Bougie, Stylets, AECs
Bougie, Stylets, AECs
Bougie, Stylets, AECs
Chapter
16 Optical Bronchoscope
P. Allan Klock, Jr, Mridula Rai and Mansukh Popat
Driver BE, Prekker ME, Klein LR, et al. (2018). Effect of use Hodzovic I, Latto IP, Wilkes AR, Hall JE,
of a bougie vs endotracheal tube and stylet on first-attempt Mapleson WW. (2004). Evaluation of Frova,
intubation success among patients with difficult airways single-use intubation introducer, in a manikin.
undergoing emergency intubation: a randomized clinical Comparison with Eschmann multiple-use introducer
trial. JAMA, 319, 2179–2189. and Portex single-use introducer. Anaesthesia, 59,
Duggan LV, Law JA, Murphy MF. (2011). Brief review: 811–816.
supplementing oxygen through an airway exchange Nolan JP, Wilson ME. (1992). An evaluation of the gum
catheter: efficacy, complications, and recommendations. elastic bougie. Intubation times and incidence of sore
Canadian Journal of Anaesthesia, 58, 560–568. throat. Anaesthesia, 47, 878–881.
139
Table 15.2 Airway exchange catheters
Device Material Colour Length (cm) Outer diameter Hollow DLTs Notes
Fr (mm)
Endoguide Tefloned PVC White 525/700/830 15 Fr (5) Yes Yes (size limit) Tin wire inside for
(Teleflex Medical) modelling
VBM PET Light blue 80 11/14/19 Fr Yes Yes (size limit)
Aintree intubation PET Light blue 56 19 Fr Yes (4.7 mm) No Special for FOB
catheter intubation
(Cook Medical)
AEC PET Yellow 83 8/11/14/19 Fr Yes (1.6/2.3/3/ Yes (size limit)
(Cook Medical) 3.4 mm)
Arndt AEC PET Yellow (50/65/78) (8 Fr) Yes (0.38 inch tip) Yes (size limit) Wire-guided,
(Cook Medical) 70 14 Fr bronchoscope
port
AEC soft-tip PET/soft tip Green-violet 100 11/14 Fr Yes (2.3/3 mm) Yes Stiff body/soft tip
(Cook Medical)
Tube Exchanger PET Blue 53.5/70 2/3.3/5 No Yes (size limit)
(DEAS)
Cannula AEC PET Yellow 45 8 Fr Yes No
(Cook Medical)
Tracheostomy PVC Transparent 40 6.0/7.0 mm Yes No Rounded tip with
Cannula lateral holes,
Exchange Guide depth markers
(DEAS)
Staged Extubation PET Green-violet 83 14 Fr Yes Yes 0.0135 inch/145 cm
(Cook Medical) guidewire and
soft-tipped airway
catheter
DLT, double-lumen tube; FOB, flexible optical bronchoscope; Fr, French; PET, polyethylene; PVC, polyvinyl chloride.
Chapter 15: Bougies, Stylets and Airway Exchange Catheters
another or for management of ‘at-risk’ extubation. • In the case of rapid decompensation of a patient
While bougies may be used for the same purpose with an AEC in situ, reintubation should be
they are generally too rigid and too short and AECs prioritised over oxygenation via the AEC.
are better suited to the role. The hollow lumen of the • Use a tracheal tube with a tip designed to avoid
AECs enables oxygen administration during or after impingement on the airway (e.g. ILMA tracheal
the procedure but this is a high-risk strategy. tube, Parker tip tube) during railroading.
• Direct or videolaryngoscopy during intubation
Tracheal Tube Exchange over an AEC (both during tube exchange and
AECs are made from a range of materials (including reintubation) is likely to facilitate the procedure
a combination of stiffer catheter body with a softer and is recommended.
distal tip intended to reduce the risk of direct trauma) • Successful reintubation over an AEC should
and vary in length and diameter (Table 15.2). AECs always be confirmed with capnography and
designed for double-lumen tube exchange are longer a backup plan should be in place for failure.
than those for single-lumen tubes (≈100 cm vs. • When used for ‘at-risk’ extubation, the patient
≈80 cm). should be nursed in high dependency or intensive
care unit and the AEC only removed when the
airway danger has resolved.
Use during ‘At-Risk’ Extubation
An AEC may be placed in the airway prior to
extubation of a patient with a difficult airway and
Airway Trauma Potential and Pitfalls
If used inappropriately, AECs have potential to cause
may be tolerated by awake patients for up to 72
serious airway injury. Due to their length, these
hours. Local anaesthetic may be placed on the
devices are often inserted too far into the airway and
AEC or administered through its lumen. If reintu-
this risks direct airway trauma. Oxygen administra-
bation is required the tracheal tube is railroaded
tion via an AEC has an even higher potential to cause
over the AEC using this as a guide. AEC-guided
life-threatening or fatal airway injury. When the tip of
reintubation success rates are ≈85% with a risk of
the AEC is above the carina, oxygen administration
pneumothorax during the procedure of ≈1.5%.
through the AEC is unlikely to cause barotrauma
This is discussed further in Chapter 21.
whatever the oxygen flow rates. However, when
inserted deeper into the airway to the first point of
Optimal Use of AECs resistance oxygen administration from a high-
AEC use for tube exchange or safe extubation seems pressure source (e.g. wall or cylinder) can cause bar-
to be a safe and effective procedure if basic rules are otrauma within few seconds even at oxygen flow rates
followed. as low as 2 L min−1.
• Lubricate the AEC before use. Bougies, stylets and AECs are simple and highly
• Insert the AEC no more than 20–24 cm orally and
effective devices which when used appropriately
27–30 cm nasally in an adult patient. This ensures have an important role in managing a range of air-
the AEC sits within the tracheal tube with minimal way challenges, from difficult intubation to tube
or no protrusion beyond the tip of the tube and it exchange manoeuvres and safe extubation strategies.
does not reach the carina. Maintaining the AEC Complication rates are low when used correctly, but
tip above the carina will reduce patient discomfort there is a risk of major harm if poor quality devices
and trauma risk. are used or technique is poor. Insertion of either
device too far into the airway is the single greatest
• During AEC use administer oxygen by face mask
pitfall to avoid.
or nasal specs. Oxygen administration through the
lumen of an AEC is associated with a significant
risk of barotrauma and should be avoided unless Further Reading
there is clear benefit over standard administration Axe R, Middleditch A, Kelly FE, Batchelor TJ, Cook TM.
routes. (2015). Macroscopic barotrauma caused by stiff and
• If oxygen is administered via an AEC it should be soft-tipped airway exchange catheters: an in vitro case
via a low-pressure source at low flow (≤ 1 L min−1). series. Anesthesia & Analgesia, 120, 355–361. 137
Section 1: Airway Management: Background and Techniques
(a) (b)
Figure 15.4 Stylets. (a) Standard malleable stylet, (b) preformed stylet for use with an angulated videolaryngoscope – inserted in tracheal
tube, (c–e) a deformable stylet: it is supplied in its ‘unactivated position’ (c), and is activated by pushing the proximal end, which causes it to
bow (d); when this is done with the stylet in the tracheal tube it curves the tube (e).
recommended. Bougie placement through an SGA with further than the Murphy eye or ≈1.5 cm proximal to
FOB guidance has a high success rate but requires two the tip of the tracheal tube. The passage of the sty-
skilled operators. Use of an Aintree intubation catheter letted tube should then be observed continuously
is likely a preferable technique – see Chapter 13. during its passage through the airway. When the
A bougie may also be used to aid placement of the tube tip reaches the glottis, the stylet should be pro-
ProSeal LMA – this is described in Chapter 13. gressively withdrawn as the tracheal tube is advanced,
so that the stylet tip never reaches the glottic opening.
Standard stylets are plastic-covered pieces of mal-
Bougie Use during Emergency Front leable wire (Figure 15.4). Preformed, mostly rigid,
of Neck Airway (eFONA) stylets are increasingly produced by individual VL
A number of national airway management guidelines manufacturers and used during VL intubation
promote the scalpel-bougie as a technique of choice (Figure 15.4). The stylets are designed so that the
for eFONA (this is described in Chapter 20). curve of the stylet matches the curve of the hyper-
angulated VL blade. This enables the styletted tube to
run along the distal end of the VL blade during intu-
Stylets bation, in a technique that greatly simplifies intuba-
Stylets are rigid tracheal tube guides that are inserted tion (see Chapter 17).
into the tracheal tube before intubation. They may be Deformable stylets are available that can be
used to curve straight or non-rigid tubes and also to deployed to create a ‘dynamic’ curve such that the
accentuate the curve of curved tubes, especially during curve of the tracheal tube matches that needed to
intubation with a hyperangulated VL. Traditionally bou- achieve intubation (Figure 15.4).
gies have been favoured in the UK and the stylet in many
other parts of the world but especially in North America.
With increased use of VLs this variation is reducing. Airway Exchange Catheters (AECs)
The major pitfall to use of a stylet is that its rigid AECs are long, narrow, semi-rigid hollow tubes,
tip may cause significant airway injury. To avoid this inserted through an in-situ airway device in order to
136
the distal tip of the stylet should never be inserted exchange one airway device (tracheal tube or SGA) for
Chapter 15: Bougies, Stylets and Airway Exchange Catheters
there are some concerns about cross-contamination rigidity of a stylet may be preferred for VL-guided
risk, though no data are available to support or dis- intubation and this is discussed below. Stylets with
courage their (re-)use. a flexible tip may provide benefit but at present are
under-evaluated (see Chapter 17).
Aid to Videolaryngoscope-Guided
Intubation Airway Trauma Associated with Combined
The advantages of videolaryngoscopy in the manage- Bougie and Videolaryngoscope Use
ment of the difficult airway are well documented, but The incidence of bougie-related airway trauma
airway adjuncts may be needed to aid the VL-guided during VL-guided intubation appears to be smaller
intubation. Bougies or stylets may help guide the tube than during direct laryngoscopy, with a reported
into the trachea when tube advancement is proble- incidence of 0.8% in a recent observational study
matic despite a full view of the glottis, especially when of 543 intubations using a videolaryngoscope with
a hyperangulated VL is used. A bougie may improve the Frova bougie. The issue of the ‘blind spot’ and
speed and success in up to one third of VL-guided trauma during intubation is discussed in Chapter
intubations and some advocate routine use especially 17.
in emergency settings and in the pre-hospital setting.
When used with a hyperangulated blade VL the bou- Bougies for Intubation through an SGA
gie needs to be curved to match the blade profile
(Figure 15.3), and the degree to which this curve is or for SGA Placement
maintained during intubation will depend on the Bougies have been used to aid intubation through an
bougie and environmental factors such as tempera- SGA. Techniques include blind bougie placement or
ture. The narrow external diameter of the bougie may combined with a flexible optical bronchoscope (FOB).
improve manoeuvrability (compared with a styletted Blind attempts at tracheal intubation via an SGA have
tracheal tube) but there are also reasons why the very low success rates, risk airway trauma and are not
Figure 15.3 Assembling and shaping of tracheal introducers with different direct laryngoscopes (MacIntosh, Miller blade) and channelled/
unchannelled videolaryngoscopes. In each of the lower figures the bougie must be curved to match the curve of the videolaryngoscope to 135
achieve its goal.
Section 1: Airway Management: Background and Techniques
Figure 15.2 Indications for use of tracheal introducers (bougies): note that use of bougies in Grades 3b and 4 (Cook’s modification of the
Cormack and Lehane grading) – i.e. when the epiglottis either cannot be lifted from the pharyngeal wall or is not seen at all – is unlikely to be
effective and is strongly discouraged. The top right figure illustrates the variation in shape and material of the bougies (Some images courtesy
of Giulio Frova).
Fr, French; ID, inner diameter; NA, information not available; OD, outer diameter; PET, polyethylene; PTFE, polytetrafluoroethylene; PVC, polyvinyl chloride; TI, tracheal intubation; TT, tracheal
tube; UV, ultraviolet.
Table 15.1 Tracheal introducers – bougies
potential to improve success rates of bougie-guided anticlockwise rotation during tube advancement
direct and VL intubation. However, they are likely to may achieve the same effect but tube impingement
require practice to master and to be relative rigid. It is on the laryngeal aryepiglottic folds is more likely
therefore possible they will slow down during routine during rotation.
intubations and have increased risk of trauma. Their A multicoloured bougie has been described (traffic
place in airway management practice is yet to be light bougie) which uses colours to highlight when
established. the safe limit of insertion depth has nearly (orange) or
has (red) been reached. This decreases over-insertion
Tips on Optimal Use but is not yet commercially available.
Preloading a curved bougie prior to intubation is
• Hold the bougie 25–30 cm from the tip as this
advocated by some users to be faster and may be
improves control when manoeuvring the
especially useful to airway managers working without
bougie.
assistance. It may help awkward intubations but in
• Curve the distal 20 cm of the bougie so the truly difficult intubations the presence of the tracheal
curvature imitates the curvature of the airway. tube may hamper bougie manipulation.
This is particularly relevant with Grades 2b
(only posterior laryngeal structures visible) and
3a (only epiglottis visible). Different curves Single-Use or Reusable Bougie?
might be needed according to the bougie used, The original Eschmann ‘gum elastic’ bougie has been
depending on the materials used and its shape in use for more than 50 years with very few reports of
memory. airway trauma. Some hospitals use this reusable bou-
• A bougie can be used in Grade 1 -2a (cords visible) gie as a single-use device because of cross-infection
views to minimise laryngoscopic traction, in order concerns.
to reduce potential airway trauma. Some single-use bougies have been introduced
• Advance the bougie into the trachea no more than into clinical practice with little or no clinical evi-
20–24 cm mark at the incisor level (in adults). This dence of comparative performance or safety.
ensures the position of the bougie tip is above the Success rates are generally lower than with the
carina and is likely to significantly reduce the risk Eschmann reusable bougie, with the Frova bougie
of airway trauma. approaching equivalence. Single-use bougies are
• Load the tracheal tube over the bougie with the variably stiffer and have greater airway trauma
tube bevel facing posteriorly in relation to the potential, with reports of severe airway trauma.
patient. Advance it in this position. A 90° The potential for airway trauma is increased if 131
Tracheal Tube Introducers (Bougies), Stylets
Chapter