Vidhi-MH Public-Libraries

Putting the
Public Back in
Public Libraries
Restructuring the
Governance of Public
Libraries in Maharashtra
February 2022
1
This report is
an independent,
non-commissioned
piece of work by
the Vidhi Centre for
Legal Policy,
an independent
think-tank doing
legal research to
help make
better laws.
About the Authors
Dr. Rahela Khorakiwala is Senior Resident Fellow and

Lead, Vidhi Maharashtra
Sakshi Pawar is Research Fellow, Vidhi Maharashtra
Pratik Dixit is Research Fellow, Vidhi Maharashtra
Acknowledgments
The authors are grateful to the anonymous peer

reviewers for peer reviewing this report.
The authors are also grateful to Sneha Yanappa,

Research Fellow, Vidhi Karnataka for going through an
earlier draft and for her research assistance on this
report.
For conversations that helped framing this report we

are thankful to Preedip Balaji, Dr. R S Balekar, Poonam
Bhonsle, Aarti Desai, Dr. Mohan Kherde, Mridula Koshy,
Wasimbarry Maner, Ahalya Momaya, Mr. Rameshwar
Pawar, Madhumita Rajan and Purnima Rao.
The authors are thankful to Vistasp Irani, Research

Fellow, Vidhi Maharashtra and Vidhi interns Shrishti
Nathani, Saloni Kumari and Stuti Srivastava for research
assistance on this report.
Any errors are the authors’ alone.

Contents 1 Executive Summary/
कार्य कारी सारां श
I II
5 Introduction 6 Development of Public
Libraries in Maharashtra
(Pre-Independence)
7 Library Committees and their

suggestions for public library
reforms in Maharashtra
III IV
8 The Public Library System 20 Library Authorities and
in Maharashtra Councils
8 Structure of the Maharashtra 20 Directorate of Libraries

Public Library Act, 1967 22 State Library Council and
9 Types of public libraries in District Library Committees
Maharashtra 27 Public Library Associations
11 Number of public libraries 28 Role of Panchayats
13 Establishment of public libraries
15 Definition of libraries or library
services in the MPLA
18 Other types of libraries
V VI
29 Funding 40 Public Library Employees
30 Funding of libraries as per the

MPLA
30 Contribution from State
Government
31 Local taxation as a source of
revenue
36 Other sources of revenue
9
VII VIII
43 Publicity and Books 47 Libraries as Community
Spaces
43 Publicity and marketing
45 Books 47 Public Libraries as Community
Centres
50 Forging partnerships with local
schools
IX X
52 Digitisation of Libraries 57 Accessibility of Public
and Access to Information Library Services to Persons
and Communication with Disabilities
Technology
57 Guidelines under the PWD Act
52 Initiatives taken by the central 59 Re-designing the Maharashtra
government Public Libraries Act, 1967
53 Initiatives taken by other states
55 Initiatives taken by the
Maharashtra government
XI
62 Conclusion 65 Annexe of the Maharashtra
Public Libraries Act, 1967
10
Executive Summary
Maharashtra has a rich history of public libraries run by the government as

well as charitable institutions. The public libraries in the state are regulated
under the Maharashtra Public Libraries Act, 1967 (“MPLA”). The working and
maintenance of the public library system in Maharashtra is overseen by the
Directorate of Libraries. The MPLA primarily deals with two types of public
libraries: (i) government libraries; and (ii) grant-in-aid libraries. The government
libraries are established at the state, divisional, and district level and are under
the complete control of the state government. The grant-in-aid libraries are run
by private, non-governmental and charitable institutions and given recognition
by the Directorate of Libraries in accordance with the criteria laid down in the
MPLA.
Due in part to the public library movement as well as the MPLA, Maha-
rashtra, with 12,229 libraries, has the highest number of public libraries in
India. However, public libraries in Maharashtra have been afflicted with various
issues since 1967. By analysing the present state of the public library system
in Maharashtra, we find that the MPLA requires updating to tackle the changing
landscape of public libraries in the state.
With this report, we aim to contribute to the limited body of literature doc-
umenting the working of the public library system in Maharashtra. We analyse
the government reports, state assembly debates, model library bills, and pub-
lic library legislations enacted by other states to observe that the public librar-
ies in Maharashtra are falling short of their goal of being vibrant community
spaces within society.
We discuss the key reasons for the failure of the MPLA to adequately pro-
mote establishment and maintenance of public libraries across the state. Addi-
tionally, through our consultations with government officials and civil society
organisations working in the public library space, we present certain recom-
mendations for the MPLA with an intent of reforming public library legislation in
Maharashtra and fostering further debate and deliberation on the importance
of the public library system in general. In this report we discuss the salient
aspects of the MPLA and other allied issues such as the role of library author-
ities, levy of membership fees, accessibility for the differently-abled, stocking
of books, and providing community spaces, among others.
This report starts by presenting the contextual background and history of
the public library system in Maharashtra. It then discusses the establishment
of public libraries under the MPLA to suggest that the government must take
on greater responsibility of establishing public libraries, especially in areas still
underserved by libraries. The next part outlines the key authorities envisaged
under the MPLA as well as their roles and responsibilities. It suggests decen-
tralisation of important financial and administrative powers and involvement
of Panchayats in the district library associations and councils. The report also
1
discusses the importance of funding for the operational efficiency of public
libraries and suggests that the government should revise grants devolved to
the states and also consider introducing cess as an alternate form of revenue
source for financing public libraries. Relevant here is the role that public library
employees play and how funding issues also affect staffing and thereby man-
agement and administration of public libraries.
The next part underscores the importance of adopting methods of pub-
licity and marketing by libraries to reach out to their communities. The report
emphasises the important role played by public libraries in the development
of their communities and also as a community recreational space. It also dis-
cusses the need for public libraries to adapt to the rapidly developing infor-
mation and communication technologies. The next part analyses the barriers
faced by persons with disabilities in accessing library services and suggests
amendments to the MPLA to foster universal access to knowledge and infor-
mation. Finally, we conclude that the MPLA must be amended to equip pub-
lic libraries to play a transformative role in providing educational and cultural
development within their communities.
2
कार्य कारी सारां श
सरकार तसे च से वाभावी संस्थां मार्फत चालवल्या जाणाऱ्या सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालयां चा समृ द्ध इतिहास
महाराष्ट्राला आहे . राज्यातील सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालयां चे नियमन महाराष्ट्र सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालय अधिनियम,
१९६७ ("MPLA") अन्वये केले जाते . महाराष्ट्रातील सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालय व्यवस्थे चे कामकाज व
दे खभाल ग्रंथालय संचालनालयामार्फत पर्य वे क्षीत केली जाते . MPLA प्रामु ख्याने दोन प्रकारच्या
सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालयां शी संबंधित आहे : (i) सरकारी ग्रंथालये ; आणि (ii) अनु दानित ग्रंथालये . शासकीय
ग्रंथालये राज्य, विभागीय व जिल्हा पातळीवर स्थापन झाले ली असू न ती राज्य सरकारच्या संपू र्ण
नियंत्रणाखाली असतात. अनु दानित ग्रंथालये खासगी, अशासकीय व से वाभावी संस्थां मार्फत चालविली
जातात व MPLA घालू न दिले ल्या निकषां नु सार ग्रंथालय संचालनालयाकडून मान्यता दिली जाते .
सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालय चळवळ, तसे च MPLA च्या काही प्रमाणामु ळे १२,२२९ ग्रंथालये असले ल्या
महाराष्ट्रात, भारतात सर्वाधिक सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालये आहे त. मात्र, महाराष्ट्रातील सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालये
१९६७ पासू न विविध प्रश्नांनी ग्रस्त आहे त. महाराष्ट्रातील सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालय व्यवस्थे च्या सद्य:स्थितीचे
विश्ले षण करून आपल्याला असे लक्षात ये ते की, राज्यातील सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालयां च्या बदलत्या
परिस्थितीचा सामना करण्यासाठी MPLA ला अद्यायावत करण्याची गरज आहे .
या अहवालाच्या माध्यमातू न महाराष्ट्रातील सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालय प्रणालीच्या कामकाजाचे
दस्तावे जीकरण करणाऱ्या साहित्याच्या मर्यादित संस्थे ला हातभार लावण्याचे आमचे उद्दिष्ट आहे .
महाराष्ट्रातील सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालये समाजातील चै तन्यशील समु दायाच्या जागा असण्याच्या त्यां च्या
ध्येयापे क्षा कमी पडत आहे त, हे लक्षात घे ण्यासाठी इतर राज्यांनी लागू केले ले सरकारी अहवाल, राज्य
विधानसभा वादविवाद, आदर्श ग्रंथालय विधे यके आणि सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालय कायदे यां चे आम्ही
विश्ले षण केले आहे .
राज्यभरातील सार्व जनिक ग्रं थालयां च्या स्थापने स आणि दे खभालीला पु रे से प्रोत्साहन
दे ण्यात MPLA अपयशी ठरल्याच्या मु ख्य कारणां वर आम्ही चर्चा करतो. याव्यतिरिक्त, सार्व जनिक
ग्रंथालयाच्या क्षेत्रात काम करणार् ‍या सरकारी अधिकारी आणि नागरी समाज संघटनां शी (CSO)
आमच्या सल्लामसलतीद्वारे , आम्ही MPLA साठी काही शिफारसी सादर करतो, महाराष्ट्रातील
सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालय कायद्यात सु धारणा करण्याच्या उद्दे शाने आणि सर्व साधारणपणे सार्व जनिक
ग्रंथालय प्रणालीच्या महत्वावर अधिक चर्चा आणि विचार-विनिमय करण्यास उत्तेजीत करण्याच्या
उद्दे शाने सादर करतो. या अहवालात आम्ही MPLA च्या महत्त्वकां क्षी पै लूं वर चर्चा करतो आणि इतर
संबंधित मु द्यां वर जसे की ग्रंथालय प्राधिकरणां ची भू मिका, सदस्यता शु ल्क आकारणे , दिव्यां गां साठी
सु लभता, पु स्तकां चा साठा करणे आणि समु दायाच्या जागा उपलब्ध करून दे णे .
महाराष्ट्रातील सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालय व्यवस्थे ची संदर्भा त्मक पार्श्वभू मी व इतिहास मां डून या
अहवालाची सु रुवात होते . त्यानंतर MPLA अंतर्ग त सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालयां च्या स्थापने बाबत चर्चा केली
जाते , ज्यात असे सु चवले जाते की सरकारने सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालये स्थापन करण्याची अधिक जबाबदारी
स्वीकारली पाहिजे , विशे षत: अजू नही ग्रंथालयां द्वारे से वा दिली जात नसले ल्या क्षेत्रां मध्ये . पु ढील भागात
MPLA अंतर्ग त कल्पना केले ल्या प्रमु ख प्राधिकरणां ची तसे च त्यां च्या भू मिका आणि जबाबदाऱ्यां ची
रूपरे षा दिली आहे . जे महत्त्वपू र्ण आर्थि क आणि प्रशासकीय अधिकारां चे विकेंद्रीकरण आणि जिल्हा
ग्रंथालय संघ आणि परिषदां मध्ये पंचायतीं चा सहभाग सू चित करते . या अहवालात सार्व जनिक
ग्रंथालयां च्या कामकाजाच्या कार्यक्षमते साठी निधीचे महत्त्व दे खील सां गण्यात आले आहे आणि असे
सु चविण्यात आले आहे की सरकारने राज्यांना हस्तां तरित केले ल्या अनु दानात सु धारणा करावी आणि
सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालयां ना वित्तपु रवठा करण्यासाठी महसू ल स्त्रोतां चा पर्याय म्हणू न उपकर लागू करण्याचा
विचार करावा. सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालयातील कर्म चारी काय भू मिका बजावतात आणि निधीच्या मु द्द्यां चा
कर्म चार् ‍यां वर कसा परिणाम होतो आणि त्याद्वारे सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालयां चे व्यवस्थापन आणि प्रशासन
कसे होते हे ये थे समर्प क आहे .
3
त्यां च्या समाजापर्यं त पोहोचण्यासाठी ग्रंथालयां नी प्रसिद्धी आणि विपणनाच्या पद्धतींचा अवलंब
करण्याचे महत्त्व पु ढील भागात अधोरे खित केले आहे . सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालयां नी त्यां च्या समु दायाच्या
विकासात आणि सामु दायिक करमणु कीची जागा म्हणू न बजावले ल्या महत्त्वपू र्ण भू मिकेवर या
अहवालात भर दे ण्यात आला आहे . वे गाने विकसित होत असले ल्या माहिती आणि संप्रे षण तंत्रज्ञानाशी
जु ळवू न घे ण्यासाठी सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालयां च्या आवश्यकते बद्दलही यात चर्चा केली गे ली आहे . पु ढील
भागात अपंग व्यक्तींना ग्रंथालय से वां मध्ये प्रवे श करण्यात ये णाऱ्या अडथळ्यां चे विश्लेषण केले आहे
आणि ज्ञान आणि माहितीच्या सार्वत्रिक प्रवे शास उत्ते जन दे ण्यासाठी MPLA मध्ये सु धारणा सु चविल्या
आहे त. शे वटी, आम्ही असा निष्कर्ष काढला आहे की MPLA मध्ये सु धारणा करणे आवश्यक आहे
जे णे करून सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालयां ना त्यां च्या समु दायां मध्ये शै क्षणिक आणि सां स्कृतिक विकास प्रदान
करण्यात परिवर्तनशील भू मिका बजावण्यासाठी सु सज्ज केले जाईल.
4
I Introduction
According to the International Federation of Library Associations and Institu-

tions (“IFLA”), an international body seeking to improve library services around
the world, a public library:
“is an organisation established, supported and funded by the community,
either through local, regional or national government or through some other
form of community organisation. It provides access to knowledge, information,
lifelong learning, and works of the imagination through a range of resources
and services and is equally available to all members of the community regard-
less of race, nationality, age, gender, religion, language, disability, economic
and employment status and educational attainment.”1
Maharashtra has a rich history of such public libraries. Since the 1800s,
many public libraries have been opened by governments and charitable insti-
tutions. The legislation to provide for the ‘establishment, maintenance, organ-
isation and development of public libraries’2 in Maharashtra called the ‘The
Maharashtra Public Libraries Act’ (“MPLA”) was enacted only in 1967. Maha-
rashtra was the fourth state in post-independent India to pass a public library
legislation. Currently nineteen states in India have enacted a public library
legislation.
Under the aegis of the MPLA, the Maharashtra public library system cur-
rently has 12229 public libraries.3 Recently, some initiatives have been taken
by the state government and local authorities to create village libraries,4 estab-
lish bigger libraries5 as well as mobile libraries in cities6 and inculcate reading
habits in children.7 However, public libraries in Maharashtra have been afflicted
with various issues since 1967 and the MPLA requires updating to tackle the
changing landscape of public libraries in the state.
This report analyses the present state of public library management
and development in Maharashtra and suggests amendments to the MPLA
accordingly.
1 Christie Koontz and Barbara Gubbin, ‘IFLA Public Library Service Guidelines’ (IFLA, 2010) <https://repository.ifla.org/bit-
stream/123456789/988/2/ifla-publication-series-147.pdf> accessed 9 February 2022.
2 Preamble, Maharashtra Public Libraries Act (1967).
3 Conversation with officials at the Directorate of Libraries dated 15 February 2022.The information provided by them was dated
31 March 2021.
4 Subhash Desai, ‘Maharashtra To Have A Village Of Books In Every District Soon’ (The New Indian Express, January 2022)
<https://www.newindianexpress.com/good-news/2022/jan/15/maharashtra-to-have-a-village-of-books-in-every-district-
soon-2407104.html> accessed 9 February 2022.
5 Nadeem Inamdar, ‘Ghole Road To House Mega-Library With At Least 50,000 Books And Digital Section With 40 Computers’
(Hindustan Times, December 2021) <https://www.hindustantimes.com/cities/pune-news/ghole-road-to-house-mega-library-
with-at-least-50-000-books-and-digital-section-with-40-computers-101639327923350.html> accessed 10 February 2022.
6 Chaitanya Marpakwar, ‘BMC: Mumbai: After No To Food Trucks, BMC To Distribute Mobile Libraries | Mumbai News - Times Of
India’ (The Times of India, November 2021) <https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/mumbai/mumbai-after-no-to-food-trucks-
bmc-to-distribute-mobile-libraries/articleshow/87725044.cms> accessed 9 February 2022.
7 Swati Gole, ‘Maharashtra Education Department Launches 100-Day Drive To Restore Reading Habit In Pupils | Pune News
- Times Of India’ (The Times of India, January 2022) <https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/pune/maharashtra-education-de-
partment-launches-100-day-drive-to-restore-reading-habit-in-pupils/articleshow/88677620.cms> accessed 9 February 2022.
5
II Development of Public Libraries in Maharashtra
(Pre-Independence)
One of the first steps towards developing public libraries in India was when the
Literary Society of Bombay was established on 26 November 1804. It created
its library in 1913. In 1947, this (which later became the Royal Asiatic S
ociety
of Bombay) was declared as the State Central Library. Thus, the first major
library of Maharashtra was founded.8 In 1994, the management of the library
was transferred to the state government.9
By the middle of the 19th century, major cities such as Bombay, Calcutta
and Madras had public libraries founded by the British. However, these libraries
were not ‘public’, as their use was confined to a thin upper layer of the society
and they were subscription based.10 An example of libraries established by the
British in the Bombay Presidency (reorganised into Maharashtra) is the Pune
City General Library by Judge Henry Braun of Bombay in 1848.11
To encourage the spread of education, rulers of princely states and other
noted personalities opened many regional libraries across Maharashtra. These
libraries were called ‘Vachan Mandir’, simply translating to the temple of words.
Some of these libraries are still surviving today as government libraries. One of
these is the Karveer Nagar Vachan Mandir, a 157 year old library located in Kol-
hapur and established by the Maharaja of Kolhapur’.12 Now, libraries in Maha-
rashtra are referred to as ‘Sarvajanik Granthalaya’ or ‘Sarvajanik V achanalaya’
(meaning public reading rooms).13
Prior to 1947, the Marathwada region of present-day Maharashtra was
governed by the Kolhapur Public Libraries Act, 1945. Post 1965, after the reor-
ganisation of states, which brought certain parts of Karnataka and Madhya
Pradesh into Maharashtra, the MPLA was passed to govern public libraries for
Maharashtra.
8 Satya Pandey, ‘Public Library System in the State of Maharashtra and Marketing and Promotion of Public Library Sevices: A
Futuristic Approach’(KLIBJLIS, 2018) <http://www.klibjlis.com/5.1.7.pdf> accessed 9 February 2022.
9 ‘Setup Of State Central Library | Government Of Maharashtra, Higher And Technical Education Department Directorate Of
Library, India|’ (Directorate of Libraries) <https://dol.maharashtra.gov.in/en/setup_of_state_central_library> accessed 9 February
2022.
10 Zahid Wani, ‘Development of Public Libraries in India’ (Library philosophy and practice e-journal, March 2008) <https://digital-
commons.unl.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1168&context=libphilprac> accessed 9 February 2022.
11 ibid.
12 Amita Rao, ‘Vachan Mandir - Oldest Native Libraries Of Maharashtra’ (The Indian Quest Digital , January 2018) <http://www.thein-
dianquest.com/blog-details/Vachan-Mandir---Oldest-Native-Libraries-of-Maharashtra> accessed 9 February 2022.
13 Pandey (n 8) 76.
6
Library Committees and their suggestions for public library reforms in
Maharashtra
The erstwhile Government of Bombay appointed a Committee in 1939 under

the chairmanship of Shri A. A. A. Fayzee to consider and report on library
development in the Bombay Presidency. The Fayzee Committee submitted its
report in 1940.14
It was the first report in British India that considered all aspects of a qual-
ity library and provided details about their organisation and management.15 It
put forth a scheme of developing libraries in the province in stages,16 with a
top-bottom approach where central and divisional libraries were to be estab-
lished first and then the district and taluka libraries. The Fayzee Committee
also recommended encouraging local initiatives by recognising private librar-
ies and giving them grants as long as the library ensured free and non-discrim-
inatory use of its services.17
Implementation of the recommendations of the Committee did not
begin until after independence. The Fayzee Committee was followed by the
Prabha Rao Committee (1973),18 the V S Page Committee (1977),19 the Patki
Committee (2001)20 and the Rathod Committee (2019).21 However, the state
government did not finalise these reports so their recommendations are not
publicly available.22
14 P.M Joshi and S.L Kapadi, ‘Report Of The Library Development Committee, Bombay, 1939 - 40’ (INDIAN CULTURE, 1941).
15 Pandey S.K. Sharma, Public Libraries in India (Ess Ess Publications 1985).
16 Ministry of Education, Government of India, ‘Report of Advisory Committee for Libraries’ (1959) <http://14.139.60.153/bit-
stream/123456789/8541/1/REPORT%20OF%20ADVISOR%20COMMITTEE%20FOR%20LIBRARIES-VB-CSL-IO02444.pdf>
accessed 1 January 2022.
17 ‘Public Library System In The State | Government Of Maharashtra, Higher And Technical Education Department Directorate Of
Library, India|’ (Directorate of Libraries) <https://dol.maharashtra.gov.in/en/public_library_system_in_the_state> accessed 9
February 2022.
18 Pogula Giri Kumar, Library Movement And Library Development In Maharashtra And Goa (2008).
19 Kolhapur Region Public Libraries Act (Shivaji University) <http://ir.unishivaji.ac.in:8080/jspui/bitstream/123456789/3588/8/08_
Chapter%203.pdf> accessed 9 February 2022.
20 Pogula Giri Kumar (n 18) 275.
21 Maharashtra Government Resolution dated 3 March 2019 <https://dol.maharashtra.gov.in/sites/default/files/GR%206%20
March%202019.pdf> accessed 9 February 2022.
22 RTI Applications filed for copies of these reports were not responded to with the required information.
7
III The Public Library System in Maharashtra
Structure of The Maharashtra Public Libraries Act, 1967
The government of Maharashtra enacted the MPLA in 1967 to bring consis-

tency to the public library system in the state. The preliminary chapter of the
MPLA lays out the definitions that are applicable in this context. Important
definitions, including the understanding of what is considered a book and what
is recognised as a public library are part of section 2. Chapter II of the MPLA
provides for the creation of a State Library Council to advice the state govern-
ment on all matters relating to the development of the public library system in
the state. The working and maintenance of the public library system under the
MPLA is overseen by the Department of Libraries as created through Chapter
III of the MPLA. The Director of Libraries is listed as the head of the Depart-
ment (section 8) and is responsible for maintaining, organising, and developing
public libraries in Maharashtra. This chapter also creates a State Library Ser-
vice through section 10.
Chapter IV governs the establishment and maintenance of public librar-
ies in the state. Section 11 establishes government libraries at the state and
divisional level and section 12 allows for the State Library Council to advice on
the functioning of public libraries. Chapter V envisions the creation of library
committees at the district level. The chapter details the constitution, adminis-
trative and other functions of these committees (sections 13 to 17).
Provisions for funding are covered from sections 18 to 22 (Chapter VI),
wherein the MPLA accounts for a library fund, contributions by the state gov-
ernment and recognises special grants by the state government also. The
penultimate chapter (sections 23 to 25) of the MPLA mandates reports and
inspections of public libraries in the state. The last section (section 26) grants
powers to the state government to make rules in order to implement the pur-
pose of the MPLA.
8
Types of public libraries in Maharashtra
Type of Public About the Public Library

Library
Government-run • Governed in accordance with the MPLA.

public libraries • Established and maintained entirely by the government (section 2(xi)(a) of the
MPLA).
• Open to the public for free but charge a nominal membership fee for borrowing
books.
• Managed by the Directorate of Libraries under the Higher and Technical
Education Department, Maharashtra (section 8 of the MPLA).
• Receive money through grants from the state government and the Raja Ram
Mohan Roy Library Foundation (section 18 of the MPLA ).
• Currently there are 43 government-run public libraries.23 These libraries include:
1 State Central Library, 6 divisional libraries, 35 district libraries and 1 reference
library (Dr. Babasheb Ambedkar Memorial Reference Library).24
• The State Central Library in Maharashtra is one of the libraries in the state
tasked with ensuring the safety of archaic manuscripts. It is also the depository
library of the state that is responsible for receiving copies of books under The
Delivery of Books and Newspapers (Public Libraries) Act, 1954 and Press and
Registration Act, 1867.
Government • These libraries fall under the ambit of the Higher and Technical Education
University Department, Maharashtra but the Directorate of Libraries and the MPLA do not
Libraries govern university libraries.
• However, some university libraries such as the University of Mumbai’s
Jawaharlal Nehru Library allow public access to view the library’s books.25
Grant-in-aid • Governed in accordance with the MPLA.

Libraries • These public libraries are run by social organisations or trusts. They are
recognised by the Directorate of Libraries and paid grants according to the
Maharashtra Public Libraries (Recognition for Grant-in-Aid and Building and
Equipment Grants) Rules, 1970 (“1970 Rules”) framed under the provisions of
the MPLA. Under the 1970 Rules, libraries can also apply for such recognition
by the Directorate (section 2(xi)(b) of the MPLA).
• Open to the public for free but charge a membership fee (as decided by their
management) for borrowing books.
31 March 2021.
24 Functions Of DOL | Government Of Maharashtra, Higher And Technical Education Department Directorate Of Library, India|’
(Directorate of Libraries) <https://dol.maharashtra.gov.in/en/functions_of_DOL> accessed 09 February 2022.
25 ‘Services And Facilities’ (University of Mumbai) <https://archive.mu.ac.in/service_library.html> accessed 9 February 2022.
9
• The libraries must be registered under the Public Trust Act, 1950 or Societies
Registration Act, 1860 (rule 4(1) of the 1970 Rules).
• These libraries are classified into A, B, C, and D categories according to their
book stock, periodicals and users, with A category libraries providing more
services and D category libraries the least.
• Currently there are 12149 grant-in-aid public libraries in the state.26
Research or • Governed in accordance with the MPLA.

Academic • These are libraries of research institutions that conduct research in Marathi
Libraries and libraries of literary institutions that promote Marathi literature. Through the
Maharashtra Libraries (Libraries of Research & Literary Institutions Recognition
for Grant-in-aid) Rules, 1974 they have been recognised by the state
government as public libraries under the MPLA (section 2(xi)(c) of the MPLA).
• Open to the public for free. These are considered as ‘reference libraries’ with
books that can be accessed by the public but not borrowed by them.
• Currently, there are 37 such libraries in the state.27
Public Libraries • These libraries do not come under the Directorate of Libraries and are not
run by governed by the MPLA.
Trusts/ Social • They are public libraries run by private organisations that receive the entirety
Organisations of their funding through trusts/donations/CSR activities and therefore do not
apply for government recognition and grants. For example, community libraries
set up in rural areas.28,29
▲ Information on public libraries in the state
In this report we will address reforms required for government-run pub-

lic libraries and government grant-in-aid libraries as mentioned under section
2(xi)(a) and (b) of the MPLA.30 Unless specified, ‘libraries’ or ‘public libraries’
mentioned in the report refer to both these types of libraries.
31 March 2021.
27 ibid.
28 Swarnami Mondal, ‘Himachal To Jharkhand, A Community Library Project Is Bridging Divides’ (Business Standard, November
2019) <https://www.business-standard.com/article/current-affairs/meet-the-group-trying-to-bridge-gaps-through-community-
libraries-119112300623_1.html> accessed 9 February 2022.
29 ‘Setting Up Libraries In Rural Maharashtra - Pratham Books’ (Pratham Books, 2018) <https://prathambooks.org/blog/set-
ting-up-libraries-in-rura/> accessed 9 February 2022.
30 Public Library System In The State (n 17).
10
Number of public libraries
As per the Raja Ram Mohan Roy Library Foundation (“RRRLF”), the nodal
agency of the central government for library development in India, Maharash-
tra has the highest number of public libraries in the country with 12191 of
India’s 46746 public libraries. Kerala and Karnataka have the second and third
highest number of libraries with 8415 and 6798 libraries respectively.31
However, information on the number of libraries in Maharashtra varies
across the RRRLF website32,33and Maharashtra’s Directorate of Libraries web-
site.34,35(A lack of uniformity in maintaining records on public libraries in the
country by the RRRLF and by respective state governments has been noted in
a policy review on the Indian public library system.)36
The total number of public libraries in Maharashtra, upon clarification by
the Directorate of Libraries, is as follows:
43 37
Government-run public libraries Research or academic libraries
12149 1222937
Grant-in-aid libraries Total
▲ Number of public libraries in Maharashtra
Inferring from multiple sources, it appears that Maharashtra encompasses

almost one-fourth of the total public libraries in the country.
31 (Raja Ram Mohan Roy Library Foundation) No. of public libraries in different States and Union Territories <http://rrrlf.nic.in/Docs/
pdf/PUBLIC_LIBRARY_DATA.pdf> accessed 9 February 2022.
32 ibid.
33 ‘Public Library Scenario in India’ (Raja Ram Mohan Roy Library Foundation) <http://rrrlf.nic.in/StaticPages_PubLibSystem/PubLib-
Scenario.aspx#:~:text=There%20are%2013%20zonal%20libraries,the%20matching%20assistant%20of%20RRRLF> accessed
9 February 2022.
34 ‘Functions Of DOL (n 24).
35 ‘Grant-In-Aid | Government Of Maharashtra, Higher And Technical Education Department Directorate Of Library, India|’ (Director-
ate of Libraries) <https://dol.maharashtra.gov.in/en/grant_in_aid> accessed 9 February 2022.
36 Preedip Balaji, M S Vinay, J S Mohan Raju, ‘A Policy Review Of Public Libraries In India’ (Indian Institute for Human Settlements,
March 2018) <https://iihs.co.in/knowledge-gateway/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/A-Policy-Review-of-Public-Libraries-in-India.
pdf> accessed 9 February 2022.
31 March 2021.
11
26.2%
Maharashtra
73.8%
Rest of India
▲ Percentage of public libraries in Maharashtra compared to the rest of the country

(using numbers provided by the Directorate of Libraries for public libraries in
Maharashtra and the latest information on public libraries in the country reflected on
the RRRLF website) 38,39
Moreover, grant-in-aid libraries comprise nearly the entirety of the public librar-
ies in the state.
99.3%
Grant-in-aid
0.3%
Research/Academic
0.4%
Government-run
▲ Percentage of the types of libraries in Maharashtra
In Maharashtra, the Aurangabad division records the highest number of grant-

in-aid libraries and Mumbai the least.
4050 1587 1902

Aurangabad Nasik Amravati
2969 1055 586

Pune Nagpur Mumbai
▲ Division wise break up of grant-in-aid libraries in Maharashtra40
38 No.of public libraries in different States and Union Territories (n 31).

39 Using RRRLF data for public libraries in Maharashtra instead of the data provided by the Directorate of Libraries results in a mere
difference of 0.1%.Additionally, the result reflected in the image is an approximate percentage considering that the data on the
final number of public libraries across the country may not be accurately reflected on the RRRLF website.
31 March 2021.
12
Mumbai 4.8%
Aurangabad 33.3%
Pune 24.2%
Amravati 15.7%
Nasik 13.1%
Nagpur 8.7%
▲ Percentage of grant-in-aid libraries in each division
Establishment of public libraries
According to IFLA, there should be one library for 3,000 people.41 While Maha-
rashtra appears to fare better than other states in India,42 it has a ratio of one
library to 9,191 people,43 which does not match the ratio provided by IFLA.
Even while comparing major cities, Bengaluru has lesser libraries but maintains
a better ratio of libraries to people than Mumbai.44
The MPLA stipulates that the state government may establish State Cen-
tral and divisional public libraries. Additionally, it creates a supervisory respon-
sibility on the state government for the establishment of village and taluka
libraries. The burden of ensuring their establishment lies instead with the local
authorities. The MPLA however, provides that the state may establish libraries
in those areas where local authorities have failed to provide library services to
the satisfaction of the public.
Section 11 of the MPLA:
(1) The State Government may establish a State Central Library for
the whole of the State, and a Divisional Library for every Division.
(2) Where in any local area, provision for library service to the public
is not made to the satisfaction of the Director by any local authority,
or any society registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860
or any trust registered under the Bombay Public Trusts Act, 1950
or where the State Government is of the opinion that any such local
authority, society or trust is not willing or is incompetent to provide
41 Library And Information Science (E-pathshala) <https://epgp.inflibnet.ac.in/epgpdata/uploads/epgp_content/S000021LI/

P000211/M002124/ET/145259796716-Etext.pdf> accessed 9 February 2022.
42 ‘In Madhya Pradesh, ‘There Is One Public Library Per 17 Lakh People’ (The Wire, August 2019) <https://thewire.in/government/in-
madhya-pradesh-there-is-one-public-library-per-17-lakh-people> accessed 9 February 2022.
43 Ratio taken using approximate numbers of 12,229:11,24,00,000 (libraries: number of people in Maharashtra as per Census 2011).
44 Siddhant Kalra and others, ‘Bengaluru’s Library System: Long Way To Go’ (Citizen Matters, Bengaluru, February 2020) <https://
bengaluru.citizenmatters.in/bengaluru-public-libraries-funding-cess-legislation-42532> accessed 9 February 2022.
13
library service to the public to the satisfaction of the Director in any
local area, the State Government may establish a library for the use of
the public in that area:
Provided that, no such library shall be established without giving an
opportunity to the local authority, society or, as the case may be, the
trust to show cause why the State Government should not establish a
library in the said local area.
Despite such a responsibility being placed on the state government,

some areas such as the district of Palghar created in 2014 do not have a dis-
trict library till date.45 Moreover, Maharashtra only has around 12000 libraries
despite having 42000 villages in the state.46
The Maharashtra legislative council was of the opinion that people’s
movements were the route through which public libraries could be created in
the smaller districts and villages of the state.47 To this end, the 1970 Rules
were enacted and they detail how the state government can provide grants
to the already established district and village libraries on the condition that
they stock a minimum number of books, magazines and periodicals and have a
minimum number of users. The 1970 Rules read with section 11(2) of the MPLA
form the backbone of the ‘Gaav tithe Granthalaya’ slogan by the Directorate
of Libraries which was created to show the government’s intention to provide
libraries in all 42000 villages in Maharashtra by establishing or recognising the
libraries already established there.48
In 2017, ‘Bhilar pustakancha gaav’, India’s first ‘village of books’ was

inaugurated in Maharashtra’s Bhilar village. Hay-on-Wye, a Welsh village
with several bookshops known for its annual literary festival was the
inspiration behind creating this village. The funding and management of
this village was undertaken by the Marathi Language Department (not
the Directorate of Libraries). The Department commissioned artists
to paint several homes and community spaces around the village and
provided many books to these places to create various well-stocked
and decorated libraries.49 The project now receives regular funding for
its maintenance through a government scheme.50
45 ‘Office Of The District Library Officer | Government Of Maharashtra, Higher And Technical Education Department Directorate
Of Library, India|’ (Directorate of Libraries) <https://dol.maharashtra.gov.in/en/Office_the_district_library_officer> accessed 9
February 2022.
46 राज्य सरकारकडूनच ‘गाव तिथे ग्रंथालय’ योजना बासनात’ (Lokmat, October 2017) <https://www.lokmat.com/kolhapur/village-there-library-
scheme-basna/?utm_source=Lokmat.com&utm_medium=InfiniteArticle-Desktop> accessed 9 February 2022.
47 Sri R.J. Mantri, Maharashtra Legislative Council Debate (1967) 602.
48 राज्य सरकारकडूनच ‘गाव तिथे ग्रंथालय’ योजना बासनात’ (n 46).
49 Panchali Dey, ‘Bhilar, India’s First ‘Book Village’, Welcomes You To Test Your Reading Skills’ (Times of India Travel, June 2018)
<https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/travel/destinations/bhilar-indias-first-book-village-welcomes-you-to-test-your-reading-
skills/as64734558.cms> accessed 9 February 2022.
50 Swatee Kher, ‘‘Village Of Books’ Project In The Sahyadris Now Government Scheme | Pune News - Times Of India’ (The Times of
India, September 2019) <https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/pune/village-of-books-project-in-the-sahyadris-now-a-govt-
scheme/articleshow/70967726.cms> accessed 9 February 2022.
14
Despite initiatives such as ‘Gaav tithe Granthalaya’ and ‘Bhilar p
ustakancha
gaav’, the number of libraries in Maharashtra has been stagnating since 2012-
2013. Around 2012, a survey was conducted by the state’s revenue depart-
ment to investigate the functioning of around 12000 libraries that were listed
under the MPLA then. Since serious errors were found in nearly 600 libraries
(in some cases no libraries were there and only a board was placed), recogni-
tion and provision of grants for new libraries was halted. Since then, the public
library system has not been able to penetrate many parts of the state.51
Currently, as a consequence of the absence of government initiatives and
a lack of political will to ensure that libraries are established throughout the
state, many social organisations or philanthropists are taking up the role of
establishing libraries across villages in Maharashtra.52
suggestions Recognise the responsibility placed on the state government under

section 11 of the MPLA and establish or recognise more libraries
across the state.
Create library villages in Maharashtra using the example of the

‘Bhilar pustakancha gaanv’ project, with a focus on community
collaboration.
Ensure that data on the number and types of libraries is updated

and easily available on the Directorate of Libraries website and
audits are conducted every few years to keep a track of these
libraries.
Definition of libraries or library services in the MPLA
While establishing sufficient libraries is a duty that the state government must
strive to accomplish, the current provisions and services offered by the gov-
ernment-run libraries and grant-in-aid libraries must also be considered. In the
past few years, newspapers have regularly published articles on the lack of
51 राज्य सरकारकडूनच ‘गाव तिथे ग्रंथालय’ योजना बासनात’ (n 46).

52 ‘Elderly Man In Maharashtra On Mission To Inculcate Reading Habit Among People Through His ‘Library On Bicycle’ (Tribune India
News Service, January 2022) <https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/schools/elderly-man-in-maharashtra-on-mission-to-incul-
cate-reading-habit-among-people-through-his-library-on-bicycle-362903> accessed 9 February 2022.
15
adequate provisions available to existing libraries for buying books,53 54 main-
taining archaic documents55,56 and improving infrastructure.57 As a conse-
quence, the community’s expectations from public libraries have not been met.
IFLA notes that services and functions of libraries should be mentioned
either by the state government, local bodies or by the libraries themselves.58
Some library legislations in India define or list ‘library services’59 or different
kinds of services such as ‘extension service’60 or ‘book services’61 and ‘refer-
ence services’.62 Such delineation then places the responsibility on the gov-
ernment to provide adequate grants or supervise libraries to ensure that these
services are met. These services range from inculcating reading habits, pro-
moting production of literature, ensuring books for differently abled people,
children, senior citizens and creating libraries as a community space or as a
place for recreation.
Some legislations also specify the functions of different levels of libraries
such as the State Central, district and village libraries.63 This allows additional
responsibilities and more stringent standards to be placed on State Central
and divisional libraries which can then act as models for the remaining libraries
in the state.
The MPLA provides which libraries would be ‘public libraries’ governed
by the Act but does not provide a definition of ‘library’ or ‘library service’ or an
indicative list of library services. It also does not make it compulsory for the
government to ensure that such library services are provided. This creates a
loophole in the legislation regarding the service or functions that the public is
entitled to expect from public libraries. Such an absence of standards or lack
of emphasis on the development of a library movement was also noted by a
member of the opposition during the 1967 Maharashtra assembly debates
who mentioned that the MPLA merely provided a bureaucratic set-up of the
public library management system in the state.64
53 Vitthal Copper, ‘राज्यातील ग्रंथालय मोजताहे त शे वटची घटका’ (eSakal - Marathi Newspaper, March 2020) <https://www.esakal.com/maha-
rashtra/library-issue-state-267440> accessed 9 February 2022.
54 ‘मुं बई मराठी ग्रंथसंग्रहालय दात्यां च्या प्रतीक्षे त’ (Loksatta, March 2021) <https://www.loksatta.com/mumbai/mumbai-marathi-library-await-
ing-for-donor-dd-70-2412334/> accessed 9 February 2022.
55 Sanket Jain, ‘In The Digital Age, A 120-Year-Old Library In Rural Maharashtra Shows That Books Aren’T Dead’ (Scroll, July 2018)
<https://scroll.in/magazine/881275/in-the-digital-age-a-120-year-old-library-in-rural-maharashtra-shows-that-books-arent-
dead> accessed 9 February 2022.
56 Sudhir Suryavanshi, ‘Maharashtra Floods Damage Prized Collection At 156-Year-Old Library’ (The New Indian Express, August
2021). <https://www.newindianexpress.com/nation/2021/aug/02/maharashtra-floods-damage-prized-collection-at-156-year-
old-library-2338862.html> accessed 9 February 2022.
58 IFLA (n 1) 24.
59 Goa Public Libraries Act 1993, s 3; Gujarat Public Libraries Act 2001, s 2(j); Arunachal Pradesh Public Libraries Act 2009, s 3;
Mizoram Public Libraries Act 1993, s 14; Rajasthan Public Libraries Act 2006, s 2(a),2(i), 2(j) and 2(k).
60 Gujarat Public Libraries Act 2001, s 2(h)
61 Goa Public Libraries Act 1993, s 2(e).
62 Goa Public Libraries Act 1993,s 2(i).
63 Kerala Public Libraries Act 1989, s 8, s 17 and s 25; Chattisgarh Public Libraries Act 2008, ss 9-11; Arunachal Pradesh Public
Libraries Act 2009, s 14(3) and s 15(2); Uttar Pradesh Public Libraries Act 2006, ss 8-11; Goa Public Libraries Act 1993, s 9 and
s12.
64 Sri B.K. Boman-Behram, Maharashtra Legislative Assembly Debate (1967) 176.
16
Section 2(xi):
“public library” means,—

(a) a library established and maintained by the State Government for
the use of the public ;
(b) a library recognised by the Director for the purposes of grant-in-
aid from the Library Fund, and
(c) any other library which the State Government by notification in The
Official Gazette declares it to be a public library for the purposes of
this Act.
Moreover, while section 12 of the MPLA read with section 26 (2)(vii) allows
the state to create rules that delineate services and functions of libraries, the
same have only been provided for grant-in-aid libraries under the 1970 Rules.
These functions are also very limited and only require the libraries to ensure
that they are open to the public for free without discrimination, are well lit, ven-
tilated and furnished.65 Additional library services that are briefly mentioned
are the conduction of cultural programs in a year by grant-in-aid libraries66
and the requirement for district and taluka libraries to promote reading habits
within their area.67
suggestions Based on legislation from other states or on the guidelines pro-

vided by IFLA, create a baseline of uniform standards for all public
libraries and types of library services. These can be provided in the
MPLA or through rules created under section 26(2)(vii) of the MPLA.
From this baseline, create additional standards for the State Cen-
tral and divisional libraries to ensure that they act as model libraries
for the remaining public libraries in the state.
Amend section 11 of the MPLA to ensure that the government is

responsible for not just establishing libraries but also providing
library services.
Other types of libraries
Other state legislations also provide for prison libraries,68 children libraries,69
hospital libraries, school libraries and mobile libraries.70 These do not find men-
tion within the MPLA. Although a speaker in the legislative assembly debate
65 Rule 4 of the 1970 Rules.

66 Chapter III of the 1970 Rules.
68 Goa Public Libraries Act 1993, s 3(j).
69 Kerala Public Libraries Act 1989, s 8(f)(g) and s 47; Goa Public Libraries Act 1993, s 3(k).
70 Goa Public Libraries Act 1993, s 3(k).
17
had mentioned that the MPLA should emphasise on the development of chil-
dren’s libraries, his recommendation was not incorporated.71 Chapter XIV of
the Model Prison Manual, 2016 also provides the types of services that need
to be offered in prison libraries, but such provisions or their reference does not
find mention in the MPLA.72
The 1970 Rules as well only briefly mention providing grants to ‘circulating
libraries’.
Rule 15 of 1970 Rules:
Circulating Library. - A public library shall not be classified as a “Cir-

culating Library” unless-
(1) the public library makes available library service in one or more
places in a locality where a stationery library service is not available;
(2) the library sends sets of books to different places and exchanges
them regularly or takes such sets of books and issues them to the
public in different locality : Provided that the circulating library shall
be either an independent library or a part of a library falling under “ A”
or “ B “ Class library.
While no circulating libraries are currently being provided money under

the 1970 Rules,73 the government has been providing a ‘4K scheme’ in the past
few years which includes creating mobile libraries for rural areas in Maharash-
tra. 74 However, this scheme has been paused due to the pandemic—at a time
when mobile libraries are especially important because people cannot access
or travel to avail library services. Mobile library services play a crucial role in
bringing books to readers during the pandemic.75,76 Therefore, there is a need
to encourage the creation of such libraries through the MPLA.
It is important to note however that mobile libraries must only be intro-
duced to supplement physical libraries wherever possible to ensure the con-
tinuity of mobile services during circumstances such as the pandemic or to
serve people living in the remotest parts of the state. They should not serve
as replacements for physical libraries which are essential.
71 Sri Hanshu Advani, Maharashtra Legislative Assembly Debate (1967) 168-170.

72 Ministry of Home Affairs Delhi, Government of India (2016) <https://www.mha.gov.in/sites/default/files/PrisonManual2016.pdf>
accessed 9 January 2022.
31 March 2021.
74 Conversation with officials at the Directorate of Libraries dated 2 November 2021.
75 ‘Mobile Libraries On Camel Carts Providing Education To Children In Remote Villages Of Rajasthan’ (ANI News, September 2021)
<https://www.aninews.in/news/national/general-news/mobile-libraries-on-camel-carts-providing-education-to-children-in-re-
mote-villages-of-rajasthan20210903014645/> accessed 9 February 2022.
76 ‘Taking Learning To Children’s Doorsteps: Our Mobile Library In Bihar Reaches 6400 Children - Save The Children’ (Save the
Children, July 2021) <https://www.savethechildren.in/news/our-mobile-library-ensures-learning-continuity-for-6400-children-
in-32-villages-across-rural-bihar/> accessed 9 February 2022.
18
Moreover, Karnataka’s Department of Public Libraries has established
127 libraries for nomads and 100 libraries in slums areas.77 Such libraries,
that cater to specific communities, people and areas, can also be created for
Maharashtra.
suggestion Amend the MPLA to include a section on the creation of different

forms of libraries such as nomad libraries, WhatsApp libraries,
prison libraries, hospital libraries, slum libraries and children librar-
ies. The definition should be expandable to include all forms of
libraries that might be viable in the future.
77 ‘About Department’ (Department of Public Libraries Karnataka) <https://dpl.karnataka.gov.in/info-1/About+Department/en>

accessed 17 February 2022.
19
IV Library Authorities and Councils
The ground implementation of the MPLA and its rules in the state shows that
there is a lack of clarity on who is responsible for establishing new libraries,
monitoring pre-existing libraries and guiding libraries. This was apparent when
the COVID-19 pandemic and its lockdown affected the state.78
The absence of libraries and library services and the lack of supervision
and guidance for libraries can be remedied by strengthening the administra-
tion of libraries in the state, easing unnecessary restrictions and empowering
them with unambiguous responsibilities stipulated within the MPLA or its rules.
Directorate of Libraries
In 1959, the Advisory Committee under the chairmanship of K. P. Sinha sug-

gested the creation of a separate independent department for libraries in India
considering the special skills required for managing libraries (“1959 Advisory
Committee Report”).79 Its recommendations have been accepted by many
states, including Maharashtra.
The MPLA has established a Directorate of Libraries headed by an
independent Director of Libraries, who is an ex-officio member of the
State Library Council (“SLC”)and serves as its Secretary. 80 The Direc-
torate is under the administrative control of the Higher and Technical
Education Department of the government of Maharashtra. As per the pro-
visions of the MPLA, the Directorate is responsible for maintaining, organ-
ising, and developing the public libraries in the state.81 In addition, the
Directorate has divisional and district library offices to oversee and regulate
public library services at the divisional and district level. Presently, the Direc-
torate has the following 50 library offices under its direct administration:
78 Shirish Khare, ‘Public Libraries In Maharashtra Face Crisis During Covid Pandemic| Countercurrents’ (Countercurrents, Septem-
ber 2021) <https://countercurrents.org/2021/09/public-libraries-in-maharashtra-face-crisis-during-covid-pandemic/> ac-
cessed 9 February 2022.
79 1959 Advisory Committee Report (n 16) 36.
80 MPLA, s 8.
81 MPLA, s 9.
20
1 6 35
Headquarters Government Government
of the Divisional Libraries District Libraries
Directorate,
Mumbai
1 1 6 50
State Central Dr. Babasaheb Assistant Total
Library Ambedkar Memorial Director offices
Reference Library
▲ Data provided by the Directorate of Libraries on the number of offices in the

state82
The Directorate is entrusted with the responsibility of developing and

maintaining the public library system in Maharashtra.83 The most important
responsibility of the Directorate under the scheme of the MPLA is granting
recognition to public libraries and disbursing grants to them.84
The MPLA created a separate Directorate with the aim of minimising the
political interference in the development of the public library system in the
state.85 The Directorate provides a pivotal function of coordinating between
the state government and the public libraries in the state. Additionally, the
Directorate is also tasked with promoting establishment of public libraries,
maintaining accounts of library funds, annually publishing a bibliography of all
books published in the state, preparing and submitting an annual report on
working of public libraries to the state government, among others.
However, the requirement to regularly supervise, inspect and survey
libraries is not clearly entrusted to the Director under the MPLA. It can only be
said to be implied by the following provisions:
Section 9(2) of the MPLA:
In particular, and without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing

provision, the Director shall-
(a) be responsible for the planning, maintenance, organisation and
development of public libraries and public library system;
(b) superintend and direct all matters relating to public libraries;
…
(e) maintain accounts of the Library Fund and ensure its proper
utilisation:
82 ‘Functions Of DOL (n 24).

83 MPLA, s 9.
84 ibid.
85 Sri M. D. Chaudhary, Maharashtra Legislative Council Debate (27 July 1967) 613-614.
21
…
(g) submit to the State Government every year, a report on the work-
ing of public libraries under this Act;
…
The Director or any person authorised by him in this behalf shall have
power to inspect any public library or any institution attached thereto
for the purpose of satisfying himself that the provisions of this Act
and the rules made thereunder are carried out.
Even the 1970 Rules do not impose a requirement on the district and
taluka libraries to supervise the libraries within their jurisdiction. It merely cre-
ates a generic responsibility on their part to ‘guide’ these libraries.86 Addition-
ally, Chapter VI of the 1970 Rules create a requirement on the management
of the grant-in-aid libraries to ensure that they maintain proper records in the
event that they are inspected. However, a specific requirement for inspecting
these libraries is not provided in the MPLA or any of its rules.87 From our con-
versations in the office of the Directorate these checks do occur88 but as per
our reading of the MPLA and the 1970 Rules they are not organised or man-
dated in a structured form.
suggestion Amend section 9 of the MPLA and Chapter VI of the 1970 Rules
to place a clear responsibility on the Director and district libraries
respectively to supervise and ensure inspection of all public librar-
ies in the state and regularly conduct audits and surveys.
State Library Council and District Library Committees
Considering the role of libraries as a local community service, the planning and
design of the public library system needs to take into account local interests.
This implies devolution of some authority to the local governments.
Presently, the MPLA adopts a two-tiered library governance structure
consisting of the State Library Council (“SLC”) and District Library Committees
(“DLCs”). The Maharashtra Public Libraries, State Library Council and District
Library Committees (Transaction of Business Procedure) Rules, 1973 (“1973
Rules”) prescribes the functions of the SLC and DLCs and the manner in which
they will transact their respective business as well.
The SLC is entrusted with advising the state government in the following
matters:

87 Chapter VI of the 1970 Rules.
88 Conversation with officials at the Directorate of Libraries dated 15 February 2022.
22
Rule 9 of the 1973 Rules:
a) functions of the Central Library, a Divisional Library and other pub-

lic libraries in the state;
b) employment of trained professional staff of different grades for
public libraries in the state;
c) publication of annual bibliography of all the books published in the
state,
d) promotion of standards for library buildings, fittings and furniture
for library techniques;
e) planning organisation and development of libraries for adults, chil-
dren, and handicapped,
f) preservation of old and rare books and manuscript and other
documents;
g) training of candidates in Library Science.
Its structure under the MPLA is envisioned as an all-inclusive body con-

sisting of state ministers, people’s representatives, state officers as well as
people related to the field of library services.89 The SLC is chaired by the Min-
ister for Higher and Technical Education and comprises around 30 members.
While abiding with the requirements prescribed under the MPLA, the state
government and Directorate of Libraries decide on the members that form
part of the SLC. Both, the SLC and DLCs have a term of three years.90
During the Maharashtra assembly debates, Mr. B K Boman Behram had
described the SLC as a bureaucratic body because of its size and undue rep-
resentation of elected representatives.91 This statement is partially supported
by the current position of the SLC in the public library system of the state.
The Maharashtra government has not been able to constitute an SLC
since 2009.92 As a body dependent on elected representatives for 50 percent
of its composition, the membership of the SLC keeps changing due to numer-
ous elections in the state that take place round the year. Moreover, even by the
time the SLC is constituted by the Directorate, some of the members listed
change as a consequence of these elections.93 The problem created by these
changes is further exacerbated by the fact that the quorum of the SLC as per
the MPLA is about ten members without which no decision can be made.94 Due
to these issues, since the formation of the last SLC in 2006, no new SLC has
been formed.
The lack of a functional SLC has significantly hampered the overall func-
tioning of the public library system in Maharashtra, particularly with regards
to upgradation of the library infrastructure, provision of adequate grants to
89 MPLA, s 3.
90 MPLA, s 5(1) and 14(1).
91 Shri B. K. Boman Behram, Maharashtra Legislative Assembly Debate (14 November 1967) 176-177.
92 Namita Dhuri, ‘‘राज्य ग्रंथालय परिषदे ’अभावी ग्रंथालयां चे प्रश्न प्रलंबित’ (Loksatta, February 2021) <https://www.loksatta.com/mumbai/library-
questions-pending-due-to-lack-of-state-library-council-abn-97-2397685/> accessed 9 February 2022.
93 Conversation with officials at the Directorate of Libraries dated 15 February 2022.
94 MPLA, s 7(3).
23
libraries, and improvement of remuneration paid to various employees and
staff and overall guidance as to the maintenance and functioning of public
libraries. This situation was exacerbated with the onset of the COVID-19 pan-
demic as it was an unprecedented situation for libraries and with no protocol
available in literature, legislations or at the central government level, libraries
were left to deal with this health emergency without guidance or assistance.95
In comparison, the DLCs consist of local people’s representatives and
people knowledgeable in the field of library services.96 The DLCs are headed by
the Chairman of the Education Committee of the Zilla Parishad and comprise a
maximum of ten members. Thus, to a large extent the composition of DLCs is
concise and effectively represents the interests of the public libraries. During
the various lockdowns, DLCs could have been empowered to decide how best
public libraries can serve their communities during public emergencies. As
COVID-19 spread at different rates across the state, each district could have
made an independent assessment as to the role the public library could have
played at this time. Along with empowering DLCs, the MPLA and/or municipal
corporation legislations should account for the role of public libraries during
health or other emergencies.
The 1973 Rules do not assign any specific functions and responsibilities
to the DLCs except those already specified in section 16 of the MPLA. The
section primarily enlists the following two functions for the DLCs:
It shall be the function of a Committee,-

(i) to advise the’ State Government on all matters relating to develop-
ment of library service in the district on proper lines;
(ii) to ensure that the prescribed function of the public libraries are
performed by them satisfactorily
This shows that the structure of public library services in Maharashtra is

largely centralised with a majority of powers and responsibilities vested with
the SLC. Perforce, the onus is entirely on the SLC to ensure smooth function-
ing of the public library system in India.
The empowerment of DLCs under the MPLA can be compared to local
library authorities in other states:
95 ‘ग्रंथालयां ची टाळेबंदी वाचनवे ड्यांना साहवे ना’ (Maharashtra Times, June 2020) <https://maharashtratimes.com/maharashtra/mum-
bai-news/due-to-coronavirus-libraries-are-lockdown/articleshow/76497521.cms> accessed 9 February 2020.
96 MPLA, s 13.
24
Tamil Nadu “section 9: Powers of Library Authorities.—A Local Library Authority may—
Public Libraries (a) provide suitable lands and buildings for public libraries and also the furniture,
Act, 1948 fittings, materials and conveniences requisite therefor;
(b) stock such libraries with books, periodicals, newspapers, maps, works and
specimens of art and science, lantern slides, cinema reels and any other thing
suitable for their purpose;
(c) employ from time to time such staff as it considers necessary, for such libraries;
(d) with the previous sanction of the Government, close or discontinue any public
library or change the site thereof;
(e) accept, with the previous sanction of the Director or the Government, any
gift of books, or, with the previous sanction of the Government, any other gift or
endowment for any purpose connected with its activities;
(f) provide for lectures and the holding of classes; and
(g) in general, do everything necessary to carry out the provisions of this Act.”
Kerala Public “section 17: (1) Save as otherwise provided in this Act, every District Library Council
Libraries Act, shall have power-
1989 (a) to elect members to the State Library Council to the extent of one for each taluk
in the district;
(b) to establish new libraries within its jurisdiction with the previous sanction of the
State Library Council;
(c) to supervise, co-ordinate and control the library service under its jurisdiction
in the district and to promote co-operation between libraries and cultural and
educational institutions in the country;
(d) to provide library service and mobile library service to the persons residing in the
district;
(e) to provide suitable lands and buildings for public libraries and furniture, fittings,
equipment and other conveniences necessary for the purpose;
(f) to provide such libraries with books, periodicals, newspapers, maps, radios,
manuscripts, works and specimens of art and science, lantern slides, films, video
films; cinema projectors, recorders, cassettes, television sets, charts, tape recorders,
video cassette players, video cassette recorders and the like;
(g) to shift, reorganise, or close or amalgamate any public library established or
maintained or run directly by the District Library Council;
(h) to appoint and control such officers and servants as may be necessary for the
efficient performance of its duties and functions under this Act and the rules made
thereunder;
(i) to accept any endowment or gift for any purpose connected with its activities;
(j) to provide for lectures, seminars, symposia, conferences and conduct study
classes to strengthen the functioning of the Libraries and conduct other activities as
may be conducive to the carrying out of the purposes of this Act
(k) with the sanction of the State Library Council to do any other thing that may be
conducive to the furtherance of the purposes of this Act; and
(l) to exercise such other powers and perform such other duties as may be conferred
or imposed on it by or under this Act or the rules made thereunder.”;
▲ Duties provided to local library authorities in some other states in India
25
Therefore there is a need to shift the burden of responsibilities vested
with the SLC onto the DLC, which till date does not have any specific functions
provided under the MPLA or the 1973 Rules.
suggestions The composition of the SLC should be made concise by reducing

the number of members to optimal. Depending on the revised num-
ber of members, the quorum of the SLC should be reduced as well.
Amend section 5(1) and 14(1) of the MPLA to increase the term
of the SLC and DLCs respectively, from three years to at least five
years to ensure greater continuity.
Amend the MPLA to bestow the character of a body corporate on

the SLC and DLCs. Presently, many states including Kerala and
Tamil Nadu in their respective legislations have bestowed body
corporate status on the state and district library authorities.97 This
ensures that the bodies do not dissolve while waiting for the state
government or Directorate to appoint new members for them.
Amend the 1973 Rules to entrust the duty of establishing public

libraries with the DLCs. This will ensure that the government does
not need to depend upon non-governmental organisations to set
up public libraries in rural areas. Instead, the DLCs should provide
guidance to village Panchayats currently not being served by public
libraries to establish new public libraries. Such decentralisation will
require empowering the DLCs, both financially and administratively.
Provisions of the Tamil Nadu and Kerala public library legislations
can serve as an example for the same.
Provide for the role of public libraries during health or other emer-
gencies, natural disasters and similar situations in the MPLA and/or
its rules.
97 Tamil Nadu Public Libraries Act, 1948, s 6; Kerala Public Libraries Act, 1989, s 3 and s 10.
26
Public Library Associations
Aside from the SLC and DLCs, the MPLA also envisages another body called
Public Library Associations (“PLAs”). PLAs are different from the SLC and DLCs
which include mostly elected representatives and government officials in the
state or district. Instead, PLAs include librarians, library workers and persons
interested in library development at the local level.
In this regard, the government has formulated the Maharashtra Public
Library Association (Recognition of Grant-in-aid) Rules, 1971 (“1971 Rules”).
These Rules provide for recognition of PLAs at state (State Library Association
(“SLA”)), division (Divisional Library Association (“DSLA”)), and district (District
Library Association (“DLA”)) levels.
As the name suggests, a DLA is an association of public libraries in each
district.98 In order to be constituted, the DLA requires a minimum of hundred
members, including a minimum of 25 members representing libraries, schools
and other cultural institutions.99 The DSLA then, is an association formed by
members of the recognised DLAs100 and accordingly, the SLA is made up of
members of the DSLAs.101
The duties of DLAs include promoting development of library services in
the district, providing technical guidance to libraries, establishing new public
libraries, coordinating the activities of the public libraries, and cooperating with
other DLAs in the state.102 The duties of DSLAs and SLA have been formulated
on similar lines to include promotion of library development at division and
state levels, helping DLAs by giving technical guidance, promotion of research
and publishing public periodicals on library science.103
It is interesting to note that under the MPLA, the responsibility of estab-
lishing new public libraries is entrusted exclusively on the DLAs. It is suggested
that such onus on DLAs is attuned with the basic philosophy of the public
libraries movement in Maharashtra, which is based on public libraries estab-
lished by non-governmental organisations.104 However, the reality suggests
that the DLAs can do very little in terms of establishing new public libraries if
they do not get the necessary financial support from the state government.105
The 1971 Rules provide for payment of an annual maintenance grant to
DLAs on items of admissible expenditure such as allowances of staff, travelling
expenditure, rent and taxes, expenditure on furniture, equipment, and books,
among others.106 Incidentally, the said Rules do not provide for payment of
98 Rule 2(d) of the 1971 Rules.

100 Rule 2(d-A) of the 1971 Rules.
101 Rule 2(g) of the 1971 Rules.
103 Rule 12-A and Rule 13 of the 1971 Rules.
104 ‘Library Association | Government Of Maharashtra, Higher And Technical Education Department Directorate Of Library, India|’
(Directorate of Libraries) <https://dol.maharashtra.gov.in/en/library_association> accessed 9 February 2022.
105 Milind Tambe, ‘ग्रंथालय अनु दानाला सरकारची कात्री! कर्म चाऱ्यां मध्ये संताप; व्यवस्थापन कोलमडण्याची भीती’ (eSakal - Marathi Newspaper, No-
vember 2020) <https://www.esakal.com/mumbai/library-grants-have-been-reduced-state-government-379318> accessed 9
February 2022.
106 Schedule II of the 1971 Rules.
27
grants for acquisition of land or construction of library buildings, expenditures
which are more expensive and essential for the establishment of a public
library.
Since SLA, DSLAs, and DLAs are representative bodies of public libraries
in Maharashtra, their focus should remain largely on issues and problems of
existing public libraries in the state rather than establishing new ones. That
responsibility should be entrusted to the state government, the SLC and DLCs.
suggestion Responsibilities such as establishing libraries should be entrusted

to the state government, SLCs and DLCs and the responsibility of
the DLAs should be limited to ensuring the promotion of and guid-
ance of libraries within their area.
Role of Panchayats
The Constitution envisages devolution of powers and responsibilities to the

Panchayats to enable them to function as institutions of self-government.107
The Eleventh Schedule enlists 29 subjects, including ‘Libraries’, powers regard-
ing which can be entrusted to the Panchayats. Accordingly, in Maharashtra the
state government amended the Maharashtra Village Panchayats Act, 1959
entrusting the Panchayats to make reasonable provisions with respect to
‘adult literacy centres, libraries and reading rooms’.108 However, the MPLA has
not been amended accordingly to involve the Panchayats in the effective and
efficient management of the public libraries system in the state. It is suggested
that to fully realise the government’s ‘Gaav tithe Granthalaya’ slogan, Pancha-
yats should be made an integral stakeholder in the public libraries system.
suggestion Panchayats should be involved directly by the DLC and DLAs for
the promotion and establishment of public libraries in their commu-
nity. A village Panchayat member could be made a representative
of the DLC and DLAs.
107 Constitution of India 1950, Art 243G.

108 Maharashtra Village Panchayats Act 1959, s 45 read with Schedule I.
28
V Funding
Libraries require continuous funding to organise activities, programs and ser-

vices. Additionally, the steadiness of funding needs to be ensured for long
periods of time to allow libraries to build up a collection of literature and mem-
bership of people over many years.109
No permission for new libraries or upgradation of libraries has been pro-
vided in Maharashtra since 2012-2013.110 There are also regular delays in pro-
viding honorariums to staff and disbursal of funds.111,112
News reports across Maharashtra indicate that public libraries have not
adequately addressed the population’s needs.113 The limited financial budget
does not permit the maintenance or creation of new infrastructure,114 timely or
sufficient payment to staff,115,116 and the strengthening of book collections.117
These libraries are in dire need of funding to maintain their present infrastruc-
ture and staffing,118,119 let alone achieve goals that are laid out by model public
libraries.
Moreover, the primary grant amount is divided into salaried and non-sal-
aried income. The 1970 Rules provide that for recognised libraries, 50 percent
of the grant money is to be spent on books.120 However, it is becoming diffi-
cult for libraries to maintain this allocated expenditure for books. The salaried
income is used to pay salaries to members of the Directorate of Libraries and
librarians, along with honorariums for library staff. The non-salaried funds are
further used to ensure the upkeep of the libraries and payment for miscella-
neous items, leaving inadequate funds for the purchase of the books.121
109 ‘Library Finance’ (Journal of Critical Library and Information Studies, December 2014) <http://brauss.mp.gov.in/Uploaded%20
Document/Documents/OnlineLearning/PublicLibrarySystems2.pdf> accessed 9 February 2022.
110 Pramod Chaudhary, ‘सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालय चालकां च्या अडचणीत वाढ’ (eSakal - Marathi Newspaper, October 2020) <https://www.esakal.
com/nanded/increased-difficulty-public-library-operators-nanded-news-357033> accessed 9 February 2022.
111 Amey Tirodkar, ‘Without Subsidy Lockdown Employees in Public Libraries of Maharashtra Struggle’ (Newsclick, August 2020)
<https://www.newsclick.in/Without-Subsidy-Lockdown-Employees-Public-Libraries-Maharashtra-Struggle> accessed 9 Febru-
ary 2022.
112 Vilas Shinde ‘Library staff salaries will be credited directly into their bank accounts’ (e-Sakal - Marathi Newspaper, January 2021)
<https://www.esakal.com/marathwada/library-staff-salaries-will-be-credited-directly-their-bank-accounts-online-uday-samant>
113 Pramod Chaudhary, (n 110).
114 ibid.
115 Vilas Shinde, ‘कोरोनाने सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालय कर्म चारी मरणासन्न अवस्थे त; ग्रंथालयां चे नियमित अनु दान नाही’ (eSakal - Marathi Newspaper, May 2021)
<https://www.esakal.com/marathwada/corona-has-stopped-receiving-grants-to-public-library-staff> accessed 9 February 2022.
116 Vilas Shinde, ‘राज्यातील बारा हजार ग्रंथालय अनू दानाच्या प्रतिक्षे त’ (eSakal - Marathi Newspaper, June 2021) <https://www.esakal.com/
marathwada/twelve-thousand-libraries-in-the-state-are-waiting-for-grants-parbhani-news> accessed 9 February 2022
118 Vilas Shinde (n 115).
119 ‘मुं बई मराठी ग्रंथसंग्रहालय दात्यां च्या प्रतीक्षे त’ (Loksatta, March 2021) <https://www.loksatta.com/mumbai/mumbai-marathi-library-await-
ing-for-donor-dd-70-2412334/> accessed 9 February 2022.
120 Form B of the 1970 Rules.
121 Vitthal Copper (n 117).
29
Funding of libraries as per the MPLA
State funds support public libraries either through the creation of a designated
fund (block grants from any level of the government) or through local taxation,
such as by levying a surcharge on property tax. Additional sources include
donations, special grants by the government for specific activities and in mar-
ginal quantities, user fees and penalties.122
The MPLA broadly adheres to this classification and creates a ‘library fund’
which receives money from the various sources provided below:
(1) The State Government shall constitute a fund called the Library
Fund.
(2) The Library Fund shall consist of—
(a) contribution made by the State Government under section 20;
(b) any special grants given by the State Government under section
21;
(c) any grants given by the Government of India to the State Govern-
ment for development of public libraries; and
(d) any contributions or gifts made by the public for development of
public libraries.
Contribution from State Government
Section 20 of the MPLA only assures a minimum grant of INR 25 lakh to the
public libraries in the state. Additionally, the Maharashtra public libraries rely
primarily on a block grant received from the state. There is no provision for
cess.
The State Government shall, after due appropriation made by law on

this behalf, contribute to the Library Fund every year, a sum not less
than twenty-five lakhs of rupees.
In Maharashtra’s legislative council debates in 1967, it was mentioned

that the minimum amount of 25 lakhs should be revised at a later date.123 How-
ever, the amount has still not been revised.
122 IFLA (n 1) 18.

123 Sri Hanshu Advani, Maharashtra Legislative Assembly Debate (1967) 167-170.
30
Moreover, funds for Maharashtra public libraries and grant-in-aid libraries
haven’t increased since 2012-2013.124,125 Maharashtra has allocated a budget
of approximately INR 140 crore for the development of public libraries in the
year 2021-2022,126 and this is similar to the grants offered in 2020-2021127 and
2019-2020.128 There are also consistent delays in disbursing the budgeted
amount129 and often the entire amount is not provided as well.130 This has been
further complicated by COVID-19 wherein it has become difficult for the Direc-
torate to receive grants after the pandemic.131 This problem can be attributed
to section 20 of the MPLA which is now obsolete and serves no legislative
backing to address the problem of infrastructure and funds that are affecting
library services within Maharashtra today.
Aside from Maharashtra, another state specifies an amount or a portion of
the budget that is to be used for libraries. The Goa Public Libraries Act, 1993,
states that aside from having a cess, the government “shall provide one per
cent of the Education Budget for promoting the service of Public Libraries in
the State.”132 Unlike section 20 of the MPLA, such a provision prevents the
budget for libraries from being decreased due to inflation each year.
suggestion Amend section 20 of the MPLA to provide a percentage of the

Higher and Technical Education Department’s yearly budget for
libraries. Accordingly, the disbursal of the amount will not fluctuate
depending on external circumstances and the budget for libraries
will remain updated with time. The Goa public library legislation can
serve as an example for the same.
Local taxation as a source of revenue
As mentioned above, the Goa Public Libraries Act, 1993, along with allocating
a portion of its education department’s budget, imposes a cess for financing
of its libraries.
124 ‘New Policy On Libraries In Next Legislature Session: Maharashtra Government’ (The Indian Express, March 2020) <https://in-
dianexpress.com/article/education/new-policy-on-libraries-in-next-legislature-session-maharashtra-government-6299012/>
125 Vilas Shinde, ‘राज्यातील सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालय अनु दानात वाढ तर नाही उलट कपात; ग्रंथालयाचे भवितव्य धोक्यात’ (eSakal - Marathi Newspaper,March
2021) <https://www.esakal.com/marathwada/increase-public-library-grants-state-if-not-reverse-reduction-future-library-jeop-
ardy> accessed 9 February 2022.
126 Maharashtra Government Resolution dated 20 August 2021 <https://www.maharashtra.gov.in/Site/Upload/Government%20Res-
olutions/English/202108201647265508.pdf> accessed 9 February 2022.
127 Maharashtra Government Resolution dated 14 January 2021 <https://www.maharashtra.gov.in/Site/Upload/Government%20
Resolutions/English/202101141059435708.pdf> accessed 9 February 2022.
128 Vilas Shinde, ‘राज्यातील सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालय अनु दानात वाढ तर नाही उलट कपात; ग्रंथालयाचे भवितव्य धोक्यात’ (eSakal - Marathi Newspaper, March
2021) <https://www.esakal.com/marathwada/increase-public-library-grants-state-if-not-reverse-reduction-future-library-jeop-
ardy> accessed 9 February 2022.
129 Vilas Shinde, ‘राज्यातील बारा हजार ग्रंथालय अनू दानाच्या प्रतिक्षे त’ (eSakal - Marathi Newspaper, June 2021) <https://www.esakal.com/
marathwada/twelve-thousand-libraries-in-the-state-are-waiting-for-grants-parbhani-news> accessed 9 February 2022.
130 Conversation with officials of Directorate of Libraries dated 15 February 2022.
131 ibid.
132 Goa Public Libraries Act 1993, s 19.
31
Professor Dr. S.R. Ranganathan had advocated for a cess as a primary
source of revenue for libraries. His drafts of the Model Public Library Act,133
and library legislations for Tamil Nadu and Kerala reflect this preference.134
While there was overwhelming support for cess by the 1959 Advisory
Committee Report,135 leaders of India’s public library movement136 and even
the Maharashtra legislative council;137 the Maharashtra legislative assem-
bly debates in 1967 considered that revenue from cess would be too low to
fund public libraries. To arrive at this conclusion, a comparison was made
between the minimum grant of INR 25 lakh proposed by the government, to
revenue from the highest cess imposed by a state then, i.e. Tamil Nadu. In the
years preceding 1967, the cess collected by the Tamil Nadu government was
approximately five lakhs, whereas the Maharashtra government was providing
upwards of INR 30 lakhs. The yearly expenditure of Maharashtra public libraries
in 1967 was not beyond INR eight lakhs and therefore it was assumed that by
offering a minimum amount of INR 25 lakhs the state was providing a sufficient
budget for the library system to expand and improve. Hence, the introduction
of cess was debated but eventually rebutted with these factors.
Maharashtra was, at that time, the fourth state to legislate public libraries
after Tamil Nadu, Kerala and Karnataka,138 and was also the first state to not
introduce cess in their public library legislation. Most of the library legislations
that followed thereafter did not have provisions for cess and relied on state
government funding.
Only seven states in India: Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, Telangana,
Karnataka, Haryana, Kerala and Goa have mentioned library cess in their
legislations:
State Section of the Act Rate of Cess (provided with other sources of
funding)
Tamil Nadu Section 12 of the Tamil Nadu five paisa per rupee on property tax
Public Libraries Act,1948
“Every Local Library Authority shall levy in its area
a library cess in the form of a surcharge on the
property tax or house tax levied in such area”
Revised in 1992 from five paisa to ten paisa
133 (Egyankosh.ac.in) <https://egyankosh.ac.in/bitstream/123456789/35239/5/Unit-5.pdf> accessed 9 February 2022.

134 Egyankosh (n 133) 9, 10.
136 IIHS (n 36) 18, 19.
137 The Maharashtra legislative council had advocated for cess and had even considered the types of cess that could be imposed.
An option proposed was that a portion of the education cess being charged then could be used for public library development.
However,the introduction of a cess would make the draft MPLA a money bill, which the legislative council could not legislate on.
Hence the Council could not insert a clause on cess in the MPLA.
138 Egyankosh (n 133) 17.
32
Andhra Pradesh Section 20 of the Andhra Surcharge on house tax and property tax at the rate
Pradesh Public Libraries of eight paise per rupee
Act,1960
“ (a) Every ZGS shall levy in its area a library cess
in the form of a surcharge on the property tax or
house tax levied in such area under the relevant
laws providing for the levy of such property tax or
house tax, at the rate of four naye paise for every
rupee in the property tax or house tax so levied ;
(b)A ZGS may, with the previous sanction of the

Government and shall if directed by them, increase
the rate specified in clause (a) so as not to exceed
EIGHT naya paise for every rupee.”
Telangana Section 20 of the Telangana Surcharge on property tax or house tax, at the rate
Public Libraries Act, 1960 of eight paisa for every rupee
“Every Zilla Grandhalaya Samstha shall levy in its

area a Library Cess in the form of a surcharge on
the property tax or house tax, levied in such area
under the relevant laws providing for the levy of
such property tax or house tax, at the rate of eight
paisa for every rupee in the property tax or house
tax so levied”
Karnataka Section 30 of the Karnataka Surcharge on tax on lands and buildings, entry of
Public Libraries Act, 1965 goods, vehicles, professions, trades at the rate of
three paise per rupee
“a library cess in the form of a surcharge on tax on

lands and buildings shall be levied in the area within
the jurisdiction of every District Library Authority,
under the relevant laws relating to local authorities
providing for the levy of such tax at the rate of three
paise for every rupee of the tax so levied.”
Haryana Section 20 of the Haryana Surcharge on house tax and property tax
Public Libraries Act ,1989
“Every local body in a district may levy in its area a
library case in the form of surcharge on property tax
and house tax at such rate as the Government may
decide from time to time.”
33
Kerala Section 48 of the Kerala Surcharge on house tax and property tax at the rate
Public Libraries Act,1989 of five paise for a rupee
“The State library Council shall levy a library cess in

the form of a surcharge on the building tax levied
under Municipality Act, 1994 (20 of 1994)] at the
rate of five paise for the whole rupee in the building
tax or property tax, as the case may be, so levied.”
Goa Section 18 of the Goa Public Surcharge on excise duty on liquor at the rate of
Libraries Act, 1993 one rupee fifty paise per bulk litre
“The Government shall levy a library cess in the form

of a surcharge on the Excise Duty payable under
Goa Excise Duty Act, 1964 at the rate of 0.50 (paise
fifty only) per proof liter of the (I.M.F.L.) Indian Made
Foreign Liquor and at the rate of Rs. 0.50 (paise fifty
only) per bulk liter of beer.”
The Act also provides for one percent of the

Education Budget.
▲ Details of library cess in the public library legislations of India
Arguments for cess Arguments against cess
Over years, the cess amount adjusts to inflation In certain instances, such as the COVID-19
as it is a percentage of the tax received. While pandemic, tax reliefs were provided, reducing the
the value of block grants, such as in Maharashtra, amount available to spend on the libraries.
decreases each year.
Additionally, cess comes from local tax, which differs
This ensures a regular and increasing source of between each municipality and district, creating an
income, which is a must for all libraries.139 unequal investment in public libraries across the
state.140,141
139 Egyankosh (n 133) 9, 10.

140 IIHS (n 16) 27.
141 Avadaiappan, N. (2015) ‘Financing public libraries for the future: Tamil Nadu model’ (2015) <http://delnet.nic.in/Avadiappan%20
FINANCING%20PUBLIC%20LIBRARIES%20FOR%20THE%20FUTURE.pptx.> accessed 9 February 2022.
34
Cess is also levied to fulfil a particular state goal Cess is often created for purposes such as boosting
and cannot be used for other purposes. A library specific sectors. They create an additional tax
cess, therefore, empowers states to exclusively burden on the taxpayer. Therefore, cess is ordinarily
use the cess for library development.142 levied as a temporary measure and should not serve
a long term fund. Once the purpose is fulfilled, it is
removed.143
Studies have shown that states implementing Cess money needs to be transferred by the revenue
library cess have an efficient and robust public authorities to the library; however, that does not
library system.144 They also have high school always happen. Therefore, implementation of cess
enrollment and literacy rates as opposed to states may not form the basis of the efficient public library
without a cess.145 system or improved literacy.
This can be seen in Bengaluru where nearly 300

crores are yet to be disbursed to the library
authorities,146 and cities such as Chennai,147
Coimbatore,148 Visakhapatnam149 and Hyderabad,150
to name a few.
Cess has the advantage of providing an earmarked amount of money for

library development in the state, therefore, keeping in mind its drawbacks it
can be implemented in the state. Alternatively, if people are not willing to take
on an additional tax burden, a portion of a pre-existing tax can be used for
public libraries in the state.
suggestions In addition to the portion of the Higher and Technical Education Department’s
budget,
A percentage of a pre-existing tax such as property tax (instead of

creating a surcharge) can be earmarked for expenditure on librar-
ies. This would be different from states that have imposed cess by
142 IIHS (n 36) 18, 19.

143 ‘What Is Cess?’ (The Financial Express, June 2019) <https://www.financialexpress.com/what-is/cess-meaning/1616176/> ac-
144 Ajit Pyati, ‘View Of Public Library Revitalization In India: Hopes, Challenges, And New Visions | First Monday’ (Journals.uic.edu,Ju-
ly 2009) <https://journals.uic.edu/ojs/index.php/fm/article/view/2588/2237> accessed 9 February 2022.
145 IIHS (n 36) 15.
146 Ranjani Govind, ‘Since 2012, These Libraries Have Not Received Cess’ (The Hindu, November 2015) <https://www.thehindu.com/
news/cities/bangalore/since-2012-these-libraries-have-not-received-cess/article7879214.ece> accessed 9 February 2022.
147 Ajitha Kathikeyan, ‘Local Bodies Fail To Remit Library Cess | Chennai News - Times Of India’ (The Times of India, September
2010) <https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/chennai/local-bodies-fail-to-remit-library-cess/articleshow/6639646.cms>
148 Vishnu Swaroop, ‘Corporation Has Backlog Of Rs 33 Crore To Pay Dist Library Commission | Coimbatore News - Times Of India’
(The Times of India, May 2019) <https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/coimbatore/corpn-has-backlog-of-rs-33cr-to-pay-dist-
library-commission/articleshow/69549760.cms> accessed 9 February 2022.
149 ‘Zilla Grandhalaya Samstha Seeks Library Cess Dues From Civic Body’ (The Hindu, July 2021) <https://www.thehindu.com/news/
cities/Visakhapatnam/zilla-grandhalaya-samstha-seeks-library-cess-dues-from-civic-body/article35149543.ece> accessed 9
February 2022.
150 Coreena Suares, ‘GHMC Robs Library Cess’ (Deccan Chronicle, November 2017) <https://www.deccanchronicle.com/nation/cur-
rent-affairs/031117/ghmc-robs-library-cess.html> accessed 9 February 2022.
35
way of surcharge and would not create an additional burden on the
taxpayer. (Karnataka, for example, in section 30 of its public library
legislation provides for an annual grant to the district library author-
ity by the government of an amount equal to three per cent of the
district’s land revenue collection).
Alternatively, if cess is imposed,
The MPLA can ensure that even when the cess is not transferred
by the collecting authorities, a grant will be provided by the state
government instead. The MPLA can provide for the transfer of such
contingency funds.
A certain portion of the cess from each district can be set aside
to assist other lesser developed districts. It has been seen in the
case of states such as Tamil Nadu that to ensure equitable distribu-
tion of funds to all districts, 20 percent of the cess collected from
each district is maintained in a general fund to assist any financially
weaker library authority.151 That solves the problem of inequitable
funds from cess collection at the level of the local bodies.152
Funding should be revised every five years. The funding from the state’s
budget can be used for larger non-recurring expenses such as establishing
libraries and the funding from cess can be used for recurring expenses such
as payment of salaries to staff.
Other sources of revenue
Grants from Government of India
The Ministry of Culture, Government of India lends its support to the state gov-
ernments for the development of public libraries and RRRLF acts as its nodal
agency.153
The RRRLF runs a matching scheme with state governments through
which it provides financial aid for conducting seminars, maintaining infrastruc-
ture and buying books, computers, photocopy machines and cupboards.154 In
2021-22, the government allocated INR three crore as its contribution to the
151 Tamil Nadu Public Library Act 1948, s 14A.

152 IIHS (n 36) 27.
153 (Raja Ram Mohan Roy Library Foundation) About RRRLF <http://rrrlf.nic.in/StaticPages_AboutUs/AboutRrrlf.aspx> accessed 9
February 2022.
154 R.R.R.L.F. Scheme | Government Of Maharashtra, Higher And Technical Education Department Directorate Of Library, India|’
(Directorate of Libraries) <https://dol.maharashtra.gov.in/en/r.r.r.l.f._scheme> accessed 9 February 2022.
36
matching scheme.155 Maharashtra and RRRLF invest 50:50 in the matching
scheme, and therefore RRRLF provides INR three crore as its portion under
the scheme.156
A non-matching scheme is also provided by the RRRLF, where based on
the proposals provided to it, it grants funds for development of children, citizen
or senior citizen corners in libraries.157 For approval of these proposals, a State
Library Planning Committee (“SLPC”) is established every three years. This
committee also ensures that RRRLF grants provided through the matching
scheme are used judiciously by the Directorate of Libraries. The latest SLPC
was established on 2 December 2021.158
It has been seen however that not enough proposals are sent to the
RRRLF and its SLPCs and therefore funds are underutilised by states.159 There-
fore, there is a need to ensure that libraries in Maharashtra avail these funds for
improving services offered by them.
suggestion The Directorate of Libraries along with the DLCs and DLAs must
encourage the utilisation of RRRLF schemes by libraries in the state.
The implementation of these schemes can assist libraries in ensur-
ing that the standards created under the MPLA will be maintained.
Grants from endowments and charitable institutions
All public library legislations in India include donations as a source of reve-

nue for their library funds as during the 1950s to 1970s, there was a people’s
movement for libraries in India.160 Members of the state legislative assembly
anticipated that on account of this movement, considerable donations would
be made to the library fund.
Presently, donations are not made to the library fund itself, however they
are made individually to the public libraries.161 Local organisations and mem-
bers directly offer donations to public libraries within their vicinity. This has
been noted recently, when libraries were damaged due to floods in July 2021.162
suggestion Donations to the library fund must be encouraged by the Director-

ate of Libraries.
155 ‘Maharashtra Government Resolution dated 3 October 2021 <https://www.maharashtra.gov.in/Site/Upload/Government%20

156 RRRLF scheme (n 154).
157 ibid.
158 Maharashtra Government Resolution dated 2 December 2021 <https://www.maharashtra.gov.in/Site/Upload/Government%20
159 Saket Suman, ‘India’s 70,000+ Public Libraries And Its Untapped Potential: A Study In Contrast’ (Business Standard, May 2017)
<https://www.business-standard.com/article/news-ians/india-s-70-000-public-libraries-and-its-untapped-potential-a-study-in-
contrast-117053100538_1.html> accessed 9 February 2022.
160 Sri M. D. Chaudhari, Maharashtra Legislative Assembly Debate (1967) 161-163.
161 Conversation with District Library Officer Pune dated 26 October 2021.
162 Ajay Jadhav, ‘Damaged By Floods In Sangli, Library’s Mission To Save 75,000 Books: Staff, Students, 6 Hair Dryers’ (The Indian
Express, September 2019) <https://indianexpress.com/article/india/damaged-by-floods-in-sangli-librarys-mission-to-save-
75000-books-staff-students-6-hair-dryers-5970550/> accessed 9 February 2022.
37
Fees, subscriptions and membership deposits taken by the library (ad hoc,
non-recurring and meant for specific purposes with restrictions on allocation
and use)
Public libraries are not revenue earning institutions. This is because making
membership fees a primary revenue source for the library makes the ability to
pay the fees a criterion in using the library. This in turn, reduces access, ren-
dering ineffective the purpose of having public libraries.163 The 1959 Advisory
Committee Report also supported the inadvisability of considering subscrip-
tion as a source of revenue.164
Some states, as detailed below, make reference to the imposition of a
membership fee or deposit:
Uttarakhand “section 2(f): “Library Fee” means the library fee levied, as prescribed by the
Public Library Government;”
Act, 2005 “section 20(1): The State Government shall impose fee for the purposes of libraries.”
Arunachal “section 2(3): “Public Library” means a Library which permits members of the public to
Pradesh Public use it for reference or borrowing reading materials with or without charging nominal
Libraries Act, fees;”
2009
Goa Public “Rule 5: The members shall pay the membership deposit (refundable) as shown
Libraries below:—
Membership i. For State & District Library : Membership deposit of Rs. 200/- (for adults) and Rs.
Rules, 1999 50/- (for children)
ii. For Taluka Library : Membership deposit of Rs. 50/- (for adults) and Rs. 25/- (for
children)
iii. For Village Library : Membership deposit of Rs. 25/- (for adults) and Rs. 10/- (for
children)
The membership deposit is subject to revision from time to time.”
Haryana Public “section 2(3): “Public Library” means a Library which permits members of the public to
Libraries Act , use it for reference or borrowing without charging fee or subscription;”
1989 While the Haryana Public Libraries Act , 1989 implies that no membership fees must
be charged, some libraries in Haryana impose a membership fee.165
▲ References to membership fees and security deposits in public library

legislations
163 IFLA (n 1) 19.

165 District Library Panipat (e-Granthkosh Haryana) <https://www.districtlibrarypanipat.ac.in/> accessed 9 February 2022.
38
In Maharashtra, the membership fee for government run public libraries is
INR 100 for two years with INR 500 as a security deposit.166 The library rooms
and reading of books within the premises can be used free of charge and the
fee is only for borrowing books. The membership fee for the Asiatic Library
which serves as the State Central Library is different.167
Additionally, for all government-aided libraries which receive funds from
the Higher and Technical Education (“HTE”) Department, the government-aided
library’s managing committee has the discretion to impose membership fees.
However, to continue to receive grants from the HTE Department, they need to
follow all the rules and standards prescribed for the grading of these libraries.
Presently, under the 1970 Rules, free and open access to libraries (but not free
membership) is the condition to be recognised as a public library for receiving
grants.
While in some countries168 a nominal fee is charged not for the purpose
of serving as a source of revenue but to heighten the appreciation of library
services, delays in receiving funds from the government require libraries in
Maharashtra to rely on membership fees as a source of revenue.169 This was
seen through the inability of public libraries in Maharashtra to sustain them-
selves during the pandemic when membership fees were reduced during the
lockdown.170
It is also important to note that the imposition of any membership fees or
deposit can create barriers to access public libraries and automatically elimi-
nate a certain group of people for whom access is immediately denied on the
basis of cost. The average urban Indian spends INR 90 on fruits and nuts per
month.171 If you take this example it provides perspective to understand that
the fees and deposits imposed by the public libraries would be unaffordable
to most. Therefore, a membership fee of any kind has to be understood as dis-
enfranchisement and exclusion at the first instance. This in turn discourages
membership and reading, resulting in a loss to society.
suggestions The funding for public libraries in Maharashtra should be increased

to the extent that they do not rely on membership fees and depos-
its as a source of revenue.
To the extent possible, membership fees and deposits should be

removed as a requirement for borrowing books from libraries.
166 Maharashtra Government Resolution dated 22 February 2018 <https://www.maharashtra.gov.in/Site/Upload/Government%20

Resolutions/English/20180222155812 108.pdf> accessed 9 February 2022.
167 Conversation with the Directorate of Libraries dated 2 November 2021.
168 ‘Public Libraries And User Fees’ [ May 1993] The Australian Library Journal.
169 Rajiv Joshi, ‘अबोल पु स्तके, सु न्न ग्रंथालये !’ (Maharashtra Times, October 2020) <https://maharashtratimes.com/editorial/samwad/rajiv-
joshi-article-on-lockdown-and-public-library/articleshow/78593284.cms> accessed 9 February 2022.
170 ibid.
171 Rukmini S., Whole Numbers and Half Truths: What Data Can and Cannot Tell Us about Modern India (Context, 2021) 127.
39
VI Public Library Employees
Public libraries across the country face difficulties in staffing a sufficient

number of people with the necessary qualifications.172 In Punjab, for exam-
ple, around 75 percent of the libraries are running without the required man-
power as 74 out of the 96 sanctioned posts of librarians in 62 libraries are lying
vacant. A library in Hoshiarpur was even shut down after the only worker, a
class IV employee, retired.173
Library staff in Maharashtra have regularly faced delayed payments. While
the state government recently made changes such as direct salary payments
to prevent any delays174 to the approximately 22,000 library staff,175 there are
other problems as well which affect the library staff.
In Maharashtra, over the last 45 years, the pay scale of public library staff
has not been pegged to the Minimum Wages Act, 1948. Aside from the already
low expenditure on library staff, grants from the government and membership
fees from readers were reduced during the pandemic further constricting
other sources of revenue that help pay the library staff. Consequently, since
the last two years library staff in the state have been struggling due to the
irregular library subsidies and rising inflation caused by the pandemic.176
As per the Supreme Court of India, government employees must be paid
as per the Minimum Wages Act, 1948 on an hourly basis, however this has not
been followed by nearly half the libraries in the state.177 There can be two rea-
sons for this, (i) there are no qualifications specifically required for library staff
and therefore (ii) the posts in public libraries have not been regularised by the
government.
Under the MPLA, there are provisions to regularise members of the ‘Maha-
rashtra State Library Service’ and create rules for them.
172 IIHS (n 36) 25, 28.

173 Navrajdeep Singh ‘Punjab libraries cry for attention, most on verge of closure’ (Hindustan Times, June 2017) <https://www.
hindustantimes.com/punjab/punjab-libraries-cry-for-attention-most-on-verge-of-closure/story-unFy6BuJCYSDj3eiEf0enJ.ht-
ml#:~:text=across%20the%20state.-,The%2062%20libraries%20in%20the%20state%2C%20including%2014%20district%20
libraries,for%20the%20past%20many%20years> accessed 17 February 2022.
174 Library staff salaries will be credited directly into their bank accounts (n 112).
31 March 2021. The number of staff provided was 21615 for grant-in-aid libraries. An approximate number of 22000 has been
taken to account for staff from other public libraries in Maharashtra as well.
176 कोरोनाने सार्व जनिक ग्रंथालय कर्म चारी मरणासन्न अवस्थे त (n 115).
177 ibid.
40
(1) The State Government shall establish a Maharashtra State Library

Service, and appoint persons thereto.
(2) The Maharashtra State Library Service shall consist of such
classes and categories of posts as the State Government may from
time to time determine. All members of the said service shall be
Government servants and their recruitment and conditions of service
shall be regulated by such rules as may be made by the State Govern-
ment from time to time.
(3) The salaries, allowances, gratuity, pension and other emoluments
of the members of the Maharashtra State Library Service, shall be
paid from the Consolidated Fund of the State.
(2) In particular, and without prejudice to the generality of the forego-

ing power, such rules may provide for all or any of the following mat-
ters, namely:
(vi) under sub-section (2) of section 10, the requirement and condi-
tions of service of members of the Maharashtra State Library Service;
Such rules however have not been provided. The Karnataka Public Librar-
ies Act, 1965, which is similar to the MPLA, provides that:
Section 15 of the Karnataka Public Libraries Act, 1965:
(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in any other law, all posts

in the Department of Public Libraries, the State Central Library and
every Local Library Authority shall be filled by appointment of per-
sons belonging to the [Karnataka State Library Service].
(2) The [Karnataka State Library Service] shall consist of the [Director
of Public Libraries], Chief Librarians of Cities and Districts, Librarians
and such other classes and categories of posts as the State Gov-
ernment may from time to time determine. All members of the said
service shall be Government servants, and their recruitment and con-
ditions of service shall, subject to the provisions of Article 309 of the
Constitution, be regulated by such rules as may be prescribed.
(3) The salary, allowances, gratuity, pension and other benefits of the
members of the [Karnataka State Library Service] shall be met from
the Consolidated Fund of the State.
Although Article 309 of the Constitution of India, which finds reference in

the Karnataka legislation is not mentioned in the MPLA, it is the constitutional
provision from which the Maharashtra government derives the power to regu-
late the conditions for posts in public services.
41
Article 309 and its jurisprudence requires that the state government lay
down specific rules and conditions for these posts concerning the employ-
ees’ promotion, transfer and remuneration. Such provisions, however, have not
been provided for under the MPLA.178
suggestions Create rules under section 10 read with 26(2)(vi) the MPLA to
provide for conditions of service, salaries and other benefits to
employees under the Maharashtra State Library Service.
Ensure that the salaries provided to the library staff are raised to
match the salaries under the Minimum Wages Act, 1948.
178 ‘CHAPTER XVIII: PROMOTION’ (Department of Personnel and Training, Government of India) <https://dopt.gov.in/sites/default/
files/ch-18.pdf> accessed 9 February 2022.
42
VII Publicity and Books
Publicity and marketing
Professor Rangathan stated that public libraries should necessarily indulge

in publicity activities to fulfil the Third Law of Library Science which says that
‘an appropriate reader should be found for every book’.179 As per Professor
Ranganathan, every public library has the duty “of converting every person
in its neighbourhood into a habitual goer and reader of books.”180 In light of
this view, it becomes a necessity for libraries to adopt methods of publicity to
involve the general public in the public library system.
Professor Ranganathan stated the need for public libraries to engage

in publicity and marketing activities in the following words:
For some, the library is still mediaeval, to others it is principally a pur-

veyor of entertaining novels. Surprise is continually expressed when
the public discovers the width of its service and catholicity of its
interests. “I didn’t know that you had music books?” “Are you open on
holidays? I didn’t know that.” ‘’I didn’t know that your catalogue is so
analytic.” Such expressions as these, no doubt, interest and please
librarians; but they are also a disquieting indication that a knowledge
of the service he offers has not yet spread over the entire public. They
make it evident that well considered publicity is as necessary for the
public library, as for a commercial firm, in order that the public may
know of its existence and of the varied services that it offers.181
He also suggested that libraries should adopt various modes of publicity

and marketing such as publication of recent additions to libraries in local news-
papers, articles in newspapers recounting the library services and resources;
conducting exhibitions and distributing leaflets by libraries, and organisation of
library talks and story hours to stimulate the interest of public in the services
and resources of libraries.182 To execute the aforesaid activities, he suggested
that each library should have its own publicity program manned by specialised
full-time officers in the library—publicity officers—after analysing the needs of
the community they serve.
179 S R Ranganathan, The Five Laws of Library Science (Madras Library Association, 1931) 315.
180 S R Ranganathan, Library Administration (Madras Library Association,1935) 468.
181 The Five Laws of Library Science (n 179) 316.
182 ibid 464-466.
43
The basic purpose behind publicising and marketing in the context of pub-
lic libraries is to educate the community about the various library services and
resources and also to upkeep their knowledge by providing them the required
information.183 Since the words ‘marketing’ and ‘publicity’ are generally asso-
ciated with for-profit organisations and corporations, they have negative con-
notations in the context of public libraries, which are inherently perceived as
social organisations. However, research has shown that in recent years librar-
ies are more willing to adopt marketing principles to identify and meet informa-
tion needs of the readers.184
The Maharashtra government has started few initiatives to inculcate the
importance of reading and public libraries. In this regard, the government has
declared 15 October as ‘Vachan Prerna Divas’ to commemorate the birth anni-
versary of Dr. APJ Abdul Kalam.185,186 On this occasion, the government has
tasked the Director of Libraries and public libraries across the state to orga-
nise programs and exhibitions to inspire and cultivate reading habits among
the members of the society. Further, the government also awards the Dr.
Babasaheb Ambedkar Utkarsh Granthalaya Award187,188 and Dr. S R Rangana-
than Granthamitra Award189 to the best performing public library and librarian
respectively. Such initiatives keep the public informed about the services pro-
vided by public libraries in the state.
suggestions In the present digital age, public libraries have to make creative
use of the internet and social media to market their services and
resources. Libraries should start by creating their own website with
all the relevant information and cataloguing its books and services
to inform and educate the users.
Public libraries should also use interactive social media to articu-

late the library services and resources within a community. Librar-
ies can also create groups for their users on various social media
platforms to regularly update them about various library activities
as well as available books. This will inevitably lead to word of mouth
publicity and attract more users from the community.
183 S K Patil and Pranita Pradhan, ‘Library promotion practices and marketing of Library services: A role of Library professionals’
(2014) 133 Procedia – Social and Behavioral Sciences 249, 250.
184 Rajesh Singh, Does your library have an attitude problem towards ‘marketing’? Revealing inter-relationship between marketing
attitudes and behaviour’ (2009) 35(1) The Journal of Academic Librarianship 25-32.
185 Maharashtra Government Resolution, dated 1 October 2015 <https://www.maharashtra.gov.in/Site/Upload/Government%20
186 ‘‘Vachan Prerna Divas ‘On Oct 15: ‘Promote Book Reading On Dr Kalam’S Birth Anniversary’ (The Indian Express, October 2017)
<https://indianexpress.com/article/india/vachan-prerna-divas-on-oct-15-promote-book-reading-on-dr-kalams-birth-anniversa-
ry-4881303/> accessed 9 February 2022.
187 Maharashtra Government Resolution dated 27 August 2015 <https://www.maharashtra.gov.in/Site/Upload/Government%20Res-
olutions/English/201508271533119708.pdf> accessed 9 February 2022.
188 Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar Utkarsh Granthalaya Award, Government Of Maharashtra, Higher And Technical Education Department
Directorate Of Library, India’ (Directorate of Libraries) <https://dol.maharashtra.gov.in/en/dr._babasaheb_ambedkar_utkrush-
ta_sarvajanik_granthalaya_puraskar> accessed 9 February 2022.
189 Dr. S R Ranganathan Granthamitra Award, Government Of Maharashtra, Higher And Technical Education Department Directorate
Of Library, India’ (Directorate of Libraries) <https://dol.maharashtra.gov.in/dr._s.r._ranganathan_grantha_mitra_award> accessed
17 February 2022.
44
Libraries should also have community outreach programs and
create reading and book discussions for people within the vicinity
of the library.
Books
Professor Ranganathan opined that selection of books should be left to the

libraries, who should be aided by external experts.190 The public library system
in Maharashtra follows a similar approach, where the Directorate of Libraries
issues a book list on the recommendation of an independent book selection
committee.191
However, it is a fact that public libraries in Maharashtra are often paid
commissions by publishers to stock their books.192 As a result, libraries do not
stock books by other publishers. This leads to a situation where readers are
discouraged from visiting libraries as they cannot find the books they want to
read.
As per the 1970 Rules, public libraries in Maharashtra have to spend not
less than 50 percent of the grant-in-aid on books, out of which not less than
25 percent must be spent on purchase of books from the lists issued by the
Directorate.193 While there is already a shortage of funds for purchasing books,
with libraries being left with less than 50 percent of the money, the require-
ment of purchasing 25 percent of the books by the Directorate may stifle their
capacity to purchase books suggested by readers in their community. Thus,
under the MPLA, financial and administrative control of book purchases in
libraries must be reduced.
Special emphasis can be created by public libraries on purchasing books
for children. Children are especially interested in picture books. 194 Studies
have shown that picture books impact children’s learning and development in
a positive manner.195 Therefore, to cater to the needs of such children, public
libraries must keep a considerable stock of children’s books, viz. illustrated
books, interactive books, in addition to other useful reference books to attract
children to public libraries. Picture books also make reading a happy and plea-
surable experience for children; a formative experience necessary to foster
life-long relationships with books.
190 Library Administration (n 180) 93.

191 Maharashtra Government Resolution dated 20 January 2021 <https://maharashtra.gov.in/Site/Upload/Government%20Resolu-
tions/Marathi/202101201624323808.pdf> accessed 17 February 2022.
192 ‘वाचवू या पु स्तकां ची घरे !’ (Maharashtra Times, January 2019) <https://maharashtratimes.com/maharashtra/mumbai-news/save-
these-books/articleshow/67605283.cms> accessed 9 February 2022.
193 Schedule I, Form B of the 1970 Rules.
194 Uma Dasgupta, ‘Local Initiatives Are Spreading The Magic Of Public Libraries Across Rural Karnataka’ (The Hindu, September
2021) <https://www.thehindu.com/society/local-initiatives-are-spreading-the-magic-of-public-libraries-across-rural-karnataka/
article36644280.ece> accessed 9 February 2022.
195 Gabrielle A Strouse, Angela Nyhout, and Patricia Ganea, ‘The role of book features in young children’s transfer of information
from picture books to real world contexts’ (2018) 9(50) Frontiers in Psychology 1, 6.
45
suggestions Rules under the MPLA should require that libraries provide a sug-
gestion box in their premises to ensure that readers can request for
the books they wish to read.
Special emphasis should be given for purchasing picture books for

children.
Grants provided for libraries should be increased such that

money provided for books is not spent on other more pressing
expenditures.
46
VIII Libraries as Community Spaces
Each community needs certain spaces where the public is free to mingle and
interact. Such spaces take the form of streets, public parks, schools, muse-
ums, shopping malls, among others. Apart from schools and museums, public
libraries are a few public spaces where the individual can engage in a range of
social and intellectual activities. In doing so, public libraries increase equality
in access to the material conditions to live a flourishing life.196
Traditionally, public libraries have been providing services such as lending
books, maps, information, and photocopying equipment, among others. It is
true that not all members in a particular community may use the public library
for all or any of the aforesaid services. Yet, public libraries have a social impact
in terms of sustaining local communities and developing informed societies.
An informed society is a prerequisite of citizenship and forms the foundation
of a vibrant democracy.197 Thus, public libraries play an essential role in the
community by providing a sense of space and vital information resources.198
In recent years, however, the perception of public libraries has undergone
dramatic changes largely attributed to changing socio-economic and tech-
nological environments. Apart from their aforementioned traditional services,
libraries today provide community services that people cannot get elsewhere.199
Thus, the greater challenge for the public libraries is to remodel their buildings
and infrastructure to effectively present an alternative community space.
Public Libraries as community centres
While introducing the MPLA before the Maharashtra Legislative Assembly, M

D Chaudhary, the then Education Minister, expressed that the public library
movement in Maharashtra should be driven by the people at the grass-roots
level.200 However, the reality suggests that in today’s age, where technology
and digital gadgets are ubiquitous, people have low priority for libraries. A pub-
lic library is a dynamic institution and should evolve according to the needs of
the community.
The IFLA/UNESCO Public Library Manifesto, 1994 defined a public library
as “the local centre of information, making all kinds of knowledge and infor-
mation readily available to its users.” Public libraries can serve as an effective
196 Erik Olin Wright, Transforming capitalism through real utopias’ (2013) 21(2) Irish Journal of Sociology 6, 18.
197 Alan Bundy, ‘Growing the Community of the Informed: Information Literacy - A Global Issue’ (2002) 33(3) Australian Academic &
Research Libraries 125, 129.
198 Ajit K Pyati and Ahmed Kamal, ‘Rethinking community and public space from the margins: a study of community libraries in Ban-
galore’s slums’ (Wiley Online Library, 2012).
199 Rachel Scott, ‘The Role of Public Libraries in Community Building’ (Public Library Quarterly, 2011) <https://www.tandfonline.com/
doi/abs/10.1080/01616846.2011.599283> accessed 9 February 2022.
200 Sri M.D. Chaudhary, Maharashtra Legislative Assembly Debate (1967) 160-165.
47
medium of community information. Therefore, to become a true resource cen-
tre for the community, the public libraries must first make efforts to assess and
understand the information needs of the community.
However, it has been highlighted that public libraries in India cannot prop-
erly conduct assessment of their community’s information needs because of
a lack of human resource capacity and financial constraints.201 Therefore, there
is a need to ensure that public libraries in the state are adequately staffed and
provided with sufficient financial incentives to conduct assessment needs of
their community.
In order to become effective community information centres, public
libraries should initiate community information activities based on the demo-
graphic needs of the community. For instance, across towns and rural areas
in Maharashtra, students, especially aspirants for competitive examinations,
need space and resources to study for long hours.202
Additionally, many older adults and senior-citizens face social isolation
because of limited socialisation options. Public libraries have a special role
to play in the community with regards to reducing this form of isolation. The
spaces provided by public libraries can help the elderly and senior citizens in
maintaining their social connections and promote community involvement.
In a community, public libraries can provide community information ser-
vices either directly or in association with other community agencies. For
example, during the Covid-19 pandemic, many libraries across India carried
out relief campaigns by conducting health awareness, setting up randomised
testing facilities, and also serving as sites for vaccine registration.203 Further, a
few libraries in Uttar Pradesh partnered with Accredited Social Health Activist
(“ASHA”) and anganwadi workers to set up relief works in the community.204
Community engagement and outreach by libraries: Buguri Commu-

nity Libraries, Karnataka
Hasiru Dala is a social impact organisation working with waste collec-

tors in Karnataka.205 In order to create and nurture spaces for children
of waste collectors, Hasiru Dala started Buguri Community Libraries
(“BCL”) in Bangalore, Mysuru, and Tumkura near the localities where
201 Manohar Lamani, Anil Talawar, and BD Kumbhar, ‘Rejuvenate the Public Library as Community Information Center: A Case Study
of District Central Library, Dharwad’ (International Journal of Information and Dissemination, 2014) <https://www.researchgate.
net/publication/301889717_Rejuvenate_the_Public_Library_as_Community_Information_Centre_A_Case_Study_of_District_
Central_Library_Dharwad> accessed 9 February 2022.
202 ‘CBD Library A Big Hit, Footfall Rising Steadily | Nashik News - Times Of India’ (The Times of India, October 2019) <https://
timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/nashik/cbd-library-a-big-hit-footfall-rising-steadily/articleshow/71668349.cms> accessed 9
February 2022.
203 Satviki Sanjay, ‘How Public Libraries Have Evolved To Sustain Low-Income Communities Amid Pandemic’ (The Indian Express,
June 2021) <https://indianexpress.com/article/lifestyle/life-style/public-libraries-sustained-low-income-communities-sec-
ond-wave-pandemic-7348144/> accessed 9 February 2022.
204 Kushal Choudhary, ‘How A Village’s Community Library Continues To Brave COVID-19 Crisis In UP | Newsclick’ (NewsClick, June
2021) <https://www.newsclick.in/how-village-community-library-continues-brave-COVID-19-crisis-UP> accessed 9 February
2022.
205 ‘Our Story’ (Hasiru Dala) <https://hasirudala.in/about/our-story/> accessed 17 February 2022.
48
the waste pickers reside. During the COVID-19 induced lockdowns, the
BCL decided to harness technology to reconnect children with libraries.
During the lockdown, the libraries contacted the children’s parents and
created WhatsApp groups, through which they shared books with the
children.206 The BCL also tried to keep the children engaged through
activities such as Q&A sessions, book reading, drawing, music, and
similar activities. The BCL also started radio and podcast shows broad-
casting outreach programs for children.
During the COVID-19 pandemic it was highlighted that nearly 50 per-

cent of students in Maharashtra have limited or no access to online education
because of poor internet connectivity.207 Therefore, in the changing socio-eco-
nomic environment, public libraries should have adapted new methods and
approaches to become effective community spaces. Such methods and
approaches could have included provision for accessibility, learning informa-
tion technology (“IT”) skills, information and communication technology (“ICT”)
services, digital cataloguing, digitisation of manuscripts, e-book resources,
and staff motivational programs.208
However, when lockdowns were announced, public libraries across
Maharashtra closed to the public at a time when they were needed the most.
Therefore, it is incumbent upon the public libraries to adapt to the changing
scenarios to continue their engagements with the community.
Additionally, public libraries can be developed as community centres that
promote events like seminars, discussions, roundtables, talk shows, cultural
celebrations, be used as an event space and any other such activities based
on the community assessment and requirements.
suggestions Surveys can be conducted by managements of libraries to assess

satisfaction of library users and determine the kind of services
required by their community. Suggestions can also be provided by
the authorities under the MPLA, such as the DLAs and the DLCs, to
help them improve their services.
Staffing and funding of public libraries should take into consid-

eration the ability of the libraries to not just maintain books and
resources but also play a role as community information centres
and places for community engagement.
206 Chaitra Acharya, ‘The Library Is Present | Torchlight’ (Torchlight: A Journal of Libraries and Bookish Love,June 2020) <https://
journal.bookwormgoa.in/the-library-is-present/> accessed 9 February 2022.
207 Ankita Bhatkhande, ‘Only 57% Maharashtra Students Have Internet Connectivity’ (Hindustan Times, July 2020) <https://www.
hindustantimes.com/mumbai-news/only-57-maha-students-have-internet-connectivity/story-rIhrSeDyVuR5XMjE72tzDJ.html>
208 Osama Manzar, ‘Technology And Public Libraries’ (LiveMint, January 2015) <https://www.livemint.com/Opinion/fEhj3roPRIYlb-
naUk0VyiI/Technology-and-public-libraries.html> accessed 9 February 2022.
49
The needs of the community, such as providing material for com-
petitive exams, providing access to ICT, functioning as information
centres in time such as pandemics can be included within the
MPLA or its rules as part of the baseline of standards that libraries
must adhere to.
Librarians can engage with local civic and business community

organisations such as Rotary International and Lions Club, which
participate in community building and charitable activities across
districts in Maharashtra.209 Such partnerships will allow the librar-
ians to gain a greater insight into their communities, which then
can be used to design collaborative programmes and other such
community engagement services. Building partnerships with the
local community organisation could also help in garnering mone-
tary support for the library.
Library leaders, volunteers and interns can be recruited from within

each community to facilitate the functioning of public libraries.
Community volunteering programs like that for ASHA workers can
be created to make a formalised and paid role for community mem-
bers within the library system.
Forging partnerships with local schools
It has been suggested that creating linkages between schools and public
libraries is mutually beneficial in the following two ways: first, it allows the stu-
dents access to books and exposes them to their community; and second,
it allows the public library to interact with the community and increase their
patrons.210 Recently, the government of Tamil Nadu had also proposed linking
public libraries to schools to nurture reading habits among school students.211
As part of this scheme, every student automatically gains membership of a
public library, which they can access remotely by means of their school.
In Maharashtra, it is the case that many schools lack proper library facil-
ities.212 Hence, many public libraries have understood the acute need to link
schools with public libraries to inculcate positive reading habits in children. For
example, in Solapur District the District Public Library has initiated the ‘Shala
Tethe Granthalaya’ (Library for Each School) scheme.213 Such schemes should
209 Jeffrey Hancks, ‘Rural Public Libraries’ Role in Community Economic Development’ (2012) 31 Public Library Quarterly 220, 227.
210 D Jackson Maxwell, ‘Forging Partnerships: Schools, School Libraries, and Communities’ (1999) 26(4) Teacher Education Quarter-
ly 101.
211 Amrutha Varshinii, ‘TN Govt To Link Major Public Libraries, Schools By Next Year | Chennai News - Times Of India’ (The Times of
India, October 2017) <https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/chennai/tn-govt-to-link-major-public-libraries-schools-by-next-
year/articleshow/61111430.cms> accessed 9 February 2022.
212 Tanushree Podar, ‘Half of the state schools have no libraries’ (DNA, April 2016) <https://www.dnaindia.com/mumbai/report-half-
of-the-state-schools-have-no-library-2199326> accessed 14 February 2022.
213 ‘शाळा ते थे ग्रंथालय’चा सोलापू र पॅटर्न तयार करणार’ (eSakal - Marathi Newspaper, December 2016) <https://www.esakal.com/paschim-ma-
harashtra/shala-tethe-granthalay-solapur-pattern-22561> accessed 09 February 2022.
50
be implemented across all districts in Maharashtra, requiring all the public
libraries to adopt local schools and thereby reach out to all the students in
their community.
suggestion Create schemes linking schools to libraries as undertaken by

Solapur’s ‘Shala Tethe Granthalaya’ (Library for Each School)
scheme.
51
IX Digitisation of Libraries and Access to
Information and Communication Technology
In developing countries, public libraries can act ‘as an information safety net
for the information have-nots’. The inability to access internet technologies
creates a possibility of social exclusion from technological advancements. As
information providing institutions, public libraries are best placed to bridge this
gap.214 By providing access to computers, the internet and imparting educa-
tion on how to use these digital means, libraries could greatly benefit people
who do not have access to the same.
The other aspect of libraries and ICT services comprises creating digi-
tal libraries with digitised content such as e-books and online subscriptions.
However, current investment in public libraries is first needed to maximise
resources to help people in ‘desperate need of learning’.215
Initiatives taken by the central government
• The National Mission on Libraries, 2014 is an initiative by the central govern-

ment that seeks to modernise, digitise and increase access to public libraries.216
One of the components of the National Mission on Libraries (“NML”) is the
National Virtual Library of India (“NVLI”) which aims to digitise reading materi-
als in different languages.217 The reading materials would encompass informa-
tion about India and information created in India.218 It intends to target not only
students, researchers, doctors and professionals but also the educationally,
socially, economically and physically disadvantaged groups.219 Through this it
aims to ensure equal access to information for all. Despite the stated goal, the
initiative appears to only empower digitally literate people with ready access to
the internet. This does not remedy the problem of the digital divide.
• One of the other goals of the NML is to build the capacity of libraries and library
staff to eradicate information poverty and train library personnel but little infor-
mation on proceeding with such steps has been provided.220,221
214 K.G. Saur, The Public Library Service (IFLA, 2001) <https://www.ifla.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/assets/hq/publications/
archive/the-public-library-service/publ97.pdf> accessed 9 February 2022.
215 Chitralekha, ‘Which Way for Public Libraries in India?’ ( August 2014) Vol. 49, No. 31 EPW 25.
216 ‘National Mission On Libraries Launched By President Shri Pranab Mukherjee’ (PIB, February 2014) <https://pib.gov.in/newsite/
PrintRelease.aspx?relid=102951> accessed 9 February 2022.
217 ‘Creation Of National Virtual Library Of India As One Of The Components Of National Mission On Libraries’ (PIB, February 2019)
<https://pib.gov.in/Pressreleaseshare.aspx?PRID=1562603> accessed 9 February 2022.
218 ‘Librarians To Be Trained In e-Granthalaya | Goa News - Times Of India’ (The Times of India, October 2018) <https://timesofindia.
indiatimes.com/city/goa/librarians-to-be-trained-in-e-granthalaya/articleshow/66369851.cms> accessed 9 February 2022.
219 National Mission On Libraries Launched By President Shri Pranab Mukherjee (n 216).
220 ‘Work Undertaken Under National Mission On Libraries’ (PIB, March 2021) <https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx-
?PRID=1706998> accessed 9 February 2022.
221 ‘41 Proposals From 22 States/Uts For Have Been Sanctioned With Budget Of Rs 42.42 Cr To Set Up Model Libraries Under NML’
(PIB, March 2018) <https://pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=1526705> accessed 9 February 2022.
52
• E-granthalaya is an online automation system created by the National Infor-
matics Centre that is in the process of creating an online record of books avail-
able in libraries. It updates information online about which books are available
in which libraries and keeps up to date information on public library clusters222
in India. It is part of an initiative by Digital India.223 The e-granthalaya software
has over six lakh titles from Maharashtra as part of its digital catalogue.224 Only
automation and record updation of some libraries in Maharashtra is remaining.225
Initiatives taken by other states
• The Kerala Government has demonstrated a strong will to ensure digitisation

of libraries and access to ICT. A digital literacy program led by the PN Panicker
Foundation along with the Indian Public Library Movement (“IPLM”) is setting
up ICT infrastructure and providing digital literacy programs across Kerala.226
• NetWork, an initiative backed by various elected representatives in Kerala
ensures access to devices and training for digital literacy. To ensure that the
essence of a library, that is learning through social development is maintained
in the process, this measure is provided along with physical visits to the librar-
ies where internet is provided.227
• Karnataka created its digital library application (which provides e-books
and other digitised reading content) online in 2020 which has till date been
accessed by lakhs of people.228
• Andhra Pradesh has created a new project to establish ‘digital libraries’ (librar-
ies that provide access to devices and the internet even in remote areas). How-
ever it appears to be aimed at helping people that are working from home and
students studying for UPSC exams.229 The government has proposed to estab-
lish 4,314 digital libraries across the state and wants the Collectors to ensure
that the internet is available to all households that require it.230
• Some states have even included such measures or the necessity for them in
their public library legislations:
222 As per our conversation with the Directorate of Libraries dated 15 February 2022, information on public library clusters includes
compiling information on the date of establishment of libraries, their addresses, the number of members registered with them
and the number of books they have.
223 e-Granthalaya <https://egranthalaya.nic.in/> accessed 9 February 2022.
224 Conversation with the Directorate of Libraries dated 2 November 2021.
225 ibid.
226 ‘Kerala To Get Four Digital Libraries’ (Elets eGov, October 2016) <https://egov.eletsonline.com/2016/10/kerala-to-get-four-digi-
tal-libraries/> accessed 9 February 2022.
227 Parvathi Benu, ‘How This Kerala MP Is Using Public Libraries To Help Rural, Tribal Children Get Access To Education’ (Edex
Live,October 2021) <https://www.edexlive.com/news/2021/oct/03/how-this-kerala-mp-is-using-public-libraries-to-help-rural-
tribal-children-get-access-to-education-24510.html> accessed 9 February 2022.
228 ‘Karnataka Digital Library Stands First Among Other Libraries In The World - Star Of Mysore’ (Star of Mysore, August 2021)
<https://starofmysore.com/karnataka-digital-library-stands-first-among-other-libraries-in-the-world/> accessed 9 February
2022.
229 Gopi Dara, ‘Work Kicks Off On 13,000 Digital Libraries Across Andhra Pradesh | Vijayawada News - Times Of India’ (The Times
of India, October 2021) <https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/vijayawada/work-kicks-off-on-13k-digital-libraries/article-
show/87377189.cms> accessed 9 February 2022.
230 Gopi Dara, ‘Jagan: Accelerate Construction Of Clinics, Digital Libraries: Andhra Pradesh CM Y S Jagan Mohan Reddy | Vijay-
awada News - Times Of India’ (The Times of India, October 2021) <https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/vijayawada/acceler-
ate-construction-of-clinics-digital-libraries-jagan/articleshow/87192562.cms> accessed 9 February 2022.
53
Goa “section 3(2)(k): The Government shall establish, maintain and develop Library Service
in the State. For carrying out the purpose - the Government promote mobile libraries,
audio libraries for blind and special libraries for hearing impaired, text-book library,
children library computerization, microfilming of rare documents.”
Gujarat “section 2(a) (v): ‘Book’ includes - computer output in any form and computer
programmes”
Chattisgarh “section 9(k): The functions of the State Central Library shall be to promote
computerization in public libraries of the state and organize training programs for the
benefit of the professionals working in public libraries.”
Arunachal “section 3(7): The Government shall establish , maintain and develop Library Service
Pradesh in the State for carrying out the following purpose- Promote mobile libraries, audio
visual Libraries for children, audio libraries for blind and special libraries for hearing
impaired, text book library, children library, computerization, Microfilming or rare
documents.”
Orissa “section 2(m): “Library services” means the services provided by a public Library in
relation
to lending of Hooks and references, abstracts, bibliographies and indexes of
books and access to information recorded by electronic media;9(k): The functions
of the State Central Library shall be (k) to promote computerisation in libraries of
the state and organise training programs for the benefit of professionals working in
public libraries.”
Uttarakhand “section 14 (b): A District Library Authority may stock such libraries with books,
periodicals, newspapers, manuscripts, maps, works and specimens of art and
science lantern slides, films, cinema projectors, recorders, CD-ROMs audio-visual
material, digital documents and the like within available resources or forward
proposals or demand to State Library Committee.”
Rajasthan “section 2(a)(v): book includes computer output in any form and computer
programmes”
Uttar Pradesh “section 9(k): The functions of the State Central Library shall be (k) to promote
computerisation in libraries of the state and organise training programs for the
benefit of professionals working in public libraries.”
54
Kerala “section 8 (i)(viii): Provide in the Trivandrum Public Library or in such other State
Libraries, books, periodicals, newspapers, maps, radios, manuscripts, works and
specimens of art and science, lantern slides, films, cinema projectors, recorders,
television sets, charts, video cassette players, video cassette recorders and
computer and the like”
▲ References to digitisation of libraries and access to ICT in public library

legislations
Initiatives taken by the Maharashtra government
The MPLA makes no mention of e-books, digitisation of libraries or provisions

for access to ICT. The closest the MPLA comes to making a reference to dig-
ital technologies is the definition of books under section 2(i) which includes
mention of ‘discs or tapes used for audio-visual information’. Further, the
2012 amendment to rule 20 of the 1970 Rules provides that ‘computerization
of library services’ and ‘provisions for buying computers’ will be included as
admissible expenditure for the purpose of providing grants to the recognised
libraries. However, it appears that these provisions apply to purchasing com-
puters for library staff rather than providing ICT services to library users.
The legislative assembly debates had discussed the requirement for
libraries to be kept up to date with the latest technologies and the require-
ment for providing training to library staff for such technologies.231 However,
the MPLA does not reflect the intention of the state legislative assembly. More-
over, there are also no provisions for providing ICT access or training on digital
literacy to staff and users of the library.
Since 2017, the Directorate of Libraries has taken note of upgrading
library services.232
• Steps have been taken to digitise Marathi literature and make them available
on the Directorate of Libraries website or on Wikimedia Commons.233,234
• A new e-library website is now being set up by the Directorate where members,
(after paying a small fee) could access all e-books and e-resources available
on the website. Books in Marathi, English and Hindi will be made available on
the website.235
231 Sri M.D. Chaudhary, Maharashtra Legislative Council Debates (1967) 617.
232 ‘सरकारचे पु ढचे पाऊल “ई-ग्रंथालय’ (eSakal - Marathi Newspaper,August 2017) <https://www.esakal.com/pune/pune-news-e-li-
brary-67451> accessed 9 February 2022.
233 ‘Marathi Digitize/PDF Format Books - Total – 1636 | Government Of Maharashtra, Higher And Technical Education Department
Directorate Of Library, India|’ (Directorate of Libraries) <https://dol.maharashtra.gov.in/en/digilib> accessed 9 February 2022.
234 ‘Rare Collection Of 24 Marathi Books Published Between 1832 & 1900 Digitised’ (The Indian Express, October 2020) <https://
indianexpress.com/article/india/rare-collection-of-24-marathi-books-published-between-1832-1900-digitised-6790851/>
235 Maharashtra Govenrment Resolution dated 21 June 2021 <https://www.maharashtra.gov.in/Site/Upload/Government%20Reso-
lutions/English/202106211738218708.pdf> accessed 9 February 2022.
55
• Apart from the initiatives mentioned above, the Directorate of Libraries plans
to digitise all books and manuscripts which are over 100 years old and make
them available on the new e-library website. This process has begun in the
State Central Library.236,237
• Three ICT centres have been inaugurated in Jalna, Nanded and Andheri
(Mumbai).
suggestions If Maharashtra were to focus on ensuring accessibility to digital

information, large scale strategic planning will be required. First the
following alterations may be made within the MPLA:
(i)Definition of ‘books’ amended to include e-books and other digi-

tised information.
(ii) Definition of ‘library services’ created to include providing digital
literacy, access to computers and internet connectivity.
If digital initiatives, whether by providing access to ICT or providing

digital content are initiated, they must be incorporated in tandem
with the physical public libraries to ensure that the community
development and social aspect of libraries is maintained.
236 Karishma Hingorani, ‘Over 1 Lakh Rare Books, 2,500 Manuscripts Set To Be Digitised’ (The Hindu, March 2016) <https://www.the-
hindu.com/news/cities/mumbai/over-1-lakh-rare-books-2500-manuscripts-set-to-be-digitised/article7519164.ece> accessed 9
February 2022.
237 Maharashtra Government Resolution dated 27 May 2021 <https://www.maharashtra.gov.in/Site/Upload/Government%20Resolu-
tions/English/202105271459342608.pdf?> accessed 9 February 2022.
56
X Accessibility of Public Library
Services to Persons With Disabilities
Persons with disabilities (“PwDs”) face significant barriers in accessing knowl-

edge. Particularly, research has shown that people with disabilities find it dif-
ficult to seek and search information.238 Public libraries have the unique role
and responsibility of equalising access to information and resources to people
who might not otherwise have access.239 Therefore, ensuring accessibility to
everyone in the community, and especially persons with disability, should be
fundamental to the very concept of a public library.
For persons with disabilities, public libraries could ideally serve as a space
to be part of their community. Public libraries should also provide opportunities
for persons with disabilities to engage in community activities. Such engage-
ments are crucial for PwDs to overcome the disability induced social isola-
tion.240,241 However, public libraries often fail to meet these accessibility needs,
and therefore can be intimidating and uncomfortable spaces for them. There
are many studies which highlight the barriers faced by persons with disabilities
in accessing library resources in India.242 In most instances, public libraries are
unable to fulfil their obligations as set out under the Rights of Persons with
Disabilities Act, 2016 (“PWD Act”).243
Guidelines under the PWD Act
The PWD Act is a landmark legislation enacted by the central government

enshrining the rights of persons with disabilities. The PWD Act mandatorily
requires the government to make all the public buildings and infrastructure
accessible to PwDs.244 Accordingly, the Rights of Persons with Disabilities
Rules, 2017 (“2017 Rules”) states that the accessibility standards for public
buildings should adhere to the Harmonised Guidelines and Space Standards for
Barrier Free Built Environment for Persons with Disabilities and Elderly Persons
(“Harmonised Guidelines”) issued by the Ministry of Urban Development.245
238 Gerd Berget and Andrew MacFarlane, ‘What is known about the impact of impairments on information seeking and searching?’
(2020) 71(5) Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology 596-611.
239 Russell SE and Huang J, “Libraries’ Role in Equalizing Access to Information” (Library Management, January 2009) <https://www.
emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/01435120910927538/full/html> accessed February 09, 2022
240 Joanne Kaeding, ‘Opening Access To Public Libraries For Children With Special Needs & Their Families’ (2015) <https://apo.org.
au/sites/default/files/resource-files/2015-10/apo-nid60694.pdf> accessed 9 February 2022.
241 Suresh Solanki and Shishir Mandaliya, ‘Enhancing Library Resources Access for Different Abled Persons Through ICT’ (2016)
6(1/2) International Journal of Information Science and Techniques 257.
242 KP Singh and Easther Moirangthem, ‘Are Indian Libraries VIP-Friendly? Information Use and Information Seeking Behaviour of
Visually Impaired People in Delhi Libraries’ (2010) 374 Library Philosophy and Practice 1-14.
243 ‘Case Registered Against Thiruvananthapuram Public Library For Not Making Building Disabled-Friendly’ (The New Indi-
an Express, December 2021) <https://www.newindianexpress.com/cities/thiruvananthapuram/2021/dec/08/case-regis-
tered-against-thiruvananthapuram-public-library-for-not-makingbuilding-disabled-friendly-2392917.html> accessed 9 Febru-
ary 2022.
244 Rights of Persons With Disability Act, s 40 and s 45.
245 Rights of Persons with Disability Rules 2017, rule 15.
57
The Harmonised Guidelines lay down standards with regard to the design,
planning, and construction of accessible spaces and buildings to optimise
independent access to PwDs.246 With regards to libraries the Harmonised
Guidelines provide the following three suggestions:
1. All open book stacks should be accessible

2. All library facilities and equipment should be accessible
3. A special room should be provided for people with hearing and vision
impairment who need assistance while reading.247
A bare perusal of the above suggestions laid down in the Harmonised

Guidelines shows that the central government has conceptualised access
to public libraries for persons with disabilities in a generic sense. Particularly,
the government has failed to lay down the specific ways and means by which
public libraries could be made accessible to persons with disabilities not just
physically, but also virtually, intellectually, sensorily, emotionally, and psycho-
logically.248 Therefore, even if the public libraries fail to design disabled friendly
libraries, the law is not robust enough to hold them accountable.
Case study on accessibility: The Sweden Library Act, 2013
In 2013, Sweden enacted the Public Libraries Act (“Swedish Act”)

to establish a framework for regulating its public library system. The
Swedish Act was enacted with an overarching aim of promoting the
‘development of democratic society by contributing to the transfer of
knowledge and the free formation of opinions.’249 In pursuance of this
aim, the Swedish Act considers universal access to knowledge and
information as an essential precondition for the development of demo-
cratic society.250 In this light, the Swedish Act has incorporated certain
provisions to prioritise the needs of PwDs, particularly section 4 which
states as follow:
‘The libraries in the public library system shall devote particular atten-
tion to persons with disabilities, including by offering, based on the
varying needs and prerequisites of such persons, literature and assis-
tive technology so that they are able to gain access to information.’251
246 Harmonised Guidelines and Space Standards for Barrier Free Built Environment for Persons with Disability and Elderly Persons,
February (2016) <https://cpwd.gov.in/publication/harmonisedguidelinesdreleasedon23rdmarch2016.pdf> accessed 9 February
2022.
247 ibid 16.
248 Kaeding (n 240).
249 The Sweden Public Libraries Act 2014, s 2.
250 Promoting the development of democratic society: The Swedish library act according to the legislator (2015, Swedish Library
Association) available at: <https://naple.eu/?mdocs-file=90> accessed 17 February 2022.
251 The Sweden Public Libraries Act 2014, s 4.
58
Re-designing the Maharashtra Public Libraries Act, 1967
As things currently stand, Maharashtra does not account for PwDs as one of
the important stakeholders in the public library system in the state. This is
largely evident in the MPLA as well as the 2017 Rules framed thereunder. In
comparison, many other states like Goa have enacted public libraries legisla-
tion with a specified aim to promote and develop library services for the PwDs
in the state. 252
The MPLA and the 1970 Rules would need to be amended to make rec-
ognition of public libraries conditional upon the accessibility of their buildings,
services, and materials. This would provide an added financial incentive to the
libraries to make their infrastructure accessible to be eligible for various gov-
ernment grants. Public libraries already recognised under the MPLA should
be assessed for existing levels of accessibility, and should be provided with
a time-frame to meet the accessibility needs to keep their recognition valid.
However, in their endeavour to become accessible, the public libraries across
the state would require significant financial support from the government.
suggestions Expand the definition of ‘books’ under the MPLA to include docu-
ments in all accessible formats such as braille, large prints, audio
recordings, and electronic formats.
Obligate the Directorate of Libraries under section 9 of the MPLA

to ensure that all the public libraries in the state are planned and
designed to become accessible.
Amend the MPLA and the 1970 Rules to make recognition of public
libraries conditional upon the accessibility of their buildings, ser-
vices, and materials. For this, additional funding should be provided
to the libraries.
In addition to amending the MPLA, the government may consider the following:
suggestions Web accessibility and maintenance

In Maharashtra, the State Central Library as well as most district
libraries maintain online websites providing information about the
history of the library, book collection, photo and video gallery, as
well as an online public access catalogue (“OPAC”). However, the
websites are not accessible for PwDs as per the standards laid
down by World Wide Web Consortium’s (“W3C”) Web Content
Accessibility (“WCA”) Guidelines.253 Therefore, to make the website
252 Goa Public Libraries Act 1993, s 3; Arunachal Pradesh Public Libraries Act 2009, s 3.
253 W3C (WAI), ‘WCAG 2 Overview’ (Web Accessibility Initiative (WAI)) <https://www.w3.org/WAI/standards-guidelines/wcag/> ac-
59
accessible, the government of Maharashtra must ensure that all
the state library and district library websites, including the OPAC
databases, are in compliance with the WCA Guidelines.
Staff awareness
Librarians and staff members in public libraries across Maharash-
tra must be given proper training to respectfully and appropriately
interact with PwD users. In this regard, the government should
prescribe a set of guidelines for librarians and staff members
on properly interacting with PwDs and sensitise them about the
accessibility needs of the PwDs. Understanding of the PWD Act
as well as the basic characteristics of the disabilities will help the
library staff respond appropriately to the needs of the PwD users.
Hiring persons with disabilities as well as providing scholarships
to PwDs to pursue degrees in library science will ensure inclusivity
within library staff as well.
Physical environment of the library

The physical environment, that is the infrastructure and furniture,
in the public libraries must be designed and developed consider-
ing the accessibility needs of the PwDs. This includes improve-
ments such as ramps for wheelchairs both for entering and within
the library, non-slip surfaces, adequate lighting, indicative braille
signages, adjustable desks and chairs, among others. The IFLA
has already laid down detailed guidelines aimed at making public
libraries accessible to PwDs.254 It is suggested that the Maharash-
tra government should also issue similar binding guidelines on
accessibility to all the public libraries in the state.
Library offerings and services

In light of the PWD Act, it is incumbent upon the public libraries
to put considerable effort into development of a technological
learning environment for PwD users and patrons. Information and
communication technology has transformed the nature of library
services across the globe. However, it has been observed that the
PwDs are at a severe disadvantage in terms of accessing these
technologies at public libraries.255
Public libraries should make provision of assistive technolo-
gies such as electronic text and image magnifiers, screen readers,
personal reading machines, closed-circuit television enhancers,
assistive listening systems, and braille translation softwares. These
254 Birgitta Irval and Gyda Skat Nielsen, ‘Access To Libraries For Persons With Disabilities - CHECKLIS’ (International Federation of
Library Associations and Institutions) <https://archive.ifla.org/VII/s9/nd1/iflapr-89e.pdf> accessed 9 February 2022.
255 V O Ekwelem, ‘Library services to the disabled students in the digital era: Challenges for outcome assessment’ (2013) 970
Library Philosophy and Practice 4.
60
assistive technologies should be in addition to other basic assis-
tive technologies, viz. large print books, audio books, audio news-
papers, audio magazines, braille books, descriptive DVDs, and
similar assistive tools.
Marketing materials
Marketing of the library services, especially the accessible ser-
vices, is necessary if public libraries want to expand their services
to PwDs. Most PwDs in India are unaware about the assistive tech-
nologies adopted by public libraries, and therefore, do not visit the
local public libraries. Public libraries should make utmost efforts
to inform the general public as well the PwDs through marketing
campaigns about accessible services offered by them. Further,
such information should also be prominently displayed on library
websites and through newspaper advertisements and brochures.
61
XI Conclusion
The MPLA provides the structure for the governance of public libraries in
Maharashtra but does not envision the transformative role that public librar-
ies can play as community spaces providing educational, literary, cultural and
overall societal development.
Many states, such as Tamil Nadu and Punjab have constituted public
library committees to suggest amendments or create modeern public library
legislations.256,257 The Maharashtra government also constituted the Rathod
Committee in 2019 which provided a report to the government (not available
publicly) but no amendments suggested by the Rathod Committee were intro-
duced in the MPLA. It is evident from news reports and our reading of the Act
and its rules that there are still considerable changes required to be introduced
in the MPLA.
To summarise, our main suggestions are as follows:
As a priority, the creation of a baseline of public library service

standards for existing libraries under the MPLA.
Library services created should include web-based and physi-

cal accessibility provisions for disabled people, the promotion of
reading habits, literature production, and provisions of books for
all ages. Furthermore, considering the present digital age, libraries
should also offer programs on basic digital literacy and access to
ICT services (computers and internet connection).
Libraries should not just be considered storehouses of books but

also act as a community space for attending plays, meetings, and
cultural celebrations.
Libraries can conduct surveys of their members or engage with

projects within their community to better understand the expecta-
tions that the community has from libraries in the present day.
Public libraries can also play an important rule during this (or any
future) pandemic. Traditional libraries can provide their books to
mobile libraries to be distributed across the community. Addi-
tionally, to those who cannot directly access resources, libraries
256 T. Ramakrishnan, ‘Public Libraries Act, Rules to be revisited’ (The Hindu, January 2022) <https://www.thehindu.com/news/nation-
al/tamil-nadu/public-libraries-act-rules-to-be-revisited/article38326409.ece> accessed 9 February 2022.
257 Navrajdeep Singh (n 173).
62
can double as information resource centres that impart important
information on government initiatives and also provide assistance
to connect to any resources, if required.
Achieving this goal would require addressing the shortage of qualified staff
and lack of adequate funding. This can be addressed through:
Creating rules under the MPLA that detail the qualifications of all
staff, service requirements and remuneration offered to them.
Incentivising library professionals to become part of the public

library system in the state by increasing salaries and regularising
staff such that they are government employees as per the ‘Maha-
rashtra State Library Service’.
Increasing funds for public libraries in Maharashtra in a two-fold

manner, first, by allocating a percentage of the Higher and Techni-
cal Education Department’s Budget for public libraries and second,
allocating a percentage of a pre-existing tax such as revenue or
property tax for library development. Additionally, cess as a sur-
charge can also be imposed on revenue or property tax.
Ensuring that additional sources of revenue, such as sending

proposals to RRRLF for the establishment of children, citizens and
senior citizen corners are tapped into for improving public library
services. The Directorate should also encourage donations to the
Library Fund.
Functioning of the public library authorities in the state also require

amendments:
Reducing the number of members who are part of the SLC to

improve its functioning and efficiency.
Empowering DLCs to ensure the establishment of libraries in the

state.
Providing the Directorate and the district libraries with clear provi-
sions to conduct regular inspections, surveys and audits of public
libraries in the state.
Ensuring interaction between Panchayat members and public

library authorities by including them as members of the DLCs in
their district.
63
Therefore, substantial changes will be required under the MPLA to recreate a
community service or space of relevance for the public today.
A survey and audit of all libraries, including a survey of

the employees and users of public libraries in Maha-
Way rashtra can be conducted on the basis of the recom-
Forward mendations laid down in this report. A subsequent
detailed policy document can be created based on
the findings of these surveys.
64
Annexe of the
Maharashtra
Public Libraries
Act, 1967
65
MAHARASHTRA ACT No. XXXIV OF 19671 1
[THE MAHARASHTRA PUBLIC LIBRARIES ACT, 1967]
[20th December 1967]
Amended by Mah. 11 of 1998.
,, ,, Mah. 27 of 2005.
AnAct to provide for the establishment, maintenance, organisation and development of
public libraries in the State of Maharashtra.
WHEREAS, it is expedient to provide for the establishment, maintenance,
organisation and development of public libraries, in the State of Maharashtra and for
purposes connected with the matters aforesaid; It is hereby enacted in the Eighteenth
Year of the Republic of India as follows :—
CHAPTER I
PRELIMINARY
1. (1) This Act may be called the Maharashtra Public Libraries Act, 1967. Short title,
extent and
(2) It extends to the whole of the State of Maharashtra. commence-
(3) It shall come into force on such date2 as the State Government may, by notification ment.
in the Official Gazette, appoint in that behalf; and different dates may be appointed for
bringing this Act into force in different areas of this State.
2. In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires,— Definitions.
(i) “book” includes every volume, part or division of a volume and pamphlet in any
language, and every sheet of music, map, chart or plan separately printed or
lithographed, newspapers, periodicals, paintings, films, slides, discs or tapes used for
audio-visual information and such other materials ;
(ii) “Committee” means a Library Committee appointed under section 13 ;
(iii) “compensatory allowance” means the travelling allowance, the daily allowance
or such other allowance which is paid to the members of the Council or Committee
for the purpose of meeting the personal expenditure incurred by them in attending
the meetings of such Council or Committee or in performing any other functions as
such members for the purposes of this Act ;
(iv) “Council” means the State Library Council constituted under section 3 ;
(v) “Director” means the Director of Libraries appointed under section 8 ;
(vi) “district” means a revenue district ;
Mah. 3
[(vii) “Division” means a revenue division specified under clause (i) of sub-section
XLI
of (1) of section 4 of the Maharashtra Land Revenue Code, 1966 ;]
1966. (viii) “municipal corporation” means a municipal corporation constituted under
Bom. the 4[Mumbai] Municipal Corporation Act or the *Bombay Provincial Municipal
III of
1888. Corporations Act, 1949 or the † City of Nagpur Corporation Act, 1948 ;
Bom.
LIX of
1949.
C. P.
&
Berar
II of
1950.
1
For Statement of Objects and Reasons, see Maharashtra Government Gazette, 1967, Part V, Extra, Page 144.
2
1st day of May 1968 (in the whole State)-(vide G. N., E. & S. W. D., No. LIB-2567-A, dated 27th April 1968).
3
Clause (vii) was substituted by Mah. 11 of 1998, s. 2 (a).
4
This word was substituted for the word “Bombay”, ibid, s. 2 (b).
* The short title of this Act was amended as “the Maharashtra Municipal Corporation Act” by Mah. 23
of 2012, s. 4.
† This Act was repealed, ibid, s. 7.
66
2 Maharashtra Public Libraries Act, 1967 [1967 : Mah. XXXIV
2
[(ix) “Municipal Council” means a Municipal Council constituted or deemed to be Mah.
constituted under the Maharashtra Municipal Councils, Nagar Punchayats and XL
Industrial Townships Act, 1965 ;] of
1965.
(x) “prescribed” means prescribed by rules made under this Act ;
(xi) “public library” means,—
(a) a library established and maintained by the State Government for the use of the
public ;
(b) a library recognised by the Director for the purposes of grant-in-aid from the
Library Fund; and
(c) any other library which the State Government by notification in the
Official Gazette declares to be a public library for the purposes of this Act;
(xii) “year ” means the financial year.
CHAPTER II
STATE LIBRARY COUNCIL
Constitution 3. (1) As soon as may be, after the commencement of this Act, the State Government
of State shall, by notification in the Official Gazette, constitute for the purposes of this Act a Council
Library to be called the State Library Council.
Council.
(2) The Council shall consist of the following members, that is to say,–
(i) the Minister for 2[Higher and Technical Education,] who shall be ex-officio
President of the Council;
(ii) the 3[Minister of State for Higher and Technical Education,] who shall be
ex-officio Vice-President of the Council;
4
[(iii) the Principal Secretary or Secretary to the Government of Maharashtra,
Higher and Technical Education Department ;]
(iv) the Charity Commissioner or his nominee not below the rank of Assistant
Charity Commissioner;
(v) 5[ the Director of Higher Education,] Maharashtra State for the time being in
office;
6
[(vi) two members of the Maharashtra Legislative Assembly nominated by the
Speaker of the Maharashtra Legislative Assembly;
(vii) one member of the Maharashtra Legislative Council nominated by the
Chairman of the Maharashtra Legislative Council;]
(viii) one person nominated by the State Government to represent Municipal
Corporations functioning in the State of Maharashtra;
(ix) one person nominated by the State Government to represent 7[Municipal
Councils] functioning in each of the Divisions;
1.
This clause was substituted by Mah. 11 of 1998, s. 2 (c).
2.
These words were substituted for the words “the Minister for Education of the State,’’ ibid., s. 3(a).
3.
These words were substituted for the words “the Deputy Minister for Education of the State,’’ibid., s. 3(b).
4.
This clause was substituted, ibid., s. 3(c).
5.
These words were substituted for the words “the Director of Education,’’ ibid., s. 3 (d).
6.
These clauses were substituted by Mah. 27 of 2005.
7.
These words were substituted for the word “ Municipalities’’ by Mah.11 of 1998, s.3 (e).
67
1967 : Mah. XXXIV ] Maharashtra Public Libraries Act, 1967 3
(x) one member from each Division nominated by the State Government to
represent the Zilla Parishads functioning in that Division;
(xi) the President of the body known as the Maharashtra Rajya Granthalaya
Sangha;
(xii) one member nominated by the said Maharashtra Rajya Granthalaya
Sangha from each Division to represent that Division;
Bom. (xiii) the Chairman of the body known as the Sahitya Mahamandal, a Society
XXIX registered under the *Bombay Public Trusts Act, 1950;
of
1950.
(xiv) four members nominated by the State Government from amongst persons
who, in its opinion, have special knowledge or interest or practical experience in mat-
ters connected with library service;
(xv) the Director of Libraries who shall also be the Secretary of the Council.
(3) A person so elected under paragraphs (vi) and (vii) of sub-section (2) shall cease
to be a member of the Council if he cease to be a member of the Maharashtra Legislative
Assembly or the Maharshtra Legislative Council.
4. It shall be the function of the Council to advise the State Government on all matters Function of
connected with the administration of this Act. Council.
5. (1) Save as otherwise provided in this Act, at the members of the Council, not being Term of
members ex-officio, shall hold office for a term of three years commencing on the date office of,
on which the first meeting of the Council is held after the nomination of the members under and
sub-section (2) of section 3. allowances
to members
(2) The members of the Council shall be entitled to such compensatory allowances and of Council.
at such rates as may be prescribed.
6. A vacancy in the office of a nominated or elected member of the Council occurring Casual
otherwise than by efflux of time shall be filled by nomination or election, as the case may be, vacancies
and the person nominated or elected to fill the vacancy shall hold office only for the remain- in Council.
der of the term for which the member whose place he takes was nominated or elected.
7. (1) The Council shall meet not less than twice in every year, on such dates and at Meetings of
such hours as may be fixed by the President; and six months shall not intervene between two Council.
successive meetings.
(2) The President of the Council may, whenever he thinks fit, and shall, upon the written
request of not less than one-third of the total number of members of the Council, and on a
date not later than thirty days after the receipt of such request, call a special meeting of the
Council.
(3) One-third of the total number of members of the Council shall form the quorum.
(4) The Council shall transact business in such manner and in accordance with such
procedure as may be prescribed.
CHAPTER III.
DEPARTMENT OF LIBRARIES.
8. (1) For the purposes of this Act, a Department of Libraries shall be constituted by Depart-
the State Government with a Director of Libraries as its head and with such other officers and ment of
servants as the State Government may think fit. Libraries.
(2) The State Government shall appoint a whole-time officer having the prescribed
qualifications to be the Director of Libraries.
*
The short title of the Act was amended as “the Maharashtra Public Trust Act” by Mah. 24 of 2012
entry 43, w.e.f. 1-5-1960.
68
Functions 9. (1) Subject to the superintendence, direction and control of the State Government,
of Director.
the Director shall be responsible for the administration of this Act.
(2) In particular, and without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing provision, the
Director shall—
(a) be responsible for the planning, maintenance, organisation and development of
public libraries and public library system;
(b) superintend and direct all matters relating to public libraries;
(c) promote the establishment of public libraries to achieve the purposes of this Act;
(d) recognise, in accordance with the rules made under this Act, public libraries and
State, Divisional and other public library associations for the purposes of grant-in-aid
from the Library Fund and sanction and disburse grants to them ;
(e) maintain accounts of the Library Fund and ensure its proper utilisation;
(f) publish annually a bibliography of all the books published in the State;
(g) submit to the State Government every year, a report on the working of public
libraries under this Act;
(h) collect and preserve old and rare books, periodicals, manuscripts and other docu-
ments of educative value in public libraries;
(i) organise programme for training candidates in library science and conduct
examinations for the candidates of recognised library training courses; and
(j) exercise such other powers and perform such other duties as may be conferred or
imposed on him by rules made under this Act.
State Library 10. (1) The State Government shall establish a Maharashtra State Library Service, and
Service. appoint persons thereto.
(2) The Maharashtra State Library Service shall consist of such classes and categories
of posts as the State Government may from time to time determine. All members of the said
service shall be Government servants and their recruitment and conditions of service shall
be regulated by such rules as may be made by the State Government from time to time.
(3) The salaries, allowances, gratuity, pension and other emoluments of the members of
the Maharashtra State Library Service, shall be paid from the Consolidated Fund of the
State.
CHAPTER IV.
PUBLIC LIBRARIES.
Establish- 11. (1) The State Government may establish a State Central Library for the whole of
ment and the State, and a Divisional Library for every Division.
maintenance
of public (2) Where in any local area, provision for library service to the public is not made to the
libraries. satisfaction of the Director by any local authority, or any society registered under the
Societies Registration Act, 1860 or any trust registered under the * Bombay Public Trusts XXI
Act, 1950 or where the State Government is of the opinion that any such local authority, of
1860.
society or trust is not willing or is incompetent to provide library service to the public to the Bom.
satisfaction of the Director in any local area, the State Government may establish a library for XXIX
the use of the public in that area: of
1950.
Provided that, no such library shall be established without giving an opportunity to the
local authority, society or, as the case may be, the trust to show cause why the State
Government should not establish a library in the said local area.
*
The short title of the Act was amended as “the Maharashtra Public Trust Act” by Mah. 24 of 2012, Sch.,
entry 43, w.e.f. 1-5-1960.
69
(3) All libraries established under this section shall be maintained, organised and
developed by the State Government through the Department of Libraries.
12. The functions of the public libraries shall be such as may, on the advice of the Funactions
Council, be prescribed. of public
libraries.
CHAPTER V.
LIBRARY COMMITTEES.
13. (1) For every district, the State Government shall appoint a District Library Constitution
Committee. of Library
Committees.
(2) The Committee shall consist of the following members, that is to say,––
(i) The Chairman for the time being of the Education Committee of a Zilla Parishad
functioning in the district, who shall be ex-officio President of the Committee;
(ii) the President of the District Library Association of the district (if any);
(iii) one of the Chairman of the Managing Committees of recognised public libraries
functioning in each taluka of the district nominated by the State Government;
(iv) five persons nominated by the State Government, one of whom shall be a librarian
possessing the prescribed qualifications and two shall be persons representing libraries
in the areas within the limits of a 1[Municipal Council] or municipal corporation in the
district;
(v) one of the Presidents of the municipalities in the district nominated by the State
Government;
(vi) the Education Officer for the time being of the Zilla Parishad functioning in the
district, who shall also be ex-officio Secretary of the Committee.
(3) The State Government shall appoint a Library Committee for 2[Brihan Mumbai]
consisting of ––
(i) the Chairman for the time being of the Education Committee of the municipal
corporation of 2[Brihan Mumbai] who shall be the ex-officio President of the Committee;
(ii) five persons nominated by the State Government one of whom shall be a librarian
possessing the prescribed qualifications and two shall be persons representing libraries
in 2[Brihan Mumbai];
(iii) Education Officer for the time being of the municipal corporation of
[Brihan Mumbai];
2
(iv) Educational Inspector, 2[Brihan Mumbai], who shall also be the ex-officio
Secretary of the Committee.
14. (1) Save as otherwise provided in this Act, the nominated members of the Term of
Committee shall hold office for a term of three years commencing on the date on which the office
and allow-
first meeting of the Committee is held after their nomination. ances to,
members of
(2) The members of the Committee shall entitled to such compensatory allowances and Committee.
at such rates as may be presribed.
1.
These words were substituted for the word “ Municipality ” by Mah. 11 of 1998, s. 4(a).
2.
These words were substituted for the words “ Greater Bombay”, ibid, s. 4(b).
70
Casual 15. A vacancy in the office of a nominated member of the Committee occurring other-
vacancies in
Committee.
wise than by efflux of time shall be filled by nomination and the person nominated to fill the
vacancy shall hold office only for the remainder of the term for which the member whose
place he takes was nominated.
Functions of 16. It shall be the function of a Committee,—
Committee.
(i) to advise the State Government on all matters relating to development of library
service in the district or, as the case may be, 1[Brihan Mumbai] on proper lines;
(ii) to ensure that the prescribed function of the public libraries are performed by
them satisfactorily; and
(iii) to perform such other duties as may be prescribed.
Manner of 17. The Committee shall transact business in such manner, and in accordance with such
transaction
of business
procedure, as may be prescribed.
by
Committee.
CHAPTER VI.
FINANCE and ACCOUNTS
Library 18. (1) The State Government shall constitute a fund called the Library Fund.
Fund.
(2) The Library Fund shall consist of—
(a) contribution made by the State Government under section 20;
(b) any special grants given by the State Government under section 21;
(c) any grants given by the Government of India to State Government for develop-
ment of public libraries; and
(d) any contributions or gifts made by the public for devlopment of public libraries.
Application 19. (1) The moneys in the Library Fund shall be utilized by the State Government for
of Library carrying out the purposes of this Act.
Fund.
(2) Without prejudice to the generality of sub-section (1), the moneys in the Library
Fund may be utilized by the State Government to defray expenditure on the following :—
(a) establishment, maintenance and development of public libraries;
(b) compensatory allowances payable to members of the Council and of the
Committee ;
(c) grants-in-aid to public libraries and library associations recognised for the
purpose by the Director of Libraries.
Contribution 20. The State Government shall, after due appropriation made by law in this behalf,
by State contribute to the Library Fund every year, a sum not less than twenty-five lakhs of
Government.
rupees.
Special 21. The State Government may make special grants to the Library Fund.
grants by
State
Government.
1.
These words were substituted for the words “ Greater Bombay ”, by Mah. 11 of 1998, s. 5.
71
22. All property, movable and immovable, acquired or held for the purpose of any Vesting of
public library maintained by the State Government shall vest in the State Government. properties
held for
purpose of
Government
public
libraries.
CHAPTER VII.
REPORTS AND INSPECTION.
23. Every person who is in charge of the management of a public library shall submit Reports and
such reports and returns and furnish such information as the Director may from time to time returns.
require, to the Director or any person authorised by him in this behalf.
24. The Director or any person authorised by him in this behalf shall have power Inspection
to inspect any public library or any institution attached thereto for the purpose of of public
libraries.
satisfying himself that the provisions of this Act and the rules made thereunder are
carried out.
25. Within six months from the end of every year, the Director shall prepare an Submission
annual report on the progress made by public libraries in that year and submit it to the of annual
report by
State Government together with such information and particulars as may be Director.
prescribed :
Provided that, no such report shall be submitted to the State Government unless it is
approved by the Council.
CHAPTER VIII.
MISCELLANEOUS.
26. (1) The State Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette, and subject Rules.
to the condition of previous publication, make rules to carry out the purposes of this Act.
(2) In particular, and without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing power, such
rules may provide for all or any of the following matters, namely :—
(i) under sub-section (2) of section 5 and sub-section (2) of section 14, the compen-
satory allowances payable to members of the Council and of the Committees and the rates
at which such allowances shall be payable;
(ii) under sub-section (4) of section 7 and section 17, the manner in which and the
procedure in accordance with which the Council and a Committee shall transact their
business;
(iii) under sub-section (2) of section 8, the qualifications required for being
appointed as the Director;
(iv) under clause (d) of sub-section (2) of section 9, rules in accordance with which
the Director shall recognize public libraries and State, Divisional and other public library
associations for the purposes of grant-in-aid from the Library Fund;
(v) under clause (i) of sub-section (2) of section 9, the other powers and duties
which the Director may exercise or perform;
72
(vi) under sub-section (2) of section 10, the requirement and conditions of service of
members of the Maharashtra State Library Service;
(vii) under section 12, the functions of public libraries;

(viii) under section 13, the qualifications of a librarian to be nominated on a
Committee;
(ix) under section 25, the information and particulars to be submitted to the State
Government.
(3) Every rule made under this section shall be laid as soon as may be after it is made
before each House of the State Legislature while it is in session for a total period of thirty
days which may be comprised in one session or in two successive sessions, and if before the
expiry of the session, in which, it is so laid or the session immediately following, both Houses
agree in making any modification in the rule or both Houses agree that the rule should not be
made, and notify such decision in the Official Gazette, the rule shall, from the date of
publication of such notification, have effect only in such modified form or be of no effect, as
the case may be; so however that any such modification or annulment shall be without
prejudice to the validity of anything previously done or omitted to be done under that rule.
1
[* * *]
1.
Schedule was deleted by Mah. 11 of 1998, s. 6.
PRENTED AT THE GOVERNMENT PRESS, NAGPUR.
73
www.vidhilegalpolicy.in
Vidhi Centre for Legal Policy
A-232, Block A, Defence Colony,
New Delhi 110024
011-43102767
[email protected]
74

Vidhi-MH Public-Libraries

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Vidhi-MH Public-Libraries

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Vidhi-MH Public-Libraries

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Putting the

Dr. Rahela Khorakiwala is Senior Resident Fellow and

The authors are grateful to the anonymous peer

The authors are also grateful to Sneha Yanappa,

For conversations that helped framing this report we

The authors are thankful to Vistasp Irani, Research

Any errors are the authors’ alone.

7 Library Committees and their

8 Structure of the Maharashtra 20 Directorate of Libraries

30 Funding of libraries as per the

Maharashtra has a rich history of public libraries run by the government as

According to the International Federation of Library Associations and Institu-

The erstwhile Government of Bombay appointed a Committee in 1939 under

Structure of The Maharashtra Public Libraries Act, 1967

The government of Maharashtra enacted the MPLA in 1967 to bring consis-

Type of Public About the Public Library

Government-run • Governed in accordance with the MPLA.

Grant-in-aid • Governed in accordance with the MPLA.

Research or • Governed in accordance with the MPLA.

▲ Information on public libraries in the state

In this report we will address reforms required for government-run pub-

▲ Number of public libraries in Maharashtra

Inferring from multiple sources, it appears that Maharashtra encompasses

▲ Percentage of public libraries in Maharashtra compared to the rest of the country

▲ Percentage of the types of libraries in Maharashtra

In Maharashtra, the Aurangabad division records the highest number of grant-

4050 1587 1902

2969 1055 586

▲ Division wise break up of grant-in-aid libraries in Maharashtra40

38 No.of public libraries in different States and Union Territories (n 31).

▲ Percentage of grant-in-aid libraries in each division

Establishment of public libraries

Section 11 of the MPLA:

41 Library And Information Science (E-pathshala) <https://epgp.inflibnet.ac.in/epgpdata/uploads/epgp_content/S000021LI/

Despite such a responsibility being placed on the state government,

In 2017, ‘Bhilar pustakancha gaav’, India’s first ‘village of books’ was

suggestions Recognise the responsibility placed on the state government under

Create library villages in Maharashtra using the example of the

Ensure that data on the number and types of libraries is updated

Definition of libraries or library services in the MPLA

51 राज्य सरकारकडूनच ‘गाव तिथे ग्रंथालय’ योजना बासनात’ (n 46).

“public library” means,—

suggestions Based on legislation from other states or on the guidelines pro-

Amend section 11 of the MPLA to ensure that the government is

Other types of libraries

65 Rule 4 of the 1970 Rules.

Rule 15 of 1970 Rules:

Circulating Library. - A public library shall not be classified as a “Cir-

While no circulating libraries are currently being provided money under

71 Sri Hanshu Advani, Maharashtra Legislative Assembly Debate (1967) 168-170.

suggestion Amend the MPLA to include a section on the creation of different

77 ‘About Department’ (Department of Public Libraries Karnataka) <https://dpl.karnataka.gov.in/info-1/About+Department/en>

In 1959, the Advisory Committee under the chairmanship of K. P. Sinha sug-

▲ Data provided by the Directorate of Libraries on the number of offices in the

The Directorate is entrusted with the responsibility of developing and

Section 9(2) of the MPLA:

In particular, and without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing

82 ‘Functions Of DOL (n 24).

Section 24 of the MPLA: