Min20020501 V75 05

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 32

international Journal for Pastors May 2002

F I R
MINISTRY
Ministry is the international journal of the
Seventh-day Adventist Ministerial Association
and has been published since 1928.

Association Secretary James A. Cress

Editor Wilimore D. Eva


What matters more: Container
Managing Editor Julia W. Norcott
or content? Editorial Assistant Sheila Draper
The comparative value of what is proclaimed Professional Growth and Inter-church Relations
Nikolaus Satelmajer
versus who proclaims it Contributing Editors: Sharon Cress, Peter Prime, Joel
Randall L. Roberts Sarli, Kit Watts

E ysFs g- Pain
International Editors:
inter-American Division Felix Cortes
South American Division Zinaldo A. Santos

The impact of the Cross on human pain and Consulting Editors:


Ben Clausen, Raoul Dederen, Teofilo Ferreira, Ron
Letters anguish Flowers, John M. Fowler, Michael Hasel, Roland
Hegstad, Kathleen Kuntaraf, Ekkehardt Mueller, Jan
Clifford Goldstein Paulsen, Robert Peach, Angel Manuel Rodriguez, Penny
3
Shell, William Shea, Russell Staples, Richard Trbbits, Ted
Wilson, Edward Zinke

Deciding between dialogue Pastoral Assistant Editors: John C. Cress, Fredrick


Russell, Maylan Schurch, Loren Seibold
Editorial and debate
international Advisors: Alejandro Bullon, John
4 Alternative approaches to processing the Duroe, Andrews Laurence Ewoo, Paulraj Isaiah, Anthony
Kent, Jairyong Lee, Ivan Manilich, Zacchaeus Mathema,
differences that arise between people Gabriel Maurer, Ivan Omana, David Osborne, Peter
Roennfeldt, Raymond Zeeman
Ian Hartley
Pastor's Pastor Pastoral Advisors: Leslie Baumgartner, S. Peter
Campbell, Miguel A. Cema, Jeanne Hartwell, Mitchell
31 Overcoming the Superman Henson, Greg Nelson, NonnaOsbom,leslie Pollard,
DaliSmith, Sleve
syndrome ,Advertising Editorial Office
How the pastor meets human needs without Subscriptions and Circulation Jeannette Calbi

neglecting his own Cover Illustration Harry Knox

Resources Cathy Payne


Stephen Lim

Preaching with power Subscriptions: 12 issues: United States US$29.95;


Canada and overseas US$31.75; airmail US$41.75;
The role of clarity and simplicity in preaching single copy US$3.00. To order, send name, address,
and payment to Jeannette Calbi, Ministry Subscriptions,
Morris Chalfant 12501 Old Columbia Pike, Silver Spring, MD 20904
U.S.A.
Subscription queries and address changes:
The courage to face our fears Email: calbil@gc.adventistorg
Fax: 301-680-6502
Pastoral pressure points: Part 3 in a six part series Phone: 301-680-6503
Archibald D. Hart To Writers: We welcome unsolicited manuscripts.
Editorial preference is to receive manuscripts on
diskette with name, address, telephone and fax
Positive ways to deal with criticism numbers, and Social Security number (if U.S. citizen or
possessing a U.S. Social Security number). Send
Understanding and dealing constructively with editorial correspondence to 12501 Old Columbia Pike,
Silver Spring, MD 20904-6600.
negative criticism Phone: 301-680-6510; fax: 301-680-6502;
Email: norcottj@gc.adventist.org or
Teena M. Stewart drapers@gc.adventist.org (editorial offices).

Writer's Guidelines available on request.

Ordination in the New Testament? Ministry (ISSN 0026-5314), the international. journal
of the Seventh-day Adventist Ministerial Association
A perceptive view of biblical ordination © 2002, is published monthly by the General
Conference of Seventh-day Adventists and printed by
Nancy Vyhmeister Pacific Press® Pub. Assn., 1350 N. Kings Road,
Nampa, ID 83687-3193. Member Associated Church
Press. Standard mail postage paid at Nampa, Idaho.
Should we be postmodern to PRINTED IN THE U.S.A.
minister to postmoderns? Vol. 74 Number 5

An interpretative reflection on the approach of the Bible credits: 5cnptures quotations from The Message. Copyright 0 by
pastor to postmodern people Eugene H. Peterson 1993,1994, 1995. Used by permission of Nov Press
Publishing Group. Verses marked TLB are taken from The Living Bible.
Copyright D 1971 by Tyndale House Publishers, Wheaton, Ill. Used by
Donkor Kwabana permission. Texts credited to NIV are from the Holy Bible, New International
Version. Copyright D 1973, 1978, 1984 by the International Bible Society:
Used by permission obZondervan Bible Publishers. Bible texts credited to
RSV are from the Revised Standard Version of the Bible. Copyright C 1946,
195Z 1971 by the Division of Christian Education of the National Candi
of the Churches of Chnst in the USA. Used by permission.

2 MINISTRY May 2002


L E T TERS

THE ART iCLE TAUS' WAS FRUSTRAT NG


FOR M AS A YOUNG ADULT
SEVcN ADVENTiST C - RiSt AN.

Case for creationism devoured as those who are starving." It history and effect of music. Such an arti-
'started as an academic physicist makes me want to study the Bible with cle would deal with changes in music
I before ordination, teaching at several a deeper and more absorbing interest. and worship patterns through the ages,
United Kingdom universities, and I have Could we think over how people are edifying ministers on the many sides of
to say that the many evangelical craving to be enlightened through this the worship debate.
Christians with whom I fellowship in the channel approach? If church worship services echoed the
science and religion fields will be —Estrella Anacleto Jordan, Prilly, Switzerland. traditional, formal style that Oliver
appalled by the shoddy and misleading Jacques enjoys, the congregation would
scholarship in John Ashton's "Case for he article "Taps" was frustrating for match—older or retired persons. My
Creationism" (September 2001)
To argue that evolution is prohibited
T me as a young adult Seventh-day
Adventist Christian. I grow weary with
question is: Do we wish our church to be
only for the old and retired, or should it
by the Second Law of thermodynamics such articles on either extreme of the be one where we, through a variety of
shows ignorance of both. A physical or contested worship debate. The extreme musical and worship forms, can attract
biological system can move to a state of subject used for "example" was people of all ages and religious upbring-
increased order as long as it receives described in such slanted phrases as ing to the foot of the cross and a
energy from outside (technically, a dissi- "gospel rock" and "a daring mix of relationship with Jesus Christ?
pative system) and there are a number swing and ragtime." It seems that this —Mark 0'Ffill, Orlando, Florida.
of examples of this in the physical world. article is based, like so many others, on
Ashton is quite right to point out that the emotional attachment older SDA Editorial comment: Please resur-
we do get some occasional odd dating Christians have to "the way things used rect the September 1996 issue of Ministry
results, but these are trivial compared to be," automatically equating the tra- and notice a much more complete discus-
with the rest of the evidence. The point ditional with the holy, and the new with sion of this question, one which more fully
with which Ashton started his article still the unholy. recognizes and embraces the concerns
holds in any university. You will not find I especially take issue with his state- raised in the above letter. If you have dif-
(a) professional academic biologists/ ment "Nothing wrong with the songs, ficulty finding this issue of Ministry, email
geneticists, etc., who do not treat evolu- really . . . though I don't hear about or call us and we will send you a copy. (We
tionary theory as basically sound, and Adventist themes...." Could it be that hope that it will not be long before our
(b) an academic cosmologist or geolo- the reason that contemporary Christian readers will be able to go to the Internet
gist who holds a young-earth theory of music doesn't have many Adventist to access all such issues.)
creation. artists is because of a mindset such as is
evident in this article, that "new music hanks so much for the January 2002
—Mike Parsons, Montpellier, Gloucester,
United Kingdom. styles are not bad music styles," thus T issue. Oliver Jacques's solid reason-
ing (as well as interesting writing) in
discouraging young, gifted, godly
January 2002 issue artists from ever becoming a part of the "Taps" addresses concerns I've had for
. Grant Swank, Jr.'s article "Preaching contemporary Christian music scene? years, but without the because-it's-not-
With Certainty Here and Now" gives Instead of simply fueling the fire with traditional-it-must-be-wrong flavor.
J
me a profound vision of how we can emotional articles that do not try to dis- Both this article and Jack Van Ens's
ultimately take the gospel. I like the cover the fundamental issues of this "Why Christianity Lite is Less Filling"
charge, "God's menu will give the debate, Ministry should publish articles currently rest in my filing cabinet!
might to withstand, but it must be that would educate the readers in the —Bill Krick, Clovis, California. 741

If you're receiving Ministry bimonthly and haven't paid for a subscription, it's not a mistake. Since 1928 Ministry has been
Free Subscription
published for Seventh-day Adventist ministers. We believe, however, that the time has come for clergy everywhere to experience a
resurgence of faith in the authority of Scripture and in the great truths that reveal the gospel of our salvation by grace, through faith alone in Jesus Christ.
We want to share our aspirations and faith in a way that will provide inspiration and help to you as clergy. We hope you will accept this journal as our
outstretched hand to you. Look over our shoulder, take what you want and find helpful, and discard what you can't use. Bimonthly gift subscriptions are
available to all licensed and/or ordained clergy. Requests should be on church letterhead and addressed to the editorial office.

May 2002 MINISTRY 3


E D I TORIAL

Making faith
and freedom
randy was our female Dachshund.
one stream, each member, whether of one

B Baffy, our neighbor's male Peking-


ese. Between our properties was a
chain-link fence which among other
opinion or another, was called upon to:
+ Freely accept the differences there
were in others over these issues
things kept Brandy away from the (Rom. 14:1-3).
amorous advances of the likes of Baffy. + Leave all judgment to God who was
The two dogs clearly liked one recognized as entirely able to guide
another and spent large portions of one's fellow Christian (verses 4, 10,
their time running up and down the 13).
fence, each on opposite sides, trying to + Allow each person his or her own
find a way through to one another. convictions over these things (verses
They would jump and bark and touch 5, 22).
noses and paws through the barrier, but + Accept that a fellow Christian does
much to our relief and their frustration, As much as anything, it was the out- what he or she does out of sincere
the fence stood firm. ward things, the observable behaviors devotion to God (verses 6-9, 22).
Within all of us there is a great long- that could be noted and mentally or + Concentrate on that which brings
ing to be close to someone, to have a verbally "evaluated." Circumcision was harmony and encouragement into
sense of relationship, to be in uninter- a major one of these (Acts 15:1, 2, etc.). the fellowship (verse 19).
rupted touch with some other and What should not be eaten, or which But third, and very significantly, in
really with all others. All of us spend holy days ought to be kept were others order to discipline the freedom implied
significant portions of our time search- (Rom. 14:1, 2). in these teachings and to encourage the
ing the barriers between us for a way Reading the New Testament shows harmony that was the overall intention,
through to more satisfying experiences us graphically that conflict over these the fellowship was reminded:
of togetherness. kinds of things challenged the leader- + That everything done within the
Barriers to unity and oneness are very ship of Paul and others as much as community was done "to the Lord"
common on every major and minor anything else they faced. and not merely in the light of one's
avenue of life, and the church is by no Each of these matters, along with the own personal preference or pleasure
means as exceptional as we might wish. contention that goes with them, has its (verses 7, 8).
Many come to our churches hoping to rather obvious parallels in today's + That as a Christian acts, he or she
find their need for closeness and rela- church. How did Paul and the early must do so with sensitivity and con-
tionship met, only to find that for them church view and face these matters and sideration toward others, remember-
what they expected to be an experience the conflicts that seemed to gather ing the weaker (not necessarily the
of fellowship and friendship has become around them? more conservative) members of the
a source of frustration and painful fric- First, in the minds of the leaders community (verses 15, 16, 21-23;
tion. these issues were intentionally kept sub- 1 Cor. 8:4-13).
It is sobering to realize that often the ordinate to that which was genuinely There is no more pressing matter fac-
very things we have come to believe are essential. They were kept in perspective ing our churches today than that we
so important to the validity of our faith in relation to matters that were clearly find constructive ways of dealing with
are the things that, given our outlook central. When it comes to these things, these kinds of differences among our-
and attitudes, are the most divisive Matthew 23:13-30; Acts 15:6-11, 28, selves. Because of the struggles of the
within the actual everyday life of the 29; Romans 14:17, 18; and other pas- first-century church we possess an
church. sages are worthy of our careful study. inspired, tried, true, and practical model
What kinds of things caused divisions Second, when dealing with issues for working towards and achieving har-
amongst the New Testament believers? that were actually tributary to the main- mony within and amongst ourselves. N

4 MINISTRY May 2002


ministry is not about us, it's about someone
else." This is the reverse of what is commonly
the case in professional life. Ministry, there-
fore, is an odd job, first of all, because it's an
upside-down job.
It's upside down to the way we normally
do things. We say, "If you don't take care of
yourself, no one will." Our world is pock-
marked by shameless self-promotion. In the
world we work to advance our own agendas,
not those of other people.

What matters Throughout his football career, Deion


Sanders was a flashy, brassy personality. A
while back, Sanders, a Christian, stated that

more: Container the position he plays on the football field


ought to be renamed. Instead of calling it
"cornerback," Deion says that he has so rede-

or content? fined the way this position is played that it


should be called by his name. In other words,
when a professional football scout asks a
prospective player, "What position do you
play?" the player shouldn't respond, "I play

I
n ministry, what matters most is not the cornerback." No, says Sanders, the player
Randall L. Roberts
container, but the content. "Remember, should now simply answer, "I play Deion!"
our Message is not about ourselves; Maybe this is just part of his act. Most
we're proclaiming Jesus Christ, the would never be so brazen. Yet we all are
Master. All we are is messengers, errand tempted to self-promotion. Even our most
runners from Jesus for you. It started when noble accomplishments come from mixed
God said, 'Light up the darkness!' and our motives. But Paul says, "We do not preach
lives filled up with light as we saw and under- ourselves. We preach Christ." In fact, we're
stood God in the face of Christ, all bright and simply errand runners, delivering messages
beautiful. for the King.
"If you only look at us, you might well D. M. Canright was a gifted but vacillating
miss the brightness. We carry this precious and volatile preacher in early Adventism.
Message around in the unadorned clay pots of During the summer and fall of 1880, along
our ordinary lives. That's to prevent anyone with a number of students from Battle Creek
from confusing God's incomparable power College, Canright attended Professor Hamill's
with us. As it is, there's not much chance of School of Oratory in Chicago. Canright and
that. You know for yourselves that we're not his friends sought to fine-tune their develop-
much to look at" (2 Cor. 4:5-7, The Message). ing oratorical skills so they could communi-
As a minister, I have an odd job. Don't cate the gospel more successfully in the
misunderstand—I love it. But it is an odd job, pulpit.
and that is because of the two realities Paul Each student was assigned a critic.
states in the above passage. Canright's teacher and critic was D.W. Reavis.
During the time they spent together, they
Not about us became quite well acquainted.
The first reality appears in these words: A gifted speaker, Canright was invited to
"Our Message is not about ourselves; we're preach in many Chicago churches. Reavis
Randall L. Roberts,
proclaiming Jesus Christ, the Master" (2 Cor. attended to analyze his application of orator-
D. Min., is senior
4:6, The Message). ical principles. Canright was so accomplished
pastor of the Loma
Linda University
In 2 Corinthians, Paul defends his call to that invitations flowed in, and eventually he
Church of Seventh-day apostleship. Some have depreciated his call to accepted invitations only from the largest and
Adventists, Loma ministry, questioning his apostolic creden- most popular churches.
Linda, California. tials, so he addresses the issue. In so doing, he One Sunday night he addressed more than
speaks to any called to ministry: "This call to 3,000 people in the largest church on the west

May 2002 MINISTRY 5


-.•, • • I, k

f.r-* 1.44.044,111' was seeing were her hair rollers.


410,0-
When the official opened the suit-
easoned With Love II case, what did they find but—bullets!
Then, standing near a wall, she saw
A Second Helping her suitcase, which looked identical
to the one she had accidently carried
to the customs agent.
It's no secret that pastoral wives are some of Moral of the story? Don't judge by
the best cooks in the world. Whether outward appearance but by inner
preparing huge quantities of food for potluck content!
dinners or entertaining angels unawares, food
and fellowship form an integral part of their Double advice
lives. Now these special women share their The day I was ordained to the
favorite (ovo-lacto) recipes from around the gospel ministry, I wrestled with the
globe for your enjoyment. competing twin feelings: the grandeur
Makes a great gift for holidays, birthdays, of the task to which I had been called,
and bridal showers. and my own inadequacies and lack of
qualification for it. I remember two
S$ 1495 + 18% s&h significant conversations I had with
pastoral colleagues while walking
Resource Center * General Conference Ministerial Association toward the ordination service in the
12501 Old Columbia Pike * Silver Spring, MD 20904 auditorium.
Phone: 888.771.0738 (toll-free) or 301.680.6508 These two men, both older than I,
Fax: 301.680.6502 + E-mail: paynec@gc.adventist.otr"" offered some advice. They were
Web site: www.ministerialassociation.com standing only about 20 feet apart, but
aior(s
Also available at your local Adventist Book Cenli4.41-1.:"!):%**,411 I soon realized that a much wider gulf
.,:. separated their philosophies.
The first pastor said to me, "Let me
side of Chicago. When he finished, don't promote ourselves. In fact, the give you a piece of advice, something
people mobbed him, thanking, prais- whole job is about Someone else. I learned years ago that might also
ing, and lauding him. It took some help you in your ministerial career." I
time for the crowd to disperse so that Content, not packaging was all ears, eager to hear wisdom
Canright and Reavis could leave. Paul adds a second reality about from a more experienced colleague.
Finally, at a late hour, they went to the ministry of the gospel that warns He proceeded to carefully show me
a park where Reavis could offer his us that it's an odd job. Not only is it how to wear a paper clip behind my
criticisms and suggestions. But he had an upside-down job; it takes place in tie so it would not be noticeable, and
been so absorbed in Canright's pres- an inside-out world. He says: "But we yet would hold my tie in place. By
entation of Bible truth that he had no have this treasure in jars of clay to doing that I could keep my tie in
criticisms to offer, no suggestions to show that this all-surpassing power is place and yet not call attention to
extend. They talked for a while, when from God and not from us." This job myself by wearing an ornate tie clip.
suddenly Canright sprang to his feet. is not about the package, but about A few paces further a second sea-
"D.W." he said, "I believe I could what's in the package. It's not about soned pastor stopped me and when I
become a great man were it not for the jar of clay, but about the treasure said that I felt unworthy of this call-
our unpopular message." inside the jar. In the world of ministry, ing, he responded, "You're right. You
Reavis replied, "D.M., the message the value of what is done cannot be don't deserve it. In fact, the only rea-
made you all you are, and the day judged by what it looks like on the son you're here today is because He
you leave it, you will retrace your outside, because it is what's on the called you, not because you merit it.
steps back to where it found you." inside that counts. But since He called you, He will qual-
Canright's wish? "If I could do my My wife was traveling abroad. ify you. You stand there in His
own thing, be the source of the missive While passing through customs at righteousness."
and not just the errand runner, I could her port of entry, the agent looked at Over the years, those two brief
become great!" But Paul steps in and her suitcase through X-ray equip- conversations have come to represent
says, "We do not preach ourselves. We ment, and then said to her, "You have two directions to take in ministry.
preach Christ." We're delivering mes- bullets in your suitcase." She denied The first is the direction of making
sages for the King. In this job, we it, of course, claiming that what he certain everything looks OK on the

6 MINISTRY May 2002


outside. The "do-what-you-do-to- agendas, and in the process become a be tempted to feel good about our min-
please-people" approach. Do it to mile wide and an inch deep. That's istry because of the blessings that
avoid conflict. Do it to promote your- why what Paul says is so vital. When surround it. People criticized Paul's
self and your programs. Spend time it comes to ministry, what really mat- ministry because of the discouraging
polishing the otherwise unadorned ters is what's inside. nature of its container, as they might
clay pot of the outward self. The Corinthians were tempted to do with ours. But they might also
The second choice is to take care of depreciate Paul's ministry because of affirm our ministry simply because of
the inner life, the spiritual walk, the the often-discouraging circumstances the successful trappings that surround
soul's health. To spend time and that surrounded it. Apparently he was it. Again, what matters most is not
effort and energy understanding, tak- a small man, had bad vision, wasn't a the container, but the content. We are
ing in, and applying the message of great speaker, and was constantly on still, after all, only errand runners for
Christ. On my better days, I have the run. He had enemies galore and the King. We strive to deepen, and let
been able to choose the second. On critics aplenty. He was hard-pressed, God broaden.
my more ignoble days, I have fallen perplexed, and persecuted. If one's Just before preaching my first ser-
prey to the first. focus was on the clay pot of his life, mon in my current assignment, I was
many reasons existed to question his feeling quite anxious. I was worried
Deepening versus broadening success. about what to say and how to say it. I
During my early days of ministry But that leads to a critical conclu- shared my anxiety with two friends.
someone gave me a motto I adopted: sion about ministry, this upside-down Their words brought me back to the
"Deepen your ministry and let God job in an inside-out world: In min- core of ministry and the reality of
broaden it." When we succumb to istry, what matters most is not the Paul's passage: "Randy," they said,
the temptation of putting the broad- container, but the content, not the pack- "don't forget that we are just errand
ening of our ministry first, we end up aging, but the filling, not the external boys for the King. Therefore, we have
brushing and buffing and burnishing elements, but the heart. only to please Him."
a clay pot. We become shallow public We face the same temptation, with It may be an odd job, but what a
relations people, broadening our own a different slant. We may more often majestic calling! IN

.yfftc c
NATHAN GREENE
The Lamb of God
Studio Canvas Gicle',e
31"x 38 5/8'', $1,495
19 5/16" x 24", $695
Edition: 1,998 for each size

Limited Edition Lithograph


19 1/2" x 25"
5,000 signed & numbered
lithographs, $125
200 signed & numbered Call today to receive
artist's proofs, $175 a free catalog

1-800-487-4278
www.hartclassics.com

Hart Classic Editions


P.O. Box 2377 te Fallbrook, California 92088 l

May 2002 MINISTRY 7


one at a time. However we die, however we
suffer, whether alone or in bundles, corporate
agony, collective pain, doesn't actually exist;
we are islands of anguish unto ourselves.
This privatization of pain, this personaliza-
tion of anguish, it's good—because it means
that no one has ever suffered more than an
individual can. Grief remains finite, hedged in
by what's as minuscule as the human. We
know no more suffering than our personal
metabolism allows, no more pain than our
delirious cells can carry. No matter how many
miles of nerves are wired through us, what are
they but a few frayed and twisted threads in
contrast to the light-years of reality that sur-
round us? Our finitude is our defense, our
physical borders our best protection. How for-

Pain tunate that pain and suffering remain hedged


in and limited by the inherent confines of
individuality. It's hard enough, this bearing of
our own pain. Can we even imagine carrying
others' as well?
n the end," wrote Nietzsche, "one expe- There's an exception, however, to this oth-

I
Clifford Goldstein
riences only one's self." Nietzsche is erwise pandemic personalization of pain;
right. When we grieve with the grieving, only one time when this universal paradigm
weep with the weeping, and suffer with of individuated anguish shifted, and that was
the suffering—we experience only our the Cross. Only as we understand what hap-
own grief, our own cries, and our own pened there, to God Himself in contrast to
anguish—never anyone else's. We bleed our anything and everything that happens to us,
own blood, spew our own spit, and secrete our can we begin to understand what's perhaps
own sweat—never another's, no matter how the most difficult question that ministers face
fused our flesh. Other people's pain comes to from their parishioners: Why does God allow
us filtered, always and only, through our own. human suffering?
Our own, then, is all we ever actually know. Only on the cross can we find, if not certain
When the Twin Towers crashed, and thou- answers, at least some hope amid the pain.
sands of mothers, fathers, sisters, and brothers
perished in a crushing cascade of steel, fire, A clear view
and blood—each one felt only his or her own To begin, if one could shovel away the
fear, only his or her pain, only his or her own debris, climb over the rubble, and wade past
suffering; no one else's. Whether a mother the moral and physical wreckage left in the
holding a feverish infant to her breast, or a wake of two thousand years of Christian his-
father clutching a crumpled wife, neither can tory in order to see the cross, what would
splice into the nerves of the other to feel a appear? If one could peel off the cross the cen-
spasm of their woe, a prick of their pain, or a turies of ecclesiastical riffraff, what would
sputter of their sorrow. remain? If one could unravel all presupposi-
No matter how loud, outrageous, or con- tions and prejudices amassed from lifetimes
suming, pain remains more private than of lies, myths, and religious illusions, all in
thought; thought can always be shared, pain order to have a clear, unadulterated and
never really can. Unlike the liver, the heart, or undistorted view of the cross—what would
Clifford Goldstein is
the editor of the
blood—suffering is nontransferable, non- they see?
Adult Bible Study transfusable, and nontransplantable. What's They would see the Creator of the uni-
Guide at the General yours is yours alone. verse—the Being who spoke the strong force,
Conference of When famine descended upon Ethiopia, the weak force, electro-magnetism, and gravi-
Seventh-day and tons of flesh withered and faded back ty into existence; the Being who sprinkled
Adventists. into the earth, they did so, each quivering infinity with the Eagle Nebula and Orion; the

8 MINISTRY May 2002


Being who threaded 100 billion bil- Creator of the universe, having taken infinite would assume finitude (while
lion superstring loops into every upon Himself our humanity, died still remaining infinite), that's incred-
proton—they would see the Christ from the evil of that humanity—or He ible enough. But that God would, in the
shrunk into human flesh and nailed didn't. There's no middle ground form of finitude, suffer only as the infi-
to two pieces of wood, His life here, no compromise. Either Jesus was nite could suffer? Logic and reason
crushed out by all the pain, suffering, God Himself, or He was just a good knuckle under the notion; before a
and anguish of a world that He with man (and an infinite qualitative dif- sketch, or even a rough draft, the
His creative syllables had crafted into ference exists between the two), or imagination surrenders. Only the
existence. maybe even a bad man, or maybe metaphysics of faith can approach it.
Again, though we experience only never a man at all. But if He were But more importantly, if Jesus
our own fear, only our own loathing,
no one else's—at the Cross, Jesus
experienced everyone else's. The indi- ROM THE PAIN OF THE CHILDREN MUTILATED
vidual miseries of humanity were,
one by one, added up and the grue- AND THEN MURDERED BY MENGELE ... TO THE
some sum fell on the Creator. At the
Cross, everything noisome and evil SEMI%
that ever rippled through our nerves
rippled through His—at once. ?FINITE EVILS FELL ON
However much blood, sweat, and
tears have spilled, dripped, and
flowed under anemic moons; despite merely a good man, or a great one, or "tasted death for everyone" (Heb. 2:9,
the cancerous color of the soul and even the greatest—yet not God too, TLB), if He died "for the sins of the
the loathsome fates of so many little then the Cross is a noxious lie. whole world" (1 John 2:2), if upon
ones—none of them, none of us, suf- "Man simply invented God," it has Him was placed the iniquity "of us
fered more than a single human can. been said, "in order not to kill him- all" (Isa. 53:6)—then all of us are
Our pain never surpassed our fini- self." If so, then man invented not implicated in the Cross because all of
tude. No one ever ached more than only God, but One who suffered infi- our evil was there.
he or she, individually, could with- nitely more than the creature, any Either the Cross is true or it is lie. If
stand; the moment the threshold was creature, He created. Belief in a false a lie, then it's just a black hole into
crossed, death cracked it off. god is bad enough; belief in a cruci- which so much hope, promise, and
In contrast, at the Cross, the evils fied one is even worse, for while the prayer have been poured, with little
of the world, and all their doleful belief helps tame the cruel, empty or nothing in return. But, if it's true,
results, honed in on Him at once. spaces of the universe—the lie makes then it means that our lies, our greed,
From the pain of the children muti- them more hellish than ever. our envy, our lust, our pride, our
lated and then murdered by Mengele, cheating, our selfishness, our injus-
to even the Herr Doktor's personal The infinite divide tice, and all the nasty and dirty little
tremors of guilt, from the first However incredible the Cross, things we have thought and done; all
swollen belly to the last emphysemic there's nothing contradictory about the things that by themselves might
lung, from abused to abuser, all the it. The Power who uttered into exis- not seem so bad but if added up,
planet's finite evils fell on Christ and, tence infinity, eternity, and matter shoved in our face, and exposed for
amassed at once, they were enough to and wrapped them together and what they really were would cause us
kill Him. draped the result across nothing, cer- to claw at our own flesh—all of them
Putting aside postmodern mum- tainly would have the capacity to were there, at the Cross, borne by
bling about perspectivalism, rela- garb Himself in human flesh and Christ, killing Christ so that when all
tivism, pluralism, about Foucalt's then die in that flesh. The One who the evil moments of our life are tal-
Interpretative Analysis, or Derrida's created all of what's created could lied and weighed, they don't have to
Deconstruction of the text, or Witt- become part of what's created. The ultimately, and forever, kill us.
genstein's language games . . . either issue is not physics (How did He do it?) There's no justice in this life. But if
England is an island near Europe or it but morality (Why did He do it?) God exists, and if He is just, then jus-
isn't; either Jonathan Swift wrote A If ascending from zero to one takes tice will be done—which means
Tale of a Tub or he didn't; either an infinite step, what's the moral cal- sooner or later we'll have to answer
George Washington was the Prime culus of descending from the infinite for everything; for the dirty secrets
Minister of France from 1926-37 or he to the finite? That God Himself that occasionally appear in our
wasn't; and, either at the Cross the would become a human, that the dreams, for the pangs that itch in

May 2002 MINISTRY 9


Don t he too surprise •
For nearly two decades, we' ye manufactured chairs that are more comfortable, more durable, and
So it was only a matter of time until we
a better value than any other church chair on the ma
what else would you expect from
found a line of tables to match. Now we have ... but
"The Original Church Chair Specialists"?

Church Chair Industries


is pleased to carry the full line
of high quality folding tables from

dwest
FOLDING PRODUCTS Plastic Laminate over 314 - Plywood

Manufactured from the highest RECTANGULAR TABLES


quality materials, these tables are AS LOW AS
designed to stand up to the stress Quantities
of constant use, and come in
a variety of colors and finishes.

IDEAL FOR USE IN:


• Fellowship Space
- Banquet Halls
• Classrooms
• Any Multi-use Space
Plastic Laminate over we Plywood
ROUND TABLES
AS LOW As
$83.12
Quantities of 24 or more

The Cathedral Stacker


Features 4114" high density foam seat, free lumbar support, 20 year
steel frame guarantee, and 5 year fabric and foam guarantee!
Ow Most

$24.75
If you're considering the purchase of 100 or more chairs Affordable Multi-Use Chair!
in the next 12 months, call toll-free today for your
JUST
FREE SAMPLE CHAIR! of 100
All prices subject to change without notice.

ASK FOR YOUR FREE INFORMATION PACK www.churchcha re0


(including samples of chair fabric colors and patterns) 7007 New Catoun Hwy N
,IsPUSTR28S. iNC
1800-331 5411 Rome. Georgia 30161
places we can't scratch, and even for Themselves accessible as never but wouldn't share their restrooms
all the things that we long ago justi- before. To have the eternal and infi- with a Black person? Or the folks who
fied and then, conveniently, forgot. nite God clothe Himself in human shoved Jews into gas chambers
Imagine facing every evil thought, flesh in order to save us from the Monday through Saturday but rested
word, and deed at once, with all inevitable doom of our own rotting from their work on Sunday? From the
excuses, rationalizations, and justifi- wraps—and then only to have those Crusades to the Inquisition, from the
cations swept away by the peering temporal and rotting wraps purposely Ku Klux Klan to the most orthodox
eyes of an all-seeing, all-knowing God reject what He did for us—what's left? fascists, why has Christianity provid-
who exposes the deepest, most carnal There's an infinite gap between the ed the vehicle, the incentive, and the
motives until there's nowhere to finite and the infinite; those who rationale for so much of what rots the
hide. have rejected what Jesus has done for planet? And why has much of what's
If all the evil we have ever com- them have, in a sense, breached that been noxious been nurtured in the
mitted or will ever commit fell on gap; it is the ultimate transgression cold, lurid womb of the church,
Jesus to spare us from the punish- because it is an infinite one. Of all the which served for centuries as the intel-
ment that justice demands, then the evil of the world at the Cross—the lectual, cultural, and moral dungeon
Cross has an absolute moral claim on us. of the West?
Whether we believe it or not, Though good questions, none are
whether we accept it or not, the claim N THE END, good excuses. Jesus Himself warned
remains—and all other ties, in con- about those who would, under the
trast, bind us in nothing but pink I NOTHING guise of Christian faith, work iniquity
ribbons and bows. No one, nothing (Matt. 7:21-23). Millions of professed
else, has such a stake in us because no Christians have, for almost two thou-
one, nothing else, has done (or could sand years, provided convenient
do) so much for us. excuses to reject the Cross; what they
If at the Cross Christ paid the IT REMAINS. ABOVE haven't provided are adequate ones,
penalty for every wrong thing we because nothing has changed the
have ever done, if He bore the brunt I AND BEYOND Cross, where God died for and from
of our evil, if in His flesh He felt at the world's evil—an infinite act that
once the painful consequences of our EVERYTHING ELSE . transcends all finite ones, even the
foul deeds, and if He did it in order to ones done in the name of the act
spare us from having to face divine itself.
judgment for all these things we have murders, the rapes, the incest, the In the end, nothing nullifies the
done and yet we reject the provision, barbarity—the only one not there, Cross. It remains, above and beyond
what's left? the only one not provided for is the everything else, and its claims are so
That's heavy. Whatever else we do only one that's infinite, the one in universal, so sweeping, and so grand
or have done to others, we do or have which the finite rejects the Infinite. that they blow away all excuses, even
done to those of the same noisome good ones about human suffering.
brew as ourselves. We are finite crea- The dilemma No matter what we have suffered,
tures who do things, sometimes Of course, belief in this Infinite we have suffered only as individuals.
petty, sometimes puerile, sometimes death isn't in itself productive of lov- No more. In contrast, God took on
terrible, but always only finite and ing and lovable Christians. On the the form of humanity and died a
temporal things, nothing more. The contrary, corporate Christianity often death not only worse than the worst
gap between who we are, what we do, produces corporate wretches. It's one of the best of humanity but suffered a
and to whom we do them stays finite, thing to have vile folks walk into a death worse than all of humanity
and finite minus finite equals only church—that might be expected. But (even the worst of it)—combined.
finitude. to have them leave worse because And though that amazing death does
The Cross, however, presents to their villainy is now absolved by a not answer all the questions about
humanity something infinite, some- conscience confirmed in the certainty evil and pain, it does put them in a
thing eternal. Instead of hovering of terminal truth—that cannot be perspective that could help us past our
"out there," as concepts merely expected. own anguish and that of others if for
sensed or intuited, the Infinite and How does one explain those who no other reason than that, because of
Eternal stepped directly into the have murdered, raped, and pillaged in the Cross, the moral hues, the tones,
equations of our lives, wrote the name of Jesus? Or what about and the tenor of the cosmos have rad-
Themselves into the formulas of our those God-fearing, church-going ically changed, and the music of the
immediate existence, and made white Protestants who loved the Lord spheres becomes howling praise. rffl

May 2002 MINISTRY 11


entation may occur in dialogue too.
What is unique to debate is the force with
which the presentation is made. It is assumed
in debate that the most forceful presentation
wins the day. This means the presenter with
the best logic, eloquence, or power of persua-
sion has the truth.

Deciding Dialogue
Dialogue is about relationship, about
understanding other people. Dialogue is at

between the heart of friendship. It is the language of


intimacy, the language of lovers. Dialogue
affirms and empowers, it seeks to build under-

dialogue and standing of the other.


All lasting relationships depend on dia-
logue for maintenance and extension.

debate Successful families and societies are grounded


in dialogue. Dialogue adds value to all
involved. It creates a win/win situation. In the
postscientific or postmodern society, people
work with facts all day long at work and seek
ere are two broad divisions in meaning outside of facts in relationships, in
Ian Hartley
communication style—dialogue dialogue.
and debate. Radio and television Business people know that dialogue
stations often focus on one of the improves customer relationships. They also
two. Congregations and cultures know that these relationships are much more
also seem to gravitate toward debate or dia- important than merely being right. For good
logue. The predominant communication style business the customer is always right!
in an organization will, to a large extent, There is the classic story of the customer
determine the quality of relationships experi- who bought a pair of jeans which turned out
enced. to be too short and so he shortened them into
cutoffs. The customer then decided the cut-
What is dialogue and debate? offs were not what he wanted and so took the
To dialogue is to listen to the other, to draw three pieces of "jeans" back for a refund. The
the other out, to try and understand another's store refunded the full price and won a cus-
point of view. Dialogue presumes an interest tomer forever.
in what the other has to say. It is thus a sensi-
tive experience in which the listener has the Debate
opportunity of walking through an often Debate implies confrontation and is energy
unknown forest of ideas. intensive. To debate is at least to question if
Of course the word "dialogue" implies the not to insult a position the other has taken,
speaker and listener exchange roles from time and we know it takes 7-12 compliments or
to time. It is a mutual journey, a cooperative affirmations to negate one insult if the rela-
venture, a partnership, a marriage of two tionship is to be preserved.
minds or souls. In true dialogue, it is as if the Debate is adversarial by nature, an attempt
universe is no longer a vast, cold, empty space to separate truth from error. Most judicial sys-
but a warm, friendly, inviting place to be. tems depend on debate even though it creates
Ian Hartley is pastor
Dialogue is premised on cooperation and a win/lose situation. Many parliamentary sys-
of the Red Deer
Seventh-day
mutual respect. tems are grounded on debate, debate between
Adventist Church,
Debate, on the other hand, is concerned government and opposition.
Alberta, Canada. with getting my facts, my point of view, my There are negative outcomes which can
way of seeing transferred into your head. It is result from a preoccupation with being right.
not just the presentation of these ideas or I know of congregational leaders who have
views that occurs in debate because this pres- had heart attacks at church board meetings or

12 MINISTRY May 2002


shortly after a precipitated heated + I communicate to care for you. becomes reality for you. This is the
debate. I know of two missionaries + I affirm you and care for you, back power of words in dialogue. Here is
who came to blows on Communion and forth, for a long time, so my the reason we must tell the story of
Sabbath about an issue none of the love is clear. our relationship with Jesus.
witnesses of the confrontation can + I am concerned with your views. In telling our experience of His
remember now. In South Africa the Having said all this, we must also presence in our lives we confirm and
early evangelists for Adventism used concede that there are some advan- extend the reality and the power of
to hire the town hall and advertise a tages to debate. Often the energy this divine human relationship.
debate over which was the correct mustered for debate overcomes apa- There can be no silent Christians any
day on which to worship. They won thy and lethargy. However, if no more than there can be silent mar-
most of the debates, as well as only a dialogue is established in addition or riages or silent families. We are
few converts and a town full of ene- consequent to the debate, soul com- created for communication and we
mies. munication is missed and we are left find our meaning and fulfillment in
Today, in many quarters, it seems either triumphant or depressed. dialogue.
one only has to mention wine and Include debate as part of the dialogue,
the Bible, the ordination of women, but only as a part. Jesus in dialogue with a
or what constitutes sacred music, and Today and tomorrow we must congregation
a good debate is in progress. Debaters communicate with each other. We Here is an example of Jesus in dia-
seem to believe they will be proved can communicate with purpose and logue with a congregation. He is
right when Jesus comes, and the oth- we must do so. Life includes the telling His story and also our story.
ers will be proved wrong. I remember weather, who is ill and who has a new "He went to Nazareth, where he had
debates which I have won, while at baby, but life is really about how we been brought up, and on the Sabbath
the same time I have lost what really care for each other and seek to day he went into the synagogue, as
mattered, the relationships I needed encourage one another on the jour- was his custom. And he stood up to
to keep. ney of living. read. The scroll of the prophet Isaiah
We must debate from time to time, was handed to him. Unrolling it, he
truth is as stake, but we need to Debate and dialogue in the found the place where it is written:
remember that if we only debate, the Bible `The Spirit of the Lord is on me,
results are rejection and isolation. Healthy interpersonal relation- because he has anointed me to
This is the price we must pay for cold ships require at least the desire to preach good news to the poor. He has
debate. understand the feelings and experi- sent me to proclaim freedom for the
The language of debate is: "You ences of the other person. The priests prisoners and recovery of sight for the
should . . ," "If you would . . ," "It in the Old Testament had their ears blind, to release the oppressed, to
is time you . . ." anointed with blood (Exod. 29:20). proclaim the year of the Lord's favor.'
They were to develop listening skills "Then he rolled up the scroll, gave
The differences and those skills were to have an inti- it back to the attendant and sat down.
It is helpful to list the differences mate connection with the blood of The eyes of everyone in the syna-
between debate and dialogue: Jesus. This was a serious commitment gogue were fastened on him, and he
Debate happens when: to understanding those who came to began by saying to them, 'Today this
+ I focus on facts or truth. speak to them. scripture is fulfilled in your hearing.'
+ I feel or am responsible for telling Jesus debated with some who All spoke well of him and were amazed
truth. would have this way of communica- at the gracious words that came from his
+ I feel it is important to understand tion. Perhaps they knew no other lips. 'Isn't this Joseph's son?' they
truth. way. In His spellbinding conversation asked" (Luke 4:16-22, NIV, italics sup-
+ I communicate to convince. with Nicodemus there is debate but it plied).
+ I argue back and forth on the same is only an introduction to the most As a citizen of the kingdom of
point trying to make the point profound dialogue ever recorded. God, desire the delight of dialogue
clearer. Jesus' favorite way of communicat- above debate. In this way the Spirit of
+ I am concerned with my views. ing was with stories. Stories are just the Lord is upon us too, for His glory
Dialogue happens when: that, accounts of how we experience and our joy. N
+ I focus on relationships and peo- life, and they are a way for intimate
ple. dialogue. In dialogue I unravel my
+ I feel or am responsible for loving story for you, but in doing so I also www.ministerialassociation.com
you. unravel my story for myself. When
+ I must try to understand you. you tell me your story, your story

May 2002 MINISTRY 13


accepted my humanness.
For years I did not recognize the symp-
toms of the Superman Syndrome as they
manifested themselves in my daily life. Also,
while my motives sounded noble, I learned
that other forces lurked just beneath the sur-

Overcoming face. What are the symptoms, consequences,


and causes of this syndrome? And what can
spiritual leaders do to overcome it?

the Superman Symptoms


A basic symptom is the desire to make el/0y-

syndrome one happy. We want to live up to people's


images and expectations, however unrealistic.
So we strive to meet all of their needs and find
it hard to say No to any requests.
Meeting needs while In our own minds we may create and strive
to maintain an image of ourselves as heroic prob-
ignoring our own lem solvers. We see ourselves as the extraordi-
nary person, maybe even a little "messianic,"
who is less vulnerable to personal needs than
other people are. Rescuing others from their

A
Stephen Lim
s the wheels of my car jumped plight makes us feel good about ourselves.
the curb, the jolt awakened me, In our compulsion to meet every need in
and I saw a palm tree looming in the church, our time is progressively squeezed
my path. I slammed the brakes until there is none left for anything but "the
as my car smashed into the tree. work." Gradually we discard the needs that
Emerging from the wreck, I thanked God that every normal human being has. We can sim-
He had protected me from injury. ply do without. We repress our needs for
The schedule I had created for myself led to adequate rest, play, spiritual renewal, and per-
this accident. For years I had set my alarm sonal growth. Taking time to enjoy the
clock for 4:50 a.m., when I had dragged myself scenery is a luxury rarely indulged. We
out of bed and dressed. By 5:00 a.m., I was sit- deceive ourselves into thinking that we don't
ting at my desk for devotions, and then I need nurturing. In denying our humanness
worked for a few hours. Often my mind failed we live behind the mask of self-sufficiency.
to engage and the time passed unproductively. Furthermore, we hide our true selves, fear-
I had convinced myself that I could func- ing that our weaknesses and struggles will be
tion adequately on no more than six hours of discovered. One writer observes, "We try to
sleep. After all, as a pastor with many impor- disguise ourselves as Superman, but beneath
tant responsibilities, couldn't I accomplish the surface, we are really only Clark Kent. Is
more by sleeping less? Often during the day I it any wonder that we won't pull open the
felt sluggish, drowsy. Rarely did I work effec- buttons on our shirt to let people see who we
tively. And occasionally as I drove, my eyes really are?"'
would momentarily close. Also, frustration takes residence. For no
Now I realize that much of this was symp- matter how hard we try, we will disappoint
tomatic of the "Superman Syndrome." This some people. We simply cannot meet every-
common affliction of ministers consists of the one's expectations—especially when they
failure to recognize our human needs and conflict. Nor can we be the perfect person we
limitations, while seeking to meet the needs strive to be. Despite our best efforts, a sense of
Stephen Lim, D.Min.,
of others. I believed, "It's up to me to meet the hypocrisy and guilt intrudes. Our sense of
is associate professor needs of the members and the church. unmet needs only adds to our frustration.
of Leadership at Furthermore, the world is perishing, and I've
Assemblies of God got to do everything possible to save as many Consequences
Theological Seminary, as possible. So I've got to keep pushing." What consequences result from the
Springfield, Missouri. Ironically, I accomplished less than if I had Superman Syndrome? As expectations and

14 MINISTRY May 2002


demands increase, fatigue builds. most important ministry, but in prac- an acute need for approval, so I
That's why I crashed into a tree. On tice, we fail to live this out. In trying craved acceptance and appreciation
another occasion I experienced severe to meet the needs and expectations of by others, and liked to think of
nausea and weakness for days as my others, we don't have adequate time myself as the hero who rescued them.
body rebelled against the demands I for them. "They'll understand," we This sense of inferiority drove me to
placed on it. repeatedly rationalize, "and one day strive for success in order to prove to
In our weariness and frustration, when my schedule is less hectic I'll myself that I had value as a person.
we begin to resent those we help. As make it up to them." This can eventu- Unfortunately, the anesthetic of
they become a burden we grimly ally lead to their alienation from us, achievement only temporarily
bear, joy ebbs from our hearts, and it's and even from God. My problem con- numbed the pain, before I needed
often replaced by anger. tributed to my older daughter's another dose. In reality, then, my
Buried in human demands and enduring a rocky adolescence before desire to be Superman stemmed from
needs, we fail to maintain spiritual her life turned around. feeling like "sub-par man."
health through intimacy with God. Second, we may possess an erro-
Gradually we lose a keen sense of Why we want to be Superman neous theology that causes us to
divine calling and the spiritual energy While the importance and urgency believe that God's servants are not to
it inspires. Though outwardly we may of God-given tasks served as my consider their own needs and
still appear to be effective, spiritually rational, conscious motivation, I wants—or at least put them too far
we dry and wither. gradually came to realize that four down on the list of priorities. To
Emotional burnout results from unconscious forces formed a powerful attend to these, we think, would be
spending our inner reserves without undercurrent shaping my behavior selfish. In this kind of theology, the
replenishing ourselves spiritually just as powerfully. If strong enough, beautiful reality of "dying to self"
and personally. It also arises from just one of these can trigger the becomes a matter of killing ourselves.
our frustrating inability to live up to Superman Syndrome. Compounding the syndrome is our
our Superman image. First, the low self-esteem, which I legitimate desire for significance—
Finally, we neglect our families. In had suffered since youth, generated wrongly pursued. God created us to love
theory we know they are our first and two unhealthy dynamics: It created and obey Him, and to serve Him

a network of
supporting friendships
among missional leaders
committed to transformation
and the shaping of the
emerging church.

OVI
Jeremiah 29:4-7/Jonah 4:11/Romans 12:21

new york, new york


august 28-31, 2002
www.re-church.org

May 2002 MINISTRY 15


ness to others. By doing so, we make it
harder to pretend to ourselves or oth-
ers. Bill Hybels, as the pastor of a
megachurch, has consistently tried to
be open with his staff and congrega-
tion, eliminating any pretense of
SEAMED WITH perfection. Because this enables oth-
ers to identify with him, it actually
gives him more credibility and
{ enhances the effectiveness of his min-
istry.
Fourth, we need to consciously do
our best and leave the results to God.
One of my professors at seminary
shared his experience in counseling a
suicidal woman for hours late into the
A Tossed Salad of Tales evening. Around midnight he told
about Parsonage Pandemonium
and Ministerial Mayhem
her, "I'm going home and going to
bed. If you're still alive in the morn-
'IItft01 11, li I s ing, we'll talk some more." Was he
callous? No. He realized that he had
done all he could to help, and that it
was not up to him to solve everyone's
problems. The woman survived?
While emergencies arise which
demand exhausting hours, this
should not become the standard
practice in ministry. In getting
enough rest I actually find myself far
according to our individual gifts, How can we resign the role of more productive and creative in my
opportunities, and calling. In this we Superman (or Superwoman) to live a ministry. I can do more, do it better,
find our own highest purpose and ful- more balanced and God-honoring and do it much more joyfully.
fillment, especially as we do our best life? With God's help, we can take the Fifth, we need to practice what we
and leave the results in God's hands. following steps to remove our capes. preach—that God is in control of our
As in my case, the problem arises First, we need to recognize our lives. We are to serve faithfully, believ-
when we equate significance with human needs. Like everyone else we ing that it is not up to us but God to
outward achievement. I mistakenly get tired, frustrated, and wounded. We prosper our ministries in the ways He
thought that the more I worked and need refreshing and renewing of chooses (1 Cor. 3:6-8).
accomplished for God, the more valu- mind, body, and spirit. As leaders Finally, we need to make ourselves
able my life would be. under special stress, we much need accountable to trusted individuals,
Finally, in some cases of the the love, support, and encouragement who know us well enough to discour-
Superman Syndrome a more subtle of family and friends. If we have diffi- age us whenever the urge arises to
force is the fear of dependence, which culty seeking and accepting these, we leap tall buildings in a single bound.
results from several childhood condi- need to discover why. Jesus reminds those who find
tions. Some have had overly control- Second, we must place a priority Superman's cape heavy, "My yoke is
ling or protective parents—which I on nurturing our relationship with God. easy, and my burden is light" (Matt.
experienced. As adults we fear that Not only is He the source of our joy 11:30). We need to hear God say to us,
depending on others will lead to the and strength, but our only means of "Lighten up! You don't have to save
further smothering of our spirits. So bearing lasting spiritual fruit. "'I am the world. Only my Son can do that.
we decide that we do not need the the vine," Jesus said, "'you are the You're not the Savior; you're not even
nurture of others. branches. If a man remains in me and Superman. Take off your cape!" N
I in him, he will bear much fruit.
Taking off our capes Apart from me you can do nothing"
1 Jack Kuhatschek, Superman Syndrome (Grand
Trying to be more than we are (John 15:5, NIV). Rapids, Mich.: Zondervan Pub. House, 1995), 159.
results in being less than we could be. Third, we need to reveal our human- 2 Ray Anderson, Fuller Theological Seminary.

16 MINISTRY May 2002


Preaching
with power
t was no doubt an accident, but it did plain, much to the point, and deeply in

I carry a message. In printing the


preacher's sermon, the local newspa-
per carried an interesting mistake in the
MORRIS CHALFANT
earnest. Some preachers have the
instinct of aviators—they announce a
text, taxi for a short distance, then take
introductory verse: "Though I speak off from the earth and disappear in the
with the tongues of men and of angels, cloud. After that only the din of explod-
and have not clarity, I am become as ing gas is heard, signifying that they are
sounding brass, or a tinkling cymbal" flying high, very high above the heads
(1 Cor. 13:1). of their hearers. It could be said of them
Inadvertently placing an "I" in the in the language of an ancient event,
place of the "h" in the word "charity" "While their hearers beheld, they were
and thus making the word "clarity," taken up; and a cloud received them
suggested to my mind a deeper truth: out of their sight." The miracle of the
without clarity, the message we seek to help people live in a difficult and com- Ascension is still manifested in some of
convey in our preaching may well cause plicated world. our pulpits. A sermon, rightly, is not a
our proclamation to come across as a Augustine once said, "A wooden key meteor but a sun. Its true test is, can it
sounding brass or clanging cymbal. is not so beautiful as a golden one, but make something grow?
Clarity calls for simplicity, but sim- if it can open the door when the golden The Lord did not drop golden tablets
plicity in preaching does not mean one cannot, it is far more useful." Luther which could not be deciphered. He
shallow or superficial preaching. What is added, "No one can be a good preach- spoke and still speaks through the
needed is clarity of thought and expres- er to the people who is not willing to prophets, the apostles, and through His
sion—the ability to tell others what one preach in a manner that seems childish Son. If He has committed to us the min-
has seen and felt until they see and feel and coarse to some." John Wesley wrote istry of reconciliation, He also expects us
it for themselves. all his sermons in full, and read them to to preach to people, not over their
Fog is good for lima beans; they the maid. All the words she couldn't heads. We must study for ourselves the
prosper in its clammy dampness. But understand, he eliminated. concepts and motives which change
fog has little to offer people. Scientific An 11-year-old girl, after hearing a lives. Then our task begins anew; we
experiments have indicated that a bank new minister for the first time, said, have got to study for the sake of others
of fog three feet thick, six feet high, and "Daddy, that preacher is not so smart. I the ways of describing those ideas so
one hundred feet long contains less understood every word he said." That that they can see them as clearly as we
than one seventh of a glassful of water! preacher was not only brilliant but also do. "He preaches over our heads" is no
One cannot quench thirst with fog. wise, for he had followed the example compliment. N
There is only one thing to do with fog, of Jesus. He preached in a language
and that is to keep out of it. There was that all could understand. He preached
no fog about the gospel when Christ with power. Morris Chalfant is a pastor in Kankakee,
and Paul presented it. A sermon should In all our preaching, let us be simple, Illinois.

3:Ae ♦
cSAeperoless infern¢fronalresourcefor minisfry spouses

Deoolionals
of 0arnal ♦ 3?eleocuzi articks speciPeaff yeared fo clergy spouses

♦ c_5L22-7.129 6fessinys anoi festhnonials

♦ 70arfolathie news of euenls cznoi czefluifies

Conthcryour focal conference o ce fo thuire ab-ouf a conference-sponsored sub-scrip/ion.

May 2002 MINISTRY 17


I PASTORAL PRESSURE POINTS I

The courage to
face our fears

I
t is the early hours of the morning. A point for a pastor to keep in mind, we
loud bang outside your bedroom have effective medication to control
window jolts you out of a snooze. anxiety when it gets out of control, but
Clunk, clunk, again. You are now bolt no medication can directly help us deal
upright, uncertain about whether you
ARCHIBALD D. HART
with fear.
should wake your wife who is still sound Fear involves a "hit and run" process
asleep. Then outside the window a in the brain. Survival is its sole purpose.
shadow passes, cast by the street light. Anxiety, however, stirs a slower reaction
Is it a burglar? Perhaps even a serial that lasts a while. In fact, anxiety, as
killer, the one you heard about on the we've previously established, can take
TV news the night before. Your imagi- over and entrench itself in such a way
nation is running wild. Your heart is that it appears to be there all the time.
beating hard and you are bursting to at what the future holds, grappling with The take-home point I want to com-
least tell someone else that there's the downturn in the economy with loss municate to Christian leaders here is
someone outside with evil intent. of jobs and a general increase in feelings that it is extremely important that we
A small, almond-shaped area of your of vulnerability, are taking their toll. help people bring their fear responses
brain called the "amygdala" is doing Even though for some non-North- under control as soon as possible.
what God created it to do. It is receiving American readers it might feel that the Failure to do so will result in an escalation,
signals of a potential danger, and it is United States is a long way away, the even entrenchment, of some form of
letting off a series of alarms throughout impact of terrorism is being felt severe anxiety disorder.
your body to prepare you to protect throughout the world with a conse- Unresolved fear is a powerful stressor
yourself. After all, this may be a threat quent increase in everyone's fear level. I that turns even a healthy fear into an
on your very existence! was in Australia on September 11 and ugly fretfulness. It's the form of stress
Clunk, clunk. There it is again. Now experienced firsthand the dramatic that is designed to be short lived. You
you know that you are not imagining it. effect it had there. On the other hand, can prevent prolonged fear from
It certainly is not a bad dream. But then we are slowly unraveling the fear becoming damaging through informed
the amygdala begins to get additional response and finding new and effective counseling and by preaching a healthy
messages. In the bright moonlight you ways of dealing with it when it gets out acceptance of fear. Pastors, especially
can make out the wavering images of a of control. preaching pastors, can play a very sig-
branch of the tree close to your window As in the previous two articles, my nificant role in these frightening days in
and a strong wind blowing. No need to goal is to help Christian leaders under- helping people avoid becoming trau-
bolt or scream out. Your fear is firmly stand as best they can all that we matized by prolonged fear.
snuffed out and all the alarm systems currently know about important emo-
are reset. Calm returns, though you tional problems people face today. By Kinds of fear
may still feel super-alert and vigilant for understanding the "fear circuit" it is Psychologists study many kinds of
a while. Now you're glad you didn't hoped that we will develop more effec- fear. Not all fears are of the dramatic,
wake your wife. You would have paid tive treatments for fear-related disorders life-threatening sort. So, while fears per-
for it in untold tales told at ladies' gath- such as phobias where fears are taken to sist about terrorist attacks we should
erings about just how "scaredy-cat" extreme. not ignore the more common variety of
some men are! In a previous article I made a distinc- fearful reactions that are very much
tion between fear and anxiety. The two more commonplace.
Unraveling the fear response become so entangled that sometimes There are "lesser" forms of fear that
We live in remarkable times. On one we cannot tell the one from the other. can be just as debilitating as the major
hand, since September 11, Americans Clearly, fear will give rise to anxiety forms. Take for instance, someone with
and others have experienced a dramatic when imagination takes over and exag- an extreme fear of germs. They intel-
upward shift in our general level of fear gerates the fear. But anxiety, we now lectually know that germs don't inhabit
arousal. The sudden loss of security, our know, uses different brain mechanisms. every piece of furniture or doorknob.
scared psyches, the uncertainty about For instance, and this is an important But intellectual reasoning has nothing

18 MINISTRY May 2002


to do with obsessive-compulsive disor- given an opportunity to talk about their effect many are now experiencing
der, which is what I am describing feelings surrounding such trauma. given the time that has elapsed since
here. Such people will incessantly wash Externalizing one's feelings is part of September 11 of last year.
their hands after touching something how the brain is designed to heal them. People need to be helped to "let go"
like a doorknob, often to the point of I say this because I believe that spiritual of fears that are no longer imminent
causing lesions and bleeding. All this is resources, especially having a healthy and to embrace a more positive outlook
because they fear that germs are invad- faith, can help to heal these memories toward the future. Reassurance of so
ing their skin. The fear of germs leads by robbing them of their sting. much that has and is being done to
them to try and eradicate the imag- make our world safer, needs to be
ined, invading microbes. Understanding the fear embraced in the context of our faith in
Another very common group of fears response a God who does control our world,
are phobias. Phobias are irrational fears: It is vital that all "people helpers" even though the way He is doing it may
While the feared object has some reason understand the fear response, if only to not always be obvious.
for creating fear, the sufferer cannot avoid perpetuating damaging beliefs
control the fear through reason. A fear that could reinforce unhealthy fears. Bringing fear under control
of flying, high buildings, snakes, and spi- Although a reaction to some fearful The first and one of the most impor-
ders are all quite natural in that these event is perfectly natural, it can be quite tant ways for dealing with fear is help
can harm you. But a normal person can unpleasant. As mentioned earlier, it all the person find out where the fear is
keep the fear in check by understanding starts in the amygdala that is weighing coming from. Is this fear a carry-over
the limits of the threat. If a snake is the evidence coming from all the body's from some bad childhood event? For
behind a glass wall it cannot bite you. sensors and searching for a possible many, bad childhood experiences have
For someone with a phobia, a glass wall threat. If a threat is sensed, it immedi- inculcated a conditioned response in
makes no difference to the fear. ately sends out signals to the adrenal which any similarity between some-
One particular fear related anxiety dis- glands, which in turn cause the heart to thing in the present (that might be
order, called Generalized Anxiety Disorder pump more blood to the brain and quite harmless) with something in the
(abbreviated GAD), is quite common. muscles. Breathing quickens, pupils past (that was terrifying) triggers a fear
While it is referred to as an "anxiety" widen, saliva dries up, and the hands response that really doesn't belong in
disorder it is more akin to fear than anx- become cold and clammy—all very nec- the present.
iety. Affecting at least four million essary for survival and part of how God This is illustrated in the experience of
people in the U.S. alone, it afflicts twice has created us. One of the conse- a couple I once counseled, who were
as many women as men. quences of this inbuilt alarm system is having marital difficulties. The husband
People with GAD have an exaggerat- that fear weakens the ability to concen- happened to be a pastor who was a lit-
ed and persistent fear sensitivity and it trate. You are easily distracted and tle impatient and reactive. Whenever he
can cause an enormous amount of cannot focus on much besides what is raised his voice at his wife she would go
stress. While there is some strong evi- causing your fear. into a catatonic state and start to trem-
dence that a small genetic factor may While this is healthy in an extraordi- ble from fear. He couldn't understand
play a role in its development in that nary fear-provoking situation like the this extreme reaction and so he became
identical twins have a high rate of con- clunks mentioned earlier, when the angry with her when she reacted in this
cordance in developing GAD, the actual danger is less acute and prolonged, this way. Of course, this only made matters
mechanism is the tagging of fear with response can be debilitating. This is the worse.
certain memories that do not fade like
other memories.
Such a person, then, has a brain that You Can Keep Them If You Care
is tagged and a fear structure is put in Helping new members stay on board V KEEP
place. This is why trauma needs to be ,. 11E1i IF YOU
dealt with as early as possible. Seeing a
If keeping new members is ..Aur problem—here are the ,p.. rp, Sky on I;ounf
answers! In this serious challenging book by James A.
friend killed or facing a severe risk to Cress. you will find theological imperatives for new
one's own life can, in people who are member assimilation as well as practical, how-to methods
vulnerable, permanently fire up their which work in real life.
fear response.
Helping people deal with the memo- MINISTERIAL ASSOCIATION RESOURCE CENTER
ry of some tragedy or fear as soon after Phone: 1.888.771.0738 (toll-free) or 301 .680.6508
Fax: 301.680.6502 Email: paynec@gc.aaventist.org
the event has occurred is, therefore, an Web: www.ministerialassociation.com
extremely important aspect of ministry.
In particular, victims of trauma must be

May 2002 MINISTRY 19


for pastors to consider in helping them-

A Great Resource for Elders selves and others:


+ Reassure people that they are not
crazy to continuously feel bothered by
current events and threats. It is normal
to be afraid, even for months after-
wards. As concentration-camp survivor
Viktor Frankel remarked: "An abnormal
reaction to an abnormal situation is nor-
mal behavior."
+ Reactions to fear that may be
expected include preoccupation with
recent events, some sleep disturbances,
resurgence of previously frightening
Please begin/continue my subscription to Elder's Digest memories, limited ability to attend to
❑ One year; payment of 15$9.95 enclosed
normal routines, and increased emo-
❑ Three years; payment of us$24.95 enclosed
tionality such as depression and crying.
Please type or print: + To prevent these reactions from
becoming excessive, limit attention to
media coverage (turn off the news if it
Name bothers you), focus on distracting tasks
or hobbies, and carry on your life as you
Mailing Address
normally would. Do what you would
City normally enjoy.
+ Look for a positive perspective on
State/Province Zip/Postal Code Country negative events. Find ways to help oth-
ers and engage in constructive
To subscribe, send a check/international money order or
credit card number with expiration date to: discussion only with those who have a
Elder's Digest Subscriptions + Ministerial Association Resource Center positive outlook.
12501 Old Columbia Pike + Silver Spring, MD 20904
+ Take extra time to rest; exercise
Phone: 888.771.0738 (toll-free) or 301.680.6508
Fax: 301.680.6502 + Email: paynec@gc.adventist.org and eat healthfully, and avoid taking on
Web: www.ministerialassociation.com too many outside activities.
+ Spend time with God—in praise,
meditation, and prayer. After all,
As we explored her reaction (and his need to be challenged, not left to do Scripture still has the most powerful
temper) it emerged that her father, also their damage. God designed us to deal antidote for fear: "Do not be anxious
a pastor, would lose his temper and with real fears only. about anything, but in everything, by
physically slap her. So, even though her Third, the imminence of the fear prayer and petition, with thanksgiving,
husband would never do this, just a should be examined. For instance, we present your requests to God. And the
slight anger reaction in him would all fear death. But most of us don't peace of God, which transcends all
bring out all the fear that was connect- expect to die in the foreseeable future. If understanding, will guard your hearts
ed to her father. we have just received traumatic news of and your minds in Christ Jesus" (Phil. 4:
We worked at helping her "discon- some terminal illness then it is appropri- 6, 7, NIV). N
nect" her fear for her father from her ate to be fearful and then to take steps
husband's reactivity, and, obviously, to deal with the certainty of that fear.
helped the husband to stop his behav- For those who fear death a long way off, Archibald D. Hart, Ph.D., EPPR., is professor of
ior, which now he knew was traumatiz- inevitable as it is for all, they need to be psychology at the Graduate School of
ing to his wife. enabled to put that fear aside and get Psychology, Fuller Theological Seminary, in
Second, the person should also be on with the business of living. Pasadena, California.
helped to explore whether the fear is Lastly, because it is not possible to
imagined or not. Not all fears are based eliminate all threats and therefore all Editorial note: This is the third in a
in reality. Sometimes we create fears in fear (we'd be creating a monster if we six-part series entitled "Pastoral Pressure
our imagination or by reading or hear- did), we need to facilitate ways in Points," by Dr. Hart. The remaining three
ing about something that happened to which a person can better tolerate rea- articles will appear in our July, September,
someone else. Such improbable fears sonable fear. Here are some suggestions and November issues.

20 MINISTRY May 2002


making a difference with the number of vol-
unteers we had, but no one seemed to notice
the good stuff. They were focused on every-
thing they saw wrong. I couldn't help but
think that if they were personally expected to
bring about the changes they wanted they
would quickly give up. To them it was a
church leadership problem and they were
quick to find fault.
I am married to an ordained minister, and
we have served in numerous churches.

Positive ways Criticism comes with the territory. Lay con-


stituency frequently holds staff members to a
higher standard. First Timothy 3:1-13

to deal with explains how overseers and deacons must be


beyond reproach. When you couple this
expectation with the fact that people are pay-

criticism ing a leader's salary, the standard for excellent


performance is higher.
Although we are called to be exemplary
leaders, we are still works in process, saved by
grace just like other believers. Unfortunately,
o avoid criticism do nothing, say members occasionally forget this little detail,
Teena M. Stewart
nothing, be nothing" (Elbert developing a higher set of expectations for
Hubbard). While serving as their leaders than for themselves.
Ministry Empowerment Director The cold hard fact is, we will never please
of a church, I worked rather close- all of the people all of the time. Under-
ly with some church members. This meant standing why people criticize and learning
having to deal directly with criticisms and how to handle those criticisms, helps me, as a
complaints. As a people pleaser who wants to leader, equip and fortify myself to withstand
keep everyone happy, I have discovered how the waves of criticism.
difficult it is to please everyone.
Our church offered regular gift-discovery Reasons people criticize
classes. I oversaw the follow-up placement Those with poor self-esteem are often the
process connecting volunteers with lay min- quickest to find the "speck" in their brother's
istry opportunities. My responsibilities eye because tearing someone down seems to
included supervising a group of ministry con- lessen the scrutiny of their own faults.
sultants. We made progress with our Administrators often operate under the
volunteer placements and were excited to be unspoken premise, "I wouldn't manage
putting people in positions they felt passion- things that way," assuming alternative meth-
ately about. Despite the positive results of ods would make things work more smoothly.
ministry mobilization, after one recent place- Still others are perfectionists and cannot
ment session every consultant voiced a tolerate imperfection. Someone has said,
different complaint. They proceeded to criti- "Criticism is the disapproval of people, not
cize everything they saw wrong, and each for having faults, but having faults different
seemed to have a separate agenda for how he from your own." Criticism stems from a per-
or she wanted things to work. sonality clash and sometimes it happens
I walked away from the meeting deflated. because people don't have a clear under-
Didn't anyone see how far we had come? Just standing of the church's internal mode of
two years earlier we had no placement process operating.
in place and people were virtually clueless A pastor friend told the following story:
Teena M. Stewart is a when it came to knowing how to get con- "Stress factors from my pastorate were caus-
freelance writer from nected with volunteer ministry. I had worked ing my wife, Esther, and I to have enormous
Benicia, California. hard to set the wheels in motion and it was marital and family difficulties. At times it was
working. The lay mobilization process was nearly beyond our ability to cope. After one

May 2002 MINISTRY 21


particular bad day of criticism, I left doing this soon makes itself known, ance were instrumental in his trans-
work terribly angry. I drove home and since everyone wants something dif- formation and restoration.
parked my van in a vacant lot next to ferent. People pleasers are more likely St. Francis de Sales once wrote,
my home. Still fuming, and alone, I to listen to complaints. "When you encounter difficulties
got out of the van, slammed the door, At my ministry consultant meet- and contradictions, do not try to
and huffed and puffed my way into ings I was setting myself up to receive break them, but bend them with gen-
the house. complaints by allowing consultants tleness and time."
Pray. Have people pray for your
F I PUT ON AN IRREPROACHABLE AIR leadership on a regular basis. Likewise,
pray for those who criticize you. The
pastor who was struggling under the
.1_ QT. PEREEcTtc),INI. I SET MYSELF UV AS A burden of his parishioner's criticisms
.4.1 was encouraged and uplifted when he
TARGET FOR CRITICISM learned that someone was praying for
him. God can work in the hearts of
"Unknown to me, a friend and to get off track and chase rabbits. our critics (even the chronic ones).
neighbor, whom my wife had just led Sticking to a set agenda and bringing Ask Him to uncover the truth and the
to Christ, watched from her two-story consultants back to task reduces the root cause of the criticism.
window. If I'd known, I certainly opportunity for criticism. Keeping Consider the source. "Let a righteous
would have hidden my anger. God's purpose and will at the fore- man strike me—it is a kindness; let
"A day later, Esther happened to front puts everything in its proper him rebuke me—it is oil on my head"
meet with our neighbor. The neighbor place. (Ps. 141:5, NIV). Some people are just
brought up the incident. 'Your hus- Drop the act. People can spot a natural faultfinders but within our
band must have been having a bad phony a mile away. If I put on an irre- congregations there are certain mem-
day,' she said. 'When I saw him, I proachable air of perfection I set bers we respect because of their
began praying for him. Is he all right?' myself up as a target for criticism. If I wisdom and godly ways. A reproof
"I was much better after hearing admit I am capable of error, those from one of these members carries a
her response! Such a response from a around me will be more likely to for- lot of weight and I am more likely to
parishioner after seeing her pastor give me when I make a mistake, or receive it as truth.
being so human, was not only when I take a course of action they Look for the grain of truth. If one per-
encouraging for us, but is unfortu- don't like. son corrects me I may or may not take
nately rare!" Attitudes toward critics. Use gentle- their words to heart, but if two or
A church regularly encouraged ness and compassion. "A gentle more people are raising the same
members and visitors to complete answer turns away wrath" (Prov. 15:1, issue, their words carry more weight.
communication cards in order to give NIV). If the criticism seems totally out of
feedback and updates on addresses Pastor Dan's eyes filled with tears line with no true merit, cast it aside. If
and prayer needs. One Monday as he read a scathing letter from one there is a grain of truth, then adjust-
morning staff members sifted of his core leaders. The man gave a ment of my actions and/or behavior is
through the cards. On one card a blow-by-blow account of everything probably in order.
member had written, "The pastor's wrong with Dan's leadership and Responding to criticism. If you want
sermon was good but it's too long. It teaching style. The leader-critic was to really tick off a critic then just give
needs to be about ten minutes short- so displeased he resigned from his a pat answer. They'll see right
er." Another card in the same pile position and left the church. through you. I don't want to come
read, "The sermons are too short." Dan felt betrayed and deeply hurt, across as flippant and uncaring but I
Trying to please everyone is like but rather than respond with bitter- have developed some ready-made
walking a tightrope. If we try to per- ness he "retaliated" by continuing to responses that have proven helpful.
form so that we don't ruffle any send the leader birthday cards, letters, Sincerely saying, "Oh, I can see why
feathers we lose our effectiveness and even invitations to breakfast. All that might bother you," or "Thanks
totally. So, what's the answer? his efforts, however, were rebuffed. for bringing that to my attention,"
Two years passed. Then one day are ways I show I care.
Answers to criticism the leader returned and stood before a When someone corrects me I lis-
Reducing criticism. If you are a peo- gathering of Dan and other church ten attentively, then make the
ple pleaser, your first inclination is to leaders where he asked forgiveness for judgment call. If I immediately see
do everything in your power to please his poor judgment and wrong atti- the criticism is on target, I tell the
your critics, but the impossibility of tude. Dan's gentleness and persever- giver what action I will take to correct

22 MINISTRY May 2002


it. If I feel the criticism isn't merited, dle it well. I already had scheduled a a meeting with the pastor in charge of
I tell them gently but firmly. meeting with the pastor who admin- those areas.
If a particular church member con- istrated in that particular area, so People pleasers carry invisible
tinually criticizes it helps to pinpoint when I met with him I raised the backpacks. As we go along and hear
the cause. I've discovered that the issue and explained the lay worker's criticisms, we add a stone to the pack.
most critical members are often not complaints. Before long the weight of the bulging
serving in any capacity and have too The pastor patiently listened and pack is unbearable. Now, when some-
much time on their hands. I can help explained why things stood as they one criticizes another coworker,
alleviate some of the friction by find- did, giving me an entirely new per- instead of placing the stone in my
ing an area where they are gifted to spective on the situation. He gently backpack, I hand it back to the initia-
serve. pointed out that I should not have tor and suggest they address the
shouldered these issues because they leader directly.
When others are being were really out of my realm of respon- Don't dodge. Criticism can be so
criticized sibility. unbearable that sometimes we are
But what about when criticism is At the time I was annoyed that he tempted to hide from the situation.
leveled at someone else? On several seemed to brush the issues aside, but Usually, however, dodging the prob-
occasions I have been approached by later, after mulling over what he said, lem makes the situation and the critic
individuals who level criticism at a I realized he had handled it well. more hostile. Meet the criticism head
fellow staff member or lay leader When I got back to my office I con- on. Even Christ, when confronted,
because they see me as being on the tacted the lay worker and gently dealt with His critics.
inner circle of leadership. shared the new information I had When we follow His example we
Recently a lay worker "dumped a gleaned. Then people-pleaser me did sharpen our problem-solving skills
load," regarding some issues she was something I was really proud of, I put and grow in the process. The better we
having with how prayer requests and the responsibility back on the lay become at dealing with painful cir-
church notices were being handled. worker's shoulders and suggested if cumstances and individuals, the more
The people pleaser in me didn't han- she still had issues, she should set up resilient we become as leaders. X

MB INI
SU SCRIBER SERVI
O Please send me a one-year subscription (12 issues) of Ministry.
(United States: 115 $29.95; Canada and overseas: 931.50)
O Please renew my subscription.
O Please update my address. (Enter new address below and include old mailing label.)

if you recently moved, enter previous address:


My Name Name
Current Mailing Address Mailing Address
City City
State/Province Postal Code State/Province Postal Code

Credit card orders please complete the following:


O MasterCard 0 Visa Card Number ____ - Exp Date
Cardholder's Signature

PLEASE ENCLOSE PAYMENT WITH YOUR ORDER. MAIL TO:


Ministry Subscriptions + c/o Jeannette Calbi + 12501 Old Columbia Pike + Silver Spring, MD 20904
Email: calbij@gc.adventist.org + Fax: 301.680.6502 + Phone: 301.680.6503

May 2002 MINISTRY 23


with which they are marked."'
While the English verb "ordain" can mean
to "issue an order," its ecclesiastical meaning
is "to invest with ministerial or priestly
authority." Such a meaning is not present in
the New Testament.
Biblical terminology for induction into
office, especially in the Old Testament,
includes anointing and laying on of hands.
For commissioning or induction into office,
the New Testament uses additional words,
none of them associated with "ordination" in
the ecclesiastical sense.

Ordination in the Anointing


In the Old Testament, things, places, and
persons are anointed to make them holy, to

New Testament? set them apart for a holy use. For example,
Jacob anointed a memorial stone at Bethel
(Gen. 28:18) and the Levites anointed the tab-
ernacle and its contents (Exod. 40:9) in order
to "consecrate" them.
he elders were kneeling in a circle At the beginning of their priestly service,
Nancy Vyhmeister
around George, who was about to Aaron and his descendants were anointed
become a deacon. The pastor was with fragrant oil (Exod. 30:30-32). While
praying for George, for his family, there is no specific mention of the ordination
for his ministry to the church. As of each of the kings of Israel and Judah, there
laying on of hands was mentioned, each elder is evidence that anointing the king at the
reached out to touch George. beginning of his reign was habitual. This was
Was this the way ordination took place in done either by a priest, such as Jehoiada who
the times of Peter and Paul? I went home and anointed Joash (2 Chron. 23:11) or by a
turned to my Bible that afternoon. prophet, such as Elijah who anointed Jehu
Unfortunately, the New Testament gives (1 Kings 19:16). The verb used is mashach, to
little specific information about services such smear, to anoint with oil. The king thus
as the one I saw that morning. Twelve pas- became a mashiach, an "anointed one." This
sages speak of some kind of appointment or Hebrew term was equivalent to "Messiah."
commissioning, but none uses the word In the New Testament, two different Greek
"ordination." To understand the topic, let's verbs are used to convey the meaning
briefly review the biblical terminology for "anoint." One is aleipho,2 which appears eight
commissioning, followed by an analysis of times. Four refer to the anointing (with per-
these 12 passages. fume) of Jesus by a woman (Luke 7:38, 46;
John 11:2; 12:3), two to the use of oil in the
Terminology healing of illness (Mark 6:13; James 5:14), one
The term "ordination" comes from the to the burial of Jesus (Mark 16:1), and one to
Latin ordinare, "to put in ordo," with ordo cosmetic anointing (Matt. 6:17). None of
meaning "row, rank, or order." In ancient these examples has any connection to cere-
Rome, ordo referred to a category of people, as monial anointing for induction into office.
in the "order of senators," distinguished from The second verb is chrio, "to anoint," from
Nancy Vyhmeister,
the plebe. which comes the title Christos, "the anointed
Ph.D., is professor
emerita of Andrews In ecclesiastical Latin, ordo refers to the one," corresponding to the Hebrew mashiach.
University, Berrien "holy orders" and ordinare to the ceremony The verb itself is used only five times, always
Springs, Michigan. of induction into holy orders. According to referring to anointing by God. In four cases,
Canon Law, the "sacrament of holy orders" God anoints Jesus (Luke 4:18; Acts 4:27;
constitutes some faithful Christians as "sacred 10:38; Heb. 1:9). In the other, God gives spir-
ministers by means of the indelible character itual anointing to believers (2 Cor. 1:21). A

24 MINISTRY May 2002


related verb, egchrio, appears in the hands" is one of the basics of of Jesus' calling or choosing (kaleo)
invitation to Laodicea to anoint their Christianity, along with baptism and twelve of His disciples after a night
eyes to regain sight (Rev. 3:18). resurrection, suggesting that this cer- spent in prayer. He thus made them
emony may have been part of the into apostles (Luke 6:13-16).3
Laying on of hands initiation rites of new believers. Jesus also appointed the Seventy
Laying on of hands can refer to Laying on of hands is mentioned (or seventy-two) to ministry.
giving a blessing (Gen. 48:8-20). It three times in relation to appoint- According to Luke 10:1-9, He "point-
also appears in two Old Testament ment to office. The apostles ed them out" (anadeiknumi), gave
examples of induction into office. At commissioned the Seven by the lay- them power, and sent them before
the beginning of their ministry the
Levites were purified by washing and

W
shaving; then they received the lay- HILE THE ENGLISH VERB "ORDAIN" CAN
ing on of hands by the whole
congregation. MEAN TO "ISSUE AN ORDER" ITS
Their induction ceremony was
completed by their laying hands on ECCLESIASTICAL MEANING IS "TO INVEST WITH
the bulls to be sacrificed (Num. 8:5-
26). According to Numbers 27:12-23, ,18,4j:KOTILAI.:,01t 1':61UT. HPRI.
Moses appointed Joshua as his succes-
sor by laying his hands on him. Even MEANING IS NOT PRESENT IN THE NEW TESTAM:;'.
though Joshua had authority and was
endowed with the Spirit of God, he
was to receive divine instruction ing on of hands (Acts 6:6). The Him to preach and to heal. Their
through Eleazar the priest. teachers and prophets at Antioch laid appointment is similar to that of the
The Greek phrase equivalent to hands on Paul and Barnabas at their Twelve.
"laying on of hands" occurs 26 times commissioning for ministry to the After Jesus' ascension, the eleven
in the New Testament. In the largest Gentiles (Acts 13:3). Paul instructs decided to replace Judas. Following
number of times (12) the phrase is Timothy to be cautious in commis- prayer they cast lots for Matthias. He
used in the context of the laying on of sioning local church leaders by the was chosen (eklego), then "enrolled"
hands to bring about healing. Of laying on of hands (1 Tim. 5:22). or added to the eleven (Acts 1:21-26).
these occurrences, eight have to do In the New Testament, inductions His task thus became the same as that
with Jesus: He lays hands on a person into office or commissioning for mis- originally entrusted to the Twelve by
who then receives healing (Matt. 9:18; sion involve four distinct groups of Jesus.
Mark 5:23; 6:5; 7:32; 8:23; 8:25; Luke people: (1) the disciples who become Although they do not report any
4:40; 13:13). Once the disciples are apostles, (2) the Seven of Acts 6, (3) specific ceremony, these passages
promised the gift of healing through Paul and Barnabas, and (4) local show a transition. The disciples
laying on of hands (Mark 16:18). In church elders. become apostles; they form the inner
Acts, three verses speak about healing Several different Greek verbs are circle of Christ's followers; they
brought about by the laying on of used in passages that describe these receive power to heal and preach, as
hands (Acts 9:12, 17; 28:8). ceremonies. In the analysis that fol- they further Christ's mission.
Closely related to the idea of heal- lows, specific Greek words are given
ing is the reception of blessing for each instance. The Seven
through the laying on of hands Acts 6:2-6 tells of the excessive
(Matt. 19:13, 15; Mark 10:16). The Disciples to apostles work load for the Twelve and the eth-
reception of the Holy Spirit and of the Three texts refer to Jesus' appoint- nic disputes that led to the selection
gifts of the Spirit is linked to the lay- ment of the twelve disciples. In of seven wise and Spirit-filled men to
ing on of hands (four times each). In Matthew 10:1-5, Jesus calls (kaleo) the "serve tables" and care for the wid-
Acts, new converts were filled with Twelve to Himself and gives them ows. Thus the Twelve would be free to
the Spirit when the apostles laid their power over disease and evil spirits. dedicate their time to prayer and
hands on them (Acts 8:17-19; 19:6). While in verse 1 they are "disciples," preaching.
Paul speaks of the spiritual gifts in verse 2 they are "apostles." In Mark These men were chosen (eklegomai)
Timothy received with the laying on (3:14-19), Jesus "makes [poieo] by the church; the appointment cere-
of his own hands (2 Tim. 1:6) and the twelve" and "names" them apostles. mony included prayer and the laying
laying on of the elders' hands (1 Tim. He does this so that they may be with on of hands. While their first task was
4:14). In Hebrews 6:1-2, "laying on of Him and go out to preach. Luke tells to "serve tables," two who figure in

May 2002 MINISTRY 25


later events are noted for tasks other ceremony marked the beginning of is not specified. We can assume that
than the care of the physical needs of Paul's apostleship.' at some point Timothy was made an
church members: Stephen was a great elder, but no details are given.
preacher, martyred for his Lord (Acts Church elders Information about the work of eld-
7); Philip was an evangelist (Acts Three passages speak about the ers, especially concerning their
8:5-40). appointment of church elders, all in commissioning, is scarce. We know
This ceremony approaches the relation to Paul's ministry. As Paul that these were church leaders, whose
ones we see today in Seventh-day concludes his first missionary jour- task was spiritual. They were called
Adventist and other churches. It ney, he and Barnabas revisit the elders or presbyters because older per-
marked the commissioning of seven places they had evangelized. Among sons were traditional leaders. Some
men to a specific church appoint- other activities destined to "strength- kind of ceremony installed them in
ment. Interestingly, these Seven are en" the "disciples," they appoint their church office. This installation
not called "deacons." In the Pastoral (cheirotoneo) elders in the churches, seems to have included laying on of
Epistles, deacons appear as church after fasting and prayer (Acts 14:23). hands.
leaders (1 Tim. 3:8, 12), ones who The verb used for "appointing" is
serve the church (diakonos). There is used only this once in the New So what did I learn?
no mention of their ordination.' Testament. In classical Greek usage, You have just read the results of my
this word meant raising the hand as study—only partly completed that
Paul and Barnabas to vote. Whether it meant anything Sabbath afternoon. The information I
Acts 13:1-3 narrates the appoint- different, such as laying on of hands, gathered was not as much as I would
ment of Paul and Barnabas to in Paul's Christian ecclesiastical have liked. There was practically
ministry for the Gentiles. While the usage, we have no idea. In any case, nothing on the organization of the
prophets and teachers in the church the appointment of local church eld- church. Yes, there were apostles,
of Antioch were worshiping God and ers as part of church organization elder/bishops, and deacons. But how
fasting, the Holy Spirit told them to seems to be clearly in view. did they relate to each other? Apostles
"separate" (aphorizo) Barnabas and In 1 Timothy 3, Paul delineates the and elders were commissioned; noth-
Saul for the work to which they had spiritual qualifications for church ing is said about deacons. Was there a
been called. officers—bishops, deacons, and ceremony for them?
Verse 3 says that they fasted and "women." But he gives no instruc- Yet, I found enough information
prayed and layed their hands on tions on any induction ceremony on New Testament appointments to
them—but fails to specify who "they" until a passing mention in 1 Timothy ministry to be reasonably sure of the
were. This commissioning includes 5:22. Here he warns Timothy not to following:
more elements than any other "lay hands" (cheir epitithemi) prema- (1) Qualified believers were
recorded in the New Testament. The turely on anyone as by doing this he appointed to specific ministries or
Holy Spirit takes an active part; the might "share responsibility for the tasks.
local church leaders do the commis- sins of others." Evidently he is plead- (2)Some kind of empowering took
sioning. Prayer, fasting, and the lay- ing for mature Christians to be place: The ones invested became
ing on of hands are included. church leaders. what they had not been until then.
In his later years, Paul writes Paul left Titus in Crete to set the (3) The appointments had distinct
Timothy about his own appointment church in order. Among others, the spiritual overtones: the Spirit led,
to service. He claims that he was matters he was to "put in place" Jesus called; there was prayer and fast-
"placed" (tithemi) as a preacher, apos- (kathistemi) was the function of elders ing; thus the commissioning was not
tle, and teacher of Gentiles in witness in the different cities. This Titus entirely human.
to Jesus, who gave Himself a ransom should do "as I have directed you" (4) The appointments were made
for all (1 Tim. 2:7). He repeats the (Titus 1:5). Unfortunately, Paul's spe- by the church for the benefit of the
same assertion in 2 Timothy 1:11, cific directives on this issue have not church.
noting that he was "put" (tithemi) or come down to us in Scripture. (5)Certain qualifications had to be
appointed as preacher, apostle, and To these three cases might be met by those appointed.
teacher for the sake of the gospel. No added Timothy's experience. Paul (6)The ultimate object of appoint-
additional details are given, but one reminds this young minister of the ment was mission—the spreading of
may rightly suppose he was thinking gift he received with the laying on of the gospel.
of the appointment described in Acts hands by the presbytery or elders What I did not find was any
13. (1 Tim. 4:14). Whether this was notion of hierarchy or power. Having
Ellen White calls this appointment induction into office, a healing serv- hands laid on them prepared apostles
an ordination. She indicates that this ice, or the reception of the Holy Spirit and elders to do more work, to be bet-

26 MINISTRY May 2002


ter servants, to be more responsible should we insist that current soulsaving."' To fulfill this commis-
for their actions. This responsibility Seventh-day Adventist Church sion all—not merely the priests and
seems to have been to the congrega- organization and ceremony are mod- kings of Israel—may be qualified by
tion rather than to a central church eled directly after the pattern of the the anointing of the Holy Spirit. After
authority, which of course did not New Testament. all, we are, says Peter, a royal priest-
exist as it does today. Finally, I cannot help but consider hood (1 Peter 2:9). IN
Instructions on how, when, where, the gospel commission (Matt.
and even why believers were commis- 28:18-20), "Go and make disciples," 1 Canon 1008, Canon Law of 1983.
2 To facilitate typesetting, no distinction is made
sioned to specific tasks or offices may as the ultimate commission, given to between long and short Greek vowels.
not be clear. However, it is evident every Christian. This appointment 3 At the beginning of chapter 30 of The Desire of Ages,
that ecclesiastical appointment was— parallels that received in ordination. Ellen White quotes the KJV of Mark 3:13, 14: "He
ordained twelve" (290). Although she does call this
and is—part of the church's It makes believers what they were not their "ordination" (293), she says nothing about any
legitimate activity. It seems to be one before (as Ellen White so poignantly ceremony.
4 Ellen White uses the term "ordain" to refer to what
of those items which the church notes: "Every true disciple is born
happened in Acts 6 (Acts of the Apostles, 90). In Acts of
"binds on earth" (Matt. 16:19). into the kingdom as a missionary"6), the Apostles the Seven are called "deacons" (90). In the
The church is empowered to make and empowers them for ministry. Spirit of Prophecy (3:293) and The Story of Redemption
(260), they are "chosen men," not identified as dea-
decisions and carry out appointments This appointment takes place at cons.
in order to fulfill its mission. George's baptism and includes those "upon 5 Ellen G. White, Acts of the Apostles (Nampa, Idaho:
ordination was appropriate, yet we whom human hands have never Pacific Press® Pub. Assn., 1911), 164.
6 -, The Desire of Ages (Nampa, Idaho: Pacific Press®
cannot affirm that it was done "exact- been laid in ordination, [who] are Pub. Assn., 1898), 195.
ly as in the New Testament." Neither called to act an important part in 7 , Acts of the Apostles, 355.

New Testament Appointments


Appointment of Text Greek word Purpose Appointer Additional elements

The 12 Matt. 10:1-5 Give power to heal and [Jesus] Power


cast out demons

The 12 Mark 6:14-19 poieo; make Be with him; send to [Jesus] Power
preach and have power
over demons

The 12 Luke 6:13-16 kaleo; call Be apostles [Jesus] All-night


onomazo; name prayer

The 70 Luke 10: 1-9 anadeiknumi; appoint Go before him, preach The Lord
and heal

Ananias Acts 1:21-26 eklego; choose Replace Judas in ministry Peter & the brethren Lots Prayer

The Seven Acts 6:2-6 eklegomai; choose Serve tables The apostles Prayer Laying on
of hands

Paul & Barnabas Acts 13:1-3 aphorizo; set apart Go to Gentiles The Holy Spirit Prayer Laying on Fasting
of hands

Paul 1 Tim. 2:7 tithemi; place Be a herald and apostle Christ Jesus (verse 6)

Paul 2 Tim. 1:11 tithemi; place Be herald, apostle, teacher Christ Jesus (verse 10)

Church elders Acts 14:23 cheirotoneo; vote Be church elders [Paul & Barnabas] Prayer Fasting
by stretching out
the hand

Church elders 1 Tim. 5:22 cheir epitithemi; Be elders (verse 17) [Timothy] Laying on
lay on hands of hands

Church elders Titus 1:5 kathistemi; put in Be elders [Titus]


place

May 2002 MINISTRY 27


shifts we need to make to increase our under-
standing, respect, and compassion for
postmodern people."'
The author discusses these three shifts as:
from triumphalism to humility, from ration-
alism to mystery, and from objectivism to
other ways of knowing. As we consider minis-
tering to postmoderns in the context of these

Should we be recommended conceptual shifts, a few ques-


tions come to mind: Where would these
conceptual shifts, if we were to make them

postmodern "really," leave us theologically? Should we


become postmodern to minister to postmod-
erns? Are these shifts being recommended

to minister to only as adjustments of expediency, simply for


the convenience of ministry? Or are we to
make them to really reflect our frame of

postmoderns? mind? These articles did not leave me with an


unequivocal answer to these questions, yet
the necessary connection between ministry
and theology requires that we explore this
question, because our ministry ought to be
here is no question that contem- informed by our theology. Though I believe

T
Kwabena Donkor
porary western culture is changing that a clear understanding of the postmodern
in its philosophical outlook. situation is a necessary prerequisite to a suc-
Today, western culture is challeng- cessful ministry to postmoderns, I do not
ing the modern way of thinking, think that Seventh-day Adventists should be
which emphasized objectivity and absolute postmodern ourselves in order to minister
certainty. Modernity's distinctions between successfully to this group.
subject and object, knowledge and opinion,
and science and superstition, are being blurred Postmodernism and modernism's
in the contemporary postmodern climate. triumphalism
Ministry in times like these calls for reflection, In what sense did modernism represent tri-
and Samir Selmanovic's two-part article titled umphalism? Modernism's triumphalism is
"Pastoring on the Postmodern Frontline" (see said to consist in its striving for what has been
Ministry, July and September 2001) begins an described as the "grand narrative." Post-
important discussion on this vital issue. modernists use the term "narrative" to
Indeed, it raised the crucial question: How do describe a system of beliefs and values that
we minister in a postmodern milieu? legitimize a society by acting as a force that
These articles raise a larger question about binds that society together. A narrative (i.e.,
the crucial connection between ministry and the belief system that holds the society
theology or, stated differently, between praxis together) is "grand" when it is comprehensive
and theory. The author correctly perceives the in explaining and providing meaning to
connection between praxis and theory as whatever the society does and believes. Such
unavoidable. In two places in the first part of a belief system, which holds true always, and
the articles he alludes to this connection. In not only for a particular historic period,
advocating the need for change in ministry as underlies and permeates every aspect of the
we confront the postmodern "hurricane," the society's life. On the other hand, a belief sys-
Kwabena Donkor,
author writes, "We must change not only our tem may sustain only a segment of people for
Ph.D., Senior Pastor,
Toronto-Ghanaian
methods but also our understanding of how a particular historic period. Such is a "local"
Seventh-day
people think and feel and thus how we are to narrative.
Adventist Church, think as we seek to meet their minds and Modernism sought to explain and provide
Toronto, Canada. hearts."' Again, we are admonished that in meaning to all reality on the foundation of
preparing to deal with practical ministry reason. In other words, the world was what
adjustments, ". . . there are three conceptual reason claimed it to be, and this was to be

28 MINISTRY May 2002


taken as universally true and for all It is quite significant to note that bib- ness of the individual phenomena of
time. Postmodernism claims that the lical grand narratives appear to pre- our experience. In this way, reality is
very idea of a belief system that is date modernism. brought under the grip of reason to
always and universally true (i.e., a serve as its principle and to explain its
grand narrative) is no longer credible. Postmodernism and origin. Especially in the modem peri-
It is argued that the very fact of our rationality od reason took the form of scientific
situatedness in particular historical We indulge in questions about reason, and only that which was sci-
contexts forces us to experience the rationality when we raise issues about entific in nature counted for reality.
world through our individual and the nature, place, and competence of Postmodernism properly criticizes
unique perspectives ("local" narra- human reason. It has been character- this form of rationality as arrogant.
tives). To claim that one's viewpoint is istic of philosophy from the early There are thinkers such as Foucault
always and universally true is to Greek thinkers to the modern period who wish to dispense with the whole
demonstrate lack of humility, a mark to use reason to explain reality in a notion of rationality as a western tra-
of arrogance and triumphalism. This way that brings coherence and unity dition that has turned out to be a
was the hallmark of modernism's
rationality. However, to be postmod-
ern is to denounce grand narratives of HIS CHALLENGE TO MODERN RATIONALITY
any sort; the postmodern outlook
"demands an attack on any claim to APPEARS TO MAKE ROAM. FOR THE NO',17.2N OF
universality."' 1
, •

ft._r;
C:1
Postmodernism's insistence that
all belief systems are unique view-
7 ST TUT r TT - r cr I F ROM RI-VrT 0-1. 4 I SM
points, contextual and, therefore,
provincial has significant implica- 0 MYSTERY BE A SAFE RETREAT?
tions for Christian ministry in "MI

general, and for Adventist ministry in


particular. What should Christian to all reality. For example, Plato's doc- repressive myth.' Others, such as
ministry do with such "grand narra- trine of Forms or Ideas is regarded as Habermas, wish to replace modern
tives" as, "For there is one God, and one of his significant contributions to rationality with a procedural rational-
one mediator between God and men, philosophy. In Plato's system, the ity. Procedural rationality is when
the man Christ Jesus" (1 Tim. 2:5)? Forms represent eternal and unchang- reason is denied the ability to
Or, "And there is salvation in no one ing patterns of which the objects we describe what reality is, only the
else, for there is no other name under actually see are shadowy copies. But capacity to evaluate knowledge and
heaven given among men by which Plato comes up with this doctrine as a moral claims in the context of a set of
we must be saved (Acts 4:12, RSV)? means to explain the nature of exis- procedures.'
Do distinctive Adventist doctrines tence. Plato reasoned that when we Obviously, this challenge to mod-
still have a place in evangelism in a say, for example, that a thing is beau- ern rationality appears to make room
postmodern context? tiful or that an act is good, we imply for the notion of mystery. But will the
It is true that throughout Christen- that a standard of beauty or good shift from rationalism to mystery be a
dom we are urged to show respect for exists somewhere which is distinct safe retreat? There may be questions
world religions and be accommoda- from that thing which we say is beau- that we cannot answer, and we should
tive to faiths other than our own. tiful or that act which we say is good. not lose our faith if we were to admit
Obviously, ecumenism thrives in such Furthermore, while the particular that we do not have all the answers.
a pluralistic postmodern context. It thing that is described as beautiful Nevertheless, Adventist theology and
may be that the shift from triumphal- may perish with time, the very idea of ministry is built on a concept of reve-
ism to humility in a postmodern con- beautiful itself is timeless. For Plato, lation-inspiration that should enable
text represents a "politically correct" then, the idea Beautiful inhabits a us, indeed force us, to employ a pro-
move. But a real question remains: world that is more real than the cedural notion of rationality within
Should Christian ministry, and for world, which the particular thing that the confines of revelation-inspiration.
that matter Adventist ministry, intend is beautiful inhabits. Plato concluded While postmodern critique of modern
to bring postmoderns to an accept- that the real world must lie beyond rationality is a welcome development,
ance of biblical grand narratives, or the visible world. In this way, Plato I do not think that ambiguity and
should we not advocate them because employs reason not only to explain mystery represent the necessary alter-
they tend to paint our ministry in col- the origins of reality, but also to show native. We should not lose sight of the
ors that reflect control and conquest? the internal relations and connected- fact that postmodern epistemology

May 2002 MINISTRY 29


(theory of knowledge), denies us the struct, based in historical communi- "high view" of inspiration for exam-
right to state any position with ties and comprising of a web of ple, the answer to the postmodern
absolute certainty. If we were to build beliefs.' challenge that all belief systems repre-
ministry on such a foundation, to Given the supposition that min- sent particular viewpoints may be not
what spiritual certainties would our istry (praxis) ought to be based on a simply to state that one's "faith com-
postmodern friends be called? Or sound theology (theory), a more fun- mitment is grounded in history,
should their spirituality consist in ever damental choice faces us other than embodied in the community of my
developing spiritual beliefs? Or in the one between the modernist con- Church ... ,"1° a supremely postmod-
sympathy with postmodern non- ception of building beliefs on a ern answer, but to state as well the
foundationalism, should ministry not foundation and the postmodernist basis of the belief in inspiration. This
be built on certain sure foundational notion of a web of beliefs. This is the means that we may not minister to
beliefs? The present statement of our choice between the belief in the exis- postmoderns on the basis of beliefs
theology would seem to deny a prac- tence of an objective world and the that are grounded simply in the his-
tice of ministry that is based on existence of a reality that is the cre- toric faith community, but pre-
ambiguity and mystery. ation of our language. Our choice will eminently on the basis of an inspired
profoundly impact our approach to Bible.
Postmodernism and ministry. Does this mean that in ministry we
modernity's objectivism should not approach postmoderns
Since in philosophy reason tries to Assumptions and from where they are coming? Not at
construct and explain all reality in a consequences all: We should understand the think-
unified and orderly fashion, modern Postmodernism's critique of ing and experiencing processes of
philosophy tried to conceive of our modernity centers on its concept of postmodern persons in order to min-
world as eminently objective. By this, rationality, which supports an objec- ister to them. Yet a sympathetic
modernists wanted to say that the tive view of reality as explained above. understanding of postmodernism
world of our senses exists really apart Although postmodernity finds it does not necessarily require the epis-
from us and should be the proper sub- objectionable to be defined as a temological shifts discussed here. In
ject of our study. Furthermore, mod- worldview, it is precisely that, as fact a shift from rationalism and
ern rationality brought unity to all Selmanovic rightly observes.' This objectivism to mystery and other
reality by assuming that everything means that postmodernism, like mod- focus of knowing respectively, repre-
consists of bodies in motion, and ernism, employs reason to construct a sent a shift from one form of rational-
therefore everything conforms to a view of reality, albeit different from ity to another. Who knows what
mechanical model. Being objectively that of modernity. Reality, according epistemological approach may be in
real, modernism could easily say that to postmodernism, is progressive and the offing? Compassion, respect, feel-
the world could be known objectively relative. In other words, there is not ings, emotions, and intuition may all
through observation and induction. one view of reality that is true for all. be elucidated from the biblical per-
In the modernist system, such objec- Reality is as one conceives it from spective if we patiently and conscien-
tive knowledge is universally and one's particular viewpoint, hence the tiously articulate them as we seek to
absolutely true. Postmodernism notion that "every point of view is a minister meaningfully to postmodern
rejects the notion of an objective view from a point."' Therefore, the persons. N
world, and consequently the possibil- point is inescapable that in the con-
ity of objective knowledge. In adopt- text of belief, whether we approach Editorial note: We definitely
ing this position, postmodernism ministry on the basis of modernity's appreciate the quality of this response
depends in part on twentieth-century foundationalism or postmodernity's to the Selmanovic articles. We do not
linguistic theory. According to this web of beliefs, we function on the believe the Selmanovic or Donkor arti-
view, what we generally assume to be basis of reality as constructed by rea- cles advocate becoming postmodern in
an objective world is in reality a cre- son. order to reach postmoderns.
ation of ours through our use of lan- Is it possible to find an objective
guage. It is in this sense that language world that is not the creation of rea-
1 Samir Selmanov, "Pastonng on the Postmodern Frontline (part I)," In
is said to be our access to the world. By son but in which the parts of all of its Mondry, July 2001, 10
2 Ibid , 11.
this they "contend that what we call experience are meaningfully related? 3 Stanley J. Greer, A Prima on Postmodernism (Grand Ramds. Lernmans Pub.
Co., 1996), 45
the real world is actually an everchang- The Bible presents us with such a 4 Anton A Van Phelerh 'Pon:metaphysical Versus Postmodern Thmlong"
Philosophy Today39 (1995). 177.
ing social creation."' Therefore, there world not on the basis of reason but 5 Ibid., 175.
6 Grens, 42.
are no certain foundations to our on the basis of inspiration. One's 7 See Marl 1 Wallace, 'The New Yale Theology," Christran Scholar's Renew 17
(1988). 154-170
knowledge of reality. Meaning, like stand on inspiration becomes opera- 8 Selmanovm, part 2, 20
9 Sebnanovm part 1, 13
reality is an ever-changing social con- tive here. From the perspective of a 0 Selmanovic, part 2,21

30 MINISTRY May 2002


PASTOR'S PASTOR

Traveling
mercies
nyone who equates work- baggage. At first, Chek Yat thought this

A related travel with fun has yet to


endure their third trip. Mind
you, I love my work—especially when I
JAMES A. -CRESS
not all that unusual since he had
observed me groping for documents at
other stops, but after about ten minutes
arrive and can interact with pastors and of fruitless searching, his tolerance level
their spouses, local elders, and ministe- was reduced to the point that he
rial secretaries. But the process of grabbed my roll-aboard and began his
"getting to work" is often a frenetic, own personal search through all my
fatiguing, frustrating foray. belongings.
A few recent incidents demonstrate No boarding pass. No passport.
the old song's veracity—"all day, all Stuck in Viet Nam. Who to call? And if
night, angels watching over me." We you thought the denominational
don't just believe in miracles, we rely on restroom and secure a bottle of water bureaucracy was complicated, try
them! before exiting the airport customs area. explaining your predicament to some-
Russell Burrill, of Andrews University Then there was the Sabbath which one whose only word of English is
Seminary, and I boarded a flight out of began at 6:00 a.m. and concluded 15 "No!"
Egypt in the deep-night hours of hours later with my hosts' bewilder- By this time the chief representative
September 10. In bemused observa- ment that I was unwilling to experience of Singapore Airlines had been sum-
tion, we commented about the lax the treat of dinner at a restaurant fea- moned. She graciously but firmly
security which allowed us to depart turing local delicacies. Sometimes the instructed me to search again for the
Cairo without a serious check of either phrase, "killing with kindness" becomes missing documents which she knew I
our baggage or passports. By the next reality. had possessed when she checked me in
flight, we welcomed three-hour waits Other times we bring our troubles and which I would have had to produce
and multiple security checks in the upon ourselves. Chek Yat Phoon, to pass through security and customs to
aftermath of September 11. Southeast Asia Union Ministerial this transit area.
Enduring longer waiting lines in Secretary, will not forget how we After holding the flight for 20 min-
exchange for enhanced security seems arrived at the Ho Chi Minh City utes—and this from an airline known to
fair. Having an agent explain that either (Saigon) airport three hours early, the be the world's most efficient—the
Sharon or I must endure a 14-hour flight first passengers to check in for our agent sent me onto the plane with stern
cramped into a middle seat because the flight. After proceeding through immi- admonition to keep searching because I
airline's policy does not permit two pas- gration to the transit area, we looked surely would not be allowed ongoing
sengers of the same family to occupy an around a bit and then I settled in for a transit or entry into Singapore. As we
aisle and window seat—or even two two-hour working session of paperwork boarded, I was praying and grumbling
aisle seats—is unreasonable punish- while we waited. aloud that heaven would have to find
ment, especially when standby fliers are As I completed each item, I tore the my passport since it was more logical
boarded at the last moment and seated paper in half to separate "keepers" from that I had thrown it away as it was like-
in exit-row aisles and windows. trash and rejoiced in the amount of ly to be found in my carefully-searched
Well-meaning friends also contribute work I was accomplishing as evidenced briefcase. Both God and Chek Yat must
to travel stresses. I vividly remember my by the growing stack of discarded have heard my prayer because he
keen frustration (hopefully it was con- paper that piled up beside me. turned back and requested security to
cealed but Sharon doubts my ability to When the time arrived to head for check the trash bin where, sure enough,
disguise my feelings) after an exhaust- the gate, I tossed all the scrap which they found my castoff passport and
ing 30-hour, much-delayed flight had accumulated into a nearby trash ticket in with my discarded paperwork.
itinerary when, rather than being taken bin and casually approached the board- The angels worked overtime, and I
directly to the hotel for a shower and ing agent who asked to inspect my am certain they deserve—and I need—
rest, I was "shown the sights" of tourist passport and ticket. a vacation! So, watch your passport and
interest and new church projects. At Checking my pockets and finding say a prayer of thanks with me for prov-
least I have learned to always use the neither, I began to search my carry-on idential blessings. X

May 2902 MINISTRY 31


Dear stor.. responsibility.
mplicat ed
co else,
al church
toisbea certain that, whatever
Running a
That's why yo h out to the community.
mac
isLiberty
able magazine will keep you informed about the state of your
religious liberties. We have been monitoring legal and sociological
changes in this area for over 95 years. 1-lot topics include.. charitable
choice initiatives, school prayer, zoning, the moral future of your country.
gregation deserve the opportunity to regularly read
magazine. Why should state and federal politicians, judges,
pivotal religious
You and your COD
in ix not-tobe-missed
Liberty
and lawyers be the only ones informed about theses
Liberty
liberty
issues aissues? Right now
year, mailed youto
directly can have
your home or central church location

for only $6.95.


Just send your name and address to Liberty magazine,
12501 Old Columbia Pike, Silver Spring, Maryland 20904-6600
along with your check. Or call us at 301-680-6690.

GENERAL CONFERENCE OF
SEVENTH-DAY ADVENTISTS Nonprofit Organization
MINISTRY U.S. Postage
1350 N. KINGS ROAD PAID
NAMPA, ID 83687-3193 Nampa, ID
Permit No. 147
CHANGE SERVICE REQUESTED

You might also like