Moscito Notes
Moscito Notes
Moscito Notes
Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. Hand Evaluation
3. Preemptive Opening Structure
4. Limited Opening Bids
5. Relay Auctions and the Strong Club Opening
6. Appendixes
1. Introduction
This document provides a complete description of the MOSCITO system that is currently
being played by Richard Willey. This document is largely based on Paul Marston’s
system notes, however, I have included some extensive expansions on his original system
notes in order to provide more explicit examples for new players.
I used a somewhat idiosyncratic structure in presenting this material. Most people think
of MOSCITO as a relay system. As such MOSCITO treatments often focus on
symmetric relay and strong game forcing auctions. In reality, the relay structures are
simply an enabling tool for the light and limited constructive openings that are the
cornerstone of the system.
The MOSCITO opening structure was designed to support a highly aggressive "quick-in /
quick-out" auction style. There is a significant advantage to being able to place the hands
in an acceptable contract as quickly as possible. This bidding style consistently forces
the opponents to guess whether or not to balance at a high level. Furthermore, if the
opponents are unable to exchange information during the bidding, they will often be
poorly positioned when defending hands. MOSCITO achieves this design goal by using
a descriptive and constructive opening structure in first and second seat, often allowing
responder to immediately place the final contract with a single bid.
The light and limited opening structure is anchored at the top by a strong club opening
that typically promises 15+ HCP. A comprehensive set of preemptive openings are uses
to describe hands that are too weak for a constructive opening bid. Chart 1 on the
following page provides a summary of the systems opening bids and provides basic
information regarding the relative frequency of the different openings.
the 1♥ opener's hand is relatively well defined. All that is known about declarer is that
he has 3+ card trump support, less than game invitational values, and denies a hand
suitable for an immediate fit showing jump.
Chart 1
Opening Frequency Summary Description
Pass 40.98%
1♣ 15.60% Strong, artificial, and forcing
1♦ 11.79% 4+ Hearts, could have longer minor
~ 9 - 14 HCP
1♥ 10.71% 4+ Spades, could have longer minor
~ 9 - 14 HCP
1♠ 3.89% 4+ Diamonds, unbalanced hand, could have longer clubs
~ 9 - 14 HCP
1N 6.81% 12 - 14 HCP balanced
2♣ 1.48% 6+ Clubs,
~ 9 - 14 HCP
2♦ 2.55% Mini-Multi, 6+ Hearts or 6+ Spades
2♥ 2.52% 5+ Hearts, undisciplined
~ 5 - 10 HCP
2♠ 2.55% 5+ Spades, undisciplined
~ 5 - 10 HCP
2N 0.64% Bad three level preempt in either minor
3♣ 0.43% Natural and constructive preempt
Promises two of the top three honors
3♦ 0.43% Natural and constructive preempt
Promises two of the top three honors
3♥ 0.79% Natural
3♠ 0.77% Natural
3N 0.11% Four level preempt in either minor
4♣ 0.12% NAMYATS
4♦ 0.12% NAMYATS
4♥ 0.12% Natural
4♠ 0.10% Natural
The MOSCITO system summary also provides a comprehensive description of
Symmetric Relay. When presenting the relay structures, I very deliberately chose the
ordering in which materials are presented. It is my belief that this provides the easiest
way to learn a relay system.
1. MOSCITO has recently adopted an improved response structure over the strong
club opening. This structure is based on
(a) An immediate 1♦ response to show most game forcing hands
(b) An immediate 1♠ response to show double negatives
(c) Most other bids show semi-positive hand patterns
2. The response structure over 1♦ and 1♥ openings was modified so that opener
immediately clarifies whether the length of his major is 4 cards or 5+.
3. The 2♦/2♥/2♠ opening bids were changed to incorporate assumed fit principles.
This document would never have been possible without extensive help from a wide
variety of sources. Paul Marston provided detailed copies of his own system notes and
tirelessly corrected my frequent misunderstanding. Hans Van Stavern ’s Dealer program
was my most important tool throughout this entire process. A wide number of bridge
partners including Kevin Wasserman, Patrik O'Hagen, and Brian Meadows tolerated my
all too frequent system edits and changes. Gunther Schutzenmeier provided tireless
proofreading and caught a truly terrifying number of typos and systemic misbids in
examples. Tim Goodwin also helped to clean up my all too frequent errors.
2. Hand Evaluation
Any good player starts to develop an instinctive feel for hand evaluation. In many ways,
trying to define a rigorous formula for hand evaluation is a hopeless task. However, for
the purpose of this document, it will be necessary to agree on certain hand evaluation
metrics. Most notably, the following metrics are used extensively both in describing the
system and defining the Dealer scripts that were used to simulate different openings.
Point Count refers to the original point count system used by the Four Aces.
Ace = 3
King = 2
Queen = 1
Jack = 0.5
10 = 0.25
Using Dealer, the function c13 is used to calculate the Point Count.
Ace = 3
King = 2
Queen = 1
Singleton Aces still count as 3 slam points. Singleton Kings and Queens do not count
towards Slam Points.
Kaplan Rubens Point Count [abbreviated as CCCC] is too complex to document here.
However, there is ample documentation describing this metric available on the web.
Using Dealer, the function CCCC is used to calculate Kaplan Rubens Point Count.
High Card Points abbreviated as HCP refers to the standard Milton Work Point count
system.
Ace = 4
King = 3
Queen = 2
Jack = 1
3. Preemptive Openings
Opening bids of 2♦ and higher are preemptive openings that complement MOSCITO's
limited opening bids. In particular, it is important to note that many 9-10 HCP hands with
5+ hearts or 5+ spades are opened with a high level opening bid. As a general rule, if an
unbalanced hand has 6 Slam Points [either an Ace, a King, and a Queen or alternatively
two Aces/three Kings …] I prefer to open with a limited opening bid.
Before describing the preemptive opening structure, it is worth noting the most
significant boundary conditions between the high level opening bids and the constructive
opening structure.
Single suited hands with 6 hearts or 6 spades may be opened with a multi-2♦.
A 2♦ opener could potentially hold up to 9-10 HCP with 6332 shape.
The 2♥ opening shows hands with 5+ hearts. A 2♥ opener could potentially
hold up to 9-10 HCP with 5332 shape.
The 2♠ opening shows hands with 5+ spades. A 2♠ opener could potentially
hold up to 9-10 HCP with 5332 shape.
The 3♣ opening shows a single suited hand with 6+ clubs headed by exactly 2
of the top three honors, and denies a side suit Ace or King. Holding AKQxxx
in clubs, 2♣ is the preferred opening bid.
The 3♦ opening shows a single suited hand with 6+ diamonds headed by
exactly 2 of the top 3 honors, and denies a side suit Ace or King. Holding
AKQxxx in diamonds, 1♠ is the preferred opening bid.
The Frelling 2 bid structure detailed in the Appendix represents an alternative preemptive
opening structure that seeks to maximize the obstructive elements of the system.
High Level Minor Suit Preempts
Much of high level MOSCITO bid structure is based on a set of recommendations from
the book Preempts from A to Z by Sabine Auken and Ron Anderson. Example hands can
be found in this book.
4NT Opening
The 4NT opening bid shows a constructive hand with either minor. The requirements for
this bid include:
Pass is to play
5♣ is pass or correct
5♥ shows first round control in hearts and the other minor and denies a spade
control
5♠ shows first round control in spades and the other minor and denies a heart
control
5NT shows first round control in both majors and denies a control in the other
minor
5♣/5♦ Openings
The 5♣/5♦ opening bids show weaker minor suit hands. The requirements for these bids
are:
In response to a 5m opening:
An eight or nine card broken minor suit headed by at least two of the top four
honors
No side suit Ace or King
6 to 6+ playing tricks at favorable vulnerability
7 to 7+ playing tricks at equal vulnerability
8 to 8+ playing tricks at unfavorable vulnerability
No four card major
In response to a 3N opening
This 4NT trump ask can also be used after the 4♦ shortness ask. After opener has
responded to the 4NT trump ask, new suits are a shortness ask in the bid suit.
3♣/3♦ Openings
The 3♣ and 3♦ promise a 6+ card suit with exactly two of the top three honors and deny
a side suit Ace or King . Responder will usually be well placed to determine the final
contract.
In response to a 3♣ or 3♦ opening:
The 2N opening shows a bad three level preempt in either minor. This opening is used to
describe hands that are too weak for a constructive 3♣ or 3♦ opening bid.
Playing these suggested methods, there is only one hand type that falls into a noticeable
gap. If opener is dealt a hand such as
♠ K7
♥ 64
♦ KQT8752
♣ 85
there could be a problem. Opener is too weak for a 1♠ or 2♣ opening bid. Opener is too
strong for 2NT and a 3♦ opening typically denies a side suit Ace or King. An opening
bid of 3♦ seems to be the smallest lie. Note: If you chose to pass, you may NEVER be
able to take a bid later on. If partner makes any bid, a Diamond bid by you during a
competitive auction will probably be interpreted as fit showing.
Change the King of Diamonds to the Ace or add in an additional side suit Queen and a
1♠ opening is preferred.
High Level Major Suit Preempts
4♣ and 4♦ Openings
4♣ and 4♦ are used as NAMYATS showing a good 4 level preempt in Hearts and
Spades. Hands that qualify for these openings promise:
In response
4♥ and 4♠ Openings
4♥ and 4♠ opening bids are natural bids, used to show weak 4 level preempts. The
opening bids promise a good seven or eight card suit. Non-vulnerable, the hand could
have two trump losers. Vulnerable, the hand should be able to play for one loser opposite
a singleton in partner's hand. Partner should not have more than one side suit Ace or
King. The hand should have seven playing tricks non-vulnerable and eight playing tricks
vulnerable.
New suits at the five level (or 4♠ over 4♥) are control asking bids
4NT is RKCB for partner's suit
Direct raises to 5M are invitations
- Pass shows more than 1 trump loser
- Six of the major shows one trump loser
- Cue bids show a second round control of a side suit and no trump losers
5NT is Grand Slam Forcing
- 6♣ shows a hand missing two of the top three trump honors
- 6♦ shows two of the top three honors, but denies the Ace or the King
- 6♥ shows the Ace and King of trump, but denies the Queen
- 6♠ shows the AKQ of trumps
3♥/3♠ Opening
3♥ and 3♠ openings are natural bids, typically promising at least 7 cards in the bid suit.
[Non vulnerable, you could potentially open a good six card suit with 6331 shape].
In response
A 2♦ opening shows a single suited hand with six Hearts or six Spades. The minimum
strength of the bid is about five HCP. Opener could be as strong as 10 HCP, however, if
opener has 9-10 HCP, he will almost certainly hold a sterile 6322 shape. Most hands
with 9-10 HCP with 6331 shape are better opened with either a limited opening bid or a
three level preempt.
In response to a 2♦ opening
The 2♥ and 2♠ opening bids are natural openings, showing 5+ cards in the bid suit.
These openings are extremely undisciplined and could easily be made on any shape
ranging from a semi-balanced 5332 hand to a radical 5530 two-suiter. The minimum
strength for the opening bid is about five HCP. Opener could be as strong as 10 HCP. If
opener has 9-10 HCP, then he will almost certainly hold a sterile 5332 shape.
If opener has six cards in his major, then he will also have a 4+ cards in a side suit.
New suits are natural and non-forcing. Responder is scrambling for a better
place to play
Raises are invitational to 4M
2NT is forcing for 1 round. Opener's rebids are
- New suit shows 4+ cards in the bid suit
- Three of the anchor suit shows a weak 5332 hand with ~ 5-7 HCP
- 3NT shows 5332 shape with 8 - 10 HCP
After a 2NT asking bid, a rebid of 3 of the anchor suit by responder is natural
and game forcing.
4. Limited Opening Bids
The MOSCITO system is based on two basic premises:
MOSCITO is designed to dominate the part score battle by consistently forcing the
opponents to guess whether or not to balance at the three level. Our goal for part score
hands is to conclude the auction with a natural and non-forcing bid at the two level or
three level as quickly as possible. Whenever possible, we seek to move immediately to a
contract of 2♥ or 2♠ when holding a known 7+ card major fit.
Opening Strength
Playing MOSCITO the minimum strength for an opening bid is significantly less than
when using a "standard" system. The following examples provide illustrations of
minimum strength opening bids
♠ 32 ♠ 64 ♠ AKT82 ♠9 ♠ J87643
♥ KJ74 ♥ A2 ♥ 65 ♥ AT9753 ♥ AK94
♦6 ♦ QT976 ♦ T2 ♦ A65 ♦6
♣ AJT932 ♣ K975 ♣ QT53 ♣ 842 ♣ 93
If it is ever necessary to describe the strength for a MOSCITO opening bid using a strict
High Card Point Scale, it is best to describe the bid as showing 9 to 14 HCP. In first and
second seat you should plan on opening most shapely 9 counts and balanced 11 counts.
Typically, in order to make a limited opening bid, a hand should have at least six Slam
Points. However, if a hand has at least 10 combined cards between two suits, it will often
be appropriate to make a limited opening bid with only five Slam Points.
Using Hans Van Stavern's Dealer program, the following algorithm is used to determine
the minimum strength for a limited opening bid.
opening_strength =
(
(
cccc(north) - 25 * shape(north, any 4441 + any 5440) >= 1050
or hcp(north) >= 11
)
The maximum strength for a limited opening bid is bounded by the strong club opening.
The 1C opening will be discussed in detail during a later chapter. However, the
following examples show hands that I consider to be slightly too weak for a Strong Club
opening despite holding 15 HCP.
The response structure to major suit openings is one of the most distinctive features of the
MOSCITO structure. In many bidding systems, the constructive response structure is
grounded on the fundamental assumption that the partnership is using sound opening
bids. Within the context of such an opening structure, it makes sense to devote large
portions of responder's bidding space to allow the partnership to accurately explore for
game and slam. The sound opening structure allows players to adopt treatments such as
2/1 game forcing responses. With a weak hand with no interest in game, responder can
use some kind of "utility" bid such as a forcing NT response. However, MOSCITO is a
light opening system. Opposite a typical MOSCITO limited opening bid, responder's
main concern is identifying a playable part score contract. In many cases, the limit of the
two hands might be 1NT or 2m.
Traditionally, light opening systems have used two different approaches to allow
practitioners to sign off at a low level opposite a weak and limited opening bid. One
approach that is very popular in Scandinavia is to have responder use transfers opposite a
limited opening bid. [An excellent example of this type of response structure is available
in the write-up describing Magic Diamond.] A second potential approach is to combine a
natural and non-forcing 2/1 structure for weak hands with a relay structure for strong
hand types.
The MOSCITO response structure rejects transfers for two main reasons:
Transfers do not put sufficient pressure on the opponents. Transfer bids are
intended as a forcing response. As such, the transfer positive response
provides an opponent in direct seat two separate chances to show his hand
type. Holding a strong hand, LHO can bid directly over the transfer bid. With
a weak hand, LHO will still have the opportunity to balance or pre-balance.
In contrast, opposite a natural and non-forcing 2/1 response LHO will be
forced to show many more hand types directly. It is worth noting that transfer
response structures are played by nearly all players who use a strong NT
opening. In contrast, most players who have adopted a 10-12 HCP mini-NT
opening use 2♥ and 2♠ responses as natural and non-forcing.
Typically, transfer responses are used with both weak and strong hand types.
In many cases, this can leave opener poorly placed during the competitive
auction because responder's hand is still unlimited. In contract, opposite a
natural and non-forcing 2/1 response, opener is well positioned to judge the
limit of the two hands.
The MOSCITO response structure over limited opening bids is designed to provide as
many options as possible to make natural and non-forcing responses to a limited opening.
Following responder's initial bid, opener is well positioned to judge the limit of the two
hands.
The MOSCITO opening structure is designed to clarify opener's major suit holdings as
quickly as possible. MOSCITO uses a 1♦ opening to show limited opening bids with 4+
Hearts. A 1♥ opening bid is used to show limited opening bids with 4+ Spades.
MOSCITO uses a major's first opening style. Most hands with 4 cards in a major and a
longer minor will initially show the major suit.
MOSCITO 2000 does NOT use any form of canape in the majors. Opener will always
open in his longer major. Holding 4-4 in the majors, opener will initially show Hearts.
Holding 5-5 in the majors, opener will initially show Spades. Adopting an opening
structure that uses canape in the majors would simplify some portions of the relay
response structure. For example, it is possible to design a very simply relay structure if
opener bids 1♦ with all hands with 4+ hearts, regardless of the length of the spade suit.
Despite the potential to simplify some aspects of the relay response structure, MOSCITO
2000 rejects canape in the majors because we believe that it is more important to
immediately clarify length relative length in the majors.
MOSCITO allows players significant flexibility in choosing whether or not to open 1M.
The system has significant overlap between the major suit opening range and the 1NT
opening range. MOSCITO’s 1NT opening promises 11+ - 14 HCP. If a player also
holds a 4 card major, he has the option of opening 1NT or 1M [Note: With 4333 or 3433
shape, a 1NT opening bid is mandated]
There are two logical schemes that can used determine whether or not to open 1M.
The first structure is designed to ensure that the major suit openings have some "bite” and
have some lead directing value. This structure also decreases the chance that you declare
2M with a trump holding of xxxx opposite xxx.
The second structure is designed to eliminate the chance that opener has a balanced hand
with game ambitions opposite a single raise. Following the auction 1M – 2M, responder
could hold a balanced hand with 10-11 HCP. If opener holds 13+ - 14 balanced, it is
conceivable that the partnership could have enough for game. Moving the maximum
strength balanced hands into the 1NT opening eliminates this possibility.
I prefer to use the first opening style. Better players than me disagree. However, either
style is playable as long as you and your partner are on the same wavelength. It must be
noted that regardless of what structure you chose to adopt, opener is still occasionally
forced to bid one major holding four small trump. Specifically, if opener holds a
major/minor two suiter with either a 5431 pattern or a 5422 pattern, he will be forced to
open his 4 card major regardless of suit quality. Also, holding a three suited hand
pattern, opener will need to open in his longer major.
Holding a weak four card major and a 6+ card minor, opener has the option of opening in
the minor suit. The choice is typically based on suit quality. Following the auctions 1♦ -
2♥ or 1♥ - 2♠, opener does not have the option to rebid 3♣ or 3♦ to suggest a better
place to play. This may affect the choice of opening bid with a six card minor and Qxxx
in a major.
Opener has the option of systematically lying about his shape if he can not tolerate
opening in a weak 4 card major. For example, holding ♠KQJ5 ♥5432 ♦5 ♣AK54,
opener should systemically open 1♦ showing hearts. However, opener has the option of
bidding 1♥, showing 4+ spades. If responder starts a relay sequence, opener intends to
describe his hand shape as a 5314 shape. Obviously, there is some potential danger in
misrepresenting shape, however, in this case, the discrepancy in major suit holdings so
extreme that I would recommend the 1♥ opening. If you are thinking about
misrepresenting shape during a relay sequence, try to avoid lying about a first or second
round control. Partner may be very upset when he bids a magical slam and you show up
with a small doubleton in a suit rather than the singleton that you promised.
Structure of Limited Opening Bids
The 1NT Opening
The 1NT Opening shows 12-14 HCP in a balanced or semi-balanced hand. The 1NT
opening denies a biddable 4 card major unless the hand is 4333. If opener shows a 4 card
major via Stayman or some form of super-accept, responder should note the implications
regarding suit quality.
The following hands are all good examples of 12-14 HCP NT openings
Notice that Hand 4 has a biddable spade suit. However, holding 4432 shape, opener
would need to open 1♦ if he wanted to start by opening in a major. Here opening 1NT is
clearly preferred. On hand 6, opener only has 11 HCP, however, the hand is still worth a
12-14 HCP NT opening. On hand 2, opener has a biddable major, however, holding
4333 shape there is no option other than a NT opening.
MOSCITO 2000 is compatible with any well constructed weak NT response structure. I
am personally partial to the Scanian NT response schedule.
The 2♣ Opening
The 2♣ opening shows one of two hand types: Opener will either have a single suited
hand pattern with 6+ clubs OR he will hold a two suited hand pattern with 6+ clubs and
an unbiddable 4 card major. [Holding 6+ clubs and 4 Diamonds, open 1♠]
3♣ = Preemptive
2N = Forcing for 1 round [Responder holds a strong hand that does not want to relay]
3N = Balanced Maximum
3♠ = Spade Shortage
3♥ = Heart Shortage
3♦ = Diamond Shortage
3♣ = Any minimum hand
2♠ = Natural, non-forcing
2♥ = Natural, non-forcing
2♦ = Relay
2♥ = 4 hearts and 6+ clubs
2♠ = 4 spades and 6+ clubs
2N+ = Single suited hands with clubs
The 1♠ Opening
The 1♠ opening shows unbalanced hand patterns with 4+ diamonds and no biddable 4
card major. The opening includes single suited hands with primary diamonds, two suited
hands with 6+ diamonds and a weak 4 card major, and two suited hand with both minors.
♠- ♠ AKJ ♠7 ♠ 853 ♠5
♥ J753 ♥K ♥ AJT ♥- ♥ 72
♦ AQ8752 ♦ QT9832 ♦ Q765 ♦ AK62 ♦ KT872
♣ K64 ♣ J65 ♣ AJT74 ♣ A87632 ♣ AQT72
Responder's double raise to 3♠ systemically shows any hand with 4-5 card trump support
that is too weak to invite game. The following hands all represent good examples of
direct raises to 3♠.
In particular, it should be noted that responder's systemic bid with a balanced hand with
6-9 HCP and four card spade support is to immediately preempt to 3♠. Potentially, the
limit of the two hands will be 2♠, but in this case the opponents should have a making
part score. On occasion, the opponents may be able to collect 300-500 defending 3♠
doubled. However, equally often we will be able to make 3♠ doubled or extract a
penalty of our own when the opponents are forced to an ugly four level contract.
Opener has the option of raising partner's 3♠ value raise. In some cases opener has a
sufficiently strong hand to hope to make game. In these cases, opener should hold a
shapely maximum hand with quick tricks and side suit controls. Hands like
all have the maximum HCP count for a 1♠ opening, however none of these really offers a
strong chance to make game opposite partner's 3♠ value raise. In contrast, any of the
following hands is worth an immediate raise to game
In some cases, opener will rebid 4♠ simply to further the preempt or take an advanced
sacrifice over the opponent's 4♥ contract.
Responder's single raise shows three card spade support and ~7-10 HCP.
In some cases, responder may chose to make a single raise holding a balanced hand with
four card spade support and between 3-5 HCP. For example, I would consider a raise to
2S holding the following hands
The advantage of allowing the raise to 2♠ on this hand type is that partner can not be
passed out in a three card heart fit with an eight card spade fit available. However, there
are two main dangers to making the raise. The first is that partner is going to expect
substantially more HCP strength and one less trump. You are going to be very poorly
positioned if partner decided to reopen the bidding with a penalty double. In particular, if
you decide to run to 3M, the opponents will often be able to find an easy penalty double
of their own. A second danger is that partner is comparatively likely to make a game try.
[The weaker responder's hand is, the more likely that opener will have sufficient strength
to explore game after a single raise] While your hand does provide an extra trump, it will
be significantly weaker than expected.
Holding a very weak hand with four card trump support and 0-3 HCP, responder can
often pass comfortably known that the opponents should have game in hand. Holding
such a hand, responder should either pass or bid and immediate 3♠.
Following the auction 1♥ - 2♠, opener should pass with any balanced hand. Opener
should also pass with a four card spade suit and a longer minor. If opener has such a
great discrepancy in the strength of the minor compared to the major that he would want
to play 3m, opener should have started with a 2♣ or 1♠ opening. In our experience,
exploring for a Moysian major suit game after 1♥ - 2♠ does not typically work well, so
we reject opener's rebid in a minor as a canape style long suit game try.
Opener’s Rebid
Following the auction 1♥ - 2♠, opener’s rebids are assigned precise meanings:
Responder can rebid 3♠ to reject the game try or 4♠ to accept the game try. 3♦
and 3♥ rebids are counter trials that show maximum hands with values in the bid
suit.
• 2NT = Maximum hand with 6331 shape. Responder can rebid 3♣ to ask for
shortage or show values with a 3♦ or 3♥ rebid.
Following the fit showing jump, opener will be well placed to judge the combined
potential of the two hands.
With hand 1, opener has an easy raise to 4S, counting on six club winners and 5-6 spades.
With the King of Hearts protected on the opening lead, the opener should expect to make
11 tricks.
Hand 2 also rates to be worth a jump to game. Opener has a control rich hand, excellent
spades opposite Hxx, and a fitting club honor.
In contrast, with hand 3 opener should pass. The hand is not worth playing in a game
contract. 3S does not look like a good contract since there will not be enough entries to
develop the club suit playing in a spade contract. Furthermore, the opponents rate to lead
trump against a spade contract cutting down possibilities for a cross-ruff.
With hand 4, Opener should also pass. The partnership has already reached the best
contract.
Hand 5 presents opener with an interesting choice. It is difficult to tell whether the hands
will play better in spades or clubs. Playing IMPs Opener should prefer to pass 3♣. This
bid puts more pressure on the opponents. If the opponents scramble to their diamond fit,
Opener can comfortably rebid 3S. However, 3♣ doesn't rate to be a good contract at MP.
Here I prefer to correct the contract to Spades.
I prefer not to make a fit showing jump with hands like the following.
Opener will not be able to accurately judge a holding Like Kxx in responder's long suit if
responder could jump shift with this weak a holding. With any of these hands, responder
should prefer a simple raise to 2♠.
The 1NT response to a major suit opening is played as a natural and non-forcing
response. The 1NT response denies primary or secondary support in a major. Holding
3+ card Spade support, responder will typically make a Spade raise. Holding a 5431
hand with a singleton spade, responder should prefer a 2/1 response into his 5 card suit.
As such, the 1NT response typically shows a 4432 or 5332 hand.
Opener's strongest rebids are 3♠ and 2NT. A 2NT rebid specifically promises a 6331
hand with game invitational values. Responder can rebid 3♣ to ask for shortage
[Opener's shortage will be shown using the standard High Shortage First structure, so a
3♦ rebid shows Heart shortage, 3♥ shows Diamond shortage, and 3♠ shows club
shortage] A 3♠ rebid typically shows a 7321 hand and is strongly invitational.
Opener's next strongest rebid is a jump shift in a new suit. This rebid shows at least 5-5
shape and a good hand. With a weak 5-5 hand, opener will make a simple rebid at the
two level.
Opener's rebid of 2♠ is natural and non-forcing promising a 6 card spade suit. This rebid
could be made holding decent value. [Recall that a minimum 6322 hand will open 2♦
rather than 1♥.]
After the auction 1♥ - 1NT, opener will pass with a balanced hand. Holding a 5332 hand
opener should typically pass [responder has already denied 3 card Spade support].
Holding any 5431 shape, opener will make a natural rebid in his second suit. If opener
rebids 2♥ after a 1♥ opening, he promises 5+ spades and 4+ hearts. If opener makes a
rebid of 2♣ or 2♦, he could hold either five spades and a four card minor or four spades
and a five card minor. Following the auction 1♥ - 1NT - 2♣ or 1♥ - 1NT - 2♦,
responder should take preference to 2♠ holding two card spade support and a 3 card
minor. This sequence promises exactly two card spade support and a 3+ card minor.
Opener will be well positioned to place the final contract. Holding a 5332 hand,
responder has the option of rebidding his 5 card suit at the 2 level. This will reveal his
complete shape. Holding 4 card support for opener's second suit, responder has the
option of passing or raising. The raise shows a better offense to defense ration]
Example Hands
Opener Responder
♠ AKQT32 ♠ 75
♥ AT8 ♥ Q543
♦4 ♦ KQJ5
♣ 542 ♣ T63
Opener Responder
1♥ 1NT 1♥ = 4+ spades, 1NT = natural, balanced
2NT 3♣ 2NT = 6331, game invitational, 3♣ = asking bid
3♥ 3♠ 3♥ = Diamond shortage, 3♠ = to play
Opener Responder
♠ AKQ543 ♠ J3
♥ 73 ♥ KQT9
♦ 82 ♦ T532
♣ Q93 ♣ K93
Opener Responder
1♥ 1NT 1♥ = 4+ spades, 1NT = natural, balanced
2♠ Pass 2♠ = 6+ spades, good hand
Opener Responder
♠ AQ763 ♠ KJ
♥5 ♥ J96
♦ 84 ♦ QJ92
♣ AK632 ♣ J987
Opener Responder
1♥ 1NT 1♥ = 4+ spades, 1NT = natural, balanced
3♣ Pass 3♣ = Maximum hand, 5-5 or better
Opener Responder
♠ AKT63 ♠ Q4
♥9 ♥ J652
♦ QT6 ♦ K732
♣ QT98 ♣ A76
Opener Responder
1♥ 1NT 1♥ = 4+ spades, 1NT = natural, balanced
2♣ 2♠ 2♣ = 2 suited, spades and clubs, 2♠ = 2 spades
Opener Responder
♠ A864 ♠ 75
♥ 984 ♥ J875
♦ A6432 ♦ K98
♣K ♣ AQT8
Opener Responder
1♥ 1NT 1♥ = 4+ spades, 1NT = natural, balanced
2♦ 2♠ 2♦ = 2 suited, spades and diamonds, 2♠ = 2 spades
3♦ 3♦ = 5+ diamonds and 4 spades
Opener Responder
♠ 96542 ♠ AJ
♥4 ♥ J875
♦ AJ72 ♦ KT83
♣ AQ3 ♣ T84
Opener Responder
1♥ 1NT 1♥ = 4+ spades, 1NT = natural, balanced
2♦ 3♦ 2♦ = 2 suited, spades and diamonds,
3♦ = 4 card diamond support, good ODR
Opener Responder
♠ KJ742 ♠ 83
♥ KJ ♥ J64
♦ AJ643 ♦ Q953
♣8 ♣ A864
Opener Responder
1♥ 1NT 1♥ = 4+ spades, 1NT = natural, balanced
2♦ Pass 2♦ = 2 suited, diamonds and spades
Pass = 4 card diamond support, poor ODR
Opener Responder
♠ T8742 ♠ K9
♥4 ♥ KT763
♦ AT2 ♦ Q75
♣ AKJ7 ♣ Q54
Opener Responder
1♥ 1NT 1♥ = 4+ spades, 1NT = natural, balanced
2♣ 2♥ 2♣ = 2 suited hand, Clubs and Spades, 2♥ = 2533 shape
2♠
The auction 1♥ - 2NT has a very precise meaning. 2NT is used to show any hand with
5+ hearts, 5+ cards in either minor, and game invitational values. This specific
convention needed to be adopted because this hand type presented an impossible rebid if
the auction started with a strong, artificial, and forcing 1♠ response. Remove this hand
type from the 1♠ response significantly improves constructive auctions following 1♥ -
1♠.
Opener will typically be well positioned to place the final contract. In particular, holding
primary heart support and a control rich hand, responder can often simply bounce the
auction to 4♥.
Holding hand 1, Opener should pass. Opener has a good hand, however, it’s best to be
cautious with a misfit. The chances that the partnership is missing a 10 card diamond suit
are minute.
Holding hand 2, opener should bid 3♦. If responder shows a maximum hand, opener
can bid 3N. If responder rebids 3♥ showing a minimum, opener can rebid 4♣. It is
doubtful that the partnership has enough controls for a 5m contract.
Holding hand 3, I would simply blast to 4♥. Odds are that it will make.
Holding hand 4, I would simply bid 3♥. Partner rates to have hearts and diamonds.
Responder's 2/1 is natural and non-forcing promising 5+ cards in the bid suit. Typically,
responder will either hold 6+ cards in the bid suit or a two suited hand with 5+ cards in
the bid suit and 4+ card side suit.
The following hands all represent good examples of 2♦ responses to a 1♥ opening bid.
Holding 4+ card support and less than a maximum hand, opener will make a
simple raise.
With any minimum hand with tolerance for responder's suit, opener will pass.
Holding a 6 card suit and a minimum hand, opener will rebid 2♠.
With a minimum two suited hand without tolerance for responder's suit,
opener will rebid a new suit at the two level.
Holding 4+ card support for responder's suit and a maximum hand, opener
will rebid 2NT.
Holding a self sufficient 6 card suit and game invitational values, opener will
make a jump rebid in Spades.
Holding a strong hand with at least 5-5 shape, opener will rebid his second
suit at the 3 level.
The following six hands were generated as illustrative examples of 1♥ openings opposite
a typical 2♦ response. Dealer's pre-deal function was used to assign
♠ T ♥J98 ♦KJT872 ♣K64 to responder.
Holding hand 2, opener should rebid 2NT showing a strong raise to 3♦. Here, I would
expect responder to rebid 3♦ showing a minimum hand. I don't see a convincing way to
bid the 20 point minor suit game.
Holding hand 3, opener should rebid 2♥. This shows 4+ hearts, 5+ spades and denies
tolerance for diamonds. Here, responder should pass, leaving the partnership to rest in
the 4-3 fit.
Holding hand 4, opener must pass. Potentially, the partnership could miss a 4-4 heart fit,
however, there is an assured 5-3 fit in diamonds. More significantly, the partnership
could be forced to the three level if responder holds a misfitting 1255 hand.
Holding hand 5, opener should make an immediate raise to 3♦. This promises 4+ card
diamond support and is preemptive in nature.
Holding hand 6, opener should rebid 3♣. This "high reverse" shows a strong hand with
at least 5-5 in the spades and clubs. Here, responder will pass with a minimum hand and
club tolerance.
Holding Hand 1, opener has an easy rebid of 2♠. Here, as responder, I would probably
pass. However, responder, might consider a raise to 3♠. Alternatively, responder could
rebid 2NT asking for shortage, intending to bid 4♠ if opener shows club shortage or heart
shortage.
Holding hand 2, opener should pass 2♦. Notice the disastrous consequences if opener
shows hearts holding a 5422 hand opposite responder's potential 1255 shape.
With hand 3, opener should rebid 2♥, natural and non-forcing. The partnership should be
able to find a 4-3 heart fit, a 5-2 spade fit, or a 5-3 club fit.
With hand 4, opener should simply jump to 4♠. If you feel conservative, you might
consider a 3♠ invitational rebid. According to Paul Marston, opener should simply blast
to game with a hand like
With hand 5, opener should rebid 4♣ as a splinter, showing a strong diamond raise with a
singleton or void in clubs.
Raise structure
4♦ = Splinter, 4+ card trump support
4♣ = Splinter, 4+ card trump support
3♠ = Splinter, 4+ card trump support
3♥ = Value raise. Unbalanced hand, 4+ card trump support
Making game will depend on controls rather than slow values.
3♦ = 3 hearts and 6+ diamonds, non-forcing
3♣ = 3 hearts and 6+ clubs, non-forcing
Response structure
Following the auction 1♦ - 2♦, opener's 3♣ rebid is a weak raise of clubs. Holding a
strong hand with clubs and diamonds, opener will start by rebidding 2NT showing a
strong raise of either minor. Responder will rebid 3♣ to show any minimum hand, 3♦
with a maximum with nothing to show, and 3♥/3♠ with a maximum and a fragment.
The other major difference occurs when opener wants to make a game try holding a 6331
hand after the auction 1♦ - 2♥ or 1♦ - 1NT. In both cases, opener shows the 6331 game
invitational hand by rebidding 2♠. Responder's 2NT rebid asks opener to place his
singleton [3♣ = spade shortage, 3♦ = diamond shortage, 3♥ = club shortage]. Opener's
2N rebid is artificial and shows Spades. This inversion of the 2♠ and 2NT rebids is
necessary to allow opener enough room to show all three 6331 hand types.
Competitive bidding after limited openings
We open 1♦/1♥/1♠
1. Double of 1 or 2 then bid is weak. 1♦ (2♣) X (P) 2♥ (P) 2♠ is say - AJxxxx, Jx,
Qxx, xx. double of a game overcall is cards. That is, a penalty double without
trump cards.
2. Single jumps are weak – double jumps are fit-showing. Game in non-oppo suit is
natural.
3. 2NT is natural.
4. Cue is good raise to next level+.
5. Double is negative to 4♠. Higher = cards.
6. They double - XX = values to compete, 2NT = good raise to three or more, Else =
as before.
7. They overcall UN2NT 3♣=good hearts, 3♦=good spades, 3♥/♠ = NF. Dbl = 3-
card raise, then all dbls = pens. Opener’s dble is T/O.
8. They bid Michaels - Dbl = 3-card raise, then dbl=pens (fit established). cue =
good raise New minor = force. Pass then dbl = pens. Opener’s dble is T/O.
9. Responder bids and they overcall - double is takeout.
10. If you responded with a natural notrump bid, your double is penalty. But the
opener’s first double is still takeout. E.g
Using Hans Van Stavern's Dealer Program, we use the following function to define
strong club openings.
one_club =
(
hcp(north)>=17
or
c13(north) >=1000
or
or
or
or
(
hcp(north)>=15 and
shape(north, any 4333 + any 4432 + any 5332 + any
5422)
and
c13(north) >= 900
)
)
The following hands are all examples of minimum strength Strong Club openings
♠- ♠ AQ32 ♠ KT ♠ AQT542 ♠T
♥ AJ85432 ♥- ♥ K4 ♥- ♥ AQJ983
♦ AKJ32 ♦63 ♦7 ♦ AK742 ♦-
♣9 ♣ AKT9652 ♣ AKT97542 ♣ T8 ♣ AQT874
Introduction to Symmetric Relay
This chapter provides an introduction to symmetric relay methods and assumes that the
reader has little to no experience with Symmetric Relay. Players who are already
experienced with symmetric relay may want to skim over this section. In presenting this
material, we have made the deliberate decision to focus on the relay responses
immediately following strong club openings. This structure presents symmetric relay in
its purest form and will provide the simplest introduction for new players.
Symmetric relay is based on a series of relay modules. Each module is used to describe a
different set of hand shape.
Module 1 describes single suited hand patterns. This module includes the 6322,
6331, 7321, and 7330 shapes. (Throughout the system, special provisions are
made for freak hand patterns)
Module 2 describes two suited hand patterns. This module includes the 5431,
5422, 6421, 5521, 5530, 6520, 6511, and 7411 shapes.
Module 3 describes 3 suited hand patterns. This module includes the 4441 and
5440 hand patterns.
Module 4 describes balanced hand patterns. This module includes the 4432,
5332, and 4333 shapes. [Balanced hand are described in a separate chapter]
The following chart provides a basic description of the response structure over the strong
club openings.
Chart 1
The most important point to understand about the relay structure is that responder to relay
does not show his longest suit first. For example, RR's 1♠ response to the strong club
opening explicitly denies four spades (any unbalanced hand with 4 spades would have
started by bidding 1♥ regardless of the relative length of his suits). Similarly, RR will
bid 1♠ with any hand holding 4+ hearts regardless of his length in the minors. RR would
bid 1♠ holding four small hearts and a solid 7 card diamond suit.
Note: Much of the response structure is based on transfer responses. (1♣ - 1♥ shows
spades, 1♣ - 2♣ shows diamonds) The main motivation for this usage is to maximize the
chance that the relayer will be declarer. Following 1♣ - 1♥, R will normally make a
relay ask by bidding 1♠, right-siding a potential spade contract. Following 1♣ - 2♣, the
2♦ relay will right-side a diamond contract. The same usage is followed throughout the
relay structure.
The simplest way to learn symmetric relay is to focus on individual modules and learn
them one at a time. The first module to be discussed provides a simple relay structure that
can be used to completely describe the shape of any two suited hand pattern. This
module is applied any time that the responder to relays has shown a two suited hand
pattern with two known suits.
When responding to a strong club opening, immediate bids of 2♥ or greater are used to
show two suited hands with both minors. This example will be used as an introduction to
symmetric relay methods. Observe that any possible hand pattern except two suited hands
with both minors would be shown via a lower bid.
When describing a two suited hand pattern with two known suits, RR's first priority is to
define the relative length of his two long suits. The primary rule used throughout the
relay structure is High Shortage First. Anytime that RR is comparing the length of two
suits, the cheapest bid always shows shortness in the highest possible suit.
Example: Two suited hand patterns are always shown using bids from 2♥+. In this
case, the cheapest possible bid (2♥) is used to show shortness in the higher of the two
primary suits. In our first example where RR is showing two suited hand patterns with
both minors, the 2♥ bid is used to show any 2 suited hand pattern where diamonds are
the shorter suit. This means that RR holds 4 diamonds and longer clubs. If RR held
Clubs and Spades, the 2♥ bid would show 4 Spades and longer Clubs.
Chart 2: Responses over Strong Club openings (continued)
Observe that any bid higher than 2♥ promises a hand with 5+ diamonds.
The most compact way to describe detailed relay sequences is to make use of tables. A
single table can be used to show a series of relay bids and response sequences.
Table 1
The first column in Table 1 identifies the level of various bids. The second column
shows RR's direct response structure over the R's strong club opening. These two
columns provide precisely the same information that was presented in Chart 2.
The first entry in column 3 is the word "Relay" in the second row. This indicates that
following RR's 2♥ bid, a 2♠ response by R is a relay asking RR to further describe his
hand. The remaining rows in column 3 describe RR's rebids over the 2♠ relay.
Example: The auction has started 1♣ - 2♥ - 2♠ - 3♥. Reading across Table 1, we can
determine that this auction means the following.
Note: The 2♥ bid is often referred to as the "reverser" since its purpose is to reverse the
length of the two primary suits.
Note: The level at which individual shapes are resolved is typically a function of the
frequency of the shape. 5431 hands are more common than 2164 shapes. Therefore,
5431 shapes are resolved with a lower bid. This applies throughout the relay structure.
Once the relay responder has defined the relative length of his two primary suits, his next
priority is to define the relative length of his two short suits. Once again, RR shows the
relative length of the two remaining suits using the basic High Shortage First
methodology.
The initial bid where RR clarifies the relative length of his short suits is 2N. Notice that
the immediate 2N bid shows shortage in the higher of the two remaining suits. In this
example, the two remaining suits are Spades and Hearts. The 2N response shows short
Spades. Observe that any bid higher than 2N denies spade shortage.
Table 2
2♥ Exactly 4 Diamonds and longer Clubs
2♠ 5+ Diamonds and 5+ Clubs
2N 4 Clubs, 5+ Diamonds, High shortage
3♣ 2254 shape Relay
3♦ 3154 shape 1354 shape
3♥ 2164 shape 1264 shape
3♠ 3064 shape 0364 shape
3N 2074 shape 0274 shape
4♣ 1174 Shape
Example Hands
Opener Responder
♠ AK4 ♠T
♥ AT632 ♥ KQJ
♦ T6 ♦ KQ953
♣ AQ8 ♣ KJT4
Opener Responder
1♣ 2N (1♣ = Strong, 2N = 4 clubs, 5+ diamonds, high shortage)
3♣ 3♦ (3♣ = Relay, 3♦ = 1354 shape)
Opener Responder
♠ 85 ♠ 93
♥ AKQ764 ♥ J9
♦ AJ65 ♦ KQ97
♣6 ♣ AT532
Opener Responder
1♣ 2♥ (1♣ = Strong, 2♥ = 4 Diamonds, 5+ clubs)
2♠ 3♣ (2♠ = Relay, 3♣ = 2245 shape)
Following a strong club opening, RR's immediate 2♠ response is used to show two suited
hands with at least 5-5 shape in the minors.
Table 3
2♠ 5+ Diamonds
and 5+ Clubs
2N 4 Clubs, 5+ Diamonds Relay
High shortage
3♣ 2254 shape 5♣/5♦ High shortage
3♦ 3154 shape 1165/1156 shape Relay
3♥ 2164 shape 2155 shape 1255 shape Relay
3♠ 3064 shape 3055 shape 0355 shape 1156 shape
3N 2074 shape 2056 shape 0256 shape 1165 shape
4♣ 1174 shape 2065 shape 0265 shape
The development of the relay response structure after the 2♠ response follows the same
basic principles as the 54/64 patterns. RR's initial response clarifies the relative length of
responder's short suits. Higher responses clarify precise distribution. Once again, most
hand patterns are resolved with identical bids. (3♥ always shows 5521 shapes, 3♠
always shows 5530 shapes).
Note: The 6511 and 6520 hand patterns are not resolved using the normal symmetric
scheme. These shapes are resolved at different levels. In a similar fashion, 6520 hands
also need to be resolved asymmetrically. Notice that the resolution of both these hands
patterns follows the traditional High Shortage First structure.
Example Hands
Hand 1
Opener Responder
♠ AQ542 ♠ KT
♥ A8 ♥T
♦ AKT7 ♦ Q6542
♣ 97 ♣ AT864
Opener Responder
1♣ 2♠ (2♠ = 5+ Clubs, 5+ Diamonds)
2N 3♥ (3♥ = 2155 shape)
Hand 2
Opener Responder
♠ AJ8762 ♠-
♥ K3 ♥ J9
♦ KT3 ♦ AT9875
♣ AJ ♣ KT875
Opener Responder
1♣ 2♠ (1♣ = Strong, 2♠ = 5+ Clubs, 5+ Diamonds)
2N 3♣ (2N = relay, 3♣ = High shortage)
3♦ 4♣ (3♦ = Relay, 4♣ = 0265 shape)
Showing single suited hand patterns
We will illustrate the module for showing single suited hand patterns using the example
auction 1♣ - 2♦. (1♣ - 2♦ shows any single suited hand with a 6+ card club suit)
R relays with 2♥ and RR's bids from 2♠+ clarify shape.
Table 4
2♦ Single suited hands
With 6+ ♣
2♥ 4 ♦, 5+ ♣ Relay
2♠ 5+ ♦, 5♦ ♦ High shortage
or 3226/2326 shape
2N 4 ♣, 5+♦ Middle Shortage Relay
3♣ 2254 shape 2227 or 2236 shape 3226/2326 shape Relay
3♦ 3154 shape 3316 shape 1336 shape 3136 shape Relay
3♥ 2164 shape 3217 / 2317 shape 1327/1237 shape 3127/2137 2227 shape
shape
3♠ 3064 shape 3307 shape 0337 shape 3037 shape 2236 shape
When describing shape, RR's initial 2♠ response shows either a single suited hand with
high shortage or a 6322/6232 pattern. In our example, RR's known long suit is Clubs.
Spades is the highest remaining suit, so 2♠ shows Spade shortage.
Following
1♣ - 2♦
2♥ - 2♠
R relays with 2NT. RR's rebids from 3♦ up showing single suited hands with long Clubs
and Spade shortness.
The 6331/7321/7330 shapes establish the symmetric portion of the single suited relay
structure. These shapes are always resolved with the same bids.
The initial 2N response shows middle shortage. (Heart shortage in our example).
Observe that after R's 3♣ relay, RR's 3♦/3♥/3♠ responses are once again symmetric in
nature describing the 6331/7321/7330 patterns.
Immediate bids from 3♦ up show single suited hands with low shortage. (Diamond
shortage in our example). Once again, the response structure is symmetric.
For whatever reason, showing 6322 and 7222 hand patterns seem to be the most difficult
part of the entire symmetric relay system to remember. When describing a single suited
hand, RR needs to be able to describe three separate 6322 hand patterns and one 7222
pattern. In our original example where RR is describing a single suited hand with primary
Clubs, RR needs to be able to differentiate between the following shapes:
3226
2326
2236
2272
Normally, we use the mnemonic High Shortage First to describe what order we will
show cards. However, High Shortage First only applies when we are comparing the
length of two known suits. In the case of the 6322 hand, we are actually attempting to
describe the location of the three card long fragment which could be located in any one of
three different suits. In our example, RR could have either 3 spades, 3 hearts, or 3
diamonds.
Any time that we are trying compare the relative lengths of 3 or more suits, we rely on a
second basic principle. ♠ > ♥ > ♦ > ♣.
[Spades are shown before Hearts. Hearts are shown before Diamonds
Diamonds are shown before Clubs]
The ♠ > ♥ > ♦ > ♣ ordering is very easy to remember because it corresponding to the
natural ordering of the suits. Furthermore, this same ordering has the useful property of
right-siding most relay contracts.
When showing a 2 suited hand pattern, RR's initial 2♠ response shows either high
shortage, or two of the three 6322 patterns. This 2♠ bid will show the two patterns with
three card fragments in the two highest possible suits. Going back to our initial example,
where RR has shown long clubs, the 2♠ bid shows either a 3226 or 2326 shapes. RR
shows the 6322 hands via a 3♣ rebid following R's 2N relay.
The complete auction
In this auction, since we started the relay by showing spades first, we finish showing
shape by showing shapes first. Hence, the 3♥ response shows 3226 shape. The 3♠
response shows 2326 shape.
An immediate 3♣ club after the 2♥ relay shows the 7222 hand pattern or the last 6322.
[The 3♣ response can be thought of as a junction bid for the 6322 hands] The 7222 hand
patterns are more common than 1/3rd of all 6322s. Thus the 7222 pattern is shown earlier
in the response structure. After R's 3♦ relay, 3♥ = 2227 shape, 3♠ = 2236 shape.
Example Hands
Hand 1
Opener Responder
♠ AQ76 ♠ T2
♥ AQJ74 ♥8
♦ QJ ♦ KJ3
♣ Q4 ♣ AKT8764
Opener Responder
1♣ 2♦ (1♣ = Strong, 2♦ = 6+ clubs)
2♥ 2N (2♥ = relay, 2N = middle shortage)
3♣ 3♥ (3♣ = relay, 3♥ = 3127/2137 shape)
Hand 2
Opener Responder
♠ A2 ♠ 74
♥ Q8764 ♥ AT
♦ AJ2 ♦ Q6
♣ AT3 ♣ KQ97652
Opener Responder
1♣ 2♦ (1♣ = strong, 2♦ = 6+ clubs)
2♥ 3♣ (2♥ = relay, 3♣ = 2236/7222 shape)
3♦ 3♥ (3♦ = relay, 3♥ = 2227 shape)
Hand 3
Opener Responder
♠ KQJT2 ♠ A8
♥ AQ ♥ KJ5
♦ 75 ♦ 63
♣ AT98 ♣ KQ7653
Opener Responder
1♣ 2♦ (1♣ = strong, 2♦ = 6+ clubs, single suited)
2♥ 2♠ (2♥ = relay, 2♠ = High shortage or 3226/2326 shape)
2N 3♣ (2N = relay, 3♣ = 3226/2326 shape)
3♦ 3♠ (3♦ = relay, 3♠ = 2326 shape)
Hand 4
Opener Responder
♠ A43 ♠ J2
♥ A3 ♥T
♦ AQ62 ♦ KJ7
♣ KT83 ♣ AQ97542
Opener Responder
1♣ 2♦ (1♣ = strong, 2♦ = 6+ clubs, single suited)
2♥ 2N (2♥ = relay, 2N = Middle shortage)
3♣ 3♥ (3♣ = relay, 3♥ = 2137/3127 shape)
The same basic relay principles that guide the development of the two suited module and
the single suited module apply throughout the relay structure. Once you are thoroughly
comfortable with the first two modules, you should be ready to study the response
structure as a whole. Table 5 illustrates a complete response structure following the
strong club opening.
Table 5
1♦ Negative Response
1♥ 4+ Spades
1♠ 4+ Hearts Relay
1N Balanced hands ♠+♥ Relay
2♣ 6+ Diamonds (1 suited) or Two suited with Two suited with
3 suited with both minor ♠+♦ ♥+♦
2♦ 6+ Clubs 5+ ♠ and 4+ ♣ 5+ ♥ and 4+ ♣ Relay
2♥ 4♦, 5+ ♣ 4♠ and 5+ ♣ 4♥ and 5+♣ 3 suited, both minors
2♠ 5+ ♦, 5+ ♣ Single suited ♠ Single suited ♥ Single suited ♦
High shortage High shortage High Shortage
2N 4 ♣, 5+ ♦, Single Suited ♠ Single suited ♥ Single suited ♦
High shortage Middle shortage Middle shortage Middle shortage
3♣ 2254 shape Single Suited ♠ Single suited ♥ Single suited ♦
7222 or 6223 2722 or 2623 2272 or 2263
3♦ 3154 shape 6331 shape 3631 shape 3361 shape
3♥ 2164 shape 7321 / 7231 shape 3721 / 2731 shape 3271 / 2371 shape
3♠ 3064 shape 7330 shape 3730 shape 3370 shape
3N 2074 shape
4♣ 1174 shape
Remembering three basic principles will allow you to make sense of nearly the entire
table.
Note: Two suited hands with both majors are described by first bidding 1♥ showing
spades. RR's second bid is 1N (showing both majors). RR's third bid will be 2♥+
showing a 2 suited hand with both majors.
Example hands
Hand 1
Opener Responder
♠4 ♠ AKQJ
♥ K754 ♥ Q3
♦ AKQ85 ♦ T7642
♣ A64 ♣ K3
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♥ (1♣ = Strong, 1♥ = 4+ spades)
1♠ 2♣ (1♠ = Relay, 2♣ = 2 suited, Spades and Diamonds)
2♦ 2♥ (2♦ = Relay, 2♥ = 4 spades, longer Diamonds)
2♠ 3♣ (2♠ = Relay, 3♣ = 4252 shape)
Hand 2
Opener Responder
♠A ♠ KQJ765
♥ QJ95432 ♥ K8
♦ AK ♦ 987
♣ A73 ♣ K5
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♥ (1♣ = strong, 1♥ = 4+ spades)
1♠ 2♠ (1♠ = relay, 2♠ = high shortage or 6322/6232 shape)
2N 3♣ (2N = relay, 3♣ = 6322 / 6232 shape)
3♦ 3♠ (3♦ = relay, 3♠ = 6232 shape)
Hand 3
Opener Responder
♠ AK7 ♠ 93
♥ K964 ♥ JT853
♦ AJT42 ♦6
♣7 ♣ AKQT9
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♠ (1♣ = Strong, 1♠ = Hearts)
1N 2♦ (1N = Relay, 2♦ = 5+ Hearts, 4+ Clubs)
2♥ 2♠ (2♥ = Relay, 2♠ = 5+ Hearts, 4+ Clubs)
2N 3♥ (2N = Relay, 3♥ = 2515 shape)
Hand 4
Opener Responder
♠ 97 ♠ AT8642
♥ AKT7 ♥ Q654
♦ A8 ♦T
♣ AQ542 ♣ KT
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♥ (1♣ = Strong, 1♥ = 4+ Spades)
1♠ 1N (1♠ = Relay, 1N = Both majors)
2♣ 2N (2♣ = Relay, 2N = 4 hearts, longer spades, high shortage)
3♣ 3♥ (3♣ = Relay, 3♥ = 6412 shape)
The module for describing three suited hands is extremely simple. RR has a very limited
number of shapes that need to be described. The 4441 and 5440 shapes can be described
quickly and economically. Typically, when the three suited hand module is being
applied, RR will be describing a three suited hand pattern with two of the three suits
known.
2♥ Relay
2♠ High Shortage
2N 4441 shape Relay
3♣ 5440 shape 4414 shape
3♦ 4540 shape 5404 shape
3♥ 4450 shape 4504 shape
3♠ 4405 shape
RR's first step response shows that the higher of the two remaining suits is shortest.
RR's second step shows a specific 4441 shape. Higher step's show 5440 hands.
Remember that the placement of the five-card suit is shown in order ♠ ♥ ♦ ♣
Example hands
Hand 1
Opener Responder
♠ AT85 ♠K
♥ AT3 ♥ K764
♦ A8 ♦ KJ94
♣ AJT6 ♣ K987
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♥ (1♣ = Strong, 1♥ = 4+ spades)
1♠ 1N (1♠ = Relay, 1N = spades and hearts)
2♣ 2♦ (2♣ = Relay, 2♦ = 3 suited, both majors)
2♥ 2♠ (2♥ = Relay, 2♠ = High shortage)
2N 3♥ (2N = Relay, 3♥ = 4504 shape)
A 1N response over a strong club opening is used to show all balanced hand patterns.
This response is mandatory - regardless of major suit holding - with any of the following
shapes: 4432, 5332, 4333. The incorporation of the 5332 pattern into the balanced
positive response represents a clear departure from earlier versions of the MOSCITO
response structure. The primary motivation for this change was the observation that two
minimum balanced hands with game forcing values are often best bid naturally. With
these hand types, preserving sufficient room to explore for stoppers is often much more
important than relaying for precise shape. As such, the response structure used to
describe balanced hands provides multiple defined relay breaks to switch to natural
bidding.
The decision to treat the 5332 hand type as a balanced pattern does provide some other
systemic advantages. By removing this hand pattern from the single suited response
structure, it is possible to compress the final stage of the shape definition (3♦ = 6331
shape, 3♥ = 7321 shape, 3♠ = 7330 shape). In addition, the new response structure for
balanced hand types preserves an attractive symmetry
At first glance, it might seem as if the natural 1N response could potentially wrong-side
many contracts. Most of the response structure over 1♣ openings is based on transfer
positive responses to maximize the chance that the asking hand will declare the contract.
In the case of the response structure over 1N, a reverse relay is used to accomplish the
same purpose. Holding an unbalanced hand that this unlikely to want to play in NT,
opener will start a relay sequence with a 2♣ rebid. With a minimum balanced hand
[~15-18 HCP], opener will show his hand type using the same response structure.
The identical relay response structure applies in two different circumstances
When memorizing the relay structure, there are four main points to remember:
All 4333 hands are shown with an immediate 2S response (Any other
response show either a 4432 or 5332 hands)
Suits are shown via transfer responses
- An immediate 2♦ response shows hearts
- An immediate 2♥ response shows spades
- A rebid of 3♣ shows two suited hands with diamonds
5332 hands are typically shown using the 2N responses as a junction bid. To
show a 5332 hand, first show your suit using the standard response structure
and then rebid 2N. Other rebids show a second suit and promise 4432 shape.
The hand that is showing will always zoom to 3♣+ with a one or two suited
hand with clubs
Table 1
1N Balanced hands
2♣ Relay
2♦ 4+ Hearts
2♥ 4+ Spades Relay
2♠ 4333 hands 4432 (♥ + ♠) Relay
2N Any 5332 with ♦ 5332 with ♥ 5332 with ♠ Relay
3♣ 4432 (♣ + ♦) 4432 (♥ + ♦) 4432 (♠ + ♦) 4 card minor Relay
3♦ 2335 shape 2434 shape 4234 shape 4333 shape 2353 shape Relay
3♥ 3235 shape 3424 shape 4324 shape 3433 shape 3253 shape 4423 shape
3♠ 3325 shape 3352 shape 4432 shape
Hand 1
Opener Responder
♠ KT873 ♠ AJ4
♥ AQJ7 ♥ K8642
♦7 ♦ A9
♣ AQ3 ♣ 842
Opener Responder
1♣ 1N (1N = any 4432, 5332, 4333 hand)
2♣ 2♦ (2♦ = hearts)
2♥ 2N (2N = any 5332)
3♣ 3♥ (3♥ = precisely 3523 shape)
4♣ 4♥ (4♥ = 3 key cards)
4N 5♣ (A or KQ in spades)
6♥
Hand 2
Opener Responder
♠ AKQ84 ♠ J75
♥ A863 ♥ KQ95
♦7 ♦ K85
♣ QT5 ♣ K74
Opener Responder
1♣ 1N (1N = any 4432, 5332, 4333 shape)
2♣ 2♠ (2♠ = any 4333 shape)
2N 3♥ (3♥ = 3433 shape)
4♦ 4♥ (4♥ = No extra strength)
(b) Strong hands that would zoom over partner's sign off bids (4♦ or 3N)
Hand 1
Opener Responder
♠ AJ7 ♠ K965
♥ AKJ82 ♥ Q93
♦ 854 ♦ K96
♣ AK ♣ Q92
Opener Responder
1♣ 1N (1N = any 4432, 5332, 4333 shape)
2♣ 2♠ (2♠ = any 4333 shape)
2N 3♦ (3♦ = 4333 shape)
3♥ 3♠ (3♠ = 6 AKQ relay points)
4♣ 5♣ (5♣ = 1-2 controls in spades, hearts, diamonds, clubs
only one spade control)
6N
Hand 2
Opener Responder
♠ AQJ5 ♠ K982
♥ AKQ9 ♥ J2
♦ T2 ♦9875
♣ KT6 ♣ AQ9
Opener Responder
1♣ 1N (1N = any 4432, 5332, 4333 hand)
2♣ 2♥ (2♥ = 4+ spades)
2♠ 3♣ (3♣ = 4432 with spades and diamonds)
3♦ 3♥ (3♥ = 4243 shape)
3♠ 3N (3N = 6 controls)
4♠
(c) 5332 hand patterns with long clubs and a weak doubleton
Hand 1
Opener Responder
♠ AJ7 ♠ Q653
♥ KJ2 ♥ AQ4
♦ 93 ♦ KT82
♣ AK982 ♣ Q2
Opener Responder
1♣ 1N
2♣ 2♥
2♠ 3♣
3♦ 3♥
3N
Note: With 15-17 HCP and a doubleton honor, zoom and show shape.
Hand 1
Opener Responder
♠K987 ♠ AQT3
♦ K7 ♥ AJ42
♥ AK93 ♦ J5
♣ K93 ♣ AQ8
Opener Responder
1♣ 1N (1N = any 4432, 5332, 4333 hand)
2♥ 2♠ (2♥ = 4+ spades, 4432/5332 hand)
3♣ 3♦ (3♣ = spades and diamonds, 4432 shape)
3♥
Hand 2
Opener Responder
♠ AQ82 ♠ KJ93
♥ KJ84 ♥ AT52
♦ Q9 ♦ AJ6
♣ K84 ♣ Q7
Opener Responder
1♣ 1N (1N = any 4432, 5332, 4333 hand)
2♦ 2♥ (2♦ = minimum balanced hand, 4+ hearts)
2♠ 2N (2♠ = 4432 with both majors)
3♣
In many cases, the relay asker will chose to break relays and revert to natural bidding.
Typically, this is done when the asker suspects that 3N will be the optimal contract, but
needs to explore determine whether or not the partnership possess appropriate stoppers.
The relay asker has the opportunity to revert to natural bidding at almost any time during
the balanced relay sequence. The most noticeable exception is immediately following the
intial1N response where the relay break starts the reverse relay.
The second major exception occurs after a 2N bid showing a 5332 hand pattern. In this
case, a 3♣ response is used to ask for stoppers. Asker can relay for shape by bidding 3♦.
Asker's 3♥ bid is an AKQ control ask. Bids of 3♠ and above are key card asks and set
the trump suit with the usual exceptions (3N = to play, 4♦ = terminator puppet)
Example Hands
Hand 1
Opener Responder
♠ KQ6 ♠ A84
♥ AK94 ♥ J3
♦ J983 ♦ KT64
♣ A2 ♣ KT85
Opener Responder
1♣ 1N (1N = any 4432, 5332, 4333 shape)
2♦ 2N (2♦ = minimum balanced hand, 4+ hearts)
3N
Hand 2
Opener Responder
♠ AKQ54 ♠ 86
♥ T53 ♥ AK86
♦ 95 ♦ J63
♣ AK8 ♣ Q974
Opener Responder
1♣ 1N (1N = any 4432, 5332, 4333 shape)
2♥ 2N (2♥ = minimum hand, 4+ spades)
3♣ 3♥ (3♣ = club stopper, 3♥ = heart stopper)
3♠ 4♣ (3♠ = spade stopper, no diamond stopper)
(4♣ = scrambling, could be passed)
4♠ (4♠ = to play, 5332 shape)
Hand 3
Opener Responder
♠ Q62 ♠ 95
♥ AKT93 ♥ Q42
♦ K5 ♦ A64
♣ QJ3 ♣ AKT92
Opener Responder
1♣ 1N (1N = any 4432, 5332, 4333 hand)
2♦ 3♣ (2♦ = relay break, showing 15 - 18 balanced with 4+ hearts)
(3♣ = relay break, natural, 5 clubs)
3♥ 4♦ (3♥ = 5332, 4♦ = cue in support of hearts, denies spade control)
4♥
Hand 4
Opener Responder
♠ KQ ♠ 943
♥ KT932 ♥ AQJ
♦ AJ3 ♦ 9742
♣ A98 ♣ K43
Opener Responder
1♣ 1N (1N = any 4432, 5332, 4333 shape)
2♦ 2♥ (2♦ = minimum balanced hand, 4+ hearts)
2N 3♣ (2N = 5 hearts, 5332 shape, 3♣ = stopper ask)
3N (3N = all suits stopped)
Hand 5
Opener Responder
♠ AQ82 ♠ KJ93
♥ KJ84 ♥ AT52
♦ Q9 ♦ AJ6
♣ K84 ♣ Q7
Opener Responder
1♣ 1N (1N = any 4432, 5332, 4333 hand)
2♦ 2♥ (2♦ = minimum balanced hand, 4+ hearts)
2♠ 2N (2♠ = 4432 with both majors)
3♣ 3♦ (3♣ = 4423 shape)
3♥ 4♥ (3♥ = 9 AKQ relay points)
Hand 6
Opener Responder
♠ Q62 ♠ 95
♥ AKT93 ♥ Q42
♦ K5 ♦ A64
♣ QJ3 ♣ AKT92
Opener Responder
1♣ 1N (1N = any 4432, 5332, 4333 hand)
2♦ 3♣ (2♦ = relay break, showing 15 - 18 balanced with 4+ hearts)
(3♣ = relay break, natural, 5 clubs)
3♥ 4♦ (3♥ = 5332, 4♥ = cue in support of hearts, denies spade control)
4♥
Please note: Any system will have certain hands that present a problem.
As examples
Hand 1
Opener Responder
♠ AK ♠ Q73
♥ 985 ♥ QJ
♦ QJ92 ♦ AKT65
♣ AKT9 ♣ QJ4
Opener Responder
1♣ 1N (1N = any 4432, 5332, 4333 hand)
3♣ 3N (3C = minimum balanced hand, 4432 with both minors)
Partner has a minimum balanced hand. Despite the known 9 card diamond fit, 5D seems
questionable. 3N also seems problematic. Partner is more likely than not to have 3
hearts, but there is no guarantee of a stopper. Still, 3N seems to be the pragmatic bid.
Hand 2
Opener Responder
♠ AKQ4 ♠ 863
♥ T3 ♥ AK8
♦ 952 ♦ J63
♣ AK86 ♣ Q974
1♣ 1N
3♥ 3N (3♥ = 3235 shape, doubleton honor in hearts)
System will probably lead to a bad 3N contract, regardless of what sequence responder
chooses to employ. However, we expect to have company. Many natural systems will
fail to expose the heart weakness after simple auctions like
1N - 2♣
2♦ - 3N
Auction Termination
Auction termination refers to bidding methods that are used to conclude a game-forcing
auction. Playing a natural bidding system, auction termination is usual a simple process.
Both members of the partnership are describing their hands. It is usually obvious to both
players what strain is being investigated. In contrast, if a relay system is being used, only
one player has enough information to accurately place the final contract.
Correspondingly, relay systems require explicit methods to indicate when the relay asker
is setting the final contract as opposed to simply making an interrogative.
The key to understanding the auction termination process is to carefully consider what
information is possessed by the each member of the partnership at different stages of the
auction.
Once shape has been revealed, the relay asker (R) knows two key pieces of information
In some cases, the relay asker will also know the maximum strength that could
potentially be held in teller's hand. For example, if partner has opened the bidding with a
limited opening bid, there is precise upward limit on hand strength. However, in many
cases the relay asker will not be able to accurately judge the maximum combined strength
of the two hands. The maximum strength for a positive response to a strong club is
effectively unbounded. [It is strongly recommended that players familiarize themselves
with the frequency distribution tables for slam points and high card points. Separate
tables have been provided for both opening bids and responses.]
In turn, the responder to relay (RR) possesses one key piece of information: By choosing
to use a relay sequence, R has indicated that he holds a strong hand. During the course of
the auction, the R will often make further signals that provide an increasingly accurate
description of the relay asker's strength. Under specific circumstances, RR will be in the
best position to determine whether the partnership should make a slam investigation.
The overall goal is to define a set of boundary conditions that identify how the remainder
of the auction should proceed.
Throughout this presentation, we are deliberately not describing the early stages of the
auction where shape is defined. Different relay systems (even variants of a single system
like MOSCITO) will often use very different methods to resolve shape. For each
example hand presented, detailed explanation of the auction will "start" with the final bid
describing shape. (In each case, this bid corresponds to the shape resolving bid used for
the MOSCITO variant described during the later chapters of this work.) When
appropriate, the example hand will also describe information about the minimum and
maximum strengths that could be held.
Readers who want to immediately study shape resolution can skip this chapter and then
return once they are comfortable with defining shape. (Please note, no discussion of
auction termination would be complete without discussing when to use relay breaks.
However, due to the complexity of this topic, it is being reserved for another chapter)
Relay systems typically distinguish between two different types of game contracts. The
first type is a 3N contract. The second type is a suit contract where a player plans to
declare 4M or 5m. MOSCITO provides players with clear methods to signoff in either
type of game.
3N contracts
Placing a contract in 3N is very simple. Any time that 3N is bid by the player making
asking bids, 3N is to play. 3N might be bid directly after shape resolution. 3N might be
bid after asking for controls. In some cases, the asker might chose to jump to 3N before
completing shape resolution. In each case, the 3N bid is a clear indication that asker
thinks that 3N is the best contract. 3N is a weak bid by the relay asker. The bid indicates
that the asker does not believe that the partnership should investigate slam. It strictly
limits the maximum strength of the relay asker. (Under some unusual circumstances, RR
can choose to bid on after 3N. This typically indicates that RR has unexpected strength).
Example hands
Asker Teller
KQT9 5
AKT QJ72
A986 K752
62 KQ54
1♣ 2♣
2♦ 2♥
2♠ 2N
3♣ 3♦ (3♦ = 1444 shape)
3N Pass (3N = to play
Asker Teller
8642 QT7
AQ8 6
T8 AK954
AKQ4 J973
Another average 1♣ opening with poorly placed honors. RR would need an exceptional
hand to have a good play at 6♣. [Note, change the position of some key honors by
moving the Queen of hearts to diamonds and the Ace of hearts to spades and the hand
revalues significantly]
Asker Teller
7 AK843
A87 963
AK9752 QT
A98 T54
1♣ 1N
2♣ 2♥
2♠ 2N (2N = any 5332 hand with 5 spades)
3N
The relay asker holds a minimum strong club opening and a small stiff opposite partner's
5 card suit.
Asker Teller
K4 AQ6
65 T9873
AK975 Q84
AQ54 K7
1♣ 1N
2♣ 2♦
2♥ 2N (2N = 5 hearts, any 5332 shape)
3N (3N = to play)
A pair of balanced hands facing one another need extra strength to make a slam. In this
example, the critical flaw for the 1♣ opening is the small doubleton opposite partner's 5
card major. Change the hands so that the relay asker had AQ54 in hearts and exploring
for slam becomes much more attractive. Even with three hearts to an honor, it would still
be worth placing partner's doubleton and checking if the partnership had a pair of 5-3 fits.
Suit contracts
Example hands
Asker Teller
AQ832 9
AK96 T853
4 AT986
QJ8 AK2
1♣ 1♠
1N 2♣
2♦ 2♥
2♠ 2N
3♣ 3♦ (3♦ = 1453 shape)
4♦ 4♥ (4♦ = end signal, 4♥ = forced)
The strong club opener has a minimum opening. Neither hand fits well together with
singletons opposite long suits.
Teller Asker
AT76 K842
7 KQ864
A8432 K
K72 AT5
1♦ 1♥
2♣ 2♦
2♥ 2♠
2N 3♣
3♦ 4♦ (3♦ = 4153 shape, limited opening bid, 4♦ = end signal)
4♥ 4♠ (4♥ = forced, 4♠ = to play)
Opposite a limited opening bid, there is little chance of slam. In particular, once RR
shows a singleton opposite asker's KQ864 in hearts and only 3 clubs, the hands devalue
substantially. R uses the end signal and then rebids 4♠ to set the final contract.
Asker Teller
K6 Q92
AK543 J98
J953 AQ42
AT Q85
1♣ 1N
2♣ 2♠
2N 3♣
3♦ 3♥ (3♥ = 3343 shape)
4♦ 4♥
With a minimum strong club opening, slam looks extremely unlikely unless teller has
significant extra strength. Here once again, if the two hands had sufficient strength for to
invite slam, asker would be investigating a 6♦ contract. However, since the limit of the
two hands is game, asker is content to steer the contract to 4♥.
Once RR has shown his complete shape, the asker has the option of exploring for slam.
Slam exploration consist of two phases: Identifying whether or not the partnership has
sufficient strength to consider a slam and finding the location of key controls. With slam
invitational values, following final resolution of shape, RR will typically make a one step
response to ask teller how many AKQ slam points he holds. For example, if the teller's
last bid was 3♣ showing a 5422 hand, a 3♦ bid would ask for slam points. If RR's last
bid was 3♦ showing a 6331 hand, 3♥ would ask for slam points.
The slam point total for a hand is calculated by counting three points for each Ace, two
points for each King, and one point for each Queen held in the hand. Singleton Kings
and Queens are not counted towards the slam point total. However, singleton Aces still
count as 3 slam points.
Note: If partner resolves shape with a 3♠ bid, 3N is still to play. Partner would bid the
NEXT step (4♣) to make an AKQ slam point ask.
The response scale to the AKQ slam point ask uses steps to provide a precise count of the
number of slam points held in the relay teller's hand.
If RR has opened with a strong club opening bid, then the base count for the
AKQ slam point ask is 9.
If RR has opened with a limited opening bid OR made a positive response to a
strong club opening, then the base count for the AKQ slam point ask is 6.
If RR initially made a negative response to a strong club opening bid, then the
base count for the AKQ slam point ask is 4.
For example, suppose that the RR opened the bidding with 1♥ and later bid 3♦ to show a
5431 hand. In response to R's 3♥ ask, responder would bid
Alternatively, suppose that a reverse relay sequence lead to a strong club opener
describing his shape. The strong club opener revealed his complete shape with a 3♦ bid.
In response to R's 3♠ slam point ask, responder would bid
Note: If RR has shown 10+ cards in two suits, subtract 1 from the base slam point
total. For example, after the auction
3♠ = 5 slam points
3N = 6 slam points
4♣ = 7 slam points
…
Once one member of the partnership has identified the total number of AKQ slam points
held in the two hands, they are well positioned to judge whether the hand will have a
good potential to make a slam.
Note: There are a total of 24 AKQ slam points in the deck. If you subtract the
combined slam count of the two hands from 24, you can very easily picture what
cards might be missing from the combined hands.
Examples
Holding
A83
Q73
AK
AQ962
Holding
AK
K64
KQ852
AQ7
Once R has identified the total number of slam points held in the two hands, there are two
basic choices. First, if the relay asker determines that there are insufficient controls to
explore further for game, he has the option of signing off.
Asker Teller
KJT A8743
AQT 8
AKT95 742
72 AJ65
1♣ 1♥
1♠ 2♦
2♥ 3♦ (3♦ = 5134 shape)
3♥ 3♠ (3♥ = AKQ control ask, 3♠ = 6 slam points)
4♠ (4♠ = to play)
Despite the fact that the strong club opener only holds 11 slam points, with two 5-3 fits
its worth exploring for slam. However, after discovering that the combined hands only
hold 17 controls between them, slam looks to be very low percentage. Asker bids 4♠ to
set the final contract. (Notice that there is no use of the end signal once R has asked for
slam points)
1♦
1♥ 2♦
2♥ 2N
3♣ 3♦ (3♦ = 1534 shape)
3♥ 3N (3♥ = Slam Point Ask, 3N = 7 slam points)
4♥
With a double fit it appear right to explore for a 6♣ slam. However, once the combined
slam points of the two hands do not seem to justify further exploration. In this case, the
decision is made to play in 4♥. Notice that the singleton Ace does count towards the
slam point total.
However, change the hand slightly so that responder holds
1♦
1♥ 2♦
2♥ 2N
3♣ 3♦ (3♦ = 1534 shape)
3♥ 3♠ (3♠ = Slam Point Ask, 3N = 6 slam points)
4♥
Asker Teller
AK853 762
AQ82 J
A72 KQ43
7 KQ832
1♣ 2♥
2♠ 3♦ (3♦ = 3145 shape)
3♥ 3♠
4♠
Once again, too many controls are missing to justify further inquiry.
Placing Controls
In many cases, following the AKQ slam point ask, the relay asker is still interested in
investigating slam. At this point in time, the relay asker has a complete count of all the
controls in the two hands. At this juncture in the auction, the primary bidding technique
that is used is called "denial cue bids". As the name suggests, denial cue bidding
sequences are structured to place the location of missing cards. Denial cue bidding
accomplishes this by using step responses to indicate whether or not controls are held in
suits.
A first step response after partner's AKQ control count is starts denial cue
bidding. (The usual caveats regarding 3N response apply)
If RR makes the lowest possible bid, he denies a control in the suit being scanned. If the
relay teller skips a step, he confirms a control in that suit. (During the initial scan, a
control is defined as an Ace, a King, or a Queen)
The first step in using denial cue bids is to establish an order in which suits will be
scanned. The most common way to define the scanning order is to base it on the relative
lengths of the different suits.
The longest suit will be the first suit in the scanning order. The second
longest suit will be the second suit in the scanning order….
If two suits have the same length, ties will be broken in order ♠ > ♥ > ♦ > ♣
Singleton suits are not included in the scanning order
Examples
The initial denial cue bid asks partner is he has any controls in the first suit in the
scanning order. If the relay asker has no controls, then he makes the cheapest possible
response.
Examples
If RR has a control in the first suit in the scanning order, he will skip one step in the
bidding for each suit in the scanning order where he holds a control.
Example
Once all four suits in the scanning order have been swept once, the scan continues
starting once again at the start of the scanning order. To continue with this example:
5♣ promises controls in spades, diamonds, clubs, and hearts, but denies a second
spade control.
Once the RR has denied a control in a suit, the relay asker has two choices. A one step
response restarts the scan. Any higher bid is to play. If the relay asker decides to restart
the scan, the scanning order starts at the point at which the last scan was broken.
Once R has made two passes through the scan, the third pass asks for Jacks in suits with
2+ cards.
Example
The relay teller has just bid 3N showing 6 AKQ slam points.
The scanning order is ♥, ♣, ♦, ♠.
The relay bidder has just bid 4♣ starting denial cue bidding and the relay teller responded
4♥ (promising one or more controls in hearts, but denying a control in clubs). At this
point in time
Asker Teller
A5 K97
K87 A94
AKQ J832
QT742 AK9
1♣ 1N
2♣ 2♠
2N 3♣
3♦ 3♥ (3♥ = 3343 shape)
3♠ 4♠ (4♠ = 10 AKQ slam points)4N 5♣ (5♣ = no
control in diamonds)
5♦ 6♦ (6♦ = controls in ♠, ♥, ♣, ♦, no second spade control)
6♥ 6♠ (6♠ = no second heart control)
7N Pass
Asker has a very good hand (18 HCP, a 5 card suit, and 12 AKQ slam points) and is
shocked when responder shows 10 AKQ controls. At this point in time, 6N or 6♣ is
virtually assured. The partnership is missing either a King or 2 Queens.
R starts the denial cue bid sequence with 4N, and is not surprised by partner's 5♣
response. 5♦ is a second denial cue, this time starting with the spade suit. Responder's
6♦ bid shows in turn, controls in spades, hearts, diamonds, and clubs and denies a second
spade control. At this point in time, the relay asker knows that the teller's hand is either
missing the King of spade OR the Queen of spades and Queen of hearts. Responder's 6♠
bid confirms that the Queen of hearts is also missing, and declarer can count 13 tricks.
Note: Since the first scan of diamonds denied the Ace, King, or Queen, the next diamond
scan asks about the Jack
Asker Teller
AQT42 K986
KJ43 AQ92
K3 A975
AJ 5
1♣ 1♥
1♠ 1N
2♣ 2♦
2♥ 2N (2N = 4441 shape)
3♣ 3N (3N = 9 AKQ slam points)
4♣ 4N (4N = controls in ♠, ♥, ♦, no second spade control)
5♣ 5♥ (5♥ = 2 heart controls, no second diamond control)
7♥
RR's 3N shows that 4 AKQ slam points are missing. Responder could be missing either
an Ace + Queen, a King + King, or a King + 2 Queens). The first sweep reveals that
partner has no club honors. Therefore, the missing honors must be the KQ of clubs and a
red Queen. Once asker can place responder with the Queen of hearts he can count an
easy 13 tricks in hearts.
Asker Teller
42 AKQ
KQT5 7
AK6 Q8742
AK64 Q952
1♠
1N 2♣
2♥ 3♥ (3♥ = 4153 shape)
3♠ 4♦ (4♦ = 8 AKQ slam points)
4♥ 5♣ (5♣ = 1-2 controls in ♦, ♣, 0 or 3 controls in ♠)
6N Pass
RR's 4♣ showed that 3 AKQ slam points are missing. Hence, responder could be
missing either an Ace, a King + Queen, or three Queens. The initial sweep reveals that
the relay asker has controls in both diamonds and clubs. If responder holds both major
suit Aces, then 7N is the percentage contract. If responder has the AKQ of spades, then
6N is the limit to the hand. Notice that during the initial sweep, responder showed zero
controls in the spade suit even though he held AKQ. This treatment is systematic. After
getting a slam point count from responder, asker is usually very well placed to determine
whether responder has no controls in a suit OR AKQ in the suit. Therefore, the denial
cue bidding sequence stops if responder holds either extreme. This allows the relay asker
to quickly place multiple missing controls.
Note: If the relay teller stops on a suit during denial cue bidding he shows either no
additional controls in a suit or AKQ in that suit. If the relay teller skips a suit, he is
known to hold either one or two honors in that suit.
Asker Teller
QJ 9753
KJ5 AQ6
AK9854 Q3
AQ K865
1♣ 1N
2♣ 2♥
2♠ 3♥ (3♥ = 4324 shape)
3♠ 4♣ (4♣ = 7 AKQ slam points)
4♦ 4♥ (4♥ = 0 or 3 controls in spades)
5♦ Pass
With 19 AKQ slam points and a 6 card suit, the relay asker has some hopes of slam.
(move the Ace of hearts to spades and …). However, the denial cue bidding sequence
quickly reveals the weak spade suit and the relay asker settles in 5♦.
Asker Teller
Q432 J97
AKQ9 T7
AKT86 QJ742
----- AKJ
1♣ 1N
2♣ 2N
3♦ 3♠ (3♠ = 3253 shape)
4♣ 4♦ (4♦ = 6 AKQ slam points)
4♥ 4N (4N = 1-2 control in diamonds, 0 or 3 in spades)
5♦ Pass
Asker Teller
KQ A7
Q7 K3
AK3 J9876
KT9872 AQ53
RR's 4♣ response revealed that the partnership possessed 20 AKQ slam points. Asker
holds three Kings and 2 Queens, so it is known that and Ace and a Queen are missing.
Denial cues show that Teller is missing the Queen of Diamonds, and the auction dies in
4N.
Advanced Topics
One of the trickiest parts of the entire auction termination process is appropriately
judging when the partnership should signoff in game as opposed to exploring for slam. It
is particularly important to be able to accurately judge when to use one of the immediate
auction termination bids (3N and 4♦) as opposed to starting denial cue bids. As always,
experience is the best guide to developing good bidding judgment. However, it is
possible to provide some basic insights that may prove helpful to players who are initially
experimenting with these methods.
First and foremost, slam hands are often quite rare. The following charts provide basic
information about the frequency distributions for slam points when one player has opened
with a strong club opening and the other has made a positive response.
Table
Total 1 Points (Strong Club Opener and Positive
Relay Relay Points Frequency Cumulative
Response) Points Frequency
12 0.00017 0.00017
13 0.005893 0.006063
140000 14 0.050036 0.056099
120000 15 0.135084 0.191183
100000 16 0.194095 0.385279
80000 17 0.206721 0.591999
Relay Points 18 0.171195 0.763194
60000
19 0.116193 0.879387
40000
20 0.069378 0.948765
20000
21 0.033428 0.982193
0 22 0.012931 0.995124
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 23 0.004232 0.999356
24 0.000644 1
The first chart provides a frequency distribution for total slam points assuming a strong
club opener and a positive response by responder. [All charts were generated using a set
of scripts for Hans Van Stavern's Dealer program. Scripts are provided in the appendix.]
Notice that the vast majority of hands contain between 16 and 18 slam points. Fully
76.3% of all these hands contain 18 or fewer slam points. Recalled for a moment, that
holding only 18 slam points a pair of hands will be missing either a pair of Aces, three
Kings, or an Ace, a King and a Queen.
Monte Carlo based computer simulations suggest that on average, responder will hold
approximately 6.94 slam points opposite a strong club opening. In isolation, this figure
can actually be quite misleading. (For example, it would be entirely inappropriate to add
7 to the slam point total in the strong club hand and expect to accurately estimate the total
combined strength of the two hands). The strength of a strong club opening hand and the
strength of responder's hand are negatively correlated with one another. The more slam
points that are present in the strong club hand, the weaker responder's hand is going to be.
To compensate for this effect, a more extensive set of simulations was performed to
attempt to determine conditional probabilities. In this series of Monte Carlo simulations,
the strong club opener was deliberately assigned a specific number of slam points. We
then calculated the mean number of slam points held by responder along with a frequency
distribution.
Table 2
Opener's Relay Points 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
The chart provides some good basic guidelines regarding how strong a hand is necessary
to explore for slam. With two balanced hands opposite one another, the relay asker
should not ask for controls unless he holds 12 or more slam points. If, however, one or
both hands have significant extra shape or a double fit is present, the relay asker can
consider a slam ask with a weaker holding.
As noted at the start of this chapter, the relay asker is often poorly positioned to judge the
combined strength of the two hands. This problem typically occurs when the relay asker
has opened with a strong club and the relay teller has made a positive response. Another
possible case is if the relay teller has opened a strong club and then transitioned to a
reverse relay sequence.
In many auctions, holding a minimum hand the relay asker will chose not to explore for
slam. Instead, the relay asker will bid 3N or use the 4♦ end signal to signoff in game. If
the relay teller holds significant extra strength, it is his responsibility to ignore the signoff
and show his hand type. Responder uses a step response scale to show extra strength.
Bidding one step over the relay asker's sign off (a 4♣ free bid over 3N, a 4♠ free bid over
the end signal) shows 3 controls more than base. The second step shows 4 controls more
than base.
Example
The relay asker opened with a strong club and the teller made a positive response. After
shape was revealed, the relay asker bid 4♦ as end signal. The relay teller bids
After the relay teller has shown extra strength, the relay asker has a variety of bids
available to him
Example hands
Asker Teller
AJT5 Q7
93 AKQ8
84 AKJ72
AKQJ4 65
1♣ 1♠
1N 2♣
2♦ 2♥
2N 3♣ (3♣ = 2452 shape)
3N 4♠ (3N = to play, 4♠ = 12 AKQ slam points)
6N
Note: Alternatively, R might choose to use a 3♦ slam point ask immediately following
the 3♣ response.
Asker Teller
AKJ8 Q5
AQ952 73
6 AKJ5
Q42 AJ985
1♣ 2♥
2♠ 3♣ (3♣ = 2245 shape)
3N 4♣ (4♣ = 9 AKQ slam points)
4♦ 5♣ (1 or 2 controls in ♣,♦,♠. No ♥ control)
6♣
Denial cue bids are a very powerful method to explore for slams. However, in some
cases an alternative asking bid structure will provide better information for slam
investigation. With our existing response structure, three bids are reserved once auction
termination is complete.
1. a 3N bid is to play
2. a 4♦ bid is a puppet to 4♥
3. a first step response asks for AKQ slam points.
Any other bid by the relay asker is 1430 Roman Key Card Blackwood, simultaneously
setting the trump suit and asking for Aces. If the relay asker makes the lowest unreserved
bid, he is bidding RKCB in partner's longest suit. If the relay asker makes the second
unreserved bid, he is bidding RKCB in partner's second longest suit. Ties are broken in
order ♥ > ♠> ♣> ♦.
There are very logical reasons to adopt this ordering structure when breaking ties. We
initially base the asking order on RR's suit length because we are most likely to want to
be able to set RR's long suit as trump. The order in which we resolve ties is designed to
maximize the amount of bidding space available before passing the safety level for a
given hand. There is less room to explore for game versus slam when hearts are trump
than when spades are trump. As such, we ask about hearts before asking about spades.
Example
Example Hands
Asker Teller
963 AQJ754
K763 AT4
AKQJ 4
A2 Q98
1♣ 1♥
1♠ 2N
3♣ 3♦ (3♦ = 6313 shape)
3♠ 4♥ (3♠ = RKCB for spades, 4♥ = 2 key cards + trump queen)
6♠
Relay asker's primary concern is the strength of responder's trump suit and getting a
count on Aces. In this case, the 3♠ RKCB ask provides the quickest way to focus on this
information.
Asker Teller
KQT9832 764
AT K954
AQJ K9
4 KQ98
1♣ 1N
2♣ 2♦
2♥ 3♥ (3♥ = 3424 shape)
4♠ 5♣ (4N = 3/0 Keycards)
5♠ Pass
Here again, the relay asker's primary concern is determining whether the teller has Aces.
4♠ is RKCB in Spades. 5♣ shows 3/0 Keycards. Opener is happy to signoff in 5♠.
Asker Teller
K95 A7
KJ2 98
KT96 AJ
KQJ AT98643
1♣ 2♦
2♥ 3♣
3♦ 3♥ (3♥ = 2227 shape)
3N 4♣ (4♣ = 9 controls)
4♥ 5♥ (5♥ = 3 Aces)
6N
Once RR has given a count of key cards, the relay asker has a variety of ways to continue
the auction. Bidding the trump suit is to play. New suits are Control Asking Bids, asking
partner to clarify high strength in the bid suit.
Step 1 = A or KQ
Step 2 = Q or AK
Step 3 = K or AQ
Step 4 = AKQ
Note: If the trump Queen has not yet been shown, the first step asks for the Queen. If the
relay asker lacks the Queen, he will make a 1 step response. Holding the Queen, the
relay teller should zoom and describe his holding in the longest side suit at the same time.
1 = A or KJ
2 = J or AK
3 = K or AJ
4 = AKJ
Example
The relay teller has bid 3♦ to show 3361 shape. The relay asker replied 3♠, RKCB for
diamonds. Responder's 4♣ rebid showed 3 or 0 keycards. At this point in time, 4♦ by
the relay captain is an ask for the trump Queen. In reply
4♥ = no Queen of trump
4♠ = Queen of trump, A or KQ in spades
4N = Queen of trump, Q or AK in spades
5♣ = Queen of trump, K or AQ in spades
5♦ = Queen of trump, no spade control
5♥ = Queen of trump, AKQ of spades
Note: Here once again, rebidding the trump suit denies a control in the long suit being
scanned.
Teller Asker
AT8 7
A954 KQ63
T4 AKJ6
AQ73 KJT2
1♦ 1♥
1N 2♣
2♦ 2♥
2N 3♣
3♦ 3♠ (3♦ = 3424 shape, 3♠ = RKCB for hearts)
4♣ 4♠ (3/0 keycards, 4♠ = Control Asking Bid in ♦)
5♥ 5♠ (5♥ = no ♦ control, 5♠ = Control Asking Bid in ♣)
6♦ 7♥ (6♦ = K or AQ in ♣, 7♥ = to play)
The relay asker's main concern is getting a count on Aces and is gratified to find that
partner has three of them. (Note that holding 0 keycards, opener would be placed with
KQx xxxx Qx Qxxx which is too light to open) Once asker is able to place the Queen
of clubs, the grand seems reasonable.
Note: The relay asker can only ask once in a given suit. If the relay asker had the
opportunity to ask for controls in suit but skipped it, he can not ask later in the auction.
Higher bids are to play.
Asker Teller
K9842 AQT5
T AK82
QJ64 A97
AKQ JT
1♣ 1N
2♣ 2♦
2♥ 2♠ (2♠ = 4432 with both majors)
2N 3♦ (3♦ = 4432 shape)
3♠ 4♣ (4♣ = 3/0 keycards in spades)
4♦ 5♣ (4♦ = asking for trump queen, 5♣ = Queen of Spades
AK or Qxxx in Hearts)
5♦ 5♥ (5♥ = A or KQx in Diamonds)
6♠
The hand illustrates a couple important points. First, the strong club opener has a very
minimum hand. From the perspective of the relay asker, he is steering towards 4♠ as
soon as he discovers the 5-4 major suit fit. None-the-less, the 1♣ opener continues to
relay out the hand and discover the complete shape. Teller's 1N response is completely
unlimited. The 1♣ opener relays out the complete shape to prepare in case the teller
shows extra strength. Following the tellers 3♦ bid, the relay asker has enough space to
use RKCB.
4♦ asks for trump Queen. Missing the trump Queen, responder would have bid an
immediate 4♥. Holding it, responder immediately starts to show controls in his longest
remaining suit (in this case hearts). Responder makes a 2 step response (4♠ is a rebid in
the trump suit and would have denied any control in hearts, 4N is a first step response and
shows A or KQ, 5♣ shows AK or Q). In this case, responder is know to have 3 Aces and
must hold the AK of hearts.
Special Cases
The information documented so far is able provides a sound bidding structure that will
allow R to accurate explore for game or slam. However, there are a variety of exceptions
to the normal auction termination sequences. In nearly every case, the exceptions occur
because there has been an “abnormal” auction. Normally RR will completely show his
shape with a bid between 3♦ and 3♥. However, on rare occasions RR might completely
show his shape with an extremely low bid such as 3♣ or a high level bid [3♠ or above].
In these cases, the normal auction termination structure has been optimized for the
amount of bidding space available.
Invitational Sequences
In some cases, R has sufficient bidding space available to be able to add an artificial
range ask to his arsenal. Most often, this will happen when R has been able to start a
denial cue bidding sequence at a low level. For example:
1♣ 1♥ 1♥ = 4+ Spades
1♥ 2♣ 2♣ = Spades and Diamonds
2♦ 3♦ 3♦ = 5341 shape
3♥ 3N 3N = 7 Slam Points
At this point in time, a 4♣ bid would initiate a denial cue bidding sequence. Bids of 4♥
and higher are to play. However, R's 4♦ bid does not yet have a defined meaning.
The 4♦ bid is used as a slam invitation. While RR has already described his slam points,
he could still hold useful cards such as supporting Jacks or singleton honors. The 4♦ bid
asks RR to evaluate his hand in light of the information that he has already provided and
judge whether it is a minimum or a maximum. When responding to the 4♦ asking bid,
RR will make a first step response with any minimum hand. Rebids of Step +1 and
higher show a maximum hand and use the "Standard" denial cue bidding response
schedule.
Symmetric Relay modifies the standard auction termination methods any time that RR
completes resolving shape with a bid of 4♣ or higher. Experience has shown that there is
not sufficient bidding space available to properly apply denial cue bids under these
circumstances. The modified structure is based on the standard RKCB used in the
system. Any time shape is resolved with a bid of 4♣ or greater:
Example Hands
In order to save bidding space, RR has the option zoom into control showing bid
following the final resolution of shape. As a specific example, symmetric relay resolves
a 7411 shape using a bid of 4♣. If RR bids 4♣ he show a 7411 hand that would not kick-
on following R's end signal. A 4♦ bid would show the same 7411 shape however, it
would promise 3 controls more than RR's base. 4♥ would show 4 controls more than
RR's base. Applying this structure will save two steps of bidding space during a tightly
cramped auction.
Example Hands
Relay Structures After Limited Opening Bids
MOSCITO 2000 treats a first step response to the limited Openings as a strong, artificial,
and forcing response. The bid shows at least game invitational values. The first relay bid
will usually reveal Opener's basic hand type [single suited, two suited, balanced, or three
suited]. If R makes a relay bid once he knows hand type, the partnership is in a game
forcing sequence. This second bid establishes the relay. [A complete definition
regarding when relays are established is available in the section detailing competitive
bidding at the close of this document.]
If R has a game invitational hand, he should make a natural bid following RR's first
rebid. This bid is defined as natural and non-forcing. If opener has shown a two suited
hand, the relay break should deny a double fit.
Example auctions
1♦ - 1♥
2♣ - 2♥ 2♥ is natural and non-forcing, promising 3+ hearts.
If R has 4 hearts, he will hold a minimum balanced hand
1♦ - 1♥
2♣ - 3♥ 3♥ is natural and non-forcing, promising 4+ hearts
1♦ - 1♥
2♣ - 2♠ 2♠ is natural and non forcing, promising 5 good spades.
RR's 3♠ rebid shows a 5431 shape with 3 card spade support.
RR's 2N rebid suggests a 5431 hand with a singleton spade
1♦ - 1♥
2♣ - 2N 2N is natural and non-forcing
RR's 3♥ or 3♦ rebid shows a broken 6 card suit.
1♦ - 1♥
2♠ - 3♥ 3♥ is natural and invitational
1♦ - 1♥
2N - 3♦ 3♦ is natural, and non-forcing.
RR's 2N rebid shows diamond shortage, so R must have a good suit.
1♥ - 1♠
2♣ - 3♦ 3♦ is natural and promises 4+ card diamond support.
The 3♦ response tends to deny 3 card spade support.
[Holding a double fit, R should game force]
1♥ - 1♠
2♦ - 2♠ 2♠ is natural and non-forcing, suggesting 3 spades.
The 2♠ response tends to deny 3 good clubs
1♥ - 1♠
2♣ - 2♥ 2♥ is natural and promises 5 good hearts
1♥ - 1♠
2♥ - 3♣ 3♣ is natural and non-forcing, promising 3+ clubs and suggesting
0-2 spades
R will be well positioned to judge the combined potential of the two hands. Recall the
following points:
The biggest problem hand pattern for these methods is when R holds a 5-5 hand pattern
with game invitational values. After a 1♦ opening, responder could be badly placed if
forced to relay with a hand like ♠KQJ63 ♥J2 ♦4 ♣AQ642. A disturbing percentage of
the time, the auction would start 1♦ - 1♥ - 2♣ - ??? and R would be pickled on his rebid.
A 2♦ rebid establishes a game forcing sequence. 2♠ would suppress the club suit, and
2♥ could lead to playing in a 4-2 trump fit. In order to solve this problem, we have
introduced two conventional bids to remove these hand patterns from the relay sequence.
If responder holds a game invitational hand with 5 spade and 5 hearts opposite a 1♠
opening, he should initially bid 2♦ as a transfer to spades and then rebids 3♥.
Relay Structures after a 2♣ Opening
2♦ Relay
2♥ 6+ Clubs and 4 Hearts
2♠ 6+ Spades and 4 Spades Relay
1N Relay
2♣ 2 suited, ♣ + ♦
2♦ Single suited ♦ To Play
2♥ 6+ ♦ and 4 Hearts Relay
2♠ 6+ ♦ and 4 Spades Relay 4♦ + 5+♣
1♥ - 1♠ = Relay
Table 1
1N Balanced hands or
3 suited short hearts or
3 suited short minor or
5+ Spades and 4 Hearts
2♣ Two suited hand Relay
Spades and Diamonds
[Standard relay module]
2♦ Two suited hand Balanced hand pattern
5+ Spades, 4+ Clubs
2♥ 4 Spades, 5+ Clubs 3 suited hand pattern Relay
High shortage Short hearts
[Standard relay module]
2♠ Single suited hand 5+ spades, 5+ hearts 5332 hands Relay
High shortage or
6322/6232 shape
2N Single suited hand 5+ spades, 4 hearts 4432 shape 4144 shape
Middle shortage High shortage ♠+♦
[Standard relay module]
3♣ Single suited hand 5422 shape 4234 shape 5044 shape
7222/6223 shape
3♦ 6331 shape 5431 shape 4324 shape
Notice that in the auction 1♥ - 1♠, 1N - 2♣, Opener rebids 2♦ to show a balanced hand
pattern and rebids 2♥ to show a 3 suited hand pattern. Throughout the structure of the
limited opening bids, a 2♦ rebid is often used as a balanced hand junction. 2♥ is often
used as a 3 suited junction.
Note: Three suited hand patterns with a short minor are shown using a somewhat
idiosyncratic sequence. There are two such hand patterns to worry about: 5404 shape
and 5440 shape.
1♦ - 1♥
1♠ 4+ spades
1N Balanced or
3 suited short spades
2♣ Two suited hand Relay Relay
Hearts and Diamonds Over 1♠ Over 1N
[Standard relay module]
2♦ Two suited hand Balanced, Balanced hands
5+ Clubs, 4+ Hearts 4423/4432 shape
2♥ 4 Hearts, 5+ Clubs 3 suited 3 suited Relay
High shortage hearts and spades short spades
[Standard relay module] short minor
2♠ Single suited hand 6+ hearts, 5 spades 5332 shape
High shortage or
3622/2632 shape
2N Single suited hand 5+ hearts, 4 spades 4432 shape
Middle Shortage High shortage ♥+♦
3♣ Single suited hand 4522 shape 2434 shape
2722/2623 shape
3♦ 3361 shape 4531 shape 3424 shape
Notice that here, once again, 2♦ is used as the balanced hand junction. 2♥ is used as the
three suited hand junction. Following 1♦ - 1♥ - 1♠, 2♣ is used as the relay to preserve
these junctions.
Notice that in the auction, 1♦ - 1♥ - 1♠ - 2♣ - 2♠, opener is know to have 6 hearts and 5
spades. [Holding 5-5 in the majors, opener would start with a 1♥ opening].
All other response show limited hands with between 15 and a bad 18 HCP and clarify
Opener's shape. In general, the higher the level of Opener's rebid, the more specific the
hand type that is being shown. A great deal of emphasis during this part of the response
schedule is spent trying to ensure that the partnership does not miss good 5-4 or 4-3
major suit fits.
Note that responder's ability to show a wide variety of semi-positive hand patterns
immediately following the strong club opening helps to limit his hand type during the
follow on bidding.
Opener's 1♥ Rebid
1♥ is used as a strong Relay, showing 18+ HCP. Following the 1♥ rebid, responder uses
the basic response schedule after the strong club opening, except that all responses are
two steps higher.
1♠ = Second Negative
1N = 4+ Spades, unbalanced hand
2♣ = 4+ Hearts, 0-3 spades, unbalanced hand
2♦ = Any balanced hand pattern
2♥ = Single suited with Diamonds or 3 suited with both minors
2♠ = Single suited with Clubs
2N = 4 Diamonds, 5+ Clubs
3♣ = 5+ Diamonds, 5+ Clubs
3♦ = 4 Clubs, 5+ Diamonds, High Shortage
The 2N response shows a minor oriented hand. Opener denies a 3 card major and has at
most 3 cards combined between the majors. Opener explicitly promises Diamond length
greater than Club length. Opener's most likely shape is xx64.
3♣ = To play
3♦ = To play
Opener's 2♠ Rebid
The 2♠ response shows also shows a minor oriented hand. Opener denies a 3 card major
and has at most 3 cards combined between the majors. Opener's Club length is greater
than or equal to his diamond length. Opener's most likely shapes are xx55 or xx46
Opener's 2♥Rebid
2♠ = 5+ spades, constructive
2N = Puppet to 3 clubs, showing a signoff or constructive hearts raise with
spade values
3♣ = Heart fit, feature showing
3♦ = Heart fit, feature showing
3♥ = Shape raise, semi-preemptive
Opener's 2♦ Rebid
Opener's 1♠ Rebid
1N = Natural
2♣ = Does not promise a canape
2♦ = Does not promise a canape
2♥ = 5+ spades, 4+ hearts
2♠ = Non-maximum, 6+ spades
2N = Maximum hand, Canape (pass or correct bidding follows)
3x = Natural, maximum hand 5-5 shape
2♣ = 3 card spades support, maximum hand
2♦ = Natural
2♥ = Natural
2♠ = preemptive
2N = 4 card spade support, 6-8 HCP
Opener's 1NT Rebid
Example Hands
Opener Responder
♠ A7642 ♠ JT9
♥ AK ♥ Q94
♦ QJ76 ♦ 542
♣ K4 ♣ T876
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♦ (1♣ = Strong, 1♦ = Negative Response)
1♠ Pass (1♠ = 4+ spades, unbalanced hand)
Opener Responder
♠ AK432 ♠5
♥ K62 ♥ AT74
♦ AJ85 ♦ KT62
♣8 ♣ 7542
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♦ (1♣ = Strong, 1♦ = Negative Response)
1♠ 1N (1♠ = 4+ spades, unbalanced hand)
2♦ 3♦ (2♦ = spades and diamonds, 3♦ = constructive)
Pass
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♦ (1♣ = Strong, 1♦ = Negative Response)
1♠ 2N (1♠ = 4+ spades unbalanced hand, 2N = 4+ Spades, max)
3♦ 4♠ (3♦ = Natural + maximum, 4♠ = to play)
2N shows a game invitational raise with 4 card spade support. Here the strong club
opener feels that first round controls in long suits are more important than just simple
HCP. 4♠ is clear over either a 3♣ or 3♥ bid. It is probably justified over 3♦ as well. I
would not argue with a non-forcing 3♠ rebid, however.
Opener Responder
♠ AQJ8 ♠ 9754
♥ QJ862 ♥ J2
♦7 ♦ K642
♣ AQT ♣ 872
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♦ (1♣ = Strong, 1♦ = Negative Response)
2♣ 2♦ (2♣ = 2 or 3 suited hand with hearts, 2♦ = Scrambling)
2♠ Pass (2♠ = 5+ hearts + 4 spades, Pass = to play)
Opener Responder
♠ A9 ♠ J832
♥ AQ962 ♥ 54
♦ 94 ♦ Q732
♣ AQ76 ♣ K82
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♦ (1♣ = Strong, 1♦ = Negative Response)
2♣ 2♦ (2♣ = 2 or 3 suited hand with hearts, 2♦ = Scrambling)
2♥ Pass (2♥ = 5+ hearts and 4 card minor, Pass = to play)
Opener Responder
♠ KQJ6 ♠7
♥ AT862 ♥ QJ95
♦2 ♦ JT43
♣ AJ6 ♣ KT95
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♦ (1♣ = Strong, 1♦ = Negative Response)
2♣ 2N (2♣ = 2 or 3 suited hand with hearts, 2N = Relay)
3♠ 4♥ (3♠ = Spades + maximum, 4♥ = to play)
Opener's 2♣ shows a two or three suited hand with hearts with a minimum strong club
opening. 2N by responder shows a maximum 1♦ response and suggests a heart fit.
Measuring HCP, opener has a true minimum opener. However, the hand also holds two
Aces and a supported King in a 6 loser hand. 3♠ is an aggressive bid. It commits the
partnership to game. I feel that the bid is justified. [Switch the spade suit and either the
club suit or diamond suit and the natural exploratory 3♣/3♦ is clear]
Opener Responder
♠ K62 ♠ J87
♥ KQJ98 ♥ A72
♦5 ♦ Q876
♣ AQ86 ♣ 953
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♦ (1♣ = Strong, 1♦ = Negative Response)
2♣ 2♥ (2♣ = 2 or 3 suited hand with hearts, 2♥ = 3 hearts)
Pass (Pass)
Opener Responder
♠J ♠ 982
♥ K83 ♥ T52
♦ KJ86 ♦ T54
♣ AKQ52 ♣ J963
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♦ (1♣ = Strong, 1♦ = Negative Response)
2♦ Pass (2♦ = Minors)
Opener's 2♦ rebid shows a 5431 or 5530 pattern with both minors. Responder has two
reasonable choices. He can pass and play in 2♦ or rebid a non-forcing 3♣. The 3♣ bid
would assure at least a 4-4 fit, but force the bidding to the 3 level. I prefer to pass.
Opener Responder
♠ AQ7 ♠ J3
♥6 ♥ J7532
♦ AJ842 ♦6
♣ AJ43 ♣ 97652
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♦ (1♣ = Strong, 1♦ = Negative Response)
2♦ 2♥ (2♦ = Minors, 2♥ = Scrambling)
2♠ 3♣ (2♠ = Non-maximum with 3 spades, 3♣ = to play)
Pass
Opener Responder
♠3 ♠ JT97
♥ AK5 ♥8
♦ KJ973 ♦ 82
♣ A652 ♣ JT9743
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♦ (1♣ = Strong, 1♦ = Negative Response)
2♦ 3♣ (2♦ = Minors, 3♣ = to play)
On this hand, responder has the option of scrambling with 2♠. However, a direct, non-
forcing 3♣ seems much more practical. This is not the right hand to play a Moysian fit at
the 2 level. Furthermore, opener could chose to super-accept over the 2♠ scramble.
Opener Responder
♠ A5 ♠ T9
♥Q ♥ J98542
♦ AQJT2 ♦ K3
♣ K9842 ♣ QJ3
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♦ (1♣ = Strong, 1♦ = Negative Response)
2♠ 2N (2♠ = Both minors ♣ >= ♦, 2N = Club preference)
3♣ Pass (3♣ = to play)
Opener Responder
♠ Q3 ♠ A852
♥2 ♥ J73
♦ AQ962 ♦ J75
♣ KQJ93 ♣ T62
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♦ (1♣ = Strong, 1♦ = Negative Response)
2♠ 3♣ (2♠ = Both minors ♣ >= ♦, 3♣ = Bid Diamonds with 5-5)
3♦ Pass (3♦ = At least 5-5 in minors, Pass = To play)
Opener Responder
♠ K5 ♠ Q2
♥4 ♥ AT65
♦ KQ53 ♦ JT62
♣ AKJ942 ♣ T75
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♦ (1♣ = Strong, 1♦ = Negative Response)
2♠ 3♣ (2♠ = Both minors, ♣ >= ♦, 3♣ = Bid Diamonds with 5-5)
Pass (Pass = To play)
Relay Breaks
A positive response to a strong club opening establishes a game forcing auction. In most
cases, the strong club opener will proceed by relaying to determine RR's shape, asking
for controls, and then placing the contract appropriately. There are, however, some cases
where the strong club opener will chose to make a bid other than the first step relay. This
is referred to as a relay break. Relay breaks are one of the most complicated part of any
relay system. Relay breaks have for different meanings depending on when during the
auction opener breaks the relay. For example, a relay break once responder has promised
a two suited hand has a very different meaning than a relay break opposite a single suited
hand pattern or an indeterminate response. In a similar fashion, a relay break during a
game forcing auction has a different meaning than a during a game invitational relay
sequence. In this chapter, we will focus on relay breaks during game forcing sequences.
[Relay breaks used during game invitational relays sequences following a limited
opening bid will be covered during a separate chapter.]
During the early stages of a relay auction, the strong club opener has the option of
breaking relays and describing his shape. There are two primary cases where a strong
club opener will break relays during immediately following responder's first bid.
If responder has unbalanced hand and opener has a misfit for the suit initially shown by
responder, opener has the option to break relays. Bids between Step +1 to Step +4 are
used to specifically show hands with a singleton or void in the suit shown by responder.
1. Following the auction 1♣ - 1NT, opener can break relays to show a weak
balanced hand and explore for stoppers. These auctions have already been
described in an earlier chapter and will not be reviewed here.
When holding a misfit for partner's suit, it is often best for the strong club opener to
transfer captaincy and begin describing his hand to responder. Relay systems often work
best when a balanced or semi-balanced hand pattern is asking and the unbalanced hand
patterns show shape. The more balanced hand patterns are better positioned to determine
whether to explore for slam or when trying to place controls. Furthermore, experience
has shown that the low level relay breaks leave the partnership in a better position to
determine whether they hold a fit while still preserving space to break to intelligently
explore for a possible 3N contract.
When using this series of relay breaks, the strong club opener can potentially hold a
single suited hand, a two suited hand, or a three suited hand. It is important to remember
that the strong club opener will always hold a singleton or void in partner's suit.
The basic response structure used for these low level relay breaks conforms to the rest of
the relay system. The response structure is symmetric in nature, with suits shown in
order ♠ > ♥ > ♦ > ♣.
Our initial example will consider relay breaks following the auction 1♣ - 1♥. A 1♠ bid
following responder's 1♥ would be a relay. Bids from 1N+ are relay breaks and show the
strong club opener's shape.
There are a few basic points to remember about the relay structure.
Any raise of partner's initial suit shows a single suited hand. In this example,
a break to 2♥ over responder's original 1♥ shows a single suited hand with
clubs. Breaking to 1N over 1♥ shows hearts. Rebidding 2♥ shows a single
suited hand.
Raise -1 of partner's suit shows a 3 suited hand.
The relay structure is closely modeled after standard response structures,
however, there is no need for a high shortage junction. [The strong club
opener's short suit is already known]
- The ordering for the symmetric relay is preserved
- Single suited hands are shown in order 6331, 7321, 7330.
- Two suited hands are shown in order 5431, 6421, 6430, 7420,
7411
- Hand patterns that are shown asymmetrically like 6511 hands or 6520
hands are also shown using the "standard" relay sequences. [The
junction bid for 6511 hands is shown as a first step response. The two
6520 shape are shown immediately following the 5530 pattern]
Table 1
1N 4+ ♥
2♣ 4+ ♦ Relay
2♦ 3 suited hands 2 suited, ♥ + ♦ Relay
2♥ Single suited ♣'s Single suited, ♥'s Single suited, ♦'s Relay
2♠ 2 suited, ♥ + ♣ 2 suited, ♥ + ♦ 1444 shape Relay
Reverser Reverser
2N 5+/5+, ♥ + ♣ 5+/5+, ♥ + ♦ 0544 shape 1336 shape
3♣ 1534 1354 04 54 1327/1237 Relay
shape shape
3♦ 1624 1264 0445 shape 0337 shape 1516/1615
shape
3♥ 0634 0364 1525 shape
3♠ 0724 0274 0535 shape
3N 1714 1174 0526 shape Relay
4♣ 0625 shape 1516 shape
4♦ 1615 shape
Example Hands
Hand 1
Opener Responder
♠ --- ♠ Q8632
♥ A653 ♥ KQJ
♦ KQJ763 ♦ A84
♣ A92 ♣K
Auction 1
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♥
1♠ 2♦
2♥ 3♦
???
Notice how poorly positioned the strong club opener is to explore for slam. He holds a
minimum opening hand. Exploring for slam bypasses 3N - often a risky position. If the
strong club opener signs off in 3N, responder does not have enough strength to zoom and
show controls.
Auction 2
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♥ (1♣ = Strong, 1♥ = 4 + spades)
1N 2♣ (1N = 4+ hearts, 2♣ = relay)
2♦ 2♥ (2♦ = hearts and diamonds, 2♥ = relay)
2♠ 2N (2♠ = Reverser, 2N = Relay)
3♥ 4♣ (3♥ = 0463 shape, 4♣ = RKCB on Diamonds)
4♥ 4♠ (4♥ = 3/0 Key cards. 4♠ = Queen ask)
4N 7♦ (4N = Q of trump, A or KQ in hearts. 7♦ = to play)
After the reverse relay, the balanced hand pattern is better positioned to judge the two
hands potential. It is a simply matter to ask for Keycards, place the trump Queen, and bid
the slam.
Hand 2
Opener Responder
♠3 ♠ AKT76
♥ AKT85 ♥ Q3
♦ KJ2 ♦ 43
♣ A864 ♣ KJ93
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♥ (1♣ = Strong, 1♥ = unbalanced hand, 4+ spades)
1N 2♣ (1N = 4+ hearts, 0-1 spades, 2♣ = Relay)
3♣ 3♦ (3♣ = 1534 shape, 3♦ = Control Ask)
3♠ 3N (3♠ = 10 AKQ controls. 3N = to play)
Hand 3
Opener Responder
♠A ♠ QT9653
♥ KQJ64 ♥ A83
♦ AT852 ♦ J9
♣ Q5 ♣ KJ
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♥ (1♣ = Strong, 1♥ = unbalanced hand, 4+ spades)
1N 2♣ (1N = 4+ hearts, 0-1 spades, 2♣ = Relay)
2♦ 2♥ (2♦ = Hearts and Diamonds, 2♥ = Relay)
2N 3♣ (2N = 5+/5+ shape, 3♣ = Relay)
3♥ 4♦ (3♥ = 1552 shape, 4♦ = End Signal)
4♥ Pass (4♥ = no extra strength)
Hand 4
Opener Responder
♠8 ♠ KT742
♥ AKQ642 ♥ ---
♦ AJ2 ♦ KT76
♣ KJ3 ♣ A732
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♥ (1♣ = Strong, 1♥ = unbalanced hand, 4+ spades)
1N 2♣ (1N = 4+ hearts, 0-1 spades. 2♣ = Relay)
2♥ 3N (2♥ = Single suited with hearts, 3N = To play)
Holding a minimum hand, and able to judge that there is a complete misfit, responder has
an easy 3N bid
The Symmetric relay response structure described in Table 1 can be generalized for any of the following auctions:
1♣ - 1♥ (1♥ = 4+ spades)
1♣ - 1♠ (1♠ = 4+ hearts)
1♣ - 2♣ (2♣ = 4+ Diamonds)
1♣ - 2♦ (2♦ = 4+ Clubs)
Instead to assigning a specific meaning to given suit, the generalized response schedule uses a step response system.
Once again, suits are shown in order ♠ > ♥ > ♦ > ♣. A raise (Step +4) always shows a single suited hand. Step +3 always shows a
three suited hand.
Table 2
Step +1 4+ Suit A
Step +2 4+ Suit B Relay
Step +3 3 suited hands 2 suited, A + B Relay
Step +4 Single suited Single suited, Single suited, Relay
(raise) Suit C Suit A Suit B
Step +5 2 suited, A + C 2 suited, B + C 1444 shape Relay
Reverser Reverser
Step +6 5+/5+, A + C 5+/5+, B + C 0544 shape 6331 shape
Step +7 5431, A + C 5431, B + C 0454 shape 7321/7231 Relay
shape
Step +7 6421, A + C 6421, B + C 0445 shape 7330 shape 1516/1615
shape
Step +8 6430 6430, B + C 1525 shape
Step +9 7420 7420, B + C 0535 shape
Step +A 7411 7411, B + C 0526 shape Relay
Step +B 0625 shape 1516 shape
Step +C 1615 shape
Example Hands
Hand 1
Opener Responder
♠ 763 ♠ K84
♥3 ♥ KQT65
♦ AQ6 ♦ KJ53
♣ AKQJ62 ♣7
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♠ (1♣ = strong, 1♠ = 4+ hearts)
2♠ 3N (2♠ = Single suited, clubs. 3N = to play)
Hand 2
Opener Responder
♠ AJ ♠ 965
♥ AQT873 ♥ ---
♦T ♦ KQ963
♣ A962 ♣ KQ875
Opener Responder
1♣ 2♣ (1♣ = Strong, 2♣ = 4+ Diamonds)
2♠ 2N (2♠ = 4+Hearts, 0-1 Diamonds. 2N = Relay)
3N 4♦ (3N = 2614 shape, 4♦ = End signal)
4♥ 5♣ (4♥ = no extra strength, 5♣ = to play)
Hand 3
Opener Responder
♠ AQJ 8 ♠ 76
♥ J8764 ♥Q
♦J ♦ AT862
♣ AK4 ♣ QT986
Opener Responder
1♣ 2♣ (1♣ = Strong, 2♣ = 4+ Diamonds)
2♥ 2♠ (2♥ = 4+ Spades, 2♠ = Relay)
2N 3N (2N = Spades and Hearts, 3N = To play)
Hand 4
Opener Responder
♠ KQJ8 ♠ 97
♥Q ♥ J754
♦ A932 ♦ KQJT5
♣ A873 ♣ K2
Opener Responder
1♣ 1♠ (1♣ = Strong, 1♠ = 4+ hearts)
2♥ 2♠ (2♥ = 3 suited, 2♠ = relay)
2N 3♣ (2N = 4144 shape, 3♦ = Asks for Relay Points)
3♦ 3N (3♦ = 9 AKQ relay points. 3N = To Play)
On occasion, the relay asker will know the placement of 12 out of the 13 cards in the
relay teller's hand. For example, in the auction
1♣ - 1♥
1♠ - 3♣
R is known to hold precisely 7222 or 6223 shape. In this case, R knows the location of
12 out of RR’s 13 cards
Examples
7321 hands are shown with a 3♥ bid. The relay asks knows the location of
the seven card suit and the singleton but can not place the 3-2 combination.
6511 hands are shown with a 3♦ bid. The relay asker knows the location of
both singletons but doesn't know the relative length of the two long suits.
In these cases, we use a slightly different version of the standard auction termination
mechanism. A first step response is a relay for shape asking the relay teller to show
length or shortness. Step +1 or higher is Roman Keycard Blackwood. Suit ordering is
set in the standard order. As always, 3N is to play.
Note: Recall that Slam Point Asks only apply when R knows the location or all 13 of
RR’s cards. If R decides to break relays, he will break to Roman Key Card Blackwood.
In most case, the relay asker will chose to move forward with some form of control ask
rather than relaying out complete shape.
112
Example
Example hands
Asker Teller
65 AKJT874
AQ63 K5
AKQ6 2
Q96 AJ5
1♣ 1♥
1♠ 2♦
2♥ 2N
3♣ 3♥ (3♥ = 7 spades, one diamond, 2-3 ♥/♣)
4♣ 4♥ (RKCB for Spades, 4♥ = 0/3 Keycards
4N 5♣ (4N = Trump Queen Ask, 5♣ = no trump Queen]
6♠
Asker Teller
AQJ4 KT973
AK96 3
T96 2
KT AQ8762
1♣ 1♥
1♠ 2♠
2N 3♦ (3♦ = 6115 or 5116 shape)
3♠ 4♦ (3♠ = RKCB for spades, 4♦ = 2 key cards, no Queen)
4♥ 5♦ (4♥ = Control Asking Bid in Clubs, 5♦ = K or AQ)
6♠ Pass
Following responder's 3♦ rebid, the relay asker's own shape provides a good guess as to
responder's relative length. The relay asker chooses to move directly into RKCB since
113
this will save a step of bidding space. Notice that at the point where the relay asker uses
RKCB, the teller has not shown his relative length in the Black suits. Hence, the ordering
for the Roman Key card ask is for Spades before Clubs.
In some cases, the relay asker will not need to identify RR's complete shape and will
want to break relays at a relatively low level. 5332 hands are shown using a variety of
low level bids. For example, following 1♣ - 1N, 5332 hands are resolved via 2N.
Following auction like
In each cases, the relay asker is able to place the five card suit, but not the doubleton. In
this example, where 12 card shape is know at or below the level of 2N, we once again use
a special response scale. This same response structure applies any time that responder
knows the location of 12 of the 13 cards below the level of 3♣
As always, 3NT is to play. Since only 12 of the 13 cards are know, 4♦ is not the end
signal
Example Hand
Opener Responder
♠ A7 ♠ KT98
♥ KJ ♥ AQ6
♦ AK97652 ♦ QT4
♣ Q7 ♣ AT8
In this example, opener is not worried about placing responder's 13th card. Instead, the
main priority is to be able to ask for Aces below the level of 3NT.
Responder's hand is know to be some 4333. By default RR will place the 13th card in the
highest suit. In this case, coincidentally that happens to be Spades.
114
Competitive Bidding After a Strong Club Opening
MOSCITO has adopted a well defined response structure to attempt to handle
interference during our strong club auctions. We will consider two separate cases: The
first is direct seat interference after a strong clubs opening. The second is interference
during our relay auctions.
Defensive agreements following a strong club opening depend on the level of the direct
seat overcall and whether or not the overcall promises a known anchor suit. Low level
interference such as double or 1♦ does not break the relays. If the opponents interfere
with either of these bids will actually increase the amount of bidding space available to
our partnership. Responder will use this bidding space to immediately clarify his hand
type.
If the opponents overcall 1♥ or higher, relays are broken. In this case our defensive
system depends on whether or not the opponents have shown a known anchor suit. If the
opponents do not show an anchor we play a direct seat double as balanced and game
forcing and attempt to extract a penalty. If the opponents make a natural bid then direct
seat doubles are takeout oriented.
Overcall
Double 1♥+ = System on
1♦ = 6 - 9 HCP balanced
1♥ = Relay [Continuations as after 1♣ - 1N]
New suits are forcing for 1 round
2♣ = 15-17 HCP, two or three suited with 4+ ♥
[Same as after 1♣ - 1♦ - 2♣]
XX = 6-9 HCP unbalanced
1♦ = Relay [Drop 1N step]
New Suits are forcing 1 round
115
Overcall Known Anchor Suit No Known Anchor Suit
1♥ or 1♠ X = 6 - 9 HCP, Takeout oriented X = Balanced Game Forcing
1NT = 6-9 HCP with stopper 1NT = 6-9 HCP balanced
System as after 1N opening System as after 1N opening
Puppet Stayman + Puppet Stayman
Cue Bid = Game Force, balanced no stopper Cue Bid = Natural
2N = Game Force Natural 2N = 5/5 shape
System as after 1N opening
Puppet Stayman
New Suit = Game Force Natural New suit = Game Force Natural
Jump Shift = Weak Jump Shift = Weak
1N - 2♠ New Suits are Game Force Natural New Suits are Game Force
Jumps are weak Natural
X = Takeout Jumps are weak
Non jump = natural and weak X = Balanced and Game Forcing
2N, Cue bid, or jump = Game Cue Bid = Game Forcing Natural
Forcing. 2N by opener may be 2N = 5/5 shape
Unbalanced
Cue Bid = 5/5 shape
2N = Game Force Natural, Balanced
If 1N shows the minors then
2♣ = Good with ♥
2♦ = Good with ♠
2♥ = Natural and weak
2♠ = Natural and weak
If 1N is strong then 2N is the only Game
Forcing Bid
2N+ Anything but pass is game forcing Anything but pass is game
Double = Penalty forcing
Double = Penalty
116
Interference during a relay auction
MOSCITO has a rigorous definition describing when a relay auction has been
established. A relay auction is established when any of the following situations occurs:
Examples
1♣ - 1♥ relay is established
1♣ - 2♦ relay is established
2. Following the auction 1♣ - 1♦, the strong club openers rebids 1♥ and responder
makes a positive response
Examples
1♣ - 1♦ relay is established
1♥ - 2♣
1♣ - 1♦ relay is established
1♥ - 1♠
117
3. Following a limited opening bid, relay is established if R makes a relay response once
he knows responder's basic hand type [single suited, two suited, three suited, or balanced]
Examples
1♥ - 1♠ Relay is not established. R knows the hand type [two suited] but R has
2♣ not made a relay response
1♥ - 1♠ Relay is established. R knows the hand type and has made a relay
2♣ - 2♦ response.
1♦ - 1♥ Relay is not established. R does not know the hand type. RR could be
1♠ - 1N two suited with hearts and spades, balanced, or three suited.
4. Relay is established any time that R knows the location of 12-14 cards in RR's hand.
Examples
If the opponents interfere once relay is established, then the following set of rules applies
Examples
Hand 1
1♣ - (P) - 1♠ - (2♣)
???
Pass by R is relay
A double by RR is penalty. [RR could have 4+ clubs on the auction]
RR will bid 2♦ with a normal 1N response. RR will bid 2♥ with a normal 2♣ response.
Relays continue, but the level is elevated by 2 steps.
118
Hand 2
1♦ - (P) - 1♥ - (P)
2♣ - (P) - 2♦ - (2♠)
???
Hand 3
1♣ - (P) - 1♠ - (2♠)
Potentially, we may experience hands where the opponents bid during a relay auction
before a relay is established. For example consider 1♦ - (P) - 1♥ - 2♣ R has made an
initial relay, however there is interference before the relay is established.
In this situation, the agreements depend on whether the intervention took the form of a
double or an overcall.
Examples
Hand 1
1♦ - (P) - 1♥ - (X)
???
119
Pass by RR is a normal 1N response. [After 1♠ - (X), R will redouble to play and bid 1N
as the relay]
1N by RR is a normal 2♣ response.
Relays continue at step -1.
If the opponents overcall before relay is established, relays are off. In direct seat, the first
double is takeout. The second double is penalty. New suits are forcing for one round. In
balancing seat, doubles are still for takeout, however, new suits are non-forcing.
Examples
Hand 1
1♦ - (P) - 1♥ - (2♣)
X - (3♣) - X
Hand 2
1♦ - (P) - 1♥ - (2♣)
X - (2♦) - X
Hand 3
1♥ - (P) - 1♠ - (2♦)
3♣
120
Appendix Structure:
The MOSCITO variant described in the core of the system notes is simple version of the
system that can be learned with minimal effort. The appendix system is designed to
provide “improved” variants of the system. These system variants significantly improve
the efficiency of the system at the expense of adding some complexity to the relay
structures. Typically, I recommend that players who are new to relay methods focus on
learning the simplified variant of the system. As you gain experience with the system,
the basics of symmetric relay will become ingrained. Equally important, you will start to
appreciate some of the inefficiencies with the basic relay structures. At this point in time,
you might consider adopting one or more of the alternative response structures.
Currently, there are three different appendixes, each designed to address a different
element of the bidding system.
Appendix A provides an improved response structure over the strong club opening.
121
Appendix A: Improved Relay Structure over 1♣
122
Table ???
1♣ Strong Club Opening
1♦ Strong, artificial, forcing response
1♥ Relay
Single suited with Spades OR
Single suited with Diamonds OR
1♠ 2 suited with Spades
1NT Balanced or any 4441 Relay
Single suited with Clubs OR Single suited with Diamonds or
2♣ 2 suited with Clubs and Hearts 2 suited with Spades and Hearts
2♦ Hearts and Diamonds, 2 suited Spades and Diamonds, 2 suited Relay
2♥ Single suited with Hearts Single suited with Spades Single suited with Diamonds
2♠ 4 Diamonds, 5+ Clubs 4 Spades, 5+ Clubs 4 Spades, 5+ Hearts
2NT 5+ Diamonds, 5+ Clubs 5+ Spades and 5+ Clubs 5+ Spades and 5+ Hearts
3♣ 4 Clubs, 5+ Diamonds, High Shortage 4 Clubs, 5+ Spades, High Shortage 4 Hearts, 5+ Spades, High Shortage
3♦ 2254 shape 5224 shape 5422 shape
3♥ 3154 shape 5314 shape 5431 shape
3♠ 2164 shape 6214 shape 6421 shape
3NT 3064 shape 6304 shape 6430 shape
Table ???
1♣ Strong Club Opening
1♦ Game force
1♥ Relay
Spades OR
Diamonds OR
1♠ 2 suited with Spades
1NT Balanced or any 4441
Clubs OR Relay
2♣ Clubs and Hearts
2♦ Hearts and Diamonds 4+ Hearts
2♥ Single suited with ♥ 4+ Spades Relay
2♠ 4 Diamonds, 5+ Clubs 4441 shape 4432 (♥+♠) Relay
2NT 5+ Diamonds, 5+ Clubs Any 5332 with 5♦ Any 5332 with 5♥ Any 5332 with 5♠ Relay
3♣ 4♣, 5+♦, High Shortage 4432 (♣ + ♦) 4432 (♥+♦) 4432 (♠+♦) 1444
3♦ 2254 shape 2335 shape Minimum x4x4 Minimum x4x4 4144
3♥ 3154 shape 3235 shape Maximum 2434 Maximum 4234 4414
3♠ 2164 shape 3325 shape Maximum 3424 Maximum 4324 4441
3NT 3064 shape 3334 shape
124
Appendix B: Alternative Relay Structure over 1♦/1♥ openings
Appendix B provides an alternative response structure over 1♦ and 1♥ opening bids.
There are two primary goals in changing the response structure. First, the relay asker is
able to get immediate information regarding whether opener has a 4 card major or a 5+
card suit. If the relay asker does not have slam ambitions this information often allows
him to immediately place the final contract. In addition, in some cases, the improved
response structure also allows the relay asker to get immediate information about
opener’s range.
These two changes address one of the major weaknesses with the original relay structure:
Responder was often faced with an awkward rebid holding an invitational hand with 3
card support for opener’s major. The new structure often allows responder to directly
place the contract after opener’s rebid.
After 1♦ - 1♥, immediate bids of 2♣+ are used to show maximum strength unbalanced
hands with 5+ Hearts. An immediate 1♠ response shows minimum strength unbalanced
hands with 5+ Heart. The 1NT response shows balanced hands and unbalanced hands
with exactly 4 Hearts. The first 2 tables provides a summary of the response structure
over 1♦ openings. Notice that standard symmetric relay principles apply: The relay
response structure after 1♦ - 1♥ - 2♣+ is complete symmetric to 1♦ - 1♥ - 1♠ - 1NT - 2♣+
Table 1
1♦ “Normal” 1♦ opening bid
1♥ Relay
1♠ 5+ Hearts, minimum hands
1NT 4 Hearts or balanced hands Relay
2♣ 5+ Hearts and 4+ Diamonds 5+ Hearts and 4+ Diamonds
2♦ Single suited hands Single suited hands
2♥ 5+ Hearts and 4 Clubs 5+ Hearts and 4 Clubs
2♠ 5+ Hearts and 5+ Clubs 5+ Hearts and 5+ Clubs
2NT 4 Spades, 5+ Hearts, High Shortage 4 Spades, 5+ Hearts, High Shortage
3♣ 4522 shape 4522 shape
3♦ 4531 shape 4531 shape
3♥ 4621 shape 4621 shape
3♠ 4630 shape 4630 shape
Holding either a balanced hand or any unbalanced hand with exactly 4 hearts, opener will
rebid 1N over the 1♥ relay. Note that the 1NT response does not provide any immediate
information about range.
126
The relay structure to show hands with 5+ Hearts is extremely simple and follows
standard symmetric relay principles. The only “unusual” feature how opener shows 5440
hands with 5 Hearts. Opener’s 2♣ rebid is used to show either a two suited hand with
Hearts and Diamonds OR the three suited hand pattern.
Table 2
1♦ “Normal” 1♦ opening bid
1♥ Relay
1♠ 5+ Hearts, minimum hands
1NT 4 Hearts or balanced hands
2♣ 5+ Hearts and 4+ Diamonds
2♦ Single suited hands Relay
2♥ 5+ Hearts and 4 Clubs Any 5440 hand with 5♥
2♠ 5+ Hearts and 5+ Clubs 5+♥ / 5+♦ Relay
2NT 4 Spades, 5+ Hearts, High Shortage 5+♥/4♦ High shortage 0544 shape
3♣ 4522 shape 2542 shape 4504 shape
3♦ 4531 shape 3541 shape 4550 shape
3♥ 4621 shape 2640 shape
3♠ 4630 shape 3640 shape
The relay structure used to show hands with precisely 4 Hearts is slightly more complex,
based on the requirement to include several disparate hand types including balanced hand
patterns, 4441 hand patterns, 5440 hands, as well as two suiters.
Here once again, we have tried to construct an intuitive relay structure that applies
symmetric relay principles. However, it was necessary to elevate certain 2 suited hand
patterns by one step.
Table 3
1♦ “Normal” 1♦ opening bid
1♥ Relay
1♠ 5+ Hearts, minimum hands
1NT 4 Hearts or balanced hands
2♣ 5+ Hearts and 4+ Diamonds Relay
2♦ Single suited hands Balanced hands or 4441s
2♥ 5+ Hearts and 4 Clubs 4♥ and 5+ ♦
2♠ 5+ Hearts and 5+ Clubs 4♥ and 5+ ♣ Relay
2NT 4 Spades, 5+ Hearts, High Shortage 5332 hands, minimum strength 5440 hand patterns
3♣ 4522 shape 2533 shape, maximum 4♥ and 5+♦, High shortage Relay
3♦ 4531 shape 3523 shape, maximum 2452 shape 4450 shape
3♥ 4621 shape 3532 shape, maximum 3451 shape 4405 shape
3♠ 4630 shape 2461 shape 0454 shape
3NT 3460 shape 0445 shape
Table 4
1♦ “Normal” 1♦ opening bid
1♥ Relay
1♠ 5+ Hearts, minimum hands
1NT 4 Hearts or balanced hands
2♣ 5+ Hearts and 4+ Diamonds Relay
2♦ Single suited hands Balanced hands or 4441s
2♥ 5+ Hearts and 4 Clubs 4♥ and 5+ ♦ Relay
2♠ 5+ Hearts and 5+ Clubs 4♥ and 5+ ♣ ♠+♥ Balanced or 4441
2NT 4 Spades, 5+ Hearts, High Shortage 5332 hands, minimum strength ♠+♦ Balanced Relay
3♣ 4522 shape 2533 shape, maximum 3433 shape 1444/4414/4441
3♦ 4531 shape 3523 shape, maximum 4xx4 (minimum) 44xx (minimum)
3♥ 4621 shape 3532 shape, maximum 4234 (maximum) 4423 maximum
3♠ 4630 shape 4324 (maximum) 4432 maximum
3NT
Relays after the 1♥ opening
The relay structure over the 1♥ opening is modeled after that over 1♦. An immediate
1NT rebid shows either balanced hands or hands with precisely 4 Spades. All hands with
5+ Spades are immediately shown using a rebid of 2♣+.
Table 1
1♥ “Normal” 1♥ opening bid
1♠ Relay
1NT 4 Spades or a Balanced hand
2♣ 5+ Spades and 4+ Hearts
2♦ Single suited hands Relay
2♥ 5+ Spades and 4+ Diamonds 5440 hand patterns
2♠ 5+ Spades and 5+ Clubs 5+ ♠ and 5+ ♥ Relay
2NT 5+ Spades, 4 Clubs, High shortage 5+ ♠, 4♥, High shortage 5044 shape
3♣ 5224 shape 5422 shape 5404 shape
3♦ 5314 shape 5413 shape 5440 shape
3♥ 6214 shape 6412 shape
3♠ 6304 shape 6403 shape
Substantially few hand patterns are opened with 1♥ as compared to 1♦. [All 4432
patterns with 4-4 in the majors are opened 1♦. All 5440 hand patterns with 4-4 in the
major are opened 1♦. All 4441 hand patterns with both majors are opened 1♦].
Table 2
1♥ “Normal” 1♥ opening bid
1♠ Relay
1NT 4 Spades or a Balanced hand
2♣ 5+ Spades and 4+ Hearts Relay
2♦ Single suited hands Balanced hands or 4441 shape
2♥ 5+ Spades and 4+ Diamonds 4 Spades and 5+ Diamonds
2♠ 5+ Spades and 5+ Clubs 4 Spades and 5+ Clubs Relay
2NT 5+ Spades, 4 Clubs, High shortage 5332 shape, minimum strength 4054 / 4045 shape Relay
3♣ 5224 shape 5233 shape 4♠ and 5+♦, High shortage 4♠ / 5+♣ High shortage
3♦ 5314 shape 5323 shape 4252 shape 4225 shape
3♥ 6214 shape 5332 shape 4351 shape 4315 shape
3♠ 6304 shape 4261 shape 4216 shape
3NT 4360 shape 4306 shape
Table 3
1♥ “Normal” 1♥ opening bid
1♠ Relay
1NT 4 Spades or a Balanced hand
2♣ 5+ Spades and 4+ Hearts Relay
2♦ Single suited hands Balanced hands or 4441 shape
2♥ 5+ Spades and 4+ Diamonds 4 Spades and 5+ Diamonds Relay
2♠ 5+ Spades and 5+ Clubs 4 Spades and 5+ Clubs Spades and Diamonds
2NT 5+ Spades, 4 Clubs, High shortage 5332 shape, minimum strength 4333 / 4144 shape Relay
3♣ 5224 shape 5233 shape 4xx4 shape, minimum 4x4x shape, minimum
3♦ 5314 shape 5323 shape 4234 shape, maximum 4243 shape, maximum
3♥ 6214 shape 5332 shape 4324 shape, maximum 4342 shape, maximum
3♠ 6304 shape
3NT
Appendix D: New Preemptive Opening Structure
Frelling Two Bids
2 Diamond Opening
2 Heart Opening
2 Spade Opening
132
restrictions for the various opening bids. It seemed most accurate to eliminate suit
quality requirements altogether during the initial simulations.)
The second simulation measured the safety of the preemptive opening style. Our goal
was to simulate the frequency with which a preemptor would be able to successfully
scramble to an eight+ card fit opposite a 2♦ or 2♥ opening compared to players using
traditional preemptive methods. Responder will scramble whenever his diamond length is
less than or equal to his length in each major.
The percentage chance that the partnership will successful scramble to an 8+ card fit can
be modeled as the percentage chance that [responder does not scramble and the
partnership has an 8+ card diamond fit] plus [the percentage chance that responder does
scramble, opener's hearts are greater than his spades, and the partnership has an 8+ card
hearts fit] plus [the percentage chance that responder does scramble, opener's spades are
greater than his hearts, and the partnership has an 8+ card spade fit].
Simulations show that following a two diamond opening, the partnership will be able to
scramble to an 8+ card fit at the two level approximately 64.6% of the time. A similar
analysis was performed for the two heart opening and found that the partnership is able to
scramble to an eight card fit in Hearts, Spades, or Clubs 66.4% of the time. Both opening
bids will identify a seven+ card fit 90% of the time. In this case, the more traditional
preemptive style does come out ahead. Opposite a single suited preempt showing 6322 or
6331 hand type, the partnership will have an 8+ card fit in the bid major on about 76.4%
of all hands. However, as an interesting point of comparison, “aggressive” players in the
North America are frequently including 5332 or 54xx hand patterns inside their 2M
opening bids. A 2M opening based on a 54xx or 5332 hand pattern will hit an eight card
fit in the bid major approximately 54.3% of the time. Players who are interested in
adopting a more aggressive preemptive structure might find assumed fit methods to be a
safe alternative to highly undisciplined single suited preempts.
The last important question that needs to be considered is whether these preempts will
typically allow the partnership to achieve a positive score against strong opponents using
effective counter measures. My own experience with these opening bids suggests that
133
there is a distinct relationship between the strength range shown by the opening and the
partnerships expected result. These bids are much more effective when they are anchored
by a light opening system such as MOSCITO then when used in conjunction with a very
sound opening style. There are two main reasons that explain this observation. First,
while the 2♦ and 2♥ opening bids are highly obstructive to the opponents, they also
impede the ability of our own partnership to exchange information. Delicate slam
explorations can be difficult following one of these openings. The weaker the strength
range of the opening preempt, the less likely that responder will have a hand that is strong
enough to require a delicate slam inquiry. The response structure can be better optimized
if the focus is restricted to part score and game decisions.
Second, the weaker the strength range shown by the opening bid, the more likely that
responder will pass the preemptive opening holding a "strong" hand. In turn, this puts
much more pressure on the opponent sitting in the balancing position. Simply put, when
an opponent is judging whether to balance, a weaker range for the opening bid leaves
more HCP strength unaccounted for. This in turn provides more opportunities for the
opponents to guess wrong, and increases the opportunity to extract a good result opposite
a bad balancing decision.
134
Frelling Two Bids: Response Schedule
We suggest a basic response for use over the different opening bids. A number of
explicit design criteria were used when creating the response structure. In discussing the
design criteria, I will use the 2♦ for my examples, however, the same basic structure is
used over the 2♥ opening bid.
135
2 Diamond Opening
136
Specific auctions for a number of different hand types will be used to show how the
suggested response structure fulfills the design criteria.
Hand type 1: Responder wants to invite game if opener holds a maximum hand with 4+
Hearts. Responder wants to play in 3♦ opposite any hand with Spades.
Auction. 2♦ - 3♣
Opener will rebid 3♦ holding Diamonds and Spades
Opener will rebid 3♥ with Hearts and a minimum.
Opener will rebid 3N+ with Hearts and a maximum
Hand type 2: Responder wants to invite game if opener holds a maximum hand with 4+
Spades. Responder wants to play in 3♦ opposite any hand with Hearts.
Auction: 2♦ - 2♠, 2N – 3♦
Opener will pass holding Hearts
Opener will rebid 3♠ holding Spades and a minimum
Opener will rebid 3♥+ holding Spades and a maximum
Hand type 3: Responder holds a game invitational hand with 4+ cards in both majors.
Responder wants to invite game if opener has a maximum hand.
Auction: 2♦ - 3♣
If opener shows Hearts and a maximum, bid 4・
If Opener rebids 3♦ showing Spades (any strength hand), responder will bid 3♠ to invite
4♠ opposite a maximum hand.
Auction: 2♦ - 2N
Opener will rebid 3♦ with any minimum hand.
Opener other rebids will show maximum hands and indicate responder’s major and their
length. (After the auction 2♦ - 2N – 3♣, a 3♦ rebid asks for Heart length)
137
Hand type 5: Responder holds a single suited hand with Hearts and game invitational
strength
Auction: 2♦ - 2♠
Responder will rebid 3♥ after opener’s 2NT rebid
Hand type 6: Responder holds a single suited hand with Spades and game invitational
strength
Auction: 2♦ - 2N
After a 3♣ or 3♦ response, responder will rebid 3♠ showing a single suited hand with
Spades and game invitational strength
Auction: 2♦ - 2♠
Responder will rebid 3♣ after opener’s 2N rebid. {Some players may prefer to treat this
auction as showing a single suited hand with clubs and game invitational values. Opener
will rebid 3N with a suitable maximum)
Auction 2♦ - 2♠
Responder will rebid 3・ after opener’s 2NT rebid.
138
2 Heart Opening
3♠ = Pass or Correct
3♥ = Preemptive raise of Hearts
3♦ = Asking bid: Opener will clarify his Spade holding and range
4♥ = 6 Spades, maximum hand, no side controls
4♦ = 6 Spades, maximum hand, Diamond control
4♣ = 6 Spades, maximum hand, Club control
3N = 4-5 Spades and a maximum hand
3♠ = 4 Spades and a minimum hand
3♥ = Hearts and Clubs and a minimum
3♣ = Relay for Shape/Range
3N = 5+ Spades and a maximum
3♠ = 4 Spades and a maximum
3♥ = Any minimum hand
3♦ = Hearts and Clubs and a maximum
2N = Puppet to 3♣
3♠ = Single suited hand with Spades, invites 4S opposite suitable hand
3♥ = Game invitational single suited hand with Hearts
3♦ = Asking bid: Invites 4H opposite a maximum
4♥ = 6 Hearts, maximum hand, no first/second round controls
4♦ = 6 Hearts, maximum hand, 1st/2nd round control in Diamonds
4♣ = 6 Hearts, maximum hand, 1s/2nd round control in Clubs
3N = 5 Hearts and a maximum hand
3♠ = 4 Hearts and a maximum hand
3♥ = Any minimum hand
Pass = to play
2♠ = Pass or correct
139
Two Spades Opening
3♠ = 4+ Spades
Forces 4S opposite a single suited hand
Invites 4S opposite 4 Spades and maximum
3♥ = Natural, invitational to 4H opposite suitable hand
3♦ = Natural, non-forcing
3♣ = Pass or Correct
Following 2♠ - 3♣
Pass = Spades and Clubs
3♦ = Single suited with Spades, Diamond fragment
3♥ = Single suited with Spades, Heart fragment
3♠ = Single suited with Spades, unsuitable for a red suit contract
2N = Asking bid
4♠ = 6 Spades, maximum hand
4♥ = 6 Spades, maximum hand, 1st/2nd round control
4♦ = 6 Spades, maximum hand, 1st/2nd round control
4♣ = 6 Spades, maximum hand, 1st/2nd round control
3N = Maximum hand, 5-5 shape
3♠ = 6 Spades, minimum hand
3♥ = Spades and Clubs, maximum hand, 3 card fragment
3♦ = Spades and Clubs, maximum hand, 3 card fragment
3♣ = Spades and Clubs, any minimum hand
140