All About Love - New Visions (PDFDrive)
All About Love - New Visions (PDFDrive)
All About Love - New Visions (PDFDrive)
www.britishcouncil.org/
climate-connection
#TheClimateConnection
The Climate
Connection
Global
Youth Letter
on Climate
Action:
final report
Acknowledgements
This report was commissioned by the British Council
from Catalyst in Communities (CIC) who are a not-for-profit
social enterprise specialising in youth engagement,
research, and training. CIC has a network of international
partners who were engaged for this project to connect
with young people, facilitate youth discussion and
collate youth views. This report is the result of the
contributions of the CIC team, CIC partners and in-country
advocates.
02
Contents
Executive summary 6
Young people and the climate challenge 6
The Global Youth Letter on Climate Action 7
Scope and scale 7
Key messages 8
Recommendations 9
Introduction 10
Objectives 11
Outputs 11
Methodology 12
Sampling approach 12
Instruments of analysis 12
Survey tools 12
Focus groups 12
Pilot study 13
Crowdsourcing eco-system 14
Way forward 27
Contents 03
Top-level findings
Participation by gender
1 2 3
43% 55% 2%
Prefer
Male Female
not to say
5 25% Rural
6 17% Peri-urban
41% Advanced
7 37% Intermediate
22% Elementary
04
Young people’s readiness
for climate action
(self-reported)
report that they have the skills to deal
8 75% with climate issues in their communities
05
Executive summary
1
See the 2020 British Council Soft Power Perceptions Research:
https://www.britishcouncil.org/research-policy-insight/policy-reports/2020-British-Council-soft-power-perceptions-research
2
“Conference of the Parties” is the decision-making body of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change
3
See Young People and Climate Change (a British Academy COP26 briefing):
https://www.thebritishacademy.ac.uk/documents/3285/Young-people-and-climate-change.pdf
06 Executive summary
The Global Youth discussions and online surveys, to engage young people
(aged 18 to 354) with varying levels of education
and skills. The surveys were disseminated digitally
Action
and geographical locations. To improve the validity
and credibility of survey data, the team also collected
data from people aged 26 to 35 through focus group
To lead the project, the British Council commissioned discussions and interviews.
not-for-profit social enterprise Catalyst in Communities
(CIC), that specialises in youth and community
engagement. CIC has a network of trusted international
partners who provided access to young people
facilitated youth discussion and collated youth views
in each country. These partners included universities,
Scope and scale
consultants and youth specialists, who connected The British Council chose to target 23 countries, based on
with their own in-country contacts to reach all members climate vulnerability, size of youth population and geo-
of the youth community and capture young people’s graphical spread. These were grouped into
voices on climate change. With these insights, three clusters, determined by the approach used to
they produced the Global Youth Letter on Climate Action, collect data.
and statements for each participating country, to engage
young people, inform discussions leading up to COP26 • Cluster A: countries where new data was gathered
and, ultimately, to influence real action. using the HyperVoice platform and tools:
Brazil, India, Indonesia, Kenya, Mexico, Nepal,
To increase participation and engagement, the research Nigeria, Philippines, South Africa, Turkey
team developed a brand for all research activities, and the United Arab Emirates.
called HyperVoice. Under this banner, they used
a crowdsourcing approach, combined with focus group • Cluster B: countries where data was taken
from the British Council’s Next Generation5
research and updated where possible6: Ethiopia,
Germany, Ireland, Italy, Myanmar, the UK, Vietnam
and Zimbabwe.
4
As schools in some rural areas cater for students aged 18 and above, some pupils were included in the exercise
5
Next Generation reports: https://www.britishcouncil.org/research-policy-insight/research-series/next-generation
6
The research team undertook a refresh of data in cluster B countries, to update the datasets not directly collected by the research team, although
this happened with limited success due to the short timeframes and COVID-19 restrictions, which limited the mobilisation of in-country teams
7
A total of 11,632 responses were gathered from clusters A and C
8
See Annex A for Global Youth Letter on Climate Action
Executive summary 07
Key messages
The strongest and most prominent message to come
from the research exercise was that across 23 countries,
there is a strong unanimous voice of young people
in relation to climate change.
While young people are willing and able to act – and, They should, therefore, be provided with easy access to
in many cases, believe they have the skills to do so – local and global literature and resources around climate
there is still a need for relevant education, training, science, climate action and resilience building. Commu-
public awareness and access to information, as these nication, creative problem-solving and active citizenship
are all critical for building the skills for effective climate skills should also be key learning priorities, so that young
action. They are aware that the climate challenge people can effectively relay their concerns and propose
is too big for them to tackle alone, yet they not only actions to their peers, families, communities and leaders.
lack avenues for active participation, but also the
climate literacy, language and leadership skills to
initiate climate action amongst their peers and within
their communities.
08 Executive summary
Recommendations
Based on this research, this report puts forward the
following key recommendations for policy makers
and national governments in relation to increasing
youth participation in the climate debate.
Executive summary 09
Introduction
approaches (online surveys, face-to-face focus groups,
WhatsApp groups, Basecamp groups), the project
gained access to hard-to-reach cohorts of
young people, largely from the Global South, and
from a diverse range of backgrounds (all aged 18 to 35).
The large number of young people who participated
through social channels – particularly Facebook,
Instagram and Twitter – is evidence of their active
engagement.
The Global Youth Letter on Climate Action research To reach young people from diverse backgrounds,
project aims to share the crowdsourced voices of young despite Covid-19 constraints, CIC, leading a team
people from 23 countries around the world, augmented of country-level partners,9 delivered a set of data nodes
with a mixed methodology approach to enable young across the 11 cluster A countries to frame the data
people to make contributions to discussions in the collected.10
run up to COP26 and beyond.
9
See list in appendices
10
While the project effectively reached diverse audiences, it was hampered by short timeframes, Covid-19 restrictions
and limited access to 18-25-year-olds
10 Introduction
Outputs
This report provides a summary of the views of
young people from countries in cluster A, while
offering insights from clusters B and C, where the
data was mainly quantitative.11
11
Quantitative data limits the ability to extract a ‘voice’ from target audiences, which was identified early in the study, resulting in a greater focus on
engaging young people with a climate change agenda (accounting for the high level of awareness from those engaged)
12
For cluster A, country-level researchers took the decision on whether to translate the survey; in most cases, the translated versions of the survey
saw less engagement than the English version (with the exception of the Portuguese and Spanish surveys)
13
Social media presence had to be built from scratch, and while some channels received significant interest, engagement was asynchronous,
mainly serving to educate users of Pre-COP26 and COP26 activities, which can be seen from the number of respondents who were aware
of COP26 and the UN Sustainable Development Goals; from this perspective, the HyperVoice social media campaign proved to be successful
from an educational perspective
14
This data went on to inform the Global Youth Letter on Climate Action
Introduction 11
Methodology
Sampling
approach
The study was delivered through national surveys,
focus groups and interviews.15 The same survey was
used for countries in clusters A and C (and data was
gathered in parallel through the respective research
projects). The target was to obtain a minimum sample
size of 500 survey responses in each country.
The surveys primarily targeted young people
(aged 18 to 25) and covered different occupations, The British Council provided the research team with
genders and geographical locations. Data was taken a survey for collecting data in cluster A countries, which
from nine Next Generation countries (cluster B) was also used in cluster C. This survey was informed
to broaden the scope of the study. by the datasets available for countries in cluster B17
(Next Generation research). Where possible, the structure
The approach to data collection was adapted to of the survey used in cluster A was kept as close as
national and local contexts, and used a mix of online possible to that used in cluster C, so data could be
tools, mobile applications, gamification devices cross-referenced easily. However, some revisions
and focus group discussions, engaging with over were made after the pilot, in consultation with the
200 national partners in hard-to-reach areas. The data, project team, to increase engagement amongst the
gathered through surveys, focus groups, interviews target audience.
and the Next Generation datasets, provided a sound
evidence base for data triangulation to generate Considering ’survey fatigue’ due to Covid-19, and
credible insights. to ensure a higher completion rate, the team kept
the number of questions to a conservative level,
Instruments
thus improving the likelihood of survey completion.18
Focus groups
of analysis The focus groups were held after the first iteration
of the survey, so those running the focus groups could
Survey tools account for any biases or themes that emerged from
the initial dataset. Focus groups were held either
As a mixed methodology approach was employed, face-to-face (where Covid-19 constraints allowed), or on
structured and semi-structured tools were used for platforms like Basecamp, WhatsApp and Zoom. There
the surveys, focus groups and interviews.16 These tools were also some online focus groups.
were designed with key assessment markers, including
parameters for gauging: Data was analysed in four stages.
These tools helped to generate more diverse insights The focus groups were designed to complement the
across the target countries. quantitative exercise, and enabled the team to explore
the quantitative results in more depth with young people.
15
See: https://www.hypervoicecop26.com/focus-groups/
16
See: https://www.hypervoicecop26.com/focus-groups/
17
The questionnaires used for the Next Generation research were diverse and only generated limited data to inform this research
18
See: https://forms.gle/MAJnDJjE9CiHfQRb8
12 Methodology
They also helped to ensure that any underrepresented
parts of the target population not reached via the survey
Pilot study
could be included. As there was limited time available to extract suitable
data to support the development of the Global Youth
The project delivery team developed a strategy that Letter on Climate Action, different approaches were
aimed to balance the limitations of the online focus applied in some target countries. All networks were
groups with face-to-face approaches, to address engaged with a clear agenda to assess young people’s
some of the initial weaknesses that had been identified views on climate change and to promote transparency
in the pilot rollout phases. These were: in terms of how their voices could feed into COP26
and related events.
a. limited reach into the young unemployed
and NEET19 communities The team initially deployed a cluster A survey link
b. bias towards urban communities. to generate datasets, to assess the reach of the
country-level teams and to refine the survey tool.21
Each country was free to adapt the qualitative approach Kenya was selected as a pilot country, given the
and questions for their national and regional contexts. in-country partners were already in place. The pilot
However, the core questions remained consistent generated 21 responses and allowed the team to
at the baseline across all countries. This qualitative refine the survey tool21 and generate more qualitative
approach enhanced the cross-country contextual data to support research exercises.
evaluations and assisted in extracting and validating
a consistent voice to support the final narrative. It was evident from the pilot that a purely data driven
exercise (i.e., surveys) would not provide enough
The methodology, tools, analysis and report were insights to develop the Global Youth Letter on
independently reviewed and approved by an external Climate Action. It was, therefore, decided to supplement
Ethics Committee led by Professor Jeff Gow.20 It was the quantitative data with additional qualitative data
recognised that listing climate change as an issue through focus groups and interviews, to generate
might lead to selection bias, but this was inevitable sentiment that could be analysed. While the use of
given the need to extract young people’s voices about social media did generate responses on Facebook,
climate change specifically, plus the need to build the Twitter and Instagram, these channels were more
exercise around a social media campaign concurrently effective in educating and informing young people,
would inevitably lead to bias. This was mitigated with rather than drawing out sentiment. Plus, developing
the help of data triangulation, but was not eliminated, these social media channels from scratch over a period
and is identified as a limitation of the study. of eight weeks was unlikely to deliver the relevant
material for effective sentiment analysis.
19
Stands for ‘Not in Education, Employment or Training’
20
See: https://staffprofile.usq.edu.au/profile/jeffrey-gow
21
All tools used during the research were subject to process and ethics assessments to ensure the rigorousness of the data (within the limits applied);
however, given the time scales, tools and data collection strategies were deployed through various iterations, so for countries where online
surveys were less suitable, a shortened version was used (in line with the approved research strategy), to ensure baseline data and insights
could still be gathered
Methodology 13
The focus group strategy was hampered in most internet, including lack of electricity and connectivity.
countries by Covid-19 restrictions and had to be For context, studies24 state that just 11 per cent of people
digitally driven (i.e., Basecamp, WhatsApp, Facebook, in Burundi, 12 per cent in Chad, and 18 per cent in Malawi
Instagram, Twitter and online surveys). Through have electricity. These barriers must be addressed to
HyperVoice, CIC created focus groups across enable sustained engagement of excluded youth.’
all cluster A countries, as well as some cluster B (Italy)
and C (Pakistan and Sri Lanka) countries. The research team used crowdsourcing to raise
awareness of the issues by sharing the research link
Focus groups were used to obtain qualitative data via relevant blogs and news articles. This had the
and to attempt to compensate for any bias from advantage of generating fast and wide engagement
leading questions in the survey. The basic structure from potential participants, but also had the obvious
for the focus groups followed those previously bias that they would already have an interest in the
employed to generate the cluster B datasets, to ensure subject. However, it enabled the research team to
consistency. However, upon reviewing the cluster B have a presence on the social media platforms that
process, it was felt that there was potential bias in the young people use, strengthening engagement and
order of the questions, which was corrected to prevent participation and enabling them to reach less-heard
leading questions around climate change. National, young people.25 Given the timeframes of the study,
regional and global focus groups all took place. the effectiveness of this approach was limited, and
signalled the need for focus groups, discussed further
The HyperVoice platform managed to provide balanced below.
insights into the views of young people to the level
that could be achieved within the context of Covid-19 The team looked at social media use in each country
lockdowns. and targeted the most appropriate and popular apps
used by young people locally. Discussing these
social media platforms with the in-country experts
Crowdsourcing eco-system led to three key platforms being selected for
The research team used crowdsourcing22 to raise the research: Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.
awareness of the project and to obtain data on
youth perceptions on climate change from as many
young people as possible in each target country.
22
Crowdsourcing is the collation of information, opinions, work or funding to achieve a common goal, usually via social media or the internet.
It is the collective development of a project – generally on a voluntary basis, or by invitation – by a multitude of people outside the company
who launched it.
23
See OECD Perspectives on Global Development 2019: https://www.oecd.org/doev/Overview_EN_web.pdf (accessed 23 May 2021)
24
See: https://www.cisl.cam.ac.uk/news/blog/climate-talks-will-fail-without-more-young-peoples-voices
25
For the purposes of this project, the British Council defined ‘unheard’ as female, rural and unemployed
Brazil 557 31
India 946 80
Indonesia 588 64
Kenya 516 49
Mexico 511 36
Nepal 557 28
Nigeria 567 65
Philippines 537 37
South Africa 711 61
Turkey 529 45
United Arab Emirates 574 26
Total 6,593 522
Cluster C country Numbers of surveys Numbers of interviews
Afghanistan 1,194 12
Bangladesh 1,630 15
Pakistan 1,215 32
Sri Lanka 1,000 25
Total 5,039 84
Total A and C 11,632 606
Next Generation data for cluster B countries was updated where possible. Data for cluster C was collected
via the British Council’s research on youth perceptions in South Asia, and went on to inform both projects.26
26
The cluster C data in this report can be cross-referenced with finding of the British Council’s South Asia research on perceptions of young people
on climate change and action project to gain more insights
below by gender, location and employment status, to help build a mosaic of voices
from cluster A countries.
1. Females
A total of 2,943 respondents were female.
22%
25%
43%
58%
17%
35%
24.32%
Yes No
75.68%
Strongly Strongly
disagree 10.78% disagree 6.94%
Slightly Slightly
disagree 9.42% disagree 9.25%
Slightly Slightly
agree 28.10% agree 26.23%
Strongly Strongly
agree 33.74% agree 36.85%
27
All data is self-reported
2. Males
Male participation by area Male English ability (self-reported)
22%
24%
39%
60%
15%
39%
I have the skills to deal with climate change I am familiar with the UN Sustainable
in the community Development Goals
Strongly
disagree 9.61%
Slightly
26.61% disagree 6.22%
Neither agree
nor disagree 18.92%
73.39%
Slightly
agree 27.84%
Strongly
agree 37.41%
Yes No
Strongly
disagree 11.79%
Slightly
disagree 6.86%
Neither agree
nor disagree 21.36%
Slightly
agree 26.93%
Strongly
agree 33.06%
3. Urban
Cluster A : urban English ability (self-reported)
2%
15%
44%
52%
54% 33%
I have the skills to deal with climate change I am familiar with the UN Sustainable
in the community Development Goals
Strongly
disagree 9.45%
Slightly
26.58% disagree 7.87%
Neither agree
nor disagree 18.64%
73.42%
Slightly
agree 26.57%
Strongly
agree 37.47%
Yes No
Strongly
disagree 11.99%
Slightly
disagree 9.37%
Neither agree
nor disagree 21.52%
Slightly
agree 25.42%
Strongly
agree 31.71%
4. Peri-urban
Cluster A : peri-urban English ability (self-reported)
4%
16%
40% 41%
56%
43%
I have the skills to deal with climate change I am familiar with the UN Sustainable
in the community Development Goals
Strongly
disagree 8.94%
Slightly
30.76% disagree 11.62%
Neither agree
nor disagree 20.78%
69.24%
Slightly
agree 27.49%
Strongly
agree 31.17%
Yes No
Yes No
Strongly
disagree 11.40%
Slightly
disagree 8.16%
Neither agree
nor disagree 20.03%
Slightly
agree 27.49%
Strongly
agree 27.93%
5. Rural
A total of 1,344 respondents were from rural areas.
3%
16%
42% 43%
55%
41%
I have the skills to deal with climate change I am familiar with the UN Sustainable
in the community Development Goals
Strongly
disagree 4.99%
20.39% Slightly
disagree 6.10%
Neither agree
nor disagree 14.11%
79.61%
Slightly
agree 30.62%
Strongly
agree 41.15%
Yes No
Strongly
disagree 5.06%
Slightly
disagree 6.18%
Neither agree
nor disagree 18.45%
Slightly
agree 28.94%
Strongly
agree 41.37%
1%
36% 38%
42%
55%
26%
28%
36%
36%
I have the skills to deal with climate change I am familiar with the UN Sustainable
in the community Development Goals
Strongly
disagree 8.28%
Slightly
26.09% disagree 10.19%
Neither agree
nor disagree 11.78%
73.91%
Slightly
agree 31.10%
Strongly
agree 38.64%
Yes No
Strongly
disagree 6.58%
Slightly
disagree 7.43%
Neither agree
nor disagree 15.92%
Slightly
agree 25.37%
Strongly
agree 44.69%
24 Thematic analysis
2. Participation in policy intervention and advocacy
Young people want to be heard. And, ultimately, that
means not just being part of discussions on critical
matters, but also having a say in solutions. They want
to be a part of the policy making process, as this directly
impacts their lives, now and in the future.
Thematic analysis 25
3. Skills development (social media and green skills)
Policy makers need to recognise that many young people
feel leaders and decision-makers aren’t doing enough
to address climate change. They also need to value the
role and potential of young people in climate change
mitigation. Since a significant proportion of those
who participated in this research believe they have the
potential to make meaningful contributions to climate
action, there is a need to channel their passion and
enthusiasm in more practical and structured ways.
This means that governments and policy makers need
to identify the role young people can play, and give them
access to resources and training that can support them
in fulfilling their potential.
28
Towards a Green Economy: Pathways to Sustainable Development and Poverty Eradication:
https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/index.php?page=view&type=400&nr=126&menu=35
26 Thematic analysis
Way forward
Listen to us and understand the seriousness
of climate change and its impact on us,
our communities, and our countries. Involve
us and we can contribute to making positive
changes. We have the skills, drive and motivation,
just provide us with the opportunity.
29
For more information on British Council’s 8,000 Rising Campaign, see https://www.britishcouncil.org/climate-connection/get-involved/global-youth-letter
Way forward 27
Annexes and appendices
Annex A: The Global Youth Letter
on Climate Action (with introduction)
The Global Youth Letter The Global Youth Letter on Climate Action, and
accompanying 8,000 Rising campaign, is part of the
on Climate Action British Council’s The Climate Connection programme,
a global platform for dialogue, cooperation and action,
The Global Youth Letter on Climate Action is a call for
connecting millions of people through shared solutions
action from young people globally, directly addressing
to the climate crisis.
the leaders attending COP26 – the 26th UN Climate
Change Conference, in Glasgow, November 2021.
Young people are at the centre of this collaborative
approach, as we support them to raise their voices,
It is the result of a large-scale research exercise between
and gain the skills and networks to participate in
the British Council and not for profit social enterprise
meaningful dialogue and bring about real change
Catalyst in Communities, who used a mixed methodology
for our planet.
approach including crowdsourcing to garner the views,
experiences and aspirations of 8,000 young people
We hope the following letter inspires you to think
across 23 countries.
about your role in tackling climate change and
motivates you to take action in whatever way you can.
Aiming to be as representative as possible in terms of
gender, background, location and socio-economic status,
Find out more about the Global Youth Letter on
the research team worked through global Covid-19
Climate Action research, read the report, and join
restrictions to amplify the unheard voice of the climate
in the 8,000 Rising campaign here
debate: today’s young people. Research for the report
was carried out between January and March 2021.
Further reading
The Global Youth Letter on Climate Action was created
using qualitative and quantitative data gathered during
a large-scale research project commissioned by
the British Council, in 23 countries30 globally.
Key messages
The strongest and most prominent message to come
from the research exercise is that there is a strong,
unanimous voice of young people in relation to
climate change, across all 23 countries.
30
Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Brazil, Ethiopia, Germany, India, Indonesia, Ireland, Italy, Kenya, Mexico, Myanmar, Nepal, Nigeria, Pakistan, Philippines,
South Africa, Sri Lanka, Turkey, the UK, the United Arab Emirates, Vietnam and Zimbabwe.
31
While personal circumstances are relevant, the qualitative strategy needs to enhance the willingness to share opinions and not be too focused
on these factors. Such a generic question allows the respondent to lead and share what they consider important, and allows for them to recognise
the locus of control of the data extraction is firmly located with them.
32
The quantitative survey has generated a comprehensive list for each country and this question acts as a regulator for voice extraction, i.e.,
cross-referencing in a non-leading context.
33
From this category, Basecamp groups were managed to encourage dialogue and the honing of young people’ voices. The time frame limited the scope
for sentiment analysis; these tools were applied as datasets grew.
34
Focus group mediators were encouraged to generate dialogues on each of the goals and their significance in the country context.