Financial
Financial
Financial
Lesson 01
INTRODUCTION TO FINANCIAL ECONOMICS
Financial economics usually involves the creation of sophisticated models to test the variables
affecting a particular decision. Often, these models assume that individuals or institutions making
decisions act rationally, though this is not necessarily the case. The irrational behavior of parties
has to be taken into account in financial economics as a potential risk factor. This branch of
economics builds heavily on microeconomics and basic accounting concepts. It is a quantitative
discipline that uses econometrics as well as other mathematical tools.
Financial decisions:
1. Spread out over time and
2. Usually not known with certainty in advance by either the decision makers or anybody
else.
A financial system is a set of institutions, such as banks, insurance companies, and stock
exchanges that permit the exchange of funds. Financial systems exist on firm, regional, and global
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 1
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
levels. Borrowers, lenders, and investors exchange current funds to finance projects, either for
consumption or productive investments, and to pursue a return on their financial assets. The
financial system also includes sets of rules and practices that borrowers and lenders use to decide
which projects get financed, who finances projects, and terms of financial deals.
The set of markets and other institutions used for financial contracting and the exchange
of assets and risks.
It includes stocks, bonds and other financial instruments; financial intermediaries such as
banks and insurance companies; and regulatory bodies
Multiple components make up the financial system at different levels. The firm's financial system
is the set of implemented procedures that track the financial activities of the company. Within a
firm, the financial system encompasses all aspects of finances, including accounting measures,
revenue and expense schedules, wages, and balance sheet verification.
On a regional scale, the financial system is the system that enables lenders and borrowers to
exchange funds. Regional financial systems include banks and other institutions, such as
securities exchanges and financial clearinghouses.
The global financial system is basically a broader regional system that encompasses all
financial institutions, borrowers, and lenders within the global economy. In a global view, financial
systems include the International Monetary Fund, central banks, government treasuries and
monetary authorities, the World Bank, and major private international banks.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 2
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
There are four main financial decisions- Capital Budgeting or long-term Investment decision
(Application of funds), Capital Structure or Financing decision (Procurement of funds), Dividend
decision (Distribution of funds) and Working Capital Management Decision in order to accomplish
goal of the firm viz., to maximize shareholder’s (owner’s) wealth.
A limited partnership has a single general partner who runs the business and is responsible for
its liabilities, plus any number of limited partners who have limited involvement in the business
and whose losses are limited to the amount of their investment.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 3
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
A corporation is a legal entity that’s separate from the parties who own it, the shareholders who
invest by buying shares of stock. Corporations are governed by a Board of Directors, elected by
the shareholders.
Advantages include: limited liability, easier access to financing, and unlimited life for the
corporation.
Disadvantages include: the agency problem, double taxation, and incorporation expenses and
regulations.
A limited liability company (LLC) is similar to a C-corporation, but it has fewer rules and
restrictions than a C-corporation. For example, an LLC can have any number of members.
A cooperative is a business owned and controlled by those who use its services. Individuals and
firms who belong to the cooperative join together to market products, purchase supplies, and
provide services for its members.
A not-for-profit corporation is an organization formed to serve some public purpose rather than
for financial gain. It enjoys favorable tax treatment.
An acquisition is the purchase of one company by another with no new company being formed.
A hostile takeover occurs when a company is purchased even though the company’s
management and Board of Directors do not want to be acquired.
• Ability to run the business
• For the efficient scale of a business resources are to be pooled
• Diversification of risk is needed to overcome uncertainty
• Saving in the cost of gathering information
• The “learning curve” or “going concern” effect
• Primary goal of a corporate management
• Maximize shareholder wealth
• Maximize shareholder wealth
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 4
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 02
FINANCIAL MARKETS AND INSTITUTIONS
Financial markets refer broadly to any marketplace where the trading of securities occurs,
including the stock market, bond market, forex market, and derivatives market, among others.
Financial markets are vital to the smooth operation of capitalist economies.
Financial markets play a vital role in facilitating the smooth operation of capitalist economies by
allocating resources and creating liquidity for businesses and entrepreneurs. The markets make
it easy for buyers and sellers to trade their financial holdings. Financial markets create securities
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 5
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
products that provide a return for those who have excess funds (Investors/lenders) and make
these funds available to those who need additional money (borrowers).
The stock market is just one type of financial market. Financial markets are made by buying and
selling numerous types of financial instruments including equities, bonds, currencies, and
derivatives. Financial markets rely heavily on informational transparency to ensure that the
markets set prices that are efficient and appropriate. The market prices of securities may not be
indicative of their intrinsic value because of macroeconomic forces like taxes.
Some financial markets are small with little activity, and others, like the New York Stock
Exchange (NYSE), trade trillions of dollars of securities daily. The equities (stock) market is a
financial market that enables investors to buy and sell shares of publicly traded companies. The
primary stock market is where new issues of stocks, called initial public offerings (IPOs), are sold.
Any subsequent trading of stocks occurs in the secondary market, where investors buy and sell
securities that they already own.
The invisible hand is a metaphor for the unseen forces that move the free market economy.
Through individual self-interest and freedom of production and consumption, the best interest of
society, as a whole, are fulfilled. The constant interplay of individual pressures on market supply
and demand causes the natural movement of prices and the flow of trade. The term "invisible
hand" first appeared in Adam Smith's famous work, The Wealth of Nations, to describe how free
markets can incentivize individuals, acting in their own self-interest, to produce what is societally
necessary.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 6
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
TOPIC 008: TYPES OF FINANCIAL MARKETS
Stock Markets
Perhaps the most ubiquitous of financial markets are stock markets. These are venues where
companies list their shares and they are bought and sold by traders and investors. Stock markets,
or equities markets, are used by companies to raise capital via an initial public offering (IPO), with
shares subsequently traded among various buyers and sellers in what is known as a secondary
market.
Stocks may be traded on listed exchanges, such as the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) or
Nasdaq, or else over-the-counter (OTC). Most trading in stocks is done via regulated exchanges,
and these play an important role in the economy as both a gauge of the overall health of the
economy as well as providing capital gains and dividend income to investors, including those with
retirement accounts such as IRAs and 401(k) plans.
Typical participants in a stock market include (both retail and institutional) investors and traders,
as well as market makers (MMs) and specialists who maintain liquidity and provide two-sided
markets. Brokers are third parties that facilitate trades between buyers and sellers but who do not
take an actual position in a stock.
Over-the-Counter Markets
An over-the-counter (OTC) market is a decentralized market—meaning it does not have physical
locations, and trading is conducted electronically—in which market participants trade securities
directly between two parties without a broker. While OTC markets may handle trading in certain
stocks (e.g., smaller or riskier companies that do not meet the listing criteria of exchanges), most
stock trading is done via exchanges. Certain derivatives markets, however, are exclusively OTC,
and so they make up an important segment of the financial markets. Broadly speaking, OTC
markets and the transactions that occur on them are far less regulated, less liquid, and more
opaque.
Bond Markets
A bond is a security in which an investor loans money for a defined period at a pre-established
interest rate. You may think of a bond as an agreement between the lender and borrower that
contains the details of the loan and its payments. Bonds are issued by corporations as well as by
municipalities, states, and sovereign governments to finance projects and operations. The bond
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 7
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
market sells securities such as notes and bills issued by the United States Treasury, for example.
The bond market also is called the debt, credit, or fixed-income market.
Money Markets
Typically the money markets trade in products with highly liquid short-term maturities (of less than
one year) and are characterized by a high degree of safety and a relatively low return in interest.
At the wholesale level, the money markets involve large-volume trades between institutions and
traders. At the retail level, they include money market mutual funds bought by individual investors
and money market accounts opened by bank customers. Individuals may also invest in the money
markets by buying short-term certificates of deposit (CDs), municipal notes, or U.S. Treasury bills,
among other examples.
Derivatives Markets
A derivative is a contract between two or more parties whose value is based on an agreed-upon
underlying financial asset (like a security) or set of assets (like an index). Derivatives are
secondary securities whose value is solely derived from the value of the primary security that they
are linked to. In and of itself a derivative is worthless. Rather than trading stocks directly, a
derivatives market trades in futures and options contracts, and other advanced financial products,
that derive their value from underlying instruments like bonds, commodities, currencies, interest
rates, market indexes, and stocks.
Futures markets
Futures markets are where futures contracts are listed and traded. Unlike forwards, which trade
OTC, futures markets utilize standardized contract specifications, are well-regulated, and utilize
clearinghouses to settle and confirm trades. Options markets, such as the Chicago Board Options
Exchange (CBOE), similarly list and regulate options contracts. Both futures and options
exchanges may list contracts on various asset classes, such as equities, fixed-income securities,
commodities, and so on.
Forex Market
The forex (foreign exchange) market is the market in which participants can buy, sell, hedge, and
speculate on the exchange rates between currency pairs. The forex market is the most liquid
market in the world, as cash is the most liquid of assets. The currency market handles more than
$6.6 trillion in daily transactions, which is more than the futures and equity markets combined.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 8
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
As with the OTC markets, the forex market is also decentralized and consists of a global network
of computers and brokers from around the world. The forex market is made up of banks,
commercial companies, central banks, investment management firms, hedge funds, and retail
forex brokers and investors.
Commodities Markets
Commodities markets are venues where producers and consumers meet to exchange physical
commodities such as agricultural products (e.g., corn, livestock, soybeans), energy products (oil,
gas, carbon credits), precious metals (gold, silver, platinum), or "soft" commodities (such as
cotton, coffee, and sugar). These are known as spot commodity markets, where physical goods
are exchanged for money.
The bulk of trading in these commodities, however, takes place on derivatives markets that utilize
spot commodities as the underlying assets. Forwards, futures, and options on commodities are
exchanged both OTC and on listed exchanges around the world such as the Chicago Mercantile
Exchange (CME) and the Intercontinental Exchange (ICE).
Cryptocurrency Markets
The past several years have seen the introduction and rise of cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin
and Ethereum, decentralized digital assets that are based on blockchain technology. Today,
thousands of cryptocurrency tokens are available and trade globally across a patchwork of
independent online crypto exchanges. These exchanges host digital wallets for traders to swap
one cryptocurrency for another, or for fiat monies such as dollars or euros.
Because the majority of crypto exchanges are centralized platforms, users are susceptible to
hacks or fraud. Decentralized exchanges are also available that operate without any central
authority. These exchanges allow direct peer-to-peer (P2P) trading of digital currencies without
the need for an actual exchange authority to facilitate the transactions. Futures and options
trading are also available on major cryptocurrencies.
Interest rates thus apply to most lending or borrowing transactions. Individuals borrow money to
purchase homes, fund projects, launch or fund businesses, or pay for college tuition. Businesses
take out loans to fund capital projects and expand their operations by purchasing fixed and long-
term assets such as land, buildings, and machinery. Borrowed money is repaid either in a lump
sum by a pre-determined date or in periodic installments.
For loans, the interest rate is applied to the principal, which is the amount of the loan. The interest
rate is the cost of debt for the borrower and the rate of return for the lender. The money to be
repaid is usually more than the borrowed amount since lenders require compensation for the loss
of use of the money during the loan period. The lender could have invested the funds during that
period instead of providing a loan, which would have generated income from the asset. The
difference between the total repayment sum and the original loan is the interest charged.
When the borrower is considered to be low risk by the lender, the borrower will usually be charged
a lower interest rate. If the borrower is considered high risk, the interest rate that they are charged
will be higher, which results in a higher cost loan.
The example above was calculated based on the annual simple interest formula, which is:
Simple interest = Principal X interest rate X time
The individual that took out a loan will have to pay $12,000 in interest at the end of the year,
assuming it was only a one-year lending agreement. If the term of the loan was a 30-year
mortgage, the interest payment will be:
Simple interest = $300,000 X 4% X 30 = $360,000
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 10
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
A simple interest rate of 4% annually translates into an annual interest payment of $12,000.
After 30 years, the borrower would have made $12,000 x 30 years = $360,000 in interest
payments, which explains how banks make their money.
The interest owed when compounding is higher than the interest owed using the simple
interest method. The interest is charged monthly on the principal including accrued interest from
the previous months. For shorter time frames, the calculation of interest will be similar for both
methods. As the lending time increases, however, the disparity between the two types of interest
calculations grows.
Using the example above, at the end of 30 years, the total owed in interest is almost $700,000
on a $300,000 loan with a 4% interest rate.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 11
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 03
INTEREST RATES AND RATES OF RETURN
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 12
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Real Rate of Return (RoR) vs. Nominal Rate of Return (RoR)
The simple rate of return is considered a nominal rate of return since it does not account for the
effect of inflation over time. Inflation reduces the purchasing power of money, and so $335,000
six years from now is not the same as $335,000 today.
Discounting is one way to account for the time value of money. Once the effect of inflation is taken
into account, we call that the real rate of return (or the inflation-adjusted rate of return).
Real Rate of Return (RoR) vs. Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR)
A closely related concept to the simple rate of return is the compound annual growth rate (CAGR).
The CAGR is the mean annual rate of return of an investment over a specified period of time
longer than one year, which means the calculation must factor in growth over multiple periods.
To calculate compound annual growth rate, we divide the value of an investment at the end of the
period in question by its value at the beginning of that period; raise the result to the power of one
divided by the number of holding periods, such as years; and subtract one from the subsequent
result.
Assume, for example, a company is considering the purchase of a new piece of equipment for
$10,000, and the firm uses a discount rate of 5%. After a $10,000 cash outflow, the equipment is
used in the operations of the business and increases cash inflows by $2,000 a year for five years.
The business applies present value table factors to the $10,000 outflow and to the $2,000 inflow
each year for five years.
The $2,000 inflow in year five would be discounted using the discount rate at 5% for five years. If
the sum of all the adjusted cash inflows and outflows is greater than zero, the investment is
profitable. A positive net cash inflow also means that the rate of return is higher than the 5%
discount rate.
The rate of return using discounted cash flows is also known as the internal rate of return (IRR).
The internal rate of return is a discount rate that makes the net present value (NPV) of all cash
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 13
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
flows from a particular project or investment equal to zero. IRR calculations rely on the same
formula as NPV does and utilizes the time value of money (using interest rates).
When calculating the rate of return, you are determining the percentage change from the
beginning of the period until the end.
Example
𝐂𝐚𝐬𝐡 𝐃𝐢𝐯𝐢𝐝𝐞𝐧𝐝 𝐄𝐧𝐝𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐏𝐫𝐢𝐜𝐞 𝐨𝐟 𝐚 𝐒𝐡𝐚𝐫𝐞−𝐁𝐞𝐠𝐢𝐧𝐧𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐏𝐫𝐢𝐜𝐞
• r = 𝐁𝐞𝐠𝐢𝐧𝐧𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐏𝐫𝐢𝐜𝐞 + 𝐁𝐞𝐠𝐢𝐧𝐧𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐏𝐫𝐢𝐜𝐞
Investors follow different market indexes to gauge market movements. The three most popular
stock indexes for tracking the performance of the U.S. market are the Dow Jones Industrial
Average (DJIA), S&P 500 Index, and Nasdaq Composite Index. In the bond market, Bloomberg
is a leading provider of market indexes with the Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate Bond Index serving
as one of the most popular proxies for U.S. bonds. Investors cannot invest directly in an index, so
these portfolios are used broadly as benchmarks or for developing index funds.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 14
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
2. Dow Jones Industrial Average
3. Nasdaq Composite
4. S&P 100
5. Russell 1000
6. S&P MidCap 400
7. Russell Midcap
8. Russell 2000
9. S&P 600
10. U.S. Aggregate Bond Market
11. Global Aggregate Bond Market
Investors often choose to use index investing over individual stock holdings in a diversified
portfolio. Investing in a portfolio of index funds can be a good way to optimize returns while
balancing risk. For example, investors seeking to build a balanced portfolio of U.S. stocks and
bonds could choose to invest 50% of their funds in an S&P 500 ETF and 50% in a U.S. Aggregate
Bond Index ETF.
Investors may also choose to use market index funds to invest in emerging growth sectors. Some
popular emerging growth indexes and corresponding exchange-traded funds (ETFs) include the
following:
The iShares Global Clean Energy ETF (ICLN), which tracks the S&P Global Clean Energy
Index
The Reality Shares Nasdaq NexGen Economy ETF (BLCN), which tracks the Reality
Shares Nasdaq Blockchain Economy Index
The First Trust Nasdaq Artificial Intelligence and Robotics ETF (ROBT), which tracks the
Nasdaq CTA Artificial Intelligence and Robotics Index
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 15
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Why Are Indexes Useful to Investors?
Indexes provide investors with a simplified snapshot of a large market sector, without having to
examine every single asset in that index. For example, it would be impractical for an ordinary
investor to study hundreds of different stock prices in order to understand the changing fortunes
of different technology companies. However, a sector-wide index like the NASDAQ-100
Technology Sector Index can show the average trend for the sector.
Indexing
Indexing, broadly, refers to the use of some benchmark indicator or measure as a reference or
yardstick. In finance and economics, indexing is used as a statistical measure for tracking
economic data such as inflation, unemployment, gross domestic product (GDP) growth,
productivity, and market returns.
• Indexing is an investment strategy that seeks to match the investment returns of a
specified stock market index.
• In the investment market, indexes exist to represent specific market segments.
• Costs involved must be considered in addition to Average Return Per Anum
• Costs to be considered
• Fund’s expense ratio (e.g. advisory fee, distribution charges, operating expenses)
• Portfolio and transaction costs (brokerage and other trading costs)
Passive Investing
1. Indexing is Passive investing technique,
2. Passive investing broadly refers to a buy-and-hold portfolio strategy for long-term
investment horizons, with minimal trading in the market.
Active Investing
• Active investing refers to activities entered into by investors or fund managers seeking to
rearrange a portfolio of securities. Active investors constantly seek alpha, which is the
difference between a return on any actively managed portfolio compared to an index,
benchmark, or similar passive investing strategy. It involves on-going buying and selling.
• Example: Suppose nominal rate of return is 8% and inflation is 5%. What will be the real
rate of return?
0.08 −0.05 0.03
• Real Rate= 1+0.05
= 1.05 =0.02857=2.857%
Interest rates represent the cost of borrowing and the return on savings and investing. They're
expressed as a percentage of the total amount of a loan or investment. They can be the total
return lenders receive when they offer loans or the return people earn when they save and invest.
Interest rates can be expressed in nominal or real terms. A nominal interest rate equals the real
interest rate plus a projected rate of inflation. A real interest rate reflects the true cost of funds to
the borrower and the real yield to the lender or to an investor.
The nominal interest rate is the rate that is advertised by banks, debt issuers, and investment
firms for loans and various investments. It is the stated interest rate paid or earned to the lender
or by investor. So, if as a borrower, you get a loan of $100 at a rate of 6%, you can expect to pay
$6 in interest. The rate has been marked up to take account of inflation.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 17
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
EXCERCISE
• Suppose the risk-free nominal interest rate on a one-year Treasury bill is 6% per yearand
the expected rate of inflation is 3% per year. What is the expected real rate of return on
the T-bill? Why is the T-bill risky in real terms? (=0.03/1.03=0.02913)
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 18
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Productivity of capital goods
• Capital goods are goods produced in the economy that can be used in the production of
other goods.
• e.g. mines, roads, canals, dams, factories, machinery, inventories, patents, formulas,
brand-name recognition.
• Capital’s productivity is represented by rate of return on capital.
• The return on capital is the source of dividends and interest paid to the holders of the
stocks or other financial instruments holders.
• The expected return on capital varies over time and space.
• Space: technology, availability of other factors of production.
• The higher the expected rate of return on capital, the higher the level of interest rates in
the economy.
Risk Aversion
• The greater the degree of risk aversion of the population, the higher the risk premium
required, and the lower will be the risk-free rate of interest.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 19
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 04
FINANCIAL INTERMEDIARIES
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 20
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Financial sector of Pakistan predominantly comprises of banks, as they hold the largest
share of financial assets as a percentage of GDP.
State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) regulates Banks, DFIs, Exchange Companies and MFBs, while
Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP) regulate NBFCs, Insurance
Companies and Modaraba Companies.
Discount House
• A discount house is a firm that buys, sells, discounts, and negotiates bills of exchange
or promissory notes.
• This is generally performed on a large scale with transactions that also include
government bonds and Treasury bills.
• NBP Capital Discount Ltd.
A normal yield curve is one in which longer maturity bonds have a higher yield compared to
shorter-term bonds due to the risks associated with time. An inverted yield curve is one in which
the shorter-term yields are higher than the longer-term yields, which can be a sign of an upcoming
recession. In a flat or humped yield curve, the shorter- and longer-term yields are very close to
each other, which is also a predictor of an economic transition.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 22
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
This is the most common type of yield curve as longer-maturity bonds usually have a higher yield
to maturity than shorter-term bonds.
For example, assume a two-year bond offers a yield of 1%, a five-year bond offers a yield of
1.8%, a 10-year bond offers a yield of 2.5%, a 15-year bond offers a yield of 3.0%, and a 20-
year bond offers a yield of 3.5%. When these points are connected on a graph, they exhibit a
shape of a normal yield curve.
A normal yield curve implies stable economic conditions and should prevail throughout a
normal economic cycle. A steep yield curve implies strong economic growth in the future—
conditions that are often accompanied by higher inflation, which can result in higher interest
rates.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 23
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• The increasing onset of demand for longer-maturity bonds and the lack of demand for
shorter-term securities lead to higher prices but lower yields on longer-maturity bonds,
and lower prices but higher yields on shorter-term securities, further inverting a down-
sloped yield curve.
Such a flat or humped yield curve implies an uncertain economic situation. It may come at the
end of a high economic growth period that is leading to inflation and fears of a slowdown. It might
appear at times when the central bank is expected to increase interest rates. In times of high
uncertainty, investors demand similar yields across all maturities.
• A flat yield curve may arise from the normal or inverted yield curve, depending on
changing economic conditions. When the economy is transitioning from expansion to
slower development and even recession, yields on longer-maturity bonds tend to fall and
yields on shorter-term securities likely rise, inverting a normal yield curve into a flat yield
curve.
• When the economy is transitioning from recession to recovery and potential expansion,
yields on longer-maturity bonds are set to rise and yields on shorter-maturity securities
are sure to fall, tilting an inverted yield curve toward a flat yield curve.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 24
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
TOPIC 018: ANOMALY IN THE BOND MARKET AND THE RECESSION
Reasons
• Expectations
• An inverted yield curve indicates that the market believes the Fed will lower rates in the
future. If the Fed lowers interest rates, there is a chance that the economy is not growing
very quickly. This may lead to recession.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 25
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Yield Comparisons
Yields
10-year 5.05
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 26
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 05
FINANCIAL REGULATIONS
TOPIC 020: FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE AND REGULATION
Financial infrastructure is a set of institutions, which provides an enabling environment for the
effective operation of financial intermediaries. In broad terms, the financial infrastructure
encompasses the existing legal and regulatory framework that plays a vital role in determining
the structure, growth and the health of financial sector. A safe and efficient financial infrastructure
fosters financial stability and is imperative for the successful operation of modern integrated
financial markets. On the other hand, a weak financial infrastructure can result in major disruptions
to the smooth operation of financial markets, directly exposing market participants to greater
financial risk.
Accounting Systems
• The discipline that studies reporting of financial information is called accounting.
• Ancient Babylon (around 2000 B.C.)
• Double entry bookkeeping (Italy)
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 27
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
TOPIC 021: REGULATION BY GOVERNMENT
Government regulation affects the financial services industry in many ways, but the specific
impact depends on the nature of the regulation. Increased regulation typically means a higher
workload for people in financial services, because it takes time and effort to adapt business
practices that follow the new regulations correctly.
While the increased time and workload resulting from government regulation can be detrimental
to individual financial or credit services companies in the short term, government regulations can
also benefit the financial services industry as a whole in the long term. The Sarbanes-Oxley
Act was passed by Congress in 2002 in response to multiple financial scandals involving large
conglomerates such as Enron and WorldCom.
The act held senior management of companies accountable for the accuracy of their financial
statements, while also requiring that internal controls be established at these companies to
prevent future fraud and abuse. Implementing these regulations was expensive, but the act gave
more protection to people investing in financial services, which can increase investor confidence
and improve overall corporate investment.
• Governmental and Quasi-Governmental Organizations
– Central Banks
– They promote public policy objectives by influencing key policy variables such
as money supply, bank rate
– Price stability
Special-Purpose Intermediaries
This group of organizations includes entities that are set up to encourage specific
economic activities by making financing more readily available or by guaranteeing debt
instruments of various sorts.
e.g.
First Securitization Trust
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 29
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 06
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
Investors and financial analysts rely on financial data to analyze the performance of a company
and make predictions about the future direction of the company's stock price. One of the most
important resources of reliable and audited financial data is the annual report, which contains the
firm's financial statements.
The financial statements are used by investors, market analysts, and creditors to evaluate a
company's financial health and earnings potential. The three major financial statement reports
are the balance sheet, income statement, and statement of cash flows.
• They provide information to the owners and creditors of the firm about the company’s
current status and past financial performance.
• Financial statements provides a convenient way for owners and creditors to set
performance targets and to impose restrictions on the managers of the firm.
• Financial statements provide convenient templates for financial planning.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 30
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
The balance sheet provides an overview of a company's assets, liabilities, and shareholders'
equity as a snapshot in time. The date at the top of the balance sheet tells you when the snapshot
was taken, which is generally the end of the reporting period. Below is a breakdown of the items
in a balance sheet.
Assets
Cash and cash equivalents are liquid assets, which may include Treasury bills and certificates of
deposit.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 31
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Accounts receivables are the amount of money owed to the company by its customers for the
sale of its product and service.
Inventory is the goods a company on hand it intends to sell as a course of business. Inventory
may include finished goods, work in progress that are not yet finished, or raw materials on hand
that have yet to be worked.
Prepaid expenses are costs that have been paid in advance of when they are due. These
expenses are recorded as an asset because the value of them has not yet been recognized;
should the benefit not be recognized; the company would theoretically be due a refund.
Property, plant, and equipment are capital assets owned by a company for its long-term benefit.
This includes buildings used for manufacturing for heavy machinery used for processing raw
materials.
Investments are assets held for speculative future growth. These aren't used in operations; they
are simply held for capital appreciation.
Trademarks, patents, goodwill, and other intangible assets cannot physically be touched but have
future economic (and often long-term benefits) for the company.
Liabilities
Accounts payable are the bills due as part of the normal course of operations of a business. This
includes the utility bills, rent invoices, and obligations to buy raw materials.
Wages payable are payments due to staff for time worked.
Notes payable are recorded debt instruments that record official debt agreements including the
payment schedule and amount.
Dividends payable are dividends that have been declared to be awarded to shareholders but have
not yet been paid.
Long-term debt can include a variety of obligations including sinking bond funds, mortgages, or
other loans that are due in their entirety in longer than one year. Note that the short-term portion
of this debt is recorded as a current liability.
Shareholders' Equity
Shareholders' equity is a company's total assets minus its total liabilities. Shareholders' equity
(also known as stockholders' equity) represents the amount of money that would be returned to
shareholders if all of the assets were liquidated and all of the company's debt was paid off.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 32
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Retained earnings are part of shareholders' equity and are the amount of net earnings that were
not paid to shareholders as dividends.
QUESTION
• What difference would it have made to the end-of-year balance sheet if Company XYZ
had issued an additional $50 million in long term debt during the year and added that
amount to its holdings in cash and marketable securities?
Operating Revenue
• Revenue realized through primary activities
Non-Operating Revenue
Revenues realized through secondary, non-core business activities
• The net money made from other activities, e.g. sale of long-term assets.
• These include the net income realized from one-time non-business activities, like a
company selling its old transportation van, unused land, or a subsidiary company.
Expenses
Primary expenses are incurred during the process of earning revenue from the primary activity
of the business. Expenses include the cost of goods sold (COGS), selling, general and
administrative expenses (SG&A), depreciation or amortization, and research and development
(R&D).
Typical expenses include employee wages, sales commissions, and utilities such as electricity
and transportation.
Expenses that are linked to secondary activities include interest paid on loans or debt. Losses
from the sale of an asset are also recorded as expenses.
Losses as Expenses
• All expenses that go towards a loss-making sale of long-term assets, one-time or any
other unusual costs, or expenses towards lawsuits.
Gains/Other Income
• The net money made from other activities, e.g. sale of long-term assets.
• These include the net income realized from one-time non-business activities, like a
company selling its old transportation van, unused land, or a subsidiary company.
Expenses
1. Cost of Goods Sold $110 million
(production+materials+labor)
Gross Margin =
2. General, administrative, and selling (GS&Aa) expense.
Operating income = gross margin-GS&A
GS&A expenses in 2001 – 30 million
Operating income = 60 million
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 35
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Income Statement - Sample
The Cash Flow Statement (CFS) measures how well a company generates cash to pay its debt
obligations, fund its operating expenses, and fund investments. The cash flow statement
complements the balance sheet and income statement.
• The income statement is based on accrual accounting methods hence not every revenue
is an inflow of cash and not every expense is an outflow.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 36
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• Net income depends on judgments e.g.
– how to value inventory
– how to depreciate tangible assets
– how to amortize its intangible assets
Major Components
1. Cash flow from Operating Activities
2. Cash Flow from Investment Activities
3. Cash Flow from Financing Activities
The cash flow statement includes cash made by the business through operations,
investment, and financing—the sum of which is called net cash flow.
The first section of the cash flow statement is cash flow from operations, which
includes transactions from all operational business activities.
Cash flow from investment is the second section of the cash flow statement, and is the
result of investment gains and losses. For example, cash spent on property, plant, and
equipment.
Cash flow from financing is the final section, which provides an overview of cash used
from debt and equity.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 37
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Cash Flow Statement - Example
Operating Activities
The operating activities on the CFS include any sources and uses of cash from running the
business and selling its products or services. Cash from operations includes any changes made
in cash accounts receivable, depreciation, inventory, and accounts payable. These transactions
also include wages, income tax payments, interest payments, rent, and cash receipts from the
sale of a product or service.
Investing Activities
Investing activities include any sources and uses of cash from a company's investments in the
long-term future of the company. A purchase or sale of an asset, loans made to vendors or
received from customers, or any payments related to a merger or acquisition is included in this
category.
Also, purchases of fixed assets such as property, plant, and equipment (PPE) are included in this
section. In short, changes in equipment, assets, or investments relate to cash from investing.
Financing Activities
Cash from financing activities includes the sources of cash from investors or banks, as well as
the uses of cash paid to shareholders. Financing activities include debt issuance, equity issuance,
stock repurchases, loans, dividends paid, and repayments of debt.
The cash flow statement reconciles the income statement with the balance sheet in three major
business activities.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 39
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Limitations of Financial Statements
Although financial statements provide a wealth of information on a company, they do have
limitations.
The statements are open to interpretation, and as a result, investors often draw vastly different
conclusions about a company's financial performance.
For example, some investors might want stock repurchases while other investors might prefer to
see that money invested in long-term assets. A company's debt level might be fine for one investor
while another might have concerns about the level of debt for the company.
When analyzing financial statements, it's important to compare multiple periods to determine if
there are any trends as well as compare the company's results to its peers in the same industry.
Last, financial statements are only as reliable as the information being fed into the reports. Too
often, it has been documented that fraudulent financial activity or poor control oversight have led
to misstated financial statements intended to mislead users. Even when analyzing audited
financial statements, there is a level of trust that users must place into the validity of the report
and the figures being shown.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 41
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 07
MARKET VALUES AND BOOK VALUES
Determining the book value of a company is more difficult than finding its market value, but it can
also be far more rewarding. Many famous investors, including billionaire Warren Buffett, built their
fortunes in part by buying stocks with market valuations below their book valuations. The market
value depends on what people are willing to pay for a company's stock. The book value is similar
to a firm's net asset value, which jumps around much less than stock prices. Learning how to use
the book value formula gives investors a more stable path to achieving their financial goals.
Book value is the net value of a firm's assets found on its balance sheet, and it is roughly equal
to the total amount all shareholders would get if they liquidated the company. Market value is the
company's worth based on the total value of its outstanding shares in the market, which is its
market capitalization.
Market value tends to be greater than a company's book value since market value captures
profitability, intangibles, and future growth prospects.
Book value per share is a way to measure the net asset value investors get when they buy a
share.
The price-to-book (P/B) ratio is a popular way to compare book and market values, and a lower
ratio may indicate a better deal.
The book value literally means the value of a business according to its books or accounts, as
reflected on its financial statements. Theoretically, it is what investors would get if they sold all
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 42
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
the company's assets and paid all its debts and obligations. Therefore, book value is roughly
equal to the amount stockholders would receive if they decided to liquidate the company.
Example
Suppose that XYZ Company has total assets of $100 million and total liabilities of $80 million.
Then, the book valuation of the company is $20 million. If the company sold its assets and paid
its liabilities, the net worth of the business would be $20 million.
Total assets cover all types of financial assets, including cash, short-term investments, and
accounts receivable. Physical assets, such as inventory, property, plant, and equipment, are also
part of total assets. Intangible assets, including brand names and intellectual property, can be
part of total assets if they appear on financial statements. Total liabilities include items like debt
obligations, accounts payable, and deferred taxes.
Market Value
The market value represents the value of a company according to the stock market. It is the price
an asset would get in the marketplace. In the context of companies, market value is equal
to market capitalization. It is a dollar amount computed based on the current market price of the
company's shares.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 43
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Market Value Formula
Market value—also known as market cap—is calculated by multiplying a company's outstanding
shares by its current market price.
If XYZ Company trades at $25 per share and has 1 million shares outstanding, its market value
is $25 million. Financial analysts, reporters, and investors usually mean market value when they
mention a company's value.
• It represents the value of a company according to the stock market.
• It is the price an asset would get in the marketplace
• In the context of companies, it represents the market capitalization
• It is the aggregate market value of a company represented as a dollar amount.
• Since it represents the “market” value of a company, it is computed based on the current
market price (CMP) of its shares.
As the market price of shares changes throughout the day, the market cap of a company does so
as well. On the other hand, the number of shares outstanding almost always remains the same.
That number is constant unless a company pursues specific corporate actions. Therefore, market
value changes nearly always occur because of per-share price changes.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 44
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
TOPIC 030: LIMITATIONS OF BOOK VALUE AND MARKET VALUE
One of the major issues with book value is that companies report the figure quarterly or annually.
It is only after the reporting that an investor would know how it has changed over the months.
Book valuation is an accounting concept, so it is subject to adjustments. Some of these
adjustments, such as depreciation, may not be easy to understand and assess. If the company
has been depreciating its assets, investors might need several years of financial statements to
understand its impact. Additionally, depreciation-linked rules and accounting practices can create
other issues.
For instance, a company may have to report an overly high value for some of its equipment. That
could happen if it always uses straight-line depreciation as a matter of policy.
Book value does not always include the full impact of claims on assets and the costs of selling
them. Book valuation might be too high if the company is a bankruptcy candidate and has liens
against its assets. What is more, assets will not fetch their full values if creditors sell them in a
depressed market at fire-sale prices.
The increased importance of intangibles and difficulty assigning values for them raises questions
about book value. As technology advances, factors like intellectual property play larger parts in
determining profitability. Ultimately, accountants must come up with a way of consistently valuing
intangibles to keep book value up to date.
Long-term investors also need to be wary of the occasional manias and panics that impact market
values. Market values shot high above book valuations and common sense during the 1920s and
the dotcom bubble. Market values for many companies actually fell below their book valuations
following the stock market crash of 1929 and during the inflation of the 1970s. Relying solely on
market value may not be the best method to assess a stock’s potential.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 45
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
TOPIC 031: COMPARING BOOK AND MARKET VALUE
• Most investors and traders use both values
Scenario 1: Book value greater than market value
It usually indicates that the market has momentarily lost confidence in the company. It may be
due to:
1. Problems with the business,
2. Loss of important business-related lawsuits, or
3. Chances of financial anomalies.
Value investors often prefer such companies hoping that the market perception turns out to be
incorrect in the future.
However, there is no guarantee that the price will rise in the future.
It is unusual for a company to trade at a market value that is lower than its book valuation. When
that happens, it usually indicates that the market has momentarily lost confidence in the company.
It may be due to business problems, loss of critical lawsuits, or other random events. In other
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 46
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
words, the market doesn't believe that the company is worth the value on its books.
Mismanagement or economic conditions might put the firm's future profits and cash flows in
question.
Value investors actively seek out companies with their market values below their book valuations.
They see it as a sign of undervaluation and hope market perceptions turn out to be incorrect. In
this scenario, the market is giving investors an opportunity to buy a company for less than its
stated net worth. However, there is no guarantee that the price will rise in the future.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 47
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
The price-to-book (P/B) ratio is a popular way to compare market value and book value. It is equal
to the price per share divided by the book value per share.
For example, a company has a P/B of one when the book valuation and market valuation are
equal. The next day, the market price drops, so the P/B ratio becomes less than one. That means
the market valuation is less than the book valuation, so the market might undervalue the stock.
The following day, the market price zooms higher and creates a P/B ratio greater than one. That
tells us the market valuation now exceeds book valuation, indicating potential overvaluation.
However, the P/B ratio is only one of several ways investors use book value.
• Both book value and market value offer meaningful insights to a company's valuation
• Comparing the two can help investors determine whether a stock is overvalued or
undervalued given its assets, liabilities, and its ability to generate income.
• An investor must determine when the book value or market value should be used and
when it should be discounted or disregarded in favor of other meaningful parameters
when analyzing a company.
Income/Earnings/Profit - Definition
According to John R. Hicks, income is the amount that you could spend during the period while
maintaining the wealth with which you started the period.
The accounting definition ignores unrealized gains or losses in the market values of assets and
liabilities.
Accounting Profit
It is the net income for a company.
It's the profit after various costs and expenses are subtracted from total revenue or total sales
as stipulated by generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP).
• It is the amount of money left over after deducting the explicit costs of running the
business.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 48
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• Explicit costs are merely the specific amounts that a company pays for those costs in
that period – for example, wages.
• Typically, accounting profit or net income is reported on a quarterly and annual basis
and is used to measure the financial performance of a company.
Economic Profit
• Similar to accounting profit in that it deducts explicit costs from revenue. However,
economic profit also includes the opportunity costs for taking one action versus another in
the period.
• Economic profit is determined by economic principles, not by accounting principles.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 49
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 08
RETURN ON ASSETS AND RETURN ON EQUITY
TOPIC 034: FINANCIAL RATIOS
• Financial ratios are powerful tools to help summarize financial statements and the health
of a company or enterprise.
• Total Shareholder Return (TSR)
Ratio analysis is a quantitative method of gaining insight into a company's liquidity, operational
efficiency, and profitability by studying its financial statements such as the balance sheet and
income statement. Ratio analysis is a cornerstone of fundamental equity analysis.
Example
Assume that an investor bought 100 shares at $20 and still owns the stock. Company paid out
$4.50 in dividends since the investor bought the stock and the current price is $24.
• TSR = { (current price - purchase price) + dividends } ÷ purchase price
• TSR = { ($24 - $20) + $4.50 } ÷ $20 = 0.425 * 100 = 42.5%
Key Points
• There are two basic ways that an Investor makes money in stocks - capital gains and
current income (dividends).
• Total Shareholder Return factors in capital gains and dividends when measuring the
total return generated by a stock to an investor.
• TSR represents an easily understood figure of the overall financial benefits generated for
stockholders.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 50
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Classification of Financial Ratios
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 51
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Formula:
Net Income
ROE = Average Shareholders' Equity
• Net Income is the amount of income, net of expense, and taxes that a company generates
for a given period.
• Average Shareholders' Equity is calculated by adding equity at the beginning of the period.
The beginning and end of the period should coincide with that which the net income is
earned.
• Net income over the last full fiscal year, or trailing 12 months, is found on the income
statement—a sum of financial activity over that period.
• Shareholders' equity comes from the balance sheet—a running balance of a company’s
entire history of changes in assets and liabilities.
Example
𝐍𝐞𝐭 𝐈𝐧𝐜𝐨𝐦𝐞
ROE =
𝐒𝐡𝐚𝐫𝐞𝐡𝐨𝐥𝐝𝐞𝐫𝐬 ′ 𝐄𝐪𝐮𝐢𝐭𝐲
$𝟐𝟑.𝟒
ROE = = 0.078 = 7.8%
$𝟑𝟎𝟎
Rule of thumb
• Relatively high or low ROE ratios will vary significantly from one industry group or sector
to another.
• When used to evaluate one company to another similar company the comparison will be
more meaningful.
• A common shortcut for investors to consider a return on equity near the long-term average
of the S&P 500 (14%) as an acceptable ratio and anything less than 10% as poor.
Return on equity (ROE) is a measure of financial performance calculated by dividing net income
by shareholders' equity. Because shareholders' equity is equal to a company’s assets minus its
debt, ROE is considered the return on net assets.
ROE is considered a gauge of a corporation's profitability and how efficient it is in generating
profits. The higher the ROE, the more efficient a company's management is at generating income
and growth from its equity financing.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 52
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
ROE is expressed as a percentage and can be calculated for any company if net income and
equity are both positive numbers. Net income is calculated before dividends paid to common
shareholders and after dividends to preferred shareholders and interest to lenders.
Net income over the last full fiscal year, or trailing 12 months, is found on the income statement—
a sum of financial activity over that period. Shareholders' equity comes from the balance sheet—
a running balance of a company’s entire history of changes in assets and liabilities.
It is considered best practice to calculate ROE based on average equity over a period because
of the mismatch between the income statement and the balance sheet.
Where:
• Operating Profit is calculated as earnings before income and taxes, or EBIT.
• Net sales is the sum of a company's gross sales minus its returns, allowances, and
discounts.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 53
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• Investors, creditors, and other debt holders rely on this efficiency ratio because it
accurately communicates the percentage of operating cash a company makes on its
revenue and provides insight into potential dividends, reinvestment potential, and the
company's ability to repay debt.
• ROS is used to compare current period calculations with calculations from previous
periods. This allows a company to conduct trend analyses and compare internal efficiency
performance over time. It is also useful to compare one company's ROS percentage with
that of a competing company, regardless of scale.
Example
• ROS is larger if a company's management successfully cuts costs while increasing
revenue.
• For example, the company with $50,000 in sales and $30,000 in costs has an operating
profit of $20,000 and a ROS of 40% ($20,000 / $50,000).
• If the company's management team wants to increase efficiency, it can focus on
increasing sales while incrementally increasing expenses, or it can focus on decreasing
expenses while maintaining or increasing revenue.
These ratios convey how well a company can generate profits from its operations. Profit margin,
return on assets, return on equity, return on capital employed, and gross margin ratios are all
examples of profitability ratios.
For most profitability ratios, having a higher value relative to a competitor's ratio or relative to the
same ratio from a previous period indicates that the company is doing well. Profitability ratios are
most useful when compared to similar companies, the company's own history, or average ratios
for the company's industry.
Gross profit margin is one of the most widely used profitability or margin ratios. Gross profit is the
difference between revenue and the costs of production—called cost of goods sold (COGS).
Some industries experience seasonality in their operations. For example, retailers typically
experience significantly higher revenues and earnings during the year-end holiday season. Thus,
it would not be useful to compare a retailer's fourth-quarter gross profit margin with its first-quarter
gross profit margin because they are not directly comparable. Comparing a retailer's fourth-
quarter profit margin with its fourth-quarter profit margin from the previous year would be far more
informative.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 54
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Examples of Profitability Ratios
Profitability ratios are one of the most popular metrics used in financial analysis, and they
generally fall into two categories—margin ratios and return ratios.
Margin ratios give insight, from several different angles, on a company's ability to turn sales into
a profit. Return ratios offer several different ways to examine how well a company generates a
return for its shareholders.
Some common examples of profitability ratios are the various measures of profit margin, return
on assets (ROA), and return on equity (ROE). Others include return on invested capital (ROIC)
and return on capital employed (ROCE).
Profit Margin
Different profit margins are used to measure a company's profitability at various cost levels of
inquiry, including gross margin, operating margin, pretax margin, and net profit margin. The
margins shrink as layers of additional costs are taken into consideration—such as the COGS,
operating expenses, and taxes.
Gross margin measures how much a company makes after accounting for COGS. Operating
margin is the percentage of sales left after covering COGS and operating expenses. The pretax
margin shows a company's profitability after further accounting for non-operating expenses. The
net profit margin is a company's ability to generate earnings after all expenses and taxes.
Example
• Suppose Sam and Fran start shawarma stands. Sam spends $1,500 on the stand and
Fran spends $150000 on his unit. Suppose Sam had earned $150 and Fran had earned
$1,200. Sam’s ROA =$150/1500 = 10%
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 55
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• Fran’s ROA = $1200/$15000 = 8%
• Fran’s business is more valuable but Sam has an efficient one.
Example
• Let's evaluate the return on assets (ROA) for three companies in the retail industry:
• Macy's (M)
• Kohl’s (KSS)
• Dillard's (DDS)
• The data in the table is for the trailing twelve months as of Feb. 13, 2019.
Data
Explanation
• The data shows that every dollar that Macy's has invested in assets generates 8.3 cents
of net income.
• Macy's is better at converting its investment into profits, compared with Kohl’s and
Dillard’s.
• One of management's most important jobs is to make wise choices in allocating its
resources.
• It appears Macy’s management is more adept than its two peers.
Profitability is assessed relative to costs and expenses and analyzed in comparison to assets to
see how effective a company is deploying assets to generate sales and profits. The use of the
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 56
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
term "return" in the ROA measure customarily refers to net profit or net income—the value of
earnings from sales after all costs, expenses, and taxes. ROA is net income divided by total
assets.
The more assets a company has amassed, the more sales and potential profits the company may
generate. As economies of scale help lower costs and improve margins, returns may grow at a
faster rate than assets, ultimately increasing ROA.
• Both ROA and return on equity (ROE) are measures of how a company utilizes its
resources.
𝐍𝐞𝐭 𝐈𝐧𝐜𝐨𝐦𝐞
– ROA =
𝐓𝐨𝐭𝐚𝐥 𝐀𝐬𝐬𝐞𝐭
𝐍𝐞𝐭 𝐈𝐧𝐜𝐨𝐦𝐞
– ROE =𝐒𝐡𝐚𝐫𝐞𝐡𝐨𝐥𝐝𝐞𝐫𝐬′ 𝐄𝐪𝐮𝐢𝐭𝐲
• Essentially, ROE only measures the return on a company’s equity, leaving out the
liabilities.
• Thus, ROA accounts for a company’s debt and ROE does not.
• The more leverage and debt a company takes on, the higher ROE will be relative to ROA.
• The biggest issue with return on assets (ROA) is that it can't be used across industries.
• That’s because companies in one industry—such as the technology industry—and
another industry like oil drillers will have different asset bases.
• The St. Louis Federal Reserve provides data on US bank ROAs, which have generally
hovered around or just above 1% since 1984, the year collection started.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 57
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 09
ASSET TURNOVER RATIOS
TOPIC 039: ASSET TURNOVER RATIO
• It measures the value of a company's sales or revenues relative to the value of its assets.
• This ratio can be used as an indicator of the efficiency with which a company is using its
assets to generate revenue.
• The higher the asset turnover ratio, the more efficient a company.
• If a company has a low asset turnover ratio, it indicates it is not efficiently using its assets
to generate sales.
The asset turnover ratio measures the efficiency of a company's assets in generating revenue or
sales. It compares the dollar amount of sales (revenues) to its total assets as an annualized
percentage. Thus, to calculate the asset turnover ratio, divide net sales or revenue by the average
total assets.
• Add the value of accounts receivable at the beginning of the desired period to the value
at the end of the period and divide the sum by two to get the value for the denominator in
the formula.
• Divide the value of net credit sales for the period by the average accounts
receivable during the same period.
• Net credit sales are the revenue generated from sales that were done on credit minus any
returns from customers.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 58
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Receivable turnover ratio
𝐍𝐞𝐭 𝐂𝐫𝐞𝐝𝐢𝐭 𝐒𝐚𝐥𝐞𝐬
= 𝐀𝐯𝐞𝐫𝐚𝐠𝐞 𝐀𝐜𝐜𝐨𝐮𝐧𝐭𝐬 𝐑𝐞𝐜𝐞𝐢𝐯𝐚𝐛𝐥𝐞
Balance sheet discussed earlier shows Accounts Receivable for 2000 and 2001 as $50 and $60
respectively.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 60
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Example of Calculating Inventory Turnover
• For the fiscal year ending January 2018, Wal-Mart Stores (WMT) reported annual sales
of $500.34 billion, year-end inventory of $43.78 billion, and an annual cost of goods
sold (or cost of sales) of $373.40 billion.
• Walmart's inventory turnover for the year equals:
• $373.40 billion ÷ $43.78 billion = 8.53
The asset turnover ratio measures the value of a company's sales or revenues relative to the
value of its assets. The asset turnover ratio can be used as an indicator of the efficiency with
which a company is using its assets to generate revenue.
The higher the asset turnover ratio, the more efficient a company is at generating revenue from
its assets. Conversely, if a company has a low asset turnover ratio, it indicates it is not efficiently
using its assets to generate sales.
Asset Turnover Ratio Formula:
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 62
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• Since this ratio can vary widely from one industry to the next, comparing the asset turnover
ratios of a retail company and a telecommunications company would not be very
productive.
• Comparisons are only meaningful when they are made for different companies within the
same sector.
• Let's calculate the asset turnover ratio for four companies in the retail and
telecommunication-utilities sectors –
– Walmart Inc. (NYSE: WMT),
– Target Corporation (NYSE: TGT)
– AT&T Inc. (NYSE: T), and
– Verizon Communications Inc. (NYSE: VZ)
for the fiscal year ended 2016.
• AT&T and Verizon have asset turnover ratios of less than one, which is typical for firms in
the telecommunications-utilities sector.
• Since these companies have large asset bases, it is expected that they would slowly turn
over their assets through sales.
• Clearly, it would not make sense to compare the asset turnover ratios for Walmart and
AT&T, since they operate in very different industries.
• But comparing the asset turnover ratios for AT&T and Verizon may provide a better
estimate of which company is using assets more efficiently.
• For example, from the table, Verizon turns over its assets at a faster rate than AT&T.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 63
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• For every dollar in assets, Walmart generated $2.30 in sales, while Target generated
$1.79.
• Target's turnover may indicate that the retail company was experiencing sluggish sales or
holding obsolete inventory. Furthermore, its low turnover may also mean that the company
has lax collection methods. The firm's collection period may be too long, leading to
higher accounts receivable. Target could also not be using its assets efficiently.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 64
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 10
FINANCIAL LEVERAGE RATIOS AND LIQUIDITY RATIOS
A ratio greater than 1 shows that a considerable portion of debt is funded by assets OR the
company has more liabilities than assets.
A high ratio also indicates that a company may be putting itself at a risk of default on its loans if
interest rates were to rise suddenly.
• A ratio below 1 translates to the fact that a greater portion of a company's assets is funded
by equity.
• The debt ratio is also referred to as the debt-to-assets ratio.
Too much debt can be dangerous for a company and its investors. However, if a company's
operations can generate a higher rate of return than the interest rate on its loans, then the debt
may help to fuel growth. Uncontrolled debt levels can lead to credit downgrades or worse. On the
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 65
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
other hand, too few debts can also raise questions. A reluctance or inability to borrow may be a
sign that operating margins are tight.
There are several different ratios that may be categorized as a leverage ratio, but the main factors
considered are debt, equity, assets, and interest expenses.
A leverage ratio may also be used to measure a company's mix of operating expenses to get an
idea of how changes in output will affect operating income. Fixed and variable costs are the two
types of operating costs; depending on the company and the industry, the mix will differ.
Finally, the consumer leverage ratio refers to the level of consumer debt compared to disposable
income and is used in economic analysis and by policymakers.
• The result is a number that shows how many times a company could cover its interest
charges with its pretax earnings.
• It is also referred to as the interest coverage ratio.
A better TIE number means a company has enough cash after paying its debts for investment.
The TIE ratio is an indication of a company's relative freedom from the constraints of debt.
Generating enough cash flow to continue to invest in the business is better than having enough
money to stave off bankruptcy.
Example
• Assume, that XYZ Company has $10 million in 4% debt outstanding and $10 million in
common stock. The company needs to borrow more loan. The cost of capital for issuing
more debt is an annual interest rate of 6%. The company's shareholders expect an annual
dividend payment of 8% plus growth in the stock price of XYZ.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 66
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• The business decides to issue $10 million in additional debt. Its total annual interest
expense will be: (4% X $10 million) + (6% X $10 million), or $1 million annually. The
company's EBIT is $3 million.
• This means that the TIE ratio for XYZ Company is 3, or three times the annual interest
expense.
The times interest earned (TIE) ratio is a measure of a company's ability to meet its debt
obligations based on its current income. The formula for a company's TIE number is earnings
before interest and taxes (EBIT) divided by the total interest payable on bonds and other debt.
The result is a number that shows how many times a company could cover its interest charges
with its pretax earnings.
TIE is also referred to as the interest coverage ratio.
Obviously, no company needs to cover its debts several times over in order to survive. However,
the TIE ratio is an indication of a company's relative freedom from the constraints of debt.
Generating enough cash flow to continue to invest in the business is better than merely having
enough money to stave off bankruptcy.
A company's capitalization is the amount of money it has raised by issuing stock or debt, and
those choices impact its TIE ratio. Businesses consider the cost of capital for stock and debt and
use that cost to make decisions.
Assume, for example, that XYZ Company has $10 million in 4% debt outstanding and $10 million
in common stock. The company needs to raise more capital to purchase equipment. The cost of
capital for issuing more debt is an annual interest rate of 6%. The company's shareholders expect
an annual dividend payment of 8% plus growth in the stock price of XYZ.
The business decides to issue $10 million in additional debt. Its total annual interest expense will
be: (4% X $10 million) + (6% X $10 million), or $1 million annually. The company's EBIT is $3
million.
This means that the TIE ratio for XYZ Company is 3, or three times the annual interest expense.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 67
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• For example, TKMaxx has $15.53 billion in debt and $4.32 billion in equity (FY 2019).
• The company's D/E ratio is thus:
$15.53 billion
= = 3.59
$4.32 billion
• TKMaxx's liabilities are 359% of shareholders' equity which is very high for a retail
company.
• A high debt/equity ratio generally indicates that a company has been aggressive in
financing its growth with debt.
• This can result in volatile earnings as a result of the additional interest expense.
• If the company's interest expense grows too high, it may increase the company's chances
of a default or bankruptcy.
• Typically, a D/E ratio greater than 2.0 indicates a risky scenario for an investor; however,
this yardstick can vary by industry.
• Businesses that require large capital expenditures (CapEx), such as utility and
manufacturing companies, may need to secure more loans than other companies.
• It is a good idea to measure a firm's leverage ratios against past performance and with
companies operating in the same industry to better understand the data.
Liquidity is the ability to convert assets into cash quickly and cheaply. Liquidity ratios are most
useful when they are used in comparative form. This analysis may be internal or external.
• Internal analysis regarding liquidity ratios involves using multiple accounting periods using
the same accounting methods.
• Such comparison helps to track changes in the business.
• A higher liquidity ratio indicates that the company is more liquid and has better coverage
of outstanding debts.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 68
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• External analysis involves comparing the liquidity ratios of one company to another or an
entire industry.
• This information is useful to compare the company's strategic positioning in relation to its
competitors when establishing benchmark goals.
For example, internal analysis regarding liquidity ratios involves using multiple accounting periods
that are reported using the same accounting methods. Comparing previous periods to current
operations allows analysts to track changes in the business. In general, a higher liquidity ratio
shows a company is more liquid and has better coverage of outstanding debts.
Limitation
• Liquidity ratio analysis may not be as effective when looking across industries as various
businesses require different financing structures.
• Liquidity ratio analysis is less effective for comparing businesses of different sizes in
different geographical locations.
• The quick ratio measures a company's ability to meet its short-term obligations with its
most liquid assets and therefore excludes inventories from its current assets.
• It is also known as the "acid-test ratio.”
• Quick Ratio
C+MS+AR
=
Current Liabilities
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 69
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Example
• Consider two hypothetical companies—ABC Inc. and XYZ Co.—with the following assets
and liabilities on their balance sheets (figures in millions of dollars). We assume that both
companies operate in the same manufacturing sector.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 70
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Cash $5 $1
Marketable Securities $5 $2
Inventories $10 $5
Current Assets
• Current ratio =Current Liabilities
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 71
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Calculations - XYZ Co.
• Current ratio = $10 / $25 = 0.40
• Quick ratio = ($10 – $5) / $25 = 0.20
• Debt to equity = $10 / $40 = 0.25
• Debt to assets = $10 / $75 = 0.13
Conclusions
• ABC Inc. has a high degree of liquidity. Based on its current ratio, it has $3 of current
assets for every dollar of current liabilities.
• Its quick ratio points to adequate liquidity even after excluding inventories, with $2 in
assets that can be converted rapidly to cash for every dollar of current liabilities.
• XYZ Company's current ratio of 0.4 indicates an inadequate degree of liquidity with only
40 cents of current assets available to cover every $1 of current liabilities.
• The quick ratio suggests an even more dire liquidity position, with only 20 cents of liquid
assets for every $1 of current liabilities.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 72
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 11
MARKET VALUE RATIOS
Formula
• P/E Ratio
Market Value Per Share
= Earnings per share
• To determine the P/E value, one simply must divide the current stock price by the earnings
per share (EPS)
• Sometimes, analysts investigate long term valuation trends and consider the P/E 10 or
P/E 30 measures, which average the past 10 or past 30 years of earnings, respectively.
• These measures help to gauge the overall value of a stock index, such as the S&P 500
since these longer term measures can compensate for changes in the business cycle.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 73
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
TOPIC 050: MARKET PRICE TO BOOK RATIO
Companies use the price-to-book ratio (P/B ratio) to compare a firm's market capitalization
to its book value. It's calculated by dividing the company's stock price per share by its
book value per share (BVPS). The price-to-book ratio is often used by value investors
looking for stocks that are underpriced by the market.
An asset's book value is equal to its carrying value on the balance sheet, and companies
calculate it by netting the asset against its accumulated depreciation.
Book value is also the net asset value of a company calculated as total assets
minus intangible assets (patents, goodwill) and liabilities.
For the initial outlay of an investment, book value may be net or gross of expenses, such
as trading costs, sales taxes, and service charges.
Some people may know this ratio by its less common name, price-equity ratio.
Formula
Price Equity Ratio
Market Price Per Share
= Book value per share
In this equation, book value per share is calculated as follows: (total assets - total liabilities) /
number of shares outstanding). Market value per share is obtained by simply looking at the share
price quote in the market.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 74
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
TOPIC 051: THE RELATIONS AMONG RATIOS
• ROA is a product of two Ratios
• These include:
– Return on Sales (ROS)
– Asset Turnover Ratio (ATO)
EBIT SALES
ROA = SALES X ASSETS
• Firms in different sectors with different ROS and ATO can have same ROA
• For example:
• A supermarket chain can have a low profit margin but high turnover ratio, but a high-priced
jewelry store can have a high profit margin but low turnover ratio.
• Return on Sales (ROS) is the indicator of operational efficiency.
• Asset Turnover ratio (ATO) also indicates how efficiently the company is deploying its
assets to produce revenue.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 75
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
TOPIC 052: THE EFFECTS OF FINANCIAL LEVERAGE
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 76
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• This equation implies that if a firm’s ROA exceeds interest rate that it pays, then ROE will
exceed (1-Tax Rate) times ROA plus debt/equity ratio times the difference between ROA
and interest rate.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 77
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 12
THE FINANCIAL PLANNING PROCESS
First, obtain or calculate the return on equity (ROE) of the company. ROE measures the
profitability of a company by comparing net income to the company's shareholders' equity.
Then, subtract the company's dividend payout ratio from 1. The dividend payout ratio is the
percentage of earnings per share paid to shareholders as dividends. Finally, multiply the
difference by the ROE of the company.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 78
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Current assets include anything that can be easily converted into cash within 12 months. These
are the company's highly liquid assets. Some current assets include cash, accounts receivable,
inventory, and short-term investments. Current liabilities are any obligations due within the
following 12 months. These include accruals for operating expenses and current portions of long-
term debt payments.
This metric takes into account how much time the company needs to sell its inventory, how much
time it takes to collect receivables, and how much time it has to pay its bills.
The CCC is one of several quantitative measures that help evaluate the efficiency of a company’s
operations and management. A trend of decreasing or steady CCC values over multiple periods
is a good sign, while rising ones should lead to more investigation and analysis based on other
factors. One should bear in mind that CCC applies only to select sectors dependent on inventory
management and related operations.
Since CCC involves calculating the net aggregate time involved across the above three stages of
the cash conversion life cycle, the mathematical formula for CCC is represented as:
CCC = DIO + DSO – DPO
Where: DIO = Days of inventory outstanding (also known as days sales of inventory)
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 79
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
DSO = Days sales outstanding
DPO = Days payables outstanding
DIO and DSO are associated with the company’s cash inflows, while DPO is linked to cash
outflow. Hence, DPO is the only negative figure in the calculation. Another way to look at the
formula construction is that DIO and DSO are linked to inventory and accounts receivable,
respectively, which are considered as short-term assets and are taken as positive. DPO is linked
to accounts payable, which is a liability and thus taken as negative.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 80
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 13
INTEREST RATES AND YIELD TO MATURITY
Present Value
The concept of present value (or present discounted value) is based on the commonsense notion
that a dollar paid to you one year from now is less valuable than a dollar paid to you today. This
notion is true because you can deposit a dollar today in a savings account that earns interest and
have more than a dollar in one year. Economists use a more formal definition, as explained in this
section.
Let’s look at the simplest kind of debt instrument, which we will call a simple loan. In this loan, the
lender provides the borrower with an amount of funds (called the principal) that must be repaid to
the lender at the maturity date, along with an additional payment for the interest. For example, if
you made your friend, Jane, a simple loan of $100 for one year, you would require her to repay
the principal of $100 in one year’s time, along with an additional payment for interest—say, $10.
In the case of a simple loan like this one, the interest payment divided by the amount of the loan
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 81
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
is a natural and sensible way to measure the interest rate. This measure of the so-called simple
interest rate, i, is:
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 82
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Simple Loan
Concept of Present Value
Simple loan of $1 at 10% interest
Years
1 2 3 n
For example: A person borrowed $1000, a fixed-payment loan might require you to pay $126
every year for 25 years. For example, auto and home loans.
$126 $126 $126
$1000 = (1+i) + (1+i)2+…+ (1+i)25
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 83
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
(i = 12%)
FP FP FP
• LV = + +…+
(1+i) (1+i) (1+i)
• LV = Loan value
• FP=Fixed yearly cash flow payment
• n=number of years after maturity
Strategy
• Equate today’s value of the bond with its present value.
• Present value of the bond is calculated as the sum of the present values of all the coupon
payments plus the present value of the final payment of the face value of the bond.
• Example: Pakistan Investment Bond
Example
If the face value (FV) of a bond is Rs 1000 with 10 years to maturity and yearly coupon payments
of Rs 100 (a 10% coupon rate). Find the present value?
100 100 100 1000
P=(1+i) + (1+i)2+… + (1+i)10 + (1+i)10
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 84
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Relationship between Price and Yield to Maturity
1200 7.13
1100 8.48
1000 10.00
900 11.75
800 13.81
Perpetuity
• A perpetual bond, also known as a "consol bond" or "prep," is a fixed income security with
no maturity date. This type of bond is often considered a type of equity, rather than debt.
One major drawback to these types of bonds is that they are not redeemable.
C
• Price of perpetuity = Pc=
iC
Perpetuity – Example
What is the yield to maturity on a bond that has a price of Rs 2,000 and pays Rs 100 annually
forever?
C C
Pc= => iC =
iC Pc
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 85
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
100
Thus iC = = 5%
2000
Current bond prices and interest rates are negatively related – When the interest rate rises, the
price of the bond falls, and vice versa.
Fisher Equation
• Developed by Irving Fisher.
• The nominal interest rate i equals the real interest rate ir
Plus the expected rate of inflation πe .
i = ir + πe
Rearranging terms, we find the real interest rate:
ir = i - πe
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 87
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• When the real interest rate is low, there are greater incentives to borrow and fewer
incentives to lend.
• It is important to consider the real interest rate for correct decision making.
The yield-to-maturity calculation for a discount bond is similar to that for a simple loan. Let’s
consider a discount bond such as a one-year U.S. Treasury bill that pays a face value of $1,000
in one year’s time but today has a price of $900. As we just saw in the preceding application, the
yield to maturity for a one-year discount bond equals the increase in price over the year, $1,000
– $900, divided by the initial price, $900. Hence, more generally, for any one-year discount bond,
the yield to maturity can be written as:
F−P
i=
P
Where,
F = face value of the discount bond
P = current price of the discount bond
In other words, the yield to maturity equals the increase in price over the year F – P divided by
the initial price P. In normal circumstances, investors earn positive returns from holding these
securities and so they sell at a discount, meaning that the current price of the bond is below the
face value. Therefore, F – P should be positive, and the yield to maturity should be positive as
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 88
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
well. However, this is not always the case, as extraordinary events in Japan and elsewhere have
indicated.
An important feature of this equation is that it indicates that, for a discount bond, the yield to
maturity is negatively related to the current bond price. This is the same conclusion that we
reached for a coupon bond. The above equation shows that a rise in the bond price—say, from
$900 to $950—means that the bond will have a smaller increase in its price at maturity and so
the yield to maturity will fall, from 11.1% to 5.3% in our example. Similarly, a fall in the yield to
maturity means that the current price of the discount bond has risen.
Summary
The concept of present value tells you that a dollar in the future is not as valuable to you as a
dollar today because you can earn interest on a dollar you have today. Specifically, a dollar
received n years from now is worth only $1/(1 + i)n today. The present value of a set of future cash
flow payments on a debt instrument equals the sum of the present values of each of the future
payments. The yield to maturity for an instrument is the interest rate that equates the present
value of the future payments on that instrument to its value today. Because the procedure for
calculating the yield to maturity is based on sound economic principles, the yield to maturity is the
measure that economists think most accurately describes the interest rate.
Our calculations of the yield to maturity for a variety of bonds reveal the important fact that current
bond prices and interest rates are negatively related: When the interest rate rises, the price of the
bond falls, and vice versa.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 89
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Example
= 0.30 or 30%
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 90
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Hence, the return on a bond will not necessarily equal the interest rate on that bond.
The distinction between interest rate and return can be important.
Many people think that the interest rate on a bond tells them all they need to know about how well
off they are as a result of owning it. If Irving the Investor thinks he is well off when he owns a long-
term bond yielding a 10% interest rate, and the interest rate then rises to 20%, he will have a rude
awakening: As we will shortly see, if he has to sell the bond, Irving will lose his shirt! How well a
person does financially by holding a bond or any other security over a particular time period is
accurately measured by the security’s return, or, in more precise terminology, the rate of return.
For any security, the rate of return is defined as the amount of each payment to the owner plus
the change in the security’s value, expressed as a fraction of its purchase price.
To make this definition clearer, let us see what the return would look like for a $1,000-face-value
coupon bond with a coupon rate of 10% that is bought for $1,000, held for one year, and then
sold for $1,200. The payments to the owner are the yearly coupon payments of $100, and the
change in the bond’s value is $1,200 - $1,000 = $200.
Adding these values together and expressing them as a fraction of the purchase price of $1,000
gives us the one-year holding-period return for this bond:
You may have noticed something quite surprising about the return that we just calculated: It
equals 30%, yet as Table 1 indicates, initially the yield to maturity was only 10%. This discrepancy
demonstrates that the return on a bond will not necessarily equal the yield to maturity on that
bond. We now see that the distinction between interest rate and return can be important, although
for many securities the two may be closely related.
More generally, the return on a bond held from time t to time t + 1 can be written as:
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 91
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Where,
g is the rate of capital gain.
The above equation can be written as:
R=ic +g
Which shows that the return on a bond is the current yield ic plus the rate of capital gain g. The
formula shows that even for a bond for which the current yield ic is an accurate measure of the
yield to maturity, the return can differ substantially from the interest rate. Returns will differ
substantially from the interest rate if the price of the bond experiences sizable fluctuations that
produce substantial capital gains or losses.
C Pt+1 −Pt
• R= +
Pt Pt
C
• Let ic = Pt
= current yield
Pt+1 −Pt
• g= Pt
= capital gain
• R = ic + g
The finding that the prices of longer-maturity bonds respond more dramatically to changes in
interest rates helps explain an important fact about the behavior of bond markets:
Prices and returns for long-term bonds are more volatile than those for shorter-term bonds. Price
changes of +20% and -20% within a year, with corresponding variations in returns, are common
for bonds that are more than 20 years away from maturity. We now see that changes in interest
rates make investments in long-term bonds quite risky. Indeed, the risk level associated with an
asset’s return that results from interest-rate changes is so important that it has been given a
special name, interest rate risk.
The key to
understanding why there is no interest-rate risk for any bond whose time to maturity
matches the holding period is to recognize that (in this case) the price at the end of the
holding period is already fixed at the face value. A change in interest rates can then
have no effect on the price at the end of the holding period for these bonds, and the
return will therefore be equal to the yield to maturity, which is known at the time the
bond is purchased.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 93
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Table 1: One-year Returns on Different-Maturity 10%-Coupon-Rate Bonds when interest
rates rise from 10% to 20%
Interest rate risk can be reduced by buying bonds with different durations, or by hedging fixed-
income investments with interest rate swaps, options, or other interest rate derivatives.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 94
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Interest rate changes can affect many investments, but it impacts the value of bonds and other
fixed-income securities most directly. Bondholders, therefore, carefully monitor interest rates and
make decisions based on how interest rates are perceived to change over time.
• Prices and returns for long-term bonds are more volatile than those for shorter-term
bonds.
• Price changes of +20% and -20% within a year, with corresponding variations in returns,
are common for bonds that are more than 20 years away from maturity.
• The risk level associated with an asset’s return that results from interest-rate changes is
called interest rate risk.
• Long-term debt instruments have substantial interest-rate risk.
• Short-term debt instruments do not have any interest-rate risk.
• Bonds with a maturity term that is as short as the holding period have no interest-rate risk.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 95
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 14
DEMAND AND SUPPLY ANALYSIS OF BOND MARKET
1. Wealth, the total resources owned by the individual, including all assets
Holding everything else constant, an increase in wealth raises the quantity demanded of an asset
2. Expected return (the return expected over the next period) on one asset relative to alternative
assets. An increase in an asset’s expected return relative to that of an alternative asset, holding
everything else unchanged, raises the quantity demanded of the asset
3. Risk (the degree of uncertainty associated with the return) on one asset relative to alternative
assets. Holding everything else constant, if an asset’s risk rises relative to that of alternative
assets, its quantity demanded will fall.
4. Liquidity (the ease and speed with which an asset can be turned into cash) relative to
alternative assets. The more liquid an asset is relative to alternative assets, holding everything
else unchanged, the more desirable it is and the greater the quantity demanded will be.
For the demand of an asset, an individual must consider the following factors:
1. Wealth, the total resources owned by the individual, including all assets
2. Expected return (the return expected over the next period) on one asset relative to
alternative assets
3. Risk (the degree of uncertainty associated with the return) on one asset relative to
alternative assets
4. Liquidity (the ease and speed with which an asset can be turned into cash) relative to
alternative assets
Wealth
When we find that our wealth has increased, we have more resources available with which to
purchase assets, and so, not surprisingly, the quantity of assets we demand increases. Therefore,
the effect of changes in wealth on the quantity demanded of an asset can be summarized as
follows: Holding everything else constant, an increase in wealth raises the quantity demanded of
an asset.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 96
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Expected Returns
The return on an asset (such as a bond) measures how much we gain from holding that asset.
When we make a decision to buy an asset, we are influenced by what we expect the return on
that asset to be. If an ExxonMobil bond, for example, has a return of 15% half the time and 5%
the other half, its expected return (which you can think of as the average return) is 10% (= 0.5 *
15% + 0.5 * 5%).
If the expected return on the ExxonMobil bond rises relative to expected returns on alternative
assets, then, holding everything else constant, it becomes more desirable to purchase the
ExxonMobil bond, and the quantity demanded increases. This can occur in either of two ways:
(1) when the expected return on the ExxonMobil bond rises while the return on an alternative
asset—say, stock in Facebook—remains unchanged or (2) when the return on the alternative
asset, the Facebook stock, falls while the return on the ExxonMobil bond remains unchanged. To
summarize, an increase in an asset’s expected return relative to that of an alternative asset,
holding everything else unchanged, raises the quantity demanded of the asset.
Risk
The degree of risk or uncertainty of an asset’s returns also affects demand for the asset. Consider
two assets, stock in Fly-by-Night Airlines and stock in Feet-on-the-Ground Bus Company.
Suppose that Fly-by-Night stock has a return of 15% half the time and 5% the other half, making
its expected return 10%, while Feet-on-the-Ground stock has a fixed return of 10%. Fly-by-Night
stock has uncertainty associated with its returns and so has greater risk than Feet-on-the-Ground
stock, whose return is a sure thing.
A risk-averse person prefers stock in Feet-on-the-Ground (the sure thing) to Fly-by Night stock
(the riskier asset), even though the stocks have the same expected return, 10%. By contrast, a
person who prefers risk is a risk preferrer or risk lover. Most people are risk-averse, especially in
their financial decisions: Everything else being equal, they prefer to hold the less risky asset.
Hence, holding everything else constant, if an asset’s risk rises relative to that of alternative
assets, its quantity demanded will fall.
Liquidity
Another factor that affects the demand for an asset is how quickly it can be converted into cash
at low costs—its liquidity. An asset is liquid if the market in which it is traded has depth and
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 97
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
breadth, that is, if the market has many buyers and sellers. A house is not a very liquid asset
because it may be hard to find a buyer quickly; if a house must be sold to pay off bills, it might
have to be sold for a much lower price.
And the transaction costs associated with selling a house (broker’s commissions, lawyer’s fees,
and so on) are substantial. A U.S. Treasury bill, by contrast, is a highly liquid asset. It can be sold
in a well-organized market with many buyers, and so it can be sold quickly at low cost. The more
liquid an asset is relative to alternative assets, holding everything else unchanged, the more
desirable it is and the greater the quantity demanded will be.
All the determining factors we have just discussed can be assembled into the theory of portfolio
choice, which tells us how much of an asset people will want to hold in their portfolios. It states
that, holding all other factors constant:
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 98
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Example:
• If the bond sells for $950, the interest rate and expected return are
1000−950
• i = Re = 950
= 0.053 = 5.3%
The analysis of interest-rate determination looks at supply and demand in the bond market so
that we can better understand how the prices of bonds are determined. Each bond price is
associated with a particular level of the interest rate. Specifically, the negative relationship
between bond prices and interest rates means that when a bond’s price rises, its interest rate
falls, and vice versa.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 99
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
The first step in our analysis is to obtain a bond demand curve, which shows the relationship
between the quantity demanded and the price when all other economic variables are held
constant (that is, values of other variables are taken as given). The assumption that all other
economic variables are held constant is called ceteris paribus, which means “other things being
equal” in Latin.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 100
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
will be greater than at point B. Similarly, at the even lower prices of $800 (interest rate = 25%)
and $750 (interest rate = 33.3%), the quantity of bonds demanded will be even higher (points D
and E). The curve Bd, which connects these points, is the demand curve for bonds. It has the
usual downward slope, indicating that at lower prices of the bond (everything else being equal),
the quantity demanded is higher.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 101
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• The relationship between interest rate and bond price is inverse.
An important assumption behind the demand curve for bonds in Figure 1 is that all other economic
variables besides the bond’s price and interest rate are held constant. We use the same
assumption in deriving a supply curve, which shows the relationship between the quantity
supplied and the price when all other economic variables are held constant.
In Figure 1, when the price of the bonds is $750 (interest rate = 33.3%), point F shows that the
quantity of bonds supplied is $100 billion for the example we are considering. If the price is $800,
the interest rate is the lower rate of 25%. Because at this interest rate it is now less costly to
borrow by issuing bonds, firms will be willing to borrow more through bond issues, and the quantity
of bonds supplied is at the higher level of $200 billion (point G).
An even higher price of $850, corresponding to a lower interest rate of 17.6%, results in a larger
quantity of bonds supplied of $300 billion (point C). Higher prices of $900 and $950 result in even
lower interest rates and even greater quantities of bonds supplied (points H and I). The Bs curve,
which connects these points, is the supply curve for bonds. It has the usual upward slope found
in supply curves, indicating that as the price increases (everything else being equal), the quantity
supplied increases.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 102
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Figure 1
In economics, market equilibrium occurs when the amount that people are willing to buy (demand)
equals the amount that people are willing to sell (supply) at a given price. In the bond market, this
is achieved when the quantity of bonds demanded equals the quantity of bonds supplied:
Bd = Bs
In Figure 1 (in Topic 10), equilibrium occurs at point C, where the demand and supply curves
intersect at a bond price of $850 (interest rate of 17.6%) and a quantity of bonds of $300 billion.
The price of P* = 850, where the quantity demanded equals the quantity supplied, is called the
equilibrium or market-clearing price. Similarly, the interest rate of i* = 17.6% that corresponds to
this price is called the equilibrium or market-clearing interest rate.
The concepts of market equilibrium and equilibrium price or interest rate are useful because the
market tends to head toward them. We can see this in Figure 1 by first looking at what happens
when we have a bond price that is above the equilibrium price. When the price of bonds is set too
high, at, say, $950, the quantity of bonds supplied at point I is greater than the quantity of bonds
demanded at point A. A situation like this, in which the quantity of bonds supplied exceeds the
quantity of bonds demanded, is called a condition of excess supply. Because people (borrowers)
want to sell more bonds than others (lender-savers) want to buy, the price of the bonds will fall,
as shown by the downward arrow in the figure at the bond price of $950.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 103
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
As long as the bond price remains above the equilibrium price, an excess supply of bonds will
continue to be available, and the price of bonds will continue to fall. This decline will stop only
when the price has reached the equilibrium price of $850, the price at which the excess supply of
bonds has been eliminated.
Now let’s look at what happens when the price of bonds is below the equilibrium price. If the price
of the bonds is set too low, at, say, $750, the quantity demanded at point E is greater than the
quantity supplied at point F. This is called a condition of excess demand. People (lender-savers)
now want to buy more bonds than others (borrowers) are willing to sell, so the price of bonds will
be driven up, as illustrated by the upward arrow in the figure at the bond price of $750. Only when
the excess demand for bonds is eliminated by the bond price rising to the equilibrium level of $850
is there no further tendency for the price to rise.
We can see that the concept of equilibrium price is a useful one because it indicates where the
market will settle. Because each price on the vertical axis of Figure 1 corresponds to a particular
value of the interest rate, the same diagram also shows that the interest rate will head toward the
equilibrium interest rate of 17.6%. When the interest rate is below the equilibrium interest rate, as
it is when it is at 5.3%, the price of the bond is above the equilibrium price, and an excess supply
of bonds results. The price of the bond then falls, leading to a rise in the interest rate toward the
equilibrium level. Similarly, when the interest rate is above the equilibrium level, as it is when it is
at 33.3%, an excess demand for bonds occurs, and the bond price rises, driving the interest rate
back down to the equilibrium level of 17.6%.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 104
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Figure 1 is a conventional supply and demand diagram with price on the vertical axis and quantity
on the horizontal axis. Because the interest rate that corresponds to each bond price is also
marked on the vertical axis, this diagram allows us to read the equilibrium interest rate, giving us
a model that describes the determination of interest rates. It is important to recognize that a supply
and demand diagram like Figure 1 can be drawn for any type of bond because the interest rate
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 105
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
and price of a bond are always negatively related for all kinds of bonds, whether a discount bond
or a coupon bond.
An important feature of the analysis here is that supply and demand are always described in terms
of stocks (amounts at a given point in time) of assets, not in terms of flows. The asset market
approach for understanding behavior in financial markets—which emphasizes stocks of assets,
rather than flows, in determining asset prices—is the dominant methodology used by economists,
because correctly conducting analyses in terms of flows is very tricky, especially when we
encounter inflation.
The theory of portfolio choice, provides a framework for deciding which factors will cause the
demand curve for bonds to shift. These factors include changes in the following four parameters:
1. Wealth
2. Expected returns on bonds relative to alternative assets
3. Risk of bonds relative to alternative assets
4. Liquidity of bonds relative to alternative assets
To see how a change in each of these factors (holding all other factors constant) can shift the
demand curve, let’s look at some examples. (As a study aid, Table 2 summarizes the effects of
changes in these factors on the bond demand curve.)
Wealth When the economy is growing rapidly in a business cycle expansion and wealth is
increasing, the quantity of bonds demanded at each bond price (or interest rate) increases, as
shown in Figure 2. To see how this works, consider point B on the initial demand curve for bonds,
Bd 1. With higher wealth, the quantity of bonds demanded at the same price must rise, to point
B′. Similarly, for point D, the higher wealth causes the quantity demanded at the same bond price
to rise to point D′. Continuing with this reasoning for every point on the initial demand curve Bd 1,
we can see that the demand curve shifts to the right from Bd 1 to Bd 2, as indicated by the arrows.
We can conclude that in a business cycle expansion with growing income and wealth, the demand
for bonds rises and the demand curve for bonds shifts to the right. Applying the same reasoning,
in a recession, when income and wealth are falling, the demand for bonds falls, and the demand
curve shifts to the left. Another factor that affects wealth is the public’s propensity to save. If
households save more, wealth increases and, as we have seen, the demand for bonds rises and
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 106
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
the demand curve for bonds shifts to the right. Conversely, if people save less, wealth and the
demand for bonds fall, and the demand curve shifts to the left.
Expected Returns For a one-year discount bond and a one-year holding period, the expected
return and the interest rate are identical, so nothing other than today’s interest rate affects the
expected return. For bonds with maturities of greater than one year, the expected return may
differ from the interest rate. A rise in the interest rate on a long-term bond from 10% to 20% would
lead to a sharp decline in price and a very large negative return. Hence, if people began to think
that interest rates would be higher next year than they had originally anticipated, the expected
return today on long-term bonds would fall, and the quantity demanded would fall at each interest
rate. Higher expected future interest rates lower the expected return for long-term bonds,
decrease the demand, and shift the demand curve to the left.
By contrast, an expectation of lower future interest rates would mean that long-term bond prices
would be expected to rise more than originally anticipated, and the resulting higher expected
return today would raise the quantity demanded at each bond price and interest rate. Lower
expected future interest rates increase the demand for long-term bonds and shift the demand
curve to the right (as in Figure 2).
Changes in expected returns on other assets can also shift the demand curve for bonds. If people
suddenly become more optimistic about the stock market and begin to expect higher stock prices
in the future, both expected capital gains and expected returns on stocks will rise. With the
expected return on bonds held constant, the expected return on bonds today relative to stocks
will fall, lowering the demand for bonds and shifting the demand curve to the left. An increase in
expected return on alternative assets lowers the demand for bonds and shifts the demand curve
to the left.
A change in expected inflation is likely to alter expected returns on physical assets (also called
real assets), such as automobiles and houses, which affect the demand for bonds. An increase
in expected inflation from, say, 5% to 10% will lead to higher prices on cars and houses in the
future and hence higher nominal capital gains. The resulting rise in the expected returns today on
these real assets will lead to a fall in the expected return on bonds relative to the expected return
on real assets today and thus cause the demand for bonds to fall. Alternatively, we can think of
the rise in expected inflation as lowering the real interest rate on bonds, and thus the resulting
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 107
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
decline in the relative expected return on bonds will cause the demand for bonds to fall. An
increase in the expected rate of inflation lowers the expected return on bonds, causing their
demand to decline and the demand curve to shift to the left.
Risk If prices in the bond market become more volatile, the risk associated with bonds increases,
and bonds become a less attractive asset. An increase in the riskiness of bonds causes the
demand for bonds to fall and the demand curve to shift to the left. Conversely, an increase in the
volatility of prices in another asset market, such as the stock market, would make bonds more
attractive. An increase in the riskiness of alternative assets causes the demand for bonds to rise
and the demand curve to shift to the right (as in Figure 2).
Liquidity If more people started trading in the bond market, and as a result it became easier to
sell bonds quickly, the increase in their liquidity would cause the quantity of bonds demanded at
each interest rate to rise. Increased liquidity of bonds results in an increased demand for bonds,
and the demand curve shifts to the right (see Figure 2). Similarly, increased liquidity of alternative
assets lowers the demand for bonds and shifts the demand curve to the left. The reduction of
brokerage commissions for trading common stocks that occurred when the fixed-rate commission
structure was abolished in 1975, for example, increased the liquidity of stocks relative to bonds,
and the resulting lower demand for bonds shifted the demand curve to the left.
Figure 2
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 108
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
TOPIC 071: SHIFTS IN THE SUPPLY OF BONDS
Certain factors can cause the supply curve for bonds to shift. Among these factors are:
1. Expected profitability of investment opportunities
2. Expected inflation
3. Government budget deficits
We will look at how the supply curve shifts when each of these factors changes (all others
remaining constant). (As a study aid, Table 3 summarizes the effects of changes in these factors
on the bond supply curve.) bonds, and the resulting lower demand for bonds shifted the demand
curve to the left.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 109
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Figure 3
Expected Profitability of Investment Opportunities When opportunities for profitable plant and
equipment investments are plentiful, firms are more willing to borrow to finance these investments.
When the economy is growing rapidly, as in a business cycle expansion, investment opportunities
that are expected to be profitable abound, and the quantity of bonds supplied at any given bond
price increases (for example, from G to G′ or H to H′ in Figure 3). Therefore, in a business cycle
expansion, the supply of bonds increases and the supply curve shifts to the right.
Likewise, in a recession, when far fewer profitable investment opportunities are expected,
the supply of bonds falls and the supply curve shifts to the left.
Expected Inflation The real cost of borrowing is most accurately measured by the real interest
rate, which equals the (nominal) interest rate minus the expected inflation rate. For a given interest
rate (and bond price), when expected inflation increases, the real cost of borrowing falls; hence,
the quantity of bonds supplied increases at any given bond price. An increase in expected
inflation causes the supply of bonds to increase and the supply curve to shift to the right
(see Figure 3), and a decrease in expected inflation causes the supply of bonds to decrease
and the supply curve to shift to the left.
Government Budget Deficits The activities of the government can influence the supply of bonds
in several ways. The U.S. Treasury issues bonds to finance government deficits, caused by gaps
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 110
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
between the government’s expenditures and its revenues. When these deficits are large, the
Treasury sells more bonds, and the quantity of bonds supplied at each bond price increases.
Higher government deficits increase the supply of bonds and shift the supply curve to the
right (see Figure 3). On the other hand, government surpluses, as occurred in the late
1990s, decrease the supply of bonds and shift the supply curve to the left.
State and local governments and other government agencies also issue bonds to finance their
expenditures, and this can affect the supply of bonds as well. The conduct of monetary policy
involves the purchase and sale of bonds, which in turn influences the supply of bonds. We now
can use our knowledge of how supply and demand curves shift to analyze how the equilibrium
interest rate can change. The best way to do this is to pursue several applications that are
particularly relevant to our understanding of how monetary policy affects interest rates. In studying
these applications, keep two things in mind:
1. When we examine the effect of a variable change, remember we are assuming that all
other variables are unchanged; that is, we are making use of the ceteris paribus
assumption.
2. Remember that the interest rate is negatively related to the bond price, so when the
equilibrium bond price rises, the equilibrium interest rate falls. Conversely, if the
equilibrium bond price moves downward, the equilibrium interest rate rises.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 111
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
The Fisher Effect is an economic theory created by economist Irving Fisher that describes the
relationship between inflation and both real and nominal interest rates. The Fisher Effect states
that the real interest rate equals the nominal interest rate minus the expected inflation rate.
Therefore, real interest rates fall as inflation increases, unless nominal rates increase at the same
rate as inflation.
Fisher's equation reflects that the real interest rate can be taken by subtracting the expected
inflation rate from the nominal interest rate. In this equation, all the provided rates are
compounded.
The Fisher Effect can be seen each time you go to the bank; the interest rate an investor has on
a savings account is really the nominal interest rate. For example, if the nominal interest rate on
a savings account is 4% and the expected rate of inflation is 3%, then the money in the savings
account is really growing at 1%. The smaller the real interest rate, the longer it will take for savings
deposits to grow substantially when observed from a purchasing power perspective.
Suppose that expected inflation is initially 5% and the initial supply and demand curves
Bs 1 and Bd 1 intersect at point 1, where the equilibrium bond price is P1. If expected inflation
rises to 10%, the expected return on bonds relative to real assets falls for any given
bond price and interest rate. As a result, the demand for bonds falls, and the demand
curve shifts to the left from Bd 1 to Bd 2. The rise in expected inflation also shifts the supply
curve. At any given bond price and interest rate, the real cost of borrowing declines,
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 112
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
causing the quantity of bonds supplied to increase and the supply curve to shift to the
right, from Bs1 to Bs2.
When the demand and supply curves shift in response to the rise in expected inflation, the
equilibrium moves from point 1 to point 2, at the intersection of Bd 2 and Bs 2.
The equilibrium bond price falls from P1 to P2 and, because the bond price is negatively
related to the interest rate, this means that the equilibrium interest rate rises. Note that
Figure 4 has been drawn so that the equilibrium quantity of bonds remains the same at
both point 1 and point 2. However, depending on the size of the shifts in the supply and
demand curves, the equilibrium quantity of bonds can either rise or fall when expected
inflation rises.
Our supply and demand analysis has led us to an important observation: When
expected inflation rises, interest rates will rise. This result has been named the Fisher
effect, after Irving Fisher, the economist who first pointed out the relationship of
expected inflation to interest rates.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 113
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 15
RISK STRUCTURE OF INTEREST RATES
Bonds with the same maturity have different interest rates due to:
– Default risk
– Liquidity
– Tax considerations
– Term to maturity
Default risk: probability that the issuer of the bond is unable or unwilling to make interest payments
or pay off the face value
– Treasury bonds are considered default free (government can raise taxes).
– Risk premium: the spread between the interest rates on bonds with default risk
and the interest rates on (same maturity) Treasury bonds.
Response to an Increase in Default Risk on Corporate Bonds
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 114
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Interest rate behavior for bonds of the same maturity shows two important features: Interest rates
on different categories of bonds, although they generally move together, differ from one another
in any given year, and the spread (or difference) between the interest rates varies over time. The
interest rates on municipal bonds, for example, were higher than those on U.S. government
(Treasury) bonds in the late 1930s but lower thereafter. In addition, the spread between the
interest rates on Baa corporate bonds (riskier than Aaa corporate bonds) and U.S. government
bonds was very large during the Great Depression years from 1930 to 1933, was smaller during
the 1940s–1960s, and then widened again afterward, particularly during the global financial crisis
from 2007 to 2009. Which factors are responsible for these phenomena?
Default Risk
One attribute of a bond that influences its interest rate is its risk of default. Default occurs when
the issuer of the bond is unable or unwilling to make interest payments when promised or pay off
the face value when the bond matures.
Corporations suffering big losses, such as the major airline companies like United, Delta, US
Airways, and Northwest in the mid-2000s, and then American Airlines in 2011, might be more
likely to suspend interest payments on their bonds. The default risk on their bonds
would therefore be quite high. By contrast, U.S. Treasury bonds have usually been
considered to have no default risk because the federal government can always increase
taxes or print money to pay off its obligations. Bonds like these with no default risk are
called default-free bonds.
To examine the effect of default risk on interest rates, let’s look at the supply and
demand diagrams for the default-free (U.S. Treasury) and corporate long-term bond
markets in Figure 2. To make the diagrams somewhat easier to read, let’s assume that
initially corporate bonds have the same default risk as U.S. Treasury bonds. In this
case, these two bonds have the same attributes (identical risk and maturity); their equilibrium
prices and interest rates will initially be equal (Pc 1 = PT 1 and ic 1 = iT 1), and
the risk premium on corporate bonds (ic 1 - iT 1) will be zero.
The demand curve for corporate bonds in panel (a) of Figure 2 then shifts to the left, from Dc 1 to
Dc 2. At the same time, the expected return on default-free Treasury bonds increases relative to
the expected return on corporate bonds, while their relative riskiness declines.
The Treasury bonds thus become more desirable, and demand rises, as shown in panel
(b) by the rightward shift in the demand curve for these bonds from DT 1 to DT 2.
As we can see in Figure 2, the equilibrium price for corporate bonds falls from Pc 1 to
Pc 2, and since the bond price is negatively correlated to the interest rate, the equilibrium
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 116
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
interest rate on corporate bonds rises to ic 2. At the same time, however, the equilibrium
price for the Treasury bonds rises from PT 1 to PT 2 and the equilibrium interest rate falls to iT 2.
The spread between the interest rates on corporate and default-free bonds—that is, the risk
premium on corporate bonds—has risen from zero to ic 2 - iT 2.
We can now conclude that a bond with default risk will always have a positive risk premium, and
an increase in its default risk will raise the risk premium. Because default risk is so important to
the size of the risk premium, purchasers of bonds need to know whether a corporation is likely to
default on its bonds. This information is provided by credit-rating agencies, investment advisory
firms that rate the quality of corporate and municipal bonds in terms of their probability of default.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 117
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
assigned to any entity that seeks to borrow money—an individual, a corporation, a state or
provincial authority, or a sovereign government.
Individual credit scores are calculated by credit bureaus such as Experian, Equifax, and
TransUnion on a three-digit numerical scale using a form of Fair Isaac Corporation (FICO) credit
scoring. Credit ratings for companies and governments are calculated by a credit rating agency
such as S&P Global, Moody’s, or Fitch Ratings. These rating agencies are paid by the entity
seeking a credit rating for itself or one of its debt issues.
Examples
Fitch Ratings
John Knowles Fitch founded the Fitch Publishing Company in 1913, providing financial statistics
for use in the investment industry via "The Fitch Stock and Bond Manual" and "The Fitch Bond
Book." In 1924, Fitch developed and introduced the AAA through D rating system that has become
the basis for ratings throughout the industry.
In the late 1990s, with plans to become a full-service global rating agency, Fitch Ratings merged
with IBCA of London, a subsidiary of Fimalac, S.A., a French holding company. Fitch also
acquired market competitors Thomson BankWatch and Duff & Phelps Credit Rating Co.
Beginning in 2004, Fitch started to develop operating subsidiaries specializing in enterprise risk
management, data services, and finance-industry training with the acquisition of a Canadian
company, Algorithmics, and the creation of Fitch Solutions and Fitch Learning.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 118
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Treasury bonds are the most liquid of all long-term bonds; because they are so widely traded,
they are the easiest to sell quickly, and the cost of selling them is low. Corporate bonds are not
as liquid because fewer bonds for any one corporation are traded; thus it can be costly to sell
these bonds in an emergency because it might be hard to find buyers quickly.
• Liquidity: the relative ease with which an asset can be converted into cash
• The more liquid an asset is, the more desirable it is (holding everything else constant).
• Treasury bonds are the most liquid of all long-term bonds; because they are so widely
traded, they are the easiest to sell quickly, and the cost of selling them is low.
• Corporate bonds are not as liquid because fewer bonds for any one corporation are
traded; it can be costly to sell these bonds in an emergency because it might be hard to
find buyers quickly.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 119
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• The lower liquidity of corporate bonds relative to Treasury bonds increases the spread
between the interest rates on these two bonds.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 120
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 16
RISK STRUCTURE OF INTEREST RATES (CONTINUED)
Example:
Suppose income tax is 40%.
For every extra 100 rupees of income you earn, you have to pay 40 rupees to the government. If
you own a Rs 1,000-face-value Treasury bond that sells for Rs 1,000 and has a coupon payment
of Rs 100, you get to keep only Rs 60 of the payment after taxes. Although the bond has a 10%
interest rate, you actually earn only 6.0% after taxes.
Summary
• Interest Rates will be LOWER if:
– default risk is low
– Liquidity is high, and
– the income tax is exempted or very low
Bonds with identical risk, liquidity, and tax characteristics may have different interest rates
because their times remaining to maturity are different.
A plot of the yields on bonds with differing terms to maturity but the same risk, liquidity,
and tax considerations is called a yield curve.
The three key types of yield curves include normal, inverted and flat. Upward sloping (also
known as normal yield curves) is where longer-term bonds have higher yields than short-
term ones.
While normal curves point to economic expansion, downward sloping (inverted) curves
point to economic recession.
Yield curves can also have more complicated shapes in which they first slope up and then down,
or vice versa. Why does the yield curve usually slope upward, but sometimes take on other
shapes?
In addition to explaining why yield curves take on different shapes at different times, a good theory
of the term structure of interest rates must explain the following three important empirical facts:
1. Interest rates on bonds of different maturities move together over time.
2. When short-term interest rates are low, yield curves are more likely to have an upward slope;
when short-term interest rates are high, yield curves are more likely to slope downward and be
inverted.
3. Yield curves almost always slope upward.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 122
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Movements over Time of Interest Rates on U.S. Government Bonds with Different
Maturities
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 123
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Theories that explain Yield Curve Patterns
Three theories explain the term structure of interest rates—that is, the relationships among
interest rates on bonds of different maturities reflected in yield curve patterns
(1) The expectations theory
(2) The segmented markets theory
(3) The liquidity premium theory
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 124
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
LESSON 17
VARIOUS THEORIES OF TERM STRUCTURE OF INTEREST RATES
The expectations theory of the term structure states the following commonsense proposition: The
interest rate on a long-term bond will equal the average of the short-term interest rates that people
expect to occur over the life of the long-term bond. For example, if people expect that short-term
interest rates will be 10%, on average, over the coming five years, the expectations theory predicts
that the interest rate on bonds with five years to maturity will be 10%, too.
If short-term interest rates are expected to rise even higher after this five-year period, so that the
average short-term interest rate over the coming 20 years is 11%, then the interest rate on 20-
year bonds will equal 11% and will be higher than the interest rate on five-year bonds. Thus the
expectations theory predicts that interest rates on bonds of different maturities differ because
short-term interest rates are expected to have different values at future dates.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 125
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
The key assumption behind this theory is that buyers of bonds do not prefer bonds of one maturity
over another, so they will not hold any quantity of a bond if its expected return is less than that of
another bond with a different maturity. Bonds that have this characteristic are said to be perfect
substitutes. In practice, this means that if bonds with different maturities are perfect substitutes,
then the expected returns on those bonds must be equal.
To see how the assumption that bonds with different maturities are perfect substitutes leads to
the expectations theory, let us consider the following two investment strategies:
1. Purchase a one-year bond, and when it matures in one year, purchase another one year bond.
2. Purchase a two-year bond and hold it until maturity.
Because both strategies must have the same expected return, the interest rate on the two-year
bond must equal the average of the two one-year interest rates. For example, let us say that the
current interest rate on the one-year bond is 9%, and you expect the interest rate on the one-year
bond next year to be 11%. If you pursue the first strategy of buying the two one-year bonds, the
expected return over the two years will average out to be (9% + 11%)>2 = 10% per year. You will
be willing to hold both the one and two-year bonds only if the expected return per year on the two-
year bond equals this return. Therefore, the interest rate on the two-year bond must equal 10%,
the average interest rate on the two one-year bonds.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 126
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• For example, if you are putting away funds for your young child to go to college in the
future, your desired holding period will be much longer, and you will want to hold longer-
term bonds.
• The risk-averse investors have short desired holding periods and generally prefer bonds
with shorter maturities that have less interest-rate risk.
• The segmented markets theory can explain fact 3, which states that yield curves typically
slope upward.
• The demand for long-term bonds is typically relatively lower than that for short-term bonds,
long-term bonds will have lower prices and higher interest rates, and hence the yield curve
will typically slope upward.
As the name suggests, the segmented markets theory of the term structure sees markets for
different-maturity bonds as completely separate and segmented. The interest rate on a bond of a
particular maturity is then determined by the supply of and demand for that bond and is not
affected by expected returns on other bonds with other maturities.
The key assumption of the segmented markets theory is that bonds of different maturities are not
substitutes at all, and so the expected return from holding a bond of one maturity has no effect on
the demand for a bond of another maturity. This theory of the term structure is the opposite
extreme of the expectations theory, which assumes that bonds of different maturities are perfect
substitutes.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 127
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
assumed to be substitutes, but not perfect substitutes. Investors tend to prefer
shorter-term bonds because these bonds bear less interest-rate risk.
For this reason, investors must be offered a positive liquidity premium to induce them to hold long-
term bonds. Thus the expectations theory is modified by adding a positive liquidity
premium to the equation that describes the relationship between long- and short-term
interest rates. The liquidity premium theory is written as
where:
nt is the liquidity (term) premium for the n-period bond at time t, which is always positive and rises
with the term to maturity of the bond, n.
• The liquidity premium theory of the term structure states that the interest rate on a long-
term bond will equal an average of short-term interest rates expected to occur over the life
of the long-term bond plus a liquidity premium (also referred to as a term premium) that
responds to supply and demand conditions for that bond.
Key Assumption:
• Bonds of different maturities are substitutes, which means that the expected return on one
bond does influence the expected return on a bond of a different maturity.
• However, the theory allows investors to prefer one bond maturity over another.
• Bonds of different maturities are assumed to be substitutes, but not perfect substitutes.
• Investors tend to prefer shorter-term bonds because these bonds bear less interest-rate
risk.
• Investors must be offered a positive liquidity premium to induce them to hold longer-term
bonds. Thus the expectations theory is modified by adding a positive liquidity premium to
the equation that describes the relationship between long- and short-term interest rates.
It assumes that investors have a preference for bonds of one maturity over bonds of another—a
particular bond maturity (“preferred habitat”) in which they prefer to invest. Because they prefer
bonds of one maturity over bonds of another, they are willing to buy bonds that do not have the
preferred maturity (habitat) only if those bonds earn a somewhat higher expected return. Because
risk averse investors are likely to prefer the habitat of short-term bonds over that of longer-term
bonds, they are willing to hold long-term bonds only if they have higher expected returns. This
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 129
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
reasoning leads to the same Equation 3 implied by the liquidity premium theory, with a term
premium that typically rises with maturity.
The relationship between the expectations theory and the liquidity premium and preferred habitat
theories is shown in Figure 5. There we see that because the liquidity premium is always positive
and typically grows as the term to maturity increases, the yield curve implied by the liquidity
premium theory is always above the yield curve implied by the expectations theory and generally
has a steeper slope.
(For simplicity, we are assuming that the expectations theory yield curve is flat.) A simple
numerical example, similar to the one we used for the expectations hypothesis, further clarifies
the liquidity premium and preferred habitat theories given in Equation 3. Again suppose that the
one-year interest rates over the next five years are expected to be 5%, 6%, 7%, 8%, and 9%,
while investors’ preferences for holding short-term bonds means that the liquidity premiums for
one- to five-year bonds are 0%, 0.25%, 0.5%, 0.75%, and 1.0%, respectively.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 130
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• Figure shown on the next slide illustrates several yield curves for U.S. government bonds,
for selected dates from 1981 to 2017.
• What do these yield curves tell us about the public’s expectations of future movements of
short-term interest rates?
The steep inverted yield curve that occurred on January 15, 1981 indicated that short-term interest
rates were expected to decline sharply in the future. In order for longer-term interest rates, along
with their positive liquidity premiums, to be well below short-term interest rates, short-term interest
rates must be expected to decline so sharply that their average would be far below the current
short-term rate. Indeed, the public’s expectations of sharply lower short-term interest rates evident
in the yield curve were realized soon after January 15; by March, three-month Treasury bill rates
had declined from the 16% level to 13%.
The steep, upward-sloping yield curves that occurred on March 28, 1985, and July 24, 2017,
indicated that short-term interest rates were expected to climb in the future. Long-term interest
rates are higher than short-term interest rates when short-term interest rates are expected to rise
because their average plus the liquidity premium will be higher than the current short-term rate.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 131
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
The moderately upward-sloping yield curves on May 16, 1980, and March 3, 1997, indicated that
short-term interest rates were expected neither to rise nor to fall in the near future. In this case,
their average remains the same as the current short-term rate, and the positive liquidity premium
for longer-term bonds explains the moderate upward slope of the yield curve. The flat yield curve
of February 6, 2006, indicated that short-term interest rates were expected to fall slightly.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 132
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
LESSON 18
Common stock is the principal medium through which corporations raise equity capital.
Stockholders—those who hold stock in a corporation—own an interest in the corporation equal to
the percentage of outstanding shares they own. This ownership interest gives them a bundle of
rights. The most important are the right to vote and to be a residual claimant of all funds flowing
into the firm (known as cash flows), meaning that the stockholder receives whatever remains after
all other claims against the firm’s assets have been satisfied. Stockholders may receive dividends
from the net earnings of the corporation. Dividends are payments made periodically, usually every
quarter, to stockholders. The board of directors of the firm sets the level of the dividend, usually
based on the recommendation of management. In addition, the stockholder has the right to sell
the stock.
One basic principle of finance is that the value of any investment is calculated by computing the
present value of all cash flows the investment will generate over its life. For example, a
commercial building will sell for a price that reflects the net cash flows (rents minus expenses) it
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 133
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
is projected to have over its useful life. Similarly, we value common stock as the value in today’s
dollars of all future cash flows. The cash flows that a stockholder might earn from stock are
dividends, the sales price, or both.
To develop the theory of stock valuation, we begin with the simplest possible scenario: You buy
the stock, hold it for one period to get a dividend, then sell the stock. We call this the one-period
valuation model.
Suppose that you have some extra money to invest for one year. After a year, you will
need to sell your investment to pay tuition. After watching CNBC or Nightly Business
Report on TV, you decide that you want to buy Intel Corp. stock. You call your broker
and find that Intel is currently selling for $50 per share and pays $0.16 per year in dividends. The
analyst on CNBC predicts that the stock will be selling for $60 in one year.
Should you buy this stock?
To answer this question, you need to determine whether the current price accurately reflects the
analyst’s forecast. To value the stock today, you need to find the present discounted value of the
expected cash flows (future payments) using the formula given below. In this equation, the
discount factor used to discount the cash flows is the required return on investments in equity
rather than the interest rate. The cash flows consist of one dividend payment plus a final sales
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 134
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
price. When these cash flows are discounted back to the present, the following equation computes
the current price of the stock:
•
• = Rs. 0.14 +Rs 53.57
• = Rs. 53.71
Example
• Market price < Present Value
• Be aware that the stock may be selling for less than Rs. 53.71, because other investors
have placed a greater risk on the cash flows or estimated the cash flows to be less than
you did.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 135
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 136
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
TOPIC 089: THE THEORY OF RATIONAL EXPECTATIONS
The analysis of stock price evaluation we outlined in the previous section depends on people’s
expectations—especially expectations of cash flows. Indeed, it is difficult to think of any sector of
the economy in which expectations are not crucial; this is why it is important to examine how
expectations are formed. We do so by outlining the theory of rational expectations, currently the
most widely used theory to describe the formation of business and consumer expectations.
In the 1950s and 1960s, economists regularly viewed expectations as formed from past
experience only. Expectations of inflation, for example, were typically viewed as being an average
of past inflation rates. This view of expectation formation, called adaptive expectations, suggests
that changes in expectations will occur slowly over time, as data for a variable evolve. So, if
inflation had formerly been steady at a 5% rate, expectations of future inflation would be 5%, too.
If inflation rose to a steady rate of 10%, expectations of future inflation would rise toward 10%,
but slowly: In the first year, expected inflation might rise only to 6%; in the second year, to 7%;
and so on.
The adaptive expectations hypothesis has been faulted on the grounds that people use more
information than just past data on a single variable to form their expectations of that variable.
Their expectations of inflation will almost surely be affected by their predictions of future monetary
policy, as well as by current and past monetary policy.
In addition, people often change their expectations quickly in the light of new information. To
address these objections to the validity of adaptive expectations, John Muth developed an
alternative theory of expectations, called rational expectations, which can be stated as follows:
Expectations will be identical to optimal forecasts (the best guess of the future) using all available
information.
What exactly does this mean? To explain it more clearly, let’s use the theory of rational
expectations to examine how expectations are formed in a situation that most of us will encounter
at some point in our lifetime: our drive to work. Suppose that if Joe Commuter travels when it is
not rush hour, his trip takes an average of 30 minutes. Sometimes his trip takes 35 minutes; other
times, 25 minutes; but the average, non rush-hour driving time is 30 minutes. If, however, Joe
leaves for work during the rush hour, it takes him, on average, an additional 10 minutes to get to
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 137
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
work. Given that he leaves for work during the rush hour, the best guess of his driving time—the
optimal forecast—is 40 minutes.
If the only information available to Joe before he leaves for work related to his driving time is that
he is leaving during the rush hour, what does rational expectations theory allow you to predict
about Joe’s expectations of his driving time? Since the best guess of his driving time, using all
available information, is 40 minutes, Joe’s expectation should be the same. Clearly, an
expectation of 35 minutes would not be rational, because it is not equal to the optimal forecast,
or the best guess of the driving time.
Rational Expectations
• In the 1950s and 1960s, economists regularly viewed expectations as formed from past
experience only.
• Stock price valuation depends on expectations
• But how are expectations formed?
• One model of expectations formation is the theory of rational expectations.
• John Muth ‘Expectations will be identical to optimal forecasts (the best guess of the future)
using all available information’
Adaptive Expectations
• Expectations of inflation, for example, were typically viewed as being an average of past
inflation rates. This view of expectation formation, called adaptive expectations, suggests
that changes in expectations will occur slowly over time, as data for a variable evolve.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 138
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
LESSON 19
EFFICIENT MARKET HYPOTHESIS
TOPIC 090: EFFICIENT MARKET HYPOTHESIS
• It is an application of rational expectations to the pricing of stocks and other securities.
• It was developed from economist Eugene Fama's Ph.D. dissertation in the 1960s.
• It is based on the assumption that prices of securities in financial markets fully reflect all
available information.
• Return can be calculated using formula:
𝑃𝑡+1 − 𝑃𝑡 +𝐶
R=
𝑃𝑡
• R = rate of return on the security held from time t to time t + 1
• Pt + 1 = price of the security at time t + 1 (the end of the holding period)
• Pt = price of the security at time t (the beginning of the holding period)
• C = cash payment (coupon or dividend payments) made in the period t to t + 1
• Expected Return can be calculated using:
𝑒
𝑃𝑡+1 − 𝑃𝑡 +𝐶
• 𝑅𝑒 =
𝑃𝑡
While monetary economists were developing the theory of rational expectations, financial
economists were developing a parallel theory of expectations formation for financial markets. It
led them to the same conclusion as that of the rational expectations theorists: Expectations in
financial markets are equal to optimal forecasts using all available information. Although financial
economists, such as Eugene Fama, later a winner of the Nobel Prize in economics, gave their
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 139
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
theory another name, calling it the efficient market hypothesis, in fact their theory is just an
application of rational expectations to the pricing of stocks and other securities.
The efficient market hypothesis is based on the assumption that prices of securities in financial
markets fully reflect all available information. The rate of return from holding a security equals the
sum of the capital gain on the security (the change in the price), plus any cash payments, divided
by the initial purchase price of the security.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 140
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 141
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
To see why the efficient market hypothesis makes sense, we make use of the concept
of arbitrage, in which market participants (arbitrageurs) eliminate unexploited profit
opportunities, that is, returns on a security that are larger than what is justified by the
characteristics of that security. Arbitrage is of two types: pure arbitrage, in which the
elimination of unexploited profit opportunities involves no risk, and the type of arbitrage we discuss
here, in which the arbitrageur takes on some risk when eliminating
the unexploited profit opportunities.
To see how arbitrage leads to the efficient market hypothesis given a security’s risk
characteristics, let’s look at an example. Suppose the
normal return on ExxonMobil common stock is 10% at an annual rate, and its current
price Pt is lower than the optimal forecast of tomorrow’s price Po t f+ 1, so that the optimal
forecast of the return at an annual rate is 50%, which is greater than the equilibrium
return of 10%.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 142
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 143
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Source: https://tradingeconomics.com/pakistan/stock-market
The term random walk describes the movements of a variable whose future values
cannot be predicted (are random) because, given today’s value, the value of the variable
is just as likely to fall as it is to rise. An important implication of the efficient market
hypothesis is that stock prices should approximately follow a random walk; that is
future changes in stock prices should, for all practical purposes, be unpredictable.
The random-walk implication of the efficient market hypothesis is the one most commonly
mentioned in the press because it is the most readily comprehensible to the public. In fact, when
people mention the “random-walk theory of stock prices,” they are in
reality referring to the efficient market hypothesis.
The case for random-walk stock prices can be demonstrated. Suppose people
could predict that the price of Happy Feet Corporation (HFC) stock would rise 1% in
the coming week. The predicted rate of capital gains and rate of return on HFC stock
would then exceed 50% at an annual rate. Since this is very likely to be far higher than
the equilibrium rate of return on HFC stock (Rof > R*), the efficient market hypothesis
indicates that people would immediately buy this stock and bid up its current price.
The action would stop only when the predictable change in the price dropped to near
zero, so that Rof = R*.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 144
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Similarly, if people could predict that the price of HFC stock would fall by 1%, the
predicted rate of return would be negative (Rof < R*), and people would immediately
sell the stock. The current price would fall until the predictable change in the price rose
back to near zero, where the efficient market condition again would hold.
The efficient
market hypothesis suggests that the predictable change in stock prices will be near zero, leading
to the conclusion that stock prices will generally follow a random walk.6
As the Global Box “Should Foreign Exchange Rates Follow a Random Walk?” indicates,
the efficient market hypothesis suggests that foreign exchange rates should also follow
a random walk.
Though the efficient market hypothesis (EMH), as a whole, theorizes that the market is generally
efficient, the theory is offered in three different versions: weak; semi-strong; and strong. The
basic efficient market hypothesis posits that the market cannot be beaten because it incorporates
all important determining information into current share prices. Therefore, stocks trade at the
fairest value, meaning that they can't be purchased undervalued or sold overvalued. The theory
determines that the only opportunity investors have to gain higher returns on their investments
is through purely speculative investments that pose a substantial risk.
Weak Form
The three versions of the efficient market hypothesis are varying degrees of the same basic
theory. The weak form suggests that today’s stock prices reflect all the data of past prices and
that no form of technical analysis can be effectively utilized to aid investors in making trading
decisions.
Advocates for the weak form efficiency theory believe that if the fundamental analysis is used,
undervalued and overvalued stocks can be determined, and investors can research
companies' financial statements to increase their chances of making higher-than-market-
average profits.
Semi-Strong Form
The semi-strong form efficiency theory follows the belief that because all information that is
public is used in the calculation of a stock's current price, investors cannot utilize either technical
or fundamental analysis to gain higher returns in the market.
Those who subscribe to this version of the theory believe that only information that is not readily
available to the public can help investors boost their returns to a performance level above that
of the general market.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 146
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Strong Form
The strong form version of the efficient market hypothesis states that all information—both the
information available to the public and any information not publicly known—is completely
accounted for in current stock prices, and there is no type of information that can give an investor
an advantage on the market.
Advocates for this degree of the theory suggest that investors cannot make returns on
investments that exceed normal market returns, regardless of information retrieved or research
conducted.
If you follow the stock market, you might have noticed a puzzling phenomenon:
When good news about a corporation, such as a particularly favorable earnings
report, is announced, the price of the corporation’s stock frequently does not rise. The efficient
market hypothesis explains this phenomenon.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 147
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
price response will occur. This is exactly what the evidence shows: Stock prices do
reflect publicly available information.
On October 19, 1987, dubbed “Black Monday,” the Dow Jones Industrial Average
declined by more than 20%, the largest one-day decline in U.S. history. The collapse
of the high-tech companies’ share prices from their peaks in March 2000 caused the
heavily tech-laden NASDAQ index to fall from about 5,000 in March 2000 to about
1,500 in 2001 and 2002, a decline of well over 60%. These stock market crashes
caused many economists to question the validity of the efficient market hypothesis.
These economists do not believe that a rational marketplace could have produced
such a massive swing in share prices.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 148
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
To what degree should these stock market
crashes make us doubt the validity of the efficient market hypothesis? Nothing in efficient markets
theory rules out large changes in stock prices. A
large change in stock prices can result from new information that produces a dramatic
decline in optimal forecasts of the future valuation of firms. However, economists are
hard pressed to find fundamental changes in the economy that would have caused the
Black Monday and tech crashes. One lesson from these crashes is that factors other than
market fundamentals probably have an effect on asset prices. There are good reasons to believe
that impediments to the proper
functioning of financial markets do exist.
However, nothing in
this view contradicts the basic reasoning behind rational expectations or the efficient
market hypothesis—that market participants eliminate unexploited profit opportunities. Even
though stock market prices may not always solely reflect market fundamentals, as long as market
crashes are unpredictable, the basic premises of efficient markets
theory hold.
However, other economists believe that market crashes and bubbles suggest that
unexploited profit opportunities may exist and that the efficient market hypothesis
might be fundamentally flawed. The controversy over the efficient market hypothesis
continues.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 149
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
LESSON 20
ASYMMETRIC INFORMATION AND THE LEMONS PROBLEM
TOPIC 096: BEHAVIORAL FINANCE
Doubts about the efficiency of financial markets, triggered by the stock market crash
of 1987, led economists such as Nobel Prize winner Robert Shiller to develop a new
field of study called behavioral finance.
It applies concepts from other social sciences,
such as anthropology, sociology, and particularly psychology, to explain the behavior
of securities prices.
One of the arguments of EMH is that unexploited profit is eliminated by knowledgeable
investors. For this to happen they must engage in short selling.
Short selling – borrowing the stock from brokers and then sell it in the market with the aim
of making a profit by buying the stock back at a lower price.
Psychologists suggest that people are subject to ‘loss aversion’. They are unhappy from
losses than happy with equivalent gains. Because the potential losses can be huge from
short selling in reality short selling occurs only in special circumstances.
Psychologists also find that people tend to be overconfident in their own judgements.
They trade on their beliefs rather than on pure facts.
Overconfidence and social contagion (fad) explain the creation of speculative bubbles.
As we have seen, the efficient market hypothesis assumes that unexploited profit
opportunities are eliminated by “smart money” market participants. But can smart
money dominate ordinary investors so that financial markets are efficient? Specifically,
the efficient market hypothesis suggests that smart money participants will sell when a
stock price goes up irrationally, with the result that the stock price falls back down to
a level that is justified by fundamentals. For this to occur, smart money investors must
be able to engage in short sales; that is, they must borrow stock from brokers and then
sell it in the market, with the aim of earning a profit by buying the stock back again
(“covering the short”) after it has fallen in price.
Work by psychologists, however, suggests that people are subject to loss aversion:
Loss aversion can thus explain an important phenomenon: Very little short selling actually takes
place. Short selling may also be constrained by rules restricting it,
because it seems unsavory for someone to make money from another person’s misfortune.
The existence of so little short selling can explain why stock prices are sometimes
overvalued. That is, the lack of enough short selling means that smart money does not
drive stock prices back down to their fundamental value.
Psychologists have also found that people tend to be overconfident in their own
judgments. As a result, investors tend to believe that they are smarter than other investors.
Because investors are willing to assume that the market typically doesn’t get it right,
they trade on their beliefs rather than on pure facts. This theory may explain why securities
markets have such a large trading volume—something that the efficient market
hypothesis does not predict.
Overconfidence and social contagion (fads) provide an explanation for stock market bubbles.
When stock prices go up, investors attribute their profits to their intelligence and talk up the stock
market. This word-of-mouth enthusiasm and glowing
media reports then can produce an environment in which even more investors think
stock prices will rise in the future. The result is a positive feedback loop in which prices
continue to rise, producing a speculative bubble, which finally crashes when prices get
too far out of line with fundamentals.10
The field of behavioral finance is a young one, but it holds out hope that we
might be able to explain some features of securities markets’ behavior that are not well
explained by the efficient market hypothesis.
The financial system is complex in structure and function throughout the world. It
includes many different types of institutions: banks, insurance companies, mutual
funds, stock and bond markets, and so on—all of which are regulated by government.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 152
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
The financial system channels trillions of dollars per year from savers to people with
productive investment opportunities. If we take a close look at financial structure all
over the world, we find eight basic facts, some of which are quite surprising, that we
must explain if we are to understand how the financial system works.
The bar chart in Figure 1 shows how American businesses financed their activities using external
funds (those obtained from outside the business itself) in the period
1970–2000 and compares U.S. data with data for Germany, Japan, and Canada. The
conclusions drawn from this period still hold true today. The Bank Loans category is
made up primarily of loans from depository institutions; Nonbank Loans are primarily
loans by other financial intermediaries; the Bonds category includes marketable debt
securities, such as corporate bonds and commercial paper; and Stock consists of new
issues of equity (stock market shares).
Now let’s explore the eight facts.
1. Stocks are not the most important source of external financing for businesses.
Because so much attention in the media is focused on the stock market, many people have the
impression that stocks are the most important source of financing for American corporations.
However, as we can see from the bar chart in Figure 1, the stock market accounted for only a
small fraction of the external financing of American businesses
in the 1970–2000 period: 11%. Similarly, low figures apply for the other countries
presented in Figure 1. Why is the stock market less important than other sources of
financing in the United States and other countries?
2. Issuing marketable debt and equity securities is not the primary way in which
businesses finance their operations. Figure 1 shows that bonds are a far more important
source of financing in the United States than stocks are (32% versus 11%). However, stocks and
bonds combined (43%), which make up the total share of marketable
securities, still supply less than one-half of the external funds needed by U.S. corporations to
finance their activities. The fact that issuing marketable securities is not the
most important source of financing is true elsewhere in the world as well. Indeed, as we
see in Figure 1, other countries have a much smaller share of external financing supplied by
marketable securities than does the United States. Why don’t businesses use
marketable securities more extensively to finance their activities?
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 153
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
5. The financial system is among the most heavily regulated sectors of the economy. The
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 154
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
financial system is heavily regulated in the United States and in all other
developed countries. Governments regulate financial markets primarily to promote the
provision of information and to ensure the soundness (stability) of the financial system.
Why are financial markets so extensively regulated throughout the world?
8. Debt contracts typically are extremely complicated legal documents that place
substantial restrictions on the behavior of the borrower. Many students think of a
debt contract as a simple IOU that can be written on a single piece of paper. The reality of debt
contracts is far different, however. In all countries, bond or loan contracts
typically are long legal documents with provisions (called restrictive covenants) that
restrict and specify certain activities that the borrower can engage in. Restrictive covenants are
not just a feature of debt contracts for businesses; for example, personal
automobile loan and home mortgage contracts include covenants that require the borrower to
maintain sufficient insurance on the automobile or house purchased with the
loan. Why are debt contracts so complex and restrictive?
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 155
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
TOPIC 098: TRANSACTION COSTS
• Transaction costs are expenses incurred when buying or selling a good or service.
• Transaction costs are the payments that banks and brokers receive from buyers and
sellers for their roles.
• Transaction costs are one of the key determinants of net returns.
• Different asset classes have different ranges of transaction costs; investors should select
assets with costs that are at the low end of the range for their types.
Say you have $5,000 that you would like to invest, and you are thinking about investing
in the stock market. Because you have only $5,000, you can buy only a small number
of shares. Even if you use online trading, your purchase is so small that the brokerage
commission for buying the stock you pick will be a large percentage of the purchase
price of the shares. If, instead, you decide to buy a bond, the problem becomes even
worse; the smallest denomination offered on some bonds that you might want to buy
is as large as $10,000, and you do not have that much money to invest. You are disappointed
and realize that you will not be able to use financial markets to earn a return on
your hard-earned savings. You can take some consolation, however, in the fact that you
are not alone in being stymied by high transaction costs. This is a fact of life for many of
us:
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 156
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Expertise
Financial intermediaries are also better able to develop expertise, e. g. in computer
technology. Low transaction costs enable financial intermediaries to provide their
customers with liquidity services. For example, money market mutual funds pay
shareholders relatively high interest rates.
Financial intermediaries, an important part of the financial structure, have evolved to reduce
transaction costs and allow small savers and borrowers to benefit from the existence of financial
markets.
Economies of Scale One solution to the problem of high transaction costs is to bundle the funds
of many investors together so that they can take advantage of economies of scale, the reduction
in transaction costs per dollar of investment as the size (scale) of transactions increases. Bundling
investors’ funds together reduces transaction costs for each individual investor. Economies of
scale exist because the total cost of carrying out a transaction in financial markets increases only
a little as the size of the transaction grows. For example, the cost of arranging a purchase of
10,000 shares of stock is not much greater than the cost of arranging a purchase of
50 shares of stock.
The presence of economies of scale in financial markets helps explain the development of
financial intermediaries and why financial intermediaries have become such an important part of
our financial structure. The clearest example of a financial intermediary that arose because of
economies of scale is a mutual fund. A mutual fund is a financial intermediary that sells shares to
individuals and then invests the proceeds in bonds or stocks. Because it buys large blocks of
stocks or bonds, a mutual fund can take advantage of lower transaction costs. These cost savings
are then passed on to individual investors after the mutual fund has taken its cut in the form of
management fees for administering their accounts.
An additional benefit for individual investors is that a mutual fund is large enough to purchase a
widely diversified portfolio of securities.
The increased diversification for individual investors reduces their risk, making them better off.
Economies of scale are also important in lowering the costs of resources that financial institutions
need to accomplish their tasks, such as computer technology. Once a large mutual fund has
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 157
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
invested a lot of money in setting up a telecommunications system, for example, the system can
be used for a huge number of transactions at a low cost per transaction.
Expertise Financial intermediaries are also better able to develop expertise that can be used to
lower transaction costs. Their expertise in computer technology, for example, enables them to
offer their customers convenient services such as check-writing privileges on their accounts and
toll-free numbers that customers can call for information on how well their investments are doing.
Low transaction costs enable financial intermediaries to provide their customers with liquidity
services, which are services that make it easier for customers to conduct transactions. Money
market mutual funds, for example, not only pay shareholders relatively high interest rates but also
allow them to write checks for convenient bill paying.
Asymmetric Information
A situation that arises when one party’s insufficient knowledge about the other party
involved in a transaction makes it impossible for the first party to make accurate decisions
when conducting the transaction—is an important aspect of financial markets.
Adverse Selection
It occurs before a transaction takes place. The parties who are most likely to produce an
undesirable outcome are also the ones most likely to want to engage in the transaction.
For example, big risk takers or outright crooks are often the most eager to take out a loan
because they know they are unlikely to pay it back.
Moral Hazard
It arises after the transaction occurs. The lender runs the risk that the borrower will engage
in activities that are undesirable from the lender’s point of view, because such activities
make it less likely that the loan will be paid back.
Moral hazard lowers the probability that the loan will be repaid, lenders may decide that
they would rather not make a loan.
The presence of transaction costs in financial markets partly explains why financial
intermediaries and indirect finance play such an important role in financial markets
(fact 3). To understand financial structure more fully, however, we turn to the role of
information in financial markets.
Asymmetric information—a situation that arises when one party’s insufficient knowledge about
the other party involved in a transaction makes it impossible for the first
party to make accurate decisions when conducting the transaction—is an important
aspect of financial markets. For example, managers of a corporation know whether they
are honest and usually have better information about how well their business is doing
than stockholders do.
Adverse selection is an asymmetric information problem that occurs before a transaction occurs:
Potential bad credit risks are the ones who most actively seek out loans.
Thus the parties who are most likely to produce an undesirable outcome are also the
ones most likely to want to engage in the transaction. For example, big risk takers or
outright crooks are often the most eager to take out a loan because they know they
are unlikely to pay it back. Because adverse selection increases the chances that a loan
might be made to a bad credit risk, lenders might decide not to make any loans, even
though good credit risks can be found in the marketplace.
Moral hazard arises after the transaction occurs: The lender runs the risk that the
borrower will engage in activities that are undesirable from the lender’s point of view,
because such activities make it less likely that the loan will be paid back. For example,
once borrowers have obtained a loan, they may take on big risks (which have possible
high returns but also run a greater risk of default) because they are playing with someone else’s
money. Because moral hazard lowers the probability that the loan will be
repaid, lenders may decide that they would rather not make a loan.
The analysis of how asymmetric information problems affect economic behavior
is called agency theory.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 159
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
TOPIC 101: THE LEMONS PROBLEM
• Nobel Prize winner George Akerlof.
• It is called the “lemons problem” because it resembles the problem created by “lemons,”
that is, bad cars, in the used-car market.
• What is the Lemons Problem?
• The lemons problem refers to issues that arise regarding the value of an investment or
product due to asymmetric information possessed by the buyer and the seller.
• If investors can’t distinguish between good and bad securities, they are only willing to pay
only average of good and bad securities’ values.
• Result: Good securities are undervalued and firms won’t issue them; bad securities
overvalued, so too many issued.
• Few bonds are likely to sell in this market, so it will not be a good source of financing.
• Investors won’t want to buy bad securities, so market won’t function well.
• Less asymmetric information for well known firms, so smaller lemons problem.
A particular aspect of the way the adverse selection problem interferes with the efficient
functioning of a market was outlined in a famous article by Nobel Prize winner George
Akerlof. It is called the “lemons problem” because it resembles the problem created by
“lemons,” that is, bad cars, in the used-car market. Potential buyers of used cars are frequently
unable to assess the quality of a car; that is, they can’t tell whether a particular used car is one
that will run well or a lemon that will continually give them grief.
The price that a buyer pays must therefore reflect the average quality of the cars in the
market, somewhere between the low value of a lemon and the high value of a good car.
The owner of a used car, by contrast, is more likely to know whether the car is a
peach or a lemon. If the car is a lemon, the owner is more than happy to sell it at the price
the buyer is willing to pay, which, being somewhere between the value of a lemon and
that of a good car, is greater than the lemon’s value.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 160
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
car available in the market will be low, and because very few people want to buy a lemon,
there will be few sales. The used-car market will function poorly, if at all.
The only firms willing to sell Irving securities will be bad firms (because his
price is higher than the securities are worth). Our friend Irving is not stupid; he does not
want to hold securities in bad firms, and hence he will decide not to purchase securities
in the market. In an outcome similar to that in the used-car market, this securities market
will not work very well because few firms will sell securities in it to raise capital.
Only the bad firms will be willing to borrow, and because investors like Irving are
not eager to buy bonds issued by bad firms, they will probably not buy any bonds at all.
Few bonds are likely to sell in this market, so it will not be a good source of financing.
The analysis we have just conducted explains fact 2—why marketable securities
are not the primary source of financing for businesses in any country in the world. It
also partly explains fact 1—why stocks are not the most important source of financing
for American businesses. The presence of the lemons problem keeps securities markets
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 161
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
such as the stock and bond markets from being effective in channeling funds from savers to
borrowers.
In the absence of asymmetric information, the lemons problem goes away. If buyers
know as much about the quality of used cars as sellers, so that all involved can tell a
good car from a bad one, buyers will be willing to pay full value for good used cars. Because the
owners of good used cars can now get a fair price, they will be willing to
sell them in the market. The market will have many transactions and will perform its
intended job of channeling good cars to people who want them.
Similarly, if purchasers of securities can distinguish good firms from bad, they will
pay the full value of securities issued by good firms, and good firms will sell their securities in the
market. The securities market will then be able to move funds to the good
firms that have the most productive investment opportunities.
The system of private production and sale of information does not completely solve
the adverse selection problem in securities markets, however, because of the free-rider
problem. The free-rider problem occurs when people who do not pay for information
take advantage of the information that other people have paid for. The free-rider problem suggests
that the private sale of information is only a partial solution to the lemons problem. To see why,
suppose you have just purchased information that tells you
which firms are good and which are bad.
The weakened ability of private firms to profit from selling information will mean that less
information is produced in the marketplace, so adverse selection (the lemons problem)
will still interfere with the efficient functioning of securities markets.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 164
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
LESSON 21
ADVERSE SELECTION AND MORAL HAZARD
The free-rider problem prevents the private market from producing enough information to
eliminate all the asymmetric information that leads to adverse selection. Could financial markets
benefit from government intervention? The government could, for instance, produce information
to help investors distinguish good from bad firms and provide it to the public
free of charge. This solution, however, would involve the government releasing negative
information about firms, a practice that might be politically difficult.
A second
possibility (and one followed by the United States and most governments throughout
the world) is for the government to regulate securities markets in a way that encourages firms to
reveal honest information about themselves so that investors can determine how good or bad the
firms are. In the United States, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is the
government agency that requires firms selling their securities
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 165
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
to undergo independent audits, in which accounting firms certify that the firm is adhering to
standard accounting principles and disclosing accurate information about sales,
assets, and earnings. Similar regulations are found in other countries. However, disclosure
requirements do not always work well, as the collapse of Enron and accounting
scandals at other corporations, such as WorldCom and Parmalat (an Italian company),
suggest (see the FYI box, “The Enron Implosion”).
Although government regulation lessens the adverse selection problem, it does not
eliminate it entirely. Even when firms provide information to the public about their
sales, assets, or earnings, they still have more information than investors: A lot more
is involved in knowing the quality of a firm than statistics alone can provide. Furthermore, bad
firms have an incentive to make themselves look like good firms because this
enables them to fetch a higher price for their securities. Bad firms will slant the information they
are required to transmit to the public, thus making it harder for investors
to sort out the good firms from the bad.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 166
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
So far we have seen that private production of information and government regulation to
encourage provision of information lessen, but do not eliminate, the adverse selection problem in
financial markets. How, then, can the financial structure help promote the flow of funds to people
with productive investment opportunities when asymmetric information exists? A clue is provided
by the structure of the used-car market. An important feature of the used-car market is that most
used cars are not sold directly by one individual to another. An individual who considers buying a
used car might pay for privately produced information by subscribing to a magazine like Consumer
Reports to find out if a particular make of car has a good repair record.
Nevertheless, reading Consumer Reports does not solve the adverse selection problem, because
even if a particular make of car has a good reputation, the specific car someone is trying to sell
could be a lemon. The prospective buyer might also bring the used car to a
mechanic for a once-over. But what if the prospective buyer doesn’t know a mechanic
who can be trusted or the mechanic charges a high fee to evaluate the car?
Because these roadblocks make it hard for individuals to acquire enough information about used
cars, most used cars are not sold directly by one individual to another.
Instead, they are sold by an intermediary, a used-car dealer who purchases used cars
from individuals and resells them to other individuals.
Used-car dealers produce information in the market by becoming experts in determining whether
a car is a peach or
a lemon. Once a dealer knows that a car is good, the dealer can sell it with some form
of a guarantee: either an explicit guarantee such as a warranty or an implicit guarantee
in which the dealer stands by its reputation for honesty. People are more likely to purchase a used
car because of a dealer guarantee, and the dealer is able to sell the used car
at a higher price than he or she paid for it. Thus the dealer profits from the production
of information about automobile quality. If dealers purchase and then resell cars on
which they have produced information, they avoid the problem of other people freeriding on the
information they produced.
Just as used-car dealers help solve adverse selection problems in the automobile market,
financial intermediaries play a similar role in financial markets. A financial
intermediary, such as a bank, becomes an expert in producing information about firms
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 167
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
so that it can sort out good credit risks from bad ones. It then can acquire funds from
depositors and lend them to the good firms. Because the bank is able to lend mostly to
good firms, it is able to earn a higher return on its loans than the interest it has to pay to
its depositors. The resulting profit that the bank earns gives it the incentive to engage in this
information production activity.
An important element of the bank’s ability to profit from the information it produces is that it avoids
the free-rider problem by primarily making private loans, rather
than by purchasing securities that are traded in the open market. Because a private loan
is not traded, other investors cannot watch what the bank is doing and bid down the
loan’s interest rate to the point that the bank receives no compensation for the information it has
produced.
Our analysis also explains the greater importance of banks, as opposed to securities
markets, in the financial systems of developing countries. As we have seen, better information
about the quality of firms lessens asymmetric information problems, making it
easier for firms to issue securities. Information about private firms is harder to collect in developing
countries than in industrialized countries; therefore, the smaller role played
by securities markets leads to a greater role for financial intermediaries such as banks.
As a corollary to our analysis, as information about firms becomes easier to acquire, the
role of banks should decline. A major development in the past 30 years in the United
States has been huge improvements in information technology. Thus our analysis suggests that
the lending role of financial institutions such as banks in the United States
should have declined, and this is exactly what has occurred.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 168
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Our analysis of adverse selection also explains fact 6, which questions why large
firms are more likely to obtain funds from securities markets, a direct route, rather
than from banks and financial intermediaries, an indirect route. The better known a
corporation is, the more information about its activities is available in the marketplace.
Thus it is easier for investors to evaluate the quality of the corporation and determine
whether it is a good firm or a bad one. Because investors have fewer worries about
adverse selection when dealing with well-known corporations, they are more willing to
invest directly in their securities. Thus, in accordance with adverse selection, a pecking
order for firms that can issue securities should exist. Hence we have an explanation for
fact 6: The larger and more established a corporation is, the more likely it will be to
issue securities to raise funds.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 169
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
TOPIC 107: ADVERSE SELECTION AND NET WORTH
• Net worth (also called equity capital), is the difference between a firm’s assets (what it
owns or is owed) and its liabilities (what it owes), can perform a similar role to that of
collateral.
• If a firm has a high net worth, then even if it engages in investments that lead to negative
profits and so defaults on its debt payments.
• The lender can take title to the firm’s net worth, sell it off, and use the proceeds to recoup
some of the losses from the loan.
• In addition, the more net worth a firm has in the first place, the less likely it is to default,
because the firm has a cushion of assets that it can use to pay off its loans.
• Hence, when firms seeking credit have high net worth, the consequences of adverse
selection are less important and lenders are more willing to make loans.
• This concept lies behind the often-heard lament, “Only the people who don’t need money
can borrow it!”
Lenders are thus more willing to make loans secured by collateral, and borrowers are willing to
supply collateral because the reduced risk for the lender makes it more likely that the loan will
be made, perhaps even at a better loan rate. The presence of adverse selection in credit
markets thus explains why collateral is an important feature of debt contracts (fact 7).
Net worth (also called equity capital), the difference between a firm’s assets
(what it owns or is owed) and its liabilities (what it owes), can perform a similar role to
that of collateral. If a firm has a high net worth, then even if it engages in investments
that lead to negative profits and so defaults on its debt payments, the lender can take
title to the firm’s net worth, sell it off, and use the proceeds to recoup some of the losses
from the loan.
In addition, the more net worth a firm has in the first place, the less
likely it is to default, because the firm has a cushion of assets that it can use to pay off
its loans. Hence, when firms seeking credit have high net worth, the consequences of
adverse selection are less important and lenders are more willing to make loans. This
concept lies behind the often-heard lament, “Only the people who don’t need money
can borrow it!
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 170
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
TOPIC 108: MORAL HAZARD AND THE CHOICE BETWEEN DEBT AND EQUITY
• Equity contracts, such as common stock, are claims to a share in the profits and assets of
a business.
• Equity contracts are subject to a particular type of moral hazard called the principal–agent
problem.
• Managers own only a small fraction of the firm they work for, the stockholders who own
most of the firm’s equity (called the principals) are not the same people as the managers
of the firm.
• The managers are the agents of the owners. This separation of ownership and control
involves moral hazard.
• The managers in control (the agents) may act in their own interest rather than in the
interest of the stockholder-owners (the principals) because the managers have less
incentive to maximize profits than the stockholder-owners do.
Moral hazard is the asymmetric information problem that occurs after a financial transaction takes
place, when the seller of a security may have incentives to hide information
and engage in activities that are undesirable for the purchaser of the security. Moral
hazard has important consequences for whether a firm finds it easier to raise funds with
debt than with equity contracts.
To understand the principal–agent problem more fully, suppose that your friend
Steve asks you to become a silent partner in his ice-cream store. The store setup
requires an initial investment of $10,000, and Steve has only $1,000. So you purchase
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 171
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
an equity stake (stock shares) for $9,000, which entitles you to 90% of the ownership
of the firm, while Steve owns only 10%. If Steve works hard to make tasty ice cream,
keeps the store clean, smiles at all the customers, and hustles to wait on tables quickly,
after all expenses (including Steve’s salary) have been paid, the store will make $50,000
in profits per year, of which Steve will receive 10% ($5,000) and you will receive 90%
($45,000).
But if Steve doesn’t provide quick and friendly service to his customers, uses the
$50,000 in income to buy artwork for his office, and even sneaks off to the beach
while he should be at the store, the store will not earn any profit. Steve can earn the
additional $5,000 (his 10% share of the profits) over his salary only if he works hard
and forgoes unproductive investments (such as art for his office). Steve might decide
that the extra $5,000 just isn’t enough to make him expend the effort to be a good
manager. If Steve feels this way, he does not have enough incentive to be a good
manager and will end up with a beautiful office, a good tan, and a store that doesn’t
show any profits. Because the store won’t show any profits, Steve’s decision not to act
in your interest will cost you $45,000 (your 90% of the profits had he chosen to be a
good manager instead).
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 172
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
LESSON 22
THE PRINCIPAL-AGENT PROBLEM
The moral hazard arising from the principal–agent problem might be even worse if
Steve is not totally honest. Because his ice-cream store is a cash business, Steve has the
incentive to pocket $50,000 in cash and tell you that the profits were zero. He now gets
a return of $50,000, and you get nothing.
Further proof that the principal–agent problem created by equity contracts can
be severe is provided by past scandals involving corporations such as Enron and Tyco
International, in which managers were found to have diverted corporate funds for their
own personal use. In addition to pursuing personal benefits, managers might also pursue
corporate strategies (such as the acquisition of other firms) that enhance their personal power but
do not increase the corporation’s profitability.
The principal–agent problem would not arise if the owners of a firm had complete information
about what the managers were up to and could prevent wasteful
expenditures or fraud. The principal–agent problem, which is an example of moral
hazard, arises only because a manager, such as Steve, has more information about his
activities than the stockholder does—that is, information is asymmetric. The principal–
agent problem also would not occur if Steve alone owned the store, and ownership and
control were not separate. If this were the case, Steve’s hard work and avoidance of
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 173
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
unproductive investments would yield him a profit (and extra income) of $50,000, an
amount that would make it worth his while to be a good manager.
In this example, the free-rider problem decreases monitoring. If you know that
other stockholders are paying to monitor the activities of the company you hold shares
in, you can take a free ride on their activities. Then you can use the money you save
by not engaging in monitoring to vacation on a Caribbean island. If you can do this,
though, so can other stockholders. Perhaps all the stockholders will go to the islands,
and no one will spend any resources on monitoring the firm. The moral hazard problem for shares
of common stock will then be severe, making it hard for firms to issue
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 174
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
them to raise capital (providing an additional explanation for fact 1).
As with adverse selection, the government has an incentive to try to reduce the moral hazard
problem created by asymmetric information, which provides another reason why the financial
system is so heavily regulated (fact 5). Governments everywhere have laws to force firms to
adhere to standard accounting principles that make profit verification easier. They also pass
laws to impose stiff criminal penalties on people who commit the fraud of hiding and
stealing profits. However, these measures can be only partly effective. Catching this kind of fraud
is not easy; fraudulent managers have the incentive to make it very hard
for government agencies to find or prove fraud.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 177
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 23
RISK MANAGEMENT AND ECONOMIC DECISIONS
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 178
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• The appropriateness of a risk-management decision should be judged in the light of the
information available at the time the decision is made.
• One of the most common is standard deviation, a statistical measure of dispersion around
a central tendency.
It is possible and prudent to manage investing risks by understanding the basics of risk and how
it is measured. Learning the risks that can apply to different scenarios and some of the ways to
manage them holistically will help all types of investors and business managers to avoid
unnecessary and costly losses.
In the financial world, risk management is the process of identification, analysis, and acceptance
or mitigation of uncertainty in investment decisions. Essentially, risk management occurs when
an investor or fund manager analyzes and attempts to quantify the potential for losses in an
investment, such as a moral hazard, and then takes the appropriate action (or inaction) given the
fund's investment objectives and risk tolerance.
Risk is inseparable from return. Every investment involves some degree of risk, which is
considered close to zero in the case of a U.S. T-bill or very high for something such as emerging-
market equities or real estate in highly inflationary markets. Risk is quantifiable both in absolute
and in relative terms. A solid understanding of risk in its different forms can help investors to better
understand the opportunities, trade-offs, and costs involved with different investment approaches.
Risk management occurs everywhere in the realm of finance. It occurs when an investor
buys U.S. Treasury bonds over corporate bonds, when a fund manager hedges his currency
exposure with currency derivatives, and when a bank performs a credit check on an individual
before issuing a personal line of credit. Stockbrokers use financial instruments
like options and futures, and money managers use strategies like portfolio diversification, asset
allocation and position sizing to mitigate or effectively manage risk.
Inadequate risk management can result in severe consequences for companies, individuals, and
the economy. For example, the subprime mortgage meltdown in 2007 that helped trigger the
Great Recession stemmed from bad risk-management decisions, such as lenders who extended
mortgages to individuals with poor credit; investment firms who bought, packaged, and resold
these mortgages; and funds that invested excessively in the repackaged, but still risky, mortgage-
backed securities (MBSs).
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 179
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
TOPIC 115: RISK EXPOSURE
• Risk exposure is the measure of potential future loss resulting from a specific activity or
event.
• An analysis of the risk exposure for a business often ranks risks according to their
probability of occurring multiplied by the potential loss if they do.
• The riskiness of an asset or a transaction cannot be assessed in isolation or in the
abstract.
• The purchase of sale of a particular asset may add to your risk exposure; in another, the
same transaction may be risk reducing.
Speculators and Hedgers
• Speculators are the investors who take positions that increase their exposure to certain
risks in the hope of increasing their wealth.
• Hedgers take positions to reduce their exposures.
• The same person can be a speculator on some exposures and a hedger on others.
Risk exposure in any business or an investment is the measurement of potential future loss due
to a specific event or business activity and is calculated as the probability of the event multiplied
by the expected loss due to the risk impact.
What is a Speculator?
A speculator utilizes strategies and typically a shorter time frame in an attempt to outperform
traditional longer-term investors. Speculators take on risk, especially with respect to anticipating
future price movements, in the hope of making gains that are large enough to offset the risk.
Speculators that take on excessive risk typically don't last long. Speculators exert control over
long-term risks by employing various strategies such as position sizing, stop loss orders, and
monitoring the statistics of their trading performance. Speculators are typically sophisticated risk-
taking individuals with expertise in the markets in which they are trading.
Hedgers are primary participants in the futures markets. A hedger is any individual or firm that
buys or sells the actual physical commodity. Many hedgers are producers, wholesalers, retailers
or manufacturers and they are affected by changes in commodity prices, exchange rates, and
interest rates.
TOPIC 116: RISK AND ECONOMIC DECISIONS
• Financial decisions expose us to various risk exposures
• Saving, Investment and financing decisions are significantly influenced by the presence
of risk, and therefore, are risk-management decisions.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 180
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• The ultimate function of a financial system is to help Implement optimal consumption and
resource allocation of households.
• Economic organizations such as firms and governments exist primarily to facilitate the
achievement of that ultimate function.
• To have a better understanding of how risk influences economic decisions, it is important
to explain it in terms of:
1. Households
2. Firms, and
3. Government.
Some financial decisions, such as how much insurance to buy against risk exposures, relate
exclusively to the management of risk. But many general resource allocation decisions, are also
significantly influenced by the presence of risk and therefore, are partly risk-management
decisions.
For example, some households saving is motivated by the desire for the increased security that
comes from owning assets that can cover unanticipated expenses in the future. Economists call
this precautionary saving.
TOPIC 117: RISKS FACING HOUSEHOLDS
Five major categories of risk exposures for households:
1. Sickness, disability, and death
2. Unemployment risk
3. Consumer-durable asset risk in case of fire, theft, technological change
4. Liability risk
• The risk that others will have a financial claim against you because they suffer a loss for
which you can be held responsible.
• For example, you cause a car accident and are required to pay for the injury and damage
caused.
5. Financial-asset risk
• The risk arising from holding different kinds of financial assets such as equities or fixed-
income securities denominated in one or more currencies.
• The underlying sources of financial-asset risk are the uncertainties faced by the firms,
governments, or other economic organizations that have issued these securities.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 181
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
There can be many types of risks which households face but there are five major categories of
risk that the households face the most.
Sickness, disability, and death: Unexpected sickness or accidental injuries can impose large costs
on people because of the need for treatment and care and because of the loss of income caused
by the inability to work.
Unemployment risk: This is the risk of losing one’s job.
Consumer-durable asset risk: This is the risk of loss arising from ownership of a house, car, etc.
Losses can occur due to hazards such as fire or theft, etc.
Liability risk: This is the risk that others will have a financial claim against you because they suffer
a loss for which you can be held responsible. For example, you cause a car accident through
reckless driving and are required to cover the cost to others of personal injury and property
damage.
Financial-asset risk: This is the risk arising from holding different kinds of financial assets such as
equities or fixed-income securities denominated in one or more currencies. The underlying
sources of financial-asset risk are the uncertainties face by the firms, governments, or their
economic organizations that have issued these securities.
The risks faced by households influence virtually all of their economic decisions.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 182
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 24
RISKS FACING FIRMS AND ROLE OF GOVERNMENT
Building risks are the most common type of physical risk. Think fires or explosions. To manage
building risk, and the risk to employees, it is important that organizations do the following:
Make sure all employees know the exact street address of the building to give to a 911 operator
in case of emergency.
Make sure all employees know the location of all exits.
Install fire alarms and smoke detectors.
Install a sprinkler system to provide additional protection to the physical plant, equipment,
documents and, of course, personnel.
Inform all employees that in the event of emergency their personal safety takes priority over
everything else. Employees should be instructed to leave the building and abandon all work-
associated documents, equipment and/or products.
Fire department hazardous material units are prepared to handle these types of disasters. People
who work with these materials, however, should be properly equipped and trained to handle them
safely.
Organizations should create a plan to handle the immediate effects of these risks. Government
agencies and local fire departments provide information to prevent these accidents. Such
agencies can also provide advice on how to control them and minimize their damage if they occur.
Among the location hazards facing a business are nearby fires, storm damage, floods, hurricanes
or tornados, earthquakes, and other natural disasters. Employees should be familiar with the
streets leading in and out of the neighborhood on all sides of the place of business. Individuals
should keep sufficient fuel in their vehicles to drive out of and away from the area. Liability or
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 184
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
property and casualty insurance are often used to transfer the financial burden of location risks to
a third-party or a business insurance company.
There are other business risks associated with location that are not directly related to hazards,
such as city planning. For example, a gas station exists on a major road, and as a result of its
location, it receives plenty of business. City planning can eventually restructure the area around
the gas station. The city may close the road the gas station is on, build other infrastructure that
would make the gas station inaccessible, or overall just not take the gas station into consideration
with any redevelopment. This would leave the gas station with no traffic to serve.
Alcohol and drug abuse are major risks to personnel in the workforce. Employees suffering from
alcohol or drug abuse should be urged to seek treatment, counseling, and rehabilitation if
necessary. Some insurance policies may provide partial coverage for the cost of treatment.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 185
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Protection against embezzlement, theft and fraud may be difficult, but these are common crimes
in the workplace. A system of double-signature requirements for checks, invoices,
and payables verification can help prevent embezzlement and fraud. Stringent accounting
procedures may discover embezzlement or fraud. A thorough background check before hiring
personnel can uncover previous offenses in an applicant's past. While this may not be grounds
for refusing to hire an applicant, it would help HR to avoid placing a new hire in a critical position
where the employee is open to temptation.
Illness or injury among the workforce is a potential problem. To prevent loss of productivity, assign
and train backup personnel to handle the work of critical employees when they are absent due to
a health-related concern.
Technology Risks
A power outage is perhaps the most common technology risk. Auxiliary gas-driven power
generators are a reliable back-up system to provide electricity for lighting and other functions.
Manufacturing plants use several large auxiliary generators to keep a factory operational until
utility power is restored.
Computers may be kept up and running with high-performance back-up batteries. Power surges
may occur during a lightning storm (or randomly), so organizations should furnish critical business
systems with surge-protection devices to avoid the loss of documents and the destruction of
equipment.
Cloud storage is another source of risks nowadays. The process involves backing up data with
Amazon Web Services, for example, using Azure, IBM, and Oracle, for instance. This is a huge
undertaking that should be considered given the reliance on cloud-based data to run most
businesses now. It is important to establish both offline and online data backup systems to protect
critical documents.
Although telephone and communications failure are relatively uncommon, risk managers may
consider providing emergency-use company cell phones to personnel whose use of the phone or
internet is critical to their business.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 187
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 188
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 189
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 25
RISK ASSESSMENT
Clearly, she needs information, and information may be costly to gather. One of the main
functions of insurance companies is to provide this kind of information. They employ actuaries,
who are professional specially trained in mathematics and statistics, to gather and analyze data
and estimate the probabilities of illness, accidents, and other such risks.\In the realm of final-
asset risks, households and firms often need expert advice in assessing their exposures and in
quantifying the trade-offs between the risks and rewards of investing in various categories of
assets, such as stocks and bonds. They typically turn to professional investment advisors, mutual
funds, or other financial intermediaries and service firms that help them make those
assessments.
• When you hedge, you eliminate the risk of loss by giving up the potential for gain.
• When you insure, you pay a premium to eliminate the risk of loss and retain the
potential for gain.
Diversifying
• It means holding similar amounts of many risky assets instead of concentrating all your
investment in only one.
Institutional arrangements for the transfer of risk contribute to economic efficiency in two
fundamental ways:
1. They reallocate existing risks to those most willing to bear them, and
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 192
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
2. They cause a reallocation of resources to production and consumption in accordance with
the new distribution of risk bearing.
Efficient Bearing of Existing Risks
It means that a conservative investor or a risk avertor investor sells his risky investments to those
who are risk lovers and buys financial investors that are considered to be less risky.
Risk and Resource Allocation
• The ability to reallocate risks facilitate the undertakings of valuable projects that might not
otherwise be undertaken because they are too risky.
• The ability to pool and share risks can lead to an increase in innovations and the
development of new products.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 193
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 194
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Risk and Resource Allocation
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 195
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 196
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 26
PROBABILITY DISTRIBUTION OF RETURNS
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 197
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Probability Distribution
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
Probability
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
-10% 10% 30%
Returns
• Suppose you expect the dividend component to be 3%, and the price-change component
to be 7%. The Expected Rate of Return
• = r = 3% +7% = 10%
• The expected rate of return (the mean) is defined as the sum over all possible outcomes
of each possible rate of return multiplied by the respective probability of its happening.
• E(r) = P1r1+P2r2+…+ Pnrn
• E(r) = ∑𝑛𝑖=1 𝑃𝑖 𝑟𝑖
Using the above data, the expected rate of return is calculated as:
E(r) = 0.2X30%+0.60X10%+0.2X(- 10%)
= 0.1 or 10%
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 199
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Where E(r) is the expected rate of return, Pi is the probability of event I, and i=1, 2, 3, …., n. r i is
the return of an outcome i.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 200
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• If the range of possible outcomes is wide, and the probabilities of returns at the extremes
is high, the stock’s volatility will be higher.
Standard Deviation as a Measure of Risk
• Standard deviation is a measure of the risk that an investment will fluctuate from its
expected return.
• The smaller an investment's standard deviation, the less volatile it is, thus less risky the
investment is.
The volatility of a stock’s return was shown to depend on the range of possible outcomes and on
the probabilities of extreme values occurring. We use standard deviation to measure the volatility
of a stock’s probability distribution of returns. The formula used to measure standard deviation is
𝜎 = √∑ 𝑃𝑖 (𝑟𝑖 − 𝐸(𝑟))2
𝑖=1
Let us take an investment A, which has a 20% probability of giving a 15% return on investment,
a 50% probability of generating a 10% return, and a 30% probability of resulting in a 5% loss. This
is an example of calculating a discrete probability distribution for potential returns.
The expected return on investment A would then be calculated as follows:
Expected Return of A = 0.2(15%) + 0.5(10%) + 0.3(-5%)
(That is, a 20%, or .2, probability times a 15%, or .15, return; plus a 50%, or .5, probability times
a 10%, or .1, return; plus a 30%, or .3, probability of a return of negative 5%, or -.5)
= 3% + 5% – 1.5%
= 6.5%
Therefore, the probable long-term average return for Investment A is 6.5%.
Calculating Expected Return of a Portfolio
Calculating expected return is not limited to calculations for a single investment. It can also be
calculated for a portfolio. The expected return for an investment portfolio is the weighted average
of the expected return of each of its components. Components are weighted by the percentage
of the portfolio’s total value that each accounts for. Examining the weighted average of portfolio
assets can also help investors assess the diversification of their investment portfolio.
To illustrate the expected return for an investment portfolio, let’s assume the portfolio is comprised
of investments in three assets – X, Y, and Z. $2,000 is invested in X, $5,000 invested in Y, and
$3,000 is invested in Z. Assume that the expected returns for X, Y, and Z have been calculated
and found to be 15%, 10%, and 20%, respectively. Based on the respective investments in each
component asset, the portfolio’s expected return can be calculated as follows:
Expected Return of Portfolio = 0.2(15%) + 0.5(10%) + 0.3(20%)
= 3% + 5% + 6%
= 14%
Thus, the expected return of the portfolio is 14%.
Standard Deviation of the Expected Return of A = √𝟎. 𝟐𝟐 (𝟏𝟓%) + 𝟎. 𝟓𝟐 (𝟏𝟎%) + 𝟎. 𝟑𝟐 (−𝟓%)
=0.1628
I have used the data followed for calculation of expected rate of return.
Standard deviation is unit free measure.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 202
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 27
HEDGING RISK USING FORWARD AND FUTURES CONTRACTS
Hedging techniques generally involve the use of financial instruments known as derivatives. Two
of the most common derivatives are options and futures. With derivatives, you can develop
trading strategies where a loss in one investment is offset by a gain in a derivative.
Forward Contract
• Hedging strategies typically involve derivatives, such as options and futures contracts.
• Anytime two parties agree to exchange some item in the future at a prearranged price they
are entering into a forward contract.
Main Features of Forward Contracts
1. Two parties agree to exchange some item in the future at a price specified now – the
forward price.
2. The price for immediate delivery of the item is called the spot price.
3. No money is paid in the present by either party to the other.
4. The face value of the contract is the quantity of the item specified in the contract times the
forward price
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 203
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
5. The party who agrees to buy the specified item is said to take a long position, and the
party who agrees to sell the item is said to take a short position.
Futures Contract
• It is a standardized forward contract that is traded on some organized exchange.
• The exchange interposes itself between the buyer and the seller, so that each has a
separate contract with the exchange.
• Standardization: the terms of futures contract are the same for all contracts
Forward and futures contracts are derivatives arrangements that involve two parties who agree
to buy or sell a specific asset at a set price by a certain date in the future. Buyers and sellers can
mitigate the risks associated with price movements down the road by locking in the purchase/sale
price in advance.
A forward contract is an arrangement that is made over-the-counter (OTC) and settles just once
at the end of the contract. Both parties involved in the agreement negotiate the exact terms of the
contract. It is privately negotiated and comes with a degree of default risk since the counterparty is
responsible for remitting payment.
Futures contracts, on the other hand, are standardized contracts that trade on stock exchanges.
As such, they are settled on a daily basis. These arrangements come with fixed maturity
dates and uniform terms. There is very little risk with futures, as they guarantee payment on the
agreed-upon date.
Futures are derivative financial contracts that obligate parties to buy or sell an asset at a
predetermined future date and price. The buyer must purchase or the seller must sell the
underlying asset at the set price, regardless of the current market price at the expiration date.
Underlying assets include physical commodities and financial instruments. Futures
contracts detail the quantity of the underlying asset and are standardized to facilitate trading on
a futures exchange. Futures can be used for hedging or trade speculation.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 204
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• Risk is due to uncertainty about the future price of wheat.
• He has a large investment in the bakery.
• The farmer and the baker agree to a certain forward price that the baker will pay the
farmer at the time of delivery.
• They sign a contract that the farmer will deliver a specified quantity of wheat to the baker
at the forward price regardless of what the spot price turns out to be at the delivery date.
• Suppose the size of the farmer’s crop is 400,000 kg (10,000 maunds)
• The forward price for delivery a month from now is Rs. 2000 per 40 kg.
• After a month, the farmer will deliver 400,000 kg wheat and will get Rs. 20 million in
return.
• With this agreement, both parties eliminate the risk associated with the uncertainty about
the spot price of wheat at the delivery date.
• They both are hedging their exposures.
Consider the following example of a forward contract. Assume that an agricultural producer has
two million bushels of corn to sell six months from now and is concerned about a potential decline
in the price of corn. It thus enters into a forward contract with its financial institution to sell two
million bushels of corn at a price of $4.30 per bushel in six months, with settlement on a cash
basis.
In six months, the spot price of corn has three possibilities:
1. It is exactly $4.30 per bushel. In this case, no monies are owed by the producer or
financial institution to each other and the contract is closed.
2. It is higher than the contract price, say $5 per bushel. The producer owes the
institution $1.4 million, or the difference between the current spot price and the contracted
rate of $4.30.
3. It is lower than the contract price, say $3.50 per bushel. The financial institution will
pay the producer $1.6 million, or the difference between the contracted rate of $4.30 and
the current spot price.
Cash flow from the futures contract Rs. 5 million paid to farmer 0
Cash flow from the futures contract Rs. 5 million paid by baker 0
Futures can be used to hedge the price movement of the underlying asset. Here, the goal is to
prevent losses from potentially unfavorable price changes rather than to speculate. Many
companies that enter hedges are using—or in many cases producing—the underlying asset.
For example, corn farmers can use futures to lock in a specific price for selling their corn crop. By
doing so, they reduce their risk and guarantee they will receive the fixed price. If the price of corn
decreased, the farmer would have a gain on the hedge to offset losses from selling the corn at
the market. With such a gain and loss offsetting each other, the hedging effectively locks in an
acceptable market price.
• The farmer is able to eliminate the price risk he faces from owning the wheat by taking a
short position in a futures contract, effectively selling the wheat for future delivery at the
futures price.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 206
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• The baker too is able to eliminate risk by taking long position in the futures market for
wheat.
Currency risk is the financial risk that arises from potential changes in the exchange rate of one
currency in relation to another. And it's not just those trading in the foreign exchange markets
that are affected. Adverse currency movements can often crush the returns of a portfolio with
heavy international exposure, or diminish the returns of an otherwise prosperous international
business venture. Companies that conduct business across borders are exposed to currency
risk when income earned abroad is converted into the money of the domestic country, and when
payables are converted from the domestic currency to the foreign currency.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 207
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
The currency swap market is one way to hedge that risk. Currency swaps not only hedge against
risk exposure associated with exchange rate fluctuations, but they also ensure receipt of foreign
monies and achieve better lending rates.
A currency swap is a financial instrument that involves the exchange of interest in one currency
for the same in another currency.
Currency swaps comprise two notional principals that are exchanged at the beginning and end of
the agreement. These notional principals are predetermined dollar amounts, or principal, on which
the exchanged interest payments are based. However, this principal is never actually repaid: It's
strictly "notional" (which means theoretical). It's only used as a basis on which to calculate the
interest rate payments, which do change hands.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 209
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• The insurance company can hedge this customer liability by buying a default-free zero
coupon bond with a face value of $1,000 issued by the government.
• The insurance company will be matching assets to liabilities
• The insurance company will buy the government bond for less that $783.53
Insurance companies and other financial intermediaries that sell insured savings plans and other
insurance contracts need to assure their customers that the product they are buying is free of
default risk. One way to assure customers about the risk of contract default is for insurance
companies to hedge their liabilities in the financial markets by investing in assets that match the
characteristics of their liabilities.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 210
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
If there are two or more ways to hedge against risk, the investor will analyze the cost of hedging
and choose the method that has less cost.
This can be explained with the help of the example presented below.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 211
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 28
INSURANCE VERSUS HEDGING AND THE DIVERSIFICATION PRINCIPLE
Example
• You are planning a trip from Lahore to London a year from now.
• You make your flight reservations now; you can buy the ticket now or close to the day of
your travel. If you decide to lock in the price today, you have hedges against the risk of
loss.
• It costs you nothing to do so, but you have given up the possibility of paying less than the
amount you have paid for the ticket.
• Alternatively, the airline may offer you that if you pay $20 now, you will have to pay $1000
whenever you buy the ticket.
• This is an example of buying insurance.
Insurance and hedging both reduce your exposure to financial risk, but they do so in different
ways. Insurance typically involves paying someone else to bear risk, while hedging involves
making an investment that offsets risk.
Insurance Shifts Risk
Buying an insurance policy that protects your home against fire does not guarantee that your
home won't burn down. Having auto insurance doesn't mean you won't crash your car, and life
insurance won't keep you from dying. What insurance does is shift potential financial losses from
you to someone else. If your house burns down or your car gets totaled, you don't have to pay to
replace it because the insurance company does.
Hedging Offsets Risk
Hedging reduces uncertainty, which is really just another word for risk. For a simple example, say
you do a lot of business with Europe, and you've discover that you lose money if the exchange
rate rises above $1.50 per euro. So you buy a series of options contracts that give you the right
to buy euros for, say, $1.40 per euro. Those options offset your risk from rising exchange rates.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 212
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
If the rate never rises about $1.40, then you just let the options expire. But if the rate tops $1.40,
then you've locked in an exchange rate that offsets the increase and protects your profit. The
options, therefore, are hedges.
• Exclusions are losses that might seem to meet the conditions for coverage under the
insurance contracts but are specifically excluded.
Caps
• Caps are limits placed on compensation for particular losses covered under an
insurance contract.
• For example, if a health insurance policy is capped at Rs. 5 lacs, it means the insurance
company will pay no more than this amount for the treatment of an illness.
Deductibles
• A deductible is an amount of money that the insured party must pay out of his or her own
resources before receiving any compensation from the insurer.
• For example, if your car insurance policy has a Rs. 1000 deductible for damage due to
accidents, you must pay the first Rs. 1000 in repair costs and the insurer will only pay for
the amount in excess of Rs. 1000.
Copayments
• A copayment feature means that the insured party must cover a fraction of the loss. For
example, an insurance policy might stipulate that the copayment is 20% of any loss,
and the insurance company pays the other 80%.
• Copayments are similar to deductibles. The difference is in the way the paying part is
computed.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 213
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Why Deductibles and Copayments are Imposed?
• Example:
– In case of health insurance, the insured pays part of the doctor’s fee
The FOUR important features of insurance contracts are EXCLUSIONS AND CAPS,
DEDUCTIBLES, AND COPAYMENTS.
Deductibles
An insurance deductible is a specific amount you must spend before your insurance policy pays
for some or all of your claims.
Insurance companies use deductibles to ensure policyholders have skin in the game and will
share the cost of any claims.
Deductibles cushion against financial stress caused by catastrophic loss or an accumulation of
small losses all at once for an insurer.
In addition to premiums, individuals must meet health insurance deductibles and may also be
required for other costs like copays and coinsurance, depending on their plans.
The general rule is that policies with higher premiums come with lower deductibles while those
with lower premiums tend to have higher deductibles.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 214
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Copays are a specified dollar amount rather than a percentage of the bill, and they usually paid
at the time of service. Not all medical services ask you for a copay. For example, some insurance
companies do not require a copay for annual physicals.
• Financial guarantees are insurance against credit risk, which is the risk that the other
party to a contract into which you have entered will default.
• A loan guarantee is a contract that obliges the guarantor to make the promised payment
on a loan if the borrower fails to do so.
Example
• Banks and other issuers of credit cards guarantee to merchants that they will stand
behind all customer purchases made their credit cards.
• Credit card issuers provide merchants with insurance against credit risk.
Financial Guarantors
• Banks, insurance companies and governments offer guarantees on a broad spectrum of
financial instruments ranging from credit cards to interest-rate and currency swaps.
A financial guarantee is an agreement that guarantees a debt will be repaid to a lender by another
party if the borrower defaults. Essentially, a third party acting as a guarantor promises to assume
responsibility for a debt should the borrower be unable to keep up on its payments to the creditor.
Guarantees can also come in the form of a security deposit or collateral. The types vary, ranging
from corporate guarantees to personal ones.
Some financial agreements may require the use of a financial guarantee before they can be
executed. In many cases, a guarantee is a legal contract that promises repayment of a debt to a
lender. This agreement takes place when a guarantor agrees to take on the financial responsibility
if the original debtor defaults on their financial obligation or goes insolvent. All three parties must
sign the agreement in order for it to go into effect.
Guarantees may take on the form of a security deposit. Common in the banking and lending
industries, this is a form of collateral provided by the debtor that can be liquidated if the debtor
defaults.
For instance, a secured credit card requires the borrower—usually someone with no credit
history—to put down a cash deposit for the amount of the credit line.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 215
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Financial guarantees act just like insurance and are very important in the financial industry. They
allow certain financial transactions, especially those that wouldn't normally take place, to go
through, permitting, for instance, high-risk borrowers to take out loans and other forms of credit.
In short, they mitigate the risk associated with lending to high-risk borrowers and extending credit
during times of financial uncertainty.
Who is an Underwriter?
• An underwriter is any party that evaluates and assumes another party's risk for a fee,
which often takes the form of a commission, premium, spread, or interest.
• Agents and brokers represent both consumers and insurance companies, while
underwriters work for insurance companies.
An interest rate cap is a type of interest rate derivative in which the buyer receives payments at
the end of each period in which the interest rate exceeds the agreed strike price. An example of
a cap would be an agreement to receive a payment for each month the LIBOR rate exceeds 2.5%.
Similarly an interest rate floor is a derivative contract in which the buyer receives payments at the
end of each period in which the interest rate is below the agreed strike price.
Caps and floors can be used to hedge against interest rate fluctuations. For example, a borrower
who is paying the LIBOR rate on a loan can protect himself against a rise in rates by buying a cap
at 2.5%. If the interest rate exceeds 2.5% in a given period the payment received from the
derivative can be used to help make the interest payment for that period, thus the interest
payments are effectively "capped" at 2.5% from the borrowers' point of view.
• Options are versatile financial products. These contracts involve a buyer and seller,
where the buyer pays a premium for the rights granted by the contract.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 217
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• Call options allow the holder to buy the asset at a stated price within a specific timeframe.
• Put options, on the other hand, allow the holder to sell the asset at a stated price within
a specific timeframe.
• Each call option has a bullish buyer and a bearish seller while put options have a bearish
buyer and a bullish seller.
• The fixed price specified in an option contract is called the option’s strike price or exercise
price.
• The date after which an option can no longer be exercised is called its expiration date or
maturity date.
• If an option can be exercised on the expiration date only, it is called a European-type
option.
• If it can be exercised at any time up to and including the expiration date it is called an
American-type option.
Options started as insurance policies for either long or short stock. A put option gives the buyer
the right to sell a set stock at a set price on or before a set date. This means that no matter how
low a stock goes, the investor has the right to sell the stock for the agreed upon price.
Why would an investor purchase insurance on the stock instead of using the stop-loss? The
answer to that question will be specific to each investor, but things like tax considerations when
selling, dividend payments, or belief in the company through a rough patch are all very valid
reasons that an investor might buy insurance on the stock.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 218
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 29
THE DIVERSIFICATION PRINCIPLE
• The cost of developing a medicine is $100,000. The rate of return is the payoff minus the
cost divided by the cost.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 219
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Diversification with Two Drugs
• The cost of developing a medicine is $100,000. The rate of return is the payoff minus the
cost divided by the cost.
Advantages of Diversification
• Thus, by diversifying and holding a portfolio of two drugs you reduce the probability of
losing your entire investment to only one-half of what it would be without diversification.
• The probability of winding up with $400,000 has fallen from 0.5 to 0.25.
If one were to poll investors and investment professionals to determine their ideal investment
outcome, the vast majority would no doubt agree: It's a double-digit total return in all economic
environments, each and every year.
Naturally, they would also agree that the worst-case scenario is an overall decrease in asset
value. But despite this knowledge, very few achieve this desired outcome; and many, indeed,
encounter the worst-case scenario—losses. The reasons for this are diverse: misallocation of
assets, pseudo-diversification, hidden correlation, weighting imbalance, false returns, and
underlying devaluation.
The solution, however, could be simpler than you would expect. In this article, we will show how
to achieve true diversification through asset class selection, rather than stock picking and market
timing.
Many investors do not truly understand effective diversification, often believing they are fully
diversified after spreading their investment across large-, mid- or small-cap stocks; energy,
financial, health care or technology stocks; or even investing in emerging markets. In reality,
however, they have merely invested in multiple sectors of the equities asset class and are prone
to the rise and fall within that market.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 220
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
TOPIC 147: THE DIVERSIFICATION PRINCIPLE- PROBABILITY DISTRIBUTION
For diversification, the probabilities of all the possible outcomes are considered in the form of a
probability distribution (discussed earlier). Expected rate of returns and standard deviations are
estimated to decide how diversification will be done.
• The formula for the expected payoff is:
• E(X) = ∑𝑛𝑖=1 𝑃𝑖 𝑋𝑖
• Expected Payoff – One drug E(X) = 0.5 (0)+0.5(400,000) = $200,000
• Standard Deviation:
• = $200,000
• Standard Deviation:
• 𝜎=
√0.25(0 − 200,000)2 + 0.5(200, 000 − 200,000)2 + 0.25(400,000−200,000)2
• = $141,421
Advantage of Diversification
When we diversify between two uncorrelated drugs the expected payoff remains
$200,000, but the standard deviation of the rate of return falls from $200, 000 to
$141,421.
If the number of drugs in the portfolio increases further:
The expected payoff stays the same, but
The standard deviation declines in proportion to the square root of the number of drugs:
𝜎𝑝𝑜𝑟𝑡𝑓𝑜𝑙𝑖𝑜 = $200,000/√𝑁
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 221
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Diversifiable and Non-diversifiable Risks
• The part of portfolio volatility that can be eliminated by adding more stocks is the
diversifiable risk, and
• The part that remains no matter how many stocks are added is the non-diversifiable risk.
Firm-Specific Risk
• Random events that affect the prospects of only one firm, such as a lawsuit, a strike or a
new product failure, give rise to random losses that are uncorrelated across stocks and
can, be diversified away.
• Such risk is called firm-specific risk.
International Diversification
• By combining stocks of firms located in different countries it is possible to reduce the risk
of one’s stock portfolio, but there is a limit to this risk reduction.
• International diversification can improve the prospects for risk reduction for people around
the world, a significant amount of risk remains for even the best-diversified global stock
portfolio.
Non-diversifiable risk can be referred to a risk which is common to a whole class of assets or
liabilities. The investment value might decline over a specific period of time only due to economic
changes or other events which affect large sections of the market. However, diversification and
asset allocation can provide protection against non-diversifiable risk as different sections of the
market have a tendency to underperform at different times. Non-diversifiable risk can also be
referred as market risk or systematic risk.
Putting it simple, risk of an investment asset (real estate, bond, stock/share, etc.) which cannot
be mitigated or eliminated by adding that asset to a diversified investment portfolio can be
delineated as non-diversifiable risks. Moreover, this is the risk you are exposed to in an individual
investment. This risk type is involved in almost every investment, i.e. uncertainty of market moving
up or down and the particular movement of the investment.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 222
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Understanding non-diversifiable risk
Being unavoidable and non-compensating for exposure to such risks, non-diversifiable risk can
be taken as the significant section of an asset’s risk attributable to market factors affecting all
firms. The main reasons for this risk type include inflation, war, political events, and international
incidents. Moreover, it cannot be purged through diversification.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 223
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 224
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 30
THE PROCESS OF PERSONAL PORTFOLIO SELECTION
A portfolio is a collection of financial investments like stocks, bonds, commodities, cash, and cash
equivalents, including closed-end funds and exchange traded funds (ETFs). People generally
believe that stocks, bonds, and cash comprise the core of a portfolio. Though this is often the
case, it does not need to be the rule. A portfolio may contain a wide range of assets including real
estate, art, and private investments.
You may choose to hold and manage your portfolio yourself, or you may allow a money manager,
financial advisor, or another finance professional to manage your portfolio.
One of the key concepts in portfolio management is the wisdom of diversification—which simply
means not putting all of your eggs in one basket. Diversification tries to reduce risk by allocating
investments among various financial instruments, industries, and other categories. It aims to
maximize returns by investing in different areas that would each react differently to the same
event. There are many ways to diversify.
How you choose to do it is up to you. Your position in the life cycle, time horizon, yYour goals for
the future, your appetite for risk, and your personality are all factors in deciding how to build your
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 225
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
portfolio. It may also get affected by the type of adice you will get from your professional asset
manager.
Regardless of your portfolio's asset mix, all portfolios should contain some degree of
diversification, and reflect the investor's tolerance for risk, return objectives, time horizon, and
other pertinent constraints, including tax position, liquidity needs, legal situations, and unique
circumstances.
TOPIC 151: PERSONAL PORTFOLIO SELECTION – LIFE CYCLE
• In portfolio selection the best strategy depends on an individual’s personal circumstances
(age, family status, occupation, income, wealth, etc.)
• For a young couple recently starting a family it may be optimal to buy a house and take
out a mortgage loan.
• For an older couple about to retire, it may be optimal to sell their house and invest the
proceeds in some asset that will provide a steady stream of income for as long as they
live.
• People of the same age, with the same income and wealth, may have different
perspectives on buying a house or buying insurance.
• The same is true of investing in stocks, bonds, and other securities.
• There is no single portfolio that is best for all people.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 226
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• The longest time horizon would typically correspond to the retirement goal and would be
the balance of one’s lifetime.
• Thus for a 25 year old who expects to live to the age of 85, the planning horizon will be
60 years.
• There are shorter planning horizons also.
• For example, if you have a ten years old child and you plan to pay for his education when
he reaches age 22, the planning horizon for this goal is 12 years.
Decision Horizon
• The decision horizon is the length of time between decisions to revise the portfolio.
• The length of the decision horizon is controlled by the individual within certain limits.
• Some people review their portfolios at regular intervals, e.g. once in a month, etc. or once
a year
Strategy
• Portfolio decisions you make today are influenced by what you think might happen
tomorrow. A plan that takes account of future decisions in making current decisions is
called a strategy.
Investors should consider how long they have to invest when building a portfolio. In general,
investors should be moving toward a conservative asset allocation as their goal date approaches,
to protect the portfolio's earnings up to that point.
For example, a conservative investor might favor a portfolio with large-cap value stocks, broad-
based market index funds, investment-grade bonds, and a position in liquid, high-grade cash
equivalents.
Risk tolerance is the degree of risk that an investor is willing to endure given the volatility in the
value of an investment. An important component in investing, risk tolerance often determines the
type and amount of investments that an individual chooses.
Greater risk tolerance is often synonymous with investment in stocks, equity funds, and
exchange-traded funds (ETFs), while lower risk tolerance is often associated with the purchase
of bonds, bond funds, and income funds.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 228
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
– Various investment accounts and mutual funds offered by banks, securities firms,
investment companies, and insurance companies.
How Financial Institutions develop Products?
• The selection is done by examining the quantitative trade-off between risk and expected
return.
• To find the portfolio that offers investors the highest expected rate of return for any
degree of risk they are willing to tolerate.
An asset manager manages assets on behalf of someone else, making important investment
decisions that will help the client's portfolio grow. An asset manager also ensures the client's
investment doesn't depreciate and that exposure to risk is mitigated. Doing this means watching
the market, keeping up to date with research and trends, and staying current with political,
financial, and economic news. The advice of the asset manager plays an important role and can
shape the portfolio selection process to a great extent.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 229
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 31
PORTFOLIO OPTIMIZATION
Optimization is the process of making a trading system more effective by adjusting the variables
used for technical analysis. A trading system can be optimized by reducing certain transaction
costs or risks, or by targeting assets with greater expected returns. The single risky-asset portfolio
is composed of many risky assets chosen in an optimal way.
Portfolio optimization is often done as a two-step process:
1. Find the optimal combination of risky assets, and
2. Mix this optimal risky-asset portfolio with the riskless asset
A riskless asset is defined as a security that offers a perfectly predictable rate of return in terms
of account selected for the analysis and the investor’s decision horizon.
When no specific investor is identified, the riskless asset refers to an asset that offers a predictable
rate of return over the trading horizon (i.e., the shortest possible decision horizon).
If Pakistani Rupee is taken as a unit of account and trading horizon is a day, the riskless rate is
the interest rate on Treasury bill maturing the next day.
Portfolio management is the art and science of selecting and overseeing a group of investments
that meet the long-term financial objectives and risk tolerance of a client, a company, or an
institution.
Some individuals do their own investment portfolio management. That requires a basic
understanding of the key elements of portfolio building and maintenance that make for success,
including asset allocation, diversification, and rebalancing. Most people have neither the
knowledge nor the time to carry out portfolio optimization.
They hire an investment advisor to do it for them or they buy finished product from a financial
intermediary. Finished products include:
Various investment accounts and mutual funds offered by banks, securities firms, investment
companies, and insurance companies.
The objective of the professional asset manager is to find the portfolio that offers investors the
highest expected rate of return for any degree of risk they are willing to tolerate.
The Professional Portfolio Managers use risk-reward tradeoff to decide between (among) various
investment options.
1. The risk-return tradeoff is an investment principle that indicates that the higher the risk,
the higher the potential reward.
2. To calculate an appropriate risk-return tradeoff, investors must consider many factors,
including overall risk tolerance, the potential to replace lost funds and more.
3. Investors consider the risk-return tradeoff on individual investments and across portfolios
when making investment decisions.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 231
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
When an investor considers high-risk-high-return investments, the investor can apply the risk-
return tradeoff to the vehicle on a singular basis as well as within the context of the portfolio as a
whole. Examples of high-risk-high return investments include options, penny stocks and
leveraged exchange-traded funds (ETFs). Generally speaking, a diversified portfolio reduces the
risks presented by individual investment positions. For example, a penny stock position may have
a high risk on a singular basis, but if it is the only position of its kind in a larger portfolio, the risk
incurred by holding the stock is minimal.
Risk-Return Tradeoff at the Portfolio Level
That said, the risk-return tradeoff also exists at the portfolio level. For example, a portfolio
composed of all equities presents both higher risk and higher potential returns. Within an all-equity
portfolio, risk and reward can be increased by concentrating investments in specific sectors or by
taking on single positions that represent a large percentage of holdings. For investors, assessing
the cumulative risk-return tradeoff of all positions can provide insight on whether a portfolio
assumes enough risk to achieve long-term return objectives or if the risk levels are too high with
the existing mix of holdings.
The Professional Portfolio Managers use quantitative analysis of risk and reward tradeoff to do
the portfolio management.
Suppose you have Rs. 100,000 to invest. You are choosing between a riskless asset with an
interest rate of 0.06 per year and a risky asset with an expected rate of return of 0.14 per year
and a standard deviation of 0.2. How much of your Rs 100,000 should you invest in the risky
asset?
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 232
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 233
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
E(r) = w E(𝒓_𝒔) +(1-w)𝒓_𝒇
= 𝒓_𝒇+ w [E(𝒓_𝒔) - 𝒓_𝒇]
The Risk-Reward Trade-Off Line
Example: Suppose w denote the proportion of the PKR 100,000 investment to be allocated to
the risky asset. Then, (1-w) will be invested in riskless asset.
Substituting 0.06 for 𝒓_𝒇 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝟎.𝟏𝟒 𝐟𝐨𝐫 (𝒓_𝒔)
The Expected Rate of Return E(r) will be: E(r) = 0.06+w(0.14-0.06) = 0.06 + 0.08 w
Interpretation
The portfolio is expected to earn a risk premium which depends on:
1. The risk premium on the risky asset E(𝒓_𝒔) - 𝒓_𝒇, which is 0.14-0.06=0.08 in the above example
2. The proportion of the portfolio invested in the risky asset i.e. w
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 234
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 236
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 32
PORTFOLIO EFFICIENCY
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 237
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Portfolio efficiency is achieved by applying Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT). This concept was first
formulated by Harry Markowitz in 1952. According to MPT, an investment's risk and return
characteristics should not be viewed alone. Instead, they should be evaluated by how the
investment affects the overall portfolio's risk and return.
An inefficient portfolio exposes an investor to a higher degree of risk than necessary to achieve a
target return.
For example, a portfolio of high-yield bonds expected to provide only the risk-free rate of return
would be said to be inefficient.
An investor could achieve the same return by purchasing Treasury bills, which are considered
among the safest investments in the world (rather than high-yield bonds, which are, by definition,
rated as risky investments).
The line that connects all these efficient portfolios is known as the efficient frontier.
The efficient frontier represents those portfolios that have the maximum rate of return for every
given level of risk.
The last thing investors want is a portfolio with a low expected return and a high level of risk.
The efficient frontier theory was introduced by Nobel Laureate Harry Markowitz in 1952 and is a
cornerstone of modern portfolio theory (MPT). The efficient frontier rates portfolios (investments)
on a scale of return (y-axis) versus risk (x-axis). The compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of an
investment is commonly used as the return component while standard deviation (annualized)
depicts the risk metric.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 238
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
The efficient frontier graphically represents portfolios that maximize returns for the risk assumed.
Returns are dependent on the investment combinations that make up the portfolio.
The less synchronized the securities (lower covariance), the lower the standard deviation. If this
mix of optimizing the return versus risk paradigm is successful, then that portfolio should line up
along the efficient frontier line.
The ultimate capital allocation line (CAL) tangent to the optimal risky portfolio is termed the capital
market line (CML), which offers the highest possible expected return for any given level of risk,
and the lowest possible risk for any given level of expected return.
• The ultimate capital allocation line (CAL) tangent to the optimal risky portfolio is termed
the capital market line (CML), which offers the highest possible expected return for any
given level of risk, and the lowest possible risk for any given level of expected return.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 240
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Risk Reward Tradeoff between two risky assets
The point corresponding to the point of tangency is the risky portfolio, indication the
optimal combination of risky assets.
Optimal = Most efficient portfolios
Graphical Illustration
The point corresponding to the point of tangency is the risky portfolio, indication the optimal
combination of risky assets.
Optimal = Most efficient portfolios
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 242
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 243
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• In a large fund with multiple managers with different styles of investing, a CEO or head
portfolio manager might calculate the risk of continuing to employ a portfolio manager who
deviates too far from the mean in a negative direction.
• This can go the other way as well, and a portfolio manager who outperforms their
colleagues and the market can often expect a hefty bonus for their performance.
• The composition of this portfolio depends on the expected rate of returns and standard
deviations of Risky Assets 1 and 2 and the correlation between them.
Preferred Portfolio will be a portfolio shown by any point between F and T. Depending on:
Planning Horizon
Life Cycle
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 244
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Risk Tolerance
To calculate a portfolio's expected return, an investor needs to calculate the expected return of
each of its holdings, as well as the overall weight of each holding.
The basic expected return formula involves multiplying each asset's weight in the portfolio by its
expected return, then adding all those figures together.
Expected returns do not paint a complete picture, so making investment decisions based on them
alone can be dangerous.
It is calculated to judge the realized performance of a portfolio manager.
In a large fund with multiple managers with different styles of investing, a CEO or head portfolio
manager might calculate the risk of continuing to employ a portfolio manager who deviates too
far from the mean in a negative direction.
People have thousands of assets to choose from but they make their choices from a list
of a few final products offered by financial intermediaries such as bank accounts, stock
and bond mutual funds, and real estate.
Intermediaries make use of the latest advances in financial technology but the basic mean-
variance approach is still the dominant method.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 246
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 33
CAPITAL ASSET PRICING MODEL (CAPM)
The Capital Asset Pricing Model is an equilibrium theory that is based on the theory of portfolio
selection. It was developed in 1964 by William F. Sharpe. The Capital Asset Pricing Model
(CAPM) describes the relationship between systematic risk, or the general perils of investing, and
expected return for assets, particularly stocks.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 247
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
It is a finance model that establishes a linear relationship between the required return on an
investment and risk. The model is based on the relationship between an asset's beta, the risk-
free rate (typically the Treasury bill rate), and the equity risk premium, or the expected return on
the market minus the risk-free rate.
CAPM evolved as a way to measure this systematic risk. It is widely used throughout finance for
pricing risky securities and generating expected returns for assets, given the risk of those assets
and cost of capital.
Assumptions
Investors are rational, mean-variance optimizers.
Investors use identical input lists, referred to as homogeneous expectations.
All assets are publicly traded (short positions are allowed) and investors can borrow or lend at a
common risk-free rate.
The formula for calculating the expected return of an asset, given its risk, is as follows:
ERi=Rf+βi(ERm−Rf)
where:ERi=expected return of investmentRf=risk-free rate
βi=beta of the investment
(ERm−Rf)=market risk premium
Investors expect to be compensated for risk and the time value of money. The risk-free rate in
the CAPM formula accounts for the time value of money. The other components of the CAPM
formula account for the investor taking on additional risk.
The goal of the CAPM formula is to evaluate whether a stock is fairly valued when its risk and
the time value of money are compared with its expected return. In other words, by knowing the
individual parts of the CAPM, it is possible to gauge whether the current price of a stock is
consistent with its likely return.
A portfolio that holds all assets in proportion to their observed market values is called the market
portfolio.
Example: Suppose there are only three assets:
GM stocks; Toyota stocks and the risk-free asset.
Total market values of each at current prices are $66 billion of GM, $22 billion of Toyota, and
$12 billion of the risk-free asset.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 248
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Total market value of all assets is $100 billion.
The CAPM says that in equilibrium any investor’s relative holdings of risky assets will be the
same as in the market portfolio.
In our example, all investors will hold GM and Toyota stock in the proportion of 3 to 1 (i.e., 66/22).
Slope of CML is the risk premium on the market portfolio divided by its standard deviation.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 249
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
TOPIC 169: DETERMINANTS OF THE RISK PREMIUM ON THE MARKET PORTFOLIO
The size of the risk premium of the market portfolio depends on:
the aggregate risk aversion of investors and
the volatility of the market return
To be induced to accept the risk of the market portfolio, investors must be offered an
expected rate of return that exceeds the risk-free rate of return.
The greater the average degree of risk aversion, the higher the risk premium needed.
Equilibrium Risk Premium
In the CAPM, the equilibrium risk premium on the market portfolio is equal to the variance
of the market portfolio times a weighted average of the degree of risk aversion of the
holders of wealth (A);
= 0.08
TOPIC 170: ACTIVE AND PASSIVE INVESTING
• Active investing requires a hands-on approach, typically by a portfolio manager or other
so-called active participant.
• Passive investing involves less buying and selling and often results in investors buying
index funds or other mutual funds.
Active Investing
• The goal of active money management is to beat the stock market’s average returns and
take full advantage of short-term price fluctuations.
• It involves a much deeper analysis and the expertise to know when to pivot into or out of
a particular stock, bond, or any asset.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 250
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• A portfolio manager usually oversees a team of analysts who look
at qualitative and quantitative factors, then gaze into their crystal balls to try to determine
where and when that price will change.
Active investing, as its name implies, takes a hands-on approach and requires that someone act
in the role of a portfolio manager. The goal of active money management is to beat the stock
market’s average returns and take full advantage of short-term price fluctuations. It involves a
much deeper analysis and the expertise to know when to pivot into or out of a particular stock,
bond, or any asset. A portfolio manager usually oversees a team of analysts who look at
qualitative and quantitative factors, then gaze into their crystal balls to try to determine where and
when that price will change.
Active investing requires confidence that whoever is managing the portfolio will know exactly the
right time to buy or sell. Successful active investment management requires being right more
often than wrong.
Passive Investing
If you are a passive investor, you invest for the long haul. Passive investors limit the amount of
buying and selling within their portfolios, making this a very cost-effective way to invest. The
strategy requires a buy-and-hold mentality. That means resisting the temptation to react or
anticipate the stock market’s every next move.
The prime example of a passive approach is to buy an index fund that follows one of the major
indices like the S&P 500 or Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA). Whenever these indices switch
up their constituents, the index funds that follow them automatically switch up their holdings by
selling the stock that’s leaving and buying the stock that’s becoming part of the index. This is why
it is such a big deal when a company becomes big enough to be included in one of the major
indices: It guarantees that the stock will become a core holding in thousands of major funds.
• Although both styles of investing are beneficial, passive investments have garnered more
investment flows than active investments.
• Historically, passive investments have earned more money than active investments.
• Active investing has become more popular than it has in several years, particularly during
market upheavals.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 251
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
TOPIC 171: BETA AND RISK PREMIUMS ON INDIVIDUAL SECURITIES
The risk of security A is larger than the risk of security B, if in equilibrium the expected
return on A exceeds the expected return on B.
In other words, along CML, among optimal (efficient) portfolios, the larger the standard
deviation of its return, the larger the equilibrium expected return E(r), and therefore, the
larger the risk.
The risk of an efficient portfolio is measured by 𝝈
The measure of a security’s risk is its beta, which is defined as:
𝜷_𝒋=𝝈_𝒋𝑴/(𝝈_𝑴^𝟐 )
Where
𝝈_𝒋M denotes the covariance between the return on security j and the return on the market
portfolio.
Equilibrium
According to CAPM, in equilibrium, the risk premium on any asset is equal to its beta times the
risk premium on the market portfolio, i.e.
E(𝒓_𝒋) −𝒓_𝒇 = 𝜷_𝒋 [𝑬(𝒓_𝑴 )− 𝒓_𝒇 ]
The security market line (SML) is a line drawn on a chart that serves as a graphical representation
of the capital asset pricing model (CAPM)—which shows different levels of systematic, or market
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 252
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
risk, of various marketable securities, plotted against the expected return of the entire market at
any given time.
Also known as the "characteristic line," the SML is a visualization of the CAPM, where the x-axis
of the chart represents risk (in terms of beta), and the y-axis of the chart represents expected
return. The market risk premium of a given security is determined by where it is plotted on the
chart relative to the SML.
The security market line is an investment evaluation tool derived from the CAPM—a model that
describes risk-return relationship for securities—and is based on the assumption that investors
need to be compensated for both the time value of money (TVM) and the corresponding level of
risk associated with any investment, referred to as the risk premium.
If any security is not on SML, e.g. it is at J, its expected return is “too low” to support equilibrium.
The existence of such situation contradicts CAPM and implies that the market is not in equilibrium.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 253
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 34
USING THE CAPM IN PORTFOLIO SELECTION
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 254
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• Indexes can also be more specialized, such as indexes that track a particular industry or
segment.
• Index providers have numerous methodologies for constructing investment market
indexes.
• Index fund management, aims to duplicate the return of a particular market index or
benchmark.
• Managers buy the same stocks that are listed on the index, using the same weighting
that they represent in the index.
• CAPM contributed to the rise in the use of indexing–assembling a portfolio of shares to
mimic a particular market or asset class–by risk-averse investors.
• This is largely due to CAPM's message that it is only possible to earn higher returns than
those of the market as a whole by taking on higher risk (beta).
• If a fund manager is underperforming the S&P 500 over the long term, for example, it will
be hard to entice investors into the fund.
What is alpha?
• Alpha is a measure of the active return on an investment, the performance of that
investment compared with a suitable market index.
Indexing, broadly, refers to the use of some benchmark indicator or measure as a reference or
yard stick. In finance and economics, indexing is used as a statistical measure for tracking
economic data such as inflation, unemployment, gross domestic product (GDP) growth,
productivity, and market returns.
Indexing may also refer to passive investment strategies that replicate benchmark indexes. Index
investing has become increasingly popular over the past decades.
Indexes typically measure the performance of a basket of securities intended to replicate a certain
area of the market. These could be a broad-based index that captures the entire market, such as
the Standard & Poor's 500 Index or KSE100 Index.
Indexes can also be more specialized, such as indexes that track a particular industry or segment.
Index providers have numerous methodologies for constructing investment market indexes. Index
fund management, aims to duplicate the return of a particular market index or
benchmark. Managers buy the same stocks that are listed on the index, using the same weighting
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 255
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
that they represent in the index. CAPM contributed to the rise in the use of indexing–assembling
a portfolio of shares to mimic a particular market or asset class–by risk-averse investors.
This is largely due to CAPM's message that it is only possible to earn higher returns than those
of the market as a whole by taking on higher risk (beta).
If a fund manager is underperforming the S&P 500 over the long term, for example, it will be hard
to entice investors into the fund.
Alpha is a measure of the active return on an investment, the performance of that investment
compared with a suitable market index. The capital market line (CML) shows the rates of return
for a specific portfolio. The security market line (SML) represents the market’s risk and return at
a given time, and shows the expected returns of individual assets. The measure of risk in the CML
is the standard deviation of returns (total risk), the risk measure in the SML is systematic risk or
beta.
CML’s equation
SML’s equation
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 256
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Capital Market Line
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 257
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• The capital market line (CML) shows the rates of return for a specific portfolio
• The security market line (SML) represents the market’s risk and return at a given time,
and shows the expected returns of individual assets.
• The measure of risk in the CML is the standard deviation of returns (total risk), the risk
measure in the SML is systematic risk or beta.
𝑫
=∑∞ 𝒕
𝒕=𝟏 (𝟏+𝒌)𝒕
Cost of capital is a company's calculation of the minimum return that would be necessary in order
to justify undertaking a capital budgeting project, such as building a new factory.
The term cost of capital is used by analysts and investors, but it is always an evaluation of whether
a projected decision can be justified by its cost. Investors may also use the term to refer to an
evaluation of an investment's potential return in relation to its cost and its risks.
Many companies use a combination of debt and equity to finance business expansion. For such
companies, the overall cost of capital is derived from the weighted average cost of all capital
sources. This is known as the weighted average cost of capital (WACC).
The concept of the cost of capital is key information used to determine a project's hurdle rate. A
company embarking on a major project must know how much money the project will have to
generate in order to offset the cost of undertaking it and then continue to generate profits for the
company.
Cost of capital, from the perspective of an investor, is an assessment of the return that can be
expected from the acquisition of stock shares or any other investment. This is an estimate and
might include best- and worst-case scenarios. An investor might look at the volatility (beta) of a
company's financial results to determine whether a stock's cost is justified by its potential return.
The concept of the cost of capital is key information used to determine a project's hurdle rate. A
company embarking on a major project must know how much money the project will have to
generate in order to offset the cost of undertaking it and then continue to generate profits for the
company.
Practitioners use a CAPM based method to estimate the cost of equity capital.
Example
Suppose you want to compute your firm’s cost of equity capital. You compute the beta of your
company’s stock and find it to be 1.1. The current risk free rate is 0.06 per year. You assume that
the market premium is 0.08 per year.
The equilibrium expected rate of return on the stock of your company will be:
E(r)= 𝒓_𝒇 + 𝜷 [𝑬(𝒓_𝑴 )− 𝒓_𝒇]
= 0.06 +1.1 (0.08)
= 0.148
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 259
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Thus, 14.8% per year is the cost of equity capital.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 260
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 35
MODIFICATIONS AND ALTERNATIVES TO THE CAPM
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 261
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Forward Markets – Pricing
• Prices in the forward market are interest-rate based.
• In the foreign exchange market, the forward price is derived from the interest rate
differential between the two currencies
• In interest rate forwards, the price is based on the yield curve to maturity.
Customers, both corporations and financial institutions such as hedge funds and mutual funds,
can execute forwards with a bank counter-party either as a swap or an outright transaction. In an
outright forward, currency A is bought vs. currency B for delivery on the maturity date, which can
be any business day beyond the spot date. The price is again the spot rate plus or minus the
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 262
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
forward points, but no money changes hands until the maturity date. Outright forwards are often
for odd dates and amounts; they can be for any size.
A futures market is an auction market in which participants buy and sell commodity and futures
contracts for delivery on a specified future date. Futures are exchange-traded derivatives
contracts that lock in future delivery of a commodity or security at a price set today.
Examples of futures markets are the New York Mercantile Exchange (NYMEX), the Chicago
Mercantile Exchange (CME), the Chicago Board of Trade (CBoT), the Cboe Options Exchange
(Cboe), and the Minneapolis Grain Exchange.
Originally, such trading was carried on through open outcry and the use of hand signals in trading
pits, located in financial hubs such as New York, Chicago, and London. Throughout the 21st
century, like most other markets, futures exchanges have become mostly electronic.
In order to understand fully what a futures market is, it’s important to understand the basics of
futures contracts, the assets traded in these markets.
Futures contracts are made in an attempt by producers and suppliers of commodities to avoid
market volatility. These producers and suppliers negotiate contracts with an investor who agrees
to take on both the risk and reward of a volatile market.
Futures markets or futures exchanges are where these financial products are bought and sold for
delivery at some agreed-upon date in the future with a price fixed at the time of the deal. Futures
markets are for more than simply agricultural contracts, and now involve the buying, selling and
hedging of financial products and future values of interest rates.
Futures contracts can be made or "created" as long as open interest is increased, unlike other
securities that are issued. The size of futures markets (which usually increase when the stock
market outlook is uncertain) is larger than that of commodity markets and is a key part of the
financial system.
Large futures markets run their own clearinghouses, where they can both make revenue from the
trading itself and from the processing of trades after the fact. Some of the biggest futures markets
that operate their own clearinghouses include the Chicago Mercantile Exchange, the ICE, and
Eurex. Other markets like Cboe have outside clearinghouses (Options Clearing Corporation)
settle trades.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 263
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Most all futures markets are registered with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC),
the main U.S. body in charge of regulation of futures markets. Exchanges are usually regulated
by the nation’s regulatory body in the country in which they are based.
Example
If a coffee farm sells green coffee beans at $4 per pound to a roaster, and the roaster sells that
roasted pound at $10 per pound and both are making a profit at that price, they’ll want to keep
those costs at a fixed rate. The investor agrees that if the price for coffee goes below a set rate,
the investor agrees to pay the difference to the coffee farmer.
If the price of coffee goes higher than a certain price, the investor gets to keep profits. For the
roaster, if the price of green coffee goes above an agreed rate, the investor pays the difference
and the roaster gets the coffee at a predictable rate. If the price of green coffee is lower than an
agreed-upon rate, the roaster pays the same price and the investor gets the profit.
• If the spot price on the contract maturity date is higher than the forward price, the party
who is long makes money.
• If the spot price on the contract maturity date is lower than the forward price, the party
who is short makes money.
• By contrast, futures contracts are standardized contracts that are traded on exchanges.
The exchange specifies the exact commodity, the contract size, and where and when
delivery will be made.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 264
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Distinctions between Forward and Future Contracts
Futures Forwards
No counterparty risk, since payment is guaranteed by the Credit default risk, since it is privately negotiated, an
exchange clearing house dependent on the counterparty for payment
Forward and futures contracts are derivatives arrangements that involve two parties who agree
to buy or sell a specific asset at a set price by a certain date in the future. Buyers and sellers can
mitigate the risks associated with price movements down the road by locking in the purchase/sale
price in advance.
A forward contract is an arrangement that is made over-the-counter (OTC) and settles just once
at the end of the contract. Both parties involved in the agreement negotiate the exact terms of the
contract. It is privately negotiated and comes with a degree of default risk since the counterparty
is responsible for remitting payment.
Futures contracts, on the other hand, are standardized contracts that trade on stock exchanges.
As such, they are settled on a daily basis. These arrangements come with fixed maturity dates
and uniform terms. There is very little risk with futures, as they guarantee payment on the agreed-
upon date.
The forward contract is a privately-negotiated agreement between a buyer and seller to trade an
asset at a future date at a specified price. As such, they don't trade on an exchange. Because of
the nature of the contract, forward contracts have more flexible terms and conditions, including
the number of units of the underlying asset and what exactly will be delivered, among other
factors. Forwards have one settlement date: the end of the contract.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 265
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Many hedgers use forward contracts to cut down on the volatility of an asset's price. Since the
terms are set when it is executed, a forward contract is not subject to price fluctuations. That
means if two parties agree to the sale of 1,000 ears of corn at $1 each (for a total of $1,000), the
terms cannot change even if the price of corn goes down to 50 cents per ear. It also ensures that
delivery of the asset or cash settlement (if specified) will take place.
Because of the nature of these contracts, forwards are not readily available to retail investors.
The market for them is often hard to predict. That's because the agreements and their details are
generally kept between the buyer and seller, and are not made public. Since they are private
agreements, there is a high degree of counterparty risk, which means there may be a chance that
one party will default.
Like forwards, futures contracts involve the agreement to buy and sell an asset at a specific price
at a future date. The futures contract, however, has some differences from the forward contract.
These contracts are marked-to-market (MTM) daily, which means that daily changes are settled
day by day until the end of the contract. The futures market is highly liquid, giving investors the
ability to enter and exit whenever they choose to do so.
These contracts are frequently used by speculators, who bet on the direction in which an asset's
price will move, they are usually closed out prior to maturity and delivery usually never happens.
In this case, a cash settlement usually takes place.
Because they are traded on an exchange, they have clearing houses that guarantee the
transactions. This drastically lowers the probability of default to almost never. Contracts are
available on stock exchange indexes, commodities, and currencies. The most popular assets for
futures contracts include crops like wheat and corn, and oil and gas.
Key Differences
One of the things that set forward contracts from futures contracts is how they're regulated.
Forward contracts aren't regulated at all while futures are overseen by a central government body.
The agency that provides oversight and regulation of futures contracts is the Commodity Futures
Trading Commission (CFTC). The CFTC was established in 1974 to regulate the derivatives
market, to ensure the markets run efficiently, and to protect the interests of investors by preventing
fraud and manipulation.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 266
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Guarantees for each contract are also provided by different parties. Since forwards are privately
negotiated, they provide the guarantee to settle the contract. Futures, on the other hand, have an
institutional guarantee provided by the clearinghouses that back them. Unlike forwards, where
there is no guarantee until the contract settles, futures require a deposit or margin. This acts as
collateral to cover the risk of default.
Suppose the distributor’s cost of physically storing the wheat is 10 cents per bushel per month.
The distributor will store the wheat only if F > $2.10. If the storage cost is 15 cents, the distributor
will sell the wheat immediately if F= $2.10.
Hence, distributor will choose to carry wheat for the next month only if
𝑪_𝒋<𝑭−𝑺
𝑪_𝒋 is cost of carry for distributor j
Spot price
F – S => Spread
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 267
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Speculators provide the markets with liquidity, aid in price discovery, and take on risk that
other market participants wish to unload.
In commodities markets, speculators also keep markets efficient and stave off shortages
of goods by bidding them up when prices fall and financing the middlemen who link supply
chains.
A speculator should thus not be confused with the middleman or broker.
Speculators often get a bad rep, especially when headlines report a crash in stocks, a
spike in oil prices, or a currency's value is shattered in short order. This is because the
media often confounds speculation with manipulation.
Manipulation is fraudulent and unethical, many times leading to extensive economic
damage; whereas speculation, while risky for the speculator, performs several important
functions that keep our markets and economy healthy.
Speculation in the commodities markets keeps not only financial markets, but also our
supermarket shelves and food supply chains running smoothly.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 268
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 36
COMMODITY SPOT AND FUTURES PRICES
TOPIC 184: RELATION BETWEEN COMMODITY SPOT AND FUTURES PRICES
• The futures price of a commodity is set in advance between producer and buyer.
• The spot price is the commodity's value when it is ready for delivery.
• The difference in the two values is where arbitrage traders make their money.
Formula
• The futures price cannot exceed the spot price by more than the cost of carry:
• F-S≤ C
• The cost of carry can vary over time and across market participants.
Futures Prices Converge upon Spot Prices
• It's a fairly safe bet that the price of a future will inch toward its spot price as the delivery
month of a futures contract approaches, and it could even match the price. This is a very
strong trend that occurs regardless of the contract's underlying asset.
The spot price is the current price in the marketplace at which a given asset—such as a security,
commodity, or currency—can be bought or sold for immediate delivery. While spot prices are
specific to both time and place, in a global economy the spot price of most securities or
commodities tends to be fairly uniform worldwide when accounting for exchange rates. In contrast
to the spot price, a futures price is an agreed upon price for future delivery of the asset.
Spot prices are most frequently referenced in relation to the price of commodity futures contracts,
such as contracts for oil, wheat, or gold. This is because stocks always trade at spot. You buy or
sell a stock at the quoted price, and then exchange the stock for cash.
A futures contract price is commonly determined using the spot price of a commodity, expected
changes in supply and demand, the risk-free rate of return for the holder of the commodity, and
the costs of transportation or storage in relation to the maturity date of the contract. Futures
contracts with longer times to maturity normally entail greater storage costs than contracts with
nearby expiration dates.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 269
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Spot prices are in constant flux. While the spot price of a security, commodity, or currency is
important in terms of immediate buy-and-sell transactions, it perhaps has more importance in
regard to the large derivatives markets. Options, futures contracts, and other derivatives allow
buyers and sellers of securities or commodities to lock in a specific price for a future time when
they want to deliver or take possession of the underlying asset. Through derivatives, buyers and
sellers can partially mitigate the risk posed by constantly fluctuating spot prices.
Example
Suppose the spot price of gold is $300 and storage costs are 2% per year, your rate of return is:
𝒓_𝒈=(𝑺_𝟏−𝟑𝟎𝟎)/𝟑𝟎𝟎 - 0.02
Another way is to take the same $300 and invest in synthetic gold (by paying the spot price).
At the same time by taking a long position in a gold forward contract with a delivery date of after
a year at a forward price of F.
The rate of return for synthetic gold is:
Suppose the risk free return r is 8%, return on synthetic gold will be:
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 271
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
By the Law of One Price, these two equivalent investments must offer the same return.
Hence by equating the two equations, we get:
(𝑺_𝟏−𝑭)/𝑺 +r =(𝑺_𝟏−𝑺)/𝑺 – b
Solving it for F, we get:
F=(1+r+b)S
Hence, the forward price for delivery of gold in one year should be:
F =(1+r+b)S = (1+0.08+0.02)X300
= 1.10X300=$330
Example
Suppose the spot price of gold is $300 per ounce, the one-year forward price is $330, and the
risk-free interest rate is 8%.
Implied Cost of Carry:
F-S = $300 - $330 = $30 per ounce
year, your rate of return is:
Implied Storage Cost:
s=((𝑭−𝑺))/𝑺 - r = 0.10-0.08=0.02
or 2% per year
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 272
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 37
FINANCIAL FUTURES AND FORWARD PRICE
Types of Futures
• Commodity futures such as crude oil, natural gas, corn, and wheat
• Stock index futures such as the PSX 100 Index
• Currency futures including those for the dollar and the British pound
• Precious metal futures for gold and silver
The concept of futures trading can seem fairly simple when we are explaining physical
commodities such as agricultural products, metals or crude oil. But things start to get more
complex when we enter the intangible world of financial futures.
This is where we get into the business of financial instruments – trading numbers and figures,
calculations and data, percentages and indexes. The products may seem abstract, but they are
integral to the world’s economies because they enable governments, businesses and financial
institutions to manage the costs of doing business.
Three types of financial futures markets
1. THE FOREIGN CURRENCY MARKET
If you buy products or services in other countries, you must manage the risk of fluctuations in
foreign exchange rates.
2. THE INTEREST RATE MARKET
If you lend or borrow money, you must manage the risk of shifting interest rates to ensure a steady
level of access to your capital.
3. THE EQUITY INDEX MARKET
If you invest in stocks, you may want to manage the risk of price changes reflected in underlying
equity indexes such as the S&P 500 and the Dow Jones Industrial Average.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 273
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 274
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Important Point
• The forward-spot price parity relation says that the forward price of the S&P for delivery
in one year must be $108.
• It means only risk premium is to be taken.
The precise meanings of the terms "forward rate" and "spot rate" are somewhat different in
different markets. In general, a spot rate refers to the current price or bond yield, while a forward
rate refers to the price or yield for the same product or instrument at some point in the future.
In commodities futures markets, a spot rate is the price for a commodity being traded immediately,
or "on the spot". A forward rate is the settlement price of a transaction that will not take place until
a predetermined date.
In bond markets, the forward rate refers to the effective yield on a bond, commonly U.S. Treasury
bills, and is calculated based on the relationship between interest rates and maturities.
If a stock that pays no dividend and offers a positive risk premium to investors, forward price is
not a forecast of the expected future spot price.
Suppose that the risk premium on S&P stock is 7% and the riskless interest rate is 8%. The
expected rate of return on S&P is 15 %.
If the current spot price is $100 per share, the expected spot price one year from now will be
$115.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 275
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
In the absence of any dividends, the ending spot price must be 15% higher than the beginning
spot price.
Example
The forward-spot price parity relation says that the forward price of the S&P for delivery in one
year must be $108.
It means only risk premium is to be taken.
Example
Suppose S=$100; r =0.08; F=$103
Putting these values in the above mentioned formula, we get:
= 100(1.08) -103
= $5
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 276
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 38
FOREIGN-EXCHANGE PARITY RELATION
The difference between the forward rate and spot rate is known as swap points.
If this difference (forward rate minus spot rate) is positive, it is known as a forward
premium;
A negative difference is termed a forward discount.
A currency with lower interest rates will trade at a forward premium in relation to a
currency with a higher interest rate. For example, the U.S. dollar typically trades at a
forward premium against the Canadian dollar. Conversely, the Canadian dollar trades at
a forward discount versus the U.S. dollar.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 277
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
TOPIC 196: PRICING OF SWAP CONTRACTS
Derivatives contracts can be divided into two general families:
Swap Contracts
• Swaps are derivative instruments that represent an agreement between two parties to
exchange a series of cash flows over a specific period of time. Swaps offer great flexibility
in designing and structuring contracts based on mutual agreement.
Conceptually, one may view a swap as either a portfolio of forward contracts or as a long position
in one bond coupled with a short position in another bond. This article will discuss the two most
common and most basic types of swaps: interest rate and currency swaps.
Consider a yen-dollar swap.
Foreign exchange markets are made up of banks, forex dealers, commercial companies,
central banks, investment management firms, hedge funds, retail forex dealers, and
investors.
The foreign exchange market—also called forex, FX, or currency market—was one of the original
financial markets formed to bring structure to the burgeoning global economy. In terms of trading
volume, it is, by far, the largest financial market in the world. Aside from providing a venue for the
buying, selling, exchanging, and speculation of currencies, the forex market also enables currency
conversion for international trade settlements and investments.
Currencies are always traded in pairs, so the "value" of one of the currencies in that pair is relative
to the value of the other. This determines how much of country A's currency country B can buy,
and vice versa. Establishing this relationship (price) for the global markets is the main function of
the foreign exchange market. This also greatly enhances liquidity in all other financial markets,
which is key to overall stability.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 279
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
The value of a country's currency depends on whether it is a "free float" or "fixed float." Free-
floating currencies are those whose relative value is determined by free-market forces, such as
supply-demand relationships.
A fixed float is where a country's governing body sets its currency's relative value to other
currencies, often by pegging it to some standard. Free-floating currencies include the U.S. dollar,
Japanese yen, and British pound, while examples of fixed floating currencies include the
Panamanian Balboa and the Saudi Riyal.
One of the most unique features of the forex market is that it is comprised of a global network of
financial centers that transact 24 hours a day, closing only on the weekends. As one major forex
hub closes, another hub in a different part of the world remains open for business. This increases
the liquidity available in currency markets, which adds to its appeal as the largest asset class
available to investors.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 280
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
TOPIC 198: IMPORTANCE OF FOREIGN EXCHANGE
The exchange rate plays an important role in a country's trade performance. Whether
determined by exogenous shocks or by policy, the relative valuations of currencies and
their volatility often have important repercussions on international trade, the balance of
payments and overall economic performance.
When a currency increases in value, it experiences appreciation; when it falls in value and is worth
fewer U.S. dollars, it undergoes depreciation.
At the beginning of 1999, for example, the euro was valued at 1.18 dollars; on Jun 19, 2017, it
was valued at 1.12 dollars.
The euro depreciated by 6%
(1.12 - 1.18)/1.18= -0.06 = -6%
Appreciation
Equivalently, we could say that the U.S. dollar, which went from a value of 0.85 euro per dollar at
the beginning of 1999 to a value of 0.89 euro per dollar on June 19, 2017, appreciated by 6%:
(0.89 - 0.85)/0.85 = 0.06 = 6%.
Foreign Exchange
When a country’s currency appreciates, the country’s goods abroad become more
expensive, and foreign goods in that country become cheaper (holding domestic prices
constant in both countries).
Conversely, when a country’s currency depreciates, its goods abroad become cheaper,
and foreign goods in that country become more expensive.
The first step to forex trading is to educate yourself about the market’s operations and
terminology.
Next, develop a trading strategy based on your finances and risk tolerance.
Finally, open a brokerage account.
It can be done online.
TOPIC 200: EXCHANGE RATES IN THE LONG RUN - LAW OF ONE PRICE
The exchange rate is determined in the long run by prices, which are determined by the
relative supply of money across countries and the relative real demand of money across
countries.
Law of One Price
The law of one price is an economic concept that states that the price of an identical asset
or commodity will have the same price globally, regardless of location, when certain
factors are considered.
The law of one price takes into account a frictionless market, where there are no transaction costs,
transportation costs, or legal restrictions, the currency exchange rates are the same, and that
there is no price manipulation by buyers or sellers. The law of one price exists because differences
between asset prices in different locations would eventually be eliminated due to the arbitrage
opportunity.
The arbitrage opportunity would be achieved whereby a trader would purchase the asset in the
market it is available at a lower price and then sell it in the market where it is available at a higher
price. Over time, market equilibrium forces would align the prices of the asset.
The law of one price is the foundation of purchasing power parity. Purchasing power parity states
that the value of two currencies is equal when a basket of identical goods is priced the same in
both countries. It ensures that buyers have the same purchasing power across global markets.
In reality, purchasing power parity is difficult to achieve, due to various costs in trading and the
inability to access markets for some individuals.
The formula for purchasing power parity is useful in that it can be applied to compare prices across
markets that trade in different currencies. As exchange rates can shift frequently, the formula can
be recalculated on a regular basis to identify mispricings across various international markets.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 282
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Example of the Law of One Price
If the price of any economic good or security is inconsistent in two different free markets after
considering the effects of currency exchange rates, then to earn a profit, an arbitrageur will
purchase the asset in the cheaper market and sell it in the market where prices are higher. When
the law of one price holds, arbitrage profits such as these will persist until the price converges
across markets.
For example, if a particular security is available for $10 in Market A but is selling for the equivalent
of $20 in Market B, investors could purchase the security in Market A and immediately sell it for
$20 in Market B, netting a profit of $10 without any true risk or shifting of the markets.
As securities from Market A are sold on Market B, prices on both markets should change in
accordance with the changes in supply and demand, all else equal. Increased demand for these
securities in Market A, where it is relatively cheaper, should lead to an increase in its price there.
Conversely, increased supply in Market B, where the security is being sold for a profit by the
arbitrageur, should lead to a decrease in its price there. Over time, this would lead to a balancing
of the price of the security in the two markets, returning it to the state suggested by the law of one
price.
1. Transportation Cost
When dealing in commodities, or any physical good, the cost to transport them must be included,
resulting in different prices when commodities from two different locations are examined.
2. Transaction Cost
These are the payments that banks and brokers receive for their roles.
In case of buying and selling real estate, transaction costs include the agent's commission and
closing costs, such as title search fees, appraisal fees, and government fees. It also include the
time and labor associated with transporting goods across long distances.
3. Legal Restrictions
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 283
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Legal barriers to trade, such as tariffs, capital controls, or in the case of wages, immigration
restrictions, can lead to persistent price differentials rather than one price. These will have a
similar effect to transportation and transaction costs, and might even be thought of as a type of
transaction cost.
4. Market Structure
The number of buyers and sellers (and the ability of buyers and sellers to enter the market) can
vary between markets, market concentration and ability of buyers and sellers to set prices can
vary as well.
• A seller who enjoys a high degree of market power due to natural economies of scale in
a given market might act like a monopoly price setter and charge a higher price. This can
lead to different prices for the same good in different markets.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 284
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 39
THEORY OF PURCHASING POWER PARITY
One popular macroeconomic analysis metric to compare economic productivity and standards of
living between countries is purchasing power parity (PPP). PPP is an economic theory that
compares different countries' currencies through a "basket of goods" approach.
According to this concept, two currencies are in equilibrium—known as the currencies being at
par—when a basket of goods is priced the same in both countries, taking into account the
exchange rates.
Relative version of Purchasing Power Parity
S =𝑷𝟏/𝑷𝟐
S = Exchange rate of currency 1 to currency 2
𝑷𝟏=Cost of good X in Currency 1
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 285
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
𝑷𝟐= Cost of good X in Currency 2
Transport Costs
Goods that are unavailable locally must be imported, resulting in transport costs. These costs
include not only fuel but import duties as well. Imported goods will consequently sell at a relatively
higher price than do identical locally sourced goods.
Tax Differences
Government sales taxes such as the value-added tax (VAT) can spike prices in one country,
relative to another.
Government Intervention
Tariffs can dramatically augment the price of imported goods, where the same products in other
countries will be comparatively cheaper.
Non-Traded Services
The Big Mac's price factors input costs that are not traded. These factors include such items as
insurance, utility costs, and labor costs. Therefore, those expenses are unlikely to be at parity
internationally.
Market Competition
Goods might be deliberately priced higher in a country. In some cases, higher prices are because
a company may have a competitive advantage over other sellers. The company may have a
monopoly or be part of a cartel of companies that manipulate prices, keeping them artificially high.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 286
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
While it's not a perfect measurement metric, purchase power parity does allow for the possibility
of comparing pricing between countries that have differing currencies.
TOPIC 202: FACTORS THAT AFFECT EXCHANGE RATES IN THE LONG RUN
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 287
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Factors that Shift the Demand Curve for Domestic Assets (continued)
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 288
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Despite the uncertainties of the COVID-19, market-based exchange rate regime helped the
external sector to record marked improvement during FY2021.The current account deficit fell to
US$1.9 billion (0.6 percent of the GDP) in FY21 from US$4.4 billion (1.7 percent of GDP) in FY20.
This is the lowest deficit in 10 years with all-time high exports (US$25.6 billion) and workers
remittances (US$29.4 billion). With the sharp rise in global commodity prices amid supply chain
disruptions, however, current account deficit widened to US$12.1 billion during Jul-Feb FY2022.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 289
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Exchange rate is continuing to play its role of shock absorber and as of 28th March 2022 is
depreciated by around 13.5 percent since end June 2021. This depreciation together with other
policy actions are expected to contain the current account deficit in the rest of FY2022 and
FY2023. Despite adverse terms of trade shock, current account deficit (CAD) narrowed sharply
to US$0.5 billion in February 2022, almost one fifth of US$ 2.5 billion in January 2022. This is a
broad-based improvement as indicated by reduction of deficits in balances of goods and services,
primary income and increase in secondary income.
To analyze the fluctuations in the Pakistan US Dollar Exchange Rate in the past three years see
the following trend diagram.
Within behavioral finance, it is assumed that financial participants are not perfectly rational and
self-controlled but rather psychologically influential with somewhat normal and self-controlling
tendencies. Financial decision-making often relies on the investor's mental and physical health.
As an investor's overall health improves or worsens, their mental state often changes. This
impacts their decision-making and rationality towards all real-world problems, including those
specific to finance.
One of the key aspects of behavioral finance studies is the influence of biases. Biases can occur
for a variety of reasons. Biases can usually be classified into one of five key concepts.
Understanding and classifying different types of behavioral finance biases can be very important
when narrowing in on the study or analysis of industry or sector outcomes and results.
Studies show that overconfident traders trade more frequently and fail to appropriately
diversify their portfolios.
One study analyzed trades from 10,000 clients at a large discount brokerage firm. The
study sought to ascertain if frequent trading led to higher returns.
The study found that the purchased stocks underperformed the sold stocks by 5% over
one year and 8.6% over two years. In other words, the more active the retail investor, the
less money they make.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 291
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• Understand that by entering into trading activities you're trading against computers,
institutional investors, and others around the world with better data and more experience
than you.
• By increasing your time frame, mirroring indexes, and taking advantage of dividends, you
will likely build wealth over time. Resist the urge to believe that your information and
intuition are better than others in the market.
After backing out tax-loss trades and others to meet liquidity needs, the study found that the
purchased stocks underperformed the sold stocks by 5% over one year and 8.6% over two years.
In other words, the more active the retail investor, the less money they make.
This study was replicated several times in multiple markets and the results were always the same.
The authors concluded that traders are, "basically paying fees to lose money."
How to Avoid This Bias
Trade less and invest more. Understand that by entering into trading activities you're trading
against computers, institutional investors, and others around the world with better data and more
experience than you. The odds are overwhelmingly in their favor. By increasing your time frame,
mirroring indexes, and taking advantage of dividends, you will likely build wealth over time. Resist
the urge to believe that your information and intuition are better than others in the market.
Loss aversion occurs when investors place a greater weighting on the concern for losses than
the pleasure from market gains. In other words, they're far more likely to try to assign a higher
priority to avoiding losses than making investment gains.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 292
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
As a result, some investors might want a higher payout to compensate for losses. If the high
payout isn't likely, they might try to avoid losses altogether even if the investment's risk is
acceptable from a rational standpoint.
Applying loss aversion to investing, the so-called disposition effect occurs when investors sell
their winners and hang onto their losers. Investors' thinking is that they want to realize gains
quickly. However, when an investment is losing money, they'll hold onto it because they want to
get back to even or their initial price. Investors tend to admit they are correct about an investment
quickly (when there's a gain).
However, investors are reluctant to admit when they made an investment mistake (when there's
a loss). The flaw in disposition bias is that the performance of the investment is often tied to the
entry price for the investor. In other words, investors gauge the performance of their investment
based on their individual entry price disregarding fundamentals or attributes of the investment that
may have changed.
In behavioral economics, inertia is the endurance of a stable state associated with inaction and
the concept of status quo bias (Madrian & Shea 2001). Behavioral nudges can either work with
people’s decision inertia (e.g. by setting defaults) or against it (e.g. by giving warnings)(Jung,
2019). In social psychology, the term inertia is sometimes also used in relation to a persistence
in (or commitments to) attitudes and relationships.
Choices can be presented in a way that highlights the positive or negative aspects of the same
decision, leading to changes in their relative attractiveness. This technique was part of Tversky
and Kahneman’s development of prospect theory, which framed gambles in terms of losses or
gains (Kahneman & Tversky, 1979). Different types of framing approaches have been identified,
including risky choice framing (e.g. the risk of losing 10 out of 100 lives vs the opportunity to save
90 out of 100 lives), attribute framing (e.g. beef that is 95% lean vs 5% fat), and goal framing (e.g.
motivating people by offering a $5 reward vs imposing a $5 penalty) (Levin et al., 1998).
The concept of framing also has a long history in political communication, where it refers to the
informational emphasis a communicator chooses to place in a particular message. In this domain,
research has considered how framing affects public opinions of political candidates, policies, or
broader issues (Busby et al., 2018).
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 294
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 40
MODERN AND BEHAVIORAL PORTFOLIO THEORIES
• They view behavioral portfolios as being formed of a layered pyramid, with each layer a
separate mental account.
• The base layers represent assets designed to provide ‘protection from poverty,’ which
results in conservative investments designed to avoid loss.
• Higher layers represent ‘hopes for riches’ and are invested in risky assets in the hope of
high returns.
• This model can help explain why individuals can buy at the same time both ‘insurance’
and ‘lottery tickets’ such as a handful of small-cap stocks.
• The theory also suggests that investors treat each layer in isolation and don’t consider
the relationship between the layers.
Modern portfolio theory (MPT) and behavioral finance represent differing schools of thought that
attempt to explain investor behavior. Perhaps the easiest way to think about their arguments and
positions is to think of modern portfolio theory as how the financial markets would work in the
ideal world, and to think of behavioral finance as how financial markets work in the real world.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 295
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Having a solid understanding of both theory and reality can help you make better investment
decisions.
Behavioral Finance
Despite the nice, neat theories, stocks often trade at unjustified prices, investors make irrational
decisions, and you would be hard-pressed to find anyone who owns the much-touted “average”
portfolio generating an 8% return every year like clockwork.
So what does all of this mean to you? It means that emotion and psychology play a role when
investors make decisions, sometimes causing them to behave in unpredictable or irrational ways.
This is not to say that theories have no value, as their concepts do work—sometimes.
Perhaps the best way to consider the differences between theoretical and behavioral finance is
to view the theory as a framework from which to develop an understanding of the topics at hand,
and to view the behavioral aspects as a reminder that theories don’t always work out as expected.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 296
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Accordingly, having a good background in both perspectives can help you make better decisions.
Comparing and contrasting some of the major topics will help set the stage.
Education can be put to work on behalf of your portfolio in a logical way, yet with your eyes wide
open to the degree of illogical factors that influence not only investors' actions, but security prices
as well. By paying attention, learning the theories, understanding the realities and applying the
lessons, you can make the most of the bodies of knowledge that surround both traditional financial
theory and behavioral finance.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 298
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Careful consideration of the outcomes of past decisions should help individuals learn to control
and work around unhelpful decision-making biases.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 299
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 41
THE EXPECTED UTILITY MODEL
"Expected utility" is an economic term summarizing the utility that an entity or aggregate economy
is expected to reach under any number of circumstances. The expected utility is calculated by
taking the weighted average of all possible outcomes under certain circumstances. With the
weights being assigned by the likelihood or probability, any particular event will occur.
The expected utility of an entity is derived from the expected utility hypothesis. This hypothesis
states that under uncertainty, the weighted average of all possible levels of utility will best
represent the utility at any given point in time. Expected utility model was developed by John von
Neuman and Oskar Morgenstern to explain rational behavior when people face uncertainty.
Expected utility theory is used as a tool for analyzing situations in which individuals must make a
decision without knowing the outcomes that may result from that decision, i.e., decision making
under uncertainty. These individuals will choose the action that will result in the highest expected
utility, which is the sum of the products of probability and utility over all possible outcomes. The
decision made will also depend on the agent’s risk aversion and the utility of other agents.
This theory also notes that the utility of money does not necessarily equate to the total value of
money. This theory helps explain why people may take out insurance policies to cover themselves
for various risks. The expected value from paying for insurance would be to lose out monetarily.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 300
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
The possibility of large-scale losses could lead to a serious decline in utility because of the
diminishing marginal utility of wealth.
Decisions involving expected utility are decisions involving uncertain outcomes. An individual
calculates the probability of expected outcomes in such events and weighs them against the
expected utility before making a decision.
For example, purchasing a lottery ticket represents two possible outcomes for the buyer. They
could end up losing the amount they invested in buying the ticket, or they could end up making a
smart profit by winning either a portion of the entire lottery. Assigning probability values to the
costs involved (in this case, the nominal purchase price of a lottery ticket), it is not difficult to see
that the expected utility to be gained from purchasing a lottery ticket is greater than not buying it.
Expected utility is also used to evaluate situations without immediate payback, such as
purchasing insurance. When one weighs the expected utility to be gained from making payments
in an insurance product (possible tax breaks and guaranteed income at the end of a
predetermined period) versus the expected utility of retaining the investment amount and
spending it on other opportunities and products, insurance seems like a better option. Expected
value is the sum of the products of the various utilities and their associated probabilities.
The consumer is expected to be able to rank the items or outcomes in terms of preference, but
the expected value will be conditioned by their probability of occurrence.
The von Neumann-Morgenstern utility function can be used to explain risk-averse, risk-neutral,
and risk-loving behavior.
Index Options
• Index options are options contracts that utilize a benchmark index, or a futures contract
based on that index, as its underlying instrument.
• Index options are typically European style and settle in cash for the value of the index at
expiration.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 302
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
• Like all options, index options will give the buyer the right, but not the obligation, to either
go long (for a call) or short (for a put) the value of the index at a pre-specified strike price.
Example
• Suppose the S&P 500 is at 4,500 points. Jane decides to sell a call option to Tim with a
strike price of 4,500. Tim pays a premium of $10. Just as a stock option typically covers
100 shares of a stock, index options typically use a multiplier of 100. So, in this case, Tim
will pay $1,000 in total.
• $10 * 100 = $1,000
• If the S&P 500 gains value, Tim’s call option will increase in price.
• If it falls, the call option will fall in price. For instance, if it rises to 4,525, Tim could exercise
the option to get a payment of $2,500.
• (4,525 - 4,500) * 100 = $2,500
Arbitrage pricing theory (APT) is an alternative to the capital asset pricing model (CAPM) for
explaining returns of assets or portfolios. It was developed by economist Stephen Ross in the
1970s. Over the years, arbitrage pricing theory has grown in popularity for its relatively simpler
assumptions. However, arbitrage pricing theory is a lot more difficult to apply in practice because
it requires a lot of data and complex statistical analysis.
APT is a multi-factor technical model based on the relationship between a financial asset's
expected return and its risk. The model is designed to capture the sensitivity of the asset's returns
to changes in certain macroeconomic variables. Investors and financial analysts can use these
results to help price securities.
Inherent to the arbitrage pricing theory is the belief that mispriced securities can represent short-
term, risk-free profit opportunities. APT differs from the more conventional CAPM, which uses
only a single factor. Like CAPM, however, the APT assumes that a factor model can effectively
describe the correlation between risk and return.
Underlying Assumptions of APT
Unlike the capital asset pricing model, arbitrage pricing theory does not assume that investors
hold efficient portfolios.
The theory does, however, follow three underlying assumptions:
Asset returns are explained by systematic factors.
Investors can build a portfolio of assets where specific risk is eliminated through diversification.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 303
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
No arbitrage opportunity exists among well-diversified portfolios. If any arbitrage opportunities do
exist, they will be exploited away by investors. (This is how the theory got its name.)
However, according to the research of Stephen Ross and Richard Roll, the most important factors
are the following:
1. Change in inflation
2. Change in the level of industrial production
3. Shifts in risk premiums
4. Change in the shape of the term structure of interest rates
In general, the financial structure of a company can also be referred to as the capital structure. In
some cases, evaluating the financial structure may also include the decision between managing
a private or public business and the capital opportunities that come with each.
Companies have several choices when it comes to setting up the business structure of their
business. Companies can be either private or public. In each case, the framework for managing
the capital structure is primarily the same but the financing options differ greatly.
Debt capital is received from credit investors and paid back over time with some form of interest.
Equity capital is raised from shareholders giving them ownership in the business for their
investment and a return on their equity that can come in the form of market value gains or
distributions. Each business has a different mix of debt and equity depending on its needs,
expenses, and investor demand.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 305
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
External sources of finance implies the arrangement of capital or funds from sources
outside the business. External Sources of finance include Financial Institutions, Loan from
banks, Preference Shares, Debenture, Public Deposits, Lease financing, Commercial
paper, Trade Credit.
Financial Institutions, Loan from banks, Preference Shares, Debenture, Public Deposits,
Lease financing, Commercial paper, Trade Credit.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 306
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 42
EQUITY & DEBT FINANCING AND CAPITAL STRUCTURE
Equity financing is the process of raising capital through the sale of shares. Companies raise
money because they might have a short-term need to pay bills or need funds for a long-term
project that promotes growth. By selling shares, a business effectively sells ownership in its
company in return for cash.
Equity financing comes from a variety of sources. For example, an entrepreneur's friends and
family, professional investors, or an initial public offering (IPO) may provide needed capital.
An IPO is a process that private companies undergo to offer shares of their business to the public
in a new stock issuance. Public share issuance allows a company to raise capital from public
investors. Industry giants, such as Google and Meta (formerly Facebook), raised billions in capital
through IPOs.
While the term equity financing refers to the financing of public companies listed on an exchange,
the term also applies to private company financing.
Equity financing involves the sale of common stock and the sale of other equity or quasi-equity
instruments such as preferred stock, convertible preferred stock, and equity units that include
common shares and warrants.
A startup that grows into a successful company will have several rounds of equity financing as it
evolves. Since a startup typically attracts different types of investors at various stages of its
evolution, it may use different equity instruments for its financing needs.
For example, angel investors and venture capitalists—generally the first investors in a startup—
favor convertible preferred shares rather than common stock in exchange for funding new
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 307
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
companies because the former have more significant upside potential and some downside
protection.
Once a company has grown large enough to consider going public, it may consider selling
common stock to institutional and retail investors.
Later, if the company needs additional capital, it may choose secondary equity financing options,
such as a rights offering or an offering of equity units that includes warrants as a sweetener.
2. Secured Debt
Secured debt is debt backed or secured by collateral to reduce the risk associated with lending.
If the borrower on a loan defaults on repayment, the bank seizes the collateral, sells it, and uses
the proceeds to pay back the debt.
3. Long-term leases
A long-term lease is simply a lease in which the agreement term is ten years or longer.
4. Pension Liabilities
Pension Liabilities means any current or future obligations, liabilities, etc. in relation to pension
plans, retiree medical, and any other long-term pension, welfare, or benefit plans.
Debt financing occurs when a firm raises money for working capital or capital expenditures by
selling debt instruments to individuals and/or institutional investors. In return for lending the
money, the individuals or institutions become creditors and receive a promise that the principal
and interest on the debt will be repaid. The other way to raise capital in debt markets is to issue
shares of stock in a public offering; this is called equity financing.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 308
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
When a company needs money, there are three ways to obtain financing: sell equity, take on
debt, or use some hybrid of the two. Equity represents an ownership stake in the company. It
gives the shareholder a claim on future earnings, but it does not need to be paid back. If the
company goes bankrupt, equity holders are the last in line to receive money.
A company can choose debt financing, which entails selling fixed income products, such as
bonds, bills, or notes, to investors to obtain the capital needed to grow and expand its operations.
When a company issues a bond, the investors that purchase the bond are lenders who are either
retail or institutional investors that provide the company with debt financing. The amount of the
investment loan—also known as the principal—must be paid back at some agreed date in the
future. If the company goes bankrupt, lenders have a higher claim on any liquidated assets than
shareholders.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 309
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Distress costs can be tangible, such as having to pay higher interest rates or more money
to suppliers upfront.
Distress costs can also be intangible, such as a loss of employee morale and productivity.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 310
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 43
FINANCING DECISIONS AND FINANCIAL METHODS
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 312
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
TOPIC 229: FLOWS TO EQUITY (FTE)
The FTE approach requires that the cash flows from the project to the equity holders of the
levered firm be discounted at the cost of equity capital. There are three steps to the FTE
approach:
3. NPV analysis
To find the present value of the cash flows to equity, we simply discount the levered cash
flows by the expected return of the levered equity. To find net present value, the present
value of the initial cash outflows are subtracted.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 313
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Weighted average cost of capital (WACC) represents a firm’s average after-tax cost of capital
from all sources, including common stock, preferred stock, bonds, and other forms of debt. WACC
is the average rate that a company expects to pay to finance its assets.
WACC is a common way to determine required rate of return (RRR) because it expresses, in a
single number, the return that both bondholders and shareholders demand to provide the
company with capital. A firm’s WACC is likely to be higher if its stock is relatively volatile or if its
debt is seen as risky because investors will require greater returns.
Where:
E=Market value of the firm’s equity
D=Market value of the firm’s debt
V=E+D
Re=Cost of equity
Rd=Cost of debt
Tc=Corporate tax rate
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 314
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
𝑬 𝑫
WACC =( 𝑽 X 𝑹𝑬 ) + (𝑽 𝑿 𝑹𝒅 𝑿 (1-𝑻𝒄 )
Where
𝐸
( 𝑉 X 𝑅𝐸 ) = weighted value of equity capital
𝐷
(𝑉 𝑋 𝑅𝑑 𝑋 (1-𝑇𝑐 ) = weighted value of debt capital
Example
• Suppose that a company obtained $1,000,000 in debt financing and $4,000,000 in equity
financing by selling common shares. Proportion of equity based financing E/V would
equal 0.8 ($4,000,000 ÷ $5,000,000 of total capital) and D/V would equal 0.2 ($1,000,000
÷ $5,000,000 of total capital).
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 315
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Lesson 44
HOW OPTIONS WORK?
The fixed price specified in an option contract is called the option’s strike price or exercise price.
The date after which an option can no longer be exercised is called its expiration date or maturity
date. Exchange-traded options have standard terms defined by the options exchange.
Options not traded on an exchange are called over-the-counter options.
An option is identified by its strike price and its expiration date.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 316
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Example
Suppose the S&P 500 is at 4,500 points. Jane decides to sell a call option to Tim with a
strike price of 4,500. Tim pays a premium of $10. Just as a stock option typically covers
100 shares of a stock, index options typically use a multiplier of 100. So, in this case, Tim
will pay $1,000 in total.
If the S&P 500 gains value, Tim’s call option will increase in price.
$10 * 100 = $1,000
If it falls, the call option will fall in price. For instance, if it rises to 4,525, Tim could exercise the
option to get a payment of $2,500.
(4,525 - 4,500) * 100 = $2,500
When Tim chooses to exercise his option, Jane and Tim will exchange money to settle the
contract. However, if exercising the option would cause Tim to lose money, he’d likely
simply let it expire, and no additional money would change hands. In this case, Jane profits
from the premium Tim paid.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 317
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
With GE trading at $27.20, Carla thinks it can trade up to $28 by March; in terms of downside
risk, she thinks the stock could decline to $26. She, therefore, opts for the March $25 call (which
is in-the-money) and pays $2.26 for it. The $2.26 is referred to as the premium or the cost of the
option. As shown in Table 1, this call has an intrinsic value of $2.20 (i.e., the stock price of
$27.20 less the strike price of $25) and the time value of $0.06 (i.e., the call price of $2.26 less
intrinsic value of $2.20).
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 318
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Short selling is an investment or trading strategy that speculates on the decline in a stock or other
security’s price. It is an advanced strategy that should only be undertaken by experienced traders
and investors.
Traders may use short selling as speculation, and investors or portfolio managers may use it as
a hedge against the downside risk of a long position in the same security or a related one.
Speculation carries the possibility of substantial risk and is an advanced trading method. Hedging
is a more common transaction involving placing an offsetting position to reduce risk exposure.
In short selling, a position is opened by borrowing shares of a stock or other asset that the investor
believes will decrease in value. The investor then sells these borrowed shares to buyers willing
to pay the market price. Before the borrowed shares must be returned, the trader is betting that
the price will continue to decline and they can purchase the shares at a lower cost. The risk of
loss on a short sale is theoretically unlimited since the price of any asset can climb to infinity.
With short selling, a seller opens a short position by borrowing shares, usually from a broker-
dealer, hoping to buy them back for a profit if the price declines. Shares must be borrowed
because you cannot sell shares that do not exist. To close a short position, a trader buys the
shares back on the market—hopefully at a price less than at which they borrowed the asset—and
returns them to the lender or broker. Traders must account for any interest charged by the broker
or commissions charged on trades.
To open a short position, a trader must have a margin account and will usually have to pay interest
on the value of the borrowed shares while the position is open. Also, the Financial Industry
Regulatory Authority (FINRA), which enforces the rules and regulations governing registered
brokers and broker-dealer firms in the United States, the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE), and
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 319
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
the Federal Reserve have set minimum values for the amount that the margin account must
maintain—known as the maintenance margin.
If an investor’s account value falls below the maintenance margin, more funds are required, or
the position might be sold by the broker.
The process of locating shares that can be borrowed and returning them at the end of the trade
is handled behind the scenes by the broker. Opening and closing the trade can be made through
the regular trading platforms with most brokers. However, each broker will have qualifications that
the trading account must meet before they allow margin trading.
Example
Imagine a trader who believes that XYZ stock—currently trading at $50—will decline in
price in the next three months.
They borrow 100 shares and sell them to another investor. The trader is now “short” 100
shares since they sold something that they did not own but had borrowed.
The short sale was only made possible by borrowing the shares, which may not always
be available if the stock is already heavily shorted by other traders.
A week later, the company whose shares were shorted reports dismal financial results for
the quarter, and the stock falls to $40.
The trader decides to close the short position and buys 100 shares for $40 on the open
market to replace the borrowed shares. The trader’s profit on the short sale, excluding
commissions and interest on the margin account, is $1,000: ($50 - $40 = $10 x 100 shares
= $1,000).
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 320
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
The Black-Scholes model, also known as the Black-Scholes-Merton (BSM) model, is one of the
most important concepts in modern financial theory. This mathematical equation estimates the
theoretical value of derivatives based on other investment instruments, taking into account the
impact of time and other risk factors. Developed in 1973, it is still regarded as one of the best
ways for pricing an options contract.
Developed in 1973 by Fischer Black, Robert Merton, and Myron Scholes, the Black-Scholes
model was the first widely used mathematical method to calculate the theoretical value of an
option contract, using current stock prices, expected dividends, the option's strike price, expected
interest rates, time to expiration, and expected volatility.
The initial equation was introduced in Black and Scholes' 1973 paper, "The Pricing of Options
and Corporate Liabilities," published in the Journal of Political Economy.
Robert C. Merton helped edit that paper. Later that year, he published his own article, "Theory of
Rational Option Pricing," in The Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science, expanding
the mathematical understanding and applications of the model, and coining the term "Black–
Scholes theory of options pricing."
In 1997, Scholes and Merton were awarded the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences for
their work in finding "a new method to determine the value of derivatives." Black had passed away
two years earlier, and so could not be a recipient, as Nobel Prizes are not given posthumously;
however, the Nobel committee acknowledged his role in the Black-Scholes model.
Black-Scholes posits that instruments, such as stock shares or futures contracts, will have a
lognormal distribution of prices following a random walk with constant drift and volatility. Using
this assumption and factoring in other important variables, the equation derives the price of a
European-style call option.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 321
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
The Black-Scholes equation requires five variables. These inputs are volatility, the price of the
underlying asset, the strike price of the option, the time until expiration of the option, and the risk-
free interest rate. With these variables, it is theoretically possible for options sellers to set rational
prices for the options that they are selling.
Furthermore, the model predicts that the price of heavily traded assets follows a geometric
Brownian motion with constant drift and volatility. When applied to a stock option, the model
incorporates the constant price variation of the stock, the time value of money, the option's strike
price, and the time to the option's expiry.
Black-Scholes Assumptions
The Black-Scholes model makes certain assumptions:
1. No dividends are paid out during the life of the option.
2. Markets are random (i.e., market movements cannot be predicted).
3. There are no transaction costs in buying the option.
4. The risk-free rate and volatility of the underlying asset are known and constant.
5. The returns of the underlying asset are normally distributed.
6. The option is European and can only be exercised at expiration.
While the original Black-Scholes model didn't consider the effects of dividends paid during the life
of the option, the model is frequently adapted to account for dividends by determining the ex-
dividend date value of the underlying stock. The model is also modified by many option-selling
market makers to account for the effect of options that can be exercised before expiration.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 322
Financial Economics (ECO-605) VU
Formula
The Black-Scholes call option formula is calculated by multiplying the stock price by the
cumulative standard normal probability distribution function. Thereafter, the net present value
(NPV) of the strike price multiplied by the cumulative standard normal distribution is subtracted
from the resulting value of the previous calculation.
___________________________________________________________________________________
©Copyright Virtual University of Pakistan 323