Ilovepdf Merged 7
Ilovepdf Merged 7
Ilovepdf Merged 7
BEHAV. &
PRACTICE
MGT. FIN 5561
4 R'S OF
MARKETING
PROF. TY SOO
4 R’s of Marketing:
04/16/2024
1. Retention:
· Involves strategies to keep existing
customers and encourage repeat business.
· Businesses aim to provide excellent products
and services to ensure customer loyalty and
minimize customer churn.
2. Referral:
· Refers to the process of encouraging existing
customers to recommend a product or service to
others.
· Positive word-of-mouth and referrals from
satisfied customers can be powerful tools for04/16/2024
3. Relationships:
· Focuses on building strong and positive
relationships with customers.
· Businesses aim to understand their customers'
needs, communicate effectively, and create a sense of
trust and loyalty.
4. Recovery:
· Involves strategies to win back customers who
may have had a negative experience or stopped using
the product or service.
· Addressing customer issues, resolving complaints,
and improving the overall customer experience 04/16/2024
HUMAN BEHAV. & PRACTICE MGT
FIN 5561
BUSINESS START UP
Prof. Ty Soo
Copyright
(FIN5561)
Different types of Financial Planners
applies to
investment income, other than
deductible dividends,
earned by CCPCs
• the corporation still pays Part I tax of
about 45%
on all of this other investment income
• however, it can credit approximately
26 2/3% of
the investment income to its RDTOH
Corporate Taxation: Filing a
Corporate Tax Return
• the corporate income tax return is
called a T2
• all corporations other than registered
charities must
file a T2 for every taxation year, even if
there was
no tax payable for that year
• the filing deadline is 6 months of the
end of the
corporation’s taxation year
• as with an individual, penalties apply
for corporate
Holding Companies
• holding companies are corporations
that exist
primarily for the purpose of holding or
owning
property
• they may hold or own:
• shares of an operating company (meaning
a corporation
carrying on an active business)
• investment portfolios
• other property
Estate Freezes Involving Holding
Companies
• an estate freeze freezes the value of
an asset such
that future growth is passed to the
intended
beneficiary and is ultimately taxed in
their hands
• the intended beneficiary subscribes to
the
common shares of HOLDCO for a
nominal cost
• the shares of OPCO are rolled over to
HOLDCO
Estate Freezes: ITA Section 85 and
Section 86
• an estate freeze can also involve
rearranging
ownership so that the taxpayer
exchanges their
common shares for preferred shares of
the same
value
• the taxpayer's intended beneficiary
subscribe to
new common shares at a nominal cost
• provisions in the Income Tax Act
permit the
HUMAN BEHAVIOUR & PRACTICE
MANAGEMENT
FIN 5561
CONSUMER BEHAVIOUR
PROF. TY SOO
COPYRIGHT © 2024 TY SOO ALL RIGHTS
RESERVED
COPYRIGHT© 2023 McGRAWHILL ALL
RIGHTS RESERVED ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
NO PART OFTHIS PUBLICATION MAY BE
REPRODUCED, STORED IN AN RETRIEVAL
SYSTEM, TRANSMITTED OR USED IN ANY
FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION
FROM THE AUTHOR/PUBLISHER
Consumer Behaviour
Consumer should
drive marketing
strategies (needs)
Firms must
understand
consumer’s needs
Founding principle:
listen & learn from
your customers
Feedback = improve
• Functional needs
• Psychological needs
Informatio
n Search
Factors
Affecting
Consumer’s
Search
Processes
Actual
or Locus of
Perceive Control
d Risk
Social
risk
Physiological
risk
Psychological
risk
© 2023 McGraw Hill Limited 4-10
Test Your Knowledge
Macy’s is part of the retrieval set of stores available to women for business apparel, but Banana Republic is in the evoked set for young
women looking for business apparel.
Accessorie Overall
Mileage Style Price
s Score
Importan
ce 0.4 0.1 0.3 0.2
Weight
Toyota 10 8 6 8 8.2
Honda 8 9 8 3 7.1
Nissan 6 8 10 5 7.2
Evaluations are based on a 1 (very poor) to 10 (very good) scale.
Based on the non-compensatory decision rule (based on price), Nissan is the best
candidate for purchase.
Compensatory
Consumer
Decision
Rules
Decision Noncompensat
Heuristics ory
Examples of decision
heuristics:
• Price
• Brand
• Product
presentation
The distinctive style of these lululemon yoga pants is a determinant attribute
that distinguishes the product from other brands.
Purchase
Decision
• Customers are ready
to buy
Increase
Conversion
rate
Reduce real
Reduce the
or virtual Merchandise
actual wait
abandoned in stock
time
carts
Postpurchase
• Three potential
outcomes
• Organic juices
packaged in
reusable glass
bottles.
• Demand forced
expansion –
leading to three Greenhouse uses intriguing product names such as Farma-C and a line of “greatest hits”
new shops.
to catch the attention of consumers.
• Organic
ingredients that
come from local
© 2023 McGraw Hill Limited 4-33
Social Factors:
Family
Decision makers
Influencers
Groups: Provide:
• Family • Information
• Friends • Rewards
• Co-workers • Self-image
• Famous people
• Shared meanings,
beliefs, morals &
customs
• Your culture group
can be your school,
country, religion
• Culture greatly
influences consumer
behaviour Marketers work to understand consumer culture and respond with products such as halal
• Marketers must
meats to meet specific needs.
understand
differences among
countries © 2023 McGraw Hill Limited 4-37
Situational
Factors
Purchase
Shopping
Temporal State
Situational factors may influence your purchase decisions. If you are buying jewellery for yourself,
you might browse the clearance counter at People’s Jewellers (top picture). But if you are buying
a gift for your best friend’s birthday, you may go to Tiffany & Co (bottom picture).
Typically, fashion apparel purchases (left) require extended problem solving, whereas grocery shopping normally requires limited problem
solving (right).
CONTACT MGT
& MARKETING
PROF. TY SOO
Source:Investope
dia 04/16/2024
Contact management and marketing:
04/16/2024
Contact Management:
1.Customer Relationship Management
(CRM) Systems:
• Implement a CRM system to centralize contact
information, interactions, and history.
• Choose a CRM platform that suits your business
size and requirements.
2.Data Organization:
• Keep contact details up-to-date and organized.
• Categorize contacts based on criteria such as
lead status, customer type, or industry 04/16/2024
3.Communication Channels:
• Integrate various communication channels like
email, phone, and social media within your
CRM.
• Ensure seamless communication across
platforms.
4.Data Security:
• Implement security measures to protect
sensitive customer information.
• Comply with data protection regulations and
04/16/2024
5.Automation:
• Automate routine tasks like data entry, follow-ups,
and reminders.
04/16/2024 6
Marketing:
1.Target Audience Segmentation:
• Segment your contact list based on demographics,
behavior, or preferences.
• Tailor marketing messages to specific segments for
better engagement.
2.Personalized Marketing:
• Utilize data from your CRM to create personalized
marketing campaigns.
• Personalization enhances customer experience and
increases conversion rates.
04/16/2024
3)Email Marketing:
• Create targeted email campaigns to nurture
leads and retain customers.
• Use analytics to measure the effectiveness of
email campaigns.
4) Content Marketing:
• Develop high-quality, relevant content that
addresses your audience's needs.
• Share content through various channels,
including social media and blogs.
04/16/2024
5)Social Media Marketing:
• Engage with your audience on social media
platforms.
• Use social media analytics to track
performance and adjust strategies.
04/16/2024
By combining effective contact management with
targeted and personalized marketing strategies,
businesses can build stronger relationships with
their audience, improve customer satisfaction,
and drive growth.
04/16/2024
HUMAN BEHAV.
& PRACTICE
MGT. FIN 5561
DRIVERS OF
CUSTOMER
SATISFACTION
& KYC
PROF. TY SOO
1
COPYRIGHT
The “Know Your Client” (KYC) rule is one of the most important rules that salespersons1 must keep in mind
when selling securities. It is designed to provide them and their firms2 with guidelines for making sure that
they collect important information necessary to enable them to assist in fulfilling a client’s investment needs.
3
HOW IS THE KYC INFORMATION COLLECTED?
Through initial face-to-face conversations with a client, the information gathered is recorded on an account application
form, typically referred to as a “New Account Application Form” or, NAAF, for short.
It sets out the minimum information an advisor or financial planner must collect from a prospective client, but a firm may
request additional information on its NAAF depending on the type of business and services it offers.
4
HOW IS THE KYC INFORMATION COLLECTED?
Client information that must be recorded on the NAAF can be grouped into four distinct sections, namely
• Personal Information
• Financial Information
• Investment Objectives
• Other Information, including Date and Signature
5
KYC REVIEWS AND SUITABILITY
In order to make certain that the client's records are up to date and that client’s investment goals continue to
be met, regulations require that the KYC information for an existing client must be reviewed and any changes
updated periodically.
6
HOW OFTEN AND WHEN SHOULD KYC
INFORMATION BE REVIEWED?
Some firms send annual letters to their clients reminding them to let the firm know if there have been any changes that
would require an update to their KYC information. It is good business practice, however, that salespersons touch base
with their clients on a more regular basis. This not only forges a good bond between the client and salesperson
relationship, but also it affords an opportunity to catch up with the client and alerts the salesperson to any changing
conditions that may affect the client’s existing financial situation and investment needs as he/she moves through life.
7
HOW OFTEN AND WHEN SHOULD KYC
INFORMATION BE REVIEWED?
Did the client lose his/her job? Receive a promotion? Are they expecting an addition to the family? Are they
planning to move? The answers to these and other questions will no doubt prompt changes to the KYC
information and perhaps change the focus of some of the investment plans altogether. It can affect their income,
liquidity concerns or even their risk tolerance in any given account.
8
HOW OFTEN AND WHEN SHOULD KYC
INFORMATION BE REVIEWED?
A client’s written authorization must be obtained for any material changes, including the client’s name, address or banking
information and supporting documents must likewise be provided for the file. Any notifications of changes required to a client’s KYC
information must be based on the written approval of the client.
The firm, moreover, “must restrict access of registered representatives and other persons to its electronic systems for maintaining
KYC information so that material information cannot be changed without the required approval”. 4 Evidence of annual KYC reviews
should also be recorded in the client’s files.
9
HOW OFTEN AND WHEN SHOULD KYC
INFORMATION BE REVIEWED?
KYC information should also be reviewed whenever there is a change of advisor. The new advisor must verify
the account information to ensure it is current.
10
THE IMPORTANCE OF UPDATING KYC
Updating KYC is important as this information is used in compliance suitability reviews. What this means is
that any subsequent trading proposed for a client's account is closely reviewed against the information the
client provided.
If the proposed trade (purchase or sale, for example) is in keeping with the client's documented KYC
information and investment goals, then the trade will be deemed suitable. If, however, the proposed trading
activity contains elements which conflict with the information gathered from the client, then, at minimum,
more information is required from the salesperson and client before the trade is placed, if at all.
11
THE IMPORTANCE OF UPDATING KYC
For example, a compliance reviewer should question and make notes with respect to the suitability of a PAC
of $1,000 per month if the client's annual income is only $25,000. In this circumstance, the salesperson and
client should re-evaluate and reconsider the appropriateness of the trade. Can a more suitable solution be
considered?
12
THE IMPORTANCE OF RECORD KEEPING
All salespersons and their firms will be subjected to audits from time to time. These can be as informal as in-
house audits whereby compliance staff will perform daily or periodic reviews of client files and trading
activity to more formal audits whereby regulators or the firm’s auditors will review the firm’s books and
records and test for compliance with the rules and regulations governing their business.
13
THE IMPORTANCE OF RECORDKEEPING
Records must properly reflect the firm’s business transactions and financial affairs. Records that must be maintained and/or
produced include the following categories:
• accounting (for both the firm’s own operation as well as the client trust accounts)
• trading and sales compliance records (client files, including new account applications and subsequent trading instructions, for
example)
• data entry and output systems (back office systems which contain client data)
• communications to clients (including any marketing materials and client statements)
• client complaints (a client complaints file and log must be maintained even if no complaints are ever received)
14
WHAT RECORDS MUST BE KEPT?
The following are some (but not all) of the items of information required to be maintained by the applicable provincial securities
legislation as per IIROC’s Dealer Member Rule 200:
• Blotters (or other original entry records) containing an itemized daily record of
• all purchases and sales of securities
• all receipts and deliveries of securities (including certificate numbers)
• all trades in commodity futures contracts and commodity futures contract
• options
• all receipts and disbursements of cash, and
• all other debits and credits
15
BY WHAT MEANS ARE RECORDS KEPT
The information may be kept by means of mechanical, electronic or other devices where such method of
record keeping is not prohibited under applicable securities legislation and where appropriate internal
controls are in place to guard against the risk of falsification of information contained in the records and
where the information is available in an intelligible and accurate form within a reasonable period of time.
16
BY WHAT MEANS ARE RECORDS KEPT
Confidentiality
As per privacy regulations and IIROC’s Dealer Member Rule 2400, all KYC and client information and other
records must be kept confidential. Besides holding information about a client confidential, the firm must “not
disclose the information to representatives, employees or agents of another financial services entity located
in the same premises, except as expressly permitted or required by law or the Rules”.
17
HANDLING CLIENT COMPLAINTS: IDENTIFYING,
MONITORING AND RESOLUTION
Maintaining investor confidence in that the salesperson and firm they are dealing with abide by fair
standards of business conduct and ethics is important in fostering an honest, efficient and healthy
marketplace.
18
WHAT IS A COMPLAINT?
A “complaint” is defined by the regulators as any written statement of a client or any person acting on behalf
of a client alleging a grievance involving the conduct, business or affairs of the dealer or any representative
of the dealer.
19
IDENTIFYING A COMPLAINT?
Much can be learned even if the complaint is not a breach of rules but is rather administrative or service
oriented
Typical complaints that may fall in this category can include:
• complaints of errors that are administrative in nature (i.e. incorrect spelling of name on account)
• complaints of poor performance in an investment portfolio (caused by stock market downturn and
economic conditions)
• poor customer service (including little attention given to a client by his/her advisor or administrative staff)
20
IDENTIFYING A COMPLAINT?
Serious complaints, or those involving a breach of the rules or the law, can include:
• complaints of value losses in an investment portfolio (caused by other than market volatility). For example,
losses incurred as a result of theft or misconduct
• suitability issues: whereby an advisor or firm sells a product that is not suitable for an investor’s
investment objectives or risk tolerance
• unauthorized transactions: performing investment transactions without client approval
21
IDENTIFYING A COMPLAINT?
Serious complaints, or those involving a breach of the rules or the law, can include:
• encouraging excessive transactions (churning). For example, purchases, sales and transfers made with the
sole purpose of garnering additional sales commissions
• misrepresentation: making false representations about an investment
• Other allegations of misconduct, including confidentiality breaches, fraud, misappropriation or misuse of
funds or securities, forgery, other inappropriate financial dealings with clients and engaging in securities-
related activity outside of the firm
22
DOCUMENTING A COMPLAINT
While most firms will have a standardized form available for ensuring that all the necessary details are
gathered, the record for each complaint should include, at minimum, the following information:
• The date and time the complaint was received by the complainant
• The complainant’s name and account number (if applicable)
• The name of the person who is the subject of the complaint
• The security or services which are the subject of the complaint and a brief description of the nature of the
complaint
23
DOCUMENTING A COMPLAINT
While most firms will have a standardized form available for ensuring that all the necessary details are
gathered, the record for each complaint should include, at minimum, the following information:
24
HOW MUST A COMPLAINT BE HANDLED
Once a complaint has been identified and documented, it needs to be acknowledged, investigated, tracked,
responded to and resolved.
25
PROVIDING A FINAL RESPONSE AND COMPLAINT RESOLUTION
Once a complaint is resolved, the firm will send a letter to the client which
identifies the error and explains how it was resolved. According to IIROC rules, firms
are required to notify clients of the results of their investigation within a reasonable
period of time.
26
HUMAN BEHAVIOUR & PRACTICE
MANAGEMENT
FIN 5561
LIFE STAGES
PROF. TY SOO
COPYRIGHT © 2024 TY SOO ALL RIGHTS
RESERVED
NO PART OFTHIS PUBLICATION MAY BE
REPRODUCED, STORED IN AN RETRIEVAL
SYSTEM, TRANSMITTED OR USED IN ANY
FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION
FROM THE AUTHOR/PUBLISHER
Copyright
At this stage, examples of questions a planner may ask of his or her client include:
Have you given thought to what age you would like to retire? Tell me about it.
At this stage, what are your financial goals and objectives? How would you prioritize
them?
Are there circumstances in your life that could delay or jeopardize your retirement
plans?
Describe your current financial situation. Have you completed a net worth statementto
determine your assets and liabilities and to get a snapshot of where you stand?
Have you begun saving for retirement? If so, how are you doing this? If not, what
obstacles are preventing you from doing so.
Do you have credit card debt or personal lines of
credit that could be consolidated to
reduce your monthly debt payments? Do you have
a plan of action to eliminate any
non-constructive debt?
PROF. TY SOO
COPYRIGHT © 2024 TY SOO ALL RIGHTS
RESERVED
NO PART OFTHIS PUBLICATION MAY BE
REPRODUCED, STORED IN AN RETRIEVAL
SYSTEM, TRANSMITTED OR USED IN ANY
FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION
FROM THE AUTHOR/PUBLISHER
Copyright
PORTFOLIO
MODELS &
DASHBOARDS
PROF. TY SOO
1
Portfolio Models and Dashboards
Portfolio Models
• Approach to organizing, analyzing assets,
investments or projects.
2
Types:
• Financial Portfolio Model-Finance
Diversifying investments across different asset
classes(stocks, bonds, real estate etc) to
achieve balance between risk and return.
7
Integration of Portfolio Models and
Dashboard
10
Risk Management: Portfolio models assist in
assessing and managing risks associated with
investments or projects, while dashboards
highlight risk metrics for ongoing monitoring.
11
Tools and Technologies:
Various toolsand technologies are available for
creating portfolio models and dashboards
including Microsoft Excel, Tableau, PowerBI, and
other specialized software based on the specific
needs of the user.
Professor Ty Soo
• Creating an Effective Marketing
Plan
6)Marketing strategy:
Creating, communicating & delivering
Value to target market
7)Marketing program
• Product
• Pricing
• Place(Channels and distribution)
• Promotion
• Services
8)Financial plans:
• Expected sales revenues and profits
• Projected budgets
• Projected costs
• 5yr term
9)Implementation:
• How implemented
• Plan of activities
10) Evaluation
• Metrics for performance measurement
• Show how and when to make adjustments to
Keep plan on track
HUMAN BEHAVIOUR & PRACTICE
MANAGEMENT
FIN 5561
SEGMENTATION, VALUE ADDED &
CUSTOMER CENTRIC
PROF. TY SOO
COPYRIGHT © 2024 TY SOO ALL RIGHTS
RESERVED
COPYRIGHT © 2023 McGRAWHILL ALL
RIGHTS RESERVED
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED . NO PART OF THIS
PUBLICATION MAY BE REPRODUCED,
STORED IN AN RETRIEVAL SYSTEM,
TRANSMITTED OR USED IN ANY FORM
WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE
AUTHOR/PUBLISHER.
Segmentation, Targeting, & Positioning
Consistent with
mission
statement
Derived from
mission &
current state
Self-concept
Lifestyles
Description information
• Experiment with
• Appreciate
historical
• Dislike ambiguity
• Not looking to
• Active consumers
• Favour prestige
confidence, future perspective change society products, conscious
of Vals oriented
• Problem-solvers
• Act in accordance
with what’s right
• Predictable, loyal
consumers
of peers
• Embrace
• Active consumers, • Not influenced by • Choose familiar technology with
cultivated tastes latest trends products, productivity
established brands benefits
It is just as easy to identify Thinkers (left) as it is Makers (right). A person is given the VALS™ questionnaire, and the
VALS™ program at SRIC-BI runs the answers through the computer for scoring to determine the VALS™ type.
Benefits
Behavioural
Occasio Usage
Segmentati
n Rate
on
Loyalty
unique?
Does each
segment require
a unique
marketing mix?
Customers must:
React positively to firm’s offering
Move toward the firm’s
products/services
Accept the firm’s value proposition
Undifferentiated/
Mass the product or service
is perceived to provide the
same benefits to everyone,
there simply is no need to
develop separate strategies for
different groups.
Differentiated
Targeting target
several market
segments with a different
offering for each
Micromarketin
g (one-to-
one)a form of
segmentation that
tailors a product or
service to suit an
individual
customer’s wants
or needs.
Build-A-Bear lets customers design their own stuffed furry friend
with unique clothes, accessories, sounds, and the name printed
on its birth certificate.
Positioning Methods
Value
Product attributes
Benefits & symbolism
Competition
Market leadership
KIND and PowerBar both offer their respective target markets a good value. KIND bars (left)
are made with natural ingredients, all of which are pronounceable, thus supporting a healthy
lifestyle. PowerBars (right) are protein bars designed to improve the performance of athletes.
Product Attributes
Emphasizes the
benefits of the
brand as well as
the psychological
meaning of the
brand to
consumers.
SoCIAL LITE Vodka targets Gen Z men and women and is positioned on
functional benefits: great taste, all natural, 80 calories, and no sugar.
Competition
Powerade (left) and Gatorade (right) are positioned similarly and compete with
each other for customers who seek healthy, sweet drinks.
Copyright 2023 McGraw Hill Limited
Value –Added
Value –added is the difference between the
price of a product or service and the cost of
producing it.
Source:Investopedia
HUMAN BEHAVIOUR & PRACTICE
MANAGEMENT
FIN 5561
STAGES OF CHANGE
PROF. TY SOO
COPYRIGHT © 2024 TY SOO ALL RIGHTS
RESERVED. NO PART OF THIS PUBLICATION
MAY BE REPRODUCED, STORED IN AN
RETRIEVAL SYSTEM, TRANSMITTED OR
USED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN
PERMISSION FROM THE
AUTHOR/PUBLISHER.
Statement of change model
PROF. TY SOO
COPYRIGHT©2024 TY SOO ALL RIGHTS
RESERVED
An example of a SWOT analysis for a financial
planning /wealth management company :
Strengths:
4) Difficult Highly
Competitive/Low Cost
Environment: The financial
planning/wealth management
company will be competing with
low cost robo advisor companies,
low cost discount brokerages.
Opportunities:
1) Digital Transformation: The
introduction of new technology into
the financial industry allow more
convenient ways to reach the
clients . E.g.online webinars and
zoom meetings with clients.
2) Economic conditions: If
economic conditions improve,
investors will be more inclined to
invest more, hence requiring more
services from wealth management
and financial planning companies.
3) Government intervention:
Utilising monetary policy, central
banks can decrease interest rates
which in turn will dercrease the cost
of borrowing. More money will now
be going to the companies’ bottom
line e.g. profits. Investors will now
be motivated to invest
PROF. TY SOO
Copyright
Behavioural finance is a sub-field of behavioural economics that uses insights from the fields of psychology, sociology and
neuroscience to understand how people make investment decisions.
Introduction to Behavioural Finance
The exact origin of behavioural economics is unknown, but to the surprise of many, elements of behavioural economic thinking
date back to the 1700s. Adam Smith, best known for The Wealth of Nations in 1776 which laid the groundwork for classical
economics, also wrote a lesser known book called The Theory of Moral Sentiments in 1759. It is in the lesser known book that
researchers now believe Smith’s ideas presage the emerging field of behavioural economics
Behavioural Finance
Hersh Shefrin Professor of Finance, Santa Clara University Beyond Greed and Fear
Robert Shiller* Professor of Economics, Yale University Animal Spirits Irrational Exuberance
Conventional economics assumes that people make rational choices to maximize self- interest. In many traditional economics
textbooks, the term homo economicus (a.k.a. economic man)is used to portray humans as rational people that seek to
maximize utility as a consumer and profit as a producer. It assumes that "we can calculate the value of different choices we
face, and that we are cognitively unhindered in weighing the ramifications of each potential choice."
Ariely, Dan. Predictably Irrational: The Hidden Forces That Shape Our Decisions. HarperCollinsPublishers, 2008. Page
239.
Conventional Finance vs. Behavioural Finance
In contrast, behavioural economics argues that humans often act irrationally. Behavioural economists argue that traditional
economic models are flawed because they don’t recognize the limited brainpower of humans, the limited time humans have to
make decisions, the fact that humans sometimes lack self- control and the reality that self-interest is not always the primary
motive.
Thaler, Richard H. and Sendhil Mullainathan. "Behavioral Economics". The Concise Encyclopedia of Economics, 2nd
Ed. http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/BehavioralEconomics.html (accessed April 17, 2016)
Conventional Finance vs. Behavioural Finance
As Duke University professor Dan Ariely aptly states in his best-selling book, Predictably Irrational, "wouldn’t economics make
a lot more sense if it were based on how people actually behave, instead of how they should behave?”
Ariely, Dan. Predictably Irrational: The Hidden Forces That Shape Our Decisions. HarperCollinsPublishers, 2008. Pages
238-244.
How We Think
While many errors in human judgement are due to emotion, leading researchers today like Kahneman, Thaler and Ariely, have
discovered that many of them are actually due to the basic wiring of our brains. "Our irrational behaviours are neither random
nor senseless – they are systematic and predictable."10
Ariely, Dan. Predictably Irrational: The Hidden Forces That Shape Our Decisions. HarperCollinsPublishers, 2008. Page
239.
How We Think
Kahneman and Thaler refer to the workings of the human brain and the way we think by describing the two cognitive systems
we all have.11 12
The terms they use are artificial, meaning they are not the biological terms a neuroscientist would use, but they are associated
with the central limbic system and the prefrontal cortex regions of the brain.
Kahneman, Daniel. Thinking, Fast and Slow. Random House of Canada Limited, 2011. Pages 20-21. 12 Thaler, R. and C.
Sunstein. Nudge: Improving Decisions about Health, Wealth & Happiness. Yale University Press, 2008. Pages 20-21.
How We Think
Fast Instinctive Unconscious Effortless Associative Slow Reflective Conscious Effortful Deductive
http://discovermagazine.com/~../../../../../../../Media/Version21/C10V21/Images/Issues/
2015/nov/brain-chart.jpg (accessed April 27, 2016)
How We Think
The activities of the Automatic System (System 1) are associated with the oldest parts of our brain. Think of it as the part of
your brain that leads to gut reactions. "Americans have an Automatic System reaction to a temperature given in Fahrenheit but
have to use their Reflective System (System 2) to process a temperature given in Celsius.”
Thaler, R. and C. Sunstein. Nudge: Improving Decisions about Health, Wealth & Happiness. Yale University Press,
2008. Pages 20-21.
How We Think
For Canadians, the opposite is true. Likewise, a person whose first language is English will struggle to speak French using their
Reflective System, and vice-versa. The vast majority of our thought processes are System 1 responses and they have been
refined by learning and practice.
How We Think
The field of psychology has come to understand that errors in judgement occur due to the interplay between the Automatic
System and Reflective System in our brains. So despite the fact that humankind can be smart enough to put a man on the
moon, we can sometimes be fooled by seemingly simple problems.
In the popular book, Nudge, Thaler and Sunstein use the following test as an example. Go ahead answer the three questions in
the next three slides, give it a try!
Thaler, R. and C. Sunstein. Nudge: Improving Decisions about Health, Wealth & Happiness. Yale University Press,
2008. Pages 20-21.
How We Think
For each of the 3 questions, write down the first answer that comes to your mind.
1. A bat and ball cost $1.10 in total. The bat costs $1.00 more than the ball.
How much does the ball cost? _____ cents.
Thaler, R. and C. Sunstein. Nudge: Improving Decisions about Health, Wealth & Happiness. Yale University Press,
2008. Pages 20-21.
How We Think
For each of the 3 questions, write down the first answer that comes to your mind.
1. A bat and ball cost $1.10 in total. The bat costs $1.00 more than the ball.
How much does the ball cost?
Thaler, R. and C. Sunstein. Nudge: Improving Decisions about Health, Wealth & Happiness. Yale University Press,
2008. Pages 20-21.
How We Think
For each of the 3 questions, write down the first answer that comes to your mind.
2. If it takes 5 machines 5 minutes to make 5 widgets, how long would it take 100 machines to make 100 widgets?
Thaler, R. and C. Sunstein. Nudge: Improving Decisions about Health, Wealth & Happiness. Yale University Press,
2008. Pages 20-21.
How We Think
For each of the 3 questions, write down the first answer that comes to your mind.
3. In a lake, there is a patch of lily pads. Every day, the patch doubles in size. If it takes 48 days for the patch to cover the
entire lake, how long would it take for the patch to cover half the lake? _____ days.
Thaler, R. and C. Sunstein. Nudge: Improving Decisions about Health, Wealth & Happiness. Yale University Press,
2008. Pages 20-21.
How We Think
For each of the 3 questions, write down the first answer that comes to your mind.
3. In a lake, there is a patch of lily pads. Every day, the patch doubles in size. If it takes 48 days for the patch to cover the
entire lake, how long would it take for the patch to cover half the lake?
Thaler, R. and C. Sunstein. Nudge: Improving Decisions about Health, Wealth & Happiness. Yale University Press,
2008. Pages 20-21.
Heuristics and Biases
As humans, we use rules of thumb, or mental shortcuts, to help us. However, these mental shortcuts, known as heuristics, can
fail to produce a correct judgement and lead to cognitive and emotional biases. A cognitive bias is a systematic error in thinking
due to inferences or predisposed beliefs that affects the decisions we make. An emotional bias is a decision-making error due
to emotional factors. Unfortunately, biases cannot always be avoided if our Reflective System has no clue to the error.
Heuristics Summary Heuristics
Heuristics Summary
Heuristic Description Problem for Investors
A mental shortcut that helps us make a If investors base their trading decision upon a
Anchoring decision by using an initial value that readily purchase price or a high price then they could
comes to mind. continue holding a falling investment.
It is a subjective estimate of probability based
A mental shortcut that helps us make a
on how "top of mind" an event is. Can lead to
Availability (Recency) decision based on how easy it is to bring
serious risk assessment errors as a result of
something to mind.
fear.
The problem arises when applying long-term
A mental shortcut that helps us make a
theory over a very short-term time horizon.
decision by comparing information to our pre-
This could make investors optimistic about past
Representativeness (Similarity) conceived ideas or stereotypes. For example,
winners even though they are overvalued and
"a recent winner must continue to be a
pessimistic about past losers even though they
winner."
are undervalued.
Investors can let their likes and dislikes
A mental shortcut in which people rely on "gut determine their beliefs about investments.
Affect (Attitudes) feelings" instead of considering risks and However, your emotional attitude can change
benefits independently (relying on facts). over time and this changes perceptions of risks
and benefits.
Common Anchors in Financial Planning
Anchor Consideration(s)
Set aside 3 months’ pay in an Emergency Fund Instead of anchoring to this, consideration should be given to income
characteristics (salary vs. commission, seasonality), job stability, health
issues, marital status, dependents, homeowner status etc.
This does not inform how much someone would need to save in order to
Save 3% of every paycheque
reach a financial goal in retirement.
Leaves clients vulnerable to insufficient savings in retirement. The
Plan for 70% of pre- retirement gross earnings expense-based approach of pricing desired retirement lifestyle should
be used instead.
These are the bank’s ratios to approve loans. However, clients should
GDS and TDS ratios of 32% and 40% respectively avoid anchoring to them, especially if they do not belong to a pension
plan or have dependents.
Behavioural Biases
Anchoring and adjustment Availability bias Conservatism bias Confirmation bias Affinity bias Disposition effect
Sources: Refer to p. 17 of Retirement Planning textbook for sources and references noted above.
Summary of Cognitive Biases and Potential Remedies
Sources: Refer to p. 17 of Retirement Planning textbook for sources and references noted above.
Summary of Emotional Biases and Potential Remedies
Sources: Refer to p. 17 of Retirement Planning textbook for sources and references noted above.
Summary of Emotional Biases and Potential Remedies
Loss aversion bias, where people try to prevent losses more than they try to make gains deserves special mention. One of the
key concepts of behavioural finance is what Kahenman and Tversky called Prospect Theory in 1979. The theory examines how
people maximize value (utility) in choosing among alternatives that carry risk. They studied how people respond to the prospect
of loss, an issue explored by Harry Markowitz in the 1950s and Daniel Bernoulli in the 1700s, by surveying responses to the
series of problems below.
Source: Kahneman, D. and A. Tversky. "Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision under Risk," Econometrica 47-2.
Mar. 1979. Page 279.
Prospect Theory and Loss Aversion Bias
At this point, it is appropriate to recognize, as Hersh Shefrin points out in his book Beyond Greed and Fear, that "one investor’s
mistakes can become another investor’s profits. But one investor’s mistakes can also become another investor’s risk." he is
referring to here is that the collective actions of individual investors can lead to Shefrin, H. Beyond Greed and
Fear: Understanding Behavioral Finance and the Psychology of Investing. Oxford, 2002. Page 4.
Implications for Financial Markets
What Shefrin is referring to here is that the collective actions of individual investors can lead to market irrationality.
Robert Shiller, another Nobel-prize winning behavioural economist, emphasizes the factor of overconfidence at a macro-level.
His work is nicely summarized in his book called Animal Spirits.
Akerlof, G. and Shiller, R. Animal Spirits: How Human Psychology Drives the Economy. Princeton University Press,
2009.
s that the collective actions of individual investors can
Implications for Financial Markets
Unlike Kahneman, Robert Shiller’s work largely focuses on the macro-side of behavioural finance. He was one of very few
economists that predicted significant problems with real estate prices in the lead up to the 2006-2007 U.S. credit crisis and
global financial crisis that followed.
Akerlof, G. and Shiller, R. Animal Spirits: How Human Psychology Drives the Economy. Princeton University Press,
2009.
s that the collective actions of individual investors can
Herding
Humans are pack animals by nature and this makes it hard to be a contrarian. Herd behaviour (the bandwagon effect) is all
about relying on the simple observation of others to acquire information. I recall someone warning me long ago that "when your
cab driver asks you about a specific stock to take it as a sign that the market as a whole is becoming irrational." This was
particularly evident during the dot-com bubble in the 1990s and the credit crisis of 2007. In Canada, at an individual stock level,
names like Bre-X and Nortel are often associated with herd behaviour.
Personality Types and Investing Success
Myth: People’s risk tolerance is variable and changes when markets rise and fall.
Reality: Risk tolerance is typically set by early childhood and it decreases only slightly with age, though major life events can
change it.
Myth: A person’s appetite for risk is the same across all aspects of their life.
Reality: Just because a person likes to take physical risks does not mean they like financial risks or other sorts of risk.
Myth: Risk tolerance will determine asset allocation within an investor’s portfolio.
Reality: A risk tolerance assessment should tell the adviser the risk an individual is prepared to take in their financial affairs. But
it is the risk profiling process that provides a proven methodology to ensure the suitability of investment advice.
Myth: Financial advisers can accurately estimate their client’s risk tolerance
Reality: Strong evidence of gender stereotyping exists. Advisers also assign too much weight to demographic variables like
income, wealth and marital status.
Myth: Risk tolerance will determine asset allocation within an investor’s portfolio.
Reality: A risk tolerance assessment should tell the adviser the risk an individual is prepared to take in their financial affairs. But
it is the risk profiling process that provides a proven methodology to ensure the suitability of investment advice.
Myth: Financial advisers can accurately estimate their client’s risk tolerance
Reality: Strong evidence of gender stereotyping exists. Advisers also assign too much weight to demographic variables like
income, wealth and marital status.
Myth: Questions on time horizon of the investment, investor’s age and when the investor will retire are relevant to
determine an investor’s risk tolerance.
Reality: While these are important aspects of knowing your client, they are separate factors to a person’s risk tolerance.
Although, time horizon, for example, might be relevant to the measurement of risk capacity or risk required, it is not relevant to
risk tolerance, which is an enduring psychological trait.
When educating clients on the biases covered in this report, and when attempting to remedy them, be sure that you criticize the
behaviour and not the person. Also, be realistic in the success of the behaviour modification strategy as emotional biases are
very difficult to correct.
Client engagement skills are all about connecting and communicating with your clients at the human level.
This is the person to person connection that drives trust, confidence and belief. Engagement skills are arguably the most
difficult but the most important skills to learn in becoming a trusted advisor and building a practice.
Because human beings are endlessly complex, no one approach, or skill will work in all instances. Humans are not only
complex, but, they can change their ideas, and motivations from meeting to meeting and even within the same conversation.
Client Engagement Skills
Client engagement skills are about mastering a set of behaviours and relationship building skills that put your customers first
and identifies you as a trusted business partner, not just as another supplier.
It means consciously thinking about your client’s experience at every touch point. Most people who have direct client contact
are often too eager to tell clients about their products, services or solution.
In taking this approach, they position themselves on the opposite side of the table; your clients sense it, understand it, know it,
and reject it.
Client Engagement Skills
As a Registered Retirement Consultant (RRC/CR), the importance of engagement skills in attracting and perhaps, more
importantly, retaining clients is often understated particularly when compared to the more tangible requirements for hard skills
such as product knowledge, educational proficiencies and technical skills.
Client Engagement Skills
Without minimizing the importance of hard skills - clearly, you must be technically competent - the reality is that it is the
engagement skills demonstrated by you that builds a trusting, enduring relationship with your clients. An RRC/CR who has
strong engagement skills will have the ability to look for clues in a client’s body language, voice, word choice and demeanor so
that appropriate questions can be asked, and a relationship built.
By comparison, hard skills are usually related to professional knowledge, tools or techniques that allow us to work within our
profession.
Personal Style
Each person is a very special and unique individual. We have our habits, our culture, our education, our ethics and manners.
And, we have a personal style, or personality or temperament. We bring our entire self to each interaction and environment we
encounter each day.
This includes work and the interactions with our clients. To be optimally effective and professional it is imperative that we
understand how we act, react and interact with the world. What makes us tick? What are our hot buttons or frustrations? How
do we prefer to communicate and listen?
Personal Style and Colours
Hippocrates was perhaps the first to reference colour with his four humours. Over the years there have been numerous
systems that have carried on with this approach and attached a colour label to a particular personality. The table below (next
slide) reviews a sampling of those systems and how they relate to Personality Lingo
Personal Style and Colours
The most popular letter systems for Temperament identification are the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator and the Keirsey systems.
The chart below shows how Myers-Briggs ad Keirsey relate to Personality Lingo:
Personality
Connector Thinker Planner Mover
Lingo®
ENFJ, INFJ ENFP, ENTJ, INTJ ENTP, ESTJ, ISTJ ESFJ, ESFP, ISFP ESTP,
Myers – Briggs
INFP INTP ISFJ ISTP
Keirsey
NF NT SJ SP
Temperament
Personal Style and Word Descriptor Systems
Diet Styles Diet Feeler Diet Thinker Diet Planner Diet Player
Character Champions Blue Dolphin Green Owl Gold Ant Orange Wolf
Who are you?
So where do you fit? What is your personal style? This is important as who we are on the personality level greatly impacts
everything we do. Engagement skills, communication, sales, leadership, learning, stress management, conflict resolution and
more are all influenced by who we are. This is how we act, react and interact with the world around us.
Let’s start with Introvert or Extrovert. Many people erroneously believe that introversion means you are shy whereas
extroversion means you are not. Both Introverts and Extroverts can be shy. Shyness is the fear of social judgement and can be
experienced by either introverts or extroverts.
Who are you? Introvert or Extrovert?
A basic definition for Introverts is that they gather or restore their energy from their internal world of thoughts, ideas and
reflections and Extroverts rejuvenate or gather their energy from the outside world of people activities and their environment.
Who are you? Introvert or Extrovert?
People with a preference for Extroversion tend to express their most dominant personality traits outward. Determining the
personality style of someone who is extroverted is usually quite straightforward – what you see, is what you get!
Introverts on the other hand tend to use their primary personality style to process internally. They may communicate outwardly
and behave in manners that are associated with their secondary style. Therefore, extra attention needs to be paid when
identifying the personality style of Introverts.
Who are you? Introvert or Extrovert?
People with a preference for Extroversion tend to express their most dominant personality traits outward. Determining the
personality style of someone who is extroverted is usually quite straightforward – what you see, is what you get!
Introverts on the other hand tend to use their primary personality style to process internally. They may communicate outwardly
and behave in manners that are associated with their secondary style. Therefore, extra attention needs to be paid when
identifying the personality style of Introverts.
Who are you? Introvert or Extrovert?
Our personalities are a very important and critical component of who we are, how we respond, how we communicate, how we
relate and how we process information.
This is foundational to learning and using excellent engagement skills to build both personal and professional relationships.
As you will learn later in this unit, your personality greatly influences how and what you verbalize and hear.
The Importance of Personality Style
You could be clearly communicating your message and be completely misunderstood! How? Easily – you speak your own
language and use words based on your personality.
You hear what other people say through your ears which filter messages through your own language based on your
personality.
Playful, high energy, easily bored, loves freedom and new ideas. Creative, great negotiators, always up for an adventure.
Loves novelty and being on the leading edge, lives in the moment.
•Strengths: embrace change, think outside of the box, love a challenge, high energy, playful and fun, very gregarious.
Mover Visual communicator.
•Challenges: easily bored, short attention span, frustrated by status quo, don’t always think before speaking.
•Communication Tips
•If you are a Mover: don’t interrupt, focus on the speaker, tone down the volume, limit wordiness and conversation
•Speaking to a Mover: Tell "people" stories, give colourful details, give attention, don’t tune out.
Logical, analytical, naturally curious, love knowledge and learning, perpetual learner. Able to easy conceptualize, reserved,
appreciate being given the time to think and process. Live in the future.
• Strengths: very knowledgeable, independent and able to work alone, reserved and proper, analytical and innovative.
Frequently ask, "Why?"
•Challenges: may come across as a "know-it-all" or arrogant, fact based rather than emotionally sensitive, very demanding
Thinker of themselves and others.
•Communication Tips
•If you are a Thinker: practise saying "please" and "thank-you". Focus on the person not the project. Practise active
listening, read to the end of the letter.
•Speaking to a Thinker: Use bullet points, not small details or stories. Give the bottom line first, give additional details only
if asked, ask questions, expect the "why" statement.
Overview of your Personality Style
Supportive, kind, positive, crave connection to others. Great imagination with love of the arts, a real people person, very collaborative and a natural mediator. Lead with their
heart and easily identify and relate to the emotional state of others. Seek personal growth and meaning
•Strengths: open and accepting, love to communicate, very cooperative, natural mediators, caring and compassionate, creative and empathetic. Soft spoken.
•Challenges: extremely sensitive, lead with their heart, often supress their own needs and wants, tentative in communicating their needs.
Connector
•Communication tips:
•If you are a Connector: express your opinion, share ideas, practise making and expressing choices, speak more quickly and boldly.
•Speaking to a Connector: show respect and look for the positive, freely give praise, give focused attention, wait to speak until they are completely finished, give a few choices.
Overview of your Personality Style
Conscientious and dependable, reliable, organized, makers of lists. Know and follow the rules, guidelines and legislation. Steadfast, goal driven, believe in right
and wrong. Strong sense of duty and commitment to the job at hand.
• Strengths: organized, productive, prepared, value citizenship, community service. Follow directions, follow through on tasks, hard working, loyal and
responsible.
Challenges: need to have a plan and clear instructions or directions, resist imposed change, puts others on an agenda, not tolerant of casual time management
Planner or being surprised. Communication tips:
•If you are a Planner: don’t overwhelm others with details, give praise when due, celebrate incremental improvements, adjust your expectations, appreciate
contributions of others.
•Speaking to a Planner: first ask if it is a good time to talk, respect their time/space/silence. Give factual and orderly details. Be prepared – think through what
you will say. Wait for their response.
The Mover
Clothing: often bright and/or intense colours, trendy threads, beads and sparkles, colourful ties often with graphics, fun
socks, novelty sweaters that tell a story.
Activity: high energy, constant movement, big gestures and movements, often touches others – clap on the back, fist
bump, tap on the shoulder. Can forget to respect the personal space of others.
What you see
Focus: very impetuous, easily distracted "squirrel!", tends to what is right in front of them, irreverent humour!
Emotions: highly charged and changeable. Emotions are not hidden, happy is elation, sad is devastating and responses are
based on the current state of emotion. May have several changes from high to low in a short span of time.
Volume: usually quite loud and easily heard across the room. Often have a very loud and distinctive laugh. Even whispers
carry quite far.
Language: not afraid to make up their own words or use slang. May use edgy and just barely appropriate language, jokes,
What you hear metaphors and fun terminology.
General: love to tell stories to make a point or just entertain. Very visual and graphic with a wide eyed "who me?"
innocence of expression. Speak very quickly with great excitement and can quickly change the subject as they can be
easily distracted.
• Personal work space can be quite chaotic. May appear to be disorganized but they will know where everything is.
Environmental Engage in high energy activities and possibly extreme sports. Love to challenge themselves and then tell a great story
Clues about their adventures.
Always open to new ideas, adventures or products. Rely on the research and opinions of others.
The Thinker
Clothing: often wears the strong power colours – black, red, navy blue, royal blue. Power clothing such as jacket and
slacks, logoed clothing, not usually seen wearing ultra casual such as baggy jogging pants and sweatshirts. Conservative
jewellery.
Activity: quick and active with purposeful movements. Each action has a reason. Able to be completely still, alert and
What you see watchful.
Focus: very decisive and direct. Always alert and watchful, easily takes charge of a conversation or situation. Focussed eye
contact.
Emotions: not readily apparent. Operates from logic rather than emotion. Emotional layer is very deep and when they rise
to the surface are expressed very strongly. Intolerant of sloppy work and mistakes and easily angered.
Volume: not necessarily loud but strong and direct. Will speak over others without raising their voice. Genuine laughter is
of moderate volume.
Language: use technical language and correct terminology. Knows how to spell and pronounce the big words and may use
What you hear
their vocabulary as a weapon rather than a tool. Enjoy utilizing a robust lexicon.
General: Want to know what you know. Asks many questions and will listen appreciatively to the answer. May challenge
your knowledge or assumptions, respects intellectual discourse.
Personal workspace will likely have evidence of several projects on the go at once. Also, research books, models,
prototypes or equipment. Love technology and the access to learning and knowledge that it represents.
Environmental Enjoy doing difficult things. Love the challenge of hard work, technically precise activities and pushing themselves to the
Clues limit while controlling their environment.
Naturally curious and thirsty for knowledge they enjoy solving problems and inventing better ways of doing things.
Prefer to keep their emotions to themselves and are slow to trust.
The Connector
Clothing: prefer comfortable and soft textured clothing. Soft knits, elastic waist, unstructured suits and sweaters. Soft
colours, pastels, browns, blues, greens, earth tones.
Activity: very relaxed and laid back, low energy. Peaceful and calm, even in chaos
What you see
Focus: will focus exclusively on those they are in conversation with. Pay close attention to feelings, language and
environment around them.
Emotions: lead with their heart. Very peaceful and calm, seldom have extremes of emotion. Balanced and rational.
Volume: most often quiet spoken with much feeling in their tone and expressions.
Language: use emotional words such as "I feel ..." very descriptive language, use lots of adjectives
What you hear
General: usually good listeners with strong focus on your words and how you are saying them. Very emotionally
intuitive, can easily pick up your current emotional state.
Have many friends and prefer to be in a group or working as a team. Would rather work with people than things or tools.
Casual about their surroundings unless it comes to comfort items. Work area will have pictures of family and friends and
some fun conversational objects. May have rocks or bottles of sand that have emotional meaning to them
Environmental clues
Wear their hearts on their sleeves and are ready to be glad or sad as the situation requires. Very openly emotional.
Always put the needs of others ahead of themselves. Very cause oriented, people, animals, environment etc.
The Planner
Clothing: the correct clothing for each activity. Tucked in, buttoned up, correct and proper, not necessarily stuffy or stiff.
Activity: very persistent and thorough, need to finish what they start. Likes to organize things and data – uses charts
and graphs.
What you see
Focus: prefer to focus on tasks rather than people. Very artistic and deeply sensitive. Can shut out the world to focus on
a task.
Emotions: very deeply emotional, quiet tears at a beautiful sunset or picture. Keep feelings to themselves but are the
most emotionally sensitive. You just don’t see it.
Volume: quiet-spoken, low tone, unemotional or intense. Very quiet laugh or chuckle. Do not draw attention to
themselves.
What you hear Language: Uses correct and precise language and terminology. Clear expectations and terminology, very articulate.
General: a very clear communicator that may start a conversation in their head and begin orally half way through. Very
organized thoughts and may speak in a "list".
Very tidy, everything in its place. Difficult to replace items when they are still useful. May have "hoarder" tendencies as it
is hard to part with familiar objects.
Works space will be very organized and likely minimalistic – one file or sheet of paper at a time on the desk. Cannot
think or work in clutter
Environment al clues
Work very well alone without supervision. Prefer to be given the job, the expectations, and the deadline and then be left
alone to work.
Like to follow the rules and procedures, most comfortable in a formal environment where everyone knows and follows
the rules.
Communication
Communication is a gift to both the speaker and the receiver. Therefore, is stands to reason that being a solid communicator
will stand a professional in very good stead. Let’s look at what good communication is and isn’t.
Communication
First, communication is not talking. You may have heard the age-old question, "If someone talks in the woods and no-one is
there to hear them, are they communicating?" Talking, is just that, talking.
Communication is the giving and taking of information, ideas, concepts or messages. Without a receiver, communication has
not occurred.
Without a message being sent in a way that the receiver can comprehend and respond to, communication has not happened
well.
How do we ensure that we communicate in the most effective way we can? The following ideas, techniques and instructions
will assist with that.
Communication
Communication consists of good speaking skills and solid listening skills, coupled with respecting and understanding how best
to communicate with the person’s individual style.
Attending skills are primarily physical behaviours that let other people know that you are focusing on them.
The SOLAR model stands for Square position, Open posture, Leaning in, Asking open questions, and Reflecting back what you
have believed you have heard.
This is an easy to remember and apply – once learned – process that will allow you to maximize your time in the client meeting.
Attending Skills – The SOLAR Model
S - Square position
Squarely face your client, whether across a desk or table, or in facing chairs. This gives the opportunity for direct eye contact
and the most room for expressive movement. It is easy to speak directly and to listen actively when sitting face to face.
Attending Skills – The SOLAR Model
O - Open posture
An open posture is where your hands and arms are relaxed and resting on the table, or desk or on the arms of chairs.
Arms and legs are not crossed, the opposing elbows are not firmly clenched in your hands and your shoulders and neck are relaxed.
For some people the habit of crossing their legs is firmly entrenched. If possible practise crossing legs at the ankles, not the knees as
this can still present an "open" attitude to your client.
Being physically open in your posture allows you to hear what is in the conversation, a closed posture – with crossed arms or legs
indicates defensiveness. Be open, engaging and vulnerable to facilitate relationship building. Open shows listening, closed indicates
decision is made, no longer listening.
Attending Skills – The SOLAR Model
Think about a social environment you may have been in – you lean in when you are engaged, listening, or engrossed in what
you are hearing.
Leaning back gives the appearance of avoidance or superiority. Leaning in shows interest, engagement and openness to the
ideas being expressed.
Attending Skills – The SOLAR Model
Open questions do not have a predefined answer. They allow for the engagement and exploration of ideas and thoughts and
provide a lot of information. A guideline would be questions that begin with how, what, where, why, or when.
For example: "What are some of the elements you consider when making plans for your future?"
An open question gives the respondent full breadth of thought and opinion in their response.
As you listen you may hear information or ideas that will help you in your further exploring for suggestions, solutions or
pathways
Attending Skills – The SOLAR Model
Always double check to ensure that your perception of what you thought you have heard, is indeed what the person believes
they have said.
WHAT? Think about a mirror for words. In some ways we are a mirror to our client’s world. Remember that there are always 2
sides to a conversation.
What the speaker believes they have said, and what the listener believes they have heard.
There are two elements at work here, personality and perception. How we speak and how we perceive the message is
influenced by our personality, in other words our perception of the message.
Soliciting Skills
Soliciting is the art of eliciting information. To solicit is to "obtain by persuasion, entreaty or formal application". We will explore
4 specific communication soliciting skills: closed-ended questions, open-ended questions, declarative probes and prompts .
Soliciting Skills
Closed-ended Questions – or closed questions can be answered with Yes or No or a one or two-word answer.
Example: "Is it raining?" – Yes. "Are you cold?" - No "What is your name?" – Tom Jones. "Where do you live?" – 123
Somewhere Street.
Soliciting Skills
Open-ended Questions – or open questions require a fuller, more informative and robust response. Open questions have
sentences, lists and stories as answers and allow respondents to include more information, including feelings, attitudes and
understanding of the subject. They often start with "How, why, what". Open questions lead to conversation and the sharing of
thoughts, ideas and information.
Example: "What do you imagine your first day of retirement will be like?" – I am going to get up early, make coffee, read the
paper and wave to everyone going by on their way to work. Then I will take my dog for a walk. For lunch …
Declarative Probes – are functionally like open-ended questions but are less interrogative. It is suggested that a declarative
probe is a "polite command". Their use is to get more information, to have the respondent open up and tell more. A declarative
probe is "Tell me more about that please.", "Elaborate a bit for me".
Soliciting Skills
Prompts – are used to gently assist or encourage a hesitating speaker to say something or to continue with what they were
saying. A prompt is used to move the conversation along. Prompts are short one or two-word phrases or non-verbal vocal
noises. Hmmmm, What else? Go on, And then … ?
Example: "My spouse thought I should come to see you" - UmHmmmm" Our brother in law is one of your clients and he seems
to be quite happy with the results of his portfolio" - Go on…"
Effective Reflections
Reflecting meaning is similar to a reflection of verbal content, with the added component of inference.
Sometimes it is necessary to infer what the other person meant or seemed to say but didn’t actually say it directly.
You are intending to infer the meaning of the statement. These inferences which are common in "normal" conversations (where
most people assume but do not verbalize their inferred meaning) need to be reflected back to the client to ensure that our
interpretations of the implied meaning are the correct ones.
Reflecting Affect (Feeling)
Reflecting affect (feeling) is a reflection of the feelings behind a client statement. As with reflections of meaning, reflection of
affect must be done tentatively.
This is one of the most powerful tools that can be used. It helps to defuse negative emotions that may be getting in the way of a
client’s capacity to deal with problem situations.
Acknowledgement of feelings such as anger, fear or frustration is often a first step in resolving a negative situation.
Effective Reflections
There are two major problems in learning how to do effective reflections: recognizing a meaning or emotion and identifying or
labeling it.
We often deal in shades of meaning, and the subtle differences in meaning between two words may be key.
Mini Glossary of Effective Reflections
Kind of feeling …
Sort of saying …
I am picking up that you …
If I am hearing you correctly …
Kind of makes (made) you feel …
What I guess I am hearing is …
Mini Glossary of Effective Reflections
Without structure, conversations and client meetings can become meaningless drifting from topic to topic with little sense of
direction, accomplishment or purpose.
There is a need to manage interviews in a manner that allows clients full opportunity for expressions, and yet still provide a
context for learning, growth and decisions.
Structure provides meaning and maximized opportunity. In this section we will look at three structuring skills: Summaries,
Overviews and Transitions.
Overview Structuring Skills
1. A brief description of how you intend to approach the meeting, interview or issue.
2. Your clients and your expectations should be clarified. Here you explain what is expected from your client and in turn what
your client can expect from you.
Overview Structuring Skills
3. Your client should be given some indication about how much time is likely to be needed and the general structure of how the
meeting will proceed. This includes the length of each meeting and how many meetings will be needed.
4. An agreement to proceed is reached based on the previously mentioned conditions and expectations.
Your Client’s Vision for the Future
Creating a Self Portrait
1.Prepare the client for a self-portrait by doing some preliminary work that includes developing rapport and, as appropriate,
visioning.
2.Identifying specific roles/jobs/activities that the client has engaged in that were particularly satisfying.
3.Identifying the skills, knowledge and attitudes the client used to successfully engage in those satisfying activities.
4.Exploring meaningfulness issues related to the satisfying activities previously explored.
Creating a Self Portrait
5. Identifying additional roles/jobs/activities that the client has engaged in both work and non-work-related.
6.Repeating Steps iii and iv for each activity identified.
7. Following the same process and referring to the client’s vision; identifying activities the client hopes to engage in and needs
to engage in, identifying related skills, knowledge and attitudes, exploring related meaningfulness issues.
Creating a Self Portrait
Interests
Building Horizons: Outcomes vs. Times Frames