TBEGuide ORM2014 SEPT29 LINKED-compressed
TBEGuide ORM2014 SEPT29 LINKED-compressed
TBEGuide ORM2014 SEPT29 LINKED-compressed
BUSINESS
ESSENTIALS
O N L I N E R E P U TAT I O N
MANAGEMENT
The essential guide for tourism businesses on how to
manage online customer reviews.
Online Reputation Management
This guide explains how tourism operators in British Columbia can take control of, manage,
and generate more business from online reviews and social media commentary. As a tourism
operator, you will learn where reviews are being posted, when and how to respond to both
positive and negative reviews, which measurement tools are available to determine how your
tourism business rates online, and how to manage your online profiles to ensure information
is current.
Copyright
Second Edition, September 2014
© 2014 – Destination BC Corp. All rights reserved. No part of this guide may be reproduced
in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, without permission in writing from
Destination BC. This guide is produced to provide information to assist tourism operators
in British Columbia. Destination BC Corp. does not endorse, recommend or assume any
liability for any of the operations or organizations referenced in this guide. Super, Natural;
Super, Natural British Columbia; HelloBC and Visitor Centre and all associated logos/
trade-marks are trade-marks or Official Marks belonging to Destination BC Corp.
Online Reputation Management Guide
Table of Contents
2
5 Monitoring Activity and Measuring Performance............................................34
Online Reputation Management: Delta Hotels and Resorts...............................................................41
6 Acting on Feedback.....................................................................................................................43
Tips from TripAdvisor’s Top-Rated BC Restaurants...........................................................................47
9 Summary..............................................................................................................................................64
Ten Key Takeaways...................................................................................................................................64
10 Additional Resources.................................................................................................................65
Appendix 1. Glossary.................................................................................................................66
3
1 Introduction to Online Reputation Management
Consumer reviews, in particular, can make This guide will walk you through the steps
or break the reputation of a business. These involved in taking control of your online
days, there are reviews on everything from reputation.
cars to dentists to university professors to
potential employers.
4
Just How Just How Popular is Social Media?
Popular is According to an eMarketer survey, nearly one in four people worldwide used social
networks in 2013. That equates to 1.73 billion people, an increase of 18% over 2012. Of
Social Media? Internet users, 68% used a social network at least once per month in 2013. That figure is
predicted to rise to more than 75% by 2016.1
Canadians are some of world’s most frequent users of social networking sites. According
to a Media Technology Monitor survey, almost 7 in 10 Canadians used social media at least
once a month, and 63% of these people used it daily. Facebook is by far the most popular
social networking site, utilized by 93% of active social media users in Canada.2 Though
only one in five respondents reported using Twitter, this was an increase of 80% over the
previous year.
At the same time, review sites continue to gain in popularity every year. According to a
2013 TripAdvisor survey, 69% of travellers worldwide say they visit travel review sites as
part of trip planning.3
1 eMarketer. (2013). Social networking reaches nearly one in four around the world.
2 MacLeans.ca. (2013). How do you compare? New report reveals stats about social media usage in Canada.
www.macleans.ca/general/how-do-you-compare-new-report-reveals-stats-about-social-media-usage-in-canada
3 TripAdvisor TripBarometer. (2013).
5
1 Introduction to Online Reputation Management
About this This guide was developed by Destination British Columbia in cooperation with tourism
businesses and regions across the province. It is written for owners, operators and employees
Guide of all types of businesses in BC’s tourism industry, from B&Bs to large hotels, from restaurants
to event venues, and from activity providers to attractions, as well as all destination marketing
organizations.
Key Learning The guide has three main objectives: media platforms. Rather, the focus is on
managing reputation on the most popular
Objectives 1. To help you understand and adopt the channels used by travellers for researching
basic trends, principles and tools of online trips and sharing experiences. These
reputation management. channels may change over time, but the
guidelines and best practices presented in
2. To provide insight into the challenges and this guide are intended to apply to any
opportunities presented by social media. channel, present or future.
3. To show you ways to manage customer If you require technical assistance, there is a
feedback in social media and use it to wealth of information online. To assist with
guide improvements and attract new your search, refer to the list of resources in
and repeat customers. Section 10: Additional Resources.
6
Key Principles Online Reputation Management Training Programs
Destination BC was early to recognize the importance of online reputation management.
The first edition of this guide was published in 2011 as part of the Tourism Business
Essentials program.
In late 2012, a one-hour online webinar featuring highlights from the workshop was
broadcast and recorded for on-demand viewing, and Destination BC introduced a
three-hour Advanced Online Reputation Management workshop.
For more information about these workshops and other resources offered by
Destination BC’s Tourism Business Essentials program, visit
www.destinationbc.ca/Programs/Guides-Workshops-and-Webinars.aspx
7
1 Introduction to Online Reputation Management
4 A hashtag is a word or phrase preceded by a hash or pound sign (#) and used to identify messages on a
specific topic on social networking sites.
8
Destination BC Top 10 Social Media Tips from BC Destination Marketing Organizations
and • Educate yourself. Understand how social media can benefit your business and use the
appropriate platforms to assist in achieving your goals.
Social Media
• Build a personality for your brand on the social platforms you choose. Engage and respond
frequently. Do not be afraid to have fun with it.
• Social media is not free. Good content and engaging stories take time and human resources
to develop; be prepared to spend time building and managing your community.
• Make social media part of your daily routine. Create a plan and stick to it.
• To capture users’ attention and increase engagement, include imagery in posts as much
as possible.
• Supply imagery (or links to video) and content for regional and community social media
channels and blogs to help promote the region and related events, activities and festivals.
• Play your part by exceeding customer expectations, participating in discussions about your
region and encouraging travellers to share their experiences.
• Ensure your posts are engaging, informative, interesting and spark positive conversation.
• Follow your local DMO on social media channels, share their content, and participate in
their contests and social media campaigns.
9
2 Why Manage Your Online Reputation?
Managing your online presence and reputation Social media has changed how travellers:
requires initial and ongoing investments
of your time. However, the payoff is high • Research trips. More travellers are using
for businesses that generate positive reviews, social networks to obtain trip information
high ratings and a stream of positive social and advice from other travellers. Reputation
media content. is quickly becoming as important as price
and location in influencing trip decisions.
Here are four reasons why managing online
reputation is a critical function for tourism • Communicate with businesses. Social
businesses: media has emerged as an important
customer service channel, fast becoming
1. Social media has changed as indispensable as email or telephone.
traveller behaviour. Increasingly, travellers turn to social
According to the Google and Ipsos networks to make inquiries of businesses
MediaCT Travel Study, the Internet is the and to provide feedback, and they expect
number-one source for planning travel.1 a quick response.
The same report found that nearly half
(46%) of respondents use social media to • Share experiences. More travellers are
share travel-related experiences. using social networks before, during and
after trips to share activities, impressions,
reviews, photos and videos.
10
2. Consumers trust other consumers influenced by sources they do not fully
more than any other advertising trust; they simply keep researching until
source. they are confident they are making the
According to Nielsen’s more recent Trust right decision. Rather, Nielsen’s survey
in Advertising survey, two of the top- suggests that to maximize effectiveness,
three most trusted advertising sources are marketers must shift more resources
personal recommendations and online toward getting people talking about and
consumer opinions.2 These sources are recommending their business.
more trusted than emails from marketers,
search engine results ads or print, radio It is important to note the second most
and television advertising. trusted source in the Nielsen survey is a
brand website (i.e. an official website
It is understandable that consumers trust created by a business rather than a third-
recommendations from people they know, party re-seller like an online travel agency).
but why such a high level of trust for Consumers are still highly influenced by
advice from strangers? Unlike marketers, brand website content, even though it
consumers are not selling anything, comes from marketers. Social media
and they do not stand to benefit from does not completely displace traditional
purchases. marketing activities.
2 Nielsen Trust In Advertising Survey. (2013.) Under the Influence: Consumer Trust in Advertising.
11
2 Why Manage Your Online Reputation?
“Despite spending a lot of money on advertising, it was our customers that turned the tide
for us, first through word of mouth but also through online platforms such as TripAdvisor
and travel blogs,” she says.
Today, Archipelago Cruises is ranked No. 1 of almost 1,000 activities in British Columbia
on TripAdvisor. Landry says that TripAdvisor has become the single most important part of
their advertising.
“Thanks to customer feedback, mainly on TripAdvisor, we are able to continue running our
tours exactly the way we envisaged from the very beginning, the way we enjoy running
them,” she says. “Best of all, it is free.”
3 Anderson, Christopher. (November 2012) The Impact of Social Media on Lodging Performance.
12
3 Setting Up an Online Reputation
Management Program
14
Where to Find Where to Find the Time and Resources
the Time and If you are wondering how to manage social media while juggling the needs and demands
of your guests, take inspiration from Victoria’s Abbeymoore Manor.
Resources
Despite having only a handful of employees, the seven-room property is highly active in
social media, with a blog, Facebook page, Twitter feed and Pinterest page. Innkeeper Ian
MacPhee says he also monitors reviews on Yelp, bedandbreakfast.com, iloveinns.com and
TripAdvisor—both for his property and for competitors.
How does he find the time? “It is very tough, but the results speak for themselves, so it is a
priority,” says MacPhee. “We use systems and tools to automate where we can. I try and set
aside some time each day. If I’m blogging I try and write several articles at once and publish
them at different times.”
To ensure a high level of service and a solid reputation, MacPhee says he invests more resources
in staffing and online marketing initiatives than most innkeepers. “Yes, it costs money,” he
explains, “but a great website coupled with a solid online reputation brings business.”
The hard work is paying off. At time of publication, Abbeymoore Manor was ranked No. 1
of 1,649 B&Bs and inns in British Columbia on TripAdvisor.
“The benefit is immeasurable in terms of driving guests to your website,” says MacPhee,
adding that he has also been able to command higher room rates.
However, he says, to reap the rewards you do not have to rank No. 1. Here he shares his
advice for tourism operators:
• There’s no use focusing on social media and online reviews unless you are confident the
reviews will be very positive. Be sure your property is the best it can be and go out of
your way for every guest.
• It all starts with your product. If you aren’t providing a truly excellent experience, do not
ask folks to share your mediocrity online. Reinvest and improve.
• Once your guest experience is solid, use tactics to increase review volume, such as
TripAdvisor review widgets and review quotes in marketing activities. Most importantly,
simply ask guests to take a moment and share their experience with the TripAdvisor
community.
• Don’t cheat or mislead. Writing your own reviews will get you in trouble. TripAdvisor
calls this “Organized Boosting” and they are very sophisticated when it comes to
weeding out those who try to “game” the system.
• Get involved with your local tourism organizations, destination marketing organization
and area accommodation group. Be collaborative and help others do their best so that
more tourists will visit your city.
• Typically guests look at the newest reviews, the worst reviews and the management
responses, so it is critical to craft an appropriate response to all negative criticisms.
15
4 Managing Listings and Content
When travellers research online trips and Online travel agencies (OTAs) such as
activities relevant to your business, you want Expedia and Travelocity rank high in both
them to find you, and accurate, appealing organic results and paid search results, which
information. are purchased by an advertiser and marked by
a shaded area or “Sponsored” label.
Review sites and social networks typically
rank high in search results related to travel To maximize your online presence, having
planning. Content, reviews and ratings from a brand website is no longer enough. It is
TripAdvisor, Yelp, Facebook, Google+ and important to maintain an active presence
Twitter often fall within the top-five organic on major review sites and popular social
search results. Organic search results are channels.
“natural” or unpaid results that are ranked
by the search engine using an algorithm In the next section, you will find the steps
according to relevancy to the search term. involved in optimizing your positioning on
social channels.
16
Perform a To understand how your business is positioned online, put yourself in the shoes of the
traveller. Conduct a reputation audit by performing the following searches:
Reputation
• Your business (e.g. “ABC Rentals Whistler”)
Audit • Your top three competitors (e.g. “Whistler Recreational Equipment Company”)
• Your business type(s) and location (e.g. “ski equipment Whistler”)
If you do not have direct competitors, search for successful businesses like yours in
other regions.
Pay particular attention to the top organic results; most searchers do not look further.
Paid results are typically at the top and to the right of the page, are shaded, and are labeled
“Sponsored” or “Ads.”
Answer the following questions and make a list of items to follow up on.
It is important to regularly perform a reputation audit (at least once every three months),
because results can change frequently. Note that information can be displayed differently
on different devices, so perform your searches on both a smartphone and tablet, as well as
a desktop or laptop computer. Furthermore, results can vary by search engine, so check
the most popular search engines: Google, Bing and Yahoo.
17
4 Managing Listings and Content
Online, there are two major audiences: trav- For example: if you publish articles on your
ellers and algorithms. In search marketing, website or blog, a calendar of events or a story
algorithms are formulas that determine which about the region’s history, add social share
content appears in search results and in what buttons so that visitors can easily share the
order. Google, Bing and Yahoo! run on information on Facebook, Twitter and other
algorithms, as do TripAdvisor and Facebook. relevant channels. Additionally, make sure
you promote these on your own social
Algorithms are updated regularly to deliver profiles.
the most relevant results to users. The details
of search engine algorithms are kept secret to This marketing tactic is sometimes referred
prevent businesses from gaming the system. to as inbound marketing. Traditional
However, there are typically two key ingre- marketing, also known as outbound
dients to algorithms: relevance, which is marketing, involves interruptive or “push”
partly measured by matching search terms tactics such as email blasts, direct mail,
to website content, and importance, which telemarketing, and TV, radio and print
is partly determined by the amount of traffic advertising. Outbound marketing tactics are
a website generates as well as the number of considered less effective today because people
links it receives from quality, popular sites. can easily block or ignore messages.
With many search terms, such as those related Inbound marketing is less about finding
to restaurants and hotels, location plays an customers than about being found by custom-
important factor in results. A user may not ers, primarily through search engines and
include a location in the search, but if they social media. It can increase your visibility
have allowed the search engine to use their in searches, and drive traffic to your website
location information, it uses GPS data to and social channels. It also helps build trust
provide results for nearby businesses. with travellers, can increase conversions
and, ultimately, will drive higher customer
Another relatively new factor in search satisfaction.
algorithms is the use of “social signals,”
which are reviews and ratings that indicate
the quality and popularity of a business.
1 Google Keyword Planner is a free tool that helps you determine the popularity of keyword search terms.
You will need a Google account to use it. For more information visit http://adwords.google.com/KeywordPlanner
18
Social Media
and Search
19
4 Managing Listings and Content
PAID
CONTENT
EARNED
CONTENT
PAID
OWNED
CONTENT
CONTENT
others.
SE LS
ES
RE
WOR S
ONL K I N T R ThA TVO U E A R M O S
E M P LOY E EI SN EF IRRTESRPTAV G
U TAT RWEI LT
e ess E R Th
entiaL I S
H lT Me esEM
CH U U
G U N STT
A D S & BThe O CThe
R essential UM
Hhuman EASN ATheGesseEntial TheEesseLntiaITOR
Rresources NA TunguItaiideH E D
sent
T The AA T F U
tour for Mguid l gui A D
E Oto developmouOIguA P E OI D I INN O N
ial
l guide for ism busi E N
mo
I S SMETourism e forT
R AU ERsusentialFguO
guide
TUHRAT L Operators.
L essentia ness to howtotoattr for BC tou n bikN S
how de ide es
ABBU D
S P O R TA T TT O I O Nguide manage tourism busines
market ingntainto de
bik velopT staIina
O S ideR I LR I S A M
sesinter e
and online custom natioto act
on how your rism bustourism , mana
and
ses on du e togur ing, m RbleMto opTh K E
to creating tourism ads
nding
P U l guide
er reviews nal visito hos ines pro gin
to understa
E R Eessentia
The
The essential
ENandTbrochures
BC.
tourism inthat attract customers.
. rs t media
. ct in an d anagStouris erae es
ism E TM E
IN M E T on how to
developG rke ing m tinseg ntan O
BUURN T A
sport
21
4 Managing Listings and Content
Review Sites As mentioned in the Introduction, social media can be divided into two main categories:
review sites and social networking sites. When it comes to reputation, review sites are the
vs. Social first priority. They drive direct business and provide invaluable customer feedback.
Networking
Sites
If you have visited the HelloBC website recently, you may have noticed a new feature on busi-
ness listings: a live feed of TripAdvisor reviews.
“We believe that displaying recent and relevant user-generated content is a consumer benefit,
making travel planning easier,” explains Kathleen Harvey, Manager, Product Services at
Destination BC.
“Once a tourism business enrolls in the HelloBC Listing Program we create a link to
their TripAdvisor listing,” says Harvey. The feed is integrated into listings for all sectors:
Accommodations, Activities & Attractions, Golf, Ski & Snowboarding, Transportation, and
Festivals and Events.
“The only exceptions are suppliers who do not yet have a listing or any reviews,” says Harvey.
Her team conducts regular audits to capture any enrolled businesses with a newly acquired
presence on TripAdvisor.
“We encourage businesses to ensure they have a TripAdvisor listing, to solicit reviews and to
comment on those they perceive to be positive or negative,” said Harvey.
23
4 Managing Listings and Content
For example, VirtualTourist, Get Your Guide and Viator are popular for tours and
excursions, whereas OpenTable and DineHere are popular for restaurants. Online travel
agencies (e.g. Expedia, Hotels.com, Priceline) feature reviews and ratings for a range of
travel businesses. Your reputation audit will help you determine which reviews sites are
popular within your business segment.
24
Social It is not as easy to draw a direct line between
activity on social networking sites and book-
Recently, Facebook introduced several
features relevant to tourism businesses:
Networking ings as it is with review sites. However, social
networking sites are increasingly popular with • Graph Search. This feature turns Facebook
Sites travellers who enjoy sharing experiences and into a search engine for friend activities
making recommendations. and interests. From the search bar users
can search for destinations their friends
They can also be effective marketing tools have been to and businesses friends have
to build awareness and are important liked, checked in to, and tagged photos of.
channels for engaging communities, Because everyone has a different network
providing customer service, and building of friends, search results for every user are
customer loyalty and advocacy. different.
Social networking sites typically require To increase the likelihood of your business
higher maintenance than review sites; showing up in relevant searches, optimize
maintaining an active presence demands your Facebook content for Graph Search,
frequent monitoring and content much like you do when optimizing website
management. content for Google search.2 Complete
your About page with a good profile
description and applicable categories,
Facebook tag all of the imagery you upload and
encourage users to like, and check in to
and tag photos of your business.
The most popular social network in the • Nearby Places. This mobile application
world, Facebook has over 1.1 billion active allows users to search, check in to, rate,
users worldwide. By maintaining an active review and upload photos of local busi-
business page you will build awareness, nesses from mobile devices. Since these
promote products and services, and establish activities show up in the user’s newsfeed,
and engage a community of people who share they help spread the word about your
an interest in your brand. business to Facebook users.
2 For tips on how to optimize your Facebook page see this infographic:
www.insidefacebook.com/2013/07/17/infographic-optimizing-your-small-business-page-for-facebook-graph-search
25
4 Managing Listings and Content
Networking
Sites
26
Social Foursquare
Like Facebook Nearby Places, Foursquare is a location-based mobile social networking site. It
Networking is particularly popular in North American urban centres. Users can browse local businesses,
check-in and share their location with their friend network. They can also rate businesses,
Sites share tips and earn points and badges.
Once you have claimed your space and updated your profile, you can monitor ratings, tips
and check-ins. Offering discounts, promotions and incentives to Foursquare users is a good
way to reward frequent customers and attract new ones.
Other Social There are countless other social networking sites, from photo-based sites (e.g. Instagram,
Pinterest, Flickr) to video sites (e.g. YouTube, Vimeo, Vine). These sites combine two of
Networking the most powerful aspects of social media: images and sharing. They can also be influential
when travellers are seeking trip ideas and inspiration.
Sites
As with other social networking sites, you can create a profile, build followings and share
imagery related to your business and destination. Be sure to monitor imagery tagged with
your business name.
27
4 Managing Listings and Content
Blogs are a highly effective inbound marketing As with your website and other social chan-
activity. There are two ways to manage repu- nels, be sure to optimize content with
tation with blogs: working with third-party descriptions, tags and keywords, and add
bloggers and administering your own blog. social share buttons to posts.
28
Forums A forum is an online community where people seek and share information and advice on
various topics. Typically, a forum is a section of a website where users post and answer
questions from other users. For example, TripAdvisor and Yelp have popular forums
dedicated to specific regions and topics.
Forums are a valuable resource to learn what questions people have about your destination.
Check them regularly for topics relevant to your business. On TripAdvisor, frequent and
valued contributors may be designated “Destination Experts,” and on Yelp they are designated
“Elite” status. Your reputation audit will help you find other forums popular in your sector
and destination.
When posting messages on forums be open about who you are. Do not directly promote
your business as it may be off-putting for other members.
29
4 Managing Listings and Content
30
Mobile: In recent years, the growth of mobile devices
has been explosive. Increasingly, people
navigate content and make a booking
regardless of the device they are using.
Decisions perform functions on smartphones that used This will help ensure mobile users do
to be reserved for desktop computers. This not abandon your site.
on the Go includes researching trips, searching for
local businesses, making bookings, planning There are two ways to approach mobile
mapping routes and sharing experiences. compatibility. First, build a separate site for
each type of device. This ensures a high level
Most social channels have a mobile applica- of customization and usability but can be
tion and website that make it easy to view expensive and difficult to maintain.
content on any type of device. Since informa-
tion can be displayed differently on different For most businesses, a more practical solu-
devices, it is a good idea to check them to see tion is responsive design. This is a process in
how your content is displayed. which a website is designed to read the user’s
device, and formats content to fit the screen,
For example, on TripAdvisor’s mobile appli- whether it is a desktop, smartphone or tablet.
cation, only the five most recent reviews of a It is less expensive and easier to maintain
business are displayed. Users can click to see than having a separate site for each device.
more reviews, but for people on the go this
may be all they need to make a decision. Regardless of the solution you choose, make
sure you have a prominent click-to-call
As for your website, a mobile-compatible option. Many people prefer to directly call
design will ensure that visitors can easily a business to make a booking.
31
4 Managing Listings and Content
Ecotours In this interview, co-founder David Udow and director of marketing Warrick Hubbard
share some of the secrets to their success.
Today, everyone in our company is aware of the importance of our TripAdvisor ranking.
We are incredibly focused on the guest experience. We’re hands on with guides and guest
services staff. Our policy is not to ask guests for reviews, but to allow it to be completely
organic. We have enough customers who love our product, so we do not need to ask them.
There are also recruitment benefits. People want to work with a winning team that takes
really good care of customers and has a strong reputation.
Our business lends itself well to video and photos. In previous years video helped people
visualize exactly what Ziptrek was all about (keeping in mind zip-line tours are only a decade
old in North America, we being the first!). Today, devices like iPhones make it all the easier
for people to capture content—and the quality has improved.
32
BC Tourism On sites like HelloBC and TripAdvisor, we take advantage of the option to showcase video
Business content. For any special events we’ve been a part of (Super Bowl, Grey Cups, Stampede,
San Francisco), we’ve uploaded video content early to garner exposure and awareness and
Profile: Ziptrek archive it on our main site for people to reference.
David Udow: Our blog is a vehicle for getting people interested in topics related to our
business such as sustainability and taking care of the planet. Even though they might not
visit us often, our fans and Facebook friends are receptive to and interested in these
types of topics.
33
5 Monitoring Activity and Measuring Performance
34
Alerts.
Alerts are the simplest, most popular monitoring tools. They notify you via email or text
message whenever your business or designated keywords are mentioned online. Rather than
you searching for mentions, they find you.
Google Alerts
35
5 Monitoring Activity and Measuring Performance
Hootsuite feeds
• Radian6, Sprout Social, Topsy, Trakur • Twellow and WeFollow are Twitter
and BrandWatch are paid tools that offer directories that help you find users by
a combination of monitoring, management interest, profession, expertise, region
and analytics functions. and other attributes.
Key Performance Indicators (KPI) are the most important measures of a business’ success
in reaching its objectives. Here we look at KPIs for three main areas of performance measure-
ment in social media: Review Performance, Social Networking Site Performance and Website
Performance.
A) Review Performance
37
5 Monitoring Activity and Measuring Performance
By monitoring and measuring performance A social media analytics tool such as Revinate
on review sites, you will gain an understand- performs sentiment analysis, a process
ing of customer likes and dislikes, how you whereby review comments are analyzed for
are performing relative to competitors and meaning, and words and phrases are classified
local businesses, comparative strengths and as positive, negative or neutral. When
weaknesses and where there is room for a large number of reviews are analyzed,
improvement. patterns emerge to help you decide how
to act.
Review performance is fairly easy to measure:
review sites require customers to rate busi- For review performance, key performance
nesses as part of a review, typically on a scale indicators may include:
of 1 to 5. Some sites also allow reviewers to
rate attributes such as service, quality and • Ranking and rating on individual review
ambience. sites
• Aggregate score from combined review sites
(this data can be provided by a
Analyzing the commentary in guest reviews is reputation management tool such as
more complex. Like comments on social net- ReviewPro or Revinate)
working sites, text in reviews is freeform and • Department ratings
unstructured, often containing both positive • Volume of reviews
and negative remarks. You will gain insight by • Review sentiment (e.g. the number of
reading review commentary, but it is difficult positive and negative reviews)
to quantify this content.
38
B) Social Networking Site Performance
Facebook Insights
Numbers tell us part of the story, such as the The number of conversions or revenue gener-
number of fans and followers. However, fans ated might be low or even nonexistent. This
have value only if they are truly interested in is, in part, due to the difficulty of drawing a
your business. A more helpful metric direct line between social media activity and
is engagement. bookings, but also because social networking
sites are rarely used as direct booking
As previously discussed, engagement is a channels.
customer’s interaction with you on social
channels. It can be measured by the number However, social networking sites still have
of likes, shares, comments, mentions, value. By helping to build awareness, increase
retweets, favourites and pluses you receive, customer satisfaction and advocacy and build
as well as the number of people who check long-lasting customer relationships, social
in to your business from social channels. media generates new and repeat business and
contributes to the bottom line in ways that
For social networking sites, key performance are not always quantifiable.
indicators may include:
39
5 Monitoring Activity and Measuring Performance
C) Website Performance
Google Analytics is a powerful free tool For your website, key performance indicators
that can help you understand the interplay related to social media may include:
between your website and social channels.
It will tell you how many visitors each • Referral traffic from social channels,
channel drives to your website, what the including number of page views and
visitor activity is, and which content is shared visit duration
on social channels via sharing button activity. • Social plug-in activity
• Conversions (bookings and/or revenue
If you set up e-commerce tracking features generated)
on your booking engine, Google Analytics • Campaign performance (the above
can also track bookings referred by social measures tracked by campaign or post)
channels, the pages people visit on the path
to conversion, and the amount of revenue
generated. You will need to assign booking
and tracking codes to measure the results of
campaigns and overall performance.
5. Report Performance
Finally, once you have determined your key performance indicators in each area, set targets
related to your objectives and create a weekly or monthly report to track them.
Share the highlights with staff to cultivate the team approach to reputation management
discussed in Section 3. Integrate the setting of targets and performance evaluation methods
in your annual budgeting and planning.
40
Online Online Reputation Management: Delta Hotels and Resorts
Reputation In 1962, Delta Hotels and Resorts opened its first property at the Vancouver International
Airport; today they are one of the leading hotel brands in Canada. The company operates
Management: more than 40 hotels, including nine properties in British Columbia. It is fully Canadian-
owned and has been ranked as “one of the 50 Best Employers in Canada” by Aon Hewitt
Delta Hotels for 14 years.
and Resorts Online reputation management is an important part of Delta’s success. Here Ricardo
Nicholas, Director, Brand Performance, discusses the company’s approach.
Tell us how Delta Hotels and Resorts manages its social media and online
reputation management functions.
As a brand we have always encouraged guests to speak with us through numerous
channels (telephone, email, our website, electronic surveys, correspondence, etc.). We have
a longstanding program called the “Voice of the Guest” that allows guests to contact us at
any time through any of these channels. All guest feedback is a priority and is acknowledged
and responded to within a defined timeframe.
We have introduced a similar approach to managing social media, with individual properties
monitoring and responding to online reviews on a daily basis. As a safety net we monitor
reviews and comments to ensure that responses reflect the tone of the brand. All of this is
structured and measured to ensure compliance to our brand standards.
41
5 Monitoring Activity and Measuring Performance
TripAdvisor
42
6 Acting on Feedback
43
6 Acting on Feedback
44
Use customer feedback to guide 9. Create a Virtuous Circle
decisions related to staffing levels, By listening to guest feedback and using it
services and amenities, and quality. For to guide improvements, you will increase
example, housekeeping staff must be customer satisfaction, receive better reviews
alerted to cleanliness issues, and kitchen and attract more customers. In turn, you will
staff must be aware of comments related attract more revenue and, in turn, more feed-
to menu items. back. This creates a virtuous circle that can be
very healthy for your business.
• Revenue Management
As the Cornell study discussed in Section 2 Alternatively, if you ignore feedback, you risk
demonstrates, reviews have a direct influ- receiving negative reviews that will frighten
ence on demand for products and services. off prospective customers and decrease
If your business receives high ratings, you revenue. This creates a vicious circle that
can charge more. If you receive low ratings, can be very damaging to business.
you will have a harder time selling products
and services, even at a discount. If guests
complain about lack of value, you will need
to either improve quality or lower prices to
stay competitive.
• Human Resources
In addition to using customer feedback
to recognize employees and determine
training needs, use it to guide recruit-
ment decisions. If you are not confident
a job candidate will consistently meet or
exceed brand expectations—keep looking.
Moreover, many job-seekers check out
review sites before deciding where they
want to work. A strong reputation will
help you attract star candidates.
45
6 Acting on Feedback
WorldHost
46
Tips from Tips From TripAdvisor’s Top-rated BC Restaurants
TripAdvisor’s When it comes to managing reputation, restaurants have several unique challenges. Typically,
customers arrive with high expectations and stay for a short time, leaving a small window in
Top-rated BC which to impress them—or to turn things around if something goes wrong.
Restaurants With the popularity of mobile devices, restaurant customers often post comments, reviews
and photos on social networks while at the dinner table. In addition to TripAdvisor, Yelp,
Facebook and Twitter, there are dozens of restaurant review sites, including CitySearch,
Urbanspoon and OpenTable.
Given the challenges, we asked a few BC restaurants how they manage to stay on top of
social media and achieve top rankings on review sites.
“Hire good staff and keep them!” recommends Richard Norwood, owner of
Norwoods in Ucluelet, rated #6 of more than 12,000 restaurants in BC (#1 in Ucluelet) on
TripAdvisor at time of publication. “Use quality products and above all always put yourself
in the guest’s shoes. It is hard to screw up if you do that.”
Without his core group of staff, achieving his TripAdvisor ranking would have been impos-
sible, says Norwood. “We are a small restaurant (just 28 seats), so the setting is intimate.
Also the kitchen is completely exposed, which creates a certain honesty between guests
and the kitchen brigade.”
Norwood says that generating reviews for his restaurant is an organic process. “Having
guests submit reviews is not something we push.” However, he does keep a sharp eye on
review sites. In addition to TripAdvisor, he monitors reviews and commentary on
Urbanspoon, Chowhound, Facebook and Yelp.
At Allegra Restaurant in Cranbrook, staff invite customers to write reviews. “We do this
by including a TripAdvisor business card with the bill,” says owner Thomas Nay. “We also
encourage our customers to ‘like’ our Facebook page.” In addition, the restaurant displays a
TripAdvisor review widget on its website.
Nay says that success comes down to pleasing customers. “I don’t think the ranking can be
influenced in any other way than by providing an exceptional product and great service.”
47
6 Acting on Feedback
Tips From Cedar House Restaurant in Golden, which often ranks in the top 20 of BC restaurants on
TripAdvisor’s TripAdvisor at time of publication, also displays a TripAdvisor badge on its website and
invites patrons to submit reviews. However, proprietor Darrin DeRosa attributes the
Top-rated BC success to exceeding expectations.
Restaurants “The food has always been incredible and we use as much organic [ingredients] as possible,”
he explains. “We all work as a team … I am involved in every aspect of the business,
including being on the floor serving and in the dish pit at the end of the night.”
How have high ratings and rankings affected revenue? “The effect on our business has been
substantial,” says Norwood.
Nay agrees. “The results so far are fantastic,” he says. “We get a lot of comments from
travellers who say they decided to visit our restaurant based on reviews. In the highly
competitive restaurant industry, social media is a way to help spread the word. I find it a
must to have as much exposure on such sites as possible. It might be a bit time consuming,
but it is worth it.”
Asked if he has any advice for BC restaurateurs who desire similar success, Nay replied,
“Above all, every customer needs to be viewed as a potential critic.”
48
7 Responding to Reviews and
Social Media Commentary
The previous section reviewed the internal response to social media feedback. In this section
we will look at the external response.
Given the public nature of social media, responding to customer feedback can be a daunting
task. If you say the right thing, you will reassure travellers and attract business. If you say the
wrong thing, you may anger the reviewer and frighten prospects away.
In this section we address common questions that tourism businesses have about responding
to reviews, to give you the knowledge and confidence you need to respond effectively to feed-
back. Every business will have a different approach, so adapt the guidelines to fit the unique
personality of your company.
1 TripAdvisor. (2012.) Survey finds half of TripAdvisor users will not book a hotel that has no reviews.
49
7 Responding to Reviews and
Social Media Commentary
50
Responding Note, however, that review sites typically will not remove a review unless the business can
prove it is fraudulent or violates site rules. They may take the stance that the guest is entitled to
to Reviews: his or her opinion and suggest that you post a reply to provide your own perspective. If so, do
this politely and respectfully. Clarify the matter, but never accuse a reviewer of dishonesty.
Answers to
Common What if I can’t fix the problem?
Be transparent. Acknowledge that it is an ongoing issue you are trying to resolve or cannot
Questions fix, and apologize for any inconvenience. Complaints about pricing, noise, location, services,
facilities and other areas can help set expectations for other travellers and thereby reduce
complaints.
If you get a lot of complaints about the same issue, respond to select reviews rather than all of
them, which may come across as defensive. Rather than expend your energy on crafting clever
responses, focus on finding a resolution.
51
7 Responding to Reviews and
Social Media Commentary
52
Examples Medical Issue
Comments: “Staff went above and beyond
Response example: “… We are a limited-
service property and our rates reflect this.
of How to after my husband fell ill during the tour. Our kitchen had to close early that night
The guide, who was certified in First Aid, due to unforeseen circumstances, and I
Respond to attended to my husband until paramedics apologize for the inconvenience. It is other-
Reviews arrived, and later staff delivered our belong-
ings to the hotel. Then that night the owner
wise open until 10:00 pm. Front desk staff
are on duty 24-hours to assist with luggage
called to see how my husband was doing. and recommendations ....”
We will be back!”
Décor
Mixed Feedback Comment: “It felt like staying at my grand-
Comments: “Staff were warm and friendly, ma’s house – floral prints, doilies and trinkets
and our view of the ocean was magnificent. everywhere. The owner was always skulking
Our dinner couldn’t have been more perfect. around, and we could hear everything from
The only issue was the band was a bit too the guests next door – I mean everything!
loud, but they stopped at 10:00 PM.” Next time it is a hotel.”
Response example: “Thank you for your Response example: “We try to provide a
kind remarks. I am delighted that you homey, country-house environment, and the
enjoyed the view and your dinner. We antique furnishings reflect our local history.
look forward to welcoming you back.” We try to convey this clearly in the photos
and descriptions on our website, but perhaps
we could do a better job. In any case I’m
Services sorry the décor wasn’t to your taste.”
Comments: “There was no concierge, no
bellman that I ever saw, and the kitchen
closes at 9:00 PM! I expected more, and
won’t be back.”
53
7 Responding to Reviews and
Social Media Commentary
54
Twitter When responding to comments on Twitter,
use the same basic guidelines as you would
As a general guideline, acknowledge posi-
tive tweets with a thank you. You might also
with online reviews and Facebook, with a few retweet the message. For negative tweets,
special considerations. attempt to take the conversation offline. If
the sender is not following you, you will not
Twitter is increasingly used as a customer be able to send a direct message. Start your
service channel, whether to make inquiries reply with the @username to limit how many
prior to a visit or to share impressions during people see it.
or after a visit. It is especially popular for
real-time commentary on mobile devices. Twitter response examples
Therefore, monitoring is particularly impor- Tweet: “What a fantastic stay at the ABC
tant. It will help you identify and resolve Lodge! Can’t wait to go back!”
issues before they escalate and find ways to
connect with customers and enhance their Response example: “We’re thrilled to hear you
experience. enjoyed your stay at @ABCLodge. We can’t
wait to welcome you back to #Smithers!”
Given the 140-character limit of tweets,
travellers do not usually go into a lot of detail. NEGATIVE
Tweets also have a short shelf life compared to Tweet: “Stood in line for 20 mins to check
reviews. The audience is limited to followers out of ABC Lodge. Won’t be back! #Fail”
of the person who sends the tweet, follow-
ers of anyone who retweets the message, and Response example: “@JohnSmith, we’re so
anyone who happens to be monitoring related sorry to hear we kept you waiting! Can we
keywords or streams. Typically tweets fade make it up to you? Please direct message me
away very quickly—unless they go viral and or email me at [email protected].”
cross over to other social channels.
55
7 Responding to Reviews and
Social Media Commentary
Handling What can you do if negative content related to your business comes up in search results? Each
situation may call for different measures, but here are some general guidelines to follow.
Negative
• Fix the problem. If you do not go to the root of the issue, it will probably come up again.
Online Make it a priority to resolve the problem.
Feedback • Go to the source. Search engines are rarely the originator of content; they pull it from online
sources. Find out where the information is coming from.
• Ask to have it removed. Depending on the source, you may be able to flag the content as
inappropriate or request that it be removed. Be polite and explain why. Do not be heavy-
handed—that may make things worse.
• Generate new content. If you cannot get it removed, push it down in results by adding new
content. Create profiles on major social networks, and generate news that will receive cover-
age on high-ranking sites and blogs.
• Pursue legal action. This should be a last resort, as lawsuits can be expensive, attract
unwanted attention, and success is never guaranteed. However, if content is false and
damaging, you may wish to consult a lawyer.
56
A Social Media Sometimes an issue goes beyond a negative
review or damaging content to become a
• Publish an official response. People can
be quick to condemn but may change their
Crisis full-blown crisis that threatens to do serious mind when they hear your side of the story.
harm to reputation. It may be a labour issue, State your case with sincerity, be open and
an environmental crisis or mistreatment of a transparent, and speak to your company’s
customer that goes viral. The source might be track record. Use online and offline media
a disgruntled guest, an ex-employee, a com- to get the message out, but choose one
petitor or a complete stranger. In certain cases channel for your official response (such as
you might not know who is behind it. your website) and direct inquiries there.
A crisis needs to be handled at the highest • Do not fan the flames. Issues tend to die
levels and may require the counsel of a public off quickly in social media. Once you have
relations firm, lawyer or reputation manage- published a response, it might be better to
ment firm. Crisis management falls beyond go silent and wait for things to settle rather
the scope of this guide; however, there are a than risk drawing more wrath. Closely
few basic guidelines that can help you avert a monitor the situation and modify your
social media crisis and mitigate the damage if approach as necessary.
one occurs.
• Rally supporters. Ask for support and tes-
• Be prepared. Every business should have a timonials from your advocates, customers,
social media policy in place with guidelines employees and industry partners, and ask
for employee conduct and the steps to take them to help spread positive information
in the event of a crisis, including communi- and clear up misinformation.
cation channels and responsibilities.
57
8 Building Communities and Advocacy
In this final section, we focus on how to strengthen reputation by preventing negative reviews,
generating positive reviews and building and engaging communities on social networking sites.
Managing
Expectations
58
Generating While the quality of reviews is most impor-
tant, volume is important as well. Travellers
2. Ask for Reviews
Generating 3. Be Remarkable
As discussed, the most effective way to
Temperature checks can help you identify
and resolve issues before the customer leaves.
Positive generate positive reviews is to consistently They also unearth minor nuisances that can
exceed expectations. Train and empower show up in reviews. For example, if a room
Reviews your staff to provide “remarkable service.” attendant asks the guest how everything is in
In the age of social media, the word remark- the room, the guest might mention a faulty
able takes on new meaning: it means “worth iron, a burned-out light bulb or a missing
remarking about.” room service menu. Temperature checks can
also present opportunities to turn a happy
People most remember negative experiences, guest into a delighted guest.
surprises (both good and bad) and emotions
(how you made them feel). Rather than 5. Build Reputation Across Channels
lavish gestures, it is often the little details TripAdvisor may be the most-visited travel
and special attention of staff that travellers site in the world, but it is not the only place
remember most. travellers go to seek opinions. As discussed
in Section 4, there are numerous review sites
Be careful not to impose. Be inquisitive and and third-party websites that carry reviews
intuitive, and tailor service accordingly. For and traveller recommendations. Do not
example, if a customer asks for a map, and put all your eggs in one basket; strive for
the employee provides a long and detailed positive reviews and high ratings on all
overview of local restaurants and attractions, popular review sites in your business sector.
that might be welcome for a leisure couple
visiting for the first time, but it may be off- 6. Do Not Cheat the System
putting for a busy corporate traveller. Inquire Offering incentives or rewards to guests for
about preferences and pay attention to verbal writing reviews, and asking employees to
and non-verbal cues. write reviews, is against the rules on review
sites. TripAdvisor and Yelp have posted
4. Perform Temperature Checks traveller alerts to listings of businesses
Despite our best intentions, problems still suspected of such activity, which can
occur. How you handle them can make the frighten off prospective guests.
difference between a positive or negative
review. Most businesses wait until departure Moreover, by falsely “stacking the deck” you
to ask guests how their visit was, but by then will set expectations you likely cannot meet,
it may be too late. which can result in a backlash of negative
reviews. You are better off focusing energy
As a preventative measure, train staff to on fixing problems and generating positive
perform temperature checks at various reviews organically.
points during the guest’s stay. Use open-
ended questions like, “How are you enjoying Also, note that encouraging guests to write
your visit so far?” and “Is there anything we reviews while on-site is not recommended;
can do to make things even more enjoyable?” numerous reviews from the same IP address
may trigger the review site’s fraud detectors.
60
Generating 7. Manage Threats from Potential Reviewers
What should you do if a customer threatens to write a bad review if you do not give in to their
Positive demands? Handle such situations with care. Take the threat seriously, but do not allow it to
cloud your judgment.
Reviews
Manage the situation as you would with any complaint. Do everything within reason to resolve
the matter. Few guests will follow through with the threat once calmer heads prevail, especially
if you conduct yourself calmly and professionally.
Afterward, record the details for future reference. If the guest does follow through, post a
response to respectfully give your side of the story. If the guest comes across as irrational or
abusive, readers are not likely to take him too seriously. If the claims are false and
damaging, dispute the review with the host site. TripAdvisor has a Review Blackmail form in
the Management Center that allows you to alert them of such situations as soon
as they happen.
Have clear guidelines in place so staff will know what to do in such a situation, and
have the confidence you will support their decisions.
61
8 Building Communities and Advocacy
Building
Communities
63
9 Summary
The many demands of managing your online reputation may seem overwhelming at first,
but it will get easier over time. The key is to invest time at the beginning to whip your online
positioning into shape. After that, it is a matter of keeping information up to date, building
and engaging your followings, and monitoring and responding to feedback.
You will not be able to do everything, so focus instead on the activities that produce the
greatest returns on objectives. As previously stated, it is better to manage a few channels
exceptionally well than do a mediocre job of a lot of channels.
By dedicating time to familiarizing yourself with popular tools and platforms, you will be
better positioned to adapt to changes over time.
Most importantly, you will be able to take advantage of the opportunities social media
provides to drive higher awareness, customer satisfaction and revenue.
8. Train and empower staff to resolve issues and recognize their successes.
64
10 Additional Resources
There are numerous online guides, how-to articles and news sites dedicated to
social media including:
• Tnooz www.tnooz.com
65
1 Appendix: Glossary
Alerts Googling
Notifications of mentions of your business Using an Internet search engine to find
or specified keywords on social channels information on a given word or phrase.
sent by email or text message. Typically refers to this activity on Google.
Algorithm Hashtag
In search marketing, a formula that A word or phrase preceded by a hash or
determines which content appears in search pound sign (#) and used to identify messages
results, and in what order, based on factors on a specific topic on social networking sites.
such as relevancy of the search term and the
importance of the website. Inbound Marketing
A marketing technique that focuses on being
Brand Website found by customers (rather than primarily
The official website created by a business finding them), by publishing helpful, relevant
rather than a third-party reseller like an content on websites, blogs and social media
online travel agency. channels.
66
OTA (Online Travel Agency) Sentiment Analysis
Short for online travel agency, an OTA is A process whereby reviews are analyzed for
a website where consumers can plan trips meaning and words and phrases are classified
and book flights, hotels and activities; as positive, negative or neutral.
companies pay a commission on bookings.
Social Media
Outbound Marketing A broad term that refers to web-based and
Traditional “interruptive” or “push” mobile applications used for social interaction
marketing techniques such as email blasts, and the exchange of user-generated content.
telemarketing and TV, radio and print
advertising. Social Media Administrator
The individual responsible for managing a
Paid Search Results company’s presence on social media channels.
Search engine results that are purchased by
an advertiser and marked by a shaded area Social Media Analytics Tools
or “Sponsored” label. Applications that track and organize
feedback and content on behalf of a business
Real-time Commentary and provide data to help measure perfor-
Social media commentary that concerns what mance and understand customer feedback.
the user is thinking or doing right now.
Social Media Management Tools
Remarkable Service Applications that allow users to administer
Service so unexpected, special or memorable multiple social networks from one dashboard.
customers feel compelled to remark about
it on review sites and social networks. Social Media Monitoring Tools
Applications that track, organize and score
Responsive Design feedback and commentary on review sites
A process by which a website is designed and social networking sites.
to read the user’s device, whether desktop,
smartphone or tablet, and display content Social Media Policy
formatted to fit the screen. A code of conduct to guide employee social
networking activity related to the company.
Review Site
A website on which users post reviews Strategy
about businesses, products or services, as The approach a business takes to achieve a
opposed to professional reviews from goal. It answers the question, “How will we
experts and the media. get there?”
Sanitizing Tactic
The frowned-upon practice of brands A tool used by a business to pursue an
deleting negative commentary from social objective associated with a strategy.
networking sites such as Facebook.
Temperature Check
SEO (Search Engine Optimization) Checking in with a customer at key points
Formatting a website’s content and design in during their visit to see how everything
order to increase visibility in relevant organic is going.
(unpaid) results in keyword searches on
search engines.
67
1 Appendix: Glossary
Trolls
People who make off-topic or offensive
comments online with the deliberate
intention of provoking a reaction.
User-generated Content
Content created and shared primarily
by consumers rather than marketers,
journalists, experts and other paid
professionals.
Vicious Circle
In reputation management, the process
by which a business does not act on
customer feedback, which could lead
to more negative reviews and frighten
prospective customers away.
Viral Content
Content – such as a video, photo or
tweet – that is shared broadly and rapidly
on the Internet and social networks.
Virtuous Circle
The process by which a business uses
customer feedback to guide improvements,
creating satisfied, loyal customers who
write positive reviews.
68
Destination British Columbia 12th Floor, 510 Burrard Street, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada V6C 3A8
69