me. If that’s even possible. The heat in his eyes matches the heavy want
gathering in my lower stomach as he swiftly turns us so he’s towering over
me, caging me in with both of his hands on the sink as my ass backs up into
the marble.
Every tension point in my body tenses before relaxing gently as I
shudder. His whole demeanour changes when he looks down at me like this
as I crane my neck to look up at him. His gaze is hungry and insatiable.
He’s looking at me like I’m the only thing in the fucking room. Like I’m the
goal he needs to reach. Like I’m the only thing he sees.
He’s looking at me like he wants me.
“You know exactly what it is that I want,” he murmurs, his mouth so
close to mine I can almost taste him. My tongue darts out, running across
the seam between my lips as my heartbeat grows erratic.
He gives me what I want – no, what I need – as he presses his weight
into me. Holy fuck. I can feel every part of him like this.
Every part.
Including the part that wants this the most.
“You’re going to have to spell it out for me,” I whisper, needing to
know what he wants, needing to know what I want before we do something
very stupid. “You know I’m a sucker for words, Connor.”
He lets out a sound between a groan and a chuckle as he moves his head
to the side of my neck, his nose grazing my sensitive skin on the right side
of my face. He brushes his knuckles against my cheek with his left hand
causing tiny fires to break out everywhere.
“I want you,” he murmurs as he presses a kiss to my neck. I think I
might pass out. Forget what I said about my social battery running out. I
think I’ve come back to life just to die again. “To dance with me.”
“You want me to…” My breath gets caught when he kisses my neck
again, his hand flexing against the side of my face, gently running down to
grip onto my neck. He squeezes my neck carefully and I clamp my mouth
shut, trying to take a deep breath. “You want me to dance with you?” He
answers by kissing me in the same sensitive spot again.
I muster up the courage to push myself away from him, gaining a shit
ton of confidence I never knew I had. I never make the first move with
guys. Ever. I brace both of my hands on his chest, looking up at him as he
looks down at me, grinning.
“Okay,” I say, pushing him slightly so he walks backwards, and I follow
him, keeping my hands on him. “I’ll dance with you, Connie.”
OceanofPDF.com
FOURTEEN
CONNOR
“YOU LOOK LIKE A DEFORMED ELEPHANT.”
OH FUCK.
Oh fuck.
Oh fuck.
I did not think this through. At all. Because Catherine Fables –
apparently the only girl to ever exist to me – is walking me backwards onto
the dance floor after I told her I wanted to dance with her. Not only does she
look fucking stunning in that dress and her hair tied up in a bun, but the way
she took control of me just then is fucking up my insides.
I needed a second away from the party and only in my wildest dreams
did I imagine that I’d end up back on the dance floor wedged between
sweaty bodies and the epitome of beauty as she stares up at me.
The noise coming from the party doesn’t seems to exist when she’s in
my view. She’s all I see. All I feel. All I hear.
My Catherine.
She drops her hands from my chest finally when we’re deep enough
into the crowd. She trails her hands down my arms, causing goosebumps to
rise across them despite the scorching heat of the room. When her hands
meet mine, she twists around, giving me her back instead and resting my
hands on her hips.
“Just follow my lead, okay?”
I don’t think I could respond if I tried. Her body instantly fits so
perfectly with mine, her ass nestled into my lap as my hands find each other
around her stomach. Tonight, You Are Mine by The Technicolours blares
through the speakers and that mixed with the darkness of the room instantly
gives us both the confidence to completely lose ourselves within each
other.
We both move to the music and each time we sway, she presses herself
further into me and I lose my mind more and more. Is this supposed to be
painful? Because I’m having a hard time forming words or even thoughts
right now.
Her head tilts back, resting on my chest as her eyes flutter closed, her
hands locking behind my neck. She wants this just as much as I do and I
fucking love it. She’s not the bossy or wound-up Catherine that would
smack me with a ruler if I said something mean to her. This is the Catherine
that likes to party, the one that likes to dance like this whilst having no idea
just what she’s doing to me.
“Is this what I get for my birthday, Catherine?” I murmur into her skin,
loving how hot and flushed it feels against my mouth. My own heartbeat is
hammering against my ribs so loud I’m sure she can hear it.
“Only because you’ve been good,” she says, her eyes opening slightly.
Our gazes lock and burn, the world around us disappearing. My hands flex
against her stomach at the lusty, hooded look her eyes give me.
“Yeah?” I tease. She nods, her teeth sinking into her bottom lip as she
purposefully grinds herself against me and I hiss. “What if I was bad? What
would you give me then?”
“A reasonable punishment,” she whispers.
“You sure? This already feels like torture.” I groan as her hands tighten
around my neck, pulling at my hair. This woman is about to drive me
fucking insane and I’m going to let her.
“Why?” she breathes out. There is no way she doesn’t know just how
badly I’ve wanted to be this close to her.
I lean over her, pressing another kiss to the spot behind her ear, claiming
it as mine. “Because I want to do more than just dance with you,
Catherine,” I admit. She sucks in a breath, her hand tightening on me once
again. “Knowing how good you feel, feeling how good you fit with me… I
don’t know how much more of this torture I can take.”
“What are you talking about?” she asks, her voice thick.
I’m about to tell her just how badly I want her, explain it to her in every
single language since words are her speciality, but I’m hit in the head with
something. Hard. Cat’s arms drop from mine as I wince, rubbing the back
of my head. I already feel empty without her touch.
I turn around to find the culprits.
Sam and Wes.
I swear I’m going to murder them both one day. Wes is baring all of his
teeth, grimacing as if he feels bad for throwing a football at my head, but
Sam is snickering like a child. I don’t know what invite Sam was given, but
he’s the only person in this joint wearing a costume that isn’t from a Disney
film as he casually rocks a Shrek cosplay outfit.
“Sorry,” Wes shouts. “Olaf is having a wardrobe malfunction, and we
need your help.”
“You need three people to help?” I ask, annoyed.
“Yeah, well, it’s not like you’re busy,” Sam says, gesturing to me and
Cat as she crosses her arms against her chest.
“I am busy,” I groan, remembering the position I was in less than two
minutes ago.
“That was a rhetorical question,” Sam argues.
I roll my eyes at him, turning back to Cat. I look down at her and she
doesn’t seem pissed like I thought she would. Instead, she looks somewhat
relieved. She gives me a weak smile.
“Somebody needs to tell him that is not what a rhetorical question is,”
she murmurs, trying and failing to hide her grin. I just want to kiss it off her,
pester her face with my kisses until she’s hot all over.
“I’m sorry. I’ll come find you later, okay?” I whisper into the space
between us. She nods, blinking up at me with her perfect eyes. “I want to
finish what we started.”
“Well, don’t take too long because I can take care of myself, Connie.”
“This is why you interrupted me?” I ask, exasperated when I finally make it
up the stairs. I’m staring at a half-naked Archer while Wes and Sam look at
me like I’m a fucking fairy godmother who is supposed to somehow fix
their problem.
“We tried to do some DIY, and as you can see, it did not go to plan,”
Wes says, gesturing toward Archer’s discarded Olaf costume which lays on
the floor of my childhood bedroom.
“Yeah, it should be called DNDIY: Do Not Do It Yourself. This shit is
ridiculous,” Sam says, placing his hands on his hips as he looks down at the
costume. Do I even want to ask? They must register the confusion on my
face because more bullshit comes out of Sam’s mouth. “You didn’t tell us
how hard it would be for him to take a leak in this thing. So, Archie Boy
took it off and we had some fun with the scissors.”
Archer holds up the costume which now has a huge hole in the crotch
area and two on both sides. What kind of idiot cuts things like that? “See
what they’ve done?”
“Oh, it’s not that bad,” Wes says. Archer scowls at him before fitting the
piece over his head which has also apparently lost a few inches because he
doesn’t get the thing any further than his chest, his hands still in the air.
“You look like a deformed elephant,” I mutter, turning back around. I
can’t believe he dragged me away from the best part of my night.
I meant what I said. I want to finish what we started.
By the time I get back to where I left Catherine, the party had grown
tenfold. I don’t know how people get invited to these things without Nora
and I saying, but knowing how she is, she probably invited everyone from
her class, afraid of telling them no.
The music is still blaring in my ears, sweat trickling down my spine as
people bump into me, drunkenly mumbling their happy birthdays as I try to
find the one good part of my day.
When I finally find her, she’s not where I left her. Instead, she’s in the
one room I never expected to find her.
My parents have a small office-like room with soft leather couches, a
coffee table and a ton of board games which they’ve hoarded over the years.
Catherine is sitting in one of the oversized chairs, curled up with her knees
to her chest.
“Are you okay?” I ask into the room. It’s quieter in here which is why
she flinches at the sound of my voice. She turns to look at me as she nods,
but I don’t believe her. I kneel in front of her, tilting my head to the side as I
rest my hand on her knee. This is not the Cat I had in my arms twenty
minutes ago. “What’s wrong?”
She sighs, laughing a little at herself. “My social battery is hanging on
by a thread.”
I nod in understanding. Cat’s a party girl. She goes out more than I do.
But sometimes I wonder if she goes out just to say she’s been out, not
because she actually cares about the stupid things that happen at parties.
“Do you want some water?” I ask and she nods. Luckily the room has a
black mini fridge disguised as a cupboard, so I open it and pull out a crisp
bottle of water, placing it into her hands. She smiles as she opens the cap,
taking a sip.
“Thank you,” she murmurs. My eyebrows pull together. She’s thanking
me? What did I do that needs a thank you from her? Does she not know that
I’d lay at her feet all day if she asked me to? “No one’s ever done that for
me before.”
“No one’s ever gotten you some water when you needed it?” I ask
curiously.
She shakes her head. “Not when I’m like this.”
I run my hand against her knee again. “You can talk to me, Cat, you
know that, right? You can tell me anything. You don’t have to hide from
me.”
“It’s nothing,” she says, swallowing.
“I doubt it.”
She sighs, a little frustrated. “I just get these… moods.”
“Moods?” I repeat.
She nods slowly. “Sad moods. Like, very sad, dark, depressive moods.”
I wish I had more to offer her than, “Oh.”
She lets out a sharp laugh. “Yeah, oh.”
I rest my hand on her knee reassuringly, steading her. “That’s okay,” I
finally say.
“Is it? It gets annoying and tiring, even for me,” she whispers. I don’t
say anything and just wait for her voice to gain momentum again. “I don’t
know… I just get stuck in my head sometimes and I don’t know how to
come out of it. It’s happened a lot since my mom died. I just kinda stay
there? It’s happening a lot at parties recently which sucks because I want to
have a good time. Then I realise I’ve been there for too long and I've
probably had this boring, passive look on my face all night and I hate
feeling like I'm not there when I am, but sometimes–”
I almost knock her completely out as I wrap my arms around her,
holding her close to me. Her body doesn’t know how to respond at first as
she stays in my arms before she slowly finds her hands around my back and
nestles her head into the crook of my neck.
God, I just want to breathe her in. Stay here with her forever. Do
anything she asked me. Listen to her talk for hours.
“Just breathe, Cat,” I murmur. She nods against my neck, and I watch
her back rise and fall. “It’s okay to feel like that. And whoever has told you
that it’s not, is fucking stupid.”
She holds on tighter to the words of encouragement and I let her mould
into me. Nothing could have prepared me for what it feels like to finally
have her in my arms. I’ve wished on nearly every star, prayed nearly every
night for her to let me in like this and get me to see her. Now that I’ve got
her, I’m afraid I won’t ever be able to let go.
Still, after we’ve been attached to each other for a few minutes, I try to
ease up off her. She doesn’t budge. Instead, she pulls me closer.
“No,” she whispers. “Don’t let go yet.”
I can’t place how long Cat and I stayed there like that. She needed to be
held as much as I needed it. I never realised or even thought about just how
exhausting her life must be with a shitty dad and her almost biological need
to be good at school.
After she collected herself, the party was still in full swing, and it only
took another round of shots for Elle to completely lose it and was dancing
against and possibly with Archer before Cat dragged her away from him.
Elle is one of the sweetest people I know, but she doesn’t go out much.
When she does, it only takes a few drinks for her to get drunk, which is why
I always take them back home after parties.
Nora disappeared at some point through the night and apparently Wes is
with her. I know he’ll take care of her, and I know I’ll take care of them.
Which is why I know to step out of Elle’s way when we get to their dorm,
and she rushes in to go to the bathroom.
“You should probably go check on her,” I say to Catherine, nodding at
the closed door of their dorm behind her. She glances back to the door and
nods slowly before turning back to me. Her mouth twitches in a smile as a
silent thank you for dropping her off, but when she’s about to turn, I clasp
my hand over her arm, pulling her back into me.
I tower over her, pressing her into the door as those chestnut brown doe
eyes blink up at me, her lips parting. “Uh, hi?”
“I just wanted to say thank you for telling me what you did earlier,” I
whisper.
“You had to push me against the door to do that?” she teases, tilting her
head to the side, that beautiful smile popping out. I shrug. “It’s not a big
deal. I don’t know why I made it into a big thing.”
I sigh, shaking my head. I know that people can get into those dark
moods sometimes. It happens to people around me all the time. But
vocalising that and acknowledging it is a big deal.
“Look,” I start, scratching my neck nervously. “I don’t know what
happened to make you feel like you don’t deserve to be cared for when you
get like that, but you deserve someone who’s going to want to be with you
all the time. In the dark when you don’t have anything to do. In the silence
when you don’t have the words to speak. In the sad moments where you
can’t figure out what’s wrong. Not just when you’re happy.”
I watch carefully as her eyes light up a little, a golden swirl glimmering
in the dull lighting of the hallway. “Thank you, Connie. That means a lot,”
she replies, dropping her gaze to the ground. She nudges her foot into mine.
“And you do too, you know.”
“What?”
Her eyes settle on mine again. “You deserve all that, too. Even though
I’ve never seen you date anyone since high school. Why is that?”
She’s right. Since I started college, I’ve not gone out with anyone past
the first date without thinking about the girl right in front of me. I tried to
date people, but no one made my chest hurt like it does when I look at
Catherine. No one made me laugh as hard as I did when I was with her.
Nobody made me want to make them smile as much as I did when I saw
her.
“No one has ever interested me,” I say, shrugging.
“That’s a lie,” she laughs. “Girls throw themselves at you like you’re
the last tamale in the tray. You have literal cheerleaders for your team.”
“Like I said, none of them interest me,” I press again. She’s never going
to get it, is she?
She rolls her eyes. “But there’s got to be someone, right? Someone
you’ve secretly had your eye on. Someone who you just have to get a
second glance at in the hallway. We all have those crushes.”
“Yeah, there might be someone,” I murmur. I try to gauge her reaction,
see if she’ll finally get what I’ve been hinting at for years, but I don’t want
to push her.
My eyes drop to her lips – perfect, wet, plush. She inhales sharply,
tilting her head up. My body is doing what it wants before consulting my
brain as I lift my hand to her chin, finally touching her the way I’ve wanted
to for fucking years. I run my thumb against her bottom lip, inwardly
groaning, knowing I can’t do more than this. My heart roars in my ears,
thrashing against my chest as I take one step away from her. “Goodnight,
Catherine.”
She just blinks at me, not knowing what to do or say. “Goodnight. And,
uh, happy birthday.”
OceanofPDF.com
FIFTEEN
CONNOR/CAT
HANGOVERS AND BRUNCH
CONNOR
EVERY YEAR, like clockwork, we have a brunch the morning after our
birthday. When we were kids, we’d have massive blow-out parties per our
parent’s requests, and the morning-after brunch was a smaller get-together
where we’d recoup. It was a way for my parents to cure their hangover
while spending time with us and making sure we had a good birthday.
Now, it’s the opposite way around. My parents usually leave the house
up to us on our birthdays while they spend their night at our cabin in Aspen
and Wes and Nora get shitfaced whilst I make sure they’re under control.
Since we turned seventeen, and alcohol became much more desirable we’ve
become the ones with the hangovers whilst our parents spread out waffles,
pancakes and French toast on the table as me, my sister, Cat, Elle, and Wes
grunt and groan whilst basking in the rare November sunshine on the back
porch.
Nora rubs her head as she attempts to sip the orange juice she has in
front of her, wearing her oversized sunglasses. “I feel like death upon death
upon more death.”
“I second that,” Elle murmurs, reaching for the tropical juice my mom
put together. Cat groans beside her in agreement, dropping her head onto
Elle’s shoulder, also wearing a huge pair of sunglasses.
“You should all take a page out of my book,” I say proudly around a
mouthful of scrambled eggs. I smile to myself, knowing I feel perfectly fine
after not having more than one drink last night. They all moan at the same
time, sounding like a pack of zombies.
“And what book is that? How to be boring and sober?” Wes asks and
he shakes his head, answering himself. He runs a hand through his hair, his
newly manicured nails glimmering in the sunlight before placing his
Drayton Hills cap back on his head, shielding him from the sun as he slowly
sinks his head into Nora’s lap. “I’m good,” he whispers snuggling into her
lap.
Nora pats his head condescendingly. “I’m never drinking again.”
Cat laughs, the sound rushing right through me even though she’s not
even laughing at or even with me. “You said that last time and the time
before that,” she replies, giggling. “Plus, we all know that when Ry-Ry’s
birthday comes up, you’re going to use it as another excuse to go out
again.”
“That’s if you’re still together by then,” I mutter. I’m sure Nora shoots
me a look behind her sunglasses, but it’s hard to tell. I don’t miss the way
Cat leans up off Elle’s shoulder, pushing her glasses to her head and glares
at me. “I mean, of course you’ll be together by then.”
“Yeah,” Nora responds quietly, resting her head against the back of the
chair.
It still baffles me every day how she manages to put up with him. He’s
good to her in all the ways that matter, – according to her – but he has a bad
habit of not showing up when he needs to.
He always has some stupid excuse and lets her down. They’ve been
together so long that I’m convinced she would let him break her heart piece
by piece then let go of him. I’ve tried talking sense into her, as has everyone
else, but she won’t give up on him. I’m terrified to find out what she’d let
him do before she finally lets him go.
“That guy is a dick,” Wes mutters. I hum in agreement and Nora hits
him on the top of his head. “Okay, ouch. I already have a headache. No
need to add salt to the wound.”
I finish off what’s on my plate, downing another glass of orange juice
before I let out a long sigh. “Well, you’re going to have to look as picture
perfect as you can, Wesley, because we have to meet coach later.”
“Oh, shit,” he curses, sitting up out of my sister’s lap. “And we’ve got
that thing at Ollie’s today.”
Catherine’s eyebrow quirks. “What thing?”
Wes opens his mouth, but I stop him. “Nothing. Just post-game stuff,” I
say to her, smiling as she narrows her eyes at me further. I turn back to Wes
as he rubs at his temples. “Get your ass up, Mackenzie.”
“I’m coming. I’m coming,” he mutters, finally getting up out of his seat
and stacking the plates on top of each other.
After we’ve cleaned up the kitchen, listened to thirty different songs and
made it back to campus, Wes is still complaining about his hangover. I don’t
know how many times I have to tell him to pace himself when he drinks,
but he never listens to me. He usually ends up in some random girl’s bed
after they give him the look and then complains about it to me for a week.
“Don’t even breathe on me, man,” he murmurs as we walk towards his
dad’s office. “I swear my brain is about to fall out of my skull.”
“You just never learn, do you?” I ask, nudging my shoulder into his.
“I was fine when I left the party. It’s your sister who doesn’t know when
to stop,” he retorts. I still have no idea what they were doing last night in
my dorm, but she was gone by the morning, so I didn’t even bother to ask.
“One more drink turns into five with her. Who knew drunk karaoke could
be so much fun.”
So that’s what all the noise was last night. I thought a deer was being
murdered.
“Besides, she’s just distracting herself because Ryan didn’t show,” I say.
Just thinking about that jackass makes me feel sick. “Did she say anything
to you about him?”
Wes shakes his head. “Nah. He called her a few times, but she put her
phone on silent. I didn’t want to poke any wounds, so I kept my mouth
shut.”
“Thank you for keeping quiet for once in your life,” I say, ruffling his
curls.
“Yeah, yeah,” he mocks. “Anything for you, Connie boy.”
CAT
OceanofPDF.com
SIXTEEN
CONNOR
BIKINIS AND HOT TUBS
IF YOU HAVE two lawyers for parents, you get a massive mansion just
outside of Denver with an infinity pool, a hot tub, six bedrooms, three
storeys, a private estate and a fridge and pantry constantly filled with
snacks.
Oliver Nayman is one lucky bastard.
The second we heard about his pool; the team begged to use it. Luckily
Oliver doesn’t have many friends outside the team, so he was more than
happy to let us use it, especially after a game.
Swimming is one of those relaxing things that doesn’t feel like too
much of a workout and it still feels comfortable. I can let the water take me
to where I want to go, knowing I’m doing something without doing too
much. It’s a perfect sport to do alongside football and an ice bath is good
for anyone. It took a while to get used to it, but now I’ve done it so many
times it doesn’t feel like anything.
Most of the team ditched Oliver’s small get-together for a bigger party,
despite the advice Coach relayed to the whole team at our meeting before
our game today. Most of the guys scoffed and continued to talk about the
parties they’re hosting this weekend and how many times they’re going to
get laid. The playboy act is getting old and pathetic by now and it seems
like me, Oli, Sam and Wes are the only people that have realised that.
After my fifteen minutes in the ice bath, I make my way into Oliver’s
huge kitchen, needing another snack. Those freezing ice cubes make me so
fucking hungry. Most of the time I just sit there, staring at the darkened
night sky, silently waiting for whatever snack I’m going to find after my
time is up.
I pull open a drawer full of every flavour of Oreo’s known to man and
pick up a packet of the birthday cake flavour – my favourite. I hear the soft
click of the door open and the gentle thump of shoes moving across the
wooden floor before they stop. I ignore it, hoping it’s one of the guys that
have realised that this kind of night in is much better than an overflowing
bar full of men and their BO. I pull a carton of milk from the fridge,
pouring some into a glass before downing it and pouring another one.
The footsteps finally pick up again, quieter and I give in to the curiosity.
No.
Fucking.
Way.
Catherine is standing before me in nothing but a purple bikini and a
transparent cover-up. Her dark curly hair flows past her shoulders, glowing
from the large French doors of Oli’s backyard. The coverup falls past her
knees where her ankles cross as she pins her hands behind her back,
showcasing her toned stomach and perky tits.
I might pass out.
Is that insane? Probably. This woman has completely bewitched me
body and soul. Or whatever that guy from the cheesy rom com says.
She’s standing there, looking absolutely magnificent as she stares at me
wide-eyed as if I’m the one in the wrong place. This is my friend’s house.
My post-game safe space. Not hers. She didn’t even know Oliver until four
weeks ago.
I forget about my precious Oreo’s and take three steps towards her as
she still stares at me. When I reach her, she lifts her head up in challenge.
“What are you doing?” she asks.
I almost scoff at her question. “What are you doing, Cat?”
She gestures to her outfit and now that I’m closer to her, I have to bite
the inside of my cheek, curling my hands into fists at my side. I want to
touch her. I need to touch her. She’s showing too much skin. Too much for
me to see. Too much for me to want.
“What does it look like?” she teases. “I’m getting in the pool.”
“Not in that you’re not,” I say, the words leaving me in a gruff, deep
tone.
“I am,” she relays. I wrap my hand around her waist, the skin to skin
contact almost making me dizzy as I pull her away from the door where the
guys could see her and press her against the wall in the kitchen.
She’s almost too much like this. She smells fucking fantastic – all sweet
and fresh. Her skin is scorching despite the weather and part of me wants to
believe it’s because of me. I don’t miss the way her eyes scan my naked
torso right up to my eyes. I lean both of my hands above her head, caging
her in.
“What do you think you’re doing?” I whisper again.
“Research,” she replies, and she has the fucking audacity to smile at me.
She’s too cocky. She knows exactly what I mean, yet she wants to play with
me.
I lean my head into the crook of her neck, dropping one of my hands to
slowly slip off the shoulder of her cover up. When the soft mesh material
falls, I pluck the strap of her bikini. A sharp gasp escapes her lips as the
bikini strap slaps back against her skin.
“Research, huh?” I run my finger down her shoulder, revelling in the
hungry feeling I get as I feel goosebumps arise across her skin. She nods,
not replying. For someone who swears by words as if they’re the key to
every problem, she doesn’t have much to say.
When my finger dips down her back, slightly tugging on the band of her
bikini top, her back arches into mine. I have to suppress my groan, feeling
just how badly I want her in my shorts. I slip my hand under the back of her
bikini, feeling her bare skin beneath my palm as my breathing matches her
desperate breaths.
“Connor…” she whispers, my name passing through her lips in a
breathy and almost unsure tone.
I ignore her plea.
“Do you understand what you’re doing to me, hm?” I swear I hear a soft
whimper leave her mouth and I almost lose my balance. I respond by
pressing further into her so she can feel just how badly I want her, how
badly I want her everything. “I’m not a jealous person, Cat. I never have
been. But with you, knowing you’re about to go out there in front of those
fucking vultures, you could say I’m a little jealous.”
Her hands finally gain some purpose as she curls both of her palms on
my waist, her nails digging into my flesh as she pulls me closer to her.
“Why? We’re– We’re just friends.”
“Friends,” I bite the word out as if it has personally offended me in
some way. “Is the very last thing on my mind when it comes to you, and
you know that.”
She blinks up at me, those gorgeous brown deer eyes staring right into
mine as her lips part. I watch her eyes dip to my lips, and I can’t help but
run my tongue against the seam of my bottom lip before biting it. She’s
about to say something, but I don’t bother to wait for a response.
“Just get in the pool, Catherine.”
OceanofPDF.com
SEVENTEEN
CAT
IS THIS SUPPOSED TO TURN ME ON?
“LET’S GO, Titans, let’s go! Let’s go, Titans, let’s go!”
If there was any time to put my head inside a bowl of ice water, now it’s
now.
Nora has been chanting like a crazy person all morning as we got ready
for the football game today. I don’t think she’s ever missed a game in her
whole time here at Drayton and each time, she just gets crazier with her
outfit choices and her chants.
Today she’s wearing Connor’s jersey with green face paint and a
number fourteen sticker on her cheek. She even convinced Elle to do face
paint too, but hers looks a lot cuter with a few green dots in a crescent shape
on the side of her head. I stuck to wearing a training jersey that I ordered
from the school site last week that doesn’t have anybody’s number on it and
added a green ribbon to my half-up and half down style my hair is in.
“Let’s go, Nora, let’s go,” I chant back to her, waiting outside the door
of our dorm. She’s giggling now as she runs out the door, a bag full of
snacks and extra face paint just in case. After she’s finally done doing her
pre-game happy dance, I lock the door and we walk down the hallway.
“Is it only me who’s actually kind of excited?” Elle asks, peering at us
in the line that we’re walking in. “Like, I’ve always thought football was an
attractive sport, but there is something in the water here.”
“I still don’t get how the game works,” I admit. No matter how many
times I watched our dads play with Wes and Connor, I could never get the
hang of it. Even now with all the research I’ve done, my brain just hurts
even more.
“You don’t have to know how it works to enjoy it,” Nora says beside
me. “It’s the atmosphere that makes it fun – the chanting, the band, the
cheerleaders, the music. It’s a little on the nose, but that’s what makes it
better.”
“I’m sure,” I mock, and she elbows me before hooking her arm into
mine and I hook mine through Elle’s.
When we get down to the pitch, the bleachers are bustling with people
all dressed like us on one side and the opposing team from the other college
sit on separate stands. Just like Nora said, the atmosphere is otherworldly.
It’s fucking freezing out here in the early November chill, but the glow
of the headlights, the massive time board on one side of the pitch and the
smell of soggy hot dogs from the concession stand makes me feel like I’m
in a movie.
The games I went to in high school were nothing like this. People were
definitely louder then, but at college level, they’re more serious. The crowd
knows that the teams aren’t playing to win a participation trophy, but they
need to win to be seriously considered to be drafted into the NFL. And from
what my research tells me, it’s competitive as hell.
We take a seat not too far and not too close on the bleachers, snuggling
close together to keep warm. We’ve got our huge jackets, gloves and
scarves on, rubbing our palms together to keep some heat going. Nora
whips off her outer layers, showcasing her jersey instead when the team
start doing warm-ups on the pitch.
That woman is crazy.
I scan the field and the bleachers, looking back to the small tunnel
where the boys walk through as I wait for something. I have no idea what.
I’m getting antsy and impatient at the thought of seeing Connor again after
what happened the other night.
Not only is it awkward as fuck sitting next to and inadvertently lying to
Nora about where I was the other night, I hate that I did whatever it was I
did with Connor just as much as I enjoyed it.
I let him touch me in the places I’ve only dreamt about him being. I
never would have told him that out loud and I don’t think I ever will.
There’s always been a tiny part of me that’s had a crush on him. Of course,
there has. It’s the oldest trope in the book.
He’s always been kind to me, especially after the way he looked after
me at the party. He listens when I ramble and even when I don’t. He looks
at me like he sees me and not like he’s judging me. It also helps that he has
the deepest brown eyes I’ve ever seen. He has soft, slightly curly hair that I
want to run my hands through, lips that look perfect for…
“You okay?” Elle asks. It’s only then that I realise I’ve been twisting my
scarf between my hands. I smooth it out easily, taking a deep breath. I
cannot get caught up with thoughts about him already. That’s just
ridiculous. “Are you nervous to see them play?”
“No,” I say, laughing as I turn to her. “Why would I be nervous? I’m
here for research purposes only.”
“Research?” Elle repeats, cocking her head to the side. That word has
been fucking me up lately and I hate it. “I’ve seen you looking at Connor
since we got here.”
“No, I haven’t. Why would I look at him?” I whisper, keeping my voice
low as Nora chats with the girl beside us animatedly. That girl can make
friends anywhere. I’m convinced it’s her superpower.
“Look, I won’t say anything, but I saw you dancing at the party. No
matter how drunk I was, there was no way I missed that,” she says to me. I
swallow. Hard. I’ve been replaying that night over and over before I go to
sleep each night. It’s a sickness. “Unless I completely misread the
situation,” she adds when I don’t say anything.
“No,” I whisper, “No, you didn’t.”
“I fucking knew it,” she says triumphantly. “You like him, don’t you? I
bet all that forced proximity is eating away at you.”
I shrug. “I don’t know yet, Elle-Belle,” I reply.
She smiles wide, her dimples sinking in. “Well, either way, that’s
fucking adorable. You deserve to be happy, Cat. Just…” She turns back to
Nora who is still talking. “Be careful.”
“I know,” I say, “I will.”
That felt like a lie the second the crowd roared when the team slowly
made their way back onto the pitch because when I saw Connor lined up,
helmet in hand, padded up and fucking massive, a piece of me died inside.
He scanned the crowd, looking and searching until his hot gaze finally
landed on me.
And then he smiled.
At me.
My stomach somersaulted at the movement, and I hope to God nobody
noticed it. My whole face lit up with the sheer excitement of what-if which I
haven’t felt for a while. What if I let myself have this? What if I let myself
fall?
Being careful seems to be the very last thing on my mind right now.
Is this supposed to turn me on, or is that just me? I don’t think I took my
eyes off the players the entire game. Did I understand what was going on?
Not completely. Did I feel my heart fall right out of my chest whenever I
watched one of the players sprint with the ball? Every. Fucking. Time.
I didn’t know how much it excited me until they started playing. The
crowd was almost animalistic as they roared and cheered with the team,
encouraging them to go on. Nora was waving her hands in the air like a
mad woman, yelling at the opposing team while Elle and I couldn’t stop
laughing. It was a new and thrilling experience and now I want to go to
every single game and deal with the chaotic aftermath.
Once the boys had showered and changed, we waited for them in the
parking lot on campus that sits between the sports arena and our dorms. We
were invited to a wind-down session back at Oliver’s house. No pool today,
unfortunately, as it’s being cleaned. I don’t think I’d be able to look at his
backyard without my thoughts turning feral.
Connor steps out of the doors to the arena, freshly showered and his
brown hair a damp mess on his head as Sam, Wes and Oliver are in tow
behind him but he’s all I see. Nora runs towards them as excited as ever.
“Holy shit,” she exclaims, looking up at Connor and Wes. “You were
fucking amazing. And that second half? I almost shit myself.”
Wes laughs, slinging his arm around her shoulder as they continue to
walk towards us. Connor doesn’t take his eyes off mine as he slowly walks
towards me. I press my back further into his truck. “What did you think,
Catherine?” he asks above Nora’s excited chatter.
I shrug. “You were good. You were all good.”
“Just good?” he asks, his voice low and scorching as he steps in closer
to me. My heartbeat increases as my chest rises and falls while I look up at
him. “We were better than good, and you know it.”
“Do I?” I tease. He presses one hand on the hood of the car, caging me
in. He just loves doing that, doesn’t he? Even when people are around. He’s
going to get us into some very deep shit if he carries on and if I continue
letting him.
He lowers his head to the side of my face, his breath hot and tantalising
against my ear. “Guess I’ll have to prove you wrong and turn that good into
a fucking fantastic.”
Before I can say anything, Nora comes behind him and pushes him off
me. “Okay, leave her alone, big guy. We’ve got celebratory shots to do!”
I never got to get a good look at Oliver’s house last week before I was
pleasantly ambushed by Connor, but holy fuck… If I could be buried
anywhere it would be here. Wooden floors, high ceilings, dark grey
reflective refrigerators, a wine cellar, a fridge dedicated to alcoholic drinks
only. It’s a frat boy’s wet dream. And mine too, apparently.
I spin in a circle before taking off my coat and hanging it by the door.
Nora and Elle walk in front of me, taking off their outer layers too,
dropping them onto an empty chair in the hallway. Wes and Sam rush past
me, almost knocking me over as Oliver huffs.
“Just don’t break anything, please,” Oli says, running a nervous hand
through his hair as we start down the long hallway. “My parents might be
out of town, but they’re not idiots.”
I laugh a little, finally shredding off my scarf and gloves as I shove
them into my coat pockets. When I turn, I almost collide straight into
Connor’s chest. Luckily for me and the huge chunk of a man, he steadies
me instantly, holding on to my shoulders.
“How many times are you going to fall into me, Cat?” he murmurs
before setting me straight. I brush off my shoulders as if he’s left a mark
there.
“How many times are you going to catch me?” I retort.
“As many times as it takes,” he answers easily, smirking at me. He
looks too good like this – fresh, happy, tall. I mean, he looks tall all the
time. It’s just a necessary description when it comes to him because it turns
me inside out every time I have to look up at him.
“I walked right into that one, didn’t I?” I rub my temples, shaking my
head at my own stupidity. His gaze travels over my outfit, looking down at
my shirt as his eyes squint.
“What are you wearing?”
“A jersey,” I say, smiling, knowing it’ll rile him up.
“Right. And whose number is on the back?”
“No ones,” I answer with a shrug. “But I was considering getting
number eighty-two. That’s yours, right?”
His eyes darken and I take a step back, loving the way I’m messing with
him. “That’s Sam’s and you know it is. Next time you’re considering
wearing anyones jersey, you wear one with my number, okay?”
I nod in fake understanding. This man is already so possessive over me.
I hate it nearly as much as I love it. “So, I have to come to you for massages
and I have to wear your jersey. It seems to me like you’re trying to keep me
already, Connie. I hate to break it to you, but I don’t come to these things
for you.”
“Is that so?”
I swallow. “Yep. I’m here for the team, not you. You just happen to be a
part of it.”
“Are you sure? Because from the way you were whining my name and
sitting in my lap last week, tells me a very different story. It tells me that
you want me, you want this, just as much as I do.”
The thickness in his voice causes a deep, heavy want in my lower
stomach as he walks closer to me, pressing my back into the wall. My pulse
grows erratic, my breathing becoming choppy.
Is he finally going to kiss me? I want him to, so badly. I want to feel the
roughness of his mouth against mine, his weight pressing into me like it did
last week. I tilt my mouth up to his as he brackets my jaw with his hand, the
heat making me grow more desperate by the second.
He leans down.
Finally.
I’m going to quash this desire and get on with my day. Just a taste. Just
the smallest amount I can get without going insane and I can continue to
live my life just with the thought of knowing what he tastes like. Just a little.
“Cat! Where are you? You need to get your little tush here
immediately,” Nora’s loud voice booms. “We can’t do shots without you.”
I sigh, closing my eyes. “I’m going to…” I nod down the hallway where
the rest of the guys are.
“You don’t have to,” he murmurs, our lips achingly close.
“But, Nora…. And, you know.” I trip over my words like an idiot and
he just continues holding my jaw, smiling at me. That fucking smile. Those
fucking lips.
“Right.” He does nothing to put any space between us. “You don’t want
her to think anything is going on, do you?”
“No,” I breathe. “Nothing is going on.”
“Then why aren’t you moving, Catherine?” His lips ghost over mine
and I swear I hear myself whimper at the slight contact.
“I’m moving,” I whisper, closing my eyes for a second. I shake my head
a little, causing Connor’s hand to fall from my face.
“Yeah,” he teases, “I can see that.”
My legs stay rooted in the spot and for whatever reason, all I can do is
stare up at him. Why am I still here? My chest is heaving now, suddenly out
of breath. When I still don’t move, Connor makes his decision for me and
he presses a quick kiss to my forehead.
My fucking forehead.
And then he has the audacity to say, “I’ll see you, sweetheart,” before
leaving me still plastered to the wall.
Fuck. My. Life.
After a few drinks and avoiding Connor like the plague, Elle and I are
already tipsy, wandering around Oliver’s house. It’s like a maze in here – a
beautifully crafted, privileged maze that I never want to escape from. Of
course, we weren’t allowed to wander unattended because he’s a control
freak and insisted on giving us a tour instead.
I pick up a large picture frame on a random coffee table in the middle of
one of the hallways on the second floor. There’s nothing inside it, not even a
stock photo. It’s just a pure gold frame with sparkles on diamonds edged
into it. “What’s this?” I ask.
“Nothing. Put it back,” he demands. The tone in his voice makes me
giggle. Oliver is one of the sweetest guys on the team – he’s usually quiet, a
little reserved and has the most common sense out of all of them, next to
Connor of course. “Eleanor! You can’t touch that.”
I turn to see Elle standing next to a teetering photo on the wall. It’s
fucking massive – at least twice the size of us. It’s one of those weird oil
paintings that you have to look at really hard to understand what it is. Elle
has always had an eye for art and photography, so she’s clearly interested.
Oliver rushes over to her, gently pushing the painting back into place.
Elle shrugs. “I was just looking,” she mumbles.
“You look with your eyes, not your hands,” he demands, and I swear I
see him wipe sweat from his forehead.
I move in step beside them as we continue walking down the hallway,
leading towards the stairs. “You need to chill out, Oli,” I say, messing up his
hair.
“That word has literally no place in my vocabulary,” he mutters, trying
to straighten out his hair again. “I should never have invited you over.”
“Have some fun, Nayman. Let loose,” Elle says, hooking her arm
through his. Some of the boys on this team are wound too tight. They care
too much about the little things. Like thousand-dollar paintings that hang
casually on the walls.
“Yeah, Nayman,” I mock, slinging my arm into the crook of his other
arm. He just laughs, shaking his head as his olive cheeks turn a deeper red
colour.
We take our time going down the floating steps, giggling as we almost
fall through the small gaps. It takes us a lot longer than it should, but we’re
already a little light-headed and the night has only just begun.
Only it hasn’t.
Because now, where the stairs usually end there’s now a flood of
people, dancing and moving around each other with drinks in their hands.
When did this turn into a fully-fledged party? I register the horror on
Oliver’s face as he unhooks his arms from ours, almost tripping down the
steps as he tries to get the party under control.
Elle steps in beside me and she frowns. “What?” I ask and then I follow
her line of vision to where my eyes snag on Connor, standing near the
French doors and he’s staring right. At. Me. “Oh.”
“He’s looking at you like he wants to eat you,” Elle whispers out the
side of her mouth. “Or eat you out. It’s hard to tell.”
The heat of Connor’s gaze is like something I’ve never experienced
before. He has this weird, rare talent where whenever I look at him,
everything, everybody just fades away and it’s just him. He makes me feel
like there’s no one else in the room other than us and my eyes can’t be torn
away from his. His face is so perfect to look at, so comforting yet so
thrilling that it throws me off.
I have no idea what’s happening between us. That kiss that we almost
had earlier is enough to know how badly this could end if someone found
out.
The face that obstructs my view gives me a second to breathe. “More
drinks?” Nora asks, grinning, holding up two solo cups to me and Elle.
When my eyes connect with Connor’s again, I know exactly what my
decision is going to be. Looking at him trips me up more than it needs to. I
just need another night to forget for a while. Forget about waiting on the
next call from my dad. Forget about the assignments that I know will make
me sick to my stomach just thinking about them.
I grab the cup from Nora’s hand, and she giggles like an excited child as
she grabs a stray cup from the bannister, and we all clink our cups together.
Here’s to forgetting.
OceanofPDF.com
EIGHTEEN
CONNOR
MY THOUGHTS ARE NOT VERY PG RIGHT NOW
THE SECOND I watched Cat take that cup from my sister’s hand, I
should have known that tonight would end up like this.
Well, not exactly like this, but close to it.
“Shhhh,” she murmurs, swaying slightly as we stand outside her
bedroom door. She presses her fingers to my lips that were not moving at
all. “You’re being too loud.”
“That’s all you, Cat,” I say against her fingers, trying my hardest to
suppress my laugh.
After cautiously watching all three of the girls drink and dance all night
at Oli’s house, I knew I would be the one bringing them back to their dorm.
Elle and Nora both crashed the second they got in, but Cat is making this
extra difficult. I just wanted to take her back, make sure she got to her door
and go back home.
Being the designated dad in the group is hard.
“When did you get so drunk?” I ask gently, attempting to put a finger on
the exact moment she started going off the rails. All I know is she was tipsy
going on a tour with Oli and then she gave me a look before disappearing.
After that, I tried to discreetly follow her around and make sure she was
okay as she avoided me like I was a fucking disease.
“You keeping tabs on me, Connie?” she asks, her tone playful and light.
“Always.”
We’re just staring at each other, both of our shoulders leaning on her
bedroom door. She licks her lips, still holding two fingers lazily against my
mouth. I don’t know what she’s doing, but I would do just about anything
for her at this point. If that means letting her stare at me while I look back at
her, so be it.
I watch her carefully as her eyes travel across my face from my hair
down to my chest. I would have never known just how much eye contact
could mess me up inside before I met her. She has this gentle, caring nature
in her eyes. It’s like she’s seen too much, knows too many things and has
too many thoughts and feelings that she doesn’t know what to do with them.
“You’re really hot, you know that?” she whispers, the words passing
through her lips in a soft whisper, crashing against the shore in my brain. I
take in a sharp breath. “Like, just so fucking sexy.”
“Okay, sweetheart,” I say in a sigh, “it’s time for bed.”
She shakes her head at me, closing her eyes slightly and probably giving
herself a headache in the process. “No, I’m being serious,” she mumbles,
slurring slightly. “You have really nice eyes.” She runs a finger between my
eyes and slowly moves it down the bridge of my nose as I keep my eyes
locked with hers. “And your lips….” Her voice grows quiet as she runs a
finger against my bottom lip. It takes all that I am to not stick my tongue
out and finally taste her. “You don’t want to know the places I’ve imagined
your mouth being.”
I try to be strong, but Catherine makes me feel fucking weak. She’s
staring up at me, her hand somehow finding its way to my neck as she
winds her finger in my hair. I can’t be with her like this. Not when I want
her so badly and she’s clearly still drunk. She needs to go to sleep, and I
need to go home.
That’s it.
She tilts her mouth up to mine, almost as close as we were at Oliver’s
house, but far away enough that she doesn’t take up every thought in my
brain like she usually does.
“I want you to come to bed with me,” she whispers, her lips
dangerously close to mine now.
“Catherine,” I warn.
She blinks up at me, her eyebrows drawn in, those soft brown eyes
pleading. I take the bait like the dumb bunny I am and push open her
bedroom door.
As expected, everything is so neat and tidy here. Her white bedspread is
made, no clothes spill out of her closet and her desk is organised with neat
piles stacked up next to thick textbooks. The only thing that is a mess is her
overflow of books in one corner of the room. She steps through the door
properly and I shut it behind us.
“Listen, you’ve got to keep things PG, or I can’t stay,’ I whisper.
“I don’t know what you’re talking about,” she mumbles, sitting on the
edge of the bed. I laugh a little as her eyes wander around the room. I stick
my tongue in my cheek, trying my hardest not to laugh. She’s a cute drunk.
Too fucking cute.
“Okay, where are your pyjamas?” I ask, placing my hands on my hips,
not wanting to rifle through her clothes without warning.
“In there,” she says, her voice suddenly breathy. I follow her weak point
to her bedside drawer and pull out shorts and a tank top, the soft material of
them almost falling through my hands. I hold them out to her, waiting for
her to nod slowly.
She’s not making any move to get dressed herself, so I kneel down in
front of her, placing my hands on her thighs and she looks down at me, her
eyes glossy. I don’t think I’ve seen her this quiet. She always has something
to say. Something for me to listen intently to. I pull on the hem of her shirt,
signalling that I’m wanting to help her get unready.
“Can I help you take this off?” I ask, my voice thick and heavy. She lets
out a gentle sigh until she finally nods. I pull up the shirt slightly, but she
still doesn’t move her arms. “Arms up, sweetheart.”
She blinks at me a few times, her eyes clearly heavy with sleep before
she lifts her arms above her head slowly. I work her free of her shirt until
she’s sitting in front of me in nothing but a peach bra and jeans.
My breathing instantly grows erratic. I’ve seen her in nothing but that
tiny bikini only a week ago, but this somehow feels different. The soft glow
coming from her lamp shines across her skin, giving her an almost
dreamlike look. She’s still looking at me, studying me, waiting for some
kind of reaction so I give her one.
“You’re so beautiful, Catherine. Just so fucking pretty.”
She doesn’t react the way I thought she would. Especially after the way
she was complimenting me a few minutes ago. Her lips part slightly, her
eyes clearly etched onto my mouth that I end up sucking in a breath.
You don’t want to know the places I’ve imagined your mouth being.
“Come on,” I say, guiding her to stand up so I can work off her jeans
after helping her into her tank top. She stumbles into me slightly and when
she’s upright again I kneel down in front of her. I’ve gotten too comfortable
being on my knees in front of her, but fuck me if it doesn’t turn me on. It
feels like I’m worshipping her, and she needs to be worshipped.
I unbutton her jeans and slide them down her thighs in a smooth motion,
keeping my eyes trained on her legs and nowhere else until she has to step
out of them, causing her to hold onto my shoulder for support.
When I reach for her shorts, she still doesn’t say anything until she
silently slips into them. “Are you not going to talk?”
She shakes her head. “You’re on your knees in front of me. My thoughts
are not very PG right now.”
Fuck me.
This was a really bad idea, knowing just how much I want her, how
badly my body wants her. I ache just by being in her presence. I swear I
fucking yearn for her. How pathetic is that? Especially when she’s only
telling me how she feels when she’s drunk and horny.
But drunk words are sober thoughts, right?
“What are you thinking, Cat?” I hear myself say.
She swallows, running her hands across my shoulders as she lowers
herself onto the bed, sitting back down. My hands move on their own
accord, lightly grazing her bare skin, the smoothness so foreign yet
comforting. Her breath hitches. “I want to do more than just dance with
you, too.”
“Yeah?”
She nods, her teeth sinking into her bottom lip. “A lot more than that.”
“I’d do anything you want me to. All you have to do is ask.”
“Then kiss me.”
“I’ll kiss you,” I confirm, “But not like this.” I sigh, taking a step back
and standing to my full height. “Come on. Let’s get you in bed.”
She sulks a little, but she listens to me, scooting back slightly until she
pulls back the covers. I lean over her, moving around her pillows until she’s
comfortable and I wrap the covers over her, tucking her in tight and she lets
me. As I’m about to pull away, she clasps her hand around my wrist.
“Stay with me. Please,” she whispers. Her eyes soften, her tone pleading
and vulnerable. It’s the very last thing I should do, but I can feel my skin
itching to stay with her longer.
“Okay,” I sigh, rubbing my hand across my face. “Okay,” I say again,
kicking off my shoes. As she snuggles under the covers, I lay beside her on
top of the covers, facing the ceiling.
“You’re too good to me sometimes, Connie,” she murmurs.
I don’t turn to her. I don’t think I could if I wanted to. Still, when her
hand reaches out and finds mine, I don’t let go. She threads her fingers
between mine, and I squeeze her hand softly. I stroke my thumb against the
soft skin beneath me as she sighs, the sound rushing straight to my brain,
making me want to curl up in a ball and settle right into her.
“That’s all I want to do, Cat. All the time,” I whisper,
I turn to her, ready to see her reaction. Her eyes are closed, her long
lashes resting against her cheeks as she breathes heavily. I let out a sigh of
relief, partly grateful knowing that she didn’t hear me.
Watching her sleep tugs a heavy, yet satisfying feeling over my whole
body like a blanket, a safe and unknown emotion resting on my chest,
knowing that she’s at peace. Her perfect lips are curved into a slight smile, a
tiny tug on her eyebrows and I hope she’s having a happy dream.
When sleep starts to pull me under too, I don’t let go of her hand.
OceanofPDF.com
NINETEEN
CAT
“YOU’RE DOING MY BROTHER?”
OceanofPDF.com
TWENTY
CONNOR
KIT-CAT
Unfortunately for me, Catherine has a lot more self-control than I’ll ever
have. Since she got the team to quieten down and she assumed her position
at the front of the small classroom, she’s not looked at me since.
I honestly shouldn’t be complaining. If she even glanced at me, I’d end
up tipping over the table, shredding the distance between us and taking that
pretty face between my hands and pressing my lips to hers.
She’s been asking the team boring questions all morning and I am this
close to dozing off. I should be paying more attention, seen as this is what
it’s going to be like in the real world if I get drafted, but I can admit that I’m
just a huge baby when I’m not getting the attention that I want.
Wes elbows me in the ribs. Hard. “What’s the matter with you, Connie
boy? I thought you’d be eating up these questions.”
I shrug. “I’m fine. Sam’s taking the lead.”
We both glance over at Sam who talks excitedly as Cat asks him about
his performance this season and how he was last year.
He cares about football as much as I do, he just shows it in other ways.
Whilst I try to keep focused on the pitch and play the ‘dad’ of the group,
keeping everyone in line, Sam likes to keep everyone motivated in other
ways by partying and creating stupid chants that he texts to the
cheerleaders. It’s a mystery to me how he has such a good performance
when he’s out nearly every night with a new girl under his arm and a beer in
the other hand.
“He’s going to make us sound like we’re a shit team,” Wes mumbles
angrily. “If Cat doesn’t dial down his attitude in writing, my dad’s gonna
freak.”
I turn to him, and I swear he’s sweating at the thought of it. Wes can act
as tough as he wants, bantering with his dad, but I know deep down he just
wants to make him proud. I don’t know what the protocol is for Cat’s report
and the newspaper, but I’m sure she’s not going to narc on us.
“We’re gonna be fine,” I assure him. When I see Sam take a breath,
sitting further back in his seat, Cat’s gaze snags on me and I smile, using it
as my chance to get involved. “Can you repeat your question, Miss
Fables?”
She rolls her eyes at the formality in my voice and the guy’s snicker. “I
was saying,” she bites out, trying her hardest not to laugh. “Did you always
want to play football, or did you ever have other career ideas? Sam over
here is saying that this was his one strike of rebellion as a teenager instead
of following in his parents’ footsteps.”
Wes snorts. “Yeah, imagine Sam as a doctor? I’d rather try my luck
healing my own injuries before ever going to him.”
“Yeah, yeah. Very funny,” Sam says, throwing a scrunched up sheet of
paper at Wes, which ultimately ends up hitting me in the face. “You’re
lucky your parents don’t care about what you do. You should have seen the
look on my dad’s face when I told him I wasn’t going to med school.”
Wes laughs quietly at that. We’re both lucky in the parent department,
so we’re extremely grateful to not having any pressure to play football or do
anything else. My parent’s only priority is making sure that Nora and I are
happy and healthy.
“So, that’s my question for you, Bailey,” Catherine begins, and my
entire world focuses completely on her. On the way her mouth moves. The
way her lips say my name. The way she grows slightly nervous when it’s
only our eyes that are connecting. “Did you ever feel like you had any other
options other than football? Did your parents ever make you feel like you
had to do anything else – be like them, for example?”
I swallow, knowing exactly what my answer is going to be. It’s not a
formal interview. I don’t have any real reason to be nervous, but the guys on
the team look up to me for advice. I carry the weight of the team on my
back as the quarterback, so I can’t fuck anything up. I’m perfect Connor
Bailey on and off the pitch.
“It’s always been football for me,” I say. My body relaxes when Cat
smiles at me, a dimple popping out on her cheek. “Growing up, I never
really had anything that I wanted to be. I don’t think I ever thought about it,
like ever. I kinda thought that I’d be a kid forever, that I’d live with my
parents, and I’d watch my sister and my parents grow older. But at some
point in middle school, I started to have aspirations. I never had a job in my
head, it was always this thing that was separate to me. I knew that I would
want to take care of my parents financially, you know, give back to them
and all that. Then when I met Russell Wilson and I stayed up every night
watching the games, I knew that I wanted to be a part of the Broncos. It was
that or nothing for me.”
The words rush out of me and I’m not sure I’m even making sense. I
don’t know what reaction I was expecting from the team. That’s probably
the most I’ve ever spoken to them in one sitting. It freaks me out as much as
it relaxes me.
I lock eyes with Catherine when I’ve finished my rant, her brown eyes
soothing me. “That was a good answer, Connor. Thank you,” she whispers
before dropping her eyes to her laptop.
“You’re a fucking poet, Bailey,” Wes exclaims, clasping his hands on
my shoulders, shaking me. “You, like, completely spoke to my soul just
then. I’m in awe.”
“Shut up,” I mutter, pushing him off me.
He shakes his head. “Nah, I’m serious, bro. You’d probably have Cat
drooling over you by now if you talked like that all the time. Or try sexting
or something, you’d probably get more action that way.”
“You’re so fucking stupid. You know that?” I murmur. He grins at me,
triumphant.
He shrugs. “I’m just saying. She’s a journalism major. She probably
gets wet over words alone.”
“Don’t use the word ‘wet’ when you’re talking about my girl,” I say,
scrubbing my hands against my face. I swear I’m getting a headache just by
being in his presence.
“Sorry,” he laughs, clutching his chest. “Did you just say, ‘my girl’?” He
continues laughing and I just blink at him. “You’re down bad way more
than I thought, Connie. You’re in some deep shit.”
I shake my head at him, turning away. As good as a friend he is, his
morals are loose, and he has this I-don’t-give-a-fuck attitude that is bound
to cause him a lot of problems later on in life. His advice is always a little
blurry, so he’s never the first person I go to for advice.
Ever.
OceanofPDF.com
TWENTY-ONE
CONNOR/CAT
“DON’T GET SHY FOR ME NOW.”
CONNOR
U up?
Good.
KIT-CAT
Idk. I’m just thinking abt u and I like knowing ur awake too.
I think for a second that I’ve scared her off as the blue bubbles appear
and then disappear again. Did I say something wrong? How can I be
messing this up before anything has even happened? My fears are quashed
when I finally see her respond.
KIT-CAT
I’m thinking about the way u kissed me. The way u touched me
in the hot tub.
What else?
KIT-CAT
KIT-CAT
I’d kiss you softly first, press my lips right against yours until
you relax for me. I’d run my tongue against the seam of your
lips until i push my tongue into your mouth. I’d kiss you so hard
that you’ll go dizzy. So passionately that it’ll feel like fucking.
Fuck. Is it true that you can come just by reading because holy fuck. The
images she’s painted makes my cock ache with need, with a desperation and
eagerness to get off. I immediately shake off my boxers, fist my erection in
one hand and reach for my phone with the other.
Answer the phone, Cat.
She doesn’t waste any time to answer it and I don’t waste any more time
to speak. I adjust myself in my bed, making myself comfortable as I close
my eyes, keeping my phone firmly pressed against my ear so I can hear
everything that comes out of her mouth.
“Do you know what you’re doing to me, Cat?” I murmur. She lets out a
shuddery exhale at the harshness in my tone and I feel my dick twitch in my
hand.
“Tell me,” she breathes out. Her voice is low and quiet, just so
extremely sexy.
“What?”
“Tell me what I’m doing to you. I want to hear you say it,” she
whispers, her voice a little stronger this time.
“I didn’t expect you to like dirty talk, Catherine, I must admit,” I muse.
She lets out a sharp laugh, but it sounds more like a whimper. I stroke my
length, unable to help myself.
“Connor,” she murmurs, “Just talk.”
Her voice is too desperate for me to question her any further. “I know
you’ve got a strong imagination, sweetheart. I hope you can picture me
naked in my bed, my cock in my hand as my body fucking aches for you. It
aches for you to do something to help make me relax. Is that what you want
me to say, sweetheart?”
“Y-Yes,” she stutters. “Keep going.”
“I will if you answer my question,” I tease, knowing it’s going to piss
her off. I can hear her choppy breathing and the soft sound of sheets
rustling. Just the thought of her possibly touching herself too causes my
hand to milk myself even faster. “Are you touching yourself?”
“No.”
“I’ll end the call if you don’t tell me the truth, Cat.”
She groans. “Fine. Yes. I am. I’m desperate, Connor.”
“You are?” I don’t even try to hide the surprise in my voice.
“I’ve been waiting for you to text me all day and you didn’t. I thought
you were trying to blow me off and I didn’t want to bug you, but I couldn’t
take it anymore, so I texted you.”
“I wasn’t trying to blow you off, Cat,” I whisper. “I wanted to text you.
I just didn’t know what to say.”
“Okay,” she replies, her breathing shallow. “Glad that’s all cleared up. I
hope you’ve found your words now, Connie, because I’m already close.”
CAT
I have no fucking idea what I’m doing.
I’ve been on edge all day and I was looking for a release. I wasn’t
expecting Connor to actually text me back. I was planning on shoving my
phone away, leaving it up to my fingers and my imagination to get myself
off.
I’ve never been the kind of girl to instigate sex, or even hint at it over
text. With him, my desire takes over my body and my brain so much that I
don’t even think about it. His voice is quiet against my ear, and it feels like
he’s in the room with me.
“You still with me, sweetheart?” he asks, his voice raspy and deep.
“Yes.”
“Good,” he whispers. “Touch your clit for me. Pretend it’s my fingers
touching you.” I do as he says, my chest rising and falling rapidly at the
ease in which the words fall out of his mouth. I don’t say anything when
two of my fingers play with my swollen clit, my head falling back into the
cushions, a whimper leaving my mouth. “That’s it.”
“Connor,” I breathe out, needing to say his name, needing to know it’s
him that is getting me so worked up. God, I wish he was here right now. I
wish it was his fingers instead of mine.
“Yes,” he replies.
“I want you to touch yourself, too. I don’t want to do this on my own,” I
whisper, slightly embarrassed. A throaty groan leaves his mouth, and it
sends shivers all across my body.
“Right ahead of you, baby,” he mutters. His breathing starts to pick up
and I can hardly hear the soft sound of flesh moving against flesh on his
side of the phone over my panting. He’s not even saying anything, but just
the thought of him getting himself off whilst listening to me is enough for
me. “Push two fingers inside of your pussy, Catherine. That’s how it’ll feel
when one of my fingers is inside of you.”
I let out a soft moan at his words, grasping my bedsheets with my left
hand, resting the phone between my shoulder and my ear. “Connor. I– I
can’t.”
“You can take it,” he murmurs, “Try for me.”
I do as he says, running my fingers through my folds until I slowly push
two fingers inside myself. It’s tight, but it feels fucking fantastic. I picture
Connor between my legs instead, his tongue on my clit instead of my
thumb.
“Does it feel good?” he asks. Does he seriously expect me to speak right
now? I can hardly form coherent thoughts, never mind words. My head is
spinning, my body is throbbing, desperate and needy. “Don’t get shy for me
now, Catherine.”
“Fuck, Connor,” I moan, trying my hardest to keep quiet, knowing that
both my roommates are home. I push my fingers in and out of my pussy
faster, moving my hips too, desperate for friction.
“I’ll take that as a yes,” he chuckles, and I can’t even shout at him for it.
There’s something so insanely sexy about the low roughness of a man’s
laugh. Just imagining his laugh against my lips sends another wave of
pleasure through my body. We’re both quiet again, nothing but heavy
breathing and pants. I said I wanted him to talk, but I don’t think I would
last longer than a minute if he did. “Faster, sweetheart. I want us to come at
the same time.”
I don’t even get to register the words before the desire rushes straight
through me, my legs closing as my orgasm soars through me, eliciting a
sharp gasp from my mouth. My whole body is on fire. My legs immediately
go languid, my hand smoothing against my clit as I hear Connor’s low
groan through the phone.
“Fuck, Catherine,” he mutters, panting. I can almost hear the smile in
his voice as he says, “That was the hottest thing I’ve ever done.”
“Me too,” I reply, still trying to catch my breath. We’re both quiet again,
just listening to each other breathe, imagining what it would be like if we
were in the same bed.
“Sweet dreams, Cat,” he whispers as if he didn’t just make me come
without even touching me. No one has ever done that to me before, and he
did it so easily it's baffling.
“Goodnight, Connor,” I whisper back, shutting off my phone.
I just had phone-sex with my best friend’s brother. What is life?
OceanofPDF.com
TWENTY-TWO
CAT/CONNOR
I MUST BE DELUSIONAL
CAT
We all have those people in our lives who just know things. You never
ask them why or how they’ve somehow acquired the wisdom they have.
They just have it and it’s like a superpower you’ll never understand. That’s
exactly how my grandma JoJo is.
The second I went to meet her today, she had one look at me and said,
“You look like you’ve had sex.”
“How do you even know these things, JoJo?” I ask, slouching in the
chair across from her. Well, technically her judgement is off. I didn’t have
sex. I had extremely passionate phone-sex with the hottest man to ever
exist, there’s a very clear difference. When she raises an eyebrow, I shake
my head. “Actually, I don’t want to know.”
She shrugs, tightening her electric blue cardigan around her. “Who’s the
lucky guy?”
“No one you’d know,” I say, resetting the game of Go on the table
between us. I know she doesn’t buy my bullshit. Both Wes and Connor have
met my grandma multiple times when she stayed with us during the
summer, and she would spoil them rotten as if they were her own
grandkids. She also knows the amount of crushes I had on Connor growing
up.
“You look just like your mother when you lie, you know?” she teases,
smiling at me.
The way I always get compared to my mom in looks always sends a
weird pang of something through my body. It’s not that I don’t remember
her. I have millions of pictures and videos of her on my phone, so it would
be impossible to do so. I just feel guilty that people can see so much of her
in me and she’s not here anymore. That’s why I want to do well in school so
I can make something of myself, so her legacy isn’t tarnished.
“Well, I’m not lying,” I say, crossing my legs. JoJo holds eye contact
with me, not dropping her defiant gaze from mine. She has a way of
looking at me that makes me want to spill my deepest darkest secrets.
Mostly because I know she’ll keep them, and she’s probably one of the only
people who would care to listen. “Okay, fine.”
“That’s my girl,” she says, cheering. Her cheer quickly turns into a
chesty cough and I lean over, immediately pushing her herbal tea back into
her hands.
“For your information, I didn’t have sex. Not the conventional way you
think, anyway,” I murmur, twisting my fingers between the hole in my
jeans.
“Glad to know you’re being creative,” she gets out around a cough. I
frown. She has zero filter, this one. “As long as you’re being safe, I’m
happy to see you’re moving on. You don’t have to be so afraid of love,
birdie.”
My eyebrows pinch together. “I’m not afraid of love, Jo.”
“No, you’re afraid of what it does to a person,” she says, seemingly
having me all figured out. “Just because you think your mom didn’t have
much going on before she met your dad, doesn’t mean the same thing is
going to happen to you and it doesn’t mean her life before him was
insignificant. You can be your own person in and outside of a relationship.”
I sigh, rolling my head back. “It feels like it's three separate timelines.
The time before you’re in love, the time when you’re in love, and then
there’s the after. I don’t want the person I am now to change just because I
get into a relationship.”
“The person you are before you meet your soulmate isn’t going to
change just because you’re experiencing life differently. A new lens is good,
Catherine. Rose tinted glasses aren’t always harmful,” JoJo explains before
taking another sip of her tea. “You don’t change. You grow.”
“Yeah,” I sigh, “I guess.”
“What have I told you about guessing, Songbird? You don’t guess
unless you are absolutely unsure. I’m telling you this because it’s true. Not
for you to just guess, okay?”
I let her words settle over me. The idea doesn’t sound so bad when she
puts it like that, but looking at the relationships around me, that kind of
change frightens me more than it excites me.
I don’t want to be a different person just because I’m in a relationship. I
don’t want to act differently or say things differently. I don’t want my past
to be a time that I class as ‘before’ instead of yesterday. Change is a scary
yet inevitable thing.
“Your dad loved your mom, Catherine,” my grandma says. My eyes
start to prickle with tears at the mention of their love. “He loved her so
much. So much so that I don’t think he knew what to do with it at the time.
And now she’s gone, it feels like a piece of him is gone too. He’s
submerging himself into his work to avoid that. Part of me thinks that he’s
just trying to shield you from his hurt.”
“I don’t want him to do that,” I whisper. “We’re supposed to be helping
each other, but all he’s done is push me away and I don’t feel like I can talk
to him.”
“You’ll find a way, Birdie, I know you will,” she encourages. I reach out
and clasp her hand between mine, needing her close to me. “I don’t know
the ins and outs of whatever you’re doing with this new boy of yours, but
keep him this time, Cat. Promise me you’ll do that. I just want you to be
happy. To hope.”
I swallow. The desperation in her eyes throws me off. I’ve never seen
her look so serious. She’s always laughing, always down to make a dirty
joke or poke fun at one of her friends. I can tell she needs this.
“I’ll try.”
For her and for my mom, I want to try.
CONNOR
“Oh, shit,” Wes exclaims, still upside down. “I have an even better idea.”
“It can’t get any worse than your last one, so hit me,” I say, giving him
the floor. Usually, if I manage to get all of his bullshit out in one sitting,
he’ll shut up for the rest of the day.
We’ve been in the gym all morning, preparing for our next away game.
Wes has been doing more shit-talking than he has working out and he’s
completely convinced that his best ideas come to him when he’s upside
down.
So, he’s leaning against the wall, topless, his hands on the ground, his
legs kicked up as he rattles on to me about how I’m supposed to get Cat to
date me. I must be delusional if I think that any of Wes’s advice will
actually work.
Okay, maybe the sexting thing did help, but still.
He doesn’t know about the way I fucked my fist to the sound of her
fingering herself over the phone and I’m going to keep it that way. I was not
planning on taking things that far the other night, but sometimes desire gets
the best of us. I don’t know where exactly we stand, and I want to let her
know that I’m in this for keeps.
“She’s into rom coms. Just watch one of those and bring it up casually
in a conversation. She’ll be all over it,” he pants, his face completely red.
That’s actually not a bad idea.
“Real question. Do you ever actually use these tactics, or are you just
that repulsive that nobody wants to date you?” I ask, trying my hardest not
to laugh.
“Nah, I’m saving these for the right girl. In the meantime, I’m happy
being the best wingman to you, Connie boy. God knows you need it,” he
replies, his voice strained. I don’t even argue with him on that.
“Dude, you’re going to pass out. Get down,” I say, scrubbing my hands
across my face.
“I’m not. You see all the red on my face? That’s just my ideas, slowly
falling down to my brain. It’s science. Don’t question it,” he says
confidently.
“I really don’t think that’s how that works, Wes. You’re–”
I barely get my sentence out before he collapses right on top of me.
OceanofPDF.com
TWENTY-THREE
CONNOR
GRAND LIBRARY
KIT-CAT
The messages start from six-thirty this morning until… How the fuck is it
ten-thirty at night? Jesus. Sweat begins to gather at the back of my neck, my
legs wobbling when I get to my feet, kicking over the popcorn bag that Wes
and I shared.
I’m such an idiot.
“Fuck, Wes,” I shout, pushing my hand through my messy hair. “I was
meant to meet Cat two hours ago. Why didn’t you tell me what time it
was?”
Wes blinks at me, spluttering. “Woah, wait. How is this my fault? You
have eyes and a brain too. There’s literally a clock right there!”
He points at the brown broken clock hanging on one of the shelves in
our lounge. “That clock has been broken since we moved in, you imbecile,”
I mutter, shoving as much shit into my bag as possible, zipping it up and
swinging it over my shoulder.
“It has?” he asks. I just stare at him, wishing my eyes could somehow
eliminate the sheer stupidity in his brain. “I thought I was just lucky that
whenever I walked in here it was always one-thirty-two.”
“You’re an idiot,” I mutter before slamming the door.
I feel like even more of a dick the whole time I walk her to my car in the
parking lot outside my dorm and drive her to the nearest Taco Bell. She
doesn’t say anything the whole time. I ordered her usual, and she thanked
me quietly and then ate in silence as we waited in the parking lot. Even
when we walked back up to her dorm, she didn’t say anything to me as she
kept her eyes on the ground, her fingers twisting inside the fabric of her
sweater.
I don’t hear a word from her until I walk her to her bedroom, shut the
door behind me and go to turn on the light.
“No, don’t turn on the light,” she mutters, moving closer to me next to
the wall. She peers up at me, those gorgeous eyes blinking up at me, and I
swear my heart stops and restarts again. I nod, listening and moving my
hand from the switch.
“Come here, Catherine,” I murmur, tugging on her sweater and pulling
her into me. “Can you look at me? Please.” She holds my gaze then, finally.
“What’s wrong? Talk to me.”
She shakes her head immediately. “Nothing,” she whispers, “I just need
to go to sleep. I’m tired, Connor.” I nod and she turns around, walking
towards her bedside table. I stay glued to my spot, watching as she picks up
her clothes from the drawer.
Before I can even turn around, she slowly pulls off her sweater, her back
still to me as she drops the fabric to the floor.
Holy fuck. There’s too much skin – long expanses of smooth, dark
brown skin and no bra to restrict her. Her braids fall down to her ass and I
don’t get a second before she shimmies off her pants, seamlessly pulling on
an oversized shirt and covering her panties with shorts.
When she moves to her bed, still staying silent, I clear my throat,
needing to give myself an out. “I guess I’ll just…” I clear my throat, again,
because she looks up at me with those innocent doe eyes the second she
slips under the covers and I just want to shred the distance between us and
take her in my arms. I can’t tell if she’s mad at me or not and I want to give
her the space to figure that out. “I’ll go. I’m sorry again, Cat.”
I don’t wait for her response as I turn around, muttering to myself about
how stupid I am to have messed up what was supposed to be an easy study
date.
I can’t even have a normal conversation with someone, never mind
trying to hold my fort in an official NFL interview. If I keep doing stupid
shit like this I’m never going to make it. I’m going to flunk out of school,
move back in with my parents, turn into one of those people who—
“Stay.”
I turn around and blink back at her in the darkness. Her covers are
tucked under her armpits, her hands twisting together on top of her
stomach. “What?”
“Don’t go yet. Stay with me until I fall asleep. I’ll sleep better if you’re
with me. Please, Connie,” she murmurs.
The helplessness in her voice has my feet moving before my brain can
fully process it. I take off my shoes, slide into the bed beside her as if it’s
the most normal thing in the world. I curl my arms around her, pulling her
close to me. The fresh smell of her immediately calms me. When my erratic
heartbeat starts to settle, I notice that she’s relaxed into me completely and I
think for a second that she’s fallen asleep until she twists in my arms,
resting one hand beneath her head as she studies me.
“Can I ask you something?” she whispers.
“Of course,” I say, swallowing, “Anything.”
“Why did you forget me today?” she asks, her voice quiet and
desperate.
“Jesus, Cat, don’t say it like that,” I mutter, stroking my thumb against
her collarbone. She drops her gaze to the comforter between us. “I was
watching a movie and I lost track of time.”
“I don’t believe you,” she mumbles.
“Well, you should.”
“Why?”
“Because I was watching it for you,” I admit, my face heating up just at
the thought of it. I’ve never done that for another person before, but for
some reason Wes’s advice seems to be working and there’s nothing that I
want more than for Cat to see me as more than her best friend's brother who
has a painful crush on her. “I wanted to impress you, so we could have
something more to talk about.”
A disbelieving laugh leaves her mouth, shaking her head as she
continues staring at me, her eyes tracing patterns across my face. “We
always have something to talk about, Connor.”
“I know, but I wanted something just for us, you know. Something
special,” I say into the space between us. I inch closer to her, pushing her
body closer to mine until her hands find their way in my hair. I kiss the top
of her nose and she scrunches it automatically, giggling as she pushes my
face away from her.
“What movie did you watch?” she asks.
“I watched at least six. You could’ve told me how addicting they are,
jeez,” I mutter, “Ten Things I Hate About You was my favourite, though.”
Her eyes light up, a child-like excitement taking over her whole face as
her hands tighten at the nape of my neck. “That’s a good one,” she says
through a giggle. The way her mind works, the way her mood changes from
this happy sunshiny person to someone who looks like she’s lived an
abundance of lives and is stuck in the one that wears her out the most, as if
she’s simply existing. “My mom named me after Catherine Earnshaw. You
know, the novel by Emily Bronte. She loved Virginia Woolf, too. She loved
reading the letters between her and Vita Sackville-West. I think that’s what
made her believe in love most.”
Her rambling is adorable. She gives me these little pockets of
information, tiny pieces of herself that I just want to treasure forever. She
doesn’t talk about her mom a lot. When she does, she gets this passive,
longing look on her face and my soul aches to take away her pain. To take
away the suffering she had from so young. I don’t even say anything for a
while, taking in her quiet and sweet voice. “I know it’s a book,” I say
through a laugh.
She pokes me in the cheek. “Then why didn’t you say anything?”
“Did you want me to?”
She shakes her head lightly. “I don’t know.” She shrugs. “Sometimes, I
just like telling you things.”
“And I like listening.”
“Yeah?” Her tone is slightly apprehensive. I bring my hand to the side
of her face, stroking my thumb over her cheek and she nestles into my
palm, closing her eyes.
“I could listen to you talk all day, Cat, and I don’t think I’d ever get
bored.”
“Do you really mean that?”
I swallow, my words shaky as I say, “I don’t think I’ve ever been more
sure of anything in my life. When you talk to me, everything goes quiet.
The noise in my head doesn’t exist anymore and it’s just… You.”
She scoffs, opening her eyes to meet my determined gaze. “You don’t
mean that.”
“I do.”
“You don’t.”
“I do.”
“You—”
“We could do this all night, sweetheart,” I murmur, pressing a kiss to
her forehead and she softens beneath me. “You’ve got to stop doing that
thing where you don’t let good things happen to you because you’re
scared.”
Her eyebrows pinch. “I’m not doing that,” she whispers. Her voice
lacks the conviction I would need to see she’s telling the truth. She’s a shit
liar.
“You’re not?” I mock. She shakes her head. “Then let me be good to
you. Let me be good for you, Cat. I know I messed up today, but I won’t do
anything like that again. I would never leave you alone like that.”
“Okay,” she says. I press my forehead to hers, taking in a deep breath.
“I really like you, Connor, like… a lot. And I don’t ever want to feel like I
did earlier. Like you forgot about me. Like I didn’t matter to you.”
“I like you too, Catherine,” I whisper, pressing my lips to her forehead,
sealing the moment. “So fucking much. You mean more to me than either of
us could ever comprehend.”
The small smile that forms on her lips at my words is all I need for the
rest of my life. Even when she’s finally fast asleep and I force myself to slip
out of her bed, I still have that warm, fuzzy feeling weighing on my chest,
just knowing that I have her through everything.
“Fuck!” I whisper-shout when I bump into my sister on my way out of
their dorm. Shit. Shit. Shit. Nora rubs at her eye, her slippers with dog ears
flopping on the floor as she squints at me.
“Connor? What are you doing here?” she asks, her voice heavy with
sleep. Jesus, I don’t even know what time it is. I swear time just doesn’t
exist when she’s around. It’s been that way since the day I met her.
“Uh, Cat passed out in the library, so I brought her back. She’s
exhausted. I must have fallen asleep,” I explain, only half-lying.
Nora’s eyes soften. “Oh… Did she say anything to you? She was off
this morning and I’m a little worried.”
My heart sinks. “No, she didn’t. Why?”
She glances back to Cat’s closed door and then to the bottle of water in
her hands. “Her mom’s anniversary is coming up soon, so I know next week
is going to be hard for her. So, if you see her around, just be nice, okay?
“I’m always nice to her,” I mutter.
She lets out a scoff, shaking her head. “Yeah,” she laughs, but I’m not
laughing. She rolls her eyes before pushing past me. “Okay. Whatever. Just
go home.”
OceanofPDF.com
TWENTY-FOUR
CAT
“IS THAT AN EIGHT PACK?”
YOU’D THINK that college football players walk around with a halo
around their head and have superhuman strength with the amount of special
treatment they get.
I knew that they got flights covered by the school for their away games,
but no one told me about the luxury suites, the fully catered meals, on-site
spa and free transport to anywhere they need to go in Arizona.
Since we landed, the boys have been training like crazy and I’ve been
working on my report and picking out new designs for the Titan’s Daily
cover.
Whilst the boys trained with Coach Mackenzie, I spent the day with
Olivia, the assistant coach, walking around a small town in Phoenix. It’s
weird hanging out with someone who is considered faculty, but is only
seven years older than me. She lets me in on all the inside gossip on the
boys. She tells me about how she tore her ACL after she graduated from
Drayton, which basically ruined all of her dreams of playing the sport she’s
been coaching for the last three years.
It was fun hanging out with her. It felt like having an older sister who
gossiped with you about boys and let you sneak your parents movies into
your room for sleepovers. I’ve never had that kind of figure in my life
before. As much as Elle and Nora are like my sisters, their advice usually
causes me to freak out more than I need to. Since we’re all the same age,
our experience is very limited with things in the wider world.
Since Olivia and I are sharing a hotel room, I get the joy of watching
her get ready. As thrilling as the game was earlier, I am preferring this so
much more. The boys won, – which was no surprise – so Coach and Olivia
are going out to celebrate and the boys are allowed to stay up past their
curfew in their suite down the hall.
The second the game was over, Connor tried to pull me into him whilst
he was sweaty and gross, but now knowing that he’s showered, I’m
desperate to see him. I know the other night didn’t go to plan for either of
us. He has a habit of tucking me into bed and weirdly enough, I want that to
happen every night. As much as forgetting about our study date sucked, the
forehead kiss and the sweet words made up for it.
“So, what are your plans tonight?” Olivia asks, talking to me through
the mirror whilst she does her makeup as I sit behind her on one of the beds.
“Nothing at all,” I say, sighing. “I’ll see if I can get a few hundred
words down. If not, I’ll probably crash before you get back.”
She shakes her head, pouting. “You should see what the boys are up to.
You never know. You could actually have fun.”
I audibly laugh at that. “I saw the videos Wes posted on Snapchat an
hour ago. I am not stepping foot into that suite. It’s already a mess and
we’ve hardly been here a day.”
Olivia throws her head back. I love that she has a good bond with them.
So good that they only call her by her first name. Mostly because her last
name is Hardon and she coaches a team full of teenage boys who no doubt
would make her life a living hell.
“That’s fair,” she says through a laugh, applying a pink lipgloss which
matches perfectly with the pink top she’s wearing. “I shouldn’t be back too
late, but it just depends on how drunk Mackenzie gets.”
“Do you guys do this often at away games?” I ask, leaning back on my
forearms as she packs away her makeup into her bag on the vanity.
“Not always,” she explains. Her eyes lock with mine in the mirror
again. “It’s just nice to get out sometimes and feel pretty. We know the boys
can take care of themselves and we’re only here for one night. Might as
well make it memorable. This whole experience is for you to make
memories as well, Cat.”
I end up taking Olivia’s advice and by the time she’s out the doors of the
hotel, I pull out my phone and call Connor. He said that he and the guys
don’t usually go out after away games after a fight broke out in Salt Lake
once, so I know he can’t be too busy.
“Hey,” I say, holding the phone to my ear as I look through the same
three outfits that I packed. All I can hear from his end is loud chattering
which is the usual noise I’m greeted to whenever I have to meet the team on
campus, so I’m not surprised.
“Can everyone be quiet! Jesus,” Connor exclaims over the phone. After
a few seconds, it starts to quieten down. “Hi, baby.”
Oh, fuck.
How does that one word make my stomach dip? I’ve never cared much
for words of endearment, but anything coming out of Connor’s mouth
sounds so insanely hot that my knees almost go weak.
“Are you okay?” I ask when the team still talks over the phone.
“Yeah, the guys are just being annoying and loud as per usual,” he
explains and I can imagine him shaking his head. He has this whole
protective dad vibe about him that I happen to find sexy.
“Come to my room,” I say before I change my mind. I’ve got to make
memories somehow. I want to be alone with Connor, awake, sober and in
my right mind for once. “It’s a lot quieter here and it sounds like you could
do with a break.”
“What?” he chokes out and it sounds muffled as if he’s covering the
mic. “And do what, Cat?” he whispers.
“You were so desperate to hang out with me the other day, Connie.
What’s wrong with right now?” I tease, playing with the hem of my shirt.
Of course he has to make this difficult. “I’m bored and Olivia has gone out.
I don’t know what else I need to say to convince you.”
I hear him groan slightly as he considers it. He worries too much —
much like me — but I know when to break the rules sometimes. I know
when to let loose and have a little fun. We’re basically alone in a hotel, the
options are limitless and if the smutty romance books have taught me
anything, I shouldn’t run out of any ideas.
“I’ll be there in twenty,” he says before ending the call.
Of course Connor does not spend his time reading romance books for
fun. Instead, he watches old romantic comedies just because he knows I like
them, which means he turns up to my room exactly twenty minutes later in
the apron I got him for his birthday and a grocery bag in hand.
“This is not what I had in mind when I invited you over, Connie,” I say,
looking him up and down after I’ve closed the door. He just grins at me, his
cheeks pink and his brown hair a mess. His apron has ‘Connie’ scrawled
across it in red handwriting. “Did you just pack that just in case?”
He steps closer to me, dropping a kiss to my lips. “You never know
what can happen in a day, Cat.”
For the next twenty minutes, we organise the ingredients for our
cheesecake, which we’re relying on the small fridge we have in the room
for them to turn out properly. Even after he’s explained to me his very
complicated recipe, I’m still unsure how he’s planning to whisk this without
a stand mixer.
He managed to convince me that he’s strong enough as I drooled over
his huge arms whisking a tiny bowl of cream.
There’s something insanely hot about a man who bakes. Yes, Connor
might be god-awful at it, but it’s his determination and the glow on his
cheeks as he works around the tiny kitchen that makes him so fucking sexy.
He bakes, I watch. It’s a good combination.
Once our semi-deformed cheesecake is in the fridge, I push myself up
onto the counter wiping down the equipment we used that we are somehow
going to have to hide from Olivia before she gets back.
“Can I ask you something?” Connor asks, stepping between my open
legs on the counter, his hands running up my thighs under my shorts. I nod
in response. “Is my baking actually good?”
I’m instantly reminded of the salty taste of the cupcakes he gave me and
the lick of the spoon he fed me five minutes ago that wasn’t any better. I
paint my face in the most sympathetic smile I can muster up. “It’s not the
best, but you can improve.”
He frowns. “Why did you lie to me last time?”
“Because I didn’t want to hurt your feelings,” I admit.
A smirk climbs across his face as he sets his palms on each side of me,
caging me in. “Do you care about me, Catherine?” His tone is light, but I
avert my eyes away from him, trying my absolute hardest not to smile.
When my eyes connect with his again, his face is so serious I almost miss
what he says. “Do you want me to take my top off? I can take my pants off
too, if you want.”
“What?” I gawk, bursting out laughing. “Why in the world would I
want that?”
He shrugs. “Because it’s hot when a guy is wearing an apron and
nothing else.”
“Yeah? According to who? The last porno you watched?” I manage to
get out around a laugh.
Connor gasps, holding up a hand to his chest. “I’ve never heard such
filthy words come out of your mouth. If I didn’t know any better, I’d be
starting to think you’re not a good girl after all.”
“I think that phone call a few days ago says very, very differently,” I
say, my voice shaking a little as I tug on his apron, pulling him as close to
me as I can get him. If he doesn’t stop looking at me like that, I’m going to
do something very stupid. I haven’t felt like myself for a long time, and
Connor has brought that fire in me that I used to have.
“So confident now, aren’t we?” he muses, dropping his head to the side
of my face. His hot breath tickles my ear, igniting an explosion inside of
me.
“Only for you,” I whisper back.
When I go to kiss him, I don’t kiss him like I have the other times, I go
in with a promise. I’m going to make you feel good, is what I’m telling him
when I run my hands across his stomach and around to where the apron ties
at his back. The second his apron is off, his shirt follows and I’m greeted to
the absolute sight of Connor’s broad, sculpted chest that I want to run my
hands all over. I want to cover him in oil and…
Oh, fuck.
Is that an eight pack?
“You finished ogling me yet, sweetheart?” he asks, tilting my head up
with two fingers under my chin.
“Actually,” I tease, “Not yet.”
I wiggle my chin out of his grasp only to press my lips against the
firmness of his chest. He hisses, his hands instantly finding themselves in
my hair. I keep kissing across his chest, moving down until I get to the hard
ridges of his abs. When I make my way back up, my tongue flat against his
skin, drawing a line down the middle of his abs, his eyes roll back.
“Jesus,” he mutters, “You look fucking stunning.”
I kiss along his throat when he leans down to give me access. “And you
taste so good. Why the hell do you taste so good?”
He pulls back. “Are you okay? I don’t think I’ve heard you compliment
me that much in the space of ten minutes.”
“Shut up,” I mutter, slipping off the counter, kissing him hard as I walk
us back to where the couch is in the open living room area of my suite.
When I manage to get him down, I climb into his lap, feeling his
erection against my core. I pull back from the kiss, biting on his bottom lip
as his hands roam around my lower back. My skin erupts with flames as his
determined hands find a home on my body, branding me.
He smiles as he looks up at me, his cheeks almost as pink as his lips.
His nails dig into my hips, pressing me closer into him as he rests against
the couch. “My body fucking aches for you, Catherine. Every part of me.”
I roll myself over his erection on purpose, loving the deep groan I get
out of him in response. “Every part of you, huh?” I tease, kissing along his
jaw as I slip my hand between our bodies, reaching to where he’s hard and
waiting for me. Fuck, he’s huge over his jeans. “What about this part?”
He lets out a low hiss. “Fuck, baby,” he mutters, his head dropping back
onto the headrest. It’s the hottest thing I’ve ever seen – Connor Bailey
unravelled and out of control for one of the first times in his life because of
me. He’s a fucking sight. I stroke him again over his jeans, needing another
reaction to know what the hell I’m doing. “You can’t– You can’t do that.”
“Do you want me to stop?”
“Yes,” he murmurs. I immediately stop what I’m doing, taking my hand
away from jeans, feeling the embarrassment all over my body, but he
latches onto my wrist, urging me to lock eyes with him. “No. Fuck… I
haven’t done this in a while and I know that if you touch me, I’m going to
lose my fucking mind, Cat.”
Is it bad that the way he looks like this is paining him is turning me on?
I’ve hardly done anything and he already looks like he could finish just like
this. Hell, I probably could if I found the right friction.
“Maybe I want that to happen. Maybe I want to see you unravel,” I
murmur, kissing across his jaw again. He nods enthusiastically. I let out a
laugh. “You’ve got to tell me you want this, Connor. I’m not going to do
anything unless you tell me.”
“Yes, Catherine. Please,” he whines, practically begging. Pleasure
rumbles in my belly as I slowly sink to my knees in front of him, undoing
his belt as I go down. He helps me work off his jeans and when his erection
finally springs free, I gulp. He’s fucking massive. My mouth instantly dries
when I spot the pre-cum dripping off the tip of his cock and I give it a timid
stroke. “You can take it, sweetheart, don’t worry.”
I blink up at him and all the nervousness that he had two minutes ago
has transferred into me. I’ve given blow-jobs before. This shouldn’t be a
hard feat. But it’s Connor and I want to make him feel good. I need to make
him feel good. He deserves this.
After a few pumps of his shaft, he patiently waits for me to fit him
down my throat and allows me to get situated. I might have sucked dick
before, but this is something different. Still, Connor’s hand on the back of
my neck, helping me ease him down my throat helps me take him to the hilt
as my lips stretch over him. My eyes instantly water, but the look on his
face and the taste of him makes this feel a million times better.
I let myself get comfortable with the angle first before I started to pump
his thick arousal, taking him as deep as I possibly can. When we both settle,
his head lolls back and he groans out ‘fuck’ as his hand tightens around my
neck. That combined with the way he feels in my mouth is like heaven. My
thighs are already aching, slick and wet with need.
I take him out of my mouth for a second, only to circle my tongue
around his tip, urging him to look down at me. The picture we’re painting is
intensely arousing, just knowing that he’s looking down at me with his face
twisted in pleasure as I get him off.
“Catherine,” he mutters, a tortured groan leaving his mouth as I slip him
down my throat again making waves flush all across my body. “Fuck. Look
at you. You’re doing such a good job, baby.”
His praise only makes me want this more. As his hands tangle in my
hair, guiding me to take him deeper and faster, I don’t know what to do with
my hands. My clit throbs at the sloppy sounds my mouth is making mixed
with his moans. Even with the drool dripping from the side of my mouth,
instead of going to wipe it away, my hand slips inside my shorts, needing to
give myself some sort of release.
“That’s it, sweetheart. Take every inch of me and make sure you come
too,” he murmurs, a sexy grin across his face as I continue taking him down
my throat as my fingers work over my clit. The second I get too in my head
about it, thinking about the what-ifs to oblivion, I realise that all my
motions have slowed down. When I find a rhythm grinding my wetness
against his leg instead, I moan around his length. “Yeah, just like that.”
I’m going to make a mess of his pants, but he doesn’t seem to care. The
satisfied smile on his face is driving me closer and closer to the edge that I
move faster against him, trying to keep up with both of my movements.
When his hips buck up, his hand around my neck flexing, I know he’s
close.
“Fuck, Catherine,” he mutters, “Will you let me come in your mouth,
baby? Or do you not like that?”
The way he asks if I’m okay with it makes my head spin. “Yes,” I
muffle, “Please.”
I’m practically choking on him, trying my hardest to keep going and
moving my hips at the same time, needing us to finish together.
And we do.
Stars burst behind my eyes the same time he comes down my throat,
groaning whilst my thighs can no longer keep up and my orgasm soars right
through me. His cum spills down my throat and I swallow all of it, loving
the salty taste of him. When he takes his cock out of my mouth he tilts my
chin up to him and I rise up on my knees as he leans in to me.
He wipes the side of my mouth, slipping the pad of his thumb into my
mouth and I taste the last drop of him. “That was fucking insane,
sweetheart,” he murmurs, pressing his mouth to mine.
“Did you lose your mind like you said you would?” I ask, still trying to
catch my breath.
“I don’t think I can even think straight,” he whispers, “You’ve ruined
me, Cat.”
You’ve ruined me too, I think to myself.
This is way bigger than either of us would have imagined it would be.
It’s not just a hallway crush that I’ve had on him for years. It’s a real,
tangible, physical and emotional thing that I never want to escape from. I
just want to be completely his.
But when I look into his eyes, still on my knees, I can’t help but think
about the repercussions of this. The line we’ve crossed. I hate how fucking
good it feels.
I don’t know how we end up spending the next twenty minutes fighting
over the remote for the flatscreen, but we do and I eventually give up.
Connor is insisting on keep his shirt off, no matter how risky it is for
him to be here in the first place, so that has been distracting me.
After mindlessly watching Lilo & Stitch, I finally have my turn to put a
good movie on. I thought as I kissed his chest and ran my hands all over
him when we sat in front of the screen, that he’d give up on trying to
convince me to watch the movie. He ended up tackling me to the ground
and tickling me like his life depended on it. Honestly, I don’t mind that
much. It reminds me a lot of my childhood, but I enjoy annoying Connor
more than any movie.
“Jesus, you’re lucky I like you,” I mutter, feeling as smug as ever as the
opening credits to ‘Set It Up,’ play on the screen. It’s finally my turn and
despite the low grunt of disapproval he gave me, he’s still holding me close
to him, his arm slung around my shoulder.
“What?!”
“Yeah, you’ve clearly got a terrible taste in movies and someone has to
educate you on what true cinema is,” I say, gesturing to the screen.
“And that someone is you, right?”
“Yup.”
“Well… What if I don’t like your movie taste,” he says, his fingers
running down my arm.
“That’s quite literally impossible,” I say, turning to look up at him.
“Sorry to break it to you, Connie, but I’m as good as you’re going to get.
Everyone likes what I like and I’m confident enough to admit that.”
“Is that right?”
“Yes, it’s an absolute fact.”
His eyes narrow, jerking his head back from me to scrutinise me.
“Right…”
“Don’t look at me like that!” I swat him on his arm.
“Like what?” he teases, pressing his lips together to hide his smile.
“Like you think I’m crazy,” I say, scooting out of his grip. You’d think
after the stellar blow-job I just gave him that he’d be more appreciative of
my fantastic taste in movies. I try to move further away on the couch, but
my back hits the cushions and he’s over me in seconds, his hands on both
sides of my head.
“Lucky for you, you’re my favourite kind of crazy,” he murmurs into
the space between us, his hips pressing into mine.
“I didn’t know there were levels to crazy,” I breathe out, trying not to be
affected by his weight. He shakes his head.
“Not levels. Categories,” he explains, “Crazy smart.” He presses a kiss
to my forehead. “Crazy talented.” He presses a kiss to my temple before
kissing my throat. “Crazy beautiful.”
My face feels like it’s on fire at the sentiment and all I do is whisper,
“Shut up.”
“Make me.”
I spend the next twenty minutes showing him how to shut up and by the
time he’s out of the room with a raging hard-on, I can’t get rid of the smile
that’s plastered on my face. I feel like a champagne bottle — all fizzy and
giggly.
That feeling lasts for a while until my brain goes into overdrive.
Having phone-sex with Connor is one thing. Flirting with him and
kissing him is another thing. But giving him one of the best blowjobs I’ve
ever given is a completely different thing. As much as I enjoyed it, I have
no fucking clue how I’m supposed to keep my attraction to him at bay when
we go back to Drayton. Nora is not an idiot. She’ll figure it out eventually.
When Olivia comes stumbling into the room after one in the morning
and I’m already snuggled up in bed, watching Modern Family reruns, she
already looks so out of it I don’t know how she managed to see the
cheesecake in the fridge.
Fuck.
The cheesecake.
Connor and I’s cheesecake.
“Catherine?” she whispers. Or, well, I think she thinks she’s whispering,
but she’s so drunk she probably can’t even tell. “Did you buy this?”
“Yeah, I went to the store,” I reply, faking a yawn.
She gags. “You should really get a refund. This doesn’t seem right to
me.”
Two seconds later, I’m up out of the bed, holding back her hair as she
throws up in the mini kitchen sink.
I always said I wanted a sister, right?
OceanofPDF.com
TWENTY-FIVE
CONNOR
BAD HAIR DAY
I’VE BEEN FLOATING through all my classes today like a ghost, not
really sure what I’m doing with myself. Thanksgiving weekend is coming
up and it’s the only thing I have to look forward to, and my surprise for
Cat.
Sometimes I wish I could play football and do nothing else, but I know
that’s unrealistic.
Surprisingly, I don’t hate my literature course. I actually enjoy it. Words
and the meanings you can take from them have always spoken to me,
sometimes more than watching movies has. Learning about older written
texts and the context around them is cool, but Wes’s constant questions puts
me off going to class. Especially when the season is in full swing and all I
want to do is go to the gym and prepare myself for the upcoming games.
When I see a text from Cat an hour into my lecture, I welcome the
distraction.
KIT-CAT
KIT-CAT
I do.
I just don’t think you’ll want to stay long. I’m taking out my
braids and it’s not very entertaining.
KIT-CAT
I know that’s not the only reason she doesn’t want me to come over.
Today is the anniversary of her mom’s death, making it five years without
her. I could only imagine what it would be like losing someone so important
to you so young. Her mom was everything to her. As much as her dad was
great, Pauline is the one I have to thank for turning my Catherine into the
person that she is today.
It’s risky business deciding to go to her dorm in the middle of the
afternoon when my sister or Elle could come home at any second, but I
want to be there for her. I don’t know what happened to make her believe
that she doesn’t need to be looked after sometimes and I want to prove her
wrong, be that person for her. Everyone needs somebody sometimes and
that’s fine. I can push people away when I need them the most, but I’ve
tried to get it into my thick skull that doing that makes my problems a shit
ton worse than if I just let the people who care for me be there when I need
them.
OceanofPDF.com
TWENTY-SIX
CAT
HONEYMOON STAGE
YOU KNOW how every rom-com has that time in the story where the
main characters have finally broken that barrier that was keeping them apart
and they’re seemingly happy and everything is going right for them until it
suddenly isn't. We all know it. We’ve seen it done a million times and
you’re left screaming at the screen because you know that phase is just that,
a phase.
A few months ago, that would piss me off. I’d probably stop watching
the film or reading the book all together, trying to save myself from the
heartbreak. But experiencing that in real life, you can’t do that. You have to
follow it through and hope. You have to see where it goes.
And I can see why characters do that now. Why they ignore every single
red flag or overthink what could go wrong. Because this stage is glorious.
Mostly because Connor is just a green flag waving at me and I don’t feel
like it’s even a stage. It already feels like forever.
After the way Connor looked after me the other day, I realised that he
would do anything for me. I realised that he’s going to continue to do things
for me just because he wants to. Not because I ask him to, or he feels forced
to, but just because.
The only slight, minor, teeny weeny problem is the fact that I’m his
sister’s best friend and roommate and I’m also an idiot for inviting him over
and Nora is still at home. She’s supposed to be going to rehearsals, but she’s
insisting she wants to hang out instead. Out of every day in the week, she
wants to choose right now.
Fuck my life.
“Nor,” I press, running my hands down my face as she packs and
unpacks her bag on the kitchen counter. “Just go. I’ll be fine.”
“Catherine, we’ve not hung out in days,” she whines. “I feel like a part
of me is fading away when you’re not around. It’s like half of my body
doesn’t function when we’ve not had an intense gossip session filled with
snacks and an episode of New Girl playing in the background. I miss you,
Cat.”
A theatre major, this one. An absolute drama queen.
I’ve been trying to subtly hint at her to leave, but she isn’t taking the
bait. She’s already late to rehearsal as it is, but this girl loves to talk.
The image that she paints of our hang out sessions does tug at my heart
a little. I do miss both of my girls. Especially since Elle went back to her
parents house early to help for Thanksgiving this Thursday.
“I miss hanging out with you too, Nora, but I don’t want to pull you
away from your rehearsals. ‘Waitress’ is one of your favourites.”
She sighs wistfully at the mention of her favourite musical and the one
she is supposed to be rehearsing for right now. “You’re my best friend, Cat.
I can miss out on one rehearsal for you.”
I feel the guilt swell in my stomach. That’s the thing about the Bailey’s.
They’ll drop everything for their friends and I’m the one lying to her face,
withdrawing the fact that I have been hooking up with her brother for the
last few weeks.
“Fine,” I say, sighing and her eyes light up.
“Great! I’ll go to Raja’s and get us some snacks,” she suggests, slipping
on her coat, referring to the convenience store just across from campus. It’s
our go-to for snacks or any emergency essentials and it’s too close not to go
to it just for the fun of it. She opens the door, squealing, “I’ll be back in a
few.”
I sigh, ready to pull out my phone to text Connor to not bother coming
over, but the door opens again. “Did you forget something already, Nor?”
“Yeah, actually.”
I look up, blinking rapidly at the man in front of me. “Connor?”
He shuts the door, shredding the space between us, grabbing my face
between his hands and before I can even process it he crushes his lips to
mine, making me gasp. His tongue slips into my mouth easily and I almost
fall right off the high stool, but it doesn’t matter anyway because the second
my hands curl into his shirt, he drags me from the stool, placing me onto the
counter, kissing me hard.
I get a second to breathe when he starts to kiss across my neck, his
hands finding their way around my back. The skin to skin contact sends a
rush of pleasure down to my sex.
“Hi,” he murmurs into my neck, biting me softly. “I missed you.”
“Hi,” I giggle when his stubble tickles my skin, his hands moving
higher to the strap of my bra. “It’s been two days since I saw you, Connie.”
“And I’ve been missing you for two whole days,” he whispers. His
fingers dance across the seam of my jeans, teasing and retreating as he dips
his hands in and then back out again. “Can I take these off?”
I don’t know when I started panting, but I’m suddenly finding it hard to
breathe again. “Nora’s going to be back in five minutes.”
“Five minutes?” he asks, pulling my bottom lip into his mouth before
releasing it with a pop. My legs go weak at the hungry gaze in his eyes as
they roam over my body before he looks up into my eyes again. “Funnily
enough, that’s the perfect amount of time I’m going to need to have my way
with you.”
I tilt my head to the side. “What do you mean?”
“I mean returning the favour for what you did for me the other day,” he
murmurs, catching my chin between his hands as he lowers his mouth to the
shell of my ear. “As hot as it was watching you getting off with my dick
stuffed down your throat, it’s only fair that I get on my knees for you too,
Catherine.”
“You mean– You want to–” I stumble over my words like a fool when
my head rolls back as he kisses across the base of my throat.
“I love it when you’re lost for words,” he mutters between kisses on my
skin, “I fucking love it. But as you said, we have five minutes, so maybe we
can just skip to the part where I eat you out. How does that sound?”
Again, no words come.
“Get on the couch,” he demands.
I don’t waste any time doing exactly as he told me, scrambling over to
the couch where the blinds are closed in the living room. I reach for the
button of my jeans, lifting my hips to make it easier to take them off.
Connor makes his way over to me, shaking his head at me.
“Did I tell you to do that?” he asks, tutting. The way he’s turning me
inside out is completely embarrassing.
“You’re wasting time,” I groan, sounding as desperate as I feel. We
probably only have four minutes now. Maybe an extra minute or two if she
stops to talk with Mr. Raja for a while like she does sometimes.
“Don’t underestimate me, sweetheart. I could make you come in two
minutes if I wanted to,” he murmurs. A needy moan leaves my mouth just at
his words and he’s not even touched me yet as I look up at him. He
chuckles. “Do you want this?”
“Yes.”
A satisfied hum comes from the back of his throat as he lowers to his
knees in front of me, taking over and pulling my jeans off me until I’m left
in nothing but my blue panties. The desire in me only grows when he stares
directly at the wet spot and just the heat of his gaze makes me wetter.
He runs his thumb on the inside of my thigh, too close to my heat. The
slickness from my pussy coats his finger when he reaches high enough and
my thighs tremble. “So fucking pretty and so wet for me, aren’t you?”
My head falls back onto the headrest, unable to look at him. “You’ve
got three minutes now, Bailey. Stop with the dirty talk.”
“I’ll stop when I want to stop,” he groans, “Are you going to be good
for me and let me do this for you? I know how much you like to be in
control, but you don’t have to do that with me.”
He rips down my panties, causing me to gasp as the rush of cold air
pushes against my clit when I’m bare in front of him. Just knowing that I’m
this wet in front of him, my whole body starts to ache, needing attention.
“Fuck,” he mutters. I’m about to tell him to get on with it, but his thumb
presses against my entrance where I’m eagerly waiting for him, soaking
wet, causing all rational thoughts to stop. He collects my arousal, pressing
his thumb against my clit and I almost come on the spot.
He circles his thumb around me and it feels like my body is betraying
me. Just from the simple touch, goosebumps arise across my chest and on
my legs. My thighs quake, my hips instantly bucking upwards to gain more
from him, but he doesn’t do or even say anything.
“Connor, please,” I beg, sounding as pathetic as I thought I would.
“Don’t– Don’t tease me.”
He listens immediately, penetrating me with one finger. A loud moan
escapes my throat – so loud and sharp that I don’t even recognise it came
from me. He was right. Two of my fingers feel like what one of his fingers
feel like inside me. He pushes in deeper and I have to turn my head onto the
headrest, gripping aimlessly onto the cushions.
“Oh, God,” I cry out when he pumps into me faster.
“Is this what you wanted, hm? Did you want my fingers deep in your
tight pussy for the first time while you try to rush me with this work of art?”
he asks, his voice low and annoyingly sexy. I barely mumble an mhm when
his thumb starts to pay intense attention to my clit and I almost burst into
flames. “I want to hear you say it, Catherine. As pretty as your pussy looks,
as good as it’s going to taste, I need you to say this what you want. What
you need.”
His words cause my thoughts to fall right out of my head. No one has
ever talked to me like this before. The way he switches from his adorable
nervous self to this fucking sex God terrifies me as much as it turns me on.
“Connor,” I whine when the pleasure builds in my lower stomach. “I
need…”
I don’t even know what I’m trying to say. Connor’s second finger starts
to tease at my entrance and my mouth clamps shut, trying not to let out
another moan. “I’ll give you whatever you want, pretty girl. I know you’re
good with words, so don’t get shy with me now.”
“God,” I groan, my whole body feeling weaker by the second as I try to
move my hips along with his fingers, but my brain and my body get
confused with wanting to let him do his job or needing to help get myself to
the edge quicker. I settle for the former. I relax into the couch as he
continues to pump his fingers in and out of me so fast that I forget that he
was talking.
“Are you speechless right now? I never thought I would see the day,” he
muses, thinking this is the perfect time for jokes as he tries to push his
second finger inside me. One of his fingers is already huge as it is, I don’t
think I can take another.
I regain my voice. Sort of. “I can-t…” I whimper when he manages to
get the tip of two of his fingers into my tight heat. “Connor, I can’t.”
I look down at him finally and he has the smuggest, sexiest look on his
face that another shuddery moan leaves my mouth without permission. He
still continues to tease his fingers and I open my legs wider, trying to help.
“You can take it, baby. Just breathe for me,” he murmurs, and I do
exactly that. I relax so much so that all my senses come alive again and I
grow wetter until he manages to fill me with two fingers to the hilt. Fuck.
“That’s it,” he encourages and my head spins.
“Stop. Talking,” I bite out.
“Happily,” he murmurs and he finally presses his mouth to my clit,
sucking it into his mouth.
I swear I’m dying.
My legs and arms go weak as he continues to move his tongue
seamlessly in time with his fingers pushing mercifully in and out of my
pussy. My whole body reacts to him, becoming suddenly sensitive. When
his teeth graze against my clit, my stomach clenches, my thighs shake and I
come all over his tongue, waves of pleasure pulsating throughout my entire
body.
When I think I’ve settled, his fingers still deep inside me, he manages to
pull out another orgasm from me and my reaction is so immediate I don’t
even get to think about how loud I’m being. A huge part of me doesn’t care.
I just want to feel good, and that’s exactly what Connor is doing.
He pulls his fingers out of me, sucking them into his mouth and my
mouth parts, panting as he tastes me again, keeping his eyes locked with
mine. I pull his shirt into me, capturing his lips to taste the saltiness of both
of us together and he groans into my mouth.
“That’s my girl,” he murmurs against my lips. “Do you like how good
you taste?”
“Yes,” I whisper when his tongue slips into my mouth. When I come
back down to earth, my heartbeat doesn’t let up and I realise how long has
passed. “You need to—“
“Go?”
“Yeah.”
He blinks at me. “I probably should, shouldn’t I?”
“Yeah,” I say again, because apparently I can’t form any more words
than that.
“What if I don’t want to?” His voice is so desperate and whiny, my
thighs start to clench again. He brushes his nose against my neck. “What if I
wanted to stay with my head between your legs forever?”
“Then I’d tell you that you’re obsessed with me and you need to get
help,” I say, trying to laugh, but I end up moaning when he nips at the skin
on my neck.
“Already tried,” he says, “Want to know what the doctor prescribed?”
“Let me guess,” I muse, “Something to do with how the only cure is to
get one last taste?”
“Exactly. Now can you put me out of my misery and let me? Doctors
orders.”
“As good as that was, I doubt you could make me come in less than a
minute,” I say, leaning down to pull on my panties and my jeans. He
watches me carefully, not taking his eyes off me for a second. “Time to go,
big guy.”
“Fine.” He rises off his knees, towering over me. He leans down,
tucking a strand of hair behind my ear. “You want me to wait? I’ll wait. But
it’s you that’s going to suffer because your fingers will never be as good as
mine and you’ll constantly be comparing the two.”
He leaves me stunned as he casually walks out the room, throwing a
wink over his shoulder.
Even after Connor’s gone and I’m laying in my bed with Nora watching
New Girl, I can feel him everywhere. I even consider coming clean for a
second when we have a deep and long winded discussion about the last
book we read together. When she looks at me and tells me excited she is for
me to spend Thanksgiving with her family, I realise how royally fucked I
am.
OceanofPDF.com
TWENTY-SEVEN
CONNOR
THE BAILEY LODGE
Later, when the sun has set into a deep orange along the horizon, I wander
back down stairs to where the fresh smell of my mom’s famous gravy is
brewing on the stove. I’ve always loved this part of Thanksgiving. The
moment of momentary peace where everyone is doing their own thing
before dinner.
Nora is off on the phone to Ryan in the living room. My dad is sorting
out the wood for the fireplace, walking back and forth from the garage and
into the living room.
When I walk back into the kitchen, my mom and Cat are laughing over
something, passing each other as Cat cuts up vegetables on the counter.
Everything about it just being my mom and Cat in here feels so right. So
special. Like it was just meant to be. She fits in so perfectly here with my
family. With me.
She’s wearing the most gorgeous green dress I’ve ever seen in my life.
It cuts off at her thighs, flowing out, the corset hugging her curves nicely,
shaping her ass. She flicks her long curls over her shoulder as I continue to
watch her from the doorway, completely mesmerised.
“You know what?” my mom starts, glancing over at me. “I prefer these
quieter days with just us rather than when everyone else is here. Is that
bad?”
“No, I think it’s perfect,” I answer before Cat can. She turns around,
surprised to see me, but when she does her whole face lights up as if she
hasn’t seen me all day. “Can I steal you for a minute?”
“Hopefully not for too long.” My mom narrows her eyes at me and then
turns to her. “I need my sous chef.”
Cat wipes her hands on a tea towel, answering my question for me. She
walks over to me, a giddy smile plastered across her face. When my hand
extends to her, she takes it willingly.
OceanofPDF.com
TWENTY-EIGHT
CAT
GOOD DIFFERENT
MAYBE IT’S the fact that this is the second year in a row where I haven't
spent Thanksgiving with my dad. Or maybe it’s because I’m surrounded by
people who care about me and are there for me no matter what, but this
night feels extra special.
As soon as I took Connor’s hand, I knew I should have asked where he
was taking me, but part of me is wanting to see where just hoping for things
to happen will get me. Which means blindly following him into the
backyard of the Bailey’s lodge until we reach a secluded bench tucked away
between bunches and tall trees.
It’s probably the only place we’d be able to get privacy this weekend.
Stealing secret kisses on the hike was risky, but he has this weird ability to
make me want to take those risks. To stop trying to be a picture-perfect girl
and just do whatever I want. And doing whatever I want includes being
curled up in Connor’s lap on a dusty bench as we both look up at the clear
night sky, constellations shining down on us.
I feel so completely safe and comfortable with him that I’m not
concerned when we’ve been sitting down on the bench for almost ten
minutes, neither of us saying anything, just enjoying the other’s presence.
It’s weird when I think about it.
On paper, he’s exactly the type of guy I would forbid myself from
dating or even having a crush on. He’s popular, he’s handsome, he’s
annoying, he’s cocky when he wants to be and he’s sarcastic. But he’s also
sweet, caring and gentle and he makes me feel like he’s always going to
have my back as long as I have his. When I started on my project, this was
the very last thing I was anticipating would happen.
“I come here every year, but this year it feels different,” I whisper to
him.
“Good, different?” he asks me, his voice thick with emotion.
“Yeah, a good different,” I say back.
I look up at him and he’s looking down at me like I'm the brightest star
in the galaxy. The small tug of a smile on his lips makes me realise just how
hard I’ve fallen for him.
As much as being with Connor feels like one of the best things to ever
happen to me in a long time, he loves to torture me.
After helping Emma and Mark set up the dinner table with Nora,
singing along to old R&B songs, we're all sitting in the dining room and
Connor’s large hand is resting on my thigh under my dress.
For the last ten minutes, the skin to skin contact has made me feel like
my head has been spinning. No one has noticed or even cared to ask why
his chair is so close to mine, but Nora’s chatter about Waitress fills up most
awkward pauses.
The way she tells a story is so engaging that you have to keep your eyes
on her at all times so you don’t miss anything. I’ve always wondered if
people just have that natural ability of being able to tell a story in a way that
leaves you wanting more.
Once she’s told everyone at length about her new year's resolution –
which is going to be trying to stop watching Hamilton three times a week
and try to settle for two – Emma’s red-cheeked smile wanders over to
Connor.
It’s probably the raging mommy issues I have, but there is something so
special about Emma Bailey. She literally looks like an angel and she acts
like one too. She’s always got something funny or sweet to say. She always
has an abundance of good advice even though she’s not that old.
Most importantly, she’s always there for Connor and Nora and the rest
of us too. As much as all our parents got along, I always thought that the
other parents resented Emma and Mark because they were so young raising
the twins and they never seemed to complain. They got lucky in the kid
department and Connor and Nora got lucky in the parent department. They
act and they seem like a true, real family, which is why being here hurts as
much as I love being included.
“What’s your resolution going to be, Connie?” Emma asks, resting both
of her elbows on the table, dropping her head into her hands. Connor clears
his throat beside me and I slip my hand under my dress to rest on top of his,
squeezing his hand slightly.
“Good question,” he hedges, laughing nervously.
This is his family. He doesn’t need to be nervous around them. Or is it
me he’s nervous around? I can’t tell.
I used to think that he was lying about needing help talking to people.
An egotistical part of me even thought he was doing it just so he could hang
out with me. But there’s something deeper underneath the Connor that I
know that’s holding back something that could be bigger than the both of
us.
“I’m going to try to work harder on and off the pitch to make sure my
game is as good as it can be next season,” he explains. Emma’s face tilts,
her mouth immediately forming into a frown. “What?”
She shrugs, shaking her head, but Mark answers for her. “How about we
do it differently this year? There’s only five of us anyway. Let’s make
resolutions that aren’t related to school or work. Can we do that?” We all
nod in agreement and Nora lets out a long sigh. “Em, do you want to go
first?”
She nods happily. “I am going to take better care of our garden. It’ll
give me something to do when I’m not teaching,” she replies.
Mark slams his fist on the table, dramatically and all of our eyes widen.
“Thank god for that!” he exclaims and we all burst out laughing. I swear
he’s one of the most dramatic people I have ever met. “I’ve been pretending
to digest these Brussel sprouts all night. They taste like shit, honey.”
“Whatever,” Emma says, pushing him away with one hand as he tries to
kiss her on the cheek. “What about you, then? Because if your resolution
isn’t taking regular showers, I’ll have to pull out the divorce papers. Again.”
“Touché,” Mark mumbles, sliding back into his seat. I take a bite of my
crispy potatoes as he thinks. Connor’s hand rubs absentmindedly on my
thigh, his thumb drawing circles on the apex of my thighs. “I’m going to
finally start doing couples yoga.”
“With me?” Emma beams, clasping her hands together as she blinks up
at him. Nora snorts beside me.
“Who else?” Mark retorts.
“I don’t know. You could have hoes,” she responds, mumbling and we
all burst out into hysterical laughter.
When we’ve all settled down, Nora puts up a fight about how her
Hamilton obsession technically counts as her hobby and part of her degree,
but her argument is too weak and her mom makes her change her
resolution. Instead, she vows to volunteer more regularly at the animal
shelter. Connor decides he wants to read more fiction books and I decide to
take better care of my physical and mental health with more self-care days
and less studying.
I love moments like these where everything just feels so right. There’s
no negative energy. No one is talking about oblivion or trying to sour the
mood with sad memories. It feels like we’re living in the present, trying to
get somewhere that isn’t where the bad memories have been held.
For so long, I’ve felt like I was being held back by my past and the
grief, but now I finally feel like I’ve stepped out of the quagmire and I’m
finally living again.
OceanofPDF.com
TWENTY-NINE
CAT
“I WANT TO SEE YOU. ALL OF YOU.”
THE DAY after Thanksgiving is always my favourite. It’s the quiet in the
air after a chaotic few days. It’s the Bailey’s lodge with an abundance of
food that you know will never run out. It’s the large fireplace in the living
room that is always radiating warmth. It’s the looks Connor keeps giving
me from across the room as we pass each other in the house.
Today is a day for relaxing, stuffing ourselves with more food and cake
and playing board games.
As mean as it is to admit, I’m glad my dad isn’t here. It wouldn’t feel
right. Most times we’ve attempted to get together with the Bailey’s, the
night ends in some sort of argument that my dad usually starts. Since he
tried to make me feel bad about not spending the day with him after he was
the one who cancelled on me, I’m waiting until Christmas to have a real
conversation with him. It’s like having a moody teenager as a parent.
Speaking of moody teenagers….
After more complaining from Nora this morning as the soreness from
the hike kicked in, we bundled up in our winter clothes and made huge
mugs of hot chocolate, settling on the porch swing. The air is freezing, but
being snuggled up next to my best friend and thick gloves around my
hands, overlooking the leafy forest, it’s one-hundred-percent worth it.
“Is it time?” Nora asks me, hauntingly, pulling her phone out of her
pocket. She has a habit of making the tiniest things into blockbusters.
“It is time,” I reply, nudging her shoulder. She giggles, searching for
Elle’s contact.
Living with the girls has given us some real attachment issues. When
we’re separated for more than two days, I swear our bodies start to
decompose. I’ve spent nearly every day of my life with them for the last
eleven years, so it’s been hard having Elle away from us at her parents
house. She’s been avoiding seeing them for months, and we know that
being with her moms has probably stressed her out. Both of our signals are
weak, so we tried to schedule a time where we could talk without the risk of
the phone shutting off.
Elle picks up on the fourth ring, her tanned face filling the screen, her
curly hair tied up into a ballet bun. Her cheeks are red, her lips a glossy
pink colour and her dimples are popping out. Our Eleanor in a nutshell.
“Hi, guys! I miss you,” she says immediately, pouting. Nora already
tries to fight me to fit us both on the screen, but I push her arm up and aim
it a bit higher so she can see us both better.
“We miss you too,” I reply, glancing over at Nor as she nods. “How are
things in Wonderland?”
Even though Elle’s moms only have two kids, Elle and her little brother
Mason, they have the biggest house I have ever seen. It comprises of at
least four separate buildings and three storeys. We got banned from
catching the bus to their side of town as kids because we would spend all
day up there playing hide and seek and one time we accidentally lost Mason
when he was a toddler and Annie and Phoebe banned us. It was fun while it
lasted.
Elle sighs, looking off behind her phone and then back to us. “It’s fine, I
guess. Mason has a new bit this year since my mom got him an iPhone for
his birthday. So, now whenever we’re out he films us and pretends we’re
wild animals.”
Nora snorts. “That kid is so funny.”
“He’s a menace is what he is,” Elle mumbles, rolling her eyes. “How’s
everything up there? I bet Emma’s been on Connor’s case again with the
resolutions.”
“How did you figure that one out,” Nora replies, muttering angrily.
It’s common knowledge that Connor has problems with talking about
things that aren’t to do with football, but he’s working on it. I promised I
would help him, and after this break, that’s exactly what I’m going to do.
He’s improved a lot since the first disaster at my dorm, so the progress is
slow, but still moving.
I nudge Nora in the arm. “Did you tell your moms about the Christmas
recital?”
Elle shakes her head. “Not yet. I’m going to wait–” The sound of Annie
and Phoebe’s shrill voices take over Elle’s voice and the screen too. Both of
their eyes widen when they see Nora and I, smiling wide as they wave
erratically.
“Hi girls! You look so grown up.” Annie greets, still waving. Nora and I
are laughing so hard at the fact that Elle has now momentarily disappeared
from the screen as her moms take over. “I miss your wikkle faces.”
“You’re going to wait for what?” Phoebe asks Elle and I hardly get to
hear the conversation before she quickly says goodbye and ends the call.
That girl hides a lot from her parents, which I understand. They’re
extremely protective over her, especially after her accident last year which
she’s still technically in rehab for.
“Well,” Nora says, getting up from the swing. “I guess that’s our cue to
get ready for dinner and board games.”
“I guess it’s time for you to get ready to get your ass beat,” I retort,
following her into the warm comfort of the house. She turns back to me,
narrowing her eyes as she walks backwards.
“That was one time and I wasn’t even paying attention,” she argues.
“If I remember correctly, you were involved in a very heated
conversation with your dad. Wes had to talk you down from a ledge when
you were sulking all evening,” I challenge. She just rolls her eyes at me and
turns back around, walking the right way. I giggle as I catch up with her,
slinging my arm around her shoulder. “It’s okay, Nor-Nor. I promise I’ll go
easy on you.”
“Whatever,” she groans through a laugh, pushing me away from her as
we make our way into the kitchen. I move over to the window, placing our
now empty hot cocoa mugs into the sink and I notice Connor sitting by
himself on the bench at the side of the house.
What is he doing on his own? And how do I get to him without making
it obvious. We’re supposed to be getting ready to eat and play board games
in five minutes, but something is tugging at me to know what is going on in
his brain right now.
“Don’t you think Connor’s been acting weird recently?” Nora’s voice
startles me and I almost let the mug slip through my hands. I turn to her,
resting my back against the sink.
“What do you mean?” I ask shakily. She shrugs, pulling open one of the
drawers filled with snacks.
“I dunno. He’s always been uptight. We know that. But recently… I
don’t know. Other than that slip up yesterday, he’s been more chill than
usual,” she explains, sighing. “Maybe it was you.”
I almost choke on air. I clear my throat, trying to play it out. “What?”
“You know, with the thing you’re doing for the team,” she replies and I
sigh. I need to work on keeping my cool around her whenever she talks
about Connor. It’s not a good look. “Honestly, props to you. That team is a
nightmare.”
“Tell me about it,” I mutter, although I know she’s only partly right.
As much as they irritate me and can be a handful, I love them all so
much. They’re chaotic and loud, but the main thing is they care about each
other and their sport. They’re dedicated regardless of the jokes they play
and with the games I’ve watched them win, they’ve proved that more than
once.
“This game is rigged. I’m not playing anymore,” Nora sighs, sulking back
in her chair.
We’ve been huddled around the dining room table for the last hour after
eating our dinner, and since we started playing Monopoly, we’ve had this
back and forth with a certain drama queen.
“It’s not rigged, honey,” Emma coos, organising the fake money again.
Nora peers beside her, looking over at the bank she’s set up and rolls her
eyes.
“I think Cat’s cheating,” Mark says.
I gasp. “What!? I’m not even doing anything.”
“That’s the problem,” Connor says beside me, teaming up with his dad.
He smiles at me, those brown eyes squinting as his cheeks turn the sweetest
shade of pink. “You’re not even paying attention, yet you’re still ahead of
us all.”
“Well, I keep getting distracted,” I mutter.
Connor tilts his head innocently. “Hm, by what?”
I’ve hardly been paying attention because all I’ve felt since I sat down
has been Connor’s huge hand on my thigh. I’m wearing a long, light red
dress with a slit along the side, which gives Connor the perfect opportunity
to torture me. He’s had his hand there all night, silently squeezing, teasing
me by dragging his hand higher up and then back down again. I’m not
wearing anything under this dress and I’m terrified for when he figures that
out.
I pretend to fiddle with my property piece in front of me. “Maybe I’ve
just outsmarted you all,” I say coyly.
They all laugh and the game moves on around us. Connor squeezes my
thigh again, not looking at me as he rubs his thumb up and down. If
someone sees what he’s doing he’s going to get us both in big trouble.
“If Ryan was here, he definitely would’ve outsmarted you too, Cat,”
Nora mentions, smiling at the thought of her boyfriend. Connor’s hand
flexes on my thigh.
“Is that right?” I muse and she nods, sticking her tongue in her cheek.
“Yeah, how is Ry-Ry?” Emma asks, nudging Nora in the shoulder. “I’m
surprised that was his first cameo of the night. How are things with you
two?”
“Things are good. He’s just… busy,” she mumbles. We all narrow our
eyes at her, but she doesn’t seem to notice, or care. They’ve kept their
relationship private from us and we never question it. He’s good to her…
Most of the time. And she’s probably the best girlfriend he will ever have.
“Right. So he’s ‘busy,’” Mark says with air quotes, rolling his eyes as he
turns his attention to Connor. “If you need me to beat someone up, Nor, I’ll
do it.”
“Mark,” Emma chides.
“You don’t need to do that, dad,” Nora murmurs, shaking her head.
“I’ll do it, Nor-Nor, and you know I will. No one messes with my little
girl,” he mutters before painting on a smile. “What about you, Con? Are
you dating anyone? How’d things go with the girl you asked me for advice
on?”
I actually choke this time, spluttering like a complete fool. All the
Bailey’s look at me like I’m crazy and I pull up a glass of water to my lips,
trying to sip discreetly. “Sorry,” I mutter, turning to Connor. “You asked
your dad for advice on a girl? How sweet.”
“She must be pretty special if you asked for his advice,” Emma mutters
and Nora snorts.
Connor’s eyes hood as he tilts his head at me. “Yeah,” he drawls, his
hand moving further up my thigh. My whole body comes alive from his
touch as his hand reaches the apex of my thighs where I’m aching for him.
“She’s pretty fucking perfect.”
He doesn’t stop the movement of his hands even when I squeeze my
thighs together. My arousal is completely covering his hand now and I
swear I almost moan just from the slight friction.
“As sweet as that was, no swearing at the dinner table,” Emma
responds, narrowing her eyes at him. He nods obediently as if he isn’t two
minutes away from finger-fucking me under the table.
I push out my chair so abruptly that everyone on the table turns to me. I
smooth out my dress as Connor rests both of his hands in his lap. I clear my
throat. “I’m going to get a drink. Does anyone want one?”
Emma frowns. “We have drinks here, sweetie. I can get you one from
the cooler.”
“No, it’s okay. I’m just really craving… tap… water.”
I turn around before I can completely register the confusion on their
faces and hightail it to the kitchen. My entire body feels like it’s on fire and
it needs to be dunked in an ice bath.
Just from the light touches he’s given me over the past two days, the
desire in my lower stomach has just been growing. I feel like I’m hungry
for him.
I’m a simple girl. I’ve always enjoyed sex. But there’s something about
the sheer thought of sleeping with Connor that turns me inside out.
He’s got this kind, gentle and caring nature on the outside, but from the
way he’s spoken to me with his face between my legs and when I was on
my knees for him, I know there’s another side to him that I’m dying to
discover.
I should have known the second I got up from the table that he would
follow me. Still, I can’t hide the shudder that runs through me when he
sneaks up behind me, wraps his arms around my waist and starts kissing me
along my neck.
I melt into him instantly, my ass nestling into his lap as he keeps himself
pressed to me without saying anything. “Connor.”
“Hm?” he asks into my skin, softly biting my neck as I swallow back a
moan.
“Your sister and your parents are in the other room,” I say, trying to give
myself some reason to stop. His fingers dance across my stomach. He
touches my body like he just knows what to do with me.
“My parents don’t care. And for Nora, she’s too caught up in her own
shit to notice,” he replies easily, still kissing me along my neck. My head
lolls back as he presses himself into me and I can feel his hard erection
against my ass. “You want me to make you feel good, don’t you?”
“Yes,” I breathe out.
“Then let me.” He spins me around, pinning me to the counter with his
hips as I look up at him. He wets his bottom lip, but he doesn’t kiss me.
“Here’s what we’re going to do. I’m going to say I feel sick from dinner
and I’m going to go to my room to lay down. You’re going to play two
rounds of Uno with everybody and by the time they want to move on to
charades, you say you’re heading up to your room. I’ll wait for you. Don’t
change. Don’t do anything to your hair. You’re perfect just like this.”
His rough words light me up inside. I pull on the hem of his shirt,
pulling him down to kiss him hard. He stumbles a little at the force before
smiling back into the kiss. “Okay,” I murmur.
“Okay.”
After doing exactly what Connor told me, I stand next to the huge window
at the other end of the guest room, looking out at the night sky and the
frosted window, the pale moonlight shining through the transparent curtain.
I hear the door click open and then shut again, a lock turning. I freeze in
place. I never wanted someone as much as I want him. Never craved
anyone as much as I do him, and the slow taunt of his footsteps make this
process that much more gruelling.
I hear the shuddery breath he takes when he’s behind me and he pushes
my curls over my right shoulder. I turn to him slightly, but my eyes close
the second his mouth makes contact with my neck, setting me on fire.
I feel beautiful. Luminescent.
He brings his mouth to the shell of my ear, his other hand playing with
the strap of my dress. “Take off your dress for me, Catherine. I want to see
you. All of you.”
OceanofPDF.com
THIRTY
CONNOR/CAT
THERE’S AN INDENTATION IN THE SHAPE OF YOU
CONNOR
The second that dress pooled to the floor, I was greeted to the sight of
long expanses of dark brown skin. She is glowing in the moonlight as if
she’s spent the entire day being bathed in sunlight for this specific moment.
The curls that drape along her back that are so easy to wrap around my fist.
That round ass of hers sculpted perfectly as she stands on one foot and then
the other, not turning around to me, letting me take her in from this angle.
As forward as I’ve been, I still want to tease her.
“What did you do last night, Catherine?” I ask, biting softly on her
shoulder before she tilts her head back, resting it on my chest with a shaky
exhale.
“What do you mean? We were together the whole day,” she says, not
getting what I’m hinting at.
The walls between my room and hers are thin, and I heard every single
time she softly moaned my name whilst she touched herself to the thought
of me. It drove me insane all night and I was seconds away from running
straight through the walls and eating her out just the way she deserves,
showing her how much better I am than her fingers.
I wrap my warm hand around from her stomach to cup her breast,
swiping my thumb against her nipple and she lets out a soft moan, shifting
beneath me.
I hum into her neck. “Yeah, you sounded just like that.”
“You heard that?” she asks, her hand joining mine on her stomach.
“I heard everything, sweetheart,” I whisper. She starts to move our
hands further down her stomach, desperate and eager to do more, but I stop
her.
Using the last shred of self-control that I have, I spin her around, having
no time to process her naked body in front of me before I press my lips to
hers in a frenzied rush of desperation, groaning as she greedily pulls my
hair.
“I want to see you exactly like you were last night.”
Her breath hitches as she pulls away from me. “I’ve never…. No one
has ever asked me to do that before.”
I run my hand down the side of her face, my fingers resting possessively
on her collarbone. “That’s the thing, Cat. Every person you have been with
before me doesn’t matter. Because from now on, it’s just me and you.”
“Just me and you,” she repeats, kissing me back deeply.
I walk her to the edge of her double bed, unable to stop my hands from
running across her wide hips, feeling her curves beneath my hands as we
don’t break our kiss.
It’s unfair that she’s completely naked in front of me and I still have all
my clothes on, so I reach for the hem of my shirt, tugging it off. Her eyes
light up with excitement as her hands fumble for the button of my jeans. I
let her work them off me until I’m only wearing my boxers.
She sits back on the bed, looking up at me with those innocent brown
eyes, resting her arms back behind her as her whole body is on display for
me.
She’s fucking stunning.
Each time I look at her, my whole body aches with how perfect she is.
How each part of her is just as pretty as the last. She unknowingly
captivates me just by breathing, by existing, in my presence. It should be a
crime for someone to look so good all the fucking time.
I lean down into her until her elbows buckle beneath her, not catching
her lips the way she wants me to. As much as it’s going to be torture for the
both of us, I want to know exactly what she was doing last night so I know
how to make her feel good, which means not kissing her until she tells me.
When her back hits the bed, her body instantly arches into me, her lips
parting.
“Show me what you do when you’re alone,” I say into the space
between us. Her eyebrows furrow, looking both angry and intrigued at the
same time. “I want to know your body like the back of my hand, cherish
every single sound that you make just for me, know every single way to
make you feel good.”
“You already know how to make me feel good,” she whispers.
Even though that statement fills me with pride, it’s not exactly what I
want to hear right now. I push off the bed, leaving her staring up at me
before I hook my hand around her ankles. She laughs through a gasp as I
pull her to the end of the bed. She leans up, shaking her head at me with a
smirk as I kneel at the end of the bed.
“Show me what makes you feel good, Catherine, or I won’t touch you at
all,” I explain. Her chest rises and falls at my words and her tongue sneaks
out, wetting her bottom lip. Fuck. I’m definitely not going to last. “I’m
pretty good at keeping my hands to myself when it comes to you.”
“Your hand was up my skirt the entire meal, Connie. That alone tells me
very differently,” she muses.
“And I’ve been dying for a taste of you since I felt how wet you were,”
I reply gruffly, circling my thumb around the soft spot of her ankle. She
shudders at my words and goosebumps arise along her legs.
“For someone who has such trouble speaking in front of crowds, you
have the dirtiest mouth,” she mutters. Then she has the fucking audacity to
raise her hand to her breast, circling her nipple until it hardens and I bite
back a groan.
“Show me, Catherine. I’m fucking dying here,” I get out through gritted
teeth.
She finally listens to me then, laying back on the bed and spreading her
legs wider, propping one leg up onto the mattress.
This is a fucking sight – her legs opened in front of me, her pretty pussy
on display just for me. Every part of her, inside and out, is perfect to me.
She slides her hand down from her chest, across her stomach and then
down towards her heat. Her head is still tilted to the ceiling and I watch
every single one of her movements like it’s the best movie I’ve ever seen in
my life. I can see just how wet she is and when her fingers contact her
arousal, her body immediately contracts.
“Fuck,” she gasps. I don’t say anything. I try to keep as quiet as
possible, only focusing on what she’s showing me. Two of her fingers play
with her swollen clit, causing my eyes to roll to the back of my head. It’s
fucking uncomfortable sitting here, my cock desperate for attention as she
gets herself off. Her pace increases and I almost lose my mind. “Connor,”
she moans. Is it possible to come from that sound alone? “I can’t– Fuck. I
can’t.”
“You’re doing so good, baby. Keep going,” I encourage, palming my
erection in my lap. She continues working her fingers over her clit, not
penetrating herself with any of her fingers, but her whole body starts to
spasm. Her legs open and close around her fingers, tiny gasps escaping her
lips that make my dick throb in my hand. “That’s it.”
I don’t know why I decided to talk, because the second the words left
my mouth, her thighs shook as she came hard, twisting her face into the
side of the bedsheets, stifling her moan.
I still don’t touch her as her body settles, her chest heaving. Her fingers
still aimlessly move around her sex, but I don’t think she even notices she’s
doing it. She looks so fucking hot like this – all worked up and dishevelled
just for me. My Catherine.
When her eyes connect with me, a lazy smile on her lips as she leans up
on her elbows, I know now more than ever how badly I want her. How
badly I want her to feel the rawest part of me.
“Kiss me now,” she whispers, almost begging, “Kiss me anywhere.”
CAT
Since Connor shucked off his boxers and towered over me on the bed, my
whole body hasn’t been able to stop shaking. He’s made me come multiple
times just by looking at me. I’m fucking terrified for the moment when he’s
inside me.
I’m about to have sex with Connor Bailey for the first time and my
thoughts won’t stop spinning. What are we doing? Are we just hooking up,
or are we more than that? Is this just a fling for this semester until he gets
bored of me, or when he starts to get sick of my sad moods?
As if he can read my thoughts, he tilts my face to him, cupping my
cheek with one hand. “I’ve got you sweetheart. You can stop worrying,” he
murmurs, pressing a kiss to my lips. I let him melt into me for a second
before I push him back slightly.
“Connor, what are we doing? I can’t do this unless I know what we
are,” I explain, feeling completely embarrassed. But I need some clarity.
I’ve never been good at just playing it cool. “Are you my boyfriend, or not?
Are we going to go on dates and hold hands? Are we just fooling around? Is
this just a one-time thing or… what?”
He laughs quietly, kissing the side of my mouth, but I’m still frowning.
“You’re my girlfriend, Catherine. I thought that was obvious. I’m yours and
yours only. You’re the reason I want to get up in the morning just so I can
make you smile. I want to be around you all the time. I’ll hold your hand if
that’s what you like. I’ll take you on as many dates as you want. I’ll be the
best you’ve ever had.”
The words weigh on me, almost making me dizzy. “Just like that?”
“Just like that,” he replies, kissing me deeply. He brushes my sweaty
curls from the side of my face. “Great. Glad that’s all cleared up. Can we
have sex now?”
“Yes,” I reply through a giggle, unable to stop myself from laughing at
the absurdity.
I really should have prepared myself more for this because the second
he rolls on the condom, braces his hands on my hips and lines up his cock
with my entrance, I know my life is going to be irrevocably changed.
I’m already panting, a wet mess, helplessly desperate for him. He keeps
his eyes locked with mine when he slowly – so slowly – nudges the tip into
me. It’s hardly anything, but my whole body instantly responds to him and a
soft whimper leaves my mouth. Even when he pushes more of himself into
me, filling me up so fucking well, my eyes can’t help but close with
pleasure.
It feels like I’ve been set on fire from the inside out. Every pressure
point in my body tightens with need as he slowly rocks himself into me.
“Is this good?” I nod frantically, gasping for air when his nails dig into
my hips. “Talk to me, baby.” He leans down and kisses across my breasts as
he continues slowly pushing himself into me. “Is this good for you?”
“Fuck, Connor,” I whine, my hand tightening on the sheets of the bed.
He tilts his head playfully, that smug smirk on his mouth, knowing exactly
what he’s doing to me. He pushes into me again, filling me to the hilt and a
loud moan escapes my mouth at the euphoric sensation. “God. That feels so
good.”
He laughs quietly, but he styles it out with a groan when I finally
manage to move my hips slightly.
“You’ve got to be quiet, Catherine. Can you do that for me?” My head
falls back just from the words that leave his lips, causing me to slap my
hand around my mouth, trying to be as quiet as possible.
“I’m trying,” I muffle as he continues pushing in and out of me, the
sloppy wet noises filling the room as his face twists with pleasure. I look
down to where we’re connected. Big mistake. The second I look down,
seeing how much I’ve stretched to fit his shaft inside me, he brings two of
his fingers to my clit, teasing me gently. “Go faster,” I pant, needing the
release now more than ever. “Faster, please.”
He responds with one of the sexiest groans I’ve heard in my life as he
does exactly what I asked. He thrusts his cock in and out of me, causing the
bed to shake as I still try to cover my moans. Connor continues playing with
my clit, trying to draw out my orgasm, but I can tell he’s close too.
“God, Catherine,” he groans, shaking his head with a laugh. “I wish you
could see yourself right now. You look so fucking pretty taking all of me so
well.”
My chest fills with warmth. “Yeah?”
“Fuck, yeah,” he replies. He works himself in and out of me at just the
right speed, hitting the spot that needs it the most and I can hardly keep my
eyes open, overcome with pleasure. “You fit so well with me, Cat. So
fucking good.”
It feels like my entire body, my soul, was made to be and do exactly this
for and with Connor. It never feels like a competition or like we have to be
intimate. He understands my body and my wants in ways I can’t fully
comprehend myself. All I know is that I am a complete fool for him.
His voice brings me back to the conversation. “Hey, eyes on me, pretty
girl.” I manage to open my eyes again, just at the second he pinches my clit
and my head spins. He runs his hands from my hips to cup my breasts,
circling his thumb around my nipple and I moan. “That’s my girl.”
That’s what does it.
From all the stimulation and the words that come out of his mouth, my
whole body comes alive before the orgasm crashes through me, my thighs
and stomach convulsing beneath him. From the low groan and the jerk of
his cock inside me, I can tell he came too. Even with my body in sweats, I
feel like I’ve reached the peak of my existence.
We both breathe heavily, realising the severity of what we’ve just done.
Or maybe I’m the only one overthinking this. I try to let my anxieties
soothe when Connor disposes of the condom and crawls back into the bed
next to me.
I’m still naked, but he pulled back on his boxers. He quickly pulls up
his shirt from the floor, slipping it over my head seamlessly as it swallows
me whole. I pull out my curls from the neck of the shirt and sigh, staring
back at him as he sits crossed legged on the bed, mirroring my position.
When he blinks at me, he shakes his head, his gorgeous face turning red.
“What?” I ask. “Why are you looking at me like that?”
A short laugh escapes his throat before he drops his forehead to mine.
He brushes a strand of my hair behind my ear and I rest my hand on his
cheek, stroking my thumb under his eye.
His throat bobs. “I just can’t believe that I have you now.”
“I can’t believe it either,” I mutter into the space between us. He runs
his hand up my thighs. “Are you going to sleep in here tonight?”
He shakes his head. My heart dips. “I can’t. My parents always wake
me up whenever I’m here just like they used to when me and Nor were
younger.”
I hate how much that statement fills me with sadness. It shouldn’t. I’m
happy that he has two people who care so much about him. Two people
who would do anything for him. I just wish it wasn’t my mom that had to
go. As horrible as it is to even muse, I can’t help but wonder what it would
have been like if my dad had been the one who died instead.
I instantly feel guilty just by thinking about it. I shake my head to get
rid of the thoughts.
“Okay,” I whisper, running circles on his knee. “Do you… Do you think
we should tell Nora soon?”
He tenses. “Do you want to?” I shrug. “It’s completely your choice, Cat.
It’s your friendship that will change. Anything that happens with me and
Nora, I can handle. I won’t do anything until you tell me first.”
I nod. “I don't know. Not yet. I don’t like lying to her, but I want you to
myself for a little bit longer.”
He laughs quietly, still keeping his forehead pressed to mine. “Very
possessive, aren’t you?” I rock my head forward, pushing him back a little.
“What can I say? I’m an only child. I’m not used to sharing my toys,” I
say, shrugging.
“Oh, so I’m an object to you now? Have you been using me this whole
time just for my body.” He gasps dramatically, holding his hand to his chest.
“Yes, that’s definitely the reason why I’m with you,” I mutter, rolling
my eyes.
“Don't worry, sweetheart. The feeling’s mutual. Since that day in the
closet, I didn't want anyone else in your vicinity. Wes thought I was crazy.”
I giggle. “You are crazy, Connie.”
“Yeah, I'm crazy for you.”
For whatever reason, when he says it, it doesn’t make me want to curl
up in a ball and die of cringe. It only makes me realise how much more I
like him and his strange personality.
He’s just my Connor. And I don’t ever want to let him go.
OceanofPDF.com
THIRTY-ONE
CAT
“I’M SWOONING.”
I have an idea.
CONNIE
I’ll have you know Wes is not the only one who can come up
with ideas, sweetheart.
CONNIE
Yeah…
CONNIE
Really?
CONNIE
CONNIE
Right…
CONNIE
It sounds okay.
CONNIE
OKAY????
Connie
The three dots appear then fade away multiple times before he finally
responds.
Have a good day without on my hot and sexy body. Can’t wait
to stick my tongue down ur throat.
OceanofPDF.com
THIRTY-TWO
CAT
MERRY CHRISTMAS
OceanofPDF.com
THIRTY-THREE
CAT
JEALOUSY, JEALOUSY
YOU CAN ARGUE ALL you want about what the best day of the year is,
but we all know there is something extremely magical about New Year’s
Eve. I’ll have a load of anxiety throughout the day until the next morning,
but that doesn’t make it any less magical.
There’s something so comforting about being surrounded by my friends
in a random house as we sing and dance along to Christmas songs and old
2000’s hits waiting for the ball to drop on the flatscreen in the living room.
And this year, that feeling has grown tenfold because it’s Connor’s hand I
have on my back as we move through the crowds.
I honestly didn’t think I would have ended up back at Jason Bassey’s
party after the way the last one ended, but it’s given me a boyfriend, so I
shouldn't really complain. Not only that, but it’s given me the chance to
hope again, to dream, to want.
We tried to time our arrivals so we would be the first two here out of
everyone in our friendship group. Connor picked me up with Wes and
apparently Archer has been on duty to pick up Elle and Nora twenty
minutes from now. We got here over half-an-hour ago, so we’ll have almost
an hour to ourselves until they turn up.
Which is why I can’t help myself and when we’re deep into the
crowded room, I lean up and kiss him deeply on his full lips. He stumbles
slightly in surprise, but I tug on his shirt, keeping him close to me and he
smiles against my mouth.
“What was that for?” he mumbles, pulling back from me, grinning. I
absentmindedly run my hand through his thick hair, resting my hand on his
neck.
“Just because,” I shrug, giving him another kiss before starting to walk
beside him.
It’s not just because. Well, mostly it is, but it’s also the fact that the
music is just right and I want him. There’s always that fear of someone
catching us and I want to be a little reckless. Plus, he looks so fucking hot
today. He always does, but today especially.
His hair is messy because the second he got to my door and I answered
it, he pushed me against the closed door and kissed me like his life
depended on it. He’s wearing dark pants and a white button down with his
sleeves rolled up, showing off his huge tanned arms.
He’s got this new sense of confidence around him. Maybe it’s because
I’ve stopped my weekly interrogations and the play-offs have been going
incredibly well for the Titans. Either way, he looks happy and comfortable
and I love that for him.
He slings his arm around my shoulder, tugging me into his side as we
walk around. I’m surprised no one has said anything to us yet. Part of me
has been waiting until we get caught and another part of me is too afraid to
straight-out tell Nora what’s going on between us. Besides, Connor is one
of the most popular guys on campus so I’m surprised people aren’t drooling
at his feet right now.
It feels good having these secret moments between us and I’ve been
resisting the urge to soft launch our relationship on Instagram. I know we
have to wait a little longer until I’m fully comfortable with the idea of
telling Nora.
“What would you do if I just blabbed and told every living soul that
we’re together?” I ask when we get to a quieter corner of the house. We’re
both leaning against the windowsill, using the warmth from the radiator
beneath us. “Like, would you completely freak out, or what?”
He looks down at me, a lazy grin hanging off his lips. “If I could scream
at the top of my lungs that you’re my girlfriend, I would do it in a heartbeat,
you know that.”
“Do I?” I tease, unable to stop myself from curling my hands into the
bottom of his shirt.
“Do you want me to prove it?” he argues, squinting his eyes at me. My
heartbeat increases at the challenge in his voice and I nod, running my hand
over his stomach, feeling him tense beneath me.
He steps away from me and I’m ready for him to do whatever he’s
suggesting to prove it to me, but a brunette I have only spoken to in passing
steps in beside us.
Hailey Dermont is known across campus as a playgirl. I never talk
down on women, but this one makes me see red. If she was all up over
someone else’s man I would have questioned her from afar, but having her
this close to Connor makes my blood boil when there’s nothing I can do.
Hailey is a gossip, and if I tried to tell her to stay away from him, she
would blab to every single sophomore at Drayton and that is not the kind of
attention I need right now. I’ve had a public relationship before, and I know
how easily they can blow up in your face. The last thing I want is to put us
in the spotlight.
Just as I expected, she completely ignores my existence as she steps
closer to Connor with her back to me, but I can still hear her whispering.
“So, Con, it’s been a long time.” Just the sound of her voice makes acid
pool in my stomach.
“Not really,” he replies, his tone clearly bored. “I saw you at the game.
You know, when you had Oli’s number on your cheek.”
She laughs so loud I swear my eardrums almost burst. I know my man
is funny, but he’s not that funny. Connor looks over at me, eyes wide and
clearly apologetic.
“Oh, yeah. Don’t worry. You’re still my favourite player. Oliver is such
a prude. You’d think he would want some of this–” She gestures to herself
and her tiny dress. “But apparently not.”
Connor just blinks at her as I try to burn holes through her back, hoping
she’d just disappear. Should I say something? I mean, what’s the worst that
could happen. If she wants to blab, it would give me an excuse to tell Nora.
“Okay?” Connor says, his eyebrows scrunched. He’s clearly confused
and doesn’t want to talk to her, but he can’t ask her to leave. “Look, Hailey,
I’m kinda in the middle of–”
“I said you can call me Hails, last time, remember?” she teases. My
temper goes from mild to fucking unbearable when she starts to trail her
finger on his arm. I smile, holding my ground as I try to wait her out.
“Well, Hailey,” he bites out with more force and I watch her flinch
back. That’s my boy. “I’m trying to tell you that I’m busy and I don’t—”
She cuts him off. “So, who are you kissing at midnight?”
He looks down at her. “Not you,” he replies. He looks at me and his
eyes shine before he looks back down at her. “If you could open your eyes,
you would have been able to tell we were in the middle of a conversation.”
He manoeuvres away from her to stand beside me, immediately
wrapping his arm around me as she spins around and her mouth hangs
open. “I’m sorry,” she says with disbelief. “You’re blowing me off for…
her?”
My stomach twists. This is exactly what I didn’t want to happen. I’ve
always been pretty confident with my looks, but it took some time to get
there. Growing up, I’ve always felt like I wasn’t as pretty as everybody else
because I’m not white, blonde and skinny, but that should have never been
my thought process. Having darker skin and slight curves makes me
beautiful and I’ve learned to love myself in every way that counts.
When I see the way Connor looks at me and compliments me, I feel
even more special, so I should not be feeling insecure around her. She’s
pretty, undeniably, but I can’t tell if she’s Connor’s type or not. It shouldn’t
matter. His type shouldn’t matter to me, since I’m the one he’s chosen. I’m
the one he wants. Sometimes I need to get that in my stupid brain.
His arm around my shoulder tightens. “Yes, is that a problem?”
Her eyes widen. “I– I mean…. You could have anyone you want, Con,
and you’re with her?”
He lets out a nervous laugh. “I don’t remember saying you could call
me ‘Con,’ Hailey. Let’s stick to first names only to make you understand
this easier,” he says sternly. His face hardens and I have to hide my grin. I
like this side of him a little too much. “When I’m talking to someone else –
looking at them like they’re the only girl in the entire room – that should be
enough of an indicator that I’m not interested in anything else. In case that
isn’t clear, I don’t want to talk to you. Especially after you mentioned how
you tried to sleep with my teammate and my friend whilst trying to make a
move on me. I hope for all of our sakes that you find something better to do
in your spare time, Hailey, because I really don't think you can put this on
your CV. And for God’s sake, leave Oli alone. The poor guy is probably
frightened of you.”
Holy shit.
I can’t tell what is better: the look of pure horror and embarrassment on
her face, or the fact that that is the most I’ve heard Connor talk to another
person in months. I just want to jump into his arms and tell him how proud I
am of him for sticking up for me when I lost the words.
“Okay, chill,” she scoffs, “that was not needed at all.”
“It was,” he replies. She just blinks at him, her head cocked and eyes
still wide. “Come on. Don’t act like this is the first time you’ve tried it.
You’re just annoyed that I’ve turned you down more than once and you’ve
had your fun with everyone else on the team. Which, by the way, I’m not
shaming you for. You do you, you know? Whatever. But when I try to get
out of a conversation with you, that doesn’t give you the opportunity to be
rude to my girl. I don’t ever want to hear you say a single thing about Cat
ever again. Got it?”
My chest blooms with pride. As much as I know I can usually stand my
ground, I like the feeling of Connor protecting me like this. I like the way
he talks about me and defends me. It makes me feel like I could drop all of
my trust into the palm of his hand and never have to worry about it ever
again.
“Good to go?” I ask him as her mouth twists in disgust. Connor nods at
me and we walk away, faster than we’d both admit, to the other side of the
room.
When I turn to lean against the wall, Connor’s body coming closer into
mine, I can’t help but laugh. Tears are springing to my eyes by the time he
starts to laugh too. “That was insane. I mean, I knew you were popular, but
I didn’t know people were that desperate for you.”
His face suddenly turns serious. “You know it’s only you for me, don’t
you?”
“I know,” I reply. His eyebrow crunches as if he doesn’t believe me. “I
know, Connor.”
“Good,” he says, leaning down to press a kiss to the side of my mouth.
“What I said was true, too. You’re the only person I see when I walk into a
room and you’re there. I mean that. The whole world falls silent when
you’re near me, Cat. Do you know how distractingly beautiful you are?
Like, I feel light-headed whenever I’m around you. Can you even
comprehend how insanely maddening it is to just be in your presence?”
I suck in a breath. “All this talking practice has turned you into a poet,
Bailey,” I tease to cover up the intense feeling I have running throughout
my entire body.
“Tell me you understand that, Cat, or I’m going to start to feel like I’m
going crazy,” he murmurs, his voice so low it makes my stomach
summersault.
“I understand,” I murmur and I kiss him on his lips, letting his mouth
linger for a second before pulling away. “Are you going to be my midnight
kiss, Connie?”
“Yes, Catherine, I’ll be your midnight kiss and every kiss you ever have
after that,” he responds, kissing my nose. I immediately scrunch it in
response, shaking my head. “I’ll kiss you again at midnight on January first,
the second, the third, the fourth, the fifth, the sixth.” He smiles wide. “Stop
me, or I’ll keep going,” he murmurs and I shake my head. “Then a big, long
one on your birthday, January seventh. Then the eighth, the ninth, the
tenth….”
When he continues to list every day of the month until March, I’ve
finally gotten sick of listening to him say numbers. We’re still against the
wall and I look up into his brown eyes and I swear I see a future in them.
Our future.
Because there is no future I want to be a part of where Connor Bailey
doesn’t recite days of the month to me, vowing he’s going to give me a kiss
on every one of those days. That’s the future I want. With him.
OceanofPDF.com
THIRTY-FOUR
CAT
“FICTIONAL MEN.”
To my Catherine.
Twenty roses for your twentieth.
I am so proud of you everyday. You’re my
favourite person ever.
Love from, Connie.
I hear Nora and Elle’s voices coming from around the corner. Before I
can comprehend the sentiment in the note, I shove it into my pyjama
pocket.
Nora comes into view first. “Who was… Ohmigod!” Her screech is so
loud I move back into the kitchen with them to rest the flowers onto the
counter and her mouth doesn’t close. “They’re gorgeous, Cat!”
“Holy shit!” Elle screams, bouncing up and down as she sits on the
stool, staring up at them, her head in her hands. “Who sent these to you?”
Since the last game that we all went to, Elle has known something has
been going on with Connor and I before I was ready to realise it myself. So,
now, as she looks at me with her honey coloured eyes, I can tell she wants
me to tell the truth, but I bite the inside of my cheek.
I shrug. “I don’t know. Chris said he couldn't say.”
Elle frowns as Nora fuses over them. “There wasn’t a note, or
something?”
“Nope,” I say, popping the ‘p.’ Elle’s frown deepens and I feel the guilt
churn in my stomach. I hate lying, but I’m also terrified as to what is going
to change between us when Nora eventually finds out.
“Well, it must be someone from Drayton, because they’re the only
people who have access to the Post-To-Dorm system,” Nora explains, still
thoroughly inspecting the flowers. She squeals when she looks up at me.
“You’ve got a secret admirer, Cat.”
“Apparently,” I mumble, twisting the note Connor left in my pocket.
She squeals again. “This is amazing! We need to figure out who it is
immediately and then Elle needs to start dating. Imagine all of us on a triple
date.”
“That would be terrifying,” I mutter.
“Definitely,” Elle adds, “You and Ryan are disgusting around each
other.”
“Oh, I’m sorry that I love my boyfriend,” Nora retorts. This is an
argument that no one will win. We all know this, but Elle likes to try. I use
the opportunity to pull out my phone to text Connor about the flowers only
to see there’s already a message from him.
CONNIE
CONNIE
CONNIE
It’s a surprise.
Happy Birthday, Cat. I really, really, REALLY like you. Like so
much.
Thank you.
I really, really, REALLY, like you too, you idiot.
When I shove my phone back into my pocket, I can’t help the huge smile
that is plastered across my face, my heartbeat unable to settle.
For once on my birthday, I don’t feel like the world is going to crash
and burn, or that I’m out of place. I’m always going to feel a little lost,
that’s just a natural part of growing up, but I don’t feel entirely alone. I
know I have the girls and a boyfriend who will always have my back.
“Who do you think sent them?” Nora asks, snapping me out of my
daydream as she continues admiring the flowers.
“I’ve got no clue,” I lie, shrugging.
“This is crazy. Someone is clearly head over heels for you and you’ve
got no clue. It’s a perfect premise for a book,” she replies, her cheeks
turning pink just at the idea. She seems more excited than I am and I know
it’s going to crush her when she finds out that it was her brother that sent
these to me. “And purple roses. Do you know how rare they are?”
“I mean, those things only happen in books, right?” Elle says, enabling
her delusions. “One of the last books I read, the guy filled her whole room
with flowers just because he was five minutes late to her birthday dinner.
I’m not settling for anything less than that when I eventually start dating.”
“As you should,” Nora agrees and I nod. Elle deserves nothing short of
perfect. Nora turns back to me, squinting her eyes. “So, what’s the plan for
the rest of the day? Are we going to hunt down this secret admirer?”
I laugh and shake my head. “No, I’m not really interested in finding out
who it is. I’ll wait it out and see if they send anything else. As for the rest of
the day, I really don't mind what we do. We can just watch movies all day
and pick up a cake from the store.”
Nora frowns. “Are you sure? I’m sure we could put together a party if
you wanted.”
“I’m sure,” I say. “A night in with you guys is what I need before we
start back at school again. I’m already anticipating another semester of
torture.”
“Sounds good,” she replies, turning back to Elle. “You’ve not got
training today, do you?”
Elle looks up at us, eyes wide as if she hasn’t been listening. “Guys,
don’t think I’m crazy, but I completely zoned out during half of that
conversation.”
Nora squints her eyes. “What are you thinking about?”
She sighs wistfully, shaking her head. “Fictional men.”
When we all burst out laughing, I know there is no one else I’d want to
spend my birthday with. I might not have got a text from my dad at all
today, but I know my mom is looking down at me and I know she’s proud
of me.
The call from JoJo at 12 AM solidified the fact that the people that care
about me will show up and make an effort, no matter how small the
occasion. They are the kind of people who I will dedicate my life to be
surrounded by.
My real family.
OceanofPDF.com
THIRTY-FIVE
CAT/CONNOR
FIRST DATE
CAT
CONNOR
If I knew a bookstore could make my girl this happy, I would have taken
her a long time ago.
I’ve never really been on a date before and I don’t understand the exact
rules for them, so I tried to come up with something fun to do today.
The hike was unexpected, but totally worth it. Watching Cat watch the
sunrise is going to be an image I’ll burn into my memory forever.
She looked so peaceful and content beneath me. It’s been a while since
I’ve felt that way. With the season now in full swing and the semi-finals
coming up soon, this date couldn’t have come at a better time.
The best part of having a girlfriend is by far holding hands. Yes, I might
have one hand occupied with a basket full of books as we make our way
through the shelves, but my other hand is completely tethered to hers. I’ve
never truly enjoyed these small acts of intimacy until I met her.
She makes the simplest of touches feel like my whole body is about to
erupt. Her kisses are soft and smooth. Her hand-holding is God-like and it
makes me want to curl up into a ball and snuggle into her forever. Her hugs
make me want to die and come back to life and I can barely fathom the sex.
She tugs on my arm a little tighter as we make our way through another
fiction aisle, this one has a lot more cartoon covers than before. Is this a
kids' aisle? My mind tries to make sense of it as I stare at them.
“What are you thinking about?” Cat asks me when we get to a table of
books. She looks up at me, tilting her head to the side as she twists a
paperback in her hands.
“I’m wondering why all these books have cartoon covers, but they don’t
look like kid’s books,” I say, turning one over and reading the blurb. A
teacher and student romance novel. Interesting. “I don’t get it.”
She laughs as if this is the funniest joke she’s ever heard in her life. I
just blink at her dumbfounded. “Do you really not know what these are?” I
shake my head. She places her book back down and steps in closer to me.
“So, a lot of author’s make cute book covers with illustrations on them, but
they actually just havealotofsexinthem.”
I blink at her again. “Sorry, didn’t get the end of that, sweetheart.”
She sighs, rolling her eyes. “I said, they just have a lot ofsexinthem.”
They have a lot of….
Oh.
Oh.
I gasp dramatically, looking inside the basket which has two books with
cartoon covers. “Do you secretly have a porn addiction?” I whisper, leaning
our faces so close that I could taste her.
“It’s book porn,” she corrects me, unable to stop smiling. My eyes
lighten with surprise. Well, I shouldn’t be surprised. She can act as proper
as she wants in person, but I’ve seen what she’s like when she’s a wreck
beneath me, moaning my name. “What? Why are you looking at me like
that?”
“Nothing,” I say, shaking my head. “I’m just thinking about how I’m
going to prove to you that I’m better than all those men that you read
about.”
“It’s not a competition, Connor,” she replies. I let out a short laugh,
removing the distance between us as she backs up onto the small table, her
hands dropping to either side of her and I let the basket hit the ground.
I lean into her, breathing in her vanilla scent until it feels like it’s all I’m
going to become. My nose brushes against her neck and I inhale. “Tell me,
Cat, have you ever read about a guy finger fucking his girlfriend in a
bookstore?”
Her breath hitches. “N-No. Not yet.”
“Want to make that into a reality?” My hands find themselves
unbuttoning her coat and she helps me button it down until my hand finds
her warm skin under her sweater.
“We could get kicked out,” she whispers, tilting her head away from me
as I press kisses across her neck, feeling the heat of her skin beneath my
mouth.
“Since when don’t you want to break a few rules?” I whisper, biting her
neck slightly.
“Since my dad is the mayor and if we get caught I will be in a lot of
shit,” she challenges. Oh, shit. I almost forgot.
Catherine has done a public relationship before and that didn’t end well
for either of them. More for him than her, but still.
I pull away from her. “Yeah…. You’re right. I’m sorry. I shouldn’t have
tried to do that, that’s completely my fault,” I mutter, scrubbing my hand
across my face. When my hand drops, she locks her fingers with mine and
looks up at me. She leans up on her tiptoes, her pretty lips coming
dangerously close to my ear and I swear I almost combust.
“That doesn’t mean you can’t finger-fuck your girlfriend somewhere
else,” she murmurs, biting on my ear. Fuck. This woman has cast a spell on
me, or something, I swear.
I grip onto her hand, pick up the basket and buy all of her books so
quickly that I don’t even check the price. She tries to walk beside me
innocently as we trudge back up to my parents' empty house, but all I can
think about are her filthy words and the very filthy things I want to do to
her when we’re inside the house.
After taking off our layers at the door, she walks straight to the kitchen,
not even looking at me as she opens the fridge. I watch her do so, my cock
already hard and waiting for her as she insists on teasing me, edging me
until I can get what I want. She spins on her heels, tilting her head as she
holds up a carton of apple juice.
“Thirsty?” she asks. I eliminate the space between us, grabbing the
carton from her hand and pulling her up onto the kitchen island instead.
“What’s wrong? Do you not want a drink?”
“That’s not what I want, and you know it,” I mutter, tugging on the hem
of her sweater. She helps me pull it over her head, throwing it to the side.
“What I want is going to taste a fuck lot better than apple juice.”
“Yeah?” she teases in that breathy voice of hers as she leans both of her
arms back on the island, arching her back for me.
“Yes,” I reply, my fingers playing with the button of her jeans. “Can I
take these off and eat you out before I lose my fucking mind?’
She giggles before telling me I can. I waste no time ripping her jeans off
her until she’s in nothing but blue panties. I took off her bra the second I
could see her nipples beneath the thin material.
My eyes burn over every single inch of her body before I focus in on
her needy tits, hard and waiting for me. I lean forward, pulling one of her
nipples into my mouth and she moans so loud I almost lose my balance.
Her hands twist in my hair, gripping onto my curls as if her life depends
on it and I let her. I savour every part of her, loving the fresh taste of her
skin in my mouth. My eyes connect with hers and I suddenly feel like an
animal, needing to touch and taste every part of her.
I kiss between her breasts until I get down to her stomach before I
spread her thighs apart. My cock aches with need when I see the wet spot
on her panties, showing me just how badly she wants this. Wants me.
“Are you always this wet for me, sweetheart?” I ask, my voice gruff and
hoarse.
“Are you always this slow?” she groans. Just for that comment, I press
my fingers to her clit over the fabric of her panties, gaining a whiny moan
in response. That’s what I thought. “Connor, please.”
“Please, what?” I tease, still edging her with my fingers against her
panties, her arousal coating my fingers so much I want to taste her. “I
thought you liked it slow, Catherine. If you want me to go faster, you have
to use your words.”
She doesn’t respond. Instead, I curl my fingers inside her panties,
pulling them off her legs, leaving her a bare, wet, mess on the island. Fuck.
She looks fucking stunning like this. Her whole body is on display to
me – her legs apart, her hands on the marble, her head slightly tilted back as
her hard nipples are right in my face. I want this exact sight to be forever
burned behind my eyelids.
I push her further back on the counter until both of her feet lay flat on
the rock. “As pretty as this sight is, I’m not going to let you come unless
you ask me.”
“Please, just…” Her breath catches when I edge my middle finger at her
entrance, collecting her arousal. “Just touch me. I don’t care what you do,
or how you do it, just make me come.”
“That’s exactly what I needed to hear,” I murmur.
I do just as she asked. When my mouth connects with her needy pussy, I
curse myself for not wearing less restrictive clothing. My whole body
throbs when my tongue is on her clit, tasting and sucking as if it’s the only
thing keeping me sane. She tastes so fucking good.
Each small whimper that leaves her mouth only drives me to go faster,
pushing my tongue into her until her body shakes.
I press my palms against her slick thighs, pushing her legs further apart
to give me better access to her cunt.
From what she’s shown me, penetration doesn’t do much for her so I
stick to paying as close attention as I can to her clit. I roll it through my
mouth, my teeth lightly grazing her flesh and her thighs clamped around my
face.
“Keep your legs open, pretty girl,” I demand, opening her legs once
again. As soon as I get back to work, her legs close again and I groan. “It’ll
feel better I promise.”
“I know,” she pants. “It just– You just feel so… Good.”
“Do you like this, hm? Do you like being tongue-fucked over the
kitchen counter like the good girl that you are?” I murmur into her skin.
“Yes,” she cries, her head flying backwards.
“So fucking needy, aren’t you, baby?” I tease her again, sucking her
swollen clit into my mouth. Her thighs shake. Small sharp breaths leave her
lips and my head spins.
“Yes,” she whimpers.
She’s lost all control and I fucking love it. As much as Proper Catherine
turns me on, In The Middle of an Orgasm Catherine is something else. Her
voice changes when she moans and her whole body responds to every small
move of mine. She makes me want to memorise every muscle that moves in
her body and to study for hours on what will make her feel good.
After our little show-and-tell session back in my dorm, I know that
when my tongue moves faster and her hips start to move that she’s close. I
hold tighter onto her open legs, pressing them apart as my tongue works
seamlessly over her clit, my head shaking as I flick the small bud in and out
of my mouth.
Her orgasm is so sudden that I barely have time to process it when her
body shakes and she moans my name so loud I’m sure the neighbours
would be able to hear.
Eating her out on the counter was not in the itinerary for today. But fuck
me if it isn’t the best meal I’ve had in my life. As she catches her breath, I
help her slip back on her clothes until she looks somewhat decent.
I press my lips to hers, letting her taste how good she is and she moans
into my mouth.
“You,” she whispers against my lips. I don’t even have to think about
what she means, because I feel it too. Right down to my core.
“You,” I whisper back.
OceanofPDF.com
THIRTY-SIX
CONNOR/CAT
SICK DAYS
CONNOR
THE SECOND I started to get too full of myself with how the games
have been going, I knew something would bite me in the ass. I just didn’t
know it would be this.
I’ve tried my absolute hardest to take care of my health so I would
never miss a game. I’d spend hours researching the easiest sickness I could
get and possibly spread to my team and make sure that I knew all the ways
to prevent it rather than cure it. Maybe I did that to be smart and cautious,
or maybe because I’ve spent so many years being riddled with anxiety and
the thought of not playing.
I’ve only missed a game twice. Once because I had to go to a funeral
and the second time was when I was so sick I could barely open my eyes.
This time, we’ve already managed to win one semi-final game and our next
one is supposed to be today, but both my coach and my parents said I’m not
in a state to play and it could only make my health worse, which means not
playing in the finals if we get in.
I don’t know how I could have let this happen to me. I tried my best to
stay away from Archer and Wes when they were sick. I wiped down
everything in our dorm so they wouldn’t pass off anything to me. I steered
clear from Wes in classes and anyone else he could have been around and
I’ve still managed to get myself sick.
“These things just happen, bro,” Wes says, packing his bag full of
snacks at the counter as I lay on the couch. I feel a pang of anger and
annoyance through my core, knowing that he’s going to be training all day
for the game later and I can barely move without feeling like I’m going to
throw up. “Once you’ve rested up, I’ll come back from the game as chipper
as ever and then all you have to worry about is carrying us through the
finals.”
“That’s the thing, you idiot,” I mutter. “I want to get us to the finals, not
through them. In the nicest way possible, I’m one of the most vital
members on the team and I don’t know how much this Hayes Cohen kid is
going to be a good fill-in.”
Wes scoffs. “His dad is a legend, he’ll be fine.”
“Talent isn’t transferred through genes, you moron.”
“Being sick makes you more grumpy than usual,” Wes coos, standing
beside me on the couch. I look up at him and roll my eyes.
“I’m not grumpy, you just piss me off,” I argue, sounding as moody as
ever.
Wes leans down to ruffle my hair. “It’s okay, Connie-Wonnie. You’ll be
back on your feet in no time.” His annoying voice moves up two octaves
before he throws me a sarcastic smile and heads out the door.
I scrub my hands across my face, ready to spend the rest of the day
sulking, knowing I can’t talk to Cat since she has classes for most of the
morning.
This is going to be torture.
Instead, I spend most of the morning watching episodes of Family Guy
and questioning the God’s why I deserve this.
I’ve done everything right. I’ve stayed on track with what I eat and
where I go. I don’t drink. I don’t smoke. I train nearly every day of the
week. I give my all in every training session and at every game and there’s
still something uncontrollable that I can’t help.
I’ve not always been like this – so in my head and full of anxiety. I can’t
even pin-point the exact moment when things changed for me. I never used
to take anything this seriously. I always just let things happen and I went
with the flow. I wanted to explore and discover and create. But the second I
started taking football seriously, I couldn’t go back. My brain immediately
went into fixing and providing mode. I saw a goal and I’ve never looked
back.
I groan, turning over on my side. These thoughts are dangerous during
the daytime. I could spend hours sitting here and not even realise that I’ve
been spiralling from the same spot and get to no real conclusion.
I don’t know how long it has been when I hear a knock at the dorm
door. I don’t even have the energy to tell the possible stranger not to come
in as I curl up further onto the couch.
I swear I can feel her presence before I can see her.
Catherine stands at the edge of the couch, the bag that she uses for
classes slung over her shoulder and a thermal bottle in her hand. Her face is
etched with sadness and confusion as if she’s disappointed in me. This is the
one time I didn’t want to see her when I’m like this. I try to sit up further on
the couch and she leans down in front of me.
“What are you doing here, Cat?” I ask, my voice not sounding like my
own.
“Wes has been calling me all day and I finished classes early and I
wanted to come see you,” she replies, her voice soft and quiet.
“I’m sick. You don’t want to be around me right now,” I urge. The last
thing I want is for me to get her sick too. She doesn’t seem to listen to me
because she lifts up the blanket I have over me and slides underneath it,
sitting beside me on the couch.
“I got you some soup. Drink this and I can make you some more later if
it helps,” she whispers, bringing the warm bottle to my hands. She leans
down and pulls out two DVD’s from her bag, showing me Ten Things I
Hate About You and The Proposal as well as her Nintendo Switch. “We can
watch these so you’re not thinking about the game all day and then we can
play Mario Kart before we inevitably fall asleep.”
My chest pinches at the thoughtfulness, but I shake my head. “Cat, you
don’t have to do this. You’re going to get yourself sick.”
She turns to me, those gorgeous brown eyes staring straight into mine.
“Ask me where I want to be right now, Connor.”
I frown, knowing exactly what she’s doing. “Where do you want to be
right now?”
“With you.”
I try my hardest to swallow back the emotion in my throat as I look at
her, but just being with her makes me want to cry with how lucky I am.
I don’t deserve this. Her. Everything that she gives me. Every
vulnerable piece of herself that she’s kept hidden for so long.
“What should we watch first?”
CAT
CONNOR
For the rest of the day, I stay as close to her as possible. She holds me and
understands me and doesn’t try to fix my problems. She doesn’t try to
lecture me, or tell me what to do. She just lets me feel my feelings and I
appreciate her for it.
When Cat leaves after her dad calls her, I feel like I can breathe again.
She’s managed to calm the storm of my life so easily and I love her
more than I did a few days ago, if that’s even possible. I want to tell her that
I’m in love with her so badly. I want to tell her that she’s all I ever want and
that the love I have for her is infinite, but it’s not right just yet. We still
don’t know when we’re going to tell Nora, but after the finals seems like a
perfect time.
We’ll get our happily ever after, Cat and I. We have to.
The quiet doesn’t last long because it’s well into the night when I hear
the dorm door open followed by a very drunk Wes singing at the top of his
lungs. I’m not surprised. Whenever he gets shit-faced, he turns into a full
musical major and sings every song off the Hamilton soundtrack at full
volume. But what is unusual is the fact that the guys vowed not to have a
party tonight if they won the game.
Coach has been watching us like a hawk and he’s finally put enough
fear into them that I’ve been trying to do for years and they actually
listened. Well, everyone except his son.
I get up from the couch and turn on the light in the living room. “Wes?”
I ask and he comes into view. He’s wearing the same training uniform he
left in this morning, a beer in his hand and his hair is a sweaty mess. “Dude,
what are you doing?”
He lets out a drunken laugh and when I step closer to him, his eyes are
bloodshot, tears staining his cheeks. What the fuck is going on? My
heartbeat grows erratic, the sound roaring in my ears.
“Wes, what is going on?” I ask again as he sways towards the kitchen.
“She’s gone, Con,” he slurs, dropping his gaze to the ground.
“Who? Who’s gone?”
He shakes his head, finally looking up at me. I’ve seen every version of
Wes in my lifetime, but this one? This one is different. Broken.
“My mom… She left… She left my dad,” he says, sniffling. Jesus, how
drunk is he?
“What are you talking about?”
He groans, throwing his head back. “He cheated, Con. He said he loved
my mom and he’s been cheating on her for years. With Olivia.”
Anger boils in my stomach. “Olivia? Who the fuck is Olivia?”
His eyes lock with mine, and everything comes back to me. I don’t
know many people called Olivia, but when he looks at me, I know exactly
who he’s talking about.
Olivia Hardon. Our Assistant Coach.
Fuck. Our. Lives.
OceanofPDF.com
THIRTY-SEVEN
CONNOR
WINNER-WINNER CHICKEN DINNER
EVER SINCE WE started playing football, before the start of our final
game, we’d all have breakfast with our parents in one of the empty
classrooms at the school. When we were in little leagues, we’d have a pep
talk in the locker room whilst our parents tied up our laces and told us that
it didn’t matter if we lost.
It got better when we grew up and winning actually mattered. We could
tie our own laces and the pep talks would last a little longer. The same thing
happened last year before our first college final and it paid off.
This time, everything feels wrong.
The tension between Wes and Coach Mackenzie is lethal. Olivia called
in ‘sick’ though only Wes and I know what happened. We’ve all been so
caught up with our own shit that we would have noticed the signs a lot
earlier. I always thought it was weird how their relationship seemed to be a
little too friendly. It makes sense now that she went out when we were at
one of the away games and I spent the evening in the hotel room she shared
with Cat.
I can’t even look at him without feeling sick to my stomach.
Wes has always kept his relationship with his dad to himself, but there
have been times where they’d have arguments and he’d never tell me why.
He’d just turn up to my house one day, spend the night and go back the next
morning like everything was fine.
Coach never made it seem like anything was wrong, either. He’d coach
the team the next day and not act like he kicked his son out the night before.
He’s not a violent or angry person by any means, there’s just some parts to
his and Wes’s dynamic that I don’t think I’ll ever be able to understand.
Like right now as he talks to Wes with one hand on his shoulder in the
corner of the room whilst Wes’s eyes face the ground. I can’t hear what he’s
saying, but it looks like some sort of lecture whilst my parents yap on in
front of me.
My mom nervously nibbles on a scone whilst my dad sips on the coffee
that he’s been nursing since they got here. It’s a good and sweet tradition for
the most part. As we’ve all got used to playing under the pressure, the
parent’s all seem to have gotten more anxious over the years.
“You know what you’ve got to do if you get tackled to the ground, don’t
you? You just get right back up and show the other team what you’re made
of,” my mom says, sounding as serious as ever. I shake my head at her,
knowing what she’s like.
“I know, mom,” I repeat for what feels like the hundredth time.
“Yes, mom,” my dad mocks, bumping his shoulder into hers, “he
knows.” I nod, holding my chin high. “We know you’ve got this, Con.
You’re incredible on and off the pitch. This isn’t going to be any different.”
“Win or lose, we’ll all be cheering for you in the stands,” my mom
adds, her smile bright and triumphant.
She manages to put this insane amount of faith in me that I just want to
bottle it up and carry it around forever. When my parents look at me it feels
I’m a star they’re wishing upon. As if I’m something magical and out-of-
this-world that they need to pray and wish on for it to soar.
Months ago, that would have completely frightened me at the thought of
the weight of the team resting all on me, but now, I’ve become comfortable
with the idea of just doing my best. I’ve done all I can prepping and
training. I’ve tried to keep the team in line as best as I can, but it isn’t up to
just me how we perform. It’s how we, as a team, can work together and
kick the other team’s asses.
My phone vibrates in my pocket. I pull it out and Catherine’s contact
name flashes across the screen. I pull out my chair, excusing myself from
the conversation with my parents and my dad gives me a wink. That man
knows too much about my love-life without me saying a word.
Just the sound of Cat’s voice soothes me as we exchange hello’s.
“How are you feeling? I heard there’ll be a reporter from the Fort
Morgan’s Times at the game and some scouts too,” she says in a teasing
tone.
“I’ll be fine. I’ve done more than enough prep with you to know how to
deal with a few questions,” I say easily. “Speaking of, when can I see the
final report?”
She tuts. “Not yet. It needs some revisions and I need to bring it to my
professor for some proofreading, but soon.” I hum in response, impatiently
wanting to know more than just the snippets she’s shown the team over the
last few months. “Good luck. You’re going to kill it.”
“Thank you. I’ll be looking in the stands for you. I’ll help us win just
for you,” I whisper, making my voice sound extra sweet and I swear I can
hear her rolling her eyes.
“Win for yourself, Connie, not me,” she replies. There’s a brief moment
of complete silence on her end as if the phone is being cut off before she
speaks again. “Ugh. My dad has been calling me all day. I’m going to have
to answer it.”
“What’s been going on?”
“I don’t know. We didn’t speak much after Christmas, but he’s been
weird since he called that day at your dorm when I left. He’s saying that we
need to talk, but I don’t know what about,” she explains, sounding tired at
just the thought of having a conversation with him.
“Huh,” I murmur. “I hope everything is okay. I’ll see you soon.”
“I’ll see you. When you see a crazy lady in the stands with your jersey
on screaming like a lunatic, you’ll know it’s me,” she says. I laugh at the
image she creates. I’ve been wanting to see her in my jersey for fucking
years now and hopefully when I have her in my arms after the game, we
will have won and she’ll be cheering my name. “And, Connor?”
“Hm?”
“Just breathe, baby. I’ve got your back, always. You’re going to do
great.”
After the call ends and I’m lined up on the pitch, helmet in hand, staring
up at the full stadium, I realise this is exactly what I was made to do. Being
here, under the spotlights, the fresh smell of the pitch, the roar of the crowd,
is something I could spend forever in. And when I see my family and my
chosen family in the stands, banners in hand, I know that we’ve got this.
The team played better than we’ve ever played before. I don’t know
what was said by the parents at this morning’s meeting, but everyone is on
fire. Every pass is smooth. Every tackle is effortless. Every interference
from the referee is taken with a pinch of salt and we completely smash the
other team in a score almost too good to fathom.
When I’m running with the ball, seconds left on the clock, I feel
victorious. Nothing comes in my way. I keep my eyes completely focused
on the end of the field. Victory is so close I can almost taste it. Scoring a
touchdown is expected, but there is nothing quite like the feeling of being
able to cross that line, knowing that your team is right behind you cheering
you along the way.
When the moment comes and I’m met with wild cheers from the crowd,
my adrenaline high as fuck, I know that I’ve done this for myself. I know
that I’ve put in the work and the effort and there’s only one person I want to
see.
My heartbeat roars in my ears, the crowd silencing in my mind as I look
up to see her. My Catherine. I search for her in the crowd, finding Elle and
Nora first, cheering like crazy women. When my eyes focus on them, the
one person I wanted to see isn’t there anymore.
I haven’t been able to stop moving since the game ended. I barely made it
past the sidelines before the people in the stands came rushing down. My
vision blurs as more and more people try to talk to the team, pushing past us
and shoving flashlights and cameras in our faces. My stomach twists when I
see the reporter, James Nyguen, from the Fort Morgan Times make direct
eye contact with me. Nora and Elle are on his heels, following behind him,
huge grins on their faces.
I need to get out of here.
I don’t get far before a different reporter from the same magazine
shoves his camera and microphone in my face. “I’m sorry. I just need to–”
“I’m here with Connor Bailey. Twenty-year old quarterback for the
Drayton Titans and an absolute machine on the pitch. What a game it was
today. How are you feeling?” The shrillness of his voice catches me off
guard and I stumble a little, looking over his short frame to find my girl.
Still, I don’t see her.
“Yeah… It was a good game,” I mumble in response. Jesus. The team is
going to give me so much shit for this. All that training and practice for
nothing.
The reporter lets out a nervous chuckle. “Your team just won the college
cup and that’s all you have to say?”
I groan, desperate to roll my eyes as I take in a deep breath. “I’m trying
to look for her.”
“For who? Your mom? A girlfriend, perhaps?” he questions, shoving
both the microphone and the camera in my face. Do they both have to be so
close to me? I grip them and shove them a bit further away from me as I
stare straight into the camera.
“Yes, my girlfriend,” I bite out. I lower my voice when I look back at
the slightly petrified man beneath me. “Now, can you get out of my way?”
He blinks at me. “Please?”
When he’s finally gone to the side, I go to my next resort: my sister. She
and Elle are talking excitedly with Sam and Wes, pulling on their arms and
congratulating them. I should be enjoying that right now, but I can’t. I need
to find her. Who knows what could have happened? She wouldn’t just
disappear like that.
“Where’s Catherine?”
Nora turns to me at the sound of my gruff voice, her eyes widening in
surprise. “Oh my god! Congrats, bro. I knew you guys would win. You
were insane today. Seriously, I don’t think I’ve enjoyed watching you play
that much in so long.”
I store her compliments for later. Now is not the time, so I ask again.
“Where’s Catherine?”
Her eyebrows scrunch together. “What? Why do you want to–”
“Where. Is. She.”
Her eyes soften as she rests her hand on my forearm. I’m not annoyed at
her, I’m annoyed at the situation. I just want to know that she’s safe and that
I didn’t do anything wrong to upset her, or if someone else did then I’d be
spending my post-game celebrations in a very different way.
“Okay, okay,” Nora says softly. “Calm down. She left ten minutes into
the second half. Her dad called her. She said it was some sort of
emergency.”
Fuck. I run my hands across my face. “And you didn’t want to tell me?”
“You were in the middle of playing the most important game of your
college career with hundreds of scouts here and you expected me to tell you
where my friend was?” Her question is a valid one. For a second I consider
telling her everything. Telling her that I’ve been head-over-heels for
Catherine since the second I met her, but I want her to do that on her terms.
I shake my head as if that will take away the tightness in my chest. “No,
you’re right. But, do you know where she had to go? Maybe we can meet
her or something before the party?”
Nora rolls her eyes. “Connor, why does it matter to you so much that
she’s there? If she wants to come, she will. You’ve never cared before, so I
don’t know why you do now. She had to go. You won. Let’s just go to
celebrate.”
I mull over her point when everyone starts to leave the pitch. I somehow
manage to salvage another interview with a different reporter, hopefully
covering up the damage I made with the first one. I call Cat a million times,
but she never answers. At one point it started to go to voicemail and I
succumbed to going to the party miserable and feeling alone. Even when I
get back to my room, leaving the party early, I still haven’t heard from her.
I stare up at the ceiling and hope for both of our sakes that she’s okay.
OceanofPDF.com
THIRTY-EIGHT
CAT
DADDY DEAREST
OceanofPDF.com
THIRTY-NINE
CONNOR/CAT
HOMECOMING
CONNOR
AT SOME POINT, I will eventually learn how to tell my sister no. And
maybe she’ll also know when to listen to me.
After the game, I let her rope me into a stupid party at Oliver’s house. I
don’t understand how she managed to find out before I did. Hell, even
Archer was there and got an invite before I knew. She had a party outfit
under the jersey she was wearing and she and Elle were ready to go the
second we came back out of the changing rooms.
I let her give me more and more drinks until I couldn’t take it anymore.
I couldn’t focus on anything other than Catherine before I had the drinks
and drinking only made it worse. I always knew I would never be one of
those people who can drink loads and either not feel a thing or end up
bouncing off the walls. I’m not Wes, for God’s sake.
No.
I’m a sad drunk.
Which means leaving the party early, downing as many waters as I can
to sober up and sitting in my dorm alone as I repeatedly call Cat’s phone.
The girls didn’t tell me where she went. Not like they could anyway, they’re
both off their faces. I’m not expecting her to answer, whatever she’s doing,
but I like knowing that she knows that I’ve tried to contact her in some way
or another.
As much as I have every right to be annoyed with her, I just can’t. So
what if she missed the end of one of the greatest games I’ve ever played? I
might not have had her there, but I was surrounded by the love of my
family and my other friends. I worked well with the team and we managed
to pull off a great game. That should be enough for me.
I pace around the empty dorm, needing to do something with myself.
All the alcohol has worn off and all I’m left with is a heavy pit in my
stomach, longing for her. Fuck. I really am a sappy shit, aren’t I?
Whatever’s going on, I can’t just storm over to her dorm all the way
across campus and expect her to be there. She might not even want to talk
to me.
Oh, god.
What if she doesn’t want to talk to me? What then?
She’s quite literally the only person I want to talk to sometimes. I want
to live in a bubble with her, play house in a place where no one can hurt us.
She feels like half of my soul. She’s not the part of me I thought was
missing or needed fixing. She’s the part of me that’s always been with me
and she brought me back to life.
So if I need to wait, I’ll wait.
CAT
By the time I get back to my dorm, it’s early hours in the morning.
I’ve spent the last five hours hanging out with JoJo and finally having a
grown up conversation with my dad. I had no distractions. No phone to pull
out to use as an excuse. I didn’t try to pull out my journal and back out of
the inevitable conversation. Instead, I sat through it and I bade it welcome
home.
I didn’t realise how much we needed to have that conversation until
tonight. Like JoJo said, it shouldn’t take her almost dying in front of us to
realise we had to fix up our act. We’ve been misunderstanding each other
for years and pushing each other away instead of being there for each other
in our moments of need. She was right. We were both too stubborn to admit
how much we needed each other.
Of course she is.
When I finally push open my bedroom door, the first thing I do is plug
my phone onto charge and fall face first on my bed.
Just having regular emotions is exhausting enough. My brain is still
struggling to keep up with the events of the day, but the second my phone
restarts and my messages and miscalls start to pop up, I’m thinking of one
person and one person only.
Connor.
I sit up in the bed, pulling the covers right to my chin as I lean over,
picking up my phone still connected to the wire. All my messages and
miscalls are from him.
CONNIE
My hands shake as I press the call button, trying to see if his last
message is actually true. Part of me doesn’t want him to answer. I don’t
want him to have missed out on sleep because of me. If I was smart enough
to buy a charger whilst I was out or brought my own, I wouldn’t have to be
calling him at two in the morning.
He answers on the second ring.
“Catherine? Are you okay? Please tell me you’re at home,” he says,
breathing heavily.
“I’m in my dorm,” I whisper, turning on my side. The weight of the day
crashes onto my chest and I don’t have the energy to explain what happened
today. “Something happened with my dad and JoJo today, but I don’t want
to talk about it. Is that…. Is that okay?”
“Of course it is, sweetheart.” His voice is so soft and gentle I just want
it to put me right to sleep. Well, there’s an idea.
“Do you think you could stay with me on the phone until I go to sleep?”
I ask, twisting one of my hands in the comforting fabric of my bedsheets.
“Of course,” he replies instantly.
Comfortable silence washes over us for a few beats. “I’m sorry for
missing the game. I know how important it was for you, but I know the first
half was amazing. You were amazing.”
He sighs. “You don’t have to apologise.”
“But, I do. I hate that I left you. You know how important it is to me for
people to show up and I didn’t show up for you, and I’m sorry. I really am,”
I whisper.
“I was annoyed, but you mean so much more to me than any game
could, whether you’re in the stands or not. Your family needed you. As long
as you’re safe, that’s all that matters to me.”
I bite my bottom lip. “Are you sure? You’re allowed to be mad at me,
Connor.”
“I know, but I’m not. It was hard, but we’re both okay now, right?” I
close my eyes at the sound of his voice.
“Yeah,” I sigh, wanting him closer to me now more than ever. “Too bad
you live on the other side of campus, huh?” I try to add some sort of
humour to my voice, but it just sounds sad and weak, much like how I feel
right now.
“Yeah, it’s too bad,” he replies. “Do you want me to distract you until
you fall asleep?”
“Yes, please.”
He shuffles on the end of the phone, but I can’t tell exactly what he’s
doing. Maybe he’s getting comfortable in bed. “Okay, imagine that I’m with
you. What would you want me to do?’
I don’t even have to think about my response. It’s all I’ve thought about
since my dad dropped me off outside of campus. “I’d lay on my back, you’d
lay on my chest, where you’d be able to keep me down, keep me calm…
keeping me safe.”
“I’d like that,” he says, his voice hoarse and rough. “What else?”
“I’d stretch my arm out and you’d put your arm over mine and you’d
lock your fingers with mine. We’d stay like that for a few minutes until I
start to feel you everywhere.”
“That sounds really good,” he says, his breathing suddenly heavier.
Weird. “Keep going.” I open my mouth to speak, but when I hear a groan
on his side, I stop, frowning even though he can’t see me.
“Are you jerking off right now?” I ask, laughing quietly.
“No,” he pants.
“Are you lying to me?’
“Also, no.”
“Then what are you doing?” I get out through another laugh. I sit up
further in bed, still hearing his heavy breathing on the other end of the
phone.
“Open your door, Catherine.”
“What?” I gawk, a little too loud. “Is this your version of phone sex
where I have to open the door because you get off on knowing that someone
could walk in? Because if it is, I’m really not in the mood to–”
He groans. “Just open your door.”
I do as I’m told and walk through my bedroom door towards the door to
my dorm. The wind is basically knocked out of me when I see Connor. I
don’t know why it feels like it’s been years since I’ve seen him. Years since
I’ve felt him, or heard his voice.
He doesn’t make a move to come in. Instead, he looks down at me, his
smile bright and soft. “Spin for me.”
“What?” I laugh, a real smile spreading across my face.
“You heard me, sweetheart. The last time I saw you in a jersey, it wasn’t
my number you had on your back. I want to see you.”
He lifts one of my hands above my head and urges me to spin around. I
stumble slightly as I do, but he catches me, laughing. He tries to spin me
again the other way and I end up tripping over again and now we’re both
laughing.
“You’ve got to be quiet, baby,” he manages through a chuckle, shaking
his head at me.
“Then stop making me laugh,” I whisper-shout, hitting him in the arm.
He catches my wrist, circling his huge hand around it easily.
“Why would I? It’s my favourite thing to do,” he mutters, pulling me
further into him until his back presses against the door. He leans down to
me, and we both know what we need without saying it.
I wrap my arms around his middle, snuggling my head into his chest.
He holds me there, his steady heartbeat soft against my ear. He doesn’t
pester me, or ask me what happened today and I don’t ask him anything
either. We just exist together. Feel together. He feels like coming home.
OceanofPDF.com
FORTY
CAT/CONNOR
“YOU’RE PERFECT.”
CAT
THE BEST PART about the football season being over is that I get to see
Connor a lot more than before. It feels like he’s been tethered to me since
the final and now, weeks later, I still can’t get enough of him.
The only small tiny problem? We still haven’t told Nora yet and she’s
this close to figuring it out. I’ve had to hide him behind my door more than
once and I’m sure she must be able to hear us some nights because we’re
not always quiet.
I’ve been preparing myself to tell her next week after her boyfriend’s
birthday party. She’s planned this whole surprise party for him at his house
and she’s invited our friend group to come along. I swear I’ll tell her then.
First, I’ve got to sit through the process of letting my professor read my
official finished report for the Drayton Titans. I’ve put my blood, sweat and
tears into organising this magazine and I hope it paid off. I’d be lying if I
didn’t say I’ve had the most fun of my life writing it. It’s brought me closer
to people I never thought I would even be friends with. And it’s given me
Connor.
I’ve spent nearly every waking moment when I’m not in class in front
of a computer, trying out new fonts and new designs all by myself. I tried to
get in contact with one of the design students, but they’re always too busy.
If the paper wasn’t taken up for the last five years, I would have to be stupid
to think they’d spare some time to help me out.
Although it’s taken most of the school year to get it going, once this has
been finalised, I’ll be able to start doing monthly instalments every
semester after this and hopefully recruit a little team when they see how
much fun it is.
I didn’t mind it, though. I’ve never been able to be creative in that way
before and having free range has been amazing. I just hope I’ve managed to
pull it off. The writing and the different sections I’ve added in, I’m not so
worried about. But sitting in front of professor Rotford always brings me an
annoying amount of discomfort.
She’s read and skim read the paper three times and she hasn’t said a
word. Her office isn’t much to look at either, so there’s not even that I can
focus on. She lets out a soft hum. I can’t tell if that was a hm this is
extraordinary or hm who let this girl ever pick up a pen as a kid. Either
way, the anticipation is eating away at me.
I told Connor I’d meet him at his dorm since his roommates are out and
I don’t want to go there in tears. I want to be able to go and show him what
I’ve managed to make out of the newspaper. George has tried to reassure
me more than once, but he’s too kind for his own good, so I don’t know if
his comments are completely legitimate.
“What do you think? I’m still playing with the headers, but I think it’s
okay,” I mutter, nervously fidgeting with the loose material of my skirt.
She looks up at me and… Oh. My. God.
She’s smiling.
At me.
I’ve always craved academic validation, but getting a smile from a
teacher who I could have sworn has never smiled a day in her life is fucking
incredible. I resist the urge to smile back and wait for her to say something
instead. This could be a pity smile for all I know.
“Catherine, I’ll be completely honest,” she hedges, pushing up her
glasses onto her forehead as she leans on to the table. “I wasn’t sure how
well you would manage to pull through with this. I know I dropped this on
you, but I wanted to test you. To push you. And… Well, this is one of the
greatest things I’ve read in a long time.”
My chest expands with utter pride at her words. “Really?”
She nods, flicking through it again. “I mean, it has everything an article
needs. It tackles the subject of football in an enjoyable and accessible way.
It’s serious in some parts, talking about the injuries and the anxieties on the
team. It’s funny… I mean, it has everything you’d need. You’ve done a
really good job with this, Catherine.”
“Thank you so much,” I breathe out as if I just received the world's
greatest compliment. Well, I kind of just did. For me anyway.
“Seriously,” she says, shaking her head with disbelief. “I am really
impressed. I feel extremely proud to be your teacher. If a company gets a
whiff of this, you could be working for the New York Times. I’m really
proud of you.”
Oh shit. Here comes the waterworks. My eyes start to water
immediately at her words and my throat pinches. I can’t help the tears of
joy that stream down my face.
“Oh, God,” she mutters, fiddling for a tissue on her desk and hands it to
me. “Please don’t cry. Again.”
“I’m not crying,” I sob, clearly crying harder now. She just shakes her
head at me as I stand from my seat, my legs shaking. Pull yourself together,
woman. It’s not a big deal.
When I manage to get out of the room, I twist my mom’s necklace
around my neck and I know she’s with me, guiding me, knowing that she
lives on in me. Her love for books and literature will always be in me and
this article is living proof of that.
CONNOR
CAT
This is not how I saw today going. We hook up most of the times we hang
out, but something shifted today. I told him I loved him for the first time
and he said he loves me back. He’s shown me he loves me too.
He’s showing me again now after he just gave me a mind-shattering
orgasm. He switched our positions seamlessly and I let him. He’s now on
his back, both of his hands digging into my hips as I straddle him.
I rub my pussy against his condom-covered dick and I swear I almost
see stars. He’s so big and thick beneath me, and the more I move, the tighter
his grip on my hips get. I’m going to be bruised in the morning, but I don’t
care.
“Fuck,” he groans when my clit presses into his skin again. “That feels
so fucking good, baby.”
“Yeah?” I tease, grinding down on him again. “How good?”
His hands flex on my hips. “Too good.”
“Fuck,” I mutter when the friction starts to get too much. “I want to feel
you inside of me like this.”
“You sure you can take it?” he teases, panting as he continues moving
me over him. His face twists in pleasure and I press my lips together so I
don’t moan, not giving him the satisfaction he wants.
“You sure you can take it?”
“You’re right,” he agrees.
I get used to the rhythm, getting wetter by the second, but he moves me
further up so I’m resting on his stomach. My hands fall to both sides of his
head as I lean down. “What are you doing?”
“Sit on my face, Catherine.” His tone is so sharp I almost do exactly as
he asks before I really think about it.
I’ve never done that before and no matter how turned on I am right now,
there’s no way people actually enjoy their face being ridden.
“I– I can’t,” I stutter when he smacks my ass.
“You can,” he urges. I stare up at the ceiling when he pushes my pussy
closer to his face.
“It won’t feel good for you.”
“Sit the fuck down and I’ll show you just how good it feels for me,” he
demands. I’m about to tell him that I’ll do it, but he beats me to it. He
swiftly lifts my hips up and slides down the bed slightly and I lower myself
onto his mouth.
Holy, fuck.
My hands fly to the headboard, needing stability when his tongue slides
inside my pussy. This feels way too good. I can’t believe I was shitting on
this two seconds ago because this sensation is godly. He pushes his tongue
in and out of me as I try to move my hips. My clit throbs as my core
tightens with need, desperate for a release.
“God, Connor,” I groan, muffling my moan in the crook of my arm as I
continue to move my hips as fast as I possibly can.
“That’s it, baby. Just like that,” he encourages, panting from beneath
me. “Ride my face like you fucking own it because I’m all yours,
Catherine. All yours.”
“All mine?” I whimper when his teeth gently nip at my clit.
“All yours.”
His words work me up even more until I’m panting and I can hardly
move. He guides me with his hands and his mouth, doing most of the work
for me until stars burst behind my eyes and my entire body convulses. The
orgasm soars through me until I feel like putty and I roll onto my back.
Connor’s glistening face comes into my view and he immediately
captures my mouth, both of our tastes swirling together. It’s glorious. He’s
glorious.
When both of his knees settle on each side of me, I press my arms
around his shoulder blades and push his chest down onto mine until he
collapses.
I gasp slightly at how heavy he is. His weight is comforting, though.
Safe. He settles for a minute before he leans up on his hands, using one
hand to brush a sweaty curl from my face. “Wait. I don’t want to hurt you.
I’m heavy.”
I shake my head, pulling him back down to me. “Stay with me like this.
I like it.”
We both settled after a while, our naked bodies pressed together so
comfortably that I almost fell asleep. The only thing keeping me awake is
the fact that Connor stretched our arms out together and has been circling
his thumb over my hand.
“You’re the best thing that I’ve ever had, Connie,” I murmur into the
silence. I swallow the lump in my throat, wanting to make this moment a
happy one and not ruin it by my over emotional tendencies. “I don’t think
I’d ever be able to let you go.”
“I wouldn’t let you, anyway,” he replies, his voice heavy with sleep.
“You’re the best secret I’ve ever had to keep. The best thing that’s ever been
mine.”
With Connor's weight on my chest and the steady thrum of our
heartbeats, I know that all my dreams are going to be happy ones now that
I’m with him. I just know he’s going to continue to make me feel like I’m
the most extraordinary thing he’s seen in his life forever. I’m not hoping or
guessing anymore.
I know.
OceanofPDF.com
FORTY-ONE
CAT/CONNOR
SPIN THE BOTTLE
CAT
CONNOR
There is nothing sexier than Catherine rolling her eyes at me. She’s going to
start to stress me out if she doesn’t stop worrying about Nora. We’re meant
to be here having a good time since neither of us are busy.
I’m not necessarily here to celebrate the birthday boy. He’s good
enough to Nora as far as I’m aware, but he’s not my favourite guy on the
planet. He’s not made any effort to be a part of our friend group and I’ve
never pushed him either. I’m perfectly fine with the distance between us.
My friends are the ones who argue on the floor in the living room
aggressively arguing over whatever game they’re playing. Wes, Sam, Oli
and some other guys from the team are sitting in a circle, an empty beer
bottle in the middle as a few girls sit between the guys. I slip my hand from
around Cat’s shoulder as we walk further in, trying to see what’s going on.
“What are you guys playing?” I ask.
Wes’s smile doubles as he looks up. “I honestly don’t know. We’re just
spinning the bottle and picking up a card from this pack Sam has.”
I hum in response. “Sounds fun. Can we join?”
“Of course you can,” Wes coo’s. When I take a seat next to him, I flick
him in the head as Cat settles beside me. “There’s spare spots anyway.
Archer’s away brooding because he had to kiss Elle, but she said no.”
Catherine chokes next to me. “She said no? Why would she say no? I
mean, respectfully, Archer is gorgeous.”
Everyone in the circle laughs. As much as he’s a broody motherfucker
who doesn’t like to talk to anyone, everyone knows he’s model-level good
looking. He’s built like a giant, too. I’ve tried to convince him to try out for
the football team, or even the hockey team, but he sticks to his history
books and one-liners.
“You hear that, Connie boy?” Wes mocks, leaning into me. “She said
he’s gorgeous. How do you feel about that?”
“I don’t feel anything, Wesley,” I mutter. Catherine shuffles beside me,
bringing her hand to my back where no one else can see it.
“He’s got nothing on you, Connor. Don’t worry,” she mutters, pressing a
kiss to my shoulder.
I lean back into her, keeping my voice as quiet as possible whilst
everyone around us talks loud. “I know, baby. He’s not the one who can
make you scream the way I do.” Her breath hitches and I shuffle forward
away from her, linking my hands together. “Alright. Let’s play.”
For the most part, the game is a good distraction. Instead of worrying
about what my sister is going to say when she finds out, we’re too caught
up with the way Wes changes the rules of the game every few minutes for
his own benefit.
I have to painfully watch Oliver awkwardly make out with some girl
called Chelsea. I’m getting the idea that he’s never made out with anyone
before because each time someone has to make out with another person his
whole body cringes. I can’t wait for the day some girl changes his life and
he stops getting so uneasy at the idea.
When it’s Cat’s turn to spin the bottle, I should have known something
ridiculous would be about to happen since Wes is suspiciously shuffling the
cards. And of course, the bottle points right at me. She looks up at me, a
mischievous smirk hanging on her lips.
“Oh, fun,” Wes chirps, beaming at the two of us as he reads the card in
his hand. “You two have to recreate a sex position. Cowgirl.”
“Perfect,” Cat mutters, easily moving in front of me until she presses
her hands to my shoulder, my back pressing into the edge of the sofa. She
climbs into my lap, no questions asked, subconsciously rubbing herself
against me. I bite the inside of my cheek to suppress my groan. “How long
do we have to do this for?”
Wes lets out a cough when she moves again in my lap, her hands
tightening around my neck. “Two minutes.”
She meets my gaze, a challenge and a fire in her eyes. “Shouldn’t be too
hard, should it, sweetheart?” I murmur, bringing my mouth as close to hers
without kissing her. She wets her bottom lip, the motion so simple and sexy
my cock throbs.
“Are you sure you should be thinking about anything hard whilst your
dick is pressing into me,” she mutters back. She rolls her hips slowly. So
fucking slow. Everything else in the room disappears and she becomes all
that I see. There’s something so erotic about the fact they have no idea
about the two of us and we’re doing this more than just for the sake of the
game. Her body moulds with mine perfectly.
“Don’t act like you’re not enjoying it,” I argue, dropping my head back
to get a better look at her. Her beautiful curls are framing her face, the
purple corset top she’s wearing begging me to see what’s underneath.
She’s good at pretending that I don’t affect her, but sometimes the
pleasure takes over and she can’t help it anymore. I grip onto her hips and
pull her into me again, her core contacting my dick.
Her head falls to the crook of my neck when my nails dig into her hips,
rolling her over me once more. “Connor…” She whimpers and I swear I
almost lose my fucking mind. Her voice is so quiet, but if someone tried
hard enough, they could hear her.
“Shh, baby,” I whisper. “You don’t want people to hear how sweetly
you say my name, do you?”
I don’t get to see her reaction before Wes’s shrill voice brings us both
back to the moment. We’re in a room full of people, basically dry humping
like it’s a completely normal thing to do. Well, at parties like these, I guess
it is. What’s not normal is my sister suddenly appearing in the middle of the
circle.
Wait.
What?
Cat stumbles out of my lap, quickly jumping to her feet when she sees
Nora staring at the two of us and at Wes. Her eyebrows are knitted with
confusion, her cheeks red. Not a sweet red that she gets from watching her
favourite movie, but one filled with anger.
“Nora, hi,” Cat says, her voice way too high pitched. Nora doesn’t look
at her, though, she’s looking right at me. Twin telepathy has never worked
for us, but with the way she’s looking straight through me right now I’m
having second thoughts. “We were just—”
“Playing the game, right?” Her voice is sharp as her gaze snags on Wes
who is shuffling the cards, whistling like a fucking idiot as if he can’t see
what’s happening. She nudges him with her foot, completely ignoring my
existence. “Hey, I need you.”
What the fuck is going on?
Wes peers up at her before looking around him. He points to himself.
“Me? What for?”
My sister rolls her eyes. “Does it matter?” She reaches out a hand to
him. “Just get up.”
He slips his hand in hers. “Yes, boss,” he mutters, standing to his feet.
He lets her pull him out of the circle, but Cat goes after them and I do too.
“Nora, can we talk for a sec?” she chokes out, gripping onto Nora’s
arm.
“About what? I’m kinda busy, Cat. You know, with the party and Ryan
and everything,” she whispers. My sister’s smile softens and I can tell how
much it’s killing Cat not to say anything. There’s a time and place for
everything. Cat lets go of her arm and Nora and Wes walk away.
The rest of the party is as boring as ever. I don’t mean to talk down my
sister’s party-making skills, but since she disappeared, we haven’t been
enjoying ourselves. Elle has stuck with me and Catherine for most of the
night, but by the time it gets to midnight, we’re all ready to go home.
As we walk to the door, I spot Wes standing in the middle of the
kitchen, his fingers hovering over his mouth. What has this idiot done now?
Cat and Elle follow behind me as I make my way over to him, already
knowing something stupid is going to come out of his mouth.
“Hey, Wes. Where did you and Nora go?” Cat asks, leaning against the
counter. He doesn’t say anything, he just keeps his fingers pressed to his
lips.
I shake his shoulders. I swear he should have majored in theatre instead
of football because this guy is the most dramatic person I’ve ever met. He
knows how to create suspense when none is needed. We’re in a sweaty
house with shitty music playing and we want to leave, but of course he has
to give an Oscar-worthy performance before telling us where my sister
went.
“Wesley,” I press. He blinks, snapping out of his trance. His eyes
connect with mine and he looks like he’s seen a ghost. “Where’s my sister?”
I ask. He opens his mouth and before he can say something stupid, I stop
him. “If she’s having sex with her boyfriend, please don’t tell me. You can
just say she’s gone to the bathroom.”
He swallows. “She went back to her dorm. I think– I think something
just happened. I can hardly think straight.”
“How long ago did she leave? Did she take a car, or what?” I quiz.
There’s always been unwritten rules in our friend group that we don’t just
disappear when we go to a party together. We always need to know where
each other are if it’s late. “She can’t walk alone in the dark.”
“Yeah,” Elle agrees, “Didn’t Ryan go with her?”
“No.”
“Okay, well, we’re going to see if we can catch up with her. She’s been
off all night,” Cat says, linking her arm in Elle’s. Before I can tell them both
to be safe and to call me if they need anything, they’re already walking out
the door.
I turn back to face Wes who is still as slack jawed as he was when we
first came in here. “What have you done?”
He gasps. “Me? I’ve not done anything. It’s her boyfriend you should be
worried about.”
“What the fuck does that mean?” He shrugs. I run my hands across my
face, tilting my head up to the ceiling. “Come on. Get your jacket. We’re
going.”
“Going where?”
“Where do you think?”
She can try to run away from her problems all she wants and she can
hate me for all I care, but I’m not going to leave her alone to sulk whilst the
party she planned goes on without her.
OceanofPDF.com
FORTY-TWO
CAT
RUNAWAY SISTER
I’VE NEVER SEEN Nora go to the gym a day in my life, but she’s
somehow managing to outrun me and Elle. I’m not exactly fit either, but
jeez she’s fast. Ryan’s house is only a ten minute walk from campus and
we’re almost back to our dorm building. We’ve tried calling her, but she
won’t answer. From what Wes said, she can’t be that far in front of us, but
it’s dark and she’s not making any effort to contact either of us.
“How the hell is she so fast?” Elle pants when we push open the main
doors to our building.
“I’ve got no clue,” I say, sighing when we get in from the chill. “It’s not
like she’s got far to run now.”
We trudge up the stairs and my stomach churns. Does she already know
about me and Connor? Is that why she’s running away? Did something else
happen at the party that I can’t remember? Nora is the most sociable person
I’ve ever met and she would not turn down a party – especially one that she
planned – without a good enough reason.
I push open the door to our apartment and she’s standing there,
headphones dangling from her phone and her keys in one hand. Her dark
brown hair swishes as Elle and I step closer to her.
“Nor,” I say softly, resting my hand on her shoulder. Her eyes don’t lock
with mine and she stares at the ground instead. “Talk to us. What’s going
on?”
She takes a deep breath, staring up at the ceiling. “Nothing. It doesn’t
matter. I’m fine.”
Elle steps in front of her, urging her to look at one of us. “You’re not
fine.”
I peer over at her phone to see the song she’s been playing. “Seriously?
Dear Theodosia from Hamilton? Babe, what’s going on?”
She sighs again and we move to the other side of the counter, Nora
standing in front of the two of us. She finally meets our gaze and my
stomach turns at the thought of me, or anyone, hurting her. She’s my
lifeline. My best friend. One of the only people who gets me.
“He cheated on me.” She whispers the four words so quietly that I
almost don’t hear her. My heart breaks in two for her. “He’s been cheating
on me. I found out at the party. It’s why our chemistry has been so off on
stage.”
“Oh, baby,” I murmur. Elle and I immediately wrap our arms around our
friend, holding her tight to us. These are the kind of hugs that could last
forever. The kind of hugs that hold the weight of a thousand ones, letting
her know that we’ve always got her back. “He doesn’t deserve you, Nora.
You’re too good for this world.”
“Am I?” she breathes, her voice muffled between the three of us.
“Because sometimes, I feel like I’m barely scratching the surface of what it
means to be ‘good.’ I’m just constantly missing that mark and he realised
that and he doesn't want me anymore.”
“You’re so much more than that, Nor,” Elle says. “Anyone would be
crazy to think you’re not the brightest star in their galaxy. You shine so
bright, always. Ryan’s just got his head too far up his ass to notice that.”
“Exactly,” I whisper. “You’re our star, Nora. You don’t need to be that
for anyone else. You’re more than enough for us.”
She sniffles. “You guys get really poetic when I’m sad, you know that?”
We laugh and squeeze her tighter before we let go. “We know,” I sigh.
“Now, what do you need from us? We kinda panicked about where you are,
so the boys will probably be here any minute.”
“Perfect,” she says, wiping at her face before showing me a bright
smile. There’s my girl. “How about we just watch a movie? I’ll get our
blankets, Elle can get the snacks and you can choose the movie. The boys
can suck it up.”
“Sounds good,” Elle chirps, already on her way to the kitchen.
I do just that. I know she doesn’t want to talk in detail about what
happened, but I want her to process it however she needs to. Being cheated
on is the worst feeling ever and I’ll do anything to make her feel better,
which means ignoring the huge elephant in the room.
As I wait for the TV to load up, I pull out my phone ready to tell
Connor that she’s safe and that he doesn’t need to worry, but my gaze snags
on Nora as I look up.
She’s standing in the door of my bedroom, my weighted blanket in one
hand and something else I can’t see in her other. Her chin wobbles as she
looks at me. My chest tightens. “What’s this?”
I swallow even when my throat goes dry. “What’s what?” I step closer
to her as the microwave stops beeping and the entire room falls silent. A
white paper is in her hand, face-up in Connor’s handwriting. “Oh.”
Her chestnut eyes connect with mine, a fire swarming within them.
“Have you been sleeping with my brother?”
“Nora, wait–”
She reads the note aloud. “To, My Catherine. Twenty roses for your
twentieth. I’m so proud of you every day. You’re my favourite person ever.
Love from, Connie.” My stomach twists. Elle lets out a sigh from the side of
the room, slowly inching towards this very awkward confrontation. This is
not how it was supposed to go. Not at all. “Your birthday was months ago.
What does this mean, Cat?”
“That’s what I was trying to tell you earlier and then everything
happened and I–”
The door swings open and three men come rushing into the room. Well,
Wes and Connor make their way right over to Nora, almost knocking me
over in the process, while Archer stands awkwardly in the coroner, not sure
if he should intervene or not.
Connor holds onto Nora’s shoulders as her icy eyes don’t leave mine.
He grips her cheeks, trying to check her for injuries or any harm, but what
she’s feeling now must be rooted deep inside her. “Nora, you can’t just run
off like that. What were you thinking?”
She pushes at his chest and he stumbles back into me. “I can’t run off,
but you can sleep with my best friend behind my back?”
Connor looks down at me and I have no words or thoughts to offer him.
Wes speaks for the both of us. “Oh, shit.”
Nora shoots him a look. “Yeah, oh shit,” she replies, rolling her eyes at
him. “When were you going to tell me?”
“T-Today… Tonight, I promise,” I stutter, trying to comfort her in some
way as I reach out my hands, but she crosses her arms against her chest.
“Oh, that’s fucking convenient, isn’t it?”
“Calm down, Sunshine,” Wes says, moving closer to her, but she pushes
him back.
“Do not call me sunshine and do not tell me to calm down, you fool!”
My head spins at the amount of force in her tone and the grin on Wes’s face.
I don’t think I will ever be able to understand these two.
“How am I a fool?” Wes retorts. She just stares up at him, throwing her
hands in the air as if she physically has no energy for a comeback as her
chest rises and falls. The energy between them crackles as we all look
between them. Something’s going on there. I don't know what, but it’s
something.
“You two have been weird all night. What’s going on?” Connor asks,
pointing a finger between them.
“Since we’re all spilling secrets…” Nora says, looking around the room.
She drops her gaze to the ground as she mumbles, “I kissed Wes.”
It’s so quiet you could hear a hairpin drop. The moment is brief before
everyone starts to scream and shout and question the weirdest thing I could
have ever imagined to come out of Nora’s mouth. As much as he can flirt
with her, Wes has never actually crossed that line with her.
“You kissed Wes?” I repeat, eyes wide.
“Yes.”
“The real question is why wouldn’t you kiss Wes,” Elle says, instigating
as per usual. She shrugs when we both shoot her a death stare. “What? You
two act like you’re madly in love with each other.”
Wes starts laughing, throwing his head back as Connor stays silent,
clearly in shock. Nora groans loudly. “I am not in love with him. He’s my
best friend and I’ve been dating Ryan for five years.”
Archer lets out a nervous laugh, holding his hands up. “Look, guys, I’m
so honoured you wanted me to be apart of this conversation, but now I
know Nora’s safe, I’m just going to–”
“No!” Elle bursts out. As quiet and as sneaky as she is, that was an
awfully loud outburst from her. Archer turns towards her, crossing his arms
against his chest, tilting his head. “I just mean, I don’t want to be the only
one who’s watching this from the sidelines. You could get some real good
entertainment out of this, Arch.”
“Don’t call me that,” he mumbles, but he walks next to her and mirrors
her position, watching the chaos unfold.
I flap my hands around, trying to focus again on Nora. “That brings me
back to my first question. You kissed Wes?”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
“Because I was trying to make Ryan jealous,” she admits, her face
flushing with embarrassment.
“Why were you trying to make him jealous?” Connor asks, still
oblivious to what’s going on.
“Because he cheated on me! Is everyone aware of that now? He was
fucking another girl at the party I organised for him and because I have the
worst luck in the world, I walked in on it and Wes was with me, so I kissed
him to make him mad. The end.”
Connor’s face hardens as he stalks over to Wes, backing him up into the
wall. “You kissed my sister?”
“Did you not hear anything she just said? She kissed me. Not the other
way around,” Wes argues, clearly trying his hardest not to laugh. “Great
kiss, though. Lots of tongue.” Connor growls in his face, his fist tightening
in his shirt. “What did you want me to do? I offered to beat him up, but she
told me not to. I even settled for keying his car and she said no. It was the
next best thing.”
Connor releases him and runs his hands down his face. “Seriously, Wes?
Are you being fucking serious right now? We’ve had this exact
conversation before.”
“And I knew you’d react exactly like this,” he says. “Dude, can you
hear yourself right now? You’re getting mad at me for consensually making
out with your sister after she asked me, when you’ve been fucking Cat’s
brains out for months.”
Nora’s eyes go so wide I swear they almost fall out of her head. I’m
getting too dizzy for this. “You knew?!”
“Sort of….” Wes mumbles, running his hand through his hair.
She closes her eyes and takes a deep breath. She points at me and then
at Elle. “We need to talk.”
After leaving the boys up to their own devices, we settled on sitting on the
hood of Connor’s car to have the very important conversation I’ve been
avoiding for months. Nora’s reaction and the chaos that followed was
expected. I’ve known these guys long enough to know that when one thing
happens, a whole load of shit is bound to follow.
The three of us stare up at the sky in the late spring night and words are
failing us all. I ruined my chance at trying to explain myself in a justified
way and ended up rambling. Nora’s been sitting on that piece of
information for a while as Elle listens to both sides of our stories.
“I would never do that to either of you. You guys know that, right?”
Nora whispers, looking between the both of us, her eyes lined with tears.
“I mean, Cat doesn’t have any siblings. And I’d hope you wouldn’t do
that to me because that’s a felony,” Elle murmurs. A short laugh escapes my
throat and Nora shakes her head.
“You know what I mean,” she replies.
“Are you mad at me? It’s okay if you are. I should never have lied to
you, Nora. I’m seriously so sorry,” I say. Great. Word vomit again. My
anxieties are soothed partially as she rests her hand over mine, squeezing it
gently.
She sighs a little. “I’m more annoyed that you didn’t tell me. If you had
told me from the beginning, I would have had more time to process it,
but… I’ve just been broken up with and I want you to be here as my friend,
no matter what you and my brother are doing.”
“You’re always going to be first, Nor, always. And I’m sorry for not
making you feel like you were. I just got so caught up in everything and I-”
“I get it,” she says, cutting me off. She bites her bottom lip, thinking
about it and I let her take the time she needs. “I think I knew something was
going on a few weeks ago and I just didn’t want to admit it. I’ve seen the
way he looks at you, the way he worries about you when you’re not there.
He was worried sick that day you left the game. I don’t think he’s ever been
that concerned about another person in his life. It’ll take some getting used
to, for sure, but I want you both to be happy.”
My chest pinches at her words. The way Connor cares about me
frightens me, but not that I want to back out, but I want to keep seeing
where this goes. Something is telling me we’re only going to get stronger
after this and I can’t wait to see what our future is going to look like.
“Don’t think you’ve gotten out of this either,” Elle murmurs, bumping
my shoulder. “You look at him like he hung the fucking moon. You’re so in
love with each other, it’s hard to digest, honestly.” She sighs wistfully
before panic sets over her features. “Wait. You do love him, right?”
“Yeah,” I whisper. “I do.”
Nora barks out a disbelieving laugh. “It makes sense. He needs someone
like you and you need someone like him.”
“So, we have your blessing?” I ask, nudging her shoulder.
She shrugs. “I don’t love this, but I don’t hate it, either. I just want you
to be happy, Cat.”
“I want you to be happy too,” I whisper.
“I will be.”
As we all continue watching the stars, I know now more than ever that
no matter what life throws at us, no matter what the disagreement, me and
these girls are going to find our way back to each other. They’ve always
been my family when I felt like I didn’t have one and that is never going to
change.
OceanofPDF.com
FORTY-THREE
CONNOR/CAT
“JUST LIKE THAT.”
CONNOR
Sometimes I wonder how we’ve all managed to stay friends over the course
of our lives. As kids, we were all forced to spend time together given how
close our parents were, but when we got older, I thought that would fade. I
thought we’d all eventually get sick of each other and wake up one day and
realise that we’re no longer friends.
But that has never happened.
As much as Wes can get on my nerves and Archer can confuse the fuck
out of me, moving in with these two has to be the best decision I’ve ever
made. Archer might still be pretending he doesn’t enjoy our company, but
he didn’t back down when I suggested going ice skating in the middle of
April for the fun of it.
It’s the middle of the week and we’ve all got a day off from lectures and
seminars, so I suggested we could do something fun together. After arguing
in the groupchat back and forth for the most of the day, we finally managed
to book a slot at the rink for the last hour it’s open.
“This is great family bonding,” Wes mumbles, gripping onto my arm for
dear life as we skate around the rink. He’s a fucking mess on the ice, but
I’m getting a kick out of watching the fear in his eyes whenever he thinks
he’s going to fall. He leans over me to look at Cat. “How’s it feel? You’re
going to officially be a football girlfriend next season, Cat. Are you ready
for it?”
She squeezes my hand. “As I’ll ever be.”
“Wait, isn’t there a Taylor Swift song about a football player?” I ask and
then I do the worst thing I could do, and start singing. “She wears short
skirts and you wear T-shirts. She's the cheer captain and I’m on the
bleachers.” They both blink at me as if I’ve said the most ridiculous thing
ever. I’m sure those lyrics are somewhat accurate. I bump my shoulder into
Cat’s. “That’s going to be us, baby.”
She snorts, shaking her head. “That’s not what the song is about.”
“Really? I thought it was about football?” I ask.
“You’re going to have to educate him, Cat. Trust me, I’ve tried,” Nora
shouts. I ignore her and let Catherine’s laugh soothe my annoyance. The
Taylor Swift universe is too complex for me to understand right now.
“I’m enjoying this way more than I should,” Archer admits. His voice is
low and quiet, but we all hear him.
Cat barks out another laugh beside me, trying to tug me forward, but
Wes keeps pulling me back. She’s a fantastic skater. Of course she is.
We didn’t go to this rink much as kids because our parents thought it
was too dangerous. Being the perfect child she is, she managed to convince
her parents to do a summer of skating lessons since Elle was taking them.
Nora was too caught up with theatre camp, so she’s also stumbling
alongside Wes.
Elle speeds past us in the nearly empty rink, skating backwards. “Is
Archer Elliot finally admitting that he can have fun?”
“I can have fun, Harper,” he murmurs. She smiles, shrugging as she
spins away. Archer stares at her, completely taken away with her talent as
she glides and turns on the ice. We’ve been to enough of her recitals over
the years to know she’s a good dancer, but I swear we all almost lose our
breath as we watch her. It’s fucking insane.
Wes bumps his shoulder into mine, but he’s the one who stumbles more
than I do. “Did you see that?”
“See what?” I ask, letting Cat guide me so I can skate better. Wes turns
around and I follow his gaze as Archer skates at the slowest pace known to
man whilst Elle and Nora spin around. Well, Elle’s the one who can spin
properly, Nora is just doing her own thing. “Oh, that.”
Wes shakes his head. “The guy hardly says a word to us for two years,
but whenever Elle’s around he’s suddenly Mr Popular. It’s fucking weird.”
I scoff. “Speak for yourself. Me and Archer can have a conversation.”
“You mean the two minute one you had on your birthday, six months
ago?” he retorts, laughing at his own joke. I roll my eyes and Cat laughs
beside me. The sound of her laugh is the only thing that stops me from
pushing Wes into the wall. I finally shrug him off and he teeters slightly as
he floats away. “Wait! You know I can’t skate well.” He’s shouting as if
we’re not the only few people left on the rink. “Connor!”
“You’ll figure it out,” I shout back to him as she pulls me towards the
exit of the rink.
He calls my name again and I ignore him, tightening my hand around
Catherine’s gloved one. She looks up at me, her brown eyes shining as she
laughs at Wes’s wailing. I love these moments with her. When she doesn’t
have to say anything. Where I know exactly how she’s feeling without
needing her to say the words.
CAT
OceanofPDF.com
EPILOGUE
5 MONTHS LATER
CONNOR
THE END
OceanofPDF.com
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Writing this book has been the greatest joy of my life. Nothing has ever
come to me so naturally, so freely and so openly.
Catherine’s story means so much to me for so many reasons. As a black
woman and as someone who grew up with a late mother, it’s not been easy.
Grief is such a weird thing, especially for someone you hardly knew. I’ve
spent thirteen years of my life without my mum and each day that goes by
serves as another reminder as to what I’m living for. She’s my star in the
sky, my saving grace, my solace. A lot of this story is for her as it is for me.
I cannot write a book without thanking everyone who pushed me to
write it. Although she hated me for putting off her favourite book in the NU
series, Ella has been an absolute angel for helping me with Catconnor. The
love I have for you is insane, and I am so grateful to have met you. Thank
you to Emma for being there right from the beginning until the end, leaving
unhinged comments and making beautiful edits. You are an absolute star,
and I know you’re going to continue to pester me for book two, which is
your favourite couple…
Thank you to all my friends on bookstagram, especially Emily, Zil,
Meena, Mylla, Romi, Haya, Maine and Arwa who did the most amazing job
at beta reading for me. I genuinely would not have been able to finish this
book without you. A huge thank you for the millions of voice notes and
comments left by Emily, I appreciate you more than you’ll ever know.
Thank you to Alex, Niamh, Char, Kay, Keoni, Megan, and Soso for being
the cutest and sweetest team to ever exist. I appreciate you more than you
could ever know.
Thank you to my friends — my new ones at university and my friends
from home. I would not have the guts to even be doing this if it wasn’t for
your support and your constant kind messages. Thank you for always being
there when I needed a break and bringing me back to life. So, thank you,
Harriet, Ayela, Queenster, Christabel, Eva, Alannah, Olivia, Sadie and Amy
for being the most amazing friends ever. (I can’t wait to see you again.) And
to Pyro, Amy, Charlotte and Maisie for being there to listen to my delulu
thoughts and being down to go to Spoons whenever. I love and appreciate
you all so much.
Thank you to my amazing cover designer, Layla! You and your talent
needs to be appreciated by the world and I am so happy with the way it
turned out. A million purple roses for you for helping bring Cat and
Connor’s story to life. You’re incredible.
Thank you to every single person who has picked up this book and
trusted me enough to take you on this journey. I would not be here without
you all. I love you more than words could describe.
OceanofPDF.com
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Janisha Boswell is an eighteen-year-old author who loves romance and sickly-sweet stories that make
her feel welcomed and comforted. Her first series of books is the 'North University' series, following
three college students navigating the truths of what their future careers may hold and the love and
hate that comes along with it. Her sophomore series is set at another college in Colorado, which will
consist of four interconnected stand-alones. Books hold a special place in her life, and they always
will as she writes heart-warming romantic and steamy books.
To keep up with Janisha and her book progress, you can follow her on these sites and check out
her Website. janishaboswell.com and janboswellauthor.com
OceanofPDF.com