1124 NMN
1124 NMN
1124 NMN
net/publication/377076400
CITATIONS READS
0 42
2 authors:
All content following this page was uploaded by Ahmed Mohammed Abbas on 02 January 2024.
تصميم وتحليل أداء األلكترودات في مكائن القطع بالشرارة الكهربائية لتحسين عملية التشغيل
2
علي عبار خليف،1احمد محمد عباس
.العراق/ الجامعة التقنية الشمالية/ المعهد التقني – الحويجة/ قسم التقنيات الميكانيكية1
. العراق- بغداد/ الجامعة التكنولوجية/ قسم هندسة االنتاج والمعادن2
الخالصة
) واحدة من أكثر مكائن التشغيل كفاءة في عمليات التصنيع في استخدام الطاقةEDM( تعتبر مكائن التشغيل بالشرارة الكهربائية
. وبغض النظر عن الخصائص الميكانيكية للمواد،خصوصا ً تلك الصناعات التي تتطلب الدقة العالية وألي مادة موصلة للكهرباء
العدد، بما في ذلك صناعة الطيران،في هذه العملية التي ال تالمس العدة المشغولة فهي منتشرة وتُستخدم في كثير من الصناعات
على الرغم من. وهي مفيدة بشكل خاص للمواد الصلدة ذات األشكال الهندسية البسيطة أو المعقدة، واألدوات الطبية،والقوالب
إال أن خصائص. في تشغيل المعادن "التي يصعب تشغيلها" مثل تلك المستخدمة في صناعات القوالبEDM استخدام مكائن
.المعدن تشير الى االمكانية المحتملة في مجال معالجة السطح بسبب الشرارة الكهربائية التي تحدث بين األلكترود ومادة المشغولة
باستخدام معظم المتغيرات المؤثرة وكيف يمكن أن تساهم زوايا األلكترود علىX210 في هذا البحث تم دراسة الصلب السبائكي
، والتي تستخدمها المصانع لصنع عدد القوالب، والخشونة السطحية، نسبة تآكل األلكترود، معدل ازالة المعدن:المخرجات مثل
استخدمت مكائن سلك الشرارة، في تشغيل العينات90º و0º أُستخدمت األلكترودات بزوايا. وغيرها،وأجزاء السيارات
، وتيار تفريغ النبضة، التيار، زاوية األلكترود: متغيرات هذه الدراسة كانت. لتصنيع األلكتروداتWEDM (dk7740)الكهربائي
أُجريت دراسة على هذه المتغيرات ثم أُجري تحليل تأثيرات، في حين أن جميع المتغيرات األخرى ثابتة،وتيار توقف النبضة
تطوير نماذج االنحدار.MINITAB باستخدام برنامجANOVA المتغيرات األربعة على المخرجات إحصائيًا باستخدام مبدأ
. لزيادة اإلنتاجيةX210 تم تطوير النماذج الرياضية االنحدارية لعينات الصلب السبائكي.للمخرجات
. النمذجة، معدل ازالة المعدن، الخشونة، الشكل الهندسي لأللكترود، مكائن التشغيل بالشرارة:الكلمات الدالة
1.INTRODUCTION
Recent advancements in electronic products, granules in the gap are crucial for establishing
such as mobile phones, PDAs, and handheld steady machining conditions by improving
media players, have proven the need for items spark position distribution, and a dielectric that
with intricate and undercut designs. Electro- is too clean can lead to uncontrolled sparking
discharge machining (EDM) is a material [8]. This investigation presents an overview of
removal process that uses electric spark the modern technologies using the EDM
discharges to machine conductive materials [1]. process. Shukry works with electrodes made of
Alloy steel compressor and gas turbine carbon steel CK 60 for the workpiece and brass
fabrication are examples of promising for the tool, and these electrodes can have flat,
applications besides producing tools and molds conical, or spherical geometries. The material
from hard materials, such as high-hardness removal rate was shown to be most affected by
materials. The electrode (tool) and the the duty factor, i.e., the percentage of the ratio
workpiece are submerged in a fluid (dielectric) between pulse duration and total cycle time,
that carries an electrical current. During the and current in experiments. According to the
process, the anode and the cathode are placed results of this research, the electrode form
very close to one another, creating a plasma using a flat tool produced the highest MRR
stream [1, 2]. The process’s essence is compared to other electrode shapes [1].
converting electrical energy in the form of Nadeem et al. modified a standard tool design,
sparks into thermal energy. The electric spark including relief angles in the electrodes. The
occurs when the distance between the tool and workpiece and electrode were made of WC and
the electrode is close enough to create a micro- copper, respectively; when it came to relief, the
conductive ionized channel [3]. Alloy tool steel angled tool electrodes behaved better than their
is used for various purposes, from cutting tools cylindrical counterparts. The machining time
and hammers to stamping and metalworking has been cut by 49% due to the relief-angled
molds and machine parts. The enormous electrodes [4]. Electric machining of tool steel
demand for tools, tooling, dies, and molds is by Hanan et al. analyzed the effect of the tip
due to the extensive use of these items in angle and tip radius of a copper electrode tool
production. How likely a discharge is (AISI D2). Compared to other electrodes, it was
determined by how easily electricity can be discovered that the conical electrode with a
broken down within the spark gap [4, 5]. Any radius of 1 mm delivered the highest MRR,
point between the two electrodes will while the conical electrode with a radius of 0
experience a more severe electrical breakdown mm offered the lowest EWR [9]. Uhlmann et al.
if debris is present. This debris can cause explored how changing the electrodes' exterior
unstable electrical conditions; thus, flushing is shape on cylindrical tools could improve the
performed under standard machining settings efficiency of electric discharge drilling. Brass
to remove it from the cutting gap [6, 7]. Debris electrodes with helical flutes along the shank
were compared to the standard form of a tool with a stepped cylindrical shape consisting
cylindrical rod electrode to determine which is of a (body), "shank," and "neck," and a
more effective at clearing out waste. The workpiece of AISI P20 (Step-cylinder). The
drilling EDM method might be improved by percentage of wear was lower, and the MRR was
setting a minimum flute depth and angle[6, 10]. higher than conventional electrode
By employing the EDM method of cutting high- instruments. Electrodes with a higher surface
speed steel, Asaad and Maan investigated the roughness than the normal shape [16].
impact of various parameters on the material According to Naveed et al., a Taguchi L9 array
removal and wear rates with five forms of was used for multiple positive-voltage
electrode tool (triangle, square, circular, electrodes, i.e., graphite, aluminum, copper,
cylindrical solid, and polygon). The results and brass. Also, a Taguchi L9 array was utilized
indicated that the rectangular geometry of the for many negative-voltage electrodes.
electrode holes was the most effective electrode Consequently, 72 separate trials were
shape. With the same form, the best electrode conducted. To obtain the lowest possible levels
wear ratio was added. The electrode with the of tool wear and overcut (OC) around the
square hole had the highest MRR [11]. Micro machined surfaces, it is necessary to study the
precision in mold manufacture was nature of these responses. A tool with common
investigated by Pellicer et al., who examined the tool polarity was selected as optimal to achieve
impact of different EDM machining parameters the assessment approach of least tool wear and
and tool steel electrode shapes. Various minimal level OC [17]. The height of re-sticky
electrode geometries, i.e., flat, depth, slope, and particles decreased with increasing lift
width, and AISI H13 workpieces were studied. distance, as previously observed by Shih-Hsien
Regular polygons like rectangles and squares and Wang and throughout the current
best illustrated high precision in groove investigation. However, the finished product
processing due to their high EWR and stable exhibited a slight degree of material re-
machining. Due to rapid wear along the stickiness. However, almost 90 μm of height
electrode's triangular edges, this tool is was generated. Further, after a piece of the
ineffective [12]. Pani and Masanta investigated electrode was cut from the base of the trash re-
a copper-based hexagonal electrode tool sticky to the cylinder rod along its longitudinal
through a series of tests. A plate made from Al axis, the machined surface would gradually
alloy (A6063) was used in the production diminish. When the width of a specialized
process. This study's findings were used to electrode was 0.6D, re-sticky debris was also
refine the regression method, and RSM was minimized. The issue completely vanished [18].
employed to highlight the connection between Kliuev investigated a method to capture high-
stimulus and effect. A giant crater was created, speed, microscopic images of an EDM drill bit
and the rate at which material was removed, as in action. The average workpiece speed in the
the high current and spark output, was electrode's outflow area was 0.9 m/s, while the
increased. No interaction between the duty electrode was nearing the condition. In the
factor and pulse-on-time affects the removal second scenario, the electrode was situated
rate [13]. Tool steel P20 was the workpiece for inside the eroded cavity, and the average gap
Shailesh Kumar's presentation of a hollow U- velocity was 0.75 m/s [19].
shaped copper electrode tool with an internal 2.EXPERIMENTAL WORK
flushing mechanism; this steel is crucial in the This experimental investigation determines the
fabrication of mold steel. Taguchi analysis was effects of varying the electrode angle, current,
used to determine the optimal values for three pulse-on, and pulse-off times for an Electric
machining parameters, i.e., pulse on time, tool Discharge Machine while machining an Alloy
diameter, and discharging current. This study steel X210 workpiece (see Fig. 1). A detailed
demonstrated that current significantly research technique is offered, including
affected MRR, increasing MRR with current. guidelines for conducting experiments,
Tool wear can also be affected by the presence analyzing data, and drawing conclusions. As a
of current. The current discharge has a far more result of its high efficiency, copper was selected
significant effect on overcut than the pulse on as the electrode material for this experiment
time [14]. Kamlesh and Patel utilized an (see Fig. 2). (CM 323C+50N) EDM machine
ANOVA analysis with a few factors. Four copper was used in this study. Chemical composition
electrode tool shapes were employed with steel was analyzed by an ARL spectrometer in North
(AISI) H13 utilized primarily in tooling dies: Gas Company (NGC)-Kirkuk/Iraq. The X210
rectangular, square, triangle, and round. Alloy tool steel employed in the present
Electrode shape was an essential aspect investigation is the subject of the possible
affecting performance evaluations. Electrode process parameters for the objective response
shape contributed between ten and twenty parameters. The chemical elements of Tool
percent to analyses of variance and signal-to- steel X210 alloy are provided in Table 1.
noise ratios [15]. For drilling large holes, Electrodes with 0° and 90° angles have been
Jamkamon and Janmanee relied on a copper produced.
5.RESPONSE-BASED VARIABLE
Material Removal Rate quantifies the efficacy of
any machining technique, including electrical
discharge machining (EDM). The EDMs’ ability
to calculate a volume cut-to-machining-time
ratio allowed for accurate estimation of
material removal. Therefore, mathematically
[21].
𝑊 −𝑊
𝑀𝑅𝑅 = 𝑖 𝑓 (1)
Fig. 1 Machined Workpiece by EDM Process. 𝑡 .ρ
where 𝑊𝑖 = initial weight before machining
(gm), 𝑊𝑓 = final weight after machining (gm), t
= machining time (min), and ρ= density of
workpiece (gm/mm3).
As in the MRR procedure, the workpiece
replaced an electrode. The equation for
Electrode wear ratio (EWR) is stated according
to [21]:
W𝑖𝑒 −W𝑓𝑒
𝐸𝑊𝑅 = (2)
𝜌𝑒 𝑡
where W𝑖𝑒 = initial weight of electrode before
machining (gm)
W𝑓𝑒 = final weight of electrode after machining
(gm), t = machining time, and ρe = electrode
Fig. 2 Copper Electrode with a Transverse
density (gm/mm3).
Hole.
The essential parameter Ra was used to
3.ANGLED ELECTRODE quantify the roughness of a surface; it is
A copper electrode was selected as the material obtained from the ratio of the highest and
electrode, and the process parameters that lowest points on a surface, which is then
might yield the desired value of response averaged over a given length [22]. In this study,
variables were identified. Two electrodes, one Ra was measured using a Pocket Surf III/ PMD
at an angle of 0° and the other at an angle of 90101 from the (Mahr Federal) company in the
90°, were designed, and a transverse hole was USA, with an accuracy of 0.05. All the acquired
drilled into them. Throughout this work, Fig. 3 variables for each controlled parameter set are
displays a comparison between the listed in Table 3. Minitab's analysis of variance
conventional and the novel electrodes [20]. (ANOVA) is a standard tool for examining
potential differences in the response
parameters' standard deviations. The central
hypothesis of ANOVA argues that any changes
made to the controllable variables or
interactions would result in similar changes to
the parameters measuring the mean response
[23]. The results showed that the parameters'
and interactions' impact on the variables was
Fig. 3 Angled Electrodes. negligible. The hypothesis suggested a
0, 90: EA (degree)
15, 35: Current (A)
60,300: Pon (µs)
20,140: Poff (µs)
0, 90: EA (degree)
15, 35: Current (A)
60,300: Pon (µs)
20,140: Poff (µs)
Hexagonal Shaped Tool Electrode. [21] Meshram DB, Puri YM, Ambade S, Gohil
Materials Today: Proceedings 2019; 18 V, Navnage GR. (2022). An Approach
:2723-2730. for Machining Curve Cooling Hole in
[14] Dewangan SK. Experimental Plastic Injection Mold. In
Investigation of Machining Computational Intelligence in
Parameters for EDM Using U- Manufacturing (pp. 23-46). Woodhead
Shaped Electrode of AISI P20 Tool Publishing.
Steel. M.Sc. Thesis. Department of [22] Davis R, Singh A, Amorim FL, Jackson
Mechanical Engineering National MJ, Sales WF. Effect of Tool Geometry
Institute of Technology Rourkela, India: on the Machining Characteristics
2010. Amid Sic Powder Mixed Electric
[15] Kamlesh V, Dave DSP. Influence of Discharge Drilling of Hybrid Metal
Electrode Geometry and Process Matrix Composite. Silicon 2020; 14(1)
Parameters on Surface Quality and :27-45.
MRR in Electrical Discharge [23] Ramakrishnan R, Karunamoorthy L.
Machining (EDM) of AISI H13. Modeling and Multi-Response
International Journal of Engineering Optimization of Inconel 718 on
Research and Applications 2012; 2(3): Machining of Cnc WEDM Process.
1498-1505. Journal of Materials Processing
[16] Jamkamon K, Janmanee P. Improving Technology 2008; 207(1-3):343-349.
Machining Performance for Deep [24] Kumar J, Soota T, Rajput SK, Saxena KK.
Hole Drilling in the Electrical Machining and Optimization of
Discharge Machining Process Using Zircaloy-2 Using Different Tool
a Step Cylindrical Electrode. Applied Electrodes. Materials and
Sciences 2021;11(5): 2084, (1-15). Manufacturing Processes 2021; 36(13)
[17] Ahmed N, Ishfaq K, Rafaqat M, Pervaiz S, :1513-1523.
Anwar S, Salah B. EDM of Ti-6Al-4V: [25] Oskueyan S, Abedini V,
Electrode and Polarity Selection for Hajialimohammadi A. Effects of Hybrid
Minimum Tool Wear Rate and Al2o3- Sio2 Nanoparticles in
Overcut. Materials and Manufacturing Deionized Water on the Removal
Processes 2019;34(7):769-778. Rate and Surface Roughness During
[18] Chou S-H, Wang AC. Investigating and Electrical Discharge Machining of
Removing the Re-Sticky Debris on Ti-6al-4v. Proceedings of the Institution
Tungsten Carbide in Electrical of Mechanical Engineers, Part E: Journal
Discharge Machining. The of Process Mechanical Engineering 2022;
International Journal of Advanced 236(3):1122-1133.
Manufacturing Technology 2014; 71(5- [26] Khan F, kumar J, Soota T. Optimization
8):1151-1158. of EDM Process Parameter for
[19] Kliuev M, Baumgart C, Wegener K. Fluid Stainless Steel D3. Materials Today:
Dynamics in Electrode Flushing Proceedings 2020; 25:635-638.
Channel and Electrode-Workpiece
Gap During EDM Drilling. Procedia
CIRP 2018; 68:254-259.
[20] Ahmed M. Abbas AAK. The Influence of
Angled Electrodes on Various
Characteristics in EDM Process -
Review Paper. Tikrit Journal of
Engineering Sciences 2023; 30(2):1-9.