Mustread
Mustread
Mustread
201600435 Concepts
An integration of CO2-free hydrogen generation through meth- solid carbon and a hydrogen/methane mixture that can be di-
ane decomposition coupled with hydrogen/methane separa- rectly fed to a hydrogenation unit to load a LOHC with hydro-
tion and chemical hydrogen storage through liquid organic hy- gen. This allows for a straight-forward separation of hydrogen
drogen carrier (LOHC) systems is demonstrated. A potential, from CH4 and conversion of hydrogen to a hydrogen-rich
very interesting application is the upgrading of stranded gas, LOHC material. Both, the hydrogen-rich LOHC material and the
for example, gas from a remote gas field or associated gas generated carbon on metal can easily be transported to desti-
from off-shore oil drilling. Stranded gas can be effectively con- nations of further industrial use by established transport sys-
verted in a catalytic process by methane decomposition into tems, like ships or trucks.
Introduction
Today, more than 60 million tons of hydrogen are produced to the stoichiometry of the methane reforming and water-gas
and utilized industrially.[1] The largest part of this quantity is ap- shift reactions, the energy consumption of the process, and
plied in the petrochemical and chemical industry, mainly for the molecular masses of the molecules involved.[5]
desulphurization of fuels and hydrogenation reactions, for ex- Aiming for the sustainable (zero emission) production of hy-
ample, the production of ammonia and methanol.[2] In the drogen, electrolysis of water using renewables is one possible
near future, hydrogen is expected to gain additional impor- option. However, electrolysis is still relatively expensive (3 E
tance as a green energy vector for the mobility sector, because per kg of hydrogen).[6] As an alternative, hydrogen production
its combustion in fuel cells or combustion engines produces from hydrocarbons avoiding CO2 emissions can be considered.
water as the only combustion product.[3, 4] Whereas CO2 capture and storage (CCS technology) is energy
However, to consider hydrogen as a sustainable fuel, it is im- and cost intensive,[7] and associated with ecological uncertain-
portant to assure that its production is free of CO2 emissions. ties, hydrogen production through catalytic decomposition of
This is not a trivial task given that 95 % of today’s industrial hy- hydrocarbons linked to elemental carbon sequestration is
drogen production is generated from fossil fuels by steam re- a promising option. In particular, the moderately endothermic
forming, partial oxidation, or gasification processes. All of catalytic methane decomposition to carbon and hydrogen
these produce significant amounts of CO2. For example, 1 ton holds great promise for the sustainable production of hydro-
of hydrogen produced by using methane as raw material was gen.[8]
reported to produce more than 10 tons of CO2 simply owing
CH4 ! C þ 2 H2 DH25 C ¼ 74:5 kJ mol1 ð1Þ
[a] S. Drr, M. Mller, A. Bçsmann, Prof. P. Wasserscheid
Lehrstuhl fr Chemische Reaktionstechnik Whereas purely thermal decomposition of methane occurs
Friedrich-Alexander-Universitt Erlangen-Nrnberg at process temperatures above 1200 8C,[9] the use of an appro-
Egerlandstr. 3, 91058 Erlangen (Germany)
priate catalyst has been reported to bring the operating tem-
[b] H. Jorschick, Prof. P. Wasserscheid
Helmholtz-Institut Erlangen-Nrnberg fr Erneuerbare Energien (IEK-11) perature down to 550 8C.[10] Regarding suitable catalysts for
Forschungszentrum Jlich GmbH catalytic methane decomposition (CMD), the literature pays
Egerlandstraße 3, 91058 Erlangen (Germany) special attention to supported group 8–10 base metal cata-
E-mail: [email protected]
lysts, in particular nickel, iron, and cobalt.[11] While nickel cata-
[c] M. Helmin, Prof. R. Palkovits
lysts are limited in CMD to operating temperatures below
Lehrstuhl fr Heterogene Katalyse und Technische Chemie
RWTH Aachen and JARA Energy 700 8C, iron systems have been reported to operate even
Worringerweg 2, 52074 Aachen (Germany) above this temperature.[11] Despite these differences, any cata-
E-mail: [email protected] lyst used for CMD eventually deactivates as result of deposition
Supporting Information and the ORCID identification number(s) for the of carbon-rich polyaromatic structures, amorphous, filamen-
author(s) of this article can be found under http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/
tous, or graphitic carbon on its surface.
cssc.201600435.
CMD is a complex process that can be divided into three
This publication is part of a Special Issue celebrating “10 Years of Chem-
SusChem”. A link to the issue’s Table of Contents will appear here once key steps: (i) hydrogen generation by a sequence of methane
it is complete. adsorption and dissociation at the metal surface and simulta-
ChemSusChem 2016, 9, 1 – 7 1 2016 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim &
A significant part of the world’s methane reserves is located In this contribution, we propose the combination of CMD
far from industrial and population centers, and transportation with hydrogen storage in liquid organic hydrogen carrier
cost hinders its efficient utilization. Moreover, many of these (LOHC) systems as a very attractive option to overcome the
gas fields are far too small to justify chemical conversion of named limitations and to establish a technology to upgrade
methane by current gas-to-liquid technologies that gain eco- stranded methane in the form of storable and transportable
nomic attractiveness only in the form of world-scale units.[13] hydrogen equivalents ready for industrial use at any far distant
Thus, the term “stranded gas” refers to methane resources location. LOHC systems are composed of pairs of hydrogen-
at places and in quantities that do not justify the installation of lean, mostly aromatic compounds and hydrogen-rich, mostly
pipeline infrastructures, for example, associated gas from an alicyclic compounds. By reversible hydrogenation and subse-
off-shore oil drilling rig or from oil drilling at remote locations quent dehydrogenation, LOHCs can be used to safely bind,
in the desert. Currently, such stranded gas is typically flared, store, transport, and release hydrogen on demand.[17–20] De-
vented or re-injected.[14] Consequently, new technologies able pending on the LOHC system, hydrogen storage is possible at
to convert this gas in small facilities of low investment cost di- a material-based energy density of up to 72 gH2 LLOHC or
rectly at the gas source would benefit from a very low or even 2.4 kWh L1. Thus, the concept allows hydrogen storage over
negative feedstock price. It is common understanding among long times at high volumetric energy densities as well as hy-
experts that the amount of stranded gas is on the order 40 to drogen transport over long distances without losses using ex-
60 % of the proven global natural gas resources.[15] isting infrastructure for liquid fuels (e.g., ships, trucks, rail
CMD is, in principle, ideally suited for a treatment of strand- trucks, and tank farms). Figure 2 shows the proposed combina-
ed methane. Compared to common gas-to-liquid technology, tion of CMD and hydrogen storage through LOHC systems.
CMD represents a relatively simple one-step process that con- Herein, we demonstrate new insight into the combination of
verts methane directly into two valuable products, hydrogen CMD and LOHC hydrogenation by using representative hydro-
and carbon-loaded metal. However, two aspects prevent the gen-methane mixtures from CMD as substrate for charging
use of CMD as economic option in stranded gas upgrading: a selected, suitable LOHC system.
(i) for thermodynamic reasons, the CMD process provides no
full methane conversion in the desired temperature range of
Hydrogen production through CMD
its catalytic operation, and hydrogen–methane separation is re-
quired to recycle unconverted methane back into the CMD The influence of the reaction temperature on hydrogen yield
process and to obtain pure hydrogen; and (ii) whereas carbon- in CMD was studied using a 20 wt % Ni/Al2O3 catalyst in the
loaded metal can be easily shipped from the remote place to temperature range of 550 to 700 8C. Figure 3 shows the outlet
a potential consumer, the produced hydrogen is characterized hydrogen stream as well as methane conversion as a function
& ChemSusChem 2016, 9, 1 – 7 www.chemsuschem.org 2 2016 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Figure 2. The proposed two-step upgrading process for stranded gas: meth-
ane is converted in a catalytic decomposition process to carbon and hydro-
gen, which is subsequent purified from remaining methane and transferred
into a transportable form by LOHC hydrogenation.
Figure 4. TEM micrographs of the spent Ni/Al2O3 catalyst at (a, b) 600 8C and
at (c, d) 700 8C.
ChemSusChem 2016, 9, 1 – 7 www.chemsuschem.org 3 2016 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim &
& ChemSusChem 2016, 9, 1 – 7 www.chemsuschem.org 4 2016 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Conclusions
Figure 7. Effect of hydrogen pressure on hydrogenation of H0-DBT; Our contribution highlights the fact that a combination of cat-
T = 180 8C, 5.9 mol DBT, 0.25 mol % Ru applied as 5 wt % Ru on Al2O3, 3 h re- alytic methane decomposition (CMD) and hydrogen purifica-
action time. tion and storage by hydrogenation of LOHC systems offers
a versatile, economically attractive, and new way for upgrading
To evaluate whether H0-DBT hydrogenation is a suitable stranded gas towards green, CO2-free hydrogen production.
method to purify hydrogen from hydrogen/methane mixtures Whereas the CMD step has been shown to operate in
out of the CMD process, our next set of experiments was dedi- steady-state for at least 5 h converting 14 % of the offered
cated to batch reactor hydrogenation studies using hydrogen/ methane into hydrogen and carbon, the LOHC charging step
methane mixtures. As shown in Figure 8, no negative impact operates beneficially with diluted hydrogen/methane streams
of methane on the reaction rate or H0-DBT conversion was ob- to hydrogenate dibenzyltoluene to perhydro-dibenzyltoluene.
served for comparative experiments in which 20 bar 2 MPa of In the scenario of a stranded gas resource, for example, at
methane were added to 40 bar 2 MPa of hydrogen. During an off-shore oil platform or at a remote drilling site in the
these runs (pH2 = 40 bar, pCH4 = 20 bar) even a remarkable in- desert, methane would be converted in the proposed technol-
crease of the reaction rate was observed at low degrees of H0- ogy sequence into carbon rich metal (for metallurgic process-
DBT conversion. es) and transportable hydrogen in the form of a hydrogen-rich
Figure 8 clearly illustrates increased reaction rates for both organic liquid.
experiments applying a mixed gas phase hydrogen substrate. It is fair to note, though, that nearly all studies on CMD to
Compared to the runs with pure hydrogen, higher degrees of date have been performed at ambient pressure as an increase
hydrogenation were achieved after given reaction times. Fur- in total pressure is expected to have a detrimental effect on
ther experiments featuring different methane partial pressures the reaction rate owing to thermodynamic effects.[38] Actually,
(see the Supporting Information) did not reveal any further in- CMD conducted under pressure is a largely uninvestigated
fluence on reaction rate or reaction time (until full hydrogena- field of research in the area of methane decomposition. There-
tion was reached). In addition, the influence of stirrer speed fore, it is expected that some compression of the methane/hy-
was examined using the same hydrogen/methane mixture drogen mixture from CMD is required to provide the pressure
(40 bar hydrogen/20 bar methane). Increase in stirrer speed for the hydrogenation step. However, the energy input into
this compression step will depend on the compression ratio
and with that the starting pressure delivered by the CMD step
is important. This turns studies of CMD under even slight pres-
sures into a highly relevant field for further investigations.
Experimental Section
Catalytic methane decomposition
The 20 wt % Ni/Al2O3 catalyst used in this work was prepared by in-
cipient wetness impregnation of g-Al2O3 (Sasol Germany) with an
aqueous solution of Ni(NO3)2·6H2O (Sigma–Aldrich). Prior to im-
pregnation the g-Al2O3 spheres were ground and sieved to a parti-
cle size of 500–630 mm. The impregnated sample was dried at
100 8C for 24 h and subsequently calcined at 500 8C for 4 h. The
Figure 8. Comparison of hydrogenation performance by using pure hydro- metal loading was verified by inductively coupled plasma atomic
gen and a hydrogen/methane mixture; T = 180 8C, 5.9 mol DBT, 0.25 mol % emission spectroscopy (ICP-AES). Prior to reaction the catalyst was
Ru applied as 5 wt % Ru on Al2O3. reduced in a 50 mL min1 hydrogen (Air products) stream for 2 h.
ChemSusChem 2016, 9, 1 – 7 www.chemsuschem.org 5 2016 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim &
& ChemSusChem 2016, 9, 1 – 7 www.chemsuschem.org 6 2016 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ChemSusChem 2016, 9, 1 – 7 www.chemsuschem.org 7 2016 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim &