REFX-IFRS16 and ASC 842 Document
REFX-IFRS16 and ASC 842 Document
REFX-IFRS16 and ASC 842 Document
Operating Lease
Accounting under ASC
842 Explained with a Full
Example
by Kiley Arnold, CPA, Sr. Product Marketing Manager | Mar 12, 2023
1. Operating lease treatment under ASC 842 vs. ASC 840:
What changed?
2. Operating lease vs. finance lease identification under
ASC 842
Transference of title/ownership to the lessee
Purchase option
Lease term for major part of the remaining economic
life of the asset
Present value represents “substantially all” of the
fair value of the asset
Asset specialization
3. Is lease capitalization required for all operating leases
under 842?
4. Operating lease accounting example and journal entries
Details on the example lease agreement
Step 1: Determine the lease term under ASC 840
Step 2: Determine the total lease payments under
GAAP
Step 3: Prepare the straight-line amortization
schedule under ASC 840
Step 4: On the ASC 842 effective date, determine the
total payments remaining
Step 5: Calculate the operating lease liability
Step 6: Calculate the right-of-use asset (with journal
entry)
1. Transference of title/ownership to
the lessee
Ownership of the underlying asset is transferred to
the lessee by the end of the lease term.
2. Purchase option
The lease arrangement grants the lessee an option to
purchase the asset, which is reasonably certain to be
exercised. It is important to note, the purchase option must
be reasonably certain to be exercised for this criteria to
met.
3. Lease term for major part of the
remaining economic life of the asset
The lease term spans a major part of the remaining
economic life of the underlying asset.
Note: The FASB provided additional clarification that “major
part” can be consistent with the 75% threshold used under
ASC 840. Companies are allowed to determine how they
will define the “major part” threshold. In practice, though, a
large portion of organizations tend to lean towards using the
75% threshold previously seen in ASC 840.
4. Present value represents
“substantially all” of the fair value of
the asset
The present value of the sum of the remaining lease
payments equals or exceeds substantially all of the
underlying asset’s fair value. If applicable, any residual
value guarantee by the lessee not already included in lease
payments is also included in the present value calculation.
Note: The FASB provided some additional clarification that
“substantially all” can be consistent with the 90% threshold
used under ASC 840. Here also, companies are allowed to
determine their own “substantially all” threshold, but in
practice the majority of entities are continuing to use 90%.
5. Asset specialization
The underlying asset is of such a specialized nature that it is
expected to have no alternative use to the lessor at the
end of the lease term.
Is lease capitalization
required for all operating
leases under 842?
An entity can establish an accounting policy to exclude
operating leases with a lease term of 12 months or less at
lease commencement (provided they also do not have a
purchase option that is reasonably certain of exercise)
from capitalization on the balance sheet. Further, while ASC
842 does not have an exclusion for low-value assets, some
companies have established a capitalization threshold.
Similar to a capitalization threshold for fixed assets, the
company has determined that leases below this value are
not material to the company and therefore, are not
recognized on the balance sheet.
What is a capital/finance
lease?
A capital lease, now referred to as a finance lease
under ASC 842, is a lease with the characteristics of an
owned asset. Under US GAAP, a lessee records the leased
asset for a finance lease as if they purchased it with funding
provided by the lessor.
As a refresher, an operating lease functions much like a
rental agreement; the lessee pays to use the asset but
doesn’t enjoy any of the economic benefits nor incur any of
the risks of ownership.
Finance lease vs. capital lease
Why will capital leases now be referred to as finance
leases? This is one of the changes to lease
accounting under the new lease accounting standards and
the reasoning behind it is simple. The existing nomenclature
of “capital lease” is no longer specific to one lease type
because the majority of leases will now
be capitalized (except those with a term of 12 months or
less at commencement). Hence, the new term, “finance
lease,” is used under ASC 842.
IFRS 16
IFRS 16 is the new international lease accounting standard.
This pronouncement also requires lessees to recognize a
lease liability calculated as the present value of the
expected lease payments and a related ROU asset. An
additional change in the IFRS guidance is that all leases will
be classified as finance leases, which differs from US GAAP.
This single model approach eliminates the operating lease
classification for lessees under IFRS. The standard’s
effective date was January 1, 2019.
While the lessee model for IFRS 16 is a single model
approach, for lessors the operating and finance
classification model continues. Lessors are required to
determine if a lease is classified as an operating or finance
lease and use the appropriate accounting treatment.
The main driver between operating and finance leases for
lessors under IFRS 16 is transfer of ownership. Lease
agreements where the lessor maintains ownership are
operating leases. For operating leases, the lessor continues
depreciating the leased asset and records the incoming
lease receipts as revenue on a straight-line basis over the
lease term.
IFRS 16 leases
What is considered a lease under IFRS 16?
2. IFRS 16 finance lease example (lessee)
Amortization schedule
Journal entries
3. IFRS 16 disclosures
4. Summary
IFRS 16 summary
Companies previously following the lease
accounting guidance under IAS 17 likely transitioned
to IFRS 16 during their 2019 fiscal year, in accordance with
the standard’s effective date of January 1, 2019, for annual
reporting periods beginning on or after that date. Therefore,
the standard is now effective for all organizations following
international accounting standards.
This article will walk through the key changes between
the lessee accounting model under IAS 17 and IFRS 16 and
also provide a comprehensive example of lessee accounting
under IFRS 16. The lessor accounting model under IFRS 16
remains relatively unchanged from IAS 17 and will not be
covered in this article.
Note: This article has been updated for the benefit of
organizations who have already transitioned to IFRS
16. Click here to read or download the previous version of
this article, which includes two transition examples.
IFRS 16 leases
Within the lessee accounting model under IFRS 16, there is
no longer a classification distinction between operating and
finance leases. Rather, now a single model approach exists
whereby all lessee leases post-adoption are reported as
finance leases. These leases are capitalized and presented
on the balance sheet as both assets, known as the right-of-
use (ROU) asset, and liabilities, unless subject to any of the
exemptions prescribed by the standard.
Similar to finance lease accounting under IAS 17, the
accounting treatment for finance leases under IFRS 16
results in the recognition of both depreciation and interest
expense on the income statement. For those entities dually
reporting under both IFRS 16 and ASC 842, you will notice
that the accounting for finance leases under IFRS 16
resembles the accounting for finance leases under ASC 842.
However, ASC 842 still retains the operating lease
classification.
In conjunction with the change in the lessee’s financial
statement presentation, IFRS 16 also requires more robust
disclosures.
Amortization schedule
Based on the facts above, we’ll take the following steps to
generate the IFRS 16 amortization schedule:
1. Calculate the initial lease liability as the present value
of the total remaining lease payments as of the
commencement date.
2. Calculate the initial right-of-use asset as the lease
liability at commencement plus or minus any necessary
adjustments.
3. Amortize the lease liability over the lease term to
reflect both lease payments and interest on the liability
using the effective interest method.
4. Depreciate the ROU asset in a systematic and rational
manner over the useful life of the underlying asset or
the lease term, whichever is shorter.
Using the values noted above, the amortization schedule at
the commencement date of the lease is as follows:
To calculate the present value of the future lease
payments, apply the lessee’s incremental borrowing rate of
6%. Per IFRS 16, lessees are encouraged to use the rate
implicit in their lease. However, if that is not readily
determinable, then a lessee is provided further leeway to
use their incremental borrowing rate as we have done in this
example.
As we can see in the above schedule, because no
adjustments were necessary to calculate the opening ROU
asset at commencement, the ROU asset is equal to the
lease liability. Thereafter the ROU asset is depreciated in a
systematic and rational manner (e.g. straight-line in our
case) over the lesser of the lease term or useful life of the
underlying asset. In our example, the ROU asset is
depreciated over the 10-year lease term, which is shorter
than the leased asset’s useful life of 25 years.
Journal entries
The initial journal entry under IFRS 16 records the asset and
liability on the balance sheet as of the lease commencement
date. Below we present the entry recorded as of 1/1/2021 for
our example:
U
tilizing the amortization table, the journal entry for the end
of the first period is as follows:
IFRS 16 disclosures
Now let’s cover the disclosure requirements for lessees
under IFRS 16. Within the notes to the financial statements,
an entity is expected to present both qualitative and
quantitative disclosures regarding their leasing activities for
the respective reporting period(s). The quantitative
disclosures required by IFRS 16 for lessees include but are
not limited to:
The carrying amount of all ROU assets summarized by
asset class as of the end of the reporting period
ROU asset depreciation expense, summarized by asset
class for the reporting period
Total interest expense on lease liabilities for the
reporting period
Expenses from short-term leases not included on the
balance sheet as of the end of the reporting period
Expenses from low-value asset leases not included on
the balance sheet as of the end of the reporting period
or in the expense summary of short-term leases for the
reporting period
Expenses from variable lease payments excluded from
the lease liability calculation
Sublease income for the reporting period
Any gains or losses recognized from sale-leaseback
transactions
Total cash outflows for leases
Any ROU asset additions
A maturity analysis of all lease liabilities as of the end
of the period
Furthermore, the lessee is required to disclose certain
qualitative information to help financial statement users
understand the entity’s leases and leasing activities,
including the following:
Summary of leasing activities
Commitments for leases not yet commenced (i.e. a
liability is not yet recorded on the balance sheet)
Summary
This concludes our high-level overview of IFRS 16. We
introduced the key differences for lessee accounting under
IAS 17 and IFRS 16, provided an example of a lessee
amortization schedule and the related journal entries, and
discussed the required disclosures.