Language Awareness in Teaching A Toolkit
Language Awareness in Teaching A Toolkit
Language Awareness in Teaching A Toolkit
Timothy Chadwick
WORKING WITH
A catalogue record for this publication is available from the British Library
Contents
Acknowledgements iv
About the author v
Foreword: Why this Toolkit? by Paul Ellis vi
Preface viii
Introduction 1
Section 1: Classroom 8
Section 2: Co-ordination 35
Section 3: Exams 43
Answer key 54
Afterword: First language awareness by Maurice Carder 69
Afterword: How to create interlingual classrooms by Eithne Gallagher 72
Index 75
Acknowledgements
We are grateful to the following for their comments on the Toolkit:
Peeter Mehisto (certain sections)
Justyna Proksza, Prywatne Liceum Ogólnokształca˛ce im. Melchiora
Wańkowicza, Katowice, Poland
We would like to thank Maurice Carder and Eithne Gallagher for their
contributions.
We would also like to thank colleagues at University of Cambridge
International Examinations and at Cambridge University Press for their
valuable input.
We very much hope that you find this Toolkit to be a useful companion when
considering the academic language demands and support you provide in your
school classrooms.
If you would like to give your views on this Toolkit, please email
[email protected] (Subject: ‘To Education Division: Language Awareness in
Teaching’).
For further information about University of Cambridge International
Examinations, please visit the website: www.cie.org.uk.
1
Investigating the Relationship Between Performance in Language Assessment and Other,
Non-Language IGCSE Subjects, Phase 1: Analysis of question papers and mark schemes &
Phase 2: Analysis of candidate output (Stuart Shaw, University of Cambridge International
Examinations internal research report, 2011).
2
Cambridge IGCSE® is the registered trademark of University of Cambridge International
Examinations.
3
Calpability: Achieving in Content Through Language: Teacher Perceptions, Examiner
Expectations and Student Performance in Cambridge IGCSE History (Helen Imam,
unpublished MA thesis sponsored by Cambridge Assessment, 2010).
to reflect on the ideas contained within it, using your own background and
knowledge to emerge as a more confident teacher, more able to innovate and
engage with your students. Whilst this Toolkit focuses on second language
awareness, the two Afterwords raise the importance of first language awareness
in multicultural contexts and provide some practical suggestions. We hope
you will soon discover the vital importance of language and its use in the
classroom.
paul ellis
Head of Curriculum Strategy
Education Division
University of Cambridge International Examinations
Preface
Welcome to the Language Toolkit.
This Toolkit aims to help you, as content and English language teachers,
support your students in developing the academic language skills they need to
be successful in those content subjects that they are studying through English.
1
For further information on CLIL, see, for example, Coyle, D., Hood, P., and Marsh, D. 2010.
CLIL. Cambridge University Press; Mehisto, P., Marsh. D., and Frigols, M. J. 2008. Uncovering
CLIL: Content and Language Integrated Learning in Bilingual and Multilingual Education.
Macmillan; and https://www.teachers.cambridgeesol.org/ts/teachingqualifications/clil
Preface ix
Section 1:
Classroom
How does the content teacher support academic language
in the classroom?
In this section, we will look in greater detail at exactly what is meant by
supporting students with language in the content classroom.
We will begin (Objectives 2–4) by looking at the type of language needed to
master content.
Subject-specific language that is essential in order to master content is often
referred to as content-obligatory language and includes specialist vocabulary
(Objectives 2 and 3) as well as functional language (Objective 4). This
language is distinguished from content-compatible language, which is helpful
but not essential for a particular subject. (For more information on this, see,
for example, the work of Snow, Met and Genesee.1)
We will then (Objective 5) take examples of tasks that content teachers
would ask their students to do in class and identify the language demands of
those tasks and suggest specific strategies that provide support.
These tasks will be broken down into the three areas we mentioned in the
introduction: vocabulary, word and sentence level functional language, and
language skills.
1
Snow, M., Met, M. and Genesee, F. (1989) ‘A Conceptual Framework for the Integration
of Language and Content in Second / Foreign Language Instruction’, TESOL Quarterly,
23, pp. 201–217.
1 Classroom 9
carry out, observe, set up, add, measure, give off, react (violently)
with, form
Practical task 2
History
1 List content-obligatory vocabulary on the topic ‘Slavery during the American
Civil War era’.
2 List content-compatible vocabulary that you think is generally useful for this topic.
Maths
1 List content-obligatory vocabulary on the topic ‘Ratios and proportion’,
e.g. equivalent ratio.
2 List content-compatible vocabulary that you think is generally useful for
this topic.
Science
1 List content-obligatory vocabulary on the topic ‘Photosynthesis’.
2 List content-compatible vocabulary that you think is generally useful for this topic.
Refer to the Answer key on pages 55–56 for some suggested answers.
Practical task 3
What strategies could you use to help students understand the meaning of the
following items? Make notes.
1 conical flask, beaker, test tube, pipette, tripod
2 ribbon development, nucleated settlement, green belt, Central Business
District, urban sprawl
3 multiply, divide, cube root, greater than, less than, decimal point, pi
4 first, then, wheat, harvest, export, store, silo, finally, insecticide, separate,
chaff, next
5 robust, hasty, unnerving, heroic, solitary
Refer to the Answer key on page 56 for some suggested answers.
1 Classroom 11
Examples Examples
Examples
Adapted from Shaw, 2011 (unpublished). Builds on Bloom’s taxonomy of educational objectives, 1956;
Anderson and Krathwohl’s revision of Bloom’s taxonomy, 2001; Mohan’s Knowledge Framework, 1986;
Black et al. Critical Thinking Taxonomy, 2007; suggested IELTS skills taxonomies; contributions from
Chadwick, 2011
1 Classroom 13
3. Language of process
Examples
• describing a process
• sequencing
• using spatial temporal relationships
• describing cause and effect
• forming personal opinions
• making generalisations
• making analogies
• making connections
• selecting relevant material
• constructing arguments
• producing
• planning
• responding
• decision making
• communicating
• generating
Examples
8. Language for creating
6. Language of conclusion
Examples
• explaining
• suggesting
• hypothesising
• drawing conclusions
• developing
• considering
• reasoning
• presenting arguments
• presenting conclusions
• expressing personal opinions
• determining cause and effect
• evaluating
NB: One strategy that is not a good idea is to point to a word on the
whiteboard and ask, ‘What does this mean?’. This is actually a very difficult
thing for your students to do because they need very precise vocabulary. Try it
for yourself with simple words like saucepan, table and cushion. For example:
‘A saucepan is a round cooking utensil with a long handle and a lid used for
cooking food.’
1 Classroom 15
First, match the functional language below (a) to (e) below to the thinking skills
listed in Column 1 of the table. Then, try to write full sentences from this and
similar functions. An example from Geography is provided.
a We know this text is objective / subjective because …
b Firstly, secondly, then, after that, finally … / A is added to B, C is emitted
causing D to occur …
1 Classroom 17
c X is a … which we use to …
d It is often said that … , but I think / In my view, … / I believe …
e We should / ought to / could try …
Thinking skill What the students are doing
1 classication dening:
2 description compare and contrast:
Limestone is a porous rock whereas granite isn’t.
3 process sequencing / describing a process:
4 analysis detecting purpose / bias (usually in a text):
5 evaluation recommending:
6 conclusion expressing personal opinions:
Refer to the Answer key on pages 56–57 for some suggested answers.