Adigrat
Adigrat
Adigrat
The Effect and challenges of Accounting Information System (AIS) on internal control
(in case of construction and business bank Adigrat Branch)
A senior essay submitted to department of accounting and finance for the partial
fulfillment of the requirement of BA degree of arts in accounting and finance.
ID Number 2664/05
June, 2015
Adigrat, Ethiopia
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Firstly, I want to express gratitude to Almighty God for enabling me to overcome the difficult
challenges that I faced on the path of my education and blessing me and the results of my efforts.
Secondly, I want to thank my family for giving me all the opportunities to pursue my education
and encouraging me in all my initiatives at all levels during my education. Further, I would like
to thank my Adviser Ruth for his unlimited advising services.
Finally, I thank those who were involved in the making of this paper for their help, supply of raw
data and different ideas, very important for completing this paper.
ABSTRACT
This research conducted in construction and business bank in Adigrat branch .which operates
banking services. The study would focus on the effect of accounting information system on
internal control. The main objective of the study is to show whether the employees have
adequate awareness about accounting information, its essential the integrity, confidentiality and
reliability of critical data and to show dependability on extensive accounting information to
administer internal control over the preparation of financial statement.
The researcher collect data through quisioneries from judgmentally selected the employees of
construction and business bank in Adigrat branch. Currently accounting information system is
widely used in bank for internal control, because the most of the bank activities are depends on
information. The result indicate that the use of accounting information system at this bank is
caused the improvement of manager decision making process ,internal controls and the quality of
the financial for internal control.
Acronyms
AIS:-Accounting information system
1. Introduction
Perhaps the most important aspect of AIS is the role it plays in an organization internal control
process. The term internal control process suggests actions taken within an organization to
regulate and direct the activities of the organization. Much information need by management to
control finances and operation comes from AIS .One of the management responsibility is
stewardship. The role of importance of accounting information system in the bank of activity is
derived from the role and function commercial bank themselves. Banks are the great financial
inter mediates in economy. (George and willians, 1998).
There are some questions with accounting information system on internal control that would be
answered by the researcher
4. How can the challenges faced by the bank regarding internal control while using AIS be
assessed?
2. To assess AIS is essential for the integrity, confidentiality, and reliability of critical data while
reducing the risk of error, frauds and other illegal acts.
4. To assess the challenges faced by the bank regarding internal control while using AIS.
1.4 Significance of the study
The result of the study would help CBB to understand the strangeness and weakness of AIS.
Besides this research also use for other organization on the same sector such as commercial bank
of Ethiopia. Adigrat bank and etc. Therefore hope fully that CBB would take all the necessary
measures to overcome the problems of the AIS.
Absence of manager from office due to meeting during data collection period.
The lack of related literatures useful as reference
The inefficiency and reluctant of members to respondents the questions, prepared by the
researcher
Lack of finance and accessibility to computers write the research
Questionnaires are distributed to judgmentally selected employee also is conducts with the
managers of the bank. Secondary data were collected from published materials of the
organization like company profiles and report books.
The researcher would use judgmental sampling technique which is a non-probability sampling
tool. The selection of this method is enabling the researcher freely selecting any respondents that
by considering whether the responder would fit to the question or not.
LITRATURE REVIEW
For this reason, computerized information system (CIS) is designed and implemented (Mahdi
Sale, 2010]
Good cooperation
TO meet the needs of multi user
To control afterward and control in advance and in concurrent (Mahdi
Saleh .2010).
External include stock holder, creditor ,government agency ,customer and compotator, labor
union and public at large .they receive at depend on variety of output from organization
accounting information system. Many of these outputs are routine in nature.
Particular function they perform. The AIS summarize and filter the data available to decision
maker by processing data and AI influxes’ organization decision. The uncertainty of the
environment in which information in developed and presented means of the estimate and
judgment must be made. No Information system can ignore the partiality of presenting
information .various government agencies, private agencies and legislation set statuary
retirement for record keeping and report (Marshal Romney).
(S.KBhattachey,1975).
Performance review
Information processing control
Physical control
Segregation of duties
A. Performance review
These control include review of actual performance as compared to budget ,forecast and prior
period performance relating different set of data do one another ,and performance over all review
of performance review provide management with an overall in direction of wither personnel at
various level are effectively.
Variety of control activities is performed to check the accuracy, completeness, and authorization
of transaction. The two broad categories information control include general control activities,
which apply to all information processing pro cedars, and application control activities, which
apply only to one particular activity.
C. Physical control
These controls include those that provide physical security over both record and other asset
activities that safeguard may include maintaining, control, at all-time overrun-issued per number,
document as well as other journal and ledgers and restricting asset to compute programs and data
files.
D. Sesegregation of duties
A fundamental concept of internal control is that no one department or person should handle all
aspect of transaction from beginning and to end. In similar manner, no one individual should
perform more than one of the functions of authorized transaction, recording transactions and
maintains custody over assets. Also to extent possible individuals exercising the specific
transaction should be segregated from these functions.
2.5.4 Information and communication
Information refers to the organizations accounting systems which consists of methods and
records established to identify, assemble, analyze , classify , record and report the organizations
transaction and to maintain accountability for the related asset and liabilities maintain
organizations have systems that are able to process huge numbers of various types of
transactions. Information system are designed , and installed not only to produce the ledger
balance from which financial statement are prepared, but also to produce management control
and operation information thus, accounting system and operation control are closely related in an
organization. Good communication requires effective oral communication adequate procedure
manuals and other types of documentation.
2.5.5 Monitoring
Monitoring is the internal control component which involves the ongoing process of assigns the
quality of internal controls over time and taking corrective action when necessary. The quality of
control might be adversely affected in various ways including lack of compliance, changing
condition or even miss understanding monitoring is accomplished through ongoing activities
separate evaluation or the same combination of the ongoing activates would include management
supervise activities and other actions the personal might take to assure an ongoing effective
internal control processes. An internal audit function is common in large organization to monitor
and evaluate controls ongoing basis. The expanded span of control and the growth in the volume
of transaction associated with a large organization where factors in the emergency of internal
control function. The objective of internal audit function is to serve management by finishing
management with results of analysis and appraisal of such activities and system as
External auditors may performance in monitoring controls it is common practice s for external
auditors to provide lists of specific recommendations for management to improve internal control
(George, Williams, 2000)
2.6 Analysis of internal control process
The analysis of internal control process requires an understanding of the process both as it is
designed and as it is actually operates. The actual process may or may not conform to
expectations. Documentations may be out dated and the structure may be operating under new
procedures. Internal control process routinely collect information concerning fulfillment of
internal of duties transfer of authority’s approval and verification. This documentation of internal
control duties must be examined to evaluate the reliability of the system operation. Reliability is
independent on the people who administer internal control processors. Designing an internal
control process is only the first part of the problem it is essential that internal control duties are
actually performed as prescribed. (George, Williams, 2000).
They use and invest the information system by banking organization are important for two
reasons. First many customers and bank employees are using this system to manage their money,
account and saving information’s. Secondly, banking information system is important to enhance
effectiveness and efficiency by improving service delivery and reduces cost .Banking
information system input include a type ofaccount, data and account of deposit and withdrawals.
Their output consist of statement which show interest paid of owed balance and other
information.(Harangues Daniela,2005 )
The classification of bank operation in active and passive depending on the way they are found
in the balance sheet also underline the role and important of accounting information in the whole
banking activities .Activity bank operation generate accounting information regarding the
placement of bank resource (in credit ,placement on the interbank market etc.).passive bank
operation generate accounting information regarding the attraction of resource by the bank (own
capital, deposit for the client).Bank accounting information allows the commercial to speculate
up to some attractive business opportunity connected to give credit ,guarantee, and other
facilities in favors of performing client.(Harangues and Daniel ,2005.).
Client account which can be availebity in the bank account ,current account and stock
account or credit account.
Bank entity account which refer specially to cash accountants stock account, inter
banking settlement account, income and spending account of the bank etc.
Account outside the bank cash statement, which are reflected in to engaged guarantee
record engagement unfolding credit guarantee related to credit, claims from current asset
and flowed afterward.
Bank computerized programs, which mange accounting data and statically data, bank
management etc.
In bank the main source for collecting accounting information come from the front office. Client
operation and inter and intra banking operation. The type of accounting information in the bank
activity refers to the value of account surplus stock (initial and final), debit and credit turnover of
these accounts, the number of registered account operation and their value. The quantitative
structure of accounting operation overage. All these type of accounting information may exist in
raw or advanced form with the aid of computerized program user of bank accounting information
can be:
Internal user: bank client, stockholder, office, employee and bank manager.
External user: client business partner, supplier and their cleat financial and fiscal institution
and other bank.
All these external user take accounting information from the client account made available to
them by the client .The bank must respect the confidentiality principle for their operation in the
client account and for these resistant ,they usually give accounting information only to the
internal user. In the analysis of accounting information of its accuracy and importance for the
bank stock holders, the issue of the bank accounting system transpierce is interesting to approach
(Harangues and Daniel, 2005).
CHAPTER THREE
3.1 Introduction
The main purpose of this chapter is to analyze data collected through questionnaires’ related in to
AIS of CBB in Adigrat branch. As indicated in chapter one .relevant data were gathered though
questionnaires. The questionnaire conducted form CBB employees. This chapter mainly
concerned with the effect of accounting and internal control.
As clearly stated in chapter one of the paper. The collected data by using questionnaires is
analyzed through quantitative method of data analysis. Including table and percentages were
employees and presented in the preceding section of this chapter.
Additionally, the researcher collects data about governance and organizational hierarchy which
of them are general assembly of shareholder, the board of director, executive, management and
departments. The general assembly of CBB shareholder is at the helm of CBB organization
structure. As such it is entrusted among others, with making decision with regard to the
following
• The appoint and removal of the members of CBB´s board of directors and its external auditors.
• The amount of money that should be given out to CBB´s shareholder as divided and the capital
Issuer of the bank.
Finally in this chapter, the researchers try to evaluate the effect accounting information system
on internal control in CBB of Adigrat branch. The researcher distributed 7 questionnaires and
that are direct related employees and all questionnaires are collected.
As shown in table 3.1 above from, respondent of 7, 5 are males and 2 are a female which means
the males take the majority number from the respondent and minority of the respondents are
females.
Table 3.2: Is summarize the Age of the respondents
Age of the respondents Number of respondents Percentage
20 – 30 5 71.42%
31 – 40 1 14.28%
41 – 50 1 14.28%
51‒ 60 0 0%
Total 7 100%
Source: Questionnaire
As indicated in table 3.2 about 71.42% of respondents are between 20 – 30 ages, 14.28% of the
respondents are between 31 – 40 ages, 14.28% of the respondents are between 41 – 50 and 0%
are above 50.this indicate the age between 20 – 30 are more in bank.i.e the majority employee of
construction and business bank in Adigrat branch age is young as compared to the other type
bank.
Table 3.3: responses on educational background
Educational background No of respondents Percentage
12 completed 0 0%
Diploma 1 14.28%
First Degree 6 85.72%
Master Degree and above 0 0%
Total 7 100%
Source: Questionnaire
As it is indicated in table 3.3, the respondents’ educational level is more of first degree. This
insures that most of the employees are well educated and they are much aware about accounting
information system in the bank .In the other case, the researcher can infer that the bank is aiming
to maximize their customer by employing BA degree which has good education level. There is
no employee who scores master degree and above and 12 completed background.
Table: 3.4: Responses work experience in the bank.
Service year No of respondents Percentage
0 – 3 years 5 71.42%
4 – 10 years 2 28.58%
5 – 20 years 0 0%
Above 20 years 0 0%
Total 7 100%
Source: Questionnaire
As it is indicated in table 3.4, the work experience respondents are categorized in to four
categories. That is from 0 – 3 years, 4– 10 years, 5 – 20 years and above 20 years. Most of the
respondents (71.42%) have 0 – 3 years’ work experience in the factory and this implies that they
are well familiar with jobs they have been assigned based on the questionnaire responses. Hence
the researcher hopes that there will be a faire response from the respondents. There is no
employee who has work experiences from the age of 5-20 and above 20 years in construction
and business bank.
3.3.2 AIS as a tool of ensuring integrity, confidential and reliability on critical data
As it is possible to understanding from the respondents. AIS are very importance to ensure the
integrity, confidentiality and reliability of critical data. It is obvious that there are a number of
activities operating in this bank. They have their own data and work together by interchanging
these data. These data are not functioning in one activity but also in there activates. So in this
case those data are used as AIS for each activity.
Table 3.6: Ensuring integrity, confidentiality, and reliability of critical data
Ensuring I.C.R of critical data No of respondent Percentage
Yes 6 85.71%
Partially yes 0 0%
No 1 14.29%
Partially No 0 0%
I don’t know 0 0%
Total 7 100%
Source: Questionnaire
As shown in the above table. The inference can be drawn that about 85.72% of the total
respondent are agree that AIS can ensure the integrity, confidentiality and reliability of critical
data in every activities and 14.29% of the respondents are not sure. From this the researcher can
understand that accounting information system can ensure integrity, confidentiality and
reliability of data in the banks.
3.3.3. Contribution of AIS in reducing the risk of the errors, frauds and other illegal acts.
In addition to ensuring the integrity, confidentiality and reliability of critical data. AIS have a
great role reducing the risk of error, frauds and other illegal acts. Now a day’s most of business
organization including CBB uses computer based AIS in order to reduce the risk of error. Even
though computer is operated by human most of the time if do not accept the correct data .In such
case the operator can catch where there is an error and re- correct again and order the computer
to re- process.
Table 3.7 AIS in reducing risk, frauds and other illegal acts.
Reducing risk No of respondent Percentage
7 100%
YES
NO 0 0%
I don’t know 0 0%
Total 7 100%
Source: Questionnaire
The above table can be summarized that the total respondents agree that AIS can reduce the risk
of error, frauds and other illegal acts. Almost no risks occur in the organization according to the
employee construction and business bank and they use risk reduction technique.
Certainly 4 57.14%
Possibly 1 14.28%
Probably 2 28.58%
I don’t know 0 0%
Total 7 100%
.Source: Questionnaire
From the above table it can be generalized that respondents who has been giving an opinion of
this view. About 57.14% of the respondents or that AIS has contribution to process reliable
financial reporting and the other 28.58% and other are not sure so the bank has to give awareness
for the employees that how AIS and financial reports are inter dependents to each other.
The above table indicates the respondents explain their reasons related to reliable of financial
reporting. Since it is periodical analysis it results in reliable financial reports and also without
AIS no financial can be done reliable financial report can be done if AIS used correctly. Through
data collection to preparation of financial statements.
From the above table, the inference can be drawn that about 71.42% of the total respondent have
a hint on the AIS on internal control fully and the remain not hint on the AIS on internal control
fully. But most of them have a concept on it. From the above responses, information system has
a constructive role in the overall operation of the CBB not only in internal control department.
In the above table the more respondent answer will be yes the reasons is in their any activities for
the government at controlling system. In case of that it makes easy and clearly. And also it may
have different controls internally for how to finance the accounting. All financial statements are
passed though the AIS.
Chapter four
4.1 conclusions
The role of accounting information system in the bank activity is extremely important in the
orientation of the bank management toward successful strategies. Bank accounting is the domain
where all accounting information system is essential for bank activities are collected and
synthesized, construction and business bank after started operation it adapted main progress and
new systems. By adapting these new system CBB some important in it, over all operations.
In addition to this the researcher has derived the following points from the analysis.
The main purpose of AIS is to provide efficient, effective and accurate information for
the information users.
AIS are used as a tool to ensure integrity, confidentiality, and reliability of critical data.
AIS are used to reduce risk of error, fraud, and other illegal acts occurring in the
operation of bank.
The main challenge of information system department at the bank is lack of efficient
infrastructure in the country, disapproval of new information system and budget
consistent by top management and internal control of the bank.
AIS help the bank to be competitive organization in the market.
The AIS process reliable in financial report are used as accounting information or raw
data to process reliable financial reporting as whole for bank.
There is preparation of financial statement to administer internal control that depends on
the AIS.
The majority of the respondent have hint about AIS internal control system fully.
AIS minimize the problem by improving decision making process, quality of accounting
information and internal control.
AIS use properly that performances and accounting information system ensures banks the
path to success.
The awareness of AIS is very important for the employees and for an organization
especially of service giving business organization like CBB is very crucial.
Generally, internal control is impossible without accounting information system.
4.2 Recommendation
Even though the bank has achieved its objectives becoming efficient dynamic and competitive in
the country and in internal market. Much coercion should be taken to make information system
dynamic and internal control efficient. So as the researcher derived the following points as
remedies for further information system and efficient internal control.
The bank should employ the professional related with banking as much as
possible BA degree and above.
Top management of the Bank should give emphasizes to information system
development and allocate necessary budget to information system
department .In a addition to information system department should develop its
internal strength by arranging different train’s to its staffs.
The bank management should be flexible to cope up with the changing
environment and continuous department of information system.
Information system department should be given necessary training to its staff
where necessary.
Every transaction should be reviewed by the internal controls auditors to
discover any error and frauds occurred in the all activities of the employees.
Both information system department and internal control department must do
together for efficient and effectiveness of the construction and business bank.
In General, the bank should focus around its information system in relation to internal control
and so that action would be taken to make the system more efficient.
REFERANCE
George H Bodnar .Williams. Hopwood (1998), Accounting information system.
Harangues Daniela (2005), Accounting information in bank activity.
H.sajady Midestaginof information sciences and technology. Volume 6.NO.2 July 2008.
M ahadisalehi (2010), international journal of economics and finance.
Marshal Romney (2000).Accounting information system.
S.K.Bhattacharyya.Johan Deaden (1976), .Accounting for management.
Whitigtonnpany (2008).principle of auditing.
Appendix
ADIGRAT UNIVERSITY
COLLEGE OF BUSINESS AND ECONOMICS
Questionnaire
N.B There is no need of writing your name
1 Personal profile
1. Sex
Male Female
2 Age
1. Do you think that employees of CBB have adequate awareness about the importance of
accounting information system (AIS) of (CBB)?
3. Does AIS has a contribution in reducing risk of error, frauds other logical acts?
_____________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________