EJ1376585
EJ1376585
EJ1376585
December 2022
Malka S. Moya
Brigham Young University - Provo, [email protected]
Recommended Citation
Caldarella, P., & Moya, M. S. (2022). Reported Benefits of Yoga in Middle Schools: A Review of the
Literature. Middle Grades Review, 8(3). https://scholarworks.uvm.edu/mgreview/vol8/iss3/4
This Research is brought to you for free and open access by the College of Education and Social Services at UVM
ScholarWorks. It has been accepted for inclusion in Middle Grades Review by an authorized editor of UVM
ScholarWorks. For more information, please contact [email protected].
Reported Benefits of Yoga in Middle Schools: A Review of the Literature
Abstract
Middle school is a time of adjustments in youth: physical, intellectual, and social changes often
result in stress. Middle school students are vulnerable to academic, behavioral, and mental health
problems. Yoga is an Indian discipline practiced for health and relaxation. School-based yoga
programs are becoming increasingly common given their potential benefits for students. We
conducted a literature review of studies of middle school-based yoga programs, focusing on the
reported benefits for students. We identified and retrieved 12 studies from electronic databases
including Education Resources Information Center, PsycINFO, and Google Scholar that met
inclusion criteria: (a) examined the benefits of yoga as the primary intervention conducted in a
middle school setting with students ages 10 to 15 years old, (b) was published by June 2022, (c) was
reviewed either by a journal editorial board or by a student’s dissertation or thesis committee, (d)
was available in English, and (e) a full text copy was available. Results of studies were synthesized
by clustering findings into common domains. Study results suggested that middle school-based
yoga interventions showed mental health, executive functioning, physical, social, and academic
benefits for students. Yoga also showed benefits for middle school students who were stressed,
anxious, or depressed, and those at risk. We provide considerations for those contemplating the
implementation of yoga in middle schools.
directions or may engage in other non- of Hindu scriptures. The Bhagavad Gita first
compliant behaviors (Hecker et al., 2014). refers to yoga as an unbiased balance between
two polarized ends of a spectrum. A second
Various mental health difficulties and definition refers to avoiding fixed mindsets in
emotional disorders also begin to emerge favor of malleable mindsets to achieve
during adolescence (McGorry et al., 2011). happiness. A third definition is that yoga is
During the transition to middle school, the highest state of fulfillment, resilient to
students often alter their friendship groups despair and bereavement.
and experience decreased general social
support (Evans et al., 2018). Merikangas et al. According to the Bhagavad Gita, yoga was
(2010) reported data from the National first introduced to the Eastern hemisphere in
Comorbidity Survey Replication-Adolescent the 1st millennium B.C. Yoga was brought to
Supplement indicating that anxiety disorders the West in the 1950s (Hammond, 2007).
were the most common (31.9%) during Priyadarshan (2018) notes several differences
adolescence, followed by behavior disorders between Eastern and Western orientations to
(19.1%), mood disorders (14.3%), and yoga. For example, in the East, yoga is seen as
substance use disorders (11.4%). The median an important part of the culture and as
age of onset for anxiety disorders was 6 years mentioned in the Bhagavad Gita has ties to
(with symptoms often persisting into middle everything from sustenance and nourishment
school years), 11 years for behavior disorders, to relationships with others. In the West, yoga
13 years for mood disorders, and 15 years for is often seen as another form of physical
substance use disorders. Such results show exercise. The East and West also differ in
the increasing prevalence of distress their approaches to meditation and
experienced by many middle school aged mindfulness. In the East, ample time is
adolescents. In fact, an estimated one-fourth naturally embedded into the day to allow for
of youth between the ages of 8 and 15 years yoga poses and quiet introspection. In the
have a mental health disorder: Unfortunately, West, yoga is often done at a set-aside time as
it is estimated that only about half receive a part of peoples’ busy days. Priyadarshan
treatment (Merikangas et al., 2009). goes on to note that in the East, people tend
to live more simply regarding their home, and
Changes and vulnerabilities during the apparel, and do more simplistic yoga
stressful middle school transition require postures. They may practice yoga alone or
varied school programs and opportunities. with only one other person. The West tends to
Schools are increasingly being asked to be more materialistic and focused on
provide initiatives targeting students’ social- appearances while practicing yoga. Yoga in
emotional competence, physical health, and the West is also viewed as more of a social
mental health (Diamond, 2010; Graham et event, with yearnings for challenging postures
al., 2011). An intervention that may benefit and more complex forms of practice such as
students is school-based yoga practice. The hot yoga. Hookham (2021) also points out
positive impact of yoga on adolescents has differences in the guru-student relationship
gained interest due to its increasing from East to West. In the East, a guru passes
popularity in the general population and an down traditional teachings to their students
increasing prevalence of school-based yoga to obtain spiritual awakening. The guru is
programs (Caldarella & Lulla, 2022; White, seen as a spiritual guide and the student will
2009). only achieve spiritual awakening if they open
their hearts and minds. In the West, the
Yoga relationship between student and yoga
teacher is more of a typical relationship
In ancient Indian philosophy, the term yoga between two individuals performing a
has held various meanings. A common business transaction or two casual friends.
meaning includes a mechanism of subduing
the mind and senses (Joshi, 1965). Yoga is There are different branches and styles of
referenced multiple times in the Bhagavad yoga each with distinct traditions and
Gita (Mitchell, 2007), one of the most sacred practices (Feuerstein, 2012). Yoga was
https://scholarworks.uvm.edu/mgreview/vol8/iss3/4 2
Caldarella and Moya: Benefits of Yoga in Middle Schools
originally practiced for relieving suffering research designs used were quasi-
(duhkha) and gaining liberation (moksha or experimental (n = 54%), experimental (n =
nirvana) or enlightenment (bodhi). Today in 27%), qualitative (n = 14%), and mixed
the West, yoga does not align to any belief methods (n = 4%). Caldarella and Lulla noted
system or religion, rather it is considered a that high school-based yoga programs
practice for fostering inner wellbeing showed promise in terms of their physical,
(Basavaraddi, 2015). Reasons for practicing social, academic, and mental health benefits
yoga often include maintaining fitness, for students. Yoga also showed benefits for
improving health, calming the mind, and students who were stressed, anxious, or
living meaningfully (Feuerstein, 2003). depressed, and those at risk for abusing
Contemporary yoga consists of a combination substances or dropping out of school.
of physical postures (asanas), breathing
techniques (pranayama), and meditation Purpose
(dyana) (National Center for Complementary
and Integrative Health, n.d.). There has yet to be a literature review
specifically examining the benefits of yoga
Yoga in Schools implementation in middle school settings.
Therefore, this review focused on the
Research suggests that there has been an reported benefits of middle school-based
increase in yoga practice among school-aged yoga programs for students and
youth. Black et al. (2018) found a significant considerations for those wishing to
increase in the use of yoga among children implement such programs.
ages 4–17 years in the US, increasing from
approximately 3% in 2012 to over 8% in 2017. Review Search Strategy
Khalsa and Butzer (2016) identified eight
school-based yoga publications from 2000 to Education Resources Information Center
2009, increasing to 39 from 2010 to 2015. (ERIC), PsycINFO, and Google Scholar
Most of these studies were conducted in databases were used to locate studies. A
elementary schools, followed by high schools, variety of search terms were used including
and fewer in middle schools. The authors adolescence, middle school, yoga, yoga
found wide variability in these studies. For intervention, and yoga program.
example, between 5 and 100 yoga sessions Quantitative, qualitative, and mixed-methods
were held; yoga ranged from 1 to 52 weeks; studies were included based on the following
and the duration of each yoga session ranged criteria: The study (a) examined the benefits
from 4 to 180 minutes. Khalsa and Butzer of yoga as the primary intervention
noted that school-based yoga research conducted in a middle or junior high school
appeared to be in the early stages as setting with students ages 10 to 15 years old;
evidenced by various study limitations such (b) was published by June 2022; (c) was
as small sample sizes, lack of randomization, reviewed either by a journal editorial board or
limited details about the intervention, and by a student’s dissertation or thesis
absence of control groups. committee; (d) was published in English; and
(e) a full text copy was available. We also
Caldarella and Lulla (2022) conducted a completed an ancestral search of all eligible
review of the reported benefits of high school- studies to locate additional sources.
based yoga programs and found a similar
increase in yoga studies. All 22 studies which Summary of Eligible Studies
met their inclusion criteria were published
since 2006, with the majority (60%) The 12 eligible studies reviewed in this paper,
published since 2013. Most studies (77%) as outlined in Table 1, were published
were conducted in the US with the remainder between 2001 and 2021.
conducted in India. The most common
Table 1
Bergen-Cico Quasi- 144 students in 6th Mindfulness Hatha Students in the yoga
et al. (2015) experimental grade at a middle yoga practiced 3 group demonstrated
school in Boston, times per week for 4 significant increases in
MA (yoga n = 72, min at the beginning both global and long-
control n = 72). of English language term self-regulation
50.5% female, arts class for compared to the control
predominantly approximately 6 group. Positive
White (57.5 %) and months. feedback from the
Asian (32.6 %). teacher and most
students regarding yoga
feasibility and effects.
Bhardwaj & Experimental 44 participants Yoga (breathing The yoga group showed
Agrawal (yoga n = 22, techniques, postures, a significant increase in
(2013) control n = 22) and relaxation the level of overall,
from a school in technique), or 35 general, and social self-
Haridwar, India minutes daily for six esteem.
ages ranged days a week for one
between 10 and 12 month.
years.
https://scholarworks.uvm.edu/mgreview/vol8/iss3/4 4
Caldarella and Moya: Benefits of Yoga in Middle Schools
Butzer, Qualitative 16 students in 7th Kripalu Yoga in the Students had positive
LoRusso, grade at a public School’s curriculum opinions of the effects
Windsor et school in Boston, practiced 1 to 2 times of yoga on stress, sleep,
al. (2017) MA. 50% female, per week for 35 min and relaxation, as well
predominantly integrated into generally positive
White (63%), Asian Physical Education opinions of yoga
(19%) and Black curriculum for helping with self-
(12%). approximately 6 regulation, social
months. interaction, substance
use, and academic
performance.
Frank et al. Experimental 159 students in 6th Transformative Life Students in the yoga
(2017) and 9th grades at a Skills (TLS) yoga group rated the
diverse, high curriculum taught in intervention positively
poverty inner city home room classes and showed significant
middle school in during 30-minute reductions in
CA. 53.5% male, sessions 3-4 unexcused absences
predominantly times/week for one and detentions, as well
Latino (54.2%), semester (18 weeks). as significant increases
mixed race in school engagement
(21.9%), and and positive stress
African American coping strategies,
(16.8%). emotion regulation, and
positive thinking.
Manjunath Experimental 20 girls between 10 One hour fifteen Yoga training improved
& Telles and 13 years of age, minutes per day executive functioning
(2001) studying at a seven days a week for by reducing planning
residential school one month of yoga and execution time in
were randomly (Asanas, Pranayama, simple as well as
assigned to two Kriyas, meditation, complex tasks and
groups Yoga (n = Bhajans, and facilitated reaching a
10) vs physical relaxation target with a smaller
training (n = 10) in techniques). number of moves in a
India. complex task.
McMahon Quasi- 119 students, ages 6-weeks, with two 40 Students in the yoga
et al. (2021) experimental 11–14 from after- min classes per week program reported
school programs of Kundalini yoga. significant decreases in
for middle school emotion dysregulation
students in North across the program.
Carolina (yoga n = Students in the yoga
52, control n = 66) program also reported
42.5% African significant decreases in
American, 24.2% anger, depression, and
Latinx, 15% White, fatigue over one yoga
10% Asian, 5.8% session. Students in the
Multi-Racial. comparison condition
only reported decreases
in fatigue over one
session of the
alternative activity.
Rangan et Quasi- 49 boys in India 3 hours daily for one Planning and executive
al. (2008) experimental with ages ranging year using the abilities were better
from 11 to 13 years Gurukula education using the Tower of
who were part of a system with London test at the start
yoga curriculum yogasanas, ablutions, and the end of an
were compared to puja, yogic games, academic year with the
49 other boys who and pranayama. yoga group than the
were not in yoga non-yoga group.
(98 students total).
https://scholarworks.uvm.edu/mgreview/vol8/iss3/4 6
Caldarella and Moya: Benefits of Yoga in Middle Schools
Two (17%) of the studies were published from Transformative Life Skills (TLS). Yoga classes
2001 and 2011 and 10 (83%) were published lasted an average of 58 min (range = 4 to 180
between 2012 and 2021. Seven of the studies min) and were held an average of 3 times per
(58%) were conducted in various parts of the week (range = 2 – 6) over an average of 15
US, while five (42%) were conducted in India. weeks (range = 4 - 48).
A total of 83% of the studies were conducted
in regular schools, while 17% were conducted Implementation Considerations
in alternative schools. The most common
research designs used were quasi- As the literature demonstrates, yoga appears
experimental (n = 6), followed by to provide various benefits for middle-school
experimental (n = 5), and qualitative (n = 1). students. It also appears acceptable and
The average study sample size was 77 (range feasible to implement yoga practice for at-risk
= 15 to 159). A variety of yoga practices were adolescents in middle school settings (Frank
implemented including pranayama (breath et al., 2017; Hagins et al., 2013; Kwasky &
regulation), asanas (body postures), omkar Serowoky, 2018; McMahon et al., 2021). A
jap and nidras (meditations), bhajans great deal can be learned from reviewing how
(songs), and yogic games. Some studies used middle schools have implemented yoga
specific types of yoga including Kripalu, programs in previous studies. This section
Mindfulness Hatha Yoga, Kundalini, and explores considerations for implementing
yoga in middle schools.
Table 2
Implementation considerations
Time of day When will yoga lessons be conducted: Before, during, or after school?
Student gender Will students be comfortable with combined or separate gender yoga
groups?
Yoga instructors Will the school hire outside yoga instructors, or will staff members teach
yoga? What are the minimum qualifications required to teach yoga?
At-risk students Will students with particular risk factors affect how yoga is implemented?
Location Where will the yoga lessons be conducted? Will the setting need to be
adapted to provide privacy and minimal distractions and noise?
Other factors How will yoga be incorporated into the school schedule, classes, and
activities? Be prepared to respond to possible pushback from school faculty
and staff.
Windsor et al., 2017; Frank et al., 2017; five trained yoga teachers in McMahon et al.,
Hagins et al., 2013; Rangan et al., 2008). Two 80% were female.
studies implemented yoga after school
(Kwasky & Serowoky, 2018; McMahon et al., At-Risk Students
2021). One study (Jain, 2019) implemented
yoga at a school camp. Banerjee (2014) was As stressors vary from school to school in
the sole study which implemented a yoga terms of socioeconomic status, neighborhood
intervention before school started. The risks, and adverse childhood experiences, this
remaining two studies did not specify the impacted how yoga was implemented. A total
time of day that yoga was implemented of 36% of the reviewed studies targeted at-
(Bhardwaj & Agrawal, 2013; Manjunath & risk students. The term at-risk in our review
Telles, 2001). refers to studies of students from low-
socioeconomic neighborhoods, in urban
Student Gender areas, from minoritized backgrounds, with
histories of academic and behavioral
The middle school studies we reviewed challenges, and/or adverse childhood
differed in terms of how students of different experiences. Low socioeconomic status refers
genders were involved. Most studies (64%) to a regions’ median income being below the
combined genders for their yoga classes poverty level, often with high unemployment,
(Banerjee, 2014; Bergen-Cico et al., 2015; low parental education, high welfare
Bhardwaj & Agrawal, 2013; Butzer, LoRusso, eligibility, and high rates of single parent
Windsor et al., 2017; Frank et al., 2017; families (Reardon, 2016).
Hagins et al., 2013; Jain, 2019). However,
two studies targeted only female students When implementing a yoga program for
(Kwasky & Serowoky, 2018; Manjunath & adolescent girls in a latch key afterschool
Telles, 2001) and Rangan et al. (2008) solely program, Kwasky and Serowoky (2018) made
targeted male students. McMahon et al. sure their students’ physical needs were met
(2021) implemented yoga interventions by loaning out workout leggings and yoga
separately to groups of male and female mats and offering a meal after class. When
students. implementing yoga in an inner-city high
poverty middle school, Frank et al. (2017)
Yoga Instructors focused lessons on teaching students to
understand the stress response, physical and
A total of 45% of the reviewed studies emotional awareness, self-regulation, and
mentioned using trained instructors to teach creating healthy relationships to reduce stress
yoga (Bhardwaj & Agrawal, 2013; Bergen- and promote social-emotional health and
Cico et al., 2015; Frank et al., 2017; Hagins et physical wellness. When working with at-risk
al., 2013; McMahon et al., 2021). In terms of middle school students with histories of
previous experience teaching yoga, only two academic and behavioral challenges,
studies provided that information. Frank et McMahon et al. (2011) focused on trauma
al. mentioned that their yoga instructors had informed yoga practices and teaching ways to
a few years of acquired experience in the cope with academic, emotional, and
school setting and at least two years teaching behavioral problems. One lesson contained
elsewhere. Hagins et al. stated their yoga positive self-talk mantras and discussion of
teachers had three and five years of yoga the concept of right action: channeling
teaching experience, respectively. The energy that is usually used for yearning,
remaining three studies did not disclose yoga jealousy, aggression, or physically attacking
teacher experience outside of their completed others into self-regulation, candor,
yoga training (Bhardwaj & Agrawal; Bergen- compassion, and altruism. This instruction
Cico et al.; McMahon et al.). In terms of was designed to encourage students to engage
gender of trained yoga teachers, only two in behaviors informed by their long-term
studies reported this. Bergen-Cico et al. noted goals instead of their short-term emotional
that their one yoga teacher was female. Of the reactions.
https://scholarworks.uvm.edu/mgreview/vol8/iss3/4 8
Caldarella and Moya: Benefits of Yoga in Middle Schools
questionnaires included items from the Yoga also appears to have a positive impact
Kendall-Wilcox Self-Control Schedule on depressive symptoms and anger.
(Kendall & Williams, 1982), the Anger Following both a single session and six weeks
Control Subscale of the Children’s Anger of 40-minute sessions twice a week of an
management Scale (Zeman et al., 2002), the after-school Kundalini yoga intervention,
Children’s Sadness Management scale McMahon et al. (2021) found that 52 at-risk
(Zeman et al.), and the Substance Use middle school students with academic and
Willingness Scale from the Youth Risk behavioral challenges reported significantly
Behavior Survey (Center for Disease Control, fewer depressive and anger symptoms on the
2014). Long-term follow-up revealed a Depression Anxiety Distress Scale-21
pattern of delayed effects in which females in (Lovibond & Lovibond 1995) and the Profile
the yoga condition, and males in the physical of Mood States-Adolescents (POMS-A: Terry
education group, demonstrated et al., 1999) than an alternative activity
improvements in emotional regulation. comparison group.
Students in the yoga condition were also
significantly less willing to try smoking Butzer, LoRusso, Windsor et al. (2017)
cigarettes post-intervention than participants conducted a qualitative study of 16 students
in the control condition. who participated in a 35-minute Kripalu yoga
intervention twice a week for six months.
Yoga has also been reported to help middle Yoga classes consisted of centering and
school students increase self-esteem. breathing exercises, warm-ups, yoga poses,
Bhardwaj and Agrawal (2013) separated 44 student-led poses and discussions, and
Indian middle school students into two relaxation exercises. Results indicated
groups: a treatment group and a control students generally perceived yoga to be
group. The treatment group received 35 beneficial for relaxing and dealing with stress.
minutes of yoga instruction six days a week.
All students were administered the Indian Executive Function Benefits
adaptation of Battle’s Self-Esteem inventory
for Children (1988), a forced-choice (yes/no) Yoga has been reported to positively impact
questionnaire, pre and post-test. Results middle school students’ executive function,
indicated that students in the yoga group which is defined as mental mechanisms used
significantly increased their self-esteem while to direct behavior to reach a specified goal
students in the control group remained the (Banich, 2009). Executive function involves
same or decreased. mental processes that enable an individual to
plan, focus attention, remember instructions,
Yoga has been reported to be effective in and manage multiple tasks (Fischer, 2010).
boosting mood and reducing anxiety among Jain (2019) examined 40 middle school
middle school students. Middle school students in a one-month yoga participation
students have reported that when yoga condition versus a control group. Before and
stretches and breathing techniques are done after the study, students were administered
consistently it allows them to improve their the Digit Letter Substitution Test (DLST:
ability to relax and remain calm during Natu & Agarwal, 1995) to assess attention and
stressful situations, such as during a triggered the Wechsler Memory Scale, fourth edition’s
panic attack, or when they are feeling (WMS-IV; Wechsler, 2009) digit forward and
overwhelmed (Butzer, LoRusso, Windsor et backward to assess memory. In the DLST,
al., 2017). Similarly, in a quasi-experimental digit forward, and WMS-IV backward
study, Jain (2019) found that seated subtests, students in the yoga condition
mindfulness, breathing, loosening exercises, showed significantly greater improvements in
asana, and relaxation techniques reduced attention and memory than did the control
anxiety and increased mindfulness among 40 group.
students in eighth and ninth grades
compared with a similar control group.
https://scholarworks.uvm.edu/mgreview/vol8/iss3/4 10
Caldarella and Moya: Benefits of Yoga in Middle Schools
Banerjee (2014) conducted a quasi- age and socioeconomic status. For one year,
experimental study over a two-month period half of the students participated in yoga
where 40 middle school students were exercises interspersed throughout the school
equally divided between a control group and a day and the other half did not. The students’
60-minute morning yoga intervention group. planning, execution, and number of moves
The researchers examined differences in were compared to their counterparts on The
memory between control and experimental Tower of London test (Shallice, 1982). Results
yoga groups as a whole and control and indicated that students enrolled in the yoga
experimental groups by gender alone using curriculum performed significantly better
the Post-Graduate Institute (PGI; Pershad & than the control group in planning, accuracy,
Wig, 1977) memory scale. At post-test, speed, and meticulous task execution.
students in the yoga intervention scored
significantly higher on the PGI than students Physical Benefits
in the control group. In addition, female
students enrolled in the yoga intervention Research on yoga in middle school has also
received higher memory scores than female found physical benefits such as improved
controls. Male students enrolled in the yoga fitness and weight loss. Kwasky and Serowoky
intervention also received higher memory (2018) recruited 15 at-risk female middle
scores than male controls. school students to be part of a quasi-
experimental after school yoga study twice a
A randomized experimental study by week for eight weeks. Students were
Manjunath and Telles (2001) separated 20 considered at risk due to living in urban
middle school students into a month-long environments with high levels of violence and
seven day per week, 75-minute yoga trauma. Waist circumference was measured
intervention or a generic physical training in inches and reaching flexibility was
intervention lacking instructions to relax. measured with the Accuflex Sit and Reach
Pre- and post-interventions, all students were Test (Wells & Dillon, 1952) at baseline,
asked to attempt three different exercises, during, and after the yoga intervention.
involving arranging colorful beads in a Results indicated a lower waist
specific pattern to three vertical rods, part of circumference, indicating weight loss, and
a standardized measure of planning ability increased flexibility, indicating improved
(The Tower of London test; Shallice, 1982). fitness, following exposure to yoga.
Each exercise was more difficult than the last
with an exact number of moves to be made – Yoga has also been reported as benefitting
two, four, and five moves. Planning and middle students’ sleep and fatigue. Using
execution time were measured in seconds as interviews, Butzer, LoRusso, Windsor et al.
well as the amount of moves each student (2017) found that most students post-yoga
made during each task. Results indicated that intervention reported that they spent less
students in the yoga condition had 53.9% time falling asleep, were able to achieve
lower planning time with two and 59.4% deeper sleep, achieved less interrupted sleep,
lower planning time with four move exercises, and improved their sleep satisfaction
63.7% lower execution time for four and compared to before the yoga intervention.
60.3% lower execution time for five move Middle school students also reported
patterns, and 20.9% lower individual number significantly less fatigue on the POMS-A
of moves in four move exercises than the immediately after attending a single yoga
physical training group. These results session compared with before the session
suggested that the yoga intervention helped (McMahon et al. (2021).
improve the students’ processing speed and
decision-making efficiency. Social Benefits
Rangan et al. (2008) conducted a quasi- Research reports that yoga can also have
experimental study where 49 residential social benefits for middle school students.
middle school students at two different Yoga lessons consist of didactic and
schools were matched one-to-one in terms of experiential content. During interviews with
Butzer, LoRusso, Windsor et al. (2017), schools; however, there were some
students participating in yoga noted their limitations. There was one small
satisfaction of working and being part of a experimental study (Hagins et al., 2013)
small group and having an equal opportunity which found that a 15-week yoga program did
and open space for sharing insights with one not provide significant differences in stress
another. Middle school students in Kwasky reactivity compared to a physical education
and Serowoky’s (2018) study practiced yoga class in sixth grade students. The reasons for
at school twice weekly for eight weeks. Self- these results were hypothesized to be due to
efficacy was measured using the standardized the yoga intervention failing to focus on stress
Self-Efficacy Questionnaire for Children management but may also have been due to
(Muris, 2001). Results indicated that the small sample size (15 in each
participants showed significantly increased experimental group).
social self-efficacy at posttest and at one
month follow-up. It should be noted that Another limitation was that we did not
some middle school students have expressed conduct a meta-analytic review due to the
discomfort in attempting yoga positions in a variety of research methods (i.e., quasi-
large group setting, next to unfamiliar experimental, experimental, qualitative) used
members of the opposite sex, and/or those in the literature. However, a set of inclusion
with more experience and skills (Butzer, criteria were used to evaluate each study to
LoRusso, Windsor et al.). ensure minimal selection bias. Other
limitations were that there are not yet many
Academic Benefits middle school yoga studies, and there was a
large variability in the type and quality of
Yoga has been reported to positively impact studies, with some not reporting the specific
middle school students’ academic type of yoga implemented.
performance. During interviews, Butzer,
LoRusso, Windsor et al. (2017) found that We agree with McMahon et al. (2021) that
most students reported success in ridding further research needs to be conducted due to
themselves of anxiety by using yoga breathing the frequent lack of randomization at the
exercises before school assignments, tests, student level. We further agree that the
and oral presentations, which resulted in literature could benefit from a longitudinal
better academic performance. In the Frank et study on the physical, mental health, and
al. (2017) randomized controlled trial, academic effects of yoga in middle school,
researchers examined student academic and examining socioeconomic status as an
behavioral records and administered the influential factor with larger sample sizes
School Engagement Scale (Cernkovich & (Bhardwaj & Agrawal, 2013; Kwasky &
Giordano, 1992). These researchers found Serowoky, 2018; McMahon et al., 2021). The
that at-risk students who participated in yoga literature also included little information on
decreased their unexcused absences, the fidelity of yoga implementation in middle
detentions, suspensions, and increased school school, like results found in high school
engagement, such as belonging and working studies (Caldarella & Lulla, 2022).
hard in school. Math and English grades for
these at-risk students also increased Conclusion
following the yoga intervention. Others have
reported that, as yoga can help improve The results of this first literature review
students’ focus, memory, self-esteem, and specifically focused on middle school settings
anxiety/stress in school, their academic suggest that yoga appears to provide a variety
performance often improves as well of mental health, executive functioning,
(Caldarella & Lulla, 2022; Wei, 2016). physical, social, and academic benefits for
students. The studies reviewed also suggested
Limitations that yoga can benefit adolescents who are
stressed, anxious, depressed, or those who
This study included a review of the literature are at risk. However, these results
examining the benefits of yoga in middle represented just 12 studies published across
https://scholarworks.uvm.edu/mgreview/vol8/iss3/4 12
Caldarella and Moya: Benefits of Yoga in Middle Schools
*Bhardwaj, A. K., & Agrawal, G. (2013). Yoga Cernkovich, S. A., & Giordano, P. C. (1992).
practice enhances the level of self- School bonding, race, and
esteem in pre-adolescent school delinquency. Criminology, 30(2),
children. International Journal of 261-291.
Physical and Social Sciences, 3(10), https://heinonline.org/HOL/Landin
189-199. gPage?handle=hein.journals/crim30
&div=24&id=&page=
Chung, H., Elias, M., & Schneider, K. (1998). to secondary education. Frontiers in
Patterns of individual adjustment Psychology, 9(1482), 1-18.
changes during middle school https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2018.
transition. Journal of School 01482
Psychology, 36(1), 83-101.
https://doi.org/10.1016/S0022- Feuerstein, G. (2003). The deeper dimension
4405(97)00051-4 of yoga: Theory and practice.
Shambhala Publications.
Coelho, V. A., & Romao, A. M. (2016). Stress
in Portuguese middle school Feuerstein, G. (2012). The yoga tradition: Its
transition: A multilevel analysis. The history, literature, philosophy, and
Spanish Journal of Psychology, practice. SCB Distributors.
19(61), 1-8.
https://doi.org/10.1017/sjp.2016.61 Fisher, P. (2010). In brief: Executive
function: Skills for life and learning.
Conboy, L. A., Noggle, J. J., Frey, J. L., Center on the Developing Child at
Kudesia, R. S., & Khalsa, S. B. S. Harvard University.
(2013). Qualitative evaluation of a www.developingchild.harvard.edu
high school yoga program: Feasibility
and perceived benefits. Explore, 9(3), *Frank, J. L., Kohler, K., Peal, A., & Bose, B.
171-180. (2017). Effectiveness of a school-
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.explore.201 based yoga program on adolescent
3.02.001 mental health and school
performance: Findings from a
Connor-Smith, J. K., Compas, B. E., randomized controlled
Wadsworth, M. E., Thomsen, A. H., & trial. Mindfulness, 8(3), 544-553.
Saltzman, H. (2000). Responses to https://doi.org/10.1007/s12671-016-
stress in adolescence: measurement 0628-3
of coping and involuntary stress
responses. Journal of Consulting and Graham, A., Phelps, R., Maddison, C., &
Clinical Psychology, 68(6), 976-992. Fitzgerald, R. (2011). Supporting
https://doi.org/10.1037//0022- children’s mental health in schools:
006X.68.6.976 Teacher views. Teachers and
Teaching, 17(4), 479-496.
Diamond, A. (2010). The evidence base for https://doi.org/10.1080/13540602.2
improving school outcomes by 011.580525
addressing the whole child and by
addressing skills and attitudes, not Gutman, L. M., & Midgley, C. (2000). The
just content. Early Education and role of protective factors in
Development, 21(5), 780-793. supporting the academic
https://doi.org/10.1080/10409289.2 achievement of poor African
010.514522 American students during the middle
school transition. Journal of Youth
Dotterer, A. M., McHale, S. M., & Crouter, A. and Adolescence, 29(2), 223-249.
C. (2009). The development and https://doi.org/10.1023/A:10051087
correlates of academic interests from 00243
childhood through
adolescence. Journal of Educational *Hagins, M., Haden, S. C., & Daly, L. A.
Psychology, 101(2), 509-519. (2013). A randomized controlled trial
https://doi.org/10.1037/a0013987 on the effects of yoga on stress
reactivity in 6th grade
Evans, D., Borriello, G. A., & Field, A. P. students. Evidence-Based
(2018). A review of the academic and Complementary and Alternative
psychological impact of the transition
https://scholarworks.uvm.edu/mgreview/vol8/iss3/4 14
Caldarella and Moya: Benefits of Yoga in Middle Schools
Hammond, H. (August 29, 2007). The Kendall, P. C., & Williams, C. L. (1982).
timeline and history of yoga in Assessing the cognitive and
America. Yoga Journal. behavioral components of children's
https://www.yogajournal.com/yoga- self-management. In P. Karoly, & F.
101/history-of-yoga/yogas-trip- H. Kanfer (Eds.), Self-management
america/ and behavior change (pp. 240-284).
Pergamon.
Harrison, J. R., Vannest, K., Davis, J., &
Reynolds, C. (2012). Common Khalsa, S. B. S., & Butzer, B. (2016). Yoga in
problem behaviors of children and school settings: A research
adolescents in general education review. Annals of the New York
classrooms in the United States. Academy of Sciences, 1373(1), 45-55.
Journal of Emotional and https://doi.org/10.1111/nyas.13025
Behavioral Disorders, 20(1), 55-64.
https://doi.org/10.1177/10634266114 *Kwasky, A. N., & Serowoky, M. L. (2018).
21157 Yoga to enhance self efficacy: An
intervention for at-risk
Hecker, B., Young, E. L., & Caldarella, P. youth. Archives of Psychiatric
(2014). Teacher perspectives on Nursing, 32(1), 82-85.
behaviors of middle and junior high https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apnu.2017.
school students at risk for emotional 10.009
and behavioral disorders. American
Secondary Education, 42(2), 20-32. Laurent, J., Catanzaro, S. J., Joiner Jr, T. E.,
Rudolph, K. D., Potter, K. I.,
Hookham, L. S. (2021). The Guru Principle: Lambert, S., ... & Gathright, T.
A guide to the teacher-student (1999). A measure of positive and
relationship in Buddhism. negative affect for children: Scale
Shambhala Publications. development and preliminary
validation. Psychological
*Jain, D. (2019). Impact of yoga intervention Assessment, 11(3), 326.
on exam anxiety, mindfulness,
attention, and memory in school Lovibond, P. F., & Lovibond, S. H. (1995).
going children. Delhi Business The structure of negative emotional
Review, 22(2), 85-90. states: Comparison of the Depression
https://doi.org/10.51768/dbr.v22i2.2 Anxiety Stress Scales (DASS) with the
22202109 Beck Depression and Anxiety
Inventories. Behaviour Research and
Joshi, K. S. (1965). On the meaning of yoga. Therapy, 33(3), 335-343.
Philosophy of East and West, 15(1), https://doi.org/10.1016/0005-
53-64. 7967(94)00075-U
https://doi.org/10.2307/1397408
*Manjunath, N. K., & Telles, S. (2001).
Kaufman, J. S., Jaser, S. S., Vaughan, E. L., Improved performance in the Tower
Reynolds, J. S., Di Donato, J., of London test following yoga. Indian
Bernard, S. N., & Hernandez- Journal of Physiology and
Brereton, M. (2010). Patterns in Pharmacology, 45(3), 351-354.
office referral data by grade, https://www.ijpp.com/IJPP
race/ethnicity, and gender. Journal archives/2001_45_3/351-354.pdf
of Positive Behavior
Interventions, 12(1), 44-54.
https://scholarworks.uvm.edu/mgreview/vol8/iss3/4 16
Caldarella and Moya: Benefits of Yoga in Middle Schools