An Empirical Case Study and Approach On TQM in A S
An Empirical Case Study and Approach On TQM in A S
An Empirical Case Study and Approach On TQM in A S
2*
Department of Civil Engineering, Koneru Lakshmaiah Education Foundation, Vaddeswaram,
Guntur (Dt.), 522502, AP, India. (Corresponding Author), [email protected]
ABSTRACT: In comparison to other sectors such as manufacturing and service, the construction
sector is perceived to impose a low value on performance. TQM is implemented by very few
construction companies in this world, and the top-down technique is widely used. To incorporate
TQM in a company, top management must contribute to a "bottom-up" strategy by creating a
"Quality Circle." According to this study, the first and most important criteria for introducing TQM
in construction firms is top management involvement, other obstacles that companies must
overcome include a lack of education, lack of confidence, lack of common trust, a lack of skilled
staff, market competition, weak strategies and requirements, bad behavior, the availability of
experienced field managers, and so on. In this approach, one case study is analyzed to show how
Total Quality Management (TQM) is efficiently applied by using a "bottom-up" approach and
creating a PMO in an Indian construction company. After some study of the Pareto graph, and
identifying root causes using Root Cause analysis, experience is applied in the provided studied
construction firm to apply TQM. Following that, a method for applying TQM in a building company
is suggested.
Keywords: Total Quality Management (TQM); TQM Gurus, TQM Implementation; TQM tools;
Quality Circles; Pareto analysis.
1. INTRODUCTION
Total quality management (TQM) is a concept of continual improvement focusing on the customer
and quality[1]. It is the outcome of quality improvement. It was established by Walter Shewhart
in the early 1920s when statistical theory was used for product quality control. Following that, in
the 1940s, the concept was proposed in Japan under the leadership of Americans such as Deming,
Juran, Feigenbaum, and Crosby [2]. Appropriate standards of quality have long been a concern in
the construction sector. Each year, significant amounts of time, money, and capital, both human
and material, are ruined because of ineffective or nonexistent quality control procedures. Total
Quality Management (TQM) principles, first used in Japan and recently adopted in the United
States, have boosted production reduced component costs, and enhanced production efficiency in
the manufacturing industry. These ideas also apply to the building industry [3].
Quality is a concept used to describe the twenty-first century. Performance would have to be
incorporated into all elements of a competitive company if it is to gain market share. Quality is a
Content from this work may be used under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 licence. Any further distribution
of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the title of the work, journal citation and DOI.
Published under licence by IOP Publishing Ltd 1
International Conference on Advances in Civil Engineering (ICACE 2021) IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 1197 (2021) 012037 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/1197/1/012037
resource or an element. Quality is a significant concept that is usually applied to the end-use of a
consumer. Quality is characterized as a product's ability to meet the needs of its consumers.
In other words, consistency is an indicator of a product's ability to meet the needs of the final
consumer. In general, quality refers to the characteristics of an item or service that determine its
ability to reliably meet or surpass consumer standards. Characteristics are applied to a product or
service at any stage of its life cycle, from content processing to consumer use. As a result, all
divisions of an organization have a role to play in deciding the quality of the product or service.
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1. EVOLUTION OF QUALITY
Quality management is a new trend. Clients could choose products that are created using advanced
crafts in advanced cultures. Professional craftsmen or artists in those communities oversee their
own workshops and educate and track others. A mass manufacturing and regularly scheduled
process rendered artisan skills unnecessary. Mass manufacturing was the aim. Eli Whitney was the
first pioneer in the United States who introduced parts manufacture for muskets, a practice that set
up a musket production line. Several people, including Frederick Winslow Taylor [5], called for
the next step. He has been called the "father of research management." His approach also covered
aspects of quality management, such as interoperability and the implementation of improved
approaches. Henry Ford has made major contributions to improving assembly line quality
management and procedures. In Germany, Karl Friedrich Benz is known as the "father of the car,"
though real mass manufacture started with Volkswagen after World War II. North American
industries now stress production at a lower cost and greater productivity.
After the Second World War, Japan wanted to make quality management a citizen as part of
restructuring their economy. Several active-quality programs have been created by the Japanese.
Quality programs in products from the 1950s through the 1970s led to Japan attaining very high
standards of quality. Quality management is becoming more holistic, with considerations for
people, methods, and commodities all being included. Many of the approaches not only have
strategies, but also quality culture (i.e., citizen factors) [5].
2
International Conference on Advances in Civil Engineering (ICACE 2021) IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 1197 (2021) 012037 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/1197/1/012037
TQM may be applied in three phases inside an organization: investigation and awareness, planning
and coordination, and execution. The majority of firms in the construction sector were hesitant to
apply TQM, believing that the ISO 9000 series was sufficient but also that management did not
attempt to commit their workforce to more "acculturative stress." Additionally, organizations
perceive that there may be other vital concerns, such as safety. Additionally, firms in the
construction sector have delayed adopting TQM procedures due to an apparent lack of short-term
advantages. Due to the inherent complexity of construction works and their ever-changing
atmosphere. The management system must be adaptable, attentive to proper communication, and
ever improving. Clients would forgo the constitution of allocating bids based on the lowest bid
and instead push to compensate the smartest developers and vendors capable of providing the
greatest service. the acknowledged relationship between numerous market situations and TQM
procedures. This indicates that competitive forces will drive TQM implementation. Firms should
form customer collaborations by emphasizing quality above pricing when selecting vendors.
(1) Management is accountable for committing to, leading, empowering, encouraging, and
supporting technological and human processes. The top management must provide the
atmosphere and structure for operations within a company. It is critical that management
encourages workforce interest in quality enhancement and cultivates a quality culture by altering
workers' perceptions and behaviors about quality.
(3) The importance of employee education and preparation is emphasized in terms of changing
employees' values, behaviors, and perceptions as well as improving employees' ability to perform
their duties.
(4) It is critical to monitor processes and to continuously develop the quality framework and
product design. The priority is defect prevention, not post-mortem testing.
3
International Conference on Advances in Civil Engineering (ICACE 2021) IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 1197 (2021) 012037 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/1197/1/012037
(5) Quality is a systemic enterprise-wide operation that spans the supply chain from manufacturers
to consumers. Quality management efforts should include all practical practices, including
marketing, planning, engineering, sourcing, assembling, testing, shipping, billing, implementation,
and operation.
Additionally, comparable organizations employ various Quality Tools (QTs), with significant
effects. Currently, companies hire the QTs indicated by the quality improvement paradigm.
However, no organization can profit from every QT, and there is no guidance to assist companies
in making decisions on which ones to utilize [12]. The basic seven fundamental tools are a Check
sheet, Histogram, Pareto analysis, Process flow chart, Cause-Effect diagram, Scatter diagram,
Control chart [13]. In this study, we are only using two of the seven fundamental tools. Those two
fundamental methods are Check sheet and Pareto analysis.
4
International Conference on Advances in Civil Engineering (ICACE 2021) IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 1197 (2021) 012037 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/1197/1/012037
3. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
A construction firm in Hyderabad, India, has been chosen as a case study from the start of the
research. Data was collected in this company and analysis was done. This company's primary
objective is the development of buildings and the sale of apartments. They construct residential
and industrial buildings and then sell them to customers. The following are the reasons for
choosing this firm: there are a lot of opportunities for implementing quality tools in various areas
of the company's market, and the author of this research is a full-time employee of this company.
This company's managers tried to increase the efficiency of their jobs as well, but they did not
achieve the best results.
A check sheet is used to gather information from an external flat buyer as well as internal staff.
The gathered data is then evaluated using Pareto analysis to classify the key problems that can
have the greatest benefits if solved. The root causes of a process flow are identified. Identifying
root causes necessarily involves any method of research. Finally, several basic root causes for
change are defined.
4. DATA COLLECTION
A preliminary investigation was conducted to gain an understanding of the work procedures of
various divisions of a construction company, such as construction managers, construction sites,
ready-mix concrete plants, architecture division, architect section, quality control section, real
estate section, human resources section, and marketing section. Additionally, it assists in
identifying any potential problems in the work phase that appear regularly in specific sections.
Data was gathered from 100 external consumers (flat purchasers) on their perceptions of quality
and management problems. The data gathered is then summarized on the check sheet. Another
internal client (staff member) check sheet is accomplished by gathering data from the firm's
internal staff about their knowledge and perceptions of quality problems. The data gathered by the
checklist is then ready for Pareto analysis. The data is sorted ascending, and average percentages
are calculated by counting or comparing the frequency of occurrences. According to Vilfredo
Pareto's 80-20 rule, vital few and trivial much are defined. Following the review and identification
of problems by various teams and divisions of the construction company, detailed outcomes are
listed, such as identified major problems, minor problems, and specific points to be resolved for
effective TQM implementation. Finally, some specific topics are addressed briefly.
5
International Conference on Advances in Civil Engineering (ICACE 2021) IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 1197 (2021) 012037 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/1197/1/012037
Typically, the results of a Pareto analysis are described by a Pareto cart. The map illustrates the
different variables considered in descending order. This map is shown in the format of a bar chart
in descending order and assists in identifying the aspects that are critical by superimposing a line
graph that cuts an 80% average percentage and assists in finding out the factors that have the
minimum number of benefits and vice versa. Joseph Juran expanded on this idea and discovered
that it applies to a wide variety of areas of daily life [16]. For instance, it can be extended to a
variety of topics, including looking for books online in a library resources database, deciding
which activities in a project can have the greatest effect, finding the main sources of consumer
concerns about goods or services, and identifying the products or services that generate 80% of
the profit.
120 120%
95% 96% 98% 98% 99% 100%100%
100 90% 92% 94% 100%
84% 88%
77%
80 69% 80%
60%
60 51% 60%
41%
40 31% 40%
21%
20 11% 20%
100 96 94 93 91 86 83 74 65 32 23 16 14 14 12 12 8 6 5 3
0 0%
Frequancy Cumulative %
Figure 2. The Pareto Chart illustrates the relationship between external customers (flat buyers)
and issues related to quality and service.
6
International Conference on Advances in Civil Engineering (ICACE 2021) IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 1197 (2021) 012037 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/1197/1/012037
Table 1. The Pareto Chart illustrates the relationship between external customers (flat buyers)
and issues related to quality and service.
S. No Name of Complaints Frequency Cumulative Cumulative %
1 Handover delay 100 100 11%
O & M (operation and maintenance)
2 96 196 21%
handing over
Availability of Skilled and
3 94 290 31%
experienced O&M team
4 Plaster crack 93 383 41%
5 Bad workmanship 91 474 51%
6 Sanitary fitting height issues 86 560 60%
Addition /omission mismanagement
7 83 643 69%
and delay
8 Door, window related problems 74 717 77%
9 Snag Works 65 782 84%
10 Dampness Issues 32 814 88%
11 Tiles hallow Sound problems 23 837 90%
12 RCC construction joints crack 16 853 92%
13 RCC top floor ceiling leakage 14 867 94%
14 Parking problem 14 881 95%
15 Pressure problem in water taps 12 893 96%
16 Electrical line related problems 12 905 98%
17 Drainage problem 8 913 98%
18 Toilet floor slope problem 6 919 99%
19 Lift related problem 5 924 100%
20 Others 3 927 100%
Frequancy Cumulative %
Figure 3. Internal employee survey on quality problems. The survey is done using 100 cases (at
Site & management at the Head Office)
7
International Conference on Advances in Civil Engineering (ICACE 2021) IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 1197 (2021) 012037 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/1197/1/012037
Table 2. Internal employee survey on quality problems. The survey is done using 100 cases (at
Site & management at the Head Office)
S. No Name of Complaints Frequency Cumulative Cumulative %
1 Lack of incentives 97 97 9%
2 Motivational deficit 94 191 17%
3 Inexperience of labor 92 283 25%
4 Inaccurate master budget 88 371 33%
5 Inexperience of Supervisor 78 449 40%
6 Modifications to the scope 78 527 47%
7 Overhead reduction policy 77 604 53%
8 The Inexperience of Site Engineer 72 676 60%
9 Recruitment discrimination 67 743 66%
10 Inappropriate HR function 64 807 71%
11 Lack of a planned schedule 58 865 77%
Lack of ability to make the right
12 56 921 82%
decisions
13 Lower wages 52 973 86%
14 Delay in the supply of materials 32 1005 89%
15 Inadequate materials 31 1036 92%
16 Inexperience of Manager 26 1062 94%
17 Manpower crisis 23 1085 96%
18 Inadequate drawing supply 22 1107 98%
19 Wastage 14 1121 98%
20 Others 8 1129 100%
8
International Conference on Advances in Civil Engineering (ICACE 2021) IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 1197 (2021) 012037 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/1197/1/012037
if their work is properly reviewed and rewarded consistently. Although this organization has a
human resources department, they are not completing their primary tasks, which include proper
employee performance appraisal and reward based on demand, ongoing staff training, and inspiring
staff through promotional offers. They are predominantly driven by upper management. As a result,
some prospective workers become dissatisfied and reduce their productivity.
9
International Conference on Advances in Civil Engineering (ICACE 2021) IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 1197 (2021) 012037 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/1197/1/012037
kept consistent if designers consult with one another through the design process. There is a
consultant with whom architects consult and get guidance from time to time during the design
process. However, perfect design resemblance is not reached. The difficulty stems from the lack of
desire to consult with experts. Another reason is that this section lacks a senior coordinator.
6. CONCLUSION
The construction sector has various challenges in achieving high-quality performance because of the
sector's complexity. TQM is progressively being used in the construction industry to address quality
issues. TQM deployment requires a shift in organizational culture and management behavior.
Historically, building enterprises have been overlooked and have been structured inappropriately in
several companies. The organization's present culture must be transformed into a TQM environment
that prioritizes quality as a primary strategy. A review of the literature, findings and analysis of a
case study conducted in various departments of a construction firm recognizes several key aspects
that lead to the effective implementation of TQM, including organization commitment, education
and training, teamwork, human resource management, and empowerment, supplier relationships,
quality planning and strategic, process management. These quality culture elements should be
incorporated into the construction organization's TQM implementation for continual development.
REFERENCES
[1] T. Elghamrawy and T. Shibayama, “Total Quality Management Implementation in the
Egyptian,” vol. 24, no. 3, pp. 156–161, 2008.
10
International Conference on Advances in Civil Engineering (ICACE 2021) IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Materials Science and Engineering 1197 (2021) 012037 doi:10.1088/1757-899X/1197/1/012037
[2] I. Othman, S. Norfarahhanim, M. Ghani, and S. Woon, “The Total Quality Management (
TQM ) journey of Malaysian building contractors,” Ain Shams Eng. J., no. xxxx, 2020.
[3] D. Arditi and H. M. Gunaydin, “Total quality management in the construction process,” vol.
15, no. 4, pp. 235–243, 1997.
[4] W. J. Miller, “Working Definition for Total Quality Management ( TQM ) Researchers,” J.
Qual. Manag., vol. I, no. 2, pp. 149–159, 1996.
[5] J. Yong and A. Wilkinson, “The long and winding road : The evolution of quality
management,” Total Qual. Manag., vol. 13, no. January 2015, pp. 37–41, 2010.
[6] L. S. Pheng, “A framework for implementing TQM,” TQM Mag., vol. 8, no. 5, pp. 39–46,
2006.
[7] R. Kumar, R. Duhan, and S. Duhan, “Quality Circle : A Methodology to Identify Scope of
Quality Improvement through Kaizen Approach,” vol. 5, no. July, pp. 43–51, 2015.
[8] B. Neyestani, “Principles and Contributions of Total Quality Management (TQM) Gurus on
Business Quality Improvement,” SSRN Electron. J., 2018.
[9] J. Jos and V. Sabater, “Quality tools and techniques : Are they necessary for quality
management ?” vol. 92, pp. 267–280, 2004.
[10] P. G. H. R.E. McQuater, C.H. Scurr, B.G. Dale, “Using quality tools and techniques
successfully,” TQM Mag., vol. 7, no. 6, pp. 37–42, 2006.
[12] E. Aspinwall and P. A. Sampaio, “Total Quality Management & Business Excellence
Performance measures and quality tools in Portuguese small and medium enterprises :
survey results,” no. June 2015, pp. 37–41.
[13] M. Sokovi, J. Jovanovi, and A. Vujovi, “Basic Quality Tools in Continuous Improvement
Process,” vol. 55, pp. 1–9, 2009.
[14] H. F. Cervone, “Managing Digital Libraries : Applied digital library project management
task importance rankings,” 2009.
[15] G. Karuppusami and R. Gandhinathan, “Pareto analysis of critical success factors of total
quality management A literature review and analysis.
[16] F. Talib, Z. Rahman, M. N. Qureshi, and T. Roorkee, “Pareto Analysis Of Total Quality
Management Factors Critical To Success For Service,” Int. J. Qual. Res., vol. 4, no. 2, pp.
155–168, 2010.
11